This week's Knicks highlights include praising the team's dismantling of the Sixers to enter the All-Star break on a high note. Plus, Evan and Tiki compare the Mike Brown Knicks to last year's group under Tom Thibodeau, and marvel at the fanbase invading Philadelphia for a road game.

Francisco Lindor is heading for hand surgery, and the Evan and Tiki crew debate if the star shortstop can be ready for Opening Day. Plus, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle wonder how long it will take Lindor to get his power stroke back, and more reactions to Juan Soto moving to left field.

Derek Carr walks back Jet hops, NBA All Star Weekend is here, Valentine's Day surprise from Tiki, and much more

The Derek Carr rumor cycle takes a hard turn as new comments force Evan to rethink everything he thought he heard in December. Is Carr actually open to coming back, or is he quietly ruling the Jets out unless they magically become contenders overnight? The guys break down what Carr really means by “the perfect situation,” which teams actually fit that description, and why the Jets may already be on the outside looking in. The quarterback discussion spirals into full Jets chaos, from Malik Willis to Kyler Murray, Tua, Cousins, Rodgers rumors, draft options, and the reality that there is no clean answer. Evan announces an upcoming Jets QB Big Board, callers argue over upside vs. desperation, and the debate over winning now versus setting up 2027 heats up. Plus, Tom Brady somehow narrates a 49ers documentary and still finds a way to take a cheap shot at Jets fans, sparking a classic Evan rant. The hour also introduces the idea of a weekly “worst take of the week” segment, with more than a few WFAN personalities already lobbying their case.

The Knicks made a move that barely made a ripple, but it could matter way more than people realize, and we explain why. Plus, a brand-new weekly segment launches at 11:30am: “Are You Kidding Me?” where we crown the dumbest sports opinion from the station, including some absolutely unhinged nominees. Then we pivot to the NFL’s plan to kick off Week 1 with Rams vs. 49ers in Australia and possibly start the season on a Wednesday or Thursday, and what that does to the tradition of the defending champ opening the year. We also get into the Jets debate: is it better to tank for a top pick or build a real roster even if it lands you in draft purgatory? Featuring caller heat, host arguments, and a full “who had the worst take” showdown.

Evan and Tiki react to the Knicks' latest roster addition, Jeremy Sochan. After being waived by the Spurs, is the young defensive agitator the perfect "dog" for the Knicks' stretch run? The guys also settle a bet regarding Knicks fans taking over Philly with the "Jose" chant for Jose Alvarado. Then, concern grows in Yankees camp as Cam Schlittler is scratched from throwing off a mound due to back tightness. Evan and Tiki debate if the young right-hander will make the Opening Day roster and if fans would sign up for a guaranteed 94-win season. Plus: A shocking email from a Giants fan who defected to the Jets. Shaun Morash’s "Cinco de Lunch Show": The Top 5 Most Useless Valentine's Day Gestures. Presidential trivia ahead of the long weekend.

The 4th and final hour of Evan & Tiki brings classic WFAN chaos, sports debates, and plenty of laughs. The show opens with reaction to Nick Castellanos being released by the Philadelphia Phillies and whether he makes any sense for the New York Mets. The guys break down why signing him would directly impact Mark Vientos, and whether Mets fans should trust the young slugger or chase a revenge storyline against Philly.

The guys try to wrap their heads around the NBA All Star Game’s new format and quickly realize it is way more confusing than expected. Team World vs USA Stars vs USA Stripes, short games, round robin rules, and age based rosters all get debated. They question whether splitting Team USA actually makes sense, why some players feel old already, and whether fake allegiances can create real intensity. Kevin Durant’s comments about effort spark a bigger discussion about whether this year’s game might actually matter, especially with international stars being called out. Add in the NBA’s return to NBC, mixed feelings on the dunk and three point contests, and a classic Friday segment of Idiots With Idioms, and the conversation goes everywhere in the best possible way.

Nick Castellanos is suddenly available, and some Mets fans are intrigued by the idea of adding a proven bat on the cheap, especially one who might terrorize the Phillies out of spite. But does that actually make sense for this roster? The guys break down why Castellanos’ declining offense, brutal defense, and age raise real concerns, and why any move for him would directly eat into Mark Vientos’ at bats. It comes down to a simple question: do you believe in Vientos enough to give him a clean shot, or are you ready to pull the plug? Plus, why signing players out of fear of division rivals is a dangerous way to build a team.

It’s a Valentine’s Day edition of Cinco De Luncho, and the gloves are off. The guys count down the top five most useless Valentine’s Day gestures, from sending nudes and buying chocolates to flowers that die, corny Instagram posts, and overpriced prix fixe dinners that rush you out the door. Along the way, the list completely derails into classic show chaos with real relationship confessions, unsolicited advice, and stories that probably should not have been told on the air. Equal parts comedy, honesty, and bad ideas you should absolutely avoid.

Spring training brings the kind of Yankees update that always raises eyebrows as Cam Schlittler is pulled off the mound with back tightness. The guys break down why any pitching issue, even a “no big deal” one, feels different than it would for a position player, especially with the rotation already shorthanded. Is this something that simply pushes Schlittler back a turn or two, or a warning sign that keeps him off the Opening Day roster entirely? Plus, a bigger discussion on how minor setbacks for young pitchers can quietly snowball once the calendar starts moving.

A brand new weekly segment is born: “Are You Kidding Me?” where the show rounds up the dumbest sports opinions from around the station and crowns a winner. The inaugural list comes in hot. It starts with Boomer’s take on an Olympic athlete feeling conflicted about representing Team USA, and a bigger debate about whether fans can say “keep politics out of sports” while still celebrating icons like Muhammad Ali. From there it gets even more ridiculous: Keith McPherson going after Luke Weaver for showing up to Mets camp with Yankees gear, Tommy’s “Aaron Judge is the best right fielder in New York sports” line, and Craig Carton going full scorched earth by calling for LeBron James to be suspended for sitting out. Then it turns into a full-blown trial about what actually counts as a “real sports opinion” when Sean Morash’s Brian Cashman wardrobe rant becomes the lightning rod. The crew argues, votes get disputed, and callers jump in to break the tie as the segment goes off the rails in the best way.

The conversation flips to the NFL announcing a Week 1 game in Australia between the 49ers and Rams, and the idea that the season could start on a Wednesday or Thursday before the traditional defending champ opener. Tiki breaks down the brutal travel angle as a former player, while Evan argues the fan side and why the opener tradition matters. The segment wraps with Jets talk: is the job more attractive if you build a real roster and stay competitive, or do you embrace the tank for a potentially loaded QB draft? Plenty of caller fuel, Giants comparisons, and a classic argument about what actually makes a franchise desirable for a coach.

The guys dive into why “more quarterbacks in the draft” is actually good news for the Jets, even when names like Dante Moore and Trinidad Chambliss choosing to return to school feel like a gut punch. They unpack the bizarre NCAA eligibility circus surrounding Chambliss, including the court injunction letting him play a sixth year and why an appeal could keep the story alive. From there, the conversation turns into a full-blown debate about what the Jets should do at quarterback, with calls ranging from “swing big” trade ideas to realistic veteran targets. Evan also announces a new Jets QB “big board” reveal coming next week, because of course he does. Plus: Joe Judge’s strange comments making the rounds, the show tees up a new weekly “worst take” segment for WFAN, and Tom Brady catches heat for taking an unnecessary swipe at Jets fans while narrating AMC’s 49ers documentary. The segment closes on a heavier note with reaction to the Steve Tisch and Jeffrey Epstein document disclosures, what the Giants should do next, and why fans are furious even without any new allegations of criminal conduct being made in the reporting.

A scary Friday the 13th story kicks things off before the conversation turns into full Jets chaos. The guys break down how whispers about Derek Carr coming out of retirement to play for the New York Jets went from sounding obvious to suddenly feeling unrealistic. After revisiting Carr’s December comments and his latest clarification, the debate shifts to what he really wants, which teams actually make sense, and why the Jets keep finding themselves stuck in quarterback limbo. Plus, concern over Yankees injuries, early thoughts on a new weekly “worst take” segment, and the exhausting reality of chasing veteran QB solutions with no clear answer in sight.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Is the Mets roster a given, especially now with the news of Francisco Lindor having hand surgery. Evan and Hoff give their predictions on the 2026 opening day roster. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Knicks bounce back in a big way, the future of Kavon is in question, and much more

The Knicks roll into Philadelphia and absolutely embarrass the Sixers, and no, we are not hearing the “Embiid didn’t play” excuses, because that is the whole point with Philly. From the jump it felt like a home game, with Knicks fans taking over the building and chanting for Jose Alvarado as he put on a ridiculous show. Then, with the All Star break here, it turns into a one day only temperature check on the coaching change: Mike Brown vs Tom Thibodeau. The guys dig into the biggest differences so far, including the bench usage, the minutes coming way down, and why the Knicks might have a higher ceiling this year while also looking uglier in their bad losses. Plus, the joy of winning in someone else’s building, road trip talk, and a caller debate on whether the “minutes panic” is real or overrated.

Are the Knicks already disqualified from being a true title contender? Evan, Tiki, and Sean debate Phil Jackson’s famous 40-20 rule, why the Knicks falling short might matter, and why this season’s parity could blow the whole “rule” up anyway. Plus, the crew gets into whether you’d rather see Detroit early or late in the playoffs, stories from Giants fans traveling to Packers games, and a hilarious detour into the Cashman wardrobe take that may have been “borrowed” by a coworker. Then it’s All-Star Weekend talk and why nobody truly cares about the dunk contest anymore.

Francisco Lindor’s surgery timeline has Mets fans doing calendar math as Opening Day approaches. If he is not ready, Carlos Mendoza finally lays out the emergency shortstop options, and we ask the obvious question: why not just bring back Jose Iglesias on a low-risk deal? Plus: a caller’s looming 2027 lockout fears, a winter classic edition of “Cinco de Luncho” ranking New York teams closest to a title, and a new MLB rule aimed at keeping base coaches in the box to curb sign-stealing angles.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with chaos, controversy, and classic WFAN storytelling. The guys react to Craig Carton putting Todd Hundley on the spot about steroid allegations from the Mitchell Report — and whether anyone even cares about PED accusations anymore. That sparks a deeper conversation about the Mitchell Report itself, George Mitchell’s Epstein connections, and what that means (if anything) for baseball history.

With New York Giants head coach John Harbaugh officially in charge, the focus shifts from coaching hires to what comes next for the roster. This segment dives into the growing debate around Kayvon Thibodeaux and Dexter Lawrence, and whether either star could be on the move as Harbaugh puts his stamp on the organization. The discussion centers on accountability, motivation, cap flexibility, and how much loyalty exists under a new regime. Is this simply offseason noise, or are major roster changes actually on the table? With value, contracts, and performance all in play, the Giants face tough decisions that could reshape the defense and define the Harbaugh era.

It starts with an airport shutdown in El Paso, Texas that somehow gets blamed on a party balloon and instantly spirals into aliens, cartels, spy balloons, and a full blown trust crisis. The guys break down why none of these official explanations ever feel believable anymore, especially after the Chinese spy balloon saga and the mysterious drone sightings in New Jersey. From there, the conversation takes a sharp and hilarious turn into social media paranoia, targeted ads that feel way too specific, and whether our phones are definitely listening to us. That leads to an unexpected deep dive into refrigerators, how we are apparently using them wrong, and a preview of Al Dukes showing off the inside of his fridge. The segment also detours into sports culture with a great origin story of the Chiefs’ shredder hats, legendary fan traditions, and a nostalgic conversation about Bob Sheppard, his iconic voice, and why his legacy still looms large in New York sports. Add in stories involving Tiki Barber, Giants memories, and classic radio tangents, and you get a perfectly chaotic hour that somehow connects aliens, appliances, and the greatest PA announcer of all time.

Cinco de Luncho returns with Shaun Morash officially unveiling his list of the five New York teams closest to winning a championship, and it goes exactly as you would expect. Shaun puts the Islanders at No. 1, drops the Knicks to No. 2, and ignites a full blown debate over playoff certainty versus championship chaos. The guys argue whether hockey randomness should outweigh NBA consistency, where the Yankees and Mets truly belong, and why everything beyond the top tier feels miles away. Knicks fans will be furious, Islanders fans will be confused, and Shaun stands his ground.

Francisco Lindor’s hamate surgery puts the Mets on the clock, with Opening Day looming and no guarantees he will be ready in time. As the team insists patience is the priority, Carlos Mendoza finally names the emergency shortstop options if Lindor needs extra time. That opens the door to a bigger debate. Should the Mets turn back to a familiar face and bring back Jose Iglesias on a short term deal? We break down the internal options, the long term plan for Ronny Mauricio, and why a simple stopgap move might make the most sense if Lindor misses the first week or two.

The Great Knicks Debate: The hosts push back against Boomer Esiason and Craig Carton’s theory that the Knicks should avoid the Pistons until the Conference Finals. They argue why facing a dangerous team early—before they earn postseason "battle scars"—is actually the smarter path. Office Controversy: Sean alleges that a coworker "stole" his specific critique of Brian Cashman’s spring training wardrobe (likening him to a World Series of Poker player), sparking a debate on radio etiquette and borrowed opinions. Road Game Realities: The crew and callers trade war stories about the dangers of being a visiting fan in hostile environments like Philadelphia and Dallas—specifically the eerie silence (and occasional flying beer bottles) that follows a road team victory. The Dunk Contest & Giants Updates: A look at why even $1 million offers to stars like Kobe and LeBron couldn't fix the Dunk Contest, followed by injury recovery timelines for Giants players Cam and Malik Nabers.

Can you judge a championship contender before the ball even tips? In this segment, the guys break down the math of NBA dominanceand why the New York Knicks (currently 35-20) might be facing a historical uphill battle after a tough loss to the Pacers. We debate whether the league’s current parity has finally broken the old rules of "elite" status, or if we’re just making excuses for the mediocrity of the East.

The Knicks didn’t just beat the Sixers, they turned Philly into a second Garden. The guys relive the takeover from the stands, the “it sounded like MSG” broadcast moment, and the wild scene of Sixers fans bailing early while Knicks fans kept getting louder. Jose Alvarado becomes the main character in real time, splashing threes, swiping steals, and getting a full blown chant going in Philadelphia like it was a playoff game. From there, it turns into a bigger conversation about the pure satisfaction of winning in someone else’s building, the best road win stories, and which trips are actually worth it for New York fans. Plus, a minutes played debate, why comparing the Knicks to KD’s situation in Phoenix is a bad comp, and why smart load management matters if your goal is April, May, and June.

Even a Knicks hater had to admit it: watching New York go into Philadelphia and smack the Sixers around was flat out fun. And save the “Embiid didn’t play” talk, because that is the story of the Sixers. If your whole plan hinges on a guy who never seems available, you are not a real postseason threat. The Knicks deserved credit for showing up tough in the final game before the All Star break, with Jose Alvarado bringing edge and the whole team playing more physical, more direct, and way less whiny. But the bigger question is the one Knicks fans have been living with all season: this team looks capable of being great, and also capable of the most annoying letdown losses imaginable. So with the break here, the guys make a one day only exception and do the Mike Brown vs Tom Thibodeau temperature check. Do you feel better, worse, or the same about the Knicks right now, and what do you make of the inconsistency heading into the stretch run?

The Mets move Soto, Lindor is getting surgery, the Yankees report, and much more.

The show opens with three major stories that broke after the show ended the night before. The Knicks suffer a brutal overtime loss to an undermanned Pacers team, Francisco Lindor’s hamate bone injury raises concerns about Opening Day and lingering power issues, and the Mets announce a surprising positional shift for Juan Soto from right field to left field on the eve of spring training. Evan and Tiki debate which storyline actually matters most, why the Soto move makes sense on the field but feels strange in timing and messaging, and how the World Baseball Classic factors into both conversations. Plus, fan calls, injury comparisons around baseball, and why Lindor’s situation could linger far longer than the Knicks loss or Soto’s defensive switch.

In Hour 2, the conversation starts with how teams across MLB handle injury timelines and expectations. David Stearns says the Mets expect Francisco Lindor to be ready for Opening Day, while other organizations take a far more cautious tone. The guys compare Lindor’s situation to Corbin Carroll and Jackson Holliday, and debate whether honesty or optimism is the better approach, including comments from Orioles GM Mike Elias. Then the focus shifts to the Knicks and the growing frustration around Karl-Anthony Towns. Why has he become such a lightning rod for criticism, and why did even the MSG broadcast turn on him? With clips and reactions from Mike Breen and Clyde Frazier, the discussion breaks down the complaints, the fouls, and whether KAT needs to change how he plays and carries himself on the court.

Spring training is here, the Yankees are healthy, and it should feel like a celebration. Instead, Shaun Morash finds a way to sound the alarm, and it has nothing to do with the roster. His issue? Brian Cashman’s “walk-in” look: hoodie, trucker hat, backpack, iced coffee, and a vibe that screams “too comfortable.” Evan and Tiki push back hard, debating whether this is a real red flag or just peak offseason nitpicking, while callers line up to either roast Shaun or agree the Yankees brand demands more professionalism. Plus, Evan spins the argument into a new idea: a weekly vote for the dumbest opinion on WFAN, and Shaun might already be the runaway favorite.

Evan & Tiki close out the show with a packed final hour full of New York sports drama and plenty of laughs. The guys react to Isiah Kiner-Falefa’s comments about the Yankees and why players and teams seem so comfortable taking shots at the Bronx Bombers. Plus, the Luke Weaver “Yankees bag at Mets camp” controversy gets revisited and debated.

The Knicks and Sixers matchup gets framed as a “regular season game that matters” for one reason: the standings. With New York sitting in the top tier and Philadelphia lurking a few games back, the outcome has real seeding implications, plus the tiebreaker is on the line. The crew debates how much home court should matter, whether the Knicks can still make a run from a lower seed, and why this specific head-to-head feels bigger than most. Then the conversation turns into a full takedown of the NBA’s tanking culture. From blatant late-game lineup shenanigans to teams sitting capable players, the guys argue the league is watching “fake games” night after night. They throw out potential fixes, including flattening lottery odds for all non-playoff teams, and question whether Adam Silver can actually stop teams from gaming the system. The segment also pivots to Mets injury reality, as a caller shares firsthand experience with hamate surgery, prompting a discussion about timelines, rehab, and why comparing everyday recovery to a pro athlete can lead you down the wrong road.

Cinco de Luncho delivers a full football breakdown as the guys rank the five best veteran quarterback options for the New York Jets heading into 2026. From off-the-wall trade ideas to realistic stopgap solutions, the list sparks debate about upside, durability, and whether the Jets are actually a decent landing spot for a veteran passer. Names like Tyson Bagent, Kirk Cousins, Derek Carr, Deshaun Watson, and Mac Jones are all dissected, with arguments over ceiling versus floor and whether copying the Sam Darnold revival model is the smartest path forward. The segment also turns light and chaotic, from smoothie reveals and Cinco history tracking to callers roasting Shaun over his Brian Cashman wardrobe takes. It wraps with Mets talk as the crew predicts when Francisco Lindor will return from hamate surgery and when he will launch his first home run of the season. Classic Cinco energy with equal parts football theory, New York sports chaos, and laughs.

Giants fan asks the big question: should Big Blue consider trading back from No. 5 to pick up extra capital, especially without a third-round pick? The guys debate whether the smarter move is accumulating assets or staying put for an immediate-impact defender. If the right Ohio State defensive stud is there, do you just make the pick and move on? The conversation also touches on how players are remembered, from Rob Gronkowski and his Buccaneers stint to legacy debates that shape how fans view careers. Then it gets deeper into front office strategy. If a team truly believes it has found its franchise quarterback, is there any price that changes its mind? The crew breaks down draft value charts, negotiating leverage, and what an “overpay” really means when you are convinced a quarterback can transform your franchise. Would the Jets have to offer multiple first-rounders to move up, and would it even matter if the Raiders are sold on their guy? It is a wide-ranging football hour that blends draft logic, fan emotion, and the chess match behind the scenes.

Spring training opens with good news for the New York Yankees. Everyone is healthy, no surprise injuries, and Aaron Boone confirms the roster is ready to go. So why is there outrage on Day One? The debate explodes when Brian Cashman arrives in a hoodie, trucker hat, and backpack. What starts as jokes about his Starbucks order turns into a full-blown argument about professionalism, comfort, and whether the Yankees’ longtime GM has grown too comfortable in his role. Is criticizing Cashman’s outfit fair, or does it distract from real issues like roster construction and accountability? Fans call in, tempers flare, and the show wrestles with what Yankees standards are supposed to look like in 2026.

the guys break down a Knicks loss that “won’t ruin the season,” but absolutely cannot happen against a bad, tanking opponent. They debate Jalen Brunson’s late-game hero ball, the missed Landry Shamet look that almost stole it, and how the Knicks left everything on the floor just to go scoreless for long stretches in overtime. Then the NBA drops the punishments from the Pistons-Hornets brawl, headlined by Isaiah Stewart’s seven-game suspension, plus penalties for Miles Bridges and Jalen Duren. The key question: how does this impact the Knicks when Detroit comes out of the All-Star break, and why does it suddenly matter for seeding? Finally, the hour turns into Jets draft chaos as Evan breaks down clips from new Raiders head coach Clint Kubiak and owner Mark Davis that hint at what Las Vegas wants to do with the No. 1 overall pick and QB Fernando Mendoza. The guys debate whether the door is even slightly open for a trade, how Todd McShay’s take on the 2026 vs 2027 draft changes the math, and why the Jets’ pile of 2027 picks makes this a rare “perfect storm” scenario. Plus, the Derek Carr breadcrumbs keep piling up.

The discussion opens with how MLB teams handle injury timelines and expectations. David Stearns insists the Mets expect Francisco Lindor to be ready for Opening Day, while other organizations take a much more conservative approach. The guys compare Lindor’s situation to Corbin Carroll and Jackson Holliday, whose season will start late after surgery, with Orioles GM Mike Elias flatly ruling him out for Opening Day. Is this honesty, gamesmanship, or simply different philosophies on setting expectations? From there, the conversation shifts to the Knicks and the growing backlash against Karl-Anthony Towns. Why has he become the ultimate lightning rod, and why did even the MSG broadcast turn on him? With pointed criticism from Mike Breen and Clyde Frazier, the segment breaks down the nonstop complaining, bad fouls, and whether Towns needs to play more physically to change the narrative.

With Francisco Lindor’s hamate bone injury looming, the show pivots to the sudden wave of baseball injury news around the league, including Corbin Carroll and Jackson Holliday also dealing with hamate issues. The guys explain why this injury can be deceptively tricky, why power can take longer to return even after the “six week” timeline, and why Yankee fans are bracing for the next bad spring training update when Boone and Cashman meet the media. They also revisit the original “three big stories” debate, weigh Soto’s move to left field against Lindor’s injury as the most important headline, and take early calls from fans on what the Mets should do if Lindor is not ready. Then the conversation swings back to the Knicks, breaking down the overtime loss to Indiana, Karl-Anthony Towns disappearing, Brunson forcing it late, and the accusation that Rick Carlisle coached like he was trying to lose.

Three major stories broke after the show ended, but the conversation quickly zeroes in on the most polarizing one. Evan and Tiki debate Juan Soto’s move from right field to left field, why it actually makes sense at Citi Field, and why the timing and explanation from the Mets still feels strange. The discussion digs into Soto’s defensive history, his split time between left and right field throughout his career, and whether the World Baseball Classic played a bigger role than the team wants to admit. Plus, questions about roster construction, fan reaction, and why this move was obvious to some long before it became official, even if it still feels awkward the way it rolled out.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): In this offseason we've seen the roster completely turn over. Fan favorites have left the building like Brandon Nimmo, Edwin Diaz and Pete Alonso. The replacements of Bo Bichette, Marcus Semien, Jorge Polanco, Luis Robert Jr. and Freddy Peralta are here. The question isn't if we like what David Stearns did. The question is "Are the Mets better?". Well, are they? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Jets get a couple of intriguing quarterback options on the market. Spring Training gets set to start.

Is the next big football story in New York already here? The guys explain why the Giants feel “done” for now, while the Jets are just getting started with Aaron Glenn back, Frank Reich running the offense, and a full QB room rebuild ahead. Then the conversation turns into a full-on Derek Carr deep dive after a real report says he is considering a comeback and he is throwing with zero shoulder limitations. Is Carr the perfect bridge for the Jets, or could he actually be more than a one year stopgap? Plus, the crew weighs Carr vs Kirk Cousins, why Carr’s year away might be a huge benefit, what options truly exist for the Jets, and why Carr’s own words might be the biggest clue about where he wants to land.

On this segment of Evan & Tiki, the guys dive into the latest reports from Adam Schefter regarding potential NFL rule changes. Evan and Tiki debate the pros and cons of allowing teams to trade draft picks up to five years in advance and whether the league should finally replace the onside kick with a 4th-and-13 play from the 25-yard line. Then, the show goes off the rails when a caller claims Patriots QB Drake Maye is already "leaps and bounds" better than Eli Manning after just two seasons. Evan loses his cool, defending Eli’s clutch legacy against what he calls "stat-padding" from the Patriots' young star. Also in this hour: St. John's Expectations: With the Johnnies sitting at 19-5, is it "Elite Eight or Bust" for Rick Pitino? Posting and Toasting: The crew plays their favorite tweet game, featuring debates on parallel parking skills and Al Dukes’ bizarre requirements for watching Olympic swimming. The Return of Adam Gase: Reaction to the news that the former Jets head coach is back in the league working with Justin Herbert—and why the framing of his resume drove Evan crazy.

MLB’s package situation is a total headache: do you need the ESPN app, what does the bundle actually get you, and why does nobody seem to know the real price? With spring training kicking off, the guys talk Big Mac’s very “serious” spring training party, why this moment matters (the offseason is finally over), and whether MLB is botching the messaging to fans right before baseball returns. Plus, they rewind to the crew’s Yankees offseason “wish list” from November and compare it to reality, as Cashman basically brings back the same roster. Is “Run It Back” a smart bet on internal improvement, or a lazy gamble that leaves real holes? And wait… Opening Day on Netflix? Good luck explaining that to everyone’s dad.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki opens with spring training controversy as Yankees fans erupt over Mets pitcher Luke Weaver arriving at camp with a Yankees bag, sparking a broader debate on why the Yankees get mocked more than any team in sports. The guys react to Isiah Kiner-Falefa’s comments about preferring to face the Yankees in the playoffs, discuss institutionalized Yankee hate, and whether it’s earned. Then the show pivots to the NFL with a deep dive into Deshaun Watson’s future after his remaining lawsuits are dismissed, including a heated debate on whether the Jets should take a flier on the former elite quarterback versus pursuing Derek Carr. Calls pour in on reputation, risk, and what Jets fans are willing to tolerate. Plus, Knicks talk featuring Josh Hart’s refreshing self-awareness, breaking Mets bullpen news, Justin Verlander returning to Detroit, and a critical Yankees discussion on Anthony Volpe, service time manipulation, and why fans may not see him for a while. Classic Evan & Tiki chaos to close out the show.

The conversation quickly moves past the Luke Weaver Yankees bag debate and into a much bigger question. Should the Jets even consider Deshaun Watson if he becomes available? The guys break down Watson’s fall from elite quarterback to damaged asset, how the legal cloud has changed, and whether time away from the chaos could help him rediscover his game. They also explain why any Jets move, especially one this controversial, is guaranteed to be laughed at regardless of logic, context, or upside.

After giving it 36 hours to breathe, the show goes full “Cinco de Luncho” and ranks the five worst Super Bowls of our lifetimes, chaos included. Evan, Tiki, and Morash each reveal their lists from No. 5 to No. 1, comparing classic blowouts like Giants-Ravens, Seahawks-Broncos at MetLife, Cowboys-Bills, and Patriots-Rams, plus newer disasters that still feel fresh. Along the way, they debate what actually makes a Super Bowl “bad.” Is it the final score, how you felt in the moment, or whether there was anything memorable at all? They get into the 90s dud era, the difference between “historic defense” and “unwatchable football,” and why this most recent game might end up remembered as the “Drake Maye game” years from now. Plus, callers jump in with forgotten all-time stinkers, and the conversation spirals into why the NFC owned the Super Bowl for over a decade and how that shaped an entire generation’s view of the league.

The Yankees officially chose the most polarizing path possible: run it back. With the offseason over, we rewind to November and replay everyone’s original Yankees plans to see just how far off the front office went from fan expectations. From dream scenarios involving Alex Bregman, Josh Naylor, Steven Kwan, Sandy Alcantara, and bullpen reinforcements, to the reality of Cody Bellinger returning and almost nothing else changing, the gap is glaring. So what does it actually mean that nearly the entire roster is back? Is Brian Cashman betting on internal growth, better health, and fewer October failures? Or did the Yankees miss a real opportunity to raise their playoff ceiling? We break down the leadoff problem, bullpen concerns, roster stagnation, and whether believing in improvement from Volpe, Dominguez, Rice, Wells, and others is enough to justify one of the most extreme “run it back” seasons in modern Yankees history.

It is time for Posted & Toasted, where the crew plays a classic guessing game using old tweets and posts that feel a little too confident in hindsight. From thinking Olympic sports look way easier than they are, to wild takes about curling, luge, bobsledding, and ice skating, the guys debate which host fired off each post. The conversation drifts into winter hats worn in August, why certain things are oddly comforting, and whether anyone actually could medal in a parallel parking Olympics. Plenty of laughs, self-awareness, and classic show banter packed into one segment.

What starts as a simple caller debate turns into a full-on on-air fight between Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash over one loaded question: is Drake Maye already ahead of Eli Manning. Evan argues the narrow “through two years” case, while Shaun pushes back hard on why that framing is cheap, misleading, and disrespectful to what Eli actually accomplished when it mattered most. The segment spirals into shouting, interruptions, and pure sports radio chaos as Boston hype collides with New York legacy, playoff performance vs regular season numbers, and why comparing careers through tiny windows misses the entire point. A heated reminder that Eli still lives rent free in Patriots fans’ heads and that nothing ignites a show faster than quarterbacks, rings, and revisionist history.

After a blowout loss, Will Campbell reveals he played through a torn knee ligament and skipped the podium. Was he being honest or did it come off as making excuses. The guys debate whether athletes are better off saying nothing after tough losses and why injury explanations always land differently when they come from the player himself. The conversation then shifts to a major NFL offseason topic sparked by Adam Schefter, as reports suggest at least one team wants to extend how far into the future draft picks can be traded. Would moving from three years to five years help teams or completely mess with accountability. Plus, thoughts on proposed rule changes like replacing the onside kick with fourth-and-long and why some ideas sound smarter in theory than reality.

The Derek Carr-to-the-Jets idea goes from rumor to “wait a second…” as the show lays out three pieces of evidence from Carr’s own podcast that make it sound like he is absolutely open to New York. He praises Garrett Wilson, gushes about Aaron Glenn, and even shouts out Jets fans in a story that somehow involves a Henry Ruggs bomb and a charity donation wave. Then the conversation widens: if Carr is truly healthy and wants to play, is he the perfect bridge who finally buys the Jets time to develop a young QB the right way? Plus, callers weigh in on whether Tom Brady’s famous “you’re sticking with that guy over me?!” was aimed at Carr or Jimmy Garoppolo, why that matters for a potential Raiders reunion, and how the 2027 draft hype could change the way teams think about trading picks. And at the end, the looming question returns: with all these moving parts, is Carr actually the most realistic Jets answer, or just the latest offseason rabbit hole?

The next big football story in New York might be the Jets, not the Giants. While the Giants feel “done” after locking in their coach and QB plan, the Jets are staring at a total quarterback reset with Aaron Glenn back, Frank Reich running the offense, and zero easy answers on the market. Then a weekend report lights the fuse: Derek Carr is seriously considering a return, his shoulder is reportedly fully healthy, and the Saints still hold his rights. Is Carr the smart “bridge” the Jets actually need, or is this just another offseason mirage? Plus, why Carr vs Kirk Cousins is a real debate, how the Raiders could complicate everything, and the moment the conversation flips into “wait… does Carr actually want to be a Jet?”

From 'NYYST' (subscribe here): The Run It Back ‘26 puzzle added another piece when the Yankees re-signed 1B Paul Goldschmidt. Is Brian Cashman actually right about this team? Also, is it a possibility that Jasson Dominguez starts the season in AAA? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Everyone called Super Bowl 60 boring, but Evan and Tiki explain why watching the Patriots get embarrassed by the Seahawks was actually a thrill ride. The guys break down the game, including Drake Maye’s playoff struggles, the dominance of Kenneth Walker, and the irony of Sam Darnold getting a ring. Later, the show goes off the rails regarding a broadcast moment that enraged Jets fans: Mike Tirico calling Adam Sandler a Patriots fan "as per usual." They debate who is more at fault Tirico for the lazy research, or Sandler for wearing a hat with the Patriots logo on it.

The guys break down the most baffling coaching decision of the Super Bowl and celebrate a massive weekend for New York sports. Topics discussed include: The 2-Point Conversion Debate: Why Mike Vrabel’s decision to kick the extra point down 19-6 made absolutely no sense to the crew. Drake Maye "Seeing Ghosts": Reacting to the rookie quarterback’s struggles against the dominant Seahawks defense, now dubbed "The Dark Side." Knicks > Celtics: The guys gloat about the Knicks' blowout win in Boston and roast the Celtics' excuse that the "start time was too early." Halftime Show Reviews: Was Bad Bunny’s performance a hit or a miss? Plus, the crew makes their long-term predictions for next year’s performer. Sandler & Tirico: A quick reaction to Mike Tirico confusing Adam Sandler’s fandom during the broadcast.

In this post-Super Bowl breakdown, the guys dive into the "unprecedented" nature of a game where the kicker was the MVP favorite for three and a half quarters. Evan is forced to face the music (and wear a literal "L") after a year-old take on Super Bowl champion Sam Darnold comes back to haunt him. Plus, the crew ranks their favorite (and least favorite) commercials—including a heated debate over a patriotic Pegasus—and discusses the sheer audacity of Jordan Hudson’s "Orchids of Asia" t-shirt. Was it a defensive masterclass or just a boring dud? And why is Tony Gonzalez wearing a Falcons jersey in a prostate cancer commercial? We’re getting to the bottom of it all.

In the final hour of the show, Evan, Tiki, and Sean look ahead to next year by predicting the matchup for Super Bowl 61 in Los Angeles. The guys break down the current betting odds, debate whether the Baltimore Ravens are the team to beat in the AFC, and discuss if the Washington Commanders or Dallas Cowboys are legitimate NFC contenders. Plus, the crew reacts to the shocking news of Adam Gase returning to the NFL with the Los Angeles Chargers and tackles the "controversy" surrounding Mets pitcher Luke Weaver showing up to Spring Training with a Yankees bag.

Super Bowl 60 is in the books, and Adam Sandler may be the only controversial thing to have come out of the game.

Evan and Tiki debate who the Super Bowl champion Seahawks will host to kick off the 2026 NFL season. With the Rams and 49ers heading to Australia, the guys analyze the remaining options including the Chiefs, Chargers, and Bears and argue whether the John Harbaugh led Giants are ready for the prime-time spotlight. Plus, the crew discusses the lack of cold-weather Super Bowls and Tiki sets his price tag for the Jets to acquire Mac Jones.

Evan and Tiki rank their top 5 Super Bowl commercials, debating the merits of humor versus heart—including a heated argument about the Clydesdales versus Ben Stiller's "slapstick" moment. The guys also discuss the "Orchids of Asia" t-shirt worn by Bill Belichick's girlfriend, Jordan Hudson, and whether it crossed a line in trolling Robert Kraft. Plus, a look at the confusing new MLB streaming paywall, a nostalgic trip through 80s movies like Real Genius and Weird Science, and why Tony Gonzalez in a Falcons uniform just felt wrong.

Evan and Tiki debate whether Seahawks kicker Jason Myers deserved the Super Bowl MVP over Kenneth Walker given the unique, low-scoring nature of the game. The guys discuss the historical rarity of a Super Bowl MVP potentially leaving in free agency and fact-check if it has ever happened before. Later, the crew reacts to Sam Darnold winning a championship after years of criticism, debates the nostalgia of Blockbuster Video versus Amazon rentals, and discusses if K-Pop is the future of the Halftime Show.

The conversation spirals from unforgettable Super Bowl halftime shows to the ones nobody remembers, with everything from Dre and Snoop to dancing sharks and post 9/11 U2. The crew debates whether comedy belongs at halftime, why vulgar humor usually lands the hardest, and how easily people get offended during the biggest TV event of the year. Bad Bunny’s lyrics spark a surprisingly awkward moment, leading into a larger discussion about shock value, culture, and where the NFL draws the line. The segment wraps with bold, way-too-early predictions for next year’s halftime performer, including Miley Cyrus, Beyoncé, Jelly Roll, and a few wild cards, plus classic sports radio detours that only make the debate better.

The Knicks walk into Boston and flat-out embarrass the Celtics, and the best part might be the meltdown afterward. Jalen Brunson cooks, Josh Hart does Josh Hart things, and Boston bricks everything in sight, but Celtics fans and media still found excuses. First it was the early tip time. Then it was, seriously, the Super Bowl and Patriots fans selling tickets that “let Knicks fans invade the Garden.” The guys break down why the excuses are nonsense, why this February win actually matters in the standings, and how different fan bases handle losses. Plus, the conversation swings back to the Super Bowl fallout with calls about benching Drake Maye, the offensive line getting wrecked, and the “seeing ghosts” line that might have been said before anyone else.

A little bit of everything after Super Bowl 60. The crew dives into why policing fandom is ridiculous, how Mike Tirico managed to misread allegiances and irritate half the audience, and the moment the game turned after a shirtless fan sprinted onto the field. Then it gets tactical as Mike Vrabel’s late-game decision making comes under the microscope, especially the two-point math that made no sense. Add in a Mack Hollins appreciation segment, gambling talk without the gambling, Drake Maye seeing ghosts, and a larger debate about whether quarterbacks actually decided this Super Bowl at all. A packed segment mixing sports logic, fan culture, and classic Monday morning frustration.

A random Super Bowl celebrity shoutout turned into an all out Jets fan meltdown. Evan and Tiki react to Mike Tirico calling Adam Sandler “a Patriots fan as per usual” and why that one line put a dark cloud over the rest of the night for a lot of Jets fans. Was it a simple camera angle misunderstanding because Sandler was wearing a Super Bowl hat with both logos? Or is the real crime Tirico confidently saying “as per usual” like it is fact? The guys debate what is more egregious: Tirico mislabeling Sandler’s fandom on national TV, or Sandler even putting a Patriots logo on his head in any context.

While most fans called it boring, this was a perfect night for anyone who enjoys watching the New England Patriots fall flat on the biggest stage. We break down why Super Bowl 60 was far more entertaining than people want to admit, especially if you are a Jets fan or anyone tired of Patriots success. From Seattle Seahawks controlling the game with defense and the run, to New England Patriots looking overwhelmed offensively, this episode dives into why the outcome felt inevitable early. We talk about Drake Maye struggling under playoff pressure, why the Patriots’ easy path finally caught up to them, and how Seattle won without needing a heroic performance from Sam Darnold. Was the game ugly? Absolutely. Was it satisfying? For at least one bitter Jets fan, it was four hours of joy. We also look ahead to what this loss means for the Patriots, why getting close does not guarantee you will ever get back, and whether Seattle can realistically repeat this formula next season.

Evan & Tiki react to the Jose Alvarado trade as the news breaks during their show. Plus, Boomer & Gio on what the move means for the Knicks (12:55); the trade has Craig Carton feeling confident the Knicks can go all the way (18:29); the Knicks’ OT win over the Nuggets shows Boomer & Gio the team is kicking things into high gear (42:40); Evan Roberts on why you can believe in the Knicks (57:29); Evan & Tiki on the Deuce McBride injury (1:14:05); Craig Carton basks in the recent Knicks’ success (1:26:24).

Sam Darnold is in the Super Bowl, leading Evan and Tiki to look back on how far the Jets draft bust has come. Craig Carton doesn't believe anyone declaring that they won't watch this Sunday, though Chris McMonigle doesn't believe it is a "sexy" matchup. Plus, can the Giants follow the Patriots path and become contenders next year?

This week's Jets highlights are all about the hiring of Frank Reich as the team's new offensive coordinator, and reactions to Shaun Morash's report that Darren Mougey is already fed up with Woody Johnson. Plus, is there any hope the owner "pulls a James Dolan" and finally changes his ways?

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Super Bowl week in the NFL. Seahawks, Patriots. Tom Brady can't pick a team? Prop bets for the big game. Mike's 5 leg parlay. In depth storylines and much more. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Our final Football Friday has us showing two teams that each of our locals can envision for a vision. Our picks, and a question about Super Bowl Party etiquette.

With Super Bowl week as the backdrop, the conversation zooms out to the big picture question every New York fan is asking: how close are the Giants and Jets really? The Giants are front and center as the hosts draw direct parallels to the Patriots’ rapid turnaround, from a young quarterback in Jaxson Dart to proven leadership under John Harbaugh. The similarities to New England Patriots and Drake Maye are hard to ignore, and the case is made that a double digit win jump is very realistic for the New York Giants. The focus then shifts to the Jets and why their path feels much longer. Using the Seattle Seahawks as the model, the discussion centers on building the roster first and finding the quarterback last, a formula that worked with Geno Smith and now Sam Darnold. The question becomes whether Aaron Glenn can make a similar year two leap to what Mike McDonald did in Seattle, or if the New York Jets are still years away. Along the way, the hosts debate whether there is one true formula to building a contender, why quarterback obsession can be misleading, and how close being close actually matters. Plus, Tiki Barber weighs in on just how well coached Seattle really is, and the show wraps with some very human locker room talk that only Super Bowl week can inspire.

The hour starts with a full-on takedown of Giannis’ “legends don’t chase” victory lap, with one bold prediction: he is getting moved this summer and the tweet is going to age horribly. Then the convo pivots to NFL Honors, where Stafford wins MVP in a razor-thin race and it sparks a hilarious relitigation of last year’s Giants debate: would you rather have gone all-in for Stafford, or be in the Jaxson Dart era right now? It gets even weirder with NFL Honors moments that left everyone confused, plus callers diving into Super Bowl strategy (Patriots defense vs Seahawks weapons), the never-ending Brady vs Belichick argument, and an alternate universe where the Jets drafted Brady in 2000. Along the way: a legendary Reese’s slip-up, why Philly suddenly feels like it’s falling apart, what Stoutland and Schwartz resignations could mean, the Giants adding Greg Roman, a Malik Nabers injury timeline breakdown, and a closer look at Russell Wilson’s social media behavior that somehow makes Brady’s “no dog in the fight” look normal.

From Radio Row, Jets DT Harrison Phillips delivers three brutally honest clips that cut right to the franchise’s biggest issue: culture. He explains why a connected locker room beats raw talent, then drops a headline-grabber by calling the “Same Old Jets” mindset a “cancerous” problem that infects the building when losing starts to snowball. The guys also react to Brian Costello’s follow-up clarification and why it actually makes Phillips’ point even stronger. Then the show pivots to a wild sports-media moment where Evan finds out on-air that the Nets waived Cam Thomas, and spirals at the thought of him landing with the Knicks. Plus, NFL Honors quick hits (including Jaxson Dart’s ROY vote), and a full breakdown of the “5 things you cannot do” at a Super Bowl watch party, including the chaos of split-TV streaming delays and the most controversial take of the hour: should funeral homes be closed on Super Bowl Sunday? Close it out with a reality check on tonight’s St. John’s vs UConn game at MSG and why February hype doesn’t matter nearly as much as March.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki opens with breaking Knicks news as New York trades for Jose Alvarado just moments before reports surface that Deuce McBride will undergo core muscle surgery and could miss the rest of the regular season. Evan and Tiki break down what the injury really means, playoff timelines, and why the move reflects how well-run the Knicks have become. The conversation shifts to NBA trade deadline fallout, Giannis’ future in Milwaukee, James Harden analogies that hit a little too close to home, and Hall of Fame debates involving Eli Manning, Luke Kuechly, and Jason Witten.

What starts as total confusion over Olympic scheduling and where to even find the Knicks on TV quickly turns into side-eyeing the timing of a heavily hyped Lindsey Vonn moment on Super Bowl Sunday. The debate escalates into classic “just asking questions” territory before the show completely leans into chaos with another laugh-out-loud edition of Idiots With Idioms, featuring mangled phrases, accidental word crimes, and the weekly reminder that idioms are undefeated.

A brutal, no-win question gets put to new Bills defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard: was that controversial playoff play a catch or not? The guys break down why it’s such a loaded spot for a coach, debate how they would have answered it, and then give Leonhard full credit for threading the needle with a smart, honest, and loyalty-protecting response. From there, the conversation spirals into classic Buffalo heartbreak, Bills fan trauma, and how one call can completely change a Super Bowl path. It’s a reminder of how fine the margins are, how fans never forget, and why sometimes the best answer is barely answering at all.

The guys react to a truly uncomfortable Super Bowl Sunday dilemma: a wake scheduled right in the middle of the game window. Sean tries to walk the line between paying respects and saying what every sports fan is thinking, while Evan wonders how something this obvious can even happen, then realizes most of the country simply isn’t living inside the nonstop Super Bowl bubble. That turns into a hilarious, slightly dark debate about funeral etiquette, “buying your way out” with a charity donation, and how different people process grief, tradition, and obligation. It’s one of those conversations where everyone agrees it’s serious, but nobody can stop the jokes. Then they cleanse the palate with sports, as a caller tries to sell St. John’s vs UConn at MSG as the biggest college hoops game of the year. Evan pushes back with the cold truth: it’s a great night out, but February results don’t define anyone. Same goes for the Knicks and Pistons tonight. The only games that matter are the ones in March, then April through June.

Evan kicks off Cinco de Luncho with a personal drive-time ambush: he turns on Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle and finds out the Nets waived Cam Thomas, instantly launching a full roast of Brooklyn as a “relegation” level embarrassment. Evan, meanwhile, takes it personally. Cam was “his guy,” and the only outcome he truly can’t live with is Cam Thomas ending up on the Knicks. From there the show hits quick NFL Honors reactions, including Jaxson Dart getting just one vote for Offensive Rookie of the Year and a rapid run through the Hall of Fame class, plus a mini-debate on whether local bias affects how people view Dart. Then Shaun unveils the ultimate Super Bowl watch party rulebook: one parlay mention only, no walking in front of the TV during action, stop asking about squares, absolutely no double-dipping, and most importantly, shut up during the game. The segment wraps with the ultimate party debate: two-room setups sound great until the streaming delay turns the casual room into accidental spoilers.

Evan breaks down three must-hear Radio Row clips from Jets DT Harrison Phillips, starting with a simple truth: he’d take a connected team over a more talented one, every time, and even tells a classic “I literally pushed my lineman into the hole” story to prove it. Then it gets spicy. Phillips says Aaron Glenn inherited a “cancerous” vibe and explains how losing turns into a survival mindset that spreads from vets to young players. The conversation shifts when Brian Costello follows up and Phillips clarifies he wasn’t targeting individuals, he meant the “Same Old Jets” mentality that kicks in once things go sideways. That turns into a bigger debate about whether “Same Old Jets” is a fan label or a real locker room infection, and why winning is the only cure. From there, the phones take over. Evan answers an all-time Jets favorite question and drops a curveball: Mo Lewis, and he’s furious that a great 13-year Jet gets reduced to one hit. Then a Mets caller drags the show into trade rumor chaos, with Evan drawing a hard line on dealing Brett Baty or Mark Vientos for prospects, while also admitting Vientos is a perfect Yankees fit if the return is real major-league help.

This segment rips through a wild coaching carousel update: Jim Schwartz reportedly gets disrespected on his way out, then decides he’s done with Cleveland and sits out, raising the big question of whether teams can still “hold rights” on coordinators the way they do with head coaches. From there, the spotlight swings to Jeff Stoutland’s resignation in Philadelphia and why it screams dysfunction, especially after his run game coordinator role got yanked mid-season. The convo turns into “who benefits?” fast, with Jets and Giants angles, Frank Reich’s connection, and the reality that if Philly blocks a lateral move, Stoutland might have to sit too. Add in the Eagles vibe check, AJ Brown trade chatter, retirement rumors, and suddenly the NFC East feels wide open, with Giants optimism creeping into the conversation again. Then it’s calls: a Brady vs Belichick argument that spirals into a Jets-drafted-Brady alternate universe, why Super Bowls need luck plus infrastructure, and a reminder that the best Super Bowl is the one that is actually a football game, not a headline circus. Finally, the cherry on top: Brady’s “no dog in the fight” gets compared to Russell Wilson’s all-about-me feed, and the idea that Russ might secretly root against Seattle just to protect his own legacy.

Matthew Stafford takes home MVP in a razor-thin finish over Drake May, sparking a deep dive into how close the race really was and why Stafford’s late-career surge keeps getting louder. That leads straight into a relitigation of last year’s Giants argument: should the Giants have pushed in for Stafford when the rumors were flying, or is landing Jaxson Dart and resetting the franchise timeline the better path? From there, the NFL Honors recap turns into a comedy of confusion, including awkward announcing moments and the kind of “how did this happen?” production decisions that leave everyone staring at each other. The segment wraps with callers and a classic debate about judging Hall of Fame players across eras, plus a reminder that you cannot just box-score your way through football history.

This turns into a brutally honest Super Bowl rant. Forget style points or a classic finish. The only thing that truly delivers is watching the New England Patriots get dismantled. From Jets fan bitterness to why a lopsided game can still be wildly entertaining, the crew debates what fans actually want when hatred is involved. The conversation branches out into expectations for Seattle Seahawks dominance, rooting for Sam Darnold, and whether a comfortable win is more satisfying than late game drama. There is also a deeper look at coaching legacy with Mike Vrabel and Mike Macdonald, plus why this Super Bowl rematch feels nothing like the one from a decade ago. If you think every Super Bowl needs to be close to be great, this segment strongly disagrees.

As Super Bowl 60 approaches, Evan tries to “squint” and find hope for New York football, and Tiki actually sees a real blueprint. The Giants, led by John Harbaugh and rookie QB Jaxson Dart, look eerily similar to the Patriots’ recent turnaround: solid run game, defense ready to modernize under Denard Wilson, and a rookie season stat line that mirrors Drake Maye. The big swing factor: can Matt Nagy be the Josh McDaniels type who accelerates Dart into stardom?

The Knicks win a thriller, they add defense while losing Deuce. Plus the Super Bowl storylines continue to be discussed.

Evan and Tiki try to “breathe” after an insane double-overtime Knicks win at MSG that almost turned into an all-day referee meltdown. They break down Mikal Bridges’ brutal night (and the massive corner three), why Knicks fans are suddenly saying “we don’t need Giannis,” and the real takeaway: Mitchell Robinson looking like a one-man defensive cheat code against Jokic and Jamal Murray. Plus, trade deadline talk with the latest buzz, the Knicks’ minor money move, what the buyout market could look like, and calls on Brunson’s clutch DNA and a wild Draymond-to-NY idea. Then the hour takes a hard turn to hockey as the Rangers ship Artemi “Breadman” Panarin to the Kings, sending Sean into full Fan Focus fury about Drury, the direction of the franchise, and why this “retool” feels like a wrecking ball. Also: an unexpected debate on the worst U.S. president of all time.

iki and Evan dive into the controversy surrounding Tom Brady's recent comments about the Patriots in the Super Bowl. Despite his former teammate Mike Vrabel coaching New England, Brady claims he has "no dog in the fight," sparking outrage among Boston fans and former players. The guys debate whether Brady is being corporate, disconnected, or just trying to protect his new ownership interests. Later, the show shifts to Major League Baseball as the Detroit Tigers make a splash by signing Framber Valdez, leading to a debate on whether the Tigers are now legitimate threats to the New York Yankees in the American League.

Hour 3 opens with Giannis dominating the NBA deadline conversation, plus the fallout from Tom Brady’s “no dog in the fight” comments as even active players pile on. Then the real deadline bomb drops: Shams reports the Bucks are keeping Giannis, which the show calls the best possible news for Knicks fans and a major setup for a wild summer. Minutes later, the Knicks strike anyway, landing Jose Alvarado in a low-risk move built for playoff minutes. The guys break down why he’s a perfect pest defender, why it helps if Deuce McBride’s injury lingers, and how “Jose Jose” might return at the Garden. It also sparks a classic New York argument: Knicks title odds vs Islanders “sport nature” logic, complete with soapbox energy and lap talk. The hour wraps with Jets frustration returning fast as the conversation shifts to roster building, reputation, and why the Knicks are the blueprint for fixing a broken franchise. Leon Rose gets his flowers for deadline hits, while the Jets still feel stuck in the cycle.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki opens with breaking Knicks news as New York trades for Jose Alvarado just moments before reports surface that Deuce McBride will undergo core muscle surgery and could miss the rest of the regular season. Evan and Tiki break down what the injury really means, playoff timelines, and why the move reflects how well-run the Knicks have become. The conversation shifts to NBA trade deadline fallout, Giannis’ future in Milwaukee, James Harden analogies that hit a little too close to home, and Hall of Fame debates involving Eli Manning, Luke Kuechly, and Jason Witten. Plus, the guys dive deep into Super Bowl Week, ranking the least appealing Super Bowl matchups of the last 20 years, debating Patriots vs Seahawks fatigue, Tom Brady’s competitiveness, and whether this game has any real juice. All that, Cinco de Lunch, calls, laughs, and peak WFAN energy to close out the show.

Cinco sets the tone for Super Bowl week and admits it out loud. The excitement just is not there yet. As the booth spirals into controlled chaos, the crew debates whether this year’s matchup belongs in the conversation as the least appealing Super Bowl in recent memory. That leads to a full countdown of the five least exciting Super Bowl matchups going in over the past 20 years, based on hype, star power, and buzz at the time, not how the games eventually played out. From Steelers Seahawks to Panthers Broncos, the guys argue legacy quarterbacks, franchise fatigue, and whether dominant regular seasons always translate to must-watch Sundays. The discussion circles back to this year’s game, the perception of quarterbacks like Sam Darnold, and whether coaching intrigue and future legacy can overcome a lack of pregame juice. Plus, a quick temperature check on why we always end up watching anyway, even when the matchup does nothing for us.

Everything snaps into focus once The Athletic report drops: Deuce McBride is getting surgery for a core muscle injury and might be out until the playoffs. Five minutes ago, the Alvarado trade felt like smart “just in case” depth. Now the “just in case” has a name and it’s a scalpel. The guys immediately pounce on what feels “off” about the situation. McBride had been listed as left ankle injury management, then it morphed into an ankle issue, and now it’s suddenly a core muscle surgery that never showed up on the injury report in any obvious way. That whiplash becomes the story, not just the injury itself. They compare it to how different leagues handle transparency, with the NFL forcing specifics while other sports can play games with wording, competitive advantage, and vague reporting.

Breaking news hits mid-show and the Knicks make a classic contender move, grabbing Jose Alvarado from the Pelicans. The guys immediately lean into the New York angle, Alvarado is a local kid, and the “homecoming” vibe matters because this is a player built for Madison Square Garden energy. They run through the scouting report fast: high motor, pest defender, full-court pressure, and the nickname says it all. “Grand Theft Alvarado” is about taking the ball, not the video game jokes, even if they still squeeze those in. Then the return drops and everyone starts laughing because it’s one of those deals where you almost assume there has to be more. The Knicks give up newly acquired Dalen Terry and two second round picks. That’s it. It also sets up a mini victory lap at the reporters who said the Knicks were nowhere close to Alvarado. From there, the basketball case gets loud. This is a playoff-rotation pickup, not a headline grab. They frame Alvarado as a weapon for a series where you need someone to harass a primary ball handler, with Cade Cunningham being the example that keeps coming up. He also becomes insurance for Deuce McBride with the injury situation still weird and vague. The point is simple: you just added a guy who will actually play when it matters, without touching the core.

Hour 3 kicks off with the NBA deadline chaos and the biggest headline hanging over everything: Giannis. The show then pivots to the Tom Brady controversy after he says he has “no dog in the fight” for the Super Bowl. Patriots fans are annoyed, former teammates are chirping, and an active player goes as far as saying he’s “disgusted,” turning Brady into a weird New England villain story. The guys debate whether Brady is detached, protecting broadcast credibility, or just wired to compete at whatever he’s doing next. Then the real breaking news hits. Shams reports the Bucks have told teams they are keeping Giannis through the deadline. Evan frames it as the best possible outcome for Knicks fans because it keeps a rival from getting stronger now, while leaving the door open for summer chaos. They also talk through the strange ripple effects: Milwaukee possibly shutting him down, Shams’ careful wording, and how Giannis could still weaponize his leverage later by scaring off teams with the “I’m not re-signing there” card. The segment ends with the bigger theme: the East feels wide open, the Celtics are compromised without a fully healthy Tatum, and this is exactly the kind of season where the Knicks get a real shot to “finish the story” before the summer superstar carousel starts again.

The hot stove finally cools down as the Detroit Tigers sign ace pitcher Framber Valdez to a massive 3-year, $111 million deal. Tiki and Evan debate whether this move makes Detroit a legitimate World Series contender or if they are simply capitalizing on a weak AL Central—and how they stack up against the New York Yankees in a potential playoff series. Then, the results are in for the show's MLB Free Agency Bingo. After months of tracking, a winner is crowned (spoiler: it’s Tiki), while Tommy finishes dead last. The guys also pivot to a bizarre history lesson, discussing Robert Todd Lincoln’s uncanny proximity to three presidential assassinations and the irony of the man who saved his life.

Tom Brady set off a full-blown Patriots fan meltdown after saying he has “no dog in the fight” when asked who he’s rooting for in the Super Bowl. Boston fans and former Patriots are ripping him for sounding cold, scripted, and weirdly detached from the franchise that made him. The guys break down the full context of the clip, why the “resume speech” made it worse, and whether Brady is trying to please everyone as a broadcaster and part-owner of the Raiders. Plus, the show compares it to the old “Tiki rooted against the Giants” stereotype, talks loyalty in sports, and takes calls from fans with theories on what Brady is really doing.

The idea sounds wild, but once you dig in, it completely falls apart. The guys explain why Karl-Anthony Towns and Draymond Green could never coexist on the same team, starting with a total lack of respect and ending with impossible chemistry and salary math. From Draymond’s history with teammates to the uncomfortable comparison to the Jordan Poole situation, this debate breaks down why a theoretical New York Knicks move makes no sense. Would you really trade Josh Hart or Mikal Bridges for Draymond? And even if you could, should you? The answer here is pretty clear.

The inevitable finally happens as the Rangers move on from Artemi Panarin, and emotions run hot in the studio. Then the focus shifts to the Knicks, who make a quiet but calculated deadline move, dumping salary and adding Delon Terry with limited short term expectations. What does it really mean for the playoff rotation? From there, the conversation widens to the NBA trade deadline chaos. The Knicks stay disciplined, the Milwaukee Bucks listen but likely hold Giannis Antetokounmpo until the offseason, and contenders like the Golden State Warriors pivot after swinging and missing. Plus, reaction to James Harden landing in Cleveland and why it does not change the Knicks’ postseason outlook. Calls from Knicks fans wrap it up, including buy-in debates, playoff trust issues with Karl-Anthony Towns, and why this deadline may be remembered more for what did not happen than what did.

A wild double overtime night at Madison Square Garden had everything. Late whistles. Missed shots. Big nerves. And a Knicks team that refused to fold. Evan and Tiki break down the double overtime win over the Denver Nuggets and why this one felt different from past seasons. The conversation starts with the controversial loose ball foul that nearly flipped the night and why the Knicks overcame a moment that usually ends in disaster. From there, the focus shifts to the trade deadline chatter and why a game like this makes you wonder if the Knicks even need Giannis Antetokounmpo to compete with the league’s best. At the center of it all is Mitchell Robinson. His ability to guard Nikola Jokic in the paint and switch out onto Jamal Murray on the perimeter is dissected in detail, along with why his defensive impact might be the real difference between a good team and a Finals team. Jalen Brunson gets his due for late game poise, Karl-Anthony Towns’ bloody toughness moment is discussed, and the roller coaster night from Mikal Bridges is put into full context. Plus, legendary calls from Walt Clyde Frazier add another layer to an already unforgettable night. A reminder to stay calm during an 82 game season, but also a clear message. This Knicks team can beat anyone when it defends like this.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): It's another version of the "Rico 10". So let's catch you up with all things Mets related you may have missed. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Bantamweights Mario Bautista & Vinicious Oliveira clash at UFC Fight Night 266 for a chance to try and crack the top 5 in the division. Pete Hoffman gets a chance to speak with Mario Bautista during fight week to talk about the huge matchup! Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram, TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Jets mess enters another day, they hired Frank Reich in a sign of good news, and Super Bowl week pushes on.

The Jets finally make it official: Frank Reich is the new offensive coordinator, and Evan and Tiki debate whether it’s a stabilizing move or just another “single to center field” for a franchise that always finds a way to spiral. Evan breaks down why Reich’s résumé works, why the Carolina stint shouldn’t be the whole story, and why none of it matters until the Jets find an actual quarterback. Then the show turns into a full-on Jets credibility cage match. Shaun Morash joins the hour and answers the backlash from his reporting, clears up what he said about Darren Muji, and explains why people around the league keep calling the Jets a toxic environment. Plus, Evan puts the ultimate poll to the audience: who do you trust more, Morash or Craig Carton, and the early results might surprise you.

With the NBA trade deadline just hours away, the league is holding its breath after a revealing quote from Giannis Antetokounmpo: “I want to be here, but I want to win.” Evan and Tiki react to what that really signals about Giannis’ future in Milwaukee and whether the Knicks were ever truly in the mix. The guys are joined by Ian Begley to break down why Giannis may ultimately stay put, how his situation slowed the entire trade market, and what realistic moves the New York Knicks could still make before the buzzer. They also examine how recent moves by Cleveland and Boston reshape the Eastern Conference, why asset limitations matter for New York, and whether the real Giannis sweepstakes are more likely to spill into the offseason. It is a deadline-eve deep dive into superstar leverage, front office patience, and what Knicks fans should actually be rooting for when the clock hits 3:00 PM.

Sam Darnold is finally rewriting his story, but the Jets chapter still has one moment that refuses to die: “seeing ghosts.” We dive back into the WFAN archives for the original Joe & Evan reaction, how Adam Gase took the early heat, and why the soundbite became a national punchline that followed Darnold for years. Plus, the show goes fully behind the scenes as a Mike Vrabel clip turns into a studio fire drill, and we check in on the ongoing “who do you trust more” poll chaos. Finally, Cinco de Luncho shifts gears with the five must-haves for your Super Bowl table, including a dip-first philosophy and a pigs-in-a-blanket debate that gets personal.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with laughs, debates, and classic WFAN chaos. The guys revisit their NFL head coaching predictions and score themselves in “NFL Coaching Bingo,” reacting to hires like Todd Monken, Mike McCarthy, Klint Kubiak, and more. They debate which new head coach will be the first one fired and whether dysfunctional franchises like the Browns or Raiders are doomed to repeat history.

A hilarious Jeff Francoeur story turns into an all-time sports prank: Greg Maddux allegedly signed autograph balls as “Jeffrey Dahmer” to mess with suspected resellers, while making sure kids still got the real signature. The crew debates how anyone could miss it, then a caller from the Upper East Side drops a perfect firsthand twist from a 2014 autograph event where Maddux allegedly joked about not writing a serial killer name on his jersey. From there the segment spins into a convo about all-time greats struggling as owners and coaches.

The guys go back to the prediction desk and grade their NFL head coaching “bingo” cards now that the jobs are filled. Sean comes out on top, Evan salvages a couple, and Tiki somehow goes 0-for-10. Then the conversation shifts to the real fun question: which of these new hires is the first one fired? The Browns and Raiders dysfunction debate gets heated, Tom Brady’s Raiders influence comes up, and the segment detours into a Michael Jordan ownership discussion before taking a caller who jumps into Yankees lineup controversy with Trent Grisham vs Jasson Domínguez.

The show tries to do the responsible thing and hold takes accountable, but it turns into total chaos when a classic Mike Vrabel “how far would you go to win a Super Bowl” clip hits the system without the proper edits. The crew scrambles to dump, bleep, and re-cut the audio on the fly while Evan loses patience and Sean spirals. Then the “Who do you trust more” poll update drops, and it is suddenly uncomfortably close between Shaun Morash and Craig Carton, with Craig firing back at the whole idea.

Sam Darnold may be writing a new chapter in his career, but one Jets moment still lingers. The guys revisit the infamous “seeing ghosts” game against the Patriots, how it defined Darnold’s New York tenure, and why Adam Gase initially took most of the blame. A deep dive into WFAN archive audio, how one mic’d-up moment became a national punchline, and why Jets fans still can’t shake it, even as Darnold moves on.

With two first-round picks in hand, the New York Jets may have the flexibility to make a bold quarterback move in the upcoming draft. Evan and Tiki dive into the idea of using a high pick on Ty Simpson, a prospect whose stock has swung wildly over the last college season. They revisit how quickly quarterback evaluations can change, why waiting can be risky if you truly believe in a player, and how past debates like the Daniel Jones draft still shape how fans view early QB selections today. The conversation also expands to broader draft philosophy, media hype cycles, and why it may be too early for anyone to feel confident about next year’s quarterback class. A thoughtful look at patience, projection, and pressure when it comes to finding the next franchise quarterback.

Trade deadline eve gets spicy fast after a new report out of The Athletic delivers the money quote from Giannis: “I want to be here, but I want to win.” Evan and Tiki translate what that really means for Milwaukee, why the Giannis uncertainty froze the market, and why so many teams made their moves early. Then Ian Begley joins the show to lay out the hard truth for Knicks fans: New York is on the outside looking in on Giannis right now, not because they “love their roster,” but because they simply do not have the assets to win that bidding war. Begley explains what the Knicks could still do before 3:00 PM, including potential targets like Jose Alvarado and a backup big, plus how Deuce McBride’s status factors in. Finally, the conversation widens to the East shifting under everyone’s feet, from Cleveland’s aggressive swing to Boston’s moves, and why the real Giannis sweepstakes might be headed for the offseason.

Evan tries to calm the Carton vs Morash noise by admitting he respects both, then throws gasoline on it anyway by posting the ultimate Twitter poll: who do you trust more, Craig Carton or Shaun Morash? The guys break down the voting blocs, Mets fans still angry about the Kyle Tucker saga, Jets fans furious at Morash, and the “swing states” that decide the whole thing. Early returns come in and Shaun is actually winning, which turns into a hilarious reality check on what it even means to be in a trust poll with a Radio Hall of Famer. The calls keep it moving, the Jets credibility debate keeps boiling, and then the show pivots to the night in New York sports: the Knicks crush the Wizards and keep their win streak alive, the Nets get run off the floor by the Lakers, and the Islanders finally grab a win in a wild one. Plus, a quick laugh at Big Mac refusing to run the poll, some family fandom warfare, and then the focus shifts to what’s next for the Knicks with the NBA trade deadline looming and Ian Begley joining to break it all down.

The Jets finally make it official: Frank Reich is the new offensive coordinator. Tiki calls it a smart, stabilizing hire for Aaron Glenn, but Evan keeps it real, a “single to center field” that doesn’t fix the one thing that matters most: quarterback. They dig into Reich’s résumé (Philly success, Indy chaos, Carolina disaster), why some fans can talk themselves into it, and why the vibe around the franchise still feels inevitable. Then it turns into a full-on Jets credibility brawl. Shaun Morash is in the crosshairs of Jets fans and Craig Carton after yesterday’s reporting, and Evan lays out why the public treats them like extremes. Morash pushes back, defends his sourcing, clarifies the Darren Muji comments, and explains why the Jets always seem to be playing defense. Plus, the show tackles the bigger point behind all of it: Woody Johnson’s involvement, the “toxic” perception around the league, and why Jets fans can’t get inspired until the organization proves it can simply win.

WFAN dives deep into the shockwaves following the New York Giants’ decision to hire former Chiefs OC and Bears Head Coach Matt Nagy as their next offensive coordinator. As the "John Harbaugh era" officially takes shape in East Rutherford, the station debates whether Nagy’s experience under Andy Reid is the secret sauce needed to unlock Jaxson Dart’s superstar potential—or if this is a repeat of past offensive frustrations

Super Bowl Week continued with breaking Giants and Jets news, plus Evan proves Aaron Boone may be wrong.

The New York Giants finally lock in their offensive coordinator as Matt Nagy comes over from the Kansas City Chiefs to join John Harbaugh. The crew breaks down what Nagy’s offense could mean for Jaxson Dart, why Theo Johnson might be a sneaky winner, and how much credit should go to Andy Reid after Nagy’s mixed run with the Chicago Bears. Then the mood flips to the New York Jets, as exclusive reporting paints a franchise with no real head coach autonomy, with Woody Johnson stepping in and Aaron Glenn getting undercut, including a wild twist involving Wink Martindale. Giants competence, Jets chaos, and a fan base bracing for impact.

Hour 2 keeps the spotlight on the growing divide between New York football franchises. The New York Giants officially bring in Matt Nagy, and the discussion centers on competence, development, and why this staff feels trustworthy under John Harbaugh, even if the hire is not flashy. On the other side, the New York Jets remain mired in dysfunction. Woody Johnson is painted as increasingly hands on, confidence in Aaron Glenn continues to erode, and fans openly wonder if there is any path to credibility without a complete reset or a powerful buffer between ownership and football operations. The hour also features a classic Posted & Toasted segment that dredges up old takes, cold tweets, and station personalities getting exposed, followed by a full blown showdown involving Aaron Boone. Boone fires back at criticism over how the New York Yankees handled Jasson Domínguez, prompting a deep dive into the actual numbers that turns anecdotal frustration into hard evidence. Add in raw Jets fan calls, season ticket soul searching at MetLife Stadium, and the growing sense that one franchise is moving forward while the other is stuck arguing with itself.

Evan and Tiki turn a messy headline into a game: how many times would the media actually press Roger Goodell about Steve Tisch and the newly released Jeffrey Epstein email exchanges. The league drops a brief statement, then the room goes right at it, including questions from Judy Battista and Albert Breer. The guys react to Goodell’s careful wording, debate what an actual NFL “fact-finding” process even looks like, and whether “not illegal” can still be “bad enough” under the personal conduct policy. Plus: quick hits on the Rooney Rule, Goodell going out of his way to praise officiating, and the league’s thoughts on Bad Bunny and the halftime spotlight.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki dives deep into the reaction around the New York Giants hiring Matt Nagy as offensive coordinator and why fans are split between trust and skepticism under John Harbaugh. The guys also rank the top Jets offensive coordinator candidates, debate Greg Roman vs Frank Reich, and break down uninspired vs experienced hires. Plus, Evan reveals his prank call on Tommy Lugauer, Knicks trade deadline talk heats up with Giannis rumors, James Harden trade speculation, and plenty of classic Evan & Tiki banter to close the show.

The New York Giants officially land on Matt Nagy as their next offensive coordinator, and the reaction is exactly what you would expect. After Todd Monken heads to Cleveland, John Harbaugh pivots to Plan B, bypassing names like Kliff Kingsbury and Charlie Weis Jr. and choosing experience over mystery. The crew breaks down why Giants fans are already uneasy, where the criticism of Nagy actually comes from, and why the surface-level stats do not tell the full story of his time in Kansas City or Chicago. Is this really a boring hire, or just a familiar one for a fanbase conditioned to expect disappointment? The conversation then swings to Florham Park, where the New York Jets continue their own coordinator search. Frank Reich, Greg Roman, and Darrell Bevell are on the board, and the guys rank the candidates while unpacking what Aaron Glenn actually needs right now. Giants optimism, Jets uncertainty, and a reminder that sometimes the loudest reactions come from the least informed places.

Super Bowl 42 officially turns 18, and that means the Helmet Catch is now an adult. With Giants fans already feeling old, the crew takes a nostalgic turn on Cinco de Luncho by ranking the five MVPs of the historic upset over the Patriots who were just as vital as Eli Manning. From clutch catches and relentless pass rush to an unforgettable halftime moment that steadied an entire fan base, they break down the plays, performances, and forgotten heroes that made one of the greatest Super Bowls ever. A pure Giants throwback that still feels as good as it did in 2008.

After a quiet Friday news dump, the focus turns to the Steve Tisch connection to the Epstein emails and how the NFL chose to handle it. The crew plays a game predicting how many times Roger Goodell would actually be asked about the situation, then listens back as the commissioner faces three pointed questions at the podium. From the league’s vague preemptive statement to Goodell’s careful non answers, they break down what was said, what wasn’t, and what an NFL “investigation” even means in this context. The conversation expands to personal conduct standards, how far the league should go with owners, and whether this opens a much bigger can of worms. Along the way, they also react to other Goodell topics from the podium, including the Rooney Rule, officiating, tanking, and the Super Bowl halftime show.

Things get personal when Aaron Boone unexpectedly fires back at on-air criticism, directly calling out comments made by Shaun about how the New York Yankees handled Jasson Domínguez. What follows is a full blown fact check, as Evan digs into every two-hit game Domínguez had last season and proves Boone sat him eight times immediately after, including against multiple right-handed pitchers. Anecdotes turn into data, and the numbers spark a heated debate about development, matchups, and trusting young players when they are hot. From there, the conversation shifts back to the New York Giants and the hiring of Matt Nagy. Callers weigh in on what Nagy really brings after his time with the Kansas City Chiefs and Chicago Bears, debating how much credit he deserves, what he learned from Andy Reid, and why his role alongside Jaxson Dart matters more than his head coaching record. The segment wraps with classic sports-radio chaos, including a live season ticket negotiation at MetLife Stadium, fan frustration boiling over, and a quick pivot toward the next headline involving Roger Goodell and league level scrutiny.

The show takes a sharp and hilarious turn with Posted & Toasted, as the crew digs up old tweets from WFAN coworkers and lets Tiki Barber guess who posted them before deciding who deserves to be toasted. It starts with an all time 2020 cold take shredding Doug Pederson and Matt Nagy while propping up Eric Bieniemy and questioning the greatness of Andy Reid. Tiki immediately sniffs it out as a vintage Shaun Morash take. Then comes a dark 2017 train ride tweet that shocks everyone when it turns out to belong to Chris McMonigle, followed by a 2023 confession from Evan Roberts admitting he roots against the New York Yankees just to hear Big Mac battle callers over Aaron Boone.

his segment opens with a full takedown of what the Pro Bowl has become and why it no longer means what it used to. Justin Fields turning down the Pro Bowl earns respect, while seeing Shedeur Sanders labeled a “Pro Bowler” highlights how hollow the honor has become. The crew argues the solution is simple: keep Pro Bowl selection as a standalone honor, then separate it from the exhibition event entirely, possibly reimagined as a fan focused showcase tied to flag football and the future Olympic push. From there, the conversation swings back to New York football. The New York Giants are praised for leaning into real coaching and teaching under John Harbaugh, with callers emphasizing fundamentals like catching, tackling, and development, especially with young players such as Theo Johnson. The takeaway is that this staff feels deliberate and built to improve players, not just manage games. Meanwhile, the New York Jets spiral continues. Calls center on ownership dysfunction, whether Woody Johnson is driving the franchise into a dead end, and the bleak reality that even big name saviors like Mike Tomlin feel unrealistic. The hour circles the same haunting question Jets fans cannot escape: who, if anyone, can actually save this franchise.

After painting the bleakest picture yet of the New York Jets, the crew tries to find the one possible silver lining: if this thing fully detonates, does Woody Johnson finally have his “James Dolan moment” where he spends big on a true franchise savior and then actually steps back? They debate what the Jets are missing most, not just a quarterback or an OC, but a real football “filter” between ownership and the people trying to do the job. The frustration boils over when money enters the chat: rumors of Aaron Glenn earning massive dollars, fans getting crushed by rising costs at MetLife Stadium, and the core question that drives every call: if you are charging people a fortune, how do you not do everything possible to win? Plus, calls pour in as Jets fans hit their breaking point, from “denouncing” fandom to wondering if the league would ever step in, while the show circles back to the reality that competence is the rarest commodity in this building right now.

Breaking news hits early as the New York Giants officially hire Matt Nagy as offensive coordinator under John Harbaugh. The crew digs into Nagy’s winding path from Chicago to Kansas City, his fit with Jaxson Dart, and why Theo Johnson could quietly thrive in this offense. It is not a splashy hire, but it feels deliberate, competent, and very Giants. Then the conversation takes a sharp turn to the New York Jets, where exclusive reporting paints a bleak picture of an organization unraveling from the top down. Woody Johnson is accused of stripping authority from head coach Aaron Glenn, blocking key hires including Wink Martindale, and creating a culture so toxic that league insiders are warning others to stay away. As the Giants project stability and direction, the Jets appear stuck in a familiar cycle of dysfunction with no clear exit in sight.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Pete Alonso, Edwin Diaz are just the more recent Mets legends that we've had to say goodbye to in free agency. Over the franchise's history we can go down the list of names that completely tugged at Mets fans heartstrings. Here's an episode dedicated to those that should have not been allowed to leave in free agency. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Yankees manager Aaron Boone joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on The Carton Show on WFAN for a wide-ranging, no-nonsense interview that hits every topic Yankees fans obsess over. Boone addresses long-standing rumors about Brian Cashman and analytics controlling in-game decisions, responds to criticism about accountability, and explains why he won’t rewatch painful losses. Plus, Boone opens up on Aaron Judge’s leadership, Giancarlo Stanton’s health, Gerrit Cole’s rehab, Anthony Volpe’s future, bullpen struggles, running it back in 2026, and the pressure of managing the New York Yankees without a championship. A must-watch conversation during Super Bowl week as Boone heads to Tampa for spring training.

Super Bowl Week Has Begun, is there any interesting storylines to this game? The Knicks win, and much more

Newly released emails connected to Jeffrey Epstein put New York Giants minority owner Steve Tisch in the spotlight, raising serious questions about accountability, league standards, and whether the NFL will actually confront uncomfortable issues involving ownership. The guys break down what is known, what is denied, and why this story barely registered across national NFL media. They also dig into what authority Roger Goodell truly has, how past ownership scandals were handled, and why the Giants brand and the Mara family sit at the center of the conversation. The show pivots to the Knicks. Was it worth paying a fortune to see LeBron James at Madison Square Garden, an all-time Reggie Miller broadcast moment that drove fans crazy, and whether the Knicks’ recent run changes the urgency to chase Giannis. A caller floats a Mikal Bridges for Jrue Holiday trade, and the guys explain why that idea quickly falls apart.

The crew pivots from the chaos of the morning and jumps into a rapid-fire exercise: stack this year’s Super Bowl (Patriots vs Seahawks) against the last decade and decide, honestly, which matchups had more juice before kickoff. It turns into a full breakdown of storylines, star power, coaching intrigue, and why some teams can be great but still feel bland. They debate whether it’s East Coast bias, fatigue from seeing the same franchises, or simply that the newer versions of these teams are less interesting than the Brady era Patriots and the Legion of Boom era Seahawks. There’s also a Monday vibe prediction that this one could get ugly, plus a quick detour into the coaching carousel, why some jobs are becoming toxic, and what that could mean for teams like the Jets. Then things go full radio: the hypocrisy conversation hits, how fans pick and choose outrage, and why perspective matters more than perception. It wraps with lighter chaos from the weekend, including concert takes, the legendary “Evan seats,” a wild UBS Arena story with Jon Ledecky, and the Islanders using Tommy’s Rangers-sweep rant as hype-video fuel.

In this hour, the guys dive into the latest controversies surrounding New York sports and the NFL offseason. The Yankees & Trent Grisham Saga The show opens with a reaction to Brian Cashman’s recent interview, where he doubled down on the Trent Grisham trade and contract. The Debate: Cashman calls the $22 million deal a "steal" in the current market, while the hosts debate if Grisham is merely an expensive insurance policy that blocks younger talent like Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones. The Roster Impact: Is Grisham’s presence stunting the development of "The Martian," or do the Yankees need veteran depth for a World Series run? Giants Ownership & The Epstein Files The conversation shifts to the reports regarding Giants co-owner Steve Tisch and leaked emails connecting him to Jeffrey Epstein. NFL Discipline: A discussion on whether the league will punish Tisch similarly to how they handled other owner controversies, or if the lack of criminal charges protects him. Future Ownership: Speculation arises on the Koch family’s minority stake and if they are positioning themselves to take over a local team in the future. Super Bowl Storylines & The "Boring" Build-Up With the Super Bowl approaching, the hosts struggle to find compelling narratives, leading to a "Top 5 Storylines" list that includes: Sam Darnold’s "Middle Finger Tour." Fears of a new Patriots Dynasty. The Seahawks/Patriots revenge narrative. Stefon Diggs winning a ring before Josh Allen. 49ers practice facility conspiracy theories. The Kwesi Adofo-Mensah Firing & Paternity Leave A heated discussion regarding the firing of Vikings GM Kwesi Adofo-Mensah and reports citing his two-week paternity leave during training camp as a point of contention. The Contrast: The hosts compare this to Bills coach Joe Brady’s comment about missing his child's birth for a game, ultimately concluding that both approaches are personal choices ("to each his own") rather than fireable offenses. NBA & MLB Notes KAT vs. The Critics: A deep dive into Karl-Anthony Towns' statistics. While he is averaging 19 points and 11 rebounds, the hosts note this is his lowest career field goal percentage and effective field goal percentage, sparking a debate on his All-Star validity vs. Pascal Siakam. Reds Sign Suarez: Reaction to Eugenio Suarez signing with Cincinnati and what that means for the Mets' reliance on Mark Vientos.

The 4th and final hour of the Evan & Tiki Show dives deep into the NFL coaching carousel and the local fallout. Evan and Tiki break down the Giants and Jets offensive coordinator searches, debate candidates like Kliff Kingsbury, Jim Bob Cooter, and Alex Tanney, and react to how wrong everyone was in coaching bingo. The guys also tackle big-picture questions for Roger Goodell, including tanking, ownership controversies, and league accountability, plus spirited calls on the Jets’ historic playoff drought, Giants ownership drama, Knicks trade buzz, Islanders vs Rangers debates, and classic Evan & Tiki banter to close out the show.

With the Giants still searching for their offensive coordinator, the focus turns to one thing that matters most: who is best equipped to develop Jaxson Dart. The crew runs through the full list of known candidates, including Kliff Kingsbury, Jim Bob Cooter, Alex Tanney, Brian Callahan, Davis Webb, Shane Day, and more. How much do short coaching stints really matter? Is this a spot where you swing big or trust John Harbaugh to make it work no matter what? From scheme fits to resumes to gut feelings, we break down who excites us, who scares us, and who actually makes sense for the Giants right now.

Cinco de Luncho kicks off in full chaos before settling into a brutally honest question: is this the least interesting Super Bowl in years? The crew admits the buzz just is not there and tries to force together five storylines anyway, from San Francisco injury paranoia and Stefon Diggs possibly winning one before Josh Allen, to Seahawks revenge against the Patriots and fears of another New England run. It all leads to the most uncomfortable angle of the week: Sam Darnold standing at the center of Super Bowl week while Jets fans watch from home. Equal parts funny, annoyed, and real, this is Cinco de Luncho doing what it does best, cutting through the noise when there is barely any noise to cut through.

The focus shifts straight to the Yankees as Brian Cashman publicly defends the decision to bring back Trent Grisham on a one year, $22 million deal and even frames it as a bargain. The crew breaks down why that explanation is driving fans crazy and whether the logic actually holds up in today’s market. The discussion turns into a deeper argument about how the Yankees build rosters, the balance between spending and flexibility, and whether veterans like Grisham are acting as smart insurance or actively blocking the development of younger players like Jasson Domínguez and Spencer Jones. Is this disciplined roster management or the same thinking that keeps the Yankees from fully committing to their future?

Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle finally gets his long-awaited meeting with Yankees manager Aaron Boone, and the guys predict absolute awkwardness and hero worship. That leads into a hilarious recap of a night at UBS Arena, including a fake speakeasy setup, Jon Ledecky playing it cool, and Big Mac getting ribbed on the big screen with an all-time mispronunciation of his name. The segment also dives into Tommy’s Islanders rant being used as a full-blown hype video, how nervous that made him once the puck dropped, and why that moment meant more than any billing order on the scoreboard. From there, the conversation turns serious again with callers weighing in on the Steve Tisch situation, what Roger Goodell can actually do, and how many real questions the commissioner will face about it. It wraps with broader league talk, including revenue sharing, small-market realities, and why the NFL model works where baseball continues to struggle.

A caller raises the alarm about the growing trend of coaches pulling out of interviews, and the guys connect it to what the Jets could be staring at next. If the roster stays thin, ownership stays noisy, and you are firing a coach after one year, who is actually lining up to take that job? The discussion hits the Browns and Cardinals as warnings, debates the real risk of moving on from Aaron Glenn too fast, and questions whether the “best and brightest” would even want the Jets. Then the segment shifts into a bigger conversation about hypocrisy and how fans react differently depending on the name, the talent level, and the stakes. It turns into a blunt talk about outrage, perspective, and why sports media can’t just repeat the same point every minute of every show. Finally, the whole thing takes a left turn into weekend stories, including a Rascal Flatts concert, “Evan seats” as the perfect concert hack, and an Albany surprise with an International Wrestling Hall of Fame sighting, capped off with Royal Rumble predictions and a reminder that the wrestling savant era might be here.

A bold claim that Patriots vs Seahawks is the least appealing Super Bowl of the last decade. To prove it, the guys run through Super Bowls year by year, comparing pregame intrigue, star power, coaches, quarterbacks, and overall buzz. Brady vs Mahomes, Stafford’s redemption, dynasties, underdogs, and first-time contenders all get stacked up against this matchup, and nearly all of them come out ahead. The debate dives into why this Super Bowl feels flat, whether it is fatigue with familiar franchises, less compelling versions of past dynasties, or simply a lack of must-see characters. It wraps with a Monday gut prediction that this game could get ugly, even if opinions might change by kickoff.

The Knicks take down LeBron and the Lakers 112-100 as the win streak keeps rolling, and Karl-Anthony Towns gets the All-Star nod. Then the real question: if you dropped $1,200 a ticket at Madison Square Garden, did you walk out feeling like it was money well spent, or instantly regretting it? The guys debate whether the Knicks are back to their best version, with ball movement, defense, and rebounding looking like a team that can beat anybody. They also torch Reggie Miller for an all-time overreaction on a LeBron dunk and argue he shouldn’t be calling Knicks games at all. Plus, with the trade deadline approaching, the Giannis conversation heats up again. If the Knicks are rolling and the East feels wide open, do you still push the chips in or protect the chemistry? A caller floats a Mikal Bridges for Jrue Holiday swap, and the guys explain why trading a prime player for an aging vet makes zero sense unless it’s part of something much bigger.

The release of thousands of Jeffrey Epstein related emails puts uncomfortable attention on the NFL, including the naming of New York Giants minority owner Steve Tisch. The discussion breaks down why some mentions are meaningless, why others can seriously damage reputations, and why this one sits in a very different category. The guys question why national NFL media largely ignored the story, what responsibility Roger Goodell has when it comes to ownership optics, and whether the league actually has the will to act when no crime is alleged but the association itself is troubling. They also examine how this impacts the Giants brand, the Mara family, and why protecting the shield has mattered in past ownership cases. Ultimately, it becomes a larger conversation about power, accountability, and whether the NFL will confront uncomfortable realities or quietly move on once the headlines fade.

The Yankees general manager has spoken, and we have a lot of thoughts on his assessment of the offseason, from Craig Carton strongly defending Cashman to Tommy Lugauer ripping the Yanks for essentially running it back.

Craig Carton believes the Giants suffered a setback as Todd Monken accepted the Browns head coach job over Giants offensive coordinator. Plus, Boomer and Gio on who the best fit to help develop Jaxson Dart would be (25:43); Evan & Tiki react to a report that former Jets OC Tanner Engstrand is in play with the Giants (36:10); Tiki also gives his top five candidates for OC (53:56); Craig and C-Mac debate whether the Giants or Jets have the brighter future (1:14:05)

Boomer and Gio are intrigued by a report that the Jets reached out to Jon Gruden for a coordinator position. Plus, why Evan Roberts believes this is all a set up for Gruden to become head coach in 2027 (18:20); Evan & Tiki discuss the hopelessness of the Jets (35:23); Craig Carton calls out the Jets and the Gruden delusion (59:00); Boomer and Gio on the mess that the Jets find themselves in with their coordinators (1:13:28).

Matthew Schaefer called in to Boomer and Gio after his Islanders finished off a season sweep of Boomer's Rangers, while Team USA legend Mike Eruzione also joined the show. Plus, SNY's Connor Hughes gave Evan and Tiki the latest on the Jets quest to fill their coaching staff, and Ian Begley provided the Giannis trade intel.

Boomer and Gio react to the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade demand and the possibility of him becoming a Knick. Plus, SNY Knicks reporter Ian Begley joins Evan & Tiki to talk Giannis and more (12:13); Evan & Tiki give their thoughts of a potential Giannis trade (28:58); Craig Carton and C-Mac talk Giannis to the Knicks with ‘Basketball Jones’ (46:17), and Craig and C-Mac on the likelihood that the Knicks part ways with Karl-Anthony Towns for Giannis (57:39).

The Rangers get swept but dos it count? The Jets may have another QB option, the Knicks prep for Lebron, and much more

Evan wakes up furious at the two people he works with, and it starts with a simple point: the New York Islanders swept the New York Rangers and Evan wants full credit, no asterisks. Shaun tries to wave it off with “the Rangers quit,” which turns into an all-out fight about what “counts,” rivalry pride, and whether Ranger fans are ducking the embarrassment after the Garden got loud for Islanders fans at Madison Square Garden and UBS Arena. Then Tiki Barber lights the fuse on a totally different argument: could Kirk Cousins actually make sense for the New York Jets, not just as a stopgap starter but as a future “player-coach” type who helps shape the offense? The crew debates the age factor, the directionless feel of the Jets, and whether this is a “bottom out” year or a “build something” year, with names flying everywhere from Atlanta Falcons money mechanics to Frank Reich, Aaron Glenn, Malik Willis, and J. J. McCarthy. Plus, the phones go crazy: Islanders fans demand Shaun “own it,” Rangers fans double down on the apathy defense, and the hour ends with more fuel added to the fire, including Matthew Schaefer “king of New York” talk, Chris Drury trust issues, and a surprise moment where James Dolan somehow enters the chat.

Hour 2 opens with Jon Gruden finally addressing the rumor mill on Tampa sports radio, flatly saying there was “never anything” from the New York Jets. Evan and Tiki Barber dig into what that actually means, parsing the difference between an “offer” versus contact through agents, friends, or back channels, and why the wording can be technically true while still avoiding the full story. They also push back hard on fans dismissing credible reporting, defending Diana Russini and Zack Rosenblatt and explaining how information can be real while still being shaped by the motivations of whoever leaked it. The conversation turns into a bigger question: who benefits from the Gruden chatter being out there, and could it make Aaron Glenn look better or worse depending on what gets pinned on him versus Woody Johnson? Then the show takes a left turn into comedy when a caller, Ozzie from Woodridge, “bullies” both Evan and Shaun about their hair on YouTube, leading to on-air style changes, hat reveals, and plenty of roasting. On the phones, the Malik Willis conversation heats up with callers pitching him as a real Jets swing, plus trade ideas and fear that he ends up elsewhere. The hour closes by pivoting to the NBA trade deadline drama: how a potential Giannis Antetokounmpo move could ripple into a New York Knicks decision on Karl-Anthony Towns, why Oklahoma City Thunder and Golden State Warriors keep getting mentioned, and the ultimate high-risk debate: is Anthony Davis worth the gamble if you are chasing a title?

Evan starts by waving the white flag on winter, then quickly pivots into a debate that takes over the segment: why are Los Angeles Lakers at New York Knicks tickets at Madison Square Garden suddenly the hottest regular-season get in years? Is it the “last chance” to see LeBron James in the Garden, is it actually about Luka Dončić, or is it just pure MSG hype? The crew argues about whether LeBron even has a real Garden legacy, why Barclays does not command the same prices, and how much of this is New York chasing a moment they do not want to miss. Along the way, callers weigh in on the iconic player plus iconic venue theory, and Evan admits he once paid big to see LeBron and barely remembers the details now, making the whole “last chance” logic even funnier. Then the segment takes a sharp turn into classic New York chaos when a caller tries to pitch a blockbuster New York Mets and New York Yankees trade involving Juan Soto, and Evan shuts it down fast, with plenty of jokes and disbelief before the show rolls on.

The 4th and final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with Jets drama and classic WFAN chaos. Zack Rosenblatt of The Athletic joins to break down the reported Jon Gruden phone call with the Jets, who made the call, Aaron Glenn’s shaky footing, Woody Johnson’s involvement, and the uncertain plan at offensive coordinator and quarterback. Plus, calls on the Rangers vs Islanders rivalry, Knicks history debates, Mets vs Yankees lineup arguments, WWE Royal Rumble predictions, and a hilarious edition of Idiots With Idioms to close out the show.

It is a packed sports and pop culture run as the Brooklyn Nets hit the road, the New York Rangers, New Jersey Devils, and New York Islanders all take the ice, and New York Knicks host the Los Angeles Lakers at MSG in what might be the hottest ticket in years. Then the conversation veers into WWE madness with the Royal Rumble airing at a very strange Saturday afternoon time from Saudi Arabia. Viewing habits get debated, streaming platforms get questioned, and bold predictions are made, including a surprise pick involving Braun Breaker, plus talk of Roman Reigns, Cody Rhodes, Liv Morgan, and Sami Zayn. And just when things cannot get any more unhinged, the weekly fan favorite returns as “Idiots With Idioms” delivers an all time long, chaotic recap of verbal slip ups across the station. Sports, wrestling, nostalgia, and total nonsense all wrapped into one very busy segment.

The conversation picks up on the Jon Gruden storyline with Evan laying out why, if the idea truly came from ownership, it would signal just how desperate the New York Jets might be. Evan argues that if Jon Gruden ever returns to coaching, it would take both money and real power, and the Jets might be the only team willing to hand him the keys to the franchise. The crew also discusses the unspoken reality that any team openly embracing Gruden could face quiet backlash from the rest of the league, even if fans never see it publicly. From there, the phones flip the segment toward hockey and New York sports pride. Callers gush over Matthew Schaefer, with bold claims that he is already the new king of New York sports. Evan pushes back on the hype, agreeing Schaefer is special but cautioning against crowning dynasties after a few months, which turns into a heated back and forth about prospects, sure things, and why fans always protect their own guys. The segment closes with a classic Knicks history argument as callers debate who really kept the New York Knicks from winning a championship in the 1990s. Evan breaks down why both Michael Jordan and Hakeem Olajuwon were roadblocks, but draws a clear distinction with LeBron James, arguing LeBron never haunted the Knicks the way Jordan did, and that the lingering resentment toward him says more about fan emotion than actual history.

Zack Rosenblatt of The Athletic joins the show to address Jon Gruden publicly denying the Jets rumor and makes it crystal clear: he stands by his reporting that the New York Jets made a phone call to gauge interest, not that they offered him a job. Zack explains why Gruden might be playing semantics, why it may not benefit him to embarrass a team, and how stories like this get distorted once they hit the rumor mill. From there, the conversation turns to the Jets larger plan, or lack of one. Zack says the offensive coordinator search has been messy and shifting, but he still believes Frank Reich is the most likely landing spot because he would function as the “head coach of the offense,” allowing Aaron Glenn to focus on defense. They also dig into the quarterback problem, the thin list of realistic options, and why the Jets are stuck between short-term band-aids and a long-term rebuild. Finally, Zack tackles the biggest fear Jets fans have: Woody Johnson getting too involved as pressure mounts. He describes how quickly the internal plan seemed to change, why the coaching staff decisions scream disarray, and how the Jets are being mocked around the league in a way he has not seen during his time covering the team. The interview ends with the blunt question of whether this job is becoming toxic, and what happens next if the Jets stumble again.

Evan reacts to Robert Saleh being introduced as the new head coach of the Tennessee Titans and plays the clip that is driving New York Jets fans crazy, Saleh joking that in New York, when he did not call plays, he felt like a “timeout and red flag guy” with the best seat in the house. Evan explains why it does not annoy him the way it annoys Jets fans, and instead turns it into a bigger point about how hard the jump is from coordinator to head coach when you are no longer fully plugged into the scheme every snap. From there, the conversation shifts into a blunt lesson about the risks of hiring first-time head coaches and why Woody Johnson keeps putting the Jets in the same cycle. The crew connects it back to the current direction under Aaron Glenn and why the rumored pursuit of veteran offensive leadership like Frank Reich makes sense if you want the “head coach of the offense” alongside a defensive-minded head coach. Then, right on cue, the segment flips into levity as Shaun launches Cinco de Loncho, a rapid-fire Top 5 of what to watch with no football this weekend, including the debut of NBC Sunday night hoops, the Grammys, and anything Craig has not already spoiled.

Evan finally tapping out on winter, then immediately pivots into the strangest market story in New York sports right now: why Los Angeles Lakers at New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden has turned into a premium ticket that is somehow bigger than recent LeBron visits and even other historic regular-season moments. Evan challenges the idea that this is about a “last chance” to see LeBron James at MSG, arguing there is no real Garden legacy the way Michael Jordan had, and questioning why the cheaper Barclays Center option does not scratch the same itch. Then the twist: a caller insists the real draw is Luka Dončić, not LeBron, which sends the crew into a full LeBron vs Luka demand debate, including the “iconic player, iconic venue” argument and whether paying that kind of money is actually worth it years later. From there the segment veers into pure Nets anxiety. A caller asks for a sanity check on reports and speculation linking Giannis Antetokounmpo to the Brooklyn Nets, and Evan goes off: if the Nets chase Giannis right now while tanking, he wants heads to roll. He breaks down what is real reporting versus dot-connecting, why offseason timing matters, and why Brooklyn should only be involved as a facilitator for assets, not as a desperate buyer. The rant brings back an all-time flashback to Evan’s on-air reaction to the James Harden trade, and he warns that a Giannis move would make that meltdown look tame.

With the NBA trade deadline days away, the conversation turns into pure domino math: what happens to the New York Knicks if Giannis Antetokounmpo does not get moved, and why that directly impacts Karl-Anthony Towns. Evan and Tiki Barber lay out the “60/40” trade vibe, the incentive for Giannis to move before the deadline, and why the Bucks might wait for a better summer offer. They also explain why the Knicks are boxed in by pick rules and roster construction, meaning a separate KAT deal could actually hurt their chances if the real goal is a future Giannis swing. The segment then pivots to fit, coaching, and buy-in, including a telling quote from Mikal Bridges about being “coachable,” and what it says about the Knicks identity under Mike Brown. The calls bring the chaos: are the Oklahoma City Thunder the real threat with all that draft capital, do the Golden State Warriors have the Super Bowl-week buzz angle, and is the ultimate gamble worth it, flipping KAT for Anthony Davis if it means a higher title ceiling?

Jon Gruden finally addresses the Jets rumor on Tampa sports radio, saying there was “never anything” from the New York Jets. Evan and Tiki Barber break down the wording and explain how this can turn into a semantics game, offer versus contact, agent versus direct call, and why reports can be true even when the details get twisted. They also defend Diana Russini and Zack Rosenblatt from the “they’re making it up” crowd, while admitting everyone involved has motivations when stories leak. Then the segment takes a hilarious detour when Ozzie from Woodridge bullies Evan into changing his hair and bullies Shaun into hiding under a winter hat on YouTube, leading to an on-air reveal and plenty of roasting before the calls keep rolling.

The Jets quarterback conversation hits a breaking point as Evan, Tiki Barber, and Shaun run through the brutal list of realistic options, from Kirk Cousins to lottery tickets and pure desperation. The debate centers on one question every New York Jets fan is asking right now: are you building something for the future or should you just bottom out completely? They argue why being stuck in the middle is the worst possible outcome, why the Jets feel directionless at quarterback, and whether a short-term Cousins plan makes any sense as a bridge, mentor, or future coach-in-waiting. Callers throw out names like Malik Willis and J. J. McCarthy as the frustration grows, with everyone agreeing on one thing: right now, nobody knows what the Jets plan actually is.

Evan comes in fired up and wastes no time calling out both sides, starting with the New York Islanders sweeping the New York Rangers in dominant fashion. What should be a simple celebration turns into chaos when Shaun claims the sweep “doesn’t count” because the Rangers have quit on the season. That argument sends the show into a full-blown Islanders vs Rangers war, with fights over excuses, pride, tanking, and whether fans get to decide what counts and what doesn’t. The debate hits everything from the letter sent to Rangers fans, shut-down stars, and embarrassing losses at Madison Square Garden and UBS Arena, to callers piling on and demanding Shaun own it. Islanders fans celebrate taking “blood,” Rangers fans insist they do not care, and Evan refuses to let anyone rewrite the rules after a season-long sweep. This one spirals fast and never lets up.

Brian Cashman claims the Yankees aren't the same team, Eli won't get in the Hall, and much more

Evan and Tiki react to Brian Cashman’s media session and the line that set Yankee fans off: the idea the Yankees are not “running it back.” Is he right, just terrible at saying it, or both? The guys debate whether last year’s trade deadline basically was the Yankees’ offseason, what’s still missing without a true Soto replacement, and how the team should handle Anthony Volpe’s rehab and role when he returns. Then the calls roll in, from prospect trade debates and “go get a bat” arguments, to a Mets tangent on Eugenio Suárez vs. giving Mark Vientos one last runway. Hour wraps with Knicks trade chatter and Mikal Bridges’ brutally honest “entitlement” quote as Giannis rumors hang in the background. Time Codes 00:00 — Cashman meets the media, Yankees fans immediately annoyed 01:18 — “Just say it’s similar” vs Cashman over-explaining why they’re different 02:23 — The blunt truth: “They added ONE player” and it feels like the same roster 04:41 — Bigger issue: 15 years, one World Series run, and no Soto replacement 05:15 — Tiki’s counter: Cashman is right, just said it in the worst way 05:55 — The trade deadline as the real “offseason” and why that’s actually unique 07:03 — AL East framing: Blue Jays, Red Sox, and why “track record” matters 10:40 — “Leave no doubt” offseason vs Yankees budgeting, Dodgers standards, and choices 16:24 — Volpe update: “110%” and “deploy properly” sounds like a role change 18:49 — Call: Yankee fan talks trades, Dominguez and Spencer Jones, and patience 24:30 — Call: Mets tangent, Kyle Tucker opt-out mechanics and the Suárez debate 26:12 — Mark Vientos “final stand” season and why a one-year vet could block him 28:05 — Call: Paul Skenes trade fantasy, prospect “forbidden fruit,” and control years 31:17 — The “pied-à-terre” detour and why it turns into a comedy bit 35:42 — Call: Yankees flexibility, then Knicks trade anxiety after a win 40:14 — Mikal Bridges’ “entitlement” quote, being coachable, and trade-rumor pressure 43:16 — Giannis reality check: if it happens, Bridges is likely in the deal

Evan and Tiki start Hour 2 with a stat that confirms what everyone’s been feeling: the NFL playoffs have been called way looser, with penalties, false starts, and especially holding dropping hard compared to the regular season. They debate whether it’s better teams, better discipline, or a league-wide “let them play” emphasis, plus the one-off moments that still ruin it for everyone. From there, the show pivots back to New York, starting with calls on the Yankees and the bigger question of what fans even expected this offseason. The conversation turns into a Monday morning quarterback exercise, including the idea that the one move that could have changed everything was adding a true lockdown bullpen arm. They also hit the ongoing concern: too many “ifs” across the roster, and whether the bullpen is the biggest risk heading into 2026. Then the hour goes full New York chaos: a date-night detour about Rascal Flatts, a quick Mets roster chemistry question, and a deep dive into the real Giannis conversation, not just “can he play,” but can he handle New York. The guys replay Giannis’ famous “failure” press conference exchange and ask the only question that matters if he becomes a Knick: will that mindset survive a brutal city after a playoff loss? Calls roll in on what “the core” even means, which players are truly untouchable, and whether New York fans will ever accept anything but championship or bust.

The crew goes off on the Hall of Fame “leak season” and argues why the NFL should stop the slow drip and just make it a true NFL Honors moment. Then it turns into a full Hall of Fame courtroom: why Bill Belichick didn’t get in (and whether “still coaching” is the real reason), how the voting rules have changed for coaches, contributors, and veterans, and why conspiracy theories pop up the second the process gets murky. Plus, the Giants angle: is Eli Manning a first-ballot lock or a classic “he’ll get in, just not right away” case? The guys go through the finalists list, debate what actually matters now (stats vs. greatness vs. uniqueness), and push back on the loudest anti-Eli arguments. And to close it out, the Knicks get a major piece of outside help as a new report throws real uncertainty into Jayson Tatum’s return timeline, which could flip the entire East playoff picture.

Hour 4 of Evan & Tiki gets wild as a Vikings fan letter sparks a deep dive into a long-forgotten conspiracy theory accusing the Giants of cheating in the 2000 NFC Championship Game. Tiki Barber shuts it down in emphatic fashion, breaking down why the 41-0 blowout was no fluke. Plus, calls on Jets patience, Yankees playoff expectations, Cody Bellinger’s awkward press conference, Knicks trade rumors involving Giannis, Super Bowl QB matchups, and classic Evan & Tiki chaos to close the show.

A listener drops an all time Minnesota classic: Vikings fans swear the Giants “cheated” in the 2000 NFC Championship by tapping into on field communications and knowing every play. The guys react in real time, pull up the old accusation, and then immediately do the obvious thing that ruins the conspiracy. They replay how that 41-0 game actually unfolded, how fast it became a bloodbath, and why “they stole our signals” sounds a lot like what people say when they cannot accept a historic beatdown. Tiki, who was on the team, shuts it down flat and explains why something like that would not stay secret in an NFL locker room. From there, the show pivots right back into New York pain with Jets calls. A fan admits it is getting harder and harder to defend the current direction, but also makes the point that firing coaches nonstop does not magically make the job more appealing. The guys break down the ugly truth: for the Jets, trust is only earned one way, winning, and everything else is just noise.

Is there actual tension brewing between Bo Nix and Sean Payton, or is it just a miscommunication blown up into a storyline? The guys react to the “verbal spat” vibes, Payton joking about Nix’s medical history, and why that kind of honesty might play with fans but can rub a quarterback the wrong way. Then the conversation turns into pure Jets desperation logic. If there’s even a whiff of a QB being unhappy somewhere, Jets fans start drawing up trades on a napkin. Would you take a swing on Bo Nix if the price was somehow reasonable, or is Tiki right that it’s pointless without the coach and infrastructure that made him succeed in the first place? The crew debates the fantasy vs. reality, the “we’ve got nothing to lose” mindset, and why a Denver breakup doesn’t automatically mean a New York solution. And then the Knicks get the kind of outside help that changes a season. A new report adds real uncertainty to Jayson Tatum’s return outlook, which could swing the East race and reshape what a Celtics matchup looks like in the spring.

The guys are sick of “leak season.” Instead of letting the Hall of Fame results trickle out through reports and whispers, they argue the NFL should make it a real moment again, like a true NFL Honors reveal, not the schedule-release-style slow drip that ruins the drama. From there, it turns into the two biggest lightning rods: Bill Belichick and Eli Manning. Why is the Belichick conversation always louder than it needs to be, and is the simplest explanation the real one, that the Hall doesn’t want an active coach getting in? And for Giants fans losing their minds over Eli not being first ballot, the crew tries to cut through the outrage and talk reality: he’s getting in, but the “slam dunk” resume argument is not as clean as people want it to be. It’s a debate about the process, the presentation, and why the NFL keeps stepping on its own big moment.

The Giannis trade chatter keeps building, and this segment hits it from every angle. It starts with Robin Lopez saying Giannis “fits” best with the Miami Heat, which immediately sets off the pushback. Do the Heat really want it more, or is that just Pat Riley mythology? From there, Evan and Tiki reveal they made Giannis trade predictions months ago and decide to keep them sealed until a deal actually happens. Calls pour in and quickly turn the conversation to the Knicks’ real problem: if you’re trading for Giannis, what exactly is “the core” you’re trying to protect? Jalen Brunson is the obvious untouchable, but everything else gets debated, including Josh Hart’s impact on the locker room and how many key pieces you realistically have to give up. Then it becomes the biggest question of all: can Giannis handle New York? The guys break down his famous “failure” press conference moment and argue that the explanation might play in Milwaukee, but it will not fly here. In New York, if you gut the roster for a superstar, the expectation becomes simple: win a championship, or it’s a failure.

Evan and Tiki kick off with the numbers behind what it feels like everyone has noticed: the NFL playoffs have been called looser, with penalties way down and offensive holding dropping dramatically. They debate whether it’s simply better, cleaner teams or a deliberate “let them play” postseason emphasis, plus the rare moments when the whistle suddenly tightens and drives everyone crazy. Then it shifts back to New York sports expectations. A Yankees caller argues that being better on Opening Day actually matters and that Cashman can always patch holes at the deadline. That leads to a bigger discussion about how low the bar has gotten for Yankees fans, what upgrade they actually wanted, and why the bullpen still feels like the shakiest part of the 2026 picture. Finally, the Knicks conversation turns into a full-on Giannis reality check. The guys replay his famous “is this season a failure?” press conference exchange and ask the only question that matters if he lands in New York: can that mindset survive the Knicks’ championship-or-bust pressure, the media, and the fan base after a playoff loss.

Evan and Tiki dive into the idea of “forbidden fruit” trades and what it would actually take for Yankees fans to part with elite young talent in a true blockbuster scenario. The conversation shifts to roster flexibility, prospects earning real opportunities, and why patience still matters more than panic. From there, the focus moves to the Knicks, where recent wins clash with ongoing trade rumors. The guys break down why Mikal Bridges still divides the fan base, how his own comments about coachability and entitlement stood out, and why any serious pursuit of Giannis Antetokounmpo would almost certainly have to include Bridges. A classic Evan and Tiki segment that blends big swings, reality checks, and a few entertaining detours along the way.

Brian Cashman’s update on Anthony Volpe stands out when he says the shortstop will return at “110%” and be “deployed properly.” Evan and Tiki break down what that wording really means, why it could signal a change in how Volpe is handled, and whether the Yankees are finally moving away from force feeding him everyday reps. The discussion spills into roster flexibility, prospect patience, and a few classic Yankees fan trade fantasies.

Brian Cashman met the media and managed to do the one thing Yankee fans knew was coming but still weren’t ready for. He pushed back on the idea that the Yankees are “running the same team back,” and in the process somehow made everyone even angrier. Evan and Tiki break down what Cashman meant versus how he said it, why Gerrit Cole’s return is both obvious and not enough, and how the front office keeps leaning on last year’s trade deadline as proof this team is different. The guys debate whether the Yankees actually improved, or just reframed the same roster with better PR, why the “growing pains” comment made no sense, and how losing Juan Soto still hangs over everything. Is Cashman technically right but emotionally tone deaf, or is this just another case of Yankees fans being sold the same story with new wording? Plus, a deeper look at roster flexibility, young players like Jason Dominguez and Spencer Jones, and why this franchise still refuses to leave “no doubt” heading into Opening Day. Featuring discussion of the New York Yankees, Brian Cashman, Gerrit Cole, Cody Bellinger, Anthony Volpe, and how this all stacks up against division rivals like the Toronto Blue Jays and Boston Red Sox.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): In this episode, Evan Roberts takes a look back to the Edwin Diaz trade between the Mets and the Mariners. Where does it rank within the all-time Mets trades? Carlos Mendoza opens up on how he plans to put together his new bag of toys! Does Evan agree? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Jets sprial into a further mess, the Giants need for an OC takes a turn, and Giannis asks out, sort of.

The Jets hit the reset button again, and the fallout is ugly. With Aaron Glenn firing coaches and still searching for an offensive coordinator, the conversation turns to the wildest report yet: the Jets allegedly offered Jon Gruden a staff role, and the guys think that only happens if Woody Johnson is the one making the call. That sparks the bigger question: is this the setup for Gruden to become the next Jets head coach once the season goes sideways? Hour 1 dives into why the Jets feel like a disaster in the making for 2026: no OC, no QB, and a staff that looks like a collection of “singles to center field” hires. The crew debates whether the franchise should just go full drastic now, or ride out Glenn, embrace the tank, chase the No. 1 pick, and then make the big swing later (Arch Manning dreams included). Plus, a heated caller debate on whether Gruden should ever be hired again, the reality of the Jets’ league-wide reputation, cap space vs dead money, and a potential “path forward” that includes a real play-caller and a quarterback swing like Malik Willis or Teddy Bridgewater. Then it’s a quick pivot to Knicks notes after a win, with Karl-Anthony Towns again sitting late, Clyde calling out the defense, and more questions about crunch-time lineups.

Hour 2 opens with the debut of “Tiki’s Top 5,” as Tiki lays out his preferred Giants offensive coordinator candidates after Todd Monken comes off the board. Matt Nagy sits at the top of the conversation thanks to the Andy Reid connection and play-calling experience, with other names like Kliff Kingsbury, Dave Ragone, Davis Webb, and a young riser in Declan Doyle getting a look. The big theme: Giants fans are ready to trust John Harbaugh no matter what, but the OC choice matters for Jaxson Dart and the direction of the offense. Then the show pivots back to the Jets, who reportedly hire a new defensive coordinator (Brian Duker) after a virtual interview just hours earlier. The guys react to what it says about the organization, how it essentially makes Aaron Glenn the real defensive boss while also trying to survive as head coach, and why Jets fans are spiraling into full-on “Woody meddling” paranoia. From there it turns into a true sports buffet: Giannis trade buzz heats up with Knicks fans debating whether the best move is waiting for the offseason leverage, while the crew rips into the Hall of Fame process after Bill Belichick is not first ballot and Bill Polian claims he is not 100% sure who he voted for. Plus, a classic WFAN flashback featuring Steve Summers going at the lone writer who did not vote for Jacob deGrom, and a hilarious detour into Charlie Weis Jr, Jaxson Dart, and an accidental Mark Wahlberg conspiracy.

The Jets rumor mill hits a new level when reports surface that New York reached out to Jon Gruden, and the crew immediately connects the dots to a bigger, messier question: is this really Aaron Glenn’s show, or is Woody Johnson still lurking with “suggestions” that can shake the whole building? Connor Hughes joins to explain what he’s hearing from inside the organization, why the Jets’ coaching plan has felt scattered, and how quickly a bad start could turn any “big name” hire into instant chaos. Along the way, the conversation digs into how toxic the Jets’ reputation has become around the league, why the staff changes caught people off guard, and why the franchise feels like it’s stuck in a never ending cycle of headlines, embarrassment, and “trust us” messaging. If Gruden turned them down once, does that make it even more likely the Jets come crawling back later, especially if the season goes sideways again? And if the Jets keep operating like this, what does that say about who’s really steering the ship?

Evan & Tiki react to Art Stapleton linking former Jets OC Tanner Engstrand to the New York Giants, debate whether the Jets are officially the NFL’s most dysfunctional franchise, and dive into coaching chaos, quarterback uncertainty, and front office leadership issues. Plus, fiery caller reactions, media feuds involving Joel Sherman, Jets despair at an all-time high, Yankees trade chatter, Mets contract talk, and classic WFAN banter you won’t get anywhere else.

We went back into the archives to see how we actually reacted when Sam Darnold signed with Seattle, and it turns out we barely reacted at all. Instead of breaking down Darnold, we immediately pivoted to what it meant for everyone else. Now that Darnold is in the Super Bowl, we revisit that moment and ask what we missed. Plus, a surprising on-air moment involving Jerry Recco and an open Tampa Bay Buccaneers radio job. Why didn’t Jerry bring it up directly, what the role really entails, and why this might be a bigger opportunity than it sounds. A mix of hindsight, media honesty, and a classic WFAN sidebar that turns into something much more interesting.

A new Giants OC curveball hits when Art Stapleton floats Tanner Engstrand as a legitimate candidate after his Jets exit, citing his coaching ties and the idea that he may have been doomed by the Jets’ quarterback situation. Evan and Tiki debate whether a fresh start with Jaxson Dart could unlock something different, even if Engstrand's first run as a coordinator didn’t exactly inspire confidence. It quickly turns into a bigger point about trusting John Harbaugh, and the hilarious reality that Engstrand becoming competent in New York would only add another chapter to the “Jets ruin everyone” narrative. Then the show takes a sharp left into the station’s internal soap opera as Tommy’s group chat presence, late-night takes, and “who stole whose idea” drama becomes its own mini-segment, complete with receipts and a little friendly sabotage speculation. After that, the Mets portion arrives: Freddy Peralta meets the media and gets asked about an extension, and the crew reads between the lines. The instant “I just got here” framing tells the story, he’s not eager to talk long-term yet, and it doesn’t sound like something that’s happening soon from either side. The segment closes with WFAN audio gold, including the rediscovery of the John Heyman blow-up clip and a new Clyde Frazier drop that instantly earns a spot in the rotation.

Pure Browns dysfunction after Jim Schwartz reportedly tells Cleveland he wants out, creating a ridiculous scenario where candidates were told “you have to keep the DC,” only for the team to hire Todd Monken and suddenly the DC doesn’t even want to stay. Evan and Tiki rip the process as another example of an organization tripping over itself, and Evan admits it almost makes Jets fans feel a tiny bit better knowing there’s another franchise living in the same mess. From there, the conversation spirals into a broader takedown of how “bad organizations stay bad,” plus a quick rant on how meaningless the Pro Bowl has become, before Evan unveils his Top 5 most likely Jets head coaches for Week 1 of 2027, headlined by the nuclear prediction everyone is bracing for: Jon Gruden. Then the show pivots hard into Yankees frustration after Joe Sherman’s rant goes viral and Sean fires back, calling out the “old guard” of baseball writers and the idea that fans with microphones are supposed to apologize for criticizing the team’s spending. The anger keeps rolling when a lifelong Yankees fan calls in and says she’s finally refusing her season tickets after three decades, forcing the crew to walk the tightrope between “the offseason hasn’t impressed” and “this team is still a postseason lock if the core is healthy.”

Evan lays out his blunt read on the Jets reaching out to Jon Gruden: it feels less like a coordinator search and more like a preview of what Woody Johnson might do when Aaron Glenn is gone. To separate paranoia from reality, the show brings in Jets reporter Connor Hughes to explain what he’s hearing inside the building, how “hands off” Woody really is, and why a name like Gruden almost certainly touched ownership at some level. Connor details how the Jets’ staff plan has shifted in real time, why candidates believed the defensive coordinator job was traditional before Aaron Glenn decided he wanted to call plays, and how the process spiraled from big-name interviews into a lesser-known hire with Glenn essentially running the defense. On offense, he explains the original plan to keep Tanner Engstrom in place with a veteran “head coach of the offense,” why firing him complicates things, and why Frank Reich is trending as the likely answer once the required interview process plays out. The bigger takeaway is the one Jets fans can’t escape: the organization is getting mocked league-wide, the timeline to get a staff and quarterback plan in order is shrinking fast, and any Gruden connection is gasoline on a situation that already feels toxic. The segment then pivots to the Giants, where optimism is rising under John Harbaugh and the OC opening is suddenly one of the most attractive springboards in the league. Finally, the show reacts to fresh Browns drama involving Jim Schwartz, adding another dose of “what are they doing?” dysfunction to a day that already has plenty of it.

The show turns into a full sports smorgasbord, starting with the latest Giannis “ready for a new home” reporting and why the timing matters. The conversation breaks down how Giannis’ leverage changes depending on whether a deal happens now or in the offseason, why a team like Detroit could make a move before he can fully steer the destination, and why Knicks fans might actually want this to wait so Giannis can pull the ultimate power move: the “no extension” threat that funnels him toward New York. From there, the discussion pivots to the Bill Belichick Hall of Fame weirdness, the Spygate bitterness lingering behind the scenes, and the most outrageous part of all: a voter claiming he can’t even remember who he voted for. That leads to a classic WFAN flashback on the eternal question of public shaming voters, highlighted by the legendary Steve Summers moment that still makes everyone laugh. The segment wraps with calls on the Giants OC search, why Matt Nagy feels like a clean fit, and an unhinged but hilarious sidebar on Charlie Weis Jr, Jaxson Dart, and the conspiracy theory nobody asked for but everyone will remember.

With Todd Monken officially off the board, Tiki drops a fresh “Top 5” list of preferred Giants offensive coordinator candidates, ranging from familiar names like Matt Nagy and Kliff Kingsbury to intriguing newer options tied to successful coaching trees. The conversation hits what the Giants job actually offers, why play-calling matters, and why the safest endorsement might simply be “whoever John Harbaugh picks.” Then the show gets sideswiped by breaking Jets news that somehow feels even more Jets than usual: New York hires Brian Duker as defensive coordinator after a virtual interview just 21 hours earlier, with the clear implication that Aaron Glenn is essentially taking over the defense himself. The reaction is immediate, equal parts disbelief and dread, as callers torch Woody Johnson, question how any of this qualifies as a plan, and argue the only person who could survive this level of dysfunction is a full power “CEO coach” like Jon Gruden. The segment closes with the larger fear hovering over everything: the Jets’ reputation is so bad that even elite quarterback prospects may steer clear, which turns “hope” into something darker, rooting for the No. 1 pick and praying the next coaching hire finally resets the franchise.

Jets fans hit a new low, so Evan turns to Tiki Barber for the one thing the fanbase is desperate for: an actual path forward. Tiki lays out a realistic short-term blueprint, starting with finding a competent, slightly “down on his luck” offensive mind, then using the Jets’ cap flexibility to take a swing at a real QB plan that doesn’t feel like another doomed lottery ticket. That leads straight into the Malik Willis idea, why he’s viewed differently than Justin Fields, and why a Bridgewater-plus-Willis approach could at least make the offense functional and watchable. From there, the calls light up with the real issue hovering over everything: Jon Gruden. Is he even hirable? Do the Jets need a “CEO coach” to fix the entire operation? And if the Jets are already sniffing around Gruden, does that mean ownership is setting the table for the inevitable move next year? The segment wraps with a brutally honest look at the Jets’ league-wide reputation, the fear that top quarterbacks simply won’t choose New York, and the uncomfortable reality that “hope” might now mean rooting for the No. 1 pick and praying the next coach can finally change the culture.

The Jets blow up their coaching staff, rumors swirl about Jon Gruden, and one uncomfortable conclusion starts to feel unavoidable. After reports that the Jets reached out to Gruden for an offensive role, the discussion turns into a full blown look at who actually made that call, why it almost certainly came from ownership, and what it says about Aaron Glenn’s future. As the Jets drift toward another chaotic season with no coordinator, no quarterback, and no clear direction, the idea takes hold that this is all groundwork for what comes next. A brutal 2026, a desperate franchise, and a coach no one else seems willing to touch. The conversation breaks down why firing Glenn now makes no sense, why bringing Gruden in today could be worse than waiting, and why a year from now Jets fans may finally get exactly what they have been asking for.

The Knicks are in the mix for an MVP once again, Carlos Mendoza acknowledges a truth, and coaching rumors swirl the NFL

Evan unloads a rapid-fire stack of reports that all point to one wild possibility: the Knicks making a real run at Giannis Antetokounmpo before the NBA trade deadline. They dig into the smoke around Giannis potentially leaving Milwaukee, Rich Paul circling, Portland lurking as a multi-team power broker, and the Knicks quietly testing the market on Karl-Anthony Towns. Then the debate gets real: does a Giannis blockbuster raise the ceiling or shrink the window? What does it cost (Bridges, KAT, McBride, swaps), and can the Knicks actually win with chemistry and health risks midseason? Plus, the guys react to fan calls, the idea that Giannis’ personality might play very differently in New York, and a head-scratching Mike Brown moment where he admits he doesn’t even know the upcoming schedule. To close out Hour 1, the conversation swings to Super Bowl talk: Seahawks vs Patriots, why Seattle feels like the better team, and whether New England can keep pulling off wins even if the score doesn’t always look pretty.

Hour 2 opens with a hard look at the Jets’ coaching mess and why firing Aaron Glenn after one year was never going to bring in a top-tier replacement. Evan and Tiki explain how Cleveland’s chaotic search reinforces the idea that some NFL jobs have become flat-out undesirable, and why Glenn blowing up his own staff feels both necessary and desperate. Then the conversation pivots to breaking NFL news as the Bills make a surprise move by promoting Joe Brady to head coach. The guys react to Buffalo passing on bigger names, what it means for Brian Daboll’s future, and why internal hires sometimes signal fear of losing “the next guy” rather than true conviction. The hour wraps with Super Bowl talk, Tiki breaking down ball security and the Peanut Punch, and a chaotic Posting and Toasting segment that spirals into snow-football arguments, old WFAN tweets resurfacing, and a surprisingly heated debate over one question: is it acceptable for a Jets fan to wear a Sam Darnold jersey during Seahawks week?

Hour 3 starts with the Mets, as Carlos Mendoza’s comments on a “corporate” clubhouse reignite the chemistry conversation. The guys break down what Mendoza really admitted, why Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor’s personalities matter when things go bad, and whether leadership has to come from someone other than the highest-paid star. They also hit the idea that locker rooms are messy everywhere, even for “great leaders,” and why David Stearns is about as untouchable as it gets in New York sports. Then it pivots back to the NBA with Ian Begley joining to sort through the Giannis noise, Jrue Holiday rumors, Karl-Anthony Towns tension, and what the Knicks can realistically do with the trade deadline a week away. Begley gives a sober read on whether this roster is truly championship built, what happens if the team sputters before the deadline, and why any Jrue move is likely tied directly to the Giannis chessboard. The hour closes with quick hits: Buffalo’s Joe Brady hiring reshapes the coaching carousel and Brian Daboll’s options, plus a rapid-fire look at what’s next on the sports calendar as deadlines and Super Bowl week collide.

Aaron Judge is officially revealed as the MLB The Show cover athlete for the second time in his career. The guys run through the full history of the game’s cover athletes, react to Judge joining a very short list, and debate whether it means anything at all without another Yankees ring to go with it. Then the show completely veers off the rails with Cinco de Luncho, as Shaun Morash unveils his list of 2026 sports events he already knows he does not care about. Dodgers fatigue, World Baseball Classic arguments, Rangers post Olympic apathy, World Cup rooting rules, and Lindsey Vonn Olympic promos all turn into rapid fire arguments that only escalate as the list goes on. The hour keeps rolling with callers weighing in on Mets clubhouse chemistry, Lindor and Soto leadership dynamics, Idiots With Idioms callbacks, Patriots fans defending their Super Bowl path, and a deeper conversation about Sam Darnold, Seattle’s rise, and why so many preseason takes aged poorly. It is a classic Evan and Tiki final hour where baseball, basketball, football, lists, and nonsense all collide at once.

Cinco de Luncho kicks off in full chaos as Shaun Morash takes over and rolls out his list of 2026 sports events he already knows he does not care about. From total Dodgers fatigue to World Baseball Classic apathy, Rangers post Olympic burnout, and a World Cup take that lights the room on fire, the list instantly turns into a loud, hilarious argument about what actually matters and what is just being jammed down everyone’s throat. The segment then bleeds into callers, Mets clubhouse leadership debates, Idiots With Idioms callbacks, and Patriots fans pushing back on the “easy path” Super Bowl narrative. It is classic Evan and Tiki madness where lists spiral, egos get bruised, and absolutely nothing stays on the rails.

With the trade deadline nine days away, Ian Begley joins to cut through the noise on the Giannis chatter and what it really means for the Knicks. Begley explains why Milwaukee is still more likely to wait until the offseason, but teams are doing their homework now in case Giannis decides he is ready to be “the bad guy” and ask out. The guys dig into why Jrue Holiday rumors keep getting tied to the Knicks, not as a standalone move, but as a way to make a Giannis pitch more attractive if a bidding war forms. They also tackle the uncomfortable Karl-Anthony Towns conversation, with Begley acknowledging the comments and body language are not nothing, even if it is unclear how deep the issue runs. Begley then gives a blunt answer on the biggest question for Knicks fans: is this roster built to win a title as it is? His view is no, even while admitting the postseason can flip narratives fast. Finally, they get into the practical side of a deadline move, what the Knicks can realistically offer, why certain rotation pieces are hard to move, and how any big swing would have to account for the center situation and Mike Brown’s preferred style.

The phones take over with everything from Super Bowl skepticism to full-blown life advice. A caller argues the Patriots had one of the easiest paths ever to the Super Bowl, but Evan and Tiki make the point that banners do not come with footnotes. Win the game and history does not care how you got there. Then the conversation takes a hard left into one of the most relatable debates of all. Should you ever meet your heroes? From a heartfelt Sam Darnold encounter story to Evan’s painfully awkward run-ins with Carrie Underwood and Kurt Angle, the segment spirals into a hilarious breakdown of why admiration is safer from a distance. The takeaway is simple. Players and celebrities are human, fans are weird, and sometimes the best move is saying nothing at all.

With Opening Day creeping closer, the Mets’ clubhouse chemistry is back under the microscope after Carlos Mendoza’s comments on the Heyman and Sherman pod. Asked if there were issues last year, Mendoza starts with “yeah,” then explains what he really means: the room was professional, respectful, and at times way too “corporate,” without enough celebrating or looseness when things got tough. The guys connect that to the dynamic between Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor, two stars with totally different personalities. Soto is all business, Lindor is the constant energy guy, and that contrast can be fine when you are winning, but tricky when the season gets stressful. They also zoom out to a bigger point about locker rooms: even “great leaders” can have messy relationships, and plenty of winning teams keep everything quiet, which is why we rarely hear these stories until someone finally says the quiet part out loud.

Breaking news hits in real time as the Bills make a surprise coaching hire, promoting OC Joe Brady instead of going outside the building for a bigger name like Brian Daboll. The guys react to what it says about Buffalo’s interview list, what it could mean for Daboll’s next move, and why teams sometimes promote from within out of fear of losing “their guy.” Then Posting and Toasting takes over: old coworker tweets get exposed, the snow-football debate reignites, and the conversation spirals into a very specific New York sports question. If you’re a Jets fan, can you wear a Sam Darnold jersey during Seahawks week, or is that crossing the line?

Evan explains why most Jets fans wanting Aaron Glenn fired sounds logical on the surface, but completely ignores reality. The big-name coaches fans dreamed about were never coming, and Cleveland’s messy search proves just how toxic certain NFL jobs have become. The conversation dives into Glenn blowing up his own staff, why that signals both accountability and inexperience, and how the Jets are stuck without the relationships, quarterback, or organizational respect needed to attract top coaching talent. The segment closes with a sobering truth for Jets fans: the only real path forward might be painful losing, draft capital, and finally finding a quarterback who can build the bridge this franchise desperately lacks.

The guys dig into the uncomfortable question nobody wants to ignore: would Giannis actually survive New York? From his defensive postgame press conferences in Milwaukee to the recent fan booing incident, they explain why that behavior might fly with the Bucks but would explode instantly at Madison Square Garden. Evan and Tiki debate the mercenary reality of New York sports, the brutal expectations that come with it, and why winning immediately would be Giannis’ only protection. The conversation then spills into Knicks roster fit, Karl-Anthony Towns trade value, Mike Brown’s eyebrow-raising schedule comments, and a spirited Super Bowl breakdown with Seahawks-Patriots predictions from callers.

Evan lays out every major report from the last 48 hours and asks the big question Knicks fans cannot avoid anymore: is a Giannis Antetokounmpo trade actually happening? From Milwaukee’s growing acceptance that a split may be coming, to Rich Paul circling, Portland lurking in a multi team deal, and the Knicks quietly testing the Karl Anthony Towns market, the smoke is everywhere. The guys debate whether the Knicks should pull the trigger before the deadline, what it would cost, how it impacts chemistry and health, and whether this move raises the ceiling or slams the championship window shut.

WFAN hosts are erupting over former Jets quarterback Sam Darnold reaching the Super Bowl, sparking a heated debate on whether his success serves as the ultimate proof of the Jets' organizational failure

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets take a chance on Craig Kimbrel. Evan dives into the Mets backup plan. Plus, we read through all of your emails regarding your Freddy Peralta reactions. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan, Tiki, and Shaun unpack a jam-packed Championship Monday that spirals from weather chaos to franchise regret. The show opens with the AFC Championship turning into a snow-covered throwback and whether that kind of football should decide a title. From there, the guys debate Sean Payton’s 4th down decision, Sam Darnold reaching the Super Bowl, and which franchises should feel the most pain. The Steelers shock the league by breaking decades of tradition with a Mike McCarthy hire, igniting Aaron Rodgers speculation and questions about the future of coaching stability. Along the way, the Pro Bowl loses all remaining credibility, MLB drops a bizarre video game announcement, and Jets fans descend into full existential dread while the Patriots once again seem to benefit from the football gods. Timestamps: 00:00 – Championship Sunday chaos, snow football, and whether weather should decide titles 21:00 – Sean Payton’s 4th down decision and how the game flipped 44:00 – Sam Darnold to the Super Bowl and ranking which teams regret him most 1:18:00 – Cinco de Luncho: Sam Darnold regret list sparks Jets vs Vikings war 1:58:00 – Steelers hire Mike McCarthy and completely abandon their historic model 2:32:00 – Aaron Rodgers futures, Vikings buzz, and who actually has a quarterback 3:05:00 – Pro Bowl outrage, MLB The Show cover mystery, Jets misery, and why the Patriots always get the breaks

Evan can’t stop thinking about the AFC Championship turning into a full-blown snow game, and the guys debate whether the weather made it legendary or ruined the product. They break down how the Patriots benefitted once they had the lead, why the second half felt like 1960s football, and whether every stadium should just have a retractable roof. Plus, the Sean Payton decision that changed everything, going for it on 4th-and-1 instead of taking the points, and what a different QB might have meant once the conditions got ugly. Calls roll in, the poll is basically split down the middle, and yes, Evan discovers the meaning of “5280” on the Broncos helmets.

Evan, Tiki, and Shaun dive into the complicated emotions of watching Sam Darnold reach the Super Bowl and what it does, and does not, say about the Jets. The argument heats up over whether this is more embarrassing than the Saquon situation, and Evan takes an L after realizing “I see ghosts” is back in the conversation. They also debate the fine line between aggression and stupidity on big decisions, pivot to the Rams-Seahawks coaching choices, and give Tom Brady his flowers as an analyst while still calling out the hypocrisy. Plus, the viral preseason graphic that “predicted” Darnold vs Drake Maye, Spencer Roberts makes a chaotic cameo, and the hour wraps with calls, Jets coordinator chatter, and a tease of Giants and Mets drama.

The Jets are preparing to move play-calling away from Tanner Engstrand, and Evan and Tiki react to the idea of adding a veteran voice, with Frank Reich suddenly in the mix. They debate what it says about Aaron Glenn, whether the Jets are shopping for true “best and brightest” hires, and why experience might matter if Glenn is on thin ice. The hour also swings to the Giants hiring Denard Wilson, then back into the never-ending weather debate and a call from Colorado that claims the blizzard timing was predictable. Cinco de Luncho turns into a full argument as Shaun ranks the teams with the biggest Sam Darnold regrets, sparking a Jets vs Vikings vs Giants fight. Plus, the show closes with the strange SNY Mets director situation, rumors, and why it’s smarter for everyone to step back until real facts come out.

Evan and Tiki react to the Steelers making a stunning pivot, hiring Mike McCarthy and ending the franchise’s decades-long tradition of young, defensive-minded lifers. They debate what it means for the Rooney family, whether this signals a new era in coaching philosophy, and how the quarterback dominoes could lead to Aaron Rodgers following the Favre script to Minnesota. Then the show takes a hard turn into pure insanity as the Pro Bowl somehow adds Shedeur Sanders, sparking a rant about how meaningless the “Pro Bowler” label has become. Calls roll in on officiating, the need for tech like a chipped football, and why the NFL never adjusts kickoff times even when weather is predictable. Evan also hits a quick baseball note with Harrison Bader landing in San Francisco, before the hour closes with a full Jets fan meltdown, a Mike McCarthy hiring regret spiral, and the ultimate coping mechanism: the only explanation is that God is a Patriots fan. Plus, a last-second cameo from the Roberts household to cap it all off.

Quick baseball free agency follows with Harrison Bader landing a two-year deal with the Giants. Then the phones light up with Giants roster-building talk, including a fan playing GM and pushing for a big move on the offensive line. A wild wrinkle comes from a caller with a meteorologist connection who says Belichick used to seek ultra-specific forecasts, which sparks more debate about how much coaches should know about incoming weather. The hour swings back to Jets pain as callers re-litigate the Sam Darnold alternate history, and it ends with a full tilt spiral: why the Jets chose Adam Gase over Mike McCarthy, why it still makes fans sick, and the only logical explanation for the Patriots always getting the breaks. Plus, a quick cameo from Jet to sign off and get a verdict on the new background.

The Steelers stun the league by hiring 62-year-old Mike McCarthy, a total departure from Pittsburgh’s decades-long model of young, defensive-minded lifers. Evan and Tiki debate what it says about a shifting NFL philosophy, how long McCarthy realistically lasts, and the bigger question that decides everything: who is the quarterback? That conversation quickly turns into Aaron Rodgers speculation, with the guys reading the tea leaves on a Vikings pivot and why Pittsburgh feels like it needs a “Jets-style” veteran swing. Calls follow on parity in today’s NFL, coaching candidates, and the absurdity of “scripted” theories, before breaking news detonates the segment: Shedeur Sanders gets added to the Pro Bowl roster, prompting a rant about how meaningless the Pro Bowl label has become. They wrap with a debate on officiating, replay, and why the league still won’t fully commit to technology like a chipped football to eliminate the biggest spot-of-the-ball controversies.

A listener pitches a wild idea: split the NFL into “good weather” and “bad weather” conferences so championship games aren’t decided by teams caught in conditions they never play in. Evan and Tiki debate it, Shaun hates it, and the conversation turns into a dome vs rivalry argument in a hurry. Then Cinco de Luncho pours gasoline on the Sam Darnold discourse with a ranked list of the teams that should be sick over letting him go, sparking a Jets vs Vikings fight that refuses to die. Later, callers weigh in on the Patriots’ road and whether the NFL should have adjusted kickoff time knowing the storm was coming. The segment closes with a strange Mets broadcast story as “creative differences” turns into a weekend of rumors, and the guys agree the smartest move is to step back until actual facts come out.

The Jets are already signaling a major change for 2026, with Tanner Engstrand not expected to call plays and Frank Reich emerging as a veteran option to stabilize Aaron Glenn. Evan and Tiki debate whether Reich is a solid move or just another safe hire, and what it says about the Jets hunting for experience over upside. Then the phones light up with more Sam Darnold regret arguments, including why QB mistakes hit harder than the Saquon situation and how the Giants’ draft decisions still haunt them. The hour takes a sharp turn into baseball and New York sports hierarchy as Anthony Rizzo introduces Aaron Judge as the “King of New York,” reigniting the Judge vs Jalen Brunson debate. Plus, the Knicks win again, and the guys tease a hilarious Ryan Ruocco moment that got way dirtier than anyone expected.

Evan opens up about a very real debate at home over doing the show from the house, then the conversation takes a hard left into a viral graphic that has people claiming the NFL “told us” back in September it would be Drake Maye vs Sam Darnold. The guys laugh through the conspiracy, point out the other names hidden in the image, and then get right back into the AFC Championship aftermath as callers rip Sean Payton’s decision-making and the play call that helped sink Denver. The segment also hits the weather angle, how the Patriots approached the second half, and whether the “cover up” sounded worse than the original decision. Plus, Spence pops in with a prediction, more calls roll in, and the hour tees up Jets and Giants coordinator news and a strange Mets producer story.

Evan, Tiki, and Shaun unpack the complicated emotions Jets fans are feeling as Sam Darnold reaches the Super Bowl. Is this actually embarrassing for the Jets, or is that blame misplaced? The guys debate why this situation feels very different from Saquon Barkley, why the Vikings deserve more criticism than the Jets, and how environment and timing shaped Darnold’s career arc. They also react to Shaun doubling down on his take, revisit the “I see ghosts” moment resurfacing in real time, and explore how Darnold’s maturity and multiple stops helped unlock the quarterback he is now. Plus, a deeper discussion on quarterback narratives, breaking the mold of how Super Bowl QBs are supposed to emerge, and why this run defies everything we think we know.

The moment that flipped the game. Sean Payton’s 4th down decision near the goal line looms large as the Broncos never score again. Evan, Tiki, and Sean react to Payton’s explanation, dissect the play call, and debate whether aggression made sense with a backup quarterback and points at a premium. Listener calls weigh in on old-school football, weather chaos, and whether that 4th down choice still looks defensible once the snow took over.

The AFC Championship turned into a full-on weather event, and Evan and Tiki debate whether that chaos made the game unforgettable or completely unwatchable. They break down how the Patriots benefitted once they had the lead, why the second half felt like 1960s football, and whether weather should ever decide a championship. Plus, the poll that perfectly split the audience, the contrast with a beautifully played NFC title game, and the bigger question looming over the NFL. Did the snow make this game legendary, or did it ruin real football?

Hear from John Harbaugh, Joe Schoen (17:54), and Pat Leonard of the New York Daily News (32:42) on another eventful week for the New York Giants.

Evan & Tiki talk about rooting for Sam Darnold and how things could have panned out differently in New York for him. Plus, Evan wonders what would have happened if the Jets drafted Josh Allen instead (18:41); Craig on the possibility of Lamar Jackson on the Jets (39:53), and a caller asks Craig if he has inside info on defensive coordinators who refused to interview with the Jets (46:54).

This week's Yankees highlights are all about Cody Bellinger, as the Yanks finally signed their top offseason target. Evan and Tiki give their instant reactions, while Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the contract and debate if Bellinger was worth the price.

The Mets have completely turned their offseason around with a busy week. Boomer and Gio react to the blockbuster Freddy Peralta trade and how fans have changed their tone on David Stearns, while Craig Carton rips any fans who still don't like the offseason. Plus, Evan Roberts reveals his concerns about the deal, and reacts to the Luis Robert Jr. trade.

Boomer & Gio give their first impressions of John Harbaugh following his introductory press conference. Plus, Craig Carton and C-Mac debate if the Harbaugh excitement is overblown (14:50); Evan & Tiki interview Harbaugh (36:47), and ponder if Rex Ryan could join his staff (54:41); Boomer & Gio also discuss potential coordinators and coaching staff (1:19:09).

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): David Stearns has had quite an off-season. From Mets fans screaming bloody murder for trading away fan favorites and losing others in free agency. Has this week completely changed your feelings? Let's hear what David Stearns has to say, maybe that will make us feel great about the direction of this team. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Championship weekend in the NFL. Should Ben Johnson have went for 2? Boomer feels bad for Bo Nix and Josh Allen. Mcdermott's exit from Buffalo. Catch or interception in Broncos Bills game? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Sam Darnold is a win away from the Super Bowl, does this make the Jets look even worse? Our picks for Sunday, thought's on snow, and much more

Sam Darnold is one win from the Super Bowl, and Jets fans have no idea what to do with themselves. On one hand, they still like Sam and want to see him succeed. On the other, they can already feel what’s coming next: two straight weeks of “LOL Jets” takes if Seattle punches the ticket. The guys relive the Jets era, the “seeing ghosts” moment that became a defining label, and the decision to move on for Zach Wilson. They debate alternate history: what if the Jets kept Darnold, traded back, and built the roster right? Plus, how much credit does Sam deserve for Seattle’s run, and why this feels even more brutal than watching Saquon win with the Eagles. Also: the poll results, and which fan base actually has it worse.

Sean Payton drops a line that sounds like a sneaky guarantee, and the guys argue if it counts. A new poll update pours gasoline on the Jets vs Giants embarrassment debate. Fernando Mendoza’s interview sparks a surprisingly heated Apple Maps vs Google Maps argument. Plus, Giants fans get a letter from John Harbaugh, and the staff overhaul begins with early reports on who’s staying and who’s gone.

Hour 3 gets loud, even when the voice stays calm. The guys react to Dolphins DC Anthony Weaver’s intense, old school defensive mindset and why his Harbaugh ties and resume make him a real Giants candidate, whether as a coordinator or a head coach. Then it turns into a full-on snowstorm debate after a viral tweet sparks a weather war, plus a classic caller joke that actually lands. Finally, the Patriots title game drought gets the Cinco de Luncho treatment, and the conversation veers into Super Bowl memories, controversy fatigue, and why fans never shut up about old calls.

Evan & Tiki react to an unbelievable Giants draft story where a top prospect literally slept through meetings — and still got picked. Plus: Giants culture under Harbaugh, Philly fans losing their minds over the Mets, snow chaos, NFL Championship picks, and classic WFAN banter that goes completely off the rails.

The guys circle back to an emailed question they missed and finally explain the Cody Bellinger contract debate. If the Mets offered Kyle Tucker four years and $160M, why not offer Bellinger the same? The answer comes down to age, value, and how the Mets view Tucker compared to Bellinger, plus the sense that Bellinger’s market was basically the Yankees. Then it’s time for the weekly highlight reel: “Idiots With Idioms,” where everyone gets roasted for mangling phrases, mixing metaphors, and inventing brand new sayings on live radio. Add in storm chatter affecting schedules and travel, and the hour closes with Championship Sunday picks and updated playoff standings, including the big debates around Patriots at Broncos and Rams at Seahawks.

The guys react to a wild behind the scenes Giants draft story as Cam Skattebo admits he showed up late to a team visit, thought he torched his chances, and then got the call anyway. It turns into a bigger conversation about how teams weigh “red flags” versus pure talent, and why the Giants deserve credit for not overthinking it. Then the show swings back into snowstorm chaos. A caller checks in from a Target parking lot, Tiki talks about having the keys to the Giants facility for life, and a mailman calls in to deliver the ultimate reality check on why snow is not a cute little snowman moment when you have to work through it. The back and forth spirals into a funny debate about hypocrisy, selfishness, and why everybody loves weather right up until it costs them something.

Cinco de Luncho hijacks the hour as the guys try to prove it has been a lifetime since the Patriots were in a title game, using five perfect time capsules from the sports and real world timeline. From the misery of that Patriots Rams Super Bowl to the never ending argument about which controversial calls actually follow a Super Bowl around, the conversation turns into a full debate about what fans remember, what they pretend to forget, and why Bills fans always keep receipts. Then the calls fire up. Giants fans react to a surprising offensive line coaching shakeup, and the show dives into how much trust John Harbaugh gets in the early honeymoon phase. The hour closes with Buffalo drama, Josh Allen tape breakdowns, and a hilarious detour into a 25 year old snow shovel that somehow becomes the most relatable take of the day.

The guys debate how teams should handle first-round busts, comparing the Giants’ situation with Deontay Banks to the Yankees once rethinking Giancarlo Stanton. Is it smarter to cut ties, or squeeze value out of what a player can still do? Then things heat up with Jets fans reliving their quarterback misery as Sam Darnold discourse spirals into regret, blame, and social media fights, plus why comparisons to Saquon Barkley still hit a nerve. And just when you think it can’t get more chaotic, a viral snowstorm take ignites a full-blown war over shoveling, kids playing outside, selfish weather joy, and one perfectly timed snow blower joke that somehow brings everyone back together.

A Giants season ticket holder letter from John Harbaugh hits the inbox and instantly becomes a conversation starter. The message is classic new-coach energy: honor the tradition, promise toughness, preach culture, and tell the fans they’re going to get the football they deserve. It’s equal parts inspiring and perfectly timed. The guys debate what these kinds of letters actually mean, how jaded Giants fans should feel after years of frustration, and why the “everyone loves it” factor can sometimes be a red flag in sports. But they also make the case that a proven Super Bowl winning head coach is as close to a sure thing as the Giants can get, because a coach doesn’t forget how to coach. It ends with the best summary possible: enjoy the honeymoon, then show us on Sundays.

Dan Orlovsky dropped a scorching hot take after Texans vs Patriots, saying Houston wins that game with “31 other quarterbacks” instead of C.J. Stroud. The guys actually debate it, build the list, argue over what Orlovsky really meant, and land on the real truth: the number might be insane, but the point isn’t. From there it turns into a full-on quarterback philosophy fight. Would Justin Fields win that game with a safer game plan? How much of it was Stroud’s turnovers vs the Patriots capitalizing in bad conditions? And if it “wasn’t going to take much,” why didn’t Houston consider going to Davis Mills at any point? They also hit the bigger takeaway: apologizing for a sports take like that is ridiculous, especially when the core point is pretty close to true.

The conversation takes a dark turn for Jets fans: even if they drafted Josh Allen, would it have mattered, or would the Jets have broken him too? The guys dig into how much quarterback development is about the organization, coaching, and timing, using Darnold’s journey as the prime example. Then the calls roll in. One caller argues the bigger joke might actually be on the Vikings for moving on from Darnold and tying their future to J.J. McCarthy. Another says Jets fans should stop living in regret because Darnold never becomes this player if he stays in New York. Plus: the “Ghostbuster” debate if Darnold faces the Patriots, a poll comparing Jets pain to Giants fans watching Saquon win with the Eagles, and a quick Nets tangent that somehow turns into a real conversation about player development.

A Jets fan dilemma: Sam Darnold is one win from the Super Bowl, and the fan base is split between rooting for a guy they still like and bracing for the avalanche of “LOL Jets” takes that would follow. The guys revisit how the Jets handled Darnold, how the “seeing ghosts” moment became a career-defining label, and why moving on for Zach Wilson still feels like the franchise’s biggest sliding doors decision. They also debate how much credit Darnold deserves for Seattle’s success, why Jets fans fear two weeks of nonstop relitigating, and whether this would be more embarrassing than Giants fans watching Saquon win it all in Philly. Plus, the poll question that could start an all-out NY fan war.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat, we hardly knew you. But to get a top of the line starting pitcher in Freddy Peralta it's worth it. The Mets also get back Tobias Myers. Is this the final stamp Mets fans have been waiting for this offseason? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan isn't in love with the Mets big trade for Peralta, callers react, a look ahead to Championship Sunday, plus a Giant reshaping.

Evan isn’t screaming, he’s just being honest: he did not celebrate the Freddy Peralta trade. Yes, the Mets are better right now and the rotation finally looks legit, but Evan’s main fear is simple: this feels like a one-year rental, and they paid two top-100 prospects (Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat) to do it. That sparks the real debate for Mets fans: what result makes a rental worth it, World Series or bust? Plus, Mets fans flood the phones to defend the move, rip the move, and argue whether Stearns and Cohen are building a sustainable plan or living year to year. And Evan delivers a classic story from MSG, including the rough night as a Nets dad and the even tougher conversation explaining to his son why “Jet” is suddenly no longer a Mets prospect.

Hour 2 starts with the crew wrapping up their MLB Free Agency Bingo board, with only one final name left on the list and plenty of laughs at who nailed predictions like Cody Bellinger and who completely whiffed. Then the conversation shifts into the big-picture question: what do Vegas win totals say about the Yankees and Mets right now, and do those numbers match reality? Evan explains why he would have been far more comfortable paying a premium for an elite like Tarik Skubal than a “really good” Freddy Peralta, and why the “five-inning pitcher” label matters when you are giving up top prospects. Calls pour in debating whether the Mets should push Peralta deeper into games, whether an extension is actually possible, and whether this whole plan is a smart year-to-year build or just living on rentals. Plus: a wild Jets caller tries to “grease the wheels” for a Josh Allen fantasy, the guys roast the sad state of Jets fandom, and a fan checks in with life updates that send the show down an unexpectedly funny path. And to close the hour, the crew dives into pronunciation chaos, including a pitcher clarifying how to actually say his name, and a Drury joke that deserved better timing.

Hour 3 opens with Evan owning his “Nets shocked the world” slip, plus a full recap of the quickest 6–4 hope in sports history as he takes his five-year-old to MSG and watches the Knicks turn it into a crime scene. Then the guys debate whether Tommy is officially a group chat squatter and if the crew should quietly boot him at the perfect time. From there, it’s real Giants business: the organization starts clearing out long-time staffers as John Harbaugh puts his stamp on the building, with Tiki explaining how those behind-the-scenes changes actually work and why some “family” staples may not survive this new era. Then the moment of the hour: Andrew Caplan’s audio package that proves John Harbaugh and Joe Biden are voice doppelgangers. Once you hear it back-to-back, you cannot unhear it. Plus: Mets fans call in with the perfect word for this offseason, confusion, as the “hope mode” roster debate rages on. And the hour closes with pure Cinco de Lunch chaos as the crew fires off their top five New York starting pitchers lists and immediately starts a civil war over where Peralta, McClain, Rodon, Cole, and the new Yankees arms belong.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with baseball, football, and classic New York sports banter. Evan and Tiki react to a whirlwind MLB offseason, including the Mets’ aggressive moves for Freddy Peralta, Luis Robert Jr., and Bo Bichette, and debate whether Peralta is a risky rental or a long-term building block. The Yankees’ decision to retain Cody Bellinger sparks further discussion about roster construction and championship expectations in a Dodgers-dominated league.

The crew opens with a big-picture baseball thought experiment: MLB should invent “Fugazi deadlines” to turn the offseason into a fast, chaotic sprint, because the last week has felt like an NFL-style frenzy. The Mets’ entire winter gets compressed into a handful of headlines, from missing on Kyle Tucker to landing Luis Robert Jr. and adding Freddy Peralta, plus the value of getting a controllable arm like Tobias Myers as part of the bigger move. Then the conversation shifts into the real Mets fan experience right now: confusion, nerves, and a growing divide. One side sees the Peralta trade as an obvious upgrade. The other sees a potential rental that cost two top prospects, and says if you do that, you better be serious about keeping him. From there, it becomes a full debate about how “rentals” actually work, with a Mike Piazza comparison, plus the bigger question hanging over everything: can anyone realistically beat the Dodgers. The answer is complicated. The Dodgers might be the best team, but baseball still gives you a shot if you catch the right breaks and play clean, because you cannot afford a single slip against a team that deep.

Championship Sunday can’t get here fast enough, and this segment sets the table with a wild, history-flavored nugget: the Broncos are massive home underdogs in a conference title game, a point spread that almost never happens. The crew digs into recent championship games where the home team still got points, including the Nick Foles Eagles and the Peyton Manning Broncos, then lands on the rare example where the home dog actually lost in a tight one. From there, it turns into full sports-radio paranoia: is this a Patriots coronation, or can Denver’s altitude, coaching, and a competent Jarrett Stidham performance flip the script. The conversation spirals into what a Stidham win would do to the QB market and whether quarterback-desperate teams would start talking themselves into it by Monday morning. Then the segment swerves into pure show chaos with Cinco de Luncho, featuring a rapid-fire Top 5 starting pitchers in New York and an immediate counter-list that turns into a debate about respect, projection, and whose “ace” is really built for the moment. It wraps with a quick tease that a weird streak ended during Knicks-Nets that’s supposedly going to blow your mind.

Listeners noticed it first. Social media confirmed it. And once you hear it, you can never unhear it. The show takes a deep dive into one of the strangest and funniest discoveries of the week: New York Giants head coach John Harbaugh sounds eerily similar to former President Joe Biden. This segment features a carefully produced audio package putting their voices back to back, proving beyond any doubt that they are true voice doppelgängers. No politics, no agendas, just an uncanny comparison that leaves everyone confused, laughing, and questioning who they are actually listening to. The crew reacts in real time, explains how the comparison came together, and breaks down why this might be the most undeniable audio similarity you will hear all year. Once it clicks, it is ingrained forever.

Just days after his introductory press conference, John Harbaugh is already making meaningful organizational changes behind the scenes. Longtime Giants executive Kevin Abrams is out after decades with the team, signaling that familiar names and long standing roles are no longer untouchable. The conversation also highlights the continued presence of Ronnie Barnes, whose role may evolve but whose influence inside the building remains strong. The discussion centers on why these moves matter, how they connect to broader power structure questions involving Joe Shane, and why this level of internal change shows Harbaugh is fully in charge and committed to building a Giants organization that reflects his vision from top to bottom.

The conversation shifts from vibes to numbers as Vegas steps in. Using FanDuel win totals, the guys break down how the Mets and Yankees are actually being viewed heading into the season and the results are eye-opening. The Yankees are still favorites in the American League despite a quiet offseason, while the Mets are suddenly sitting right behind the Dodgers as one of the top teams in the National League. That leads to a deeper debate about roster construction and expectations. Why the Mets trading for Freddy Peralta was a necessity, not a luxury. Why the Yankees passing on him made sense given their rotation depth. And why David Stearns may be closer to finishing his “painting” than fans want to admit. Calls pour in arguing whether a 90-win projection is fair, whether Peralta should be pushed deeper into games, and whether an extension changes everything. Plus, the crew reacts to how tightly bunched the NL really is behind the Dodgers and asks the question Mets fans cannot avoid anymore: if Vegas believes this team is real, do you?

It’s late January, almost every MLB domino has fallen, and the crew pulls out the Free Agency Bingo board to see who actually knew what they were talking about. They relive the Cody Bellinger call, admit who got played, and set the stage for the final remaining free agent while arguing about whether trades should even count in the game. Then Evan doubles down on the biggest Mets debate: why paying a premium for “really good” Freddy Peralta is not the same as paying up for a true monster like Tarik Skubal. The “five-inning pitcher” label gets thrown on the table, the Peralta vs Skubal comparison heats up, and the Mets’ long-term plan gets questioned again. Plus, the phones go sideways. A Jets caller tries to “grease the wheels” for a Josh Allen trade fantasy, the guys roast how dark it has gotten for Jets fans, and a caller checks in with a life update, a joke, and a Mets reality check that turns into a full-blown offseason therapy session.

The guys boil the Freddy Peralta trade down to one core issue: the Mets improved immediately, but it still feels like a short-term roster with short-term bets. If Peralta is a one-year rental and anything goes sideways, the whole thing can feel like a “temporary Picasso” that gets ruined the second it gets wet. Then the phones light up. One caller thinks the Mets changed philosophy because of media pressure, but Evan pushes back hard and says the front office has actually been consistent all along. That leads into the bigger theme: the Mets’ approach to short-term deals, what Bo Bichette’s press conference really told you about the plan, and why fans keep asking what “good enough” is when you cash in top prospects. Plus: a debate over the “roadblock” narrative with Jett Williams, what happens if Luis Robert Jr struggles early, and how quickly the Mets would pivot if performance is not there. And it ends with a hard pivot to hoops: the Knicks annihilate the Nets, the “players-only meeting” story gets dissected through Josh Hart’s comments, and the real question becomes what the Knicks do next, not what they did to Brooklyn.

Evan makes one thing clear right away: he does not hate the move, but he is not celebrating either. The Mets are undeniably better after adding Freddy Peralta, and the rotation finally looks respectable. The problem is the price. Two top-100 prospects for a pitcher Evan believes is a one-year rental based on the track record of David Stearns. That sparks a deeper conversation about what the Mets are actually building under Stearns and Steve Cohen. Is this a smart year-to-year strategy, or a risky way to live as a fan? Evan lays out why a rental only works if it leads to a World Series run, compares the move to past Mets rentals, and asks fans the real question: what result makes this trade worth it? Plus, a hilarious and painfully real dad moment from Madison Square Garden, where Evan has to explain to his kids both Nets misery and why Jet Williams is suddenly no longer a Mets prospect.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): It finally has happened. The New York Mets have made a trade with the White Sox for center fielder Luis Robert Jr. The Cost? Luisangel Acuna & Truman Pauly. The question at hand now, what took so long? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

A day full of baseball news including a Mets trade and a breaking Yankee re signing we have been waiting for

The Mets finally pull the trigger on the move they’ve been circling for what feels like forever, landing Luis Robert Jr. and immediately reshaping the conversation around their lineup. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down why the deal makes sense even with the obvious red flags: recent struggles, durability concerns, and the price tag. They debate the upside of a true change of scenery in New York, what Robert’s defense means for a team that badly needed real center field stability, and why this is a low risk swing with potentially massive reward. Plus, the ripple effect: where does this leave the Mets in the Cody Bellinger chase, and why Yankees fans might be feeling more confident today than they did yesterday as the staredown with Scott Boras continues. The hour also touches on growing buzz around the Giants, adding another major New York storyline to a packed opening segment.

The hour centers on what comes next for the Giants now that John Harbaugh is in place, with the spotlight firmly on coordinator hires and staff building. The guys react to Harbaugh’s comments about Rex Ryan, debate how realistic a return to the sideline would be after a decade away, and whether Harbaugh’s presence changes that equation. From there, it turns into a full breakdown of ideal coordinator fits, including why Harbaugh’s credibility gives the Giants access to top tier candidates. Names like Todd Monken, Anthony Weaver, Jim Leonhard, and Antonio Pierce come up as the discussion shifts to scheme, quarterback development, and long term vision. Jets fans also get pulled into the conversation, especially around potential crossover candidates and rivalry tension, as callers weigh in on what a successful Giants staff could look like and why these decisions may define the entire era.

Big Mac storms in with a brutal comp, calling the Mets’ Luis Robert Jr. trade the “Anthony Volpi” of moves, and the debate takes off from there. Why are Mets fans still fighting over the offseason, while Yankees fans are somehow… calm? The crew breaks down what the Robert Jr. deal signals about Cody Bellinger, why the Yankees’ quiet winter has fans stuck in limbo, and why one announcement could flip the entire New York baseball mood overnight. Then it pivots hard to the Knicks, and the questions get louder: effort, energy, body language, and whether this looks like a team drifting from its coach. From Josh Hart’s late-night TV appearance to the bigger issue of urgency, chemistry, and buy-in, the conversation turns into a real temperature check with CP “The Franchise” on what’s actually happening and what (if anything) can fix it fast before things get ugly.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down a wild day in New York sports. The Yankees finally re-sign Cody Bellinger to a five-year deal, bringing relief to Bronx fans after a quiet offseason. The Mets pivot with a Luis Robert Jr. trade, signaling that Cody was never headed to Queens and raising questions about David Stearns’ long-term philosophy. Plus, Giants fans continue to buzz after John Harbaugh’s official introduction as head coach, Knicks fans grow uneasy amid a slump, and Evan explains why the Yankees could actually be better in 2026 despite the lack of splashy moves. All that and more on WFAN’s Evan & Tiki.

As Cody Bellinger edges closer to re-signing with the New York Yankees, we unpack why this move feels more like relief than celebration for Yankee fans. After months of leaked contract numbers, missed backup plans, and a quiet offseason, the expectations in the Bronx have clearly shifted. We discuss how the market dried up, why the Yankees backed themselves into needing Bellinger’s bat, and how the bar slowly got lowered from blockbuster dreams to simply “being set.” Plus, an honest look at how the Yankees could still improve without a flashy offseason, relying on internal growth, healthier pitching, and year-two impact from deadline additions. It’s a reality check on the Yankees’ winter, the psychology of fan expectations, and why January optimism looks very different than it did in November.

Breaking news out of the Bronx as Cody Bellinger is officially re-signing with the New York Yankees. We react in real time to what this move means for the Yankees lineup, the balance of the roster, and how it impacts their plans heading into the season. Is this the stabilizing bat the Yankees needed, or just the first domino in a bigger offseason picture? We break down the contract implications, lineup fit, and how Bellinger’s return reshapes expectations in the AL.

CP the Franchise joins the show for a real Knicks therapy session as the losses pile up and the panic meter rises. Is this just the dog days, or is something broken between Mike Brown, Karl-Anthony Towns, and the locker room? CP breaks down what he’s seeing on the floor, what he’s hearing around the team, and why tonight vs the Nets feels way bigger than it should.

It starts with the absurdity of modern sports news: reporters at an intro press conference, waiting for their phones to light up with the real headline. While fans are tracking every Yankees move (and Mets fans are locked into the latest Mets storyline), the crew questions why teams even stage the big production when one notification can steal the entire spotlight. Then the tone shifts to the Knicks, who suddenly look like a mess: bad effort, bad vibes, and the kind of body language that makes fans wonder if the locker room is fractured or if the team has checked out on the coach. The Josh Hart on Jimmy Fallon debate becomes the lightning rod, with one simple question at the center: should players keep living their lives when the team looks like it’s collapsing? From there it opens up to calls, including a Jets fan dealing with furious Buffalo relatives over Sean McDermott being fired, and a bigger Jets dilemma: do you really want to draft a quarterback who’s literally suing for another year because he isn’t ready? The segment wraps with real worry, real laughs, and the kind of New York chaos that never takes a day off.

The NFL coaching carousel takes another unexpected turn as Mike McDaniel lands with Jim Harbaugh and the Chargers, choosing Justin Herbert over other potential landing spots. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down why quarterback fit matters more than anything for offensive minds and why certain franchises remain coaching dead ends. From there, the focus shifts to the Bills’ underwhelming head coaching search, Brian Daboll’s growing appeal, and whether Buffalo moved too quickly at the wrong moment. The conversation then explodes into draft season chaos, with a deep debate on how far teams should go to trade up for a franchise quarterback, why offensive line concerns should not stop you from taking the guy, and how recent playoff performances change evaluations overnight. The segment wraps with spirited calls, Jets and Giants tension, and a bigger question facing every front office right now: when you believe in the quarterback, is any price really too high?

After sitting down with John Harbaugh for an extended interview, the focus turns to what comes next for the Giants: building the right coaching staff. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun explain why Harbaugh’s credibility and coaching tree give the Giants an immediate advantage when it comes to attracting top tier coordinators. The discussion includes Harbaugh’s comments on Rex Ryan, how realistic a reunion actually is, and whether time away from the sideline matters. From there, the guys map out ideal coordinator fits, debate innovation on offense and stability on defense, and explain why this phase of the process may ultimately define the success of the Giants more than any single player move.

The conversation takes a sharp turn from today’s Mets news into a bigger baseball legacy debate. Evan makes the case that Carlos Beltran has been unfairly defined by one moment, even though he was clutch and deserves Cooperstown. From there, the discussion spills into Andruw Jones and whether his defense alone should make him a Hall of Famer, with Evan calling him the best defensive center fielder he’s ever seen and the phones lighting up immediately. Then it gets heated with the cheating and Hall of Fame standards argument. Beltran’s Astros ties spark a broader debate about what counts, what doesn’t, and why certain players get judged differently than others. The segment ends with a funny detour into real life chaos, then pivots back to the NFL with major coordinator chatter. Dianna Russini’s report on Brian Daboll’s possible landing spots leads to a bigger question for New York: what would a Daboll move mean for the Giants moving forward, and why Giants fans might actually view this as a sneaky win.

The Mets finally make the move everyone assumed would never happen, acquiring Luis Robert Jr. and forcing a hard look at what this roster is really becoming. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun debate why the trade makes sense defensively, why the upside is real despite two rough seasons, and why the only true risk might be financial. The conversation turns into a deeper breakdown of David Stearns’ long term vision, the famous “painting” analogy, and whether this lineup is better, worse, or just wildly different after losing Pete Alonso and reshaping the middle of the field. They dive into Robert’s change of scenery potential, the Mets’ desperate need for a real center fielder, and how bad last year’s production truly was at that spot. Plus, the ripple effect on the Cody Bellinger sweepstakes, why the Mets likely have a short term offer out, and why Yankees fans may feel more confident as the staredown with Scott Boras continues. The big question remains: when you squint at this roster, is the picture starting to come together or does it still feel unfinished?

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): The Jets are in a rare spot, there are plenty of head coaching jobs available and they aren't one of them. However, maybe they should be. Follow @HoffWFAN on Instagram, TikTok & X To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan and Tiki broadcast live from the Quest Diagnostics Training Center on a landmark day for the New York Giants as John Harbaugh is officially introduced as the franchise’s next head coach. The show begins with live reaction from inside the building as the Giants stage the press conference, ownership speaks, and Harbaugh lays out his vision for toughness, culture, and winning football in New York. Across all four hours, the guys react in real time to what Harbaugh said, how he said it, and why it immediately resonated with players, media, and fans. They break down the themes that defined the day, loving football, earning success, winning in the margins, and why Harbaugh felt like a natural fit for the Giants from the start. The show also examines what this hire means for the roster, the quarterback position with Jaxson Dart, the offensive line and run game, and the overall direction of the franchise. The centerpiece of the show is an extended sit down interview with John Harbaugh, where he talks openly about leaving Baltimore, his relationship with Lamar Jackson, how he evaluates modern quarterbacks, what excites him about the Giants’ roster, and where things stand with his coordinator search. He also delivers a clear message to Giants fans about pride, identity, and building a team they can believe in again. Joe Schoen also joins the show to explain the coaching search process, why Harbaugh became the clear choice, and how the organization positioned itself to land one of the most respected head coaches in football. The show wraps with full analysis, fan reaction, and perspective on why this day signals a turning point for the Giants, not just in expectations, but in professionalism, preparation, and belief moving forward.

The Giants kick off a new era as John Harbaugh arrives and the guys say the quiet part out loud: this might be the closest thing to a “sure thing” coaching hire New York sports has seen in decades. Live from the Quest Diagnostics Training Center ahead of Harbaugh’s introductory press conference, they debate how fast he can flip the culture, what realistic expectations should be for next season, and whether Giants fans should already be thinking playoffs. Then it turns ugly in the Garden. The Knicks get embarrassed again, the boos rain down, and the conversation gets uncomfortable fast: is the Mike Brown and Karl-Anthony Towns relationship already beyond repair? The guys lay out the three options, ride it out, dump KAT, or fire the coach, and explain why none of them feel clean. Plus, fan calls on what Harbaugh means for the Giants and what’s actually wrong with the Knicks right now.

Hour 2 opens with a bold prediction: if the Knicks lose to the Nets at MSG, Mike Brown might be gone immediately. The guys debate how quick the trigger could be, what a replacement could look like, and whether the Knicks are at the point where you do something drastic or just pray it magically fixes itself. Then the show pivots back to Giants Day with an early Cinco de Luncho: Shaun ranks the five most exciting Giants moments since Super Bowl XLVI, with Jaxson Dart’s arrival, draft night hope, and today’s John Harbaugh introduction sitting at the top of the list. The building buzz is real at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center as the press conference gets closer. The calls bring heat on both sides: Knicks fans go in on Karl-Anthony Towns and the locker room chemistry, plus a fascinating Carmelo Anthony clip about KAT’s “rabbit ears” and how outside noise can wreck a player mid game. The guys also talk about where the Knicks spiral actually began, what’s changed in their style and urgency, and why the vibe feels broken. Finally, the Harbaugh optimism gets its first speed bump when a caller brings up late game coaching decisions and blown leads in Baltimore. The guys discuss coaching shelf life, evolution, and why a fresh start can actually sharpen a coach who’s already proven he can win big.

It's John Harbaugh’s introductory press conference and the guys react to the biggest themes, the tone, and the energy inside the fieldhouse as the Giants officially turn the page. Harbaugh hits on what matters most, toughness, physical football, “the team” above everything, and a clear message that he wanted this job and believes the Giants can win. Then Giants GM Joe Schoen joins the show and walks through how the hire came together so fast, why the Giants were prepared for unexpected coaching movement, and what made Harbaugh the perfect fit. Schoen breaks down the collaboration he expects with the new head coach, how Jaxson Dart factored into the appeal of the job, and why he believes the roster has enough pieces to keep building quickly. The conversation also gets real about Schoen’s tenure, how he grades himself, the pressure that came with the Daniel Jones decision, and why he refused to chase short term fixes at the expense of sustainability. Plus, they touch on roster priorities heading into free agency and the draft, and why the Giants believe they are set up for a legit turnaround under Harbaugh.

Hour 4 is the full reaction to a historic Giants day. The guys break down what John Harbaugh’s press conference and interview revealed about who he is, why he wanted this job, and why the “love football” message landed so hard. They focus on the tone, the family element, and how naturally Harbaugh fits with the Giants identity, plus the way he spoke directly to the players in the room. They also debate expectations. Is the goal immediately playoffs, or is the real win simply eliminating the “miserable football” feeling and becoming a consistent, prepared, physical team every week? The conversation turns to what the Giants have lacked in recent years, situational mastery, discipline, and the details that decide close games, and why Harbaugh’s track record suggests those issues finally get fixed. There are also quick temperature checks on a few storylines, including why Jaxson Dart was not in the building for the introduction and whether that matters at all, and how Joe Schoen’s visibility shifts now that the franchise becomes “the Harbaugh show.” Fan calls pour in with the excitement level through the roof, and the show closes with more reflections on what winning culture actually looks like and what Giants fans should realistically demand next season.

New Giants head coach John Harbaugh sits down with Evan and Tiki right after his introduction and gets into what made this job feel inevitable, why the Giants are an iconic fit, and what he believes the team can become. Harbaugh talks about leaving Baltimore, his relationship with ownership, and the role his family and faith play in how he approaches the grind of coaching. On the football side, he dives into what he saw on tape, why the run game starts up front, and what excites him about the Giants’ backfield and offensive line. He discusses Abdul Carter’s rookie finish, the importance of physicality, and how he wants the Giants to win in the margins. Harbaugh also explains how he views Jaxson Dart as a modern quarterback who gives an offense options, from RPOs to quarterback driven concepts that stress defenses. Harbaugh updates where he is in the coordinator search, confirms he is meeting with the current staff, and even entertains the idea of reaching out to familiar names from his past. He also shares what he wants Giants fans to feel watching this team, pride, identity, and effort that shows up on tape every week. The interview closes with a few lighter moments, including the early morning workout routine and the competitive edge that comes with a fresh start in New York.

Live from the Giants fieldhouse, the scene is set with hundreds in attendance, current players in the building, and the room going silent as the organization prepares to introduce its next head coach. The guys play a quick prediction game on what Harbaugh will cite first for taking the job, then the moment arrives as Joe Schoen steps to the podium and officially introduces John Harbaugh as the new head coach of the New York Football Giants. Harbaugh’s opening remarks hit hard. He makes it clear he wanted the job, embraces the expectations of New York, and lays out a foundation built on toughness, physical football, discipline, and finishing. He emphasizes “team” repeatedly, thanks ownership, and brings the room into his mindset with a message about attacking every day with “enthusiasm unknown to mankind.” In the Q&A, Harbaugh addresses why he didn’t take time off, what he likes about the roster, and why he’s excited to work with Jaxson Dart. He talks staff building starting immediately, explains what “culture” means in football terms, and even nods to Andy Reid’s advice that “change can be good.” The press conference closes with Harbaugh reinforcing that success starts with how the Giants work every day and how they choose to play on tape.

Giants general manager Joe Schoen joins the show fresh off the hiring of John Harbaugh and walks through how the process came together so quickly. Schoen details why the Giants were prepared for unexpected coaching movement, how early research mattered, and why they moved decisively once Harbaugh became available. Schoen also opens up about roster construction, the importance of Jaxson Dart’s development, and why the Giants believe their young core made the job attractive. He addresses his own performance as GM, the Daniel Jones decision, resisting short term fixes, and the plan to keep building through free agency and the draft. The conversation closes with roster priorities, staff building, and why Schoen believes the Giants are positioned for a real turnaround under Harbaugh.

Shaun unveils his full Cinco de Lunch countdown, ranking the five most exciting Giants days since Super Bowl XLVI and explaining why today stands above them all. The list revisits moments Giants fans almost forget, like clinching a playoff spot on New Year’s Day 2023 and the unexpected thrill of beating the Vikings in the 2022 playoffs, even knowing how quickly things unraveled afterward. The conversation then jumps to recent hope. Draft night optimism with Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart, followed by Dart’s prime time statement game against the Eagles, is framed as a turning point fans will look back on as the night he truly arrived. At the top of the list is today. John Harbaugh becoming the head coach of the New York Giants is declared the most exciting Giants day since 2012, regardless of what he says at the podium. The segment also addresses fair concerns about Harbaugh’s late game decisions in Baltimore, with comparisons to Andy Reid and why elite coaches can evolve after a long run in one place. As dignitaries arrive and the building buzz grows, Shaun makes it clear why this moment feels different. For Giants fans, the shelf life starts now, and the optimism is real.

The discussion starts with the surprise firing of Sean McDermott and why, despite his résumé, there has been almost zero immediate interest around the league. The guys explain how teams were already deep into their interview processes, why McDermott’s exit from the Buffalo Bills caught the industry off guard, and how playoff consistency does not always translate to hot coaching demand. From there, the focus shifts back to the Knicks and what feels like a deeper problem than wins and losses. Callers and hosts break down the lack of urgency, respect, and cohesion surrounding Karl-Anthony Towns, including frustration with his on court habits and body language. A revealing clip from Carmelo Anthony adds context to the idea that outside noise and “rabbit ears” can derail a player mid game. The segment also digs into where the Knicks slide really began, why New Year’s Eve in San Antonio feels like the turning point, and how unresolved locker room tension can quietly snowball. All of it unfolds with a major contrast in the background as anticipation builds at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center, where Giants fans await the arrival of John Harbaugh and a moment that feels stable and hopeful in a New York sports landscape full of chaos.

The segment opens with a bold declaration that if the Brooklyn Nets beat the New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden, Mike Brown could be fired almost immediately. The guys debate how real that scenario is, why this moment feels different from past Knicks slides, and whether ownership is nearing a breaking point with a team that entered the season with championship expectations. The conversation quickly turns into a deep dive on Karl-Anthony Towns, his trade value, his on court frustrations, and the growing belief that he is not respected around the league or even fully protected internally. Callers weigh in on whether dumping KAT actually improves the roster or simply removes a problem from the locker room. From there, the show widens to New York sports big picture talk, comparing this Knicks chaos to past transformational hires like Pat Riley and Bill Parcells, and why those moments mattered. The segment also detours into Jets talk, including why elite coaches gravitate toward stability and quarterbacks, and why the Giants job clearly beat the Jets in this cycle. All of it plays out with one major backdrop looming over the hour: the anticipation building at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center as Giants fans wait to hear from John Harbaugh, with the optimism around the Giants standing in stark contrast to the dysfunction unfolding at MSG.

The Knicks conversation gets grim. After another ugly loss and boos at MSG, the guys lay out the three options facing New York: ride it out, dump Karl-Anthony Towns, or fire Mike Brown. They discuss whether the locker room has quit, why the KAT relationship feels beyond repair, and how stunning it is that this is even the conversation in January.

The Giants officially usher in a new era with John Harbaugh, and for once the conversation is simple. There is nothing to nitpick. Live from the Quest Diagnostics Training Center, the guys explain why this feels like a rare sure thing in New York sports, from Harbaugh’s résumé as a Super Bowl winner to his reputation as a culture builder and program stabilizer for the New York Giants.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): It's been over 48 hours since the Mets missed on Kyle Tucker and pivoted to Bo Bichette. This can't be the final stamp on the off-season, right? Evan dives into what's next as we're now less than a month away to pitchers and catchers. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

A weekend of NFL Playoff controversy, Sean McDermott gets fired, and Harbaugh becomes official.

The show opens with an uncomfortable truth for Evan: he hates the Bills, celebrated their loss, and still believes Buffalo got completely screwed. Evan and Tiki dissect the overturned interception, the lack of a serious review in overtime, and the pass interference calls that suddenly appeared after flags were swallowed all game. The conversation turns to Sean McDermott’s firing and whether this loss actually cost him his job or simply gave the Bills the excuse they were waiting for. The guys debate Josh Allen’s turnovers, Denver’s resilience at altitude, and the league-wide inconsistency that fuels conspiracy chatter. Finally, the focus shifts to what’s next in Buffalo, including head coach bingo, why John Harbaugh was never in play, and which names actually make sense for a team that believes it is still in a Super Bowl window.

Hour 2 opens with the latest coaching dominoes and the final details behind the John Harbaugh hiring. The crew reacts to Ian O’Connor’s reporting on what actually caused the late-week holdup, including Harbaugh pushing for real organizational control across the entire operation and clarity on who wins a draft-day stalemate with Joe Schoen. They discuss how close it got, why the Titans were still in the mix deep into the weekend, and how John Mara stepped in to finish it. From there, the conversation shifts to what this means inside the Giants building: a potential staff shakeup, a new chain of command, and a Harbaugh-driven culture reset in a locker room that has not always felt fully together. The hour rolls on with calls and a look at what comes next with coordinators and the remaining coaching openings.

C.J. Stroud’s performance vs the Patriots was labeled “a disgrace” after a brutal four-interception day that could have been even worse. The guys break down what looks like real regression: sloppy fundamentals, indecision, and turnovers that are no longer just “bad luck.” Plus, Troy Aikman delivers a cold, direct assessment of Stroud on the broadcast, and the discussion turns to the bigger issue for Houston: is this a quarterback problem, a coordinator problem, or both? They also rip Demeco Ryans for punting late while down two scores, debate how much the weather mattered, and why the Texans’ elite defense made the missed opportunity feel even more painful. Then the hour swings to a wild list of “best plays by losers,” and finishes with MLB hot stove talk as the Cody Bellinger sweepstakes heats up, including what the Yankees should do if the Mets come with a huge short-term offer.

The 4th and final hour of Evan & Tiki on WFAN dives deep into New York sports and beyond. Evan and Tiki react to the Mets’ aggressive pivot with Bo Bichette and debate David Stearns’ long-term strategy, fan trust, and the difficulty of forming attachments in today’s MLB. The Knicks’ recent struggles and Mitchell Robinson’s eventful weekend take center stage, including concerns over his cryptic social media posts and the Knicks’ get-right opportunity against an injury-riddled Mavericks team. The guys also break down the Giants’ future under John Harbaugh, cap flexibility, and boldly predict a Giants playoff berth in 2026.

Trust in Cohen and Stearns collapsing, rock-bottom after missing Tucker, then suddenly hope again after the Bo Bichette pivot. The conversation turns into a real debate about what the Mets’ actual plan is, why they keep leaning on short-term, big-money deals, and how hard it is to build a connection when every jersey feels like a one-year rental. Then it flips to the Yankees and Cody Bellinger, with New York leaking every detail of their “final offer” while fans wonder if it is all posturing until they actually pivot. A caller suggests a big swing like Framber Valdez, and the show breaks down why that does not really fit the Yankees’ long-term pitching commitments, plus what a realistic pivot even looks like if Bellinger walks. Also in the mix: early lockout talk, what opt-outs could mean if labor chaos is coming, and why Mets fans might want to enjoy Bichette now without getting too attached.

The New York Yankees make a quiet move by signing Seth Brown to a minor league deal, but that is just background noise compared to the real drama. All eyes are on Cody Bellinger and the contract decision that could reshape New York baseball. The Yankees have reportedly put their best offer on the table, a five-year deal they refuse to go past. Meanwhile, the New York Mets are lurking with the same strategy they used earlier this offseason, a massive short-term contract designed to outbid everyone without long-term risk. Add in Scott Boras working the market and the possibility of the Toronto Blue Jays jumping in, and the pressure is mounting. Is Bellinger better off locking in long-term security with the Yankees, or betting on himself one more time with a short, high-dollar deal elsewhere? The Mets’ roster strategy, the Yankees’ luxury tax stance, and the shrinking free agent market all collide as this decision reaches its breaking point. The clock is ticking, and a resolution feels imminent.

What starts as a simple question about what to wear to the Giants facility spirals into fashion panic, locker room etiquette, and pure lunchtime chaos. Hoodies, ties, first impressions, and somebody hide the queso. Then the show pivots hard into one of the most fun debates you will hear all week. The greatest plays by players whose teams still lost the game. From Endy Chavez to Jermaine Kearse, from DJ LeMahieu to modern miracle throws, every iconic moment gets argued, ranked, yelled about, and torn apart.

What we saw was a disgrace. C.J. Stroud imploded against the New England Patriots, throwing four interceptions and nearly seven in what was one of the ugliest performances of his career. This was not just a bad stat line. It was bad fundamentals, indecision, and mistakes that raised serious questions about whether Stroud is the same quarterback he was as a rookie. The conversation goes beyond the turnovers. From dropped passes to coaching decisions, coordinator changes, and a controversial late-game punt by DeMeco Ryans, everything is on the table. Add in Troy Aikman delivering a brutally honest assessment on the broadcast, and suddenly the Texans are facing a much bigger issue than just one bad game. Is this a temporary slump, a coaching problem, or real regression from a quarterback once viewed as the future of the franchise? And with extension talks looming, how close are the Texans to a true crossroads with Stroud?

The conversation turns fast when the news drops: Bo Nix broke his ankle, had surgery, and is officially out for the season. The guys rewatch the play trying to figure out how it even happened, point out the subtle tells on the very next snap, and talk through how stunning the timing is with Denver heading into the biggest game of the year. Then it takes a hilarious detour into Sean Payton’s postgame comments, when he tries to console Nix with a “second-year QB history” claim that instantly sets off Evan’s internal fact-check alarm. From there, the segment spirals into the real-world problem: can Denver actually bring in anyone off the street, or is it Jarrett Stidham by default? They run through the names people always throw out, why most of them are unrealistic or unavailable, and what it would actually take for the Broncos to survive against the Patriots with their season flipped upside down overnight.

The guys react to the latest coaching chaos and pivot back to the Giants, where the John Harbaugh hire briefly felt shakier than expected late Friday. With Ian O’Connor’s reporting in hand, they lay out what the holdup actually was: Harbaugh pushing for real influence across the entire organization, from staff and spending to analytics and infrastructure, plus clarity on who wins a draft-day disagreement with Joe Schoen. They also run through the behind-the-scenes pressure points, including a second quiet meeting with Chris Mara, the Titans still lingering in the background, and John Mara stepping in to finally close it. From there, the conversation turns to what this new power structure means, how it could reshape the Giants’ building and locker room culture, and why Giants fans are suddenly talking like a turnaround is coming fast.

The calls light the fuse on the coaching chaos: does John Harbaugh regret choosing the Giants now that the Bills job is open, and could Mike Tomlin ever wind up in Buffalo? Evan shuts that down fast, saying Harbaugh wanted the Giants job and knew the Bills opening could be coming if Buffalo lost. From there it turns into full “head coach bingo” for the Bills. The guys weigh big names like Pete Carroll and Bill Belichick, talk through why the mandate in Buffalo is Super Bowl or bust, and land on a prediction that actually makes too much sense: Brian Daboll. They dig into Daboll’s history with Josh Allen, what Buffalo would need on defense, and why Giants fans should feel even better knowing Harbaugh chose New York before the Bills vacancy even hit the market.

Evan opens with a brutal but honest take: he hates the Bills, celebrated their loss, and still believes Buffalo got completely screwed. The guys break down the interception that never should have stood, why the lack of a real review in overtime is indefensible, and how nearly the same play was officiated the opposite way just one day later. The discussion turns to the pass interference calls that suddenly appeared after flags were swallowed all game, and whether Sean McDermott truly lost his job because of the officiating or if Buffalo was already looking for an exit. Josh Allen’s turnovers, Denver’s credit, and the league’s obsession with “consistency” all collide in a segment that explains why this loss felt bigger than just one bad night.

Evan & Tiki discuss if the hiring of John Harbaugh means it’s playoffs or bust in Year 1. Plus, Craig Carton and C-Mac hear from callers and debate QBs C-Mac would trade Jaxson Dart for (23:00); Boomer & Gio look ahead to what Harbaugh’s coaching staff may look like (46:50) and the anticipation for Harbaugh’s introductory press conference (53:49).

This week's Jets highlights include Craig Carton calling Dante Moore's decision to stay in college a blessing for Gang Green, while Evan Roberts rips that opinion. Plus, Craig is dreaming for Mike Tomlin to be the coach in 2027, and Tommy Lugauer says these playoffs should be a wake-up call for the organization.

This week's Mets highlights include all the reactions to Kyle Tucker signing with the Dodgers, and what it could mean for the future of baseball. Plus, instant reactions to New York's pivot of signing Bo Bichette to a three-year deal.

The Giants and John Harbaugh are close to finalizing a deal to make him their new head coach and Boomer & Gio are ecstatic for the franchise. Plus, Boomer & Gio on the behind-the-scenes action on how the Giants wined and dined Harbaugh (17:51); Evan & Tiki on why Harbaugh is a franchise-altering moment (25:49); Craig Carton and C-Mac have differing reactions to Harbaugh (43:38); C-Mac and Craig on why this hire feels different (1:09:03); Evan and Tiki on what it says about the Giants that Harbaugh chose them (1:24:44).

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): 4 years and $240 million dollars. The Los Angeles Dodgers have done it again. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram, TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

A Football Friday is filled with a Mets roller coaster that starts sad, got happy with Bichette signing in show. Plus the Rangers warnt heir fans again.

Tiki tries to keep it calm, Evan absolutely does not. Kyle Tucker is officially a Dodger, and the anger is not just about losing the player, it’s about how the Mets ended up stuck with no clear direction again. Evan breaks down why the Mets’ offer was real, why being “close” never matters against L.A., and how the Dodgers treat the luxury tax like pocket change. The conversation quickly turns into a full Mets identity crisis. No Pete Alonso, no obvious pivot, and spring training right around the corner. Calls pour in debating whether Tucker could survive New York, why stars keep choosing the Dodgers, and how the Mets are supposed to compete with Philly and Atlanta. Plus Evan drops a full conspiracy theory on Rob Manfred, MLB, and why the Dodgers dominating the sport might be exactly what the league wants.

With Kyle Tucker off the board, the Mets are staring into the void and Evan lays out why Cody Bellinger is not a realistic “panic buy,” even with rumors of the Yankees sitting around five years and $160M. If the Mets wouldn’t go long for Tucker or Alonso, why would they suddenly cave to Scott Boras? Then the debate turns into the uncomfortable part: what’s the actual pivot? Evan pitches a wild, short-term, mega-AAV idea for Bo Bichette that’s basically a Tucker-style offer to blow him away, get an opt-out, and take another swing at free agency before 30. The problem: where does he play, and how much run prevention are you willing to sacrifice to get a real bat? Tiki pushes back on the defensive domino effect, the “versatility” trap, and the weekly second-guessing Mets fans would live through. The guys kick around the alternatives (including a one-year Eugenio Suárez power play), plus why pitching still has to be the priority no matter what. And of course, the segment ends with the same challenge: if you hate the plan, tell us a better one.

The show comes to a screeching halt with legitimate breaking news as the Mets land Bo Bichette on a three-year, $126 million deal, and Evan immediately reminds everyone he called the pivot before it happened. Evan and Tiki react in real time to the signing, the massive AAV, the opt-out structure, and what this move says about how David Stearns is operating in the market. They break down where Bichette fits defensively, why third base appears to be the early plan, and how much offensive ground this actually recovers after losing Pete Alonso and Kyle Tucker. The guys debate the risk of one-year and two-year opt outs, the surprising draft pick cost, and whether this is a necessary concession in today’s marketplace. Plus, what this move means for Philadelphia after reportedly agreeing to a long-term deal, how Toronto now pivots, why Cody Bellinger still does not make sense for the Mets, and whether this finally changes the tone of a chaotic Mets offseason. Live calls, instant reactions, and a full breakdown of how the roster and expectations shift after the biggest move yet.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with New York sports chaos. Evan, Tiki, and Sean react to the Mets’ stunning pivot to Bo Bichette after missing on Kyle Tucker and officially closing the door on Pete Alonso. Giants fans remain on John Harbaugh watch as contract details drag on, while the guys debate what his leadership would mean for Big Blue. The hour takes a sharp emotional turn with the Rangers’ brutal Friday letter signaling a reset, sparking an all-time rant from Sean. Plus, Yankees offseason questions, AL East power rankings, NFL Divisional Round picks, and plenty of passionate fan calls to close out a wild Friday on WFAN.

The discussion opens with the moment Mets fans still argue about. Pete Alonso’s defensive mistake that altered an entire season and still hangs over his departure. Now the reality is unavoidable. Pete Alonso is gone, and the New York Mets are moving in a completely new direction. That direction comes into focus with the addition of Bo Bichette, a bold pivot after missing out on Kyle Tucker. The guys break down why the Mets moved fast, how Bichette reshapes the lineup, and why this roster feels unfamiliar from top to bottom. The bullpen is just as different, with Edwin Díaz out and Devin Williams stepping into a high pressure closer role. From the lineup to the ninth inning, this is a new Mets identity, and everyone is about to find out if that change actually works.

The Mets sign Bo Bichette, and immediately the word panic starts flying. Evan explains why the money is not the panic at all. The Mets were ready to spend even more on Kyle Tucker, and short-term premium contracts are clearly part of the plan. The real concern is the opt-out. Giving up draft pick compensation for a player who could walk after one season feels less like free agency and more like a deadline rental, something David Stearns has historically avoided. The conversation turns into a deep debate on whether one year of elite talent is worth the risk, how past Mets contracts like Carlos Beltrán shape fan perspective, and why even a move everyone likes can still carry a subtle sense of urgency. The guys also dive into roster ripple effects, including what this means for Brett Baty, the Mets’ trade flexibility, and how the upcoming CBA could impact Bichette’s opt-out decision. Mets fans and Yankees fans both weigh in as New York’s baseball balance of power continues to shift.

The show spirals immediately. A little Giants contract paranoia. A little Mets panic even while liking the move. Absolute chaos in the booth as the phones light up, voices overlap, and Cinco energy takes over. Then it turns into a full rooting guide for the NFL playoffs. From old grudges to fresh annoyances, the guys count down the five easiest teams to root against this weekend. Rams, Broncos, Bills, Patriots, Seahawks, nobody is safe. Along the way there’s Giants coaching intrigue, Sam Darnold discourse, backup quarterback nightmares, and a reminder that New York fans never forget. Plus, the Mets land Bo Bichette while Kyle Tucker bolts for the Dodgers, setting up a massive day for both New York baseball teams. Loud, unhinged, and extremely opinionated.

Evan and Tiki react in real time to the breaking news that the Mets have signed Bo Bichette, finally answering the biggest question of the offseason. After weeks of debating pivots, desperation, and whether the Mets would actually pull the trigger on a major bat, the move is real. They break down why the Mets chose Bichette, what it says about David Stearns and Steve Cohen, and how this signing fits into the bigger picture after missing out on Kyle Tucker. The guys debate where Bichette plays, how much the bat changes the lineup, and whether this move actually closes the gap with the league’s elite. Plus, immediate fan reaction, instant expectations, and the real pressure this puts on the rest of the offseason.

It turns into an all-Rico day as Evan’s Kyle Tucker meltdown spills into the newsroom, the breaks, and basically the entire show. From there, the guys pivot to a throwback clip of Steve Cohen admitting he wants the Mets to model themselves after the Dodgers, and why that gap still feels massive beyond the farm system. Then the conversation swings to how Tucker’s decision can ripple to the Yankees with Cody Bellinger, including why Toronto suddenly looms as a real threat if they are willing to throw big years and money around. And because it’s New York sports radio, the segment closes with a true courtroom drama: Evan’s infamous “Edwin Díaz re-signed” line versus Craig Carton’s “I believe” Kyle Tucker guarantee. Who committed the bigger sports talk felony, and can “I believe” really save you when you were ready to take credit if you were right?

Evan lays out why Cody Bellinger is simply not a realistic option for the Mets, even with the Yankees reportedly sitting around five years and $160 million. If the Mets refused to go long-term for Kyle Tucker or Pete Alonso, why would they suddenly cave to Scott Boras now? The discussion turns to what desperation would actually look like, why David Stearns and Steve Cohen are unlikely to abandon their principles, and why relying on the kids may be the real outcome if no clean pivot exists. The guys also agree that pitching should be the priority regardless, and explain why even missing on Tucker does not mean the Mets are about to hand out contracts they do not believe in.

Evan unloads a full conspiracy theory: Rob Manfred is not mad about the Dodgers dominating baseball, he’s thrilled. The idea is simple and terrifying. Let the Dodgers keep stacking stars, let fans scream “baseball is broken,” and then use that outrage to win the PR war for a salary cap the players will hate. Tiki buys it immediately, even as they admit it still might never work. From there, the focus snaps back to the Mets problem that keeps getting louder: they can “try” for Tucker, but where’s the backup plan? A caller compares Cashman’s quick Soto pivot to the Mets dragging their feet, and the guys dig into the bigger issue: Stearns will spend huge AAV, but refuses to go long term, which kills half the market. Then it turns into pure show chaos: Free Agent Bingo standings, Knicks misery, and Mets fans roasting the offseason, including a fake “Mets fan” troll call and the return of the “chomping at the bit” debate right before Evan teases a pivot plan that does not include Cody Bellinger.

Kyle Tucker’s $240 million deal with the Dodgers sparks a loaded fan debate. Calls flood in on whether Yoshinobu Yamamoto or Garrett Crochet is the better arm, and why the Mets came up short on both. Evan and Tiki break down what it really takes to beat the Dodgers in negotiations, why “being close” never works, and how absurd offers are now the baseline. The conversation turns emotional as Mets fans wrestle with a brutal question: did they dodge a bullet with Tucker, or was this another missed opportunity that only hurts because it feels familiar? There’s a deep dive into New York pressure, why stars thrive in L.A., and whether elite free agents truly want the Mets or just cannot say no to the Dodgers. By the end, one thing is clear: there are only a few teams at the top of the market, and right now, everyone else is playing catch up.

The news Mets fans feared becomes reality as Kyle Tucker chooses the Los Angeles Dodgers over the New York Mets. Evan reacts with raw frustration, breaking down why this one hurts even though the Mets made a massive and legitimate offer. Tiki Barber explains why the Dodgers always win these battles, how their financial edge changes everything, and why no one should be surprised. The conversation turns from Tucker to the bigger picture as Evan questions the Mets’ offseason direction, the failure to replace Pete Alonso, and what the real pivot is with spring training approaching. Is this anger really about Tucker, or about the position the Mets have put themselves in? Plus a Winston Churchill inspired rally cry, and a brewing conspiracy involving MLB and Rob Manfred. A must listen for Mets fans trying to figure out where this team goes next and whether there is still a path to contention.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets up their offer to 4 years on Kyle Tucker. The only good news about Ranger Suarez not signing with the Mets is he's out of the NL East! Plus more news. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

We have full reaction to the news of John Harbaugh taking the Giants job as Head Coach. Plus, The Kyle Tucker rumors continue to swirl.

John Harbaugh to the Giants feels like the rare “everyone wanted him and you actually got him” moment, and the guys dive into why this hire is different from the team’s recent coaching cycles. They also give Joe Schoen credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job appealing enough for Harbaugh to skip other interviews entirely. Plus, the phones light up with fans debating Harbaugh vs. McCarthy, the “can a coach win a Super Bowl with two teams” question, and whether anyone owes an apology to ownership. Then the show pivots to a brutal Knicks loss, a Brunson ankle scare, and why the effort level (especially from KAT) had everyone boiling.

The guys go down a fascinating New York sports rabbit hole: how often does a coach or manager arrive here already owning a championship, and how rarely it actually turns into a title in New York. They land on Weeb Ewbank as the lone example of someone who won before coming to a New York team and then won again here, framing just how unique the John Harbaugh moment is for the Giants. Then the phones roll with Harbaugh hype, expectations for Year 1, and early buzz about what his staff could look like, including chatter around Todd Monken. The segment also takes a detour into classic New York fan trauma, comparing “can’t miss” celebrations (Nets Big 3, Rodgers to the Jets) to why the Giants situation feels different. And of course, the Jets can’t stay out of it: Dante Moore going back to school sparks a full blown debate about options, draft pressure, and what the organization should do at quarterback next.

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Hoff explains his issues with David Stearns and how he's playing too many games during this off-season. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

With a real head coach now in place, the entire Giants conversation shifts from “hope” to “expectation.” The guys debate what the floor actually is in 2026: simply a winning season, meaningful football in December, or a flat-out playoff mandate. They also dig into the reality of the NFC landscape, the pressure on Joe Schoen now that the “big hire” is done, and why some fans are setting the bar high while others are preaching patience. Plus, callers weigh in on whether this feels like a true turning point, and why Harbaugh should inspire more confidence than past “winning coaches” like Dan Reeves.

It’s a wild day in New York sports. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Giants hiring John Harbaugh as their next head coach and break down what it means for Big Blue moving forward. Plus, the guys dive deep into the Kyle Tucker sweepstakes, debating the Mets’ reported short-term mega offer versus Toronto’s long-term deal, whether Tucker is worth $50 million per year, and what decision makes the most sense for both the player and the Mets. Giants history, Mets roster construction, Yankees crossover fallout, and plenty of classic Evan & Tiki banter all in one jam-packed segment on WFAN.

The Mets are reportedly in with a massive short-term offer for Kyle Tucker, while Toronto looms with long-term security and the Dodgers lurk as a wildcard. The guys debate the core question every star free agent faces: take the absurd annual payday and bet on yourself, or lock in a decade of guaranteed money and never look back. They dig into whether Tucker is truly worth Juan Soto-level money, the risks of overpaying on a short deal, and why a ten-year commitment feels dangerous for the Mets. From roster construction to championship ceilings to quality-of-life considerations, this turns into a full breakdown of what Tucker should do, and what the Mets should be willing to live with if they miss out.

Cinco De Luncho takes center stage as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun rank the five greatest games ever played at the old Giants Stadium. From iconic playoff blowouts to unforgettable regular season moments, each list sparks debate, nostalgia, and plenty of arguing over what truly belongs in the top five. The conversation weaves through legendary wins, painful losses that shaped championships, and personal memories from the field and the stands. A full-on Giants history lesson with strong opinions, laughs, and classic sports radio chaos.

The Giants finally have a real head coach, and everything feels different. Evan, Tiki, and Sean debate how much the John Harbaugh hire should immediately raise expectations in Year 1. Is a winning season the floor, or is it fair to expect playoff contention right away? The guys dive into what this move means for Joe Shane, how tough the NFC really is, why meaningful football in December matters, and whether Giants fans should aim high or stay patient. One thing is clear: the bar has officially been raised in New York with John Harbaugh now leading the franchise.

A passionate debate erupts over tanking, fandom, and what fans are actually supposed to root for in September and October. The guys argue whether it’s ever acceptable to cheer for losses, how draft position really changes franchises, and why fans should never be told to embrace losing. The conversation spills into Giants optimism under John Harbaugh, Jets misery, long term expectations, and whether New York sports fans are finally allowed to believe again or if that’s just asking to get burned.

A full blown Jets meltdown after Dante Moore decides to return to college. The guys debate why Moore staying in school actually hurts the Jets by taking options off the board, killing trade down possibilities, and increasing pressure on the front office to get quarterback right. What starts as a simple prediction check quickly turns into a heated argument about draft philosophy, organizational competence, and whether Jets fans are actually celebrating being saved from themselves.

The guys break down a wild stat that makes the John Harbaugh moment feel even bigger: the Giants almost never bring in a head coach who already has a Super Bowl on his resume, and across New York sports it’s surprisingly rare to land a proven champion and have it translate into titles here. That leads to the Weeb Ewbank deep dive as the lone example of a coach who won elsewhere and then won again with a New York team, plus a rapid fire debate over which sports even “count” in the conversation. Then the callers take over, mixing Harbaugh euphoria with classic New York superstition, including one fan reaching for “Giants were first to do this” trivia and the show pushing back with a simpler point: Harbaugh means consistent competence, yearly playoff contention, and eventually a real shot at a title. The segment also hits on 2026 expectations with Jaxson Dart entering Year 2, and why this feels different than other “can’t miss” New York celebrations like Aaron Rodgers to the Jets or the Nets superteam. The message is basically this: even if it doesn’t immediately end in a parade, Harbaugh can still be the turning point that drags the Giants out of the mud for the long haul.

John Harbaugh did not just take the Giants job. He chose it. The guys explain why Harbaugh skipping other interviews is such a powerful signal about where the New York Giants are headed, and why this hire stands apart from past coaching cycles. They also dig into how Joe Schoen’s roster build and the drafting of Jaxson Dart helped make the Giants the most appealing destination on the board. From past misses to present momentum, this is the clearest case yet that the Giants finally got it right.

The New York Giants finally land the coach everyone wanted. The guys break down why John Harbaugh choosing the Giants over every other opening is such a massive statement for the franchise, and why this cycle feels different from the last decade of misses. They also explain how Joe Schoen deserves real credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job irresistible for a Super Bowl winning head coach. From coaching failures of the past to why this move feels like a true turning point, this is why Giants fans have every reason to believe again.

Kyle Tucker watch is underway while John Harbaugh finally leaves Maryland for Blue Sky's.

The Mets offseason is at a tipping point, and Kyle Tucker is the one move that could change the entire mood. Evan and Tiki debate why Tucker would “save” the winter, why the Mets’ only real edge is money, and how David Stearns’ short-term, high-AAV philosophy is shaping everything after losing Pete Alonso. Then it turns into a wild New York sports morning: John Harbaugh meets with the Giants, fans call in on Tucker vs pitching help (Suarez, Valdez, Giolito), and the guys hit the Yankees’ under-the-radar Ryan Weathers trade before circling back to the big question: who’s the Mets ace right now? Chapters 00:00 Kyle Tucker “saves” the Mets offseason 03:20 Mets vs Dodgers vs Blue Jays and what actually matters 06:25 Trusting Stearns, roster “maybes,” and the first base frustration 14:00 Giants news: John Harbaugh meeting and the Tisch plane buzz 18:30 Calls: Tucker vs Suarez/Valdez, plus the rotation anxiety 35:15 Yankees add Ryan Weathers, then Giolito and the Mets “ace” debate

The Giants finally get their face-to-face with John Harbaugh, and the debate turns into a full blown strategy session: is it better to go first and try to close immediately, or go last and land the final pitch? The guys size up the competition from Tennessee and Atlanta, including why both spots are way more appealing than fans want to admit. Plus, Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti’s brutally honest press conference becomes must-listen audio, from Harbaugh’s next move to Lamar’s role in the coaching search. Then the show hits a whirlwind of calls on everything from Brian Daboll’s next stop, the Jets’ draft options and quarterback chaos, to what a “successful” Mets offseason even means and why Kyle Tucker suddenly feels like a must.

The Athletic’s Ian O’Connor joins Evan and Tiki with the latest on the John Harbaugh meeting and why the Giants appear to be leading the race. Ian explains what today’s sit-down really means, why the face-to-face time with Joe Schoen matters most, and what Harbaugh is looking for when it comes to roster power and the quarterback plan. Then the conversation widens to the other suitors, including why Atlanta and Tennessee might come to Harbaugh instead of the other way around, plus the one “looming” team that could still complicate things. Ian also gives his current odds on Harbaugh landing with the Giants, and why money will not be the issue. Finally, it turns to Aaron Rodgers and what comes next, including the possibility of Minnesota, a fascinating GM “word salad,” and what it all signals about the Vikings’ quarterback direction. Oh, and yes, the show also finds time for an all-time Cinco de Lunch moment: the “salmonella vs semolina” bread confusion goes fully off the rails.

In this 4th and final hour of the show, Evan accuses Chris McMonigle of a crime against his fanhood and all hell breaks loose. Also more on the John Harbaugh front.

A full on courtroom breaks out on the show when allegations surface that coworker Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle coached his kid’s flag football team… as the Eagles… while wearing Kelly green. Sean serves as prosecutor and lays out the case for why a real Giants fan should refuse the Eagles assignment, rename the team, and never chant “Go Eagles” under any circumstances. Big Mac storms in to defend himself, arguing it was a league issued NFL Play 60 shirt, not real fandom, and that being a good dad matters more than jersey politics. The debate escalates into fantasy football hypocrisy, coaching fashion solutions, and Tiki delivering the final verdict: guilty. Evan agrees, says he would never wear the rival gear himself, and Big Mac leaves branded with the scarlet letter of a convicted sports fan manatee whenever he steps into their territory.

A casual idea for tomorrow’s Cinco turns into a full blown argument when Evan and Tiki start debating the best games ever played at old Giants Stadium. Evan plants his flag on the Jets beating the Bengals in the final game at the building, Tiki roasts him for treating a glorified preseason as history, and the whole thing spirals into condescension, yelling, and an all time “I hope Harbaugh leaves” line. Then the Cinco de Lunch-o aftermath keeps rolling: Sean gets publicly assigned the show’s “L” on YouTube for the semolina vs salmonella disaster, the chat piles on, and a caller solves Evan’s late night PB&J problem in two seconds by diagnosing the real culprit: refrigerated peanut butter.

Cinco de Lunch officially pivots away from football for the first time as Evan unveils his Top 5 Sandwiches of All Time and the studio immediately turns it into a food debate. The guys rank an Italian hero, grilled cheese, grilled chicken with roasted peppers and mozzarella, PB&J, and a turkey club, plus they argue the eternal question: does adding bacon change the name of the sandwich? It all peaks with an all time slip when “semolina” bread becomes “salmonella” bread live on air, leading to a full on correction, laughter, and a reminder of what you definitely do not want on your lunch.

Veteran New York reporter Ian O'Connor joins Tiki and Evan to break down the most pivotal day in the New York Giants coaching search. O’Connor explains why the Giants are firmly out in front in the pursuit of John Harbaugh, why New York’s quarterback situation gives them an edge over Atlanta and Tennessee, and how today’s meeting could determine whether this saga ends quickly or drags on. Plus, why there is effectively no true Plan B, what could cause hesitation, and why this hire would be the biggest the Giants have made in decades.

The Harbaugh watch hits peak intensity as reports say he’s flying in on a private plane and there’s a real chance he never leaves the Giants facility without a contract. The guys debate the nightmare scenario if he walks out and heads to Nashville or Atlanta, and why this is not a normal coaching search at all. It’s Harbaugh interviewing the Giants, not the other way around. Then the conversation swerves into Jets draft chaos with the Dante Moore declaration deadline, why more quarterback options is automatically good news for New York, and a classic argument over “old” takes suddenly becoming “new” again. Plus, callers jump in with Mets pressure, contract aging debates, and a brutally honest, comedy-heavy “if we ran the Giants and Jets” segment that turns into a wish list of grass fields, ticket freezes, and fan-friendly chaos.

The Giants finally get John Harbaugh in the building, and the whole hour turns into one question: is it better to get the first meeting and try to close immediately, or is “first” actually a disadvantage because Tennessee and Atlanta can sell him on everything after? The guys break down why Nashville feels like a legit destination, why Atlanta can outspend anybody, and why the Giants have to land the plane and finish the deal before Harbaugh even gets a chance to look around. Plus, a brutally honest Steve Bisciotti press conference adds fuel to the fire, including what he thinks Harbaugh needs most in his next job. Then the calls take over, from Jets frustration with Aaron Glenn to the quarterback reality check that could eliminate the Jets from the Harbaugh sweepstakes entirely.

Evan and Tiki open the phones and Mets fans go straight to the big question: if you can only make one marquee move, is it Kyle Tucker or a top arm like Ranger Suárez or Framber Valdez? Evan argues Tucker’s 162-game impact is bigger than any starter’s, even while admitting the rotation still screams for certainty. The conversation rolls into David Stearns’ short term, high AAV strategy, whether “connections” matter at all in free agency, and why the Dodgers are always lurking if money is close. Plus: the Pete Alonso fallout won’t go away, the “is $50M worth it?” camps battle, the Yankees finally make an under the radar move with Ryan Weathers, and a caller throws Lucas Giolito into the mix as the show debates what actually qualifies as a Mets ace right now.

Mets fans are running out of patience, and it all comes down to one name. Evan and Tiki break down why signing Kyle Tucker would not make this a perfect offseason, but could absolutely save it. They dig into the bidding war with the Dodgers and Blue Jays, Steve Cohen’s willingness to flex financially, and David Stearns’ short term contract philosophy. Plus, why missing out on Tucker would leave the Mets banking on too many maybes, reopen the Pete Alonso wound, and make this offseason feel just as bleak as it did a month ago. Everything is on the line in the next 24 hours.

Have we seen the end of Mike Tomlin as a coach in Pittsburgh and can that benefit the Jets? Plus the Mets are interested in Kyle Tucker and things are moving fast.

The Steelers do it again: playoff game, offense disappears, season ends, and Steeler fans immediately want Mike Tomlin gone. The guys debate whether it’s actually Tomlin who might be ready to walk away, Sean Payton-style, take a TV break, and reset. They break down the never-ending Pittsburgh QB problem, why the timing makes a Giants move tough (contract and trade compensation), and why a one-year Tomlin hiatus could be a Jets fan’s dream scenario down the line. Plus, Aaron Rodgers’ early exit turns into a bigger conversation: what’s his next move, and has he stopped being the “difference-maker” at this stage of his career? The hour also hits the record-setting coaching vacancy chaos, fan reaction clips, and the bigger “great coach vs. postseason ceiling” debate.

Hour 2 dives deeper into the John Harbaugh sweepstakes and asks the real question: who actually threatens the Giants most. The crew runs a “Pick 3” ranking of the top teams that could lure Harbaugh away, weighing roster appeal, quarterback situations, draft capital, cap space, and the one factor they keep coming back to: ownership stability. Atlanta’s reputation and leadership get a hard look, Cleveland is framed as the storm you monitor but do not fear, and Tennessee jumps into the conversation as a sneaky powerhouse threat with a young QB, a high pick, major cap room, and an intriguing roster base. Then it gets personal as Logan Ryan takes shots at Joe Shane, and the guys debate how much to trust criticism that might come from a bad breakup. Plus, a fun detour into what a “lunch meeting at Harbaugh’s house” should actually look like, a caller claims Tom Coughlin may have made a key outreach, and the hour spirals into Posted and Toasted, Al Dukes going viral over “F the Packers,” and a bigger argument about class, rivalries, and why fans love hearing their coach talk like a fan.

Hour 3 starts with a brutal scorecard check on the show’s MLB free agent predictions, as everyone whiffs on Alex Bregman landing with the Cubs. Then it turns into full-blown “Head Coach Vacancy Bingo,” with rapid-fire picks across the league and a heavy Giants focus as the crew debates John Harbaugh vs. Kevin Stefanski, plus the looming possibility of a Mike Tomlin breakup in Pittsburgh and who could replace him. The hour also features a troll-heavy “Aaron Rodgers 5 Greatest Career Accomplishments” list that spirals into a Jets expectations argument, followed by Rodgers’ postgame comments defending Mike Tomlin and taking shots at media “experts.” On the baseball side, the Mets get linked to a short, mega-AAV Kyle Tucker offer, then Jeff Passan’s report drops with Nolan Arenado finally getting traded. Plus, a classic Evan social moment: Sean Morash compared to a Cabbage Patch Kid, with the receipts. #EvanAndTiki #Giants #JohnHarbaugh #MikeTomlin #AaronRodgers #Jets #NFLCoachingCarousel #MLBHotStove #Mets #KyleTucker #NolanArenado #WFAN

Listen to the 4th and final hour of this edition of the Evan and Tiki show.

With Mike McCarthy meeting the Giants, the crew plays out what the interview really needs to cover and what answers could actually change minds. The focus stays on McCarthy’s staff plan, how he would keep up defensively with modern offenses, and whether he can restore real on field accountability after too many Giants lapses. The conversation widens into full Harbaugh watch, with John Harbaugh framed as the Juan Soto of the coaching market and the clear prize everyone is waiting on. Calls weigh in on how Giants fans would react to a McCarthy hire, fears of settling if Harbaugh goes elsewhere, and what kind of staff Harbaugh would build for a young quarterback like Jaxson Dart. The segment also veers into a heated debate on teams threatening season ticket holders over secondary market sales, with Evan arguing it is unfair for long suffering fans to take losses for years and then get blocked from finally making money back when a team gets good.

The Mets are making a real push for Kyle Tucker, with reports of a massive short term, high AAV offer that fits David Stearns and Steve Cohen’s recent roster philosophy. The crew debates whether the Mets can actually beat out the Dodgers or Blue Jays, and why Tucker might prefer a short deal to reenter a thin future free agent market.

Shaun Morash fires up full Cinco de Luncho mayhem, sending the booth into total chaos with yelling, laughing, and a runaway bumper. The show then pivots to Aaron Rodgers and the strangest possible retirement scenario: he quietly disappears without ever officially announcing he’s done, while nobody even knows who he married.

Evan and Tiki pull out the “prediction desk” to grade their MLB free agent picks and immediately take an L: everyone misses on Alex Bregman, who signs with the Cubs. The scoreboard gets updated, the slow-burn MLB offseason gets roasted, and then the show pivots hard into “NFL Head Coach Free Agent Bingo.” They fire off early predictions for the Browns, Raiders, and Titans, with names like Mike McCarthy, Jim Schwartz, Brian Flores, Jesse Minter, Joe Brady, and Matt Nagy getting tossed around. The segment crescendos into the Giants debate, where the crew lines up on John Harbaugh vs. Kevin Stefanski and what each hire would mean for the franchise moving forward.

A brand-new Posted and Toasted kicks off with a rapid-fire trip through old takes and wild questions, including “Who leaves the Chargers first, Justin Herbert or Jim Harbaugh?” and a flashback to harsh Harbaugh slander that did not exactly age well. Then the segment turns into a full-blown debate after Al Dukes posts a viral complaint about Ben Johnson’s “F the Packers” moment. Tiki is genuinely annoyed, Evan defends rivalry heat, and the guys argue whether fans actually want more personality from coaches or more “class.” It gets even better when the show plays Ben Johnson’s response and he basically refuses to apologize, leaning into the rivalry. Add in a side quest about “skinny fat,” the YouTube chat judging Evan’s belly, and the whole thing becomes classic chaos.

The Giants’ coaching search heats up as the guys rank the top three teams that could realistically steal John Harbaugh away from New York. Cleveland is framed as the storm you monitor but do not fear, Atlanta’s ownership and reputation put them firmly in the mix, and Tennessee emerges as the surprise heavyweight with cap space, draft capital, and a quarterback Harbaugh might actually prefer. The conversation shifts from fan logic to what truly matters in these decisions: ownership stability, roster flexibility, control, and long-term vision. Logan Ryan’s blunt criticism of Joe Shane sparks debate over bias versus truth, while callers weigh in on Tom Coughlin’s reported outreach and whether behind-the-scenes relationships could help close the deal. Plus, the show takes a hilarious detour into what really happens at a coach recruiting lunch, who should bring the food, and why stadium talk might be nothing more than noise.

The NFL coaching carousel might be headed for history: the guys note the league could be staring at a record number of head coach openings if Pittsburgh joins the party. Then the show pivots into full New York sports pain, with the Rangers getting buried, “Fire Drury” chants, and the Nets openly tanking. After that, it’s Steelers fan therapy time. They play viral fan reactions that range from blaming Arthur Smith to blaming the crowd itself, then get into the uncomfortable part: if Pittsburgh moves on from Tomlin, are there even enough legit candidates to replace a guy who never has a losing season? The debate turns into a bigger sports question: when you’re sick of the ceiling, is blowing it up worth the risk? The hour finishes with a sharp breakdown of Aaron Rodgers’ sideline blowups and why it hits differently when you have not earned years of trust in a locker room. Jets perspective, Steelers perspective, and the brutal truth about disappointment all collide.

Another January, another familiar ending in Pittsburgh. The Steelers bow out early, the offense goes silent, and Steeler fans immediately turn their frustration toward Mike Tomlin. But the conversation shifts to a more uncomfortable question: what if Tomlin is the one who’s ready to move on? The guys break down the post Ben Roethlisberger quarterback void, the never-ending coordinator carousel, and why the Steelers’ constant playoff appearances may actually be trapping them in mediocrity. They explore the Sean Payton comparison, the idea of Tomlin stepping away to reset, and why that scenario could quietly benefit the Jets while complicating things for the Giants. Plus, Aaron Rodgers’ latest playoff exit raises real questions about his future and whether this version of Rodgers can still lift a team when it matters most.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Is Evan totally wrong about the Mets going after Kyle Tucker? Plus, the rumored trade for Edward Carera. Alex Bregman fall out, Yankees out on Cody Bellinger and how it impacts the Mets. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Giants get good news out of Green Bay, plus a full recap of perhaps the greatest Wild Card Weekend ever

Wild Card Weekend had everything, including one brutal Packers collapse that had everyone wondering if Matt LaFleur could actually be in trouble. Then Adam Schefter pours water on it with a new contract expectation, and Evan and Tiki connect the dots to the coaching carousel and why John Harbaugh might be the one move that freezes everything else. The guys hit the Sirianni vs AJ Brown sideline blowup, what Philly’s loss really means, and why Giants fans can probably relax about certain “new” vacancies. Then they dive into the Bills vs Jaguars finish and the debate that took over sports bars everywhere: kneel at the 1 and bleed clock, or take the touchdown and trust your defense? Plus, the end-of-half officiating mess that almost became the story of the week. Also in Hour 1: why the Jets feel like they’re playing a different sport after watching playoff football, what makes the Patriots defense so hard to diagnose, and Tony Romo’s all time confusing broadcast moment that had everyone asking, “What game are you watching?”

Hour 2 starts with one of the strangest timing moments you’ll hear all season: the Bears are in the middle of an epic home playoff comeback against the Packers when news breaks that the Cubs are stunningly signing Alex Bregman. Evan and Tiki debate how a city even processes a massive baseball move during the biggest football night in years, plus a Barstool meltdown from the Boston side of the deal. Then the calls take over, starting with a deep dive into the modern fourth down obsession and the Jaguars decision to pass up points against Buffalo, especially after being gifted field position. The guys break down why “take the points” still matters in January and how one empty possession can flip a playoff game. The hour also hits the Jets fan reality check after watching real playoff football, the quarterback trade up fantasies, and why one Fernando Mendoza quote might have ended Jets dreams on the spot. Plus: the Liam Cohen press conference moment that has media people furious, a debate on whether a reporter can be supportive, and a round of playoff hot takes including which coaches are easiest and hardest to root for.

Hour 3 opens with the biggest win of Wild Card Weekend: the games were awesome, competitive, and for once the NFL escaped without a single officiating disaster hijacking the conversation. Evan and Tiki love that the storyline stayed on football, and they argue the league feels completely wide open, with guaranteed new blood headed to the Super Bowl. The guys then hit the funniest “info win” from the weekend, including a bizarre baseball stat tied to a Bills defender that somehow becomes a running joke for Buffalo’s playoff run. Calls follow on how to combat tanking in the NFL, Buffalo’s chances on the road, and why the Bills’ path is brutal even if the vibes feel like “this is their year.” Then it turns into full Jets fan pain as Evan lays out the nightmare remaining AFC field, debates what would hurt Jets fans most, and gets pulled into a Justin Herbert discussion: is he overrated or just stuck with no help? The hour also includes Cinco de Luncho ranking the Wild Card games, Yankees anxiety over Cody Bellinger, Mets hopes for Kyle Tucker, and a darkly hilarious Jets Super Bowl timeline that spirals all the way into the distant future.

Evan & Tiki close out the show with a wide-ranging and emotional final hour, headlined by Evan’s raw rant on why it’s never been more depressing to be a Jets fan. The guys dive into the “LOL Jets” stigma, Davante Adams’ unnecessary shade, and whether the franchise is miles behind the rest of the AFC. Plus, a spirited debate on whether fans can (or should) ever abandon their team, stories about long playoff droughts, and why winning after decades of pain just hits different.

After a weekend of playoff football, Evan and Tiki hit the harshest reality for Jets fans. The Patriots look sharp, Drake May is already being talked about like a future MVP, and Josh Allen is still standing in the AFC. The question becomes brutally simple: can the Jets realistically find a quarterback who can go toe to toe with those two in the division? The guys rip into the gap between the Jets and the best coached playoff teams, debate Aaron Glenn’s future, and react to a perfectly timed shot from an Amazon Prime pregame clip that sums up the Jets’ current reputation. Then the punchline arrives: the Jets announce a futures deal with Bailey Zappe, turning the whole situation into peak “are we being trolled?” energy. It’s Jets despair, league wide trolling, and the uncomfortable truth that nothing changes until the Jets start winning.

While Wild Card Weekend dominated the headlines, a major MLB bomb dropped in the background. The New York Yankees are now operating under the assumption that Cody Bellinger could sign elsewhere as contract talks stall over years, not dollars. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down the reported standoff with Scott Boras, why the Yankees are refusing to negotiate against themselves, and why this situation feels eerily similar to what the New York Mets dealt with last year. The conversation pivots to potential fallback options, including interest around Kyle Tucker, the realities of short term high AAV deals, and why teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers and Toronto Blue Jays loom large in the background. Plus, a deeper debate on free agency leverage, market reality, and why Yankee fans may want to stay calm as this staring contest plays out.

Cinco de Luncho takes over the booth as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun rank every game from an unforgettable Wild Card Weekend. From the snoozer at the bottom of the list to an epic rivalry comeback at the top, the guys debate what actually makes a playoff game great. Is it the ending, the full three hour ride, the stakes, or the atmosphere? They break down Chargers vs Patriots, 49ers vs Eagles, Bills vs Jaguars, Rams vs Panthers, and the emotional roller coaster between the Packers and Bears. The discussion turns into a full blown argument over best ending versus best overall game, DVR watching versus live chaos, and why some games get punished just for kickoff time or location. Pure sports radio energy, food jokes included, as Cinco de Luncho delivers the definitive Wild Card Weekend rankings.

Wild Card Weekend delivered exactly what fans have been begging for. Close games, real drama, and no officiating controversy stealing the spotlight. Evan and Tiki break down why the biggest win of the weekend was actually talking about football again, not refs or rule debates. They dive into the wide open feel of the NFL, debate the legacies of Josh Allen and Justin Herbert, and explain why this postseason feels different from the dynasty driven years dominated by Kansas City and New England. The conversation shifts to belief and perspective for struggling franchises, including why fans of the New York Giants

With the coaching carousel settling for now, the spotlight unexpectedly shifts to Jacksonville after the Jaguars’ playoff loss to Buffalo. A local reporter steps to the mic and skips the question entirely, offering Liam Cohen a heartfelt pep talk instead, and the media world erupts. Evan and Tiki find the moment funny, human, and completely overblown as a controversy. They push back on the outrage from fellow reporters, arguing there’s room for empathy as long as the tough questions still get asked, and imagine what the New York version of that moment would sound like if the Jets ever won 13 games. The conversation then spills into the Bills-Jaguars finish, revisiting the score versus kneel debate at the goal line, the fear of false starts and bad snaps, and why trusting your defense still makes sense in today’s NFL. Plus, calls on playoff officiating, pocketed flags in January, and a walk down memory lane with Giants fans reliving the most painful postseason losses of their lifetime.

A Bears-Packers playoff comeback is already chaos, then Chicago gets a second shockwave mid-game: news leaks that the Cubs are signing Alex Bregman. Evan and Tiki debate how any fan is supposed to process a blockbuster baseball move during the biggest football moment in years, plus why good news can wait but bad news hijacks your brain instantly. Then the show pivots back to the NFL with a caller hammering the league’s new addiction: going for it on fourth down. The guys break down the Jaguars’ pivotal decision to pass up points against Buffalo, why it felt even worse after a gifted short field, and how one empty possession can swing a playoff game. From there it turns into full Jets fan therapy. Calls flood in with trade-up fantasies for Fernando Mendoza, reality checks on what it would actually cost, and the clip that sent Jets hopes into a spiral when Mendoza names Tom Brady as his dream dinner guest. Plus: a debate on Ben Johnson’s “talking spicy” persona, whether he’s hard to root for, and why Sean McVay is the easy choice when likability becomes part of the playoff rooting chart.

Evan and Tiki open the phones on the Giants coaching search, but the conversation quickly pivots to the most entertaining game of Wild Card Weekend: Bills vs Jaguars. After Josh Allen’s ridiculous late push, the classic barstool argument erupts at the goal line. Do you take a knee at the 1 and bleed clock, or punch in the touchdown and trust your defense? Evan says it’s simple: if you need a touchdown, you take the touchdown, because nothing is guaranteed in the red zone. The crew debates the value of those 30 extra seconds, the risk of giving away a down, and why Buffalo’s past “13 seconds” trauma still hangs over every late game decision. Then the calls roll in, including a furious breakdown of a chaotic end of half sequence that nearly handed Jacksonville points and could have changed the entire game if the kick was made. And to top it off, Evan unloads on Tony Romo’s bizarre broadcast, from head scratching commentary to a moment where Romo somehow convinced himself a clear Josh Allen touchdown might not count.

The Packers melt down in an all time ugly loss to the Bears, and for a minute it feels like Matt LaFleur could actually be in trouble. Then Adam Schefter drops the update: Green Bay expects a new deal, and the conversation flips from “fire him” to “what if the contract talks get weird?” From there, Evan and Tiki zoom out to the Giants’ view of Wild Card Weekend and why it didn’t create any scary new openings. The real issue is the same one it’s been: the entire coaching market is basically stuck until John Harbaugh makes his move, with teams like the Giants and Browns convinced they have a shot. They debate the reported Harbaugh price tag, why the top coach available is going to push for top dollar, and how LaFleur’s postseason résumé has taken hits despite regular season success. Plus: Schefter’s “Packers connection” to Harbaugh, why it’s interesting but not needle moving, and what would actually make Green Bay a real threat if a vacancy somehow opened up.

Boomer & Gio on why the Oregon-Indiana College Football Playoff semifinal could shed more light on the Jets’ quarterback future. Plus, Craig Carton sounds off on Aaron Glenn’s arrogance (9:43); Carton and C-Mac also take calls on the Jets and discuss Breece Hall’s future (29:45); Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash listen to Glenn and GM Darren Mougey and react to their answers (45:41)

Craig Carton warns Giants fans not to crown John Harbaugh as the next head coach just yet. Plus, Boomer & Gio raise the possibility of the Eagles or Bills pursuing Harbaugh (22:57); Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash discuss the risks of going all in on Harbaugh and other coaches who could emerge (33:07); Tiki Barber argues he’d rather have Kevin Stefanski over Harbaugh (52:57); Craig and C-Mac on Stefanski sighting in New Jersey (1:10:00); Gio makes the case for Stefanski prior to Harbaugh news (1:25:20)

This week's highlights include James Dolan in studio with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to talk all things Knicks and Rangers, while MLB commissioner Rob Manfred also paid them a visit. Plus, Blueshirts legend Mark Messier in studio with Boomer and Gio, and Joe Benigno joined Evan and Tiki for a classic Jets rant.

This week's Knicks highlights include James Dolan's extensive in-studio interview with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, and the guys reacting to the interview and Dolan's expectations for this team. Plus, both Evan Roberts and Tommy Lugauer don't think there should be much concern with the team's recently-halted four-game losing streak.

Craig Carton shares breaking news that John Harbaugh is now available on the coaching market, much to the delight of C-Mac. Plus, SNY’s Connor Hughes delivers the latest on the Giants pursuit of Harbaugh (17:33); Evan & Tiki analyze Harbaugh’s playoff resume and hear from callers (39:31); Boomer & Gio on what Harbaugh needs to hear from the Giants front office (58:28), and what his staff could look like (1:15:11); Craig and C-Mac on what Giants need to do to secure Harbaugh (1:30:21).

The Dolphins make a GM decision that eases Giants fans worries, plus a Football Friday playoff edition with all the trimmings.

The Giants coaching search hits a fever pitch as the show debates why it suddenly feels like John Harbaugh is the one hire that changes everything, and why missing out could trigger a full fan meltdown. Evan and Tiki break down the Dolphins GM curveball, what it means for Harbaugh’s options, and why Kevin Stefanski is still a real long-term alternative. Plus, Giants fans call in on ownership, Joe Schoen’s role in the search, wild record predictions for next season, and the viral Jaxson Dart lip-reading moment that has everyone trying to decode the future.

Hour 2 starts with the mystery of Evan’s pre-recorded question for MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred that never made air, and the behind-the-scenes explanation from Craig Carton on why it got spiked. The guys finally reveal the question, argue whether it was fair or “too much,” and debate Manfred’s obsession with a salary cap and the financial gap between big and small markets. Then the conversation turns into full MLB confusion as Manfred talks realignment, geography, and keeping the Mets and Yankees separate, and nobody can quite agree on what he actually meant. Calls roll in to interpret it, while Evan vents about owners crying “unable” instead of “unwilling” to spend. Plus, the show pivots to Wild Card weekend storylines, including how often teams win rematches, and a fun deep dive into Tiki Barber’s playoff games where he faced an opponent for the third time in the same season. The hour also touches on the Giants coaching search optics, Evan’s choice between banishing Woody Johnson or Rob Manfred, and a Yankees offseason debate about Cody Bellinger’s market and whether Brian Cashman should pivot to Bo Bichette.

It’s Wild Card Weekend, so we’re playing the most dangerous game: who are we selfishly rooting for and why. The guys go matchup by matchup with Jets and Giants agendas all over the place, from hoping Carolina creates Bryce Young doubt (hello, Jets QB options) to rooting for pure chaos in Bears-Packers if it means more coaching openings. They also hit Bills-Jaguars, Eagles-Niners (and the John Harbaugh fear factor), plus the Patriots as the ultimate “please lose” postseason villain. Then it turns into full New York sports radio perfection: Cinco de Luncho takes over, Evan’s brain gets exposed, and the crew reacts to the Saquon Barkley billboard shot at Giants fans on I-95. Hour 3 also dips into Knicks/Wizards draft-pick drama, Giants coordinator continuity talk (Kafka, Dart development), and a college QB watch that turns tonight’s game into a Jets scouting mission. Key moments: rooting-interest power rankings, Giants coaching search circus, Saquon billboard outrage, Cinco de Luncho, and the phones lighting up with callers.

Hour 4: Could Trinidad Chambliss be the Next Jets QB? WFAN Jeopardy Controversy

The Mets choose not to hold FanFest, and the optics could not be worse. The guys break down why skipping a fan event makes the organization look scared of its own fans, especially when there is nothing new to celebrate. Outside of modest moves, nothing about this roster feels better than it did months ago, and fans can feel it. The conversation then pivots to the New York football picture, including Antonio Pierce emerging as a legitimate sleeper candidate in the New York Giants head coaching search if it is not John Harbaugh or Kevin Stefanski. From there, the show spirals into classic chaos, Cinco de Lunch energy, Wild Card Weekend rankings, draft obsession, quarterback scouting madness, and the brutal reality that most fans watch sports through selfish rooting interests. It is part Mets frustration, part Giants coaching intrigue, and part unhinged Friday sports radio at its finest, with food debates, cheese takes, and playoff chaos layered on top.

The guys kick off Wild Card Weekend by laying out their “selfish rooting interest” list, where Jets bitterness, Giants coaching paranoia, and pure chaos all collide. It starts with Rams-Panthers and a very specific agenda: hope Carolina’s Bryce Young doubt grows just enough to create more QB options for the Jets, while also keeping the Panthers from becoming a real future threat. Then it turns into Bears-Packers, where personal grudges (Ben Johnson), weather talk, and the dream of a coaching-search circus take center stage. If the Packers lose, does it crack open another job and send the league into full-blown coach chaos? That’s the debate. They hit Bills-Jaguars with the “maximum pain” theory for Buffalo fans, plus the Harbaugh ripple effects in Eagles-Niners, before the segment swerves into the Saquon billboard drama that feels like a direct shot at Giants fans. The back half includes Knicks-Wizards draft-pick paranoia, Giants OC continuity talk (Kafka and the Dart development angle), and a mini debate on why you can’t blindly trust AI without fact-checking.

Evan explains how he was promised a chance to ask Rob Manfred a question on the air, only to have it pulled at the last second for being “too disrespectful.” The show finally reveals the question about a salary cap, debates whether it crossed the line, and argues if it would have forced a real answer from the commissioner. Craig Carton explains why it never aired, while Tiki Barber compares his version of a Manfred question to how it was actually asked on the show. The segment then spirals into total confusion when Manfred discusses MLB realignment, geography, and keeping the New York Yankees and New York Mets out of the same division. Evan and Tiki try to decode what he actually meant, whether MLB is moving toward an East vs West conference model, and why the explanation left more questions than answers. The segment wraps with listener calls, World Baseball Classic timing debates, and breaking news that Ketel Marte is not being traded after weeks of rumors.

Evan takes the unpopular stance with Jets fans: you can’t fire Aaron Glenn after one season just to take a blind swing at John Harbaugh, especially when Harbaugh isn’t committing to anybody and might even consider taking a year off. That’s why Schefter’s reporting matters, and why the Dolphins were able to play it differently since they were already on the fence with Mike McDaniel. The conversation then flips back to the Giants, where the urgency is real, the fan base is locked onto one name, and the stakes feel enormous if ownership can’t close the deal. Calls roll in on whether Mara and Tisch need to directly recruit Harbaugh, what Joe Schoen’s role really is, and why being “Harbaugh or bust” might be unfair, but also totally inevitable.

The Giants coaching search has reached the point where it feels like one name is towering over everyone else: John Harbaugh. Evan explains why this has become a “massive disappointment” situation if the Giants don’t land him, even if the replacement is a proven coach like Kevin Stefanski or Mike McCarthy. Tiki pushes back with a reality check: Harbaugh could want a break, he might not want a rebuild, and nothing is guaranteed. The big question becomes simple: are Giants fans being reasonable… or is this officially turning into Harbaugh or heartbreak?

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The offseason is extremely slow moving. Even with it dragging, it feels like the direction is not going the right way for Mets fans. Evan takes you through all the latest rumors and where the Mets stand. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Tiki is back and prefers Stefanski to Harbaugh. Mike McDaniel gets fired in show leading to more Harbaugh speculation.

Hour 1 kicks off with the Giants coaching search heating up fast. With names like Bill Belichick floating out there, Tiki Barber drops a stunner: he’d lean Kevin Stefanski over John Harbaugh. The guys debate QB development, offensive upside, and why building the right staff might matter even more than the head coach. Plus, the “sure thing vs bust factor” argument, Harbaugh’s coordinator track record, and the one concern that could change everything: does Harbaugh still have the fire for a full rebuild in New York?

Hour 2 opens with some off the rails concert and weekend planning before the show snaps back to Giants business. The guys react to Joe Schoen basically bragging about how “cheap” the Giants’ core is, and debate if that’s smart roster building or a quote that could annoy his best players. Then it turns into full Harbaugh madness: why the Giants can’t assume anything, what factors really drive a coach’s decision, and the conflicting reports from the league’s biggest insiders on what actually happened in Baltimore. Plus, the Joe Schoen question hangs over everything, fans fear it could cost the Giants Harbaugh, and the crew makes official date and time predictions for when the Giants finally hire their next head coach. They wrap with Belichick talk, skepticism about his “I’m happy at North Carolina” line, and a larger debate about age, perception, and whether one recent coaching flop changed the market for older legends.

Hour 3 spirals fast as the guys revisit their preseason Super Bowl predictions and realize just how wide open and chaotic this playoff field really is. Updated picks get bold and uncomfortable with Jacksonville, Seattle, and Buffalo all in the mix, while trust in the NFC completely collapses. The conversation shifts back to the Giants coaching search, fan fear over “settling” for Kevin Stefanski, and Rex Ryan questioning whether Stefanski belongs in the elite tier. Tiki pushes back with a strong case for crisis management and leadership in New York. The hour ends with a full Northeast parent meltdown when the crew learns school may start before Labor Day, triggering boycott talk, PTA outrage, and an all time relatable rant.

The 4th and final hour of the Evan & Tiki Show

The crew debates the one question every baseball fan would want to ask Rob Manfred. The conversation dives into the widening financial gap in Major League Baseball, whether teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers are exploiting the system, and why a true salary cap could blow up the sport all over again. From fears of another labor war to the idea that would hit New York fans hardest, the possibility of the New York Yankees and New York Mets eventually sharing a division, this segment breaks down what really matters, what Manfred will never say out loud, and why one honest answer could change baseball’s future overnight.

Parents officially lose it after learning New York schools are starting before Labor Day. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun react in real time to the calendar shocker, threaten a full-scale parent boycott, and argue why the Northeast has one sacred rule you do not break. The conversation spirals into vacation chaos, NFL timing, snow days that never happen, and why this decision feels like a direct attack on families who plan their lives around that final summer week.

The crew revisits their preseason Super Bowl predictions and quickly realizes how wrong almost everyone was, highlighting just how wide open and chaotic this playoff field feels. Buffalo, Philly, Baltimore, Kansas City, and Green Bay all get put under the microscope as old picks get roasted and eliminated. From there, the discussion pivots to bold updated predictions, with Jacksonville, Seattle, the Rams, and Buffalo emerging as trendy and uncomfortable new favorites. The segment closes with a heated Giants coaching debate, as fans panic over the idea of Kevin Stefanski being the answer, Rex Ryan openly questions his résumé, and Tiki fires back with a strong defense centered on crisis management and surviving dysfunction in New York.

The guys put their reputations on the line by predicting the exact date and time the Giants’ next head coach will be reported by Schefter or Rapoport, not the press conference, the real breaking news moment. From there, the conversation swerves into a brutal reality check on Bill Belichick. Is the greatest resume in NFL history suddenly irrelevant? They dissect why the phone might not be ringing anymore, how Pete Carroll’s one and done stint changed league perception, and why age suddenly feels like a bigger factor than anyone wants to admit. Then it turns into a wide ranging debate on Harbaugh vs McCarthy, playoff failures, coaching “stench,” and whether history actually matters when hiring a Super Bowl caliber head coach.

What starts as a lighthearted detour into concert plans and feeling old quickly turns serious once Joe Schoen’s latest comments hit the table. The guys debate whether Schoen basically admitted the Giants’ best players are underpaid and if that kind of honesty helps roster building or risks irritating the locker room. From there, the conversation pivots back to John Harbaugh and why his decision may come down to far more than roster strength, including lifestyle, geography, and even old family ties to Cleveland. The segment heats up with conflicting reports from Ian Rapoport and Adam Schefter on whether Harbaugh truly lost the Ravens locker room, and Tiki explains why both sides can actually be true. The hour closes with mounting fan anxiety that retaining Joe Schoen could cost the Giants their dream coach and shape the narrative around this hire no matter how it ends.

The coaching carousel gets even crazier when Mike McDaniel suddenly becomes available, and the guys immediately frame him as a potential offensive coordinator jackpot, not the Giants head coach. They break down why his scheme is so “nerdy” and QB friendly, why Jaxson Dart could benefit from that kind of detail and precision, and why Stefanski and Harbaugh still sit in a different tier as head coach options. Plus, the conversation swings into the staff building obsession, the Dolphins emerging as a real Harbaugh threat, and the chaos theory: when an upgrade appears, teams start firing coaches just to get in the race.

Tiki Barber doubles down on his surprising stance in the Giants coaching debate, explaining why Kevin Stefanski edges out John Harbaugh for him. The discussion centers on QB development, staff building, and long term upside versus the comfort of a proven track record. The guys dig into Stefanski’s “boost factor,” Harbaugh’s elite résumé, concerns about burnout, and why the Giants may need hunger and fire as much as experience in their next head coach.

FULL SHOW: John Harbaugh is exactly what the Giants have been looking for, Evan gives the pros and cons of Harbaugh as an HC, Connor Hughes joins the show, Cinco De Lunch-O, and much more.

Hour 1 opens with a wild thought experiment: what if the Giants coaching market gets even crazier, with longshot names like Sean McVay or Matt LaFleur potentially entering the mix? With Shaun Morash filling in for Tiki, the show debates the core question every Giants fan is wrestling with: do you strike fast for John Harbaugh, or stay patient and let the full “historic” coaching class reveal itself? Evan argues the Giants cannot afford a waiting game where they lose Kevin Stefanski while hoping Harbaugh doesn’t pick a more playoff-ready “mystery team.” The conversation turns into a full breakdown of urgency versus patience, Rooney Rule logistics, and whether the Giants should have been interviewing candidates weeks ago to get a true head start. Then it gets even messier: Jets fans start dreaming about firing Aaron Glenn for a tiny shot at landing Harbaugh, leading to a heated debate about realism, desperation, and whether a “secret backchannel” is the only way to even find out if a coach would consider the job. The hour wraps with a spirited caller segment, resume comparisons (Harbaugh vs McCarthy), and a preview of a deep dive into why some Ravens fans turned on Harbaugh in recent years.

John Harbaugh’s playoff résumé compared to the Giants’ last 20 years sparks a brutal reality check, then the guys break down why Ravens fans actually turned on him. From big-game failures and conservative decisions to staff loyalty and late-season fades, every criticism gets aired out. Plus, a surprise contender emerges as a real threat in the Harbaugh sweepstakes with Cleveland entering the picture, fueled by deep family ties and an all-time White Castle honeymoon story. Calls pour in on whether Harbaugh would even choose the Giants, how much money should matter, and whether Joe Schoen helps or hurts New York’s case.

Hour 3 focuses on the latest reporting around John Harbaugh and whether Joe Schoen will actually factor into the Giants coaching decision. With early indications that Schoen is not a roadblock, the conversation centers on power dynamics, long term control, and why Harbaugh would immediately become the unquestioned voice in the room for the New York Giants. The hour then turns to intense debate and caller reaction on what happens if the Giants miss on Harbaugh, whether first time head coaches are even sellable to the fan base, and why this hire feels different than recent searches. It all builds to a heated on air showdown over Kevin Stefanski, complete with audio receipts, arguments over playoff wins, and a real time dispute about honesty, framing, and taking accountability on the air.

Hour 4: Connor Hughes Talks Harbaugh Sweepstakes, Shaun's Hat, and More on the Coaching Carousel.

Connor Hughes joins the show to deliver a deep dive into why momentum is building toward John Harbaugh becoming the next head coach of the New York Giants. Connor explains why the process will take time despite clear interest, how the Rooney Rule factors into the timeline, and why Harbaugh has quickly separated himself from the rest of the field. The conversation digs into the power dynamic between Harbaugh and Joe Schoen, whether ownership would reshape the front office to land a proven coach, and how Harbaugh’s presence would immediately change decision making inside the building. Connor also addresses competition from other potential openings, why the Giants are viewed as the most desirable vacancy, and whether candidates like Kevin Stefanski remain realistic alternatives. The interview wraps with expectations if Harbaugh is hired, from short term win projections to long term culture change, and Connor ultimately makes his call that all signs point toward Harbaugh and the Giants coming together sooner rather than later.

Edward Cabrera is off the board, and not to the Yankees. With Ken Rosenthal reporting the Cubs land the hard-throwing righty, the conversation shifts to what this means for New York’s offseason plan, why Cabrera made sense as a target (upside, velocity, control), and why the Cody Bellinger situation might be clogging up every other move. From there, it turns into a bigger picture Yankees debate: how badly do they really need another starter, what kind of trade is coming next, and what happens when the rotation logjam hits in May. Plus, the show veers into peak chaos with Harbaugh countdown talk, tanking jokes that can get you in trouble, and an all-time “take the L” moment as Sean gets called out on the Stefanski playoff win debate.

The Giants coaching search takes center stage as early reports suggest Joe Shane will not be a roadblock if John Harbaugh seriously considers the job. The discussion breaks down why Harbaugh would immediately hold the power in the room, how this hire could future proof the organization even if Shane is gone in a year, and why fans view Harbaugh as a rare no bust option. The conversation also spins into classic WFAN chaos with on air debates, caller reactions, awkward office stories, and plenty of laughs along the way.

Everyone assumes John Harbaugh choosing his next job is a straight Giants conversation, but there is one team that keeps popping up as a legitimate surprise contender. The Cleveland Browns. The guys break down why Cleveland should not be dismissed, digging into the Harbaugh family’s deep personal ties to the city, including stories passed down through Jim Harbaugh that reveal just how strong that emotional connection really is.

The numbers are staggering. John Harbaugh has won at least one playoff game in nine different seasons with the Baltimore Ravens, while the New York Giants have managed playoff wins in just ten seasons across the entire Super Bowl era. The guys dig into what that gap really means, how often Harbaugh has hosted playoff games, and why Giants fans are still dreaming of a January home playoff tailgate. The conversation then shifts to why Ravens fans turned on Harbaugh, breaking down the biggest criticisms from playoff failures and late game decision making to staff loyalty and late season collapses. Are those flaws deal breakers, or just the normal baggage that comes with any long tenured successful coach? Plus, a candid debate on whether Harbaugh is truly the best possible answer for the Giants right now, and why even elite resumes always come with real concerns.

The coaching carousel turns into chaos as the conversation shifts from the Jets to the Giants and back again. Should the Jets really consider firing a first year head coach just to chase a slim chance at landing John Harbaugh? And if money is the only leverage, would Woody Johnson have to make him the highest paid coach in NFL history to even listen?

The Giants are caught between temptation and patience as the coaching market heats up. Evan and Shaun debate whether chasing John Harbaugh is worth the risk of losing Kevin Stefanski, and why this search could turn historic fast. Desire, panic, and power plays collide as the New York Giants try not to blow the biggest hire of the decade.

Evan opens a chilly Tuesday in NYC with Shaun Morash filling in for Tiki, and it immediately turns into a full-blown Giants coaching search argument. Is Kevin Stefanski the clear best option for Big Blue, or is he being overrated because the other candidates feel like bigger risks? Evan and Shaun go back and forth on Stefanski’s résumé, the red flags, and why fans are split between “safe hire” and “dream hire” as names like Mike McCarthy, Brian Flores, and other coordinators get dragged into the debate. Then the conversation shifts to the New York Knicks after another ugly loss and a stretch of sloppy, low-effort basketball. Are the warning signs real, or is this just a January lull that good teams go through? Plus: a preview of what’s coming later in the show, including reaction to James Dolan’s appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, and hearing from Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey.

Hour 2 starts loose and gets weird fast before settling back into serious Giants talk. Evan, Shaun, and Tiki explain why they were standing during the show, joke through an awkward cold weather discussion, and set the table for a packed hour. The focus quickly turns to James Dolan’s in studio appearance, breaking down what stood out from his answers on the Knicks and Rangers. Dolan saying Leon Rose can overrule him sparks a real conversation about ownership, power, and trust, while his patience with Chris Drury frustrates Rangers fans and draws comparisons to the Giants sticking with Joe Schoen. From there, the Giants coaching search takes over again. Callers debate Kevin Stefanski versus Mike McCarthy, defensive minded hires versus offensive development for Jaxson Dart, and whether keeping Schoen could cost the Giants their top coaching choice. The Knicks slump, Trae Young trade rumors, and draft pick implications also get mixed in before the hour takes another sharp turn with an unforgettable Boomer Esiason massage story that completely hijacks the show.

Hour 3 centers on the question Giants fans actually want answered: why Joe Schoen is still the general manager. Evan and Shaun react to Schoen’s press conference and replay his explanation for keeping the job, then rip apart the idea that the Giants have merely “stubbed their toe.” The discussion turns into a blunt breakdown of accountability, ownership patience, and whether Schoen is underselling just how bad things have gone. The hour also dives into whether Jaxson Dart should have any input in the next head coaching hire. Schoen’s dismissive answer sparks frustration, with Evan arguing that listening to your young quarterback does not mean handing him the keys. The guys explain why ignoring Dart’s perspective sends the wrong message about development, leadership, and the future of the franchise. From there, the Giants coaching search opens back up. Kevin Stefanski, Mike McCarthy, Rex Ryan, Bill Belichick, and surprise candidates all come up, with a focus on who the Giants are most likely to hire rather than who fans want. Callers weigh in on dynastic ownership, why bad owners only fix things by accidentally hiring the right person, and whether the Giants should slow the process in case a major name becomes available. The hour ends with classic show chaos, including Jets misery comparisons, Olympic hockey arguments, media access stories, and a reminder of the hard truth of fandom: you scream, you argue, and then you hope you are wrong.

FULL SHOW: Evan and Shaun debate if Kevin Stefanski is the right hire as the new Giants Head Coach. Plus, reacting to Mougey and Glenn's press conference, Yankees offseason talk, Bill Belichick is not a legitimate HC candidate for the Giants, the Knicks have looked lifeless since the NBA Cup, and much more.

Hour 4: Darren Mougey & Aaron Glenn Speak but Did They Say Anything?

Evan and Shaun listen to Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey meet the media and react in real time, pausing after each answer to break down what was actually said… and what wasn’t. The Jets leadership promises to “exhaust every option” at quarterback, but the follow-ups (or lack of them) leave a lot hanging in the air. They debate whether the Fields signing was a clear mistake, why Glenn keeps hijacking answers meant for Mougey, and how much confidence fans should have in this staff’s ability to develop a young QB. Plus, the guys kick around potential defensive coordinator candidates (including a big name idea), question the bold “we can be competitive next year” claim, and point out why Jets talk always seems to turn into motivational slogans instead of real substance.

Time for Cinco de Lunch-o the show turns into a full-blown vent session for New York football fans. Evan and Shaun rank the five figureheads fans should be most furious with, starting with the Giants’ defensive mess and ending with the most infuriating answer of all: how the Giants can justify bringing Joe Schoen back. Along the way, they debate whether Aaron Glenn’s “tough guy” approach should matter, and why Jets ownership keeps making the job feel impossible. Then the show pivots into baseball with a hilarious MLB free agency bingo update where everybody whiffs on where Murakami would land. That leads into Evan’s frustration with the Mets and Yankees seemingly passing on a perfect fit from Japan, and why the price tag makes it even more annoying. The segment closes with a surprisingly honest conversation about being a sports fan: you scream, you vent, and then you’re forced to live with whatever your team does. Plus, a quick dive into early 2026 win totals and why Mets fans might have to accept an “86 wins is fine” mindset on January 6. Finally, the phones bring the chaos, including coaching takes, a Nets trade detour, and an all-time moment with a “17-year-old” caller who is definitely, absolutely, totally not cutting school.

Evan and Shaun dive into two key moments from Joe Schoen’s press conference and why Giants fans still aren’t buying what he’s selling. First, they react to Schoen being asked to justify keeping his job, and why his “course correction” explanation feels like it minimizes how bad things have gotten. Shaun lays out the kind of brutally honest answer he wishes Schoen gave, one that actually owns the misses and explains why the last two years should matter. Then comes the big topic that Giants fans care about most: should Jaxson Dart have any input on the next head coach? Schoen dismissing it sparks a debate about leadership, ego, and whether ignoring your young quarterback’s perspective is a massive mistake even if he’s not making the decision. The segment rolls into more Giants coaching talk with calls on what the team needs most, why waiting could matter in case a surprise candidate shakes loose, and the idea that the only thing that truly fixes “dynastic ownership” is accidentally hiring the right person and staying out of the way. Plus, a quick detour into Big Mac’s Dolan interview bet story, and whether the Giants should at least have a conversation with Bill Belichick before making the biggest hire of the offseason.

It’s a new edition of Posted and Toasted with old WFAN tweets resurfacing, including some very questionable takes that did not age well. The conversation then swings back to serious Giants coaching debate, comparing Kevin Stefanski, Mike McCarthy, Todd Bowles, and the risk of letting ownership decisions derail the search. Plus, a bizarrely unforgettable Boomer Esiason massage story, Knicks draft lottery intrigue tied to Trae Young rumors, and more calls from fans trying to make sense of everything.

Evan and Shaun dig into James Dolan’s appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle. They break down the short-term bet on Big Mac’s first question, Dolan’s comments on the Knicks, trade deadline expectations, and what it really means when Dolan says Leon Rose can overrule him. Then the conversation turns to the Rangers, Chris Drury, and Dolan preaching patience, which sparks frustration and skepticism. The Knicks slump comes back into focus with more reaction to their lack of effort and whether this rough stretch actually matters long term. Plus, more Giants coaching search calls, Kafka criticism, defensive coach debates, and a live report from Detroit after another ugly Knicks performance.

The Knicks get blown out by the Pistons and Evan says this isn’t a one-game overreaction, it’s a real slump that’s been building since the NBA Cup. The effort is awful, the ball movement has vanished, and the numbers are getting ugly, including Karl-Anthony Towns having the worst statistical game of his career and Jalen Brunson finishing with zero assists. Evan tries to calm the panic by pointing out even elite teams like OKC have hit a midseason wall too.

Evan says Kevin Stefanski feels like a solid option, but not the automatic answer many fans are demanding, pointing to Cleveland’s recent offensive struggles, head-scratching decisions, and the concern of a coach jumping right into another job after getting fired. Shaun pushes back hard, arguing Stefanski is the best available “CEO type” and the safest move compared to rolling the dice on coordinators, especially with a young quarterback like Jaxson Dart in place. The debate turns into a bigger question: is Stefanski a perfect fit for the Giants, or just the best option because the rest of the market is shaky? Plus, if the Giants want him and he turns them down, does that become a flashing warning sign about the organization and Joe Schoen’s presence?

We share the best reactions to the Giants' 34-17 win over the Cowboys and the decision to retain Joe Schoen from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show

WFAN presents a selection of conversations about the Jets and their season-ending blowout loss at the hands of the Buffalo Bills from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The New York Mets pass on another player as Kazuma Okamoto signs a 4 year deal with the Toronto Blue Jays. What is David Stearns doing? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Jets reach new lows to end of the year, he Giants officially keep Joe Schoen, and much more we we begin our reign in Mid Days

Evan and Tiki break down the brutal reality of the New York Jets after an embarrassing finish to the season and a disastrous first year under Aaron Glenn. They explain why Aaron Rodgers winning games in Pittsburgh does not mean the Jets made the wrong decision, and why keeping him would have actually made the future worse. The conversation dives into whether firing Aaron Glenn after one season would truly fix anything, or if it would push the Jets further into dysfunction. Evan lays out why “trust me” and “have faith” is not a real plan, while still arguing that a one and done firing may do more harm than good without a clear upgrade waiting. They examine how trading Sauce Gardner and Quinnen Williams changed the locker room, why the roster looked nonprofessional down the stretch, and how the Jets ended up here with so little talent on the field. Plus, a realistic look at the quarterback options, draft capital, cap space, and whether there is any legitimate reason for hope moving forward. It is an honest Black Monday discussion about a franchise at rock bottom and the dangerous choices that come next.

Hour 2 kicks off with the Giants making it official: Joe Schoen is staying as GM, and the debate instantly turns into one question, what does “stability” actually buy you when the wins are this low? Evan, Tiki, and Shaun Morris argue the case for and against running it back, and why the next head coach hire has to be a proven, veteran voice if the Giants are going to avoid another reset. Then it’s Jets time, as Evan unloads on the “trust me” messaging from the coaching staff and why faith is not a plan for a fanbase that’s watched quarterbacks and offenses collapse for years. The calls pour in on what the Jets should do next, what kind of coach can fix this, and whether leadership needs to address the noise. Plus, Black Monday chaos continues with more coaching dominoes falling around the league, including the Raiders moving on from Pete Carroll after one year, and a truly wild coaching rumor that has everyone reacting. Subscribe for more Evan and Tiki on WFAN, featuring real-time reactions, big-picture roster talk, and nonstop New York football therapy.

Joe Benigno joins Evan and Tiki and delivers a scorched-earth review of the Jets’ season, calling the last five weeks unwatchable and questioning how the head coach could possibly return. Joe blasts the historic lack of forced turnovers, the lifeless offense, and the embarrassing mistakes that made the Jets feel closer to a college team than an NFL franchise. From there, the conversation turns to what comes next: the value of the No. 2 pick, whether a quarterback is mandatory, and how the Jets avoid repeating the same rookie QB failures with a real veteran bridge. Joe weighs in on coaching candidates, why certain names would take the job, and what kind of coordinator hires are non-negotiable if the current regime stays. The hour closes with the Black Monday carousel, the most appealing openings, and a quick detour into Mets frustration before the show pivots back to a fanbase stuck between draft hope and total exhaustion.

Hour 4: Raiders Coaching Chaos, 4th-Down Analytics Debates & Jets/Giants Predictions Revisited

The debut of Cinco de Lunch gets heated as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun argue why the Giants’ late-season win might have done more harm than good. From wrecked draft position to missed trade leverage, the crew breaks down the five reasons this victory felt hollow for Giants fans who sat through months of misery only to lose ground when it mattered most. The conversation expands into a bigger debate about tanking, draft lotteries, and whether the NFL is headed toward a system that rewards losing. Callers weigh in on whether the Giants are actually one of the most appealing coaching jobs on the market, how much draft position really matters, and why fans feel stuck between wanting wins and needing change. It’s a loud, messy, and brutally honest lunchtime segment that captures everything broken about late-season football for losing teams.

Joe B joins Evan and Tiki for a must-hear, no-filter interview as Black Monday fallout hits full force. Joe unloads on the Jets keeping Aaron Glenn after a historically brutal finish, calling it one of the most embarrassing stretches of football he’s ever seen. The conversation dives into why this coaching staff can’t be trusted to develop a young quarterback, what the Jets should do with the No. 2 pick, and whether drafting a franchise QB into this situation is setting him up to fail. Joe also lays out his blueprint for fixing the roster, from adding a real veteran quarterback to overhauling a broken defense, plus his thoughts on Rex Ryan, Mike McCarthy, Kliff Kingsbury, and why this job still isn’t attractive to top coaches. The interview wraps with Super Bowl predictions, Mets frustration, and classic Joe B rants that hit like a fastball.

With Joe Schoen officially returning, the Giants conversation turns into a full-on tug of war between two realities: is the roster quietly close, or is this just stability theater after another lost season? Evan owns the take he got wrong, Tiki meets him halfway, and the core argument becomes clear, the next head coach has to be experienced, because the margin for error is gone. The debate hits everything Giants fans fight about: how much of the losing was coaching versus roster building, whether Schoen can be trusted with another major hire, and why “meaningful December football” has to be the standard in 2026. Then it gets spicy with a back-and-forth on the salary cap, keeping key free agents like Jermaine Eluemunor and Wan’Dale Robinson, and whether the Giants are actually in a healthy spot or just kicking the can like everyone else. Plus, fan calls, Mike McCarthy as a real option, frustration with “stability” as an excuse, and the big question hovering over it all: if the roster is better, why does it keep looking worse?

Breaking news hits right away as the Giants officially retain Joe Schoen, and the debate turns into a full Black Monday autopsy: is continuity the smart play, or is ownership settling for “good enough” after back to back ugly seasons? The guys break down why the next head coach hire has to be a proven veteran, what “meaningful December football” actually looks like, and why the Giants feel closer than their record suggests.

On Black Monday, the Jets and Giants seasons officially come to an end, and the focus shifts from speculation to hard truths. The Giants retain Joe Schoen in the name of stability, while the Jets face tougher questions after another embarrassing finish. The conversation centers on continuity versus chaos, why front offices crave stability when hiring a head coach, and whether hope and faith are enough to sell a broken fan base. Plus, a blunt reaction to Aaron Glenn’s “trust me” answer, why belief without evidence falls flat, and how both franchises now face defining decisions at quarterback that will shape the next decade.

The Jets hit rock bottom over the final weeks of the season, and the frustration is justified. But this segment digs into why firing the head coach after one year could actually make a bad situation worse. From a noncompetitive roster and brutal point differentials to a locker room shaken by midseason trades, the conversation centers on why patience may be the smarter gamble when there is no clear upgrade waiting. It is a hard look at a franchise with no quick answers, no obvious savior, and a future that cannot be repaired by panic decisions.

Boomer & Gio on Joe Schoen’s standing within the Giants organization. Plus, Chris McMonigle on potential Giants coaching candidates and why Schoen remaining is hardly a surprise (11:21); C-Mac is rooting for the Giants to lose on Sunday (20:46); Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash dispute the narrative Jaxson Dart is prone to concussions (36:38); Brian Baldinger on the appeal of the Giants coaching job (48:34); C-Mac explains why Eli Manning deserves to be in the Hall of Fame (54:36).

Jon Heyman joins Marc Malusis to discuss the latest rumors around the Yankees and the direction they’re going in what has been a quiet offseason. Plus, Jerry Recco and Willie Colon speculate what the plan is for the Bronx Bombers (8:40); Chris McMonigle refutes the notion the Yankees are ‘dysfunctional’ with Hal Steinbrenner calling the shots (15:57); C-Mac also says do not expect the Yankees to make a splash (24:20)

Joe Benigno joins Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber to voice his disdain for the Aaron Glenn Jets; Boomer and Gio weigh in on Glenn’s future (22:09); Jets beat reporter Al Iannozzone joins Marc Malusis on why Glenn will likely get another year (38:50); Shaun and Tiki on whether or not the Jets coaches are in over their heads (56:21); Shaun and Tiki also discuss if Joe Burrow really is a realistic option for the Jets (1:08:23).

A Football Friday and farewell to the afternoons.

Evan doesn’t feel excited about who would replace Aaron Glenn

Evan started WFAN when New York sports were in a different place

A trip down memory lane in Jets draft history

Tips down Cinco Memory Lane plus our NFL Picks

The 5 Best moments on Evan and Tiki from the afternoon run

One final Tommy vs Shaun War

We make our predictions for 2026.

The Giants have a list of coaches they want to interview, do any excite us?

Are the Giants going to blowout the Cowboys?

C-Mac on the Giants running the risk of missing out on a top 5 daft pick. What should the Jets do with Aaron Glenn? Is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer? Are the Yankees dysfunctional?

C-Mac gives Giants fans a hard truth about Eli Manning's case to be in the Hall of Fame.

C-Mac says the Giants have a brighter future than the Jets.

C-Mac says Hal isn't that much worse than George. Where does Aaron Judge rank amongst Yankee greats in the 21st century?

C-Mac says Hal isn't that much worse than George, contrary to most fans' beliefs.

C-Mac on the ways that the NFL and MLB can make positives changes for 206 and beyond. Are the Yankees a dysfunctional franchise?

C-Mac says despite the lack of championships, Hal is not running a "dysfunctional" franchise.

C-Mac says the NFL and MLB need to make some changes for the better.

C-Mac debates callers on if tanking is bad for sports and younger generations who look up to these pro athletes.

C-Mac on the best New Year's Eve traditions, if there are any.

C-Mac says it's very important that Giants secure a top 2 pick in the 2026 draft by losing to the Cowboys.

C-Mac is starting to change his mind on what the Giants should do with GM Joe Schoen.

C-Mac opens the show by saying he is rooting for the Cowboys to beat the Giants in the season finale.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on the Giants and Jets' coaching situations, what offseason additions each team could make, Jaxson Dart's rookie season, and the Knicks' All-Star chances.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss whether or not the Jets should keep head coach Aaron Glenn for next season and what the team can do at the quarterback position going forward.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the narratives surrounding Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart, whether or not he has a problem with concussions, and if Saints QB Tyler Shough has looked better under center this season.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber spend the third hour of Tuesday's show discussing what Giants and Jets offseason targets are realistic, if the Jets' coaching staff is in too deep with this roster, and if the roster is so bad that it's unfair to fire Aaron Glenn.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber give you a New Years-themed Cinco de Five Oh, discuss the Giants and Jets' coaching situations, ask what coaches could be available, and talk some Knicks.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the first NBA All-Star fan voting returns, which feature several Knicks players but had superstar Jalen Brunson surprisingly come in third place.

Shaun presents Tuesday's Cinco de Five Oh to Tiki Barber. The 5 worst New Year's Resolutions, brought to you by Helix Wireless.

Shaun Morash hosts a new game called Real or No Real, where he poses potential offseason targets for the Giants and Jets to Tiki Barber in search of just how realistic that player (or coach) coming to New York could be.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss how fair it is to call for Aaron Glenn's firing when the Jets' roster is this gutted.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the start to Aaron Glenn's tenure as New York Jets head coach and ask if the team is best-served moving on now.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber lament the discourse surrounding Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart, whether or not Tyler Shough has a better case for OROY than him, and get fired up over the narrative that he is prone to concussions because of his playstyle.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber talk about the Los Angeles Rams' Monday Night Football loss to the Atlanta Falcons, which Shaun thinks happened because they were too reliant on analytics ... and Tiki reacts.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber open Tuesday's show by discussing Aaron Glenn's future as the Jets head coach - and whether or not he should have one.

Jerry Recco and Chris McMonigle discuss if it’s time to clean house. Marc Malusis on the Jets’ ‘historically bad’ performance against the Patriots (10:13), and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on if the lack of fight is indicative of Aaron Glenn’s future (28:14)

Jerry Recco and Chris McMonigle wonder where the Giants season went wrong? Marc Malusis believes the Giants showed they have talent (7:48), and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on why Sunday’s win is meaningful despite losing the No. 1 pick (18:38).

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber open the week by reacting to the Giants and Jets' weekend woes and questioning Joe Schoen, Jaxson Dart, and Aaron Glenn's futures in New York.

Shaun Morash and TIki Barber get the week started by wondering what the Giants and Jets have planned next, if the Giants are keeping QB Jaxson Dart and GM Joe Schoen, and how hot Aaron Glenn's seat should be amid an abysmal start.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber spend the second hour of Monday's show discussing the Giants futures of General Manager Joe Schoen and first-round draft pick Jaxson Dart, as well as filtering in some news around the NFL.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are joined by Joe Benigno, who says he's done with Aaron Glenn, and look around at the NFL playoff picture with the Week 18 schedule having been released.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber spend Hour 4 of Monday's show going through Shaun's five ways to fix the NFL, Deonte Banks' return touchdown and future in NY, and take YOUR calls.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss Deonte Banks' return touchdown against the Raiders, his standing on the Giants, and what he can learn from Tiki about learning to love everything about the game of football.

Shaun Morash gives Tiki Barber five ways to fix the NFL for Monday's Cinco de Five Oh.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber break down the NFL's Week 18 schedule and discuss which teams will look to win or lose as the season winds down.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are joined by Joe Benigno for his weekly spot on the show. This week's included plenty of ire being directed toward Aaron Glenn and Woody Johnson, for continuing to employ him.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate the merits of the Giants looking to see if Browns HC Kevin Stefanski becomes a free agent as well as field some calls with suggestions for the NFL's tanking problem.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss a pregame non-report from Ian Rapoport that Joe Schoen is expected to stay as the Giants' general manager "through the draft," as well as Jaxson Dart's standing with the organization.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber discuss the merits of tanking in professional sports in the wake of the Giants' win over the Raiders and another blowout loss by the Jets.

Shaun Morash and TIki Barber open Monday's show by discussing if the Giants lost by winning against the Raiders - and how hot Aaron Glenn's seat should be amid the Jets' disaster season.

Evan & Tiki question which is more valuable to the Giants: Jaxson Dart or the No. 1 pick? Plus, Marc Malusis on why he believes this weekend’s game vs. the Raiders is the Giants’ Super Bowl for draft capital (18:43); Malusis also expresses skepticism he has about Fernando Mendoza (32:12); Shaun Morash and Tiki dive into Dart liking a video of C-Mac’s criticism of the Giants (45:41); Jerry Recco and Willie Colon if it’s worth playing Jaxson Dart if the goal is to tank (55:20).

Joe Benigno joins Shaun Morash to talk Jets’ future and NFL Draft trade possibilities. Plus, Morash and Tiki discuss if Gang Green could realistically target Lamar Jackson in a trade; Jerry Recco and Willie Colon on whether the Jets should pursue a rookie or veteran QB; Marc Malusis entertains the possibility of a Jets-Giants draft trade for the No. 1 pick; Jerry and Willie dissect what went wrong with Justin Fields and also whether or not the Jets are stuck going nowhere.

The Mets have continued taking a sledgehammer to the team's core, trading Jeff McNeil to the A's. Jerry Recco doesn't understand the plan after parting with several key contributors, while Evan says there better be additions coming soon. Plus, Marc Malusis says the Mets are clearly David Stearns' team now, and he better get it right.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The dust has finally settled on Brandon Nimmo being traded away from the Mets. Evan gave it some time and made sure he was able to give Nimmo a proper tribute show. So without further disruption we present the top 10 moments of Brandon Nimmo as a New York Met. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): It's not a literal bag of balls, but it sure feels that way. Jeff McNeil has been shipped out to the Athletics along with $5.75M in cash for a 17 year old pitcher Yordan Rodriquez. While this sounds like a great move to get rid of more of the core, what are we doing in the outfield? Evan breaks it down! To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Full Show: Harbaugh to Giants? Lamar to Jets? Dart a WFAN listener? and is Home Alone a Christmas movie?

Hour 1: If John Harbaugh is out in Baltimore, the Giants should run to hire him. Plus, if Lamar wants out, the Jets should go get him.

Hour 2: Jaxson Dart liked a WFAN post calling out the Giants. Plus, a brand new edition of Posted and Toasted

Hour 3: Joe B. joins the Show and Tiki Does Last Minute Christmas Shopping

Hour 4: The guys debate the best and worst Christmas Movies

Cinco de Five Oh - The top 5 Christmas Characters

Joe Benigno wonders if the Giants would help the Jets by trading the first overall pick.

Jaxson Dart liked a video of C-Mac bashing the Giants current regime

If things keep going south in Baltimore, should the Jets try to trade for Lamar Jackson?

Boomer & Gio take calls from fed-up Jets fans. Plus, Marc Malusis (11:20) and Evan & Tiki (27:30) react to the loss and talk Aaron Glenn’s future.

Boomer and Gio react to the Giants’ 16-13 loss to the Vikings and wonder if Jaxson Dart should still be playing. Plus, reactions from Marc Malusis (7:13) and Evan & Tiki (21:22)

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Steve Cohen fights back on the Payroll criticism from the MEDIA, not the fans, let them be pissed. Plus, Luis Robert he next target for David Stearns? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan and Tiki talk the Giants loss to the Vikings, Jets loss to the Saints and jump around the NFL. They also talk about if domes are ending the mystique of the NFL, Jeff McNeil being traded from the Mets and this being their last show on SNY as a duo.

Evan and Tiki talk about Jaxson Dart's "regression" after his awful performance against the Vikings on Sunday. They then talk about the sports radio gold that would happen if the Giants had the number one pick in the upcoming NFL Draft.

Evan and Tiki talk about the breaking news that the Mets traded Jeff McNeil. They then talk about the Chiefs moving to the state of Kansas and how that domed stadium might be changing the face of the NFL.

Evan and Tiki talk about the QB future for the Jets and the wave that happened at the Jets-Saints.

Evan and Tiki talk about Tommy's Cinco about next Giants Head Coach Candidates as well as talk about their last ever show on SNY during the afternoons.

Tommy give his top 5 names for the next Head Coach of the Giants.

Evan and Tiki discuss the ramifications of the Jets 29-6 loss to the Saints.

The show reacts to the breaking news that the Mets have traded INF Jeff McNeil to the Athletics.

Evan and Tiki discuss the values of Jaxson Dart and the #1 overall pick in the upcoming NFL Draft,

Evan and Tiki open up their Monday show by talking about the reasons why Jaxson Dart struggled mightily against the Vikings on Sunday afternoon.

Boomer & Gio discuss the outlook for the rest of the Jets season and why they should position themselves to draft Fernando Mendoza. Plus, Boomer & Gio wonder if Aaron Glenn will be one and done; Brandon Tierney believes the Jets must tank the rest of the season; Evan Roberts asks Tiki Barber if he would want Mendoza in New York; Tierney reacts to the Jets firing of Steve Wilks.

Brandon Tierney, Boomer & Gio (18:46), and Evan & Tiki (33:47) all react to the Knicks winning the NBA Cup in-season tournament and what it means for the franchise and rest of season. Plus, Evan says the Knicks are not obligated to raise a banner for the NBA Cup (51:06); Marc Malusis makes the case to keep the core intact and not go after Giannis (1:02:31); Boomer wonders if this could be the Knicks’ year? (1:17:04)

Luke Weaver is heading to the Mets, and both Evan and Morash believe it could turn out to be a high-reward signing. McMonigle agrees, but wonders why the salary was as high as it was. Plus, Moose sounds off on David Stearns' philosophies that led to losing Pete Alonso, and McMonigle says the team is having a brutal offseason so far.

Brandon Tierney says the Yankees better not lose Bellinger to the Mets, or it will be the biggest embarrassment of the Hal Steinbrenner era. He also believes the Yanks should load up on pitching and revamp their identity in 2026. Marc Malusis rips the organization's complacency, and the Evan and Tiki crew lament New York's quiet offseason.

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti cover wall to wall NFL for week 16. Jets fire their defensive coordinator. Commanders went after Jaxson Dart. Texans are the team to beat and QB carousel for 2026. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Mets Owner takes to Twitter, Carton and McMonigle stop by, plus a Football Friday with picks and more.

The Mets owner breaks his silence on twitter, but what does it mean?

Did last night give us a hot mic moment in sports we will never forget?