The Mendoza Gamble: Is the No. 1 Pick Worth the Risk?
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMoniglePublished On: Tue Dec 23 2025
Description: In this segment, Marc Malusis dives into the high-stakes debate surrounding the upcoming NFL Draft and whether the New York Giants should use a potential #1 overall pick on quarterback prospect Mendoza. While acknowledgeing the team's desperate need for a signal-caller, Malusis expresses skepticism, comparing Mendoza’s ceiling to other prospects like Alabama’s Simpson. He argues that the organization must avoid the "trap" of forcing a selection based on need rather than evaluation. Instead, Moose explores the tactical advantage of trading down to acquire massive draft capital, suggesting that if several teams fall in love with Mendoza, the Giants might be better off building a deeper roster rather than betting it all on one arm.
The note was deleted
The note was saved
Your message was sent