Rob Manfred joins Craig and Big Mac to talk about the state of baseball, baseball realignment, salary caps and a whole lot more. Plus, why are Giants fans running scared?

Chris McMonigle kicks Craig out and answers your questions on this special segment of the Carton Show

Boomer and Gio issued a golf challenge to Craig Carton and his son Sunny and Craig has accepted. What comes next? Nobody knows!

In the first hour of the Carton Show, Big Mac & Craig get into over the Giants fans panic that the Dolphins may steal John Harbaugh from them. They also dive into Craig's 3 "outrageous" demands for his return.

Hour 2 of The Carton Show is dominated by a fiery Craig Carton rant aimed straight at New York Giants fans. After the Miami Dolphins fire Mike McDaniel, Carton unloads on Big Blue fans who panic over John Harbaugh potentially slipping away. Craig calls the reaction embarrassing, labels Miami a poorly run franchise, and argues the Giants remain the superior football job despite the noise. The hour also features heated debate on NFL coaching searches, billionaire owners throwing money around, and what insecurity has done to the Giants fan base, plus continued buildup to MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred’s in-studio appearance later in the show.

Hour 3: Rob Manfred Talks Potential Lockout, Realignment, and Softball Face-Off with Craig

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle sit down in studio with MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred for a wide-ranging, candid conversation on the state of baseball. Manfred addresses free agency deadlines, the Dodgers’ spending power, competitive balance concerns, and whether baseball needs spending incentives or a salary cap. He also discusses looming CBA fears, the integrity of the game amid gambling expansion, automated balls and strikes, the World Baseball Classic, MLB expansion and realignment, regional sports network instability, and his legacy as commissioner.

undefined

Craig and Chris wrap up a jam packed show with another exciting hour!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into two heated topics on The Carton Show. Craig questions whether Travis Kelce now regrets publicly supporting Rashee Rice after disturbing allegations surface, sparking a blunt discussion on accountability and public perception. The segment then explodes into a fiery debate over the Miami Dolphins firing Mike McDaniel and why Giants fans are suddenly panicking about losing John Harbaugh. Carton rips the insecurity of Big Blue fans, dismisses Miami as a real threat, and clashes with McMonigle over whether the Dolphins are legitimately in play.

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle kick off this segment talking WBC and if the excitement of the tournament could be replicated in the MLB Regular season. Craig also question Big Mac's choice to not get excited about international competitions and team USA.

Craig Carton unloads on New York Giants fans who panic after the Miami Dolphins fire Mike McDaniel, opening speculation around John Harbaugh. On The Carton Show, Craig calls out what he sees as insecurity, whining, and embarrassment from Big Blue fans worried about Miami stealing their top coaching target. Carton argues the Giants remain the better job, blasts the Dolphins as a poorly run franchise, and says Giants fans need to act like a premier fanbase again. A fiery, classic Carton rant on WFAN.

Craig opens today's show saying how all of the expectations of John Harbaugh may not be as much of a lock as people think. Plus some breaking news, Michael McDonald is actually Anita Baker. Plus, the Yankees let Edward Cabrera slip away and Mark Schlereth calls in to confirm Sean Payton is not a fan of Craig Carton! Also... it's the debut of What The F*** Wednesday!

Craig Carton rains on the Giants parade by breaking down why celebrating John Harbaugh as the next Giants head coach may be premature. In a long-form, heated debate with Chris McMonigle, Carton explains the NFL’s coaching chessboard, why Harbaugh has leverage over the Giants, and how jobs in Buffalo, Philadelphia, Green Bay, or elsewhere could change everything. A must-listen for Giants fans riding the emotional rollercoaster of the coaching search.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bounce all over the map in classic Carton Show fashion. The guys react to the latest Lenny Dykstra arrest update, then dive headfirst into the Giants’ coaching search—questioning why fans drool over John Harbaugh but shrug at Mike McCarthy despite nearly identical résumés. Along the way, Carton delivers scorching takes on fat-shaming coaches, overrated Italian food orders, vodka sauce crimes, and even revives his wild Anita Baker–Michael McDonald conspiracy. Sports, pop culture, and pure chaos wrapped into one unforgettable segment.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive headfirst into the New York Giants’ chaotic coaching search. The guys debate the Rooney Rule, whether the Giants botched their timing, and why waiting on John Harbaugh could be a massive gamble. From Mike McCarthy skepticism to the nightmare scenario of Harbaugh landing with the Eagles, this segment hits everything Giants fans are arguing about right now — with Carton pulling no punches and C-Mac keeping it real.

In the final hour of today's show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the high-stakes coaching search for the New York Giants. Craig argues that the Giants need to "play chess, not checkers" by satisfying the Rooney Rule immediately to finalize a massive five-year deal with John Harbaugh before the NFL landscape shifts on Monday. They debate the risk of losing Harbaugh to potential openings in Philadelphia or Buffalo if the team waste time. The hour also features the debut of a new segment, "ETF Wednesday," where the guys discuss bizarre legal stories—including a former NFL lineman suing his ex-wife over intimate comments and Candace Owens’ legal battle with the French presidential family. Plus, a deep dive into "Shohei Ohtani Day," the slow pace of the MLB offseason, and a listener's congratulatory call to CMac on his move to the afternoon slot.

Chris McMonigle discusses the Mets boring offseason, the Giants coaching search, and more.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debut a new recurring segment, WTF Wednesday, and it immediately spirals into classic Carton chaos. From a former NFL lineman suing his ex-wife over “compliments,” to defamation lawsuits that defy logic, the guys react to the wildest story on the internet. The conversation then pivots into a deep dive on MLB’s broken offseason, why free-agent deadlines make sense, Dodgers dominance, Yankees frustration, and Major League Baseball celebrating Shohei Ohtani — plus Carton’s lingering skepticism about the interpreter scandal. A segment that’s equal parts absurd, hilarious, and sports-radio therapy.

Former NFL Star and friend of the show Mark Schlereth calls into the Carton show to talk NFL Coaching Carousel and much more!

Only on the Carton Show: Craig Carton unveils a completely unhinged (and hilarious) music conspiracy theory claiming Anita Baker isn’t real—and is actually Michael McDonald in disguise. From slowed-down vocals to Nutty Professor comparisons, Carton and Chris McMonigle spiral into a classic pop culture rabbit hole before pivoting into Mets frustration, MLB offseason boredom, and why baseball can’t match the NFL’s buzz. Peak Carton chaos with laughs, outrage, and zero proof.

What starts as Giants coaching talk quickly turns into an all-time Carton Show detour when Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive headfirst into Italian food debates. From ripping vodka sauce and Alfredo as “American crimes,” to overrated red sauce restaurants, garlic-and-oil supremacy, and what you should never order at a legit Italian spot—this segment is classic Carton chaos with callers chiming in and tempers flaring over pasta.

Craig Carton plays the role of the “Grinch” as he pumps the brakes on Giants fans celebrating the idea of John Harbaugh coming to New York. In a fiery chess-vs-checkers debate with Chris McMonigle, Carton explains why Harbaugh holds all the leverage, why the Giants can’t rush this process, and how other NFL jobs (Bills, Eagles, Packers) could derail Big Blue’s plans. Is this the greatest coaching carousel ever—or a potential disaster waiting to happen for the Giants?

The show started with Craig and C-Mac agreeing that Aaron Glenn has missed the mark again meeting with the media, but the bigger question, why does Stevie Wonder wear a watch? News broke twice on the show. The first report, Kevin Stefanski was on a plane to Newark to interview with the New York Giants. The second report, John Harbaugh was let go by the Baltimore Ravens. Should the Giants send Stefanski packing before he gets off the plane?

Craig Carton is officially back—and he wastes no time unloading on the New York Jets. In Hour 1, Craig and Chris McMonigle react to the Jets’ end-of-season press conference, ripping Aaron Glenn for a tone-deaf, arrogant message that left fans more frustrated than hopeful. Why Carton says the Jets are “not allowed to have good things,” why trust in the organization is completely broken, and why this was a massive missed opportunity to show humility.

Hour 2 of The Carton Show turns into must-listen radio when Craig Carton drops breaking news that sends Giants fans into a frenzy: Kevin Stefanski is on a plane to Newark—and then officially lands. Craig and Chris McMonigle debate whether Stefanski is the guy for Big Blue, why the Giants job might be the most attractive opening in the NFL, and whether the team should make a “hotel offer” and not let him leave the building.

dive deep into the chaotic fallout of the New York Giants' coaching changes. With Brian Daboll out, the guys debate if hiring Kevin Stefanski is a masterstroke or a massive mistake, and why Kliff Kingsbury might actually be the move that makes the fans "moist." Then, the conversation shifts to the gridiron legends and the "watered down" state of the NFL Hall of Fame. Craig makes a controversial stand against Eli Manning’s induction, sparking a heated debate about whether two Super Bowl rings are enough to mask a .500 career record.

Craig and C-Mac start the hour speaking to John Fanta about a controversial call in last night's Rutgers hoops game but then News Breaks that John Harbaugh is out as Ravens Head Coach. All hell breaks loose

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the news that the Ravens have fired John Harbaugh. Safe to say Chris McMonigle is very happy.

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle discuss the news that Kevin Stefanksi is currently enroute to Newark Airport and if he is the right man for the Giants Head Coaching vacancy

The guys debate Breece Hall’s future, whether the Jets missed their chance to trade him, and why he may have no reason to return to a losing organization. Plus, a brutal breakdown of Garrett Wilson’s shocking stat line, ownership accountability (or lack thereof), and why Woody Johnson would never face the fans the way James Dolan just did. Also Madden Ratings, 100-Fry Oil, and are pig spankings coming back?

Craig hits C-Mac with some NFL trivia and the duo tries to figure out the best way to approach the Jets coaching search

On show number two of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the "stark realization" of being a Jets fan: they simply aren't allowed to have good things. The duo holds nothing back while dissecting the end-of-year press conference featuring General Manager Darren Mougey and Head Coach Aaron Glenn

We share the best reactions to the Giants' 34-17 win over the Cowboys and the decision to retain Joe Schoen from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show

WFAN presents a selection of conversations about the Jets and their season-ending blowout loss at the hands of the Buffalo Bills from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle.

Craig Carton has returned to WFAN and with him, he brings in his new co-host Chris McMonigle as they talk about the end of the 2025 season with the New York Giants and Jets. First up, Giants confirm that Joe Schoen is returning, so who do we think the next head coach will be? Plus, Aaron Glenn was part of the worst season ever in New York Jets history, so let's keep him! Plus, Governor Chris Christie calls in to welcome in the boys AND James Dolan sits down with Craig and Chris to discuss why the Knicks couldn't win with Tom Thibodeau.

In this high-energy segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the current state of New York sports following an insightful interview with James Dolan. The duo dives deep into the championship expectations for the New York Knicks and Rangers, debating whether anything short of a Finals appearance is a failure for the city's most iconic franchises.

New York Knicks and Rangers owner James Dolan joins The Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle for a rare, wide-ranging, and candid interview—his first public sit-down in years. Dolan opens up about the controversial decision to move on from Tom Thibodeau, why collaboration and player development drove the coaching change, and why this Knicks roster is built to win an NBA championship now, not just compete. On the Rangers side, Dolan explains his patience with Chris Drury and Mike Sullivan, the culture reset in progress, and why fans shouldn’t give up despite early struggles.

The Carton Show officially begins on WFAN as Craig Carton makes his long-awaited return to afternoon drive alongside Chris McMonigle. The debut show open gets off to a chaotic, hilarious start as Carton and C-Mac joke about the rocky launch, producer mishaps, and the pressure of Day 1. From there, they dive straight into Jets vs. Giants dysfunction, coaching decisions, quarterback futures, and Craig’s bold vision for fixing New York football. A must-listen opening that sets the tone for a brand-new era on WFAN.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive head-first into one of the most divisive Giants debates in years: is winning late in a lost season actually the worst result? A passionate Giants fan sparks a heated argument over draft position, instant gratification, and whether the franchise sabotaged its own future by beating the Cowboys. Craig unloads on why meaningless wins are a slap in the face to long-suffering fans, why trusting Joe Schoen on draft day is still a massive leap of faith, and how Hard Knocks permanently damaged his confidence in the Giants’ decision-makers. The discussion spirals into draft logic wars, quarterback development, tanking vs. culture, and why picking “lower” doesn’t magically make a bad GM smarter. Plus, Carton takes aim at coaching candidates, rips the idea of settling for recycled coordinators, and closes with a classic Carton rant about Madison Square Garden, Brooklyn, and celebrity bandwagon fans.

Tom Brady’s dating life from a father’s perspective, sparking a hilarious and brutally honest discussion about age gaps, parenting, and why some things just feel wrong. The show then pivots to serious New York football talk, breaking down why Joe Schoen is staying put with the Giants, how John Mara’s health factors into organizational continuity, and whether the Giants’ roster is actually closer to contention than fans want to admit. Plus, passionate calls on coaching candidates like Jon Gruden, Mike Tomlin, and Jim Harbaugh, a deep dive into why offensive line dominance is the real key to winning in the NFL, and one of the most memorable moments in WFAN history—Chris McMonigle officially “making it” with Dunkin’ Donuts after receiving donuts with his face on them. Sports, comedy, hot takes, food talk, and Carton storytelling all collide in a wildly entertaining second hour.

James Dolan joins the program and breaks his media silence as C-Mac, Craig, and Dolan get into it over a host of topics.

The third hour of the show picks up on the Giants and Jets conversation from earlier, Knicks Hopes, and much more!

Tom Brady Rant, Giants GM Debate & Dunkin’ Donut Immortality | The Carton Show

The Carton Show officially begins on WFAN as Craig Carton makes his long-awaited return to afternoon drive alongside Chris McMonigle. The debut show open gets off to a chaotic, hilarious start as Carton and C-Mac joke about the rocky launch, producer mishaps, and the pressure of Day 1. From there, they dive straight into Jets vs. Giants dysfunction, coaching decisions, quarterback futures, and Craig’s bold vision for fixing New York football. A must-listen opening that sets the tone for a brand-new era on WFAN.

Boomer & Gio on Joe Schoen’s standing within the Giants organization. Plus, Chris McMonigle on potential Giants coaching candidates and why Schoen remaining is hardly a surprise (11:21); C-Mac is rooting for the Giants to lose on Sunday (20:46); Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash dispute the narrative Jaxson Dart is prone to concussions (36:38); Brian Baldinger on the appeal of the Giants coaching job (48:34); C-Mac explains why Eli Manning deserves to be in the Hall of Fame (54:36).

Jon Heyman joins Marc Malusis to discuss the latest rumors around the Yankees and the direction they’re going in what has been a quiet offseason. Plus, Jerry Recco and Willie Colon speculate what the plan is for the Bronx Bombers (8:40); Chris McMonigle refutes the notion the Yankees are ‘dysfunctional’ with Hal Steinbrenner calling the shots (15:57); C-Mac also says do not expect the Yankees to make a splash (24:20)

Joe Benigno joins Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber to voice his disdain for the Aaron Glenn Jets; Boomer and Gio weigh in on Glenn’s future (22:09); Jets beat reporter Al Iannozzone joins Marc Malusis on why Glenn will likely get another year (38:50); Shaun and Tiki on whether or not the Jets coaches are in over their heads (56:21); Shaun and Tiki also discuss if Joe Burrow really is a realistic option for the Jets (1:08:23).

Hour 1: The Giants HC job is an attractive one, but the Giants have to get it right. The Giants have the quarterback, now they need the coach who will get the most out of him. What's the cutoff for saying "Happy New Year"? Hour 2: Art Stapleton breaks down the Giants coaching search, the draft, the offseason and could the next head coach choose a quarterback that is NOT Jaxson Dart? Would Moose ever want to do Giants play-by-play? And do the Giants' defensive failures get overlooked? Hour 3: CFB Playoff format and a plan to fix the Jets. Al Iannazzone to talk all things Jets, and Nick Kostos breaks down the week 18 gambling slate in the NFL. Hour 4: Jon Heyman joins Moose to discuss the Yankees hard budget holding them back, while the AL East, and rival Blue Jays continue to improve. Then the conversation shifts to the Mets shedding their stars and what the plan will be moving forward. Callers chime in on Aaron Glen, the Giants and the baseball offseason.

Hour 1: The Giants HC job is an attractive one, but the Giants have to get it right. The Giants have the quarterback, now they need the coach who will get the most out of him. What's the cutoff for saying "Happy New Year"?

Hour 2: Art Stapleton breaks down the Giants coaching search, the draft, the offseason and could the next head coach choose a quarterback that is NOT Jaxson Dart? Would Moose ever want to do Giants play-by-play? And do the Giants' defensive failures get overlooked?

Hour 3: CFB Playoff format and a plan to fix the Jets. Al Iannazzone to talk all things Jets, and Nick Kostos breaks down the week 18 gambling slate in the NFL.

Hour 4: Jon Heyman joins Moose to discuss the Yankees hard budget holding them back, while the AL East, and rival Blue Jays continue to improve. Then the conversation shifts to the Mets shedding their stars and what the plan will be moving forward. Callers chime in on Aaron Glenn, the Giants and the baseball offseason.

Jon Heyman joins Moose to discuss the Yankees hard budget holding them back, while the AL East, and rival Blue Jays continue to improve. Then the conversation shifts to the Mets shedding their stars and what the plan will be moving forward.

Nick Kostos joins Moose to talk all the gambling angles for this week in the NFL, plus he complains about the Giants.

Al Iannazzone joins Moose to discuss why Aaron Glenn has earned another year as the Jets head coach, and reasons for Jets fans to be optimistic in 2026.

Art Stapleton breaks down the Giants coaching search, the draft, the offseason and could the next head coach choose a quarterback that is NOT Jaxson Dart?

Hour 1: The Giants HC job is an attractive one, but the Giants have to get it right. The Giants have the quarterback, now they need the coach who will get the most out of him.

Moose unleashes on Aaron Glenn for his inconsistent messaging and being at the helm of the worst December in NFL history

Moose brings on Ralph Russo who let's us know which teams are the favorites in the College Football Playoff, and also explains why he believes that Eli Manning belongs in the Hall Of Fame

Moose explains how Dart positively impacts their coaching search and also brings on CP The Fanchise to break down the current pros and cons about the Knicks

Moose breaks down the future of the Giants, talks more Eli HOF, and gives the legendary Dov Kramer a final sendoff

Moose Breaks Down Why Aaron Glenn Is His Own Worst Enemy, Eli Manning Deserves To Be Inducted Into The Hall Of Fame, And Also Why Jaxson Dart Makes The Giants Appealing. Ralph Russo Of The Athletic Previews The College Football Playoff And CP The Fanchise Joins To Talk Knicks

Moose gives Dov Kramer a final sendoff and we hear from Dov himself one last time

Moose explains to a caller why Eli's occasional mediocrity hurts his Hall Of Fame status

Mike in Manhattan wants to talk to Moose about CMac's backstory again

Moose brings on CP The Fanchise to break down the current pros and cons about the Knicks

Moose tells us why the Giants have their guy in Dart and that impacts their coaching search

Moose explains why he believes that Eli Manning belongs in the Hall Of Fame

Moose brings on Ralph Russo who let's us know which teams are the favorites in the College Football Playoff

Moose compares Glenn walking back his effort critique of the Jets to little league coaching

Moose breaks down Aaron Glenn's mixed messaging after an embarassing Week 17 loss to the Patriots

CMac unpacks another miserable season for the Giants and Jets and who is in fact closer to turning it around.

CMac explains why the Giants beating the Raiders has no meaning and just how bad the 2025 Jets have been

CMac explains why the Giants and Jets are on opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to the quarterback position

CMac Unpacks Why Joe Schoen Has Not Done Enough With The Tools He's Had At His Disposal, The Mets Need To Do Something About Their Starting Pitching, And Brian Baldinger Gives Us The Facts About Jets, Giants & The Rest Of The NFL

Brian Baldinger joins CMac to discuss the sad realities of of both New York football teams and also how the NFL postseason will play out with teams locking into their seeds

CMac gives his vote for Eli Manning being a Hall Of Famer but it may not be in 2026

CMac explains why Schoen has been a below average GM in a situation where he's had the opportunity to be great

CMac has his doubts about Joe Schoen but believes that he should hire either Mike Tomlin or Jim Harbaugh should they become available

CMac hears the rumors but he believes that all signs point to a minimal offseason for the Bombers

CMac laments Joe Schoen still be in place as Giants GM

CMac lays out why he doesn't believe in Aaron Glenn and also how the Jets and Giants can finally get this rebuild right

CMac believes that the Jets and Jet fans alike need to operate without fear when it comes finding their next franchise QB

CMac opens the show by laying out why the first year of the Aaron Glenn experience has been the exact opposite of what Glenn promised when he was hired

Jerry Recco and Chris McMonigle discuss if it’s time to clean house. Marc Malusis on the Jets’ ‘historically bad’ performance against the Patriots (10:13), and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on if the lack of fight is indicative of Aaron Glenn’s future (28:14)

Jerry Recco and Chris McMonigle wonder where the Giants season went wrong? Marc Malusis believes the Giants showed they have talent (7:48), and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on why Sunday’s win is meaningful despite losing the No. 1 pick (18:38).

Moose breaks down the Giants win over the Raiders while talking about the Jets blowout loss to the Patriots.

Moose debates callers who believe there is too much tanking in the NFL. Shoutout to the great Dov Kramer. Have Jets fans given up on the franchise?

Jets fans have reached a breaking point after another brutal loss to the Patriots.

Callers make the claim that teams are purposely tanking in the NFL for better draft position.

Moose on the idea that Giants were better off losing to the Raiders. Should the Giants keep Joe Schoen as GM?

Moose responds to those who want Joe Schoen fired.

Moose debates a caller on the idea that the Giants should have tanked Sunday's game in Las Vegas.

Moose says the Giants have a good pool of talent to build around led by Jaxson Dart. What's next for Joe Schoen and the head coaching vacancy?

The Giants must make sure they have the right people making decisions for the future.

Moose says the Giants have a good amount of talent to build around.

Moose breaks down the disaster that is the 2025 Jets. What's the plan for 2026 and beyond at head coach and QB?

Moose on if Aaron Glenn is the right head coach for the Jets.

Moose opens the show by saying yesterday's 42-10 loss to the Patriots was nothing short of a disaster.

Evan & Tiki question which is more valuable to the Giants: Jaxson Dart or the No. 1 pick? Plus, Marc Malusis on why he believes this weekend’s game vs. the Raiders is the Giants’ Super Bowl for draft capital (18:43); Malusis also expresses skepticism he has about Fernando Mendoza (32:12); Shaun Morash and Tiki dive into Dart liking a video of C-Mac’s criticism of the Giants (45:41); Jerry Recco and Willie Colon if it’s worth playing Jaxson Dart if the goal is to tank (55:20).

Joe Benigno joins Shaun Morash to talk Jets’ future and NFL Draft trade possibilities. Plus, Morash and Tiki discuss if Gang Green could realistically target Lamar Jackson in a trade; Jerry Recco and Willie Colon on whether the Jets should pursue a rookie or veteran QB; Marc Malusis entertains the possibility of a Jets-Giants draft trade for the No. 1 pick; Jerry and Willie dissect what went wrong with Justin Fields and also whether or not the Jets are stuck going nowhere.

Hour 4: New Coaching Options for BOTH The Jets and Giants?? Mets Fans Love Pete Alonso More than they Root for the Mets?

Hour 3: The Jets Hit ANOTHER New Rock Bottom...How? Can we Stop Teams From Tanking in Sports? Can the Jets be Peer Pressured into Firing

Hour 2: Could the Jets end up with Lamar Jackson?? The Jets Need to Be Open to Moving on from Aaron Glenn This offseason

Hour 1: Do the Knicks championship expectations give you hope for the Jets and Giants futures? Gordon says it starts with making the right moves this offseason. Giannis Antetokounmpo will be a Knick, but when? The Lamar story in Baltimore is shocking, could it really fall apart for the Ravens?

The Lamar story in Baltimore is shocking, could it really fall apart for the Ravens?

Gordan Damer opens the show saying the Knicks championship expectations, proving even teams who seem hopeless -- the Giants and Jets -- can turn it around with the right moves

The Mets have continued taking a sledgehammer to the team's core, trading Jeff McNeil to the A's. Jerry Recco doesn't understand the plan after parting with several key contributors, while Evan says there better be additions coming soon. Plus, Marc Malusis says the Mets are clearly David Stearns' team now, and he better get it right.

Hour 2: The Jets MUST get their Quarterback in this year's draft. Aaron Glenn's job is reportedly safe... but should it be? Fernando Mendoza or Jaxson Dart - Who is the franchise QB? Hair transplants in 2025.

The Jets MUST get their Quarterback in this year's draft. Aaron Glenn's job is reportedly safe... but should it be?

Hour 1: Gordon says the Giants MUST lose to the Raiders so they can fully tank and rebuild this offseason. John Harbaugh vs. Mike McCarthy as next Giants HC. Who is the 'Real' Jaxson Dart?

Gordon says the Giants MUST lose to the Raiders so they can fully tank and rebuild this offseason.

In this high-stakes holiday edition, Marc "Moose" Malusis pulls no punches as he surveys the wreckage of the New York sports landscape. From the "gutting" of the Mets' homegrown core and David Stearns’ controversial scorched-earth rebuild to the Jets’ desperate search for a franchise savior in Francisco Mendoza, Moose breaks down the moves that will define 2026. Between heated calls from frustrated fans and an X’s and O’s deep dive with NFL Insider Brian Baldinger, Marc also gets personal—discussing the challenges of raising kids in a sports-betting culture and the "science" behind his perfect holiday menu. Whether it’s the Rangers’ closing window or the Giants’ coaching carousel, this is the definitive year-end guide for the New York fan.

In a blistering opening segment, Marc Malusis reacts to the "gutting" of the Mets' homegrown core following the trade of Jeff McNeil to the Oakland A's. Malusis pushes back hard on the narrative that "clubhouse chemistry" was the reason for the 2025 collapse, instead pointing the finger squarely at a disastrous pitching staff and a "leaky" organization. As David Stearns systematically replaces fan favorites like Pete Alonso and Brandon Nimmo with defensive "grinders" and reclamation projects, Malusis warns that the honeymoon is over: Stearns has officially molded this team in his own image, and in New York, his "vision" better result in wins—or he’ll be the next one on the hot seat.

In this high-energy holiday edition, Marc "Moose" Malusis dives deep into the state of New York sports as 2025 comes to a close. The conversation kicks off with the New York Jets’ draft strategy, specifically whether the team should trade a haul of picks to move up for Indiana quarterback Francisco Mendoza. Malusis weighs the massive capital required against the desperate need for a long-term solution under center, referencing the cautionary tale of Sam Darnold’s development. The focus then shifts to the New York Mets, where Moose handles a flurry of calls from frustrated fans. The debate centers on David Stearns’ analytical approach to player valuation, the departure of homegrown stars like Pete Alonso, and the glaring absence of a starting pitching rotation as Christmas approaches. Malusis also addresses rumors of a toxic clubhouse culture and the pressure on manager Carlos Mendoza to reign in a team of high-priced egos. Finally, the show touches on the Giants' coaching future and the nuances of raising "good human beings" in a fast-paced world.

In this holiday edition of the program, Marc Malusis tackles the modern intersection of family life and sports. The episode kicks off with a deep dive into the "forbidden fruit" of sports betting, as Marc discusses how to navigate the rise of gambling culture with his three sons. He reflects on his own childhood memories—from the pressure of making Christmas magical for his kids to the specific science of his holiday menu (featuring a spiral ham and homemade stuffed shells). The conversation then shifts to the field with NFL Insider Brian Baldinger, where the two break down the shifting landscape of the AFC and NFC. They discuss the resurgence of Philip Rivers, the potential for John Harbaugh to land with the Giants, and the current state of the Jets under Aaron Glenn. Between Mets hot takes and holiday prep, it’s a comprehensive look at sports and life as the year winds down.

In this fast-paced segment, Marc Malusis breaks down the pivotal decisions facing New York’s biggest franchises. He dives into the NFL Draft debate, weighing the high-stakes potential of Fernando Mendoza against the technical polish of Simpson, while cautioning the Jets against repeating their history of "convincing themselves" into a quarterback. The conversation then shifts to the ice, where Malusis offers a sobering evaluation of the New York Rangers. He discusses the closing championship window, the lack of homegrown player development, and the tough reality of navigating a veteran roster in a salary-cap world. Whether it’s draft capital or blue-line struggles, Malusis provides the essential New York sports perspective.

In this segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis dives deep into the state of the New York Rangers as they head into the 2025 holiday season. Following a call from a long-time listener, Moose offers a searing critique of Chris Drury’s roster management, arguing that the team has become "older, slower, and more expensive." The discussion heats up as Moose suggests the unthinkable: trading away superstar assets like Igor Shesterkin and Artemi Panarin to capitalize on their value before the core completely regresses. From the lack of homegrown development to the missed opportunities of recent trade deadlines, Malusis delivers a raw look at why the Rangers' championship window may have officially slammed shut.

In this segment, Marc Malusis fields a call from "Angel in the Bronx," who expresses deep concern over the New York Jets’ history of "throwing rookies to the wolves" too early. Referencing the failed tenures of Sam Darnold and Zach Wilson, the discussion shifts to the potential 2026 top prospect Fernando Mendoza (the recent Indiana Heisman winner). Malusis argues that while the Jets often rush development to spark a "maturation process," the success of a quarterback depends more on the individual player's scouting and the team's internal pressure to win immediately.

In this segment, Marc Malusis dives into the high-stakes debate surrounding the upcoming NFL Draft and whether the New York Giants should use a potential #1 overall pick on quarterback prospect Mendoza. While acknowledgeing the team's desperate need for a signal-caller, Malusis expresses skepticism, comparing Mendoza’s ceiling to other prospects like Alabama’s Simpson. He argues that the organization must avoid the "trap" of forcing a selection based on need rather than evaluation. Instead, Moose explores the tactical advantage of trading down to acquire massive draft capital, suggesting that if several teams fall in love with Mendoza, the Giants might be better off building a deeper roster rather than betting it all on one arm.

In this episode of Insider Calls, host Marc "Moose" Malusis is joined by NFL analyst Brian Baldinger to break down a chaotic Week 16 and look ahead to the 2025 postseason. They dive deep into the San Francisco 49ers' dominant performance on Monday Night Football, discussing how Brock Purdy and Kyle Shanahan have kept the team dangerous despite a litany of injuries. The conversation shifts to the drama in the NFC West, comparing the Rams and Seahawks, before tackling the "home run" potential of John Harbaugh potentially landing with the New York Giants. Baldy also gives his take on Aaron Glenn’s first year with the Jets, the "Chiefs fatigue" in the AFC, and the incredible return of 44-year-old Philip Rivers.

In this segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis takes a break from sports talk to get personal about the "tremendous amount of pressure" that comes with being a parent during the holidays. He contrasts the carefree joy of his own childhood—filled with snowball fights, sleigh riding, and Bing Crosby—with his current reality: a marathon 9-hour shift in the kitchen. From navigating high-stakes menu requests like "hollow bread French toast casserole" to the weight of creating "perfect" memories for his kids, Moose explores why the magic of Christmas feels a lot more like a full-time job once you're the one wearing the apron.

In this segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis reacts to a listener's question about the modern "birds and the bees" talk—which, according to author Michael Lewis, has been replaced by "parlays and pickins." Moose reflects on his own upbringing at the racetrack and contrasts it with the hyper-accessibility of gambling today. As a father of three young boys, he discusses his philosophy on parenting in the betting era, emphasizing transparency, moderation, and the importance of teaching responsibility before gambling becomes "the end-all-be-all."

Marc Malusis addresses the "genuine concern" of the Mets faithful regarding the lack of additions to the starting rotation. While callers worry the team is being run like a small-market franchise, Moose reminds listeners that David Stearns was hired specifically to overhaul the organization's structure. He highlights that while the team has moved on from several "homegrown" staples, the offseason is far from over. The conversation also touches on the pressure of Steve Cohen’s expectations and the potential resurgence of Mark Vientos as an internal solution to the lineup’s power needs.

In this high-energy segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis dives into the swirling rumors of discontent within the New York Mets' clubhouse. Following a disappointing season, Malusis breaks down the friction between high-priced stars, the frustration of "has-been" acquisitions, and the leadership vacuum under manager Carlos Mendoza. From Juan Soto’s massive contract tension to the perceived rift between cornerstone players like Francisco Lindor and Pete Alonso, Moose challenges the idea that "losing creates chemistry." He offers a blunt assessment of whether the issues stem from Mendoza's lack of control or a roster that has simply run its course. It’s a raw look at why the wealthiest team in baseball couldn't find its soul in 2025.

In this heated segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis tackles the ultimate New York Jets dilemma: whether to mortgage the future to move up from the No. 4 spot for Indiana’s Heisman-winning quarterback, Fernando Mendoza. Malusis argues passionately that "if you get the quarterback, it’s all worth it," regardless of the draft capital surrendered. Reflecting on the organization's past failures with Sam Darnold and Zach Wilson, he challenges the Jets to finally prioritize quarterback development over draft-pick hoarding. With the Giants potentially sitting on the No. 1 pick and already rostered with Jaxson Dart, Malusis explores the possibility of an "all-New York" blockbuster trade that could finally provide the Jets with a 15-year solution under center.

In this high-energy segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis tackles a wave of frustrated Mets callers who are skeptical of David Stearns' latest roster overhaul—specifically the acquisition of veteran second baseman Marcus Semien. While fans point to Semien’s age and recent batting average dip, Moose urges the "Orange and Blue" faithful to look at the bigger picture. He challenges the notion that the previous core (Alonso, McNeil, Nimmo) was "getting it done," reminding listeners that "the painting is not finished yet." From debating Semien’s Gold Glove defense to calling out the "leaky ship" culture in the front office, Malusis delivers a passionate defense of a front office trying to break the cycle of insanity in Queens.

On their penultimate show, Marc Malusis and his co-host break down the "calous business" of the New York Mets’ offseason following the departure of Pete Alonso. With the news of Alonso heading to the Orioles and Edwin Diaz out the door, Malusis demands to know why David Stearns and Steve Cohen—despite having the deepest pockets in baseball—refused to match a reasonable offer to keep the "Polar Bear" behind Juan Soto. The duo debates whether Stearns is a brilliant architect building a sustainable winner or a cold-hearted executive tearing down the clubhouse's soul. From the "skepticism" of the Mets' new casino-linked finances to the potential (and pitfalls) of a Kyle Tucker pursuit, Malusis leaves no stone unturned in this heated post-mortem of a franchise at a crossroads.

In this heated segment, Marc Malusis reacts to the New York Mets trading longtime infielder Jeff McNeil to the Oakland Athletics. While acknowledging the emotional toll on the fan base—especially following the departures of Pete Alonso, Brandon Nimmo, and Edwin Díaz—Malusis refuses to "cry over McNeil." He delivers a blunt assessment of McNeil’s regression, citing his obsession with launch angle and a dip in contact hitting as reasons why the "Squirrel" became expendable. More importantly, Moose challenges the front office's narrative that the 2025 season failed due to "clubhouse chemistry." He fires back with a reality check: the Mets failed because their pitching was "disastrous," and David Stearns is now gambling the franchise's future on "grinders" rather than proven stars.

Boomer & Gio take calls from fed-up Jets fans. Plus, Marc Malusis (11:20) and Evan & Tiki (27:30) react to the loss and talk Aaron Glenn’s future.

Boomer and Gio react to the Giants’ 16-13 loss to the Vikings and wonder if Jaxson Dart should still be playing. Plus, reactions from Marc Malusis (7:13) and Evan & Tiki (21:22)

In this blistering Monday midday broadcast, Marc "Moose" Malusis pulls no punches as he surveys the wreckage of New York football just days before Christmas. With both the Giants and Jets sitting at a dismal 3-11, Moose delivers a raw "Saratoga Winter Warning," labeling the Jets' decision to keep Aaron Glenn a "disaster" and slamming the Giants' "unwatchable" offensive game plan. From the "Quarterback Bidding War" over the #1 overall pick to a heated defense of Mets fans losing Pete Alonso, Malusis provides an unfiltered look at a city in sports crisis. Whether it's picking new contenders like the Texans or issuing a postseason ultimatum to the Bills, this is the Malusis Manifesto—a high-voltage breakdown of the "ice and pain" currently defining New York sports

In this heated Monday midday broadcast, Marc "Moose" Malusis pulls no punches as he surveys the wreckage of New York football just days before Christmas. With both the Giants and Jets' seasons long since buried, Moose delivers a blistering "Saratoga Winter Warning," questioning the future of both franchises as they head toward 2026. The episode centers on a fiery interrogation of the Jets' leadership, specifically slamming the reports that Aaron Glenn is "safe" for another year despite a "completely unwatchable" performance against the Saints. Malusis also turns his sights on the Giants, dissecting a baffling game plan against Minnesota that marginalized rookie QB Jaxson Dart and left MetLife Stadium half-empty and "tough to watch." From dropped passes to coaching "idiocracy," Moose provides a raw, honest look at the "ice and pain" currently defining New York sports.

In this high-octane episode, Marc "Moose" Malusis breaks down a pivotal Monday in New York football. Following a heartbreaking 16-13 Giants loss to the Vikings, Moose debates whether Jaxson Dart is the franchise savior or if the team should entertain a massive trade-down for Indiana’s Mendoza. Meanwhile, the Jets' side of the city is in a state of "pure desperation" as fans call for a complete culture overhaul, questioning Aaron Glenn’s leadership and Woody Johnson’s interference. From Mike McCarthy rumors to the potential of a John Harbaugh exit in Baltimore, Moose tackles the coaching carousels and the "quarterback-or-bust" reality facing both local franchises as they head into 2026.

In this high-voltage segment, Marc Malusis doesn’t hold back as he dissects the wreckage of the New York football season. With the Jets and Giants both sitting at 3-11, Malusis officially calls time on the Aaron Glenn "experiment," labeling it a disaster and comparing it to the league's worst coaching tenures. He pivots to the "Culture Lie," tearing into the cycle of failed leadership and the looming threat of another botched coaching search. Finally, Moose dives into the "Tank Bowl" showdown between the Giants and Raiders, weighing the desperation for the #1 overall pick against the fan-fueled "Idiocracy" of moving on from Jaxson Dart for Indiana star Fernando Mendoza. It’s a raw, unfiltered look at two franchises in a race for the bottom.

In this high-energy holiday edition of The Fan, Marc Malusis tackles the growing disconnect between New York front offices and their loyal fanbases. The "Moose" dives deep into the Yankees' shifting standards, arguing that the organizational grading system has moved from "Championship or Bust" to "Playoffs or Bust," leaving fans like caller Ramon rightfully frustrated with Aaron Boone’s job security. The show takes an emotional turn as Marc breaks down the "heartbreak" of Mets fans moving on from Pete Alonso, comparing the team's refusal to pay their stars to a failing relationship where the "date nights" have long since stopped. Finally, Marc looks toward the postseason, issuing a stark ultimatum to the Buffalo Bills: with Mahomes and Jackson out of the way, the AFC is a vacuum that Buffalo must fill now or never. Between scouting the Giants' draft needs and celebrating the legendary career of Dove Kramer behind the glass, Malusis delivers a "B+" performance (according to Pete!) that covers every corner of the New York sports landscape.

In this high-octane segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis tears into the current state of the AFC, declaring that the era of predictable dominance is over. With heavyweights like Mahomes and Lamar Jackson facing hurdles, Moose challenges Buffalo Bills fans to realize their window is wide open—it’s now or never. The discussion heats up as Moose and caller Omar debate the "toughness" of the conference, narrowing the field down to a three-team race between the Texans, Bills, and Chargers. From C.J. Stroud’s poise to the defensive grit in Houston, Moose provides a unfiltered look at who has the "franchise" DNA to survive the gauntlet and represent the AFC in the Super Bowl.

In this heated segment, Marc Malusis validates the "championship or bust" frustration of the Yankee faithful while delivering a sobering reality check on the modern MLB. Malusis acknowledges the tactical blunders—specifically the questionable use of Nestor Cortes in the World Series and the failed Devin Williams experiment—but argues that the issue is systemic. He asserts that the Yankees no longer grade their season on rings alone, instead valuing Boone’s ability to manage massive egos and navigate an analytics-heavy front office. While Malusis admits he wants more than just "competitive" seasons, he explains that in 2025, Boone is exactly the type of "player-first" manager the organization refuses to move on from, regardless of the postseason results.

In this heated segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis pulls no punches as he dissects the current state of the New York Mets. Drawing on his decades of experience in the New York sports market, Malusis compares being a Mets fan to a failing relationship—one filled with broken promises and "date nights" that never happened. From the stinging loss of cornerstone player Pete Alonso to the front office’s refusal to commit to long-term stars, Malusis explores why the "magic carpet ride" for fans has turned into a walk of shame. Whether he’s debating the merits of the current roster or calling out the "spoiled" expectations of New York baseball, this is the "Moose" at his most authentic: raw, unfiltered, and deeply passionate about the team that keeps breaking hearts in Flushing.

In this fiery segment on WFAN, Marc "Moose" Malusis breaks down why the Week 17 clash between the 2-13 New York Giants and the Las Vegas Raiders is being dubbed "The Tank Bowl Super Bowl." With the #1 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft on the line, Malusis balances the frustration of a 9-game losing streak with the high-stakes debate over the future of rookie QB Jaxson Dart. As fans call in screaming for a loss to secure Heisman winner Fernando Mendoza, Moose dives into the organizational chaos, the potential firing of GM Joe Schoen, and why winning this "Super Bowl" might actually be the worst thing to happen to Big Blue.

In this high-energy segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis dives into the boiling-point frustration of New York football as both the Giants and Jets stagger toward the end of a disappointing 2025 season. Moose takes a blowtorch to the idea of hiring "legacy" names like John Harbaugh or Mike Tomlin, arguing that New York needs fresh, innovative minds rather than "talent merchants" riding past glories. The discussion heats up as Moose shuts down "oxygen-wasting" hypotheticals about drafting new quarterbacks, firmly backing rookie Jaxson Dart as the Giants' future while demanding a coaching staff that can actually develop him. From the potential firing of Pete Carroll in Vegas to the "mercenary" return of local radio personalities, Moose leaves no stone unturned in this unfiltered look at a New York sports scene in desperate need of a total overhaul.

In this heated segment from December 22, 2025, Marc Malusis talks with "John the Fan" and other callers about the state of a "rudderless" New York Jets franchise. Following an embarrassing 3-11 stretch under first-year head coach Aaron Glenn, the discussion ignites over whether the team should pull the trigger on a "one-and-done" firing—comparing Glenn’s struggles to high-profile failures like Brandon Staley and Nathaniel Hackett. The conversation shifts toward the future, debating if a top draft pick like Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza or a star receiver can truly fix a team that hasn't seen the playoffs since 2010. Malusis weighs the value of draft capital against the obvious coaching void, exploring whether the Giants might actually hold the keys to the Jets' future in a potential draft-day trade for the ages.

Marc Malusis doesn't pull any punches following the Giants’ 16–13 loss to the Vikings, calling Jaxson Dart’s performance "bad" and a "big-time learning lesson." He engages in a heated debate over Dart's dual-threat identity—arguing that while the rookie needs to avoid unnecessary "stiff-arms" and sideline hits to stay healthy, the coaching staff cannot completely strip away his mobility without ruining his game. Malusis also shuts down "illogical" trade rumors involving Heisman winner Fernando Mendoza, insisting that despite the Week 16 clunker, Dart remains the answer for Big Blue.

Marc Malusis dives into the chaotic state of the New York Giants, focusing on rookie signal-caller Jaxson Dart. While fans and callers are frustrated by conservative play-calling and recent blowout losses, Moose argues that the 2025 season is strictly about "learning what Dart is looking at." He highlights Dart’s record-breaking athleticism while warning that without a new coaching philosophy and better protection, the Giants risk "alligator-arming" their future away. It’s a passionate plea to see the forest through the trees: Dart is the guy, but the organization must learn how to win around him.

In this high-energy segment, Marc "Moose" Malusis tackles the perennial dysfunction of the New York Jets, a franchise that hasn't seen a playoff game since 2010. Responding to a frustrated caller, Moose argues that despite the organization’s history of draft busts like Zach Wilson, they cannot afford to be paralyzed by fear. He highlights Fernando Mendoza, the Heisman-winning standout from Indiana, as the "apple of the eye" for a team that desperately needs a franchise pillar. Malusis breaks down why the Jets must utilize their massive draft capital—bolstered by the trades of Sauce Gardner and Quinnen Williams—to trade up and secure a quarterback who can finally win on a rookie deal. It’s a raw look at a fan base tired of excuses and a host demanding the "adults in the room" finally get the most important position in sports right.

In this high-octane clip, Marc "Moose" Malusis takes a detour from the Giants and Jets disaster zones to break down the brutal beauty of Saratoga and Lake Placid in the dead of winter. After a caller paints a picture of zero-degree nights and picturesque downtowns, Moose fires back with his own legendary—and painful—Upstate history. From the Olympic Oval to a concussion-inducing toboggan ride that landed him in an MRI machine at Mount Sinai, Malusis delivers a "fiery" warning to anyone headed north: pack the Under Armour, watch out for the ice, and get ready for a winter that’s as tough as New York football.

In a scathing Monday morning opening, Marc Malusis reacts to reports that New York Jets head coach Aaron Glenn is safe for a second year despite a disastrous three-game skid and a humiliating 29-6 loss to the New Orleans Saints. While Malusis acknowledges that Glenn has cleaned up the locker room "nonsense" and "leaks" that plagued the Robert Saleh/Aaron Rodgers era, he argues that the actual results on the field are an "indictment" of his leadership. Moose highlights the hypocrisy of Glenn firing his own defensive coordinator, Steve Wilks, mid-season while the team simultaneously regresses into a full-scale rebuild. Comparing the Jets' stagnation to the upward trajectory of Kellen Moore's Saints and the quarterback hope the Giants have with Jaxson Dart, Malusis warns that Glenn’s "tough love" and Bill Parcells-inspired coaching style mean nothing if they don't lead to wins. For Moose, Glenn being "safe" isn't a victory for the organization—it’s a sign of how far they’ve fallen.

It’s a bleak Monday midday at WFAN as Marc Malusis rings in the final week before Christmas with a scorched-earth assessment of the Giants and Jets. With the 2025 season effectively over for both franchises, "Moose" targets the Giants' lack of identity, slamming the "boring" and "fearful" game plan against the Vikings that stunted rookie Jaxson Dart’s growth. From Darius Slayton’s drops to Abdul Carter’s costly penalties, Malusis demands a total culture shift and a "clean sweep" of the front office if necessary. He contrasts the local dysfunction with the resurgence of the Patriots, delivering a wake-up call to the Giants and Jets: the New York standard has officially hit rock bottom, and it's time to stop the "nonsense."

Boomer & Gio discuss the outlook for the rest of the Jets season and why they should position themselves to draft Fernando Mendoza. Plus, Boomer & Gio wonder if Aaron Glenn will be one and done; Brandon Tierney believes the Jets must tank the rest of the season; Evan Roberts asks Tiki Barber if he would want Mendoza in New York; Tierney reacts to the Jets firing of Steve Wilks.

Brandon Tierney, Boomer & Gio (18:46), and Evan & Tiki (33:47) all react to the Knicks winning the NBA Cup in-season tournament and what it means for the franchise and rest of season. Plus, Evan says the Knicks are not obligated to raise a banner for the NBA Cup (51:06); Marc Malusis makes the case to keep the core intact and not go after Giannis (1:02:31); Boomer wonders if this could be the Knicks’ year? (1:17:04)

Luke Weaver is heading to the Mets, and both Evan and Morash believe it could turn out to be a high-reward signing. McMonigle agrees, but wonders why the salary was as high as it was. Plus, Moose sounds off on David Stearns' philosophies that led to losing Pete Alonso, and McMonigle says the team is having a brutal offseason so far.

Brandon Tierney says the Yankees better not lose Bellinger to the Mets, or it will be the biggest embarrassment of the Hal Steinbrenner era. He also believes the Yanks should load up on pitching and revamp their identity in 2026. Marc Malusis rips the organization's complacency, and the Evan and Tiki crew lament New York's quiet offseason.

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti cover wall to wall NFL for week 16. Jets fire their defensive coordinator. Commanders went after Jaxson Dart. Texans are the team to beat and QB carousel for 2026. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT reflects on his time at WFAN and has some special guests including A-Rod, Rick Pitino and his dad to close the show.

BT talks about how he began his journey at WFAN as an intern and spoke about how much it meant to be a part of the station.

BT revisited his viral "Unkillable" rant from September 12, 2023. The passionate broadcast followed a season-ending injury to Aaron Rodgers just four snaps into his Jets debut.

Three-time MVP Alex Rodriguez joins BT to provide a blunt analysis of the Yankees and offers a roadmap to fix Anthony Volpe’s swing. Rick Pinto joins the show to remanence with BT about WFAN and talk St. John's basketball.

In a deeply emotional and high-energy final hour, Brandon Tierney takes his last lap on WFAN, proving exactly why he is "unkillable." From reminiscing about playing for the Bronx Angels and driving his dad's Nissan Maxima to the grueling days on Ron Hunt’s farm in Missouri, BT bridges the gap between his childhood dreams and his professional reality. The hour reaches a fever pitch when his father, "Pops," calls in to recount the cross-country odyssey—from Allentown to Las Vegas to Detroit—that finally brought Brandon back to the station he grew up idolizing. BT addresses the listeners with raw honesty, discussing the Craig Carton situation with grace, celebrating his love for St. John’s and the Knicks, and delivering a tearful, powerful message to the fans: "Anything you received from me, I received more from you." It's a fiery, authentic farewell to a New York staple who earned every second of his time in the pinstripes of sports radio

In a deeply personal and raw final hour, Brandon Tierney delivers his ultimate sign-off from the legendary WFAN. The segment kicks off with a surprise call from BT’s biggest fan and toughest critic—his father—who takes listeners on a 25-year trip through BT’s career: from packing up for Allentown to the drive-time battles in San Francisco, and finally, his "dream fulfilled" return to New York. BT reflects on the "unrelenting drive" that defined his run, acknowledging that while his time in the midday slot is ending due to station shifts (the return of Craig Carton), he leaves with his head high and his competitive fire unquenched. He shares his pride in sharing studios with titans like Stephen A. Smith, calling Knicks games at the Garden, and building the "Unkillable" brand with co-host Sal Licata. It’s a tear-filled, high-energy goodbye to the city he loves, ending not with a whimper, but with a promise that the next chapter will be his biggest yet.

On his final solo day at WFAN, Brandon Tierney delivers a masterclass in resilience and professional grace. Addressing the station's lineup overhaul and the return of Craig Carton, BT remains remarkably galvanized, choosing to focus on the future rather than the "sadness" of the show's end. He reflects on his cross-country hustle—driving from Brooklyn to Las Vegas to Detroit—to prove that his career is built on a passion that doesn't stop at one station. BT also looks ahead to his burgeoning career in motivational speaking and the nearly sold-out live show in Red Bank, NJ on January 22nd with special guest Aaron Boone. Amidst heartfelt calls from longtime listeners, he even shares a laugh over his funniest radio moment involving the unfortunately named Rusty Kuntz, proving that while the business changes, the "Unkillable" spirit remains intact.

In a raw and emotional final broadcast, Brandon Tierney hangs up his WFAN headset, reflecting on a career built on "no fluff" sports talk and a deep connection to New York. From trading stories with childhood teammates about playing in the "oppressive heat" of Missouri to reminiscing about driving a Nissan Maxima from Brooklyn to the Bronx for rival baseball games, BT explores the memories that shaped him. The show features touching calls from long-time listeners—including a delivery driver finding hope in BT’s "everything happens for a reason" mantra and a St. John's fan who shared a drink with BT and Rick Pitino. Despite the "urine and weed" smells of the city and the grind of the commute, BT remains defiant and grateful, stating he "earned his spot" in the "Yankees uniform" of sports radio. He leaves listeners with a promise: the arm is still a rocket, the passion is still there, and while he’s leaving the station, he’s not leaving the game.

In a wide-ranging, high-octane interview, Hall of Famer Rick Pitino joins Brandon Tierney to discuss the state of St. John's basketball and his storied career. Pitino gets brutally honest about his current squad, admitting they lack the veteran dominance of last year's team and issuing a public challenge to Bryce Hopkins to become an "alpha dog" or risk his NBA dreams. The conversation turns fiery and nostalgic as Pitino recounts a "hysterical" story from the birth of WFAN, remembering how "clinical moron" callers wanted him fired while his Knicks were in first place. The Coach also settles New York's greatest debates, naming Pearl Washington and Kenny Anderson as the ultimate handles and Chris Mullin as the city’s premier marksman. To wrap it up, BT shares a legendary personal story of an all-night bar session with Pitino that felt like a scene straight out of The Godfather.

In this emotional and raw segment, Brandon Tierney reflects on his departure from WFAN, framed by a sense of profound professional victory rather than bitterness. BT reveals that his childhood "mission" was simply to make it onto the legendary airwaves of The Fan—a goal he officially considers "Mission Accomplished." He discusses the importance of the three pillars he teaches his children—Work Hard, Have Fun, Be a Leader—and how staying true to those values allowed him to "empty the tank" and leave without a single regret. Despite the unexpected return of Craig Carton displacing his show, BT shares a message of maturity and resilience, emphasizing that while he couldn't control management's decisions, he mastered everything within his power: his preparation, his passion, and his integrity. As long-time callers offer their tears and support, BT exits not as a victim of corporate shuffling, but as a broadcaster who achieved his dream and is ready for a new garden to grow.

In a massive, wide-ranging interview, Alex Rodriguez joins Brandon Tierney to deliver a masterclass on the current state of the game. A-Rod doesn't pull any punches, declaring the Yankees' organizational hitting philosophy "absolutely broken" and critiquing the development of Anthony Volpe, arguing the team is forcing a "little guy" to play a "big boy game" that neuters his best assets. The two discuss the ticking clock on Aaron Judge’s prime, the criteria for signing free agents like Cody Bellinger, and the "sad" takeover of data-driven analytics that has sidelined traditional baseball people. A-Rod also shares intimate reflections on his HBO documentary, the healing process of turning 50, and hilarious behind-the-scenes stories about David Ortiz and his relationship with the "2009 Homeboys." From Pete Alonso's exit from the Mets to his own refusal to manage in today's patient-less league, this is A-Rod at his most transparent and passionate.

In a morning segment dripping with New York intensity, Brandon Tierney breaks down a shockwave of tweets from Mets owner Steve Cohen. Reacting to a New York Post article suggesting a payroll dip for 2026, Cohen fired off an aggressive defense, labeling his critics "the usual idiots" and insisting he "can't imagine" the budget being lower than last year. BT analyzes the owner's shift in tone—from the "scepter-wielding" savior to a billionaire arguing about waiver claims and minor league movement. While Tierney maintains his support for Cohen, he issues a stern warning: after losing Pete Alonso to the Orioles and Edwin Díaz to the Dodgers, a Twitter war with fans isn't the victory Mets fans are looking for. Steve is feeling the heat, and if he doesn't land a big fish before Fan Fest, the reception at Citi Field won't be pretty.

In a raw and transparent episode of Unkillable, Brandon Tierney delivers a brutal post-mortem on what he calls an "utterly unwatchable" decade of New York football. As the Giants prepare for the Vikings and the Jets head to New Orleans, BT admits he’s rooting for losses to secure the future—specifically the potential of rookie sensation Jaxson Dart leading Big Blue to a title. He questions if the Giants will take a "big swing" at a coach like Mike Tomlin and wonders if Jets’ coach Aaron Glenn is already on the hot seat. The fire moves to the diamond as BT targets Brian Cashman, standing by his claim that the Yankees GM hasn't earned the right to rebuild the roster. Despite his skepticism of management, BT geeks out over a "radical" vision for the 2026 Yankees, imagining a "best in baseball" rotation featuring a vintage Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, and Japanese ace Munetaka Murakami. He also defends young guns like Austin Wells and Ben Rice, challenging fans to recognize the "stud" potential in the Yankees' homegrown talent.

On his final day at WFAN, Brandon Tierney takes listeners back to September 12, 2023—the morning after Aaron Rodgers’ season-ending Achilles injury just four plays into his Jets debut. Reliving the infamous "Unkillable" speech, BT describes the "out of body" experience of trying to find hope in "football hell" while standing up for Zach Wilson. He reflects on the vulnerability of being a raw, authentic host and explains why that "unkillable" mindset isn't just about sports—it's about surviving life's toughest hits. This is BT at his most personal, closing his chapter at The Fan with the same fire that ignited a viral movement.

In this emotional and raw segment from his final full-time show on WFAN, Brandon Tierney reflects on a career defined by volatility, grit, and an obsession with "the Batphone." BT takes listeners back to 1999 in Allentown, Pennsylvania, where he made just $16,000 a year and didn't even know how to run a soundboard. He recalls a shoestring budget operation where he sat in a separate room from his co-host, watching a single phone line light up like the Bat-signal—his cue to rip off his headset and play producer just to talk to the fans. The conversation turns from the past to the present as BT connects with "stand-up" callers like Al from Howard Beach, reminding the audience why sports radio is more than just scores—it’s about the "CYO hustle" and the shared upbringing of New York sports fans. Tierney reflects on the "brutal business" of radio with zero regrets, promising one last look at his famous "Unkillable" speech before handing the mic over to New York legends Alex Rodriguez and Rick Pitino.

In a deeply personal and high-energy final segment, Brandon Tierney reflects on his journey at WFAN, the evolution of his relationship with Sal Licata, and the "stand up" reputation they built together. BT looks back at the "full circle" moment of meeting a young Sal in a makeup room years ago and how that morphed into the "Big Brother" bond they share today. He shares touching stories of painting his son’s nursery Yankee Blue, gives raw advice to a fellow dad on raising athletes, and prepares to dust off the legendary "Unkillable" speech for one last time. It’s a heartfelt "fist pump" to the listeners who made the show a New York staple.

It’s the end of the road for a New York radio stalwart. In this emotional and high-energy final broadcast, Brandon Tierney officially signs off as a full-time host on WFAN. Refusing to go out with a whimper, BT brings in the big guns with A-list guests Alex Rodriguez and Rick Pitino to celebrate a career built on "emptying the tank" every single day. BT doesn't hold back on his final sports takes either, ripping into the "inexcusable" coaching decisions of Tom Thibodeau and standing firm as an Aaron Glenn supporter despite the Jets' defensive "train wreck." He reflects on his journey from Brooklyn Little League to the Division 1 mound and finally to the pinnacle of New York sports talk. While the day is bittersweet, BT leaves with his head high, delivering a masterclass in authenticity and connection, proving that while this chapter is closing, the "Unkillable" brand is only just beginning.

Marc "Moose" Malusis is in for BT & Sal and he's taking no prisoners! Moose delivers a blistering critique of Hal Steinbrenner’s "passive" leadership, arguing the Yankees have officially surrendered their "Evil Empire" throne to the aggressive Dodgers. He blasts the front office for letting Edwin Diaz slip away and using injuries as a crutch for a fundamentally flawed roster. Over in Queens, Moose torches David Stearns for the Pete Alonso exit to Baltimore, labeling it a "Milwaukee-style downgrade" for a franchise that used to think big. From the Rangers' scoring drought and Chris Drury’s mismanagement to the Giannis-to-the-Knicks rumors, Moose covers it all with zero filter. Plus, don't miss Moose’s personal "Happy Wife, Happy Life" survival story—cleaning up after a house full of sick kids—and the "jaw-dropping" secret behind his massive weight loss. To wrap it up, betting insider Nick Kostos stops by to draft the definitive Christmas playlist and break down a high-stakes Thursday Night Football clash!

Marc Malusis doesn't hold back as he fills in for BT & Sal, delivering a scathing indictment of the New York Yankees' "passive" offseason. He torches Hal Steinbrenner for complaining about the "hardships" of team ownership while the Los Angeles Dodgers have officially usurped the "Evil Empire" throne by spending aggressively to win. Malusis argues that the Yankees’ reliance on "October is a crapshoot" is a failed philosophy and questions if injuries are just a convenient excuse for a roster that lacks fundamental soundness. The heat continues as he pivots to Queens, discussing Pete Alonso’s departure to Baltimore. Malusis claims anyone paying attention should have seen the move coming, as David Stearns clearly favors "grinders" over high-priced stars. From Anthony Volpe’s offensive struggles to the Mets' pitching lab failures, Marc demands that both New York organizations stop looking over their shoulders at analytics and start looking in the mirror.

Marc "Moose" Malusis steps behind the mic for a fiery mid-day session, taking aim at the state of New York sports. He starts by dissecting the Rangers' identity crisis, arguing they have too many "fourth-liners" and questioning if it's time to trade Artemi Panarin while his value is high. Malusis then turns his heat toward the Yankees, labeling them "self-satisfied" and lacking the "Evil Empire" motivation needed to keep pace with the powerhouse Dodgers. On the Mets' side, the Moose doesn't hold back on David Stearns, questioning the negotiation tactics with Edwin Diaz and the refusal to pay Pete Alonso. Between sports takes, Marc shares a hilarious yet harrowing story of his entire family falling ill, emphasizing the "Happy Wife, Happy Life" philosophy as he spent a week cleaning vomit and Lysol-ing his home just to get a "reprieve" at the studio. Finally, he looks at the Giants' coaching search, demanding a proven resume like Mike McCarthy or Mike Tomlin to fix a culture of "nonsense."

Marc Malusis is back and firing on all cylinders! Moose starts the show by revealing his "jaw-dropping" secret to massive weight loss—embracing hunger and a strict one-meal-a-day schedule that has him looking years younger. But the pleasantries end there as Moose and the callers dive into a white-hot debate over the New York Mets. From the "arrogance" of the pitching lab to the heartbreak of Pete Alonso signing with Baltimore, fans are questioning if David Stearns’ "vision" is just a Milwaukee-style downgrade. Moose also tackles the Yankees' reliance on the home run, longing for the days of high-average contact hitters like those on the Blue Jays' roster. Finally, the energy shifts to the hardwood with a look at the Giannis Antetokounmpo to the Knicks rumors and a reality check on whether the Knicks should actually be proud of their NBA Cup win.

Marc "Moose" Malusis turns up the volume, debating the Knicks' championship pedigree and whether their current core has what it takes to bring a ring back to the Garden. Things take a festive but competitive turn as betting insider Nick Kostos joins the show to draft the definitive Christmas music playlist, while also breaking down a rain-soaked, high-stakes Thursday Night Football clash between the Rams and Seahawks. The fire reaches a peak when Moose takes aim at Chris Drury and the Rangers, calling for a front-office overhaul after a string of "abysmal" home shutouts. From the Giants' "VCR" (Vikings-Cowboys-Raiders) tanking strategy for the #1 pick to the Mets' leadership issues following Juan Soto's massive deal, Moose covers the New York sports landscape with zero filters.

Before the playoffs and point spreads take over, Marc "Moose" Malusis and Nick Kostos take a detour into the festive spirit for a high-stakes Christmas Music Draft. Nick Kostos reveals his "1.01 overall pick" for the greatest holiday song of all time—Nat King Cole’s "The Christmas Song"—and explains his meticulous process for building the "definitive" Apple Music holiday playlist. From the "Yacht Rock" vibes of the NFL sidelines to the timeless crooning of Frank Sinatra, Elvis, and Dean Martin, the duo debates which versions of the classics truly reign supreme. Moose throws a curveball with his love for "Do They Know It's Christmas?" (Band Aid), while the guys share how music from the likes of Burl Ives and Mel Tormé helps them survive the high-pressure "minimal sweats" of the betting season. It’s a warm, funny, and surprisingly nerdy deep dive into the sounds of the season!

Marc "Moose" Malusis dives deep into the high-stakes world of New York basketball, debating whether the Knicks have finally assembled the roster to end a half-century championship drought. Moose weighs in on the Leon Rose era, praising the front office for building a sustainable winner while questioning if the blockbuster deal for Mikal Bridges was a stroke of genius or a massive overpay. Responding to anxious callers, Moose preaches patience and warns against "blowing it all" on a trade for Giannis Antetokounmpo, arguing that the Knicks' current chemistry is their greatest weapon. Whether you're a die-hard who remembers the Patrick Ewing glory days or a new fan caught up in the current hype, Moose breaks down why this "painting" isn't finished yet—but it’s already looking like a work of art.

Marc "Moose" Malusis doesn’t hold back on the December 18, 2025 edition of The Fan, ripping into David Stearns’ brutal handling of the Mets core. With fan favorites Pete Alonso (now an Oriole) and Edwin Diaz (now a Dodger) gone, Moose questions why the richest owner in sports couldn’t "show the love" to keep elite talent. He examines the risky pivot to Devin Williams and the analytical "vision" that has left Queens unrecognizable. Moose also tackles the New York Giants' chaotic season, slamming "dopey" suggestions to trade quarterback Jaxson Dart and calling for a "proven commodity" like Mike McCarthy or Mike Tomlin to clean up the building.

Marc Malusis describes his home life over the last seven days as a complete biohazard war zone. It started with his wife, Donna, catching a brutal stomach bug from her kindergarten students, leading to a 4 AM vigil. Despite Marc's desperate attempts to fumigate the house with Lysol, the "Vomit Vortex" claimed his kids one by one—featuring projectile vomit in the bedroom, ruined rugs, and a messy Christmas cookie session turned disastrous. With his youngest son now battling Flu A and the rest of the family on the mend, Marc treats his mid-day fill-in shift at the station as a "Shangri-La" reprieve from the clogged toilets and latex gloves of Connecticut. He wraps up with a fiery reminder to all parents: when your wife gives the marching orders to clean the floor, you just do it.

Marc "Moose" Malusis doesn't pull any punches in this scathing review of the New York Rangers' current state. Comparing the team to the "boring" late-90s era, Moose slams GM Chris Drury for constructing a lineup top-heavy with AHL-level grinders and "novelty" fourth-liners who can’t put the puck in the net. The debate gets nuclear when Malusis discusses the unthinkable: trading Artemi Panarin. With the "cup window" slammed shut and the team looking "lost" under first-year head coach Sullivan, Moose questions if the Rangers are headed for a dumpster fire season. From the failure to score on the power play to the "overpassing" epidemic, this is a raw look at a team that has lost its edge and its identity.

Marc "Moose" Malusis doesn't hold back in this blistering segment, reacting to the news of Pete Alonso signing a massive five-year, $155 million deal with the Baltimore Orioles. Malusis argues that fans shouldn't be shocked—David Stearns was "never an Alonso guy," and the writing was on the wall the moment the Mets refused to offer a long-term extension. Moose labels the Mets' 2025 season an "unmitigated disaster" driven by a pitching staff that "stunk" and trade deadline moves that failed miserably. He questions Stearns' philosophy of favoring "grinders" over superstars in a market like New York, warning that if this run-prevention build doesn't result in immediate wins, Stearns will be looking for a new job. Malusis also turns his fire toward the Yankees, criticizing their "gluttony of DHs" and the defensive liabilities of players like Ben Rice and Jasson Dominguez, while questioning the analytics department's latest acquisition of Ryan McMahon.

Filling in for BT and Sal, Marc "Moose" Malusis doesn't hold back as he dismantles Hal Steinbrenner’s recent claims that the Yankees had a "championship roster" derailed only by health and bad luck. Moose and callers argue that "underperformance" is a hollow term used to mask deep organizational flaws, from a lack of player development to a flawed construction of DH-heavy lineups. Using a powerful comparison to Mark Messier’s mental toughness, Malusis explains why analytics can’t measure the "clutch gene" or the ability to perform under the bright lights of New York. From slamming the team's obsession with batting average alternatives to exposing the embarrassment of the Jacob Trouba situation with the Rangers, Moose demands that New York owners stop acting like accountants and start acting like champions.

Filling in for BT & Sal, Marc "Moose" Malusis delivers a blistering critique of the Yankees' 2025-2026 offseason, starting with Hal Steinbrenner’s bizarre media appearance where he lamented the cost of owning the team. Moose takes particular aim at the Yankees' passive approach to the bullpen, highlighting their failure to land elite closer Edwin Diaz, who instead signed a record-setting $69 million deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Moose argues that the Dodgers have officially replaced the Yankees as the "Evil Empire," operating with a "slice your head off" mentality while the Yankees settle for regular-season stability and "hope for the best" in October. From slamming the team's failed player development (citing names like Volpe, Greg Bird, and Andujar) to mocking Hal’s complaints about paying the City of New York every February, Moose demands to know: "How much does it really bother the Yankees that they haven't won since 2009?"

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): The Knicks have finally brought a championship back to New York. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT discusses the Knicks winning the NBA Cup, Yankees and Mets Hot Stove, and More

BT celebrates the Knicks capturing the NBA Cup and thinks it should be celebrated because after years of losing, the Knicks putting an emphasis on winning is being rewarded

BT tells us why the Yankees can't lose Bellinger to the Mets and also what his favorite Christmas gift was

BT wonders whether there will be an NBA Cup hangover and he also reacts to the Mets signing another Yankee away from the Bronx

undefined

BT speaks on rumors of the Mets making progress with Bellinger and why that's a worst case scenario for the Bombers

BT tells us why winning the NBA Cup should matter to Knick fans after years of losing

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Hoff talks about the end of the BT & Sal Show and then somehow goes on a rant about the Yankees and Mets awful offseasons. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

SNYtv's Knicks insider Ian Begley joins BT to talk about the NBA mid season tournaments championship game. If the Knicks win, do they finally get to put up that much need banner?

Brian Baldinger joins BT to talk Giants and Jets and the potential number one draft pick of 2026

BT dives into the Emirates NBA Cup Final, admitting his initial skepticism about the "gimmick" tournament has faded, and now he's "into it." With the Knicks facing the San Antonio Spurs, Tierney declares he's "excited" at the possibility of finally celebrating any championship with the team before his show ends. He acknowledges the extra "juice" the mid-season tournament provides and confirms the $530,933 per-player prize money for the winning team. The discussion pivots briefly to the Yankees, with BT reiterating the need for the team to tweak its roster due to a lack of right-handed power and questions about the infield defense. He strongly argues against overpaying for Cody Bellinger and suggests the Yankees should focus on using their "surplus of arms" to acquire a needed bat.

BT unleashes a fiery critique of the Yankees' slow-moving offseason, warning that the assumed return of Cody Bellinger is a false assumption and a major threat to the team's success. With a long list of young, unproven position players like Jazz Chisholm, Ben Rice, and a potential "strikeout machine" in Ryan McMahon, Tierney argues the lineup is riddled with holes. The more pressing concern, according to BT, is a disaster start: with Cole, Rodón, and Schmidt all recovering, the rotation is dangerously thin. Tierney urges the Yankees to forget big-bat spending and execute a "radical reset" by loading up on pitching depth (like signing Michael King or trading for Peralta) to ensure they don't "drown in April or May" against a rapidly improving, aggressive AL East (Jays, O's, Red Sox). The ultimate message: the path to winning is no longer through hitting, but through a surplus of elite arms.

The WFAN team talks through draft scenarios and the firing of defensive coordinator Steve Wilks following the Jets' loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars on Sunday

The WFAN team is questioning whether or not the Giants should trade the top overall NFL Draft pick after the 21-29 loss to the Washington Commanders on Sunday

From ‘Unkillable’ (Subscribe Here): On today's episode of Unkillable, Brandon Tierney gives updates on Unkillable's future as well as speaks on potential roster moves The Jets could make following a Week 14 Loss. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT cuts through the season's misery to declare the NFL Draft order and scoreboard watching the "most exciting part" of the last three weeks for the New York Jets. He breaks down the chaotic possibilities for their two top draft picks (the Jets' own pick and the valuable Colts' pick), and recounts the pure luck—from Jason Myers' heroics to a crucial late-hit penalty—that secured their recent (beneficial) losses. He then fires back at the "desperate" Jets fans who want the team to trade up for a franchise quarterback, arguing that the new regime (Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey) has a "clear mind" and will not be rushed by the "shackles of torture" that have plagued the fanbase for decades. The only way to move forward is to build the roster with a clear vision, not through desperation.

BT dives into the shocking news of Patrick Mahomes' torn ACL, questioning the future trajectory of his Hall-of-Fame career. He argues that Mahomes' "all-world production" had already "stagnated" over the last three seasons, noting a sharp drop in touchdown totals and a concerning reliance on athleticism that an ACL injury—and a "thickish" build—might permanently compromise. Tierney suggests that the injury, which typically requires a 9–12 month recovery, could keep Mahomes off the field past Week 1 of next season. The discussion points to the decline of his supporting cast (Travis Kelce, post-Tyreek Hill) and the team's confounding offensive struggles as contributing factors to his recent "rough time scoring," raising the question: Can Mahomes return to his MVP form, or is the Chiefs' dynasty officially over?

BT dives into the Jets' recent "no-shows" and the firing of Defensive Coordinator Steve Wilks. While acknowledging that Aaron Glenn deserves a pass for year one due to wretched quarterback play, injuries, and a lack of talent, BT warns that Glenn's grace period is quickly expiring. The conversation pivots to the alarming trend of Glenn's poor in-game assessment and his failure to make adjustments, particularly during the Justin Fields catastrophe. BT stresses that the Buck must stop with Glenn for bad hires and personnel decisions, and his ability to survive future mistakes is rapidly decreasing, emphasizing that protecting modern players only goes so far when the team is getting "smoked.

BT expresses his absolute exhaustion over the "brutal" state of New York football, comparing the pathetic performance of the two teams. With the Giants at 2-12 and the Jets only marginally better, he notes the irony that they are performing like "mirror images" of failure, locked in a depressing race for the bottom of the standings. The only remaining discussion points are the looming off-season, including draft talk and coaching changes—a narrative he's been "hitting for so many months." Tierney uses the Giants' recent failed game-winning drive attempt as a grim example of the season's overall ineptitude.

BT unleashes a scorching take on the perceived softness of Pete Alonso and the Mets following a caller's comment about Alonso being hit by pitches. Tierney admits he "lost a little respect for Pete" when he was drilled by a pitch and restrained by Cardinals coach Stubby Clapp, citing Alonso's weak quote about hurting someone if he got mad. BT argues that for a "big, burly" player, the failure to retaliate or have his teammates defend him reveals a deep cultural flaw. He supports the Mets' "burning it down" reboot, agreeing that the old group lacked the "nuts" to win, and challenges the notion that new baseball executive David Stearns is "incompetent" despite some rough early moves. The discussion wraps with a fond farewell to the audience before BT's final full show on Friday.

BT unleashes a fiery reaction to a quote from Tiki Barber, aggressively challenging the notion that the Giants are not a "bad, poorly coached football team." Tierney emphatically argues that the on-field product proves the coaching and talent are both fundamentally flawed. The discussion quickly shifts to the Mets, where BT defends Steve Cohen's simultaneous pursuits of a casino deal and a Mets rebuild, telling skeptical fans that he believes Cohen's ultimate motivation is to succeed on both fronts. He tackles fan disappointment over trading fan favorites (like Pete Alonso), explaining that winners think long-term, and Cohen is moving on from players the organization "doesn't value as much as some of you guys do." Tierney concludes with a passionate take on clubhouse chemistry, asserting that talent and success trump whether players are "tight" off the field.

Brandon Tierney dives into the Yankees' confusing offseason, contrasting their muddled vision with the Mets' clear rebuilding plan. The discussion immediately focuses on Cody Bellinger, whom BT desperately wants back for his versatile, "low-maintenance" qualities that echo championship-era Yankees. However, BT draws a hard line, arguing that the Yankees must not get "out of whack" and offer Bellinger an excessive, career-killing eight-year contract, warning that repeating the mistakes made with Stanton and Hicks will perpetuate the team's "dead money" cycle. A caller elevates the stakes, declaring that if the Yankees fail to re-sign Bellinger, it's time to "reevaluate the whole front office."

BT unleashes his frustration over the disappointing 2025 MLB offseason for both the Yankees and Mets, comparing the lack of major moves to a "snowball fight" that never materialized. He dissects the confusing state of both New York cores, noting the scarcity of solidified positions for either club. Tierney lays out the Yankees' dilemma: relying on a "phenomenal" rotation (Cole, Freed, Schlittler, McClain) while simultaneously "praying" that the price doesn't go up on Cody Bellinger. He argues that acquiring only a pitcher like Michael King is not an acceptable plan. For the Mets, the chaos is clearer: a dismantled core with "a million questions" at every turn, including the ongoing possibility of a Francisco Lindor trade and the debate over the future of prospects like Ben Rice at first base. BT concludes that the clock is running out, and a "very dark and very empty offseason" is becoming a frightening reality for New York baseball.

BT dives into the oddly therapeutic experience of shoveling snow before launching into a nostalgic, fiery rant about the decline of true winter mischief. He reminisces about two dangerous but fun activities from his youth—"skitching" on the back of UPS trucks and the essential rite of passage: pelting cars and buses with snowballs. His disappointment peaks when he encounters a group of kids at a stop sign, actively engaged in a snowball fight, who completely FAIL to throw a single snowball at his car. BT views this as a symbol of how much things have changed, arguing that the fear of unpredictable drivers and consequences has killed the spontaneous, risky fun of his generation. He concludes that this chapter of childhood recklessness is officially shut.

BT, living the life of a perpetually disappointed Jets fan, admits his weekend joy is now derived solely from other teams' losses—specifically the Colts' collapse. He dives into the "excruciating fashion" of the Colts blowing a winnable game to Philip Rivers and the Seahawks, and how that loss still keeps the Jets' second first-round pick in a favorable position. Tierney breaks down the serious "upward mobility" of that pick, projecting it to land around #15 but admitting it could climb as high as the top 10 if everything falls perfectly. This leads to a debate on whether the Jets should punt on a quarterback this year to build a better overall roster, using their multiple draft picks to address the offensive and defensive lines, or save their chips for a better QB next year.

BT reacts to the news that the Jets have fired defensive coordinator Steve Wilks following a string of "embarrassingly inept" performances, including a 48-20 blowout loss to the Jaguars where the defense looked like they "didn't even want to tackle." While not celebrating the firing, BT calls it the "right move" and criticizes Head Coach Aaron Glenn for his "awful" personnel decisions, specifically highlighting the hiring of Wilks and the catastrophic Justin Fields QB trade—both significant "Xs" on Glenn's resume. Tierney also offers a small dose of optimism, analyzing three distinct, radically different quarterback paths for the Jets next year, and offers some hope that undrafted rookie Brady Cook has shown enough moxie for the team to consider developing him.

BT opens the show with an emotional reflection before pivoting to the "utterly depressing" state of New York football. He breaks down the failures of both the Jets and Giants into six "non-negotiable" components (Owner, GM, Head Coach, Quarterback, O-Line, Pass Rush), arguing both franchises are miles away from NFL relevance with no quick fixes in sight. Tierney rips the Giants for a surprising meltdown and insists GM Joe Shane must be fired. For the Jets, the focus shifts to the draft, with BT debating the high-stakes potential of trading up for QB Fernando Mendoza and the worrying comparison to "Kirk Cousins-esque" moxie. He declares watching both teams' games now "feels like a job" due to the total lack of competitive football.

Boomer & Gio and BT & Sal are all wondering the same thing: where have the Yankees been at the Winter Meetings? Plus, Sal suggests Nice Hoerner as a good fit for the Bronx Bombers; a caller asks who will win the World Series first: the Yankees or Mets? And Evan Roberts dives into what the Yankees’ selecting a player in the Rule 5 Draft means for the offseason outlook.

Recent comments from Joe Burrow have Boomer & Gio and Evan & Tiki wondering about his future and if the Jets could be in play to pursue the quarterback. Plus, Gio wonders if Indiana QB Fernando Mendoza could be a potential target for the Jets; BT & Sal wonder how the Daniel Jones injury could impact the Jets in the draft, and they react to news Brady Cook will start Week 15 against the Jaguars.

The Mets have taken a wrecking ball to their core, and Evan Roberts is livid with David Stearns and Steve Cohen, while Sal Licata says the organization deserves the benefit of the doubt after letting Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz go. Joe Benigno says the Wilpons would have kept Alonso, and Boomer Esiason declares this offseason "The Great Met Reset."

Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz bolted in consecutive days, leaving Mets fans up in arms at two stars leaving for seemingly reasonable contracts. All of our main shows had heated reactions to the news, ranging from ripping the team to praising the organization for having the guts to shake things up.

BT & Sal end their midday reign on WFAN. Check out the final 4 hours of BT & Sal!

BT and Sal deliver a raw and intensely emotional final segment, reflecting on their journey together. The discussion centers on a shared, fiery motivation stemming from their fathers—the principle that "life is going to keep hitting you," and the only response is to keep fighting forward. Sal talks about playing a motivational clip for his late father, while BT recounts the life-changing moment his dad showed him support after his first firing. They discuss their turbulent start, specifically the unplanned Carl Banks firestorm, and assert that they have "no regrets" because they "gave everything they had" to the show, proud it was not a "failed experiment." With grateful thanks to the listeners and the station for the opportunity to have a proper farewell, the "Dynamic Duo" promises their partnership is far from over, signing off with a heartfelt affirmation of their bond.

In an emotional segment featuring a call from a loyal listener and former colleague Pat Boyle, BT and Sal address the inevitable question: Will listeners really miss and follow the show after their final broadcast? Sal expresses skepticism, believing "nobody's going to care in two weeks," but Tierney pushes back, passionately arguing that their "genuine" and "authentic" passion—which he likens to a "Clubber Lang" intensity versus Sal's "Rocky" scrappiness—will guarantee a following. Sal reflects on his journey and the emotional full circle of achieving his dream at WFAN, stating he has now "maxed out" and it's time to pursue a "new dream." The hosts also acknowledge a listener who will not miss the endless Pete Alonso speculation, signaling a final farewell to their most controversial topic.

In their emotional final hour, BT and Sal reflect on their two-and-a-half-year run and address the abrupt end of the show, clarifying that they were not fired but their time slot was eliminated. They hype their massive upcoming live farewell event—a combination "celebration and going away party" featuring Aaron Boone—and invite listeners to connect in person. Callers flood the lines, sharing bittersweet thanks, settling old grudges (like Kevin's Soto argument), and reminiscing about past bar events and kind personal interactions. The guys engage in one last fiery sports debate, dissecting a caller's Mets master plan involving Kwan and Cody Bellinger to build a left-heavy, run-prevention lineup. The hosts conclude with heartfelt goodbyes, stressing that while the show is ending, the "what you hear is what you get" transparency will continue as they embrace a future filled with new, bright possibilities.

NFL betting insider Nick Kostos joins BT & Sal for a fiery Week 15 breakdown, questioning the betting market for making the AFC's top two teams (Patriots & Broncos) home underdogs. Kostos's best bet is the Over in the Bills/Patriots game, predicting New England's run defense will fail. The debate ignites over the Chiefs, with Sal ready to bury them and Kostos conceding the math is getting grim, but arguing their Super Bowl pedigree makes them dangerous if they sneak in. The conversation pivots to the MVP race, which is down to Matthew Stafford (-1.80) and Drake Maye (+2.10), with Kostos giving the edge to Stafford. He then predicts the Lions will be the surprising good team to miss the NFC playoffs and ends by making a bold guess for the next Giants Head Coach: Jeff Hafley.

It's the "Series Finale" of the beloved segment "Pull Your Card," where BT and Sal open up packs of 1988 Score baseball cards and challenge each other to guess the player's team. The stakes are high, and the competition is fierce, as the hosts try to remember the teams of jobbers like Fred Manrique and stars like Wally Backman (Mets). Sal gets off to a slow start and is devastated by misses on Jeff Reardon and Rick Dempsey (who turns out to be a Dodger in '88, not an Indian). But in a twist of luck, BT gets a run of repeat cards (Fred Manrique, Ozzie Virgil), sealing a spectacular comeback victory. The segment ends with BT crowned the "Back-to-Back-to-Back Champ," leaving Sal licking his wounds and questioning if Hof orchestrated a sabotage!

BT and Sal dive into the latest Knicks trade buzz, discussing reports that the team is deep in negotiations with the Pelicans to acquire local product and defensive "pit bull," Jose Alvarado. The hosts debate the likely scenario that role players must be on the move to make the deal happen, especially with the trade window opening soon. Sal gives high praise to the fiery Alvarado, calling him a perfect culture fit. The segment is peppered with listener calls, including an emotional sign-off from "Crazy Girl" Carey and a classic Daniel Jones/Giants debate with caller Brett. The show concludes with a reflection on the hosts' final segment of Baseball Cards and their partnership.

BT & Sal kick off a fiery segment by diving into the off-air dynamics of the show's communication, aiming to settle the score on "Who's the worst texter?" The segment is framed by the host's long-running, intensely competitive "Baseball Card World Series" (and BT's broken, six-button iPad still suffering from the drama of the first loss!). The hosts trade barbs and potentially reveal which member of the show is the most unreliable, non-responsive, or frustrating communicator when the microphones are off.

BT & Sal dive into the emotional anguish of Mets fandom, debating a caller who fears waiting 50 years for another World Series and wants a win while his father is still alive. The hosts tear into GM David Stearns' perceived lack of emotional connection, arguing that running the team "like a business" without caring for the fans is a recipe for failure. The discussion quickly turns fiery, questioning the deep-seated mistrust Mets fans have for Steve Cohen and whether the Metropolitan Park casino project is the real priority over a winning team. Finally, the talk shifts to the Yankees, where Sal slams Brian Cashman for the "stupid qualifying offer" to Trent Grisham, calling it the major mistake that crippled the Yankees' ability to land Cody Bellinger and other key free agents. They debate the Yankees' appetite for a long-term deal with Bellinger, drawing parallels to the costly, ultimately failed pursuit of Juan Soto.

BT and Sal dive into the NFL slate, with Sal boldly declaring the Chiefs are "done" and predicting a massive blow-out loss for the Colts. Sal reveals his excitement to see "Brady Cook cook" for the Jets, given a full week of practice. The conversation quickly shifts to the Mets, where the hosts and callers debate the team's ongoing roster demolition. The possibility of trading Francisco Lindor is discussed, with Sal questioning if friction in the clubhouse is making a split "irreparable." The hosts conclude that while Yankee fans are "envious" of the Mets' radical core change, New York success historically hinges on the farm system being allowed to develop and "pop." Finally, the segment ends with BT—the two-time baseball card World Series champion—refusing Sal's attempt at a final, high-stakes redemption match!

BT & Sal dive into the New York Mets' messy offseason, declaring they have a "ton of work" to do with question marks spanning nearly every position on the field. They stress that President of Baseball Operations David Stearns' entire roster construction hinges on one major decision: Should the Mets trade their prospects for a frontline starter like Tarik Skubal right now, or wait for Juan Soto to hit free agency? Sal rips into the current state of the roster, rattling off a shocking list of "don't knows"—including the DH, Left Field, Center Field, First Base, Opening Day Starter, and Setup Man—as he impatiently waits for Stearns to finally build instead of just strip away pieces. The segment also features a heartfelt, emotional moment with a listener that stops the show cold.

BT & Sal aggressively agree that the worst thing the Mets could have done this offseason was bring back the same core players and simply add pitching. They argue that this core has proven they are "not good enough" and that running it back would be the "definition of insanity." Sal applauds President of Baseball Operations David Stearns for taking a "blowtorch" to the roster, making the "difficult decisions" to let players like Diaz and Soto walk to execute a necessary "foundational overhaul." While emotionally tough for fans, the hosts assert this cutthroat approach is the "absolute best possible thing" for a franchise that has historically lacked "necessary baseball components to be a champion."

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for week 15 in the NFL. Bears look for real. What happened to Jalen Hurts? Bucscaneers are floundering. Can Boomer get a first down in today's NFL right now? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

On their final show, BT & Sal dive into the hot rumor surrounding the Mets and Tigers ace Tarik Skubal, who is available with only one year of control left. Sal argues the Mets and Yankees must knock down the door for Skubal, but BT fires back, arguing the Mets should absolutely NOT include top pitching prospect Nolan McClain—calling a potential trade "idiotic" given Skubal's short-term control and impending $400M contract. They debate the Tigers' leverage and the risks of waiting to sign Skubal in free agency versus trading top farm pieces now. The hosts also discuss whether Mets owner Steve Cohen will react to the current "state of desperation" among the fanbase and overrule David Stearns' measured plan. The show wraps up with emotional fan calls and appreciation for the "juice" the New York Knicks brought to their time slot.

On their final show, BT & Sal dive into the immediate aftermath of David Stearns trading Pete Alonso, with Sal demanding to know "Why" the Mets weren't willing to meet the five-year, $155 million deal. They debate the theory that Alonso's departure was necessary to clear a path for Juan Soto to become the greatest Met ever, a theory Sal calls "complete nonsense." The discussion heats up over the pressure on David Stearns, as the hosts wonder how long he has until Steve Cohen is forced to act on public backlash if the team doesn't improve quickly, asking if the "blowtorch" approach is too risky. They emphasize that while Alonso was beloved, his departure is necessary to build a "sustained winner," urging fans to have discipline and trust Stearns' vision. The segment wraps with a look at what the Mets need next, including Skubal and Kyle Tucker, and a light-hearted moment about the show's final day.

BT & Sal dive into a heated debate on which New York team has the better chance of winning the next World Series, with Sal declaring it's the Yankees "by a long shot." They argue the Yankees' current roster is superior, their pitching is "superior," and their path in the American League is easier without a juggernaut like the Dodgers blocking the way—a major hurdle for the Mets in the NL. The discussion highlights the Yankees' frustratingly quiet offseason, with Cashman focusing on three Rule 5 picks after 14 years, while Mets rumors swirl around Paul Goldschmidt ("washed up Yankee") and a potential pursuit of former Yankees first-rounder Willson Contreras to replace the departed Alonso. The hosts conclude the Yankees are sadly in a much better position "right now," despite an unexciting winter.

Will Demeo writer and star of Gravesend talks about the brilliant acting Sal Licata brought to the show.

Brian Baldinger has his say on the New York Giants and Jets going into week 15!

BT & Sal dive into a fierce style debate over what to wear to Alex Rodriguez's holiday party. BT defends his highly questioned, fashion-forward choice: a black corduroy suit accented with a green tie and possibly red shoes (the "cockroach killers"). Sal, the self-proclaimed style expert and collector of tie bars and cufflinks, throws shade, comparing the corduroy to something from Three's Company and admitting he's leaning towards his signature turtleneck look. They debate the need for a tie, the pressure to wear dress shoes, and the complications of getting the suit hemmed amid BT's frantic holiday schedule (which now includes going to church!). The segment highlights the stress of high-profile dressing and the hilarious clash of their personal styles.

BT and Sal dive into the viral video of Giants Offensive Coordinator Mike Kafka addressing the team, with Sal strongly arguing that Kafka is "a little timid" and "lacking confidence"—fatal flaws for a potential head coach. Sal felt his attempt at using colorful language was "forced," highlighting a lack of authenticity and passion that would make him a non-starter for the top job. The discussion serves as an insight into the non-public factors—like personality and motivation skills—that separate true leaders. Tierney agrees Kafka lacks a future in public speaking and leadership, ultimately confirming that Kafka will not be the next Giants Head Coach.

BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate on the Mets' future, discussing the implications of Pete Alonso's departure and whether it clears the path for Juan Soto to eventually become the franchise's greatest player. Sal dismisses the conspiracy theory that Alonso was moved to make way for Soto's "GOAT status," arguing it was a purely financial and strategic decision. The hosts explore the concept of "The Greatest Met"—a conversation that pivots to the most "beloved" player, with the consensus landing on David Wright over Piazza and Seaver. They also touch on the Mets' new disciplined approach under David Stearns, urging fans to "trust the process" as the team moves away from the Alonso era toward a new, Soto-led future.

BT & Sal dive into the dramatic fallout from the Mets' failure to re-sign fan-favorite Pete Alonso, who signed a 5-year, $155 million deal with the Orioles. Sal concedes that letting Alonso walk is the "right thing to do" for the long-term goal of building a sustained winner, but admits Mets President of Baseball Operations David Stearns is now "Public Enemy #1." The debate centers on owner Steve Cohen's patience: Tierney questions if the public backlash from letting go of Alonso (and other core players like Díaz and Nimmo) could lead to an "irrational" decision to fire Stearns if the team misses the playoffs next season, a move Sal argues would be disastrously short-sighted for the rebuild. The hosts analyze the tension between building a "sustained winner" and succumbing to "petulant" unpredictability.

BT and Sal discuss the volatile fallout of the Mets letting both Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz walk, labeling it a "wreckage." Sal wants David Stearns to explain publicly why the Mets, with all their resources, wouldn't meet Alonso's market price, especially after a great offensive year. Tierney argues that keeping players who delivered "subpar results" makes no sense, stating that fans must choose between loving the players or demanding a winner. The conversation pivots to skepticism, addressing the caller theory that Steve Cohen's focus is now purely on the casino deal at Metropolitan Park. They also debate the future of the Mets' offense: is trading for Kyle Tucker the necessary "sexy, splashy move," or will Stearns prioritize young talent and make the team less competitive in the short term? Tierney is insistent that letting Alonso go only makes Stearns' job of building a playoff contender "more difficult."

BT & Sal unleash on the abysmal state of the New York baseball offseason, which is set on fire by BREAKING NEWS: Pete Alonso signs a 5-year, $155M deal with the Baltimore Orioles! Sal defends David Stearns' conviction on player valuation, arguing the "unsuccessful core" needed a "wrecking ball," while a furious Hof calls the GM a "moron" for letting the face of the franchise walk. The hosts question whether the Mets fanbase can "trust the process" after losing both Alonso and Edwin Diaz. The conversation pivots to the Yankees' inaction, where Sal pitches Nico Hoerner as the perfect, contact-hitting Gold Glove infielder to cure their strikeout woes. They also break down the massive hurdles—ownership approval and a huge extension—stalling the blockbuster Tarik Skubal to Dodgers trade. Finally, the hosts dive into the dark side, tallying all of Tony Soprano's personal kills, then shift to lighter fare, debating cocktail attire for Alex Rodriguez's holiday party and whether the former Yankee deserves a spot in Monument Park.

BT & Sal unleash on the current state of New York baseball's offseasons, focusing heavily on the Mets' disarray. Sal rips Edwin Diaz for his "baby" behavior, reportedly leaving the Mets due to being upset they signed Devin Williams without consulting him. The hosts debate if GM David Stearns is showing "flimsy" conviction by holding a hard line on a three-year deal for Pete Alonso despite the growing fan backlash. They question where the Mets will find a replacement power bat if Alonso walks, liking the idea of trading for Peralta and McGill combined with signing Bellinger and Okamoto for a fundamentally different, defense-first team. The discussion pivots to the Yankees, criticizing GM Brian Cashman for his lack of action. Sal pitches Nico Hoerner as the perfect scrappy, contact-hitting, Gold Glove infielder (with elite stolen base numbers) that the Yankees desperately need to replace the inconsistency of players like Jazz Chisholm

BT and Sal dive into the Tarik Skubal trade rumors, explaining exactly why the blockbuster deal sending the Tigers' ace to the Dodgers is stalled. The problem isn't the package, but the massive hurdles of Detroit ownership approval and the Dodgers' demand for a long-term extension worth hundreds of millions. Then, the mood shifts as the hosts dissect the dark side of television, detailing Tony Soprano's infamous list of personal on-screen kills, from Febby Petrulio to Christopher Moltisanti, and debating the motivations behind the mob boss's most brutal moments. Finally, the segment concludes with the always-unpredictable Three Random Questions (TRQ).

BT and Sal start by debating the concept of "glacial speed" in the slow MLB offseason, using the Titanic iceberg as a nautical analogy. The conversation is then abruptly overtaken by BREAKING NEWS: Pete Alonso has left the Mets for the Baltimore Orioles on a 5-year, $155 million deal. The hosts react to the seismic shift, with a fiery Hof calling Mets GM David Stearns a "moron" for letting the market setter walk. Sal respects the Mets' decision to draw a line in the sand, arguing the team can be better without Pete's specific production. The hosts then transition to their plans for attending Alex Rodriguez's holiday party, debating cocktail attire (corduroy suit vs. turtleneck) and how much actual face time they'll get with the Yankees legend. The segment concludes with a deep dive into A-Rod's complicated relationship with the Yankees and whether he deserves to be in Monument Park.

BT & Sal react to the seismic news that Pete Alonso has officially signed with the Orioles for 5 years, $155 million, following the earlier departure of Edwin Diaz. Sal, though saddened by the emotional loss, defends David Stearns' commitment to his valuation, arguing the "unsuccessful core" needed a "wrecking ball." Tierney agrees that Stearns is "not a dummy" and must be allowed to "cook," but the pair acknowledge the devastating emotional impact on the fanbase, instantly making Stearns "villain number one" in New York sports. The hosts debate whether fans should "trust the process" and give Stearns time, while also stressing that the Mets now need multiple "big, big moves"—like landing Bellinger or a major trade—to appease the furious season ticket holders and replace the lost power. They close by discussing the "perception problem" of popular players seemingly leaving the club and Stearns' unappealing "arrogance or detachment."

BT & Sal react instantly to the explosive news that Pete Alonso is officially gone, signing a five-year, $155 million deal with the Orioles. Sal defends the move, arguing that the Mets needed a "wrecking ball" to change a core that "wasn't working," even though he acknowledges the raw emotional pain for Mets fans who loved the "Polar Bear." Tierney pushes back, declaring David Stearns the most hated man in New York sports right now, demanding he "start cooking fast" to replace the massive power loss. They discuss the potential pivot, noting the money saved from Nimmo, Diaz, and Alonso could target players like Cody Bellinger or Kyle Tucker, but warn that Stearns has zero latitude left and must deliver major moves to avoid becoming a failure. The hosts agree that the team needs at least two big bats and two significant pitchers to prevent the 2026 roster from looking "disgracefully bad."

BT and Sal react to the seismic breaking news that Pete Alonso has officially left the New York Mets, signing a five-year, $155 million contract with the Baltimore Orioles. Hof's fiery reaction sums up the fan base's outrage, calling the decision by President of Baseball Operations David Stearns "inexcusable." The hosts debate whether this move is a necessary "ripping of the band-aid" for a flawed team or a colossal mistake, especially after the recent departure of Edwin Diaz and the trade of Brandon Nimmo. Tierney points to Stearns's focus on defense and high-OBP players like Marcus Semien as the new direction, arguing the Mets can be a better team even with fewer home runs. The key question now becomes: Did Alonso's anger over his treatment by the organization lead him to leave without giving the Mets a final chance to match the offer?

BT & Sal dive into the week's Three Random Questions, tackling life's unexpected dilemmas with their usual passionate intensity: Rewatch or New? Given limited free time, do you prioritize going back to rewatch classic, beloved shows (like The Sopranos or Star Wars), or do you dedicate that time to watching new content? The Ticket Test: If you offer someone free tickets, do you let them know how good (or bad) the seats are upfront, or is their genuine interest in spending time with you all the commitment you need? (Hint: The guys agree that asking about the seats is "tacky!") The Fan's Pain: Are you a sports fan who immerses yourself in the misery of a tough loss, listening to hours of post-game coverage for a sense of "therapy" (like Sal), or do you avoid and ignore the pain completely afterward (like BT)?

BT & Sal dive into the brutal world of Tony Soprano, sparking a fiery segment dedicated to dissecting and ranking the boss's most significant and savage personal killings throughout the iconic HBO series. The hosts weigh in on the motivation and brutality of Tony's hits, debating which "whack" was the most impactful. The discussion pivots sharply to the broken economics of Major League Baseball, fueled by a shocking financial statistic: the Dodgers' luxury tax payment alone is higher than the entire total payroll of 16 MLB teams. The hosts erupt, demanding a radical solution—team contraction—to improve competition and quality of play, arguing that league owners only care about the money, not the quality of the product.

BT and Sal discuss the trade market for ace pitcher Tarik Skubal and the sheer unacceptability of the Mets missing out on him, arguing that losing the bidding war for Skubal would be more egregious than losing players like Pete Alonso or Edwin Diaz. The hosts acknowledge that any deal for Skubal requires a "leap of faith" and a massive haul from the minor league system, especially since no contract extension is guaranteed. Sal emphasizes the importance of staying in the running for the Tigers' ace, fearing the catastrophic optics of him landing with a powerhouse like the Dodgers. The discussion transitions to Edwin Diaz, where they agree his move to Los Angeles was clearly driven by emotion and a feeling of being slighted by the Mets' free-agent decisions, like signing Devin Williams without his consultation.

BT & Sal make a forceful argument that Gold Glove-winning infielder Nico Hoerner is the perfect "scrappy" trade target to fix the Yankees' contact-starved lineup. The guys highlight Hoerner's elite profile: a .297 average, a .345 OBP, nearly 30 stolen bases, and a staggeringly low 7.6% strikeout rate last year. They compare him to a high-risk/high-reward player like Jazz Chisholm, arguing Hoerner provides the consistency and defense the Yankees desperately need. The conversation then pivots to the Mets' hot stove, with a listener proposing a radical overhaul that includes trading Pete Alonso, securing top pitching prospect Jackson Jobe in a trade for Elias Díaz (who just signed with the Dodgers), and acquiring Cody Bellinger and Japanese Gold Glove first baseman Shugo Maki. Sal agrees with the defensive shift but insists the Mets would need to land Tarik Skubal or an equivalent top-tier starter to make the complete teardown worthwhile.

BT & Sal blast the Yankees for their glacial pace this offseason, with Tierney describing the Yankees Hot Stove show as a cure for insomnia. The hosts mock GM Brian Cashman's vague Winter Meetings update that deals have been "tough so far," contrasting his comments about the "aggressive" Dodgers to the Yankees' own timid approach. The discussion quickly turns to the Yankees' glaring roster needs: a leadoff hitter and a reliable right-handed thumper to balance the lineup. They zero in on the problematic infield, with Sal calling for changes at two spots due to the mess of Volpe, Chisholm, and McMahon. Tierney floats the idea of trading Jazz Chisholm for Bo Bichette to upgrade the offense, while Sal flatly rejects the possibility of pursuing Pete Alonso, declaring, "He's just not my kind of ballplayer." The segment concludes with a spirited debate on the entitled nature of former Yankee Edwin Diaz being "upset" with the team for not consulting him before signing Devin Williams.

BT & Sal launch into a fiery debate over David Stearns' leadership, with mounting fan panic following the loss of Edwin Diaz and the looming free agency of Pete Alonso. Sal maintains that the Mets will be better, but argues that losing their top power bat without a clear replacement (Tucker? Bellinger?) makes improving on 83 wins exceedingly difficult. Tierney fires back, cautioning that if Stearns deviates from his "hard line" of three years for Alonso—simply to avoid "public backlash"—it would prove he is "flimsy" and unable to run a healthy organization, drawing a parallel to the foolishness of breaking a budget when buying a home. The discussion is punctuated by a Mets fan caller, Joe, who reads an old "Sal Was Right" tweet about never trusting Edwin Diaz.

BT & Sal explode over Edwin Diaz's shocking defection to the Dodgers for a record AAV, concluding that the closer "didn't want to be a Met" and chose status over the Mets' near-matching $66M offer. Sal rips Diaz as a "traitor" while the hosts ultimately side with the "unkillable" duo of Steve Cohen & David Stearns as they brace for a rebuild. The chaos fuels a fierce debate over Pete Alonso's future, with Sal criticizing Pete for "shopping himself" at the Winter Meetings while his potential Hall of Fame pace is fiercely debated. They dissect Kyle Schwarber's new contract and its massive implications for Alonso's market price. The show is rounded out by a hilarious dive into obscure baseball slang and a serious sit-down with WWE Executive Bruce Prichard (Brother Love) about John Cena's final match and wrestling's toughest "alpha."

BT & Sal turn up the heat on the Mets' sluggish offseason, ripping the team's obsession with pursuing former Yankees like Michael King and calling King as a "top rotation target" "nowhere near enough." The discussion barrels into the contentious Pete Alonso negotiations. Sal criticizes Pete for personally attending the Winter Meetings to shop himself to teams like the Red Sox and Orioles, seeing it as "beneath him" and a sign the Mets' leverage play is frustrating their star. They argue the Mets' alleged three-year offer is absurd, especially if Alonso is on pace to hit 500 career home runs, potentially making him a Hall of Famer—a point BT strongly debates. The segment also touches on the impact of Kyle Schwarber's market and ends with a hilarious digression into obscure baseball slang like "dry humping" (warming up a pitcher who never enters the game) and players referring to runs as "points."

BT & Sal react to the breaking news that elite closer Edwin Diaz has signed a 3-year, $69 million deal with the Dodgers, sparking immediate outrage among Mets fans. The hosts fiercely debate the move, with Sal arguing that the $18 million difference between Diaz's deal and the Mets' 3-year, $51 million signing of Devin Williams makes "no sense" and is absurd for a high-resource team. The discussion pivots to the hot stove market, analyzing Kyle Schwarber's new 5-year, $150 million deal with the Phillies and what it means for the contract price of Pete Alonso—who is now the biggest bat on the market. Ultimately, the hosts acknowledge that this is the beginning of a "wrecking ball" phase for the Mets under David Stearns, who is changing the team "radically," leading to intense pressure and public backlash. They question if Diaz simply took less to play for a World Series contender, but warn that if Alonso leaves next, Stearns will face a fan revolt.

BT & Sal kick off the show with WWE Executive Director Bruce Prichard (aka Brother Love) to discuss John Cena's final match, the evolution of wrestling, and who is the "toughest legitimate alpha" in the locker room today. Then, the focus turns to the New York Mets after Edwin Diaz signed with the Dodgers. Sal explodes after learning the Mets offered three years, $66 million and the deal-breaker was Diaz's desire to be the highest AAV closer—revealing Diaz chose the Dodgers, not the money, but for the status. Sal's fiery retort labels Diaz a "traitor," slamming the trumpets, his 2019 disaster, and his 2024 sticky stuff suspension. The guys ultimately side with the "unkillable" duo of Steve Cohen & David Stearns, believing the organization will bounce back and address the team's many holes.

BT & Sal dissect the shocking news of Edwin Diaz signing with the Dodgers for virtually the same money the Mets offered, concluding that Diaz "didn't want to be a Met" anymore and intentionally shut down negotiations, regardless of the money. Sal argues the ire should be aimed at the player, not the team, for his Dodgers defection. The hosts pivot to the ominous outlook for Pete Alonso, with Tierney downgrading his chances of returning after the loss of Diaz and the earlier Nimmo trade, suggesting GM David Stearns is willing to "rip the band-aid off" the entire core. They debate if Stearns' non-emotional approach is necessary to fix the Mets' problematic clubhouse culture. The segment concludes with The Call of the Day, featuring fans calling in enraged, demanding the Mets sign Alonso immediately and accusing Stearns of being a "disaster."

BT & Sal launch into a heated discussion on whether Pete Alonso is on a Hall of Fame trajectory, starting with a hilarious detour into baseball slang like "dry humping" and "blue ball" in the bullpen. The main event focuses on Alonso's career production, with Tierney arguing that if Pete reaches 500 home runs and 1,200+ RBIs—a feat they calculate is within reach if he averages 40 HRs for the next four years—he's a guaranteed Hall of Famer. Sal pushes back on the "massive assumption" of sustained elite production into his late 30s, citing historical trends among post-PED era players. Both hosts agree on the irony that while they debate his Cooperstown credentials, the Mets' apparent low-ball offers (a 3-year extension) are "absurd," increasing the risk that Alonso could hit his 500th home run in another uniform—a heartbreaking outcome for the franchise. The debate includes a comparison of Alonso's reliability versus the spectacular but shorter peak of Don Mattingly.

BT & Sal are fired up over the state of Pete Alonso's free agent market, specifically the reports that the slugger is meeting with the Orioles and Red Sox at the Winter Meetings while the Mets sit out, claiming "We know Pete." Sal argues the Red Sox would be "moronic" not to sign him, despite their interest in Bregman and Bichette, believing Alonso could hit 50 home runs at Fenway. The conversation pivots to the perplexing baseball market, where a durable, power-hitting player who "posts" (plays every day) like Alonso is not generating massive demand. They blame the "geek infiltration" of analytics for prioritizing defense and speed, thereby suppressing the market for traditional power hitters. The segment ends with the hosts trading their least favorite baseball jargon, from the term "posts" to the hilarious, inside-baseball term "dry humps."

BT & Sal dive into the "Call of the Day," focusing on the furious reaction from Mets fans following the loss of Edwin Diaz to the Dodgers. While fans accuse "Uncle Stevie" Cohen of "nickel-and-diming" and prioritizing his casino over fan favorites, Sal vehemently defends the Mets, arguing that Diaz simply preferred Los Angeles and had no interest in continuous dialogue. The co-hosts then spar over the impact of Juan Soto's massive contract, debating if it has limited the Mets' ability to build around the rest of the team and whether they'd rather have Soto over a core of Alonso, Tucker, and Diaz. The conversation is interrupted by a confrontational call from "Bob the Dodger Fan," leading Sal to take a verbal "blowtorch" to the idea of the Mets being the Dodgers' rival and the necessity of an elite closer to win a World Series. The segment concludes with a wild report of a rumored 3-year, $120 million offer for Kyle Schwarber, leaving BT and Sal questioning the team's priorities for Pete Alonso.

BT & Sal bring in the legendary Bruce Prichard (aka Brother Love) to discuss the WWE landscape, including the highly anticipated final match of John Cena this Saturday. Prichard shares a touching, sad moment from Cena's last bout and definitively ranks him as a Top 5 wrestler, calling him "the prototype" for success. The conversation gets fiery as they discuss the evolution of the business: what makes a wrestler "lose it" physically, the lack of script writers in the golden age, and the constant challenge of producing creative content in the age of remakes. Prichard also names Brock Lesnar (and others) as a legitimate tough guy in the current locker room, opens up about the reality TV series 'Unreal,' and recounts a surprise punch from Roddy Piper that he "never saw coming." The segment wraps with Sal demanding Brother Love determine who the true "heel" is between him and BT.

BT & Sal dive into the uproar over the Mets losing elite closer Edwin Diaz to the Dodgers for a mere three years and $\$69$ million, especially after signing Devin Williams for three years and $\$51$ million. Sal argues that the $\$18$ million difference is "absurd" and demands David Stearns justify the move, unless Diaz simply refused to return.The hosts confront angry Mets fans, reminding them that the team won only 83 games with Diaz, and that Stearns must be allowed to execute his "vision" to build a World Series winner. However, the pressure is immense, with fans now threatening to turn on Stearns and demanding he "Sign Alonso today" to prevent a total fan meltdown. The segment concludes by exploring whether a Williams/Suárez bullpen tandem could actually be an upgrade over last year's relief unit.

BT & Sal react to the breaking news that closer Edwin Diaz has signed a three-year, $69 million deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers, a figure far below the initial $100 million rumors. The hosts are stunned that the Mets, who just signed Devin Williams for three years, $51 million, couldn't bridge the mere $18 million gap to keep the elite closer. Sal argues it's an absurd holdup, especially considering Cohen's spending power and the team's costly mistakes elsewhere. Tierney wonders if Diaz simply took less money for the chance to win a championship with the Dodgers, a move Diaz's agent reportedly didn't even allow the Mets to match. A fiery Mets fan calls in, accusing Stearns of destroying the team's "culture" and leading a "wrecking ball" demolition that could push out even Pete Alonso. The segment ends with the question of whether the Mets' focus on Devin Williams (who had a rocky year and personality issues) over the consistent Diaz will haunt them.

BT & Sal dive into shocking breaking news on the MLB hot stove, reacting in real-time to two major deals: Edwin Diaz signing with the Dodgers and Kyle Schwarber returning to the Phillies for 5 years, $150 million. Sal argues that the Mets made the right long-term move by refusing to invest over $100 million in a closer, calling the move an "unreliable" luxury the team can't afford given their other holes. BT agrees, but they both acknowledge the sting for Mets fans. The Schwarber deal immediately pivots the conversation to Pete Alonso's impending contract, with the hosts questioning if $150 million sets a new floor for the Polar Bear—and where the Mets will now find replacement power if Pete walks.

BT & Sal ignite the hot stove discussion, questioning the Mets' fixation on former Yankees, specifically reporting Michael King as their "top rotation target." Sal fears GM David Stearns is setting a dangerous precedent by avoiding long-term deals for top pitchers like Tatsuya Imai. They tackle the Pete Alonso saga, wondering if his personal attendance at the Winter Meetings is a sign of a weak market, and if the Red Sox's pursuit of Alex Bregman (for defense) further complicates Pete's quest for a long-term deal. The conversation heats up around Kyle Schwarber, with BT arguing for him as a priority DH target to add consistent power, and they debate if the Mets' focus on Peralta and McGill trades signals an acceptance of losing Edwin Diaz.

Boomer & Gio, Tierney & Licata and Evan & Tiki talk through Jets offseason scenarios after the team was blown out by the Dolphins on Sunday

From ‘Unkillable’ (Subscribe Here): Following The Jet's 34-10 loss to The Dolphins, BT analyzes what The Jet's game plan should be for the remainder of the '25 NFL season. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT & Sal kick off a fiery hour, celebrating the one-year anniversary of the Juan Soto signing to prove you "can't win the offseason." The Mets focus shifts to David Stearns' controversial reluctance to give long-term deals to free-agent pitchers, with Sal arguing for trade targets like Tarik Skubal instead of overpaying for "non-aces." In a stunning take, the hosts declare the Jets' brutal loss to the Dolphins is "GOOD" for the franchise, dramatically improving their Colts' draft pick value for a franchise QB. The Yankees are slammed for focusing on irrelevant Sonny Gray history instead of signing Cody Bellinger and Kwan. Other hot topics include: an impassioned rant over the Hall of Fame Veterans Committee's disgraceful six votes for Don Mattingly; a hilarious dissection of "The Bald Look," side "wings," and producer Hoff's viral sweatpants bulge; and an attack on Giants' rookie Abdul Carter's lack of accountability amid off-field issues. The show wraps with Sal detailing his chaotic trip to Santaland and a debate on PED confessions for Hall of Famers.

BT & Sal kick off the show by celebrating the one-year anniversary of the Juan Soto signing, arguing that winning the offseason doesn't guarantee a successful season. The focus quickly shifts to the Winter Meetings and a report on David Stearns' reluctance to give out long-term deals to free agent starting pitchers. Sal defends Stearns' strategy, preferring to chase Tarik Skubal via trade or pursue Michael King over overpaying non-aces like Framber Valdez. The hosts debate whether the Mets can afford to lose Pete Alonso and Edwin Díaz if Stearns' plan to build a "better" team doesn't include massive free-agent contracts. The conversation takes a sharp turn as they discuss the Diddy documentary on Netflix, with Sal questioning whether the hip-hop mogul was responsible for Tupac's death, and noting the lack of payment to artists. The show wraps up with calls debating the Mets' potential pursuit of Kyle Schwarber and Jeff McNeil's "petulant" behavior, with the hosts wondering if a new-look team could function without their "Core Four."

BT & Sal dissect the Jets' brutal loss to the Dolphins, arguing that the pathetic gameplay is paradoxically "great for the franchise," as the defeat—coupled with the Daniel Jones injury—dramatically improves the value of their Colts draft pick, potentially securing a franchise QB like Mendoza. The conversation pivots to the Yankees, where they rail against the media's obsession with the Sonny Gray drama, demanding that Brian Cashman focus on Kwan and Bellinger instead of irrelevant history. They debate whether re-signing Bellinger is enough to make the Yankees a World Series contender and analyze the team's messy first base and left-field situation, lamenting the right-handed hitting drought if Stanton stays. The hosts then launch into a hilarious and detailed critique of "The Bald Look," with BT slamming the ridiculousness of men who maintain side "wings" and Sal detailing his neurotic shaving routine. Finally, they address the viral picture of their producer, Hoff, and his sweatpants bulge, expressing disbelief over the sudden public fascination with his "package."

BT & Sal launch into a heated discussion about Giants rookie Abdul Carter, addressing rumors of his off-field issues—including substance use, falling asleep in meetings, and poor commitment—and how it's translating to a "disastrous" on-field performance for a third overall pick. They compare his lack of accountability to the great Lawrence Taylor, who produced despite his own vices, and criticize the Giants organization for drafting a player with clear character concerns. The talk then shifts to baseball, focusing on Joel Sherman's report that Kyle Schwarber is the first offensive domino to fall this offseason, forcing the Mets to make a swift decision on their DH/1B strategy before they lose out on their best replacement options for Pete Alonso. Finally, the guys debate whether the NFL's biggest games are fading in excitement, noting how easy it's become to switch away from boring matchups, and they weigh in on the Knicks' injury scare with Miles McBride.

BT unleashes an impassioned rant over the Hall of Fame Veterans Committee disrespecting Don Mattingly, who received a shocking six votes despite his peak dominance and "contribution to the game." Tierney is furious that his all-time favorite player, a high-character star, is continually overlooked while other players with flawed résumés get in. Sal shifts gears to his chaotic weekend: a mad dash to Santaland at Macy's and the Rockefeller Tree where he battled crowds, strollers, and the clock for his family's annual picture. The hosts wrap up with the "Call of the Day," where Sal sarcastically wishes BT a "happy anniversary" of the Mets' massive Juan Soto signing—a reminder that you "can't win in the off-season." They also debate Buster Olney's call for Hall of Famers to admit to PED use to clear the way for Bonds and Clemens.

The "Call of the Day" segment begins with Sal wishing BT a "happy anniversary," marking one year since the Mets signed Juan Soto to a massive $765 million deal. BT wastes no time, rubbing in the Mets' 83-win failure and the fact the Yankees made the playoffs anyway, proving you can't win in the offseason. The conversation shifts to the Winter Meetings, discussing Pete Alonso meeting with the Red Sox and Orioles, fueling speculation that the Mets' "hard line" of a three-year deal could push the Polar Bear out. The hosts then pivot to a fiery debate on PEDs and the Hall of Fame, agreeing with Buster Olney that current Hall of Famers are cowardly for not confessing their own use, which would finally clear the way for Bonds, Clemens, and A-Rod. Finally, a controversial caller challenges the legacy of Don Mattingly, prompting BT to passionately defend "Donnie Baseball" as the most beloved New York athlete of his lifetime, arguing his career was cut short by injury, not performance.

BT & Sal go off on the Veterans Committee's shocking decision to once again deny Don Mattingly election to the Hall of Fame, especially after he received an embarrassing six total votes. Tierney, Mattingly's all-time favorite player, is perplexed and enraged, questioning how his former peers on the panel (like Ozzie Smith and Robin Yount) could overlook a player who was undeniably the best in baseball for several seasons, was a "steward of the game," and has an "incredible level of character." The debate quickly shifts to the hypocrisy of the selection process, contrasting Mattingly's brief but brilliant career and clean record with the enshrinement of players like Jeff Kent, who lacked the same accolades, raising the central question: Why are players with "legitimate holes" in their resumes getting in while Mattingly gets disrespect? The hosts lament that Mattingly's prime is now so distant, it's becoming a reference point "40 years" in the past.

BT & Sal go off on Giants linebacker and third overall pick Abdul Carter, discussing off-the-field issues that sources say stem from excessive drug use, which has reportedly led to him falling asleep in meetings and showing a clear lack of professional commitment. Tierney and Licata debate the new prevalence of THC use in the NFL and argue that while the drug itself is less harmful than alcohol, Carter's problem is the "trifecta of failure": poor production (just 1.5 sacks in his rookie season), repeated disciplinary issues (benched twice for missing team obligations), and a failure to prioritize his career. They question why the Giants organization, from the previous regime to interim head coach Mike Kafka, allowed these character flaws to fester and whether this now looks like a "disastrous pick." The segment ends with a sharp comparison: Lawrence Taylor had his issues, but he was the greatest defensive player ever—Carter has zero production to lean on.

BT and Sal dive headfirst into the heated topic of going bald. BT launches a blistering attack on men who are completely bald on top but insist on keeping the hair grown out on the sides, calling it one of the "worst looks any man can have." Sal, who fully shaves his head, admits he is currently a "neurotic" fanatic testing three different electric shavers in his quest to find a tool that can get as close as a wet shave—a method BT champions. BT details his strict routine of being a "shower shaver" at least three to four times a week to keep his "dome" perfectly tight. The conversation concludes with a hilarious, yet brief, detour into the viral photo of "Hoff's Package," which Tierney claims he barely even noticed.

BT and Sal are furious that the main takeaway from the Yankees' Winter Meetings is Brian Cashman's old Sonny Gray drama, where Cashman claimed Gray lied about wanting to play in New York. The hosts argue this is a self-made distraction to divert attention from the real issues: the team's inaction on critical offseason needs. They demand to know if the Yankees are pursuing Kyle Tucker or Cody Bellinger and are frustrated by the vague plan for left field and the ongoing leadoff hitter void. The hosts warn that simply relying on a strong rotation (which will be vulnerable early due to injuries) and the return of Judge is not enough to win a World Series, criticizing the focus on a former player instead of fixing the lineup.

BT & Sal dissect the Jets' "brutal" and "unwatchable" loss, condemning Brady Cook's erratic quarterback play and the receiver corps' lackluster performance. The upside? The guys pivot to the Jets' improving draft capital, discussing how Daniel Jones's Achilles injury has dramatically boosted the value of the Colts' first-round pick (now projected around #18). Sal argues the Jets must prioritize losing to secure a high-value pick to land their coveted franchise QB, Mendoza (an obvious college football comparison). They debate the scenarios of trading up and the conviction needed to go "all-in" for the right quarterback, even if it means risking massive draft capital.

BT & Sal dive into the explosive Diddy documentary, asking the ultimate, fiery question: "Do you think Diddy...killed Tupac?" Tierney, a self-confessed Tupac fanatic from his youth (Corvette stickers and Death Row chains included!), and Sal dissect the mogul's dark side, noting the trail of death, jail, and violence that surrounds him, starkly contrasting with his "Mr. Softy" public image. The hosts explore the documentary's revelations, including Diddy allegedly hanging Vanilla Ice over a balcony, the theory that Diddy may have been involved in Biggie's death after forcing him to travel to the West Coast, and the shocking accounts of Diddy not paying his artists. They explore how the tragedy of Biggie's death seemed to only accelerate Puff Daddy's rise to an even bigger star.

BT and Sal dive into the Mets' offseason dilemma as reports circulate that President of Baseball Operations David Stearns is hesitant to commit to long-term, high-dollar contracts for free-agent pitchers. Sal is surprised by the caution, arguing that the Mets "need an ace," but agrees that overpaying for a mid-tier arm is reckless. The hosts debate the merits of trading for an ace like Tarik Skubal versus signing a power bat like Kyle Schwarber, whose bat Sal believes is a "perfect move." Tierney presents his "perfect Mets offseason"—a four-part plan including trades and free-agent signings—which Sal adjusts to prioritize offense (Alonso/Schwarber) over re-signing closer Edwin Diaz. The segment questions whether Stearns' strategy of prioritizing long-term organizational health will satisfy fans desperate for a "number one" starter now.

BT and Sal dive headfirst into the Mets' offseason dilemma, sparked by a report that David Stearns is "reluctant" to give long-term deals to free-agent starting pitchers like Framber Valdez. Sal argues this philosophy is smart money, insisting the Mets should avoid overpaying for a non-ace like Valdez and instead aggressively target trade-and-extend options like Tarik Skubal. BT agrees Valdez isn't a true ace, but asks if the Mets can afford to be choosy after last year's rotation collapse. The debate heats up on the question of value: is a three-year deal for Michael King smarter than seven years for Valdez? The discussion expands to the future of the core, with Sal advocating for the emotional release of Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz if they demand reckless contracts, believing the Mets haven't won with them anyway. The hosts analyze Stearns' strategy and ask whether his dedication to player development will clash with the need to win now.

Hear the best interviews of the week, including Joe Benigno on the Jets; SNY NFL reporter Connor Hughes with Evan & Tiki; Brian Baldinger on the Giants with BT & Sal; NFL talk with Nick Kostos from You Better You Bet, and Hall of Famer Fran Tarkenton joins Boomer & Gio in studio.

Boomer & Gio react to the report that Giannis Antetokounmpo would only approve a trade to the Knicks shortly before he sustained an injury that night. Plus, Evan Roberts has a source that says the Knicks do not want to pursue Giannis; BT and Sal on how Giannis’ injury impacts a potential trade, and discuss which Knicks are untouchable in a potential deal and why Karl-Anthony Towns is the roadblock in the way.

Evan & Tiki evaluate the job Joe Schoen has done up to this point as GM of the Giants. Plus, Brandon Tierney and Sal Licata wonder why the Giants are sticking by Schoen and why they’d prefer a new GM to come in and pick a new head coach; Evan & Tiki on whether or not Abdul Carter is a bust; Boomer & Gio take calls on Abdul Carter and weigh in on Mike Tomlin as a possible fit for the Giants.

This week's Yankee highlights include the worry that has fallen over the fanbase after YES Network's Yankee Hot Stove hinted that the Bombers could be out on Cody Bellinger now that Trent Grisham is back on a $22 million salary. Evan says there should be big concerns in the Bronx, while Sal can't believe the mighty Yankees wouldn't be in on the likes of an Edwin Diaz or thought to be willing to spend big on Kyle Tucker.

This week's Mets highlights are full of Devin Williams reactions, from Sal calling it a good move regardless of what happens with Edwin Diaz to Chris McMonigle giving it an incomplete grade, depending on what moves are next. Plus, BT and Sal react to reports of a chilly relationship between Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor, and ponder what the market is for Pete Alonso.

BT & Sal dive into the Mets' fiery offseason, centered on the blockbuster choice: re-sign Pete Alonso (who wants a long-term deal) or replace his power with Phillies slugger Kyle Schwarber. Sal loves the idea of pairing Schwarber with Soto and is ready to trade fan favorites to change the team's DNA, putting immense pressure on President David Stearns. The conversation gets heated over trade targets, with the hosts calling the Tigers "idiots" if they don't move ace pitcher Tarik Skubal now for maximum value. They then shift to NFL Power Rankings for Week 14, where they both exclude traditional top teams and Sal shocks with the Bears at #5. The pressure is on for the Perfect Parlay—will Sal's aggressive 100-point play break his losing streak? The show wraps with wild Vegas stories and the mystery of the stolen baseball cards in the office.

BT & Sal dive deep into the Mets' high-stakes offseason, fueled by rumors linking the team to Phillies slugger Kyle Schwarber. The central debate is whether signing Schwarber means Pete Alonso is gone, as the Mets are reportedly holding firm at a three-year contract for the Polar Bear. Sal argues that Schwarber is the only comparable power bat to replace Pete and loves the idea of pairing him with Soto. They discuss the pressure on President David Stearns to radically change the team's DNA, even if it means sacrificing fan favorites, but note that losing the core makes success mandatory. The conversation also shifts to the desperate search for a center fielder, weighing the high-risk, high-reward proposition of trading for the often-injured Byron Buxton against making a costly play for Cody Bellinger. Sal is open to a four-year deal for Schwarber, which would surely anger a younger Alonso, who wants more money and term.

BT & Sal kick off with weekend plans, discussing the upcoming SantaLand queue and their fascination with the Diddy documentary, before diving into the baseball hot stove. They get fiery over Mets target Tarik Skubal, arguing the Tigers are "idiots" if they don't trade him now for max value, and debate the merits of signing Framber Valdez (a ground ball pitcher) despite the Mets' shaky infield defense. They also briefly touch on the Yankees' minimal offseason moves, the lingering Giannis rumors for the Knicks, and the mystery of who stole Sal's vintage baseball cards from the community area, symbolizing a "nose dive" in office etiquette!

BT & Sal dive into a heated discussion on the New York Jets, with BT's renewed faith in the team's "unkillable" foundation and coach Aaron Glenn leading to a debate on whether Tyrod Taylor is helping develop young talent like Mitchell (00:04:50) despite the losing season. Callers weigh in with fiery takes on the Mets' offseason, urging Steve Cohen to trade for Skubal and move on from Diaz (00:17:52). The main event is the NFL Power Rankings for Week 14, where both hosts exclude traditional powers like the Bills, Ravens, and Eagles (00:36:31). Number 1: Both agree on the dominant New England Patriots (00:42:50). Number 2: Both choose the Los Angeles Rams (00:42:19). Contention: Sal shocks with the Bears at #5 (00:37:24) and Seahawks at #3 (00:41:29), while BT defends the Packers at #5 (00:36:31), 49ers at #4 (00:38:12), and the Broncos at #3 (00:39:17). They also discuss the tenure clock ticking for the Jets' front office (00:30:32).

BT & Sal dive into a discussion about changing fan loyalties, with Sal questioning his nephew's allegiance to the Rangers despite wearing a Devils jersey, and BT revealing a potential family tie to a Devils star that might force him to convert. The main event is the Week 14 Perfect Parlay, where the pressure is on: Hof dials back to a three-team parlay despite a tight race, BT wiggles back into contention with a conservative two-team play, and Sal takes a four-team, 100-point shot to catch up, trusting his Colts "due" theory to snap a 10-game losing streak in Jacksonville. The show concludes with a wild detour into Vegas gambling stories, covering the agony of the "Blackjack Table Bullies," the self-shame of ATM withdrawals, BT's $160,000 side-bet near-miss, and Sal's theory that you play to win, not to have fun. Finally, they give their Players to Watch for the week: Josh Allen and Sam Darnold.

It's Week 14, and the Perfect Parlay competition is heating up! Host Hoff holds a narrow lead, but a streaking BT is right behind him, prompting Sal to go for a high-risk, four-team parlay for 100 points to close the gap. BT plays it conservative with a two-team parlay, betting the over in the Titans-Browns "dirt game" and backing the Jaguars as home dogs against the Colts. Hoff likes big favorites, smashing the spread with Seattle (-7) and Tampa Bay (-8), while predictably picking Miami over the Jets. Sal swings for the fences, taking the Raiders (+7.5) as a home dog and backing his Colts (-1.5) to finally snap a 10-game losing streak in Jacksonville! The segment ends with the hosts sharing crazy stories from their gambling past, including BT's near-miss of a $160,000 blackjack payout and their hard-and-fast rules about when to quit the casino ATM line.

BT & Sal dive into the most chaotic power ranking week of the season, fueled by the NFL's "up and down" parity. They agree on one undisputed leader: the New England Patriots ($11-2$ with 10 straight wins) and their impressive quarterback, Drake Maye.The rest of their lists ignite a debate, particularly over the surging Denver Broncos (Sal begrudgingly puts them at #4, BT at #3) and the surprise Chicago Bears (Sal at #5), who BT dismisses as winning with "smoke and mirrors."The discussion covers the Seahawks, the Rams' inexplicable loss to the Panthers, and why perennial contenders like the Bills and Ravens have fallen off both hosts' radar. The consensus: the NFL is unpredictable, making the search for the five best teams harder than ever.

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for week 14 in the NFL. The boys go over what happened in week 13. They pick every game against the spread and Boomer hands out his awards for the season. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT & Sal kick off a fiery segment by discussing the death of office etiquette after Sal left three boxes of vintage baseball cards (including an '88 Score Mattingly!) in a community area, only for them to vanish without a trace in under two hours. Tierney confesses he, too, swiped a few packs "just in case Santa forgets" but was shocked to find the entire haul—and even the boxes—gone on his return. The hosts rail against the "every man for himself" mentality that dominates the station's communal space. The discussion pivots to the MLB free-agent market, where Sal details Marc Feinsand's top starting pitcher rankings, including Ranger Suarez, Framber Valdez, and Michael King—all of whom the Mets and Yankees are pursuing. Sal expresses frustration over the Mets missing out on Max Fried last year, arguing that he was a better and more proven "true ace" than the high-priced, potential-based pitchers available now. Tierney highlights the defensive concerns, noting Valdez's extreme ground-ball rate and the Mets' shaky infield defense (especially at 3B/1B).

BT & Sal go off on the Detroit Tigers' hesitation to trade ace left-hander Tarik Skubal, arguing the team would be "idiots" to risk losing him for nothing when his value is at its absolute peak right now in the offseason. Tierney emphasizes that Detroit is in no position to pay the $400 million Skubal is expected to command in free agency, making a trade the only smart move. The hosts argue that Skubal is the "biggest difference maker" available and should be the Mets' absolute focus, even if it means giving up a massive package. Sal says Skubal is "ten times better" than Framber Valdez, urging the Mets not to get distracted by other lower-tier pitching targets.

BT & Sal dive into a deep-cut sports debate, first reacting to the Lions' dominant win over the Cowboys. The conversation quickly shifts to the New York baseball offseason, where Sal predicts the Mets will have a "better" and more active winter than the Yankees, particularly in "crushing the rotation." They discuss the "Giants Effect," arguing that the Mets' unexpected success in 2024 "complicated" David Stearns' job, forcing him to keep a core that should have been dismantled earlier. They analyze the Yankees' internal problems, noting the lack of improvement if Volpe can't put in work due to his shoulder injury and if the lineup relies on Stanton and Grisham. They challenge Mets fans' pessimism, demanding the team lands two top pitchers (Skubal/Suarez or Peralta/Valdes) and explore Tatis Jr. as a dynamic replacement option if Pete Alonso bolts. The segment closes with a note that Giannis will dominate Knicks coverage for the next two months.

BT & Sal ignite a debate over Mets President David Stearns' disciplined, non-budging stance on a three-year contract for Pete Alonso. Sal believes Alonso is "100% gone" for at least four years elsewhere, but Tierney respects Stearns' hard line—if he wins! The pressure is immense: if Stearns lets fan-favorite Alonso walk and the team loses, he's a "dead man." The discussion heats up over the possibility of the Mets pursuing Kyle Schwarber, with the hosts agreeing that if Stearns gives Schwarber (who is two years older) more years or money than Alonso, it would be a "dirty" move and a massive blunder. Callers chime in, suggesting front-loaded deals, while the hosts ultimately acknowledge that Stearns must be allowed to build the team his way, or else the model breaks. The excitement builds imagining a Lindor-Schwarber-Soto three-man tandem.

BT & Sal ignite a heated debate over the Mets' struggling outfield, dismissing Cody Bellinger as an unlikely option given his Yankee ties, but acknowledging his flexibility is appealing. The conversation quickly shifts to the current center field options, with Sal calling a potential Harrison Bader signing a waste of time and Byron Buxton an injury-prone gamble. The crux of the segment focuses on the future of Pete Alonso: if the Mets let him walk, they "must sign Kyle Schwarber." Sal passionately argues that Schwarber's superior plate discipline (despite the high strikeouts) and unhinged "caveman" energy make him a better power-bat acquisition than retaining Alonso. They compare the two sluggers' OPS and debate the risk of Schwarber's two-hundred-strikeout season in the postseason.

BT & Sal dive into the hot rumor connecting the Mets to free agent Kyle Schwarber, immediately questioning whether the power-hitting DH is a replacement for Pete Alonso or an addition. Sal loves the idea of adding Schwarber's prodigious power while weakening the Phillies, but BT argues it makes little sense for a team emphasizing defense and versatility under David Stearns, given Schwarber's lack of position and high strikeout rate. The conversation pivots to the "hardball" the Mets are playing with Alonso, with sources indicating the team is holding firm at a three-year offer, far below what Pete and Boras are seeking. They debate whether moving on from Alonso to pursue Schwarber—and finally breaking up the core—is a smart business decision, even if it sacrifices a fan favorite. They agree the Mets have options, including a Bellinger-Pete combo, and must prioritize pitching, but the Alonso-Schwarber ultimatum is the most fascinating offensive negotiation.

BT & Sal ignite a New York sports firestorm starting with the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade rumors, passionately arguing that Jalen Brunson is "untouchable" and debating which key player (OG Anunoby or Mikal Bridges) must be sacrificed for the Greek Freak. Sal insists the trade is pointless if the Knicks retain Karl-Anthony Towns' contract. The heat moves to the Giants, where the hosts slam the decision to keep Joe Schoen as GM, calling him a "lame duck" who will only worsen the upcoming head coach search. They then pivot to the Yankees' confusingly "lukewarm" offseason, questioning if the Bronze Bombers are serious about winning while pursuing Cody Bellinger and other Japanese stars like Kaz Okamoto and Tatsuya Imai. The segment also features NFL Week 14 "best bets" with Nick Kostos on the Chiefs' "DEFCON ONE" status, a spicy Hall of Fame debate over the eligibility of A-Rod and Manny Ramirez, and the shock of the Diddy documentary footage. The show closes with a desperate "Call from Down Under" lamenting the Mets' "slop" pitching.

BT & Sal dive into the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade rumors, which are heating up with reports that the superstar wants the Knicks. The fiery debate centers on the New York Knicks' strategy: Giannis In, Karl-Anthony Towns Out. Sal argues that keeping the overpaid and defensively exploitable KAT makes the trade pointless, even with Giannis. They discuss the likelihood of OG Anunoby and Mikal Bridges being the necessary price, and whether a Brunson-Giannis-Towns trio could ever work. Later, the conversation pivots to the New York Giants' front office turmoil, where Sal and BT react to a report from Ian O'Connor asserting that the organization made a "bad situation worse" by retaining General Manager Joe Schoen, who is now reportedly "leading the way" for the next head coach search. The hosts argue that Schoen must be removed to facilitate a clean break.

BT & Sal ignite on the Yankees' confusing "Hot Stove" reports, questioning why the Bronze Bombers aren't a threat to sign every top free agent like Edwin Diaz, though they agree with the team's pursuit of Cody Bellinger. They debate if the team is prioritizing winning and if the front office is playing possum. The conversation then pivots to the Knicks, where the hosts vehemently disagree with trading Jalen Brunson for Giannis Antetokounmpo, but analyze the difficult decision the Knicks face regarding which other key player—OG Anunoby or Mikal Bridges—would have to be moved for a blockbuster trade. Finally, Nick Kostos jumps on to share his "best bets" for NFL Week 14, calling the Lions/Cowboys game a must-win for Dallas and declaring the Chiefs are at "DEFCON ONE" ahead of their dangerous matchup against the surging Texans. They also touch on the Jaguars' trajectory and the surprising NFC North race between the Packers and Bears.

BT & Sal dive into the fallout of Giannis Antetokounmpo's calf strain, debating the conspiracy theories about whether the two-to-four-week injury is a power play to force a trade to the Knicks. Sal argues that Jalen Brunson is "untouchable" and that acquiring Giannis now is necessary to maximize the Knicks' championship window. The discussion pivots to the MLB Hot Stove as they examine the odds for several Japanese stars heading to New York. They break down the pursuit of infielder Kaz Okamoto (Yankees favored) and the intriguing pitcher Tatsuya Imai, who declared he wants to "beat the Dodgers." The hosts also weigh the cost of Japanese pitchers, discussing the impact of extra rest days on a team's rotation. The consensus: the Knicks must strike now for a championship, whether with Giannis or another star, as the window is wide open.

BT & Sal dive into the buzz surrounding the Diddy documentary, highlighting the "unreal" vintage footage and the early rise of the hip-hop mogul. The conversation shifts to a fiery debate over the 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, triggered by a voter who submitted a ballot with only David Wright's name. Sal and BT dissect their differing picks, agreeing on Carlos Beltran and Felix Hernandez, but clashing over Andy Pettitte and closers like K-Rod. They also tackle the elephant in the room: whether A-Rod and Manny Ramirez should be let in despite their PED use. In football, they debate whether the Giants should gamble on the past glory of Bill Belichick or the program stability of Mike McCarthy, acknowledging the "purgatory" status of the Yankees. The show concludes with a special "Call from Down Under" from a loyal Mets fan in Australia seeking solutions for the Mets' dire pitching situation, which Sal labels "slop."

BT and Sal dive headfirst into the controversial 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, which they deem "light." The discussion kicks off with a viral single-vote ballot for David Wright, prompting a fiery debate on the Mets Captain's true Hall credentials versus his "Hall of Fame person" status. The hosts break down their respective five- and four-man ballots, agreeing on Carlos Beltrán (despite the sign-stealing controversy) and "King" Félix Hernández (dominance over longevity). Sal makes a passionate case for Andruw Jones (ten Gold Gloves) and Andy Pettitte (postseason legacy), while BT argues for Francisco "K-Rod" Rodríguez based purely on his historic peak and questions why all the steroid-era greats like A-Rod and Manny Ramírez shouldn't just be inducted together.

BT & Sal dive into the breaking news that Giannis Antetokounmpo is officially out for two to four weeks with a right calf strain. Tierney expresses suspicion, questioning if the fall was "overly theatrical" and if Giannis might be "milking this" to force a trade, while Sal points out that reports confirming the injury won't stop the speculation. The conversation quickly pivots to the Knicks' championship window, with callers debating if the injury should deter the pursuit of the "mega-star." Sal emphasizes that Jalen Brunson is "untouchable," arguing that trading him defeats the purpose of acquiring Giannis and that the window for a title is "now." They also touch on the bizarre logistics of a "five-syllable superstar" name at Madison Square Garden.

BT & Sal bring in sports betting insider Nick Kostos to dissect the critical Week 14 NFL slate. Kostos issues a "Code Red" for the Chiefs, arguing they are a must-win team against the surging Houston Texans and declaring their season over if they lose. He reveals why the injury-depleted Lions are ripe for a Dallas Cowboys upset on Thursday night, a game he views as an "elimination game" for the NFC East race. Other hot takes include: The Colts' Collapse: Why the Jaguars will beat a team led by a quarterback playing on a broken leg. The NFC North: Why the Packers are better than the Bears, despite Chicago's recent wins. Giants' Future: A quick-fire prediction on who will be the G-Men's head coach in 2026.

BT and Sal dive into the red-hot debate surrounding the Knicks' dynamic wing duo, OG Anunoby and Mikal Bridges. With superstar trade rumors—like the ongoing Giannis Antetokounmpo chatter—heating up, the guys discuss the painful reality that to land an MVP, New York would likely have to break up their formidable wing combination. The hosts clash over which player is the more valuable long-term asset and who the Knicks would dare to include in a blockbuster trade package. The segment also touches on the debate around Karl-Anthony Towns (KAT) and his disappointing performance, and why trading Jalen Brunson for any player, including Giannis, is non-starter.

BT & Sal are fired up over the Yankees' hot stove buzz, particularly the stunning report that the Yankees are "not expected to be a threat" to sign top free-agent closer Edwin Diaz. Sal argues the Yankees should be a threat to sign every elite player, while Tierney is slightly less concerned, noting the team already has a cheap, controlled, and effective closer in Bednar. The conversation pivots to the Yankees' need for a massive offensive upgrade, with Sal expressing frustration that the Yankees are once again being "priced out" of the top tier of talent, unlike the Mets or Dodgers. The hosts agree that the Yankees must pivot aggressively to get better after losing Soto and not letting other rivals gain ground. The segment closes with breaking news that Cody Bellinger remains the Yankees' number one target, making a "big effort" to sign him, although the hosts debate if he'll give them a hometown discount or leave for the highest bidder.

BT and Sal explode over The Athletic's Ian O'Connor's report that the Giants are making a huge mistake by retaining Joe Schoen to lead the next head coaching search. With Brian Daboll gone and the losing continuing, Sal argues Schoen is the "poster boy" for the team's demise and that a clean break is needed now to prevent the situation from getting worse. The hosts worry that allowing the "lame duck" GM to pick the next coach will lead to organizational chaos, with one voice claiming the team's disastrous performance is due to the roster Schoen built versus the coaching that was just fired. The conversation then transitions to the Knicks, where a caller proposes a blockbuster trade: Jalen Brunson for Giannis Antetokounmpo.

BT & Sal dive into the Knicks' future, with Tierney dubbing them the "Bronze Bombers" for settling for less than gold. The main focus is the swirling trade rumors involving Giannis Antetokounmpo and the need to move Karl-Anthony Towns (KAT) to make a championship roster. Sal and a caller argue that keeping the Brunson-KAT tandem is a recipe for disaster due to their defensive liabilities, stating that KAT must be traded in any Giannis scenario. The hosts agree that the only viable path is Giannis in, Towns out, even if it means sacrificing Mikal Bridges and OG Anunoby. The debate turns to how the Knicks can build a supporting cast of "buyout guys" and veterans to surround a Brunson-Giannis core, especially against the "seemingly unbeatable OKC Thunder."

BT & Sal dive into the red-hot trade rumors surrounding Giannis Antetokounmpo and the Knicks, fueled by reports that the superstar only wants New York. Sal argues that Giannis's rumored preference gives the Knicks massive leverage, potentially allowing them to acquire him without giving up everything the Bucks demand. The hosts agree on one crucial point: for the Knicks to win a championship with Giannis, Karl-Anthony Towns must be traded. They debate the toxic fit of a Brunson-Giannis-Towns trio and the need to reroute Towns for the wing defenders (Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby, and picks) they would have to surrender in the initial Giannis trade. The conversation heats up when a producer suggests Jalen Brunson should be traded for Giannis, a notion Tierney instantly shuts down as "zero chance." The segment also touches on the trade restriction on Mikal Bridges (who can't be traded until early February) and questions whether Leon Rose made a strategic error by going "all-in" for Towns a year ago, thereby depleting the trade capital needed for this now-looming blockbuster.

BT & Sal kick off by addressing the "elephant in the room"—the widely rumored return of Craig Carton—and how it impacts their future. The debate immediately shifts to a fiery attack on the Giants, with Sal declaring GM Joe Schoen's tenure a "fireable offense" for overseeing the team's regression, while Tierney argues the job is suddenly "incredibly appealing" due to QB Jaxson Dart. They debate the fit of a veteran GM like Thomas Dimitroff and whether Bill Belichick's baggage is too much for the New York spotlight. In a Yankees Hot Stove segment, they debate Kyle Tucker's price tag, Sal demands a hard stop at eight years, and they analyze the potential "Superpower Strategy" of trading for an ace like Max Fried or Tarik Skubal to create the league's best rotation. The Mets debate centers on Pete Alonso's free agency, with Tierney predicting a "robust" market (including the Red Sox) that forces the Mets to pay, while Sal dismisses the notion of a significantly better offer emerging. They also discuss the Jets' momentum trending up versus the Giants' organizational rot. Finally, they tackle the hilarious and controversial Three Random Questions: Would you date a porn star? (a nod to the viral fake Soto tweet), What's the worst part of being married? (losing your schedule/having to fake interest), and What's the best part of being married? (having a supportive teammate).

BT & Sal immediately address the "elephant in the room"—the widely reported, yet unofficial, inevitable return of Craig Carton—and the future implications for their show. With that out of the way, the focus shifts to the Giants' "unstable mess." Sal emphatically argues that Joe Shane's four-year tenure has resulted in regression, and his continued presence should be a "fireable offense" that owner John Mara must correct. Tierney argues that, despite the chaos, the Giants job is now "incredibly appealing" due to the presence of QB Jaxson Dart and the potential for a clean GM/Coach synergy, possibly featuring a proven veteran like Thomas Dimitroff. They debate whether a big name like Bill Belichick is the right fit, with Tierney questioning if Belichick's age and the "unnecessary noise" from his personal life could be a problem in the high-pressure New York market. Finally, they cover the Perfect Parlay standings, with BT on a heater (6-0 in the last two weeks!) surging past Sal, who declares he's playing "under protest" due to a half-point line discrepancy on his missed Turkey Day Teaser.

BT & Sal dive into a fiery Yankees Hot Stove debate, starting with the likelihood of Cody Bellinger returning, and then pivot to Kyle Tucker, with Sal arguing that giving him 10 years or $\$400$ million is "untenable," calling for a hard stop at eight years. They discuss the Yankees' possible "Superpower Strategy" of trading for an ace like Max Fried or Tarik Skubal to create the best rotation in decades—a move that prioritizes pitching dominance over position player spending.The talk heats up as they preview the Winter Meetings chaos and touch on the persistent (but unlikely) trade rumor of Bryce Harper to the Yankees.Finally, they tackle Three Random Questions, going completely off the rails:Would you date a porn star? (Prompted by the fake Juan Soto/Mia Khalifa social media image) 📸What's the worst part of being married? (Tierney says losing your own schedule; Sal says having to pretend to care about things he doesn't.) 😂What's the best part of being married? (Both agree it's having a stable, supportive teammate who has your back.)

BT & Sal dive into the hot stove debate surrounding Pete Alonso's free agency, with Tierney predicting a "robust" market—possibly including the Red Sox—that forces the Mets into a tough decision on a five- or six-year contract. Sal, however, remains skeptical, arguing he doesn't see a "significantly better offer" emerging despite the slugger's improved year and the absence of a qualifying offer. The discussion also veers into a larger question about New York sports: Do high taxes, traffic, and media pressure make the area less desirable for top free agents who no longer need "Madison Avenue" endorsements to maximize their off-field earnings? Plus, they briefly slam the Giants' worsening track record under GM Joe Shane.

BT & Sal dive into the state of New York football, declaring the Giants' season "over" and shifting focus to the Jets, whose "stock is trending up" due to better infrastructure, young talent development (like AD Mitchell), and winning three of their last five. They contrast this with the Giants' lack of cap space and the need to "fire everybody" from the front office down. The discussion pivots to baseball, debating the contentious question of Pete Alonso's next contract. Sal defends his $180M/6-year line in a fiery exchange with a caller who suggests the Mets should let Pete walk and rely on Mark Vientos—a prospect Sal vehemently dismisses. Finally, they cover the Saint John's Johnnies Report, noting the team's surprising four-and-three start and the need for Pitino to tighten the rotation and defense. The segment ends with the "Call of the Day," a shocking, dumped-out call that leads to a hilarious discussion about Juan Soto's patience and the viral Wes Steinberg fake news tweet that garnered 25 million views.

BT and Sal dive into the day's most outrageous call, where a listener named Chris compares Juan Soto's plate discipline to Mia Khalifa's... expertise, sparking a hilarious and awkward on-air moment. The discussion quickly pivots to the sheer absurdity of social media after they reveal a fake "Wes Steinberg" tweet about a football player received over 25 million views. Finally, the hosts tackle a Giants fan's wild suggestion to trade the team's top draft pick for star WR Justin Jefferson. Sal pushes back hard, arguing the Giants have more crucial holes to fill—like the trenches and the secondary—especially given their limited cap space. The conversation closes with a listener lamenting the state of media, demanding quality and debate over shocking absurdity.

BT & Sal dive into the hot stove debate surrounding Pete Alonso's free agency, with Tierney predicting a "robust" market—possibly including the Red Sox—that forces the Mets into a tough decision on a five- or six-year contract. Sal, however, remains skeptical, arguing he doesn't see a "significantly better offer" emerging despite the slugger's improved year and the absence of a qualifying offer. The discussion also veers into a larger question about New York sports: Do high taxes, traffic, and media pressure make the area less desirable for top free agents who no longer need "Madison Avenue" endorsements to maximize their off-field earnings? Plus, they briefly slam the Giants' worsening track record under GM Joe Schoen.

BT & Sal dive into a trio of combustible topics! First, a viral (and fake) image of Juan Soto and Mia Khalifa sparks the question: Would you ever date a porn star? The hosts explore the potential challenges, from confidence issues to differing lifestyles. Next, the segment plunges into a marital "minefield" by asking, "What's the worst part of being married?" BT admits he misses being on his own schedule, while Sal and Hoff lament the need to "pretend to care" about endless stories and unnecessary communication ("Just talk to me like you're sending a text!"). Finally, they pull back from the sarcasm to share the best part of marriage: having a "pit bull" teammate and an unshakeable home base. The conversation briefly touches on a Bryce Harper to the Yankees rumor that Cashman can't seem to kill.

BT and Sal are bracing for a chaotic MLB Winter Meetings, with Sal expecting a "blockbuster blitz" of trades and signings. The hosts recall the frenzy of Juan Soto's massive signing from a previous year that broke right at the start of the meetings. The conversation quickly pivots to the Yankees, where Sal argues against the conventional wisdom of needing an entire starting rotation overhaul. He strongly asserts the Yankees are "deficient" in position players, not pitching, and should instead strengthen their existing strength to create a "superpower" rotation with the returns of Gerrit Cole and Cam Schlittler. Tierney agrees, saying the Yankees must strengthen what they're already good at, since they can't match rivals like the Dodgers or Blue Jays in other areas. The segment sets the stage for a dramatic week of hot stove action.

BT & Sal dive into the Yankees' Free Agency strategy, debating whether the team will land a big fish like Cody Bellinger or Kyle Tucker. Sal is skeptical the Yankees will match the necessary seven-year deal for Bellinger, while both hosts agree that Tucker, despite being the better all-around player, is not worth the "Soto Money" (an astronomical $765M) that Juan Soto's dominant walk year commanded. Tierney presents a plausible "outside-the-box" scenario: trading for a star like Jazz Chisholm or beefing up the rotation with a trade for a top-tier pitcher like Max Fried or Tarik Skubal to create the "best rotation this century" and pairing it with Edwin Diaz in the bullpen. Sal argues that overinvesting in pitching and neglecting the lineup is a "dangerous plan" for postseason success. The discussion centers on the core tension in MLB contracts: paying veterans for past performance due to their age at free agency (like Tucker at 29), rather than their future prime years.

BT & Sal dive into a heated recap of their "Perfect Parlay Pick" segment, where the leaderboard has dramatically shifted! BT is riding a scorching 6-0 streak after hitting two straight three-team parlays, catapulting him to 210 points, just behind "Big Hoff" at 215. Sal, however, is protesting his score of 110, arguing that he was "murdered" by the Chiefs, Lions, and Eagles upsets over Thanksgiving weekend and demanding a review of the "Turkey Day Teaser" points. The segment exposes the fierce betting rivalry and the dubious math behind the on-air competition, making every pick a matter of pride and points!

BT and Sal tear into the pathetic state of the New York Giants, responding to a furious caller who threatens to cancel his 40-year season tickets if GM Joe Shane returns—a threat Sal quickly calls "BS." They pivot to what must be done next, focusing on bringing in an experienced GM like former Falcons executive Thomas Dimitroff, whose proven track record (building the Falcons to sustained success after the Vick era) contrasts sharply with Shane’s failures. The hosts debate the correct order of hiring: GM first, then coach? They argue that only a Super Bowl winner like Bill Belichick should have the latitude to pick his GM. The episode kicks off with a heated battle over the Perfect Parlay standings, as Sal reveals he was "screwed" out of a win on his Turkey Day Teaser by a half-point line change, sparking a furious debate over NFL betting rules on a tie.

BT & Sal kick off the show addressing the elephant in the room—the breaking news about Craig Carton's inevitable return to the station—and commit to delivering the same "damn good show" regardless of the downstream effects. They then dive into a fiery post-mortem of Joe Shane's press conference, dismissing it as irrelevant compared to the bigger picture. Sal is definitive: the Giants' underperformance proves Shane must go, and he should not be allowed to pick the next head coach. Tierney argues that the Giants' job is actually highly appealing due to the lack of an Eli Manning transition roadblock, and the presence of a promising young QB in Jaxson Dart. Sal counters that the uncertainty and instability at the top of the organization make it an "unstable mess," and that the team's regression under Shane's roster influence is undeniable proof that a total clean sweep is necessary. The hosts and callers agree that there is "no support for Joe Shane" left among the fans.

The best reactions from the Giants' 33-15 loss to the Patriots from Boomer & Gio, Brandon Tierney & Sal Licata, and Evan & Tiki.

Hour 1: The Giants were embarrassed and exposed on a primetime stage, the guys say this will lead to the change necessary for the Giants to start moving in the right direction. BT loves Jaxson Dart. And, who is better dressed-- BT or Dart? Hour 2: The Mets signed Devin Williams, they still need a closer but he's a good contingency plan if Edwin Diaz walks. Sal's acting career may be taking off. Bald Faced Truth / Lie. Hour 3: Should the Giants hire Bill Belichick as their next Head Coach? The NFL Playoff picture is wide open, is that a good thing? Brian Baldinger on next Giants HC, and Calls Out Abdul Carter. Hour 4: Is Home Field Advantage Lost in the NFL? Who of the Mets Young Core Will Step Up in 2026? Jaxson Dart took another terrible hit, he needs to learn from it. Plus, Call of the Day.

Hour 1: The Giants were embarrassed and exposed on a primetime stage, the guys say this will lead to the change necessary for the Giants to start moving in the right direction. BT loves Jaxson Dart. And, who is better dressed-- BT or Dart?

Hour 2: The Mets signed Devin Williams, they still need a closer but he's a good contingency plan if Edwin Diaz walks. Sal's acting career may be taking off. Bald Faced Truth / Lie.

Hour 3: Should the Giants hire Bill Belichick as their next Head Coach? The NFL Playoff picture is wide open, is that a good thing? Brian Baldinger on next Giants HC, and Calls Out Abdul Carter.

Hour 4: Is Homefield Advantage Lost in the NFL? Who of the Mets Young Core Will Step Up in 2026? Jaxson Dart took another terrible hit, he needs to learn from it. Plus, Call of the Day.

Brian Baldinger on next Giants HC, and Calls Out Abdul Carter, plus the Jets O-line looks great!

Bill Belichick is one of the greatest of all time, but has the game passed him by? Should the Giants be interested in hiring him for their Head Coaching vacancy?

Bald Faced Truth / Lie - Will Edwin Diaz be a Met in 2026?

The Mets signed Devin Williams, this doesn't spell the end for Edwin Diaz for sure, but if it does its a great contingency plan.

Show Open: From Jaxson Dart taking bad hits, guys dropping passes, missed draft picks and Abdul Carter missing meetings, the Giants have become a complete circus. The guys say they need to bring in an adult in the room to clean up this mess.

Boomer & Gio, Tierney & Licata and Evan & Tiki break down the Jets' win over the Falcons and ask if it was worth potentially losing some draft position

Hour 1: The Jets win has the fanbase split -- root for wins, or the better draft choice? BT has changed his tone on tanking. The Jets have built the O-Line, and skilled position room, now they're ready to draft a QB. Why did anyone go to MetLife Stadium yesterday? Hour 2: Are There Any Good Teams in the NFL? Is the parity BAD for the league? Should the Jets avoid drafting a QB in this year's Draft? Should the Giants go after Mike Tomlin if he becomes available? Hour 3: The Mets appear to have chemistry issues again, is Francisco Lindor the problem? There seems to be evidence indicating he is. The Mets appear to have chemistry issues again, is Francisco Lindor the problem? There seems to be evidence indicating he is. Should the Mets trade Kodai Senga? Would they regret if they did? Sal shares some details of his budding acting career. Call of The Day and Chris Shula as the Next Giants HC. Hour 4: Could the Giants pull off the upset a big Monday Night Football matchup with the Pats? If they do, will it have long-term implications for Joe Schoen's job? Should Lane Kiffin finished Out the Year as a 'Lame Duck' at Ole Miss? Plus, Call of The Day.

Hour 1: The Jets win has the fanbase split -- root for wins, or the better draft choice? BT has changed his tone on tanking. The Jets have built the O-Line, and skilled position room, now they're ready to draft a QB. Why did anyone go to MetLife Stadium yesterday?

Hour 2: Are There Any Good Teams in the NFL? Is the parity BAD for the league? Should the Jets avoid drafting a QB in this year's Draft? Should the Giants go after Mike Tomlin if he becomes available?

Hour 3: The Mets appear to have chemistry issues again, is Francisco Lindor the problem? There seems to be evidence indicating he is. The Mets appear to have chemistry issues again, is Francisco Lindor the problem? There seems to be evidence indicating he is. Should the Mets trade Kodai Senga? Would they regret if they did? Sal shares some details of his budding acting career.

Hour 4: Could the Giants pull off the upset a big Monday Night Football matchup with the Pats? If they do, will it have long-term implications for Joe Schoen's job? Should Lane Kiffin finished Out the Year as a 'Lame Duck' at Ole Miss? Plus, Call of The Day.

Could the Giants pull off the upset a big Monday Night Football matchup with the Pats? If they do, will it have long-term implications for Joe Schoen?

The Mets appear to have chemistry issues again, is Francisco Lindor the problem? There seems to be evidence indicating he is.

Things seem to be turning sour in Pittsburgh for Mike Tomlin, should the Giants hire him? Would you trade for a Head Coach?

There have been so many upsets in the NFL, and there are no power houses. Some of the best QBs sit outside the playoff picture. The guys debate if that is good or bad for the league.

BT did not have a great experience at the Cowboys / Chiefs game on Thanksgiving, but he said that's better than anyone who went to Jets / Falcons

Show Open: The Jets win has the fanbase split -- root for wins, or the better draft choice? BT says he wanted the Tank, but with the number of times the team has messed up the QB in the draft, he says just win games and build the culture.

Evan Roberts is in tank mode as he is fully invested in the Jets losing out to secure a high draft pick. Plus, Joe Benigno reacts to a Week 12 loss to the Ravens and Chris McMonigle on why there’s nothing for the Jets to build on.

Sal Licata makes the case for Bill Belichick as the next Giants head coach. Plus, Brian Baldinger joins BT & Sal on whether or not the Giants are better than their record indicates; Boomer & Gio speculate Chris Shula as the next Giants head coach and riff on how the team is at least entertaining losers; Evan & Tiki discuss if Mike Kafka has ruined his chances at winning the head coaching job;

This week's Yankee highlights are all about the latest comments from Hal Steinbrenner. BT and Sal went off on the owner lacking emotion and even suggesting that his franchise is not profitable. Evan and Tiki agree that Steinbrenner is better off not speaking about money, and Chris McMonigle says the owner isn't doing himself any favors.

This week's Mets highlights cover all the reactions to the stunning offseason trade, which sent Brandon Nimmo to Texas for Marcus Semien. Evan says New York is now a worse offensive team, while Tommy Lugauer debates that they are immediately better. Sal Licata doesn't get the emotional attachment to Nimmo, while he and BT break down David Stearns' press conference.

Sal talks about Bill Belichick becoming the next HC of the Giants, the positivity in his life due to Jessica Alba, various Thanksgiving strategies, 3RQ, Nick Kostos joins, the 5 worst things about Thanksgiving and much more!

Sal opens up the Wednesday show by talking about why Bill Belichick should be the next Head Coach for the Giants. He also talks about the impact Jessica Alba has had on his life.

Sal talks about the difficulty in timing out your Thanksgiving meals with all of the football games going on, why Bill Belichick is the right man for the Giants head coaching job and does 3 Random Questions with Dov and Rosie.

Sal talks about Bill Belichick's candidacy for the Giants HC job, splitting time on Thanksgiving with your significant others and he chats with Nick Kostos about the NFL Thanksgiving Tripleheader and the rest of Week 13.

Sal continues to talk about Bill Belichick being the right guy for the Giants Head Coaching job, Powers up the 5 worst things about Thanksgiving and gives his Turkey Day Teaser bet!

Sal give his bets for the NFL Tripleheader on Thanksgiving tomorrow.

Sal gives his rankings on the 5 worst things about Thanksgiving.

Sal is joined by Nick Kostos to discuss all the gambling lines and bets for tomorrow's Thanksgiving Tripleheader & the rest of the Week 13 slate in the NFL.

Sal asks Dov and Rosie Three Random Questions. Feeding your pet or human first, asking for help in a store & should turkey be the main protein during Thanksgiving are on the table this Wednesday afternoon

Sal talks about the difficulty in timing out Thanksgiving meals with the three football games going on throughout the day.

Sal describes his frustrations with his social media algorithms, minus Jessica Alba's positive messages that she puts up.

Sal starts the Tuesday show by telling you why Bill Belichick should be the Giants top choice to be their next Head Coach.

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Giants may be 2-10, but in our hearts they're undefeated!!! This is the best Giants season we've watched in over a decade. So do you really want more changes next year to the staff? Plus, Aaron Glenn still has a lot to prove in year one and more fall out from David Stearns trading Brandon Nimmo. Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT & Sal torch Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner for his "tone-deaf" comments and for treating the Yankees as a business first, calling his $100 million payment to New York City an "excuse" for not spending to win. The hosts criticize Hal's complacency with Brian Cashman, demanding accountability for the championship drought and lack of player development. The debate spills over to ranking New York's sports owners (Mara, Woody, Cohen, Dolan) by their commitment to winning. In a hypothetical blockbuster, Sal makes the case for an aggressive Mets trade for Fernando Tatis Jr. over signing free agents. NFL Insider Brian Baldinger joins to dismantle the 2-10 Giants' claim that they're better than their record. The show wraps with a breakdown of the historic Thanksgiving Football slate, the "Bald Faced Lie, Bald Faced Truth" segment, and a "Call of the Day" where a furious Yankee fan "savages" Brandon Tierney for not being aggressive enough against Hal, vowing a boycott against the "trust fund puke."

BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate over Hal Steinbrenner's ownership of the Yankees, questioning if he prioritizes winning or treating the team strictly as a business, unlike his father, George. They criticize Hal for being "too complacent" with 90-win seasons and constantly referencing the luxury tax, arguing he must either spend more to compensate for team shortcomings or fire the people who spend his money poorly. The discussion pivots to Brian Cashman, asking why he continues to receive a pass despite the team's long championship drought and failure to adapt to the modern game, particularly in player development and scouting. Finally, the hosts rank New York's sports owners (Mara, Woody, Cohen, Dolan, Ledecky) based on their perceived passion vs. business focus, concluding that John Mara is the most passionate, while Hal Steinbrenner and James Dolan lean heavily toward business-first priorities.

BT & Sal kick off the show by breaking down a potentially historic Thanksgiving NFL slate, from the Lions-Packers to the huge Chiefs-Cowboys showdown, while also discussing the accelerating pace of time as you age. The focus shifts to baseball, tearing into the Yankees' potential failure to land a star like Kyle Tucker and the need for a "simple, cost-effective move" to trade for Kwan. The hosts give an update on Rick Pitino's St. John's team after a tough loss, noting the team needs to find its identity. They also react to a Japanese star's fiery quote about wanting to "take down the Dodgers." Finally, producer Hoff joins for the Bald Faced Lie, Bald Faced Truth segment, challenging the hosts with three volatile statements: The Yankees will spend more money adding to the roster than the Mets this offseason. (Lie/Truth) The Rangers will finish with a worse record than the Devils and Islanders at the end of the season. (Lie/Truth) The Knicks will win the NBA Cup this season. (Lie/Truth)

BT & Sal torch Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner for being "tone-deaf" and prioritizing the business over winning championships, specifically criticizing his $100 million payment to the city excuse. The hosts argue that Hal's complacency with Cashman and the team's lack of development is costing them a World Series. The focus then shifts to the Mets and an aggressive hypothetical trade for Fernando Tatis Jr. Sal argues that Tatis, despite his $300 million contract, is a better investment due to his age (26) and elite defense than free agents like Bellinger or Tucker. Finally, Brian Baldinger joins to dismantle the 2-10 Giants' claim that they're better than their record, calling out their defensive breakdowns. They discuss the Lions' struggles, the Bears' legitimacy, and whether Jets fans can trust QB prospect Cam Ward.

The "Call of the Day" features Jim from the Jersey Shore, a furious Yankee fan who "savages" Brandon Tierney for not being more aggressive in his criticism of Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner. Jim blasts Hal as a "trust fund puke" for complaining about the team's payroll during the COVID pandemic and vows a boycott, calling any attending fan a "sucker." The passionate rant leads to a discussion about accountability: Sal suggests frustrated Yankee fans should raise their kids as Mets fans, noting that Steve Cohen's spending ensures management is held accountable. The hosts then debate a great listener question: Which GM—Cashman or Stearns—would be better at operating under a hypothetical salary cap? They conclude that Stearns' experience in Milwaukee gives him the edge

The "Call of the Day" features a legendary, "savage" rant from Jim on the Jersey Shore, who tears into BT & Sal for not relentlessly attacking Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner. Jim calls Hal a "trust fund puke" who is "ruining our team" and suggests that any Yankee fan who attends a game next year is a "sucker." The caller specifically challenges Tierney's perceived neutrality on Hal compared to his past "savaging" of Brian Cashman, prompting a fiery defense from BT. Sal offers a solution: "Raise your kids Mets fans." The ensuing debate shifts into a deep-dive question: If a salary cap were introduced, would Stearns' small-market track record or Cashman's experience be better suited to build a winner?

BT and Sal dive into their weekly "Perfect Parlay Pick" segment early, focusing on the high-stakes, 35-point Turkey Day Teaser ahead of the Thanksgiving NFL slate. Sal is set to announce his picks tomorrow, but BT and Hof (who leads the season standings) lock in their 3-team, 10-point teasers today. BT awkwardly reveals his picks—two Unders (Packers/Lions and Chiefs/Cowboys) and taking the Bengals at +17 against Baltimore. Hof, meanwhile, goes "All Overs" on all three Thanksgiving games, setting up a sharp contrast. The segment sparks a wider debate on betting philosophy: why teasers are often seen as a "sucker bet," why Sal avoids over/unders, and the critical difference in laying the points between NFL and the "carnage" of college football where massive spreads are more common.

BT & Sal tag-team NFL Insider Brian Baldinger on the disastrous state of New York football. The discussion is immediately fiery as Sal questions the Giants' 2-10 record, demanding Baldy shut down the fan notion that their talent is better than their dismal standing. Baldy agrees, highlighting the defense's collapse, but gives Interim Head Coach Kafka a passing grade for his deceptive play-calling. The conversation shifts to the Jets' quarterback crisis, where Baldy throws a bone to the fanbase, confidently stating that Cam Ward "can play," directly impacting the Giants' draft strategy. They analyze the league's overall parity, with Baldy arguing the playoffs will be diluted by teams barely over .500, a direct result of QB mega-contracts forcing good teams like the Lions to be "thin." Finally, they debate the legitimacy of the Caleb Williams-led Bears ahead of their measuring-stick game against the Eagles.

BT & Sal bring the heat in the Bold Faced Lie, Bold Faced Truth segment with Hoff, covering New York's top sports headlines. The hosts clash over these three statements: The Yankees will spend more money adding to the roster than the Mets this offseason. (Sal & BT: LIE; Hoff: TRUTH) The Rangers will finish with a worse record than the Devils and Islanders at the end of the season. (Sal & BT: TRUTH; Hoff: LIE) The Knicks will win the NBA Cup this season. (Sal & BT: LIE) The Knicks debate gets particularly fiery, with both hosts expressing zero faith in the team's ability to win the new NBA Cup or a championship due to the continuous Karl-Anthony Towns drama and defensive deficiencies, contrasting it with a "more buttoned-up" Tom Thibodeau-led team. They also dig into the Yankees' reliance on young, low-salaried players and the Mets' potential for a massive winter splurge.

BT and Sal dive into the state of St. John's basketball following a tough loss to Iowa State in the stacked Vegas tournament. Tierney expresses his frustration, stating the team is having a "rough time finding their identity" and is filled with "puppies" who lack the "dog" mentality of last year's squad. He questions whether point guard Dylan Darling is a full-time solution and notes that star forwards Zuby Ejiofor and Bryce Hopkins seem to be playing in each other's way. The hosts lament the loss of the old Big East rivalries (like St. John's vs. Syracuse) due to the "unforgivable" nature of conference realignment. The segment wraps up by looking ahead to the Johnnies' pivotal matchup against Baylor, demanding a bounce-back performance.

BT & Sal kick off a fiery football discussion, declaring this year's NFL Thanksgiving slate the "best three-game lineup" since the league introduced the third matchup. They highlight the magnitude of the Chiefs-Cowboys game, which Tierney is attending, and the NFC North significance of Lions-Packers. The conversation pivots to the AFC North, where Joe Burrow's return makes the Ravens-Bengals game a must-watch, despite Cincinnati's three-win record, because the division is still wide open. They then dive into the overall NFL playoff picture, noting the intense volatility in both conferences. Sal argues that the NFC West (Rams and Niners) holds the only true Super Bowl contenders, despite Brock Purdy's "god awful" performance, and questions the reliability of teams like the Eagles and Bears. Tierney explains the ratio theory for why time seems to speed up as you age.

BT and Sal dive into a heated ranking of New York sports owners, judging them not just by success, but by passion versus pure business. Sal argues that John Mara is the most passionate, putting him at number one because he "bleeds blue" and is destroyed by losses. They place Steve Cohen (Mets) and Jon Ledecky (Islanders) high on the "passion" list, calling them hands-on and emotional. Conversely, they brand Hal Steinbrenner (Yankees) and James Dolan (Knicks/Rangers) as the "bottom-line bosses," prioritizing business over fanatical winning. Woody Johnson (Jets) is acknowledged for his passion and major facility investment, but his lack of a "know-how" strategy keeps him out of the top tier. The debate ultimately pits the caring owners against the calculating ones in a fiery New York sports hierarchy.

BT & Sal launch a fiery debate on the Yankees' enduring failure to win a championship, arguing that Hal Steinbrenner's business-first approach and continued lavish spending are actually making it easy for Brian Cashman to avoid accountability. They contend that the Yankees are not held to a true championship standard, with regular season wins merely being "fluff." Tierney breaks down the six levels of culpability, giving Hal a "pass" for cutting checks while placing the majority of the blame on Cashman for a lack of adaptation to the modern game, poor roster construction, and disastrous player development and international scouting. Sal argues that Hal lacks the "fire inside" of a competitive owner like George Steinbrenner or Steve Cohen, viewing the Yankees more as a "brand" than a passion play for winning.

BT & Sal aggressively debate Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner's priorities following his recent comments. Sal argues that Hal focuses too much on the "business" of the Yankees and his constant complaints about the luxury tax are just "excuses" fans don't want to hear. Tierney agrees, noting that while Hal has brought stability, the organization's "stale" leadership (Cashman and others) needs to be held accountable for years of underachievement. The hosts insist Hal must choose: either spend more to compensate for poor player development and roster construction, or fire the people who consistently fail to build a championship team. They contrast Hal's acceptance of 90-win seasons with the high standards set by his father and, across town, by Steve Cohen.

WFAN presents a selection of conversations about the latest on Big Blue from Boomer & Gio, Brandon Tierney & Sal Licata, and Evan & Tiki. Reacting to the Giants' crushing loss in Detroit -- and the team's decision to part ways with defensive coordinator Shane Bowen in the aftermath.

From ‘Unkillable’ (Subscribe Here): BT Reacts to The Jets' loss to The Ravens in Week 12 of NFL Action. He talks on the offense's promising play, future predictions and the current parity in the league. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): David Stearns is doing his best to turn the New York Mets into a David Stearns team. Sunday night he traded away fan favorite Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers for second baseman Marcus Semien. Hoff explains why this is a good move! Follow @HoffWFAN To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT & Sal bring the fire on the week's biggest New York sports bombshells. They dissect Giants interim coach Mike Kafka's shocking mid-season firing of DC Shane Bowen, debating if it's a genuine leadership move to secure the head job or just "throwing a bone to the fans." The baseball world is rocked by Mets President David Stearns' bold trade of fan-favorite Brandon Nimmo for Marcus Semien. The hosts clash over the move—BT calls it a necessary, "emotionless decision" to reset the core and upgrade the defense, but Sal warns it makes extending Pete Alonso a non-negotiable emergency. They also pick apart Stearns' transparent comments on the trade and the necessary youth movement. Finally, they unleash on Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner's media address, calling out his "Billionaire BS" for complaining about the payroll while owning an $8 billion team. The discussion centers on Hal's refusal to keep pace with the Dodgers' spending and the "radical" roster changes (like a Giancarlo Stanton trade) the Yankees must make to compete.

BT & Sal dissect the shocking mid-season firing of Giants Defensive Coordinator Shane Bowen by interim Head Coach Mike Kafka after yet another disastrous fourth-quarter defensive collapse against the Lions. Sal argues the move is merely "throwing a bone to the fans" since Bowen was gone at season's end anyway, while BT views it as Kafka establishing authority and discipline to secure the head coach job. They fiercely debate whether Kafka made the "right call" to go for a touchdown on 4th down late in the game instead of kicking a field goal, agreeing that in the Giants' current state, being aggressive and seeking a two-score lead was the only way to try and put the better Lions team away. The discussion expands to the future: should Joe Shane be kept as GM, and can Kafka's impressive two-week tenure earn him the permanent HC job? The segment includes Kafka's transparent explanation on why he chose "now" to make the difficult change.

BT & Sal launch into a passionate defense of the Mets' bold decision to trade Brandon Nimmo to the Rangers for Marcus Semien. They argue that despite Nimmo's high character, the move was a necessary, "emotionless decision" to break up a non-winning core, upgrade the defense with the Gold Glove Semien at second base, and free up a position to acquire a better offensive outfielder (like Bellinger or Tucker). Sal argues the trade makes a Pete Alonso extension a necessity, as the Mets cannot afford to lose two major bats. They also preview the big Thanksgiving Day Football slate, focusing on the highly anticipated Chiefs vs. Cowboys matchup, and discuss their reactions to the Alex Rodriguez documentary, with Tierney expressing a soft spot for the flawed former Yankee star.

BT & Sal dissect Mets President David Stearns' decisive, high-stakes trade of fan-favorite Brandon Nimmo for veteran infielder Marcus Semien, praising Stearns for making a "necessary, difficult" move to fundamentally change the clubhouse and improve the team's defensive core. Stearns confirms the trade was driven by the realization that "running back the exact same group wasn't the right thing to do" and to create space for "very young outfielders" (like Jett Williams and Carson Benge) to play. The hosts debate the emotional aspect of trading a beloved player, then clash over the wisdom of the outfield youth movement: Sal is okay with leaving a spot open for a prospect, but BT argues the Mets cannot rely on unproven young players for a winning club and must acquire two top-tier outfielders to secure the spot Nimmo vacated. They conclude by looking ahead to hear from Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner.

BT & Sal dissect Hal Steinbrenner's year-end press conference, focusing on his comments regarding the Yankees' massive payroll and his reluctance to promise another $300M+ spending spree to keep pace with the Dodgers. The hosts vent their frustration over Hal's lack of "irrational behavior" and his deflections on the team's failures, including blaming players for the summer swoons and playoffs. The discussion centers on Hal's claim that it's "not fair to assume" the Yankees make a profit, which the hosts quickly call out as a convenient gloss-over of their $8 billion valuation. Finally, they debate the necessary "radical" roster changes needed, like trading Giancarlo Stanton, to rebuild a winning club, arguing that simply running it back with a healthy rotation and Cody Bellinger isn't enough to secure a World Series.

BT & Sal tear into Hal Steinbrenner's latest comments, arguing his stance suggests "much is going to change" with the Yankees' failed formula. Sal is fed up with Steinbrenner's talk of potentially lowering payroll and his belief that rivals like the Blue Jays simply got "lucky." The hosts demand a "radical" move, specifically the trading of Giancarlo Stanton, arguing it would be "addition by subtraction" to free up the roster and payroll for needed changes, comparing it to the Mets' surprising Nimmo trade. They also slam Hal's defensive response to Aaron Boone's comment about the team being the "least analytical" in the AL East, suggesting it enables the "Department of Nerds" to continue the status quo. Finally, they criticize Hal's take on pursuing Japanese stars—like Yamamoto—acknowledging the business side, but missing the bigger picture of the Yankees losing their status as a destination for elite international talent.

BT & Sal dissect an interview with Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner, whose comments on competitive balance and finances ignite a fiery debate. Hal suggests he would consider a salary cap only if accompanied by a floor to improve balance, a concept the hosts scrutinize. The biggest eruption, however, comes when Hal pushes back on the assumption that the Yankees are profitable, citing a $100 million annual expense to New York City and high spending on development—a statement the hosts call a "lie" or a severe "understatement" for an $8 billion franchise. The discussion also hits Hal's acceptance of the team's perennial "summer swoons," which he blames on players "pushing" and not a "lack of effort," leading the guys to demand more "irrational behavior" and aggressive spending to compensate for the front office's continued lack of success.

BT and Sal tear into Hal Steinbrenner's year-end media session, criticizing his lack of "edge" and "irrational behavior" needed to fix the Yankees' championship drought. Hal defends the $319 million payroll while complaining about financial constraints, prompting the hosts to demand a "whatever it takes" spending commitment like the Mets' Steve Cohen or the Dodgers. The discussion explodes when Hal describes the Yankees' infield as "pretty good," which Sal quickly dismantles by comparing the current lineup to the championship core. They dismiss Hal's focus on base-running mistakes as missing the deeper, fundamental issues in player development and roster construction. BT and Sal conclude that Hal's calm, measured approach—and his dismissive attitude toward the Dodgers' correlation between spending and winning—signals a dangerous complacency that guarantees the Yankees will not make the necessary, aggressive moves this offseason.

BT and Sal discuss Mets President of Baseball Operations David Stearns' recent press conference, where he acknowledged the team "can't run it back" and was transparent about the Brandon Nimmo trade. While both hosts appreciate Stearns' conviction, the conversation turns fiery over Stearns' statement about using young internal options like Carson Benge and Jett Williams, along with Jeff McNeil, to fill the vacated outfield spots. Sal argues that given the Mets are trying to win now, they "can't take a chance in center field" with unproven prospects, citing the Yankees' struggles with Volpe as a cautionary tale. BT, however, argues that every good team relies on young players and the Mets would be "stupid" to plug two outfield holes and block their kids. They debate the need for a "big outfielder" acquisition like Bellinger while keeping one spot open for the youth movement.

BT & Sal are fired up by Mets President of Baseball Operations David Stearns' press conference after trading fan-favorite Brandon Nimmo to the Rangers for Gold Glove second baseman Marcus Semien. Sal hails the move as "perfect," arguing that Stearns correctly shed emotion to make a "tough decision" that separates "the men from the boys." The hosts discuss the four-fold flexibility this trade provides, especially clearing the outfield for young prospects and securing an elite defensive infielder who is a certified "dirt dog" and a "winner." They dissect Stearns' honest assessment of Semien's declining bat and his emphasis on the player's intangibles, speed, and defense. Finally, BT highlights this as Stearns' first true "stamp" on the roster, breaking away from the previous regime's core and making a crucial move toward "sustainable championship caliber play."

BT and Sal dive deep into the new "Alex vs. A-Rod" documentary, reaching a consensus that Alex Rodriguez is fundamentally "a good guy" who was his own worst enemy—he just "couldn't figure it out" and "got in his own way." Tierney admits he's "always had a soft spot" for Alex and is bothered by how the star complicated his own world. They discuss the concept of an athlete having a good personal core, yet repeatedly making self-sabotaging choices that damage their career and public image. The discussion frames A-Rod as a "Shakespearean figure" whose talent was only matched by his flawed character and need to be forthright about his struggles in the documentary.

BT & Sal kick off Thanksgiving Week by breaking down the highly anticipated holiday NFL slate. Sal drops the news that he is heading to Dallas to see the Chiefs vs. Cowboys game live, which has become a massive, high-stakes matchup with both teams coming off thrilling, season-saving comebacks. The guys also discuss the classic Thanksgiving aesthetics, arguing over which uniforms are the best (shout-out to the Eagles' Kelly Green!) and why the tradition of Honolulu Blue needs to be respected. The discussion briefly swerves into the Giants' perpetual issues and Carl Banks' ongoing agitation over the state of the team, proving that not even holiday football can distract from the state of New York sports.

BT & Sal dissect the shocking, confirmed trade of Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers for Marcus Semien. Sal hails the trade as an "awesome move," proving the Mets are finally ready to build the right way and focus on run prevention, given Nimmo's declining defense, poor arm, and lower-extremity injuries. BT argues that the move was necessary to upgrade the defense and frees up the DH spot, making it mandatory for the Mets to now re-sign Pete Alonso to replace the lost offensive power. They debate the trade's immediate impact (Nimmo for Semien is a defensive upgrade at second base, setting up Jeff McNeil to be traded) and what the next move must be: acquiring a top outfielder (Bellinger or Tucker) to fill Nimmo's spot. The hosts praise David Stearns' "gutsy, bold" decision to move past the core's sentimental value.

BT & Sal dissect Giants Head Coach Mike Kafka's decision to fire Defensive Coordinator Shane Bowen, with Kafka citing a lack of "results" after a few weeks of evaluation. Sal respects the move as "coaching one on one" and a step toward "self-preservation" for Kafka, but BT questions why it took so long. The conversation spirals into a fiery debate over the Giants' future, where one caller's "horrible ideas"—to hire Mike McCarthy, keep Kafka as OC, and bring back Wink Martindale—are shredded by BT for having "zero points for plausibility." Sal and a caller then clash with BT over fan expectations, with the caller boldly predicting eleven wins next year, leading BT to furiously demand the fan base get a "grasp of reality" after a decade of failure and another 2-10 start. Sal, however, argues the Giants have an advantage over other struggling teams because they already have their quarterback.

BT and Sal dive into the white-hot controversy surrounding Giants interim coach Mike Kafka's decision to go for a touchdown on 4th-and-goal late in the 4th quarter against the Lions, instead of kicking a field goal to go up by six. Sal emphatically defends the move, arguing that against a high-scoring team, a touchdown to go up by ten was the only way to "pierce the heart" and truly secure the victory, calling a six-point lead an "eternity" in the NFL. Tierney agrees with the aggressive mindset, stating that Kafka needs to be bold to distinguish himself and is "opening my eyes" with his disciplined, transparent, and creative approach—even if a total house-cleaning is still his leaning. The hosts use the explosive call to debate Kafka's future and whether his two weeks as interim coach have proven he has "star" potential coveted by the rest of the league.

BT and Sal dive into the firing of Giants Defensive Coordinator Shane Bowen, with Tierney arguing the move was "long overdue" and just "throwing a bone to the fans." Sal agrees Bowen "needed to be fired" but questions why it took so long, calling his tenure an "awful chapter" defined by the "inability to hold leads." The hosts debate the impact, with Sal suggesting it's primarily a move to "placate distraught, miserable, angry fans," as Bowen was never coming back next year anyway. Tierney counters that it may be Mike Kafka attempting to "clean things up" to bolster his own head coaching potential. The core of the conversation shifts to the evaluation of Joe Shane, questioning if the talent is better than the embarrassing 2-and-10 record suggests, and whether the GM deserves to stay beyond this season.

The recent actions from Cam Skattebo and Abdul Carter have Gio calling for the Giants to clean house across the coaching staff and front office. Plus, Boomer lights into Carter and other NFL players for lacking a sense of responsibility; BT & Sal have strong feelings on the Skattebo WWE appearance; Phil Simms joins BT & Sal to talk all things Giants; Evan & Tiki dive deeper into Skattebo's online streaming presence and analyze Jay Glazer's top coaching candidates for Big Blue.

The Jets officially make the switch from Justin Fields to Tyrod Taylor and Boomer & Gio give their take. Plus, BT & Sal listen and react to Aaron Glenn on switching to Taylor; Evan & Tiki find amusement in Glenn’s press conferences; C-Mac reacts to the QB change, and Keith McPherson says we don’t deserve the “same old Jets.”

This week's Mets highlights dive into some blockbuster hypothetical trades, including one that would send Francisco Lindor to the Yankees and another that brings Tarik Skubal to Queens. Plus, Sal Licata has heard a Pete Alonso return is unlikely, while Evan Roberts says Alonso HAS to be re-signed.

This week's Yankee highlights include all of the reaction to Trent Grisham accepting the qualifying offer to return to the Bronx. Boomer doesn't see the big deal, and Sal says it shouldn't impact the team's spending this winter. But BT believes this could be the start of an awful Yankees offseason, and C-Mac says the heat is now on Hal Steinbrenner to spend.

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Rumors are swirling of Corey Seager being put on the trade market. Can the Yankees swoop in to get one of the bets hitting shortstops in the league? If so, they will put themselves back into the "Evil Empire" tier! Follow @HoffWFAN To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for week 12 in the NFL. The guys tackle everything in the NFL for week 12. Eagles can win ugly. What teams are in panic mode? Cowboys deals are paying off. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT & Sal ignite an explosive discussion starting with former Mets reliever Adam Ottavino's shocking podcast remarks, where he accused manager Carlos Mendoza of "pathetic" bullpen usage leading to a surgery crisis and called Brandon Nimmo "sensitive." The focus then shifts to the Giants, as Jaxson Dart is officially ruled out this weekend, forcing a debate on protecting the young QB from "idiotic" play-calling and whether interim coach Mike Kafka is a viable long-term option. On the baseball hot stove, the hosts clash over the Yankees' free agency targets—is Kyle Tucker or Cody Bellinger the better fit?—and furiously debate a potential trade for Corey Seager, with one host willing to risk the huge contract for his October pedigree and the other calling it a guaranteed "Stanton disaster." Finally, sports betting insider Nick Kostos joins to deliver his NFL Week 12 picks, including the Giants/Lions OVER, before BT, Sal, and Hoff unveil their "Perfect Parlay" bets.

BT & Sal dive into the Giants' most critical storyline: the return of QB Jaxson Dart and the interim head coaching debut of Mike Kafka. They debate whether Kafka's new role is his best chance to distinguish himself as a viable head coaching candidate and if he'll move away from the "idiotic" play-calling that exposed Dart to injury under Daboll. The hosts slam the mindset of fans who want to "put Dart in bubble wrap," arguing that playing is essential for his development and competitive spirit. The conversation also covers the perennial optimism of some Giants fans, questioning how they can feel "close" when the team is definitively 2-9. The hosts discuss Brian Cashman's annual charity sleep-out, wondering how he handles a "dangerous world" and nighttime bathroom breaks. Finally, they look at the coaching carousel, debating if Kafka should stay on if a "big boy" like Sean McDermott or Mike McCarthy is hired, or if he should use his improved resume to find a head coaching or coordinator job elsewhere.

BT & Sal dive into a fiery discussion covering coaching chaos and major league free agency. In football, they debate the next Giants Head Coach, agreeing that the organization needs "stability" and experienced leadership like Mike McCarthy or Sean McDermott, making the "unknown" risk of promoting Kafka or hiring an untested coordinator like Chris Shula unacceptable. On the diamond, the focus is on the Yankees' offseason priorities. They clash over whether to pursue Kyle Tucker or Cody Bellinger (Sal prefers Tucker, BT values Bellinger's versatility). The biggest debate centers on a potential trade for Corey Seager. BT is willing to take the chance on the two-time World Series MVP despite his injury history, believing his October prowess is worth the risk. Sal vehemently opposes the move, seeing Seager's recurring hamstring issues and massive $190M contract as a recipe for a "Stanton disaster" and proof the Yankees continue to chase players whose best years are behind them. They also scrutinize Cashman's comments on the outfield, calling his contingency plan "unacceptable."

BT and Sal open with frustration over Jaxson Dart missing another game due to concussion protocol, stalling the Giants' future watch. They pivot to baseball, dissecting the Yankees' pursuit of an outfielder (Steven Kwan vs. Cody Bellinger) and debating whether the Tigers are "absolute morons" for potentially holding onto ace Tarik Skubal despite his inevitable $400 million contract. They welcome sports betting insider Nick Kostos to discuss NFL Week 12. The trio savages the Bills' diminishing Super Bowl window and debates whether Josh Allen's massive contract is strangling the roster. Kostos delivers his favorite bet of the week—the OVER in the Giants/Lions game—and doubles down on his controversial pick that the Chiefs are the only team in the AFC capable of winning the Super Bowl. They wrap up by discussing potential Giants coaching candidates, including Sean McDermott and Cowboys OC Kellen Moore.

BT and Sal unleash a torrent of commentary following former Mets reliever Adam Ottavino's fiery podcast remarks, where he torches Carlos Mendoza, accusing the manager of "pathetic" bullpen usage and questioning if the organization "even care[s]" about pitcher health, leading to a record number of Tommy John surgeries. Ottavino also stirs the pot by calling former teammate Brandon Nimmo "sensitive" regarding clubhouse leadership and media stories. The hosts also tackle Brian Cashman's defense of Trent Grisham using cryptic "underlying information" and debate whether the Mets should trade the declining Nimmo, McNeil, and Senga during the Hot Stove season. Finally, it's time for the "Perfect Parlay" picks for NFL Week 12. Hoff leads the scoring race, prompting a "desperate" Sal to roll out a three-team parlay with the Giants/Lions Over 50.5 and the 49ers -7. Tierney lays a big -13 with the Lions and takes the Cowboys +3.5 as an upset special.

It's Week 12, and the "Perfect Parlay" leaderboard is getting Fiery! Leader Hoff is out in front, forcing BT and Sal into desperation mode with their three-teamers. Sal throws a Hail Mary by latching onto the Giants/Lions Over 50.5, takes Cincinnati +6.5 as a home dog, and hammers the 49ers -7 on Monday Night. Hoff, feeling confident, rolls out an All-Dogs four-teamer, including the Jets +13.5 (yes, really!) and the Giants +13. BT focuses on bounce-back teams, laying a big number with the Lions -13 and backing the Chiefs -3.5, while taking the Cowboys +3.5 in a classic NFC East rivalry game. The guys also discuss the high-stakes Turkey Day Teaser that could decide their final standings and their humiliating WWE fate!

BT, Sal, and betting guru Nick Kostos unleash their fiery best bets for NFL Week 12! Kostos declares the Giants are headed for a "bloodbath" against the Lions, passionately arguing for the Over 50 total due to the Jameis Winston factor. They pivot to the AFC, where Sal takes a victory lap on the Chiefs' AFC West demise, and Kostos shockingly states the Chiefs are the only AFC team capable of winning the Super Bowl, despite their struggles (and current -200 playoff odds). The trio also breaks down the Ravens' offense being vulnerable enough for the Jets to cover, and debates whether the Giants should pursue a "good coach" like Sean McDermott or take a chance on a rising name like Cowboys offensive coordinator, Clayton Adams.

BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate over the hypothetical trade for Texas Rangers shortstop Corey Seager. Sal, prioritizing a World Series push, argues that even 100 games from a two-time World Series MVP is worth the risk, advocating for a potential move to third base to manage his recurring hamstring issues. However, Tierney is vehemently "not interested," likening the trade to acquiring a physically unreliable Giancarlo Stanton and expressing concern over Seager's significant contract and extensive injury history. They discuss whether sending prospects like Wells, Rice, and Volpe is too steep, and debate if the Yankees' biggest issue is relying on their underperforming young players or Brian Cashman's "risk-averse" philosophy.

BT and Sal tear into the Yankees' offseason plans, centered on GM Brian Cashman's recent comments about the outfield. The hosts call out Cashman's attempt to temper expectations by suggesting a "worst-case scenario" of relying on prospects Spencer Jones and Jasson Dominguez alongside Trent Grisham as "playing possum." They then debate the merits of the top two outfield free agents, Cody Bellinger and Kyle Tucker, with Sal expressing strong preference for Bellinger's versatility—but only for five or six years, fearing his market will explode to $170 million or more. The segment features BT and Sal's "Money Pit" contract guesses for Bellinger and Pete Alonso, along with a caller pushing for a trade for Bo Bichette. Finally, the show is briefly interrupted by breaking news: Jaxon Dart has not been cleared from concussion protocol, dramatically lowering Tierney's interest in the upcoming Giants game.

BT & Sal dive into the New York Giants' head coaching search, sparked by a caller who demands a total "clean house." The hosts debate whether interim coach Mike Kafka should get a serious shot, or if the Giants need to prioritize an experienced leader. Tierney makes a case for proven coaches like Mike McCarthy (who won games without Dak Prescott) and Sean McDermott, while dismissing younger coordinators like Chris Shula. Sal argues that former Dolphins coach Brian Flores is the best defensive option if they go that route, despite the lawsuit. They fiercely question the logic of passing on an experienced, successful coach like Zac Taylor (Super Bowl run) for an "unknown" coordinator. Finally, the discussion shifts to the team's appealing assets—a young quarterback, Malik Neighbors, and a potential top draft pick—leading to the question: Do the Giants trade their high pick for more capital, or take a top talent?

BT & Sal dive into the hot seat around Giants Offensive Coordinator Mike Kafka, debating whether the team's improved offensive output this season (finally scoring points!) is enough to save his job. While listeners give Kafka credit for the unexpected success with a backup QB and a better run game, the hosts question if he's truly a QB whisperer or merely riding the coattails of a better quarterback situation. The discussion pivots to the looming possibility of a major coaching shake-up, focusing on a polarizing name: Sean McDermott. BT and Sal weigh the pros and cons of hiring the embattled Bills coach—a move that would raise the Giants' "floor" to respectability but might not be a "home run." The segment concludes with a look at the Giants' struggling defense, particularly the poor play from players like Bobby Okereke.

BT & Sal kick off the show by discussing Yankees GM Brian Cashman's annual Covenant House Sleep Out, an amazing charitable commitment to raise awareness for youth homelessness. While giving him immense credit for his decade-plus dedication, Sal wonders if Cashman is secretly dreading the night, comparing it to the physical struggle of Boomer's bike tour. The debate heats up with questions about the logistics of the sleepout: How much security is provided? Does he really sleep all night, or is it a "symbolic" few hours? And what does the GM do when nature calls? Ultimately, the hosts conclude that Cashman's long-standing commitment proves he's a true "scrapper" who doesn't tap out, even on a cold New York night.

BT and Sal dive into Jaxson Dart's return to play following his concussion, focusing on how new play-caller Mike Kafka will manage the young quarterback differently than Brian Daboll. The hosts argue that the remainder of the season is solely about Dart's development and availability, not wins or losses, and that Kafka must prove he can protect the franchise QB by limiting designed runs. They vehemently criticize the "insane" mindset of fans who want to "bubble wrap" Dart for the rest of the season, asserting he needs to play to evolve. The discussion expands to the Giants' overall two-and-nine record, debating whether the team is "devoid of talent" or just poorly coached, with the hosts agreeing that the current record is worse than the roster's actual potential.

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Everyone is upset at the Yankees, Brian Cashman and Trent Grisham for signing the qualifying offer to return for the 2026 season. Hoff explains why this is not a Trent Grisham issue! Follow @HoffWFAN To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT and Sal ignite a fiery debate on the New York baseball offseason, focusing on the nightmare scenario of Pete Alonso in pinstripes and the Mets' hypothetical, high-stakes Tarik Skubal trade proposal (costing four top prospects). Sal unveils his "Grand Slam Blueprint" for the Mets' future, but the hosts slam any executive who thinks Skubal's trade value won't drop due to injury risk—calling the strategy "moronic." The discussion pivots to the Yankees' third-base quandary: Is the safer, defense-first Ryan McMahon a better fit than the superior, aging Alex Bregman? Plus, shockwaves hit as the Yankees' farm system ranks a dismal 25th to the Mets' #1. Finally, they tackle the broader sports world, with BT railing against the "unwatchable" NBA regular season due to rest days, and they argue over the Week 12 NFL Power Rankings, where BT controversially champions his Denver Broncos.

BT and Sal dive into a fiery discussion on the Yankees and Mets' overlapping offseason targets, focusing on how Cody Bellinger and Devin Williams are perfect, must-have fits for both clubs. Sal unveils his four-part, "Grand Slam Blueprint" for the Mets, which includes trading for Tarik Skubal, signing a pitcher like Ranger Suarez, re-signing Pete Alonso, and acquiring one of the big bats (Bellinger, Tucker, or Bregman). They debate the plausibility of the Mets making "massive moves"—including trading Brandon Nimmo and Kodai Senga—with Sal needing to see Stearns act like a big-market GM. The conversation shifts to the broader landscape, where they express outrage over the looming CBA expiration and the possibility of a lockout, arguing that another work stoppage would prove baseball's "greedy pigs" are disconnected from the fans. Finally, the hosts touch on the more glamorous side of the offseason, revealing they are anxiously awaiting the official invitation to A-Rod's Christmas party, with Sal admitting Alex Rodriguez even texted him about the disastrous Trent Grisham deal.

BT & Sal ignite a heated conversation around the baseball offseason and the NBA's failing regular season. They debate the hypothetical nightmare of Pete Alonso landing with the Yankees, discussing whether adding the Polar Bear's power is the "restructuring" the Bombers need (trading Stanton and IKF) or just a power overdose. The discussion pivots to the Tigers' Tarik Skubal, where Sal unleashes a scorching critique of the front office executive who believes Skubal's trade value will be the same at the deadline as it is now. The hosts call the strategy "moronic," citing the massive risk of injury (Cole, Alcantara) and the loss of full-season control. Finally, they tackle the NBA's lack of urgency, with BT slamming the regular season as "largely unwatchable" due to the constant rest days and the compromised competition. They yearn for the competitive spirit of 90s basketball and explore radical solutions (like split seasons) to make the games matter again.

BT and Sal dive deep into a fiery debate over the Yankees' third base decision for 2026: pursue the superior, clutch, but aging Alex Bregman or settle for the defense-first Ryan McMahon, warning against a DJ LeMahieu-like decline. On the Mets side, the discussion ignites over a trade proposal for Cy Young-level pitcher Tarik Skubal, requiring four top prospects (Tong, Sproat, Jett Williams, Mauricio). Sal views losing the prospects without a guaranteed extension as "irresponsible," while BT and Hof argue a generational talent like Skubal is worth the risk. Finally, the hosts battle over their Week 12 NFL Power Rankings, with BT controversially crowning his Denver Broncos as the AFC's best team, even predicting a Broncos vs. 49ers Super Bowl, while Sal struggles to trust the inconsistency of the Eagles and Bills.

BT and Sal kick off the show with the bizarre video of Cam Skattebo performing a "shoey"—drinking an energy drink from a cleat—and his sideline antics. The hosts ignite a debate over a hypothetical Yankees trade for Tarik Skubal, questioning if a package including Spencer Jones and Will Warren is enough to beat the competition, and are shocked that ESPN ranks the Yankees' farm system at a disappointing 25th, compared to the Mets' #1 ranking. The conversation pivots to the international market, where they discuss the race for Japanese stars like Kaz Okamoto and the surprisingly low batting average of Munetaka Murakami against fastballs. A caller then proposes a trade for Fernando Tatis Jr., forcing the hosts to dissect his massive, albatross-like contract. In the Call of the Day, the guys argue over Alex Bregman's declining value against Ryan McMahon's solid defense. The show wraps up with a fun time-machine question: What single historical sporting event would they go back to?

BT & Sal dive into a fiery "Call of the Day" that sparks a huge debate over player acquisitions, specifically whether acquiring Alex Bregman is a mistake, with Sal comparing him to a "declining" DJ LeMahieu due to his age (32) and salary. Tierney challenges the caller's preference for the defense-first Ryan McMahon, forcing an admission that Bregman is clearly the better player. The conversation shifts to a fascinating "Time Machine" question: If you could go back to one sporting event in history, which would it be? Sal picks a sentimental New York baseball pilgrimage to Ebbets Field and the Polo Grounds with his grandfather, while Tierney's highly unusual choice is the amateur golfer Bobby Jones in the 1920s. They also touch on the mind of A-Rod, debating his insecurities and his interview with Katie Couric.

BT & Sal ignite a debate over the latest ESPN farm system rankings, which shockingly place the Mets at #1 and the Yankees dramatically lower at #15 for 2025. They question if the Yankees' lack of development is due to constantly trading prospects for big-name acquisitions or rushing players like Volpe and Dominguez to the majors. The discussion pivots to a caller asking if the Yankees should pursue Fernando Tatis Jr. from the Padres, leading to a breakdown of his $292 million "albatross" contract and past PED issues. Finally, a mixed-race Mets fan calls in with a hot take on culture, arguing the Mets failed to land Japanese stars like Yamamoto because the organization is not "culturally intelligent" enough to make Queens appealing, despite the borough's high Asian population. They debate whether Steve Cohen did enough to honor Asian traditions during the recruiting process.

BT & Sal kick off the segment with a mix of disgust and fascination over football player Cam Skattebo's latest viral stunt: chugging an energy drink from his cleat (a "Shoey"). Then, they dive into a fiery hypothetical: an Athletic-proposed trade for Tigers ace Tarik Skubal involving a Yankees package of Spencer Jones, Will Warren, and two pitching prospects. The hosts debate whether this offer is deliberately undervaluing Skubal compared to the Mets' reported trade pieces, reigniting the argument over the true quality of the Yankees' farm system. The conversation shifts to the upcoming Japanese posting window, with Sal confidently predicting the Mets and Yankees will each land a star, while Tierney is skeptical, fearing the Dodgers will collect everyone. They discuss the worrying scouting report on star hitter Munetaka Murakami and his inability to hit fastballs over 93 MPH. The segment wraps up by venting about high NBA ticket prices and the outrage fans feel when high-priced stars like Giannis sit out.

BT & Sal lay down their fiery NFL Week 12 Power Up Rankings with some huge shakeups and controversial picks. Sal kicks off the debate by putting the Denver Broncos at number five (a team BT has championed for weeks), while BT controversially drops the 9-2 New England Patriots to number two, and excludes the Eagles entirely, despite their 8-2 record, citing a fundamental lack of belief in the champs. The big head-turner is BT's Super Bowl prediction of the Broncos vs. 49ers, as he trusts Denver's defense and Sean Payton's coaching more than the struggling Chiefs. Sal pushes the 49ers into his top five, banking on their health and "soft schedule," while he crowns the Rams as the best team in the NFC. They also briefly touch on the Bills' inconsistency ahead of their Thursday night game and the perplexing nature of the winning-but-flawed Eagles.

BT & Sal ignite a heated argument with Hoff over a hypothetical Mets trade proposal by Jim Bowden, which sends four top prospects (Tong, Sproat, Williams, Mauricio) to Detroit for one year of Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal. BT is "in a heartbeat" for the trade, arguing they must be aggressive to land a frontline ace. Hoff slams it as "irresponsible", insisting they absolutely cannot trade that "butt load of prospects" without a guaranteed contract extension, comparing the high cost to the Yankees' "bunch of nothing" price for Juan Soto. The debate centers on risk: the Mets' willingness to gamble on an extension versus the risk of being "stupid" and losing their best young talent for a one-year rental.

BT & Sal dive into a heated debate over whether the Yankees should stick with Ryan McMahon at third base or pursue free-agent star Alex Bregman. Sal champions the current player, arguing that McMahon's elite defense and lower cost at $16 million outweigh his lack of offense, especially since Bregman (turning 32) is perceived as being "on the decline," drawing parallels to the failed signing of DJ LeMahieu. Tierney fiercely counters, labeling McMahon as a "lower-level player" with "no stick" and demanding the Yankees pursue the unequivocally "better player" in Bregman, regardless of his anticipated 5-6 year contract or age, stating that the priority must be winning a World Series now. The discussion also touches on whether Cody Bellinger's history of success under New York scrutiny makes him a better target for the Mets.

BT & Sal unleash a fiery critique on the Detroit Tigers' front office for considering waiting until the trade deadline to move ace Tarik Skubal. Sal calls the idea "idiotic" and argues Skubal's value will "never be as good as it is right now" due to the high risk of injury (citing Gerrit Cole) and the loss of team control. He demands the exec who floated the idea be fired for being a "moron." The hosts pivot to a bold Mets trade scenario: acquiring elite talent like Gold Glovers Ezequiel Tovar and Brenton Doyle from the Rockies by taking on the catastrophic contract of Kris Bryant (still owed nearly $90 million). BT shuts down the idea after discovering Doyle's alarmingly low on-base percentage, but the debate emphasizes the Mets' need to be "very creative" on the trade front.

BT & Sal launch a fiery critique of the NBA, arguing that the regular season has lost its appeal due to a fundamental lack of urgency. Sal admits that without the Knicks, he'd barely watch, while Tierney slams the non-stop discussion of "maintenance days" and "back-to-backs," arguing that when teams and coaches fail to prioritize winning every game, fans stop caring. They debate the aesthetic of the modern three-point heavy offense versus the competitive grit of the 90s Knicks, with Sal giving the league credit for at least trying to solve the problem with the in-season tournament—even if it's a "gimmick" the Lakers are hanging banners for. The segment concludes with Tierney pointing out that the league is flooded with "raw" and "unfinished" rookies who lack the polish needed to maintain high-quality play over an 82-game schedule.

BT & Sal dive into a hypothetical (but fiery!) discussion about Pete Alonso wearing a Yankees uniform. While acknowledging reports that the Yankees have no interest in the Polar Bear, Sal argues that a move for Alonso would be a smart piece of a necessary "restructuring" for the Yankees—specifically, by trading Giancarlo Stanton and replacing his power and DH slot with an everyday first baseman and DH option in Pete. The conversation gets personal as they debate the emotional fallout for Mets fans if their franchise slugger jumped to the hated Yankees. Sal asserts that his hatred for the Yankees would "usurp" any affection for Pete, but Hoff and Sal debate where Mets fans would draw the line. The segment also touches on the frustrating lack of development and hype surrounding Yankees prospects like Jasson Dominguez and Mets prospect Carson Benge.

BT reveals a bombshell: he and Sal were alerted by A-Rod's cousin that they might be getting an invite to Alex Rodriguez's highly anticipated Christmas party! The hosts dive into the anxiety of waiting for the official email, with BT constantly refreshing his inbox and Sal questioning if it landed in spam. They hilariously speculate on the A-list (and maybe B-list) guests who will be attending, including potential appearances by David Ortiz ("Big Papi"). The segment underscores the power dynamic of the elusive celebrity invite—and the dilemma of balancing an A-Rod bash with a wife's birthday party.

BT and Sal unleash a fiery debate over Sal's "home run blueprint" for the Mets' perfect offseason, which centers on trading for ace Tarik Skubal, signing a frontline starter like Ranger Suarez (while Sal dismisses Dylan Cease as "just another dude"), and re-signing Pete Alonso—especially since he's open to DH. The discussion heats up as they clash over the realism of acquiring Skubal and the $400 million contract that would follow. Sal pushes for a big bat like Bellinger, Tucker, or Bregman to complete the lineup, leading to a controversial take: is trading Nimmo the better long-term move if it means keeping a DH-capable Alonso and improving the overall team defense? The stakes are high for David Stearns and Steve Cohen to execute a massive overhaul.

BT & Sal dive into a fiery debate over the Yankees and Mets' intertwined offseason, focusing on a direct clash for Cody Bellinger and the closer market (Edwin Diaz vs. Devin Williams). Sal argues the Mets must pursue Bellinger and go "pedal to the metal," while BT has more faith in Brian Cashman's urgency than David Stearns' willingness to spend like a big-market GM. The Mets' need for a "shake up" dominates the conversation, with discussion of trading Senga (despite the desperate need for pitching) and moving core players like McNeil, Nimmo, Baty, and Vientos—the guys Sal is "tired of waiting on." The segment concludes with BT teasing his "Grand Slam Mets Offseason" plan, a four-component blueprint he believes would make the Mets World Series contenders.

BT & Sal unleash a torrent of fury over Trent Grisham's shocking acceptance of the $22 million Qualifying Offer (QO), arguing it's the "first potential domino to a horrendous offseason" that kills the Yankees' chances at big targets like Cody Bellinger. Sal pushes for a bold trade for Steven Kwan, while BT fears Cashman will use the QO as an excuse to "roll back" the same failed 2025 roster. The heat continues with Three Random Questions, including a Giants legend showdown: Phil Simms vs. Boomer Esiason in a one-game Super Bowl, a gross debate on gum seats at MSG vs. public humiliation, and whether they could survive prison with a phone. Plus, Giants star Cam Skattebo is put under the microscope for clapping back at critics after his WWE ringside scuffle, and the hosts reveal their fiery early leans for NFL Week 12 Parlay Perfection.

BT and Sal unleash a fiery critique of the Yankees' front office after Trent Grisham shocked the industry by accepting the Qualifying Offer (QO) for $22 million, a move both hosts agree was a colossal misread by the team driven by the lure of a compensatory draft pick. BT argues the QO acceptance is the "first potential domino to a horrendous offseason," fearing the added salary and player complexity will make the Yankees reluctant to pursue top targets like Cody Bellinger and Kyle Tucker. Sal pushes back, insisting the Yankees can (and must) absorb the cost and still be aggressive, specifically needing to trade prospects like Dominguez or Jones for an elite piece like Steven Kwan to truly improve. The hosts also break down the financial impact and player fit, with the conversation focusing on the Yankees' urgent need for a right-handed bat (like Alex Bregman) and the danger of running back the same "not-a-championship-team" roster. Ultimately, they agree that if the QO prevents the necessary aggressive moves, it signals a failure to adapt as Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole's competitive window shrinks.

BT & Sal kick off a fiery debate on their Three Random Questions segment after having Giants legend Phil Simms on the show. The first question puts Simms head-to-head with Boomer Esiason in a one-game Super Bowl showdown, forcing the hosts to weigh Esiason's talent and MVP versus Simms' clutch performances and championship pedigree. Next, Sal recounts his recent disaster at MSG—sitting in gum—and asks which is worse: the sticky embarrassment or having a homeless person throw water in your face? The segment concludes with a question on survival: Could you survive a prison sentence if you were allowed to have your phone with you at all times? Tierney admits he'd crumble, while Sal argues the phone, and modern prison realities (like TikTok and streaming), might make the mental challenge bearable.

BT and Sal unleash a fiery critique of the Yankees' off-season strategy, arguing that Trent Grisham's acceptance of the $22 million qualifying offer is the first "domino that dooms" their plan to "roll back" the same deficient roster. Sal fears Cashman will use Gerrit Cole's return as an excuse not to make necessary, aggressive moves for players like Kwan or Tucker, while callers slam the GM for hoarding "penny stocks" prospects like Spencer Jones and Dominguez. They argue that the young core has failed to develop and the team needs an "all-in" structural overhaul. The conversation shifts to the Giants, where a caller demands that Joe Schoen must go immediately following the team's embarrassing season. BT and Sal push back on the timing, arguing that the season is lost and the organization's focus must remain on the sensitive health issues of ownership, suggesting that while Schoen should be next to go, the action will and should wait until the end of the year.

BT and Sal dive into the fiery reaction from Giants star Cam Skattebo, who clapped back at critics for judging his WWE attendance while injured. They debate the issue of professional decorum, weighing Cam's star power against the lack of self-awareness shown by fellow Giant Abdul Carter. The conversation shifts to the NFL Week 12 slate, where the hosts discuss "Parlay Perfection" strategy, revealing their early leans on the Chiefs-Colts and Cowboys-Eagles games as the pressure mounts on BT to close the gap on Hoff. Finally, they tackle the "Call of the Day" and several callers who pile on Brian Cashman, slamming the Yankees' "stale" vision, bad signings, and failed player development.

BT and Sal dive into an explosive "Call of the Day" where a fiery Yankees fan, Mike from Manalapan, torches Brian Cashman for his failure to develop position players, comparing his tight grip on prospects to holding onto a failing "Bitcoin." The caller demands the Yankees "package them all" and trade prospects like Spencer Jones and Jasson Dominguez for a top-tier player. The hosts then take a call from a Mets fan who defends the Yankees' consistent success, arguing that making the playoffs "almost every year" isn't "stale." Sal and BT push back, asserting that the Yankees' standard must be higher than mere playoff contention, and the fan frustration stems from the consistent, championship-less repeat of the same failures, worsened by recent moves like the Trent Grisham qualifying offer.

BT and Sal react with praise to Aaron Glenn's latest press conference, where he officially names Tyrod Taylor the starting QB with a defiant "Because I wanted to!" They applaud Glenn's shift in demeanor—less defensive and more directly in charge—which they believe is a template for the "New Jets DNA." The hosts speculate that the decision was likely forced by a leak from one of the quarterbacks or their agents. The conversation then turns fiery, with Sal highlighting the stunning financial mistake made by the front office: a massive $57 million allocated to Aaron Rodgers and potentially cut quarterback Justin Fields next year, calling it a major blunder by the GM.

The Yankees offseason is off to a fiery start as Trent Grisham accepts the $22 million Qualifying Offer, a move Sal Licata sees as the "domino" leading to a disastrous offseason. Sal fears the Yankees are "banking on rolling this back" with a largely unchanged roster, relying solely on Gerrit Cole's return and growth from underperforming young players like Volpe and Dominguez. BT & Sal debate whether the $22 million for a defensive specialist who had an outlier offensive year will "dissuade" the Yankees from going "all in" on high-impact upgrades like Cody Bellinger or Steven Kwan. Callers join the fray, calling Cashman out for getting "caught with his pants down" and questioning the Yankees' continued reliance on unproven prospects rather than making aggressive moves to finally win a World Series.

BT & Sal go head-to-head in Three Random Questions, starting with a fiery debate: In a one-game Super Bowl, who are you picking: Phil Simms or Boomer Esiason? Tierney gives a slight edge to Simms' clutch ability and team history, while Sal argues Boomer was the more talented player and a former MVP. What's worse: sitting in gum at MSG (like Sal did) or a homeless person throwing water in your face (like Sal's friend experienced)? Sal details the public humiliation of the gum disaster, but Tierney insists the potential danger and unsanitary nature of the water attack is far worse. Could you survive a prison sentence if you were allowed to have your phone with you at all times? Sal believes his phone could conquer the mental challenge of boredom and solitude, but Tierney delivers a harsh reality check, arguing survival is about more than just entertainment, dismissing the idea that the threat of violence is outdated, despite co-host comments about "uplifting" TikTok prison streams.

Giants legend and Super Bowl MVP Phil Simms joins BT & Sal for a fiery, in-depth NFL discussion. Simms slams the Giants' "biggest disappointment"—the defensive failure—and calls out the coaching for not being "aggressive" enough. He weighs in on the extensive head coach search, arguing that analytics have made NFL game management "stupid," and reveals what former coach Bill Parcells taught him about chasing points. Simms also tackles the Giants' "leaderless" atmosphere, the controversy surrounding Jaxson Dart's running and Cam Scott's wrestling appearance, and the "sad" state of the Giants' home-field advantage. Finally, he breaks down the top college quarterback prospects the Jets might target, including Fernando Mendoza and Ty Simpson, offering a strong take on why Mac Jones was the 49ers' true target over Trey Lance.

BT & Sal are demanding that the Yankees finally go on a "big offseason" spending spree and become aggressive in their pursuit of a championship. They debate the necessity of re-signing Cody Bellinger (arguing that losing him makes the team worse) and whether the team has the "appetite" for a massive, multi-year contract for a star like Alex Bregman (predicted to cost about $173M). The hosts also slam the organization for its glut of positional players (DHs, limited defenders) and insist that to make room for necessary additions, Cashman "has to trade" at least one young, high-potential player like Jasson Dominguez or Spencer Jones. They conclude that with the clocks ticking on Judge and Cole, the Yankees can no longer afford to be held back by smaller contracts or cheap team-building strategies.

BT & Sal go head-to-head on the stunning news of Trent Grisham accepting the $22 million qualifying offer (QO), a move most experts (and the Yankees' front office) reportedly didn't see coming. Sal is convinced this is an "F" for Brian Cashman, arguing that Grisham is an "October liability" who strikes out too much and whose defensive decline is a major issue, especially against quality pitching. Tierney, however, views the reaction as an overreaction, arguing that the one-year deal is manageable and provides insurance, essentially confirming that a frequently injured player like Stanton will be forced to DH. The duo debates whether Grisham's decision was "foolish" for his own long-term business and if the Yankees can really afford to keep him off the field in the postseason.

BT and Sal unleash a fiery discussion about Trent Grisham's decision to accept the qualifying offer ($22 million), with BT calling it a "colossal mistake" by the Yankees' front office, who seemingly misread his willingness to take the one-year deal. BT views the move as the "first potential domino to a horrendous offseason," arguing the allure of a compensatory pick blindsided them. Sal, however, believes Grisham is still a valuable commodity who can be used as a high-end fourth outfielder or trade bait (after the June 15 deadline), and that the $22 million shouldn't stop the Yankees from landing Cody Bellinger or trading for Steven Kwan. The hosts debate the impact on the roster, specifically how Grisham's presence complicates the paths for young prospects Jason Dominguez and Spencer Jones and exacerbates the Yankees' already dangerous left-handed hitting compromise. BT's main fear remains that this move encourages the Yankees to "run it back" with a team that failed to win, banking too heavily on a different outcome.

BT & Sal tear into the New York Giants' toxic culture after injured RB Cam Skattebo (on a scooter!) and reprimanded rookie Abdul Carter got physical in a WWE Monday Night Raw segment. They slam the team's "lawless" behavior and lack of self-awareness. The action shifts to MLB Free Agency with a bombshell report: an industry source says a Pete Alonso return is "very unlikely," predicting the Mets' lowball offer will send him to the "stupid team" (Angels). Furthermore, a new report confirms the Mets are ready to "blow up" the roster, making stars like Nimmo and Senga available for trade. The "Bald-Faced Lie, Bald-Faced Truth" segment debates everything from AI-built Mets rosters to Jonathan Quick's justifiable hockey violence. NFL Insider Brian Baldinger joins to pile on the Giants' dysfunction, and finally, wrestling legend Natalya Neidhart shares raw, powerful stories from her new book, The Last Hart Beating, about her father's CTE, family homelessness, and fighting for a spot in WWE.

BT & Sal tear into the New York Giants' embarrassing appearance at WWE Monday Night Raw, where injured star Cam Skattebo (on a scooter with a surgically repaired ankle) and troubled rookie Abdul Carter got involved in a physical, scripted confrontation. The hosts question the optics of Skattebo taking an unnecessary risk by getting shoved, potentially jeopardizing his recovery timeline. The conversation quickly pivots to Abdul Carter, who was just reprimanded for falling asleep during a walkthrough, yet was front and center for the WWE event. The hosts argue that Carter's involvement, coupled with him holding up a championship belt, highlights his lack of awareness and a toxic, "lawless" Giants culture. The incident was made worse when a wrestler, Dom Mysterio, was heard mocking the Giants, asking if they were finally going to "play defense."

BT & Sal dive deep into the MLB free agency landscape, using a Gemini-AI generated cliff notes version of a lengthy Jeff Passan article to hit the main points. They discuss the Mets' apparent willingness to trade almost anyone (Nimmo, McNeil, Senga, etc.) and the Yankees' dilemma over Trent Grisham's qualifying offer, with Sal arguing the move complicates the future of prospects like Dominguez. The "Bald-Faced Lie, Bald-Faced Truth" segment heats up with: The Mets Roster & AI: Will David Stearns use AI to build the team? (BT says Lie, Sal says Truth on its use). The Quick Attack: Did Jonathan Quick have the right to attack Mason Appleton for shooting the puck after the horn? (They both say Truth, respecting the unwritten rule). Nets Stink: Will the Nets win less than 10 games? (Sal says Truth, showing his disdain for the team). Finally, an industry source drops a bombshell, suggesting it's "very unlikely" Pete Alonso returns to the Mets, with the Angels being eyed as the "stupid team to overpay." The conversation concludes with a bizarre debate about the lack of urinal dividers at Citi Field and MetLife.

BT & Sal ignite the debate over Pete Alonso's future with the Mets, reacting fiercely to an industry rumor suggesting the team's max offer might be a "disrespectful" two-plus-one-year deal. They question whether owner Steve Cohen will intercede to secure the fan-favorite slugger and explore a major report that the Mets are ready to "blow up" the roster, making established players like Nimmo and McNeil available for trade. NFL Insider Brian Baldinger joins the show to unleash on the Giants' dysfunction. Baldy calls out injured running back Cam Skattebo's bizarre appearance and physical involvement at Monday Night Raw and slams rookie Abdul Carter's repeated unexcused absences, highlighting the team's critical lack of veteran leadership. Baldy also breaks down the AFC power rankings (leaning toward Baltimore) and praises the Jets' decision to play Tyrod Taylor to assess their young receiving talent.

BT & Sal sit down with wrestling royalty Natalya Neidhart to discuss her powerful new book, The Last Heart Beating. Nattie drops truth bombs on her complicated life, revealing the volatility of growing up with her father, Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart, who suffered from an undiagnosed traumatic brain injury (CTE), and the experience of her family being homeless despite his stardom. Nattie explains the "scratch and claw" fight to enter the WWE without family help, including the demand to lose 30 pounds just to get hired, and how she used her rough upbringing to fuel her drive. The conversation covers her journey to unconditional forgiveness for her father, the therapeutic experience of writing the book, and the incredible support she's received from legends like John Cena (who "bawled his eyes out" reading it) and Bret Hart. Finally, she hints at a fiery new character she's developing and throws down a challenge to current champion Rhea Ripley!

BT & Sal put producer Hoff in the hot seat for a fiery round of "Bald Faced Lie, Bald Faced Truth!" The trio debates three scorching hot takes: Whether David Stearns will use a baseball version of AI to construct the 2026 Mets roster. If Rangers goalie Jonathan Quick was justified in attacking Mason Appleton for shooting the puck after the final horn, a move Quick viewed as disrespectful to hockey's "unwritten rules." The shocking bet that the Nets will win less than ten games—a take Tierney is quick to endorse due to his deep disinterest in the team. The segment also features a major Pete Alonso update from an industry source, who claims a return to the Mets is "very unlikely," given Stearns' low-ball max offer of a "two plus one at around thirty" million dollars, and speculation that the Angels will be the "stupid team" to overpay for the slugger. Finally, Sal celebrates a win after his complaints earned him an invite to Alex Rodriguez's exclusive Christmas party!

NFL Insider Brian Baldinger joins BT & Sal for a fiery Week 12 breakdown, immediately ripping Giants rookie Cam Skattebo for his bizarre WWE appearance while nursing a fractured ankle, calling the optics "bizarre" and "unprofessional." The conversation shifts to the Giants' deeper issues, with Baldy agreeing that the team has "no internal veteran leadership" to guide young players like Abdul Carter, whose repeated tardiness to meetings was "unacceptable" and made Coach Daboll look worse. Baldy breaks down the tape, exonerating Jameis Winston on the game-ending interception and slams Jalen Hyatt's execution. He offers a shocking take on the Giants' much-maligned offensive line, calling them "middle of the pack" and "playoff worthy." On the AFC, Baldy weighs in on the contenders, calling the Baltimore Ravens a "problem" and the Buffalo Bills "a mess" defensively. Finally, he supports the Jets' move to Tyrod Taylor to gather crucial information on their young, unproven receivers like Adonai Mitchell and Mason Taylor.

BT & Sal dive into the shocking report from Jeff Passan that the Mets are "blowing up plenty" of their roster, potentially making Nimmo, McNeil, and Senga available for trade. The fiery discussion focuses heavily on Pete Alonso's future, as an industry source suggests the Mets' maximum offer is a "disrespectful" 2+1 deal at around $30 million per year. Sal argues that while Alonso deserves more than the recently signed Naylor, the Mets must resist paying $30M/year over six seasons. They debate whether Steve Cohen will override GM David Stearns to keep the fan favorite. The show also touches on potential additions like Alex Bregman and Kyle Tucker and starts with a quick rant about the Giants' lack of accountability after Abdul Carter's discipline issues and the team's ongoing "sloppiness."

BT & Sal dive into a surprisingly fiery topic: the lack of urinal dividers at Citi Field and other stadiums like MetLife. Sal questions the big deal, claiming he doesn't care who's next to him, but the consensus from BT, Hof, and a caller is a firm "divider up!" BT argues he needs privacy and would prefer Steve Cohen spend money on team improvements over bathroom renovations, though he admits the undivided trough-like setup is a problem. The conversation takes a strange turn when BT recounts a traumatizing experience standing next to Dennis Rodman in a Vegas restroom. The segment concludes with a chaotic recap of Hof's trip to the arena, involving a bloody nose and BT sitting on a piece of gum!

BT & Sal dive into Jeff Passan's comprehensive MLB offseason preview, discussing the hot rumors and high-stakes free agency decisions facing the New York clubs. For the Mets, the news is dominated by David Stearns's radical overhaul, with star players like Nimmo, McNeil, and Senga all deemed "extremely available." The hosts are energized by the possibility of the Mets pursuing a powerhouse bullpen, pairing Devin Williams with Edwin Diaz, while Sal remains convinced Pete Alonso will ultimately stay, despite the Red Sox's heavy interest in both Pete and Alex Bregman. For the Yankees, the big question is whether Trent Grisham will accept the Qualifying Offer, which BT hopes he rejects to avoid "complicating the future." The two clash over the handling of Jasson Dominguez, with BT arguing the Yankees need to get an answer on their young players at the Major League level, while Sal believes the Martian needs more time in the minors to fully develop and find a position. The segment also notes that both the Mets and Yankees are currently in the mix for star outfielder Kyle Tucker.

BT & Sal are furious about Giants rookie Abdul Carter's repeated lack of commitment and poor judgment, sparked by a caller's outrage over Carter's appearance on Monday Night Raw. They slam the linebacker for his "disgusting" decision to participate in a wrestling skit and hold a championship belt while the Giants sit at 2-9—calling it a total lack of self-awareness. The hosts highlight Carter's history of "bad optics," including missing a walkthrough, reportedly falling asleep, being disciplined with limited snaps, and his brazen request for Lawrence Taylor's #56. The biggest concern, however, is the Giants' culture: the hosts question why no veteran leader has stepped up to "check" the young player and demand he take his job seriously.

BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate over the New York Giants' embarrassing appearance at WWE Raw, where wrestlers publicly trolled the defense for its abysmal performance. The hosts clash over the sight of injured star Cam (Cam Jansen, based on context) getting physically involved in a scrum, with Tierney arguing it shows a "lawless environment" and is the final straw for the regime. Sal, however, suggests Cam just misses "physicality" and that the whole stunt is a win for WWE's brand while adding to the Giants' humiliation. They also question the judgment of Abdul Carter for being there after being reprimanded and wearing a championship belt as a two-win team.

BT & Sal torch Giants players Cam Skattebo (injured) and Abdul Carter (amid team controversy) for their physical involvement in a scripted altercation at WWE's Monday Night Raw. The hosts argue the optics are terrible for a 2-9 team, with fans already feeling an "embarrassment." They slam Skattebo for taking an unnecessary risk by getting pushed, given his severe ankle injury, with Sal calling it "dangerous" and questioning the running back's judgment. Carter, fresh off controversy for sleeping through a team walkthrough, is also criticized for his lack of awareness and showing up for the spectacle. The segment highlights the incident as another sign of the Giants' "sloppiness" and their deteriorating team culture.

The best reactions to the Giants' Week 11 loss to Green Bay from Boomer & Gio, BT & Sal, and Evan & TIki

BT & Sal go nuclear on the Giants' catastrophic season, arguing that the latest loss is proof that Joe Schoen must be fired for building a "talent-free" roster, regardless of the coaching situation. They demand the organization "bleed out" and embrace a complete organizational reset. The hosts unload on the Giants' broken culture, ripping into Mike Kafka for his "soft" punishment of rookie Abdul Carter, who was benched for repeatedly sleeping/missing meetings—a trend that started under Brian Daboll. The chaos extends to other sports: they debate whether Josh Naylor's deal sets a $180M floor for Pete Alonso, which Sal argues the Mets shouldn't pay. Plus, they react to Justin Fields' benching in favor of Tyrod Taylor and blast Jalin Hyatt for a crucial route error in the latest loss. Finally, they cover Bo Nickal's knockout win and John Cena's last MSG fight.

BT and Sal dive into the post-Daboll Giants chaos, arguing that the latest loss proves the problem lies with the "talent-free" roster built by Joe Shane, not just the head coach. They stress that the Giants must "bleed out" and keep losing to ensure a complete organizational reset, including firing Shane before he hires another coach and perpetuates the "cycle of sloppiness." Sal demands the "awful" Shane Bowen be fired immediately for the defense's constant fourth-quarter collapses, while BT is intrigued by Mike Kafka's accountability measures despite advocating for an outside hire. The segment concludes with a fiery breakdown of Bo Nickal's knockout win, celebrating his dominance and unexpected "villain" energy, which silenced the critics who deemed him overrated.

BT and Sal unleash a fiery response to the news that Giants rookie Abdul Carter was benched for one series because he missed a walkthrough while asleep in the team facility. Further reporting reveals that Brian Daboll had previously allowed Carter's trend of being late to meetings to "slide." The hosts slam the incident as an "appalling" sign of the Giants' broken culture and a lack of accountability from both the former head coach and current interim Mike Kafka, whose mild punishment is deemed insufficient. They argue that the veteran leadership, including Dexter Lawrence, is also failing to check the young player. The discussion begins with a debate over whether the Giants have been reckless with rookie QB Jaxson Dart, concluding that his rushing has been "necessary" given the team's deficiencies, but must be refined going forward. The segment closes by drawing a line from the Giants' current woes back to the neutering of Tom Coughlin's authority to placate Odell Beckham Jr., arguing the organization has prioritized talent over foundation and discipline for years.

BT & Sal are incensed by the latest reports on Giants rookie Abdul Carter, who was benched for a drive due to repeatedly sleeping/missing meetings and a walkthrough. They slam the lack of accountability that started under former head coach Brian Daboll and criticize Carter's flimsy social media defense that he was "recovering." Sal argues that Mike Kafka's light punishment (a drive on special teams) was too weak and a failure to establish necessary control over a locker room "littered with losers." The conversation shifts to the Jets, reacting to the breaking news that Tyrod Taylor will start at quarterback over Justin Fields. BT and Sal express zero expectations for the move but agree it's necessary to evaluate the vertical threats like rookie TE Mason Taylor. The segment also covers potential Giants head coaching candidates, with BT backing Brian Flores as the necessary disciplinarian and Sal supporting Mike McCarthy. Finally, they debate the dramatic possibility of trading Dexter Lawrence to shake up the spiraling organization.

BT & Sal ignite the debate over Mets slugger Pete Alonso after Josh Naylor's reported five-year deal with the Mariners, with Sal arguing the move sets a high floor for Pete's contract—likely six years for $180M—which Sal thinks the Mets shouldn't pay due to Pete's limited utility outside of power. They debate if Naylor's versatility makes him a better player than Pete for team building. The discussion shifts to the Giants' embarrassing two-and-nine season: BT rips into the notion that the team is "competitive," and Sal criticizes Jalin Hyatt for slowing down on his route to seal the loss against the Packers. They also blast the lack of accountability surrounding Abdul Carter's repeated tardiness. Finally, they briefly touch on John Cena's last match at MSG and the disgusting on-field conduct of Jamar Chase. The segment ends with Sal screaming down a caller who suggests Paul Goldschmidt as a replacement for Alonso.

BT & Sal go head-to-head on the major implications of Josh Naylor's reported five-year extension with the Mariners, arguing it has immediately set a floor for Pete Alonso's free-agent negotiations. BT argues Naylor's deal is a "good night for Pete," suggesting Alonso will now command a minimum of five years at a massive salary. However, BT insists the Mets should not sign him for six years, arguing Naylor offers a more well-rounded skill set (higher contact, better defense, better on the bases) compared to Pete's pure power. Sal fires back, calling Naylor a "poor man's Pete Alonso" and a "moneyball guy" who isn't needed in New York. He maintains that Alonso's proven power and clutch performance in the New York market are irreplaceable and that the Mets must re-sign him to maintain the team's core, especially behind Juan Soto. The conversation heats up as they debate whether David Stearns is overthinking the situation and what moves the Mets must make if they let Pete walk, with Cody Bellinger being the only acceptable replacement.

BT & Sal kick off the show with breaking news that the Jets are benching Justin Fields for veteran Tyrod Taylor in Week 12. Sal concedes it's the right move, not for wins, but to finally see what the Jets' young players can do with a "vertical passing threat," even if his overall expectations are "zero." This leads into a heated discussion on the Giants' spiraling lack of accountability, focusing on the shocking report that Abdul Carter was repeatedly sleeping in team meetings and walkthroughs. The hosts debate whether interim head coach Mike Kafka's light punishment (benching Carter for one drive) was too "weak" or a "gentler way" to discipline a Gen Z star, then pivot to the Giants' inevitable head coach search, with Sal stumping for Mike McCarthy and BT doubling down on the no-nonsense approach of Brian Flores.

BT and Sal unleash a fiery Week 11 recap, starting with seething frustration over the "atrocious" and "phantom" pass interference call that effectively ended the Lions-Eagles Sunday Night Football game. The main event is the Chiefs' collapse to 5-5, with BT reluctantly acknowledging the crisis while Sal bets against Kansas City making the playoffs entirely! They dive deep into the AFC Playoff Picture, discussing how the surging Broncos and Chargers have pushed the Chiefs to the brink and analyzing the chances for other contenders like the Ravens, Colts, and Jaguars to grab a Wild Card spot. It's an unfiltered look at the NFL's current chaos, from bad calls to dynastic downfall.

BT & Sal are furious after new reporting reveals Giants rookie Abdul Carter has been consistently late, missed a walkthrough, and was found asleep in the facility, exposing a deep-seated lack of discipline in the organization. Sal savages interim head coach Mike Kafka for his weak response—only benching Carter for six plays—calling it a "two-foot putt" that Kafka three-putted, and removing him from future head coaching consideration. The hosts argue the blame extends beyond Carter, citing Daboll's failure to establish a culture and the lack of veteran leadership to hold the rookie accountable. Tierney draws a damning line from the placating of Odell Beckham Jr. under Tom Coughlin to the current culture crisis, declaring the Giants need a "big boy with stones" to fix the mess.

BT and Sal explode over a damning report that Giants rookie Abdul Carter missed a crucial walk-through because he was asleep inside the team facility. The hosts savage the lack of accountability, with Sal stating that being benched for only six plays was "not enough punishment." The discussion quickly turns to the larger cultural rot within the Giants, with a follow-up report revealing that missing meetings has been a "trend" that former coach Brian Daboll "let slide." BT and Sal rip Daboll for his inexcusable soft approach and lambast the veteran leadership for their lack of concern, declaring that the Giants' core "needs to be rattled" because the team has become a "joke" and a "circus."

BT & Sal dive into the ferocious Bo Nickal knockout, which Tierney watched live, calling him "badass." The hosts discuss Nickal's double-bird salute to the booing Madison Square Garden crowd, debating if he has now embraced a "villain" persona to defend himself against "overrated" chants. The conversation covers Nickal's clear-cut confidence, the shock expressed by Nickal's mother about his killer instinct, and the Beat and Sal Mojo that seems to follow the fighter. This segment is juxtaposed with the Giants' "awful look," as the hosts demand immediate firings for defensive coordinator Shane Bowen—who continues to survive despite four fourth-quarter collapses—and criticize the lack of accountability and the dysfunctional "family dynamic" in the Giants' front office.

BT & Sal unleash a fiery argument for a complete organizational clean house following the Giants' continued losing. While they credit interim head coach Mike Kafka for showing "guts" by holding a star player accountable, they argue that retaining GM Joe Shane and promoting Kafka would result in a "stale" regime. The hosts fear that allowing Shane, whose roster-building track record is criticized (e.g., Evan Neal, Daniel Jones handling), to hire another head coach would only compound the team's long-term ineptitude. They stress that a "clean break" is the only way for the Giants to find new juice and finally achieve a successful rebuild.

BT & Sal erupt over another predictable Giants loss, arguing that the team's continued struggles after firing Brian Daboll definitively proves the problem lies with the "undermanned, under-talented" roster built by General Manager Joe Schoen. Tierney argues that more losses are a good thing as they should force Mr. Mara's hand to end Schoen's "colossal fail" of a tenure and allow for a clean-slate fresh start. Sal doubles down, asserting that a "lame duck GM" cannot be trusted to hire the next head coach, which would only lead to a perpetual "cycle of sloppiness" in the front office. They discuss the defensive coordinator's job security and call for a total organizational teardown to prevent a fifth consecutive losing season.

Listen to the best interviews from the week on WFAN, including Marlon Wayans, Jay Leno, Brian Baldinger, Connor Hughes, Joe Benigno and Nick Bickall.

Brandon Tierney and Sal Licata wonder if anyone in the Giants front office deserves the benefit of the doubt. Plus, BT & Sal discuss if Joe Schoen is really on the hot seat or not; Evan & Tiki wonder if the Giants head coaching job is attractive with Schoen still around; they also discuss an Adam Schefter report on the next possible Giants coach; Boomer & Gio riff on the idea of Bill Belichick coaching the Giants and react to Jameis Winston being named the starter vs. the Packers.

This week's Mets highlights include reaction to David Stearns speaking at the GM Meetings in Las Vegas. BT and Sal want Stearns to be aggressive in resolving the Pete Alonso situation to move on to other roster needs, and they debate if Brandon Nimmo can be traded to free up payroll. Plus, Boomer and Gio react to the wild story of Steve Cohen auctioning off a golden toilet, and the Evan and Tiki crew play MLB free agency bingo.

This week's Yankees highlights include reactions to the bombshell report that Paul Skenes told a Pirates teammate that he wants to join the Yankees. BT and Sal agree that the Yanks should trade the farm for the Cy Young winner, while Chris McMonigle throws cold water on the report. Plus, multiple hosts agree that the Bombers cannot afford to lose Cody Bellinger this offseason.

Hear the best reactions on the Jets’ Week 11 loss to the Patriots from Boomer & Gio, Brandon Tierney and Sal Licata, and Evan & Tiki.

BT & Sal dive into a fiery "Call of the Day" with Ray from Babylon, who slams the Jets' "dummy mistakes" in their latest loss, pointing specifically to drops, bone-headed personal fouls, and a crucial dropped interception. The segment pivots when Mary from Long Island calls in, completely "blown away" by Sal's "Words of Wisdom" on the importance of "opportunity," prompting Sal to reveal the principle was a key lesson learned from Mike Francesa. The conversation wraps with James from Massapequa railing against the Jets' "gift of desperation" fan base and the hosts debating the sustainability of young star quarterbacks Drake Maye and Jayden Daniels. The guys argue that Maye's style is more durable, while also questioning the quickness of the MVP hype surrounding Maye and the volatility of draft day quarterback evaluations.

With Hoff holding a commanding lead in the Perfect Parlay Picks contest, Sal (90 points) and BT (50 points) declare a "Hail Mary" strategy, throwing out the conservative picks to go all-in on four-team parlays for Week 11. BT, embracing the "go route," backs hot teams like the Chargers (-2.5) and Ravens (-7.5), while also taking the Bears (+2.5). Sal, down by a few touchdowns, unleashes his own four-team bomb, predicting big Bills (-5.5) and 49ers (-2.5) wins, alongside bold underdog picks for the Lions (+2.5) on Sunday Night Football and his Broncos (+3.5) over the Chiefs! The segment concludes with a debate over whether Hoff, the current leader, is being "sloppy" by not taking a more conservative approach.

BT and Sal bring in sports betting insider Nick Kostos to break down Week 11's slate and deliver some scorching hot takes. The conversation focuses heavily on the Patriots' confusing trajectory after their win, with Kostos arguing the AFC is wide open for New England, but the Chiefs are the only team capable of beating them at home. The talk turns to the miserable Giants, where Kostos repeatedly blasts the "terrible" roster and Giants fans who defend GM Joe Shane, asserting that Shane is making an "unbelievable mistake" and should be fired. He predicts a Packers squash the Giants on Sunday. Finally, they touch on the QB market for the Jets, debating whether Mac Jones is a viable "Band-Aid" and if Kyler Murray's issues in Arizona are purely stylistic, concluding with a look at the NFC's best, where Kostos still favors the Eagles over teams like the Lions and Seahawks.

BT & Sal launch a fiery debate over David Stearns' approach to free agency, specifically the looming decisions on Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz. Sal argues for a hardline, decisive approach—a "take it or leave it" offer to stop being held up by prolonged negotiations, as he believes the Mets are operating in a frustrating "gray area" by saying they want the players but waiting for the market. BT counters that the Mets need to respect the free agency process and the optics of a harsh negotiation. The hosts agree that the Mets' willingness to go all-in for Soto or Yamamoto is a clear contrast to their patient, cost-conscious stance with their own stars, which suggests they don't want Alonso back "like that." The discussion concludes with a shared frustration over agent Scott Boras's tactics and the potential for these negotiations to drag out until February.

BT, the self-proclaimed "weather snob," kicks off a fiery discussion on New York's rapidly changing climate, arguing that seasonal patterns are "getting pushed back," with October now feeling like May. He recounts a recent hail storm and questions why Halloween is no longer the freezing spectacle of their childhood. The hosts debate the lesser of two evils: attending a game in a "consistent stream" of 70-degree rain versus a "twenty and wind" deep-freeze, with Tierney admitting MetLife Stadium below 40 degrees is completely unappealing. They conclude the segment by arguing which is worse for a round of golf: rain or wind.

BT & Sal are not excited for the Giants' matchup against the Packers, viewing it as a meaningless game where winning could actually hurt the team's draft position. They analyze Mike Kafka's elevation to interim head coach, questioning if the organization is setting him up for a "Ben McAdoo" like hire and whether a clean-house approach should exclude everyone from the previous regime. The hosts also dive into the disappointing lack of effort and impact from defensive star Abdul Carter, arguing that his talent is being wasted and his performance doesn't live up to the hype he created by requesting Lawrence Taylor's number. Finally, they debate the "intrigue" of watching Jameis Winston start over Russell Wilson and the lack of a clear foundation or coach to evaluate.

From ‘Unkillable’ (Subscribe Here): BT reacts to the Patriots’ defeat of the Jets. He talks about the Jets’ inability to generate offense, Drake Maye’s play and Questions the Jets' future at QB. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): The boys cover all that happened in week 10 and preview week 11. Picks against the spread. NFC and AFC playoff picture. Where do the Giants go with their next coach? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The segment ignites with Sal questioning if his new Amazon obsession—high-sodium sesame sticks—is causing his "restless leg syndrome." This sparks a hilarious comparison of their diets, revealing Sal's monstrous Thursday night meal: an entire massive calzone (with two cheeses!) alongside a seafood salad. BT confesses he needs comfort food—a bag of chips, a pie, or even a chicken parm—to sit through a full game, exposing his own "mental block" on not snacking. Sal defends his own clean streak post-calzone, while the hosts figure out which one of them is the bigger health menace. The banter is a classic BT & Sal showdown between extreme indulgence and nervous snacking.

BT & Sal go off on the Kardashian family dynamic after hearing a clip where Aubrey O'Day (of Danity Kane fame) claimed that Kim Kardashian had a relationship with Travis Barker before he married her sister, Kourtney. Sal is fundamentally opposed to the idea of dating someone a sibling has been with, calling it "gross" and questioning why with "so many people out there," Barker and the sisters would cross that line. The hosts agree that while Kim has denied the rumors, the principle of the "family code" makes the entire situation feel awkward and "unnecessary." The conversation briefly pivots to a less heated, more analytical football discussion about the Jets' rebuild and quarterback evaluation.

BT & Sal dive into the aftermath of the Jets' loss to the Patriots, arguing it was a "good loss" that reveals a well-coached football team under Aaron Glenn. Sal defends the mindset of being "proud" of the effort, emphasizing that this is what a "real rebuild" looks like—a complete, albeit painful, resetting of the foundation and expectations. They praise Glenn's unconventional opening decision to receive the ball and execute a perfect, scripted touchdown drive, contrasting it with the "avoid getting embarrassed" style of past regimes. However, the hosts intensely critique Justin Fields' "woeful" passing and lack of big-play support, debating whether Glenn's loyalty to the quarterback is justifiable and if it's time to play Tyrod Taylor for a true evaluation of the young receivers. The discussion concludes with the consensus that the talent disparity is massive, but the team is building the right culture for the long-term, following a model similar to the first year of a successful coach like Tom Thibodeau.

BT & Sal unleash a fiery Yankees offseason demand: Cody Bellinger is a "must-sign" that the team cannot afford to miss, arguing they must abandon "fair market value" and aggressively "load up." They dissect potential trades for Steven Kwan and Alex Bregman and float the nuclear option of trading Carlos Rodón. The Mets side of the Hot Stove is equally hot with a shocking report that Brandon Nimmo is being "spitballed" as a trade piece, signaling a massive philosophical shift for David Stearns. Sal airs a hilarious personal grievance against Alex Rodriguez, who texts everyone but Sal. Off the field, the hosts dive into a bizarre celebrity tangent, debating the definition of "swordsman" sparked by Sydney Sweeney drama, and welcome Marlon Wayans to discuss comedy and crushing cancel culture. The show wraps with a brutal assessment of the Jets' upcoming primetime game and a controversial NFL Power Up Ranking that leaves the Chiefs out of the top spots!

BT & Sal ignite a fiery Yankees offseason debate, asserting that securing Cody Bellinger is a "must-sign" that the Yankees cannot afford to whiff on—unlike their approach with Soto. Sal argues they must "stop waiting" for the market and be aggressive. The discussion pivots to ideal trade targets like Steven Kwan (the perfect leadoff hitter) and Alex Bregman, and whether trading Rodón is the creative move the team needs. Off the field, the guys dive into the news of Sydney Sweeney's movie flopping at the box office, her beef with actress Ruby Rose, and the Eddie Murphy documentary, which sparks a hilarious, winding, and surprisingly academic debate about the proper definition and pronunciation of the word "swordsman."

BT and Sal tear into the Jets' primetime matchup against the Patriots, with BT predicting a "bloodbath" given the team's struggles, while Sal holds out hope for a "competitive" showing to build on the Aaron Glenn era. In baseball, the hosts turn to the Hot Stove, fiercely debating how the Yankees and Mets must "load up" to compete with the Dodgers' high-spending, star-stockpiling strategy, fueled by the Ohtani deferral model. Sal proposes an aggressive trade: Marté over Chisholm for the Yankees. Finally, legendary comedian Marlon Wayans joins the show to talk about his return to Scary Movie 6, crushing cancel culture, and why he believes the world desperately needs "no holds barred" comedy like Archie Bunker to bring people together.

BT & Sal ignite the offseason discussion, declaring Cody Bellinger the "linchpin" for the Yankees' success and arguing that both New York teams need to abandon "fair market value" for a necessary, "irrational" approach to win. They dive into a shocking report from Joel Sherman suggesting the Mets are "spitballing" a trade of Brandon Nimmo—a move that could clear salary and upgrade defense, but signals a major philosophical shift for David Stearns. The focus then pivots to the NFL for their Week 11 Power Up Rankings. Sal shocks by putting the Patriots at No. 5 and leaving the Chiefs out, while BT puts the Patriots at No. 1 due to their consistent winning and coaching, dropping the Chiefs to No. 4. The guys debate whether the Broncos and Rams have done enough to earn top spots, and predict a crushing loss for the Jets against the Patriots tonight.

BT & Sal kick off with a furious post-mortem on the Knicks' loss, with Sal taking aim at coach Mike Brown for leaving Jalen Brunson in late and comparing the heat he'd get to former coach Tom Thibodeau. They pivot to the Yankees, dissecting the long-standing "suck wind" problem of player development that continues to plague the organization. The show takes a turn as Sal hilariously airs his personal grievance with Alex Rodriguez, revealing he's offended the former slugger texts BT and a mutual colleague, but snubs Sal! The Mets discussion heats up with news that the Orioles are entering the Pete Alonso sweepstakes and a caller raising concerns over the logistical nightmare of Citi Field construction once Steve Cohen gets his casino license. The show wraps with a look at the Jets' hopeless matchup against the Patriots and a fiery call of the day.

Sal vents his fiery frustration over his lack of a texting relationship with Alex Rodriguez, feeling personally snubbed that A-Rod only reaches out to his co-host Brandon Tierney and his podcast partner, Jimmy Traina. He humorously questions what he needs to do to get A-Rod's attention—rip him or kiss up to him—and wonders if A-Rod even likes him. Tierney provides context, explaining that A-Rod expressed a genuine fondness for Sal but may simply be "Alex" (sincere and normal) with them, rather than "A-Rod" (the guarded public figure). The conversation touches on A-Rod's past, his infamous lie to Mike Francesa on The Fan, and Sal's forgotten bond with A-Rod over being an '86 Mets fan and coincidentally attending the same movie screening.

BT and Sal dive into an explosive report from Joel Sherman suggesting the Mets are "spit-balling" scenarios to trade veteran outfielder Brandon Nimmo. With five years and over $100 million left on his contract, the Mets' motivation is to upgrade a poor defense and gain roster flexibility, even if it means eating some salary. Sal supports moving on from a contract that David Stearns wouldn't have signed, while BT sees it as an "out-of-the-box" move that could define a transformative offseason. The conversation also touches on other potential trade targets, like Ketel Marte, as the guys conclude that no one is untouchable this winter for the new front office.

BT & Sal wrestle with the most challenging power rankings of the season, revealing their "Top 5" teams heading into NFL Week 11. Sal drops the Bills entirely after their embarrassing loss and shockingly places the Patriots at Number 1, praising the team's depth, coaching, and the play of Drake Maye. BT, meanwhile, sticks with the Broncos at his Number 2 spot despite their flaws and slides the Chiefs down to a questionable Number 4 due to their 5-4 record. The hosts also debate the quiet dominance of the Rams (BT's #3, Sal's #1) and discuss how the Colts and Eagles are separating themselves from the rest of the pack. They highlight the importance of key Week 11 head-to-head matchups, including Chiefs vs. Broncos and Lions vs. Eagles, that will shake up the rankings next week.

BT and Sal get a hilariously fiery interview with comedy legend Marlon Wayans, who unleashes a scorching take on "cancel culture." Wayans argues it's a fear-based illusion fueled by foreign bots and "scared executives," not what real audiences want, and declares his intent to bring back the "equal opportunity offender" laughter of In Living Color with the upcoming 'Scary Movie 6.' Marlon also opens up about the friendly jealousy among the famous Wayans brothers (and why he was their mother's favorite), reveals his "F these people" pre-show ritual for comedic fearlessness, and debates whether an Archie Bunker-style show could ever survive in today's hypersensitive world.

BT & Sal ignite a fierce debate on how the Yankees and Mets can realistically compete with the Dodgers' powerhouse, star-stockpiling strategy. They argue that both New York teams must stop being "afraid to make mistakes" and aggressively "eat" bad contracts to maintain a competitive edge, just like the Yankees of old. The conversation centers on the Dodgers' financial model, specifically the Ohtani deferral deal, which Sal calls a "perfect storm" built on a willing star, and question why the Mets and Yankees haven't been as innovative. For the Yankees, they explore bold moves like trading Rodón to make room for an elite arm like Skubal and question the value of trading a top prospect like Lombard for a rental. The bottom line: The Dodgers have raised the bar, and New York must match the intensity and financial bravado.

BT & Sal tackle the grim reality of the Jets' Thursday Night Football matchup against the New England Patriots. Sal expresses a sliver of curiosity about the team's "competitiveness," but the consensus is brutal: the Patriots are one of the NFL's best, and the Jets are one of the worst. They slam the notion of a "momentum" build, pointing out the wins against the Bengals and Browns were due to luck and special teams, not a true team turnaround. BT says it will be a "bloodbath" and a "mismatch," arguing the bar for the Jets is simply to "not embarrass themselves." He challenges head coach Aaron Glenn to "empty the tank," calling for Uber-aggressive play and trick plays to narrow the overwhelming odds. The hosts also briefly transition to a heated discussion on whether the Yankees should trade Jazz Chisholm for the Diamondbacks' Ketel Marte.

BT & Sal kick off the segment with a fiery, yet hilarious, linguistics lesson on the pronunciation of "sword," with BT's preferred "sword**"** (or "sword") sparking a comical debate about intellect and high-quality literature. The main discussion shifts to potential Yankees trade targets. The hosts dismantle a trade proposal for Ketel Marte, questioning the high asking price and his history of taking days off. The focus then turns to the "perfect fit": Steven Kwan. Sal argues that the elite, contact-hitting, Gold Glove left fielder is the ideal leadoff hitter the Yankees desperately need, contrasting him with the "analytics war" being waged by Boone and Cashman. Finally, they weigh the risks of signing free agent pitcher Michael King and debate if small, smart moves can round out the roster.

BT & Sal kick off the segment by immediately addressing the viral news surrounding Sydney Sweeney—specifically the disappointing box office flop of her latest movie, with Sal jokingly suggesting their recent interview "helped" the movie sink. They dive into the ensuing drama, including the Ruby Rose feud over the casting and a bizarre segue into the Eddie Murphy GOAT debate. The conversation pivots sharply back to sports with a fiery Yankees trade suggestion: dumping Carlos Rodón and his hefty contract to free up money for a major free agent acquisition like Shohei Ohtani or Kwang Hyun Kim (a bit of classic Sal hyperbole). The hosts criticize the Yankees' recent lack of "creative" trades, arguing they need to be more aggressive this offseason. The segment concludes with Tierney reluctantly admitting his unique, and incorrect, definition of "swordsman" after a caller brought up an old rumor about a certain sports radio host.

BT & Sal unleash a fiery debate on the Yankees' offseason, arguing the entire success of their winter hinges on re-signing free agent Cody Bellinger. Sal insists the team has "no excuse" to lose Bellinger after already whiffing on Juan Soto last year, demanding the Yankees get aggressive now and exceed the market if necessary. Tierney agrees, noting that losing Bellinger would make their already unclear roster situation "very worrisome." The hosts also pivot to a bigger picture, asking: "Is Bellinger enough?" They propose bold moves like trading for a true leadoff hitter like Steven Kwan and questioning the Yankees' self-imposed limitation at third base with Ryan McMahon when a proven winner like Alex Bregman is available. They conclude that without Bellinger and further aggressive action, the Yankees risk simply starting the next season with the same flawed team.

BT & Sal demand aggression from David Stearns, urging the Mets to stop playing a waiting game and "call the bluff" with a massive offer to lock up Pete Alonso. They debate if Stearns' "prudent" style fits the Cohen-era pressure. The guys explode over the rumor that Pirates ace Paul Skenes wants to be a Yankee, arguing New York must give up Clarke Schlittler and "whatever it takes" to acquire the generational arm. On the gridiron, they dissect the Giants' coaching chaos under Mike Kafka and slam Jets coach Aaron Glenn for his "prick" and "petty" media feuds over injury questions. Finally, the show features two star interviews: UFC middleweight Bo Nickal discusses his career and mentality, prompting BT to "hammer the bet," and legendary comedian Jay Leno shares unfiltered takes on the Conan O'Brien drama and his famous prank war with David Letterman. The segment concludes with Three Random Questions (3RQ): Is it odd to have feelings for a plant or non-living thing? What's your favorite soup? Where would you rank Sauce Gardner amongst other sauces?

BT & Sal dive deep into the Mets' offseason strategy, debating whether GM David Stearns can balance his restrained management style with Steve Cohen's massive checkbook. Sal insists the Mets need at least two top-tier starting pitchers and a major offensive change, while Tierney questions Stearns' hesitation on re-signing Pete Alonso, urging an aggressive, take-it-or-leave-it offer. The guys clash with callers over Alonso's value and debate potential free-agent fits like Bregman, Bichette, and Schwarber. The discussion explodes with an explosive report that Pirates ace Paul Skenes is "hoping for a trade" to the Yankees. The hosts emphatically agree that New York must give up "whatever it takes," including beloved young starter Clarke Schlittler, to acquire the transcendent, under-control superstar pitcher. They argue that Skenes' long-term control makes him the ultimate prize and a transformational trade target.

BT & Sal go off on the Mets' offseason strategy, arguing that the front office is playing a waiting game with Pete Alonso and should "call his bluff" with a massive, immediate offer to lock him up. They dissect David Stearns' "prudent" approach, questioning his ability to build a winner with the immense pressure and payroll of the Cohen era, especially concerning Edwin Diaz's contract demands. The focus shifts to the Giants' coaching chaos: they debate if the mid-season shake-up, placing Mike Kafka in charge, will provide a true evaluation of Joe Schoen's roster, or if any wins will be a "false representation" of a bad roster/front office. Plus, the hosts break down the Paul Skenes trade rumors, debating if the Yankees should liquidate their best prospects (Schlittler, Jones, Rice) for the "rock star" ace. Finally, the guys tackle a wild Three Random Questions: Is it odd to have feelings for a plant or non-living thing? (Tierney loves his Arborvitae!) What's your favorite soup? (Sal's Italian Wedding vs. BT's despised pea soup!) Where would you rank Sauce Gardner amongst other sauces? (Hint: he's dropped to the "discount rack"!)

BT & Sal dive into the high-stakes GM meetings, demanding the Mets' front office stop their "penny stock" ways and "Go BIG" to close the gap with the Dodgers. They debate an all-star offseason wishlist—Bellinger, Bregman, Alonso—and whether the Yankees should trade Cam Schlittler for Paul Skenes now. The temperature spikes as they slam Jets coach Aaron Glenn for his petty and unnecessary feud with the media, calling out his "prick" behavior for deflecting injury questions and questioning his overall "Parcells-lite" strategy. Finally, UFC Middleweight Bo Nickal joins the studio ahead of his main prelim event at UFC 322 at Madison Square Garden. Nickal discusses overcoming his first career loss, the mentality of a fighter, and why MMA is a more complete sport than boxing. Tierney gets so sold on Nickal's confidence that he vows to "hammer the odds" on his fight!

BT & Sal get fired up after their interview with UFC star Bo Nickal, taking his advice to "hammer the bet" on his upcoming fight. Hof then hilariously attempts to prove he could last ten seconds in the octagon against the wrestling phenomenon. Next, legendary comedian Jay Leno joins the show to provide unfiltered takes on the current state of late-night, the drama with Conan O'Brien, and his classic prank war with David Letterman (involving a meatball sandwich!). Leno also shares his secret to staying humble outside of the "Beverly Hills Bubble": working on his massive car collection. Finally, the guys discuss the Saint John's basketball program under Rick Pitino, celebrating the commitment of a top-50 high school guard and breaking down the implications of a report that MLB star Paul Skene's wants to play for the Yankees, bolstering the team's brand.

Legendary comedian Jay Leno joins BT & Sal for a fiery, in-depth conversation on his career and the changing landscape of late-night television. Leno critiques the current state of late night—too many commercials, too much political fighting—and reveals the never-before-heard truth about the Conan O'Brien/NBC debacle, stating the network's incompetence and infighting drove the wedge. Leno shares priceless stories from his career, including his years-long prank war with David Letterman involving a meatball sandwich, and the unforgettable difference between President Obama arriving to the show in a rental car versus a satellite-proof tent. Finally, he discusses the need for humility and why working on his massive car collection helps him avoid the "Beverly Hills Bubble."

BT & Sal step into the studio with UFC Middleweight star Bo Nickal ahead of his main prelim event at UFC 322 at Madison Square Garden. Nickal, an elite wrestling champion, talks about navigating the nerve-wracking emotions of fight night and how he's using his first-ever career loss as "massive motivation" for his upcoming bout. The conversation ignites when they discuss the low-key feeling of being a fighter who could "disable" anyone on the street, the debate over UFC vs. Boxing (Bo calls MMA a "complete sport"), and his thoughts on the constant temptation to fix a fight in the sport. Plus, Nickal opens up about his relationships with Kyler Murray and the late Hulk Hogan, and a surprising reveal about a potential UFC event at the White House after speaking with President Trump. Sal is so sold, he declares he's "hammering" a bet on Nickal's comeback!

BT & Sal kick off their "Three Random Questions" with a hilarious debate on odd emotional connections after Sal admits to feeling bad about trashing a plant and has a soft spot for stuffed animals, while Tierney is fiercely protective of his towering arborvitae. Next, the guys jump into a fiery Soup Segment, where Tierney's beloved pea soup is declared "gross" by Sal, who champions Italian Wedding soup and bans French Onion from the menu. Finally, they tackle the absurd question: "Where would you rank Sauce Gardner amongst other sauces?" The segment concludes with Sal declaring the star corner has fallen to the "discount rack," somewhere near Ragu, in the hierarchy of condiments.

BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate over the future of Giants GM Joe Schoen, whose job is reportedly on the line over the final seven games. They call the evaluation process "ass backwards," arguing that the team fired the coach (Brian Daboll) who had the players ready to play, while the GM who built the underperforming defense remains. Sal fears a few meaningless late-season wins against bad teams will create a "false representation" and save Schoen's job, despite a weak overall resume. Later, the conversation shifts to a massive baseball trade hypothetical: Is Pirates ace Paul Skenes, a true "rock star," worth a package that includes promising Yankees pitcher Cam Schlittler plus top prospects? They conclude that while Schlittler has potential, the elite, controllable talent of Skenes makes him virtually untradeable.

BT & Sal demand Steve Cohen and David Stearns adopt an aggressive, take-charge approach to securing Pete Alonso this offseason. Tierney argues the Mets must "call his bluff" and make him their best offer now (suggesting six years, $200 million) to test how much he truly wants to be a Met, rather than letting Scott Boras drag the process into next year. Sal emphasizes that despite the homegrown narrative, Alonso deserves and will demand fair market value after his bounce-back season. The conversation also touches on the Yankees' pursuit of Paul Skenes, the controversial trend of massive deferred payments in contracts (like the Dodgers' deal with Ohtani), and the challenge for consumers to navigate the sea of conflicting reports from national baseball reporters.

BT & Sal are in complete agreement on one fiery topic: The Yankees (and Mets) must be all-in to acquire Pirates ace Paul Skenes, who is under team control through the 2029 season. Sal argues that Pittsburgh must trade him within the next few years to maximize value, likely with three seasons left. The hosts clash with caller "Frankie from Bay Ridge," who insists that Yankees prospect Cam Schlittler is "more proven" and shouldn't be included in any deal for Skenes. The hosts vehemently disagree, arguing that Skenes is a "transformational superstar" whose every outing is equivalent to Schlittler's best playoff performance, making any package involving top prospects like Schlittler, Spencer Jones, and Jasson Domínguez a no-brainer. The segment concludes by quickly revisiting the Pete Alonso contract discussion, prompted by a caller confusing Alonso's value with Bo Bichette's.

BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate over a major rumor: Pirates ace Paul Skenes reportedly has "no confidence" in Pittsburgh's ability to win and is "hoping for a trade," with multiple teammates claiming he "wants to play for the Yankees." The hosts argue this stunning development "emboldens" the Yankees to give up whatever it takes to acquire the young, controlled superstar, comparing the potential move to the Soto trade's high-risk nature but with better long-term potential. The conversation pivots to the Mets, where Sal criticizes the team's perceived lack of "aggression" compared to the Yankees. They then run through an absurd list of high-profile free agents, including Kyle Tucker, Cody Bellinger, and Bo Bichette, evaluating whether the Mets or Yankees should pay their demanding contracts.

BT & Sal dissect David Stearns' recent comments on the Mets' offseason, debating whether the GM has the appetite—or the checkbook—to execute the massive overhaul the team needs. Sal outlines a fiery, aggressive ultimatum for Pete Alonso's agent, Scott Boras, proposing a "$180 million, take-it-or-leave-it" deal to prevent the slugger from holding up the entire offseason. The hosts agree that simply bringing back Alonso and Diaz and adding a single pitcher is "not enough," arguing that the team's core DNA must change. Tierney demands a minimum of two high-end starters plus a major position player acquisition (like Bellinger or Bregman) to make the offseason a success. They also clash over Alonso's value, with Sal focusing on his lack of production when the power isn't there, and Tierney arguing his home run numbers are irreplaceable in a lineup already lacking offensive threats.

BT & Sal are furious at the Giants' "idiotic decision" to fire Head Coach Brian Daboll while retaining GM Joe Schoen to lead the next coaching search. They slam Schoen's track record—including his draft misses and the handling of the roster—arguing he hasn't "earned the right" to hire another coach, which they say proves the franchise is "lost" and "accepting losing." NFL Insider Brian Baldinger joins the fire to dissect Daboll's risky play-calling and its impact on QB Jaxson Dart. The discussion also dives into the murky waters of ownership (and John Mara's health), a fiery segment of "Bald Faced Lie, Bald Faced Truth" baseball predictions, and Sal's ticket jinx, where a free Rangers game was pulled right before the team broke its scoring drought. Finally, the segment ends with a heated hypothetical: Would you take a Soulmate Test that reveals your true match?

BT & Sal are furious at the Giants' "idiotic decision" to fire head coach Brian Daboll but retain General Manager Joe Schoen to lead the next coaching search. They slam the move as the "worst thing they could do," arguing Schoen's track record—including an inept roster and highly questionable draft picks (Evan Neal, Deonte Banks)—has earned him no right to hire another coach. The hosts question how ownership can possibly trust Schoen, labeling the franchise "pathetic" and "lost" for repeating the cycle of keeping the GM who hired a failed coach. The discussion also heats up with callers pitching head coach replacements like Jon Gruden and Lane Kiffin, forcing BT and Sal to debate if a college coach is the right fit and if Schoen's mere presence will severely dilute the candidate talent pool. They conclude that by keeping Schoen, the Giants are essentially "accepting losing."

BT & Sal launch into a fiery debate over the Giants' messy front office, fueled by Ian O'Connor's report suggesting Joe Schoen's return is not a "certainty" and that his retention for the coaching search may be due to the health of John Mara. The hosts are infuriated that Schoen was spared while Daboll was fired, pointing to the GM's 20-40-1 record over four years and the Giants' "lack of awareness." They discuss the need for a "truth teller" to break the team's cycle of mistakes and debate whether a low-risk veteran coach like Mike McCarthy or a high-upside gamble is the right move. The segment is punctuated by the "Bald Faced Lie, Bald Faced Truth" baseball predictions (Diaz to the Dodgers? Tucker and Bellinger as teammates?) and Sal's ticket debacles, including a jinxed free Rangers game that was pulled last minute, right before the team finally broke its home scoring drought!

BT & Sal ignite the discussion on the Giants' coaching chaos, arguing that the team's rot goes beyond the firing of Brian Daboll and demanding to know the true fate of GM Joe Schoen. NFL Insider Brian Baldinger joins the fire, directly blaming Daboll's risky play-calling for the injuries to quarterback Jaxson Dart, specifically citing a dangerous protection call and unnecessary running plays. The conversation shifts to the coaching search, with Sal arguing the Giants job is highly attractive due to Dart, while the hosts slam the "stupid argument" that Belichick's success should be disregarded due to Tom Brady. Finally, in Three Random Questions, the hosts dive into a tricky personal question: If you could take a "Soulmate Test" that reveals your true match, would you do it? The hypothetical leads to humorous and fiery takes on marriage, temptation, and the nature of fate.

BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate over the post-Daboll Giants, arguing that if star QB Jaxson Dart is out, the team has "no reason to watch" and should embrace tanking for a better draft pick to set up the next head coach. The hosts slam the Giants' hierarchy, highlighting the "Call of the Day" where a caller accuses the owners of compounding problems and "not being football guys." The discussion then pivots to the coaching search, where they intensely weigh the experience of Jon Gruden (Super Bowl winner with an old-school personality) against the consistency of Sean McDermott (perennial playoff contender with the Bills), while also acknowledging the baggage of Brian Flores. Finally, the duo briefly commiserates over the ongoing struggles with the "Unperfect Perfect Parlay", with BT vowing to move to three- and four-team bets to finally escape the curse.

BT & Sal dissect the Giants' colossal organizational blunder: keeping GM Joe Shoen to lead the head coach search after firing the previous coach. The hosts slam the ownership for "compounding the problem" and operating with "no awareness." They agree with the caller that this dysfunction could easily "ruin" the career of rookie QB Jaxson Dart by wasting the crucial, cap-friendly window of his four-year rookie contract. The segment also debates the attractiveness of the Giants' coaching vacancy, discussing a list of potential candidates like Lane Kiffin, Kevin Stefanski, and Mike Tomlin, all while pointing out that the GM's uncertain job security and the shaky organizational structure make it a highly risky proposition.