The Giants released Odell Beckham Jr. after barely using him for three games. Our hosts react to the news and debate if there was ever any point of reuniting with OBJ in the first place. Plus, Evan and Tiki discuss the team's chances in the NFC East without Jaxson Dart, and if J.J. McCarthy has any chance of pushing Jameis Winston for the starting job. Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to talk all things Big Blue, including McCarthy and how he may be used the rest of this season.

The Yankees steamrolled the hated Red Sox in a two-game Wild Card Series sweep, and we have full reactions from all of our hosts, who were pleasantly surprised at how efficient the Yankee lineup was from top to bottom. Plus, debating whether or not Aaron Judge will play in the ALDS, how the Yankees will set up their rotation, and if the Bombers should be favored against the Rays. Meanwhile, Evan and Tiki feel like the Yanks were a little over the top in celebrating a Wild Card Series win, and Boomer and Gio debate which Yankee is likeliest to carry the team and be their new "Mr. October."

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Boomer and Mike are back to talk all the headlines from week 3, another splashy Cowboys trade, Week 4 picks, Game of the Week, a QB Power Rankings and more!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the New York Giants' postseason viability and the impact of the Brian Burns injury. They investigate conspiracy theories surrounding Tony Romo's CBS departure and the suspension of Jed York. The discussion also evaluates the firing of Braden Bell and the ethics of gambling in the NBA. (00:01:50) New York Sports Update (00:08:10) Giants Playoff Viability Debate (00:16:07) Romo CBS Divorce Conspiracy (00:21:52) Jed York Suspension News (00:16:22) Yankees Postseason Roster Decisions (00:17:09) Deshaun Watson Interview Analysis (00:31:03) Braden Bell Firing Controversy (00:27:46) NBA Gambling Endorsement Debate

Craig and Big Mac break down the significant injury blows for the Jets and Giants, specifically Breece Hall and Brian Burns. They weigh in on the Giants' postseason viability before diving into a wild conspiracy theory regarding Tony Romo's departure from the CBS broadcast booth. They also scrutinize NFL ownership double standards following the suspension of Jed York. (00:01:35) Jets Battle Breece Hall Injury (00:05:40) Giants Defense Without Brian Burns (00:09:32) Debating Giants' Playoff Hopes (00:15:37) The Tony Romo CBS Conspiracy (00:21:21) Double Standards in NFL Ownership (00:25:22) Halloween Laughs and The Natural

Craig and Big Mac react to a viral video suggesting referees favor Patrick Mahomes and debate if the NFL is rigged. They break down the Yankees' travel nightmare heading to Tampa and explore the rising world of microbetting and live-game gambling tech. Craig also shares a wild story from his time in prison about a cellmate's hidden mushroom grow house. (00:01:40) NFL Injuries and Yankees Travel (00:05:20) Is the NFL Fixed? (00:12:00) Microbetting and Romo Conspiracy (00:16:45) First Pitch Betting Stats (00:23:35) Gambling Tech and Latency (00:31:00) Prison Grow House Stories

Carton and Big Mac evaluate the sympathetic portrayal of Deshaun Watson in a recent interview and the controversial firing of a Trail Blazers announcer. They also discuss Victor Wembanyama's stance on gambling ads and the New York Giants' quarterback concerns. (00:02:33) Deshaun Watson Interview (00:13:02) Giants and Jets Curses (00:19:53) Battle of the Sexes Debate (00:29:02) Brayden Bell Firing (00:41:13) Giants Quarterback Situation (00:24:39) Patrick Mahomes Favoritism (00:26:06) NBA Gambling Ad Stance (00:35:36) Microdosing Experiences (00:38:51) Yankees Roster Decisions

Craig Carton and Big Mac break down the critical roster decisions facing the New York Yankees ahead of the ALDS, debating the roles of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. They analyze the starting rotation hierarchy between Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón while examining the pressure on the Giants to perform against the Arizona Cardinals. (00:01:20) Fatherhood and Flag Football (00:05:59) Yankees ALDS Roster Moves (00:13:13) Gerrit Cole vs. Carlos Rodón (00:19:32) Assessing Aaron Boone's Management (00:24:50) Giants vs. Cardinals Outlook (00:28:50) NFC Playoff Picture Analysis (00:36:00) Jets Coaching and Geno Smith (00:41:24) Yankees Series Predictions

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' roster strategy for the ALDS, specifically debating player cuts and the starting rotation hierarchy. They evaluate Aaron Boone's managerial success throughout an injury-plagued season and share a lighthearted discussion about parenting and a curious scientific theory regarding cows. (00:01:09) Parenting And Family (00:02:36) Cow Science Talk (00:06:08) Yankees Roster Cuts (00:11:45) Cole Rotation Debate (00:20:32) Boone Managerial Performance

WFAN examines the ethics of active NBA stars like Kevin Durant and LeBron James endorsing gambling platforms. They contrast these deals with Victor Wembanyama’s firm refusal to participate in betting advertisements. The discussion also explores sports superstitions and previews upcoming Yankees roster decisions. (00:02:12) Superstitions and Bad Omens (00:05:10) Mahomes Penalty Conspiracy (00:07:02) NBA Gambling Endorsement Debate (00:16:29) Microdosing and Medical Mushrooms (00:20:05) Yankees Roster Decisions

A debate ensues regarding the Portland Trail Blazers' decision to fire play-by-play announcer Braden Bell after offensive social media posts from his early teens surfaced. They also evaluate the quarterback situation involving Jameis Winston and the potential transition to younger players like J.J. McCarthy. (00:01:00) Braden Bell Firing Controversy (00:10:35) Kevin Calabro Pay Dispute (00:13:20) Jameis Winston Performance Review (00:19:48) Giants Upcoming Schedule Analysis

Carton and Big Mac criticize the Amazon interview with Deshaun Watson, arguing it avoided his legal history to make him a sympathetic figure. They also examine the supposed curses on the Giants and Jets before Carton explains his "Last Words" podcast idea. (00:01:00) Browns Victory Picks (00:02:06) Watson Interview Critique (00:13:50) Giants And Jets Curses (00:17:30) My Last Words Podcast (00:25:06) Sammy Steigman Story

Craig Carton explains the difficulties of micro-betting due to the latency between cable and streaming broadcasts. The conversation shifts to personal experiences in prison, specifically a cellmate who ran a secret mushroom farm alongside a hydroponic cannabis setup. He also discusses the 'Drive Time Crime' headline that greeted him in the New York Post during his sentence. (00:01:00) Weekend Plans and LIU Football (00:04:46) Micro-Betting and Streaming Delays (00:10:05) Prison Cellmate's Mushroom Farm

Craig and C-Mac analyze recent NFL injuries to stars like Aaron Donald and Justin Jefferson before diving into the New York Yankees' chaotic travel day ahead of the playoffs. They also discuss a viral video of a roughing the passer call on Patrick Mahomes that sparked conspiracy theories about the league being rigged. Later, they examine the mechanics of micro-betting and explore baseball's first-pitch statistics with listeners. (00:01:09) NFL Injury Update (00:02:39) Yankees Travel Nightmares (00:04:47) NFL Fixed Conspiracy (00:11:07) Micro-Betting Explained (00:16:04) MLB First Pitch Stats

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the New York Giants' early-season success and the potential for a quarterback change between Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy. They also break down the New York Yankees' roster decisions ahead of the playoffs and share humorous stories about Halloween traditions and the infectious nature of losing in sports. (00:01:39) Yankees Roster Decisions (00:02:43) Giants Quarterback Debate (00:11:03) Losing Is Contagious (00:13:43) Halloween Neighborhood Traditions

Carton and Big Mac discuss Tony Romo's departure from CBS and a conspiracy theory involving the NFL's gambling partners. They also analyze the heavy suspension handed to Jed York, contrasting it with the league's lack of action against other owners.(00:01:00) Romo's CBS Exit(00:02:39) Play Predicting Conspiracy(00:06:54) Jed York's Suspension(00:12:30) Comparing Owner Conduct

Craig and Big Mac discuss the Jets' offensive hurdles following Breece Hall's injury before Sunday's game. They also engage in a spirited disagreement over the Giants' legitimacy as a playoff contender and Jameis Winston's future as the team's starting quarterback. (00:01:37) Jets Breece Hall Out (00:05:40) Giants Brian Burns Injury (00:07:28) Giants Playoff Hopes Debate

C-Mac is popping champagne as the Yankees roll through Boston in the Wild Card Series to get back to the ALDS! Chris breaks down the game two win from Yankee Stadium, from Max Fried's strong outing to the lineup continuing to hit from top to bottom, punishing Boston pitching with an equal mix of small ball and home-run power. Plus, the youngsters continue to come through, Aaron Boone pushed all the right buttons, and is this team primed to beat Tampa Bay?EPISODE HIGHLIGHTSIntro: Welcome to a Wild Card victory! The Yankees sweep the Red Sox with back-to-back nine-run performances and brilliant situational hitting.5:20: Sonny Gray's performance under the bright lights of Yankee Stadium and the electric crowd reactions. Did Chad Tracy pull him too early?14:38: Breaking down Max Fried's start and concerns over Trent Grisham's lackadaisical defense in center field.20:47: Questionable management from Chad Tracy with his decision to pull Sonny Gray and intentionally walk Ben Rice to load the bases for Cody Bellinger.23:56: Third base coach Luis Rojas's terrible two-out send that killed a potential momentum swing.26:08: Rickie Ricardo joins the show to discuss Spencer Jones' game-changing hustle and to preview the upcoming ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays.39:36: Austin Wells flips the script on his regular-season struggles with four crucial RBIs in the Wild Card series.51:03: Final thoughts on the unmatched magic of playoff baseball and why this Yankee team is built to make a deep World Series run.

Craig and Big Mac celebrate the Yankees' dominant sweep of the Red Sox and look ahead to the ALDS matchup against the Rays. They discuss the potential return of Aaron Judge, the controversy surrounding Sonny Gray's neck, and Craig's difficult decision to prioritize the postseason over Boomer Esiason’s Hall of Fame induction. (00:01:50) Yankees Sweep Red Sox (00:05:21) Chad Tracy Mets Rumors (00:08:31) Roster And Rotation Decisions (00:14:16) Mike Tomlin Minecraft Addiction (00:17:43) Sonny Gray Cheating Allegations (00:21:41) Yankee Offensive Approach Changes (00:25:31) Fan Etiquette And Scheduling (00:33:06) Carton Skips Boomer's Induction

Craig and Big Mac analyze the most effective strategies for the Yankees to maintain their competitive advantage in the ALDS. They discuss the efficient allocation of roster spots and the collective benefits of a community-focused wager that resulted in the 'Go Get Em' oyster. The discussion evaluates how individual fan actions and managerial choices impact the overall success of the organization. (00:01:25) Yankees Sweep Red Sox (00:04:52) David Stearns Rumors (00:07:55) Starting Pitching Advantage (00:13:50) Tomlin's Minecraft City (00:16:00) Yankee Oyster Wager (00:20:10) Aaron Judge Strategy (00:23:50) ALDS Rotation Debate (00:28:40) Fan Ethics And Instincts

Craig and Big Mac evaluate the Yankees' sweep of the Red Sox, specifically addressing the cheating allegations involving Sonny Gray and the discoloration on his neck. They also examine the historic statistics of Spencer Jones and preview the pitching matchups for the upcoming postseason games. (00:01:20) Sonny Gray Cheating Allegations (00:04:40) Red Sox Managerial Decisions (00:08:45) Boston Sports Scene Struggles (00:12:15) MLB Playoff Scheduling Conflicts (00:15:06) WNBA And Knicks Memories (00:19:22) Spencer Jones Historic Stat (00:23:31) Big Mac Luxury Suite (00:29:00) Yankees Playoff Pitching Rotation

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the awkwardness of meeting Joe Girardi in a hallway and debate Aaron Judge's postseason roster status. They also address the possible eviction of the Jackie Robinson Museum and why Carton is skipping Boomer Esiason’s Hall of Fame ceremony to stay on-air. (00:01:20) Hygiene Habits And Hairpieces (00:05:30) Joe Girardi Hallway Encounter (00:09:10) Sonny Gray And Yankee Pressure (00:13:15) Judge vs Stanton Roster Strategy (00:18:30) Wedding Customs And Miracle Babies (00:24:20) Jackie Robinson Museum Crisis (00:31:40) Coverage vs Boomers Hall Of Fame (00:15:30) Professional Commitment To WFAN (00:21:50) Risking Health For World Series

Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze the Yankees' postseason momentum and Aaron Judge's availability for the ALDS. They also discuss a bizarre botched execution story from Tennessee and celebrate Victor Cruz's recent marriage to DJ Orange Calderon. (00:01:20) Craig's Oura Ring Fight (00:06:14) Alex Cora Managerial Flack (00:10:33) October Baseball Branding Irony (00:17:35) Botched Tennessee Execution News (00:26:21) Aaron Judge Injury Status (00:13:34) Victor Cruz Wedding News (00:19:00) Yankees Celebration Debate (00:24:14) Broadway Show Tune Battle

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' satisfying postseason sweep of the Boston Red Sox on The Last Stop of the Carton Show, praising the team's balance of small ball and power hitting. He addresses potential roster adjustments for the upcoming series against the Tampa Bay Rays, specifically focusing on the roles of Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and the young outfielders. (00:01:00) Yankees Sweep Red Sox (00:07:13) Pitching and ALDS Preview (00:14:49) Yankees Playoff Roster Decisions (00:18:18) Small Ball Versus Power (00:23:08) Spencer Jones Versus Grisham

Craig and Big Mac dive into the Yankees' postseason roster decisions, questioning if Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton are healthy enough to contribute in the ALDS. They also recount a socially awkward run-in with Joe Girardi and debate the non-negotiable rules for wedding food and seating. (00:01:00) Celebrity Hygiene Habits (00:04:49) Meeting Joe Girardi (00:07:06) Sonny Gray's Yankee Struggles (00:10:14) Aaron Judge Roster Status (00:14:51) Essential Wedding Rules

Craig Carton discusses the legal battle to save the Jackie Robinson Museum from eviction in downtown Manhattan. He also reveals his decision to miss Boomer Esiason’s Radio Hall of Fame induction to prioritize hosting coverage for the Yankees' upcoming postseason game. (00:02:08) Robinson Museum Eviction Struggle (00:08:43) Prioritizing Yankees Over Boomer (00:14:35) Waiting On Aaron Boone

Analysis covers the Yankees' recent victory, focusing on Trent Grisham's defensive effort and a questionable send by third base coach Luis Rojas. They also examine internal tension within the Red Sox organization and recall the 1997 Knicks-Heat playoff brawl. (00:01:00) Rutgers Ticket Giveaway (00:02:52) WNBA and Knicks Brawl (00:04:48) Grisham’s Lack of Effort (00:08:23) Luis Rojas’ Poor Send

Craig and Big Mac break down a historic Spencer Jones statistic involving two strikeouts and a stolen base in a single inning on The Carton Show. They also share stories from the Yankee Stadium luxury suites and debate the ideal pitching rotation for an upcoming series against the Rays. (00:01:00) Spencer Jones Record Stat (00:04:34) Stadium Suite Experiences (00:08:46) ATVs and Playoff Rotation

Carton and Big Mac investigate the discolored mark on Sonny Gray's neck following the Yankees' sweep of the Red Sox. They criticize Chad Tracy's bullpen management and mock the current downward spiral of Boston sports teams. The conversation shifts to a review of the NBC broadcast team and the frustration surrounding MLB's playoff scheduling. (00:01:00) Sonny Gray Cheating Allegations (00:04:31) Red Sox Bullpen Blunder (00:10:15) Lou Merloni Avoids Carton (00:12:46) Postseason Scheduling And Attendance

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome the owners of Captree Clam Company to announce a new oyster named after the Go Get 'Em podcast following a successful wager. They also analyze the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation and debate whether fans should catch home run balls hit by opposing teams. (00:01:00) Yankee Podcast Oyster Bet (00:05:55) Seafood Website Launch Details (00:10:50) Yankees Postseason Rotation Strategy (00:13:53) Fan Interference Instinct Debate

Mike Tomlin's Minecraft obsession is questioned for its potential impact on his coaching focus and recent playoff drought. Boomer and the crew discuss the New York Yankees' upcoming ALDS, analyzing Aaron Judge's return and the roster implications for players like Giancarlo Stanton. They also examine the team's shift toward successful small-ball tactics in recent games. (00:01:06) Tomlin Minecraft Obsession (00:05:06) Yankees ALDS Strategy (00:09:24) Small Ball Mentality

Craig and Big Mac celebrate the New York Yankees' dominant wild-card sweep of the Boston Red Sox, highlighting the team's improved offensive approach and lights-out starting pitching. They preview the upcoming ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays and debate the wisdom of rushing Aaron Judge back into the lineup. (00:01:19) Yankees Dominance Over Boston (00:06:56) ALDS Pitching Matchups Preview (00:11:45) Football and Judge Updates

FULL SHOW

HOUR 1

HOUR 2

HOUR 3

HOUR 4

HOUR 5

Omar Minaya joins the conversation to discuss how the New York Yankees have built a versatile roster to overcome significant injuries throughout the season. He evaluates Aaron Boone's managerial performance and offers insight into the organization's scouting and player development success. (00:01:00) Yankees Roster and Depth (00:03:23) Evaluating Aaron Boone (00:08:34) Max Fried and Analytics

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to a disgusting viral video of a player during a Red Sox game before debating the pitching rotation for the New York Yankees. They also discuss Craig's potential conflict between a postseason game and Boomer Esiason's Hall of Fame induction ceremony. (00:01:00) Gross Video Reactions (00:07:22) Cole Or Rodón Debate (00:12:37) Boomer Hall Of Fame Conflict

Eduardo Perez breaks down the Yankees' potential sweep of the Red Sox while highlighting Boston's mounting injury concerns. He shares technical hitting insights from his coaching career, including his work with Giancarlo Stanton, and reviews the latest Yankees lineup decisions. (00:01:17) Yankees Sweep Predictions (00:04:03) Baseball Hitting Philosophy (00:09:02) Max Fried Approach (00:12:21) Coaching Giancarlo Stanton (00:15:50) Yankees Lineup Announcement

Harold Reynolds joins to analyze the Yankees' postseason dominance, specifically praising Clarke Schmidt's stamina and the emergence of Ben Rice. He weighs in on the complex usage of Garrett Crochet and Giancarlo Stanton while predicting that New York will officially close out the series tonight. (00:01:00) Harold Reynolds Joins (00:05:02) Jazz Chisholm Discussion (00:08:11) Stanton and Crochet Impact

Big Mac reacts to the Yankees social media team using Robert Saleh's "All Gas, No Brakes" slogan before their playoff matchup. The discussion also covers Andrew Thomas' injury for the New York Giants and the aggressive bullpen management needed to eliminate the Red Sox. (00:01:00) Yankees And Giants Updates (00:03:44) Yankees Slogan Controversy (00:07:00) Fan Rainout Gripe (00:13:07) Bullpen Strategy Discussion

They discuss Josh Hart's revelation that finger surgery would end his career before analyzing the Yankees' playoff performance. The conversation includes predictions for the Game 2 lineup against the Red Sox, a debate over Anthony Volpe's bunting, and details on winning tickets for the Wild Card round. (00:01:00) Josh Hart's Injury Dilemma (00:03:48) Yankees Lineup Bunting Debate (00:07:41) Playoff Tickets TV Appearance

Carton and Big Mac recount the excitement of a Yankees' playoff win and the viral moment of a host pacing nervously on the field-level broadcast. They contrast the New York crowd with disappointing attendance in Houston and Atlanta while analyzing the bullpen strategy used by Aaron Boone. (00:01:00) Stadium Lunch and TV Cameo (00:04:03) MLB Playoff Attendance Issues (00:08:15) Boone Out-Manages the Red Sox

Craig and Big Mac break down the Yankees' Game 1 win over the Red Sox, focusing on Cam Schlittler’s historic performance and Ben Rice’s power. They praise Aaron Boone’s trust in his young starters and highlight the success of the organization's homegrown talent heading into Game 2. (00:01:00) Schlittler and Rice Dominate (00:05:12) Fans Mistake Mound Visit (00:08:31) Managerial Decision Comparisons (00:10:28) Homegrown Talent Success

C-Mac is celebrating LIVE from Yankee Stadium after Cam Schlittler once again owned the Red Sox in playoff action, moving the Bombers to within one win of the ALDS! Chris is joined by Shaun Morash to break down Schlittler's dominance, Ben Rice's big night at the plate, the homegrown youngsters coming through with the bat, and how the Yankees are set up the rest of the series.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTSIntro: Live from Yankee Stadium with initial reactions to the Yankees' 9-0 Wild Card Game 1 shutout over the Red Sox.2:37: Shaun Marash joins the show to praise Cam Schlittler's masterful curveball and his stress-free, 117-pitch performance.7:46: The game breakers - Ben Rice hits two massive home runs, including the grand slam that turned a close game into a laugher.12:50: The "Young Blood" steps up - How homegrown talent like George Lombard Jr. (three hits, two runs), Anthony Volpe, and Spencer Jones powered the lineup.15:03: Roman Anthony's wrist injury and a heavily depleted Red Sox bullpen.27:18: Rickie Ricardo drops by to declare the Red Sox on the ropes and call for a two-game sweep.38:22: Aaron Judge missing from pre-game field introductions, roster decisions, and setting up the rotation for Game 2 against Max Fried.

FULL SHOW

Hour 1

Hour 2

Hour 3

HOUR 4

Craigie and Big Mac break down the Yankees' postseason clash with the Red Sox, predicting a two-game sweep for New York. They discuss the Mets' management failures under Steve Cohen and react to breaking news regarding Anthony Volpe's new representation. (00:01:25) Yankees vs. Red Sox Prep (00:05:07) Mets Leadership Critiques (00:07:08) Unexpected Postseason Heroes (00:10:18) Yankees Series Predictions (00:12:22) Volpe Hires Scott Boras

Emmanuel Berbari joins to discuss the Yankees' Game 1 postseason matchup and the reasoning behind starting Anthony Volpe at second base. He analyzes Aaron Boone's decision to carry 16 position players and how Giancarlo Stanton will be utilized as a pinch hitter. The segment also covers the contrast between the success of New York teams and recent struggles in Philadelphia sports.(00:01:00) New York Philly Rivalry(00:02:43) Emmanuel Berbari Interview(00:03:23) Yankees Lineup Strategy

Suzyn Waldman joins Big Mac to discuss the Yankees' Wild Card roster decisions, specifically why Giancarlo Stanton is active while Aaron Judge remains sidelined. They examine the logic behind starting Anthony Volpe over Jazz Chisholm Jr. and the potential for a low-scoring series against the Red Sox. Waldman also shares concerns about the team's defensive lapses heading into the postseason. (00:01:26) Judge Left Off Roster (00:05:38) Yankees Lineup Decisions (00:10:54) Playoff Defensive Concerns

Yankees play-by-play announcer Dave Sims joins the program at Yankee Stadium to discuss the postseason roster and Anthony Volpe's move to second base. He shares his perspective on the matchup against the Red Sox, reflects on his legendary stories involving Ichiro Suzuki, and looks back at his early career at WFAN as The Soul Man. (00:01:00) Yankees Playoff Roster Analysis (00:04:13) Red Sox Matchup Concerns (00:06:07) Yankees Pitching Rotation Strategy (00:09:41) Memories Of Ichiro Suzuki (00:14:17) Career History At WFAN

Craig and Big Mac break down the New York Yankees starting lineup for Game 1 of the Wild Card series against the Red Sox. They debate the decision to start Anthony Volpe over Jazz Chisholm Jr. and discuss the potential return of Aaron Judge later in the postseason. (00:01:00) Yankees Starting Lineup Guessing (00:03:51) Volpe vs Jazz Debate (00:07:08) Big Mo Calls In (00:09:02) Judge's Postseason Availability (00:13:11) BP and Cake Controversy

Carton and Big Mac analyze the Yankees' decision to leave Aaron Judge off the wildcard roster and whether a series loss could lead to Aaron Boone's firing. They also break down the lineup roles for Anthony Volpe and Jazz Chisholm along with unconventional bullpen strategies. (00:01:00) Yankees Wildcard Roster Debate (00:03:02) Judge's Potential Impact on Boone (00:05:56) Yankees Lineup and Pitching Analysis

Craig and Big Mac emphasize the high expectations for the New York Yankees as they begin their playoff series against the Red Sox. They also discuss the New York Giants' unexpected first-place standing in the NFC East and analyze the team's decision to release Odell Beckham Jr.(00:01:00) Yankees Playoff Mandate(00:03:47) Giants Backup QB Situation(00:04:28) Odell Beckham Jr. Released(00:05:42) Giants Lead NFC East

Craig and Big Mac broadcast live from Yankee Stadium to discuss Aaron Judge missing the Wild Card roster due to a calf strain. They analyze the roster strategy behind carrying sixteen position players and debate Giancarlo Stanton's role in the series against the Red Sox. (00:01:00) Yankee Roster Breakdown (00:07:14) Boone's Managerial Pressure (00:10:25) Stanton's Roster Inclusion

An ugly victory couldn't mask the panic in Big Blue's front office following a season-ending ACL injury to star pass-rusher Brian Burns and a desperation trade for J.J. McCarthy. With Jameis Winston struggling to run the offense and key starters dropping fast, the Giants find themselves treading thin ice as their season descends into high-stakes drama.

Despite an explosive performance from Geno Smith and the offense, a second-half defensive breakdown cost the Jets a signature win in Detroit. From Aaron Glenn’s late-game play-calling to the frustrating two-point analytics debate, we break down every angle of New York’s heart-wrenching loss.

Jevon Holland makes the biggest play of the game in the final seconds of the 4th quarter as the Giants hang on for a 12-7 win over the Titans. Jets lose another close game late, this time in Detroit. Mets 2026 crap show of a season finally comes to an end. The Yankees set their Wild Card rotation. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok

Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Giants' decision to trade for J.J. McCarthy following underwhelming performances from Jameis Winston. They discuss the New York Jets' competitive spirit in their loss to the Lions and the devastating impact of Brian Burns' season-ending ACL injury. The conversation also previews the Yankees' wild card series against the Red Sox and proposes a radical change to NFL officiating. (00:01:50) Giants Trade for J.J. McCarthy (00:08:35) Jets' Performance vs Lions (00:17:30) Winston vs McCarthy Debate (00:45:00) Brian Dawkins Border Controversy (01:02:30) Two-Point Conversion Analytics (01:16:45) NFL Officiating Debate (01:32:30) Brian Burns ACL Confirmation (01:49:20) Drake May Patriots Struggles (02:03:15) Yankees Wild Card Preparation (02:17:45) Monday Night Football Picks

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Giants' decision to trade for J.J. McCarthy on The Carton Show following a lackluster performance by Jameis Winston. They discuss the season-ending injury to Brian Burns and compare the contrasting vibes between Jets and Giants fans. (00:01:41) Giants Trade For McCarthy (00:04:50) Giants Beat Titans Ugly (00:08:15) Jets Show Life In Detroit (00:12:30) Winston's Poor Performance Analyzed (00:18:17) Evaluating Giants Offensive Style (00:21:30) Giants Defensive Concerns Rise (00:25:15) Debate Over McCarthy Potential

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' acquisition of J.J. McCarthy following Jaxson Dart's injury and the subsequent pressure on Jameis Winston. They analyze the Jets' performance and dive into a heated debate over two-point conversion analytics. The duo also reviews coaching mistakes in the Cowboys-Ravens game and proposes a radical "honor code" weekend for NFL officiating. (00:01:26) NFL Dawkins GIF Controversy (00:05:17) JJ McCarthy Giants Trade (00:15:54) Jets Analysis and Analytics (00:16:44) Cowboys Ravens Rio Recap (00:19:45) Drake Maye Performance Critique (00:22:03) NFL No Official Proposal

Analysis covers the season-ending ACL injury to Brian Burns and the disappointing lack of production from the Giants pass rush. They also evaluate the safety concerns regarding MetLife Stadium's turf and review John Harbaugh's decision to start Jameis Winston. (00:01:20) Brian Dawkins Likeness Controversy (00:06:25) Giants Pass Rush Struggles (00:12:33) Harbaugh Backs Jameis Winston (00:20:24) NFL Referee Performance Debate (00:24:26) MetLife Stadium Turf Issues (00:28:24) Brian Burns Injury Analysis

Craig and Big Mac break down a satirical letter from Steve and Alex Cohen before analyzing Breece Hall's week-to-week injury status with the New York Jets. They also debate the Giants' addition of J.J. McCarthy and look ahead to the Yankees' difficult postseason path through the Red Sox and Astros. (00:01:20) Steve Cohen Letter Satire (00:05:15) McGraw Family History Discussion (00:10:30) Yankees Postseason Roster Outlook (00:16:45) SNL And Jalen Brunson (00:20:00) J.J. McCarthy Giants Fit (00:24:15) Vikings Quarterback Trade Reactions (00:28:30) Jets Moral Victory Debate (00:31:45) Yankees Playoff Revenge Path

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Giants' trade for J.J. McCarthy and its impact on the quarterback room during The Carton Show. They examine Aaron Judge's calf strain and his potential return to the Yankees' lineup for the upcoming Red Sox series. The conversation also shifts to the AL MVP race, debating if a pitcher can truly win the award over a dominant hitter like Yordan Alvarez. (00:01:00) J.J. McCarthy Trade (00:08:23) Aaron Judge Injury (00:12:53) Two-Point Strategy Discussion (00:17:20) AL MVP Debate

They analyze Steve Cohen's letter to Mets fans before sharing a personal story from Brian Urlacher about his father. The conversation transitions into a debate over whether Aaron Judge can effectively play in the Wild Card series and an update on Breece Hall's injury. (00:01:36) Steve Cohen Mets Letter (00:04:33) Tim McGraw Correction (00:07:26) Brian Urlacher Father Story (00:12:03) Yankees Wild Card Roster (00:14:34) Breece Hall Injury Update

Craig and Big Mac analyze Drake Maye's struggling start and the Raiders' unexpected 3-0 record. They recap a strange incident involving Travis Hunter and a ball boy before evaluating the Giants' outlook following a significant injury to Jackson Dart. The discussion also covers upcoming betting lines for the Jets and Giants.(00:01:00) Concert Ticket Giveaway(00:02:32) NFL Week 3 Recap(00:08:54) Betting Lines And Giants

Craig Carton and Big Mac dissect Brian Schottenheimer’s coaching blunders before Carton suggests a wild experiment where NFL players call their own penalties. They also touch on Lamar Jackson’s late-game heroics and Drake Maye’s struggling start to the season. (00:01:00) Banter and Silvox Sponsor (00:01:49) Cowboys and Ravens Recap (00:04:40) Drake Maye Performance Review (00:06:42) Ref-Free NFL Weekend Proposal (00:12:21) Stafford and McVay Analysis

Big Mac and Card Show analyze the New York Jets' competitive spirit following a close game against the Detroit Lions on WFAN. They debate the statistical merits of two-point conversion attempts when trailing by multiple scores. Finally, the discussion turns to the New York Giants' acquisition of J.J. McCarthy and its impact on Jameis Winston. (00:01:04) Jets and Giants Recap (00:02:37) Two-Point Analytics Debate (00:10:48) J.J. McCarthy Trade Analysis

The NFL has requested the Department of Homeland Security remove a post featuring Brian Dawkins that used his image to signal border closures. They also discuss the New York Giants' quarterback room as Jameis Winston faces competition from new addition J.J. McCarthy. (00:01:18) NFL Challenges DHS Post (00:05:35) McCarthy Trade Debate (00:09:08) Giants Quarterback Frustrations

Craig describes a unique espresso martini with Parmesan cheese before debating the New York Giants' decision to bring in J.J. McCarthy. They analyze Kevin O'Connell's evaluation of the quarterback and reflect on a lucky victory involving Cam Ward. (00:01:00) College Football & Storm Recap (00:03:07) Parmesan Espresso Martinis (00:05:31) J.J. McCarthy's Giants Future

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a wild Sunday for New York football! The Giants escape with a win over the Tennessee Titans, but their struggles at quarterback lead to a stunning move: trading a fifth-round pick for former Vikings quarterback JJ McCarthy. Is Jameis Winston already losing the Giants' trust? Does JJ McCarthy have a real chance to take over as the starting quarterback? Craig and Big Mac debate what the trade means for the Giants' season and whether the move signals a lack of confidence in Winston.

Big Mac and Carton react on The Carton Show to the New York Giants' trade for J.J. McCarthy after a poor showing from Jameis Winston. They discuss the New York Jets' improvement despite a loss to the Lions and analyze the contrasting reactions of both fan bases. (00:01:26) Jets Competent Football Recap (00:01:43) J.J. McCarthy Trade Impact (00:04:40) Giants Ugly Win Analysis (00:08:04) Jets Optimism vs Giants Frustration

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle side with Aaron Boone when it comes to the discourse surrounding Aaron Judge's return. The two also debate if Judge actually will play in the Wild Card Series against Boston, as the captain insists he plans on playing, while Boone initially said he likely won't. Plus, Evan and Tiki believe Judge is the one who gets to call the shots when it comes to his return. If Judge can't make it back from his calf injury, Tommy Lugauer believes the Yankees can still win a championship without him.

Jaxson Dart's season is done, and for Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, that means the Giants' season is done. Tiki Barber makes it clear that he does NOT feel the same, ripping any Giants fans for quitting after two games and one bad injury. Plus, Boomer and Gio discuss how expectations have changed for Big Blue, Connor Hughes joins Evan and Tiki right when the Dart news broke, and Pat Leonard of the Daily News joined The Carton Show and called out John Harbaugh and the Giants for how they handled the Dart injury updates.

From ‘Go Get ‘Em’ (Subscribe Here): Aaron Judge intends to play in the Wild Card Series, which is a far cry from Aaron Boone's previous comments. Is there a miscommunication between the manager and the captain? C-Mac has some strong thoughts on Judge's approach to his own injury updates, if he should try to push it and play against Boston, and whether the Yankees would be better off without Judge at less than 100 percent. Meanwhile, Clarke Schmidt is no longer a Wild Card Series option due to a biceps injury. Is the Yankee bullpen strong enough for a playoff run? Plus, debating what the series against the Rays potentially showed in terms of who deserves what role in the playoffs.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS1:25 - Bright spots from the recent series, focusing on Carlos Rodon's strong start and Lombard's impressive defensive and offensive output.9:40 - The Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone disconnect: Analyzing Judge's frustration over Boone publicly detailing his "moderate" calf strain.26:01 - The playoff lineup dilemma: Debating the risks of playing an injured Judge versus relying on Ben Rice or Paul Goldschmidt against left-handed pitching.31:41 - Evaluating potential postseason roster returns for Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham as late-game pinch-hit options.33:04 - The argument for leaving Ryan McMahon off the playoff roster despite his recent grand slam and five-RBI game.39:57 - Wild Card rotation strategy: Weighing whether Cam Schlittler or Max Fried should take the mound for Game 1.57:51 - Bullpen concerns mount as Clarke Schmidt hits the 15-day IL with biceps tendinitis, exposing the front office's failure to acquire relief help at the deadline.1:09:37 - Defending Aaron Boone's managerial performance and the team's achievement of winning 92 games despite Judge missing three months of the season.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle address the backlash surrounding the New York Yankees' decision to reschedule CC Sabathia's honoring ceremony due to a major storm. They debate the merits of various postseason pitching rotations and review NFL Week 2 results. The conversation also explores a recent investigation into Tim Tebow and includes personal anecdotes about high school athletics. (00:01:55) Sabathia Ceremony Controversy (00:10:55) NFL Week 2 Reaction (00:17:10) Postseason Rotation Debate (00:27:20) Tim Tebow Investigation News (00:14:20) High School Sports Memories (00:10:45) NFL Week 3 Picks

The Carton Show addresses the controversy surrounding the New York Yankees rescheduling CC Sabathia's jersey retirement due to an impending storm. They criticize fans for prioritizing bobbleheads over public safety and debate whether Clarke Schmidt should start Game 1 of the playoffs against the Red Sox. (00:01:25) CC Sabathia Ceremony Changes (00:04:36) Fan Safety vs Bobbleheads (00:10:23) NFL Week 2 Reactions (00:13:53) Yankees Ticket Policy Explained (00:17:11) Playoff Pitching Rotation Debate (00:25:15) Red Sox Pitching Matchups

Craig and Big Mac engage in a fiery debate over the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation, specifically whether Max Fried or Cam Schlittler should start Game 1. They also honor CC Sabathia's legacy at Yankee Stadium and discuss iconic music moments involving Prince, Tom Petty, and the history of sketch comedy. (00:01:29) CC Sabathia Ceremony (00:04:40) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:08:00) Playoff Bye Analysis (00:13:10) Iconic Guitar Solos (00:18:00) Sketch Comedy History (00:22:10) Yankee Rotation Logic (00:25:45) Defending Rotation Arguments

They discuss the cancellation of the AC/DC concert at MetLife Stadium and how severe weather conditions might force a postponement of the upcoming Giants game. The conversation also covers the team's quarterback depth, debunking rumors of a trade for Shedeur Sanders, and stories of rejecting famous guests like Meghan Markle. (00:01:40) TV Cameos and Rock Legends (00:05:55) Disney World vs Concierge Medicine (00:09:25) AC/DC MetLife Concert Canceled (00:15:35) Rejecting Markle and Bieber (00:22:20) Honoring New York's Bravest (00:28:05) Happy Days and TV History (00:34:25) Shedeur Sanders Trade Rumors (00:42:25) Giants Quarterback Depth Analysis

Craig Carton and Big Mac question why Tim Tebow was the primary face of a fraud investigation into LifeSurge despite other high-profile athletes being involved. They also break down upcoming NFL matchups for the Jets and Giants while sharing nostalgic stories about their high school sports careers. (00:01:32) LifeSurge Investigation Analysis (00:05:08) Allegations Against Tim Tebow (00:09:15) NFL Weekend Odds Breakdown (00:14:17) High School Sports Stories (00:18:23) Broadcasting From Yankee Stadium (00:23:44) Giants And Jets Analysis (00:10:10) Weekly NFL Picks Segment

Craig Carton describes his early morning visit to a legendary FDNY firehouse and the respect he has for the speed and bravery of firefighters. He and Big Mac then discuss the career trajectories of the Friends cast before analyzing rumors surrounding the Giants and Shedeur Sanders. They also reflect on Kevin Stefanski’s leadership following a powerful speech described by Bijan Robinson. (00:01:00) FDNY Firehouse Visit (00:07:20) Friends Cast Career Debates (00:15:47) Giants Trade Rumors (00:23:30) Stefanski's Moving Team Speech

Craig Carton recounts his cameo on the television series Royal Pains and explains the high-end world of concierge medicine. Discussion turns to the last-minute cancellation of the AC/DC concert at MetLife Stadium and how severe wind warnings might affect the New York Giants. They also reflect on past booking decisions, including turning down future stars Meghan Markle and Justin Bieber. (00:01:50) Finding TV Through TikTok (00:03:32) Cameo on Royal Pains (00:06:28) Disney World VIP Experience (00:09:15) AC/DC Concert Cancellation News (00:16:52) Rejecting Markle and Bieber

Craig and Big Mac reminisce about iconic music moments, including Prince's legendary solo and Big Mac's own musical theater past. They also debate the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation with callers and pay tribute to the career of CC Sabathia. (00:01:07) Iconic Guitar Solos (00:04:20) Host Musical History (00:08:15) Bobbleheads and Plagiarism (00:12:13) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:15:55) CC Sabathia Tribute

They debate the pitching rotation for the wild card series, specifically focusing on whether Max Fried or Cam Schlittler should take the mound for Game 1. They also discuss George Harrison's post-Beatles success and the ethics of ordering food delivery during an impending major storm. (00:01:00) George Harrison Discussion (00:03:43) MLB Postseason Stats (00:08:04) Game 1 Pitching Debate

Kickoff with Boomer Valenti: The Chiefs Dynasty is back, the Packers and Chargers might stink, and Jaxson Dart's season is over. The guys give their Week 3 picks and wrap up with a game of "QB or HC"

Big Mac and a caller clash over the Yankees' postseason rotation strategy and whether Cam Schlittler belongs in Game 1. They examine the historical success of Wild Card teams and discuss CC Sabathia's impact ahead of his stadium ceremony. The conversation also previews the Giants' upcoming matchup against the Titans. (00:01:27) Sabathia's Yankee Ceremony (00:03:40) Yankees Wild Card Rotation (00:08:02) Wild Card Success Stats (00:11:41) Rotation Strategy And Pressure (00:16:47) Giants vs Titans Preview

Craig and Big Mac address the New York Yankees' decision to reschedule CC Sabathia's ceremony on The Carton Show while criticizing fans frustrated by a shifted giveaway. They transition into a debate regarding the playoff pitching hierarchy and preview the New York Giants' upcoming game against the Titans. (00:01:00) CC Sabathia Day Update (00:02:30) Bobblehead Backlash Rant (00:08:34) Fan Call On Storm (00:11:00) Yankees Pitching Rotation Debate (00:15:29) Giants Titans Game Preview

They examine the scheduling changes for CC Sabathia's ceremony and the resulting ticket exchange options for fans. The conversation also covers a debate over the Yankees' postseason pitching strategy and previews upcoming NFL matchups for the Giants and Jets. (00:01:25) Sabathia Ceremony Schedule (00:04:01) Yankees Playoff Rotation Strategy (00:10:02) Yankees PR and NFL Preview

Craig Carton and Big Mac address the backlash regarding the New York Yankees rescheduling CC Sabathia's ceremony in light of an impending natural disaster. They also discuss Bijan Robinson's standout performance for the Falcons and a potential pitching rotation shift for the upcoming series against the Red Sox. (00:01:14) Yankees Storm Rescheduling (00:04:37) Fan Frustration and Refunds (00:08:16) CC Sabathia's Rescheduling Input (00:10:24) NFL Recap and Bijan Robinson (00:11:37) Yankees Pitching Rotation Debate

Craig and Big Mac discuss the growing tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone regarding Judge's calf injury and wild-card availability. They also analyze the New York Giants' outlook after a season-ending injury to the starting quarterback and compare local rosters. (00:02:42) Judge Boone Injury Conflict (00:11:10) Kuzmenko Father Bear Attack (00:16:41) Hostin Juror Story Fraud (00:21:23) Giants Jets Roster Debate (00:25:11) Teaching Gallo Bike Riding (00:31:03) Tebow Charity Allegations

Craig and Big Mac analyze the tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone over the captain's calf injury and playoff status. They debate whether Judge’s secrecy regarding his health is selfish while also comparing his injury history to Giancarlo Stanton's frequent setbacks. The conversation shifts to Craig’s viral banana video, a fact-check of Sonny Hostin, and a radio ratings prank. (00:01:20) Weather And Sports Updates (00:04:45) Judge And Boone Tension (00:08:58) Judge Playoff Roster Debate (00:13:45) Viral Content And Urlacher (00:17:00) Sonny Hostin Jury Lie (00:20:48) Judge Injury History Debate (00:25:15) Judge Versus Stanton Comparison (00:30:45) Radio Ratings Prank Story

Craig and Big Mac react to the shocking news that Morgan Wallen received zero CMA nominations before diving into the New York Giants' injury crisis. They debate the team's viability with Jameis Winston and criticize Kurt Warner for his comments regarding Jayden Daniels' toughness. The duo also discusses a bizarre hockey tragedy and mocks Gallo for his inability to ride a bicycle. (00:01:20) Morgan Wallen Snub (00:05:30) Giants Injury Updates (00:09:30) Giants Season Debate (00:14:45) Kurt Warner Comments (00:10:50) Andrei Kuzmenko Tragedy (00:14:20) Shaka Salamander Revenge (00:19:45) Madden Movie Trailer (00:23:00) Gallo Bicycle Mockery

Craig Carton and Big Mac debate why the Jets currently boast a superior roster over the Giants following the injury to Jaxson Dart. They blast the NFL for imposing heavy fines on celebratory demonstrations while simultaneously promoting alcohol and gambling sponsors. The discussion also covers Yankees postseason updates and a high-stakes bet regarding New York football supremacy. (00:01:20) Teaching Big Mac to Bike (00:04:15) Jets vs. Giants Roster Debate (00:08:50) Criticizing New York Football Coaching (00:14:45) Ridiculous NFL Celebration Fines (00:18:05) Yankees Weather and Stanton News (00:21:25) High-Stakes Win Total Bet (00:23:55) New York's Best Bagel Spots (00:26:50) Big Mac's Weight Loss Journey

The crew analyzes the plummeting ticket prices for the upcoming New York Giants game and evaluates potential quarterback replacements after Jaxson Dart's injury. They also critique the state of NFL pregame shows and defend Tim Tebow against recent investigative allegations. (00:01:20) Falcons Primetime Woes (00:04:20) Giants Ticket Price Analysis (00:10:29) Giants Quarterback Future (00:15:15) NFL Media Show Critique (00:19:43) NBA Personal Life Controversies (00:28:31) Tim Tebow Charity Investigation (00:16:29) Jaxson Dart Injury Status (00:22:40) Strange Culinary Discussions (00:26:56) Iconic Football Moments

McMonigle (Big Mac) analyzes the devastating impact of Jaxson Dart's season-ending injury on the New York Giants and the team's pivot to Jameis Winston. He also discusses the New York Yankees' postseason pitching rotation and the upcoming CC Sabathia number retirement ceremony. (00:03:44) Giants Season Without Dart (00:10:52) Yankees Doubleheader Update (00:14:20) Yankees Rotation Dilemma (00:17:44) Hall of Fame Debate (00:15:53) Big Mac NFL Picks

Gregg Popovich’s marriage to the ex-wife of his former assistant sparks a debate over social etiquette and the ‘guy code.’ They also dive into rock history with surprising facts about the Beatles and Eric Clapton. The conversation shifts to defending Tim Tebow’s character following investigative reports from Pablo Torre regarding charitable ties. (00:01:17) Packers Injury Problems (00:02:00) Popovich Marries Budenholzer's Ex (00:06:43) Beatles Facts And Gossip (00:10:50) Torre Investigates Tim Tebow (00:17:47) Yankees And Judge Update

Carton and the crew analyze the fallout from Jaxson Dart's injury and the impact on New York Giants ticket prices, which have plummeted for the upcoming Titans matchup. They explore potential quarterback replacements like Jimmy Garoppolo and critique the current state of NFL pregame shows. (00:01:00) Falcons Primetime Scheduling Issues (00:04:32) Giants Ticket Prices Plummet (00:11:34) Jaxson Dart Injury Concerns (00:14:13) Giants Quarterback Search (00:16:19) Critiquing The NFL Today

A heated debate breaks out on WFAN regarding whether the Jets or Giants currently possess a better roster following key injuries. They also critique John Harbaugh's recent coaching performance and analyze the Giants' chances of reaching seven wins with a backup quarterback. (00:01:05) Learning To Ride A Bike (00:03:46) Jets Vs Giants Roster Debate (00:07:47) Giants Backup QB Outlook (00:08:59) John Harbaugh Coaching Critique (00:14:37) Yankees Wild Card Concerns

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to a bizarre report regarding Andrei Kuzmenko’s father before Carton recounts a childhood revenge story involving his pet salamander. They also critique Nicolas Cage’s performance as John Madden and debate the future of the New York Giants season. (00:01:00) Andrei Kuzmenko Bear Story (00:04:33) Revenge for the Salamander (00:06:49) Nicolas Cage John Madden (00:09:45) Gallo's Biking Struggles (00:14:20) Giants Quarterback Concerns

Chris McMonigle reacts to Tiki Barber, Evan Roberts, and Sean Morash suggesting Giants fans move on from devastating injury news. The discussion also covers Clark Schmidt's move to the injured list and the perceived friction between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone. (00:01:00) Giants Fan Mentality Debate (00:07:46) John Harbaugh Photo Discussion (00:08:56) Yankees News And Friction

Craig reacts to the backlash from Giants fans after a video of him smiling during news of the team's latest injuries was posted against his wishes. They also discuss Morgan Wallen's lack of CMA nominations and critique Kurt Warner’s comments on Jayden Daniels' toughness. (00:01:01) Morgan Wallen Snub (00:05:11) Giants Video Controversy (00:09:07) Giants Season Outlook (00:14:29) Warner Critiques Daniels

Carton and C-Mac discuss the viral story of Sunny Hostin allegedly fabricating her role as a juror in a high-profile murder trial. The debate moves to the New York Yankees, specifically evaluating Aaron Judge's injury history and whether his physical frame makes him inherently prone to health issues. They also touch on the team's postseason legacy and a lighthearted prank involving show ratings. (00:01:00) Sunny Hostin's Jury Lie (00:06:21) Aaron Judge Injury Debate (00:12:21) Judge's World Series Legacy (00:14:38) Ratings and Radio Pranks (00:16:15) Giants Quarterback Update

Craig and Big Mac debate the likelihood of Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees' lineup for Tuesday's game amidst concerns over his calf strain. They analyze the tension between Judge and Aaron Boone regarding injury transparency while reflecting on Craig's bizarre viral banana video and a recent chat with Brian Urlacher. (00:01:11) Craig's Viral Banana Video (00:02:51) Brian Urlacher's Hair Plugs (00:04:27) Aaron Judge Injury Drama (00:13:12) Yankees Starting Lineup Dilemma

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the public tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone regarding Judge's calf injury and playoff availability. They also look ahead to Jameis Winston's debut for the New York Giants and the impact of a looming Nor'easter on local sports attendance. (00:01:07) Weather Impacts Local Sports (00:02:13) Judge and Boone Clash (00:11:12) Jameis Winston’s Giants Debut

Carton and Big Mac react to the devastating news that quarterback Jaxson Dart will undergo season-ending surgery for multiple knee injuries. They debate whether Jameis Winston can salvage the season or if the organization should embrace a full tanking strategy for the upcoming draft. The discussion also features a parody song about Joe Schoen and a bizarre story involving an encounter with Albert Pujols.(00:01:50) Jaxson Dart Facing Surgery(00:05:40) Debating The Tanking Strategy(00:09:55) Giants Communication Criticized(00:15:45) Jameis Winston Takes Over(00:20:35) Joe Schoen Parody Song(00:26:40) Kaepernick Rumors Dismissed(00:30:15) Dangerous Studio Social Threats(00:35:50) Organizational Tanking Debate(00:42:45) Albert Pujols Urinal Story(00:47:15) Harbaugh On Playoff Hopes

Craig Carton and Tommy Lugauer react to the news that Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart will undergo season-ending knee surgery. They discuss Jameis Winston taking over the offense, debate the merits of a 'tank-a-thon' for draft picks, and criticize the organization's lack of transparency with its fans. (00:01:22) Jaxson Dart Season Ending (00:05:01) Giants Tanking Strategy Discussion (00:09:22) Support For The Fanbase (00:14:35) Quarterback Recovery Timelines (00:18:22) Organizational Secrecy And Reports (00:11:58) Running Game Effectiveness Concerns (00:17:25) Determining The Tank Threshold (00:20:45) Comparing Dart And Burrow

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss Jameis Winston taking the reins for the New York Giants following a devastating injury to Jaxson Dart. They critique GM Joe Schoen's performance through a parody song, debate the merits of tanking for a top draft pick, and address rumors regarding a potential Colin Kaepernick signing. The conversation also highlights the lack of playoff football at MetLife Stadium and the current dynamic between Jets and Giants fans. (00:01:20) Peter Joins The Team (00:04:25) Winston Named Starting Quarterback (00:08:45) Giants Postseason Outlook (00:12:35) Comparing Giants And Jets (00:19:54) Joe Schoen Parody Song (00:23:03) Colin Kaepernick Rumors Dismissed (00:26:40) Debate Over Team Tanking (00:16:45) Andrew Thomas Injury Update (00:24:30) Jets Fans Classy Behavior

A physical therapist provides insight into Jaxson Dart's knee injury and the recovery timeline for the young quarterback. The conversation explores whether Dart can emulate the career trajectories of Joe Burrow or Matthew Stafford after early-career setbacks. Additional segments cover the New York Yankees' rotation plans and a humorous encounter with Albert Pujols. (00:01:20) Yankees Playoff Roster Decisions (00:05:06) Giants Injury Report Update (00:08:33) Analyzing Jaxson Dart's Knee (00:12:30) Giants Quarterback Comparison Debate (00:18:42) Music and Alternative Medicine (00:21:40) Meeting Albert Pujols (00:25:05) Storm Impact on Sports (00:28:10) Mets Hire Andy Green

Craig and Big Mac analyze the confusion surrounding John Harbaugh's updates on Jackson Dart's knee surgery and Jameis Winston's elevation to the starting role. They debate the feasibility of Dart returning for a potential postseason run while critiquing the Giants' transparency regarding the injury's severity. Discussions also include the New York Jets' road game against the Detroit Lions and the curious treatment of rookie Jaden Daniels by his teammates in Washington. (00:01:25) Jackson Dart's Surgery Update (00:05:30) Winston Named Starting Quarterback (00:08:50) Personal Life and Recovery (00:13:15) Harbaugh's Bizarre Playoff Hope (00:17:45) Analyzing Harbaugh's Press Conference (00:27:15) Jets and Lions Outlook (00:33:40) Jaden Daniels Injury Reaction (00:41:10) Road Trip Per Diems

The Carton Show discusses the New York Mets' decision to quickly hire Andy Green and shares a story about meeting Albert Pujols in a restroom. He and the callers shift focus to the New York Giants, debating whether Jaxson Dart is a legitimate franchise quarterback. They compare Dart's career trajectory to stars like Joe Burrow and Matthew Stafford.(00:01:15) Mets Hire Andy Green(00:02:58) Meeting Albert Pujols(00:09:24) Yankees Injury Updates(00:12:44) Jaxson Dart Debate(00:18:54) Giants Draft Outlook

Craig Carton evaluates how an impending storm will force the New York Giants to rely on their running game against the Tennessee Titans. He also analyzes the MLB Wild Card race and explains why he considers the Toronto Blue Jays to be "frauds" yet again. (00:01:04) Music And Celebrity Talk (00:04:22) Dunkin’ Black Card Issues (00:06:50) New York Cleveland Rivalry (00:08:40) Weekend Weather Forecast (00:11:42) Blue Jays Frauds Discussion

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to the official news of Jaxson Dart's multi-ligament knee injury and its impact on the Giants. They also evaluate the New York Yankees' roster moves and pitching rotation following their elimination from the division title race. (00:01:00) Yankees Division Elimination Reactions (00:05:04) Giants Practice Injury Report (00:09:31) Analyzing Jaxson Dart's Injury (00:13:43) NY's Most Devastating Injuries

The Carton Show evaluates the New York Giants' handling of recent injuries and the resulting misinformation from leadership regarding the severity of those setbacks. The conversation also covers the decade-long playoff drought at MetLife Stadium and whether Jets fans are actually behaving with class toward their rivals.(00:01:15) Giants Injury News(00:06:32) MetLife Playoff History(00:10:16) Jet Fans Showing Class

Craig and Chris McMonigle dismiss rumors regarding Colin Kaepernick joining the Giants while navigating a heated debate with a caller about Joe Burrow's injury history. They also address disturbing social media threats directed at the studio and discuss the philosophical divide between fans and players when it comes to tanking for high draft picks like Jeremiah Smith. (00:02:14) Giants Quarterback Discussions (00:06:42) Addressing Studio Threats (00:10:03) The Philosophy of Tanking

Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' bleak outlook following Jaxson Dart's injury and the transition to Jameis Winston as the starting quarterback. They also analyze the team's defensive struggles, upcoming coin-toss games, and the potential impact of losing key players like Andrew Thomas and Brian Burns. (00:01:00) New Producer and LA Trip (00:04:16) Jameis Winston Takes Over (00:07:41) Giants Irrelevance and Draft (00:13:12) Yankees and Giants Comparison (00:18:19) Injury Updates and Outlook

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to news that New York Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart requires season-ending surgery. During the Carton Show, they evaluate Jameis Winston's potential as a replacement and debate if the team should begin tanking for a top draft pick. (00:01:02) Jaxson Dart Injury Reaction (00:05:12) Giants Tanking Debate (00:08:40) Joe Burrow Comparison

Discussions center on the season-ending knee injury for quarterback Jaxson Dart and the resulting offensive shift to Jameis Winston. They also criticize the Giants organization for poor communication with the fan base following the news leak. (00:01:00) Jaxson Dart Injury Analysis (00:03:19) Jameis Winston Offensive Outlook (00:06:20) Giants Organizational Transparency Issues

Carton and Big Mac react to the devastating news that New York Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart will undergo surgery for multiple knee injuries. They debate whether Jameis Winston can keep the team competitive or if the franchise should pivot toward tanking for a high draft pick. (00:01:00) Jaxson Dart Injury News (00:04:19) Giants Draft Tanking Debate (00:09:13) Carton Supports Giants Fans

Following a crushing loss to the Rams, the Giants are spiraling after news breaks that quarterback Jaxson Dart may need season-ending knee surgery. As Jameis Winston takes the reins, the hosts clash over whether John Harbaugh and the front office lied to fans about the severity of the injury.

Carton and Big Mac React to the worst Monday ever for the New York Giants.

Carton and Big Mac react to a terrible Monday Night Football showing for the Giants

Carton and Big Mac wonder why there were conflicting messages about Dart coming out of the Giants organization

Carton and Big Mac wonder if after another injury, whether Dart is still the guy for Big Blue. They also react to the Mets shocking move.

Tiki Joins Carton and Big Mac as they pick up the pieces of a potentially lost season

Tiki Barber joins the Carton Show to break down the fallout from Jaxson Dart's significant knee injury and the challenges facing the Giants with Jameis Winston under center. He discusses the necessary adjustments for the offense and the defensive line's lack of pressure heading into a matchup with the Titans.(00:01:00) Tiki Barber Joins(00:01:51) Dart's Knee Injury(00:05:56) Winston Takes Over(00:11:09) Team Injury Morale(00:18:27) Titans Matchup Outlook

The Giants' season appears to be in jeopardy following news that Jaxson Dart's year is likely done due to a significant knee injury. Potential replacements like Anthony Richardson and Russell Wilson are weighed as the conversation shifts toward whether the franchise should prioritize a high draft pick for the future.(00:01:00) New York Sports Curse(00:02:55) Quarterback Replacement Options(00:07:53) Searching For Backups(00:12:05) Fan Frustration(00:14:12) Giants Tanking Strategy

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to reports that Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart likely faces a season-ending MCL injury. They debate the team's lack of viable alternatives and dismiss fan theories about trading for superstars like Joe Burrow.(00:01:00) Jaxson Dart Injury Analysis(00:04:56) Giants Season Silver Lining(00:08:17) QB Trade Proposals Debate(00:10:41) Giants Season Ends Early

Craig and Big Mac react to news that Jaxson Dart's injury is more severe than initially reported. Pat Leonard joins to discuss John Harbaugh's vague updates and the organization's lack of transparency regarding the injury. They also analyze the poor performance of backup Jameis Winston as the team faces a devastating blow to their season.(00:01:00) Jaxson Dart Injury Update(00:04:49) Pat Leonard Interview(00:09:42) Jameis Winston's Poor Play

The Giants are reeling from reports that Jaxson Dart might need season-ending surgery, leaving Jameis Winston as the primary option at quarterback. Chris McMonigle and his co-host clash over John Harbaugh's refusal to provide medical updates and Joe Schoen's conflicting statements from the previous night. They analyze the impact on the fan base and the lack of depth behind Winston as the season hangs in the balance. (00:01:00) Jaxson Dart Injury News (00:04:31) NFC East QB Comparison (00:06:04) Giants Organizational Leaks (00:09:25) Fans Right To Know (00:13:45) Harbaugh Transparency Debate

Craig and Big Mac break down the New York Giants' demoralizing loss to the Rams, focusing on Jaxson Dart's knee injury and Jameis Winston's ineffective relief appearance. They criticize John Harbaugh's coaching decisions regarding personnel and clock management while questioning if the team can bounce back against the Titans.(00:01:00) Jaxson Dart Injury Analysis(00:05:36) Harbaugh Coaching Decisions(00:10:54) Titans Preview And Reaction

The Carton Show reacts to the Jaxson Dart injury news.

Craig and Big Mac evaluate Jameis Winston’s poor performance following Jaxson Dart’s injury and the Giants' defensive collapse against the Rams. They debate the impact of Joe Schoen's roster decisions and the team's disappearing pass rush. They also highlight the Jets' move to sign Will Levis and discuss the Giants' upcoming schedule against the Titans and Cardinals. (00:01:00) Jameis Winston Struggles (00:06:32) Giants Pass Rush Failures (00:10:45) Jets Sign Will Levis (00:13:42) Giants Season Outlook

Tune in for a selection of Monday's conversations about Gang Green's gutting defeat at the hands of the Green Bay Packers in Week 2. Boomer and Gio lament how the Jets let a probable win slip away in the fourth quarter, while Evan and Tiki express their disappointment that the defense's dominant effort was squandered. Last, but not least, Craig blasts head coach Aaron Glenn's late-game decision-making: 'He cost us a W!' All that and more ...

What is going on with the Yankee captain? Chris McMonigle breaks it all down as well as the series in Arizona and the playoff picture.

Craig and C-Mac kick off their Monday show by talking about the Jets 20-17 OT loss to the Packers on Sunday. The boys also talk about the Giants-Rams MNF game, big storylines coming out of week 2 in the NFL, a possible September nor'easter, top comedians of all time and more!

Craig and C-Mac open up the Monday show by talking about the Jets crushing 20-17 loss to the Packers in overtime on Sunday. Who is to blame, reasons behind it and if this is really surprising result are discussed!

The boys react to Aaron Glenn not taking accountability following the team's 20-17 OT loss to the Packers on Sunday. They also talk about the potential impacts to the MLB Postseason that a nor'easter could have this weekend.

Craig and C-Mac go around the league and chat about the big storylines coming out of Week 2 in the NFL. They also discuss top stand-up comedians of all time and debate European geography.

Craig and C-Mac continue the Jets conversation, including Craig coining the phrase that the Jets are "good enough to win and bad enough to lose". The boys also discuss whether next week's Giants -Titans matchup is a trap game for Big Blue.

Craig Carton critiques Nate Burleson's wardrobe choice on CBS, labeling the suit shorts a "clown show" intended to grab attention. A debate follows between Carton and Chris McMonigle regarding the geographic differences between England and the United Kingdom before they pivot to NFL quarterback evaluations. (00:01:47) Burleson Wardrobe Critique (00:05:43) UK Geography Debate (00:08:44) NFL Quarterback Analysis

Carton and Big Mac analyze the Giants' keys to victory against the Rams, emphasizing the importance of a dominant ground game. They also critique Lamar Jackson’s late-game interception in the Ravens' loss to the Saints and debate Jerry Seinfeld's legacy as a stand-up comedian. (00:01:00) Giants vs. Rams Preview (00:05:06) Ravens and Lamar Jackson Critique (00:10:34) Seinfeld Stand-Up Comedy Debate

This Carton Show discussion explores how a looming Nor'easter might force the Red Sox into a doubleheader, potentially giving the Yankees an advantage in the postseason. They also analyze the Jets' fourth-quarter collapse and debate the merits of various diet sodas.(00:01:00) Presley Gerber Passing(00:02:25) Nor'easter Impacts MLB Seeding(00:06:05) Diet Soda Debate(00:08:32) Jets' Fourth-Quarter Collapse(00:13:24) Catchphrases And Endorsements

Analysis of the New York Jets centers on the disconnect between a strong defense and questionable offensive play-calling. They debate the logic behind using shotgun formations in short-yardage situations while evaluating Geno Smith's performance under center. The discussion concludes with a look at upcoming point spreads for Week 3 matchups involving the Lions and Dolphins. (00:01:01) Jets Defensive Performance (00:03:24) Geno Smith Assessment (00:06:14) Shotgun Formation Debate (00:11:17) Week 3 Betting Lines

Aaron Rodgers faces criticism for his passive-aggressive leadership style after publicly questioning the coaching staff's play-calling following a Jets defeat. The discussion also covers late-game mismanagement by the coaching staff and a preview of the Giants' upcoming matchup against the Rams. (00:01:22) Rodgers Critiques Jets Coaching (00:04:37) Jets Fan Sharing Misery (00:06:45) Jets Strategy Failures (00:11:53) Youth Football Coaching Issues (00:15:11) Giants vs. Rams Preview

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Jets' recent struggles, specifically targeting the coaching of Aaron Glenn and Frank Reich. They also discuss Geno Smith's cautious playstyle and address controversial comments made by reporter Ralph Vacchiano. (00:01:01) Jets Coaching Critique (00:05:19) Geno Smith Debate (00:09:22) Vacchiano Tweet Controversy

Craig and C-Mac dissect the New York Jets' recent loss, focusing on the glaring lack of communication between the coaching staff. They criticize the decision-making regarding clock management and the aggressive vs. conservative play-calling in critical moments. The discussion also touches on the team's overtime strategy and the impact of these recurring issues on the locker room morale. (00:01:10) Jets Loss Analysis (00:03:21) Clock Management Failures (00:05:44) Overtime Strategy Debate (00:09:51) Fan Reaction Segment (00:13:03) Coaching Communication Issues

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the Carton Show by breaking down the New York Jets’ crushing overtime loss to the Green Bay Packers — and Craig is putting the blame squarely on the coaching staff.

Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to give his take on Jaxson Dart making the leap in year two after a promising Week 1 performance. Plus, Evan Roberts says fans should embrace the optimism from Week 1 and believe that both New York teams could be on the rise. The Evan and Tiki crew wonder if Tyrone Tracy's job is at risk if he struggles again in Week 2, while Gio believes both the Giants and Jets are catching their Week 2 opponents at just the right time.

Pete Alonso returned to Queens this week, and it brought about PLENTY of debates. Gio says Alonso hitting his 300th career home run to tie the game in the ninth for the Orioles, and getting a curtain call as a visiting player afterward, cemented 2026 as the most embarrassing season in Mets history. Plus, KFC Barstool called in to Boomer and Gio to rip Sean Manaea for criticizing Mets fans for calling for that curtain call. Tiki Barber called out Manaea as well, while Evan sounded off on Alonso for taking the curtain call. On The Carton Show, Craig and C-Mac debate how David Stearns must feel about Alonso's return, and how it might impact Steve Cohen's thought process about the future.

Craig and Big Mac react to the shocking news that Aaron Judge is heading to the IL with a calf strain, casting a shadow over the Yankees' postseason run. They also preview the Jets' pivotal matchup with the Packers and address heated caller feedback regarding their on-air dynamic. (00:01:55) Football Friday Kickoff (00:05:45) Bills Offensive Dominance (00:09:20) Knicks Mantra Discussion (00:16:00) Jets Whiteout Debate (00:22:25) Bullying Allegations Clash (00:34:05) Aaron Judge Injury (00:45:55) Yankees Postseason Outlook

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Jets' potential for a 2-0 start as they prepare for a rainy matchup against the Green Bay Packers. They analyze the dominance of the Buffalo Bills and debate whether the Jets' success is being overlooked compared to the Giants. The conversation also explores Craig’s 'What Would the Knicks Do' mindset and the origins of Lorna Doone cookies. (00:01:20) Football Friday Opening (00:04:36) Bills Dominant Performance (00:08:22) Knicks Winning Philosophy (00:12:30) Morning Show Redux (00:17:13) Jets Whiteout Uniforms (00:20:20) Jets Versus Giants Debate (00:24:00) Shortbread Cookie History

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Jets' outlook against the Green Bay Packers and the potential impact of rain on the stadium's whiteout event. They also address a heated caller's accusations of on-air bullying and share their reactions to recent viral moments from Mina Kimes and Pat McAfee. (00:01:35) Jets Packers Whiteout Preview (00:06:10) Giants and Cowboys Analysis (00:09:45) Show Weather Reporter Search (00:15:30) NFL Week 2 Predictions (00:21:45) Confronting Bullying Accusations (00:28:20) Pat McAfee ESPN Reaction

Craig Carton and C-Mac reflect on the last time the New York Jets started a season 2-0 while debating whether Geno Smith can lead them to victory against the Packers. They also dive into a heated discussion regarding UB40 cover songs and critique the Buffalo Bills for playing the Canadian national anthem. The conversation concludes with Giants injury updates and a comparison between collegiate and professional male cheerleaders. (00:01:00) Jets 2-0 History (00:07:49) UB40 Song Debate (00:13:35) NFL Male Cheerleaders (00:17:10) Giants Injury News (00:20:59) Canadian Anthem Critique

Craig and C-Mac react to breaking news that Aaron Judge is heading to the 10-day injured list with a calf strain. They explore the Yankees' path forward through the postseason, the building mojo surrounding the Jets, and the financial success of the Knicks' playoff run. (00:01:25) Judge Injury Speculation (00:05:35) Lifestyles And 80s Stars (00:11:48) Knicks Revenue Windfall (00:15:55) Jets Momentum Building (00:19:10) Eileen On Resident Rights (00:26:10) ALS United Walk (00:31:24) Breaking Judge IL News (00:39:05) Postseason Pitching Strategy

The boys get an update on Aaron Judge's injury and Chris McMonigle has a hard time keeping it together live on air.

Carton and Chris McMonigle celebrate a potential 2-0 start for the New York Jets and revisit the team's last success in 2015. They handle a confrontational caller regarding masculinity in sports radio before exploring the surprising origins of the song "Red Red Wine" and debating the athletic merits of collegiate male cheerleaders. (00:01:00) Jets 2-0 History (00:04:45) Masculinity and Bullying Debate (00:08:44) Neil Diamond Music Trivia (00:13:30) Elvis and Footloose Evolution (00:15:44) Male Cheerleader Comparison

After reviewing successful NFL picks from Thursday night, the discussion turns to the deceptive nature of paid sports handicapping services and the flaws of trend-based betting. A firsthand account is shared regarding a visit to a high-security, windowless bunker 50 feet below the Nevada desert where analysts determine the betting lines for major casinos. (00:01:03) Friday Morning NFL Recap (00:02:14) Exposing Betting Service Scams (00:07:26) Vegas Odds Setting Bunker

Predictions for the upcoming NFL slate lead into a critique of Dan Campbell’s leadership and the Lions' defensive struggles. A contentious call from Mike in Westchester forces Craig Carton to defend himself against claims of bullying partner Chris McMonigle. Reactions to Mina Kimes' old Josh Allen takes and Pat McAfee's behavior on ESPN conclude the segment.(00:01:31) Week 2 NFL Predictions(00:04:29) Dan Campbell's Identity Crisis(00:06:09) Heated Call On Bullying(00:12:38) Pat McAfee ESPN Reaction

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Jets' chances against the Green Bay Packers, focusing on the potential impact of heavy rain and defensive injuries. They also field fan calls about the Giants and discuss personal weekend plans involving wood chopping. (00:01:04) Jets Packers Game Analysis (00:06:53) Fan Call & NY Predictions (00:10:29) Searching For A Weather Guy (00:14:46) Craig’s Weekend Wood Chopping

Craig and Big Mac discuss the refusal of building management to allow a live cow in the studio for a milking demonstration. They shift to debating the best American cookies and a bizarre new sport originating in Romania. The conversation also covers elevator etiquette and the upcoming NFL weekend for the Jets and Giants. (00:01:00) Cow Milking Denied (00:03:30) Elevator Small Talk (00:06:26) Lorna Doone Cookie (00:12:46) Romanian Ass Slapping (00:15:37) Jets and Giants

Big Mac & Craig debate the validity of a potential 2-0 start for the Jets compared to the Giants, sparking a discussion about fan expectations in New York. They analyze the strength of upcoming opponents and argue whether the Jets are finally ready to be seen as a legitimate playoff threat.(00:01:04) Jets White Out Game(00:04:15) Boone's Farm Wine Talk(00:06:12) Comparing Jets/Giants Starts(00:10:35) New York Football Divide

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle are fired up for Football Friday on WFAN! The guys break down the Jets’ Week 2 matchup against the Green Bay Packers and explain why they believe New York has a legitimate chance to start the season 2-0. Is the rain actually going to help the Jets? Can the Jets’ pass rush take advantage of Green Bay’s struggling offensive line? And could Aaron Glenn’s team really be sitting at 2-0 on Monday?

Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti: Week 1 reaction, Josh Allen's MVP performances, and Week 2 picks

It's hold-your-breath time in Yankees Universe as Aaron Judge exited Wednesday's game with lower right leg tightness. Is it time to panic?? C-Mac reveals his level of concern, and how careful the Yankees need to be until the playoffs. Plus, who will fill the shoes of Judge in his absence, and how long could that absence be? Chris also dives into the Twins series as a whole, including another extra innings loss, the game-ending play involving George Lombard Jr., and if the division is officially out of reach.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTSIntro: A gut-punch loss and the reality of the Rays taking the division.11:58: Breaking down Aaron Judge's early exit and his cryptic injury updates.21:44: Evaluating George Lombard's defensive struggles at shortstop.30:30: Ryan McMahon's offensive drop-off and building an infield vs. Boston's lefties.42:23: Positives on the mound: Max Fried's bounce-back start.45:55: Defending the Yankees' playoff clinch champagne celebration.1:04:52: "Shill or Shame" segment: Shilling for Bellinger, shaming Ramos.1:16:25: Pitching preview for the upcoming series in Arizona.

Craigie and Big Mac react to Mets owner Steve Cohen giving Pete Alonso a standing ovation at Citi Field after his 300th career home run. The Carton Show also features a conversation with Randy Levine regarding the health of Aaron Judge and the Protect College Sports Act. (00:01:50) 60 Days To Greatness (00:09:25) Aaron Judge Health Concerns (00:17:35) Randy Levine Interview (00:23:42) Scott Boras Fact Check (00:28:56) Steve Cohen Applauds Alonso (00:39:12) Sports Fashion And Masculinity (00:46:00) Mark Jackson Card Story

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Knicks' apology for a major ticket pricing error and the team's championship banner plans. They also debate the Yankees' postseason reliability, questioning if Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole can perform at a championship level given Judge's health and the team's inconsistent rotation. (00:01:04) Knicks Ticket Price Apology (00:08:08) Aaron Judge Injury Status (00:13:30) Yankees Playoff Rotation Strategy (00:17:46) Yankee Postseason Trust Ratings (00:19:46) Debate Over Judge Rehab

The Carton Show dives into the Yankees' injury concerns surrounding Aaron Judge and the strategic implications of his potential move to the DH spot. Carton details a heated phone call from agent Scott Boras regarding the Pete Alonso agent switch and critiques Steve Cohen's reaction to Alonso's 300th home run. They also explore quirky sports collectibles and the declining quality of late-night comedy. (00:01:41) Knicks Roommate Show (00:03:05) Aaron Judge Injury (00:07:44) Yankees Shortstop Debate (00:09:35) Steve Cohen Controversy (00:13:42) Scott Boras Confrontation (00:24:48) Jerry Garcia Collectibles (00:28:28) Leaving Games Early (00:31:27) SNL Comedy Review

New York Yankees President Randy Levine joins to discuss the bipartisan legislative push to regulate NIL and the transfer portal in college athletics. He also shares a status update on Aaron Judge's leg injury and joins in on a lighthearted debate regarding football game attire. (00:01:50) Mitchell Robinson Injury Mystery (00:04:50) Grandmother Sick Leave Lies (00:07:02) Randy Levine Interview (00:07:34) Aaron Judge Injury Update (00:09:11) Save College Sports Act (00:14:05) NIL and Transfer Portal (00:17:41) College Athletics Budget Gap (00:22:55) Rutgers and St. John's (00:27:10) Duke Basketball Bag Men (00:36:10) Masculinity and Game Day Outfits (00:40:30) Bill Belichick's Unfortunate Photo

Craig Carton and Anthony Gallo react to Mets owner Steve Cohen standing to applaud Pete Alonso’s 300th career home run during a loss. They debate the possibility of Alonso winning the American League MVP with the Orioles and how that would signify a disastrous year for New York. The discussion also covers Aaron Rodgers' comments about his past relationships and reviews of Ben Affleck's recent film performances. (00:01:00) Cohen Applauds Pete Alonso (00:06:42) Gallo Slams Mets Fans (00:12:07) NFL Game of the Week (00:16:19) Rodgers and Shailene Woodley (00:19:22) Film Reviews and Impressions

Sean McMonigle critiques the Mets' fanbase and owner Steve Cohen for celebrating Pete Alonso’s 300th career home run during a game that ultimately cost the team a victory. They also break down the upcoming matchup between the Buffalo Bills and Detroit Lions, offering official picks and players to watch. (00:01:24) Mets Fans Cheer Alonso (00:06:26) Mets Clubhouse Perspective (00:11:01) Aaron Judge Home Runs (00:14:27) Bills vs Lions Predictions (00:19:50) Lions Offensive Concerns (00:25:02) Cohen and Judge Analysis (00:28:31) Final Calls and Wrap

Carton and Big Mac discuss the chilling history of the 1990 Mark Jackson trading card featuring the Menendez brothers. They debate the optics of Steve Cohen applauding Pete Alonso and vent about the rising costs of parking for New York Jets fans. (00:01:16) Mark Jackson Card Story (00:06:33) Cohen Cheers Pete Alonso (00:12:20) Mets Fan Frustration (00:16:43) Jets High Parking Fees (00:19:56) Belichick Viral Photo

Craig and Big Mac critique the midday crew for debating their game-day wardrobes, arguing that such discussions undermine their masculinity. They also react to an unflattering viral photo of Bill Belichick and poke fun at Evan Roberts' preference for tropical cocktails. (00:01:00) New York Sports Update (00:01:55) Midday Fashion Debate (00:06:21) Belichick and Evan Mockery

Randy Levine joins to discuss the bipartisan Protect College Sports Act and the necessity of regulating the NIL era to prevent the total professionalization of student athletes. He also offers an update on Aaron Judge's health and critiques local politicians for opposing college sports reform. They evaluate the massive financial endowments of schools like UConn and St. John's relative to their athletic spending. (00:01:50) Mitchell Robinson Family Emergency (00:08:40) Randy Levine on Aaron Judge (00:13:15) Reforming College Sports (00:16:40) Political Resistance to Reform (00:20:35) College Financial Competition (00:27:55) College Sports Revenue Recaps (00:32:30) St. John’s vs UConn Endowments

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss Darren Rovell's bizarre Jerry Garcia memorabilia collection, including a penicillin bottle used to treat an STD. They also react to Rovell leaving a historic Knicks comeback game at halftime and debate Jalen Brunson hosting Saturday Night Live. (00:01:11) Jerry Garcia Penicillin Bottle (00:04:53) Rovell's Early Knicks Exit (00:08:08) Brunson Hosting SNL Debate

Carton shares details from a private phone call with super-agent Scott Boras, who called to dispute the reported reasons behind Pete Alonso’s switch to his agency. They also discuss the viral video of Steve Cohen applauding Alonso’s 300th home run and the resulting friction with Mets fans. The conversation further explores the New York Yankees’ injury concerns with Aaron Judge and potential postseason defensive alignments. (00:01:00) Jalen Brunson’s Block Party (00:03:16) Aaron Judge’s Injury Impact (00:07:45) Yankees’ Defensive Lineup Debate (00:09:37) Steve Cohen’s Standing Ovation (00:14:05) Scott Boras Sets Record Straight

Craigie and C-Mac debate whether the New York Yankees erred by letting Aaron Judge control his own injury recovery timeline. They evaluate the team's postseason potential and discuss the rise of new country music stars performing at Pier 17. (00:01:07) Knicks Ticket Prices (00:01:31) Yankees Division Faith (00:02:54) Judge Injury Management (00:07:41) Country Music Stars (00:09:54) Mets Scandal Tease

Big Mac analyzes the New York Yankees simulation as they prepare for a Wild Card matchup against the Boston Red Sox. They discuss the optimal pitching rotation involving Cam Schlittler and Max Fried while evaluating the reliability of Aaron Judge and George Lombard Jr. heading into the postseason. (00:01:16) Yankees Simulation Division Race (00:01:51) Postseason Pitching Rotation Strategy (00:04:39) Trust Ratings For Key Players

Carton and Big Mac examine the New York Knicks' response to a significant ticket pricing error and the organization's plan to issue refunds to affected fans. They also voice concerns over Aaron Judge's physical condition and what his compromised health means for the Yankees' championship aspirations. (00:01:04) NY Sports Outlook (00:02:24) Knicks Ticket Apology (00:08:19) Aaron Judge Injury

Yankee fans are holding their breath to hear back about the latest Aaron Judge injury. Is it really something to be worried about? Plus, Pete Alonso leaves the city of Queens with a big fat smile and paycheck! Follow @HoffWFAN on X, TikTok & Instagram

Big Mac reacts to a devastating extra-innings loss to the Minnesota Twins and the news of Aaron Judge leaving the game with a lower-body injury. He critiques the organization's decision to rehab the captain at the major league level and discusses the impact on the pursuit of the AL East. (00:01:07) Heartbreaking Loss to Twins (00:03:27) Aaron Judge Injury Update (00:09:34) Questioning Judge's Rehab Process

Pete Alonso has returned to cause Mets fans to explode on one another. Who is the embarrassing Mets fan? Let's find out. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok

Craig and C-Mac dive into the heated debate surrounding the New York Yankees' locker room celebration after clinching a postseason berth. They also provide an inside look at the contract negotiations between Pete Alonso and Steve Cohen, debunking narratives about how the slugger ended up in Baltimore. (00:01:50) Yankees Postseason Celebration (00:11:00) Coughlin Push-Up Challenge (00:17:30) Hyrox World Champion Mishap (00:26:00) Craig's Bathroom Emergency (00:34:20) NFL Week 2 Preview (00:38:15) Pete Alonso Negotiation Truths (00:53:40) Ringo Starr Debate

On the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Big Mac celebrate the New York Yankees clinching a playoff spot and address critics who believe the team shouldn't celebrate before winning a championship. They also dive into a studio push-up challenge inspired by Tom Coughlin and evaluate Aaron Judge’s impact as the playoffs approach. (00:01:20) Yankees Clinch Postseason (00:02:49) Defending Champagne Celebrations (00:06:46) Postseason Goals Strategy (00:10:05) Coughlin Push-Up Challenge (00:15:15) Early Celebration Debate (00:21:44) Judge Leads Rally

They analyze a viral Hyrox race incident involving an athlete's grit and a significant biohazard. Craig recounts an embarrassing personal story before delving into the New York Mets' roster drama. The conversation uncovers the alleged details of Pete Alonso's rejected $158 million contract and the impact of agent Scott Boras on the negotiations. (00:01:40) Taylor Swift At Game (00:04:45) Hyrox Race Incident (00:08:33) Craig’s Personal Story (00:13:50) Yankee Celebration Debate (00:21:10) NFL Betting Results (00:24:30) Mets Fans Boo Stearns (00:33:10) Pete Alonso Contract Truths (00:39:30) Business Of Baseball (00:46:30) Evaluating David Stearns

After analyzing the betting odds for the Giants and Jets' upcoming games, they debate the merits of wild card celebrations in Major League Baseball. C-Max recounts a harrowing experience where he had to save his son from drowning during a family outing, leading to a broader discussion about emergency preparedness and restaurant etiquette. (00:01:20) NFL Week 2 Outlook (00:05:41) Yankees Postseason Celebration Debate (00:10:12) Steakhouse Etiquette And Judge (00:15:14) Mariah Carey Hall Snub (00:20:35) Rock Hall Induction Snubs (00:23:47) C-Max Heroic Rescue Story

Craig and Big Mac evaluate the Yankees' pitching rotation for the upcoming Wild Card series and the decision to rest Aaron Judge. They analyze major NFL storylines following Week 1, including the Chiefs' dominance and the Giants' victory over the Cowboys. The conversation also detours into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Craig’s refusal to return to the city of Houston. (00:01:20) Yankees Rotation Strategy (00:05:15) Wild Card Race Prep (00:10:30) Craig Sounds Like Mel Brooks (00:14:15) Rock Hall Of Fame (00:17:45) NFL Week 1 Recap (00:23:40) Division Storyline Rankings (00:26:50) Host NFL Betting Records

Chris McMonigle reviews the emotional return of Pete Alonso to Citi Field and why fans turned their frustration toward David Stearns. They discuss the disconnect between ownership and the fan base following a disappointing season for the New York Mets. The segment also covers Yankees playoff rotation concerns and lighthearted trivia regarding Ringo Starr. (00:01:20) Giants Post-Game Atmosphere (00:04:27) Mets Fans Confront Stearns (00:08:52) Cohen and Management Impact (00:12:36) Pete Alonso Contract Logic (00:16:43) Ringo Starr Trivia Segment (00:22:05) Look Who's Talking Soundtrack (00:25:44) Abe Vigoda Movie History (00:28:45) Yankees Postseason Pitching Choices

Big Mac recounts a terrifying real-life experience where he had to save his young son from drowning during a boating trip. They also discuss Mel Brooks' legacy in comedy and a hypothetical scenario about jumping overboard during a Disney cruise. Additionally, the conversation touches on physical fitness and the challenge of completing a single pull-up.(00:01:01) Comedy Legends And Movies(00:05:43) Yankees Nation TV Appearances(00:06:43) Big Mac Pull-up Challenge(00:09:15) Cruise Overboard Hypotheticals

C-Mac & Craig debate whether Mariah Carey belongs in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and reviews Barry Manilow's catalog of hits. He also pushes back against fans criticizing the Yankees for celebrating their postseason clinch, highlighting the many injuries the team overcame to reach the tournament.(00:01:12) Mariah Carey HOF Snub(00:03:34) Barry Manilow's Career Hits(00:07:06) Yankees Playoff Celebration Debate(00:11:06) Silvox Outdoor TV

The conversation begins with an analysis of the betting lines for the Giants and Jets, noting their status as underdogs heading into the weekend. The discussion then covers the news of Sterling Shepard joining the Jets' practice squad before debating whether Yankee fans have become too spoiled to celebrate a postseason berth. Finally, a detour into steakhouse etiquette highlights the annoyance of overbearing tableside service.(00:01:00) NY Football Betting Odds(00:05:20) Sterling Shepard Joins Jets(00:06:40) Yankees Postseason Celebration Debate(00:12:30) Aaron Judge Dinner Habits(00:15:01) Steakhouse Etiquette Pet Peeves

Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton analyze the friction between Mets fans and GM David Stearns following Pete Alonso’s departure. They reveal behind-the-scenes details about rejected contracts, a spiritual trip to the Vatican, and how Steve Cohen allegedly kept Alonso's career on track when no other offers materialized.(00:01:20) NFL Picks and Records(00:04:25) Fans Booing David Stearns(00:08:12) Steve Cohen's Lip Reading(00:12:42) Pete Alonso Hires Boras(00:17:01) Stearns Rejects Long-Term Deal(00:21:47) Pete Alonso's Vatican Prayer(00:28:30) Stearns' Move Evaluations

Craig and Big Mac dive into the viral story of an Austrian athlete who won a Hyrox race despite suffering a messy gastrointestinal accident mid-competition. This prompts Craig to share a graphic and hilarious personal memory of a similar disaster in a hotel elevator early in his career. They also take calls to debate whether the Yankees' playoff clinch celebration was appropriate or premature. (00:01:00) Roommate Show Ticket Giveaway (00:03:14) Hyrox Athlete Poop Scandal (00:09:15) Craig's Personal Elevator Accident (00:11:48) Yankees Playoff Celebration Debate

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss finding a flyer for Tom Coughlin's push-up competition, leading to a debate about their own physical fitness. They also examine whether the Yankees should be celebrating a wild card berth and how Aaron Boone must handle his pitching staff down the stretch.(00:01:00) Sharing Desks With Tiki(00:02:30) Coughlin's Push-Up Competition(00:07:11) Studio Pull-Up Challenge(00:08:41) Yankees Playoff Celebration Debate(00:12:14) Managing Aaron Boone's Bullpen

Craig and C-Mac discuss the New York Yankees clinching a postseason berth and address criticism regarding the team's clubhouse celebration. They argue that players should enjoy the milestone of making the playoffs, regardless of whether the division is won yet. The discussion also touches on Aaron Judge's home run and the team's dominance over the Minnesota Twins.(00:01:00) Yankees Clinch Playoff Berth(00:02:03) Playoff Celebration Debate(00:08:24) Judge Homer And Twins Dominance

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Yankees clinching a postseason berth and debate the criticism surrounding their locker room celebration. They argue that reaching the playoffs is a hard-earned achievement that deserves recognition, regardless of the "World Series or bust" mentality. (00:01:00) Show Introduction (00:02:50) Yankees Playoff Celebration (00:11:03) Postseason Pitching Strategy (00:13:00) NFL Week Recap

Tune in as the hosts of Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle react to Gang Green's resounding win over the Tennessee Titans and old friend Robert Saleh. While the Titans were unimpressive, the Jets more than handled their business. What are the takeaways for this Jets team as they look to restore their credibility and build confidence within the fanbase?

The New York Giants kicked off their season with a statement victory behind Jaxson Dart's poise and a relentless ground attack. We break down Malik Nabers' return, line-of-scrimmage dominance, and what this win means for the rest of the season.

Craig Carton and Big Mac celebrate a historic 1-0 start for both the Jets and Giants following a dominant NFL opening weekend. They analyze the impact of coaching on the Giants' identity, the efficiency of the Jets' road victory, and the anticipated return of Pete Alonso to Citi Field. (00:01:50) NFL Opening Weekend (00:05:11) Giants Victory Analysis (00:09:08) Jets Dominant Win (00:16:30) Tesla Cyber Taxis (00:21:32) Aaron Judge Interview (00:24:40) Pete Alonso Return (00:29:15) NFL Week 1 Picks (00:39:41) Radio Industry Stories

Craigy and Big Mac celebrate a rare 1-0 start for both the Giants and the Jets, highlighting the physical dominance shown against the Cowboys. They discuss the impact of John Harbaugh and the performance of Jaxson Dart while venting about Sunday Ticket technical issues and the future of New York football. (00:01:20) New York's Perfect Start (00:04:45) Harbaugh Transforms The Giants (00:08:35) Jets Dominant Week 1 (00:14:20) New York Quarterback Comparison (00:18:30) Sunday Ticket Contract Rant (00:23:15) Giants Coaching And Discipline

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' dominant performance and the rising identity of their ground game featuring Patrick Ricard and Tyrone Tracy Jr. They analyze the impact of predictive markets like Kalshi on sports betting handles and debate the historical legacy of Jim Brown. Carton also proposes a "No Action Day" to encourage responsible gaming while claiming he personally influenced Jackson Dart’s on-field toughness. (00:01:22) Sports Cards on Whatnot (00:04:13) Kalshi’s Betting Handle Surge (00:07:09) Proposing No Action Day (00:10:01) Giants Ground Game Analysis (00:14:44) Jets Victory Over Titans (00:17:10) US Open Scheduling Critique (00:18:46) Comparing Giants and Jets (00:21:50) NFL High Scoring Trends (00:25:01) Debating Jim Brown’s Legacy

They discuss Pete Alonso’s highly anticipated return to Citi Field and whether fans should root for him to hit a home run against the Mets. The conversation also details the Giants’ impressive victory over the Cowboys and the cultural shift under John Harbaugh. (00:01:32) Pete Alonso's Return (00:05:05) Divisional NFL Openers (00:08:24) Target Field Discovery (00:14:26) Giants Beat Cowboys (00:20:14) Aaron Glenn Incident (00:24:16) Tony Romo Controversy (00:27:58) Golfing at Baltusrol

Carton critiques Aaron Judge for stating he would not vote for a teammate as MVP despite a dominant season on the mound. They pivot to discussing Garrett Cole's controversial pre-pitch routine and a debate over the New York Giants' playoff potential. The conversation also explores personal anecdotes ranging from passive income with Tesla taxis to wardrobe disputes during television appearances. (00:01:20) Tesla Taxi Business Plan (00:05:57) Aaron Judge MVP Controversy (00:12:04) Garrett Cole Clock Antics (00:17:59) Personal Bathroom Tales (00:22:12) Wardrobe Conflicts at Fox (00:26:45) Fennel and Italian Slang (00:30:45) Jets vs Giants Wins (00:37:42) Rick Jeanneret Mentor Story

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Giants' physical performance in their season opener, highlighting their third-down success and defensive effort. He also reviews the Jets' victory over the Titans and shares betting locks for the Monday Night Football matchup between the Chiefs and Broncos on The Carton Show.(00:01:00) Giants Physical Identity(00:06:06) Cowboys Game Analysis(00:10:41) Jets Dominant Victory(00:13:19) Third Down Conversions(00:07:31) Monday Night Picks

Craig and Chris explore the idea of starting a business with Elon Musk's autonomous Tesla Cybercabs to generate passive income. They also debate Aaron Judge's philosophy on pitchers winning the MVP award and blast Gerrit Cole for his rigid adherence to the stadium clock.(00:01:03) Tesla Cyber Taxi Investment(00:06:16) Aaron Judge's MVP Take(00:11:11) Gerrit Cole's Clock Obsession(00:14:00) Giants Future & Alonso's Return

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss Pete Alonso's return to Citi Field and whether Mets fans would cheer for him to hit a home run. They also mock Big Mac for his lack of knowledge regarding the Minnesota Twins' outdoor stadium and debate John Harbaugh's receiving rooms. (00:01:00) Pete Alonso's Citi Field Return (00:03:40) Monday Night Football Preview (00:05:59) Big Mac's Twins Blunder (00:10:31) Caller Mocks Big Mac (00:14:04) Giants and Harbaugh Debate

The Carton Show criticize the USTA for scheduling the US Open men's final against the NFL's opening Sunday before pivoting to a debate comparing Madison Beer and Taylor Swift. The conversation shifts to a deep dive into the New York Giants' recent performance, with a caller comparing the current team's potential to the 2008 squad.(00:01:36) US Open Scheduling Critique(00:03:03) Beer vs Swift Debate(00:10:05) Giants Win Over Cowboys

Craig and Big Mac debate the significance of the Giants' win over the Cowboys compared to the Jets' victory against the Titans. They discuss NFL defensive struggles during a high-scoring Week 1 and have a heated argument over Jim Brown's legacy. Craig also highlights how he supposedly influenced Jaxson Dart's strategy for avoiding the concussion tent.(00:02:17) Comparing Giants and Jets Wins(00:06:00) Preseason Impact on Defenses(00:09:11) Jaxson Dart's Performance(00:10:52) Debate Over Jim Brown(00:13:40) Craig's Advice to Dart

Craig and Big Mac break down the Giants' physical identity and their recent victory over the Dallas Cowboys. They also discuss the staggering rise of Kalshi's predictive betting markets and a proposal for a "No Action Day" to support responsible gambling. (00:01:19) WhatNot Memorabilia Marketplace (00:04:39) Kalshi Prediction Markets Growth (00:07:24) Responsible Gaming Advocacy (00:09:23) Giants Physical Identity Discussion (00:15:41) Jets Competent Performance Review

Craig Carton vents his frustration regarding a YouTube Sunday Ticket glitch that prevented him from watching the Eagles game at home. He and Chris McMonigle also break down the Giants' performance against the Cowboys, debating whether the team is poised for a successful season under their current leadership. (00:01:00) Sunday Ticket Technical Failure (00:05:40) Giants Discipline vs Cowboys (00:07:54) Harbaugh And Giants Future

C-Mac and Big Mac celebrate a perfect opening week for New York football as both the Giants and Jets secure major victories. They discuss Malik Nabers' impact on the offense and tackle a caller's frustration with the narrative surrounding Jets wins. The conversation also explores the new physical identity of the Giants and how it differs from previous seasons. (00:01:00) Giants Jets Week One (00:07:15) Jets Win Narrative Debate (00:11:07) Giants New Identity

Craig and Big Mac break down a historic opening week for New York football as both the Giants and Jets move to 1-0. They discuss the physical dominance displayed by the Giants against Dallas and the efficient performance by the Jets in their victory over the Titans. (00:01:00) New York's 1-0 Start (00:02:30) Giants Physicality vs Cowboys (00:04:54) Impact Player Breakdown (00:08:35) Jets Dominant Performance (00:12:12) Looking Toward Week 2

The Patriots losing to the Seahawks has Evan wondering if there is hope for the Jets to shock the NFL world and make a playoff push this year. Plus, should Garrett Wilson feel snubbed for not being named a team captain? Meanwhile, Boomer and Gio discuss how Sam Darnold's injury in Seattle further highlights the Jets' need for a more reliable backup quarterback, and the Evan and Tiki crew discuss what the realistic expectations should be for Geno Smith and the team in 2026.

The season is finally here, and Phil Simms sat down with Boomer and Gio to give his take on how the team looks with John Harbaugh in the fold. Plus, how will Jaxson Dart perform in year two? Evan and Tiki discuss the daunting task that awaits the Giants in their season opener against the Cowboys, Craig Carton rips the team for its handling of Darius Slayton, and debating if the Giants have better weapons on offense than the Jets. Finally, Evan wonders if Harbaugh is picking a fight with the New York media.

What a return for Anthony Volpe! Chris McMonigle reacts to Volpe's grand slam and 5 RBI night to lead the Yankees to a sweep of the Rockies. Does this mean the Yankees will have a tough decision to make when Anthony Volpe returns? Plus, Chris reveals if he has any concerns about Max Fried after his laborious start, and just how real are the Yankees' chances at the division after gaining a game on the Rays?EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS6:54 - Anthony Volpe’s unforgettable return from the minors. Shifting to second base, Volpe delivers a 3-for-4 night, an opposite-field grand slam, five RBIs, and earns a goosebump-inducing curtain call.27:33 - Examining the Yankees' homegrown talent up the middle, punctuated by Spencer Jones securing the everyday center field job with a three-hit performance.34:04 - A deep dive into Max Fried's alarming velocity drop. Exploring why a 3-4 mph dip on his fastball is a massive concern for the Yankees' championship rotation.46:10 - The "Shill or Shame" segment. Praising Volpe's massive game while shaming Jasson Dominguez following continuous defensive struggles and a sudden demotion to AAA.52:23 - Previewing the emotionally heavy September 11th series against the surging New York Mets. Breaking down the pitching matchups—Rodón, Cole, and Schlittler vs. McLean, Thornton, and Scott—and mapping out the path to catch the Rays.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open with a moving tribute to the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, sharing personal memories and hearing from emotional callers. They balance the somber occasion with sports talk, highlighting Anthony Volpe’s grand slam and the anticipation of the Subway Series. The discussion also covers the latest injury news regarding Malik Nabors and the crew’s official NFL Week 1 predictions. (00:01:50) Remembering September 11th (00:04:15) Carton's WNEW Memories (00:09:15) FDNY Robert Cashman Interview (00:12:48) Volpe's Return and Slam (00:19:21) Moving 9/11 Caller Tributes (00:30:46) NFL Week 1 Previews (00:36:12) Malik Nabors Injury Update (00:15:51) Official NFL Week 1 Picks

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle honor the 25th anniversary of September 11th by sharing poignant memories and listening to powerful survival stories from the New York community. They also analyze Anthony Volpe’s emotional return to the Bronx and how sports provided a necessary sense of normalcy during the city's darkest hours. (00:01:00) 9/11 Anniversary Tributes (00:03:46) Carton’s 9/11 Radio Memories (00:11:37) Anthony Volpe’s Yankee Redemption (00:14:47) Listener’s Emotional Survival Story

Craig and Chris McMonigle honor the 25th anniversary of 9/11 by welcoming Robert Cashman of the FDNY to share his experiences as a first responder. They engage with callers sharing personal stories of the day, including the sports world's reaction and Derek Jeter's iconic World Series moment. The conversation also covers the New York Giants' upcoming season and Craig's secret Rosh Hashanah brisket recipe. (00:01:20) FDNY Robert Cashman Interview (00:07:13) Eyewitness 9/11 Accounts (00:12:24) Knicks Trainer Memories (00:20:29) Yankees Parade Secrets (00:28:50) Giants Season Outlook (00:09:18) Prince Street Pizza (00:12:35) Staten Island Survivor (00:15:42) Brisket Recipe Discussion

Craigie and C-Mac reflect on the solemnity of the 9/11 anniversary on The Carton Show while transitioning into the latest New York sports news, including the Subway Series and Malik Nabers' injury status. They hear emotional stories from survivors and family members of first responders, highlighting the resilience of NYC. The discussion also touches on historical aviation accidents and creative punishments for their weekly NFL picks. (00:01:25) Subway Series Lineup Preview (00:05:30) Canal Street Traffic Encounter (00:09:15) Howard's 9/11 Birth Story (00:13:45) Surviving at 140 Broadway (00:17:45) Rockaway Plane Crash Memories (00:21:30) Malik Nabers Injury Update (00:28:45) Survival and Saving Kids (00:34:15) Giants Snap Count Conflict (00:16:30) NFL Picks Betting Punishments (00:20:30) Honoring a Fallen Father

Craig Carton and Big Mac provide their NFL season outlook, featuring a surprising Super Bowl champion prediction and analysis of the Jets and Giants. They also honor the 25th anniversary of 9/11 with personal anecdotes and moving calls from first responders who were at Ground Zero. (00:01:20) Rosh Hashanah And 9/11 Tributes (00:05:30) NFL Logistics In Australia (00:09:55) First Responder Stories (00:14:45) Super Bowl And MVP Predictions (00:19:15) Memories Of Ground Zero (00:23:40) Craig Recalls 9/11 Broadcast

Chris McMonigle honors the 25th anniversary of September 11th by taking emotional calls from listeners and reflecting on how sports helped New York heal. They discuss the legacy of the 2001 Yankees and the significance of Mike Piazza’s home run during that recovery period. The segment concludes with the crew’s football picks for Week 1, analyzing the Giants, Jets, and other key NFL matchups. (00:01:20) Emotional 9/11 Listener Tributes (00:07:19) Yankees Post-9/11 Normalcy (00:13:00) Teaching the Next Generation (00:15:45) Memories of Cantor Fitzgerald (00:23:14) Official Week 1 Picks (00:27:31) Jaguars and Browns Preview (00:31:31) Bills vs Texans Analysis

Chris McMonigle and his co-host discuss the emotional weight of the upcoming Subway Series coinciding with the anniversary of 9/11. They analyze the NFL's logistics for their international trip to Australia before taking calls from first responders who share powerful experiences and signs from Ground Zero. (00:01:00) Rosh Hashanah and Remembrance (00:04:07) NFL Australia Trip Logistics (00:07:40) First Responder 9/11 Stories

Craig and Big Mac debate the greatest song lyrics in history before hearing from callers sharing emotional stories regarding the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks. They also discuss the confusing injury status of Giants receiver Malik Nabers and clarify why Boomer Esiason received top billing in the show's title.(00:01:42) Greatest Lyrics Debate(00:04:11) 9/11 Survival Stories(00:10:07) Show Naming History(00:11:40) Malik Nabers Injury Update

They reflect on the anniversary of September 11th by sharing listener stories, discussing the health impacts on first responders, and previewing the Subway Series pitching matchups. They also explore aviation safety history in New York City and address the controversy surrounding Malik Nabers’ injury status. (00:01:01) 9/11 Remembrance and Subway Series (00:02:51) NYC Traffic Frustrations (00:07:20) Personal 9/11 Stories (00:16:59) NYC Aviation History (00:22:04) Malik Nabers Injury Update

Craig Carton and Chris Monaco reflect on the 9-11 anniversary with a call from survivor Ronnie before the Subway Series. They also discuss office food theft and Craig's detailed process for making the ultimate holiday brisket. (00:01:00) Pizza and Office Fridge Etiquette (00:03:42) 9-11 Anniversary and Ronnie's Story (00:08:22) Rosh Hashanah Brisket Secret Recipe

Chris McMonigle explains why he would not trade a Yankees series win against the Mets for a Giants victory over the Cowboys. They also discuss how the Rams' loss to the 49ers impacts the Giants' upcoming schedule and share stories from a listener regarding the anniversary of 9/11. (00:01:07) Giants vs Cowboys Preview (00:02:01) Rams 49ers Game Recap (00:06:13) 9/11 Tribute and Yankees

Craig and Big Mac honor the anniversary of September 11th by speaking with former FDNY official Robert Kaseman about his experiences and the tragedy's legacy. They hear from listeners sharing poignant stories of survival and reflect on whether professional sports resumed too soon after the attacks. Craig also recounts a bizarre Monday Night Football watch party where the only guest in attendance was Bobby Flay. (00:01:39) Robert Kaseman Joins (00:08:00) Personal 9/11 Reflections (00:11:38) Sports Return Debate (00:19:28) World Series Memories (00:24:10) Craig's Bobby Flay Story

Carton and Big Mac reflect on the 25th anniversary of 9/11 and the profound impact of sports on the healing process. They speak with a survivor who shares a moving account of escaping the towers and discuss how Mike Piazza's legendary home run provided a necessary moment of relief for the city. (00:01:00) Sports Preview and 9/11 Remembrance (00:04:14) World Trade Center Survivor Story (00:07:34) Piazza's Home Run and Healing

Craig and Big Mac celebrate Anthony Volpe's grand slam and emotional curtain call at Yankee Stadium. They examine his role as a replacement for Jazz Chisholm Jr. before listening to a heart-wrenching story from a caller about the legacy of 9/11 and its effect on New York families. (00:01:00) Volpe's Yankee Stadium Return (00:08:45) 9/11 Memorial Phone Call (00:12:36) Silvox TV Partnership

Craig Carton and Big Mac honor the anniversary of September 11th by sharing memories of the tragedy and its impact on the New York community. Carton describes the haunting experience of taking calls from people inside the World Trade Center while broadcasting on WNEW. They also discuss how sports aided the city's recovery and preview the upcoming Subway Series. (00:01:00) Honoring 9/11 Victims (00:03:45) Broadcasting During Tragedy (00:07:40) Legacy And Sports Healing

They critique Drake Maye's performance in the Patriots' loss to the Seahawks before debating Anthony Volpe's return to the Yankees. The conversation also explores Brian Daboll's tense media interaction regarding Malik Nabors' injury status and dives into the public feuds surrounding Aaron Rodgers' past relationships. A caller's claim to the success of Vitamin Water and personal anecdotes about business ideas are also shared.(00:02:13) Drake Maye’s Interception Meltdown(00:10:21) Yankees and Mets Updates(00:15:56) ALCS vs. Knicks Plans(00:19:15) Anthony Volpe Returns(00:31:15) Vitamin Water Ownership Claim(00:26:37) Aaron Rodgers Relationship Drama(00:21:31) Tense Giants Media Clash(00:16:36) NFL Thursday Night Picks

Carton and Big Mac analyze the New England Patriots' frustrating loss to the Seahawks, highlighting Drake Maye's fourth-quarter interceptions. They also discuss the New York Yankees' dominant win, Anthony Volpe's return to the lineup, and a humorous story about a missed business opportunity with Wendy's. (00:01:43) Patriots Loss Analysis (00:06:23) Drake Maye Comparison (00:09:51) Yankees Blowout Victory (00:15:26) Knicks Ring Ceremony (00:18:27) Anthony Volpe's Return (00:14:45) Jackson Dart Narrative (00:22:01) Wendy's Frosty Story

They analyze the latest public feuds involving Aaron Rodgers and his past relationships with Danica Patrick and Shailene Woodley. The conversation also covers the Yankees' decision to recall Anthony Volpe from the minors following an injury to Jazz Chisholm Jr. (00:01:20) NFL Betting Advice (00:05:55) Aaron Boone Texting (00:07:27) Call With Annabelle (00:10:55) Radio ID Rules (00:13:05) Vitamin Water Origin (00:19:08) Pop-Up Bagels Investment (00:22:06) Aaron Rodgers Drama (00:35:08) Halloween Candy Snubs (00:37:45) John Harbaugh Presser (00:41:12) Anthony Volpe Returns

Craig Carton and Evan Roberts react to Anthony Volpe’s return to the Yankees and debate the team's playoff positioning. They discuss Robinson Cano's legacy as a second baseman and criticize LeBron James for his gambling endorsements. The segment also covers a tense media interaction regarding Malik Nabors and the New York Giants' outlook. (00:01:25) Anthony Volpe Returns (00:05:00) Live Show Planning (00:08:30) Robinson Cano's Legacy (00:12:00) LeBron's Polymarket Deal (00:15:30) Riddles And Jokes (00:21:45) Larry In Las Vegas (00:27:15) Mickey Mantle Memories (00:34:15) Tommy Lugauer Copying Controversy (00:39:15) John Harbaugh Media Tension

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss Malik Nabors' cautious approach to his injury recovery and the mental pressure of returning to the Giants' lineup. They analyze the impact of high-profile injuries on the league, compare recovery timelines for Patrick Mahomes and Daniel Jones, and share their official NFL Game of the Week predictions. (00:01:11) Player To Watch Picks (00:03:54) Malik Nabors Injury Mindset (00:11:23) Mahomes And Jones Recovery (00:13:08) Silvox Game Of Week (00:20:19) Aaron Judge Rest Day

Larry from Las Vegas joins Big Mac to argue against Anthony Volpe's return to the lineup before participating in a prank on producer Anthony Gallo. They also reflect on the legacy of Barry Melrose and share stories about the golden era of the New York Yankees. (00:02:10) Barry Melrose and Lane Kiffin (00:03:16) Volpe Debate and Gallo Game (00:10:08) New York Yankee Nostalgia

They analyze the Yankees' critical series against the Rockies, emphasizing that a loss could signal the end of their division title aspirations. The conversation shifts to Anthony Volpe's defensive transition and where he fits into the roster alongside Jazz Chisholm Jr. They also evaluate Robinson Canó's place in franchise history and criticize LeBron James for his recent sports betting endorsements. (00:01:02) Volpe Returns to Lineup (00:02:13) Yankees Division Title Stakes (00:07:43) Volpe and Chisholm Debate (00:10:01) Robinson Cano Legacy Comparison (00:12:35) LeBron James Betting Criticism

After Jazz Chisholm's injury, the Yankees recalled Anthony Volpe to play second base. Big Mac discusses if the demotion helped Volpe find his stroke and if he deserves another shot in the Bronx. (00:01:01) Anthony Volpe's Return (00:04:16) Analyzing Volpe's Stats (00:07:32) Invention of the Microwave (00:08:46) Yankees Fan Reactions

Craig explores the public feuds between Aaron Rodgers and exes Danica Patrick and Shailene Woodley, critiquing Rodgers' recent comments about his past relationships. They also discuss his reputation for being stingy with Halloween candy compared to other NFL legends like John Elway and Boomer Esiason. (00:01:08) Aaron Rodgers Relationship Feuds (00:05:21) Rich Couple Counseling Debate (00:09:03) Analyzing Rodgers' Dating History (00:13:11) NFL Stars' Halloween Snubs (00:16:41) Yankees and Harbaugh Updates

Margaret calls in to recount her time at Coca-Cola where she suggested the company buy Vitamin Water, earning her only a small bonus for a billion-dollar idea. Craig Carton promises to put her in touch with Mike Repole and later reflects on his own missed chance to invest in Pop-Up Bagels. (00:01:00) Betting Results and Advice (00:05:42) Anthony Volpe News (00:07:30) Trucker Stories with Annabelle (00:11:59) Radio Station ID Debate (00:14:06) Vitamin Water Acquisition Claim

Craig shares the story of how he pitched a 'Mint Frosty' concept to Wendy's, only for the company to allegedly implement the idea and reward him with just a $10 gift card. He also debates the national perception of Daniel Jones and describes a grueling commute spent watching Yellowstone. (00:01:00) Burgers and Al Leiter (00:02:25) Giants Quarterback Debate (00:06:08) Cowboys Defense vs Giants (00:08:20) Commute and TV Talk (00:12:43) Wendy's Mint Frosty Fiasco

The discussion weighs the excitement of the Knicks' ring ceremony against the high stakes of a Yankees playoff game. Focus then shifts to Anthony Volpe's return from the minors and how he might platoon with Jazz Chisholm Jr. during the postseason. (00:01:00) Knicks Ring Ceremony Dilemma (00:05:03) Anthony Volpe Returns (00:07:26) Yankees Playoff Roster Decisions

Craig Carton and Big Mac break down the New England Patriots' disappointing loss and Drake Maye's costly interceptions. They also preview the Rams-Niners matchup and recap a wild night of New York baseball including the Yankees' blowout and the Mets' high-scoring thriller.(00:01:46) Drake Maye's Struggles(00:08:53) Rams Niners Preview(00:09:52) New York Baseball Recap

They analyze the start of the NFL season and a crucial Yankees-Rockies series while discussing Aaron Boone's decision to bench Aaron Judge. Former Met Todd Zeile discusses his 9/11 documentary "When America Took the Field," and comedian Aaron Berg shares insights into his new special. The conversation also details Anthony Volpe’s return to the Yankees lineup following an injury to Jazz Chisholm Jr. (00:01:50) NFL Season Kickoff (00:05:35) Boone Benches Judge (00:14:30) Zeile 9/11 Documentary (00:16:45) Theranos Fraud Discussion (00:26:45) Comedian Aaron Berg (00:18:35) Anthony Volpe Recalled (00:12:35) NFL Week 1 Picks

Craig and Big Mac dive into the return of football on The Carton Show with Big Mac, debating the New York Giants' outlook and the high stakes for the New York Jets' season opener. They analyze Aaron Boone's decision to bench Aaron Judge and reflect on the upcoming 25th anniversary of September 11th. Finally, they share their thoughts on a new documentary about Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes. (00:01:54) Giants Cowboys Ticket Prices (00:05:14) Boone Benches Aaron Judge (00:09:31) Craig's Television Setup (00:14:25) Giants Defensive Weapons (00:20:34) Jets Critical Titans Matchup (00:11:43) September 11th Anniversary Reflections (00:16:45) Elizabeth Holmes Documentary Discussion (00:19:46) Voice Of Elizabeth Holmes

Craig and Big Mac discuss Aaron Boone's accountability with the Yankees and share an emotional 9/11 story from a listener regarding Mike Piazza. They debate the merits of calling up Jasson Domínguez and Anthony Volpe while establishing the stakes for an NFL picking contest and sharing opinions on martinis. (00:01:20) Boone's Managerial Accountability (00:02:54) Tom's Emotional 9/11 Story (00:05:39) Piazza's Home Run Impact (00:09:42) 2001 World Series Parade (00:12:10) Mets Pitching and Replay (00:15:46) Volpe and Domínguez Debate (00:20:47) NFL Picks Punishment Stakes (00:24:33) Martini and Liquor Talk (00:27:40) Daniel Jones Offense Discussion

Craig Carton and Big Mac evaluate the Giants and Jets' rosters while critiquing the U.S. Open's decision to schedule a signature match at midnight. They later welcome former Met Todd Zeile to discuss his documentary, 'When America Took the Field,' which chronicles baseball's role in the healing process after 9/11. Zeile also shares a humorous story about a 'Man Dinner' with John Franco and a credit card roulette prank. (00:01:35) Debating Relationship Television Shows (00:07:42) Jets and Giants Season Outlook (00:13:15) U.S. Open Scheduling Controversy (00:17:45) Fans Dressing for the Open (00:22:50) Yankees Lineup and Injury News (00:10:10) Todd Zeile on 9/11 Documentary (00:14:40) Emotional Return to Shea Stadium (00:21:20) Mike Piazza's Iconic Home Run (00:32:10) Athletes Impacting the Community (00:38:25) John Franco's Man Dinner Prank

The discussion begins with a critique of upcoming movie sequels and a dive into classic cinema before shifting to the U.S. Open's controversial late-night match scheduling. They analyze the recent NFL investigation involving Eagles' security head Fat Dom and the online drama surrounding Emmanuel Acho. Comedian Aaron Berg joins to share stories about his new stand-up special and his dedication to fitness. (00:01:20) Movie News and NASCAR Debates (00:06:11) Stanley Kubrick Conspiracy Theories (00:10:51) U.S. Open Late Start Criticism (00:14:52) Fat Dom Eagles Security Investigation (00:19:32) Broncos Defense and Mahomes Matchup (00:24:09) Aaron Berg Discusses Comedy Special (00:30:30) Marriage Vows and Key West

McMonigle forecasts a Baltimore Ravens versus Los Angeles Rams Super Bowl and names Caleb Williams as a dark horse MVP candidate for the upcoming NFL season. He also discusses the New York Yankees recalling Anthony Volpe to replace the injured Jazz Chisholm, weighing the shortstop's potential impact against his recent minor league success. The segment concludes with official against-the-spread picks for the Seahawks and Patriots season opener. (00:01:27) NFL Season Preview (00:06:58) Super Bowl Predictions (00:10:30) Defensive Star Analysis (00:13:56) Giants Offensive Outlook (00:18:02) Anthony Volpe Recalled (00:23:37) Volpe's Hitting Approach

Aaron Berg joins The Carton Show in studio to discuss his physical transformation and his new YouTube special, 30 Minutes with Aaron Berg. He shares humorous stories about gym etiquette at Jersey Barbell and his experiences officiating a wedding through the Church of Humanism. The conversation wraps up with Berg's take on the New Jersey Devils and his prediction for a Jets Super Bowl run.(00:01:12) Aaron Berg In Studio(00:05:55) Fitness And New Special(00:10:25) Weddings And Sports Talk

Todd Zeile joins Craig and Big Mac to discuss his documentary, When America Took the Field, commemorating the 25th anniversary of 9/11. They reflect on the emotional atmosphere at Shea Stadium during the return to baseball and the symbolic significance of Mike Piazza's home run. Zeile also shares personal stories about a meeting with Sandy Koufax and the responsibilities of modern athletes. (00:01:00) Producing When America Took The Field (00:04:35) Driving To Shea After 9/11 (00:10:32) Piazza's Iconic Home Run (00:17:57) Baseball's Healing Impact (00:24:24) Sandy Koufax Birthday Encounter

Craigie and Big Mac debate the proper way to order a martini and share their distaste for bartenders who ask if the drink should be "on the rocks." They also recount a rough experience with Wild Turkey pickleback shots and explore the world of flavored vodkas and Zyn pouches. (00:01:00) Grand Marnier and Sponsorships (00:04:20) Proper Martini Drinking Etiquette (00:06:58) Picklebacks and Zyn Pouches

Big Mac, Pete Hoffman, and Anthony Gallo establish the rules for their season-long NFL picking competition, featuring mystery penalties for the last-place finisher. They also evaluate the New York Giants' passing game, debating the deep-ball effectiveness of the offense and the talent level of the current wide receiver room. (00:01:01) Pick Competition Stakes (00:04:51) Liquor Sponsor Discussion (00:06:48) Giants Passing Game Analysis

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle discuss Aaron Boone’s case for Manager of the Year following recent tactical decisions for the Yankees. A caller shares a moving story about attending the first Mets game after 9/11, leading to a discussion on the 2001 World Series and the healing power of sports in New York. They also weigh potential roster moves for the Yankees if Jazz Chisholm Jr. misses time with a thumb injury. (00:01:03) Boone Manager Of The Year (00:02:54) Emotional 9/11 Mets Story (00:05:50) Roger Clemens Interview Recap (00:13:29) Subway Series Pitching Preview (00:17:23) Yankees Roster Replacement Debate

The Guys reflect on the emotional weight of the upcoming September 11th anniversary and the significant role sports played in the healing process. The conversation shifts to a captivating documentary about Elizabeth Holmes and the Theranos scandal, including a discussion on her voice and the work of Nathan Fielder. (00:01:01) Reflecting On 9/11 Anniversary (00:04:03) Elizabeth Holmes Documentary (00:10:11) Nathan Fielder Discussion

The Carton Show analyzes Daryl "Moose" Johnston's expectations for a New York Giants improvement and debate the team's depth at wide receiver. A stark warning is issued for the New York Jets, emphasizing that a loss to the Tennessee Titans could spiral into a winless start through mid-October. (00:01:00) Daryl Johnston's Giants Outlook (00:04:16) Office Food Pecking Order (00:07:40) Jets Week 1 Must-Win

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the high ticket prices for the Giants' season opener against the Cowboys and debate the NFL's choice for tonight's Super Bowl rematch on The Carton Show. They also analyze Aaron Boone's decision to bench Aaron Judge for a pinch-hitter during a narrow Yankees win. Additionally, they compare their home television setups and preview upcoming guest appearances. (00:01:00) Giants Cowboys Ticket Prices (00:03:06) NFL Season Opener Preview (00:04:43) Aaron Boone Benches Judge (00:09:30) Home TV Setup Debate (00:12:18) Upcoming Guests Preview

Chris McMonigle reacts to Judge's first game back in 99 days, from how he looked in his three at-bats to how the Yankees will ease him back into being an everyday player. Will he be able to knock the rust off in time? Plus, reactions to another Cam Schlittler masterpiece, if Heliot Ramos' big home run can finally get him going, and the concern level for Jazz Chisholm after leaving the game in the ninth inning with a thumb injury.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTSIntro - Aaron Judge returns! Breaking down the 5-3 win over the Rockies and the Yankees' current playoff positioning.4:22 - Reflecting on the 84 games without Judge and why the pitching staff and Aaron Boone deserve credit for keeping the team in the race.10:12 - Analyzing Judge's first at-bats back, his bat speed, and the team's load management plan for the final 18 games.18:32 - Cam Schlittler's dominant performance and why he is the undisputed AL Cy Young favorite.23:59 - Offensive frustrations against a struggling pitcher and the fallout from Jazz jamming his thumb sliding into second base.27:00 - If Jazz hits the IL, should Anthony Volpe get called up to play second base?

Carton and Big Mac debate the New York Giants' decision to release veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton just before the season opener. They also celebrate the return of Aaron Judge to the Yankees lineup while discussing the ethics of sports figures like Eli Manning and LeBron James promoting unregulated gambling platforms. The conversation extends to the chaos of college football and the bankruptcy filing of Liv Golf. (00:01:55) Giants Cut Darius Slayton (00:05:40) Carton Blasts Organizational Moves (00:11:05) Aaron Judge Returns Tonight (00:15:55) Slayton Vs Darnell Mooney (00:26:40) Managing Judge's Yankee Workload (00:29:35) Evaluating The Giants Depth (00:35:45) College Football Coaching Drama (00:41:10) Liv Golf Files Bankruptcy

Craig and Big Mac debate the New York Giants' decision to release veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton just before the start of the season. They clash over the team's roster depth and the potential impact on offensive continuity while celebrating Aaron Judge's return to the Yankees. They also criticize athletes for endorsing unregulated gambling. (00:01:25) Giants Release Darius Slayton (00:05:30) Giants Roster Depth Concerns (00:10:35) Aaron Judge Yankees Return (00:15:15) Giants Offensive Continuity Debate (00:19:25) Darius Slayton Career Production (00:24:30) Giants Season Victory Predictions

Craig Carton and Big Mac criticize the New York Giants for releasing Darius Slayton, questioning the team's depth and Matt Nagy's influence on the roster. They also examine the return of Aaron Judge, debate the greatest player in Giants history, and share frustrating stories about modern air travel. (00:01:22) Giants Cut Darius Slayton (00:05:00) Herbert vs Jaxson Dart (00:08:15) Aaron Judge Conspiracy Theories (00:12:00) Rich Defends Coaching Decisions (00:15:48) Greatest Giant All Time (00:19:30) Dajon Love Roster Solution (00:24:15) Aaron Judge Return Lineup (00:28:00) Baseball Players Are Soft (00:31:20) Air Travel Etiquette Rant

The conversation critiques Michigan fans for storming the field after a close win and discusses the massive financial debt within the Rutgers athletic department. They also evaluate the New York Giants' decision to move on from Darius Slayton and compare the current offensive rosters of the Jets and Giants. (00:01:20) Michigan Field Storming Controversy (00:04:40) Rutgers Athletic Department Debt (00:07:40) College Football Transfer Portal (00:10:50) Giants Receiver Roster Debate (00:14:50) Jets vs Giants Offense (00:19:50) September 11th Memorial Discussion (00:23:40) Odell Beckham Jr Comparison (00:27:20) Airport and Airplane Etiquette

They discuss the news of Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees and settle a bet over the exact date of his recovery. The conversation covers LIV Golf's bankruptcy filing and an objective analysis of John Harbaugh's coaching record. They also provide tips for fantasy football drafts and preview the emotional Subway Series on the anniversary of 9/11. (00:01:33) Appreciating Local Teachers (00:04:01) High School Athletic Records (00:06:16) Baker Mayfield Extension News (00:07:44) Aaron Judge Return Bet (00:13:02) LIV Golf Filing Bankruptcy (00:17:14) John Harbaugh Coaching Analysis (00:19:48) Fantasy Football Draft Strategy (00:28:12) 9/11 Subway Series Tribute

Craig Carton and the Big Mac discuss the viral fame of Sarah Smith from the Ole Miss game and reflect on past internet sensations like Catherine Webb and Jenn Sterger. They break down a clever legal maneuver by LSU to challenge player eligibility rules and expose perceived hypocrisy within the SEC. Additionally, they explore the bizarre looksmaxing trend involving Clay Matthews and share frustrations regarding travel logistics and elevator etiquette. (00:01:27) Viral Ole Miss Fan (00:03:46) Viral Fan Nostalgia (00:07:38) Clay Matthews AI (00:13:48) LSU Legal Strategy (00:18:23) Travel and Elevators

The Guys critique Michigan fans for storming the field after a narrow win over Western Michigan and examine the financial struggles of the Rutgers athletic department. The conversation also covers Lane Kiffin's intense coaching style and a roster comparison between the New York Giants and Jets. (00:01:02) Michigan Replay Controversy (00:03:14) Rutgers Athletic Debt (00:06:33) Lane Kiffin Intensity (00:10:53) Darius Slayton Discussion (00:16:13) Giants Vs Jets Debate

Craig Carton examines the unsettling themes in classic comedies like Mrs. Doubtfire before shifting to a discussion about OJ Simpson’s failed prank show. He also critiques the New York Giants' wide receiver roster and shares his excitement for the start of the football season. (00:01:00) Dark Comedy Theories (00:03:50) OJ Simpson Reality Show (00:09:43) Football And Giants Analysis

Craig and Big Mac analyze Aaron Judge's return to the Yankees lineup and question the decision to play him in right field after a long injury layoff. They also reflect on a recent flight from Los Angeles, sharing frustrations over airplane Wi-Fi and boarding procedures. (00:01:04) Aaron Judge Returns (00:04:00) Half Inning Statistics (00:07:17) Craig's Travel Story

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Giants' wide receiver depth and the decision to prioritize Darnell Mooney over Darius Slayton. They investigate a social media theory suggesting Aaron Judge’s 84-game absence was a secret suspension rather than an injury, while also breaking down Daniel Jones' preseason preparation and the wild story of an NFL roster imposter. (00:01:01) Jets and Giants Outlook (00:02:30) Preseason Playing Time Debate (00:07:05) Aaron Judge PED Conspiracy (00:13:28) Giants Roster Move Reactions (00:21:04) Dajon Love Viral Story

Craig Carton and Big Mac criticize Derek Jeter, Eli Manning, and LeBron James for promoting unregulated gambling markets. They also debate the New York Giants' controversial decision to release veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton right before the regular season begins. (00:01:00) Entourage Reunion Review (00:01:30) Athlete Gambling Endorsements (00:07:33) Giants Cut Darius Slayton (00:13:23) Giants Season Outlook

The Carton Show focuses on the New York Giants' surprising decision to release Darius Slayton and the ripple effects on Jaxson Dart's passing options. They also discuss Aaron Judge's anticipated return to the Yankees' batting order for the series against the Rockies. (00:02:14) Darius Slayton's Giants Departure (00:06:23) Slayton's Future Landing Spots (00:08:15) Aaron Judge's Yankees Return

Craig and Big Mac criticize the New York Giants for releasing veteran wide receiver Darius Slayton just one day before the season begins. They analyze the impact on the roster's depth and celebrate the news of Aaron Judge's return to the Yankees. (00:01:00) Carton and Big Mac Return (00:01:29) Giants Cut Darius Slayton (00:11:33) Aaron Judge Returns Tonight

Chris McMonigle and Nick Kostos on the Yankees’ chances of catching the Rays and winning the AL East. Plus: -Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on the Yankees’ window to catch the Rays -CMac and Antony Gallo on the Yankees’ pitching staff needing to go deeper into games -Shaun and Tiki on Cam Schlitter’s home/road splits and possible playoff dilemma -Gio on Yankees fans seemingly disliking this year’s team -Gio and Bobby Berger from Bob Does Sports discuss if the Yankees are overachievers

The Jets have made it clear that Cade Klubnik is their backup quarterback, and our hosts are VERY concerned across the board. Gio says Gang Green missed the boat in adding a veteran to back up Geno Smith, Chris McMonigle can't believe the Jets don't have interest in Joe Milton, and Evan Roberts is struggling to see the plan. Plus, Evan and Tiki ponder if the Jets can make a big splash and trade for a veteran quarterback in the future.

Tiki Barber is concerned that Malik Nabers will not play in the Giants season opener after hearing John Harbaugh's latest comments. Plus, full reactions to the team's 53-man roster being revealed, including Shaun Morash declaring that Odell Beckham Jr. earned his spot, while Damien Woody believes Beckham can be a quality No. 2 receiver this year. Morash also declares that John Harbaugh's presence is actually underrated.

Big Mac and Zach Gelb analyze the shocking season-opening loss by Rutgers to UMass and debate the future of Greg Schiano. They are joined by NFL great Kurt Warner to preview the local football season and former Yankee Roger Clemens to discuss the pennant race. (00:01:54) Rutgers Debacle Against UMass (00:08:35) Yankees Chase The Rays (00:14:39) Giants And Jets Expectations (00:23:45) WFAN History And Legends (00:07:39) Interview With Roger Clemens (00:08:37) Interview With Kurt Warner (00:16:06) Eli Manning Hall Debate (00:18:46) Wednesday Wheel On Friday

Big Mac and Zach Gelb break down the national embarrassment of Rutgers football losing to UMass as 29-point favorites. They also analyze the Yankees' chances of catching the Rays in the AL East and recount legendary stories from WFAN history, including a wild encounter involving Don Imus. (00:01:21) Rutgers Embarrassment Against UMass (00:06:25) Schiano's Coaching Future (00:08:15) Yankees AL East Chase (00:14:24) Giants and Jets Outlook (00:20:05) Boomer and Carton Anniversary (00:23:54) Legendary Don Imus Stories

Hall of Fame quarterback Kurt Warner joins Chris McMonigle and Zach Gelb to discuss Jackson Dart's future with the Giants and the potential of the Jets' offense. They also evaluate the impact of Odell Beckham Jr.'s return and the embarrassing Rutgers loss to UMass. (00:02:20) Yankees Series Preview (00:07:24) Odell Beckham Jr. Return (00:13:13) Giants Season Expectations (00:19:09) Rutgers Football Debacle (00:25:45) WNBA News And Patriots (00:08:01) Warner On Jackson Dart (00:14:18) Evaluation Of Geno Smith (00:24:22) Eli Manning Hall Fame (00:33:41) Giants vs Jets Outlook

They analyze whether Eli Manning deserves a spot in the Hall of Fame and compare his postseason success to Ben Roethlisberger. The discussion also covers potential high-profile candidates to lead Rutgers football and a look ahead to the NFL season. Additionally, they revisit classic one-hit wonders and share humorous wedding tradition stories. (00:01:47) Wedding Traditions and Songs (00:06:15) Eli Manning HOF Debate (00:09:45) Ben Roethlisberger Comparisons (00:13:30) NFL Season Outlook (00:18:15) The Thunderdome Wheel Game (00:23:45) Rutgers Head Coach Search

Chris McMonigle and Zach Gelb are joined by legendary pitcher Roger Clemens to discuss his illustrious career and the current state of Major League Baseball. They also debate Eli Manning's Hall of Fame credentials and evaluate the San Francisco 49ers' prospects for the upcoming season. (00:03:53) Eli vs Peyton Manning (00:08:19) 49ers Season Preview (00:17:32) Mets Roster News (00:24:12) Tom Coughlin's Legacy (00:35:41) Roger Clemens Interview (00:39:43) Evolution of Pitching (00:50:20) Hall of Fame Snubs (01:04:45) Steroid Era Debate

Zach Gelb joins the program to debate which professional sports teams are the most unproductive franchises in history, focusing on the Detroit Lions and Cleveland Browns. They transition into playing "The Wheel," competing in categories like non-quarterback Super Bowl MVPs and 1998 box office hits. (00:02:07) Worst Franchise in Sports (00:07:29) Ben Simmons and Basketball (00:12:36) Beatles versus Yankees Debate (00:17:52) Playing the Wednesday Wheel (00:22:24) Mets and Giants Trivia

Guest Zach Gelb joins "Tony" Gallo and Pete Hoffman for a round of trivia games involving Super Bowl MVPs and MLB history. Tony Gallo clinches a victory by identifying a classic 1998 film as the segment wraps with a New York Yankees lineup update. (00:01:00) The Wednesday Wheel Begins (00:03:35) Non-QB Super Bowl MVPs (00:05:38) Mets And Giants Trivia (00:10:48) Guessing 1998's Top Movie (00:13:58) Yankees Lineup Update

C-Mac and Zach evaluate Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame credentials by comparing his postseason heroics against his regular-season statistics. They also discuss various wedding traditions and preview an upcoming interview with Roger Clemens regarding his infamous postseason incident. (00:01:00) Iconic Wedding Songs (00:04:10) Cultural Reception Traditions (00:06:17) Eli Manning HOF Debate (00:10:19) Patriots Super Bowl Losses (00:12:53) NFL Season Predictions

On The Carton Show, Big Mac and Zach Gelb react to the return of Odell Beckham Jr. to the Giants, questioning if he can still be a productive mentor. They also criticize Rutgers for an embarrassing loss to UMass and preview the Yankees' series against the Padres. (00:01:00) Karaoke and Athlete Names (00:02:45) Yankees Series Preview (00:07:43) Odell Beckham Jr. Return (00:12:52) Malik Nabers Injury Health (00:17:41) Rutgers' Loss to UMass

Big Mac and Zach Gelb share their outlook on the New York football season and the impressive success of the Los Angeles Rams. They reflect on WFAN history, including the debut of Boomer and Carton, and recount personal encounters with the legendary Don Imus. (00:01:00) New York Football Outlook (00:02:31) Analyzing Rams Success (00:07:38) WFAN Anniversary Memories (00:10:52) Personal Don Imus Stories

Rutgers football has become the laughingstock of college football after an absolutely disastrous loss to UMass. Chris McMonigle and Zach Gelb break down the embarrassing performance, the 30 unanswered points, and why they believe Greg Schiano’s time in Piscataway may have finally come to an end. The guys also hear from Rutgers fans who are fed up with the program and debate whether Rutgers can realistically compete in the Big Ten. Then, the conversation shifts to the Yankees, as New York continues its push to chase down Tampa Bay for the AL East crown. Is it time to stop talking about the Wild Card and start thinking about winning the division? Zach Gelb is filling in for Craig Carton alongside Chris McMonigle on WFAN's Carton Show.

Rutgers football suffered one of the most embarrassing losses in program history, falling to UMass after entering the game as a massive favorite. Chris McMonigle and Zach Gelb break down the disastrous performance and question whether Greg Schiano’s time at Rutgers has finally come to an end. Then, the conversation turns to the Yankees. After Tampa Bay’s recent struggles and New York getting healthier, the Yankees are suddenly just three games back in the loss column with a huge series against San Diego on deck. Are the Yankees about to make a serious run at the AL East and the No. 1 seed? Zach Gelb is filling in for Craig Carton on the Carton Show with Big Mac.

Chris McMonigle and Nick Kostos evaluate the New York Yankees' chances of winning the division and their postseason rotation depth. They also provide a comprehensive NFL preview covering the Giants' offensive potential, the Jets' backup quarterback search, and division predictions for the upcoming season. (00:01:58) Nick Kostos Joins Show (00:07:10) Yankees Division Title Race (00:14:27) Hip Hop Legend Debate (00:19:30) Giants Season Expectations (00:29:40) NFL Division Winner Picks (00:37:36) Painful Yankees Playoff Losses (00:45:18) Top 90s Music Hits (00:53:44) Don Imus WFAN Stories (01:05:22) Will Levis Jets Workout (01:11:30) Super Bowl Prediction Talk

Big Mac and Nick Kostos break down the New York Yankees' late-inning heroics and Clarke Schmidt's dominant season as they chase the division title. They also examine the New York Giants' coaching and offensive outlook, debating whether Daniel Jones can solidify himself as the franchise quarterback. (00:01:25) Nick Kostos Joins McMonigle (00:06:00) Yankees Chasing Division Lead (00:12:50) Eminem And Hip-Hop Memories (00:17:05) Giants Coaching Staff Analysis (00:20:35) Aaron Boone Management Critique (00:23:40) Daniel Jones Franchise Evaluation

Nick Kostos joins Big Mac to discuss why he believes the New York Giants can secure a 2-0 start by exploiting weaknesses in the Dallas Cowboys and Los Angeles Rams. They evaluate the New York Jets' offensive outlook with Geno Smith and break down why they are fading certain quarterbacks like Justin Fields. The conversation also explores the best uniforms in NFL history and various quarterback ratings. (00:01:20) NFL Week 1 Anticipation (00:04:22) Giants Potential 2-0 Start (00:10:22) Jets Offensive Optimism (00:17:43) NFL Uniform History Debate (00:22:30) Quarterback Passer Ratings (00:27:11) Ravens and Steelers Outlook

McMonigle and Nick Kostos take a nostalgic trip through painful memories of Giants, Yankees, and Knicks defeats, debating whether the 2001 World Series was worse than the 2004 ALCS. They also discuss the history of WFAN, sharing personal stories from their days as interns and an encounter with the legendary Don Imus. (00:01:20) Ninja Turtles Debate (00:05:05) Animation Style Critiques (00:06:58) Painful Sports Memories (00:11:33) The Crying Game (00:16:32) Aaron Boone Tenure (00:18:29) Astros Cheating Scandal (00:22:30) Nerdy Music Habits (00:26:23) Yacht Rock Metallica (00:28:10) Patrick Ewing Era (00:32:30) 2001 vs 2004

Nick Costos and Big Mac evaluate the New York Jets' decision to work out Will Levis as a potential backup for Geno Smith. They also discuss the physical durability of Jaxson Dart and Cam Skattebo while debating whether modern NFL offenses are shifting back to heavy personnel sets. (00:01:21) Tupac Murder Case Resolution (00:02:08) Giants Star Injury Concerns (00:05:45) Derek Jeter Rehab Lessons (00:09:14) Resurgence Of NFL Fullbacks (00:12:31) Top NFL Coaching Hierarchy (00:15:36) Will Levis Jets Workout (00:20:55) Competitive Pickleball Lifestyle (00:24:20) Sports Media Office Culture

Chris McMonigle and Nick Kostos debate the best 90s one-hit wonders before sharing personal stories about the emotional power of the Beatles. They analyze the New York Giants' roster and Malik Nabors' health while offering bold predictions for the NFC North and South. They also provide specific fashion advice for men and discuss Bill Belichick's clever stadium tactics. (00:01:20) 90s Music Debates (00:05:38) Beatles Emotional Stories (00:08:41) Giants Season Outlook (00:12:43) Fashion and Insecurity (00:18:14) NFC South Analysis (00:21:48) NFC North Preview (00:25:12) Patriots Scoreboard Scandal

ChrisMcMonigle and Nick kostos dive into the weird world of AI-generated Yacht Rock versions of Metallica hits on The Carton Show. They also discuss the emotional weight of sports milestones, like Patrick Ewing's exhale, and debate which Yankees playoff losses stung the most. (00:01:00) AI Metallica Yacht Rock (00:07:31) Emotional Knicks Championship Memories (00:10:34) Painful Yankees Postseason Losses

McMonigle and Nick Kostos share their favorite Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles before diving into the most emotional moments of their sports fandom on The Carton Show. They recount devastating losses for the Giants, Knicks, and Yankees, including the infamous 2003 playoff collapse against the 49ers. (00:01:00) Music and Ninja Turtles (00:06:12) Emotional Sports Moments (00:13:08) NY Sports Heartbreak (00:18:02) Aaron Boone's Future (00:19:57) Astros Cheating Scandal

Big Mac and Nick Kostos rank the best uniforms in NFL history, highlighting the New York Giants' legacy sets and the Eagles' Kelly greens. They dive into Lamar Jackson's impressive passer rating and debate his efficiency as a pocket passer compared to public perception. Finally, Costos explains why the NFC North is the most unpredictable division in football with all four teams capable of finishing first or last. (00:01:32) Ranking Top NFL Uniforms (00:06:50) NFL Quarterback Trivia Challenge (00:09:19) Evaluating Lamar Jackson's Greatness (00:12:18) NFC North Unpredictable Division

C-Mac and Nick Kostos discuss the intense preparation required for national sports talk and balancing family life during the NFL season on The Carton Show. They engage in a debate over whether Home Alone 2 surpasses the original film before shifting focus to the gridiron. Nick Kostos offers a bold guarantee for the Jets' season opener against the Titans and critiques the quarterback situations in New York and Pittsburgh. (00:01:03) National Broadcasting Prep (00:05:49) Home Alone Sequel Debate (00:09:44) Jets Week 1 Guarantee (00:13:31) Justin Fields Discussion (00:15:58) Jets Quarterback Depth

Nick Kostos joins the conversation to evaluate the New York Giants' defensive front and their potential to pressure elite quarterbacks this season. They also discuss the optimistic outlook for the New York Jets, highlighting why Geno Smith is positioned for a major bounce-back year with improved protection and playmakers. (00:01:01) Giants Pass Rush Discussion (00:04:44) Jets Offensive Optimism (00:08:44) Studio Banter and Ads

Big Mac and Nick Kostos analyze the potential for a New York Giants resurgence under the leadership of John Harbaugh. They debate the future of Jaxson Dart as a franchise quarterback and evaluate how a new coaching staff can bring respectability back to the organization. (00:01:05) New York Baseball Recap (00:02:14) Giants Coaching Optimism (00:09:11) Jaxson Dart's Future

Big Mac and Nick Kostos analyze the Yankees' postseason chances on The Cardin Show, focusing on Austin Wells' recent heroics. They debate Aaron Boone's managerial DNA compared to figures like Bruce Bochy and discuss the talent gap between the American and National Leagues. (00:01:00) Hip-Hop Intro (00:03:08) Yankees Performance Analysis (00:06:03) Austin Wells' Big Hit (00:08:18) World Series Contender Debate (00:10:45) Managerial Impact Discussion

Chris McMonigle and Nick Kostos analyze the New York Yankees' chances of overtaking the Tampa Bay Rays in the American League East. They discuss the impact of Aaron Judge's return and Cam Schlittler's bid for the Cy Young Award following a dominant performance. (00:01:00) Nick Kostos Joins Big Mac (00:02:55) Mets Beat The Rays (00:03:22) Cam Schlittler's Cy Young Run (00:05:13) Aaron Judge's Impending Return (00:09:55) Yankees' AL East Chances

Chris McMonigle and Anthony Gallo analyze the New York Yankees' performance, focusing on Gerrit Cole's durability and the competition between Spencer Jones and Trent Grisham. They also discuss the Los Angeles Clippers' NBA penalties, the sale of the LA Angels, and the New York Jets' backup quarterback situation. (00:01:50) Introduction and School Stories (00:04:32) Gerrit Cole Durability Concerns (00:15:25) Yankees Outfield Debate (00:29:55) LA Angels Sale Analysis (00:24:18) Clippers NBA Penalties (00:34:00) Jets Backup Quarterback Situation (00:28:10) Giants Season Expectations

Big Mac and Anthony Gallo analyze the New York Yankees' victory over the Angels, specifically focusing on Gerrit Cole's velocity and his tendency to struggle once his pitch count rises. They discuss whether Spencer Jones has earned a permanent spot in the lineup over Trent Grisham. Between sports segments, they share humorous stories about back-to-school morning chaos and the struggles of being a parent to the tooth fairy. (00:01:20) Morning School Routine (00:04:02) Gerrit Cole’s Command (00:08:15) Bullpen Depth Concerns (00:16:25) Spencer Jones’ Impact (00:23:13) Parenting and Injuries (00:29:28) Tooth Fairy Problems (00:37:53) Yankees Rotation Debate

Chris McMonigle and Sal Gallo weigh the merits of sticking with the veteran Trent Grisham versus starting the rookie sensation Spencer Jones in centerfield as the postseason approaches. They also analyze Gerrit Cole's recent performance and discuss the impact of Stan Kroenke's potential purchase of the Los Angeles Angels on MLB's financial landscape. (00:01:20) Jones vs. Grisham Debate (00:02:31) Cole's Recent Performance (00:07:57) The Postseason Threat (00:11:50) Ben Rice's Slump (00:14:49) Centerfield Defensive Comparison (00:18:13) Goldschmidt's Limited Role (00:23:34) Hoff's Music Taste (00:28:44) Angels Sale Ramifications (00:36:15) MLB Spending Habits (00:46:35) Mike Trout's Legacy

Big Mac and Gallo analyze the severe NBA penalties handed down to the Los Angeles Clippers in their simulation, including the loss of five draft picks. They shift focus to the gridiron to examine the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the decision to rely on Geno Smith and Cade Klubnik. The conversation also explores personal traditions like scoring baseball games by hand and celebrity sightings on Disney cruises. (00:01:20) Gallo's AS Roma Shirt (00:05:20) Disney Cruise Celebrity Miss (00:14:30) Yankees Junior Name Trivia (00:18:00) Art Of Scoring Games (00:23:48) Clippers Receive Massive Penalties (00:35:30) Jets Backup Quarterback Concerns (00:53:05) Traffic Report

Chris McMonigle and Gallo evaluate the New York Jets' roster, focusing on the urgent need for a franchise quarterback in the 2025 draft. They discuss the potential of Geno Smith, the validity of tanking for a high pick, and the rumors surrounding Mike Tomlin as a future head coach. The conversation also features a lighter segment on personal collections and childhood nostalgia. (00:01:20) Giants Season Expectations (00:06:00) Backup Quarterback Concerns (00:12:14) 2025 Draft Scenarios (00:17:23) Potential Burrow Trade (00:23:30) Nostalgic Childhood Hobbies (00:27:30) Evaluating Draft Needs (00:35:00) Mike Tomlin Rumors

Chris McMonigle and the crew share stories from their summer vacations, discussing why they still feel like children when it comes to food, video games, and bingo. They also analyze the New York Giants' roster and the optimism surrounding the team's outlook heading into the season. (00:02:10) Childhood Food Takes (00:05:15) Chicken Tender Obsession (00:10:15) Retiring From Shoelaces (00:15:15) Video Game Excitement (00:19:45) Fast Food Desserts (00:23:45) Black Coffee Debate (00:27:30) Giants Roster Analysis

Will Malik Nabers be ready to go? Who will get the credit or blame: John Harbaugh or Joe Schoen?

C-Mac and Gallo go through the NFL teams and discuss which would potentially allow the Jets to trade into the top 5 of the 2027 draft for a quarterback.

C-Mac and Gallo debate on how the Jets should approach trying to get their quarterback of the future.

C-Mac and Gallo discuss the Jets' QB room beyond starter Geno Smith and how it can improve.

Instant reactions from C-Mac and Gallo on the news about the Clippers being forced to give up multiple draft picks while members of the organization are fined and suspended.

Does the sale of the Los Angeles Angels being $4 billion prove that the issue with MLB's competitive balance stems from the small market teams not spending enough?

C-Mac and Gallo debate on who should be playing when Aaron Judge comes back: Trent Grisham or Spencer Jones

C-Mac and Gallo have concerns about the Yankees starters not being able to go deep in games, putting more stress on the bullpen.

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent series of embarrassing losses and discusses the instability within the team's bullpen. They review Tony Romo’s official statement regarding his health and examine Stan Kroenke’s newest acquisition of the Los Angeles Angels. Pop culture headlines, including a music debate and a look at upcoming New York Giants expectations, are also covered. (00:01:50) Yankees Collapse In Anaheim (00:05:27) Bullpen Management And Depth (00:14:37) New York Mets Future (00:21:07) Tony Romo CBS Update (00:24:34) Stan Kroenke Buys Angels (00:30:44) Will Fleming Broadcast Controversy (00:12:15) Duane Keffe D Davis (00:23:50) Traffic Report (00:27:40) Sydney Sweeney Lingerie Line

Big Mac analyzes the Yankees' lifeless effort in Anaheim and the dilemma of prioritizing the division title over player health during The Carton Show. They also react to news of Stanley Kroenke purchasing the Angels and debate whether the team possesses the same championship DNA as the Knicks. (00:01:20) Yankees Fall In Anaheim (00:04:41) Chasing The Rays (00:08:41) Roster And Bullpen Flux (00:12:22) Strategy For Postseason (00:18:08) Movie And Music Banter (00:22:14) Yankee Bullpen Debate (00:26:57) Knicks DNA Comparison (00:24:01) Kroenke Buys The Angels (00:29:56) Red Sox Replay Debate

Chris McMonigle reacts to the conviction of Duane Davis in the Tupac Shakur murder case and debates the early arrival of Sam Adams Oktoberfest. He evaluates the Yankees' offensive struggles and the potential of Spencer Jones while addressing Tony Romo's statement on his health and CBS broadcasting future. (00:01:38) Tupac Shakur Murder Case (00:05:28) Sam Adams Oktoberfest Debate (00:12:39) Yankees Postseason Offense Concerns (00:16:30) Grisham Versus Spencer Jones (00:22:13) Tony Romo Health Statement (00:29:35) NFL Pre-Game Show Value (00:39:08) Jazz Chisholm Retaliation Debate (00:41:10) Cookie Puss Origin Story

McMonigle and Hoffman analyze the New York Giants' upcoming season, focusing on the urgency of winning early and the critical health of rookie Malik Nabors. They debate the team's potential for an upset against the Rams while also discussing the New York Mets' roster management and the possibility of pursuing Tarik Skubal. (00:01:48) Hoffman's Inheritance Scam Call (00:04:35) Rick's Beatles Nostalgia Call (00:07:10) Giants Early Season Pressure (00:14:15) Rams Trap Game Potential (00:20:35) Nabors And Dart Connection (00:29:15) Debating NFL's Unlikable Teams (00:31:55) Position Players Pitching Issues (00:37:00) Mets Bullpen Future Roles (00:40:45) Pursuing Tarik Skubal Trade

Big Mac addresses the skepticism surrounding the Giants' Week 1 matchup against the Dallas Cowboys, questioning if Dallas is actually an NFC juggernaut. He also discusses Sidney Sweeney’s new lingerie line, Mets pitching matchups, and the controversy surrounding Tua Tagovailoa’s social media posts. Finally, he shares personal stories about high school sports awards and memories of Franklin Square. (00:02:10) Sidney Sweeney Lingerie Line (00:09:30) Giants vs Cowboys Preview (00:13:41) Jackson Dart QB Discussion (00:19:34) Dexter Lawrence Impact Analysis (00:25:08) Yankees Roster Update News (00:29:30) Chris McMonigle Award Story (00:36:56) Franklin Square Neighborhood Memories (00:15:43) Mets vs Brewers Preview (00:22:00) Tua Tagovailoa Twitter Controversy

C-Mac and Anthony Gallo discuss whether Notre Dame can thrive without a conference schedule and debate the realistic expectations for Jackson Dart and the Giants this season. They take calls from passionate fans regarding the team's difficult schedule and the impact of the new coaching staff. (00:01:20) Nostalgic TV Talk (00:07:17) Callers Connect with Hosts (00:08:38) Notre Dame Season Outlook (00:10:54) Debating Giants Reality (00:16:46) Music and Steve Miller (00:17:50) Giants Schedule Debate (00:20:30) Evaluating Jackson Dart (00:23:20) Traffic Report (00:24:50) Tom Hanks Film Rankings

C-Mac reviews Sydney Sweeney's new lingerie collection before diving into New York Giants football. He discusses the high stakes of the Week 1 game against the Dallas Cowboys and takes calls regarding the performance of Jaxson Dart and Dexter Lawrence. (00:01:48) Sydney Sweeney's Lingerie (00:05:11) Dick's Logo Discussion (00:07:17) Giants Opening Game Debate (00:14:01) Analyzing Jaxson Dart (00:20:49) Dexter Lawrence's Impact

C-Mac evaluates the New York Giants' offensive potential and the importance of health for Malik Nabors. The discussion includes a debate on Major League Baseball's blowout games and the possible implementation of a forfeit rule. Finally, they look ahead to the New York Mets' offseason and the potential pursuit of Tarik Skubal. (00:01:00) The Wheel and The Duke (00:02:45) Giants Offensive Potential (00:09:06) Seahawks and Rams Analysis (00:12:54) MLB Blowout Forfeit Debate (00:17:02) Mets Offseason and Skubal

Chris McMonigle reacts to Mad Dog Russo's claim that the Giants are guaranteed to start the season 0-2. He emphasizes the critical importance of Malik Nabers being healthy for Week 1 and discusses why the Rams matchup could be a trap game for Los Angeles. They also revisit a bizarre phone call Pete Hoffman received regarding an inheritance scam. (00:01:09) Hoffman's Bizarre Texas Call (00:05:40) Smoking Doctors And Beatles (00:08:03) Malik Nabers Injury Status (00:10:56) Rams Giants Trap Game (00:14:08) Giants Slow Start Concerns

McMonigle explores Tony Romo's recent statement addressing his health issues and the likelihood of his return to the broadcast booth. They also discuss the value of high-profile announcers compared to pregame studio shows and share anecdotes from the Giants locker room involving Odell Beckham Jr. and Dexter Lawrence. Additionally, callers weigh in on the Jazz Chisholm Jr. controversy and the surprising history of Cookie Puss. (00:02:37) Tony Romo Health Statement (00:06:38) Future Of NFL Broadcasting (00:12:00) Giants Locker Room Stories (00:17:16) Jazz Chisholm Base Stealing (00:20:29) Cookie Puss Alien Origins

C-Mac discusses the recent legal developments in the Tupac Shakur case and laments the arrival of seasonal items like Oktoberfest beer in early August. He also evaluates the New York Yankees' roster, debating the future of Trent Grisham in the lineup compared to Spencer Jones. (00:01:31) Tupac Case Update (00:03:55) Seasonal Items Rant (00:11:47) Yankees' Offensive Concerns (00:14:07) Grisham Versus Jones

Big Mac discusses the news of Stanley Kroenke and Kroenke Sports and Entertainment purchasing the Los Angeles Angels from Arte Moreno. He explores the franchise's history of expensive contract failures and takes a call regarding the recent Red Sox broadcast controversy involving Will Fleming. (00:01:12) Kroenke Buys Angels (00:04:40) Angels Ownership History (00:08:06) Red Sox-Yankees Debate

The Carton Show analyzes the New York Yankees' organizational philosophy following a frustrating loss to the Angels. They compare the Yankees' DNA to the New York Knicks' recent success and debate whether 95-win seasons satisfy the franchise's championship expectations. The discussion also touches on Long Island's music scene and the questionable quality of the movie Teen Wolf 2. (00:01:00) Long Island Bands (00:03:01) Teen Wolf Discussion (00:06:55) Yankees Reliever Strategy (00:13:11) Yankees Versus Knicks (00:20:31) Winning Standard Debate

Big Mac criticizes the New York Yankees for their lackluster performance against the Los Angeles Angels following a high-energy series against the Red Sox. The discussion covers the team's struggling bullpen, the division race against the Rays, and the return of Aaron Judge. (00:01:07) Yankees' Disappointing Loss to Angels (00:05:38) Chasing the Tampa Bay Rays (00:10:16) Revamping the Yankees' Bullpen (00:15:00) Mets and NFL News

The Yankees made a statement by taking three of four from the Red Sox, including a beatdown in Sunday's series finale. Chris McMonigle celebrates the huge victory, what it means for the postseason, and what it says about how far this Yankee team can go in October. Plus, looking at the Yankees platoon identity moving forward, praising Heliot Ramos for finally coming through with a big hit and Will Warren for his masterful start, while the offense showed encouraging signs across the board.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS3:36 - Breaking down the standings impact: The Yankees move four games up on Boston, which is essentially five games thanks to securing the tiebreaker.6:14 - Reacting to the Red Sox broadcast calling Jazz Chisholm a "bush league" player for stealing bases while up six runs.10:04 - Analyzing Aaron Boone's heavily debated platoon strategy. The decision to sit hot left-handed hitters like Luis Garcia and Ben Rice in favor of righties like Paul Goldschmidt and Ramos against left-handed pitching ultimately pays off.29:23 - Carlos Rodon's start unravels after a poor baserunning decision and terrible send at third base involving Amed Rosario.39:28 - Concerns over Max Fried's Saturday start, specifically a noticeable drop in his fastball velocity down to 92-93 mph.45:36 - Praise for Paul Blackburn and the bullpen for escaping late-inning jams to secure the victory.52:41 - Will Warren delivers the best start of his young career in a massive spot, retiring 13 consecutive Red Sox batters after allowing a leadoff double.1:04:51 - Ramos crushes a critical three-run home run on a 1-2 breaking ball.1:12:20 - Tampa Bay Rays update: The Rays sweep the Padres by rallying against Mason Miller in the ninth inning to stay five games ahead of the Yankees.1:18:52 - Looking ahead to the West Coast road trip against the Angels and Padres. Plus, predictions that Aaron Judge will return to the lineup for the upcoming homestand against the Colorado Rockies.

Big Mac analyzes the New York Yankees' dominant series win against the Boston Red Sox and the subsequent fallout from the Boston broadcast booth. He evaluates the New York Giants' roster cuts, labeling Evan Neal and Jalen Hyatt as major busts while discussing the impact of Odell Beckham Jr.'s return. Additionally, they project the long-term outlook for the Knicks following potential contract discounts from Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges. (00:02:05) Yankees Crush Red Sox (00:16:59) Red Sox Broadcaster Controversy (00:22:23) Aaron Boone Management Strategy (00:30:18) Giants Roster Disappointments (00:37:44) Rams Roster Construction Envy (00:45:08) Dramatic MLB Catch Replays (00:09:27) Knicks Contract Extension Talk

McMonigle recaps the New York Yankees' series win over the Boston Red Sox, focusing on the mental edge established during their 16-1 blowout. On The Carton Show, he critiques the WEEI radio broadcast that labeled Jazz Chisholm "Bush League" for stealing bases. The discussion also evaluates the New York Giants' roster cuts, including the status of Jalin Hyatt and Evan Neal. (00:01:31) Giants Roster Moves (00:05:03) Yankees Statement Series (00:08:51) Will Warren's Dominance (00:15:32) Red Sox Radio Outrage (00:20:06) Jazz Chisholm Controversy (00:24:46) Platoon Lineup Debate (00:33:56) Yankees Series Edge

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman break down the Baltimore Orioles claiming Luis Robert Jr. off waivers and what it means for the New York Mets' financial future. They also debate the postseason impact of Jazz Chisholm Jr., analyze Carlos Beltran’s legacy, and argue over whether Stan Lee or Steven Spielberg has a greater cultural footprint. (00:01:20) Luis Robert Jr. Claimed (00:05:15) Pete Alonso Performance Debate (00:10:00) Jazz Chisholm Playoff Expectations (00:14:00) Pedro Martinez Dominance (00:17:15) Carlos Beltran Legacy Documentary (00:21:00) Yankees Red Sox Series Recap (00:26:00) Yankees Playoff Bullpen Strategy (00:30:00) Al Pacino Classic Movies (00:38:20) Stan Lee Versus Spielberg (00:43:30) Bear Encounter In Warwick

Chris McMonigle reacts to the New York Giants' decision to bring back Odell Beckham Jr. while moving on from major draft disappointments like Evan Neal. The Carton Show explores the New York Yankees' current lineup strategy and debates the best movie sequels and old-school candy. They also weigh in on the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the challenges of watching every NFL game on Sundays. (00:02:21) Beckham Jr. Rejoins Giants (00:05:54) Giants Recent Draft Busts (00:12:11) New York Sports Update (00:15:27) Yankees Lineup Debate (00:19:46) Legacy of Odell Beckham (00:24:08) 80s Movies and Candy (00:30:02) Jets Quarterback Options (00:37:44) Giants Defensive Expectations (00:45:05) NFL Sunday Ticket Debate

McMonigle recaps a dominant series win for the New York Yankees over the Boston Red Sox on The Carton Show, highlighting Aaron Boone's role in Jazz Chisholm Jr. stealing bases. He analyzes the Los Angeles Rams' unique approach to roster management and the NFL's 'fungible' salary cap. The conversation also explores the New York Giants' draft struggles under general manager Joe Shane. (00:01:21) Jalen Brunson Birthday Song (00:04:45) Heussler's Yankee Hate (00:12:11) Rams Salary Cap Magic (00:16:59) Giants Draft History Analysis (00:25:16) Yankees Crush Red Sox (00:41:27) Boone Defends Jazz Chisholm (00:46:29) Savannah Bananas Entertainment

Anthony Gallo analyzes the Yankees' recent dominance over the Red Sox and argues why they are the primary World Series contender in a weak American League. He and DJ Hoff also discuss the Mets' pitching struggles and evaluate David Stearns' roster management. (00:01:35) Yankees Dominance Over Boston (00:07:24) American League Playoff Field (00:09:15) Mets Pitching Rotation Struggles (00:15:30) Cubs World Series Hopes (00:21:43) Aaron Judge Return Update

Chris McMonigle expresses frustration over the Los Angeles Rams' ability to consistently manipulate the salary cap to retain superstars like Aaron Donald. He also recounts legendary stories of Bob Heussler's disdain for the Yankees and discusses the hit-or-miss draft record of Giants GM Joe Schoen. (00:01:01) Celebrating Jalen Brunson (00:04:06) Bob Heussler Yankee Hate (00:10:15) Rams Cap Management Issues (00:15:21) Joe Schoen Draft Critique (00:23:11) On-Air Parenting Banter

Big Mac ridicules Craig Carton's questionable movie takes and his preference for "old person" candies like bottle caps and spice drops. They transition into a debate regarding the New York Jets' quarterback depth and the necessity of a multi-TV setup for the upcoming NFL season. (00:01:00) Debating 80s Movie Sequels (00:04:26) Craig's Bizarre Candy Tastes (00:06:40) Jets Quarterback Room Concerns (00:16:21) Giants Defensive Matchup Analysis (00:19:41) The Ultimate Sunday Setup

Chris McMonigle evaluates the New York Giants' final roster decisions, specifically highlighting the return of Odell Beckham Jr. and the release of high draft picks Evan Neal and Jalen Hyatt. He reflects on the organization's repeated failures to stabilize the offensive line and receiving corps over recent years. They also take calls regarding Aaron Boone's management of the New York Yankees' batting order during a key rivalry series. (00:02:49) OBJ Makes Giants Roster (00:04:00) Evan Neal Labelled Bust (00:11:09) Giants Personnel Failures (00:15:52) Yankees Lineup Decisions (00:19:43) OBJ Return Reactions

Pete McMonigle and Big Mac debate the cultural impact of Stan Lee compared to Steven Spielberg while revisiting classic movie scenes. They also recount a listener's encounter with a bear during an ice cream bet and look ahead to the Giants' regular-season roster. (00:01:33) Iconic Graduation Songs (00:03:45) Al Pacino Movie Classics (00:10:36) Stan Lee Versus Spielberg (00:15:01) Bear Interrupts Ice Cream Bet (00:17:47) Giants Roster Moves Update

C-Mac analyzes the Orioles' waiver claim of Luis Robert Jr. and reflects on Pete Alonso's late-season surge. They examine Carlos Beltran's complicated history with the Mets and evaluate Aaron Boone’s tactical decisions during the Yankees' series against the Red Sox. (00:01:14) Luis Robert Jr. Claimed (00:05:13) Pete Alonso’s Hot Streak (00:15:36) Carlos Beltran’s Mets Tenure (00:20:36) Yankees Red Sox Recap (00:25:34) Yankees Bullpen Strategy

Chris McMonigle reacts to controversial comments made by Red Sox broadcasters regarding Jazz Chisholm Jr. stealing bases during a blowout win. He defends the aggressive base-running and Aaron Boone's platoon lineup strategies while looking ahead to a potential playoff matchup against Boston. The discussion also examines the validity of baseball's unwritten rules and the Yankees' current team identity. (00:01:13) Giants Roster Moves (00:01:53) Red Sox Broadcast Controversy (00:03:44) Yankees Platoon Lineup Strategy (00:07:07) Boone's Management Style (00:14:02) Baseball's Unwritten Rules

The conversation addresses the heated reaction from the Boston Red Sox radio broadcast regarding Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s decision to steal bases during a late-inning lead. They reveal that Aaron Boone actually attempted to coordinate with the Red Sox bench before the steals occurred, contradicting the narrative of poor sportsmanship. Additionally, the discussion pivots to the New York Giants' recent roster moves involving draft picks Evan Neal and Jalen Hyatt. (00:01:00) Red Sox Broadcast Controversy (00:03:38) WEEI Radio Reaction (00:07:16) Aaron Boone's Warning (00:14:16) Jalen Brunson's Birthday (00:16:41) Giants Roster Cuts

Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle reacts to the New York Yankees' dominant performance against the Boston Red Sox, highlighted by a crushing blowout victory. He addresses the controversy surrounding Jazz Chisholm Jr. stealing bases and provides updates on Aaron Judge's return to the lineup. (00:01:09) Big Mac Riding Solo (00:01:48) Yankees Dismantle Red Sox (00:10:35) Chisholm Base Stealing Drama

Evan Roberts, and Shaun Morash discuss George Lombard Jr.’s defensive struggles and what it could mean for the postseason. Plus: -Why won’t Aaron Boone give Lombard a day off? -Chris McMonigle gives his thoughts on Lombard -Craig Carton says Yankees should have pushed Gerrit Cole back for Red Sox

Geno Smith was sharp in his preseason debut, leading Boomer and Gio to have some level of optimism that the Jets offense will be much improved this year. Shaun Morash went on an epic rant against the optimism level from Jets fans, scoffing at the idea that it's remotely possible for the team to win eight games with Geno under center. Plus, Evan and Morash ponder a Mike Tomlin/Lamar Jackson team-up with the Jets, while Craig Carton debates whether Joe Burrow is a possibility or a pipe dream.

Loads of Giants figures joined WFAN this week to talk about the upcoming season, including John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen, who talked with Boomer and Gio about the makeup of the team and how key players have looked in camp. Plus, Brian Burns discussed the defense's new identity with Evan and Morash, while Jaxson Dart talked about his medical tent narrative, the feeling around camp this year, and much more with Craig and C-Mac.

The Yankees picked a bad time for their offense to regress to its earlier form, musting very little against the Astros in their series finale, losing another game in the loss column ahead of a monster series with the Red Sox. C-Mac is back from vacation and ready to sound off on everything surrounding the Yanks, from the battle between pushing for the division and thinking bigger picture, to the latest on Aaron Judge and his preference to skip a rehab assignment. Plus, Luis Garcia Jr.'s continued tear, George Lombard Jr.'s struggles in the field, and whether Brian Cashman missed the boat with his lack of bullpen moves at the trade deadline given the injury to Fernando Cruz.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS6:17: An analysis of George Lombard's puzzling defensive collapse, marked by six errors in six consecutive games.12:38: Debating Trent Grisham's outfield defense versus his clutch offensive production.16:34: How Jazz is transforming the offense with his speed and small-ball execution despite ongoing inconsistencies at the plate.24:18: The Yankees are operating with a dangerously thin bullpen following Cruz's elbow injury.26:56: Re-evaluating the trade deadline. Brian Cashman's failure to acquire bullpen arms is actively hurting the team.40:00: Aaron Judge plans to skip rehab assignments and return directly to the major league lineup, potentially during the upcoming homestand against Colorado.1:00:36: Looking ahead to the biggest series of the year against the Boston Red Sox, starting with Cam Schlittler on the mound.1:06:05: Breaking down the devastating blow of Giancarlo Stanton's latest injury and the financial realities of his contract buyout.

C-Mac believes giving George Lombard Jr a day off is only going to make things worse. Is Aaron Glen already on the hot seat before the season even starts?

C-Mac says playing Jaxson Dart for a drive against the Jets backups is a waste of time. Instant reaction to the Yankees lineup.

Instant reaction to the news that Max Fried will come off the injured list and pitch against the Red Sox. John Madden tried to sue Frank Caliendo?? Someone faked being a 49ers player and scammed her out of over $1 million??

C-Mac believes giving George Lombard Jr a day off is only going to make things worse. Is Aaron Glen already on the hot seat before the season even starts? C-Mac says playing Jaxson Dart for a drive against the Jets backups is a waste of time. Instant reaction to the Yankees lineup. Instant reaction to the news that Max Fried will come off the injured list and pitch against the Red Sox. John Madden tried to sue Frank Caliendo?? Someone faked being a 49ers player and scammed her out of over $1 million?? Emmanuel Berbari joins the show to preview this crucial Yankees-Red Sox series. Jaxson not expected to play in preseason finale against the Jets.

Emmanuel Berbari joins the show to preview this crucial Yankees-Red Sox series. Jaxson not expected to play in preseason finale against the Jets.

Chris McMonigle and Emmanuel Berbari analyze the New York Yankees' strategy heading into a crucial series against the Boston Red Sox. They evaluate Anthony Volpe's recent defensive struggles, the thinning bullpen depth, and the high-stakes outlook for Aaron Judge's return to the lineup. (00:01:07) Intro with Big Mac (00:05:40) Infield Defensive Issues (00:10:26) Bullpen Management Talk (00:17:50) Jazz Chisholm Jr. Impact (00:24:22) Aaron Judge Return Status

The discussion highlights a massive fraud case involving a man posing as a San Francisco 49ers player to scam women out of $1.3 million. They also dive into the New York Yankees' lineup decisions against left-handed pitching and debate the team's reliance on specific veterans over hot hitters. Additionally, the conversation explores bizarre food preferences among the crew, including a controversial stance on chicken cutlets and ketchup on mac and cheese. (00:01:00) Mannequin Movie Memories (00:03:46) NFL Player Imposter Scam (00:08:46) Peculiar Food Takes (00:12:32) Yankees Lineup Strategy

McMonigle and Gallo react to the news that John Madden once considered suing Frank Caliendo over his famous impression. They also preview the Yankees' pivotal series against the Red Sox and discuss Max Fried's return to the rotation. (00:01:00) Sports Impression Debates (00:03:10) Madden's Feud With Caliendo (00:07:41) Wrestling Promos And Fads (00:11:00) Yankees Red Sox Preview (00:16:27) Max Fried Rotation News

Big Mac and Gallo evaluate the Yankees' decision to bench Luis García and Spencer Jones in favor of a platoon lineup against the Red Sox. They also challenge the reckless reputation of Jaxson Dart while exploring the learning curve of the new Giants offense under Matt Nagy. (00:01:04) Yankees Lineup Strategy (00:07:50) Nostalgia and Dart Narrative (00:12:08) Giants New Offense (00:18:37) Lombard's Defensive Woes

Big Mac analyzes the preseason strategies for the Giants and Jets, specifically debating the playing time for Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith. He also examines the Yankees' missed opportunity with Eugenio Suárez and dismisses a caller's theory about an Aaron Judge suspension. (00:02:14) Jets and Giants QB Plans (00:06:23) Harbaugh's Tough Training Camp (00:08:46) Eugenio Suárez Waiver Talk (00:12:16) Disney and Orlando Vacations (00:16:11) Debunking Judge Suspension Theory

Discussions range from movie nostalgia and Rick Moranis's return to acting to the coaching situation for the New York Jets. Big Mac evaluates Robert Saleh's performance and speculates on Woody Johnson's interest in hiring Mike Tomlin if the team fails to make the playoffs. (00:01:03) Movie Nostalgia and Rick Moranis (00:03:44) Football vs High School Musicals (00:05:13) Giants and Jets Preseason Preview (00:07:19) Evaluating Robert Saleh's Tenure (00:10:36) Mike Tomlin Jets Rumors

Big Mac explains why George Lombard Jr. should continue playing shortstop despite his recent defensive errors, emphasizing that the rookie needs to play through his struggles. He also analyzes the upcoming series against the Red Sox and expresses concern about the durability of the bullpen heading into the postseason. (00:01:00) Beatles and Wedding Playlists (00:02:31) George Lombard Jr. Debate (00:06:30) Red Sox Series Preview (00:12:42) Postseason Bullpen Concerns (00:22:49) Benching For Physical Errors

Big Mac analyzes the high stakes of the Yankees' upcoming series against the Red Sox and its potential impact on their playoff positioning. He also argues against benching George Lombard despite his recent errors, emphasizing the importance of keeping the young shortstop's confidence high. (00:01:00) Yankees-Red Sox Series Stakes (00:05:44) George Lombard's Defensive Slump (00:12:30) Yankees Rotation and NFL News

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle evaluate the offensive impact of Garcia and the defensive lapses of George Lombard Jr. They also discuss the viral body camera footage of Jed York's arrest and Lil Wayne's strict private chef requirements. (00:03:01) Yankees Garcia Trade Move (00:06:00) Lombard's Errors and Defense (00:13:30) Jed York Body Cam (00:23:55) Fantasy Football vs Gambling (00:32:54) Lil Wayne's Private Chef (00:42:26) George Costanza Bobblehead Night (01:02:10) Uncut Gems Anxiety Discussion (00:34:53) Seinfeld Comedy Legacy Debate

Jed York's encounter with law enforcement in Ohio takes a bizarre turn as he is spotted wearing a New York Yankees t-shirt to stay incognito. They also critique George Lombard Jr.'s defensive struggles at shortstop, comparing his recent errors to Anthony Volpe's gold glove performance. Finally, a discussion about Yankee bullpen needs leads to a debate on whether Elmer Rodriguez should transition to a relief role. (00:01:27) Yankee Defensive Problems (00:03:30) Elephant Sound Competition (00:05:30) George Lombard Jr Errors (00:09:26) Elmer Rodriguez Pitching (00:11:55) Jed York Bizarre Arrest (00:21:06) Shortstop Defensive Comparison (00:23:23) Privacy and Alexa Concerns (00:26:03) Hardware Store Habits

Craig and C-Mac discuss why the Jets and Giants need to play their starting quarterbacks in the preseason before diving into Lil Wayne’s requirement for a private chef. They also reminisce about a legendary celebrity fantasy football league and a heated fallout with Bobby Flay. (00:01:25) Preseason Quarterback Playing Time (00:04:50) Radio Studio Audio Failures (00:11:35) Gerrit Cole Pitching Decisions (00:15:25) Lil Wayne's Private Chef (00:19:50) C-Mac's Summer Substitute Hosts (00:25:00) Gambling's Impact On Fantasy (00:35:40) Bobby Flay's Tapas Outrage

Craig and C-Mac discuss the upcoming Sandlot cast reunion and the intersection of fantasy football and sports gambling. They also engage in a heated debate over the ingredients of shepherd's pie before looking ahead to the release of Grand Theft Auto 6. (00:01:20) Sandlot Cast Reunion (00:05:40) Potential Guest Hosts (00:15:20) Gambling At Games (00:21:15) Shepherd's Pie Debate (00:29:20) GTA 6 Release Date (00:38:50) Fortnite and Parenting (00:46:40) Gallo Airtime Discussion

Carton and Big Mac debate the necessity of preseason play for Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith to avoid a slow start against the Cowboys. They also discuss the George Costanza bobblehead night at Yankee Stadium and play a high-stakes round of 'The Wheel' featuring movie and Seinfeld trivia. The conversation concludes with personal reflections on the anxiety of gambling and its portrayal in the film Uncut Gems. (00:01:50) Preseason Reps Debate (00:10:38) Cam Skattebo Mentality (00:16:45) Costanza Bobblehead Night (00:24:30) Quarterback Preparedness Concerns (00:34:36) The Wheel Game (00:58:10) Uncut Gems Anxiety

The Carton Show with Craig & Big Mac explore a story about Jeff Fisher refusing to read Vince Young’s apology letter because of a minor typo. They later transition to a game of "The Wheel," featuring movie songs and a competitive Seinfeld trivia round. Big Mac eventually questions how his colleagues grew up watching Happy Days and Good Times instead of 90s sitcom classics. (00:01:01) Show Introduction (00:01:40) Fisher's Vince Young Snub (00:03:57) Playing The Wheel (00:13:08) Seinfeld TV Debate

Craig and C-Mac celebrate the confirmed release date for Grand Theft Auto 6 and call local shop owner Ben to discuss the shift to digital-only gaming. They also debate parenting tactics involving video game rewards before diving into a bizarre discussion about exotic canned foods and show dynamics. (00:01:00) GTA 6 Release Date (00:03:48) Digital vs Physical Gaming (00:08:53) Parenting and V-Bucks (00:14:05) Tinned Food and Texture (00:17:55) Listener Calls Out Gallo

Craig and C-Mac explore the idea of Mike Francesa making a cameo as a guest host while Craig is away. They also discuss the rise of in-game betting at Yankee Stadium and get into a culinary dispute over the ingredients of a real shepherd's pie. (00:01:02) Dugout Dads and Softball (00:03:32) Gambling and Fantasy Football (00:11:02) Potential Mike Francesa Return (00:15:17) Betting on Every Pitch (00:21:35) Shepherd's Pie Authenticity Debate

Craig Carton debates if legalized gambling is destroying the social fabric of fantasy football for the younger generation. He shares a hilarious story about ordering the entire menu at Bobby Flay's restaurant and reveals the origins of their public fallout over a celebrity league entry fee. (00:01:13) Fantasy Football Trophy Drama (00:02:24) Gambling Impacting Fantasy Sports (00:06:42) In-Person Draft Debates (00:10:27) Bobby Flay League Controversy (00:12:54) Fallout at Gato Restaurant

Craig and C-Mac debate whether the Giants and Jets should play their starters in the preseason before discussing the legendary rumor that Lil Wayne has not eaten a meal without his private chef in twenty years. They also critique their producer's music searching skills and review the guest hosts who filled in during vacation. (00:01:00) Preseason QB Playtime Debate (00:04:22) Theme Song Search Failures (00:08:45) Yankees Pitching Strategy Discussion (00:10:44) Lil Wayne’s Personal Chef (00:17:34) Vacation Guest Host Review

The Carton Show explore the high frequency of New York Yankees gear appearing in police reports and an anecdote about Ben Affleck's refusal to wear a Yankees hat in a film. The conversation also covers Brian Cashman's trade deadline strategy and the performance of players like Anthony Volpe and Austin Wells. Additionally, they discuss the privacy implications of smart devices like Alexa. (00:02:03) York's Incognito Look (00:06:03) Affleck's Hat Refusal (00:08:14) Yankees Roster Analysis (00:13:43) Smart Device Privacy (00:15:38) Hardware Store Habits

Chris McMonigle enjoys a custom song tribute before debating a caller over George Lombard Jr.'s defensive errors and comparisons to Derek Jeter. They analyze the Yankees' improved offense since Cody Bellinger's return and address concerns regarding the bullpen's depth. (00:01:05) Manny Rodriguez Song Tribute (00:04:44) George Lombard Jr. Debate (00:07:43) Cody Bellinger Impact Analysis (00:09:15) Yankees Bullpen Outlook

Carton and Big Mac evaluate the defensive lapses of George Lombard Jr. and the pressure of playing shortstop for the New York Yankees. They also delve into the viral story of San Francisco 49ers owner Jed York being spotted in a Yankees shirt and review Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz's successful outing. (00:01:00) Yankees Offense Discussion (00:03:30) Elephant Sound Contest (00:06:15) George Lombard Jr. Errors (00:10:14) Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz Review (00:13:51) Jed York’s Yankees Shirt

Jaxson Dart and Patrick Ricard discuss the New York Giants' physical training camp and the culture shift under the new coaching staff. They detail the depth of the receiving corps and address the narrative surrounding the quarterback's health. The conversation also covers the New York Yankees' pitching struggles and a heated debate over the NFL's top signal-callers. (00:01:50) Big Mac Returns (00:07:00) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:19:20) Professionalism And Vacation (00:26:45) Disney Cruise Details (00:15:15) Show Culture Rules (00:20:05) Yankees Bullpen Injuries (00:24:20) Patrick Ricard Interview (00:38:20) Jaxson Dart Interview (00:45:40) Receiver Depth Discussion (00:53:15) Training Camp Intensity (00:59:15) NFL QB Tiering (01:07:15) Analyzing Bo Nix (01:14:45) Purdy And Herbert (00:25:50) Interview Style Critique (00:36:15) Bullpen Arms Crisis (00:16:35) Pro Bowl Changes

Carton welcomes Big Mac back from his vacation to debate the New York Yankees' strategy regarding Gerrit Cole's starting schedule. They also preview an upcoming conversation with quarterback Jackson Dart and analyze the state of the Bronx bullpen. (00:01:20) New York Sports Update (00:05:30) Division Race Debate (00:09:19) Big Mac's Welcome Song (00:15:15) Yankees Pitching Struggles (00:20:13) Vacation And Ratings Talk (00:24:01) Radio Tease And Betrayal (00:30:06) Disney Cruise Tipping Debate

Craig and Chris speak with Patrick Ricard and Jackson Dart about the physical intensity of the New York Giants' preseason practices. They analyze the roster depth at wide receiver and debate the merits of classic films like The Rocky Horror Picture Show. The discussion also covers recent New York Yankees injuries and roster moves. (00:01:50) Dolly Parton Legacy (00:03:25) Tim Curry Film Debate (00:16:14) Dolly Parton Movies (00:18:58) Yankees Bullpen Updates (00:22:25) Patrick Ricard Interview (00:38:23) Jackson Dart Interview (00:48:18) Player Safety Discussion (01:01:07) Giants Offense Analysis

They dive into a spirited ranking of NFL quarterbacks, leading to a fiery debate over whether Justin Herbert is a top-tier player or a "loser." The conversation shifts to Big Mac’s vacation highlights, including a terrifying ordeal on a Disney gondola and the absurd punishments for their internal fantasy football draft. (00:02:03) NFL Quarterback Rankings (00:06:34) Justin Herbert Debate (00:13:02) QB Comparison Game (00:20:16) System QB Discussion (00:24:36) Big Mac Return (00:33:44) Giants Interview Review (00:39:18) Disney Vacation Stories (00:47:21) Fantasy Football Draft (00:55:47) Yankees Trade Deadline

Big Mac criticizes Brian Cashman for failing to address the Yankees' bullpen depth at the trade deadline as injury concerns mount. The conversation covers the decision to start Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz against the Astros and explores the NFL's move to eliminate the traditional Pro Bowl format. Additionally, they discuss the leadership expectations for Jaxson Dart and the legacy of Bruce Springsteen’s music. (00:01:09) Yankees Pitching Strategy (00:02:41) Cashman's Deadline Failures (00:10:39) Springsteen's Music Legacy (00:15:31) NFL Pro Bowl Changes (00:26:32) Jaxson Dart's Leadership

Big Mac returns to address a caller's claim that phone lines were easier to navigate during his absence. They critique the "glazing" interview style prevalent on the station before recapping a Jets and Giants-only fantasy draft. The discussion wraps up with the absurd penalties facing the loser, including playing imaginary golf at Dyker Heights. (00:01:00) Big Mac's Phone Impact (00:05:12) Station Interview Glazing (00:16:33) Gondola Vacation Story (00:23:09) Local Fantasy Draft (00:27:56) Imaginary Golf Penalty

They engage in a spirited debate over NFL quarterback rankings, focusing on whether Bo Nix and Jaxson Dart belong in the league's top tier. Gallo defends Nix's potential against skepticism while arguing about Justin Herbert's reputation and the legacy of Hall of Famers like Troy Aikman. (00:01:00) Petey's Hip-Hop Vibe (00:02:03) NFL Quarterback Rankings (00:06:33) The Justin Herbert Debate (00:11:25) Bo Nix Comparison Game (00:20:18) Evaluating Troy Aikman's Legacy

The Giants starting QB Jaxson Dart joined Craig and Big Mac live from training camp!

The Carton Show crew remember the lives of Dolly Parton and Tim Curry by debating their most iconic film roles. The discussion moves from the interactive experience of Rocky Horror Picture Show to a heated argument regarding the quality of Home Alone 2. They also institute a new rule where everyone must make a specific sound whenever the word motorboat is mentioned. (00:01:00) New Motorboat Rule (00:02:55) Tim Curry's Legacy (00:07:30) Movie Taste Debate (00:13:05) Top Musical Soundtracks (00:14:08) Dolly Parton Movies

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle evaluate the management of the New York Yankees' pitching staff on The Carton Show, debating if Gerrit Cole is being coddled during a division race. They also preview an upcoming interview with Jaxson Dart and discuss the etiquette of tipping parking attendants after a recent Disney Cruise trip. (00:01:00) Guest Previews and Callers (00:02:32) Yankees Pitching Rotation Debate (00:10:00) Disney Cruise and Tipping

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are back at it over the New York Yankees and their handling of Gerrit Cole! With a massive series against the Boston Red Sox looming and the playoff race tightening, Craig can’t understand why the Yankees are holding back their ace while turning to rookie Elmer Rodriguez. Is Aaron Boone playing the long game for October, or are the Yankees getting TOO cute while the division slips away? Craig and Big Mac debate the Yankees’ battered pitching staff, bullpen struggles, postseason priorities, and the race to win the AL East! Plus, Chris returns from vacation and reveals there’s one thing Craig said while he was away that actually hurt him to his soul. 😂

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the Carton Show with a heated Yankees debate! Should Gerrit Cole have pitched on regular rest to line him up for the massive series against the Boston Red Sox? With the division, Wild Card positioning, injuries, and October looming, Craig and Big Mac have VERY different ideas about how aggressive the Yankees should be down the stretch. Plus, Chris gets a hilarious welcome back to WFAN with a custom rap song, and Craig has a little fun at the Mets’ expense!

Craig Carton and the crew conduct a localized fantasy draft featuring only players from the Jets and Giants, resulting in a disastrous roster for Pete Hoffman. Because of his poor drafting, he must complete a round of "imaginary golf" with strangers at Saxon Woods, using marshmallows as markers. They also discuss LeBron James's mysterious $300M loan and the return of Pete Alonso to Citi Field. (00:02:10) Remembering Dolly Parton (00:06:25) Pete Alonso Returns (00:17:10) Giants Plane Food (00:21:43) Jed York Sting (00:13:30) LeBron’s $300M Loan (00:29:02) Darren Rovell Interview (00:09:25) Jets-Giants Fantasy Draft (00:26:03) Imaginary Golf Punishment (00:36:26) Joe Burrow Trade Talk

Craig and the crew discuss the legacy of Dolly Parton and the polarizing return of Pete Alonso to Citi Field. They also analyze a legal controversy involving Jed York and share personal anecdotes regarding massage parlor etiquette. (00:01:26) Remembering Dolly Parton (00:06:08) Pete Alonso’s Citi Field Return (00:12:31) Giants Quarterback Reps Debate (00:19:54) Jed York Scandal Analysis (00:30:58) Massage Parlor Etiquette Discussion

Craig and guest Darren Rovell examine the financial intricacies of LeBron James' $300 million loan from entities linked to Dodgers owner Mark Walter. They discuss potential tax advantages and investment strategies rich athletes use, while also debating the New York Yankees' rotation decisions and Giancarlo Stanton's legacy. (00:01:07) LeBron James' $300M Loan (00:05:14) Fenway Sports Group Stakes (00:09:48) Bobby Bonilla Payment Strategy (00:16:40) Darren Rovell Interview (00:21:34) Mark Walter Fraud Allegations (00:25:35) Titanic Collectibles Discussion (00:30:08) Card Business Growth (00:33:22) Parenting And Gambling Apps (00:36:31) Gerrit Cole Pitching Schedule (00:40:28) Giancarlo Stanton Career Bust

Pete Hoffman and Anthony Gallo engage in a high-stakes fantasy football draft featuring New York Jets and Giants players, resulting in immediate backlash from listeners. They evaluate the offensive potential of the rival teams while contemplating future quarterback options like Joe Burrow and Lamar Jackson. The discussion wraps up with a look at the impact of NIL on college sports as former professionals return to the collegiate level. (00:01:38) Fantasy Football Draft Starts (00:05:22) Draft Picks and Strategy (00:11:07) Winston vs Smith Debate (00:14:00) Evaluating Draft Rosters (00:17:50) Imaginary Golf Punishment (00:22:10) Listener Reaction Vitriol (00:30:00) Jackson Dart Performance (00:34:40) Pursuing Joe Burrow (00:41:00) Lamar Jackson Collusion Controversy (00:45:15) Pro Players Back To College

Craig Carton and the crew detail a hilarious punishment for a lost fantasy football draft involving playing nine holes of golf with an imaginary ball. They discuss the specific rules, such as dropping marshmallows as decoys and faking sand trap shots to confuse onlookers. The conversation also covers the Yankees' series against the Astros and the narrative surrounding Pete Alonso’s exit from the Mets. (00:01:20) Ja'Marr Chase Injury Update (00:05:17) Imaginary Golf Punishment Rules (00:10:12) Listener Suggestions for Golf (00:16:58) Marshmallows and Cart Logistics (00:22:50) Yankees Astros Series Preview (00:28:08) Pete Alonso and Fantasy Strategy (00:38:20) Craig’s Crab Boil Burn Story (00:48:01) Giants Training Camp Report

Pete Hoffman and Gallo face a hilarious fantasy football punishment that requires the loser to play nine holes of imaginary golf with a set of clubs but no ball. They discuss the specific rules involving dropping marshmallows on fairways and interacting with confused strangers at a public course. Callers suggest additional embarrassing caveats like shouting "Fore" and hitting out of sand traps to maximize the public spectacle. (00:01:01) Sports News Update (00:02:34) Challenged By Senior Citizen (00:05:14) Imaginary Golf Punishment (00:10:09) Refining The Golf Rules (00:18:25) Listener Punishment Suggestions

Pete faces intense criticism from listeners over his recent draft picks while C-Mac remains on vacation. Craigie leads a discussion on the New York Jets' future at quarterback, debating whether the team should trade three first-round picks to acquire Joe Burrow. They also touch on the changing landscape of college sports as professional athletes return to campus via NIL deals. (00:01:00) Listeners Roast Pete's Draft (00:06:51) Jaxson Dart Injury Narratives (00:12:00) Jets Quarterback Trade Scenarios (00:14:59) Joe Burrow's Potential Fit (00:24:11) Professional Athletes Returning College

Craig pits Pete Hoffman vs Anthony Gallo in a NY Football only fantasy draft! The loser pays an epic price!

Darren Rovell explains the financial strategy behind LeBron James' $300 million loan against his Nike contract and the potential legal risks facing Dodgers owner Mark Walter. Craig and Darren examine the commercialization of the U.S. Open and the growing dangers of unregulated prediction markets targeting younger audiences. (00:01:00) LeBron James' $300M Loan (00:03:16) Mark Walter's Financial Deals (00:11:01) Rare Titanic Artifacts (00:15:11) Rise of Prediction Markets (00:17:12) Parenting in Gambling Age

The Carton Show analyze a mysterious business move by LeBron James to secure a $300 million loan from entities tied to Mark Walter. The discussion questions the necessity of such a massive loan for a billionaire and explores potential conflicts of interest or side deals involving ownership stakes. They also criticize major media outlets for failing to cover the story and its potential implications for the NBA. (00:01:11) LeBron James Loan Details (00:05:48) Billionaire Investment Strategies (00:10:04) Lack Of Media Coverage

Carton and Gallo discuss the upcoming guest lineup including Jaxson Dart before diving into a debate about a missed lunch order. They take a call from Sasha regarding the public's moral indignation over solicitation charges involving NFL owners like Jed York. The conversation concludes with a comparison of the league's disciplinary actions for solicitation versus the assault allegations against Deshaun Watson. (00:01:03) Upcoming Guest Lineup (00:02:22) Lunch Order Conflict (00:04:37) NFL Moral Indignation

Craig Carton and the crew dive into the details surrounding 49ers owner Jed York's involvement in an Ohio prostitution sting. They debate the public perception of various owner scandals before shifting to a humorous argument about proper attire during professional massages. (00:01:01) Giants Charter Flight Food (00:05:22) Jed York Sting Details (00:15:06) NFL Owner Scandal Comparison (00:17:03) Proper Massage Etiquette Debate (00:21:23) Yankees & NFL Updates

Craig and the Crew discuss the reaction to Pete Alonso's return to Citi Field this coming September, Also Dolly Parton passes away.

Craig says the Giancarlo Stanton injury doesn't hurt the Yankees since they've been without him all year already anyway. 49ers Owner Jed York gets arrested for multiple misdemeanor charges. Are the Giants making a mistake by not playing Jaxson Dart in the preseason? Craig and Gallo debate whether or not Seth Rogan is still funny or not. Bayonne little league baseball manager, Justin Smith, joins the show. Craig pushes back on callers saying Jaxson Dart has shown enough to not need to play in the preseason. Niko has disappointed his dad for not defending the Giants. Mike Villani, co-host of The Brilliantly Dumb Show, joins Craig to talk Giants, Jets, Mike's Bears, and even Jed York's arrest.

Hour 1: Craig says the Giancarlo Stanton injury doesn't hurt the Yankees since they've been without him all year already anyway. 49ers Owner Jed York gets arrested for multiple misdemeanor charges. Are the Giants making a mistake by not playing Jaxson Dart in the preseason?

Hour 2: Craig and Gallo debate whether or not Seth Rogan is still funny or not. Bayonne little league baseball manager, Justin Smith, joins the show.

Hour 3: Craig pushes back on callers saying Jaxson Dart has shown enough to not need to play in the preseason. Niko has disappointed his dad for not defending the Giants.

Hour 4: Mike Villani, co-host of The Brilliantly Dumb Show, joins Craig to talk Giants, Jets, Mike's Bears, and even Jed York's arrest.

Mikey V from Bob Does Sports joins the show to discuss the viral success of their golf content and his transition from a regular nine-to-five job to digital stardom. Craig and his guest break down Chicago Bears fandom as a Jersey native and analyze the upcoming NFL season for the Giants and Jets. The conversation wraps up with thoughts on the New York Knicks' recent success in a weakened Eastern Conference. (00:01:00) Guest Mikey V Joins (00:04:36) Bob Does Sports Origins (00:11:09) Chicago Bears Fandom (00:15:14) NFL Season Preview (00:23:48) Knicks Basketball Talk

Craig Carton challenges the modern 'soft' mentality of New York Giants fans and debates the future of Jackson Dart with callers. The conversation takes a heartfelt turn when an FDNY veteran calls in to reflect on the upcoming 9/11 anniversary and Craig’s charitable efforts. They also discuss the Jets' outlook and Craig's memories of his arrest by a fan in the FBI. (00:01:00) Nico's Giants Fandom (00:04:53) Giants Fans Critique (00:07:49) Pete's FDNY Tribute (00:12:10) Craig's FBI Story (00:15:12) Jackson Dart Debate

Craig debates whether Jaxson Dart has taken enough preseason snaps to lead the Giants against the Cowboys in Week 1. He scrutinizes Dart's rookie statistics and the performance of Geno Smith while also discussing the dangers of alligators at Disney's Epcot. (00:01:00) Epcot World Showcase Discussion (00:03:57) Florida Alligator Safety Concerns (00:06:33) Preseason Snap Count Concerns (00:10:23) Jaxson Dart Performance Debate (00:17:29) High Expectations for Harbaugh

Craig Carton welcomes Bayonne Little League manager Justin Smith to discuss the team's journey to Williamsport and the unique experience of the World Series. He and Billy debate the difficulty of hitting youth fastballs and the preseason workload for Jaxson Dart. They also explore wedding traditions, including personal stories about asking for a father's permission to marry. (00:01:00) Justin Smith Interview (00:07:45) Fastball Skill Debates (00:12:48) Wedding Tradition Talk (00:17:44) Quarterback Snap Debate

Craig Carton takes a call from a Giants fan who advocates for Jaxson Dart to lead the team before shifting to a discussion on quarterback rhythm. He then details the history of the Ear Inn, highlighting its status as one of New York City's oldest bars with a strict no-cell-phone policy. Finally, the conversation turns to the legal situation surrounding 49ers CEO Jed York and the potential for public police reports. (00:01:08) Giants Quarterback Debate (00:05:41) Ear Inn History (00:10:19) Jed York Investigation

A caller sparks a debate regarding the New York Jets' promising preseason drive led by Geno Smith and how it compares to last year's performance under Justin Fields. They also express concern over the New York Giants' decision to limit preseason reps for their starters ahead of a tough opener against the Dallas Cowboys. The conversation shifts to a bizarre news story involving Jed York and a discussion about old HBO documentaries. (00:01:01) Monday Morning Show Banter (00:02:05) Jets Preseason Offense Review (00:05:28) Giants Quarterback Reps Debate (00:08:09) Sex Trafficking Story Discussion (00:09:42) Retro HBO Documentary Recap

Craig Carton and the team react to San Francisco 49ers owner Jed York's recent arrest in an Ohio trailer park and discuss the light sentence he received. They shift focus to the New York Yankees as they break down Giancarlo Stanton's latest calf injury and debate his overall value to the organization. The segment wraps up with a weekend sports recap covering the Mets, Jets, and local Little League action. (00:01:05) Jed York's Legal Trouble (00:06:20) Mobile Home Life Stories (00:09:10) Giancarlo Stanton Injury Debate

Craig Carton is flying solo today and is fired up about the way the Jets offense looks in their 2nd preseason game. Also they guys jump into the Giancarlo Stanton injury news.

Craig Carton calls out John Harbaugh for putting Jaxson Dart back into a meaningless preseason game. Plus: -Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts on the importance of keeping Dart healthy -Boomer Esiason disagrees with Craig on Jaxson Dart take -Bart Scott predicts a 6-11 season for the Giants -Evan and Tiki on Odell Beckham Jr.’s chances to make the team

Steve Cohen spoke to the media this week, and doubled down on his belief that David Stearns is the right man for the job. Boomer and Jerry react to Cohen's comments, as do Evan and Tiki. Plus, Craig Carton has a wild hypothetical where the Dodgers' owner suddenly selling his shares of the team leads to Shohei Ohtani in Queens, and Jerry Recco wonders if Francisco Lindor's improved play is another sign that he and Juan Soto cannot coexist.

The Yankees were hit with another injury blow, this time to Max Fried. Evan and Tiki discuss if the prognosis is truly as optimistic as Aaron Boone made it out to be, and wonder how the Yanks continue to survive this injury wave. Plus, Boomer and Jerry wonder how long the Yanks can stay afloat with so many key players out, Craig Carton and Emmanuel Berbari discuss the starting rotation without Fried, and is George Lombard Jr. the spark that can take the Yanks on a deep playoff run?

Damien Woody joins Craig on today's show. He recalls Tom Brady's rookie season, breaks down the upcoming seasons for the Jets and Giants, Matthew Gill Vice President of the Bayonne Little League joins the show, Legendary Super-Agent Don Cronson joins, and a lot, lot more, tell ya friends, tell ya friends!!!!

Hour 1: Damien Woody fills-in with Craig today, My Man Pots N' Pans!! They break down the Jets game tonight, Tom Brady's rookie year with the Patriots, what to expect from Aaron Glenn, and much more.

The Great Jaxson Dart Debate: Damien Woody Has High Hopes, Craig Has Big Doubts....Plus the VP of the Bayonne Little League Joins the Show, Damien Woody gets a sandwich named after him, and much more, tell ya friends!!!

Craig and Damien Woody are joined by retired super agent Don Cronson, who shares unbelievable stories from his time as an agent.

Craig remembers his time at Syracuse following his interview with Don Cronson, Damien Woody tries his hand at The Wheel, and a whole lot more tell ya friends!!

Legendary sports agent Don Cronson joins the program to share behind-the-scenes stories from his career representing stars like Ed 'Too Tall' Jones, Pearl Washington, and Anthony Mason. He discusses the groundbreaking business deal involving the Silna brothers during the NBA-ABA merger and recounts a high school athletic rivalry with Bill Parcells. (00:01:40) Legendary Agent Don Cronson (00:05:17) Representing Ed Too Tall Jones (00:09:24) Too Tall's Boxing Stint (00:16:32) Memories Of Pearl Washington (00:21:25) The In-Perpetuity NBA Deal (00:26:50) Dealing With Anthony Mason (00:33:35) NBA All-Time Starting Five (00:38:06) High School Rivalry With Parcells

Damian Woody joins the Carton Show to debate where Jackson Dart stands among NFL quarterbacks and defends Jalen Hurts against criticism regarding his accuracy and team support. They discuss Odell Beckham Jr.'s potential veteran presence with the Giants and take a detour to create "The Woody" sandwich at Talercios in New Jersey. The conversation concludes with a definitive ranking of the NFL's top ten quarterbacks. (00:01:00) Jackson Dart Ranking Debate (00:01:52) OBJ's Veteran Presence (00:09:39) Designing The Woody Sandwich (00:17:56) Defending Jalen Hurts (00:25:35) Top 10 Quarterback Rankings

Craigie and Damian Woody connect with VP Matthew Gill as the Bayonne Little League squad travels to Williamsport for a historic World Series appearance. They celebrate the team's blue-collar identity and offer a strong defense of Mason Incognito's viral walk-off celebration. (00:01:00) Bayonne Heading to Williamsport (00:04:34) Mason Incognito Celebration Debate (00:06:48) Community Support and Families

Craig and Damian Woody evaluate the state of the New York Jets, focusing on the pressure facing Aaron Glenn and the impact of Aaron Rodgers. They also compare the Jets' trajectory to the New York Giants, debating which franchise is closer to competence and playoff contention. The conversation wraps up with a lighthearted look at Damian's potential as a voiceover artist. (00:01:00) Damian Woody Joins Craig (00:02:18) Lawrence Taylor Plane Story (00:04:29) Jets and Aaron Glenn (00:10:31) Giants and Jets Debate (00:17:30) Damian's Radio Voiceover Potential

Damien Woody and Craig Carton joins to discuss the controversy surrounding a rookie's request for Lawrence Taylor's retired jersey number and shares tales of his toughest NFL matchups. They dive into personal histories regarding their start in football and transition into a series of humorous hunting stories involving Jim Kelly. (00:01:00) Damien Woody joins (00:02:17) LT's jersey number controversy (00:04:53) Toughest NFL opponents (00:07:24) Football origins and family (00:14:48) Hunting stories and pranks

Damien Woody joins Craig Carton to discuss the infamous Mo Lewis hit that nearly killed Drew Bledsoe and paved the way for Tom Brady's legendary career. Woody also shares stories about Brady's personality as a teammate and reflects on playing through a torn Achilles in his final NFL game. The conversation concludes with Woody's memories of a massive high school growth spurt and support for the Bayonne Little League team. (00:01:23) Damien Woody Joins Craig (00:02:04) Drew Bledsoe's Severe Injury (00:03:17) Tom Brady's Early Days (00:07:58) Playing Through Achilles Injury (00:14:14) Woody's Remarkable Growth Spurt

Damien Woody and Craig Carton analyzes the New York Jets' offensive weaponry and defensive leadership heading into the season. He also reflects on his childhood baseball experiences and reveals the truth behind the piano often seen in his home studio during television appearances. (00:01:00) Jets Season Outlook (00:04:05) Little League Baseball Memories (00:05:32) Damien Woody's Piano Mystery

Craig Carton and Damian Woody discuss Woody's tenure at ESPN and a secret FS1 dinner that almost led to a partnership. They also break down the Yankees' recent success against the Baltimore Orioles and the importance of preseason playing time for Geno Smith and the Jets' backup quarterback. (00:01:00) Damian Woody Joins (00:04:43) Yankees & Fandom (00:07:04) Jets Preseason Outlook

My Man Pots N' Pans!! Craig gives kudos to the "Bayone Gangstas", gives his thoughts on the Curious Case of Pete Alonso and his missing home run, College Sports are basically just semi-pro teams with University Employees, and much more, Tell Ya Friends, Tell Ya Friends!!

Hour 1: Craig breaks down the Bayonne Little League winning last night in the LLWS, if Pete Alonso hit a home run or not, and much more.

Craig reveals the real reason Aaron Boone points to the booth and gestures after wins, my man pots n' pans!! That and much more

Craig breaks down the ridiculous nature of College Athletics and N.I.L. and discusses how the Beatles really aren't that good and people should get over it with them.

Craig talks about how college sports are not what they used to be, restaurant stories and food nightmares, and a whole lot more tell ya friends!!

Craig and the crew debate the texture of low-sodium turkey and vent about frustrating restaurant experiences. They recount confrontational encounters with celebrity chefs Mario Batali and Bobby Flay before exploring the legendary history behind the day the music died. The discussion wraps up with a critical analysis of NIL money in college sports and its impact on university enrollment. (00:01:24) Traffic And Weather Update (00:03:29) Low-Sodium Turkey Debate (00:07:20) Celebrity Chef Pet Peeves (00:14:26) Day The Music Died (00:20:11) NIL Money In College Sports

Craig Carton & Gallo debate the legacy of The Beatles, controversially comparing the iconic band to modern boy bands like NSYNC. They also analyze the current state of NIL in college athletics and critique Greg Schiano’s performance at Rutgers. The group concludes by discussing the NBA's national television schedule and the impact of LeBron James on the Philadelphia 76ers. (00:01:00) Music Trivia Challenge (00:06:20) Roasting The Beatles (00:09:33) NIL Rule Debates (00:16:54) Evaluating Greg Schiano (00:20:46) Sixers Schedule Analysis

Craig Carton expresses frustration over the current state of NIL after South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers reveals he is not enrolled in classes. They discuss the lack of uniformity in eligibility rules, comparing Sellers' situation to professional athletes returning to college sports. Later, a 93-year-old Mets fan named Mary Riley calls in, resulting in an invitation for her family to attend a game in a luxury suite. (00:01:05) Sellers Skips Class (00:03:27) Eligibility Rule Inconsistency (00:08:07) Mets Fan Mary (00:12:04) NIL System Critique (00:18:00) Suite Invitation Offered

Craig and Gallo react to news that Geno Smith will start the upcoming preseason game against the Steelers. They also discuss the absurdity of fighting with football helmets on and reflect on Craig's encounter with Alistair Overeem. (00:01:52) Geno Smith Preseason Start (00:03:18) Fighting in Football (00:08:58) Evolution of Talk Shows (00:15:31) MMA and Self-Defense (00:20:48) Alistair Overeem Encounter

Craig Carton and guest Emmanuel Berbari break down Aaron Boone's private dugout signals and the fallout from Pete Alonso's controversial foul ball against the Yankees. They discuss the team's pitching rotation and the success of the Bayonne Little League team before reminiscing about viral media like the Jerky Boys and Faces of Death. (00:01:00) Guest Emmanuel Berbari (00:01:32) Boone's Secret Message (00:04:17) Yankees Game Review (00:12:37) Bayonne Little League (00:16:33) Nostalgic Media Grails

Craig and the crew celebrate the viral success of the Bayonne Little League team after a massive walk-off win that outpaced the Yankees in viewership. They also analyze Pete Alonso's reaction to his overturned home run in Baltimore and take a nostalgic detour to rank the kings of trashy daytime talk shows. (00:01:00) Bayonne Little League Success (00:02:05) Alonso Home Run Debate (00:07:30) Trashy TV Mount Rushmore (00:15:00) Mason Rincone's Viral Hit (00:20:40) The Official Code of Men

Craigie reacts to the Bayonne Little League's thrilling walk-off victory by Josue Rincón and defends the team's celebration against critics. They explore personal sports memories and debate the Mount Rushmore of WFAN hosts, including Mike the Mad Dog, while touching on urban legends about Bob Ross. (00:01:33) New York Sports Update (00:02:23) Bayonne LLWS Celebration Debate (00:08:08) WFAN History And Legends

They analyze Mason Rincon's dramatic walk-off home run for Bayonne in the Little League World Series and address the controversy surrounding his celebration. The conversation shifts to the disputed Pete Alonso foul ball during the Yankees-Orioles game, explaining how different camera angles changed their perspective on the play. Finally, they tease an upcoming reveal about the meaning behind Aaron Boone's post-win gesture and revisit a famous Shohei Ohtani home run call. (00:01:00) New King Of New York (00:03:35) Rincon's LLWS Walk-Off (00:10:25) Alonso's Disputed Foul Ball (00:13:40) Ohtani's Home Run Call (00:17:50) Boone's Celebration Gesture

My Man Pots N' Pans!! Craig is joined by Bart Scott, filling in for Chris McMonigle. They break down the Dodgers financial issues, why the Mets should go after Shohei Ohtani, debating who will be better this year, the Jets or Giants, and a whole lot more, tell ya friends!!

Bart Scott is filling in for Big Mac today, my man pots n' pans! Bart breaks down John Harbaugh's coaching style, the Mets should make a play for Shohei Ohtani, and much more.

Bart talks about the problem the Jets had in the 2010 AFC Championship, Jaxson Dart's possible injury concerns, and much more.

Hour 3: Craig and Bart Scott break down the Jets and Giants and why they believe there is no real reason why the Giants will be a clearly better team this year.

Craig and Bart Scott discuss travel stories and if they'll bring back the Concorde. Plus, you can't call Jaxson Dart a winner yet, Odell Beckham can still make an impact for the Giants and more.

Bart Scott joins Craig to recount legendary Lawrence Taylor stories and discuss if the Giants should take a chance on Odell Beckham Jr. They also analyze the ongoing issues with the turf at MetLife Stadium and speculate on Woody Johnson potentially moving the Jets to a new stadium in Queens. (00:01:00) Wild Lawrence Taylor Stories (00:04:38) Odell Beckham Jr. Potential (00:07:47) MetLife Stadium Turf Issues (00:09:14) Jets Relocation To Queens (00:13:35) NYC Parking And Tipping

Craig Carton & Bart Scott analyzes the NFL's plans for a European division and the logistical hurdles of global expansion. He debates a caller regarding the New York Giants' quarterback situation before predicting a 6-11 record for the team. Finally, he shares stories from his extensive travels across Africa, including his experiences in Senegal and Nigeria. (00:01:08) NFL International Expansion News (00:08:44) Giants Offensive Confidence Debate (00:13:11) Predicting the Giants Schedule (00:16:26) Great Circle Flight Logistics (00:20:30) Bart Scott's African Travels

Craig Carton and Bart Scott discuss the social circles of professional athletes before Big Mac shares a wild story involving the 1995 Philadelphia Eagles. They transition into a heated debate comparing the New York Jets and New York Giants rosters, questioning which team has a better path to success this season. (00:01:36) CeeDee Lamb Dating (00:03:23) 1995 Eagles Scandal (00:09:11) Jets Vs Giants Debate (00:15:28) Analyzing Giants Offense (00:23:52) Aaron Glenn Discussion

Craig & Bart analyzes whether Alex Cora or Carlos Beltran is the better fit to manage the New York Mets while addressing potential clubhouse friction. The discussion moves to the New York Giants' quarterback situation and the high-pressure environment for their coaching staff. Additionally, the conversation evaluates the New York Jets' defensive depth and veteran leadership. (00:01:00) Disney Cruise Discussion (00:04:07) Mets Manager Debate (00:06:11) Giants Quarterback Concerns (00:12:28) Mets Win Discussion (00:14:00) Jets Roster Analysis

Bart Scott joins the Carton Show, while Big Mac is away, to discuss the coaching philosophy of the Harbaugh family and the importance of established team culture. They analyze the leadership needs of the New York Giants and the roster construction strategies used by the New York Mets and New York Yankees. The discussion also covers the financial complexities of the Los Angeles Dodgers' recent contracts and the ownership hurdles within the NBA. (00:01:00) Bart Scott Fills In (00:02:04) Ravens and Harbaugh Culture (00:07:25) NFL Roster Building Discussion (00:10:35) Sports Ownership and Contracts (00:18:46) Mets Management vs Yankees

Bart Scott joins Craig Carton to discuss his friendship with Ray Rice and their shared high school Hall of Fame journey. He breaks down the defensive errors during the Jets' AFC Championship loss and shares a bizarre story about his namesake bleachers being stolen for scrap metal in Detroit. (00:01:27) Kitchen Cabaret Garlic Knot (00:03:35) Stolen Bleachers In Detroit (00:06:07) Ray Rice's Post-NFL Legacy (00:11:48) Penn State Drug Ring (00:16:33) Jets' AFC Championship Breakdown

Craig Carton & Bart Scott explores the possibility of Shohei Ohtani opting out of his Dodgers contract and urges the Yankees or Mets to be ready. They analyze the Yankees' record in games with low hit counts and evaluate Aaron Boone's management during their offensive struggles. The conversation concludes with an analysis of the Knicks' roster construction compared to the championship-winning Pistons. (00:01:34) Ohtani Opt-Out Potential (00:04:50) Yankees Hit Statistics Analysis (00:08:21) Aaron Boone's Management (00:14:03) Yankees Championship Expectations (00:19:13) Knicks Roster Building

With Bart Scott filling in for C-Mac, Craig breaks down what could be a dream scenario for Mets fans. Could Mark Walters selling his stake in the Dodgers lead to a Shohei Ohtani opt-out? If so would Steve Cohen go get the two-way superstar? The guys cover it all.

Tell Ya Friends, Tell Ya Friends -- Chris Christie Fills in for Chris McMonigle and the guys debate Dak vs. Jalen Hurts, the quality of Bruce Springsteen's music, a caller calls Cody Bellinger a Crackhead, a man loses his shot with his bisexual dogwalker, and a whole lot more Tell Ya Friends!

Governor Christie Fills-In for Big Mac, My Man Pots N' Pans!! They break down the Mets recent success, debate Jalen Hurts vs. Dak Prescott and much more.

Craig and Governor Christie discuss the one person the Governor would be nervous to meet, Bruce Springsteen stories, Mets optimism, the Cowboys and much more.

The debate rages over whether Bruce Springsteen makes good music or not. And an interesting caller has lots to say about many things, one of which is Cody Bellinger, who she affectionately refers to as "The Crackhead".

Governor Christie thinks the Mets still have a chance at making a run, a caller blows his opportunity with his bisexual Dogwalker, and a whole lot more, my man pots n' pans!!

Craig and Chris Christie react to a hilarious call from June, a New York Yankees fan who gives Cody Bellinger a questionable nickname while praising her 'honey' Andy Pettitte. They delve into the intersection of sports and politics following Jaxson Dart’s introduction of the president at a local event. Additionally, Christie shares a story about a family road trip in a U-Haul and his prized Bruce Springsteen guitar. (00:01:00) Noah Kahan Concert (00:04:22) Coaching Chris Christie (00:07:30) Jaxson Dart Politics (00:10:10) Christie's U-Haul Trip (00:13:52) June's Yankee Call

Craig and guest Chris Christie examine a social media mistake made by producer Pete Hoffman regarding the New York Mets. They argue over the lyrical interpretation of Bruce Springsteen's hits and share a heated debate over board game rules. The discussion also covers a major drug bust at Penn State involving the nickname Pablo Pledgescobar. (00:01:05) Pete Hoffman's Met Blunder (00:03:22) Springsteen Lyrical Meaning (00:08:33) Board Game Rules (00:12:50) NFL Quarterback Safety (00:16:36) Penn State Cocaine Ring

Craig Carton & Chris Christie discusses Bruce Springsteen's documentary and the singer's transparency regarding mental health. He shares stories from European concert venues, meeting Rob Lowe in Milan, and being intimidated by figures like Elie Wiesel before recalling a "humble pie" flight on Spirit Airlines. (00:01:01) Springsteen's Mental Health & Tours (00:06:07) Meeting Rob Lowe In Milan (00:08:50) Intimidating Figures & Spirit Airlines

Craig Carton and Chris Christie joins Asked and Why to discuss Jose Iglesias throwing out the first pitch and the return of the Mets' positive energy. They also debate whether Tommy John belongs in the Hall of Fame based on his career stats versus his massive contribution to sports medicine. Finally, they touch on the Yankees' postseason prospects and the impact of Max Fried's injury. (00:01:00) Mets First Pitch (00:07:47) Tommy John Debate (00:10:28) Hall Of Fame Elite (00:16:15) Yankees Division Race

Craig Carton & Governor Chris Christie joins the program to discuss his deep fandom of Bruce Springsteen and an unexpected encounter with Rob Lowe in Milan. They also analyze the New York Mets' roster moves under David Stearns and the team's uphill battle for a postseason berth. (00:01:02) Springsteen Movie Analysis (00:06:28) Meeting Rob Lowe (00:07:20) Intimidating World Figures (00:14:02) Mets Season Outlook (00:18:03) Postseason Probability Debate

Governor Chris Christie joins Craig Carton to discuss Von Miller joining the Dallas Cowboys and whether the team's championship window is closing. Jordan Schultz provides NFL updates on Najee Harris, Breece Hall's injury status, and training camp standouts. They conclude with a heated debate regarding the trade value of Dak Prescott compared to Jalen Hurts. (00:01:20) Von Miller Joins Cowboys (00:04:45) Harlan Coben Little League (00:07:33) Rex Ryan Softball Story (00:11:35) Najee Harris Giants Update (00:17:10) Breece Hall Injury News (00:20:05) NFL Training Camp Roundup (00:24:25) Hurts vs. Prescott Debate

Chris Christie sits in on The Carton Show to discuss the New York Mets' recent momentum and his unique personal relationship with the Dallas Cowboys organization. They also examine the New York Giants' preseason injury concerns and the latest setbacks facing the New York Yankees. (00:01:00) Chris Christie Joins Carton (00:04:49) Giants And Cowboys Debate (00:14:12) Yankees Injury News

Chris Christie is back on WFAN, filling in for Chris McMonigle, and he wastes no time making his presence felt alongside Craig Carton! Christie makes the case for the Mets’ outrageous 26-10 comeback scenario, insisting the rest of the league better “don’t let us win tonight” as New York tries to keep its slim playoff hopes alive. Craig Carton is having NONE of it.

The hosts of WFAN react to the biggest storyline of the Giants' preseason game against the Vikings: second-year QB Jaxson Dart making yet another visit to the medical blue tent for a concussion evaluation. Evan and Tiki say perception is not necessarily reality when it comes to Dart's concussion history, while Craig GOES OFF on John Harbaugh.

Craig and Zach Gelb give their thoughts on the Jets and Giants preseason games, why Jaxson Dart should not have re-entered the game, the Jets new look offense, the Bayonne Little League, why the Rizzler needs to lose weight, and much more.

My Man Pots and Pans!!! Craig and Zach Gelb, filling in for Cmac, break down the Giants preseason opener and why Craig believes Jaxson Dart should not have come back into the game. That and much more.

Craig and Zach Gelb discuss the Jets first preseason game, why Geno is the best option for the Jets at Quarterback, and more. Plus, Gallo and Gelb had wildly different opinions on the Jay-Z concert, and much more.

Hour 3: Craig, Zach, and Gallo give their thoughts on the Jets schedule, how the AFC East will look at the end of the year, and much more.

Craig says that The Rizzler needs to lose a few pounds. Plus, Craig gives some prudent parenting advice for the audience, the Bayonne Little League, and much more.

Craig Carton questions the ethics of monetizing The Rizzler's viral fame and discusses the possibility of Najee Harris joining the New York Giants. He also shares a rumor about the lack of ice in Kevin Hart's "Cold as Balls" series and reflects on legendary figures from the Little League World Series. (00:01:20) Costco And The Rizzler (00:05:55) Carton's Kettlebell Transformation (00:09:20) Aaron Glenn Coaching Debate (00:13:00) Najee Harris Giants Update (00:18:30) Raising Future Career Men (00:21:45) Kevin Hart's Ice Fraud (00:25:30) Little League Legend Stories (00:33:25) Penn State Cocaine Scandal

They analyze the New York Jets' upcoming schedule, highlighting the team's total lack of primetime games and the abundance of early Sunday kickoffs. The conversation shifts to producer Pete Hoffman’s recent suspension following a social media error regarding the Mets' front office. Finally, they evaluate Brendan Sorsby's draft prospects and his future at Texas Tech. (00:01:00) Jets Schedule Snub (00:07:43) Bills Division Outlook (00:13:57) Leon Rose Connection (00:17:38) Pete Hoffman Suspended (00:25:31) Brendan Sorsby Draft

The discussion begins with viral news clips before shifting into a heated debate over the New York Jets' quarterback situation featuring Geno Smith and Cade Klubnik. They also analyze upcoming NFL season schedules for local teams and compare the career trajectories of top coaches like Sean Payton and Mike McCarthy. (00:01:00) Viral Fox Detroit Clip (00:05:36) Local Radio Loyalty Debate (00:08:49) Jets and Giants Predictions (00:14:52) Geno Smith vs Cade Klubnik (00:22:05) Comparing Elite NFL Coaches

The show goes off the rails when Gallo details his experience taking a 100mg edible at a Mets game and recounts his bachelor party trip to the Hockey Hall of Fame in Toronto. The conversation covers the New York Giants' interest in Najee Harris following Tyrone Tracy Jr.'s preseason performance. They also debate whether the New York Jets should start Geno Smith or look toward the future with Cade Klubnik. (00:01:18) Concert Debates and Toronto Trip (00:09:52) 100mg Edible at Citi Field (00:13:46) Giants Targeting Najee Harris (00:19:00) Jets Quarterback Starting Debate

Craig and Zach evaluate the New York Jets' preseason offensive potential and the talent level of their young roster. They share humorous stories from a recent bachelor party in Toronto and debate the risks of playing starting quarterbacks in preseason games. The conversation also highlights favorite dining spots like Wolfgang's Steakhouse and the logistical hazards of shipping stone crabs. (00:01:00) Intro and Mets Banter (00:02:52) Jets Offensive Potential (00:07:12) Wolfgang's and Bairrada (00:12:11) Preseason QB Risks (00:15:51) Toronto Bachelor Party

Craig Carton and the crew discuss a drug trafficking operation involving Penn State fraternities where pledges were allegedly used as cocaine mules. They also debate John Harbaugh's coaching decisions regarding player safety in the preseason and share a classic story about Nate Newton and a rib restaurant. (00:01:05) Penn State Frat Bust (00:04:30) Buffet Stories and Ribs (00:07:43) Quarterback Safety Debate (00:13:41) NFL Season Win Predictions (00:16:11) Sid Rosenberg and Bets

Craig and the crew explore John Harbaugh's decision to play Jackson Dart in the preseason despite an injury scare. They also discuss Isaiah Likely's potential impact and debate the best pizza and food spots in New York City. (00:01:00) Penn State Frat Scandal (00:02:27) Jackson Dart Injury Risk (00:04:47) Isaiah Likely Season Outlook (00:07:46) Broadcasting Preseason Football Games (00:10:41) The Ultimate NYC Pizza Debate

Craig Carton is back on the Carton Show with Zach Gelb filling in for Chris McMonigle, and the Giants are front and center. Carton has a major question for John Harbaugh after Jaxson Dart was sent to the blue medical tent following a hard hit — why was the Giants' franchise quarterback put back into a meaningless preseason game? Carton argues that Harbaugh is getting a pass that other Giants coaches never would have received.

Boomer Esiason and Gregg Giannotti discuss the earl portion of the Giants schedule and if they can have a strong start to the season. Plus: -Shaun Morash dishes on how badly he needs the Giants to beat the Cowboys Week 1 -Tiki Barber and Shaun on what Jaxson Dart must show in Year 2. -Craig Carton shares his concerns about the Giants depth to Chris McMonigle -Craig and C-Mac on why Giants fans are expressing concern over Matt Nagy -Boomer & Gio on if John Harbaugh can continue his preseason success with the Giants

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle were live from Jets training camp this week, speaking at length with Aaron Glenn, Darren Mougey, Breece Hall, and others about the upcoming season and what changes have been made to turn the franchise around. Plus, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate if the Jets should pick up the phone and see if J.J. McCarthy is available.

Boomer and Gio believe Yankee fans take their team's success for granted, especially given where the team stands right now amid several injuries to key players. Plus, Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate if Jazz Chisholm Jr. should be benched so Luis Garcia Jr. can play second base when the team is at full strength, while Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss how Giancarlo Stanton will be handled when he returns, as he takes a next step toward being cleared to play.

In the first two games of the series, the Yankees put up 14 runs against the Mariners. On Thursday, when they needed just one to tie the game and send it to extra's the Yankees put up a big old donut! At the end of the day, they still won the series and move on to face division rivals Toronto Blue Jays. Subscribe for the latest New York sports news & videos!! Listen to the Boomer and Gio Podcast! Apple - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast... Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0ek7XQ4... Listen to the Evan and Tiki Podcast! Apple - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast... Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/6qP52qs... Listen to the Carton Show Podcast! Apple - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast... Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/38NxXo1... FOLLOW US: TWITTER - / wfan660 INSTAGRAM: / wfansportsradio FACEBOOK: / wfan660

They celebrate the return of NFL football with a look at the Giants' preseason plans and the pressure on Daniel Jones. Pat Leonard joins Anthony Gallo and Pete Hoffman to discuss training camp roster battles, while Mark Schlereth evaluates the Jets' offensive outlook. Former lineman Justin Pugh also stops by to share stories from the league and participate in a game of Spin the Wheel. (00:01:50) Daniel Jones Preseason Role (00:07:50) Jets Season Kickoff Preview (00:12:05) Gallo and Hoffman Grades (00:19:38) Josh Allen's Pistachio Farm (00:26:45) Backup Quarterback Analysis (00:36:43) Pat Leonard Giants Report (00:46:50) NFL Today New Format (00:59:34) Justin Pugh Spin Wheel

As football returns to MetLife Stadium, they debate whether Jaxson Dart should take meaningful reps for the Giants during the preseason. The conversation also highlights a surprising headline about Josh Allen's pistachio business and a critique of why Field of Dreams is a mediocre movie. (00:01:20) Preseason Quarterback Debate (00:04:51) Jets Home Opener Hype (00:08:41) Giants Training Camp Struggles (00:12:50) Host Performance Grading (00:19:05) Josh Allen's Nut Farm (00:23:51) Ranking Favorite Nuts (00:27:05) Field Of Dreams Critique (00:31:20) Cannabis Business Ventures

Pat Leonard joins Craig to evaluate the New York Giants' training camp and the performance of Daniel Jones heading into the preseason. They discuss the wide receiver depth chart and evaluate how the team will manage its running back rotation. The conversation also features a critique of current NFL pregame shows and their lack of authentic personality. (00:01:20) Giants Training Camp (00:04:52) Daniel Jones Concerns (00:09:55) Receiver Depth Battle (00:14:12) Defensive Rookie Evaluation (00:18:29) Giants Season Outlook (00:22:22) NFL Today Analysis (00:27:47) Pregame Show Formatting (00:33:57) Jets Preseason Prep

Mark Schlereth evaluates Jackson Dart’s development and the Denver Broncos' outlook for the upcoming season. Quincy Enunwa discusses Geno Smith’s maturity and opens up about the neck injury that ended his playing career. They also debate the future of NFL pregame shows and airport lounge etiquette. (00:01:50) NFL Preseason Betting (00:07:21) Mark Schlereth Joins (00:13:11) Jackson Dart Development (00:21:40) Geno Smith Evaluation (00:26:43) Broncos Season Outlook (00:37:10) Bayonne Little League (00:41:05) Quincy Enunwa Interview (00:49:04) Injury Impact on Identity (00:55:50) Airport Lounge Access

Former offensive lineman Justin Pugh joins the program to discuss his career with the New York Giants and Arizona Cardinals. He shares insights into playing for Tom Coughlin, the infamous 2017 boat trip controversy, and burying the hatchet with Geno Smith. Pete and Anthony also challenge Justin to a series of trivia games on the wheel. (00:01:35) Justin Pugh Joins (00:06:02) Italian Football Involvement (00:12:08) Coaching Under Coughlin (00:16:31) Giants Boat Controversy (00:34:04) Spin The Wheel (00:48:37) McAdoo And Geno

Former Giants offensive lineman Justin Pugh joins to discuss his transition from the NFL to the business world and his involvement with the Italian Football League. They reflect on the Tom Coughlin era, the infamous boat trip distraction, and compare the organizational consistency of the Giants and Ravens. (00:01:20) Justin Pugh Joins (00:05:41) Italian Football League (00:10:16) Coaching Under Coughlin (00:13:21) Giants Struggles Discussed (00:20:31) Harbaugh vs Coughlin (00:25:21) Football Finance Career (00:32:33) Competitive Golf Talk

Craig Carton welcomes former Jets receiver Quincy Enunwa to discuss Geno Smith's maturity as a veteran quarterback and the current state of the Jets' offensive line. They also explore the emotional challenges of career-ending injuries and debate the future of NFL pregame shows. (00:01:00) Bayonne Little League Success (00:03:21) Reimagining NFL Pregame Shows (00:07:19) Quincy Enunwa Interview (00:12:12) Life After Football (00:21:15) Airport Lounge Etiquette

Mark Schlereth joins Craig to analyze the current state of the Giants and Jets as they prepare for preseason action. They discuss the reckless but dynamic playstyle of quarterback Jaxson Dart and the offensive potential surrounding Breece Hall and Geno Smith. The conversation also explores the Denver Broncos' defensive identity and identifies potential dark horse teams for the upcoming season. (00:01:50) NFL Preseason Betting Warning (00:07:48) Mark Schlereth on Standouts (00:11:15) Jaxson Dart Giants Future (00:20:33) Analyzing Jets Offensive Potential (00:27:15) Broncos Projections and Turnovers (00:30:34) NFL Dark Horses Discussion

Craig Carton and the guys evaluate Bill Cowher's vision for a conversational shift on the NFL Today pregame show. They highlight why scripted segments often hinder personalities like Shannon Sharpe and Bart Scott compared to the free-flowing style of Inside the NBA. Finally, they discuss the quarterback situations for the Jets and Giants. (00:01:08) Critiquing NFL Today (00:06:56) Inside The NBA Model (00:11:30) Jets And Giants Preview

Pat Leonard joins Craig to share insights from his recent visit to training camp in West Virginia and the outlook for the New York Giants. They evaluate the quarterback's struggle with downfield passing, the competitive wide receiver depth chart featuring Odell Beckham Jr., and the challenges of the team's upcoming 2024 schedule. (00:01:00) Pat Leonard West Virginia Trip (00:04:07) Preseason Quarterback Performance Analysis (00:08:23) Giants Wide Receiver Roster Battles (00:12:14) Defensive Standouts Cornerback Competition (00:18:40) Giants 2024 Season Outlook

Craig and Pete critique the Field of Dreams game and movie while debating the best baseball films. They also field caller takes on ice cream, a massive Little League pitcher, and Jets rookie potential. The conversation shifts to a unique edible business venture and movie recommendations like Interstellar. (00:01:07) Field Of Dreams Review (00:04:02) Little League World Series (00:05:41) NFL Rookie Talk (00:10:14) Draft Reactions And Interstellar (00:16:52) New Edible Business Venture

Craig Carton discusses the surprising news of Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen owning a 1,000-acre pistachio farm. They share their favorite nut rankings and debate ice cream flavors before shifting focus to the New York Jets' preseason and the search for a future franchise quarterback. (00:01:00) Josh Allen's Nut Farm (00:03:52) Ranking Favorite Nuts (00:07:00) Jets Preseason Outlook (00:09:06) Evaluating Cade Klubnik (00:13:17) Greatest Jets Number Seven

On the Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton dives into the return of football and what they expect to see from the Jets and Giants. Craig insists Jaxson Dart MUST play and wants to see what the Giants rookie can do in a real preseason game. The guys also break down the Jets' first look at Geno Smith and Frank Reich's offense, the expectations for rookie stars David Bailey and Arvell Reese, and the surprising situation surrounding Odell Beckham Jr. as he fights to make the Giants' 53-man roster.

Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Yankees' recent scoring drought and Jazz Chisholm's performance during a breakdown of the team's shutout loss to the Mariners. They revisit Mena Kimes' viral reaction to Josh Allen's draft night and share a humorous story about a dress code mishap at the stadium involving Susan Waldman. (00:01:50) Yankees Offensive Struggles (00:08:52) Josh Allen Audio Game (00:14:17) George Lombard Jr. Usage (00:25:21) Deion Sanders & Shedeur (00:38:35) Press Box Shorts Story (00:13:36) Boone Motivation Debate (00:18:24) Yankees Bullpen Assessment

Craig Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Yankees' recent offensive failures and debate whether Jazz Chisholm is to blame for their scoring drought. They also react to an old clip of Mena Kimes' draft reaction and discuss the bizarre media restrictions surrounding Deion Sanders at Colorado. Finally, Big Mac recounts an embarrassing interaction with Suzyn Waldman regarding his attire at the stadium. (00:01:52) Yankees Offensive Woes (00:09:42) Mena Kimes Audio Mystery (00:15:20) George Lombard Lineup Debate (00:26:28) Deion Sanders Media Policy (00:40:16) Suzyn Waldman Dress Code

Chris McMonigle evaluates the New York Yankees' offensive woes despite their elite pitching rotation. He engages with callers to debate Aaron Boone's leadership style and explores the possibility of Cody Bellinger taking over the leadoff spot to spark the lineup. (00:01:13) Yankee Offense Struggles (00:06:54) Leadoff Hitter Solutions (00:14:00) Aaron Boone Debate (00:10:21) High School Football

Big Mac shares an awkward encounter with Suzyn Waldman at Yankee Stadium after being called out for wearing shorts in the press box. They also discuss Deion Sanders' strict media restrictions at Colorado and debate Shedeur Sanders' professional prospects. (00:01:00) Colorado Media Restrictions (00:02:08) Shedeur Sanders NFL Future (00:08:36) Radio Genius Debates (00:12:34) Suzyn Waldman Dress Code (00:20:02) Summer Vacation Plans

The Yankees' offense is struggling again, and Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton have had enough. The guys debate Jazz Chisholm's disastrous season at the plate, why expectations are so much higher for Jazz, and whether Ben Rice has also fallen off after carrying the Yankees earlier this season.

The Yankees' pitching keeps giving them a chance, but the offense continues to let them down. Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down New York's brutal 1-0 loss to the Mariners, the Yankees managing just FOUR hits, and why Jazz Chisholm is becoming a major problem at the plate.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the Giants wide receiver room and if it's good enough. What's the easiest path for the Yankees to get back to the World Series? How much better will the Jets be? Should the Knicks be scared of the LeBron James led 76ers?

Craig says the Giants are lacking strong skill position players outside Malik Nabers. The Yankees squeak out a win despite continued offensive struggles. The Lakers get sold once again. Craig has an idea for a new website.

Gallo is back from vacation and Craig and C-Mac can't believe how little he knows about famous actors. Is it weird to get a massage for your prostate? Niko, filling in for Hoff, is throwing his own birthday party.

Craig thinks the jets are capable of being a near .500 team. C-Mac believes Aaron Glenn has been humbled which is a good thing. Russell Westbrook announces his retirement from the NBA. Is he a first ballot hall of famer? Should the Knicks fear the Sixers?

Stu Feiner calls in and predicts that both the Giants and Jets will beat their respective win totals.

Russell Westbrook has officially retired after an incredible 18-year NBA career, and Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle debate where he ranks among the greatest players of his generation. From averaging a triple-double for a season to becoming an MVP and future first-ballot Hall of Famer, the guys break down why Westbrook's legacy deserves more respect.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to Aaron Glenn’s latest interview and both admit they feel MUCH better about the Jets head coach heading into the 2026 season. After a disastrous first season, Glenn appears to be embracing his strengths as a defensive coach and taking ownership of the mistakes he made. Carton says Glenn came across as confident, comfortable and genuine, while Big Mac admits he went home thinking about the interview and came away impressed.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle have a hilarious conversation about producer Nico’s REAL first name and the reveal leads to an all-out roast! Then Anthony Gallo walks into the studio and immediately gets put to the test on movies, actors, and classic books. From Robert Redford to Gary Sinise, The Natural, The Deer Hunter, Of Mice and Men and more, Carton and Big Mac discover just how little Gallo remembers!

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle get into a wild debate over Tito Jackson and the Jackson 5, with a caller making the case that Tito was far more talented than people give him credit for. The conversation then turns into a bigger debate: Who are the true musical savants? Michael Jackson, Prince, Brian Wilson, Bob Dylan, Carole King, Ed Sheeran, Kid Rock, Lil Wayne and more are discussed as Craig and Big Mac debate what separates incredible musicians from true musical geniuses. Plus, Nico's 27th birthday party, Giants talk, tailgating, and a very unexpected caller update from Lori!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the bizarre situation surrounding the New York Giants' training camp at The Greenbrier — a resort that includes a full casino and FanDuel sportsbook.

Craig and Chris McGonagle react to the massive $12 billion valuation of the Lakers and the ripple effect on the New York Knicks' market value. They also brainstorm a "Dead to Me" social media platform before a caller shares insights on the New York Giants' training camp at The Greenbrier. (00:01:00) Music Legends and Billy Preston (00:06:30) NBA Franchise Valuations Surge (00:09:44) Dead To Me Website Idea (00:14:18) Greenbrier Resort History (00:16:08) Giants Training Camp Update

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether the Giants made a major mistake by not signing Stefon Diggs after their first preseason depth chart revealed serious questions at wide receiver.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the New York Giants' first preseason depth chart, and Craig is sounding the alarm on the state of Big Blue's offense.

WFAN hosts break down the Knicks' upcoming opening night ring ceremony against LeBron James and the 76ers, debating whether $2,000 ticket prices and schedule delays stem from LeBron hype or true New York basketball fever.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the Knicks home opener, Giancarlo nearing a return for the Yankees, and chat with Jets players, coaches, and GM Darren Mougey.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the Knicks' opening night matchup against LeBron James' Philadelphia 76ers, their Christmas Day rematch against the San Antonio Spurs, and are joined by SNY's Connor Hughes at New York Jets camp.

Demario Davis joins the show live from Jets camp. Craig and C-Mac find out information that diminishes their views on the University of Michigan.

Breece Hall joins the show live from Jets camp. What does Stanton running the bases mean for the Yankees?