They celebrate the return of NFL football with a look at the Giants' preseason plans and the pressure on Daniel Jones. Pat Leonard joins Anthony Gallo and Pete Hoffman to discuss training camp roster battles, while Mark Schlereth evaluates the Jets' offensive outlook. Former lineman Justin Pugh also stops by to share stories from the league and participate in a game of Spin the Wheel. 01:50 - Daniel Jones Preseason Role 07:50 - Jets Season Kickoff Preview 12:05 - Gallo and Hoffman Grades 19:38 - Josh Allen's Pistachio Farm 26:45 - Backup Quarterback Analysis 36:43 - Pat Leonard Giants Report 46:50 - NFL Today New Format 59:34 - Justin Pugh Spin Wheel

As football returns to MetLife Stadium, they debate whether Jaxson Dart should take meaningful reps for the Giants during the preseason. The conversation also highlights a surprising headline about Josh Allen's pistachio business and a critique of why Field of Dreams is a mediocre movie. 01:20 - Preseason Quarterback Debate 04:51 - Jets Home Opener Hype 08:41 - Giants Training Camp Struggles 12:50 - Host Performance Grading 19:05 - Josh Allen's Nut Farm 23:51 - Ranking Favorite Nuts 27:05 - Field Of Dreams Critique 31:20 - Cannabis Business Ventures

Pat Leonard joins Craig to evaluate the New York Giants' training camp and the performance of Daniel Jones heading into the preseason. They discuss the wide receiver depth chart and evaluate how the team will manage its running back rotation. The conversation also features a critique of current NFL pregame shows and their lack of authentic personality. 01:20 - Giants Training Camp 04:52 - Daniel Jones Concerns 09:55 - Receiver Depth Battle 14:12 - Defensive Rookie Evaluation 18:29 - Giants Season Outlook 22:22 - NFL Today Analysis 27:47 - Pregame Show Formatting 33:57 - Jets Preseason Prep

Mark Schlereth evaluates Jackson Dart’s development and the Denver Broncos' outlook for the upcoming season. Quincy Enunwa discusses Geno Smith’s maturity and opens up about the neck injury that ended his playing career. They also debate the future of NFL pregame shows and airport lounge etiquette. 01:50 - NFL Preseason Betting 07:21 - Mark Schlereth Joins 13:11 - Jackson Dart Development 21:40 - Geno Smith Evaluation 26:43 - Broncos Season Outlook 37:10 - Bayonne Little League 41:05 - Quincy Enunwa Interview 49:04 - Injury Impact on Identity 55:50 - Airport Lounge Access

Former offensive lineman Justin Pugh joins the program to discuss his career with the New York Giants and Arizona Cardinals. He shares insights into playing for Tom Coughlin, the infamous 2017 boat trip controversy, and burying the hatchet with Geno Smith. Pete and Anthony also challenge Justin to a series of trivia games on the wheel. 01:35 - Justin Pugh Joins 06:02 - Italian Football Involvement 12:08 - Coaching Under Coughlin 16:31 - Giants Boat Controversy 34:04 - Spin The Wheel 48:37 - McAdoo And Geno

Former Giants offensive lineman Justin Pugh joins to discuss his transition from the NFL to the business world and his involvement with the Italian Football League. They reflect on the Tom Coughlin era, the infamous boat trip distraction, and compare the organizational consistency of the Giants and Ravens. 01:20 - Justin Pugh Joins 05:41 - Italian Football League 10:16 - Coaching Under Coughlin 13:21 - Giants Struggles Discussed 20:31 - Harbaugh vs Coughlin 25:21 - Football Finance Career 32:33 - Competitive Golf Talk

Craig Carton welcomes former Jets receiver Quincy Enunwa to discuss Geno Smith's maturity as a veteran quarterback and the current state of the Jets' offensive line. They also explore the emotional challenges of career-ending injuries and debate the future of NFL pregame shows. 01:00 - Bayonne Little League Success 03:21 - Reimagining NFL Pregame Shows 07:19 - Quincy Enunwa Interview 12:12 - Life After Football 21:15 - Airport Lounge Etiquette

Mark Schlereth joins Craig to analyze the current state of the Giants and Jets as they prepare for preseason action. They discuss the reckless but dynamic playstyle of quarterback Jaxson Dart and the offensive potential surrounding Breece Hall and Geno Smith. The conversation also explores the Denver Broncos' defensive identity and identifies potential dark horse teams for the upcoming season. 01:50 - NFL Preseason Betting Warning 07:48 - Mark Schlereth on Standouts 11:15 - Jaxson Dart Giants Future 20:33 - Analyzing Jets Offensive Potential 27:15 - Broncos Projections and Turnovers 30:34 - NFL Dark Horses Discussion

Craig Carton and the guys evaluate Bill Cowher's vision for a conversational shift on the NFL Today pregame show. They highlight why scripted segments often hinder personalities like Shannon Sharpe and Bart Scott compared to the free-flowing style of Inside the NBA. Finally, they discuss the quarterback situations for the Jets and Giants. 01:08 - Critiquing NFL Today 06:56 - Inside The NBA Model 11:30 - Jets And Giants Preview

Pat Leonard joins Craig to share insights from his recent visit to training camp in West Virginia and the outlook for the New York Giants. They evaluate the quarterback's struggle with downfield passing, the competitive wide receiver depth chart featuring Odell Beckham Jr., and the challenges of the team's upcoming 2024 schedule. 01:00 - Pat Leonard West Virginia Trip 04:07 - Preseason Quarterback Performance Analysis 08:23 - Giants Wide Receiver Roster Battles 12:14 - Defensive Standouts Cornerback Competition 18:40 - Giants 2024 Season Outlook

Craig and Pete critique the Field of Dreams game and movie while debating the best baseball films. They also field caller takes on ice cream, a massive Little League pitcher, and Jets rookie potential. The conversation shifts to a unique edible business venture and movie recommendations like Interstellar. 01:07 - Field Of Dreams Review 04:02 - Little League World Series 05:41 - NFL Rookie Talk 10:14 - Draft Reactions And Interstellar 16:52 - New Edible Business Venture

Craig Carton discusses the surprising news of Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen owning a 1,000-acre pistachio farm. They share their favorite nut rankings and debate ice cream flavors before shifting focus to the New York Jets' preseason and the search for a future franchise quarterback. 01:00 - Josh Allen's Nut Farm 03:52 - Ranking Favorite Nuts 07:00 - Jets Preseason Outlook 09:06 - Evaluating Cade Klubnik 13:17 - Greatest Jets Number Seven

On the Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton dives into the return of football and what they expect to see from the Jets and Giants. Craig insists Jaxson Dart MUST play and wants to see what the Giants rookie can do in a real preseason game. The guys also break down the Jets' first look at Geno Smith and Frank Reich's offense, the expectations for rookie stars David Bailey and Arvell Reese, and the surprising situation surrounding Odell Beckham Jr. as he fights to make the Giants' 53-man roster.

Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Yankees' recent scoring drought and Jazz Chisholm's performance during a breakdown of the team's shutout loss to the Mariners. They revisit Mena Kimes' viral reaction to Josh Allen's draft night and share a humorous story about a dress code mishap at the stadium involving Susan Waldman. 01:50 - Yankees Offensive Struggles 08:52 - Josh Allen Audio Game 14:17 - George Lombard Jr. Usage 25:21 - Deion Sanders & Shedeur 38:35 - Press Box Shorts Story 13:36 - Boone Motivation Debate 18:24 - Yankees Bullpen Assessment

Craig Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Yankees' recent offensive failures and debate whether Jazz Chisholm is to blame for their scoring drought. They also react to an old clip of Mena Kimes' draft reaction and discuss the bizarre media restrictions surrounding Deion Sanders at Colorado. Finally, Big Mac recounts an embarrassing interaction with Suzyn Waldman regarding his attire at the stadium. 01:52 - Yankees Offensive Woes 09:42 - Mena Kimes Audio Mystery 15:20 - George Lombard Lineup Debate 26:28 - Deion Sanders Media Policy 40:16 - Suzyn Waldman Dress Code

Chris McMonigle evaluates the New York Yankees' offensive woes despite their elite pitching rotation. He engages with callers to debate Aaron Boone's leadership style and explores the possibility of Cody Bellinger taking over the leadoff spot to spark the lineup. 01:13 - Yankee Offense Struggles 06:54 - Leadoff Hitter Solutions 14:00 - Aaron Boone Debate 10:21 - High School Football

Big Mac shares an awkward encounter with Suzyn Waldman at Yankee Stadium after being called out for wearing shorts in the press box. They also discuss Deion Sanders' strict media restrictions at Colorado and debate Shedeur Sanders' professional prospects. 01:00 - Colorado Media Restrictions 02:08 - Shedeur Sanders NFL Future 08:36 - Radio Genius Debates 12:34 - Suzyn Waldman Dress Code 20:02 - Summer Vacation Plans

The Yankees' offense is struggling again, and Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton have had enough. The guys debate Jazz Chisholm's disastrous season at the plate, why expectations are so much higher for Jazz, and whether Ben Rice has also fallen off after carrying the Yankees earlier this season.

The Yankees' pitching keeps giving them a chance, but the offense continues to let them down. Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down New York's brutal 1-0 loss to the Mariners, the Yankees managing just FOUR hits, and why Jazz Chisholm is becoming a major problem at the plate.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the Giants wide receiver room and if it's good enough. What's the easiest path for the Yankees to get back to the World Series? How much better will the Jets be? Should the Knicks be scared of the LeBron James led 76ers?

Craig says the Giants are lacking strong skill position players outside Malik Nabers. The Yankees squeak out a win despite continued offensive struggles. The Lakers get sold once again. Craig has an idea for a new website.

Gallo is back from vacation and Craig and C-Mac can't believe how little he knows about famous actors. Is it weird to get a massage for your prostate? Niko, filling in for Hoff, is throwing his own birthday party.

Craig thinks the jets are capable of being a near .500 team. C-Mac believes Aaron Glenn has been humbled which is a good thing. Russell Westbrook announces his retirement from the NBA. Is he a first ballot hall of famer? Should the Knicks fear the Sixers?

Stu Feiner calls in and predicts that both the Giants and Jets will beat their respective win totals.

Russell Westbrook has officially retired after an incredible 18-year NBA career, and Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle debate where he ranks among the greatest players of his generation. From averaging a triple-double for a season to becoming an MVP and future first-ballot Hall of Famer, the guys break down why Westbrook's legacy deserves more respect.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to Aaron Glenn’s latest interview and both admit they feel MUCH better about the Jets head coach heading into the 2026 season. After a disastrous first season, Glenn appears to be embracing his strengths as a defensive coach and taking ownership of the mistakes he made. Carton says Glenn came across as confident, comfortable and genuine, while Big Mac admits he went home thinking about the interview and came away impressed.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle have a hilarious conversation about producer Nico’s REAL first name and the reveal leads to an all-out roast! Then Anthony Gallo walks into the studio and immediately gets put to the test on movies, actors, and classic books. From Robert Redford to Gary Sinise, The Natural, The Deer Hunter, Of Mice and Men and more, Carton and Big Mac discover just how little Gallo remembers!

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle get into a wild debate over Tito Jackson and the Jackson 5, with a caller making the case that Tito was far more talented than people give him credit for. The conversation then turns into a bigger debate: Who are the true musical savants? Michael Jackson, Prince, Brian Wilson, Bob Dylan, Carole King, Ed Sheeran, Kid Rock, Lil Wayne and more are discussed as Craig and Big Mac debate what separates incredible musicians from true musical geniuses. Plus, Nico's 27th birthday party, Giants talk, tailgating, and a very unexpected caller update from Lori!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the bizarre situation surrounding the New York Giants' training camp at The Greenbrier — a resort that includes a full casino and FanDuel sportsbook.

Craig and Chris McGonagle react to the massive $12 billion valuation of the Lakers and the ripple effect on the New York Knicks' market value. They also brainstorm a "Dead to Me" social media platform before a caller shares insights on the New York Giants' training camp at The Greenbrier. 01:00 - Music Legends and Billy Preston 06:30 - NBA Franchise Valuations Surge 09:44 - Dead To Me Website Idea 14:18 - Greenbrier Resort History 16:08 - Giants Training Camp Update

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether the Giants made a major mistake by not signing Stefon Diggs after their first preseason depth chart revealed serious questions at wide receiver.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the New York Giants' first preseason depth chart, and Craig is sounding the alarm on the state of Big Blue's offense.

WFAN hosts break down the Knicks' upcoming opening night ring ceremony against LeBron James and the 76ers, debating whether $2,000 ticket prices and schedule delays stem from LeBron hype or true New York basketball fever.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the Knicks home opener, Giancarlo nearing a return for the Yankees, and chat with Jets players, coaches, and GM Darren Mougey.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the Knicks' opening night matchup against LeBron James' Philadelphia 76ers, their Christmas Day rematch against the San Antonio Spurs, and are joined by SNY's Connor Hughes at New York Jets camp.

Demario Davis joins the show live from Jets camp. Craig and C-Mac find out information that diminishes their views on the University of Michigan.

Breece Hall joins the show live from Jets camp. What does Stanton running the bases mean for the Yankees?

Jets GM Darren Mougey and Head Coach Aaron Glenn join the show live from jets camp. Giants have interest in a free agent cornerback.

Craig and C-Mac discuss the Jets being a one quarterback team that's heading into the season incredibly dependent on Geno Smith to revamp their offense under Frank Reich and Aaron Glenn.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by Jets general manager Darren Mougey to discuss his work rebuilding the team, head coach Aaron Glenn as he heads into year two, and Geno Smith's struggles at camp thus far.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by Aaron Glenn from Jets camp! The head coach discusses what's different going into Year 2 of his tenure with the clipboard, what he's expecting from his players after working with them in camp, and what he's changing after a disappointing debut season with the team.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to Giancarlo Stanton taking a big step toward returning from his right calf strain and debate how easy it is to play first base in Major League Baseball.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome Breece Hall to the show to discuss why the Jets' offense will be different this season, playing under Aaron Glenn and Frank Reich, and some random topics - Craig style - for fans to get to know their star running back even better.

Jets LB Demario Davis tells Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle about being one of the oldest players in the NFL, this being his third stint with the Jets, mentoring incoming rookie David Bailey, and what to expect from Aaron Glenn's defense.

Craig and CMac welcome SNY's Connor Hughes to the show to talk about everything they saw at Jets camp, what Connor thinks about New York's upcoming season, and even sneak in Craig's favorite Jaxson Dart debate.

Craig and C-Mac react to the Knicks' opening night bout with LeBron James' 76ers and Christmas Day rematch with Victor Wembanyama.

The Yankees failed to sweep the Braves as their lifeless lineup once again could not generate runs. Chris McMonigle sounds off on the same old story, from a brilliant Cam Schlittler outing going to waste, to the lack of hope that this offense can break out without Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger. Plus, George Lombard Jr. continues to impress in his first taste of the majors, but is that enough to get this stacked pitching staff enough run support?EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS4:14 - A deep dive into how the lack of run support is completely exhausting relievers like Bednar, Blackburn, and Cruz by forcing them into constant high-leverage, one-run games.16:03 - Why Jazz Chisholm has become the face of the offensive issues, struggling heavily and bordering on becoming a platoon player.19:55 - Recapping Max Fried's excellent start and praising rookie George Lombard's incredibly clean, Carlos Correa-esque defense.35:50 - A passionate rant on Caballero’s infuriating 10th-inning at-bat, which Chris declared the worst he's ever seen.42:27 - Gerrit Cole looks brilliant, Chris Sale gets tossed pregame for dugout chirping, and Austin Wells continues his hot 15-game stretch.48:04 - Debating Trent Grisham's place at the top of the order against righties, and why it might be too early to put leadoff pressure on Lombard.52:01 - Cam Schlittler dominates, but the offense wastes solid contact and falls to Atlanta in the series finale.58:00 - Why catching the Rays is slipping away and why avoiding a 3-game Wild Card series at Fenway Park is the team's new main priority.1:01:42 - Caballero rightfully earns the "Shame" for his offensive disaster, while Max Fried takes home the "Shill" for his clutch Friday start.

Carton and McMonigle break down the New York Yankees' recent series win against the Braves, highlighting the contrast between elite starting pitching and a struggling offense. They also delve into the chaotic state of the WNBA, the Buffalo Bills' stadium blunders, and Craig's adventurous weekend meal of a whole alligator. 01:53 - Yankees Pitching Dominates Braves 16:53 - Carton Cooks Whole Alligator 32:50 - Highmark Stadium Construction Fails 52:10 - WNBA Reality Show Drama 01:07:45 - High School Football Rivalries 01:27:20 - Upgrade To 75 Inch TV 02:05:50 - Life Inside Prison COVID 02:29:15 - Giants Offensive Coaching Concerns 02:58:40 - St John's Internship Opportunity 03:13:10 - Brian Cashman Career Legacy

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' reliance on their elite starting rotation to carry a struggling offense through the postseason. They also debate the New York Mets' recent success, discuss construction failures at Highmark Stadium, and share a wild story about cooking a whole alligator. 01:23 - Yankees World Series Dilemma 05:40 - Dangerous Playoff Pitching 10:59 - Austin Wells Progress 14:00 - Mets Cautionary Advice 16:20 - Craig's Alligator Story 26:13 - Chris Sale Ejection 16:43 - Highmark Stadium Blunders 23:30 - Defending Aaron Boone 27:45 - Judge's Lineup Impact

Craig Carton and Big Mac vent their frustrations over a disastrous performance during the Yankees' series and evaluate the franchise's situational baseball failures. They also weigh the future of the Mets against the Yankees while debating the necessity of massive television upgrades for the upcoming NFL season. 01:20 - Caballero's Egregious At-Bat 06:15 - Yankee Situational Baseball Woes 12:41 - Mets And Yankees Future 17:00 - Jets Playoff Expectations 21:45 - Football Season TV Sizes 32:25 - Cashman And High School 37:46 - Mepham Hazing Incident 41:25 - Comparing Big TV Brands

Craig and Big Mac examine the WNBA's recent political controversies and the league's attempts to define womanhood. They also delve into New York Giants coaching staff concerns and share entertaining stories regarding survival skills and Italian vacations. 01:50 - WNBA Political Drama 11:31 - Caitlin Clark Controversy 15:40 - Enes Freedom Stunt 21:40 - Deserted Island Survival 28:15 - Italian Vacation Stories 34:40 - Giants Coaching Concerns 45:30 - Southern Food Favorites 52:15 - Small Business Ideas 57:15 - Tom Hanks Family

Craig recounts a surreal experience playing bingo while incarcerated during the COVID-19 pandemic and the gut-punch of hearing his peers on the radio. They debate the greatest romantic comedies and mafia movies of all time before enlisting a young Syracuse student to become the show's official St. John's basketball correspondent. 01:50 - Prison Bingo During COVID 07:36 - Hearing Boomer in Prison 11:40 - Greatest Rom-Com Debate 12:38 - Godfather 3 Sucks 14:33 - Max the St. John's Fan 20:40 - Dylan Byer Connection 24:15 - Sweet Tea and Calories 29:45 - St. John's vs. Syracuse 33:34 - Craig's Dream Knicks Job

Craig wonders if he's indebted to his alma mater of Syracuse -- or if attendance at a St. John's game to see Rick Pitino would grant him the ability to ride the bandwagon. Also, the guys wind up talking about bunting somehow.

Craig asks C-Mac about Giants fans' apparent concerns over John Harbaugh choosing Matt Nagy as his offensive coordinator.

Craig and C-Mac think the WNBA can continue to grow, so long as it gets out of its own way with regard to topics that it should already be on top of.

Craig Carton, Chris McMonigle, and Pete Hoffman discuss their television set-ups for watching sports as the NFL season rapidly approaches -- even if Big Mac is going to be watching baseball until the Giants' preseason officially starts.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle laugh at a caller's notion that the Mets have a brighter future than the Yankees -- and Craig says he's going to learn a big Geno Smith lesson at Jets camp.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle talk about the job Aaron Boone has done at the helm of the Yankees this season, given their offensive success amid poor injury luck and struggles from their biggest stars.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the Yankees' postseason chances as they continue to bank on winning games "2-1," which might not be entirely sustainable in the postseason. Either way, the Bronx Bombers will likely be the chalk pick to win their first playoff series -- whoever it's against.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Monday's show by discussing the New York Yankees' offensive struggles -- and whether or not the strength of their pitching is enough to overcome their slump without Aaron Judge.

Willie Colon and Jerry Recco on what concerns they may have with Jaxson Dart this season. Plus: -Shaun Morash on what worries him about the Giants’ offense -Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle hear from a caller on whether John Harbaugh is right for Dart. -Tiki Barber revisits the takes around the Odell Beckham Jr. trade -Craig and C-Mac on whether or not the Giants should have pursued Stefon Diggs.

Freddy Peralta orchestrated a sitdown with Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor to squash their beef, according to ESPN. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the stunning report, while Evan Roberts wonders if brokering peace between the team's two stars changes anything about Peralta's damaged legacy in Queens. Plus, the great Jefry Yan debate, as Jerry Recco and Willie Colon debate if the pitcher's animated celebrations are appropriate, while Shaun Morash predicts the celebrating will backfire in the most Mets way possible.

George Lombard Jr. has made his Yankee introduction, and our hosts love what they see. Evan and Tiki rave about his defense at shortstop, and Ryan Ruocco of the YES Network calls in to the Morning Show to talk about Lombard's sparkling debut. Plus, Brian Cashman talks all things trade deadline with The Carton Show, and Evan Roberts is ready to declare the AL East race over.

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' current slump as the Boston Red Sox surge in the American League standings. They welcome Marcus from Cap Tree Clam Company to set a unique wager on the season's finish and discuss the Jets' quarterback future following the Hall of Fame Game. The conversation also covers radio history, the rise of cashless businesses, and a breakdown of John Travolta's film career. 01:50 - Yankees Panic Mode 06:25 - Yankees Versus Braves 11:00 - QB Dating Standards 18:45 - Wildcard Path Scenarios 28:35 - Mitch Garver Signing 34:40 - Radio History Lesson 26:10 - Cap Tree Clams 31:32 - Geno Smith Update 36:45 - Shaq Knicks Hatred 46:45 - The Porn Name 23:55 - Cashless Society Debate 28:20 - Tesla Valet Concerns 34:20 - Skin Flute Legend 39:15 - Syracuse Sports History 46:40 - Yankees September Schedule 24:15 - Spin The Wheel 26:05 - Yankees Weather Delay

Craig and Big Mac discuss the intensifying rivalry between the Yankees and the Red Sox as the two teams become tied in the loss column. They also recap a high-scoring preseason football performance and debate the best strategic path for the Yankees in the upcoming playoffs. 01:20 - Yankees and Red Sox Panic 04:47 - Red Sox Incredible Run 09:24 - Football and QB Standards 14:47 - Yankees Braves Series Preview 18:37 - Wildcard Playoff Scenarios 28:36 - Listener Calls & Manager Debate 35:53 - Phillies Guest Play-by-Play 40:06 - History of AM Radio

Craig and Big Mac discuss a wager with the owner of Captree Clam Co. regarding the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry and the potential for a "Fenway Oyster." They critique Shaq's comments on the Knicks' championship run and dive into the Jets' offensive expectations. Discussions also cover the trend toward cashless businesses and the logistical challenges of owning a Tesla in the city. 01:16 - Captree Clam Bet 06:44 - Jets Quarterback Outlook 12:43 - Shaq Criticizes Knicks 18:01 - Jalen Brunson Surgery 23:04 - Cashless Society Debate 29:15 - Tesla And Waymo 36:23 - William Paterson University 39:58 - Big East Memories 43:04 - Yankees Playoff Math

Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle evaluate the New York Giants' defensive core and the Yankees' roster choices amidst a tightening pennant race. They are joined by Al Dukes, who recounts a tense past encounter with Warren Sapp, and discuss a bizarre incident where Paul Rudd witnessed a car being vandalized outside the studio. 01:55 - NFL Preseason Reaction 05:15 - Giants Defensive Outlook 12:20 - Yankees Roster Dilemma 15:45 - MLB Roster Expansion 19:30 - Oyster Marriage Memory 23:35 - Paul Rudd Witness Story 27:35 - Pete Belotti Thumb Story 32:35 - Al Dukes & Warren Sapp 36:05 - Johnny Bench Interview 44:15 - Yankees vs Red Sox

Craig and Chris McMonigle conduct a movie and sports trivia challenge before shifting focus to the Yankees' rain delay and their struggle to hold off the Red Sox. 01:42 - Kids Starting Tackle Football 06:15 - Charles Manson Ancestry Story 12:13 - Murder House Real Estate 25:31 - John Travolta Movie Trivia 33:50 - New York Shortstop Challenge 01:06:45 - Yankees Rain Delay Update 01:12:35 - Yankees Pitching vs Hitting

CMac explains why the time for Yankee excuses is over and why the bomber and fans need to lock in.

Another epic installment of the vaunted spin that wheel

Carton and Big Mac realize that with the Rays, Red Sox, and Yankees separated by a handful of games that this AL East race will be one for the books

During a story about the great Pete Bellotti, Al Dukes calls in with some classic throwback stories

Big Mac and Carton map out the Yankee stretch run and what a successful month of September would look like

Carton and Big Mac take issue with Shaq and everyone else who go out of their way to discredit the Knicks winning the 2026 NBA title

While Carton fully embraces the Red Sox, Big Mac doesn't sound like much of Yankee shill when it comes to the status of the AL East.

SHOW OPEN. Carton believes that Yankee fans and the entire organization should be worried about the Red Sox who are on a never ending heater

The Yankees finally provided an Aaron Judge update, as Chris McMonigle reacts to the latest regarding the captain's recovery timeline. Plus, George Lombard Jr. could not have scripted a much better introduction, but the rest of the offense is as lifeless as ever, as C-Mac sounds off on the brutal showing in a series loss to the Cardinals at home.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS8:28 - A critical look at Trent Grisham's defensive misplays in center field. We discuss why his offensive struggles mean he absolutely must be moved out of the leadoff spot.20:19 - Breaking down the Yankees' maddening inability to score. The team drew eight walks and had 12 baserunners but managed only one run, going a dismal 0-10 with runners in scoring position.36:13 - We rave about George Lombard's incredibly smooth defensive plays at shortstop and his exciting home run, bringing some much-needed energy to the diamond.49:25 - Discussing the latest news on Judge's recovery. He has been cleared for outdoor running and light resistance training, but we debate what this timeline actually means since he hasn't started baseball activities yet.55:46 - Shill or Shame: Our signature segment. Lombard earns the "Shill" for his stellar debut, while Jones gets the "Shame" for going 0-for-11 with key strikeouts during the series.

CMac is still locked into football but Carton is ready for football

Carton wonders if George Lombard Jr's social media choices could lead to unwanted controversy. Plus more Yankees talk

Carton and Big Mac debate whether Boone will still be safe if the Yankees' season ends in disappointment

undefined

Carton is ready for fooTball while CMac is fully locked in on the Yankees

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to John Smoltz's suggestion that MLB go back to a split season format with a potential lockout coming up.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss how the potential of a lockout in MLB is changing how players are going to negotiate their upcoming contracts — and how it could affect Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s next deal with the New York Yankees?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss what George Lombard Jr. is doing on his off day, the time that an NYC athlete almost lived with Craig (it didn't work out), and whether or not there's a problem with the Yankees' level of urgency with regard to winning a World Series.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the New York Yankees' chances in the postseason, what it would mean for Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone if they failed to win a World Series, and how important Jazz Chisholm Jr. is to their hitting.

Craig Carton shares the BEST fantasy football punishment with Chris McMonigle before getting back to welcoming the NFL season back.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss athletes' use of social media in a time where everything is so public -- and whether or not George Lombard Jr. following Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Instagram is planting seeds for clubhouse problems.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome football back into their lives and fire back when a caller accuses John Harbaugh of coming in too hot with how he's handling incoming sophomore quarterback Jaxson Dart.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Thursday's show by tearing apart the Yankees' offense, which George Lombard Jr. might not be able to save...

Craig and Big Mac analyze George Lombard Jr.'s electric debut for the Yankees and his comparison to Derek Jeter. They also explore the Giants' wide receiver depth concerns and discuss Aaron Judge's positive injury update. 01:50 - George Lombard's Yankees Debut 07:10 - Anthony Volpe Defense Comparison 11:45 - Giants Wide Receiver Issues 18:45 - Big Mac Under Fire 24:00 - Brian Cashman Interview Fallout 29:10 - Wordy Interview Questions Debate 34:25 - Press Box Shrimp Incident 39:30 - Twitter Threats and Tattoos 46:20 - Stefon Diggs Joins Commanders 51:30 - Quarterbacks Making Receivers Better 01:00:40 - Wandy Peralta Meeting Rumors 01:06:00 - Yankee Lineup Analysis 01:11:15 - Grading Broadcast Calls 01:31:30 - Ryan Rucco Interview 01:49:30 - Aaron Judge Scan Results 01:55:00 - Return Date Prediction Contest 02:09:40 - WNBA Inclusivity Controversy 02:17:00 - Massage Parlor Street Report 02:35:00 - Old Timers Day Snubs 02:44:00 - Trade Deadline Recap

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze George Lombard Jr.'s impressive first game for the Yankees and debate whether the defensive praise is an overreaction compared to Anthony Volpe's tenure. They also examine the New York Giants' wide receiver depth and address a workplace conflict involving coworkers' criticism of a recent Brian Cashman interview. 01:34 - George Lombard Debut 04:40 - Volpe Defense Debate 08:45 - Giants Receiver Issues 14:20 - Big Mac Under Fire 20:20 - Interview Technique Clash 26:40 - Yankee Fandom Overreactions 32:00 - Press Box Stories 36:35 - Outdoor Entertainment Talk

They evaluate the impact of Stephon Diggs joining the Washington Commanders and debate if the New York Giants missed an opportunity to improve their roster. The discussion turns personal as Craig addresses a listener's criticism regarding his recovery journey and the pair explores a bizarre discovery in the studio trash. Additional segments cover the Yankees' shortstop situation and the Baltimore Ravens' receiver depth. 01:20 - Commanders Sign Stephon Diggs 05:43 - Ravens Wide Receiver Depth 12:04 - Cashman Interview Feedback 16:24 - Art Stapleton and Nightengale 19:38 - George Lombard Jr. Debut 25:22 - The PETA Envelope Mystery 34:18 - Craig Defends His Recovery

Carton and Big Mac investigate reports of a private meeting between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto mediated by Freddy Peralta. They analyze the New York Yankees' batting order and grade various play-by-play calls of George Lombard Jr.'s first career home run. The conversation concludes with an update on Aaron Judge’s injury status and a game to predict his return to the lineup. 01:54 - Peralta Arranges Mets Meeting 09:05 - Yankees Lineup Strategy Debate 16:53 - Comparing Yankees Broadcast Calls 21:56 - Grading Lombard's Historic Homer 36:05 - Ryan Rucco Interview 51:41 - Aaron Judge Scans Update 57:16 - Predicting Judge's Return Date

This segment explores the controversial discussion regarding transgender inclusion in the WNBA and the public pressure on stars like Sophie Cunningham. The focus then shifts to the New York Yankees, highlighting the immediate defensive impact of George Lombard Jr. and a critical look at Brian Cashman’s trade deadline decisions. 01:37 - WNBA Transgender Inclusion Debate 06:20 - Lori's Massage Parlor Encounter 09:10 - Reflecting On Massage Careers 12:34 - Midnight Run Movie Quotes 16:46 - Yankees Cardinals Series Update 19:02 - Anthony Volpe Defense Analysis 24:48 - Brian Cashman Performance Review

Ryan Ruocco of YES Networks joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to discuss his call of George Lombard Jr.'s first home run as a Major League Baseball player for the New York Yankees!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the news that Freddy Peralta brokered peace talks between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto, as Craig is vindicated for his belief that something was afoot between the superstars -- and asks Big Mac how they can move forward.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by Evan Roberts, who explains the strange envelope (and messages) left in the garbage of the studios at WFAN.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the news out of the NFL that Stefon Diggs signed with the Washington Commanders, giving Jayden Daniels another weapon.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle wonder how much longer Anthony Volpe has as a member of the Yankees' organization, with Big Mac saying he'll root for him for as long as he's on the roster. Craig realizes that he's never worked with a worse-dressed group of professionals in his life.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle litigate the levels of excitement that Yankee fans are allowing each other to reach after George Lombard Jr.'s tantalizing debut in the Major Leagues.

Craig Carton asks Chris McMonigle why he interrupted Brian Cashman during their interview on WFAN's The Carton Show, with the duo doling out a final ruling on whether or not Big Mac committed a social faux pas -- or if other hosts are on his case unnecessarily.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Wednesday's show by reacting to George Lombard Jr.'s Major League debut for the Yankees, and questioning just how much the Giants plan to depend on a 33-year-old Odell Beckham Jr. this season. Is Jaxson Dart in trouble?

A day after the smoke cleared, the hosts of WFAN continue to react to the Yankees' handling of the MLB trade deadline. Despite the addition of Luis Garcia Jr., who homered in his first game in The Bronx, the consensus is that Yankees didn't do enough, especially at the catcher position.

Chris McMonigle is not holding back on the Yankees and Brian Cashman's performance at the trade deadline, ripping the GM for only adding Luis Garcia Jr. and Heliot Ramos while AL East rivals like the Red Sox and Rays both beefed up at catcher, New York's biggest need. C-Mac sounds off on what he considers to be Cashman's worst deadline ever, how the Yankees will configure their roster now that Ramos and Garcia are in the fold, and try to make sense of how the Yanks did not add a catcher. News also broke during recording that the Yankees are calling up top prospect George Lombard Jr. and sending down Anthony Volpe and Jasson Dominguez. Plus, reactions to a crushing loss against the Cardinals, the bullpen implosion, and Garcia's instant impact.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS9:48 - Chris goes off on what he calls Brian Cashman's worst trade deadline, perhaps ever. He expresses utter disbelief that the team didn't acquire a starting-caliber catcher or an extra relief pitcher.20:59 - BREAKING NEWS: George Lombard Promoted! Reacting live to a report from Jack Curry, McMonigle breaks the news that prospect George Lombard is being called up to the majors immediately.31:51 - Official word comes down that Anthony Volpe and Jasson Dominguez are being optioned to Triple-A. Chris analyzes what this means for the infield and theorizes that Lombard will take over as the everyday shortstop.41:22 - Was the front office's passive trade deadline dictated by Aaron Judge's injury status?. McMonigle theorizes that the Yankees' lack of aggression signifies they just want to survive until October, rather than overextend themselves for a World Series push now.54:14 - Chris hands out a "D-" grade for the Yankees' trade deadline moves. Despite his deep frustration, he reminds fans that the season isn't over and the team is still positioned for a playoff run.

Craig and Big Mac analyze the Yankees' trade deadline decisions before welcoming General Manager Brian Cashman to the show. They discuss the choice not to overpay for a catcher and the reasoning behind promoting prospect George Lombard to the starting shortstop role. Cashman also provides vital updates on the injury status of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. 01:50 - Yankee Fan Frustrations 06:31 - Cashman's Trade Philosophy 12:34 - Steinbrenner's Absentee Ownership 25:43 - MLB Record Analysis 29:55 - Aaron Judge's Legacy 50:40 - Vincent Pastore Memories 01:15:12 - Brian Cashman Interview

Craig and Big Mac dissect the New York Yankees' inactive trade deadline and the subsequent bullpen collapse against the St. Louis Cardinals. They criticize the decision of team executives to conduct business from Tampa rather than New York City. The conversation also covers Aaron Judge's future legacy and a major shake-up for the Sunday Night Football broadcast team. 01:20 - Yankees Trade Deadline Criticism 06:15 - Cashman's Failure To Pivot 11:15 - Executives Staying In Tampa 18:45 - NFL Studio Crew Changes 25:15 - Brewers Best In Baseball 29:45 - Aaron Judge Legacy Debate 34:15 - Rucco And Sims Calls 41:20 - Rutschman Trade Values

Craig and the team analyze the New York Yankees' decision to call up George Lombard Jr. while sending down Anthony Volpe. They debate Jasson Domínguez's defensive instincts and if Aaron Judge's legacy would diminish if the team wins a title during his injury absence. The conversation shifts to a bizarre theory about Babe Ruth and a critique of Joe Schoen's reputation. 01:20 - George Lombard Jr. Joins Yankees 05:50 - Volpe And Dominguez Career Outlooks 14:04 - Aaron Judge's World Series Legacy 18:22 - Babe Ruth Conspiracy Theories 22:30 - Historic Household Income Debate 29:56 - Yankees Potential Roster Logjam 34:06 - Joe Schoen and Pat Leonard

They analyze Brian Cashman's tenure with the Yankees and debate whether consistent winning seasons justify his job security despite a lack of recent titles. The discussion covers potential Francisco Lindor trade inquiries and how Aaron Judge's absence affects the team's mental performance. Craig also details a bizarre situation where a critic in Ireland is attempting to block his induction into the New Rochelle High School Hall of Fame. 02:04 - Cashman's Yankee Legacy 07:47 - Mets Hiring Cashman Rumors 12:32 - Big Mac Weight Loss Progress 19:15 - Hunter Dobbins' Lying Scandal 23:38 - Fake Sports Career Stories 29:24 - Yankees Athleticism Without Judge 36:03 - Francisco Lindor Trade Talk 46:30 - Press Box Etiquette Debate 57:00 - Craig's New Rochelle Hall Drama

Craig and Big Mac interview Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman to analyze the team's strategy following the trade deadline. They discuss why the organization did not acquire a new catcher or reliever, the promotion of George Lombard Jr., and the decision to demote Anthony Volpe. The segment also covers crucial health updates regarding Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. 01:20 - Diddy Party Discussion 04:55 - Cashman Legacy Argument 10:46 - Boston COVID Misery 14:00 - Remembering Vincent Pastore 19:24 - Brian Cashman Interview 30:35 - George Lombard Jr. Promotion 44:44 - Anthony Volpe Demotion 49:43 - Yankees Trade Targets

New York Yankees GM Brian Cashman joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN's Carton Show to explain the Yankees' controversial trade deadline decisions. Cashman discusses why the Yankees couldn't land Orioles star catcher Adley Rutschman, the challenges of finding bullpen help, and why the organization decided the asking prices were too high. He also gives updates on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton's injuries, explains the decision to call up George Lombard Jr. and send Anthony Volpe to Triple-A, and responds to criticism that the Yankees lacked urgency at the deadline.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle explore the strange world of athletes and media personalities who fabricate their sports resumes. They share stories of a Red Sox prospect's family lies and why humoring children in backyard basketball isn't doing them any favors. 01:01 - Brian Cashman Critique 02:45 - Humbling Kids in Sports 05:50 - Disgusting Gym Incidents 08:09 - Hunter Dobbins Story 11:05 - Exposing Resume Lies

How long can Brian Cashman remain the Yankees’ decision-maker if the team keeps falling short of October glory? Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton debate whether the Yankees have reached the ceiling with Cashman as GM and if the organization needs a fresh voice to finally get back to the World Series.

The Yankees may have left fans frustrated after the trade deadline, but did Brian Cashman quietly build a better roster? Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down Luis Garcia’s impact, Aaron Judge’s uncertain return, Giancarlo Stanton getting closer, and the biggest problem facing the Yankees if everyone gets healthy: too many bats and not enough spots. The guys debate where Jazz Chisholm, Garcia, Judge, Stanton, and the rest of the lineup fit together, whether the Yankees know something they aren’t telling fans, and why the future of this roster could create a major logjam.

The Yankees looked dead in the water… until Luis Garcia delivered a huge moment in the Bronx. But after Brian Cashman stood mostly pat at the trade deadline, the bullpen collapsed and the Yankees suffered a brutal loss. Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down the Yankees’ deadline decisions, Garcia’s dramatic home run, the calls from Ryan Ruocco and Dave Sims, and whether Yankee fans have a right to be frustrated with Cashman. Plus, the guys debate if George Lombard Jr. is ready to take over as the future at shortstop.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the promotion of top prospect George Lombard Jr. and the shocking demotion of Anthony Volpe. Is this the end of Volpe's time in pinstripes, or can he fight his way back?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle tackle one of the biggest "what ifs" in Yankees history. Would a championship without their captain permanently change how Aaron Judge is remembered in the Bronx?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Brian Cashman completely failed at the deadline or if Yankees fans are overreacting. Did Cashman miss a golden opportunity to add a catcher and bullpen help, or are fans acting like the season is already over?

Chris McMonigle reacts to all the latest trade deadline drama, including the Yankees parting with four prospects for Nationals slugger Luis Garcia Jr. C-Mac gives his thoughts on the move and where Garcia will fit when/if the Yanks are fully healthy. Plus, reactions to the Camilo Doval trade, Tarik Skubal to the Dodgers and what it means for baseball moving forward, and breaking down the Yankees taking a series from the Cubs in Chicago despite the offense continuing to struggle.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS6:20 - Reacting to the Yankees trading for Luis Garcia Jr., who boasts the highest slugging percentage in the National League. Is he a perfect positional fit? No, but the offense desperately needed his bat.19:50 - Breaking down Bob Nightengale's report that the Padres rejected a deal sending Will Warren to San Diego for rental reliever Adrian Morejon.28:10 - An honest, frustrating look at Jazz Chisholm's terrible at-bats, his constant swinging and missing at breaking balls in the dirt, and why his struggles are a huge problem for the team right now.33:30 - McMonigle goes off on the Brewers, Rays, and the rest of the league for letting the Dodgers swoop in and trade for Tarik Skubal without putting up a real fight.46:00 - Calling out the Toronto Blue Jays as absolute "frauds" for selling off ace Kevin Gausman to the Cubs after claiming they had built a championship-caliber roster.49:25 - Exploring the Yankees' dire need for a catcher, looking at the numbers for potential targets like Tyler Stephenson and Adley Rutschman.54:25 - A breakdown of the excellent starting pitching against Chicago, featuring Will Warren, Max Fried, and Gerrit Cole. Plus, why Spencer Jones needs to play every day and why Jasson Dominguez is struggling in the outfield.

Carton and Big Mac react to a quiet trade deadline for the Yankees that left the organization without a new starting catcher or bullpen depth. They debate the acquisition of Luis Garcia Jr. and express deep concern over divisional rivals like the Red Sox and Rays making aggressive moves to improve. 01:45 - Yankees Trade Deadline Panic 05:55 - Luis Garcia Hitting Debate 17:40 - Dodgers Massive Spending Advantage 24:35 - Yankees Catching Search Crisis 36:40 - Bizarre Dodgers First Pitch 48:10 - Mets Sell Luke Weaver 59:15 - Red Sox Acquire Rutschman 01:13:35 - Official Yankees Lineup Revealed 01:23:30 - Final Trade Deadline Reaction 01:28:15 - Big Mac Slams Cashman

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' lack of movement as the MLB trade deadline approaches while rivals secure key players. They debate the Dodgers' aggressive spending habits and the Detroit Tigers' decision to move Tarik Skubal. The segment wraps up with a humorous look at Big Mac's interview style during a recent conversation with Jaxson Dart. 01:20 - Yankees Trade Deadline Panic 05:10 - Best Hitter Acquisition Debate 09:35 - Assessing Brian Cashman's Strategy 17:00 - Dodgers Aggressive Deadline Moves 22:14 - Rival Catcher Deals Official 28:00 - Big Mac's Interviewing Style

Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss a bizarre Dodgers first pitch ceremony involving the children of murder victims on the Carton Show. They critique the Yankees' lack of activity at the MLB trade deadline while analyzing rumors of a massive overpay by the Red Sox for a catcher. The segment transitions into a debate over American flag etiquette and proper behavior during the broadcast. 01:20 - Weird Dodgers First Pitch 05:30 - Privacy After Family Tragedy 09:41 - MLB Trade Deadline Frenzy 13:15 - Yankees Catcher Search Crisis 17:15 - Rutschman Trade Overpay 22:50 - American League Outlook 37:54 - Final Hour Trade Countdown 41:43 - Red Sox Trade Evaluation 46:12 - Trade Deadline Final Countdown 50:42 - Show Etiquette Discussion

Craig and Big Mac analyze the frantic final hours of the MLB trade deadline as the Yankees struggle to find an offensive spark. They discuss the Red Sox rising threat in the AL East and react to breaking news of the New York Mets trading Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor to the Chicago Cubs. 01:25 - Yankee Fan Hysteria 06:40 - Interacting With Fans 11:45 - Private Support Offer 15:15 - Rutschman Joins Red Sox 19:45 - Scoring Run Stats 26:00 - Yankees Versus Rays 30:05 - Lineup Speculation 34:50 - Aaron Judge Health 38:05 - Mets Fan Frustration 45:10 - Holmes Cubs Trade

Craig and Big Mac breakdown the closing moments of the MLB trade deadline as the Yankees finalize a deal for Heliot Ramos. Big Mac delivers a scathing review of Brian Cashman’s performance, labeling the lack of a catcher acquisition as "malpractice" for a championship contender. They also take calls on the Mets' rebuild and discuss the Giants' offensive struggles during training camp. 01:20 - Deadline Deals Recap 05:31 - Skepticism of David Stearns 09:21 - Heliot Ramos Trade Finalized 12:47 - Steinbrenner Legacy Debate 18:56 - Giants Training Camp Report 24:00 - Evaluating Brian Cashman's Tenure 28:37 - Adley Rutschman Trade Analysis 36:14 - World Series Odds Reaction

Craig and Big Mac react to breaking news of the Mets trading Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor to the Chicago Cubs for prospect Jefferson Rojas. They also evaluate the Yankees' urgent need for an impact catcher and the potential timeline for Aaron Judge's return to the lineup. 01:00 - Yankee Catcher Search 03:35 - Judge Return Timeline 07:58 - Mets Roster Discussion 12:36 - Clay Holmes Trade 16:13 - Trade Deadline Stress

Emmanuel Berbari Tells Hoff why the Yankees are still live in the American League and how the Bombers can with the deadline

C-Mac is sweating bullets as the Yankees continue searching for a catcher with the clock ticking. The guys debate whether Aaron Judge can return in time for the playoffs, how many at-bats he needs to get ready, and whether the Yankees have done enough to become a true World Series contender.

The Yankees are running out of time before the MLB Trade Deadline, and Chris McMonigle is NOT happy. On this segment of The Carton Show on WFAN, C-Mac breaks down why Brian Cashman must land a legitimate starting catcher and bullpen help — or risk what he calls a historic failure. Craig Carton and C-Mac debate the blockbuster Adley Rutschman trade, whether the Red Sox overpaid, and why giving up three top prospects might be too steep for the Yankees. Plus, the guys discuss the Mets making moves, Luke Weaver heading to Pittsburgh, and the pressure mounting on the Bronx Bombers with the clock ticking.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Dodgers inviting Rob Reiner's children to throw out the ceremonial first pitch following their family's tragic story, with Craig questioning whether the moment was appropriate while Chris sees it as a chance to move forward.

Discussion focuses on the New York Yankees' approach to the trade deadline and how their activity might signal the status of Aaron Judge's health. They analyze recent roster moves and debate the necessity of acquiring a catcher and additional right-handed bats to compete in a wide-open American League. 01:00 - Brewers and Yankees Trade News 02:22 - Ben Rice Trade Debate 06:16 - Judge Injury and Deadline Strategy

With the Red Sox officially landing Adley Rutschman and the Rays already upgrading behind the plate, McMonigle sounds the alarm on the Yankees' trade deadline. If Brian Cashman doesn't land a catcher before the clock hits zero, is this deadline an outright disaster? Craig Carton pushes back, keeps the laughs coming, and even takes time to roast McMonigle over one of the longest interview questions in WFAN history!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether the rest of Major League Baseball should be embarrassed after Los Angeles landed Tarik Skubal and kept adding talent at the trade deadline. Is the Dodgers' spending unfair... or should the Yankees and Mets be doing the exact same thing? The guys also break down Brian Cashman's biggest challenge, why the Yankees MUST add a catcher before the deadline, whether Mason Miller would be enough, and why standing pat could waste one of baseball's best pitching staffs.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react LIVE as the Yankees watch catcher after catcher come off the trade market while division rivals make big moves. Are Brian Cashman and the Yankees running out of options? Is Tyler Stephenson now the last realistic answer behind the plate?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate over the potential impact John Harbaugh will have on the Giants. Plus, reaction to Malik Nabers starting camp completely off the PUP list (23:55); Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash on if it’s playoffs or bust for the Giants (32:30); Evan argues the Giants should sign Vita Vea (50:03)

Tiki Barber is already putting Geno Smith on notice, declaring that Cade Klubnik should get the QB1 if he outplays the veteran in training camp and the preseason. Plus, Evan and Tiki can already see the Jets' use of AI going hilariously wrong. Boomer and Gio wonder if Aaron Glenn's job is tied to how Geno performs this season, and The Carton Show reacts to Plaxico Burress comparing playing for the Jets to being in prison.

Gregg Giannotti has had enough of the Aaron Boone criticism when it is never followed by any kind of praise. He says Boone's critics who also rip the Yankees' use of analytics need to be consistent in their arguments. Plus, Evan Roberts says vintage Gerrit Cole has returned, and the rest of the American League should be scared. Chris McMonigle calls for Brian Cashman to stack the deck with pitching if there isn't a significant bat available at the trade deadline, and Boomer and Gio wonder why Boone doesn't have better odds to win Manager of the Year.

Chris McMonigle is talking all things trade deadline, addressing the Yankees' biggest needs, where they can realistically upgrade the roster, C-Mac's most desired trade targets, and who the Yankees could ship out before the deadline. Plus, reactions to the final two games of the White Sox series, from Ali Sanchez's inexplicable gaffe to the Yankees' continued struggles in extra innings, and the team's offensive struggles that do not seem to be going away.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS3:00 - Defending Aaron Boone and why manager accountability won't fix major mental errors.12:00 - Breaking down the disastrous third game of this series, perhaps the worst loss of the season23:00 - Analyzing the inexplicable Ali Sanchez decision to throw to third with two outs and the terrible execution of spiking the ball.28:50 - Weathers pitches seven shutout innings, but the offense stays ice cold in game four.32:00 - Baserunning issues continue with Jasson Dominguez sliding past the bag and Jazz Chisholm getting picked off on an aggressive first move. 39:46 - Shill or Shame Segment: Handing out praise and blame for the series.43:50 - What the Yankees absolutely must acquire at the trade deadline to survive until their injured stars return.

The Yankees are halfway to a four-game sweep in Chicago, and Chris McMonigle is back to break down the first two games of the series, including Gerrit Cole's six scoreless innings on Tuesday night. C-Mac covers all the hot topics in Yankees Universe, from Anthony Volpe's dropped pop-up in game one to the continued optimism coming from the bullpen. Plus, all the latest trade deadline rumors and where the Yankees will have the best chance to upgrade the team.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS7:33 - Analyzing Max Fried's start, a rocky first inning plagued by sloppy defense, and the offense battling back from a 3-0 deficit.18:18 - An honest conversation about Volpe's dropped pop-up, his overall defensive abilities compared to Caballero, and his improved on-base percentage.25:26 - Cole throws six scoreless innings with seven strikeouts, successfully navigating a difficult 30-pitch fourth inning.37:36 - Giving much-needed credit to the back end of the bullpen, specifically highlighting the reliability of Headrick and Chivilli.40:35 - Why Bednar's workload is a concern and why Mason Miller is the ultimate prize for Brian Cashman.50:28 - Exploring alternative options if the Miller trade falls through, including Marlins catcher Liam Hicks and Mets outfielder Tyrone Taylor.

Craig and Big Mac sit down with Mets legend Mookie Wilson to celebrate the 40th anniversary of the 1986 World Series and his friendship with Bill Buckner. They also break down positive training camp footage of Malik Nabors and debate whether John Harbaugh is an upgrade over Brian Daboll for the Giants. Additionally, the discussion covers the Yankees' trade deadline needs and a potential new stadium location for the Jets. 01:54 - Romo and Shanahan Videos 06:45 - John Harbaugh Debate 16:12 - Robert Saleh Predictions 27:20 - Mookie Wilson Interview 30:41 - Malik Nabors Update 34:49 - Jets Stadium Rumors 45:24 - Gotham App DAZN Move 53:45 - Eagles History Trivia

Craig and Big Mac dive into a heated debate regarding whether John Harbaugh is truly an upgrade for the New York Giants or simply a coach who benefited from elite talent. They analyze his fourth-quarter track record and compare his recent struggles to Brian Daboll’s tenure. The discussion also covers Robert Saleh’s bold predictions for the Jets and the mysterious lack of body cam footage from Kyle Shanahan's car accident. 01:20 - Tony Romo DUI Video 05:05 - Radio Advice For Morash 09:45 - Harbaugh Blown Leads Debate 14:15 - Giants Franchise Embarrassment 17:25 - Robert Saleh Jets Prediction 20:30 - Caller Defends Harbaugh 26:00 - Coaching vs Player Talent 32:15 - LeBron James Bar Ban 38:40 - Giants Roster Breakdown 45:05 - Pass Rush Expectations

Mookie Wilson joins to discuss the legacy of the 1986 World Series and details his legendary Game 6 at-bat. He shares stories about his deep friendship with the late Bill Buckner and the unique chemistry of that championship squad. The conversation also covers Malik Nabors returning to practice for the Giants and the Jets' season expectations. 01:20 - Heidi Klum's Chip Brand 04:25 - Mookie Wilson Joins 08:10 - Game 6 Breakdown 18:00 - Friendship With Bill Buckner 26:30 - Mets Team Chemistry 30:15 - Malik Nabors Practice Update 40:40 - Jets Season Outlook 46:55 - Gotham App Joins DAZN

Craig and C-Mac analyze the hypothetical impact of Robert Saleh and Brian Daboll teaming up in Tennessee, debating if they could turn the Titans into a defensive juggernaut. They also delve into sports history, discussing infamous sign-stealing rumors from 1951 and the unfair legacies of Bill Buckner and Ralph Branca. 01:48 - Robert Saleh Coaching Future 06:42 - Gilligan's Island Debate 12:47 - Snow White Casting Controversy 15:47 - Branca and Buckner Legacies 25:24 - 1951 Sign-Stealing Rumors 34:30 - College Sports Profitability 46:16 - Saleh vs Gase Analysis 56:07 - Starting Lineup Figurines

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze Malik Nabers' health at training camp and debate the potential for the Jets to relocate to the Aqueduct Racetrack site in Queens. They test an intern's knowledge of Eagles history with a trivia question about 4,000-yard passing seasons. The discussion concludes with a deep dive into the Yankees' trade deadline needs and Aaron Boone's recent management success. 01:25 - Malik Nabers Impresses at Camp 06:01 - Potential Jets Move to Aqueduct 16:15 - Nashville Travel and App Issues 23:15 - Eagles QB Yardage Trivia Challenge 34:50 - Yankees Success Under Aaron Boone 45:15 - John Harbaugh and Giants' Future 51:00 - Yankees Trade Deadline Strategy

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle jump right into the fire on this segment of WFAN's The Carton Show, defending Robert Saleh against critical callers while breaking down NFL Training Camp hype, hilarious history debates, and unique fan memorabilia!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle are back breaking down a wild start to NFL Training Camp! The guys kick things off reacting to the massive relief of seeing Malik Nabers completely off the PUP list and looking electric at Giants camp. Then, things get crazy in Minnesota as reports surface of Kyler Murray and J.J. McCarthy throwing hands after a camp interception. Is competition boiling over, or is this a disaster for the Vikings? Finally, they take a call from Stevie on Long Island to debate the future of Big Blue. Is the John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart era enough to wash the 15-year "stink" off the Giants organization, or is it going to take a lot more than coaching to get back to winning? Plus, a quick shoutout to Lil Wayne and French Montana killing it in Bangor, Maine!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle dive into the wild world of college sports economics on this segment of WFAN's The Carton Show! The guys break down the staggering financial numbers from Penn State's athletic department. While the Penn State football team raked in a massive $58 million net operating profit, the athletic department as a whole only walked away with a net profit of $223,000!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle are back on WFAN with a wildly entertaining segment of The Carton Show!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle bring the heat to WFAN! In this segment, the guys talk New York Jets expectations, Yankees trade deadline moves, and a major shakeup for local sports streaming. Plus, Craig interrogates C-Mac about his parenting rules for an upcoming Disney cruise.

Forty years later, Mookie Wilson takes Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle behind the scenes of one of the greatest moments in baseball history. From his unforgettable Game 6 at-bat against the Red Sox to his emotional friendship with Bill Buckner, Mookie shares stories Mets fans have never heard. He also reflects on the chemistry that made the 1986 Mets champions, why today's Mets are falling short, and what this year's 40th anniversary celebration means. Don't miss one of the best baseball interviews you'll hear all year. 🔹 Mookie Wilson relives Game 6 pitch-by-pitch 🔹 The truth about Bill Buckner and their friendship 🔹 Why the 1986 Mets' chemistry was so special 🔹 Thoughts on the current Mets' disappointing season 🔹 Behind-the-scenes stories from the legendary championship team

The John Harbaugh debate reaches another level. Craig Carton doubles down on his controversial take that Giants fans are overrating their new head coach, while Chris McMonigle passionately defends Harbaugh's winning résumé. The two go back and forth over playoff expectations, Lamar Jackson, Joe Flacco, Brian Daboll, and whether Giants fans are setting themselves up for disappointment.

After setting Giants fans on fire, Carton doubles down on his claim that John Harbaugh is the most overrated coach in the NFL. Chris McMonigle pushes back, callers defend Harbaugh's résumé, and the debate quickly turns into one of the hottest Giants conversations of training camp.

They evaluate the Giants' chances of reaching the postseason and compare the leadership of Brian Daboll and John Harbaugh. The conversation also covers Plaxico Burris's viral comments comparing his time with the Jets to prison and the reporting surrounding Kyle Shanahan's recent car accident. 02:15 - Giants Playoff Expectations 10:35 - Plaxico Burris Slams Jets 18:20 - David Bailey Draft Critique 23:45 - Dice Clay Comedy Talk 30:25 - Harbaugh Leadership Debate 34:15 - Shanahan Accident Mystery 19:40 - Baywatch Casting Comparisons 27:15 - Pornography Movie Parody Titles 32:10 - Anthony Volpe Error Analysis 35:20 - Yankees Mets Trade Rumors

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to former wide receiver Plaxico Burris comparing his time with the New York Jets to serving a prison sentence. They also debate whether the New York Giants can replicate recent historic playoff turnarounds and revisit Carton’s awkward run-in with movie critic Rex Reed. 01:20 - NFL Playoff Turnaround History 05:00 - Giants Postseason Expectations Debate 11:35 - Plaxico Burris Slams Jets 15:30 - Jets Loser Culture Discussion 19:45 - Jets Draft Selection Critique 23:35 - Long Island Roadway Rant 27:35 - Carton Syracuse Career Story 32:00 - Port Jefferson Ferry Controversy 37:30 - Movie Review Discussion 42:30 - Famous Critic Encounter Story

The hosts engage in a spirited debate over whether John Harbaugh is truly an upgrade over Brian Daboll for the Giants, citing Harbaugh's history of blown leads. They also investigate the reported media blackout and alleged cover-up surrounding Kyle Shanahan's recent serious car accident. 01:20 - Andrew Dice Clay Discussion 04:53 - Sebastian Maniscalco Comedy Repetition 06:18 - John Harbaugh Blown Leads 13:43 - Harbaugh vs Daboll Debate 19:32 - Ravens Playoff Underachievement 24:02 - Giants Playoff Expectations 30:20 - Hypothetical Play-By-Play Call 31:10 - Kyle Shanahan Accident Cover-Up 37:25 - Media Ethics and Insiders 43:40 - Shanahan Responsibility and Fault

On The Carton Show, Carton and C-Mac explore the disparity in media coverage regarding Kyle Shanahan’s unreported car accident versus minor infractions by players like Geno Smith. They revisit a past confrontation with PETA over a show 'meat draft' involving a cow named Mookie before debating the proper etiquette for concert guests like Bruce Springsteen and Pat Monahan. The discussion also covers the Yankees' messy victory over the White Sox and rumors surrounding LeBron James and the Tyrese Maxey led 76ers. 01:22 - Livvy Dunne Vs Brooks Nader 06:45 - Evolution Of Adult Entertainment 11:50 - Kyle Shanahan Accident Reporting 18:08 - PETA Meat Draft Battle 27:15 - Psychology Of Personal Prayers 31:28 - Anthony Volpe Sloppy Error 36:15 - Springsteen Bon Jovi Duet 49:02 - LeBron James Sixers Rumors

The discussion kicks off with a lively debate about the vocal prowess and versatility of Pink compared to other legendary performers like Adele, Whitney Houston, and Taylor Swift. The conversation then shifts to the MLB trade deadline, exploring potential moves for the Yankees, including interests in Mason Miller and Tyrone Taylor. 01:00 - Pink Debate 09:51 - Yankees Trade Rumors 16:35 - Intern Joe Farewell

The Yankees escaped with a wild win, but Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle aren’t letting them off easy. The guys break down Anthony Volpe’s bizarre night, sloppy defense, the bullpen’s heroics, and how the Yankees managed to stay in the playoff race despite plenty of mistakes. Meanwhile, the Mets continue to fall down the New York sports priority list as Craig jokes they could be “relegated to the tablet” while the Yankees, Red Sox, and even Rays take over the spotlight.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the controversy surrounding Kyle Shanahan’s reported car accident and question why the story wasn’t immediately reported. The guys debate whether public figures deserve privacy or if major incidents involving NFL coaches and stars are automatically newsworthy.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle revisit one of the wildest moments from the show — the legendary “meat draft” and Craig’s beef with PETA after buying an entire cow. Would you trade a cow for 1,500 pounds of vegetarian alternatives? Craig explains why he said absolutely not. The guys also debate the greatest cuts of steak, including the legendary spinalis/deckle, ribeye, skirt steak, and whether a tomahawk steak is overrated. Plus, Craig and Big Mac dive into sports rivalries, biblical trivia, prayer, and more hilarious conversations from The Carton Show on WFAN.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into one of the strangest NFL stories of the offseason, questioning why news of Shanahan's serious car accident stayed quiet for weeks. The guys debate whether reporters should protect sources, the ethics of breaking news, and whether a bigger story is still waiting to come out.

The discussion focuses on the mysterious 11-day media silence following Kyle Shanahan’s severe car accident and reports of a potential cover-up by police. They examine why journalists and insiders like Chris Simms withheld information out of personal friendship until the San Francisco 49ers officially disclosed the crash. Finally, they cover Shanahan's press conference where he took full responsibility for the distracted driving incident. 01:07 - Kyle Shanahan Accident Details 02:39 - Alleged Media Blackout Discussion 07:32 - Chris Simms Friendship Conflict 11:31 - Shanahan Admits Fault Publicly 15:12 - Pool Noodle Safety Hack

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get into a heated debate over the Giants' future, with Carton making the shocking case that Harbaugh may be one of the NFL's most overrated coaches. The guys break down Baltimore's late-game collapses, Lamar Jackson's playoff shortcomings, Brian Daboll's tenure, and what Giants fans should realistically expect in 2026.

From crazy New York weather, the Long Island-to-Connecticut ferry debate, and movie nostalgia to Craig's unbelievable story about legendary film critic Rex Reed hitting on him after the Ghostbusters II premiere, this segment has it all. Plus, the guys rank classic movies, debate Ghostbusters, The Pacifier, Beverly Hills Cop, and preview the Giants' expectations heading into training camp.

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' path to the playoffs and the evolution of Jaxson Dart. They also react to Plaxico Burress's viral comparison between his time with the New York Jets and his prison sentence. Additionally, the conversation turns to a heated debate over Jets rookie David Bailey and local geography. 01:00 - Giants Playoff Potential 09:48 - Plaxico Burress Viral Comments 18:10 - Jets David Bailey Debate 23:23 - Long Island Geography Banter

WFAN hosts break down LeBron James’ shocking decision to sign with the Philadelphia 76ers, debating whether this new Eastern Conference superteam actually poses a threat to the Knicks or is destined for an epic collapse. Plus, the crew reacts to wild reports that LeBron plans to live in New York City and commute to Philly home games by helicopter.

Will Warren and the Yankees were hammered by the Phillies on Sunday night, losing their chance of a three-game sweep. A fired-up Chris McMonigle reacts to the series finale, Warren's continued struggles, Jose Caballero's diminishing value, Cody Bellinger's hamstring injury, and the series as a whole, including Cam Schlittler's dominating outing in the series opener. Plus, more trade deadline talk and what moves will help the Yanks regain control of the AL East.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS6:41 - Reacting to Bellinger heading to the 10-day IL and how devastating it is for a lineup already missing Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.14:18 - Comparing Anthony Volpe's hot bat to Caballero's struggles, and why playing Amed Rosario isn't working right now.22:04 - Breaking down Cam Schlittler's masterpiece and his vastly improved curveball.27:10 - Praising the elite back-end of the bullpen, which Chris says has become one of the best in baseball.45:11 - Chris vents about the umpires targeting Caballero with pitch clock rules and a ridiculous "intentional drop" call.54:02 - Reacting to the series finale and Will Warren getting lit up again.1:05:03 - Debating if the Yankees should call up red-hot prospect George Lombard after the trade deadline passes.1:09:51 - Shill or Shame Segment1:13:11 - Discussing Matt Blake's impact, the steep asking price for Mason Miller, and whether the Yankees should trade for George Springer.1:29:04 - Looking ahead to the four-game series in Chicago and setting up Thursday's trade deadline deep-dive episode.

Hoff chats with Anthony DiComo about the Mets ahead of the trade deadline.

McMonigle breaks down the devastating injury news for the New York Yankees and explores how Cody Bellinger's absence shifts their trade deadline priorities. He weighs the benefits of adding stars like Mason Miller or Luis Arraez against the current lineup's offensive struggles. The segment also features insights on LeBron James joining the 76ers, the New York Giants' cultural overhaul, and the superstitious polo curse. 01:50 - McMonigle Solo Intro 06:45 - Yankees Pitching Dominance 11:50 - Brian Cashman Strategy 17:10 - Postseason Hitting Concerns 21:43 - Music Banter Segment 26:30 - Bills Uniform Outrage 31:42 - LeBron 76ers Move 36:15 - Knicks Rivalry Discussion 41:20 - Mets Fan Call 26:35 - Mets Movie Controversy 31:55 - Francisco Lindor Rumors 18:15 - Giants Coaching Hopes 25:55 - Berbari Joins Show 31:45 - The Polo Curse 41:15 - Final Injury Update

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' trade deadline needs, suggesting that elite arms like Tarik Skubal or Mason Miller might be more valuable than minor offensive tweaks. He debates with callers about the team's struggling lineup and upcoming stars while also finding time to joke about the Red Hot Chili Peppers. 01:20 - Yankees Series Recap 05:15 - Trade Deadline Strategy 21:06 - Red Hot Chili Peppers 24:45 - Elite Pitching Targets 31:30 - Fan Reaction Segment 43:00 - Sports News Update

McMonigle reacts to the Buffalo Bills' widely criticized new uniforms and Mike Vrabel’s clever use of a puppy to disarm the media. They also break down the New York Yankees' trade deadline strategy, debating whether the team should prioritize a dominant rotation or offensive upgrades like Luis Arraez. 01:20 - Bills Uniform Criticism 05:15 - Vrabel's Puppy Presser 10:53 - Host Dog Allergy Stories 17:06 - Yankees Trade Deadline Strategy 31:14 - LeBron's 76ers New York Connection 41:00 - Craig's Bizarre Candy Preferences 46:49 - Machado And Yankees Trades

McMonigle argues that the Yankees should aggressively target Tyrone Taylor from the Mets and explore a deal for George Springer to bolster their outfield. He also evaluates the potential for a defensive turnaround for the Giants, specifically focusing on the development of Deonte Banks. Additionally, callers debate the roster value of contact hitters like Luis Arraez versus high-impact power threats. 01:20 - Tommy's Virtual Team 02:35 - Yankees Deadline Strategy 10:26 - Catching Offensive Value 15:14 - Arraez vs Devers 19:28 - Giants Defensive Changes 22:37 - Deonte Banks' Development 31:42 - Proposed Yankee Trades 40:03 - Evaluating Young Prospects

Chris McMonigle analyzes the Mets' disappointing season and the indifference of the fan base following Juan Soto's injury. He is later joined by Emmanuel Berbari to discuss Cody Bellinger's Grade 2 hamstring strain, which leaves the Yankees' offense in a vulnerable position. They also debate the future of the Giants and the potential for a George Lombard Jr. promotion. 01:20 - Mets Indifference Discussion 06:05 - Selling The Mets Core 13:47 - Giants Playoff Potential Debate 25:44 - Knicks vs Sixers Rivalry 29:44 - Yankees Offensive Lineup Crisis 42:46 - Bellinger’s Hamstring Injury Update 49:39 - George Lombard Jr Promotion

C-Mac and Emmanuel Berbari evaluate the Yankees' outlook following news of Cody Bellinger’s hamstring injury. They explore high-profile trade targets like Manny Machado and Mason Miller while debating Anthony Volpe's position in the long-term roster. The duo also addresses a caller’s frustration and a bizarre superstition involving a lost polo at the stadium. 01:29 - Cody Bellinger Hamstring Injury 05:06 - Yankees Trade Deadline Scenarios 15:58 - Jose Caballero Umpire Controversy 24:54 - Championship Expectations vs. Mets 31:38 - Massive Manny Machado Proposal 37:11 - C-Mac's Lost Polo Superstition

On this segment of The Carton Show on WFAN, Chris McMonigle flies solo and is joined by Emmanuel Berbari to react to some devastating injury news for the New York Yankees: Cody Bellinger has suffered a Grade 2 hamstring strain and will be sidelined for 4 to 6 weeks. The guys discuss how this major blow alters Brian Cashman's strategy with the trade deadline exactly a week away. With Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and now Bellinger all sidelined, Chris and Emmanuel dive into potential deadline pivots. They debate whether the Yankees should go all-in for Oakland's star reliever Mason Miller, the hesitation around calling up or trading top prospect George Lombard Jr., and what to expect from Max Fried as he takes the mound against the White Sox tonight.

Chris McMonigle evaluates the New York Giants' roster and the influence of the coaching staff on struggling players like Deonte Banks. He considers how specific scheme changes might revitalize the defense before pivoting to the New York Yankees' strategy. The discussion focuses on potential acquisitions such as Luis Arraez and Jazz Chisholm Jr. to provide a much-needed spark to the lineup. 01:01 - Giants Coaching Impact 05:25 - Deonte Banks' Potential Turnaround 11:49 - Yankees Trade Deadline Discussion 21:37 - Valuing Yankees Trade Pieces

With Cody Bellinger on the IL and the trade deadline rapidly approaching, Chris McMonigle says the Yankees can't afford to wait. On this episode of The Carton Show, Chris identifies Tyrone Taylor of the Mets and George Springer of the Blue Jays as two realistic trade targets who could immediately improve the Yankees' lineup and defense without costing the organization its top prospects.

Chris McMonigle goes completely off the rails in this hilarious segment from The Carton Show on WFAN!

CMac explores the potential impact of LeBron James joining the 76ers and how his residence in New York might fuel a new rivalry with the Knicks. He also breaks down various trade possibilities for the Yankees, debating whether high-priced stars like Manny Machado are worth the long-term risk. Additionally, they discuss personal sports memories and upcoming shifts in the Giants' defensive coaching. 01:26 - LeBron James and Sixers Rivalry 08:23 - Childhood Fandoms and Quirks 12:00 - Yankees Search for Offense 15:01 - Evaluating Machado Trade Scenarios 20:36 - Giants DC and Injury Updates

McMonigle evaluates the New York Yankees' trade deadline strategy, arguing that building a dominant starting rotation is more impactful than marginal offensive upgrades. He reviews Brian Cashman's history with prospects and the potential for a World Series run if they acquire top-tier talent like Tarik Skubal. The discussion shifts to childhood stories about pets and speculation regarding the next manager of the New York Mets. 01:00 - Phone Calls and Banter 02:28 - Yankees Trade Deadline Strategy 10:14 - Pets and Mets Talk

Should the Yankees stop trying to patch every hole on the roster and swing for one franchise-changing move? Chris McMonigle says too many Yankees fans are obsessed with adding bats at the trade deadline. Instead, he argues Brian Cashman should be willing to overpay for a true difference-maker, whether it's Tarik Skubal, Mason Miller, CJ Abrams, or Hunter Goodman, instead of making several smaller moves that only marginally improve the roster.

The Yankees' offense continues to struggle, Cody Bellinger lands on the IL, and the trade deadline is just days away. But Chris McMonigle says Brian Cashman shouldn't panic and overpay for average hitters.

Evan Roberts and TikI Barber discuss if John Harbaugh has restored Giants pride. Plus, Gregg Giannotti and Boomer Esiason discuss the hope around the G-Men this year; Gio and Jerry Recco on if the Giants are capable of winning 10 games this season; Evan and Shaun Morash discuss Malik Nabers avoiding the PUP list; Craig Carton and Willie Colon on Cam Skatteboo.

Boomer Esiason has doubled down on his stance that the Mets need to trade Francisco Lindor, and wonders if the shortstop still wants to be in Queens. Plus, the Evan and Tiki crew relate to the SNY announcers, who can't seem to help themselves when it comes to criticizing the putrid Mets. Bobby Valentine joined Craig Carton to discuss what this team needs to do to get things turned around, and Evan explains why he would cheer for Edwin Diaz when he returns to Queens this weekend.

Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash agree that it is time for the Yankees to call up George Lombard Jr., and it should be done ASAP. Plus, Jim Leyritz joined The Carton Show and went off on the use of analytics and AI in baseball today, and why the Yanks should go get Rafael Devers. Evan and Tiki debate if it would be worth it for the Yankees to take on a bad Padres contract if it meant getting Mason Miller, and Craig Carton believes Jazz Chisholm is a misunderstood player who will be vital to the team's title chances.

Craig and Big Mac react to the shocking news of LeBron James signing with the Philadelphia 76ers, debating if he can realistically challenge the Knicks in the East. They break down Tony Romo’s recent DUI arrest and discuss how it might impact his lucrative CBS broadcasting contract. The conversation also features a nostalgic look at Howard Cosell's career and a competitive chicken-themed edition of the Wednesday Wheel. 01:50 - LeBron Joins 76ers 06:45 - Knicks Roster Depth 11:45 - King James Day 16:40 - Philadelphia Fan Backlash 27:35 - Sixers Roster Weakness 31:40 - LeBron Luka Comparison 35:00 - Ego Management Issues 40:45 - Tony Romo DUI 46:30 - Host Jersey Ban 25:05 - LeBron Proclamation Pathetic 29:35 - Philadelphia Sports Identity 34:40 - Superstars Hanging On 38:05 - Radio Ratings Success 41:50 - Gunnison Beach Stories 24:00 - Yankees Phillies Series 29:35 - Topless Beach Tales 34:10 - Broadcaster Morals Clause 40:35 - Madden Cosell Legacies 27:45 - Wheel Philly Category 33:00 - Chicken Dish Debate

Craig and Big Mac break down LeBron James' move to the Philadelphia 76ers and why they believe it won't dethrone the defending champion New York Knicks. They analyze the Sixers' roster construction, debate historic NBA rivalries, and react to news involving Tony Romo and studio dress code changes. 01:20 - LeBron Joins Sixers 04:53 - Sixers Expectations Rivalry 11:05 - Embiid Playoff Struggles 15:27 - Defining Knicks Villain 21:25 - Historic Rivalry Debate 27:16 - Jaylen Brown Impact 32:30 - NBA Championship Odds 41:10 - Tony Romo News 47:42 - Studio Dress Code

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the proclamation of "LeBron Day" in Philadelphia, debating whether the aging superstar can handle the intensity of Northeast sports fans. They evaluate the 76ers' roster and playoff potential while ranking the greatest rivals of the New York Knicks. They also discuss Tony Romo’s broadcasting future and the New York Yankees' strategy ahead of the trade deadline. 01:50 - LeBron Day in Philadelphia 07:00 - Sixers' Playoff Outlook 11:35 - Aging Superstars’ Declines 18:40 - Naked Beach Stories 25:20 - Yankees Trade Rumors 35:50 - Tony Romo's Future 48:20 - Knicks Rivalry Rankings

Craig and C-Mac discuss the legendary career of Howard Cosell and share a unique story about playing for the Washington Generals against the Harlem Globetrotters. They also provide tips on breaking in a new Rawlings baseball glove and analyze the Knicks' standing compared to the Sixers. The conversation wraps up with wild stories of Vegas encounters and legendary broadcasting drinking habits. 01:20 - Categories For The Wheel 06:28 - Willie Colon Disney Partnership 12:00 - Playing For Washington Generals 17:36 - Howard Cosell's Broadcasting Legacy 24:11 - Knicks And Sixers Rivalry 30:07 - Breaking In New Gloves 36:56 - Broadcast Booth Drinking Stories 45:12 - Winning 82-0 Gaming Strategy 48:45 - Wild Vegas Pool Stories

Craig leads a special edition of the Wednesday Wheel game featuring Anthony Gallo, Pete Hoffman, and Big Mac. They tackle categories including Philadelphia landmarks and various chicken dishes before finishing with a challenge to name LeBron James' teammates. 01:04 - Wednesday Wheel Introductions 03:26 - Philadelphia Trivia Round 06:53 - Chicken Dish Debate 16:44 - LeBron Teammate Challenge

The Carton Show goes off the rails after the "Wheel of Fun" gets chaotic naming Chicken Dishes and Lebron James teammates!

Frank and Craig discuss the profound impact of broadcasting legends like Howard Cosell and Marv Albert on sports history. They reflect on Cosell’s career, his relationship with Muhammad Ali, and the controversial comment that led to his professional downfall. The conversation shifts to the New York Knicks' status as champions and a potential rivalry with the Philadelphia 76ers. 01:00 - Legendary Sports Broadcasters 03:07 - Cosell's Cultural Impact 05:42 - The Alvin Garrett Controversy 09:53 - Knicks and Sixers Rivalry 16:29 - Premium Sausage Ad

The Wheel is back on The Carton Show, and this time Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are tackling everything from Philadelphia and LeBron James to diner food debates, chicken dishes, and the most random conversations you’ll hear on WFAN. Craig also tells an unbelievable behind-the-scenes story about the time he played for the Washington Generals against the Harlem Globetrotters at Barclays Center — including a halftime locker room speech where the coach treated the game like Game 7 of the NBA Finals.

The Knicks are the best team in the Eastern Conference but who is their biggest rival? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get into a heated debate over whether the Philadelphia 76ers or Indiana Pacers are the true Knicks rival. The guys break down the Sixers’ chances with LeBron James rumors, Joel Embiid, Jaylen Brown, and why Philly still may not be on New York’s level. Plus, Craig and Big Mac revisit classic Knicks rivalries involving the Sixers, Celtics, Pacers, and Heat.

The Yankees are approaching a massive trade deadline, and Chris McMonigle is ready for a change at shortstop. Craig Carton and Big Mac debate whether Anthony Volpe and Jon Berti/Caballero have done enough, if top prospect George Lombard Jr. could get the call, and how the Red Sox becoming buyers changes the AL race.

On The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle, Craig explains why the Sixers are setting LeBron up for failure, why Philadelphia still isn't a true basketball town, and why he believes Sixers fans will eventually turn on the NBA legend if another playoff run ends in disappointment.

On The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle, Craig doubles down on why the defending NBA Champion New York Knicks have absolutely nothing to fear. From questioning Philadelphia's depth and LeBron's age to predicting chemistry issues with Joel Embiid, Tyrese Maxey, and Jaylen Brown, Carton says the Sixers are built for headlines—not championships.

On The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle, Craig unloads on LeBron's decision to join the 76ers, arguing the Knicks remain the undisputed kings of the Eastern Conference. Carton claims New York turned LeBron away, calls Philadelphia "MSG South," predicts Sixers fans will eventually turn on him, and debates whether the Sixers are even a legitimate threat to the defending NBA Champion Knicks. Will LeBron and the Sixers create the NBA's next great rivalry, or is Philadelphia destined for another playoff disappointment?

Chris McMonigle reacts to Max Fried's stellar outing in his return from injury, sealing a series win for the Yankees. Still, it wasn't all positive, as C-Mac tears into the Yankee offense once again, which continues to struggle without Aaron Judge. Chris reacts to the team's much-needed rally late in game two of Wednesday's doubleheader, the failure to capitalize on Gerrit Cole's strong outing in game one, and what options Brian Cashman and company have to get this listless lineup going again.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS4:13 - Optimism around the pitching staff after Cole and Fried pitch on the same day for the first time.13:58 - Praising the bullpen, specifically Bednar and Blackburn, while looking for one more shutdown reliever.21:00 - Evaluating Will Warren's surprise appearance in the ninth inning.28:30 - The offense is a "disaster."34:55 - Deep frustrations with Bellinger and Goldschmidt expanding the strike zone.45:05 - Why Caballero and Volpe aren't the answer, and why the Yankees need to call up Lombard NOW.46:13 - Thoughts on Caballero's pitch clock antics, his clash with Dennis Santana, and MLB's response.1:01:00 - Potential moves for Mason Miller, Shea Langeliers, and Luis Arraez.1:07:38 - "Shill or Shame" Segment.1:18:28 - Looking ahead to the pitching matchups for the upcoming weekend series against the Phillies.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle argue that the NBA is delaying its season schedule release solely to accommodate LeBron James, leaving the New York Knicks and their fans in limbo. They also analyze the Yankees' rotation stability and potential trade deadline acquisitions while debating a controversial column concerning Caitlin Clark. Additionally, they share personal stories including a family dispute involving Aaron Rodgers and a high-stakes shaving bet. 02:15 - Football Season Anticipation 06:50 - NBA Schedule Delay 11:45 - LeBron Holding Hostage 16:10 - Mets Fan Therapy 20:50 - Partnership Drama Explained 27:10 - Yankees Rotation Analysis 31:50 - Trade Deadline Strategy 38:10 - Rodgers Family Feud 45:20 - Home Security Incident 30:00 - Shaving Bet Discussion 34:40 - Media Industry Shakeups 42:15 - WNBA Racial Discourse 50:15 - Controversial Column Analysis 01:03:30 - Marijuana Brand Concepts 21:20 - Bon Jovi History 34:20 - Caitlin Clark Debate 39:45 - Malik Nabors Status

Craig and Big Mac criticize the NBA for delaying the season schedule release to accommodate LeBron James' free agency. They also analyze the Yankees' trade deadline needs and recount the origin of Aaron Rodgers' family feud. 01:20 - Football Scent In The Air 03:06 - Yankees Pitching And Offense 05:45 - NBA Schedule LeBron Drama 16:20 - Therapy For Mets Fans 19:50 - Big Mac's Gotham No-Show 24:00 - Yankees Trade Deadline Talk 39:25 - Aaron Rodgers' Family Feud 44:20 - Open Door Policy Debate

Craig Carton and C-Mac tear into the New York Mets' ticket pricing strategies and the organization's disconnect from its fan base. They analyze current StubHub prices for future games and discuss Pete Alonso's anticipated return to Citi Field with the Baltimore Orioles. Additionally, the conversation shifts to media industry egos and Craig's review of the film, The Odyssey. 01:50 - Summer Sun And Shaving 07:48 - Media Egos And Retirements 17:10 - Mets Ticket Price Analysis 23:46 - Pete Alonso Return To Queens 31:12 - Carton Reviews The Odyssey 44:09 - LeBron James NBA Hostage 50:05 - Rant Against Station Management 58:08 - Parking And Concession Issues 01:02:48 - Carton New Weed Strain

Craigie and Big Mac slam Nancy Armour’s controversial column linking Caitlin Clark to the memory of Emmett Till. They also preview an upcoming interview with Plaxico Burris where he debunks myths about his 2008 shooting incident. The conversation concludes with a deep dive into classic films and iconic Brooklyn food destinations. 01:50 - Nancy Armour's Column 09:14 - Emmett Till Comparison 17:10 - Plaxico Burris Story 30:04 - Racism Debate Caller 41:03 - John Fusco's Filmography 46:34 - Brooklyn Food Crawl 55:26 - Bay Ridge Weed Talk

Chris McMonigle analyzes the start of New York Giants training camp and the news that Malik Nabors will not begin on the PUP list. He evaluates the pressure on Jaxson Dart as the new franchise quarterback and discusses the challenge of shifting the team's losing culture under the current coaching staff. The conversation also touches on Eli Manning's Hall of Fame credentials and recent news regarding Brett Favre's health. 01:24 - Malik Nabors Training Status 04:30 - Jaxson Dart Franchise Pressure 09:10 - Giants Schedule Analysis 12:45 - Coaching Culture and Speeches 16:15 - Brett Favre Health News 19:45 - Giants Offensive Strategy 25:30 - Defensive Roster Evaluation 29:30 - Restoring the Giants Identity 36:50 - Eli Manning Hall of Fame

Craig Carton returns to the studio only to find out that Big Mac completely lost his mind while hosting the show!

Things get fiery on this segment of The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle tackle a highly controversial sports column, and drop a massive New York Giants teaser!

Craig Carton drops a massive, hilarious bombshell on Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle during this segment of The Carton Show!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the Mets’ struggling fan experience and ask whether Steve Cohen needs to do more to bring fans back to Citi Field. With the Mets struggling on the field, Craig argues the organization should lower ticket prices, parking costs, and concessions to show fans they understand their frustration. Would cheaper games, affordable food, and family-friendly pricing help get fans back in the stands?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down everything happening in New York sports on the Carton Show. The Yankees are struggling at the plate, Aaron Judge's return remains uncertain, and Craig says Brian Cashman has to make major moves before the MLB Trade Deadline. Can the Yankees fix their offense in time?

The Mets' disastrous 2026 season has reached a new low, and Craig Carton isn't holding back. Craig and Chris McMonigle break down why the Mets' decision to hold back second-half tickets completely backfired, how cheap Citi Field tickets have become, and why fans are walking away from their season tickets.

With the MLB Trade Deadline just days away, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down exactly what the Yankees need to do to become legitimate World Series contenders. Is pitching already good enough? Should Brian Cashman focus on bats instead? The guys debate the Yankees' biggest needs, including catcher, shortstop, bullpen help, and whether George Lombard deserves a shot in the Bronx. They also discuss Aaron Judge's return, Giancarlo Stanton's status, Cody Bellinger's struggles, and why the Yankees can't rely on their pitching staff to carry a lifeless offense all October.

Craig Carton sounds off on LeBron James and the NBA after the league delays releasing the 2026-27 schedule while waiting for LeBron's decision. Carton argues the defending NBA Champion New York Knicks deserve to be the center of attention—not a 43-year-old superstar deciding his next team.

Craig and Big Mac dissect the New York Yankees' recent offensive slump, highlighting Cody Bellinger's lack of production and the team's listless performance. They also debate a viral clip of John Harbaugh's speech and discuss a rumor about the New York Jets moving their practice facility back to New York. 01:20 - Yankees Offensive Struggles 07:14 - Stanton Injury Update 10:55 - Harbaugh Speech Debate 24:00 - Koreatown Massage Story 30:18 - Jose Caballero Antics 35:36 - Military Perspective Debate 43:08 - Jets Relocation Rumor

It's a wild hour on The Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle rip into the Yankees' lifeless offense, question Cody Bellinger's disappointing season, debate John Harbaugh's viral Giants speech, and Craig drops a surprising rumor about the New York Jets potentially moving their practice facility back to New York. Plus, the guys take hilarious calls, react to ESPN's Ryan Clark situation, and go completely off the rails with classic Carton storytelling.

The Yankees' offense has become painful to watch, and Craig Carton isn't holding back. Craig and Chris McMonigle break down another frustrating loss, rip Cody Bellinger's struggles, discuss Giancarlo Stanton's possible return, and debate whether Brian Cashman can save the lineup before the trade deadline. They also react to John Harbaugh's first speech to the New York Giants and Craig absolutely unloads, calling it one of the most embarrassing coach speeches he's ever heard. Do Giants fans have reason to worry already?

Craig Carton and Zach Gelb examine the New York Yankees' postseason outlook and the impact of Jazz Chisholm Jr. They discuss the New York Jets' new white-on-white uniforms and are joined by Jim Leyritz to reflect on his 2001 9/11 home run. The conversation also highlights Bobby Valentine’s take on Mets analytics and the messy firing of Ryan Clark from ESPN. 02:11 - Intro With Zach Gelb 06:45 - Yankees World Series Outlook 12:15 - Jets New White Uniforms 28:05 - Jim Leyritz Joins Segment 35:50 - AI Pitch Calling Debate 29:30 - Lionel Richie Concert Snub 16:10 - Bobby Burack Firing Analysis 19:15 - Bobby Valentine Joins Segment 30:35 - Hoffman Birthday Celebration

Zach Gelb joins to discuss the Yankees' momentum and Jazz Chisholm's dynamic role on the team. Former Yankee Jim Leyritz shares his perspective on the shift toward analytics and AI in baseball management. They also evaluate Anthony Volpe's development and debate the outlook for the Jets and Patriots in the AFC East. 01:20 - Zach Gelb Joins 04:53 - Baseball Fights Debate 09:53 - Jazz Chisholm Impact 13:16 - Jets Uniform Reveal 16:55 - AFC East Predictions 27:35 - Jim Leyritz Interview 37:03 - AI Pitch Calling 42:35 - Anthony Volpe Struggles

Craig and Zach Gelb praise the Yankees' handling of a rainout before airing a personal grievance against Lionel Richie for a late concert cancellation. They debate the musical legacy of Bruce Springsteen and Bob Dylan while confirming the return of the Pig Spanking tradition at MetLife Stadium. The conversation also explores awkward fan interactions and viral social media challenges. 01:20 - Yankees Rainout Comparison 05:00 - Lionel Richie Grievance 08:15 - Bruce Springsteen Debate 16:10 - Fan Interaction Criticisms 20:30 - Bathroom Encounter Stories 26:00 - Dawkins Watermelon Challenge 30:25 - Pig Spanking Returns 34:30 - Pink Floyd Dead Air 39:40 - Dramatic Radio Exits

Outkick's Bobby Burack joins Craig and Zach Gelb to break down the messy tactics ESPN allegedly used during Ryan Clark’s termination. They explore the internal power struggle between Pat McAfee and Stephen A. Smith and how the network handled the leak of the news. The conversation also shifts to the Yankees' championship prospects without Aaron Judge and a debate over the Jets’ win total. 01:43 - Bobby Burack on Ryan Clark 06:48 - ESPN PR Leak Allegations 14:06 - Pat McAfee Power Shift 19:45 - Handling Firing and Personal Stories 25:32 - Anthony’s Song with Lil Wayne 30:36 - Yankees Title Hopes Without Judge 39:56 - Performative Takes in Sports Media 44:34 - Jets and Patriots Season Preview

Craig and Zach talk with Bobby Valentine about the New York Mets' reliance on AI for pitch calling and the team's current organizational struggles. Bobby reflects on the profound emotional impact of Mike Piazza's iconic 2001 home run and evaluates the possibility of Alex Rodriguez becoming a big-league manager. They also celebrate producer Pete Hoffman's 44th birthday with cupcakes and take listener calls about the Yankees' playoff outlook. 01:20 - Bobby Valentine Joins 04:53 - AI Pitch Calling Discussion 08:45 - Managing Large Player Egos 13:45 - Mets Managerial Search 16:45 - Piazza's Emotional Home Run 22:00 - Bobby Valentine's Career Update 27:20 - A-Rod Manager Potential 31:24 - Birthday Cupcake Celebration 35:18 - Yankees Without Aaron Judge 40:36 - Tiger Woods Interaction

Craig Carton and Zach Gelb- filling in for Chris McMonigle- are joined by former New York Mets manager Bobby Valentine for an insightful conversation on the state of the Mets and the growing role of artificial intelligence in baseball. Valentine shares his perspective on AI calling pitches, the importance of the human element in managing a team, and the challenges facing today's Mets. He also reflects on the unforgettable emotions surrounding Mike Piazza's iconic post-9/11 home run, discusses leadership in the clubhouse, and shares stories from his legendary career in baseball.

Craig Carton and Zach Gelb (filling in for Chris McMonigle) welcome Bobby Burk from OutKick to The Carton Show on WFAN to break down the explosive fallout surrounding Ryan Clark’s ESPN departure. Bobby explains how he broke the news that Ryan Clark was being let go, why ESPN reportedly asked OutKick to delay the story, and why he believes the network turned to another outlet before the announcement went public.

Craig Carton is joined by Zach Gelb, filling in for Chris McMonigle, for a lively discussion on the Yankees' World Series chances without Aaron Judge, the upcoming MLB trade deadline, and the state of the American League. The conversation also shifts to the NFL as Carton and Gelb debate the Patriots' outlook, the Jets' ceiling this season, and whether New York's new white uniforms deserve all the hype. As it stays fresh, the guys also react to Ryan Clark's ESPN departure and take calls from fans on the biggest stories in sports.

Craig Carton and Zach Gelb (filling in for Chris McMonigle) bring the energy on The Carton Show on WFAN!

Craig Carton and Zach Gelb share some of the funniest fan interaction stories you'll ever hear on The Carton Show on WFAN! Craig opens up about a viral Twitter complaint over a fan photo, reveals the strangest places he's been recognized, tells an unbelievable bathroom story, reminisces about Fanatics Fest, and even drops a hilarious Times Square confession that has everyone in the studio cracking up.

raig Carton goes OFF on music legends Bruce Springsteen and Lionel Richie during a hilarious conversation with Zach Gelb filling in on The Carton Show on WFAN! Craig explains why he'll never forgive Lionel Richie after a canceled Madison Square Garden concert, questions Bruce Springsteen's singing ability despite calling him an all-time songwriter, and the guys even play a hilarious game of naming famous "Mikes."

Craig Carton is joined by Yankees legend Jim Leyritz for an unfiltered conversation about the Bronx Bombers' season. Leyritz shares his thoughts on Jazz Chisholm's impact, Anthony Volpe's future, Aaron Boone's leadership, and what the Yankees need to do at the trade deadline to make a World Series run.

Craig Carton is joined by Zach Gelb, filling in for Chris McMonigle, for a packed show covering the biggest stories in New York sports. The guys debate whether the Yankees are still legitimate World Series contenders despite injuries, discuss Jazz Chisholm's impact, react to the Yankees' latest win, and argue over the Jets' outlook after the release of their new white uniforms. Plus, they dive into a spirited Jets vs. Patriots debate, preview the MLB trade deadline, and touch on the latest ESPN drama surrounding Ryan Clark.

Chris McMonigle dives into a frustrating series against the Dodgers, breaking down the atrocious state of the Yankees' offense, expressing major concerns over a disappointing injury update on Aaron Judge and the severe struggles of Cody Bellinger, Jazz Chisholm, and Anthony Volpe. Looking ahead to the trade deadline, Chris insists the front office must prioritize a new starting shortstop and outlines his ultimate wish list, including Rafael Devers and Mason Miller. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 00:40 - The Elephant in the Room: The Yankees' offense is absolutely awful right now. 3:00 - A deep dive into the offensive black hole at the bottom of the lineup. Chris highlights the struggles of Cody Bellinger and Jazz Chisholm, noting that a starting infield with only one above-average hitter is unacceptable. 10:40 - The Aaron Judge Update: Chris expresses his disappointment over the latest medical update on Aaron Judge, noting that going from "sharp pain" to "dull pain" in six weeks without resuming baseball activities is a massive concern. 15:45 - Game 1 Recap & Gerrit Cole: Despite the offense only scraping together one run on an error and a wild pitch, Gerrit Cole provided a major bright spot with swing-and-miss stuff after some rough outings of late. 23:45 - Defending Boone & Grisham: Chris pushes back against fans criticizing manager Aaron Boone for leaving Cole in too long. He also defends Trent Grisham getting thrown out at the plate, attributing it to a bad base-running read rather than a lack of hustle. 43:00 - Game 3 Bullpen Heroics: A breakdown of the much-needed series finale victory, but Chris had to vent about a frustrating fifth-inning bases-loaded jam. 59:00 - Trade Deadline Wishlist: Chris demands that Brian Cashman prioritize a new shortstop. He also tosses out bold trade targets to save the season, including Rafael Devers, Luis Arraez, and Mason Miller. 1:09:20 - Shill or Shame: Reliever David Bednar earns the "Shill" for his shutdown performance out of the bullpen, while the recently demoted Jake Bird gets handed the "Shame." 1:14:00 - Silver Linings in the Standings: Despite the offensive woes and losing the series, Chris notes that the Yankees actually gained a game and a half on the slumping Tampa Bay Rays, keeping their division title hopes very much alive.

Willie Colon fills in for Big Mac to analyze the Yankees' recent series against the Dodgers and the injury scare involving Cam Skatabo's viral backflip. They also discuss the news regarding Ryan Clark's departure from ESPN, the ongoing MetLife Stadium turf debate, and Amar'e Stoudemire's surprising new business venture. 02:05 - Willie Colon Joins 03:54 - Halftime Show Critique 07:16 - Disney Cruise Review 09:15 - Yankees Dodgers Recap 13:45 - Skatabo Backflip Scare 16:45 - Jackson Dart Lifestyle 24:00 - Bronx Hoops Stories 27:50 - Willie's Jiu-Jitsu Training 29:40 - Nick Newell Fight 35:15 - Tim Tebow Story 37:20 - Ryan Clark Discourse 40:55 - Clark ESPN Departure 46:10 - Fantasia Crying Story 48:05 - Boutique Experience 36:20 - MetLife Turf Debate 39:15 - Dodgers Investigation News 43:05 - Stoudemire Cattle Farm 48:25 - Chicken Farming Dispute 57:25 - Papa Don't Preach 29:00 - Knicks Championship Parade

Willie Colon joins the program to discuss the Yankees' recent series against the Dodgers and his unexpectedly positive experience on a Disney cruise. They analyze the reckless behavior of college star Cam Skattebo following a viral backflip attempt and reflect on Geno Smith’s history of off-field headlines. The conversation also touches on personal lifestyle choices, gym habits, and locker room stories from the NFL. 01:30 - Willie Colon Joins 05:15 - Halftime Show Review 10:20 - Yankees Dodgers Analysis 14:45 - Cam Skattebo Backflip 20:15 - Gym Habits Discussion 25:30 - Yankees Fan Reactions 33:52 - Cigars and Snacks 39:00 - Geno Smith Incident

Craig and Willie debate the maturity of Cam Skattebo following a viral backflip video that risked his recovery from a catastrophic leg injury. They reflect on strict parenting values, the emotional impact of music, and the shifting public persona of Tom Brady. The discussion also touches on the responsibility of sports analysts to address social issues. 01:40 - Radio Caller Meritocracy 04:55 - Parenting and Respect 11:18 - Cam Skattebo Backflip Drama 16:10 - Ryan Clark Analysis Discussion 22:00 - Emotional Power of Music 28:10 - Nick Newell Submission Story 35:40 - Giants and Ravens Run Game 43:50 - Tom Brady's Public Persona

Craig Carton and guest host Willie Colon debate the physical demands of playing offensive line in the NFL, leading to a hilarious exchange about aerobic conditioning. They also discuss the Dodgers owner being under investigation and why MetLife Stadium needs grass instead of turf. 01:50 - Country Music Debate 02:40 - Travis Scott Club Melee 07:49 - Mets Season Struggles 13:37 - Yankees Series Recap 15:59 - Why Linemen Get Winded 20:52 - Dodgers Owner Investigation 36:23 - MetLife Grass Concerns 47:14 - Amare Stoudemire Cattle Farmer 55:18 - World Cup Halftime Review 01:01:53 - Big Mac Miss Piggy Comparison

Willie Colon joins Craig Carton to react to news of Ryan Clark’s departure from ESPN and the etiquette of supporting friends during professional setbacks. They delve into the concept of personal grudge lists and how relationships shift during times of public humiliation. The conversation also explores the Knicks' recent championship success and Cam Skattebo's playing style. 10:16 - Traffic Report and ESPN 16:19 - Etiquette After Public Firings 21:53 - Keeping A Grudge List 27:54 - Knicks Championship Parade Talk 33:37 - Cam Skattebo Mentality Analysis

Craig Carton and Willie Colon break down the shocking news that Ryan Clark has been fired by ESPN and discuss what could be next for one of the network’s biggest NFL voices. The guys debate why Clark may have been let go, his impact at ESPN, and where he could land next.

Craig Carton and Willie Colon break down one of the biggest debates in football: why doesn’t MetLife Stadium have real grass for the Giants and Jets? After seeing the World Cup played on a beautiful grass field in the same stadium, the guys discuss player safety, injuries, turf vs. grass, and why NFL players overwhelmingly prefer natural surfaces.

Willie Colon fills in for Chris McMonigle on the Carton Show and gets into a heated debate with Craig Carton about offensive linemen. Are NFL linemen really getting tired, or are they just fighting in a phone booth every play? Willie explains the brutal reality of going up against elite pass rushers while Craig isn’t buying it.

Craig Carton and Willie Colon break down the wild scene at Zero Bond involving Travis Scott, bottles flying, and Knicks champion Jordan Clarkson getting pulled out by police while reportedly trying to calm things down. The guys discuss why athletes need to know when to step away from a chaotic situation. Plus, the Mets continue to spiral as the guys debate whether there is any reason for fans to keep hope alive or if the rest of the season is simply about playing spoiler against rivals like the Phillies.

Craig and Willie analyze Tom Brady's viral slap with Logan Paul and whether the legend is humanizing himself or hurting his legacy. They also discuss Willie’s Jiu-Jitsu injury and a caller's concerns over Cam Skattebo’s risky athleticism. 01:01 - Ozempic Weight Loss Talk 02:21 - Willie’s Jiu-Jitsu Injury 05:50 - Cam Skattebo Backflip Debate 17:05 - Tom Brady Slap Reaction

Craig Carton and Willie Colon get surprisingly personal on this edition of The Carton Show on WFAN. The guys debate parenting rules, whether kids should call adults by their first names, bringing friends on family vacations, and the struggles of dealing with other people's kids.

Craig Carton and Willie Colon tackle the biggest stories in New York sports on The Carton Show!

Craig Carton and Willie Colon break down a packed Monday on The Carton Show! Craig sounds off on Giants rookie Cam Skattebo after his viral backflip at Fanatics Fest nearly ended in disaster. Is the young star being reckless before playing a single NFL game? The guys also debate whether Yankees fans are overreacting after losing 2-of-3 to the Dodgers. Despite the series loss, did New York prove it can hang with baseball's best even without Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Max Fried?

Hear why Craig Carton believes that the Jets will win the AFC East before the Giants win the NFC East. Plus, Gio wonders about the Jets expectations after Geno Smith’s latest legal headlines; Shaun Moras and Tiki Barber take calls from Jets fans and whether or not their offense can surprise, and ask if the Jets being bad in 2026 is really the worst thing?

Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash find reasons to get excited for Giants football, starting with the NFC being wide open this year. Plus, Tiki and Shaun on the Giants having a quarterback they can believe in; concerns around Malik Nabers’ health; Craig Carton cautions Giants fans that John Harbaugh alone won’t save the team; Craig and Chris McMonigle on the hype around Jaxson Dart this season.

Shaun Morash says he believes more than ever that Juan Soto misses the Yankees based on what he saw at the All-Star Game. Plus, John Franco joined Jerry Recco and discussed the toughest hitters he ever faced, and Morash and Tiki debate if A.J. Ewing can surpass Patrick Ewing to become the greatest Ewing in New York sports history.

Chris McMonigle lays out what the Yankees top needs are at the trade deadline, while Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber rave about Cam Schlittler's mentality, which showed itself again in his All-Star Game decision. Plus, Morash makes the case for the Yanks prioritizing Mason Miller over Tarik Skubal at the trade deadline, and Bernie Williams joined The Carton Show live from Fanatics Fest.

FULL SHOW: My Man Pots N' Pans Ohhhhhhh Yeahhhh | Live From Fanatics Fest the Fellas discuss the possibility of the Mets trading Francisco Lindor, great guests join the show, the Mets are letting algorithms pick their pitches, and a whole lot more. Tell Ya Friends, Tell Ya Friends!!

Craig and Cmac are live at Fanatics Fest ohhhh yeahhh -- They discuss the possibility of Francisco Lindor being traded, how he might now be a cancer to the team, and a whole lot more.

Craig and Cmac are joined by Actor and Producer Robert Wuhl as well as the Great Frank the Tank live from Fanatics Fest.

Craig and Big Mac are joined by Content Creator Rossi Takes and Entrepreneur Gary Vee live from Fanatics Fest.

Craig and the Yankee Shill Big Mac are joined by the Great Jose Alvarado, NBA Champion....Plus, the Mets might be getting in too deep with analytics.

Jose Alvarado of the NBA Champion New York Knicks joins the show.

Craig and Big Mac are joined by Jason from AA Mint Cards to take a look at some of the latest collectibles.

Entrepreneur Gary Vee joins Craig and Cmac live from Fanatics Fest to talk sports, his career path, and much more.

Craig and Cmac are joined by Rossi Takes, a content creator and Philly superfan, live from Fanatics Fest.

Frank the Tank from Barstool Sports joins the show to lament on the Mets horrible, terrible, no good, very bad season.

Craig and Big Mac talk with Robert Wuhl of Arliss, Batman, Bull Durham, and many others, about baseball and much more.

Craig talks about the possibility of the Mets trading Francisco Lindor.

FULL SHOW: My Man Pots N' Pans!!! Bernie Williams, Charlotte Flair, Andrew Giuliani, and Lil Dee join the show.....Cmac is shilling his heart out for the Yankees, soccer will not be popular in the U.S., and much, much more ohhhh yeahhh.

Craig and Big Mac are live from Fanatics Fest, breaking down last night's ESPY's, the World Cup, and Andrew Giuliani joins the show.

Craig and Cmac talk with the Great Charlotte Flair from the WWE and legendary Yankee Bernie Williams live from Fanatics Fest.

Craig and Cmac take a look at some valuables, including a Honus Wagner card and Lil Dee joins the show to discuss the Knicks run and much more.

Craig and Cmac break down the Yankees rotation coming out of the break and why Craig believes Cam Schlittler should start the 2nd half.

Craig discusses the West Side Stadium and why it never came to fruition.

Craig can hide it no longer....He officially sees Big Mac as a Yankees shill....Of all the dramatic things.

Craig and Cmac are joined by rapper Lil Dee to get his thoughts on the Knicks playoff run, a little freestyle, and more.

Craig and Big Mac speak with Mike from Heritage Auctions about some of the most valuable items in their possession.

The Great Bernie Williams joins the show live from Fanatics Fest. Bern Baby Bern!

WWE Superstar Charlotte Flair joins Craig and Cmac to talk about her experience in Wrestling and much, much more.

Andrew Giuliani joins Craig and Cmac to get their thoughts on the logistics surrounding the World Cup Final and much more.

Craig and Cmac discuss Mike Tyson's viral moment at the Espy's last night.

Craigie and Big Mac review the MLB All-Star Game performances, focusing on the disappointing Boyz II Men set and the lack of action on the field. They contrast the energy levels of American sports fans with international soccer crowds and discuss the offensive potential of the New York Giants' upcoming season. 02:24 - Boyz II Men Performance Critique 05:54 - State Of Modern Baseball 09:38 - American Sports Fandom Problems 14:19 - Miss America Anthem Controversy 17:45 - Giants QB Strategy Discussion 24:10 - Boyz II Men Basketball Story 28:57 - Global Soccer Fan Comparisons 33:34 - Stephen King And Pop Culture 40:37 - Yankee Trade Deadline Talk 57:03 - Sidney Sweeney Discussion

Craig and C-Mac critique the musical acts from the MLB All-Star Game, specifically targeting Boyz II Men's performance. They also discuss the state of American sports fandom, the evolution of the All-Star Game, and a controversial take on the current Miss America. 01:20 - Boyz II Men Critique 05:10 - MLB All-Star Evolution 10:45 - American Fan Mentality 15:05 - Miss America Controversy 18:40 - Harbaugh On QB Play 23:10 - Meeting Boyz II Men 30:25 - Global Soccer Culture 36:35 - Stephen King Discussion

Big Mac and Craig evaluate the New York Yankees' roster needs ahead of the trade deadline, specifically debating if Ben Rice should move to catcher. They shift to the gridiron to dispute Ryan Clark's controversial NFL rankings that placed Lamar Jackson significantly lower than Joe Burrow. The conversation also touches on fast food quality rumors and personal health philosophies regarding cholesterol. 02:05 - Aaron Judge Update 05:45 - Fast Food Quality Debate 10:45 - Winning Cures Everything 14:15 - Grilling & Smoker Talk 18:20 - Yankees Trade Strategy 24:15 - Ben Rice Catcher Debate 27:15 - Ryan Clark Rankings Dispute 34:10 - Conspiracies & Lab Meat

Analysis focuses on the New York Yankees' potential $3 billion deal with Apollo Global Management and their roster requirements for a World Series run. They also put an intern named Becker through a rigorous trivia challenge covering sports, music, and movies. Conversations also touch on cruise ship experiences, smoking meats for football season, and the upcoming Sylvester Stallone biopic. 01:20 - Zac Brown Band Musings 05:55 - Cruise Safety And Plans 11:31 - Smoking Meat For Football 16:12 - Yankees Trade Deadline Outlook 21:30 - Yankees Huge Financial Deal 28:05 - August Vacation Schedule Debate 36:06 - Intern Becker Knowledge Test 42:55 - Pop Culture Knowledge Challenge

Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze Argentina's dramatic victory over England in a simulated matchup and debate Lionel Messi's status as the soccer GOAT. They also explore the New York Giants' offensive plans for Jackson Dart and preview a high-stakes series between the Yankees and Dodgers. 01:25 - Argentina vs. England Simulation 04:40 - Stoppage Time Controversy 07:45 - Soccer GOAT Debate 13:20 - Listener Fast Food Memories 17:45 - Jackson Dart Offensive Strategy 24:35 - Knicks Global Impact 26:45 - Arch Manning Texas Anecdote 31:55 - Rachel Robinson Birthday 38:05 - Yankees vs. Dodgers Preview 54:50 - Fanatics Fest Details

Chris McMonigle discusses the New York baseball landscape following the All-Star game, focusing on why the Mets need to embrace a full sell-off. He evaluates potential trade targets for the Yankees, including closer Mason Miller, and reacts to the news of a significant cash influx for the organization. He also touches on upcoming events at Fanatics Fest and takes calls regarding Brian Cashman's job security. 01:20 - Fanatics Fest Bodega Set 04:26 - Disney Cruise Experience 09:21 - Mets Trade Deadline Strategy 13:33 - Potential Clay Holmes Trade 18:00 - Targeting Closer Mason Miller 21:10 - Broken Mets Fan Reaction 33:10 - Brian Cashman Tenure Debate

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle somehow go from Lionel Messi's dramatic World Cup semifinal heroics... to the New York Knicks becoming a worldwide comparison, to a hilarious debate about Sydney Sweeney, Arch Manning's college life, Rachel Robinson turning 104, and why Jaxson Dart's running ability could change the Giants. It's classic Carton Show chaos, where sports, pop culture, and comedy collide in a way only WFAN can deliver.

Lionel Messi delivers another unforgettable moment as Argentina punches its ticket to the World Cup Final against Spain, and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate where Messi belongs in the GOAT conversation. The guys also react to the electric Spanish-language goal call, discuss whether Jaxson Dart should be unleashed as a running quarterback, and explain why Giants fans should be excited after John Harbaugh says he won't limit Dart's biggest strength.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle turn the studio into a game show as a WFAN intern gets grilled on sports history, classic rock, TV, movies, and pop culture. From Navy SEALs and SCUBA to The Beatles, Eagles, Rolling Stones, Sylvester Stallone, and more, the quiz quickly spirals into hilarious chaos.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to Ryan Clark's comments about Lamar Jackson's NFL Top 100 ranking and debate whether Lamar should be ahead of Joe Burrow. The conversation quickly spirals into Patrick Mahomes' place as the NFL's unquestioned No. 1 quarterback, bizarre KFC and Taco Bell food conspiracies, lab-grown meat, Bill Gates theories, fast food nostalgia, and even cholesterol myths. One of the wildest and funniest segments from The Carton Show on WFAN!

The MLB Trade Deadline is almost here, and Chris McMonigle says the Yankees have one glaring need. Craig Carton puts C-Mac to the test, asking him to name the ONE position Brian Cashman absolutely has to upgrade. The guys debate whether the Yankees should target a catcher, go all-in for Mason Miller, move Ben Rice behind the plate, and whether Will Warren or top prospects should be on the table. Plus, they discuss Aaron Judge's injury, Max Fried's return, and how the Yankees should approach a wide-open trade market.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go completely off the rails on WFAN! The guys start with the latest on Aaron Judge’s injury imaging and Yankees return timeline, then somehow spiral into a hilarious debate about KFC, Taco Bell, fake beef, explosive diarrhea, pina coladas, mudslides, and banana daiquiris.

Anthony Gallo walked into The Carton Show studio and immediately became Craig Carton’s latest target! Craig absolutely ROASTS Gallo over his tight soccer jersey, sparking a hilarious debate with Chris McMonigle over his wardrobe. But the chaos doesn’t stop there. Craig tells an incredible story about playing pickup basketball with a member of Boyz II Men dressed head-to-toe like Michael Jordan, C-Mac reveals the bizarre movie connected to the night his first child was conceived, and everyone is stunned to learn Craig has NEVER heard of Stephen King’s It.

Craig Carton has had enough! After watching the 2026 MLB All-Star Game, Craig goes OFF on American sports fans for constantly complaining about everything — too much pitching, not enough offense, boring games, bad entertainment and more. Chris McMonigle pushes back as the guys debate whether the All-Star Game exposed a bigger problem with modern baseball — or with the fans watching it. Plus, Craig and C-Mac react to Boyz II Men’s rough performance and discuss encouraging comments from Giants coach John Harbaugh about letting Jaxson Dart use his legs.

Big Mac and Craig Carton dissect the revamped Home Run Derby format and the rowdy crowd atmosphere in Philadelphia. They transition to local football, debating whether Jaxson Dart is the franchise savior for the Giants and if Geno Smith can lead the Jets past their "crap magnet" reputation. The segment also includes lighthearted banter regarding Aruba vacation stories and an intern challenge involving cinnamon candy. 01:53 - Home Run Derby Debate 06:20 - All Star Event Rankings 11:22 - Jets Football Expectations 15:46 - Jaxson Dart Mentality 19:30 - Podcast With Lil Wayne 26:10 - Stanton Hall Of Fame 30:50 - AFC East Predictions 35:21 - Analyzing Lamar Jackson 40:35 - Giants Win Totals 48:10 - Elite Quarterback Tiers 57:05 - Intern Trivia Challenge 01:03:00 - Red Hots Challenge 37:45 - Lesbian Cricket Triangle 44:20 - Aruba Shark Story 01:02:10 - Spain Beats France 08:00 - Geno Smith Cleared

Carton and Big Mac clash over the entertainment value of the Home Run Derby before diving into the future of New York's football franchises. They discuss the contrasting off-seasons of Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith, leading Carton to issue a controversial prediction about divisional success. 01:30 - Home Run Derby Debate 04:45 - All-Star Event Quality 09:24 - Ben Rice Derby Struggles 12:40 - Geno Smith Off-Field Issues 16:28 - Jaxson Dart Offseason Focus 20:04 - Giants Training Camp Expectations 23:33 - New York Football Culture 31:28 - Bold AFC East Prediction 35:23 - Comparing NFL Quarterback Futures 38:55 - Big Mac Giant Loyalty

Craig and Big Mac debate whether Giancarlo Stanton is a lock for the Hall of Fame despite his recurring injury history with the Yankees. They also discuss the hype surrounding Jackson Dart as a potential savior for the Giants and rank the elite tier of NFL quarterbacks. 02:00 - Live Charity Podcast Announcement 10:19 - Giancarlo Stanton Hall of Fame 16:30 - Giants and Jackson Dart 29:55 - Ranking Elite NFL Quarterbacks 33:01 - Home Run Derby Recap 40:16 - Lamar Jackson Passing Debate 50:15 - Best Cheesesteaks and Food

Craig Carton puts Joe the Intern through a gauntlet of sports trivia and a spicy Red Hots challenge to earn a higher internship grade. He and Chris McMonigle delve into a debate over Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame credentials and the New York Giants' historically low win totals. They also analyze the upcoming NFL schedule and share personal vacation stories. 01:50 - Testing Joe The Intern 08:14 - NY Jets Hall Of Famers 15:30 - Eli Manning Hall Debate 23:53 - Vikings Versus Giants Predictions 38:14 - Intern Red Hots Challenge 49:15 - Giants 2024 Schedule Breakdown 55:27 - Big Mac's StainAway Invention 01:02:40 - Jets And Giants History

Craigie and Big Mac debate the logistics of a high-profile love triangle in Australian women's cricket before diving into the controversial practice of holding beach chairs in Aruba. They also entertain colorful callers, including a former model with five marriage proposals and a Giants fan looking for a favor. The segment concludes with a breakdown of recent World Cup results and the varying levels of optimism for the Jets and Giants this season. 01:45 - Lesbian Cricket Love Triangle 05:30 - Aruba Beach Chair Etiquette 13:15 - Peggy O's Modeling Past 22:05 - Radio Staff Vacation Feud 28:35 - World Cup Soccer Upset 34:10 - Football Season Optimism

Chris McMonigle evaluates the news that Geno Smith will not face battery charges following a recent investigation and reflects on the quarterback's off-field issues. He also discusses the New York Giants' coaching stability compared to the Tom Coughlin era and shares optimism for Jaxson Dart before looking ahead to the MLB trade deadline. 01:00 - MLB All-Star and Giants Talk 08:05 - Geno Smith Legal Update 13:10 - MLB Trade Deadline Outlook

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are at it again over C-Mac’s upcoming vacation plans! After a caller tries to defend C-Mac, Craig doubles down on why taking two weeks off is apparently “outlandish” — while C-Mac fires back that he’s earned every single vacation day.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle uncover a stunning Giants stat that helps explain why Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame case remains so heavily debated. Despite two legendary Super Bowl runs and two Super Bowl MVP awards, the Giants produced surprisingly few double-digit-win seasons during the Eli era.

Craig Carton and Big Mac put Rutgers intern Joe through a series of timed challenges to test his sports and pop culture knowledge. They discuss the famous fat sandwiches of New Brunswick before Joe attempts to name famous Michaels, Beatles songs, and New York Giants quarterbacks. The group also debates New York Jets Hall of Famers and the evolution of food truck culture. 01:00 - Intern Challenge Intro 02:33 - Famous Michaels Trivia 03:54 - Beatles Song Challenge 04:47 - Giants Quarterback Trivia 07:23 - Jets Hall Famers

Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down the growing hype surrounding Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart as fans start comparing him to NFL superstars like Lamar Jackson and Patrick Mahomes. Is the excitement justified, or are expectations getting way too high after a small sample size? The guys debate Dart’s rushing ability, his potential as a dual-threat quarterback, whether the Giants should use him in short-yardage situations, and why Lamar Jackson has become one of the NFL’s best pocket passers. Plus, Craig and Big Mac get into some hilarious food debates, cheesesteaks, and take your calls on WFAN.

Craig challenges Giants fans to temper their expectations, arguing that even an elite head coach can only do so much. Chris McMonigle fires back, explaining why the combination of Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart could finally give the Giants the two most important pieces of a winning franchise.

Big Mac and the group evaluate Giancarlo Stanton’s career trajectory and whether persistent injuries will prevent the slugger from reaching the Hall of Fame. They also reminisce about legendary athletes who wore the number 44 and promote a charity podcast event featuring Lil Wayne. 01:00 - Lil Wayne Podcast Event 02:33 - Celebrating Pete's Birthday 03:53 - Famous Number 44 Athletes 08:22 - Giancarlo Stanton's Yankees Future 11:27 - Stanton's Hall of Fame Case

Craig and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head over which New York football franchise is closer to turning things around, whether the Jets and Giants have become “crap magnets,” and what the futures of Geno Smith and Jaxson Dart mean for both teams.

Craig Carton has noticed a major change in Jaxson Dart and he believes New York Giants fans should be thrilled. After an offseason filled with celebrity appearances, big events and life in the spotlight, Dart has seemingly disappeared from the public eye as training camp approaches. Craig believes that means the young quarterback is locked in on football and preparing to prove he can become the Giants’ franchise quarterback. Chris McMonigle explains why he never doubted Dart’s commitment and why proving he is the long-term answer at quarterback is the biggest question facing the Giants this season.

Chris McMonigle reacts to the Yanks getting back on track with three late comebacks against the Nationals to head into the break on a four-game winning streak. C-Mac reacts to the timely hits, Cam Schlittler's latest performance and him not being selected to start the All-Star Game, where the Yankees stand at the break, and how they can keep the momentum going when play resumes.

Carton returns from vacation to join Big Mac for a breakdown of the New York Mets' embarrassing sweep and the New York Yankees' recent winning streak. They participate in a "blind rank" game to identify the weekend's biggest losers, covering everything from nature attacks to celebrity news. The discussion also explores Smurfette's secret history, Adam Schefter's business ties, and a wild listener story about a beach prank. 01:50 - Carton Returns from Vacation 05:20 - Mets Swept by Boston 09:15 - Blind Rank Weekend Fails 17:25 - Paul Virzi and Comedy 25:30 - Smurfette's Secret History 36:45 - Bryce Harper Cameo Drama 47:45 - Geno Smith Speeding Controversy

Carton returns from vacation to break down the Mets' mid-season collapse and join Big Mac in ranking the weekend's most embarrassing sports and pop culture moments. They also analyze the Yankees' recent win streak and engage in a heated discussion on whether professional success is defined by championship rings or Hall of Fame status. 01:50 - Carton Returns and Mets Struggles 08:25 - Ranking the Worst Weekends 16:05 - Yankees Win Streak Discussion 19:45 - Jay-Z Concert Delay Chaos 25:15 - Smurfs and Cartoon Crushes 35:30 - McGregor Injury and UFC Fallout 42:55 - Eli Manning vs Dan Marino 49:40 - Geno Smith Traffic Stop Drama

Craig and Big Mac dissect Bryce Harper's decision to charge fans nearly $1,000 for personal videos despite his massive career earnings. They contrast the criticism Harper faces with the acceptance of active NBA stars like LeBron James promoting gambling apps. Craig also calls out the station's digital team for rebranding the program while he was away on vacation. 01:25 - Lindor and Mets Debacle 05:00 - Bryce Harper Cameo Greed 10:30 - NBA Gambling Ad Hypocrisy 14:50 - Harper Video vs Brunson Photo 18:45 - Comedians vs Pro Athletes 22:20 - Carton Show Branding Controversy 32:00 - Red Sox Sweep Mets

Craig and Chris McMonagle evaluate the Yankees' aggressive trade deadline strategy and whether the team should bother making moves if Aaron Judge's imaging shows no progress. They also debate the true popularity of soccer in America and the hilarious branding mishap of the McMonagle Show while Craig was away. 01:20 - SNY Suite Plans 04:45 - McMonagle Branding Scandal 11:08 - Soccer Popularity Debate 20:05 - Global Sports Ratings 33:20 - Highest Paid Athletes 40:43 - Yankees Trade Deadline 48:35 - National Patriotism Discussion

Craig Carton and Big Mac examine the potential conflict of interest involving Adam Schefter co-owning a gambling company with Robert Kraft. They debate if these financial ties affect NFL reporting integrity and compare the situation to past media scandals. The segment also covers Josh Hamilton's legendary Home Run Derby performance and a bizarre story about broadcasting to dead air at WIP. 01:20 - Schefter's Conflict Of Interest 06:35 - Reporting On The Patriots 13:20 - Detour Into Smurfs Lore 16:40 - Talking With Young Fans 22:45 - Tom Brady's Ownership Role 29:25 - Home Run Derby History 34:10 - Josh Hamilton's Vision 45:30 - Broadcasting To Dead Air

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the controversy surrounding NFL insider Adam Schefter’s business relationship with Patriots owner Robert Kraft. The guys debate whether Schefter’s partnership with an NFL owner creates a conflict of interest, especially with the company being tied to sports gambling.

Craig Carton returns from vacation and discovers something happened while he was gone: The Carton Show apparently became “Chris McMonigle” on the Audacy app! After a caller exposes the change, Craig launches an on-air investigation to find out who renamed the show, while Big Mac insists he had absolutely nothing to do with it. Anthony Gallo gets called into the studio, deadlines are issued, blame starts flying and the entire show goes off the rails.

Should the Yankees go all-in at the trade deadline if Aaron Judge’s injury is worse than expected?

Things get heated on The Carton Show as Craig Carton declares that America simply does NOT care about soccer outside of the World Cup and WFAN’s Anthony Gallo isn’t having it. Gallo jumps into the studio to defend Major League Soccer and soccer’s growing popularity in the United States, leading to a hilarious back-and-forth with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle. From World Cup ratings and MLS crowds to Craig questioning how much soccer Americans actually watch, the debate gets fiery fast.

On The Carton Show, Craig and Chris McMonigle react to the controversy surrounding a Bryce Harper Cameo sent to a gambler who reportedly lost $1.5 million. While Craig defends Harper from claims that he knowingly targeted a problem gambler, he can’t understand why a superstar who has made hundreds of millions of dollars is charging fans $899 for personalized videos.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to yet another troubling offseason headline involving Jets quarterback Geno Smith. After Smith was reportedly pulled over for speeding and driving without his license, Craig questions whether the Jets can truly trust him to be the face and leader of the franchise. Is this signing already showing signs of becoming a disaster before the season even begins?

Craig Carton reveals the shocking Smurfs fact he somehow just learned, sending Chris McMonigle and the crew down an absolutely hilarious rabbit hole about Gargamel, cartoon characters and more. Then the conversation turns to Conor McGregor’s devastating injury and whether the UFC legend’s career is officially over after his highly anticipated comeback ended in disaster.

Craig Carton is back alongside Chris McMonigle on The Carton Show, and he wastes no time unloading on the Mets after they were swept by the Red Sox and stumbled into the All-Star break at 17 games under .500.

Jalen Brunson played through the Finals with a wrist injury that required surgery, and Chris McMonigle raves about how the Knicks MVP is the toughest star we have in this city. Jerry Recco wonders how the Mavericks possibly let this tough superstar get away. Plus, Evan and Tiki react to the Knicks signing Andre Drummond to replace Mitchell Robinson, while C-Mac gives his take on Robinson's long-winded social media message explaining his mysterious hand injury suffered just before the NBA Finals.

Boomer Esiason got the attention of Mets fans when he declared that the team needs to trade Francisco Lindor before the deadline. That led to Evan and Tiki debating if trading Lindor would really make sense for the Mets, and if it is even possible. Plus, reactions to Mike Francesa claiming that a Lindor/Juan Soto feud was sparked by the lack of a welcome message after Soto signed, and Boomer and Jerry believe there has to be more to the team's decision to let Pete Alonso walk.

Brian Cashman gave a discouraging update on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, leading Chris McMonigle to wonder if Stanton will return at all this season. Plus, Evan Roberts wonders if it is far to worry that Judge won't be back this season either. Evan also says the Yankees need to trade for Tarik Skubal, while C-Mac declares that the Yanks need to cut ties with Anthony Volpe.

Chris McMonagle analyzes the impact of injuries to Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, suggesting the Yankees make a massive move for a middle-of-the-order bat like Rafael Devers. They also debate which Mets players are truly untouchable in a 'Would You, Wouldn't You' trade segment while sharing rules for summer driving etiquette. 01:50 - Yankees Injury Crisis 13:40 - Rafael Devers Trade Proposal 21:45 - Movie Trilogy Debates 32:40 - Red Sox Travel Chaos 48:10 - Extending Mets Top Prospects 01:06:30 - Mets Trade Untouchables Game 01:21:05 - Spinning The Wheel Game 01:37:15 - Road Etiquette And Rant

Big Mac explores the alarming nature of Giancarlo Stanton's latest injury setback and argues why it presents a bigger challenge for the Yankees than Aaron Judge's recovery. He proposes aggressive trade targets to stabilize the middle of the order while also highlighting the Mets' fortunate situation against a travel-weary Red Sox squad. The discussion takes a nostalgic turn as he and the crew debate the merits of various iconic movie trilogies. 01:20 - Yankees Win and Judge Injury 08:10 - Stanton Versus Judge Injury Concerns 13:45 - Potential Trades to Fix Lineup 18:45 - Mets Catch Break Against Sox 21:45 - Ranking Great Movie Trilogies 32:15 - Red Sox Stranded in Chicago 37:30 - Fan Speculation on Judge Return 42:40 - Analyzing Yankees Defensive Struggles 49:30 - Navigating New York Death Spiral

Chris McMonagle analyzes a potential blockbuster trade bringing Rafael Devers to the Bronx while debating the slugger's clubhouse reputation. They also break down the controversy surrounding Carolina Hurricanes owner Tom Dundon engraving his children's names on the Stanley Cup over team personnel. Additionally, the discussion covers the Mets' strategy regarding long-term extensions for top prospects like AJ Ewing and Carson Benge. 01:11 - Red Sox Travel Issues 04:32 - Devers Yankee Trade Talk 11:24 - Best Movie Trilogies 18:45 - Yankee Hitting Statistics 23:40 - Extending Young Prospects 36:31 - Hurricanes Cup Controversy

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' shortstop situation, asserting that Jose Caballero is currently the team's best option over Anthony Volpe. He proposes a significant trade for Rafael Devers to bolster the lineup and replace Giancarlo Stanton's production. They also delve into the New York Giants' offseason concerns and debate which New York Mets players should be moved in a Would You, Wouldn't You? segment. 01:20 - Mets Face Delayed Red Sox 05:50 - Caballero Over Volpe At Shortstop 10:51 - Nabors Injury Impacts Giants Season 16:07 - Jaxson Dart Franchise Potential 21:18 - Proposal To Trade For Devers 27:04 - Scouting Trade Deadline Targets 34:13 - Extending Clarke Schmidt And Rice 43:21 - Would You Wouldn't You Mets 48:55 - Evaluating Mets Trade Candidates

C-Mac rants about slow drivers and people who decorate their car dashboards with tchotchkes like rubber ducks. They transition into a trivia game called The Wheel, where Gallo and Hoff struggle with Tom Hanks movies and Beatles facts. The segment concludes with a look at the Yankees lineup as Anthony Volpe sits once again for Jose Caballero. 01:20 - Driving Etiquette Rant 11:04 - Tom Hanks Trivia Game 18:21 - Beatles Clues Challenge 24:25 - Sox and Mets Trivia 31:40 - Anthony Volpe Benched

Big Mac pits Hoff & Gallo against each other in the Wheel of Fun in this weeks edition where he picks the topics and it doesn't disappoint

Chris McMonigle takes calls from frustrated Yankees fans demanding accountability, but pushes back on the idea that firing Boone magically fixes the team's annual midseason "death spiral." Is the problem the manager, Brian Cashman, the roster construction, or something deeper within the organization?

Chris McMonigle leads a debate with Anthony Gallo and Pete Hoffman about which players the Mets and Yankees should trade as the deadline approaches. They play a game of "Would You, Wouldn't You" to determine the value of stars like Francisco Lindor, Bo Bichette, and Clay Holmes. They also examine potential contract extensions for Yankees players Cam Schlittler and Ben Rice. 02:38 - Mets Trade Game Debate 03:41 - Yankees Contract Extensions 09:56 - Aaron Judge Injury Timetable 12:16 - Trading Lindor and Weaver 26:50 - Sports Update and UFC

The Yankees salvaged a series split in Tampa thanks to the bats finally coming alive, scoring more than five runs in a game for the first time in their last 20 games. Chris McMonigle reacts to the offensive breakout, from Ben Rice continuing his strong series to the huge third inning against Drew Rasmussen. Can this kind of game carry over and carry the Yanks out of their swoon, and did they keep their AL East chances alive by taking two of four games? C-Mac dives into all the relevant topics heading into the team's final series before the All-Star break! Plus, reaction to Brian Cashman speaking to the media and revealing the discouraging Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton updates, what he thinks of the latest summer swoon, and how he still believes in Aaron Boone. Chris wonders, given the outlook for Stanton, should the Yanks look into trading for Rafael Devers to be their DH??

Are the Mets and Yankees handling their young stars the right way? Chris McMonigle reacts to the Cardinals locking up top prospect JJ Wetherholt with a long-term extension and asks whether the Mets should do the same with rising stars AJ Ewing and Carson Benge. Plus, Chris explains why the Yankees should consider signing Ben Rice before his price skyrockets.

Should the Yankees make a blockbuster move for Rafael Devers? Chris McMonigle makes the case that Devers is the perfect bat to replace Giancarlo Stanton's production and help the Yankees make a World Series run. But not everyone agrees, as callers question Devers' clubhouse reputation and whether he'd fit in New York.

The Yankees are doing it AGAIN... and Chris McMonigle wants answers. Chris breaks down the Yankees' frustrating yearly "death spiral," questioning why one of baseball's best teams suddenly forgets how to hit, field, and win for weeks at a time. Is it Aaron Boone? The roster construction? Brian Cashman? Or something bigger? Plus, Chris reacts to concerns about Aaron Judge's injury timeline, explains why he doesn't believe the Yankees are hiding the truth, and takes calls from fans debating what's really behind another brutal midseason collapse.

Gallo and Hoff debate which movie trilogies boast the best third installments, analyzing films like Die Hard with a Vengeance and The Dark Knight Rises. They also provide an update on the Red Sox's travel delays in Chicago and what it means for their matchup with the Mets. 01:01 - Movie Trilogy Debates 05:18 - Indiana Jones Plot Holes 10:12 - Red Sox Travel Nightmare 12:49 - Favorite Trilogy One-Liners

With Aaron Judge sidelined, Chris McMonigle says the Yankees can't afford to think small at the trade deadline. While Judge's injury is impossible to replace, Chris argues the bigger long-term concern is Giancarlo Stanton's latest setback—and makes the case for Brian Cashman to swing BIG for Rafael Devers. Plus, Chris breaks down why the Yankees' win over the Rays was so important, why the AL is still there for the taking, and why standing pat at the deadline would be a massive mistake.

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' series split with the Tampa Bay Rays, focusing on Ben Rice's standout performance and a resilient bullpen effort. He discusses concerning injury updates for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton while addressing fan concerns regarding the lineup's consistency and coaching. They also cover the New York Mets' series victory over the Kansas City Royals and a significant injury to Mark Vientos. 01:53 - Yankees Salvage Rays Split 05:09 - Third Inning Rally Analysis 09:54 - Ben Rice Power Surge 15:04 - Mets Series Win Recap 25:53 - Cashman On Judge Injury 38:10 - Yankee Accountability Debate 45:40 - Evaluating Brian Cashman's Tenure

Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle breaks down the New York Yankees' 10-4 victory over the Tampa Bay Rays to salvage a crucial series split. He highlights Ryan McMahon’s twelve-pitch at-bat as a season-defining moment and discusses Ben Rice's power performance while addressing injury updates for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. 01:20 - Yankees Salvage Rays Series Split 04:42 - Ryan McMahon's Turning Point At-Bat 10:34 - Ben Rice and Offensive Outburst 13:40 - Bullpen Usage and Washington Series 17:02 - Caller Debate: Championship Expectations 21:34 - Trusting the Yankee Bullpen Arms 25:08 - Phil’s Positive Outlook on Yankees 30:38 - Brian Cashman Injury Updates 38:04 - Striking Out and Analytics Talk 43:28 - Anthony Volpe vs Jose Caballero

Chris McMonigle reacts to Brian Cashman’s grim updates regarding the recovery timelines for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. He debates the Yankees' recent 'death spiral' without their superstars, considers a potential trade for Rafael Devers, and revisits his radio roots with a nostalgic piece for Steve Somers. 01:20 - Remembering Bonnie Tyler 05:02 - Mets Care Or Not Care 08:35 - Cashman Backs Aaron Boone 12:20 - Judge And Stanton Updates 19:00 - Yankees In Death Spiral 23:01 - Trading For Rafael Devers 28:40 - 2008 Mets Nostalgia Trip 32:30 - Anthony Volpe Roster Debate 37:40 - Firing Cashman And Boone

Mac revisits a nostalgic 2008 radio segment featuring Johan Santana's shutout performance before engaging in a heated debate with callers about the Yankees. He argues that Anthony Volpe should be benched in favor of Jose Caballero due to prolonged offensive struggles. The discussion also critiques Brian Cashman’s roster construction, specifically comparing the Giancarlo Stanton trade to missed opportunities with Christian Yelich and Bryce Harper. 01:00 - Reliving Santana's 2008 Gem 07:07 - Case for Benching Volpe 12:22 - Cashman and Boone Accountability 17:28 - Evaluating the Stanton Trade

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman react to Brian Cashman’s discouraging updates on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton's health. They explore the Yankees' recent struggles and discuss why acquiring Rafael Devers could provide the necessary offensive boost. 01:00 - Bonnie Tyler Reminiscence 04:55 - Mets Care or Not Care 09:54 - Cashman Backs Aaron Boone 13:25 - Judge and Stanton Injury Updates 21:55 - Rafael Devers Trade Ideas

C-Mac evaluates the New York Yankees' offensive struggles and the significant lack of production from the catching position. He analyzes the debate between starting Anthony Volpe or Oswaldo Cabrera at shortstop while addressing the team's high strikeout rate compared to recent World Series champions. 01:00 - Highlander Movie Discussion 02:43 - Yankees Catching Upgrade Needed 06:33 - Debating Yankee Strikeout Rates 13:53 - Volpe vs Cabrera Debate 16:48 - Bellinger And Mets Update

Big Mac reacts to the Yankees' much-needed series finale victory over the Rays and explains why this wasn't just another win. From Ryan McMahon's game-changing 12-pitch at-bat to Ben Rice's monster series, Chris breaks down the biggest positives and why Yankees fans shouldn't dismiss them. He also clashes with callers who insist the Yankees still aren't contenders, discusses the bullpen, Aaron Judge's injury update from Brian Cashman, and why the upcoming series in Washington is now critical.

Chris McMonigle reacts to the Yankees' historic strikeout streak and addresses rumors surrounding Anthony Volpe's alleged refusal to move to second base. They analyze the Mets' frustrating high-scoring loss, evaluate potential trade deadline targets like Tarik Skubal, and discuss the culture shift expected at Giants training camp. 02:02 - New York Baseball Struggles 07:28 - Volpe Position Change Rumors 13:04 - Shortstop Decision: Volpe vs Cabrera 24:42 - T-Mac's Personal Anecdotes 31:40 - Yankees Lineup vs Rays 16:10 - Tarik Skubal Trade Analysis 25:18 - Reinventing the Wednesday Wheel 38:34 - Volpe Responds to Rumors 14:43 - Cabrera's At-Bat Explanation 27:38 - Giants Camp Culture Shift

On The Carton Show, Chris McMonigle addresses the historic strikeout issues plaguing the Yankees and the controversy over Anthony Volpe’s rumored refusal to change positions. He critiques the organization's loyalty to struggling prospects and the lack of production from the bottom of the lineup during a critical stretch. 01:20 - New York Baseball Recap 05:10 - Yankees Historic Strikeout Crisis 11:11 - Anthony Volpe Position Rumors 15:00 - Future of Yankees Shortstop 20:06 - Trade Deadline Pitching Needs 23:58 - Grisham and Verdugo Struggles 28:01 - Fan Calls on Prospects

Chris McMonigle analyzes the Yankees' decision to bring Anthony Volpe back to the lineup and evaluates the team's need for starting pitching help like Tarik Skubal. They critique the Mets' recent defensive embarrassment and the broader issue of player accountability under Aaron Boone. The conversation also explores the psychological toll of playing in New York and Juan Soto's standout individual performance amidst a losing season. 01:20 - Parenting and 90s Rock 04:44 - NBA 2K Obsessions 10:51 - Caballero Plate Games 14:16 - Tarik Skubal Trade Talk 17:39 - Volpe and Mental Pressure 22:50 - Boone and Team Accountability 30:34 - Yankees Rays Lineup 37:10 - Mets Defensive Meltdown 45:47 - Keith Hernandez Musings

Chris McMonigle addresses Anthony Volpe's firm denial of rumors reported by Joel Sherman and Michael Kay regarding a refused position change. They analyze the impact of injuries to stars like Carlos Rodón and Gerrit Cole while debating the pursuit of Tarik Skubal as the trade deadline approaches. 01:20 - Yankees Rays Series 08:47 - Injury Impact Debate 12:37 - Strikeout Performance Analysis 20:44 - Tarik Skubal Trade Value 23:48 - Wednesday Wheel Game Reimagined 38:27 - Anthony Volpe Denies Rumors

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' roster needs and the potential for a blockbuster trade to acquire Tarik Skubal. He criticizes Jose Caballero for a controversial plate appearance where the player dropped his bat mid-count and debates the true impact of the team's high strikeout totals. The discussion also highlights the importance of Gerrit Cole's performance in the upcoming series against the Tampa Bay Rays. 01:25 - NFL Trivia Prodigy 04:40 - Giants Culture Shock 08:03 - Tarik Skubal Market 15:44 - Caballero Bat Drop 21:35 - Yankees Trade Strategy 25:48 - Hunter Goodman Potential 16:55 - Gerrit Cole Tonight 21:10 - Strikeout Impact Debate

Should the Yankees empty the farm system for Tarik Skubal? Chris McMonigle says if New York is going to overpay at the trade deadline, it should be for the best pitcher in baseball—not for marginal upgrades.

Chris McMonigle reacts to one of the strangest Yankees at-bats you'll ever see after José Caballero explains why he intentionally dropped his bat on a full-count pitch. Chris isn't buying the explanation and says there's no excuse for giving up during a Major League at-bat.

Anthony Volpe is finally responding to the rumors that he refused to move to second base and Chris McMonigle isn't buying the narrative. After Michael Kay walks back his report and Volpe publicly denies ever refusing a position change, Chris breaks down why the damage may already be done. Plus, should the Yankees send Volpe back to Triple-A to rebuild his confidence and learn second base?

The Yankees made franchise history in the worst way, setting a record for most strikeouts in a two game span. C-Mac is NOT happy after watching the strikeout fest, and he sounds off on the team's continued offensive woes, the miserable night from Jose Caballero after getting the start at shortstop, the continued "disgusting" showing from Paul Goldschmidt, Will Warren continuing his slide, and the lone bright spot of the night in Ben Rice, who had a three-hit night and went deep for the second night in a row. Plus, why Cody Bellinger is Chris' number one culprit in the team's current swoon.

Chris McMonigle breaks down why the Yankees' expectations have changed amid injuries and an ugly slump but insists they can't let the Rays gain ground in the AL East. A split in Tampa is now the bare minimum. Then the conversation shifts to the biggest question of the trade deadline: Should the Yankees go all-in for Tarik Skubal? Chris explains why an ace like Skubal could transform New York's playoff rotation, debates whether the Yankees need pitching more than another bat, and fields calls on the team's recent struggles, strikeout woes, and Aaron Boone's club.

Chris McMonigle delivers a passionate rant on the Yankees' recent struggles, pushing back against fans demanding more "accountability" from Aaron Boone. Is benching Anthony Volpe really the answer? Should Paul Goldschmidt be punished during his brutal slump? Chris explains why the Yankees' issues run much deeper than simply holding players accountable.

Big Mac turns his attention to the Mets, whose nightmare season somehow reaches another low after a wild, 12-run offensive outburst still ends in defeat. He breaks down Juan Soto's incredible play being wasted, the team's endless defensive and pitching blunders, David Stearns' growing criticism, and why Mets fans have officially reached their breaking point.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and says the Yankees are focusing on the wrong issues. While Anthony Volpe continues to dominate the headlines, Chris argues the bigger concerns are Cody Bellinger's struggles, Paul Goldschmidt's shocking slump, and a team that's unraveling at the worst possible time.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and unloads on the Yankees after another frustrating loss. While everyone is focused on the team's record-setting strikeout totals, Chris says they're missing the real problems. He also dives into the latest Anthony Volpe controversy after reports surfaced that Volpe allegedly refused to play second base before Michael Kay walked back the story. Has the Yankees-Volpe relationship reached the point of no return?

Chris McMonigle breaks down the Yankees' pivotal win over the Rays, highlighting Cam Schlittler's dominant performance and the clear defensive upgrade provided by Jose Caballero. He also discusses Jalen Brunson's surgery, USA Soccer's disappointing loss to Belgium, and rumors surrounding Francisco Lindor's future with the Mets. 01:50 - Yankees Win In Tampa 05:10 - Caballero Versus Volpe Debate 21:47 - USA Soccer Loss To Belgium 30:44 - Schlittler Takes Win Personally 40:15 - Possible Luis Arraez Trade 27:10 - Future Of Francisco Lindor 24:17 - Brunson Plays Through Pain 21:56 - Paul McCartney Wedding Performance

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent success against the Tampa Bay Rays and debates the team's defensive strategy at shortstop. He advocates for Jose Caballero to remain the starter over Anthony Volpe, citing a disconnect between the front office's analytics and on-field performance. The discussion also covers the USMNT's recent struggles, Jalen Brunson's surgery, and potential roster changes. 01:21 - Yankees Win Over Rays 08:25 - Shortstop Depth Chart Debate 12:42 - Boone's Decision Making 18:28 - Upcoming Sports News Highlights 23:51 - The Jose Caballero Experience 29:10 - Responding to Yankee Callers 35:03 - Volpe's Career Trajectory 40:08 - Jazz Chisholm Roster Fit

Chris McMonigle praises Cam Schlittlers dominant outing and his Michael Jordan mentality of finding motivation in slights from critics. They analyze the Yankees' decision to start Jose Caballero over Anthony Volpe in the lineup. The conversation also covers rumors regarding a Francisco Lindor trade and the embarrassment of USA Soccer’s loss to Belgium. 01:20 - Cam Schliitler Dominates Rays 04:45 - Schlittler Takes It Personally 11:00 - Yankees Mentality Comparison 14:15 - Potential Yankees Trade Targets 17:35 - USA Soccer Belgium Loss 26:25 - Lindor Trade Rumors Surface 32:05 - Caballero Starts At Shortstop 42:05 - Mets Trade Rationale Breakdown

McMonigle evaluates the Yankees' recent skid and argues that Anthony Volpe might benefit from a stint in the minor leagues to regain his confidence. He also reviews the news of Jalen Brunson’s wrist surgery and debates the leadership dynamics between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto. 01:20 - Yankees Rays Series Preview 05:15 - Volpe vs Caballero Defense 12:00 - Francisco Lindor Trade Discussion 18:00 - Juan Soto Mets Chemistry 23:00 - Jalen Brunson Postseason Injury 31:20 - Anthony Volpe New York Pressure 36:30 - Aaron Boone Job Security 41:30 - Yankees Prospect Hype Machine

C-Mac evaluates the decision to start Jose Caballero over Anthony Volpe as the Yankees face the Rays. The discussion shifts to the Mets' future with Francisco Lindor and a heated defense of Aaron Boone's managerial track record regarding team accountability. Additionally, the segment covers Paul McCartney's rare performance at the Swift-Kelce wedding and trade deadline strategies involving Carlos Rodon. 01:20 - Yankees Shortstop Situation 06:07 - Mets Lindor Trade Talk 09:20 - Boone Job Security Debate 12:45 - Boone On Accountability 21:05 - Paul McCartney Wedding Story 25:37 - Ben Rice Derby Entry 29:45 - Rodon Bullpen Transition 12:35 - Argentina Soccer Update 15:05 - Jazz Chisholm Effort Debate

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on WFAN while Craig Carton is out, and he floats a fascinating idea for the Yankees ahead of the MLB Trade Deadline. Could Carlos Rodón become a postseason bullpen weapon if the Yankees add another frontline starter? C-Mac explains why it might make sense and discusses the Yankees' biggest trade deadline needs.

Chris McMonigle flies solo on WFAN while Craig Carton is out, and dives into the Yankees' recent struggles. Should Aaron Boone really be fired? Chris explains why the manager isn't the problem, why Anthony Volpe sitting is the right move, and why Yankees fans are directing their frustration at the wrong person.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and reacts to the news that Jalen Brunson underwent wrist surgery after leading the Knicks to an NBA Championship. Chris explains why Brunson's postseason performance is even more incredible knowing he played through an injury that required surgery, calling the Knicks captain the toughest athlete in New York.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and takes on one of the hottest debates in New York sports: Should the Mets trade Francisco Lindor?

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show while Craig Carton is away, and he's thrilled after seeing the Yankees finally make the move fans have been begging for—Jose Caballero starts at shortstop over Anthony Volpe! Chris breaks down why Aaron Boone got it right, reacts live to the Yankees lineup, and explains why Caballero gives the Yankees their best chance to win. Plus, Chris weighs in on the growing rumors surrounding Francisco Lindor's future with the Mets, why trading him over clubhouse drama would be a mistake, and what kind of return would actually make sense.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and can't stop raving about Yankees rookie sensation Cam Schlittler after his dominant performance against the Rays. Chris explains why Schlittler's mentality reminds him of Michael Jordan, breaking down the young pitcher's chip-on-the-shoulder approach and why that's exactly what the Yankees have been missing. Plus, Chris discusses the Yankees' World Series chances, whether they should make a blockbuster move for Tarik Skubal, and why the American League is wide open.

Chris McMonigle analyzes Cam Schlittler’s dominant start against the Rays and how his competitive fire mirrors Michael Jordan’s legendary drive. They also discuss the USMNT's embarrassing soccer loss to Belgium and explore potential trades for Francisco Lindor and Tarik Skubal. 01:09 - Cam Schlittler’s Dominant Performance 06:51 - Cam Schlittler’s Competitive Mentality 11:38 - Comparing Yankees and Rays 16:03 - USA Soccer Embarrassment 24:30 - Mets Trade Rumors

Chris McMonigle reacts to the New York Yankees' recent performance and the growing debate over the starting shortstop position. He critiques Aaron Boone's 'day-to-day' approach with Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe, while also highlighting a dominant outing from the pitching staff. The discussion on The Carton Show explores the tension between team analytics and on-field results during a pivotal stretch of the season. 01:00 - McMonigle Breaks Down Yankees Victory 03:43 - Jose Caballero Shortstop Debate 07:31 - Aaron Boone's Management Critique 12:53 - Analyzing Anthony Volpe's Struggles 17:31 - Previewing Upcoming Sports News

The Yankees have seemingly bottomed out after losing their first series to the Twins in 12 years. Chris McMonigle reacts to another lifeless series, and how the Yanks look awful in every facet of the game right now. From a punchless offense to continued starting pitching struggles amid more injuries, C-Mac gauges the level of panic heading into a massive series against the first-place Rays, and what needs to happen to wake this team up in the next four games, with the division seemingly on the line. Plus, where is Aaron Boone's place in this current swoon? Is his job on the line in the upcoming series at The Trop? Chris also dives into Carlos Langrange's injury and what that means for the bullpen moving forward, Anthony Volpe's latest error and how his playing time should be affected, and if fans are overreacting to this current stretch.

Chris McMonigle critiques the New York Yankees' recent collapse and looks ahead to a pivotal four-game series against the Tampa Bay Rays. He argues that roster construction failures under Brian Cashman and the poor performance of young players are more significant than managerial issues. The segment also addresses the Knicks' center rotation and a controversial decision in the US Soccer tournament. 02:05 - Yankees Disastrous Twins Series 07:24 - Crucial Tampa Bay Stretch 11:18 - Blaming Cashman For Roster 16:40 - Benching Anthony Volpe 19:35 - USA Soccer Controversy 27:19 - Yankee Lineup Decisions 31:00 - Managerial Accountability Debate 37:45 - Potential Deadline Trade Fits 45:30 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Truth 57:35 - Ricky Ricardo Series Preview

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent collapse and the lack of urgency regarding player performance and roster management on The Carton Show. He argues that changes are necessary at shortstop and in the bullpen to salvage the division race before the upcoming series in Tampa. 01:20 - Yankees Struggles Against Minnesota 06:26 - Division Stakes In Tampa 12:31 - Roster Construction Concerns 15:45 - Shortstop Dilemma And Volpe 21:09 - Schlittler's High Stakes Start 25:21 - Re-evaluating Management And Players 36:51 - Fan Frustrations And Pressing 50:12 - US Soccer And Knicks

Chris McMonigle critiques the Yankees' recent slide and emphasizes that the players, not Aaron Boone, are responsible for the team's poor fundamentals. He also joins Anthony Gallo to discuss the political and sporting implications of FIFA overturning Folarin Balogun's red card ahead of the USMNT match against Belgium. 01:19 - Yankees Season Outlook 04:46 - Cashman And Manager Accountability 10:15 - Yankees Catcher Debate 14:05 - Manager Comparison Analysis 18:05 - Team Fundamental Issues 20:53 - FIFA Red Card Controversy 24:53 - US Soccer Strategy 35:22 - Soccer Clock Rules Debate 40:03 - USMNT Squad Performance

Chris McMonigle dissects the controversy surrounding the USA versus Belgium match, specifically the political intervention to overturn a red card and the perceived corruption in soccer's stoppage time. He transitions to the Yankees' struggles, evaluating the decision to bench Anthony Volpe and the dire need for a catching upgrade. The segment wraps up with a discussion on trade deadline possibilities involving Bo Bichette and Luke Weaver. 01:21 - USA Soccer and Clock Controversy 08:31 - Yankees Catcher and Infield Issues 12:54 - Political Influence in World Cup 18:07 - Debate Over Stoppage Time Rules 26:49 - Yankees Lineup vs Tampa Bay 35:58 - Trade Targets: Bichette and Weaver

McMonigle and Ricky Ricardo break down the critical upcoming series between the Yankees and Rays as New York looks to snap out of a mid-season slump. They also address Mitchell Robinson's hand injury explanation and debate the future of General Manager Brian Cashman. 02:34 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Truth 06:27 - Knicks Center Options 08:53 - Sports Update 09:24 - Brian Cashman Tenure Debate 15:15 - Soccer Timekeeping Discussion 21:27 - Giancarlo Stanton's Recovery 23:49 - Yankees Trade Targets 31:20 - Ricky Ricardo Series Preview

Craig Carton is out, so Chris McMonigle takes over The Carton Show solo and is joined by Yankees Spanish radio broadcaster Rickie Ricardo ahead of a massive four-game series against the Tampa Bay Rays. Rickie explains why this series could define the AL East race, discusses what's gone wrong with the Yankees' offense, Aaron Judge's absence, Gerrit Cole's return from Tommy John surgery, Cam Schlittler's recent struggles, and why Cody Bellinger, Austin Wells, and the rest of the lineup need to step up immediately.

Chris reacts to Mitchell Robinson finally revealing how he broke his hand during the Knicks' championship run and discusses whether Andre Drummond can fill the void in New York. Plus, Yankees fans sound off on Brian Cashman's future, Chris weighs whether it's finally time for a new voice in the front office, and he dives into a passionate debate over soccer's controversial stoppage-time rules ahead of Team USA's World Cup showdown.

With Craig Carton on vacation, Chris McMonigle flies solo on The Carton Show and tackles one of the biggest sports controversies of the day. Chris and Anthony Gallo break down the USA vs. Belgium World Cup showdown, the controversial reversal of Folarin Balogun's red card, whether politics should influence FIFA decisions, and why Team USA suddenly has real momentum.

Chris McMonigle reviews the Yankees' latest lineup changes and the pressure on pitcher Cam Schlittler to perform against the Rays. He also examines trade deadline possibilities for the infield and discusses the state of US soccer following recent World Cup matches. 01:43 - Yankees Lineup Adjustments 03:28 - Cam Schlittler's Ace Potential 05:17 - Soccer and World Cup Debate 09:13 - Trade Deadline Infield Targets 13:43 - Lindor and Soto Relationship

Chris McMonigle analyzes the controversy surrounding the U.S. Men's National Soccer Team's match against Belgium after a presidential intervention overturned a red card for Folarin Balogun. He engages with callers regarding the lack of a stopping clock in soccer and explains why the current stoppage time system creates unnecessary uncertainty. The discussion also covers the New York Yankees' lineup needs, specifically the urgent requirement for a new catcher to replace the struggling Austin Wells. 01:00 - US Soccer Controversy 07:01 - Yankees Catcher Issues 11:13 - Trump Intervention Debate 16:28 - Soccer Clock Logic

McMonigle argues that the New York Yankees' recent slump is a player accountability issue rather than a failure of management by Aaron Boone. He debates callers on the team's roster construction, specifically defending Austin Wells and discussing historical comparisons to managers like Joe Torre and Joe Girardi. 01:00 - Yankees Urgency and Accountability 05:09 - Managerial Contracts and History 08:51 - Evaluating Austin Wells 11:35 - Phillies Managerial Comparisons 16:56 - Player Performance vs Management

Chris McMonigle assesses the New York Yankees' current slump and the criticism directed at Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman on The Carton Show. He analyzes the team's lack of focus, specific player struggles including Anthony Volpe and Austin Wells, and the void left by Aaron Judge's injury. The discussion also touches on rumors surrounding a celebrity wedding and upcoming news for the New York Knicks and international soccer. 01:00 - Taylor Swift Wedding Rumors 03:09 - Yankees Slump and Boone 11:18 - Volpe and Shortstop Debate 22:21 - Aaron Judge Injury Impact 27:38 - Knicks and Soccer Updates

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent series loss to the Minnesota Twins and the team's overall lack of focus on The Carton Show. He argues that the roster issues fall on Brian Cashman rather than Aaron Boone and highlights the necessity of a division title to ensure a deep postseason run. 01:00 - Yankees Struggle Against Twins 06:39 - Crucial Rays Series Preview 09:10 - Evaluating Boone and Cashman 15:29 - Shortstop Depth Chart Debate 20:06 - Cam Schlittler's Key Start

Is the heat turning up on Aaron Boone? Evan and Morash give their take on just how much at risk Boone is to lose his job. Plus, Craig and Chris sound off on the team seemingly hitting rock bottom, Morash is officially hitting the panic button on the season, and Tommy Lugauer says the team's wave of injuries has seemingly caught up to them.

Steve Cohen did an extensive interview with the New York Post, and our hosts have A LOT of questions after listening to the owner speak. Boomer and Gio wonder how Cohen could feel concerned about the state of the farm system given the team's investment in that area, while Evan and Morash wrap their heads around the Francisco Lindor/Juan Soto drama that, according to Cohen, is confined to last year. How do we know that for sure? Plus, Craig Carton went off on Cohen and the state of the Mets organization.

The longest-tenured Knick is no more, as Mitchell Robinson has signed with the hated Celtics on a three-year deal. Boomer and Gio sound off on the reality that Mitch was likely never coming back, while Evan Roberts says the move is nothing more than James Dolan's refusal to go into the second apron. Plus, Shaun Morash's instant reaction to the Mitch news, which broke while he was on the air, and Boomer and Gio react to the Knicks signing Landry Shamet to a new contract.

The Yankees losing streak has reached seven games after a brutal extra-inning loss to the Tigers, getting swept by Detroit at home for the first time since 2008. Chris McMonigle is FED UP with the Yanks woes, as he sounds off on the listless offense, Camilo Doval's implosion, the continued struggles of key players like Cody Bellinger in need of stepping up in Aaron Judge's absence, and how much of this losing streak is on Aaron Boone. C-Mac pushes back on the idea that this losing streak is just like previous June swoons (3:30), how Bellinger and Ben Rice are killing the team right now (5:00), the one part where this skid is like previous summer swoons (9:30), the highs and lows of Wednesday's heartbreaking finale (20:50), and the frustration of Yovanny Cruz being sent back to the minors (54:55).

Craig and Big Matt examine the Yankees' struggles as they endure a seven-game losing streak, questioning the job security of Aaron Boone. They dive into a hypothetical NBA landscape where LeBron James considers a move to the Knicks while the Celtics and Sixers pull off a massive trade. The conversation turns festive with a debate over July 4th traditions, featuring a guest appearance from Chris Christie and a round of the Wednesday Wheel. 01:50 - Yankees Seven Game Slide 07:00 - Boone Job Security Debate 10:30 - LeBron James To Knicks 18:15 - Mitchell Robinson Instagram Drama 27:45 - The Great Pie Debate 37:30 - Yankees Standard Broken 46:30 - Hot Dog History 31:05 - Chris Christie Joins Show 23:00 - Wednesday Wheel Game

Craig and Big Matt debate the possibility of LeBron James signing with New York for a veteran minimum contract to chase one final championship. They also analyze the New York Yankees' seven-game losing streak and address the mystery surrounding Mitchell Robinson's injury history following his departure to the Celtics. 01:20 - Yankees Seven Game Skid 05:00 - Yankees Hitting Struggles 10:05 - LeBron James Free Agency 13:45 - LeBron James Goodbye Tour 18:15 - Mitchell Robinson Exit 23:41 - MSG Celebrity Wedding 26:55 - The Wheel Topics 36:15 - Leon Rose Trust 41:35 - Boone Firing Debate

Craig Carton and C-Mac evaluate the state of the New York Yankees and whether the franchise's championship standard has slipped in recent years. They also explore the possibility of LeBron James joining the Knicks for a veteran minimum deal and argue over the necessity of apple pie on Independence Day. 01:20 - Lionel Richie Concert Grudge 05:45 - July Fourth Party Etiquette 10:50 - The Great Pie Debate 15:15 - Evaluating The Yankee Standard 19:40 - Postseason Championship Expectations 23:35 - Independence Day Traditions 27:45 - Holiday Food Allegations 34:15 - LeBron To The Knicks 38:50 - Knicks Championship Pursuit

Craig and Evan debate Aaron Judge's public comments about the Yankees' lack of focus during a losing streak while he remains sidelined with an injury. They also discuss NBA trade rumors, the history of hot dog recipes, and an experiment involving indestructible Oreos. 02:25 - Disney Dads and Reading 04:53 - Judge Questions Team Focus 10:40 - Meaning of Sports Accountability 15:30 - Yankees Trade Deadline Needs 20:15 - The Great Hot Dog Debate 25:43 - Seinfeld's Pop-Tart Movie Story 27:04 - Patriotic Apparel and Fireworks 36:34 - NBA Rivalries and Knicks 45:42 - The History of Oreos 51:18 - Mitchell Robinson Trade Talk

Governor Chris Christie joins to share his holiday plans and critique the crew's 4th of July dessert choices. He offers his take on the Knicks' chemistry and the potential arrival of LeBron James. The segment concludes with a chaotic round of the Wednesday Wheel featuring trivia on founding fathers and ringless athletes. 01:20 - Wedding Talk and Topics 04:41 - Chris Christie Joins 08:24 - State Fruit Pie Debate 13:41 - Mitchell Robinson Inside Info 15:20 - LeBron to the Knicks 18:17 - US Soccer Red Card 23:10 - Songs About America 30:05 - Founding Fathers Trivia 38:00 - Ringless Athletes Game 44:15 - Weekend Wrap

One segment... two unbelievable takes. 😂 Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the NBA's wild offseason, including the Celtics' stunning decision to trade Jaylen Brown and how it impacts the defending champion Knicks' quest to repeat. Then the conversation takes a hilarious turn as Craig reveals why he's officially sworn off Oreos forever after watching one viral video. Plus, fireworks, Fourth of July traditions, Yankees hats, dog owners, and plenty of classic Carton chaos.

With the Bronx Bombers in the middle of a brutal losing streak, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle tackle the biggest question in New York: Has the Yankees standard really fallen? Carton pushes back on the outrage, arguing that despite the frustration, the Yankees are still one of baseball's winningest franchises and that calling this era "the dark days" is an insult to what real losing looks like. The guys debate Aaron Boone, Brian Cashman, the expectations that come with wearing pinstripes, and why making the playoffs every year still matters—even if championships haven't followed.

Craig and C-Max evaluate the New York Yankees' roster gaps and trade deadline priorities as the team faces a critical stretch against divisional rivals. They also explore the competitive history of iconic food brands like Boar's Head and the origin story of the Pop-Tart. The segment features an anecdote about Jerry Seinfeld calling into the station to discuss his film, Unfrosted. 01:00 - Yankees Trade Deadline Needs 06:02 - Hot Dog Brand Rivalries 09:31 - Pop-Tart History And Seinfeld 14:13 - Afternoon Fan Updates

Craig and Chris McMonigle debate whether New York should put decades of LeBron hate aside for one more championship run. Would LeBron coming off the bench make the Knicks unstoppable? Would the circus be worth it? And would Knicks fans actually give him a standing ovation at Madison Square Garden?

A spirited debate breaks out over the necessity of apple pie on the Fourth of July and whether rejecting holiday traditions is considered un-American. The conversation shifts to favorite hot dog brands before critiquing wealthy celebrities like Michael Jordan and Brad Pitt for taking on unnecessary product endorsements. 01:00 - Ray Charles Musical Energy 02:11 - July 4th Pie Debate 04:05 - Holiday Food Traditions 07:30 - Top Hot Dog Brands 09:23 - Celebrity Endorsement Critiques

On WFAN's The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether the defending champion Knicks should actually consider signing LeBron James if he's willing to take a veteran minimum deal. Is it the perfect move for another title run, or would it turn New York into the LeBron farewell tour?

On this episode of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Aaron Boone deserves to be fired or if fans are overreacting to one brutal week of baseball. They discuss the Yankees' offensive collapse, defensive mistakes, injuries piling up, and why Boone has historically been able to pull the team out of these midseason swoons.

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to the shocking news of Mitchell Robinson joining the Boston Celtics and the Yankees' devastating seven-game losing streak. They evaluate Steve Cohen's decision to guarantee David Stearns' job security despite the Mets' struggles and a rumored blockbuster trade involving Jaylen Brown. The discussion captures the outrage surrounding New York's professional teams during a difficult summer stretch. 01:54 - Robinson Joins The Celtics 06:43 - Yankees Seven Game Losing Streak 11:51 - Steve Cohen Defends David Stearns 17:37 - Jaylen Brown Trade Rumors 22:19 - Yankees Offensive Ineptitude 27:40 - Fans Blast Aaron Boone 33:57 - Mets Front Office Future

Craig and Big Mac react to the Yankees’ seven-game losing streak and the team's struggles to execute in critical late-inning moments. They also discuss Mitchell Robinson signing with the Boston Celtics and Steve Cohen’s public defense of David Stearns' long-term plan for the Mets. 01:23 - Mitchell Robinson Knicks Exit 05:52 - Defining A Yankee Swoon 12:52 - Steve Cohen Podcast Interview 16:54 - Freddie’s Yankee Frustrations 20:05 - Managerial Decision Debates 24:10 - Knicks Roster Flexibility 29:26 - Bullpen Trust Issues 36:34 - David Stearns’ Five-Year Plan

Big Mac analyzes the breaking news of Jaylen Brown's trade to the Philadelphia 76ers for Paul George. He also expresses frustration over the New York Yankees' seven-game losing streak, criticizing Anthony Volpe's decision-making and the team's offensive struggles. 01:00 - Jaylen Brown Trade News 05:18 - Volpe Bunt Decision Critique 10:58 - Analyzing Yankees Summer Swoons 17:47 - Volpe vs Caballero Debate 21:49 - Sports Update and Recap

Chris McMonigle and Craig debate whether Cohen's commitment to Stearns is smart ownership or completely tone-deaf, especially with the Mets sitting near the bottom of the National League and reportedly preparing to sell at the trade deadline.

The Yankees' losing streak just keeps getting worse, and Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle are asking one question: What was Aaron Boone thinking?!

On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Mets owner's podcast appearance where he confirmed there was tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto during the 2025 season. Cohen also made it clear that David Stearns will remain the Mets' President of Baseball Operations through his full five-year plan, even as the team spirals.

The New York Yankees have officially entered a full-blown June swoon after dropping their 7th straight game, and Chris McMonigle has had enough. From blown opportunities to Aaron Boone's decisions, Cody Bellinger's struggles, and another frustrating extra-inning loss, Craig Carton and Big Mac break down everything that's gone wrong in the Bronx. Plus, Mitchell Robinson leaves the Knicks to sign with the Boston Celtics, ending his championship run in New York. Was letting Mitch walk the right move? Can Leon Rose replace his rebounding and defense, or will Knicks fans regret this decision?

Darryl Strawberry joins the program to share his perspective on the Mets' rebuilding phase and the need for a respected manager like Carlos Beltran or Albert Pujols. They also analyze the Yankees' five-game skid, LeBron James' departure from Los Angeles, and a significant Supreme Court ruling on transgender athletes. 01:50 - Yankees June Swoon 05:45 - Rice Offensive Struggles 11:40 - Postseason Lineup Concerns 15:20 - Supreme Court Ruling 25:15 - LeBron Lakers Exit 28:05 - Tarik Skubal Matchup 35:50 - Beatles Trivia Segment 44:00 - Darryl Strawberry Interview 51:20 - Mets Rebuilding Process

The Yankees' recent losing streak sparks a heated debate over whether the team is entering a "June swoon" amidst significant injuries to stars like Aaron Judge. Discussion shifts to a recent Supreme Court ruling on trans athletes in sports and the impressive dedication shown by Jalen Brunson to the Knicks. They also examine LeBron James' potential Lakers exit and the ongoing organizational silence from Mets owner Steve Cohen. 01:20 - Yankees June Swoon Debate 06:10 - Ben Rice Performance Struggles 14:15 - Knicks and Mets Update 18:00 - SCOTUS Trans Athlete Ruling 21:20 - C-Mac Backwards Hat Vulnerability 25:00 - Gallo World Cup Insight 29:10 - Yankees Versus Knicks Comparison 36:00 - Yankees Offensive Funk Analysis 43:10 - Future Yankees Roster Outlook

Craigie and Big Mac analyze LeBron James' departure from the Lakers, labeling his tenure a disappointment despite the bubble championship. They also debate Shohei Ohtani's historical greatness, questioning if a player can be the best ever without playing the field. Finally, they quiz a local intern on classic pop culture and discuss the intricacies of athlete hair transplants. 01:20 - LeBron Leaves Lakers 05:00 - Comparing Basketball Achievements 11:15 - All-Time Lakers Rankings 16:15 - LeBron's Disappointing Tenure 20:03 - Ohtani’s Historic Greatness 25:00 - Bronny and Kangol Style 29:30 - Celebrity Hair Transplants 36:22 - Intern Pop Culture Quiz 41:10 - Ohtani Cy Young Debate

They discuss the results of a listener poll regarding whether LL Cool J or Biggie Smalls is most associated with the song "Going Back to Cali" before pivoting to the New York Yankees' recent struggles. The conversation covers Aaron Judge's rehab progress and the pressure on younger players like Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler to fill the void. Callers also weigh in on the New York Mets' season and local Italian restaurant recommendations. 01:20 - Cali Artist Debate 05:12 - Song Title Challenge 10:36 - NBA Trade Reactions 15:12 - Mets Fan Perspective 19:03 - Italian Restaurant Talk 24:50 - Yankees June Swoon 29:56 - Aaron Judge Update 38:46 - Lakers Legend Debate 43:18 - Brooklyn Roots Invitation

Craigie and Big Mac analyze the latest "LOL Mets" moments, including an embarrassing outfield misplay and an on-deck circle injury. Mets legend Darryl Strawberry joins the program to preach patience during the rebuild and discusses the leadership vacuum within the clubhouse. 01:22 - Juan Soto's Outfield Blunder 06:40 - Fans React To Struggles 11:05 - Mauricio Hits Francisco Alvarez 16:45 - Soccer And Sports Update 21:10 - Biggie Smalls Poll Results 25:15 - Strawberry's Rebuild Message 40:45 - Predicting 100 Mets Losses 45:31 - Darryl Strawberry Joins Live

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to another embarrassing Mets loss, Juan Soto's disastrous defensive play, the growing questions surrounding the clubhouse, Lindor's visible frustration, Bo Bichette's emotional return to Toronto, and why this team is looking more like a Little League squad than a playoff contender.

The Yankees have dropped five straight, the offense has disappeared, and now Aaron Judge's injury timeline is raising even more concerns. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether this is officially a "June swoon," why Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler must carry the team, and what Judge's latest rehab update means for the Yankees' playoff hopes.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a call from 19-year-old Anthony, a passionate Mets fan who refuses to give up on his team despite a disappointing season. What starts as a baseball conversation turns into a heartfelt discussion about family, the 2015 World Series, grandma's famous meatballs, and why sports mean so much to fans of all ages.

Who owns "Going Back to Cali"- LL Cool J or The Notorious B.I.G.? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle turn a simple music question into an all-out debate, complete with a live listener poll that delivers a surprising result! Then the conversation goes completely off the rails with a rapid-fire trivia game featuring songs named after cities and states, hilarious intern struggles, and an unexpected NBA trade reaction.

From Big Mac's controversial hat getting compared to Spike Lee and LL Cool J, to Craig's brutally honest thoughts on going bald, comb-overs, and John Cena's hair transplant, the laughs don't stop. The conversation even spirals into classic TV shows, Beatles trivia with the interns, and whether Shohei Ohtani deserves to win the Cy Young Award.

Craigy and Big Mac debate the legitimacy of LeBron James' tenure with the Los Angeles Lakers and rank the greatest players in franchise history. They also discuss Shohei Ohtani's historic season and whether a player can be considered the greatest of all time without playing the field. 01:33 - Mitchell Robinson Update 02:15 - LeBron Laker Legacy 11:48 - Top Ten Lakers List 21:30 - Shohei Ohtani Debate 25:10 - Bronny James Contract

Craig and C-Mac examine the New York Yankees' recent five-game slide and debate whether the fan base is overreacting compared to previous New York Knicks struggles. They also discuss the Supreme Court's ruling on transgender athletes in sports and clarify soccer rules with Anthony Gallo. 01:00 - Soccer Shootouts and Josh Hart 03:05 - Gallo Explains Soccer Rules 07:09 - Yankees Slump vs Knicks 13:53 - Transgender Athletes in Sports 20:35 - Yankees Lineup and Catchers

Are the Yankees officially in a June swoon? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether New York's five-game skid is just a rough stretch or the beginning of something much worse. With Aaron Judge still out, Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger struggling, and the offense completely disappearing, Craig says the Yankees "stink right now" while Big Mac isn't ready to panic just yet.

Following a historically brutal weekend in Boston, we break down the Yankees' alarming offensive collapse and Aaron Boone's baffling post-game reaction. Plus, we look ahead to the trade deadline and debate whether it's finally time for Brian Cashman to go all-in.

Chris McMonigle is NOT happy after the Yankees lost what he declared the worst loss of the season to finish the worst series of the season. C-Mac sounds off on the scuffling offense, as Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger have contributed NOTHING of late, which is hurting the team while Aaron Judge is hurt (4:45). C-Mac also took exception to Jazz Chisholm leaving the clubhouse and not speaking to reporters after being ejected in the sixth inning, telling the second baseman to "grow up" (9:00). With Luis Arraez potentially on the trade market, Chris wonders if the Yankees could make a move, and if they're growing tired of Chisholm (30:00). C-Mac then breaks down the series as a whole, starting with Sunday's debacle, then breaking down why he is concerned about Gerrit Cole after he struggled again on Saturday, giving up more home runs in a rough start on Saturday when Chris was in attendance at Fenway Park (41:00). Finally, Chris breaks down his belief that the Yankees are well aware of Austin Wells' struggles and will acquire a catcher before the trade deadline, which furthers his belief that there is still no need for all-out panic, and the Yanks will ultimately be fine despite this ugly series (53:00).

Carton and Big Mac analyze Steve Cohen’s controversial behavior and his perceived disconnect from the Mets' fan base. Former Mets second baseman Wally Backman joins the studio to discuss his desire to manage the team and improve clubhouse accountability. They also examine the Yankees' recent sweep by the Red Sox and break down the news of Landry Shamet’s new contract with the Knicks. 01:50 - Steve Cohen’s Mets Controversies 07:28 - Fan Ejections and Signs 12:53 - David Stearns Leadership Evaluation 17:52 - Wally Backman Studio Interview 24:50 - Clubhouse Chemistry and Accountability 30:23 - Analytics vs Old School Baseball 37:10 - Yankees Lost Weekend Analysis 42:41 - Steve Cohen Ownership Perspective 53:58 - Mets Managerial Candidates 58:36 - Ja Morant Trade Impact

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to the New York Mets' free fall and owner Steve Cohen’s social media interactions with frustrated fans. They examine Eric Chavez’s insights into clubhouse dynamics and debate the New York Yankees' struggles after a sweep in Boston. The conversation also features a touching call from an 89-year-old die-hard fan and a critique of Emmanuel Acho’s take on Caitlin Clark. 01:08 - New York Baseball Meltdown 04:17 - Cohen’s Out of Touch Tweets 11:16 - Eric Chavez Clubhouse Claims 17:54 - Wally Backman for Manager 24:37 - 89-Year-Old Fan Call 35:03 - Carton’s New Rochelle Induction 42:56 - Acho’s Caitlin Clark Comments

Former Met Wally Backman joins the studio to discuss his new role with the Staten Island FerryHawks and offers his blunt assessment of the current Mets clubhouse culture. They also delve into a Knicks season ticket holder's legal battle and analyze Eric Chavez's revealing comments about Juan Soto's behavior during his time with the team. 01:55 - Summer Playlists 04:50 - Knicks Ticket Rights 13:15 - Mets Clubhouse Culture 18:45 - Wally Backman Interview 23:00 - Traditional Baseball Management 32:05 - Analytics and Rules 38:00 - Wrestling and Grittiness 43:15 - 1986 Flight Incidents 50:20 - Connecting With Fans

Craig and Big Mac debate if Wally Backman's old-school fire is what the Mets need while exploring the potential for Steve Cohen to sell the team. They react to the Yankees being swept in Boston and evaluate growing concerns regarding Gerrit Cole and Jazz Chisholm Jr. Additionally, they cover NBA news including Malik Beasley's indictment and Landry Shamet's contract with the Knicks. 01:20 - Wally Backman for Manager 05:30 - Stearns and Mendoza Struggles 10:35 - Steve Cohen Ownership Debate 15:40 - Sports Team Vanity Projects 19:45 - Mets Managerial Search 24:20 - NBA News Update 29:35 - Yankees Swept at Fenway 38:25 - Landry Shamet Knicks Extension 44:15 - Professional Ownership Ego 48:25 - Aaron Boone Quote Controversy

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze Aaron Boone's polarizing postgame remarks following the Yankees' sweep by the Red Sox, debating whether his optimistic leadership style is effective. They also examine the skepticism surrounding Steve Cohen's ownership of the Mets, specifically regarding his casino plans and his public handling of stadium incidents. Finally, they compare the Mets' historical championship drought to the Knicks' recent success. 01:40 - Mets Outfield Optimism Debate 04:50 - Defending Aaron Boone's Grind 11:25 - Tigers Matchup and History 18:55 - Steve Cohen’s Casino Narrative 24:55 - Owning Local Sports Teams 28:40 - Shamet Signs with Knicks 32:40 - Cohen’s Stadium Incident Tweets 38:15 - Mets and Knicks Droughts

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the latest Steve Cohen controversy and explain why many Mets fans feel the owner has become increasingly disconnected from the fanbase.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the ugly series, discuss whether Aaron Boone deserves the criticism, question Jazz Chisholm's recent behavior, and explain why injuries—not a complete collapse—are driving the Yankees' struggles. The guys also react to the Malik Beasley gambling indictment, discuss Steve Cohen's future with the Mets, and celebrate the Knicks bringing Landry Shamet back while hinting that Mitchell Robinson could be next.

The Mets' managerial search is officially underway, and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate who should replace Carlos Mendoza. Would Mets fans embrace Wally Backman, or should the organization pursue baseball legends like Albert Pujols, Carlos Beltrán, or David Ross? The guys discuss which candidate has the credibility to change the culture and reconnect with a frustrated fanbase. Plus, the show reacts to breaking NBA news as Ja Morant is traded to the Portland Trail Blazers, what it means for the Knicks, and rumors involving LeBron James, Anthony Davis, and the Warriors.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the New York Mets' disastrous season and debate whether owner Steve Cohen has become part of the problem. After discussing Wally Backman as a potential manager, the conversation turns into a heated debate over Carlos Mendoza, David Stearns, Cohen's social media presence, rising Citi Field prices, and whether the billionaire owner should actually consider selling the team.

Backman opens up about why he still wants to manage the New York Mets, what he believes is wrong with today's team, why chemistry wins championships, and how he'd handle stars like Juan Soto. He also shares incredible stories from the legendary 1986 Mets, Davey Johnson, clubhouse culture, old-school baseball, and why he'd take the Mets manager's job for FREE.

Big Mac & Craig addresses a longtime Knicks season ticket holder's frustration after having his membership revoked for reselling tickets on the secondary market. He also explores Eric Chavez's critical comments regarding the New York Mets' leadership and clubhouse dynamics. 01:00 - Don Toliver Ticket Giveaway 02:01 - Summer Vacation Playlists 03:57 - Knicks Ticket Revocation Debate 12:02 - Eric Chavez on Mets Culture 18:14 - Season Ticket Contract Clauses

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a heartfelt call from an 89-year-old lifelong Mets fan who has lived through the highs and lows of New York baseball—from the Brooklyn Dodgers leaving town to the Miracle Mets of 1969. The emotional conversation turns into one of the most memorable moments on WFAN as Craig asks whether he'll ever see another Mets championship. The guys also continue reacting to the Mets' disastrous season, Steve Cohen's leadership, David Stearns' future, and why the fanbase has completely lost faith in the franchise.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Yankees getting swept by the Red Sox, falling out of first place, and the growing concerns surrounding their postseason hopes. But according to Craig, the Mets somehow managed to have an even WORSE weekend. From Steve Cohen's controversial comments and fan backlash to the firing of Carlos Mendoza, Juan Soto clubhouse drama, and why Craig believes Cohen should take advice from James Dolan, nothing is off limits in this fiery opening segment of The Carton Show.

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate if the Yankees should pursue Tarik Skubal at the trade deadline. Plus, reaction to Jazz Chisholm's "lollipop-gate" and his heroics the next day; Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on why fans should back off Anthony Volpe; Boomer & Gio give their thoughts on Chisholm, too.

This week was NOT short on Mets rants, as Boomer and Gio sounded off on how poorly the team has played this season, with Boomer comparing these Mets to Phil Jackson's Knicks. Plus, Evan Roberts ripped the team for being "awful," and called on Steve Cohen to speak about the state of the franchise. Craig Carton did the same, while he and Chris McMonigle broke down the embarrassment the front office must have felt when Pete Alonso chants broke out at Citi Field.

The Knicks traded (a lot) during the NBA Draft, and we had all the reactions to what Leon Rose is up to this week. Plus, Becky Hammon addressed her comments about Jalen Brunson not being a 1A, leading to Evan Roberts sounding off on why that one sound bite will never go away. Plus, Boomer and Gio react to Julius Randle returning to New York...this time as a member of the rival Nets.

News broke Friday morning of the Mets firing manager Carlos Mendoza, and we had all the instant reactions, including Evan sounding off on the move being "too little, too late," Craig Carton applauding Steve Cohen for making the decision, and guesses on who will manage the team in 2027.

Craig Carton and Pete Hoffman analyze the New York Mets' decision to fire manager Carlos Mendoza following a string of embarrassing losses. They provide live coverage of David Stearns' press conference and speak with Todd Zeile, Terry Collins, and Paul Virzi about the team's future. 01:50 - Carlos Mendoza Fired 10:01 - David Stearns Blame 13:50 - Aubrey Huff Feud 21:50 - Mendoza Farewell Statement 28:32 - Live Stearns Presser 24:18 - Paul Virzi Joins 28:13 - Jackson Dart Potential 35:29 - Tipping Etiquette Debate 18:20 - Todd Zeile Interview 23:15 - Terry Collins Interview

Craig Carton reacts to the New York Mets firing manager Carlos Mendoza, arguing that the move was an act of mercy by owner Steve Cohen. He discusses why the blame now shifts entirely to David Stearns and considers whether a fiery personality like Wally Backman should lead the clubhouse. The conversation also touches on Carton's social media feud with Aubrey Huff and the general lack of accountability within the current roster. 01:20 - Mendoza Firing Reaction 05:15 - Stearns Accountability Debate 14:40 - Aubrey Huff Feud 18:50 - Mets Roster Struggles 26:35 - Wally Backman Discussion 36:10 - Future Mets Leadership 42:15 - Stearns Press Conference 46:15 - Summer Drink Talk

David Stearns holds an emotional press conference following the firing of manager Carlos Mendoza, taking full responsibility for the roster's failure and the worst Mets start since 2003. They are joined by comedian Paul Virzi to discuss the fallout, the Knicks' championship run, and the challenges of coaching in New York. 01:20 - Stearns Addresses Mendoza Firing 04:52 - Stearns Denies Stepping Aside 12:43 - Mets Not Turning Page 18:25 - Andy Green Interim Manager 19:21 - Analysis of Stearns Presser 23:48 - Paul Virzi In Studio 27:32 - Knicks Championship Memories 37:05 - Brian Daboll's Giants Tenure 39:28 - Tipping and Scissor Stories 47:05 - Lil Wayne and Manning Stories

Paul Virzi joins the program to explain why Jaxson Dart has the makeup of a franchise quarterback like Joe Burrow. They also discuss the celebrity fandom surrounding the Knicks before Todd Zeile breaks down the firing of Carlos Mendoza and the accountability of David Stearns. 01:20 - Jaxson Dart Comparison 04:45 - Famous Knicks Fans 08:32 - Mets Firing Reaction 13:40 - Weight Loss Journey 19:20 - Todd Zeile Interview 25:15 - Stearns Accountability 36:00 - Inside Manager Firing

Terry Collins joins the program to share his perspective on the New York Mets firing manager Carlos Mendoza and the team's overall lack of competitiveness. He and Craig discuss the nuances of locker room accountability and the importance of fundamentals in the major leagues. The conversation also covers the New York Knicks' roster moves, including Jose Alvarado's contract and the future of Karl-Anthony Towns. 01:20 - Carlos Mendoza Fired 05:10 - Terry Collins Interview 11:40 - Managing Team Passion 16:15 - Baseball Greats Discussion 20:54 - Mets Non-Competitive Play 25:15 - NBA Salary Cap Logic 32:15 - Knicks Fan Update 37:15 - Mets Game Excitement 41:40 - Anthony Gallo Banter

Cookie and Pete Hoffman break down the New York Knicks re-signing Jose Alvarado and the financial logistics of keeping Mitchell Robinson on the roster. They examine the fallout from the New York Mets firing Carlos Mendoza and brainstorm ways to keep fans engaged at Citi Field on WFAN. The duo also reacts to a caller's huge gambling win and critiques staff attendance during major news days. 01:54 - Alvarado Re-Signs With Knicks 07:53 - Historic Knicks Betting Win 13:18 - Mendoza Firing and Mets Woes 19:45 - Anthony Gallo’s Pink Eye 22:51 - Advice For Chris McMonigle

Chris McMonigle reacts to an ugly showing from the Yankee defense, making four errors in a series-opening loss in Boston, where Cam Schlittler gave up four runs, none of them earned. He sounded off on the growing Austin Wells problem, even if the nightmare fifth inning wasn't all his fault. C-Mac wonders if the defensive alignment is weakening the team in the field as Aaron Boone tries to get his best bats in the lineup. After a frustrating misplay at shortstop, fans want to see Anthony Volpe exiled, but Chris explains why that isn't the smart move right now.

Former Mets manager Terry Collins joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to react to Carlos Mendoza's firing and doesn't hold back. Collins explains why managers have to demand accountability, why today's Mets need to get back to baseball fundamentals, and why he still believes this team has enough talent to turn things around.

Carlos Mendoza is OUT as Mets manager, but was he really the problem? Todd Zeile joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to deliver a powerful defense of Mendoza, saying he was sent into battle with "no weapons" and that the front office deserves far more blame. Zeile also questions David Stearns' roster construction, discusses Steve Cohen's role in the firing, and reveals what really happens inside a clubhouse after a manager gets fired.

Craig Carton & Comedian Paul Virzi talk about his new found friendship with Jaxson Dart, his upcoming tour, and they take calls on the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza.

Friend of the Carton Show comedian Paul Virzi joins Craig to catch up on life including how the Knicks changed the way he viewed the world and how he views the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza through a Yankees fans lens.

Craig and Petey react to the firing of Carlos Mendoza and the need for David Stearns to take ownership of the team's struggles. They explore the lack of accountability within the roster before shifting gears to discuss a unique summer drink recipe. 01:00 - Harvard's Influence on Stearns 03:17 - Demanding Mets Accountability 09:28 - Watermelon Espresso Drink Recipe

Craig Carton reviews Carlos Mendoza's departure statement and critiques David Stearns' performance as general manager. He considers the case for Wally Backman as a potential manager who could bring much-needed toughness to the organization. Additionally, the conversation touches on the fan experience at Citi Field and the hurdles of finding a viable replacement for Stearns. 01:00 - Mendoza's Farewell Statement 06:10 - The Case for Wally Backman 09:25 - Evaluating David Stearns' Future

Carton explains why Steve Cohen actually did Mendoza a favor, shifts the blame squarely onto David Stearns, questions the future of the Mets organization, and breaks down what happens next with Andy Green taking over as interim manager.

Bret Boone joins the guys at 97.3 The Fan in San Diego to give his perspective on one of the hottest topics in Baseball - as his Brother and Yankees Manager, Aaron Boone, had to straighten one of his stars out after a questionable decision.

Chris McMonigle breaks down a big series win for the Yankees, including a thrilling win in the series finale against Tarik Skubal. C-Mac raves about the season that Paul Goldschmidt is having, how the former MVP looks like his prime self, and the Yankees can only hope he keeps up this pace, especially while Giancarlo Stanton is out (7:58). Plus, reactions to that huge home run from Jasson Dominguez against Skubal, and if that can get The Martian going (19:00). He then touches on the Jazz Chisholm lollipop drama, and why it was essentially no big deal (37:24). Chris then goes through the rest of the Detroit series, including Gerrit Cole's rough outing and if it was related to his start being pushed back (42:08), and how he thought Carlos Rodon looked in game two (46:43). Finally, C-Mac sounds off on how fans have seemingly lost the ability to root for Anthony Volpe, even while he is playing good baseball (51:23).

Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Mets’ historic defensive failure and the fan base's growing frustration with President of Baseball Operations David Stearns. They discuss the significance of the Pete Alonso chants and evaluate the team's trade assets as the season slips away. Additional topics include Nike's marketing of Victor Wembanyama and controversial rumors surrounding Hollywood legends. 02:15 - Mets Doubleheader Disaster 05:42 - Chants For Pete Alonso 10:04 - Steve Cohen Era Woes 14:31 - Stearns Evaluation Mistakes 20:00 - Bo Bichette Contract Discussion 26:56 - Drew’s Viral Chant Success 30:54 - Alonso Returns With Orioles 35:16 - MLB Contract Proposals 48:32 - Jeff Wilpon Martini Rumor 28:56 - Pregnancy Scare Prank 34:41 - 74-Year-Old Fan’s Reality 38:26 - Knicks Season Ticket Controversy 42:44 - Reselling Tickets Offline 20:41 - Statue Of Liberty Sneakers 27:00 - Wemby vs Knicks Sneaker Irony 32:05 - Jamie Lee Curtis Urban Legend 36:33 - Caitlin Clark Poster Snub 40:55 - Marilyn Manson Rib Myth 46:10 - JP Morgan Executive Firing 24:37 - Yankees Run Differential Lead

Craig and Big Mac vent about the New York Mets' embarrassing doubleheader loss, focusing on a historically bad six-error performance and the subsequent fan revolt. They discuss the viral Pete Alonso chant, criticize the front office's roster construction, and debate if a leadership change is necessary to salvage the franchise's culture. 01:45 - Mets Hit Rock Bottom 05:02 - The Pete Alonso Decision 10:51 - Cohen's Hiring Record 20:20 - Fans Demand Stearns Firing 26:30 - Viral Pete Alonso Chant 36:10 - Proposed MLB Contract Caps 41:15 - Hiring Wally Backman 49:20 - Jeff Wilpon's Revenge

Craig Carton reacts to his daughter's decision to attend a Mets game despite the team's ongoing struggles and recent blowout losses. They also debate a caller's claim that older fans may never see another Mets championship before discussing the Knicks revoking season tickets for playoff resales. Finally, the conversation turns to Nike's new Victor Wembanyama sneakers and a rumor about Jamie Lee Curtis. 01:26 - Carton's Daughter Mets Text 05:22 - Mets Title Mortality Debate 12:12 - Knicks Revoke Season Tickets 20:44 - Nike's Wemby Shoe Controversy 31:10 - Jamie Lee Curtis Rumors 37:37 - Mets Irrelevancy And Cohen

They evaluate the New York Mets' current irrelevance compared to the long-standing standard of the New York Yankees. The conversation touches on the leadership vacuum in the Mets' clubhouse following Steve Cohen's comments on team captains. They also preview an upcoming show featuring Plaxico Burress and Paul Virzi while debating viral social media trends and personal anecdotes. 01:50 - Mets Irrelevance Comparison 11:05 - Mets Student Ticket Controversy 15:20 - First Pitch Banter 21:20 - Mets Captaincy Debate 29:35 - Stearns And Rebuild Talk 37:30 - Plaxico Burress Guest Preview 48:10 - Viral JP Morgan Video 54:50 - Baking And Sourdough Banter 01:02:55 - Astoria Greek Diner Tour

Craig slams David Stearns over his roster construction as the Mets struggle with mounting defensive errors and failed reclamation projects. They highlight the massive run differential gap between the Yankees and the rest of the American League while discussing Paul Goldschmidt's MVP-level resurgence. The conversation also touches on past front office scandals and upcoming guests Paul Virzi and Plaxico Burress. 01:50 - Motown Rivalries & Samples 05:20 - Paul Virzi & Plaxico Burress 08:40 - David Stearns' Roster Critique 12:45 - Pitching Successes & Failures 16:15 - Front Office Scandal Recall 20:25 - Nextel Nostalgia & Supergirl 26:15 - MLB Run Differential Stats 09:45 - Mets' Embarrassing Struggles 13:35 - Paul Goldschmidt's MVP Play 16:45 - Analysis Of Mets Core

It is June 25, 2026, and the New York Mets are officially a $370 million disaster zone. Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle pull no punches as they declare the Mets completely irrelevant before the summer even gets rolling.

When Craig Carton suggests his co-host Chris McMonigle should throw out the first pitch at Yankee Stadium, things take a hilarious turn! Craig claims the fame is going straight to Chris's head, leading to an impromptu studio acting challenge to see how a "normal person" would actually react to the offer. Watch the chaos unfold as the Hoff, the intern, and an entirely clueless Gallo get dragged into the mix, with Gallo completely falling for the prank!

Craig and Pete preview Plaxico Burress' upcoming guest appearance before diving into bizarre urban legends like the Marilyn Manson rib rumor. The conversation shifts to a viral video involving a JP Morgan executive and a heated debate over The Beatles' discography. They also discuss the Mets' bleak future compared to the 1990 Yankees and upcoming vacation plans. 01:00 - Plaxico Burress Guest Hosting 04:23 - Marilyn Manson Urban Legends 09:25 - JP Morgan Viral Video 10:51 - Beatles Discography Debate 19:26 - Mets vs 1990 Yankees

Craig Carton goes OFF after Nike unveils a Statue of Liberty-themed sneaker for Victor Wembanyama featuring "You're Welcome" in English and French. Carton sees it as a slap in the face to Knicks fans after New York's NBA Finals victory, while Chris McMonigle thinks the shoe is actually hilarious because Wemby just lost to the Knicks.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a longtime Knicks season ticket holder who says the team revoked his tickets after he sold his NBA Finals seats. Is the organization cracking down on ticket resellers, or is this unfair to loyal fans who've supported the team for decades?

The Carton Show and several callers vent about the New York Mets' embarrassing performance and growing fan apathy following a six-error game. They discuss the potential firing of manager Carlos Mendoza and whether Wally Backman or David Stearns can fix the franchise's clown show culture. 01:00 - Mets Fan Apathy 04:39 - Hiring Wally Backman 08:34 - David Stearns' Future 13:48 - Jeff Wilpon's Reaction

After a disastrous Mets collapse, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the fan who started the viral "Pete Alonso" chant and explain why September could become a full-blown nightmare for David Stearns and the Mets front office. Will Mets fans give Alonso a hero's welcome when he returns to Citi Field with Baltimore? Could it become the loudest anti-management statement in franchise history? Carton and Big Mac break down the growing frustration in Queens and why the fan base may have officially reached its breaking point.

After surrendering 20 runs in a disastrous doubleheader and committing SIX infield errors, Mets fans are fed up. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the growing outrage at Citi Field, the chants for Pete Alonso, the backlash against David Stearns, and whether Steve Cohen's biggest gamble has completely blown up in his face.

My Man Pots N' Pans Ohhhh Yeahhhh | The fellas break down a boring NBA Draft, the Mets are in total freefall, Aliens will reportedly abduct Neymar and fans at the World Cup, Craig makes his pitch for small-town Mayor, Jaxson Dart has crazy expectations, and much, much more. Tell Ya Friends!

Craig and Cmac discuss another Kodai Senga meltdown and also last night's NBA Draft might have been the worst ever. Plus, enough of the Anthony Volpe bashing.

Craig and Cmac discuss the massive expectations surrounding Jaxson Dart this season. Plus, apparently aliens will invade the World Cup and abduct Lionel Messi and Neymar tonight.

Craig and Cmac discuss the disaster at Citi Field. Are the Wilpons still running the Mets? Plus, Craig calls multiple local butchers to find the answer on pulled pork. That and much more.

Hour 4: Craig and Cmac break down how Juan Soto must feel currently with the Mets. That and more.

On this segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Big Mac dive back into the stadium seat upgrade scandal. Callers confirm the worst: the Mets are actively trying to squeeze extra cash out of the few loyal fans left sitting in an empty ballpark. Craig drops a radical solution to fix baseball: a 7-inning, 10-run mercy rule to just let everyone go home early! Plus, a breakdown of why Bo Bichette won't be walking away from his massive contract despite an absolutely abysmal season.

On this segment of The Carton Show, Craig and Big Mac react to an absolute ghost town at Citi Field. Reports flooded in that during a miserable, empty doubleheader, the Mets' ballpark app sent an alert to the few loyal fans in attendance teasing "first come, first serve" seat upgrades. The catch? They were trying to force fans to pay the full price difference just to move down! Craig slams this "obnoxious money grab" by a team that has given up 40 runs in four games.

The New York Knicks are holding all the cards, and Craig Carton isn't afraid to let the rest of the NBA know it!

On this segment of The Carton Show, Craig and Big Mac dive into a heated debate about why American sports culture feels completely dead compared to the absolute chaos and party atmosphere of World Cup soccer. From "miserable" Wednesday night baseball crowds to why some fans completely HATE the stadium wave, Craig explains why he’s officially jealous of international fanbases.

The Mets' disastrous season takes center stage on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to furious fans demanding answers from Steve Cohen and David Stearns. Is this one of the biggest roster-building failures in Mets history? The guys break down Nolan McLean's meltdown, the decision to let Pete Alonso walk, Bo Bichette's struggles, and whether the Mets should SELL at the trade deadline.

On WFAN's The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the shocking Fanatics Fest ticket frenzy, where Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart sold out autograph and photo opportunities in just 30 minutes—despite barely starting his NFL career.

On WFAN's The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head over the growing Anthony Volpe debate. Carton argues it's time for Yankees fans to stop the constant criticism and give Volpe credit for his breakout season, while Big Mac explains why some fans still don't fully trust him.

On WFAN's The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a stunning rumor circulating around baseball: Did Juan Soto sit out on the exact day Francisco Lindor returned because the two stars don't want to play together?

Craig and Big Mac dive into 'Lollipop Gate' after Yankees manager Aaron Boone publicly criticized Jazz Chisholm for sucking on a blow pop during a game. They also discuss the Mets' controversial doubleheader scheduling and interview reporter Chrissy Froyd about NFL reporting ethics and rumors surrounding Dianna Russini. 01:50 - Lollipop Gate Hits Yankees 14:05 - Mets Rainout Ticket Controversy 25:00 - Chrissy Froyd Interview 33:55 - NFL Investigation Updates 46:50 - NBA Draft Speculation

Craig and Big Mac dive into "Lollipop Gate" after Jazz Chisholm Jr. was spotted playing second base with a blow pop in his mouth. They examine Aaron Boone’s uncharacteristic public criticism of the player and weigh the optics of in-game candy against traditional snacks like sunflower seeds. They also touch on the New York Mets' handling of a recent rainout and preview insider NFL stories from Chrissy Froyd. 01:20 - New York Sports Update 04:51 - Jazz Chisholm's Lollipop Debate 09:48 - Boone's Frustration with Jazz 15:15 - Mets Rainout Ticket Lividness 17:25 - Callers Debate Lollipop Optics 26:30 - Comparing Seeds and Candy 36:10 - Safety of Field Snacks 42:44 - Boone's Line in Sand

Craig and Big Mac host Chrissy Froyd to discuss her dismissal from USA Today and her explosive claims regarding unethical behavior among NFL reporters. They later shift focus to the New York Yankees, debating Aaron Boone's ban on lollipops following a viral moment with Jazz Chisholm Jr. at second base. 01:20 - Chrissy Froyd Interview 04:14 - USA Today Firing Controversy 07:14 - Media Misconduct Allegations 12:51 - Journalism Career Future 17:21 - Dianna Russini Scandal Discussed 22:12 - Jazz Chisholm Lollipop Ban 27:17 - Yankees Organizational Criticism 38:54 - Orange Buzz Drink Segment 42:03 - Yankees Alumni Meeting Plans

Craig Carton and the crew analyze the staggering 15.3 billion views from their recent James Dolan interview following the championship parade. They debate the NFL's disciplinary standards regarding Geno Smith and the supplemental draft, highlighting inconsistencies in the league's integrity policies. Additional discussions cover the viral moment of Jazz Chisholm Jr. eating a lollipop on the field and a humorous confusion between Todd Bowles and Ray Rhodes. 01:25 - Fanatics Fest Show Plans 05:38 - Chris Christie Co-Hosting 11:51 - Viral Dolan Interview Views 13:42 - Geno Smith Allegations Investigation 21:45 - NFL Integrity Policy Debate 29:25 - Jazz Chisholm Lollipop Controversy 43:13 - IK Enemkpali Punch Story 49:45 - Todd Bowles Presser Audio

Craigie and Big Mac dive into the controversy surrounding Aaron Boone's reaction to Jazz Chisholm Jr. eating a lollipop during a game. They also float a wild theory about LeBron James finishing his career with the Boston Celtics to challenge the New York Knicks in the East. Finally, legendary sports agent Don Cronson calls in to share stories from his time representing NBA and NFL stars. 01:00 - NCAA Rules & Lollipops 03:42 - LeBron To Boston Theory 09:05 - Heat, Giannis & Knicks 14:48 - NBA Draft & Slither.io 19:39 - Mickey Mantle & Boone

What starts as Aaron Boone’s frustration over Jazz Chisholm turns into full-blown comedy: MLB players “honoring” the lollipop controversy, bizarre on-air jokes that go off the rails, and Craig pushing the segment into uncomfortable territory nobody saw coming. Then things take a turn when a legendary former NBA/NFL agent calls in with an unbelievable résumé, prompting Craig to abruptly end the call and promise him a spot on tomorrow’s show.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the biggest NBA rumors heading into the draft and discuss why the defending champion New York Knicks still own the East. But Craig throws out a shocking scenario that would send Knicks fans into a frenzy: LeBron joining Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown in Boston.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a New York Post report involving Geno Smith and a traffic stop that raised eyebrows. The conversation quickly turns into a hilarious trip down memory lane, including the infamous IK Enemkpali punch that broke Geno Smith's jaw, Todd Bowles' awkward press conference, and Craig repeatedly calling him "Ray Rhodes" by mistake!

Craig and Big Mac discuss the staggering 15.3 billion views reported for their viral interview with James Dolan and the fallout from Jazz Chisholm's lollipop usage during games. They also address updates regarding Geno Smith's legal status and the NFL's decision-making process for the supplemental draft. 01:00 - SNY Issues And Vacation Debates 05:36 - Chris Christie Co-Hosting Friday 07:49 - James Dolan Viral Interview Success 11:28 - Geno Smith And Supplemental Draft 24:26 - Jazz Chisholm Lollipop Controversy

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the bizarre controversy surrounding Jazz Chisholm after cameras caught the Yankees infielder working on a Blow Pop during a game against the Tigers. Aaron Boone addressed it, fans are furious, and Big Mac thinks the outrage says more about Yankees fans than it does about Jazz.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome former NFL reporter Chrissy Froyd to The Carton Show on WFAN for a stunning interview about the controversy surrounding Dianna Russini and Mike Vrabel. Freud claims the issue goes far beyond one person and says she knows of other alleged relationships between reporters and NFL sources.

Chris and the callers debate whether Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s decision to suck on a lollipop during a game is a sign of a deeper culture problem or just harmless optics. They analyze Aaron Boone's uncharacteristically public criticism and consider if this 'Lollipop Gate' is the final straw for the Yankees manager. 01:37 - Yankees Management Debate 05:52 - Lollipop Safety Concerns 09:44 - Boone Slams Chisholm 18:00 - Baseball Optics Discussion 23:38 - Sports Update

On WFAN's Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the bizarre controversy surrounding Jazz Chisholm playing second base with a lollipop in his mouth during the Yankees' loss to the Tigers. Aaron Boone reportedly wasn't happy, fans exploded online, and Craig can't understand why THIS is the issue everyone is focused on while the Yankees have bigger problems.

The Yanks dropped two of three at home to Cincinnati, and Chris says it is the first time that the team's injuries have started to show themselves as a real issue for the current roster. Plus, C-Mac sounds off on the Anthony Volpe vs. Jose Caballero comparison, and how the two aren't treated equally. He also slams Jasson Dominguez's lack of instincts in the outfield (24:30), examines catching options to acquire at the trade deadline, and discusses bullpen trade options.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether the champion New York Knicks should risk team chemistry to trade for Giannis Antetokounmpo. They analyze recent New York Yankees defensive lapses, evaluate the auction prices of historic memorabilia, and share nostalgic stories from a long-time Brooklyn Dodgers fan. 02:40 - Giannis Trade Debate 07:10 - Building A Dynasty 12:40 - Roger Clemens Comparison 19:00 - Yankees Defense Issues 20:25 - Geno Smith Allegations 27:15 - Historic Basketball Values 30:45 - Türkiye Name Change 33:45 - Iconic Sports Artifacts 39:55 - Summer Song Debate 41:55 - Brooklyn Dodgers Nostalgia

Craig Carton and Big Mac argue over whether the New York Knicks should trade Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges for Giannis Antetokounmpo to solidify a dynasty. They compare the potential move to the Yankees' historic acquisition of Roger Clemens after a championship win. The conversation also covers the Yankees' recent struggles and summer gardening plans. 01:20 - NBA Draft and Giannis 04:26 - Trading For Giannis 13:54 - Yankees Comparison Case 19:52 - New York Baseball Update 24:40 - Brunson and Giannis Synergy 32:30 - Comparing Stars in Boston 39:55 - Caller Stevie Joins 43:42 - Gardening and Pickling Discussions

Craig and Big Mac explore the massive price tags for Knicks memorabilia and the allure of holding legendary artifacts like the "Immaculate Reception" ball. They also listen to an 89-year-old caller’s stories about Mickey Mantle and Sandy Koufax before debating if old-school icons could survive in the modern era. 01:20 - Value of Knicks Basketballs 05:10 - Touching the Immaculate Reception 12:26 - Knicks Birkin Bag Auction 18:25 - George Recalls Sports Legends 24:56 - Birkin Bags and Movie Trivia 30:40 - Giannis Knicks Chemistry Concerns 39:14 - Rain and Summer Songs 43:24 - Ted Williams Modern Day Debate

Craig and Big Mac analyze the allegations surrounding Geno Smith and discuss the Jets' potential interest in the supplemental draft. They also debate the name change of Türkiye, the merits of Disney vacations, and why LeBron James' off-court behavior and playing style make him a poor fit for the Knicks. 01:20 - Geno Smith Video Allegations 06:02 - Jets Supplemental Draft Strategy 11:33 - Türkiye and World Cup Woes 14:58 - Yankee Suite Polo Mishap 18:43 - The Great Disney Debate 23:05 - Slither.io and Workplace Etiquette 27:00 - Men Taking Baths Discussion 32:00 - MmmBop Release Date Argument 35:30 - Craig’s Dislike for LeBron James 40:05 - Roger Clemens Gambling Stories

Craig Carton recounts discovering a massive player points balance at Mohegan Sun and treats his crew to a shopping spree. They also compare James Dolan's ownership style to George Steinbrenner and analyze the Yankees' recent defensive lapses and Jasson Dominguez's performance. 01:06 - Craig's Mohegan Sun Story 10:08 - James Dolan's Band 12:32 - Dolan vs George Steinbrenner 15:14 - Yankees Defensive Struggles 16:48 - Jasson Dominguez Critique

Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle breaks down his upcoming summer vacation plans, which sparks Craig to recall the time they almost opened the "Boomer and Carton Grill". Craig explains how a casual trip with his crew turned into a Pretty Woman shopping spree after a casino executive exposed his hidden high-roller status.

Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle react to the breaking news and viral video involving New York Jets quarterback Geno Smith. Allegations of a wild domestic dispute, a police wellness check, and bizarre accusations have surfaced—but what is the actual truth behind the video? The guys break down the evolution of the story, the statement from the mother of Geno's child, and why a caller thinks they spotted something highly illegal hidden in the background of the footage. Plus, Craig explains why he actually agrees with part of the viral rant!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a wild and controversial segment after a viral video involving Geno Smith sparks major discussion across the sports world. The guys break down the disturbing allegations, the police wellness check, and what it all means for the New York Jets moving forward while stressing what is known vs. what is still speculation.

Absolute chaos on The Carton Show! 😂 Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go from arguing about Giannis joining the Knicks, to a hilarious Ted Williams debate that spirals completely out of control. Plus, Birkin bags, rain songs, Brook Lopez reading Silence of the Lambs, and one unforgettable WFAN caller.

Things got wild on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debated the value of iconic sports memorabilia, including the basketball from OG Anunoby's championship tip-in that could fetch MILLIONS!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle continued their fiery debate over a potential Giannis Antetokounmpo trade, and things got WILD. After hearing fans argue Karl-Anthony Towns is a better fit than Giannis, Carton couldn't believe what he was hearing. 🤯 But somehow the conversation spiraled from Knicks dynasty dreams to… homemade pickles?!

Things got HEATED on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle went head-to-head over a wild Knicks offseason debate! Should the defending NBA Champion Knicks break up their core for Giannis Antetokounmpo?

Fresh off an NBA Championship, Craig Carton throws out a bombshell idea on WFAN: should the Knicks trade Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges for Giannis Antetokounmpo?

Hear from James Dolan, Mike Breen, and Joe Benigno as they reflect on the Knicks' championship run.

Evan & Tiki are live from the parade and hear from the speeches at City Hall as the Knicks celebrate their championship with their fans. Plus, Evan & Tiki on the chaotic scene from the parade (15:52); Tommy Lugauer joins in at City Hall (30:15); Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle recap the atmosphere from the parade (48:53; Carton sounds off on celebrities having a float (1:09:31); Boomer & Gio hear from callers live from the parade (1:25:18).

Full Show: Breaking down the Parade, debauchery included, but don't change the Parade route! Plus, Cam Schlittler is the best young pitcher in baseball, Big Mac gets bougie in the Yankee Owner's Box, and much more.

Hour 1: Craig and Chris break down the Knicks parade and Craig says it's not time to move on from the title win. Plus, Craig works his magic to get Big Mac in the Owner's Box at Yankee Stadium.

Hour 2: Craig does not want the Knicks parade route changed, debauchery at the parade, plus Ben Stiller is filming a Knicks documentary and the guys wonder how. That and much more.

Hour 3: Craig and Cmac discuss the Ben Stiller Knicks documentary, how to change your phone to black and white, and much more.....

Hour 4: The fellas play spin the wheel....The intern has a rough-go of it, but so does basically everyone....Plus, USA! USA! USA! And more.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle play Spin The Wheel of Fun with Conor Green and intern Ethan, who doesn't know anything about anything.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take the reasonable approach to a complaint about Alicia Keys and the New York artists selected to perform at the Knicks' 2026 Championship Parade.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get a call from someone who tried on Charles Dolan's Yankee Championship rings and tells Craig that he might just get a 2026 Knicks ring because they "give them out to anyone." Another caller compares Jalen Brunson to Payton Pritchard. Craig took both of these things very well.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss some of the more viral moments of the Knicks' Championship Ticker Tape parade, such as the orange & blue trash can that was unceremoniously stolen, the women fighting over spots on lightposts, and the seeming lack of actual ticker tape.

Craig and CMac bring on special guest Thomas McMonigle to talk about the Yankees and his favorite Yankee player. Thomas also undergoes some of Uncle Craig's signature torture, and winds up able to go see his favorite team from some sweet seats.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate how the Knicks can defend their title with the perfect Mitchell Robinson replacement. That will be coming out of the NBA draft. These TWO college centers could really make an impact coming into Mitchell Robinson's back up role for New York.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss Karl-Anthony Towns and Josh Hart's upcoming contract extensions and just how important it would be for the Knicks' chances of repeating as Champions if either, or both, took a paycut.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Friday's show by refusing to let go of the 2025-26 CHAMPION New York Knicks, debating just how worried fans should be about James Dolan's proclamation on The Carton Show about the salary cap's second apron, and wondering if Aaron Boone might just be the best manager in MLB.

Craigie and Big Mac reflect on the electric atmosphere in Manhattan following the New York Knicks' long-awaited championship victory. They discuss Jalen Brunson’s leadership, the city’s massive turnout, and share humorous stories from their walk through the parade route. They also debate the Hall of Fame credentials of current players and the pressure on the Yankees to deliver a title of their own. 01:50 - Knicks Parade Atmosphere 06:40 - Crowds and Security 12:25 - Jalen Brunson’s Speech 16:25 - NYC Traffic Madness 25:25 - Walt Frazier Snub 35:45 - The Parade Pipe 41:40 - Yankees Management Pressure 50:35 - Championship Ring Banter 53:50 - Hall of Fame Debate

Craig and McMonigle recount their experience at the New York Knicks' long-awaited championship parade, highlighting the city's electric atmosphere. They analyze Jalen Brunson’s leadership and speech while discussing the mounting pressure on the Yankees to end their own title drought. 01:20 - Knicks Parade Experience 10:28 - Addressing Parade Complaints 14:50 - Post Championship Fan Outlook 19:45 - Celebrity Float Appearances 23:58 - Walt Frazier Debate 27:32 - Jalen Brunson Leadership 34:03 - Mony Mony Lyric Debate 40:18 - Yankees Under Pressure 46:45 - Craig Texts Yankee Brass

They recap the chaotic celebration of a Knicks championship, from viral twerking videos to James Dolan's controversial parade speech. The conversation covers a parking garage confrontation, a debate over the length of the Canyon of Heroes route, and the invention of a "Parade Pipe" for long-distance relief. Finally, they criticize a major jersey error displayed at City Hall and plan custom "Just the Tip" hoodies. 02:28 - Parade Twerking Incidents 06:50 - Domain Name Scramble 13:55 - Parking Garage Altercation 17:10 - Street Sign Fight 21:15 - Parade Route Debate 26:15 - The Parade Pipe 35:15 - Mitchell Robinson's Truck 46:15 - City Hall Blunder 52:35 - Custom Hoodie Design

Craigie and Big Mac analyze the Yankees' hot streak despite missing Aaron Judge during a lively discussion on The Carton Show. They dive into Karl-Anthony Towns’ Hall of Fame credentials and share wild stories from the Knicks championship parade, including an encounter with an underground counterfeit ring on Canal Street. The segment wraps up with a look at New York City's secret tunnels and plans for a dumpling tour. 01:32 - Yankees Dominance Without Judge 07:18 - New York Basketball Legends 16:45 - KAT Hall Fame Debate 27:50 - Custom Knicks Hoodie Workshop 37:25 - Underground Counterfeit Ring Encounter 43:45 - Secrets Of New York Tunnels 50:30 - Knicks Salary Cap Future 55:10 - Planning The Dumpling Tour

Craigie and Big Mac celebrate the championship parade while ranking the most iconic moments of the season, specifically highlighting O.G. Anunoby’s clutch plays. They also debate Karl-Anthony Towns’ Hall of Fame credentials and compare this historic run to past New York sports legends like the 1986 Mets. 01:00 - Ranking Knicks Season Moments 06:19 - Towns Hall Of Fame Debate 07:41 - Comparing Iconic Sport Runs 12:19 - Anunoby Game Winning Ball 18:21 - Brunson’s Playoff Killer Instinct

C-Mac reflects on the electric atmosphere of the Knicks championship parade and the bittersweet feeling of the celebration coming to an end. He praises Jalen Brunson's leadership and clutch performance, comparing the point guard's winner's mentality to that of Michael Jordan. 01:00 - Knicks Championship Parade Recap 03:43 - Jalen Brunson's Clutch Legacy 06:00 - Carton Show Sign-Off

Craig and Big Mac celebrate the New York Knicks' championship parade and conduct a blind ranking of the season's top moments, including O.G. Anunoby’s iconic "Tip" play. They also debate a caller's claim about Karl-Anthony Towns' Hall of Fame credentials and compare the greatest championship runs in New York sports history. 01:10 - Knicks Championship Parade Recap 02:34 - Blind Ranking Knicks Moments 06:19 - KAT Hall of Fame Debate 10:26 - Comparing NY Sports Runs 13:31 - Missing Game-Winning Basketball

They workshop designs for a 'Just the Tip' hoodie before reflecting on the wild sights and counterfeit gear found at the Knicks championship parade. One speaker recounts a tense encounter with a gang leader in a massive underground warehouse filled with designer knockoffs near Canal Street. The conversation transitions into the history of New York's Prohibition-era tunnels and a plan for a city-wide dumpling tour. 01:44 - Workshopping Hoodie Designs 07:31 - Knicks Parade Sights 10:36 - Canal Street Gang Encounter 16:37 - New York's Secret Tunnels 23:31 - Isaiah Hartenstein Debate

The Yankees’ recent success without Aaron Judge is analyzed, noting their climb in the American League standings. The conversation transitions to the Knicks’ championship parade, exploring the history of Ossie Schectman and the franchise’s first points. A heated debate follows regarding Karl-Anthony Towns and whether his career stats warrant a Hall of Fame induction. 01:32 - Yankees Success Without Judge 04:32 - Knicks Parade Callers 09:34 - New York Basketball History 14:43 - Championship Ring Debate 16:45 - Towns Hall Of Fame Debate