The Truth Bombs Drop: Giants Are Bad and Poorly Coached—Period!
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMoniglePublished On: Mon Dec 15 2025
Description: BT unleashes a fiery reaction to a quote from Tiki Barber, aggressively challenging the notion that the Giants are not a "bad, poorly coached football team." Tierney emphatically argues that the on-field product proves the coaching and talent are both fundamentally flawed. The discussion quickly shifts to the Mets, where BT defends Steve Cohen's simultaneous pursuits of a casino deal and a Mets rebuild, telling skeptical fans that he believes Cohen's ultimate motivation is to succeed on both fronts. He tackles fan disappointment over trading fan favorites (like Pete Alonso), explaining that winners think long-term, and Cohen is moving on from players the organization "doesn't value as much as some of you guys do." Tierney concludes with a passionate take on clubhouse chemistry, asserting that talent and success trump whether players are "tight" off the field.
The note was deleted
The note was saved
Your message was sent