It is two days before Packers-Jets. a White Out is in effect, NFL Picks, and all the Football Friday trimmings.

Josh Allen and the Bills open their new stadium by overwhelming Detroit, giving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber a sobering reminder of what the Jets are chasing in the AFC East. They marvel at Allen’s rare combination of passing, rushing, durability and regular-season dominance, while debating whether his legacy ultimately depends on finally winning a Super Bowl. The Jets may never find a quarterback better than Allen, but Evan argues they can still build a roster capable of beating Buffalo. The conversation shifts to why the Jets have a real opportunity against Green Bay, especially if they can control the game on the ground. Plus, the Giants’ fast start sparks optimism that John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart can create lasting stability, while a frightening Jared Young collision leads to criticism of the Mets’ national broadcast for discussing his future while he was being treated.

Jets fans have officially inherited New York’s desperation crown, at least according to Evan Roberts. Evan argues that years of losing have made Jets fans more passionate than Knicks fans after New York’s championship, sparking a heated debate with Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash over whether winning actually changes a fan base’s hunger. The hour also digs into encouraging signs around Aaron Glenn, including Demario Davis calling the Jets’ in-season practices some of the hardest he has experienced. Plus, the guys debate how the Mets should handle Howie Rose’s final broadcast if bad weather threatens Sunday’s ceremony, compare Josh Allen’s championship pressure to Aaron Judge’s, and revisit the controversy over whether O.J. Simpson should still be acknowledged in Buffalo Bills history.

The Jets want MetLife Stadium covered in white, but Evan Roberts isn’t buying in. Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether fans should feel obligated to follow the team’s whiteout request, why the Jets should provide shirts or white ponchos, and whether the entire promotion makes the franchise look cheap. Tiki explains why rainy weather could actually favor the Jets against Green Bay, while the crew also weighs Aaron Donald’s possible return against the Giants, Dan Campbell’s costly decisions, Aaron Judge’s chances of playing this weekend, and the safest NFL knockout-pool picks.

Tiki Barber details the technical changes he made to secure the football, explaining why ball security is a matter of physics rather than psychology. They provide rooting guides for Giants and Jets fans before making their official Week 2 NFL picks and debating historical MLB sabotage. (00:02:01) New York Football Rooting Guide (00:07:44) Winning vs. Tanking Debate (00:11:25) Physics of Ball Security (00:17:31) Jets Whiteout Gear Debate (00:21:02) Giants Super Bowl Hype (00:25:36) Idiots with Idioms (00:34:06) 2001 World Series Betrayal (00:37:01) Week 2 NFL Picks (00:45:31) Deonte Banks Injury Status

The Jets want MetLife Stadium covered in white, but Evan Roberts isn’t buying the plan. With fans being asked to wear white without getting free shirts, Evan rips the organization for looking cheap and predicts the whiteout could fall flat. Tiki Barber and callers debate whether fans should simply embrace the request, while the Jets’ plan to distribute ponchos only adds another wrinkle. The conversation also hits Aaron Donald’s possible return against the Giants, Dan Campbell’s questionable late-game decisions, Aaron Glenn’s changed approach with the Jets, and the Pro Football Hall of Fame’s revamped voting process.

Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti: Week 1 reaction, Josh Allen's MVP performances, and Week 2 picks

Aaron Judge and Josh Allen may play different sports, but Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash see the same pressure building around both superstars. Each has reached the top tier of his sport, but the conversation has shifted from individual greatness to one demand: win a championship. That comparison leads back into the fight over sports fandom and desperation. Evan argues that fan bases like the Mets and Jets create a different atmosphere because they have waited so long to win, while Shaun pushes back on the idea that previous championships make fans less desperate. The guys also debate whether belief, rather than desperation, is what creates those unforgettable playoff crowds, and Evan notices one surprising trend among young Knicks fans: Karl-Anthony Towns jerseys everywhere.

Evan Roberts says Jets fans have become New York’s most desperate and passionate fan base now that Knicks fans have finally celebrated a championship, and that claim sets off a heated argument. Tiki Barber sides with Evan, while Shaun Morash pushes back and argues that winning does not make fans any less desperate for another title. The debate turns into a larger fight over whether championship-starved fans experience sports differently from those who have already tasted success. Plus, Evan revisits his controversial stance that O.J. Simpson’s football accomplishments should still be acknowledged in Bills history without necessarily honoring Simpson himself, and the guys return to how the Mets should handle Howie Rose’s farewell if weather disrupts his final home broadcast.

Howie Rose’s final Mets broadcast could be threatened by miserable weather, and Evan Roberts wants the franchise prepared to give the legendary voice a proper sendoff. From moving Sunday’s game into a Saturday doubleheader to bringing Rose back for one final call on Opening Day next season, Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate how the Mets can avoid an anticlimactic farewell. The Jets are also showing early signs that Aaron Glenn’s demanding approach may be working. Demario Davis says the team’s in-season practices are among the hardest he has experienced, fueling optimism about Glenn’s defense and leadership. Plus, the guys marvel at Josh Allen playing through illness and question whether Tyrone Tracy’s flu should keep him off the field Monday.

A frightening collision leaves Jared Young motionless on the field, but the Fox broadcast quickly becomes part of the story. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question the decision to discuss Young’s future with the Mets while he was still being treated, arguing that the timing of Ken Rosenthal’s report felt completely wrong even after Young gave a thumbs-up. The conversation then takes a sharp turn when a caller rips Evan for praising “O Canada.” Evan doubles down, insisting that liking another country’s anthem does not make him unpatriotic and declaring once again that “America the Beautiful” is simply a better song than “The Star-Spangled Banner.”

John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart have completely changed the outlook for the Giants. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that fans should temper expectations, arguing that this team should not be afraid of getting good faster than expected. Unlike the 2022 Giants with Brian Daboll and Daniel Jones, they see Harbaugh and Dart as a foundation capable of delivering sustained success and keeping the franchise from falling back into dysfunction. The Jets also enter their matchup with Green Bay believing they have a legitimate path to victory. With the Packers struggling to stop the run, Evan and Tiki want the Jets to lean into their identity, control the clock and produce another punishing, double-digit-minute drive.

Josh Allen’s dominance puts the Jets’ long-term challenge in sharp focus. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber marvel at Allen’s rushing ability, durability and command of Buffalo’s offense after another explosive Bills performance, while acknowledging how difficult it will be for the Jets to eventually knock Buffalo off in the AFC East. But Allen’s career still comes with one massive question: can he finally win a Super Bowl? Evan and Tiki debate how much January success should define an otherwise brilliant quarterback, why Patrick Mahomes still gets the edge in the postseason, and whether Allen will eventually break through. They also explain why the Jets do not necessarily need a quarterback as good as Allen to beat Buffalo, pointing to the Rex Ryan era as proof that the right roster can still take down a superior quarterback.

Pete Alonso didn't take long to hit his 301st home run of his career as he sends one to the seats in he series finale. Follow that up with three more home runs later in the game and the Orioles beat up on the Mets. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Aaron Judge is injured again, is there worry? Plus Evan has an issue with the Jets home opener

Aaron Judge’s latest injury scare has the Yankees staring at a major October concern. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how worried fans should be after Judge exited with lower-body tightness, whether he can possibly be fully healthy for the postseason, and why protecting him as the designated hitter may now be necessary. That decision could force major lineup changes involving Ben Rice, Luis Garcia, George Lombard Jr. and Anthony Volpe. With the AL East slipping away, the Yankees’ priority shifts toward getting ready for October. Plus, Evan unloads on Pete Alonso’s surprising Yankee Stadium comment after his emotional return to Citi Field, while the crew examines why the Mets’ failure to properly replace Alonso made his homecoming even more painful for fans.

Steve Cohen standing and applauding Pete Alonso’s game-tying 300th career home run sets off Evan Roberts. Evan’s frustration is not simply that the Mets owner celebrated a moment that hurt his own team. It is that Cohen could have kept Alonso in New York, never made him an offer this offseason, then publicly celebrated his return to Citi Field. Tiki Barber is far less bothered, while Shaun Morash questions what Cohen’s reaction says to the players still wearing Mets uniforms. The hour also turns to Garrett Wilson’s understanding of long-suffering Jets fans and Alijah Vera-Tucker admitting how losing can become normal. Evan predicts Elliott Ramos will make a postseason impact for the Yankees, the Knicks’ championship ticket prices spark disbelief, and the Giants-Rams matchup creates a hilarious debate over whether Shaun should use the Rams as emotional insurance in his knockout pool.

The Knicks abruptly paused individual ticket sales after opening-night prices soared past $1,000 for the cheapest seats, blaming a pricing mistake and promising refunds. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether it was truly an error or whether fan backlash forced Madison Square Garden to reverse course. Plus, Tiki explains Tyrone Tracy’s fumbling problem and why ball security could decide the Giants’ matchup with the Rams, the crew revisits how Yankee fans welcomed Reggie Jackson back to the Bronx, and Evan refuses to let the Jets bully him into wearing white for their home-opener whiteout against Green Bay.

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate the Buffalo Bills' decision to exclude O.J. Simpson from the Wall of Fame at their new stadium. They also discuss the New York Jets' controversial whiteout home opener and provide picks for the Thursday Night Football matchup between the Bills and the Detroit Lions. (00:01:50) Juan Soto Position Change (00:04:50) Jets Whiteout Game Controversy (00:10:45) Mets Management and David Stearns (00:17:14) O.J. Simpson Wall of Fame (00:29:30) Bills vs Lions TNF Picks (00:34:15) New York Jets Identity (00:38:05) Weather and Jets Game Prep

The Bills’ decision to leave O.J. Simpson off the Wall of Fame display at their new stadium turns into a much more uncomfortable debate for New York sports. Evan argues that Simpson’s football history should still be acknowledged, while Tiki believes Buffalo is justified in moving on from a player whose legacy became defined by far more than football. Then the argument comes home to the Giants. Lawrence Taylor becomes the key example as Evan challenges where teams should draw the line when honoring controversial franchise legends. If O.J. is removed from public celebration, what standard should New York teams apply to their own complicated icons?

Yankee fans criticizing Mets supporters for cheering Pete Alonso have a problem: history shows the Bronx did the same thing for Reggie Jackson. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash revisit Jackson’s 1982 return to Yankee Stadium, when fans gave him a huge ovation after he homered off Ron Guidry, and Shaun unloads on anyone trying to lecture Mets fans now. The crew also debates the Jets’ first-ever whiteout against Green Bay, with Evan refusing to ditch his green jersey just because the team asked fans to wear white. Plus, the Yankees’ fading AL East hopes hinge on Tampa Bay finally losing, and Sterling Shepard’s return to New York inspires a look at some of the strangest crosstown reunions in local sports.

The Knicks suddenly paused individual ticket sales after opening-night seats appeared with a get-in price above $1,000. Madison Square Garden blamed a pricing mistake, promised to roll prices back to last year’s levels plus a 12% increase and said buyers would receive refunds. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Knicks genuinely screwed up or simply retreated after getting hammered by fans. The conversation then shifts to Jameis Winston’s growing importance with the Giants. Tiki explains why Winston has become such a valuable leader behind Jaxson Dart, while the crew points to one sideline moment that showed exactly how quickly Winston looks out for the Giants quarterback.

Tyrone Tracy’s ball security is becoming a serious concern for the Giants, and Tiki Barber explains exactly what the running back is doing wrong. Tiki breaks down the technique he used to eliminate fumbling from his own game and why one mistake against an elite opponent can completely change a game. Evan Roberts and Tiki also wonder what John Harbaugh’s actions will reveal about Tracy’s role, especially with Najee Harris pushing for opportunities. The conversation also turns to the Yankees’ catching situation after Ali Sánchez appeared unaware the game had ended, plus a fascinating Jets hypothetical: would Josh Allen have failed in New York, and would Sam Darnold have developed much faster in Buffalo?

The Giants’ matchup with the Rams turns into a hilarious fight over “emotional insurance” as Evan Roberts argues Shaun Morash should take Los Angeles in his knockout pool. The logic is simple: if the Giants pull the upset and start 2-0, Shaun will be too euphoric to care that his pool entry is dead. Shaun strongly disagrees, insisting there are smarter survivor options and no reason to risk thousands of dollars against his own team. The guys also look at the Knicks bringing recognizable veterans Bruce Brown and James Wiseman to training camp, plus Jacoby Brissett’s surprising run of passing production and why his career has made him an ideal veteran backup quarterback.

Steve Cohen standing and applauding Pete Alonso’s game-tying 300th career home run creates a heated debate over what the Mets owner was really celebrating. Evan Roberts is bothered less by the applause itself and more by the fact that Cohen could have kept Alonso, never made him an offer this offseason, then welcomed him back and cheered one of his biggest moments. Shaun Morash sees another problem: Cohen was applauding a home run that hurt his own team, which sends a strange message after years of owners insisting every game matters. Tiki Barber is less bothered, but the conversation turns to how Mets players might view the moment and whether Cohen’s handling of Alonso now feels contradictory.

Garrett Wilson understands exactly what Jets fans have endured, and Evan Roberts loves that the star receiver knows how quickly New York will rally around a team that finally gives them something to believe in. Wilson’s comments about rewarding the fan base spark a bigger conversation about why Jets fans remain so passionate despite years of losing. That leads to a revealing contrast with former Jet Alijah Vera-Tucker, who admits the losing eventually became something players could grow numb to. Tiki Barber explains why changing that culture takes more than individual players, then breaks down why advanced football grades can be misleading without knowing each player’s exact assignment. Evan also makes a bold prediction that Elliott Ramos will deliver for the Yankees in the postseason.

Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field ends with a comment that rubs Evan Roberts the wrong way. After Alonso says New York feels like a homecoming whether he’s at Citi Field or Yankee Stadium, Evan argues that lumping the two ballparks together diminishes the love Mets fans just showed him. Tiki Barber sees it as a harmless, if awkward, remark as the debate over Alonso’s relationship with New York continues. The Yankees also have decisions to make with October approaching. With the AL East essentially gone, Evan and Tiki debate whether this is the time to experiment with Luis Garcia at second base and even give Anthony Volpe a look at third.

Aaron Judge’s lower-body injury could force the Yankees into a major postseason lineup shuffle. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Judge now needs to become the designated hitter, what that would mean for Ben Rice and Luis Garcia, and whether the Yankees can trust Garcia defensively at second base with October approaching. The concern goes beyond whether Judge will return. The Yankees need his bat, but protecting him in the field could create difficult decisions everywhere else. Plus, the conversation shifts to Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field and why the Mets’ failure to adequately replace him has made fans miss him even more.

Aaron Judge’s latest injury scare has the Yankees facing an uncomfortable question just before the postseason. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how concerned fans should be after Judge left with a lower-body issue, with Evan believing the early signs suggest this is not a season-ending injury while Tiki warns that Judge has only recently returned and may not be fully ready for the grind. The bigger concern is October. With the AL East effectively gone, the Yankees need Judge healthy more than ever, and there’s no guarantee they’ll get an uncompromised version of their superstar. If the injury happened in the field, moving Judge to designated hitter could quickly become part of the postseason plan.

Pete Alonso came through with a big game tying home run in the 9th inning at Citi-Field. Unfortunately, this time he was wearing a Baltimore Orioles jersey. It also just so happen to be his 300th home run of his career. The Mets still had opportunities to win, but instead a three run in the park home run by Coby Mayo sealed the Mets fate. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

A curtain call was given to Pete Alonso and Evan is unhappy with Pete. Plus Wink Martendale throws shade at Brian Daboll, and much more in an abbreviated show

Pete Alonso’s curtain call has Evan Roberts HEATED, and the debate over Mets fans cheering his game-tying homer turns into a showdown with Tiki and Shaun Morash. Did Alonso rub it in, or did Steve Cohen and David Stearns bring this embarrassment on themselves? Plus, Sean Manaea’s comments spark another argument over how players view frustrated fans. The Yankees face a major October decision: should Gerrit Cole start against the Red Sox despite his struggles against Boston? Meanwhile, the Jets’ historic drive fuels excitement about their offense, and the Giants prepare for a prime-time test against the Rams. Plus, Wink Martindale takes a shot at Brian Daboll while praising Jaxson Dart. 00:00 Alonso Curtain Call Fight 12:52 Manaea Fires Back 38:31 Yankees Division Hopes 49:50 Wink Takes a Shot 1:01:47 Jets Make History 1:10:19 Knicks Banner Night 1:19:42 Gerrit Cole Playoff Debate 1:33:32 Cohen’s Broken Promise 1:49:37 Giants Respect Debate 1:56:52 Jets Playoff Dreams #WFAN #EvanAndTiki #Mets #Yankees #Jets #Giants

Pete Alonso’s 300th career home run came at Citi Field against the Mets, and Evan Roberts could not get past what happened next. After Alonso tied the game and received a curtain call from the crowd, Evan argued that his former favorite Met did not need to come back out of the dugout and “rub it in.” Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash pushed back hard, insisting Alonso was simply giving Mets fans the acknowledgment they demanded. The debate explodes into a larger argument over Mets fans cheering Alonso, Sean Manaea calling the reaction to an opposing player “crazy,” Kodai Senga showing far more understanding, and the anger still directed at David Stearns for letting Alonso leave. Plus, the Yankees continue owning the Twins, while Shaun refuses to completely surrender hope that New York can still chase down Tampa Bay.

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field keeps stirring up raw emotions after Mets fans celebrated his game-tying home run and pushed him out for another curtain call. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the fans crossed a line, whether Alonso needed to come back out of the dugout, and why his departure still feels so different from other former Mets. The Yankees continue owning the Twins, but Tampa Bay has now moved ahead of New York as the American League favorite while Shaun Morash still sees a possible Yankees sweep of the Rays. Plus, the Jets establish their offensive identity with the longest timed drive in franchise history, Jaxson Dart earns praise after his strong start, and Wink Martindale takes an unmistakable shot at Brian Daboll.

Gerrit Cole’s ugly history against Boston creates a massive Yankees playoff question. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Cole should even start against the Red Sox in a best-of-three Wild Card series, especially with Max Fried’s dominance in the matchup and another strong rotation option available. The conversation turns to whether Cole belongs in Game 1, should be protected from an elimination game, or could even be pushed aside as the Yankees map out October. The Mets’ handling of Pete Alonso also remains a major sore spot, with Evan arguing Steve Cohen has continued the franchise’s frustrating history of letting beloved stars leave. Plus, the Giants’ travel plan for their Monday night matchup in Los Angeles, the excuses that could follow another Giants win, Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees lineup, and Evan already dreaming about what a 2-0 Jets start could mean.

The Giants keep winning, but Evan Roberts says the excuses will keep coming no matter who they beat. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash run through how victories over the Rams, Titans, Cardinals, Commanders and even Eagles could all be explained away, while Tiki argues the way the Giants win still matters when judging their performance. Then the Jets enter the spotlight. Evan is already imagining what a 2-0 start would feel like after years of losing, especially with a home win over Green Bay potentially sending his optimism through the roof. The crew also looks back at rare seasons when both the Jets and Giants started hot and wonders how crazy New York could get if both teams keep winning.

Pete Alonso’s departure remains a major wound for Mets fans, and Evan Roberts argues Steve Cohen has only added to the franchise’s painful history of letting beloved stars leave. Evan points to Alonso and Jacob deGrom as two all-time Mets who were allowed to walk, while comparing the situation to David Wright, whose long-term deal never became a source of resentment because the organization kept its homegrown star. The conversation also turns to fans who once wanted Alonso gone and are now staying quiet, plus Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees lineup, Anthony Volpe’s work at second base, and the Yankees’ postseason rotation possibilities involving Gerrit Cole, Max Fried and Cam Littler.

Gerrit Cole’s history against the Red Sox has the Yankees facing a fascinating October decision. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Cole should start in a potential best-of-three Wild Card series against Boston, especially with Max Fried and Cam Littler producing far better results in the matchup. The question quickly becomes bigger than simply choosing three starters. If Cole is part of the rotation, should the Yankees protect him from a possible elimination game by starting him in Game 1? Or should they trust the matchup data and consider leaving him out entirely? With the postseason rotation potentially affecting the Division Series too, every choice comes with a risk.

Two years after Juan Soto chose the Mets over the Yankees, Evan Roberts admits the early results have been painful for Mets fans. The Yankees have kept reaching October, while the Mets have missed the postseason, sparking a debate over whether adding Max Fried and Cody Bellinger ultimately left the Yankees in a better short-term position than simply keeping Soto. The conversation also turns to a fascinating Mets what-if: if Soto had stayed with the Yankees, would Pete Alonso still be in Queens? Plus, Evan weighs the emotional value of a potential Knicks championship banner night against a Yankees playoff game, and the Yankees make roster moves by bringing back Clarke Schmidt while designating Oswaldo Cabrera for assignment.

The Jets may have found exactly what their offense needs to be. Their 19-play, 11-minute-and-48-second march against Tennessee was the longest timed drive in franchise history, built almost entirely on pounding the football and keeping the Titans’ defense trapped on the field. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why that bruising approach could become the Jets’ identity and give them a path to success. The record sends Evan down a rabbit hole of the longest drives in NFL history, including one from Tiki’s Giants during their 41-0 NFC Championship Game demolition that consumed nearly the entire fourth quarter.

Wink Martindale clearly hasn’t forgotten his Giants breakup. While praising Jaxson Dart, the former defensive coordinator slips in a pointed comparison involving Cam Ward that Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber immediately view as another shot at Brian Daboll. The Giants’ strong start also has the crew looking back at the old regime with a lot more amusement. The Pete Alonso debate rolls on as callers challenge Mets fans for celebrating their former star. Evan argues Alonso is a unique case, while Tiki explains why that kind of lasting love can actually show young Mets what succeeding in New York can mean. Plus, an old prediction about Alonso’s return to Citi Field comes remarkably close to reality.

Pete Alonso’s dramatic return to Citi Field sparks a fierce debate after Mets fans celebrated his game-tying home run and pushed him into another curtain call. Evan Roberts defends Mets fans for still loving Alonso but argues Pete didn’t need to come back out of the dugout after hurting his former team, while the conversation turns to why Alonso’s departure still hits differently than Jacob deGrom’s. Plus, the Yankees continue their complete domination of the Twins, but Tampa Bay has now moved ahead of New York as the American League favorite. Shaun Morash still has a gut feeling the Yankees could sweep their crucial four-game series against the Rays and turn the division race upside down.

The Yankees have crushed the Twins again, but a much bigger problem is staring them down in the American League race. Tampa Bay has finally jumped New York in the betting odds, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the Yankees are running out of time. Shaun Morash still cannot let go, convinced a four-game sweep of the Rays could completely change the division race. The conversation then swings back to Pete Alonso and the Mets fans who celebrated his return. Evan defends fans for showing Alonso love in a lost season while insisting he personally wanted Kodai Senga to strike him out. The debate expands to Jacob deGrom, whether Mets fans would ever root for a former star against their own team, and why Alonso’s departure still feels different.

Sean Manaea calls the Citi Field reaction to Pete Alonso “crazy,” and Evan Roberts immediately unloads on the Mets pitcher for missing the entire point. Alonso was not just another opposing player, and Evan argues Manaea completely ignored what Pete still means to a fan base furious that the Mets let him leave. Kodai Senga offers the exact opposite perspective after surrendering Alonso’s 300th home run, saying the reaction showed how beloved Pete remains and how much he meant to the organization. Evan and Tiki also revisit Alonso’s departure, his decision to opt out, and why David Stearns still has plenty of ground to make up before anyone can declare the Mets were right to move on.

Pete Alonso’s game-tying home run and curtain call at Citi Field sends Evan Roberts over the edge. Evan still loves Alonso, but argues that coming back out of the dugout was unnecessary and felt like one more chance to rub the Mets’ mistake in their faces. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash strongly disagree, saying Mets fans were demanding the moment and Alonso was simply giving them the goodbye they wanted after hitting his 300th career home run. The argument gets personal as Shaun calls Evan’s anger misdirected, while Evan insists cheering Alonso is one thing and watching a former Met take a curtain call on the road is something else entirely.

Pete Alonso steps back into Citi-Field for the first time since signing with the Baltimore Orioles. How will the fans welcome Pete back? Plus, Francisco Lindor AND Pete Alonso are both looking for career home run number 300. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Pete Alonso returned and Francisco Lindor didn't love Mets fans' responses. Plus the Chiefs are back, and much more.

Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field sends Evan Roberts over the edge. Evan unloads on anyone criticizing Mets fans for showering Alonso with love, insisting the fan base did nothing wrong after enduring a miserable season. His biggest target is Steve Cohen, who told Alonso that Citi Field would always be his home despite, according to Evan, never making him an offer to stay. Shaun Morash pushes back on how far Mets fans went, especially when Jonah Tong was pitching well and fans booed after he walked Alonso. Francisco Lindor’s postgame comments defending Tong add another layer to the debate, while callers clash over whether cheering Alonso crossed the line. The hour becomes a heated argument over loyalty, ownership, David Stearns, and what Mets fans are entitled to feel after a lost season.

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field reignites the fury over David Stearns letting the homegrown slugger walk. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why the Mets are undeniably worse without Alonso, why fans had every right to cheer him, and how Sandy Alderson’s defense of Pete dismantles the arguments behind the decision. With “Fire Stearns” chants ringing out, Evan says the Mets failed because they never came close to replacing their star. Plus, the Chiefs remind everyone how dangerous they can be with Patrick Mahomes and Kenneth Walker, the Giants face more questions about Tyrone Tracy after another fumble, and the Jets get encouraging injury news on Omar Cooper Jr. and Minkah Fitzpatrick.

Pete Alonso’s return sends Mets frustration boiling over as Joe Benigno unloads on David Stearns and Steve Cohen for letting the franchise star walk. Joe calls the decision one of the worst in Mets history, argues Alonso has outperformed Juan Soto, and says Andy Green deserves to remain manager after his work with the club’s young players. The mood is much brighter around the Jets after a dominant 23-10 win over Tennessee. Joe raves about Geno Smith, Breece Hall, the offensive line and the revamped defense while predicting the Jets can beat Green Bay and become much better than expected. Plus, Aaron Judge’s response to whether a pitcher should win MVP ignites a heated debate over Cam’s candidacy and whether pitchers should ever take home the award.

Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts critique Nate Burleson’s recent analysis of Robert Saleh and Joe Burrow before considering Tom Brady’s potential as a cinematic villain. They engage in a heated debate over whether Tarik Skubal is delivering the greatest pitching season in history compared to Ron Guidry and Christy Mathewson. The conversation also touches on Mitchell Voit’s appearance and Gerrit Cole’s awkward post-game celebration. (00:02:03) Burleson CBS Critique (00:06:18) Brady Villain Potential (00:11:14) Tarik Skubal Discussion (00:18:01) Predicting Craig Carton (00:21:01) Fantasy League Dispute (00:24:00) Skubal Pitching Debate (00:32:25) Pete Alonso Return

Russell Wilson stunned Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber by calling Robert Saleh the “king of culture,” prompting a brutal reaction to the former Jets coach’s new reputation. They question whether Wilson did any research before making the claim and wonder if he was simply trying to generate attention with an outrageous take. Wilson wasn’t finished. His declaration that Joe Burrow will be gone from Cincinnati if things go badly this season sparks another round of disbelief. Plus, the conversation shifts to Mets prospect Mitch Voit, a prediction that the Mets will pursue Tarik Skubal, Garrett Cole’s awkward Yankees celebration, and why Cam Schlittler has separated himself in the playoff rotation.

Aaron Judge’s stance on pitchers winning MVP sets off a heated argument over whether a starting pitcher can truly be the most valuable player in baseball. Evan argues that pitchers should remain eligible and points to Pedro Martinez’s 1999 season as proof, while Tiki and Shaun push back hard on how much value a pitcher can provide when appearing only once every five days. The debate turns into a full-on baseball philosophy fight over workload, team success and whether modern starters can ever do enough to win MVP. Plus, a Mets caller raises a bizarre question after spotting an injured player leaving Citi Field before Pete Alonso’s return, leading to a discussion about the club’s future at first base.

Joe Benigno is delirious over the Jets after a dominant 23-10 win over Tennessee, and he believes this team is ready to blow past expectations. He raves about Geno Smith, Breece Hall, the offensive line and the revamped defense, calls the Sauce Gardner trade an all-time fleece, and boldly predicts the Jets can beat Green Bay and become a legitimate factor this season. Then the mood turns furious. Joe unloads on David Stearns and Steve Cohen for letting Pete Alonso walk, calling it one of the worst mistakes in Mets history and saying Stearns should be fired. He argues Alonso has been better than Juan Soto, blasts Soto’s lack of big moments, and says Andy Green has earned the right to manage the Mets moving forward.

Posted and Toasted digs up some wild old WFAN takes, including a prediction that Pete Alonso would hit 500 home runs, Shaun Morash mocking Robert Saleh lookalikes, and Craig Carton taking a shot at Sean Payton and the Broncos that looks very different in hindsight. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber try to identify who posted each one while revisiting some of the station’s funniest receipts.

John Harbaugh’s comments about the Giants’ fumbling issues have Evan Roberts wondering whether Tyrone Tracy is already losing the coach’s trust. Harbaugh publicly backed Isaiah Likely and Cameron Scott after their mistakes, but Evan notices Tracy never received the same vote of confidence. With the Giants continuing to add competition at running back, Evan questions how many more chances Tracy will get to prove he belongs. Evan and Tiki Barber also react to encouraging Jets injury news involving Omar Cooper Jr. and Minkah Fitzpatrick, while Mets callers defend cheering Pete Alonso and blasting David Stearns for letting him walk.

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field puts the Mets’ decision to let him walk back under the microscope. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber argue the Mets are unquestionably worse without Alonso, while Sandy Alderson’s breakdown of the move leaves David Stearns’ reasoning looking even harder to defend. Evan says the biggest problem is simple: the Mets never replaced their homegrown star. Plus, Patrick Mahomes and Kenneth Walker remind everyone how dangerous the Chiefs can still be, and the electric atmosphere around the Jets sparks a debate over which New York fan base has become the most desperate for winning.

Francisco Lindor’s defense of Jonah Tong draws a warning from Evan Roberts, who insists Mets players should be careful about lecturing fans after a brutal season. Evan says he has no problem with Lindor supporting his teammate, but pushes back on the idea that Mets fans crossed a line by cheering Pete Alonso. The argument escalates as a caller calls the Citi Field reaction “pathetic,” while Evan and Shaun Morash debate whether fans were actually rooting against the Mets. A flashback to Tino Martinez’s 2003 return to Yankee Stadium adds another wrinkle, as the crew compares how Yankees fans treated a beloved former player once the game was out of reach.

Evan Roberts refuses to apologize for Mets fans cheering Pete Alonso, arguing that their support for a franchise favorite was never an attack on Jonah Tong or the current team. The debate intensifies over whether fans crossed the line by rooting for Alonso while Tong was trying to deliver one of his best starts. Tiki Barber pushes Evan on how young Mets players might view the bizarre atmosphere, while callers weigh in on the fan reaction. The conversation also revisits how Yankees fans treated Tino Martinez and how Mets fans welcomed Mike Piazza back, raising the bigger question of when loyalty to a former star should end once the game begins

Evan Roberts erupts after Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field, ripping anyone who says Mets fans were wrong for cheering their former star. Evan argues that a fan base watching an awful, underachieving team had every right to shower Alonso with love, and he unloads on Steve Cohen for telling Pete that Citi Field will always be his home despite never making him an offer to stay. Tiki Barber says Alonso’s return finally ignited years of frustration Evan had been holding in over the direction of the Mets. Shaun Morash agrees fans had every right to celebrate Pete, but pushes back when that support begins affecting Jonah Tong and the current Mets on the field.

Tune in as the hosts of Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle react to Gang Green's resounding win over the Tennessee Titans and old friend Robert Saleh. While the Titans were unimpressive, the Jets more than handled their business. What are the takeaways for this Jets team as they look to restore their credibility and build confidence within the fanbase?

The New York Giants kicked off their season with a statement victory behind Jaxson Dart's poise and a relentless ground attack. We break down Malik Nabers' return, line-of-scrimmage dominance, and what this win means for the rest of the season.

For the first time since 2009 the Giants and Jets each won their season openers in the same year. We break down the terrific day it was for the locals, plus the Yankees seize the Subway Series.

The Giants delivered everything the John Harbaugh era promised, overpowering the Cowboys in a dominant opening-night win at MetLife Stadium. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the physicality, coaching and control that made this feel different from recent Giants teams, while Jaxson Dart impressed with quick decisions, three touchdown passes and a clear evolution from last season. The running game imposed its will, Isaiah Likely created matchup problems, and the Giants overcame mistakes and questionable officiating without losing command. The Jets gave New York another reason to celebrate by pounding Robert Saleh and the Titans. Evan loves the identity Frank Reich’s offense showed behind a dominant line and heavy doses of Breece Hall and Braelon Allen, while Geno Smith delivered an encouraging debut. The Jets finally looked competent, physical and functional, leaving both New York football fan bases with something they have rarely shared lately: a happy Monday.

The Giants stunned Dallas 28-20 behind Jaxson Dart, a physical offense and a dramatic return from Malik Nabers, whose status remained uncertain until the weekend. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down John Harbaugh’s bizarre attempt to prove Nabers was healthy, the Giants’ dominant ball control, Dak Prescott’s costly interception and Tyrone Tracy’s fumble that quickly buried him in the backfield rotation. The Jets also opened with a convincing 23-10 win, but Evan spots late-first-half mistakes from Aaron Glenn and Geno Smith that better teams could punish. Plus, the Sauce Gardner trade suddenly looks even sweeter if Indianapolis struggles, the Yankees’ Subway Series win still leaves their AL East hopes hanging by a thread, and Cameron Scattabo’s backflip sparks another celebration debate.

Robert Saleh’s Tennessee debut could not have gone much worse. Titans fans were already booing and calling for his firing after an ugly loss to the Jets, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Saleh’s quick return to head coaching was questionable from the start. They also revisit Matt LaFleur’s costly fourth-down gamble, Kellen Moore’s aggressive two-point decision and another classic Chargers collapse. The Giants and Jets are both 1-0, and optimism is building around New York football. Tiki explains how the Giants can beat the Rams by controlling possession and pounding the run, while Evan argues Los Angeles is vastly overrated. Plus, Shaun Morash gets credit for warning everyone away from the Chargers in knockout pools, the Colts give Jets fans another team to root against, and the crew reacts to a wild, record-setting opening week across the NFL.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Mets fans should cheer for a Pete Alonso home run during his emotional return to Citi Field. They also break down the Giants' victory over the Cowboys, highlighting the physical presence of Patrick Ricard and the team's ability to stop the run. (00:02:02) Patrick Ricard Impact (00:06:09) Giants Post-Game Analysis (00:14:20) Pete Alonso Returns (00:20:10) Predicting Carton's Reaction (00:23:16) Backup Quarterback Value (00:31:33) Jets Victory Analysis (00:36:04) MNF Betting Picks

Tyrone Tracy’s costly fumble could put his Giants role in jeopardy just one week into the season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down a crowded backfield featuring Cam Skattebo, Devin Singletary and Najee Harris, while Tiki explains why Deonte Banks may face an even bigger challenge trying to contain Puka Nacua against the Rams.

The Chargers’ stunning loss to Arizona tops Shaun Morash’s biggest stories from a chaotic NFL Sunday, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to huge performances across the league. Lamar Jackson and the Ravens roll, Carson Wentz unlocks Justin Jefferson, and the Bears erupt for 59 points ahead of their upcoming matchup with the Jets. After the highest-scoring Week 1 ever, Tiki argues the offensive explosion is tied to starters barely playing in the preseason and defenses struggling with regular-season speed. Plus, the crew talks about influencers taking over NFL crowds, Taylor Swift fatigue and the upcoming John Tuggle movie that has Evan ready to head back to the theater.

Robert Saleh’s tenure in Tennessee is already off to a brutal start. Titans fans booed the offense, chants calling for Saleh’s firing broke out in the opener, and Evan Roberts points out that Saleh is already giving the same answers about losing that he gave during his Jets tenure. The crew questions why Saleh received another head coaching opportunity so quickly and argues Brian Daboll had accomplished more with the Giants. Attention then turns to the Giants’ upcoming matchup with the Rams. Tiki Barber explains how New York can win again by controlling possession, staying balanced and running effectively, while Evan doubles down on his belief that Los Angeles is vastly overrated and Monday night is absolutely winnable.

The Jets and Giants finally gave New York football fans something almost unheard of, with both teams winning on the same Sunday for just the 10th time since 2017. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber put the rarity of that moment into perspective before debating two massive coaching decisions that helped shape Sunday’s NFL action. Kellen Moore gambled on a two-point conversion rather than trusting the Saints defense, while Matt LaFleur gave up an eight-point lead opportunity in a decision the crew calls horrific. Plus, Shaun Morash takes a victory lap after warning everyone not to trust the Chargers in knockout pools, and a Giants fan explains why the MetLife Stadium crowd finally felt overwhelmingly blue against Dallas.

Scattabo celebrated his touchdown with another backflip, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Giants should embrace it or save it for the biggest moments. Scattabo says John Harbaugh wants him to be himself, and that freedom has become part of the identity of this new Giants offense. The conversation then turns to Tyrone Tracy after another costly fumble. Tiki explains exactly what Tracy must fix with his ball security, why he still brings a home-run element the other Giants backs do not, and why his opportunities could disappear quickly in such a crowded backfield. The guys also weigh in on Tony Romo and Mark Sanchez and why their situations are very different.

The Yankees took two of three from the Mets, but their AL East outlook somehow got worse. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Tampa Bay’s relentless winning has put the Yankees in a position where they may need to sweep a four-game series against the Rays to keep realistic division hopes alive. Attention then turns back to a huge New York football weekend. The Giants controlled Dallas with long, physical drives that kept Dak Prescott on the sideline after his costly interception, while callers celebrate what looked like a completely transformed offense. The Jets’ dominant opener has fans dreaming too, but Evan warns that one win over Tennessee is nowhere near enough for any “I told you so” declarations about Aaron Glenn.

Malik Nabers’ return came with one of the wildest stories of the Giants’ opener, as John Harbaugh actually tackled him to prove his knee was ready for contact. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Nabers’ decision to play, his strong return and why Jaxson Dart’s response to several big hits was another encouraging sign for the Giants. The Jets also cruised past Tennessee, but Evan was frustrated by Aaron Glenn and Geno Smith’s messy end-of-half execution. The mistakes did not cost them against the Titans, but both hosts agree that kind of sloppy situational football has to disappear before the competition gets tougher.

The Jets finally looked like a competent, physical football team, and Evan Roberts believes they may have found their identity. Frank Reich leaned on a dominant offensive line, fed Breece Hall and Braelon Allen, and watched Geno Smith deliver the kind of steady quarterback performance the Jets desperately needed. Tiki Barber was impressed by Geno’s accuracy and leadership, while the defense overcame Minkah Fitzpatrick’s early injury and kept Tennessee under control. Rookie Kenyan Siddiq flashed immediately, Omar Cooper showed his potential before suffering a high ankle sprain, and the Jets even controlled the game enough for fans to relax in the second half. After beating Robert Saleh and opening 1-0, Evan isn’t predicting a Super Bowl run, but for the first time in a long time, the Jets unquestionably have a season.

Jaxson Dart’s growth may be the clearest sign that these Giants are changing. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Dart’s three-touchdown performance, his quicker decision-making and the discipline he showed by taking easy completions instead of constantly chasing the spectacular play. The bigger takeaway is the identity John Harbaugh has already established. Callers celebrate a Giants team that looks bigger, stronger and far more physical, while Tiki points to the culture and humility developing around Dart. After years of ugly wins and frustrating losses, the Giants didn’t escape Dallas. They controlled the Cowboys and looked like the better team.

The Giants couldn’t have scripted John Harbaugh’s debut much better. New York controlled the Cowboys from the opening drive, imposed its physical style and delivered the kind of dominant performance Giants fans have been waiting years to see. The biggest difference was obvious: coaching mattered. Jaxson Dart looked more decisive, getting the ball out quickly and taking advantage of a Dallas defense that couldn’t pressure him. The Giants pounded the football, Isaiah Likely created matchup nightmares, and a crucial sequence after Tyrone Tracy’s fumble showed how this team can overcome mistakes instead of unraveling. Even against a flawed Cowboys defense, the Giants finally looked like the bigger, tougher and better-coached team.

The Patriots losing to the Seahawks has Evan wondering if there is hope for the Jets to shock the NFL world and make a playoff push this year. Plus, should Garrett Wilson feel snubbed for not being named a team captain? Meanwhile, Boomer and Gio discuss how Sam Darnold's injury in Seattle further highlights the Jets' need for a more reliable backup quarterback, and the Evan and Tiki crew discuss what the realistic expectations should be for Geno Smith and the team in 2026.

The season is finally here, and Phil Simms sat down with Boomer and Gio to give his take on how the team looks with John Harbaugh in the fold. Plus, how will Jaxson Dart perform in year two? Evan and Tiki discuss the daunting task that awaits the Giants in their season opener against the Cowboys, Craig Carton rips the team for its handling of Darius Slayton, and debating if the Giants have better weapons on offense than the Jets. Finally, Evan wonders if Harbaugh is picking a fight with the New York media.

Carlos Beltran is the newest baseball player to go into the Hall of Fame wearing a New York Mets hat. The Mets have decided that it's time to retire the number 15 in celebration of Carlos making the hall of fame. Evan, decided to go through the hall of famer's Mets career to find his top Mets moments. You'll be surprised and shocked at what he found! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

We look back at the tragic events 25 year's ago. wWe look ahead to a Subway Series and finally a Football preview with game previews and picks.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber reflect on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, remembering the heroes who ran toward danger and the role New York sports played in helping the city regain a sense of normalcy. Tiki recalls returning from the Giants’ opener in Denver, while Evan shares his memories of experiencing the attacks from Washington, D.C. Then the focus turns to Week 1. The Jets may have the better chance than the Giants to start 1-0, but Geno Smith remains the biggest unknown. Can he reinvent himself again, and can the Jets avoid beating themselves? Meanwhile, Malik Nabers’ uncertain status complicates the Giants’ matchup with Dallas, while the crew also debates which Giants newcomers and rookies could make the biggest impact this season.

Malik Nabers is making the final call on whether he plays against the Cowboys, and his comments about protecting his career leave Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering if the Giants will open the season without their biggest weapon. Tiki and Evan lean toward Nabers sitting, while Shaun Morash predicts he plays and delivers five catches for 56 yards. The debate turns to how teammates would handle his decision and why the mental hurdle may matter as much as the physical one. Anthony Volpe’s huge return sparks a victory lap over how the Yankees finally handled his development, while Aaron Glenn’s decision to stick with Jason Sanders at kicker raises immediate Jets concerns. Plus, John Harbaugh gets a warning about dealing with the New York media, and the show reflects on September 11, the Giants’ connection to first responders and the lasting meaning of Mike Piazza’s iconic home run.

John Harbaugh’s Giants debut against the Cowboys carries huge stakes, and history says Week 1 could be a powerful sign of where this season is headed. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash look back at Giants coaching debuts, debate how aggressively New York should attack Dallas, and explain why the Giants should want the football immediately instead of deferring. They also break down the importance of stopping the run and unleashing the pass rush against Dak Prescott. The Jets face their own Week 1 questions, including how heavily Breece Hall should be used and the franchise’s bizarre history of opening seasons with revenge games. Plus, Malik Nabers weighs in on playing under a snap count, the show remembers September 11 through powerful listener stories, and Shaun unveils another Giants-focused football segment.

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate the upcoming NFL season, specifically highlighting a grim three-win prediction for the Jets. They discuss the impact of coaching on the Giants' potential and compare the benefits of NFL Sunday Ticket versus Red Zone for fans. The conversation also previews the Yankees versus Mets series and concludes with official Week 1 betting picks.(00:01:50) Shaun Morash’s NFL Rooting Guide(00:05:11) Football’s Use of Baseball Idioms(00:08:34) Jets and Giants Season Predictions(00:14:04) Rams Predicted as NFL Busts(00:17:46) 49ers vs Rams Game Recap(00:19:58) Sunday Ticket vs Red Zone(00:27:16) Yankees vs Mets Series Outlook(00:32:14) Yankees Playoff Clinching Scenarios(00:37:01) Official NFL Week 1 Picks

The Giants cannot afford to ease into John Harbaugh’s debut against Dallas. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash explain why New York should attack immediately, lean on its running game and force Dak Prescott into obvious passing situations so the Giants’ pass rush can take over. The crew also looks back at recent Giants coaching debuts and the striking connection between winning Week 1 and reaching the playoffs. Tiki explains why stopping the run has to come first defensively, while Evan argues the Giants should take the football if they win the coin toss instead of deferring. Plus, a caller gets some jersey advice for Sunday night, and Evan doubles down on his prediction that Odell Beckham Jr. will score a touchdown against the Cowboys.

The Jets are opening another season in a revenge game, and Evan Roberts has had enough. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash run through the bizarre history of former Jets players and coaches immediately getting a shot at their old team, including Robert Saleh, Aaron Rodgers, Sam Darnold and Chad Pennington. Evan also revisits last year’s Week 1 loss and makes one thing clear: playing well means nothing if the Jets still lose. The Giants face an intriguing Week 1 trend of their own. Recent Giants head coaches who won their debut went on to make the playoffs, adding even more weight to John Harbaugh’s opener against Dallas. Plus, the crew calls out Tommy Lugauer for claiming they never reach out to him despite their active group chat.

Breece Hall is healthy enough to play, but will the Jets finally unleash him? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to Frank Reich’s comments about Hall’s workload and reveal the stunningly small number of games in which Hall has reached 20 carries. They debate whether Reich will truly feed his star running back and how Hall can hurt defenses as both a runner and receiver. Malik Nabers also makes it clear that if he plays, he does not want the Giants deciding his snap count for him, sparking a debate over who should control that decision. Plus, a caller shares a remarkable September 11 story involving the Giants, and the show looks back at the New York sports headlines from the morning of the attacks, including Michael Jordan’s looming return.

Anthony Volpe returns with a grand slam and five RBIs, but Evan Roberts sees his breakout as proof the Yankees mishandled him for years. Sending Volpe down, forcing him to earn his way back and adding defensive versatility may have finally unlocked the player the Yankees kept waiting for. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether one huge game is enough to believe Volpe has truly changed and whether his hot bat could keep Jazz Chisholm out of the lineup. Plus, Nolan McLean gets his chance to prove himself against the Yankees as the Subway Series puts the Mets rookie directly in the New York spotlight.

Aaron Glenn is sticking with Jason Sanders as the Jets’ Week 1 kicker, and Evan Roberts immediately sounds the alarm after what he saw from Sanders’ leg. With the Jets operating on such a small margin for error, Evan and Tiki Barber explain why one missed extra point or field goal could become a major problem. John Harbaugh also gets a warning about trying to intimidate the New York media, while the crew debates whether Jaxson Dart’s promising rookie season is being overshadowed by questions about his durability. The hour also includes powerful September 11 memories from a first responder and a conversation about why New York sports rivalries still mattered even after the city came together.

Malik Nabers is making the final call on whether he plays against the Cowboys, and his concern about risking his long-term career has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber leaning toward him sitting out. Shaun Morash believes Nabers will play, while Tiki explains why the decision is as much mental as physical and how the Giants locker room would handle losing its biggest receiving weapon. The conversation then turns emotional as callers share memories of September 11 and the role New York sports played in the city’s healing. Evan and Tiki reflect on the Giants’ connection to first responders and why Mike Piazza’s unforgettable home run after 9/11 remains bigger than baseball.

The Giants’ offseason overhaul takes center stage as Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts identify Tremaine Edmunds as the newcomer most likely to make the biggest impact. Tiki also explains why the team’s added size and physicality stand out as the clearest signs of John Harbaugh’s vision taking shape. The conversation also turns to the rookie class, with Malachi Fields emerging as a potential breakout contributor. Plus, callers continue reflecting on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, sharing memories of that day and the difficulty of reaching family and friends as New York and Washington dealt with the attacks.

The Jets may have the better chance than the Giants to start 1-0, but everything could come down to Geno Smith. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate which version of Geno will show up against Tennessee and whether the Jets can trust a quarterback coming off a rough season to reinvent himself once again. The Titans don’t scare Evan nearly as much as the possibility of the Jets beating themselves. Plus, the crew makes a bold prediction that the Jets will finally end their interception drought, while Malik Nabers’ uncertain status adds another major question heading into the Giants’ opener against Dallas.

Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts reflect on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, honoring the firefighters, police officers and other heroes who risked and lost their lives trying to save others. Tiki recalls returning to New York after the Giants played in Denver the night before the attacks, while Evan shares what it felt like experiencing that terrifying day from Washington, D.C. They also remember how sports helped New York begin to feel normal again, from Mike Piazza’s unforgettable home run to the Giants returning to the field. Twenty-five years later, the memories remain vivid, even as a younger generation now knows September 11 only as history.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets are trying to put their stamp on the Miami Marlins season by sweeping them. Hopefully this will be revenge for knocking the Mets out of the playoffs at the end of the season last year.

The Patriots and Drake Maye imploded, Tiki looks back at Week 1's in his career, and a failed Yankee prospect won't go away.

Drake Maye’s brutal fourth quarter has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering if the Patriots are far more vulnerable than expected, and whether that suddenly gives the Jets a clearer path to surprise people in the AFC East. Evan also admits Sam Darnold’s injury immediately made him think about Seattle potentially trading for Geno Smith, sparking a debate over Geno, Russell Wilson and how aggressive the Seahawks should be at quarterback. The Giants’ opening stretch also comes under the microscope, with Evan more confident about beating the Rams in Week 2 than Dallas in Week 1. Tiki pushes back on that logic as they debate Dak Prescott, Matthew Stafford, the Rams’ travel and the Giants’ offense. Plus, the Yankees take care of business, the Mets keep winning, and the John Sterling home run call machine makes an unexpected return.

John Harbaugh showed a much sharper side with the Giants media, pushing back on questions about Darius Slayton and refusing to reveal Malik Nabers’ status. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Harbaugh was simply having fun or trying to intimidate reporters, and why that strategy will not stop the New York media from pressing him for answers. The Yankees also lose Jazz Chisholm to the injured list, opening the door for Anthony Volpe’s return after a dominant Triple-A stretch. Evan and Tiki debate Volpe’s proper role, whether Aaron Boone can manage the situation correctly, and how his return could affect George Lombard Jr. Plus, skepticism about Matthew Stafford and the Rams, the Giants cornerback competition, and Mike Tomlin’s debut at the desk.

Mike Tomlin has Evan Roberts’ attention before the Jets even play a game. Evan admits his “wandering eye” is still fixed on Tomlin and believes the former Steelers coach already sounds like he misses coaching enough to return next year. Tiki Barber pushes back on how soon that comeback could happen, while both agree Tomlin’s blunt style and credibility make him a natural on television. Evan also delivers a confident prediction that the Mets will smoke the Yankees, while the crew debates Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and the dangerous Rays. Plus, Sam Darnold’s hip injury raises questions about Seattle’s season, Shaun Morash unveils his Giants rooting guide, NFL fan traditions get ripped apart, and Robert Saleh gets a harsh assessment as he tries to prove himself again as a head coach.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber discuss Anthony Volpe’s return to the Yankees on WFAN and revisit past predictions about his career longevity. Tiki reflects on the specific coaching adjustments that solved his NFL fumbling issues and joins the crew in analyzing the upcoming Rams-49ers game in Australia. They also examine the massive hype and record-breaking ticket prices surrounding the Giants' opener against the Cowboys.(00:01:50) Subway Series Doubleheader(00:04:13) Anthony Volpe Archive Callouts(00:07:48) MLB Playoff Format Criticisms(00:12:45) Mets Player Assessment Discussion(00:17:15) Rams Versus 49ers Strategy(00:22:30) Tiki Career Trivia Segment(00:27:00) Fixing Tiki's Fumbling Issues(00:32:04) NFL Week 1 Injury Report(00:39:00) Patriots Versus Seahawks Analysis(00:44:40) Rams Versus 49ers Picks

Shaun Morash unloads on the NFL traditions he cannot stand, blasting the Seahawks’ “12,” Bills Mafia, the Vikings’ Skol chant, Eagles fans and Detroit’s third-down signs. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber jump into the chaos as the Jets’ simple stadium chant gets rare praise.

Sam Darnold’s hip injury immediately has the crew wondering how long Seattle can survive without its starting quarterback and whether Drew Lock is enough to keep the Seahawks afloat. The uncertainty also catches Shaun Morash’s attention as a Giants fan watching potential NFC wild-card competition. That sets up the debut of Shaun’s new weekly Giants rooting guide, where every NFL matchup gets broken down based on what outcome helps Big Blue most. Evan Roberts goes from mocking the idea to embracing it, while Tiki Barber joins the debate over how the guide could eventually shift from playoff positioning to draft positioning if the Giants’ season goes south.

Mike Tomlin’s television debut has Evan Roberts convinced the former Steelers coach already misses the NFL. Evan admits his “wandering eye” remains fixed on Tomlin as a potential Jets option and believes a coaching comeback could come quickly, while Tiki Barber argues Tomlin may need more time away before returning. The Yankees debate heats up as Jose Caballero gets praised over Anthony Volpe, while the Rays’ ability to put the ball in play makes them a legitimate threat. Evan then delivers his strongest prediction of the hour, declaring the Mets are going to smoke the Yankees this weekend. Plus, Evan fires back at a caller who insists he secretly hates the Giants.

John Harbaugh’s combative approach with the media becomes the center of another Giants debate. Evan Roberts makes clear he enjoys Harbaugh pushing back, but warns that trying to intimidate New York reporters will only make them press harder. Tiki Barber agrees that Harbaugh can handle the media however he wants, but the questions are not going away. The conversation also touches on Anthony Volpe’s return and Evan’s concern about how Aaron Boone will use him before turning to the physical future of football. Tiki explains why he does not expect the sport to fundamentally change despite growing concern about head injuries, emphasizing the inherent violence players accept when they choose to keep playing.

Anthony Volpe is back with the Yankees after tearing up Triple-A, but his return comes with Jazz Chisholm headed to the injured list and major questions about how Aaron Boone will use him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Volpe should play second base, compete with Jose Caballero for at-bats, and finally settle into the utility role they believe fits him best. There is also concern about how Volpe’s return could affect George Lombard Jr., who replaced him at shortstop and gave an awkward answer when told Volpe was coming back. Plus, Evan explains why he remains skeptical of Matthew Stafford and the Rams despite Stafford’s massive previous season.

John Harbaugh’s relationship with the New York media suddenly turned combative. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Harbaugh’s sharp responses to questions about Darius Slayton and Malik Nabers, including whether he was simply pushing back or trying to intimidate reporters into backing off. Evan warns that tactic will not work in New York, where Giants reporters will keep pressing no matter how uncomfortable Harbaugh makes it. They also examine why Slayton was cut, how Deonte Banks has earned a fresh opportunity under the new coaching staff, and whether Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history should create real concern despite his huge previous season.

Evan Roberts refuses to buy the Rams hype, arguing that Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history make Los Angeles far less intimidating than everyone assumes. He even feels better about the Giants beating the Rams in Week 2 than Dallas in the opener, sparking a heated debate with Tiki Barber over Stafford, the Rams’ talent and whether their unusual travel schedule could leave them vulnerable. The conversation shifts to the Yankees after George Lombard Jr.’s grand slam, including a listener’s push to revive the John Sterling home run call simulator. Plus, a Jets fan unloads on Bill Belichick amid problems at North Carolina, while Evan and Tiki explain why Belichick’s college tenure does nothing to change how they view his NFL legacy.

The Giants’ season opens with a daunting matchup against Dak Prescott and the Cowboys, and Evan Roberts is already more confident about their chances in Week 2 against the Rams. The Giants’ ugly history against Dallas, their limited preseason work with Jaxson Dart and questions surrounding Malik Nabers all fuel the concern, while Tiki Barber pushes back on Evan’s surprising confidence in a road upset over Los Angeles. The debate centers on whether the Cowboys or Rams present the bigger early-season challenge, with Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history becoming a major point of contention. Plus, the Seahawks’ quarterback situation after Sam Darnold’s injury keeps Geno Smith and Russell Wilson in the conversation, and the Mets somehow provide one of the night’s most compelling games.

Drake Maye’s disastrous fourth quarter has Evan Roberts wondering if the Patriots are already showing signs of a major regression, and whether that could give the Jets a real opening in the AFC East. After watching Maye throw three fourth-quarter interceptions, Evan sees a possible roadmap for the Jets to surprise people this season. Sam Darnold’s injury creates a completely different Jets thought: could Seattle become desperate enough to trade for Geno Smith? Evan floats the possibility while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash immediately point to Russell Wilson as the more logical Seahawks option. The debate turns into a heated argument over whether Geno or Wilson is closer to playing winning football right now.

The NFL Season will kickoff tonight, and the Giants can look to the Patriots playing tonight as inspiration. We give our Super Bowl picks, and much more.

The Giants have a blueprint for a massive turnaround, and it looks a lot like last year’s Patriots. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber compare Jaxson Dart’s rookie numbers to Drake Maye’s, John Harbaugh’s arrival to Mike Vrabel’s impact, and explain why Big Blue could be positioned for one of the NFL’s biggest jumps. The biggest obstacle is clear: a run defense that finished near the bottom of the league must dramatically improve. Plus, Aaron Judge returns to the Yankees lineup without the storybook moment Evan wanted, while the crew looks ahead to intriguing Subway Series pitching matchups and debates whether the Mets can ever truly become New York’s baseball big brother.

John Harbaugh’s critics get called out as the Giants’ new coach becomes the center of a heated debate. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that Harbaugh’s playoff disappointments diminish his coaching résumé, comparing his career to Sean Payton, Mike Tomlin and other respected NFL coaches. They also debate what success should actually look like for Harbaugh in New York and whether matching Tom Coughlin’s two Super Bowls is an unrealistic standard. The Yankees’ division hopes are fading as Tampa Bay keeps winning, Aaron Judge’s postseason struggles return to the spotlight, and the Yankees’ incredible streak of 34 straight winning seasons gets some perspective. Plus, Garrett Wilson is left off the Jets’ captain list, MLB expansion could reshape the leagues, and Montreal, Nashville, Portland and Salt Lake City emerge as possible destinations.

Jaxson Dart holds the key to how far the Giants can climb in 2026, but Connor Hughes has serious reservations about whether Matt Nagy’s offense will bring out his best. Hughes explains why Dart may need to become a top-10 or top-12 quarterback for the Giants to make a massive leap, and why the new system could put far more pressure on him than last year’s offense. The conversation also turns to Odell Beckham Jr.’s surprising resurgence, why Darius Slayton was cut and the Giants’ defensive concerns entering the opener against Dallas. On the Jets, Hughes predicts an opening-week loss, explains why Aaron Glenn appears secure entering the season and weighs Breece Hall’s expected workload. Plus, the crew sets the stakes for another season of NFL picks.

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash announce their Super Bowl predictions, selecting teams like the Bears, Broncos, and 49ers to reach the big game. They also discuss the breaking news regarding Rutgers coach Steve Pikiell and reflect on Tiki's past NFL openers. (00:01:50) Super Bowl Predictions (00:06:28) Reviewing Past Picks (00:11:15) Title Game Logistics (00:17:07) Steve Pikiell Diagnosis (00:19:39) Tiki Career Trivia (00:31:10) Giants Roster Outlook (00:33:45) Jalen Brunson Hosting SNL (00:39:30) NFL Week 1 Picks

The Super Bowl predictions are officially on the record, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash go in three very different directions. The crew also revisits their wildly different February predictions, debates strength of schedule.

The NFL is back, but the opening-night Super Bowl rematch brings up one problem: Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash can barely remember anything that happened in last year’s championship game. They revisit just how dull the Patriots-Seahawks Super Bowl was and why that lack of memorable moments has taken some shine off the rematch. Shaun also runs through five things fans need to remember as the new season begins, from the Bills’ new stadium and coaching change to Aaron Rodgers reuniting with Mike McCarthy, Mike Evans changing teams and Jaxson Dart’s record against Dallas. Plus, a diehard Jets caller explains his anxiety over Geno Smith and the team’s quarterback situation.

The NFL picks competition is back, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash agree on a punishment designed to make the losers miserable. The two who fail to finish first will have to attend a sporting event wearing a shirt promoting an opinion they absolutely hate, sparking ideas involving Jalen Brunson, Malik Nabers, Joel Embiid and Evan’s baseball takes. The crew also revisits the Giants’ decision to move on from Darius Slayton, rejecting the idea that the veteran receiver was somehow disrespected. With a new coaching staff setting its own priorities, they argue the Giants simply made the roster decision they believed was best.

Jaxson Dart can change the Giants’ entire outlook, but Connor Hughes has major concerns about whether Matt Nagy’s offense is built to maximize the young quarterback. Hughes explains why Dart must become a top-10 or top-12 quarterback for the Giants to make a Patriots-like leap and why Nagy’s system could make that development much harder. Hughes also breaks down why Odell Beckham Jr. earned his way onto the roster and helped make Darius Slayton expendable. The conversation then shifts to the Jets, where Breece Hall’s workload remains a question entering Week 1, Hughes predicts an opening loss and explains why Aaron Glenn enters the season with significant job security.

The Yankees’ streak of 34 consecutive winning seasons gets put into stunning perspective against every other major New York sports franchise. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much credit the organization deserves, why Yankee fans may take sustained success for granted, and whether the Dodgers have any realistic chance of eventually challenging the streak.

Garrett Wilson being left off the Jets’ season-long captain list sparks questions about what the decision really means. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber listen to Wilson’s reaction, debate whether he sounds disappointed, and explain why the snub should not become a lingering issue inside the Jets locker room.

John Harbaugh’s critics come under fire as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber reject the idea that the Giants should pump the brakes on their new coach. Harbaugh’s playoff disappointments are compared to the résumés of Andy Reid, Mike Tomlin, Sean Payton and other top coaches, with the argument that players have too often failed to execute in his biggest losses. The Yankees are also running out of room in the AL East race as Tampa Bay keeps winning and a four-game series with the Rays starts to look like a must-sweep. Aaron Judge’s return sparks another debate over his postseason struggles, whether a fresher Judge can finally change the October narrative, and why this Yankees roster may not need him to carry the entire offense.

Aaron Judge returned to the Yankees lineup, but the storybook moment never came. Evan Roberts admits he was disappointed by Judge’s hitless night after comparing it to the unforgettable comeback homers from Alex Rodriguez and David Wright, while Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that Judge’s first game back mattered much at all. The Yankees also face a tricky reality as Judge works his way back and may not finish every game, creating late-inning lineup decisions like the one that put Heliot Ramos in a huge spot. Plus, the Subway Series pitching matchups take shape, and a caller sparks a bigger debate over whether the Mets could ever truly become New York’s baseball big brother.

The Giants’ turnaround case keeps getting stronger as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber point to recent NFL examples of teams making massive year-to-year jumps. With Jaxson Dart entering Year 2 and John Harbaugh taking over, the Giants have the kind of quarterback-coach combination that can change a season quickly. The conversation shifts to the Jets, where Evan dismisses the idea of curses and says years of losing come down to organizational incompetence. That leads to a dream scenario involving Howie Roseman somehow taking control of the franchise. Plus, Giants rookie Jack Kelly earns praise as the definition of a Harbaugh-style football player, and the crew gets sidetracked debating C-notes, Roman numerals, and some long-shot Giants bets.

The Giants enter the season with a stunningly similar setup to the Patriots team that made a massive leap behind Drake Maye and Mike Vrabel. Jaxson Dart’s rookie numbers closely mirror Maye’s, while John Harbaugh gives New York the accomplished veteran coach that could accelerate the turnaround. The argument is simple: if New England could make that jump, why can’t the Giants? The biggest warning is the defense. New York’s run defense was among the league’s worst, and unless that changes, the quarterback development and upgraded roster may not matter. The pass rush offers real upside, but stopping the run could determine whether this Giants season becomes a surprise or another disappointment.

Radio new year is here, Aaron Judge rides into The Bronx and the Giants and Jets officially hit game week

Aaron Judge is finally back, and the Yankees now have 19 games to turn survival into a legitimate October push. After going 45-39 without their MVP, the Yankees stayed afloat, but Tampa Bay remains four games ahead and Boston is still lurking. The debate turns to whether Judge can shake off three months without real game action quickly enough to change the AL East race. The bigger priority may be getting Judge fully ready for the postseason, especially with Aaron Boone planning to pull him early from games. Should Judge lead off to maximize his plate appearances, or should the Yankees rethink how they use him late? Plus, the lineup looks deeper with Cody Bellinger, Spencer Jones, Luis Garcia and others surrounding Judge for the stretch run.

The Giants are moving on from Darius Slayton, and Shaun Morash is taking heat for calling the veteran receiver “gutless” in big moments. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine why Slayton became expendable, from the costly drops to a disappointing camp, while questioning whether the Giants have left Jaxson Dart with one of the NFL’s weakest wide receiver rooms. Malik Nabers’ health, rookie Malachi Fields and Odell Beckham Jr. now carry even more pressure.

Aaron Judge is coming back, but how healthy is he really? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate the biggest possible outcomes for Judge and the Yankees, including the fear that pushing through his injury could threaten his postseason. They also shut down the wild internet conspiracy theory surrounding Judge’s extended absence. The Jets face what feels like an immediate season-defining game against Tennessee, while former Jets coach Robert Saleh heaps surprising praise on their offense and urges Titans fans to keep New Yorkers out of the stadium. Plus, the crew examines Jaxson Dart’s lack of chemistry with the Giants’ new-look receiving corps, the Eagles’ strange relationship with Jalen Hurts, whether Shohei Ohtani can truly keep pitching and hitting full-time, and the NFL’s growing push toward football nearly every day of the week.

Tiki, Evan, and Shaun analyze the lineup strategy for Aaron Judge's return to the Yankees and revisit their summer predictions regarding his recovery timeline. They also discuss Zach Rosenblatt’s reporting on the Jets, focusing on Woody Johnson’s relationship with Robert Saleh and the organizational outlook on Geno Smith. (00:01:50) Nicknames and Kon-Tiki (00:05:56) Jameis Winston Backup Debate (00:15:47) Judge Return Predictions (00:22:38) Zach Rosenblatt Jets Report (00:38:26) Judge Conspiracy Theory (00:43:04) Jets Super Bowl Hopes

Jameis Winston’s Giants extension sparks a heated debate over just how valuable he is behind Jaxson Dart. Tiki Barber argues Winston is one of the NFL’s best backup quarterbacks, praising his leadership, experience and impact inside the locker room, while Shaun Morash admits Winston has completely won him over after he originally hated the signing. Evan Roberts also revisits the crew’s Aaron Judge return predictions after the Yankees star finally gets back, with Morash coming remarkably close to the actual date. They debate what Judge can deliver down the stretch and why October will ultimately define the Yankees’ season.

Aaron Judge is returning, but nobody truly knows how healthy the Yankees captain actually is. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate the most likely ways Judge’s season ends, from a World Series run to another injury derailing his comeback, and question whether he may simply be pushing through pain because October is approaching. The conversation also veers into a wild internet conspiracy theory claiming Judge’s absence was actually a secret PED suspension, an idea Evan firmly denounces despite the suspicious timing fueling online speculation. Plus, the crew compares Zach Wilson and J.J. McCarthy as quarterback disappointments and debates which former first-round pick deserves the harsher bust label.

Robert Saleh is suddenly praising the Jets offense as a potential top-ten unit, but Evan Roberts isn’t buying it. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Saleh is being genuine or simply trying to bury any bitterness toward Woody Johnson after his firing. They also react to Saleh urging Titans fans not to sell their tickets to traveling Jets supporters. The focus quickly turns to how enormous Jets-Titans feels for New York’s season, with Evan warning that a loss could send everything spiraling fast. Plus, the crew questions whether Shohei Ohtani can realistically continue as a full-time starting pitcher and hitter, or whether a bullpen role makes more sense.

Jaxson Dart enters Week 1 with real questions about chemistry and preparation after nearly a month away from game action. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash examine how a new system, an unfamiliar receiving corps and limited preseason work could affect the Giants quarterback against Dallas. The Falcons are also entering another season with a different Week 1 starter, continuing a remarkable quarterback carousel that has them closing in on an NFL record. The conversation turns to Tua Tagovailoa’s opportunity in Atlanta and what Michael Penix Jr.’s health could mean for the future. Plus, the crew debates Jalen Hurts and the Eagles, whether the NFL is becoming oversaturated, and Kyle Shanahan’s hilarious attempt to explain San Francisco’s schedule adjustment for Australia.

Posted and Toasted digs up old WFAN tweets, and Shaun Morash gets caught red-handed after spending the hour crushing Darius Slayton. Years before calling Slayton “gutless” in big moments, Shaun was praising the Giants receiver as a “stud,” “the truth” and even a potential No. 1 option. Tiki Barber tries to identify who posted each old take, including a brutal Mets rant and an oddly passionate defense of chopped salads, before Shaun’s Slayton history takes over the segment. The receipts spark a hilarious debate over how dramatically Shaun’s opinion changed and how Slayton should actually be remembered after his Giants career.

The Giants catch a major Week 1 break as Cowboys starting left guard Tyler Smith is set to miss Sunday night, creating a potential mismatch for New York’s loaded pass rush. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate how much the injury changes the matchup and whether a convincing win over Dallas could immediately validate the hype surrounding John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart. The crew also looks at the Giants’ brutal recent history in season openers and the stunning drought since both the Jets and Giants won in Week 1 of the same season. Plus, Evan defends his push to bat Aaron Judge leadoff, and callers keep the Jaxson Dart blue tent conversation alive.

Darius Slayton is out, and the Giants are making a clean break from a receiver whose biggest drops became impossible to ignore. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash dig into why John Harbaugh’s regime moved on, with Malachi Fields rising, Odell Beckham Jr. earning a spot and Slayton looking expendable after a disappointing camp. But cutting Slayton creates a major new concern for Jaxson Dart. The Giants’ wide receiver room is thin, largely unfamiliar with its quarterback and filled with questions surrounding Malik Nabers’ health, Fields’ rookie readiness and Beckham’s reliability. Shaun also defends calling Slayton “gutless” in big moments, while the crew debates where Slayton could land next and whether Dart can finally stay out of the blue tent.

Aaron Boone plans to pull Aaron Judge early as the Yankees ease him back without a rehab assignment, and that could create a major late-game dilemma. If Judge leaves after five or six innings, the Yankees risk replacing their biggest bat just when the most important at-bats arrive. That leads to a wild alternative: why not bring Judge into games in the fourth or fifth inning and keep him available for the finish? The debate also turns to Spencer Jones taking over in center after Trent Grisham’s hamstring injury and why getting Judge and the Yankees’ offense fully ready for October matters more than ever.

Aaron Judge’s return immediately creates a major lineup debate for the Yankees. With only 19 games left, Evan argues Judge should lead off to maximize every possible plate appearance and accelerate his return to form before October. But Aaron Boone plans to ease Judge back by removing him early from games, treating the stretch almost like a rehab assignment. That raises another question: could pulling Judge leave the Yankees without their biggest bat in crucial late innings? The conversation also examines the deeper lineup around Judge, Austin Wells’ role, and why getting Judge playoff-ready matters even more than catching Tampa Bay.

Aaron Judge is back after missing 84 games, and the Yankees somehow survived his absence with a 45-39 record. Now comes the real challenge: can Judge shake off three months without game action quickly enough to help New York chase down Tampa Bay in the AL East? The Yankees enter the final stretch four games behind the Rays, with Boston also refusing to disappear. Judge’s return should immediately strengthen a lineup that struggled badly without him, but expectations need to be realistic. The priority is getting Judge comfortable and fully ready for October, even if the Yankees’ chances of stealing the division remain slim.

Chris McMonigle and Nick Kostos on the Yankees’ chances of catching the Rays and winning the AL East. Plus: -Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on the Yankees’ window to catch the Rays -CMac and Antony Gallo on the Yankees’ pitching staff needing to go deeper into games -Shaun and Tiki on Cam Schlitter’s home/road splits and possible playoff dilemma -Gio on Yankees fans seemingly disliking this year’s team -Gio and Bobby Berger from Bob Does Sports discuss if the Yankees are overachievers

The Jets have made it clear that Cade Klubnik is their backup quarterback, and our hosts are VERY concerned across the board. Gio says Gang Green missed the boat in adding a veteran to back up Geno Smith, Chris McMonigle can't believe the Jets don't have interest in Joe Milton, and Evan Roberts is struggling to see the plan. Plus, Evan and Tiki ponder if the Jets can make a big splash and trade for a veteran quarterback in the future.

Tiki Barber is concerned that Malik Nabers will not play in the Giants season opener after hearing John Harbaugh's latest comments. Plus, full reactions to the team's 53-man roster being revealed, including Shaun Morash declaring that Odell Beckham Jr. earned his spot, while Damien Woody believes Beckham can be a quality No. 2 receiver this year. Morash also declares that John Harbaugh's presence is actually underrated.

Rutgers suffers a stunning humiliation against UMass, leaving Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber questioning how Greg Schiano and the program recover from one of the most embarrassing losses imaginable. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and the Rutgers disaster quickly turns into a larger debate about Schiano’s future and whether anything short of a major rebound can erase the damage. The Giants-Jets rivalry heats up as Shaun argues the Giants have the better overall offense, with Malik Nabers’ ceiling, Jaxson Dart at quarterback and New York’s tight end and offensive line advantages fueling the fight. Plus, the Yankees enter a critical Padres series with a chance to close the gap on the Rays, while major changes to the Pro Football Hall of Fame voting process spark another NFL debate.

Rutgers delivers a humiliating season-opening disaster against UMass, and Shaun Morash believes the damage to Greg Schiano may be unrecoverable. Shaun is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they rip apart a loss that turned Rutgers into a national punchline, debate whether Schiano can possibly recover, and hear from frustrated fans already canceling football trips after the collapse. Tiki also looks back on his own memorable college football moments at Virginia, including heartbreaking finishes against Michigan and Texas and the legendary upset of Florida State. Plus, the Yankees get some help in the standings and face a crucial weekend against the Padres, while the Giants conversation turns to Malik Nabers, Malachi Fields, Jaxson Dart, and the brewing debate over Nabers versus Garrett Wilson.

Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and he’s done pretending the Jets have a better offense than the Giants. Shaun makes the case position by position, arguing the Giants have the edge at quarterback, tight end and offensive line, while Malik Nabers gives them at least a push against Garrett Wilson and the Jets’ receivers. Tiki weighs in on Nabers’ massive ceiling and the debate over which New York offense is actually more dangerous. The conversation also turns to major Pro Football Hall of Fame voting changes and what they could mean for Tiki, Eli Manning and Tom Coughlin. Plus, Rutgers’ ugly opener raises more questions about Greg Schiano, callers debate the Giants’ chances in the NFC East, and Labor Day weekend sparks an argument over whether it’s already way too early for pumpkin season.

Tiki Barber locks in his NFL playoff field with some massive calls, including the Steelers winning the AFC North, the Patriots taking the AFC East and the Texans and Bears missing the postseason. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate Aaron Rodgers, Mike McCarthy, Caleb Williams, Trevor Lawrence and which teams are being seriously underestimated heading into the season. The Giants also take center stage as callers look ahead to the Cowboys matchup and what an opening win could unleash from a suddenly optimistic fan base. Plus, the Yankees’ postseason lineup and bench options get examined, and Shaun closes with his five sporting events that nobody seems to care about anymore, including the U.S. Open, Preakness and Indy 500.

College football may be opening a Pandora’s box by allowing players who spent time in NFL training camps to return to school. Tiki Barber warns that without clearly defined limits, the LSU situation could create chaos for roster construction and an already unregulated system. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate where the line should be drawn between college and professional football. The Giants also face plenty of questions before their opener against Dallas, with memories of the disastrous 2023 Cowboys loss still fresh and concerns lingering about the defense. Plus, the Jets’ kicker problem draws criticism, Tiki weighs in on overlooked Hall of Fame running backs, the Yankees prepare for a crucial Subway Series against the Mets, and the show debates why tennis no longer connects with American sports fans the way it once did.

LSU allowing players who spent time in NFL training camps to return to college football sparks a heated debate over where the sport draws the line. Tiki Barber warns that even if these specific cases seem harmless, the precedent could open a Pandora’s box and make an already chaotic system even harder to control. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. The Giants also enter Week 1 carrying some uncomfortable memories of their disastrous 2023 opener against Dallas. Shaun admits that collapse still lingers, while Tiki believes this roster is better equipped to avoid another nightmare. Plus, the Jets’ kicking situation comes under fire, and Tiki makes the case for overlooked running backs from his era.

Giants optimism could turn into absolute chaos if Big Blue opens the season by beating Dallas. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they imagine obnoxious Giants fans finally emerging after years of frustration, while also acknowledging how quickly an 0-2 start could bring back ugly memories. Shaun then unveils his five sporting events that nobody seems to care about anymore. The Indy 500, WNBA playoffs, British Open and U.S. Open all make the list before the Preakness lands at No. 1. Tiki weighs in on fading star power in tennis, the WNBA’s scheduling problems and why the Triple Crown chase has lost some of its appeal.

Tiki Barber doubles down on the Steelers after Shaun Morash pushes back on Pittsburgh winning the AFC North. Shaun is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki as they debate whether Aaron Rodgers has another big season left, how much Mike McCarthy can elevate Pittsburgh, and whether McCarthy’s strong coaching record gets overlooked. The conversation then shifts to the Jets, where a caller predicts a breakthrough behind the offensive line, running game and Geno Smith. Tiki isn’t buying that they can match Buffalo offensively, pointing to Josh Allen, James Cook and the Bills’ talent as the major obstacle. They also touch on the Red Bulls and the difficulty of keeping up with every sport during a packed summer.

Tiki Barber unveils his NFL playoff field and immediately delivers some huge surprises, knocking the Texans and Bears out while backing the Patriots to win the AFC East. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate Caleb Williams, Ben Johnson, Drake Maye, Josh Allen and whether Seattle can avoid regression. The Yankees’ postseason lineup also comes into focus, with questions about Ben Rice, Paul Goldschmidt and how the bench should be deployed when Aaron Judge returns. Plus, Giants fans look ahead to the Cowboys and explain why controlling the clock and establishing the run could be the key to opening the season with a win.

The Garrett Wilson versus Malik Nabers debate returns as Jets fans push back on Shaun Morash’s belief that Nabers has the higher ceiling. Shaun is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and while Wilson gets plenty of respect, Shaun still sees Nabers as the more dynamic, elite-level talent. Labor Day weekend also sends the show completely off the rails. Shaun and Tiki argue over pumpkin season arriving too early, reminisce about scrambled cable and dial-up internet, and Shaun reveals an unforgettable Britney Spears search that his mother caught him making as a kid.

Major changes are coming to the Pro Football Hall of Fame voting process, and Tiki Barber believes the new system should help deserving candidates get a fairer shot. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki as they break down the reduced voting panel, the end of separate senior committee treatment and why the old process created too much room for politics and competing agendas. The conversation turns directly to Tiki, Eli Manning and Tom Coughlin, with Tiki saying the changes should help their Hall of Fame cases. They also revisit Rutgers, debating whether the program truly belongs in the Big Ten and how conference realignment, recruiting and NIL have completely changed the college football landscape.

Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Shaun is done pretending the Jets have a better offense than the Giants. He goes position by position, giving the Giants the edge at quarterback, tight end and offensive line while arguing Malik Nabers gives them at least a push against Garrett Wilson and the Jets’ receivers. Tiki agrees Nabers has the higher ceiling, comparing the difference in talent and explosiveness to Randy Moss and Cris Carter. The debate expands to Malachi Fields versus Adonai Mitchell, the Giants’ improved offensive line and whether last season’s late progress can carry into a legitimate NFC East push. Rutgers’ rough opener also gets another look as Tiki explains why the changing college football landscape makes Week 1 harder to judge.

Rutgers fans are already reaching a breaking point after the disastrous loss to UMass. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as a longtime season-ticket holder reveals he canceled planned road trips to Wisconsin and Boston College because of the humiliation. Shaun argues the loss is even worse than Appalachian State shocking Michigan because Rutgers has far less reason for confidence that the program will recover. The Yankees also face a crucial weekend against the Padres with a chance to keep closing the division gap. Plus, Tiki explains why Malachi Fields could outproduce Malik Nabers early in the season as Jaxson Dart continues building trust with the Giants’ young receiver, setting up another heated Nabers versus Garrett Wilson debate.

The Rutgers humiliation keeps getting worse as frustrated New Jersey fans unload on Greg Schiano after the stunning loss to UMass. Callers call the defeat a stain on the state, blast Rutgers for paying UMass to come in and beat them, and question how Schiano can possibly recover from such an embarrassing opener. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they compare the Rutgers disaster to Appalachian State’s legendary upset of Michigan and hear from a caller with a remarkable personal connection to that 2007 game. The conversation also briefly turns to Pablo Torre’s investigations, the Knicks, the Dodgers, and how difficult it is for college offensive linemen to break into the NFL.

Rutgers opens the season with a humiliating 37-21 loss to UMass, and Shaun Morash calls it an unrecoverable disaster for Greg Schiano. Shaun is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they rip into Rutgers for getting dominated at home by a team that entered on a 16-game losing streak. The embarrassment goes beyond the scoreboard. Shaun argues Schiano should step down, questions why top New Jersey recruits would still choose Rutgers, and even blasts the postgame fireworks after such an ugly defeat. Tiki says there is only one way Schiano can survive the fallout: start winning games Rutgers is not supposed to win.

The Mets have nothing to play for the rest of the year but pride as the 2026 season is officially lost. That being said, the Mets played the Rays hard and beat them 2 of 3 games. Which means, the Yankees have an opportunity to gain ground thanks to the Mets. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

John Harbaugh’s impact on the Giants is already impossible to ignore. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they react to Isaiah Likely describing a dramatically different training camp and debate whether Harbaugh’s professionalism, structure and demanding approach are being underrated before the season even begins. The Yankees also get a major boost from the Mets taking two of three from Tampa Bay, keeping the AL East race within reach. Shaun and Tiki break down the Yankees’ path to the division, Austin Wells’ resurgence, Cam Littler’s performance and the growing belief that Aaron Judge could soon return to the lineup.

Cam Schlittler’s historic road dominance creates a fascinating October decision for the Yankees. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Schlittler should start Games 1 and 5 of a playoff series or whether the Yankees should exploit his road success in a pivotal Game 3 while trusting Gerrit Cole and Max Fried elsewhere. They also defend Spencer Jones against calls for Trent Grisham to get more postseason playing time. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. They question why Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall were left off the Jets’ captain list, identify Malachi Fields and Deonte Banks as potential Giants X-factors, and explain how John Harbaugh could change the Giants’ late-game decision-making. Plus, the Clippers’ massive punishment sparks a hypothetical debate about what similar NBA scrutiny could mean for the Knicks.

Tiki Barber makes his boldest playoff cuts yet, eliminating the Chiefs, Cowboys and Giants from the 2026 postseason picture. He explains why Kansas City’s offense and defense leave him skeptical, why Dallas still has major questions, and why the Giants could improve dramatically under John Harbaugh while still finishing around .500. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. Plus, Cam Skattebo reveals he entered the NFL believing a major injury could make him walk away from football, raising questions about how close his gruesome ankle injury came to ending his career. The hour also hits the Clippers and Kawhi Leonard controversy, the Yankees’ postseason rotation possibilities, and a Cinco ranking of the greatest NBA jerseys.

Thursday Full Evan and Tiki Show.

Shaun and Tiki evaluate Greg Newsome III's comments regarding cornerback room rankings and whether the Giants' secondary can live up to high expectations. They also discuss the bizarre trend of eating banana peels, the history of undersized running backs like Tony Dorsett, and potential week one knockout pool picks. (00:01:50) Banana Peel Nutrition (00:04:40) Jets Quarterback Outlook (00:10:52) Running Back Evolution (00:16:35) US Open Tennis (00:20:35) Illegal Radio Tones (00:24:55) Jets Offense Expectations (00:32:55) Giants Cornerback Discussion (00:39:00) Daniel Jones Strategy (00:43:15) NFL Knockout Pools

The Nets are bringing the legendary Swamp Dragons concept back to life for a special January game against the Clippers, complete with merchandise and hypothetical throwback uniforms. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber react to one of the strangest abandoned identities in NBA history before Alex ranks his five greatest NBA jerseys ever. The list features classic looks from the New York Nets, Magic, SuperSonics, 76ers and Raptors, with Toronto’s iconic purple dinosaur jersey taking the top spot. The conversation then shifts to Giants-Cowboys, Dallas’ difficult early schedule and why Week One could carry major pressure for the Cowboys.

Cam Skattebo reveals he entered the NFL with one personal rule: a major injury could make him walk away from football. After suffering a gruesome ankle injury just seven games into his career, Skattebo was forced to confront that possibility before finding his way back physically and mentally. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate what the admission means for the Giants going forward, especially at a position where injuries and short careers are constant concerns. They also explain why Skattebo’s return alongside Jaxson Dart could bring back the energy that helped transform the Giants offense, before callers turn the conversation toward Mac Jones as a possible Jets option and Spencer Jones’ future with the Yankees.

Tiki Barber delivers a stunning round of NFL playoff eliminations, knocking out the Chiefs, Cowboys, Giants, Jets and Bengals as he builds his 2026 postseason field. Kansas City is the biggest shock, with Tiki questioning whether Patrick Mahomes can return to form and whether the roster has enough difference-makers to survive a loaded AFC West. The Giants also miss Tiki’s playoff cut despite his belief that they can hover around .500 and stay competitive with Dallas. Plus, the Clippers and Kawhi Leonard controversy sparks debate over possible punishment, while the Giants’ opening stretch against the Cowboys and Rams raises the pressure to show immediate progress.

The Clippers’ brutal punishment for circumventing the salary cap has Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber wondering whether the NBA could uncover similar behavior elsewhere. After Steve Ballmer’s suspension and the loss of five first-round picks, Shaun points to Pablo Torre’s previous hint involving the Knicks and Jalen Brunson and asks how nervous Knicks fans should be. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. They debate whether the NBA could ever strip a championship if wrongdoing surfaced and whether fans would still consider the title legitimate. Plus, the conversation returns to the Yankees’ playoff rotation, with Cam Schlittler’s road dominance creating a major decision about how to line up Gerrit Cole and Max Fried for October.

Cam Schlittler’s incredible road numbers force the Yankees into a fascinating October rotation debate. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh whether Schlittler should get Games 1 and 5 of a playoff series or whether his dominance away from Yankee Stadium makes him the perfect choice for a pivotal Game 3 while Gerrit Cole and Max Fried handle the other starts. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. They also push back on the idea that the Yankees lack urgency, debate whether struggling veterans are being given too much leeway, and begin examining how John Harbaugh’s decision-making could make the Giants look very different this season.

Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall are both missing from the Jets’ six-man captain group, and that immediately catches Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash’s attention. They debate what it says about two of the team’s biggest offensive names, especially with several newcomers receiving the honor instead. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. They also break down the Giants’ receiving options if Malik Nabers is unavailable, including Odell Beckham Jr., Darnell Mooney and rookie Malachi Fields. Plus, they push back on calls for Trent Grisham over Spencer Jones and explain why Deonte Banks could become a major X-factor for the Giants.

The Giants are setting up an emotional opening night, with Tiki Barber revealing that members of the 2001 team are expected to take the field as the franchise honors first responders 25 years after September 11. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki as they also run through the Giants’ home giveaways and debate whether a caller should cash in on valuable front-row tickets or experience the game himself. Then the conversation turns to Evan Neal, whose Giants tenure has reached a disappointing end after failing to make the roster or practice squad. Shaun and Tiki revisit why the highly regarded first-round pick became such a massive miss and whether the Giants deserve the same blame they received for other draft busts.

John Harbaugh has completely changed the feel around the Giants, and Isaiah Likely’s revealing comments about training camp have Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber wondering whether everyone is actually underrating his impact. Likely describes Harbaugh’s demanding, football-first approach as normal compared with what Giants players experienced in the past. Shaun and Tiki explain why Harbaugh’s experience, structure and proven methods could make an immediate difference, while pushing back on direct comparisons to Brian Daboll. With players embracing the tougher environment and a new sense of professionalism surrounding the team, optimism is building over what this culture shift could mean once the Giants finally take the field.

The Mets just gave the Yankees exactly the help they needed by taking two of three from Tampa Bay, pulling the AL East race back within striking distance. Now the pressure is on the Yankees to keep winning, survive a difficult San Diego series and make sure their upcoming four-game showdown with the Rays still matters. There is also growing excitement around Aaron Judge’s potential return. The conversation turns to how Judge’s presence could energize the entire lineup for the September push, even if he needs time to regain his form after a long absence. Plus, Austin Wells’ recent improvement offers another encouraging sign as the Yankees try to build momentum for October.

Malik Nabers’ Week 1 status is suddenly a major concern for the Giants. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Tiki remains convinced Nabers is unlikely to face the Cowboys as the star receiver works through the physical and mental hurdles of his recovery. Even if Nabers plays, expectations for his workload need to come down as the Giants prepare to lean on their run game and Jaxson Dart. The Yankees may have found an October fixture in Spencer Jones. His growth into a complete hitter has Shaun and Tiki arguing that Aaron Boone cannot push him aside when Aaron Judge returns, especially with Trent Grisham slipping. Plus, Freddy Peralta’s strong outing after the Mets moved him adds another frustrating twist to his New York story.

Malik Nabers’ Week 1 status is suddenly a major Giants concern. Tiki Barber has consistently doubted that Nabers will be ready for the Cowboys opener, and he explains why the receiver may be physically progressing but still doesn’t fully trust his repaired knee. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate whether Nabers should accept a limited role or wait until he feels capable of playing a full game. They also examine how the Giants can survive without their top receiver, why John Harbaugh’s physical approach could give them an early edge over Dallas, and how Odell Beckham Jr. earned his roster spot while providing needed leadership to a young receiving room.

Spencer Jones has forced the Yankees into a decision they can no longer avoid. With Aaron Judge nearing a return, Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber argue that Jones has earned an everyday spot over Trent Grisham. His power, defense, speed and ability to hit lefties have transformed him into a complete player, and the Yankees risk hurting themselves if they prioritize experience over merit in October. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also dig into Malik Nabers’ recovery and the mental challenge of returning from injury, the Giants’ pass rush attacking a vulnerable Cowboys offensive line, Odell Beckham Jr.’s potential leadership role, and why building the Giants around a physical running identity could be the right approach. They also react to Stan Kroenke purchasing the Angels and what another aggressive owner could mean for baseball.

The Jets may have three first-round picks, but that does not guarantee they can land their quarterback of the future. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they examine how several quarterback-needy teams could finish below the Jets and block any attempt to move up in the 2027 NFL Draft. Tiki believes the class could offer enough quality options, while Shaun warns that the projected quarterback depth could shrink dramatically by draft time. The hour also features Tiki’s predictions for every NFL division’s last-place finisher, optimism surrounding the Giants under John Harbaugh, and concerns about Jaxson Dart’s health and throwing motion. Plus, the Giants’ expanded throwback uniform schedule sparks speculation that the classic look could eventually become permanent.

Robert Saleh is praising his former Jets players ahead of Week One, but Shaun Morash sees the same problem that bothered him during Saleh’s time in New York: he may simply be too nice to have the killer instinct an NFL head coach needs. Tiki Barber agrees the Jets are the better team on paper and says there should be no excuses against Tennessee. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. The Giants also take center stage as Joe Schoen raises expectations for John Harbaugh’s first season, Jaxson Dart enters a crucial second year, and questions remain about Malik Nabers, the offensive line, defensive tackle and a crowded running back room. Plus, Shaun declares the Yankees’ matchup with the Angels a must-win as their division hopes hang in the balance.

Robert Saleh is showering his former Jets players with praise before facing them in Week One, and Shaun Morash believes it exposes the same flaw that followed Saleh in New York: he may be too nice to have the killer instinct a head coach needs. Tiki Barber says the Jets are the better team on paper and should beat Tennessee, making a loss to their former coach especially difficult to swallow. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. The Giants conversation turns to John Harbaugh establishing a tougher identity, Joe Schoen raising expectations and the importance of building the roster with Harbaugh’s type of players. Plus, Shaun’s bizarre Long Island bug invasion sparks callers to share their own storm-related encounters.

The Giants have Tiki Barber feeling far more optimistic about what John Harbaugh can unlock this season. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki, as they examine a deeper roster, improved coaching and whether the Giants can finally turn last year’s crushing close losses into wins. Tiki also addresses concerns about Jaxson Dart’s unusual throwing motion and physical playing style, arguing that Dart has not shown himself to be concussion-prone despite taking some massive hits. The conversation circles back to the Jets’ quarterback future and the danger of assuming three first-round picks guarantee access to a top 2027 prospect. Plus, Shaun celebrates the return of school and the structure that comes with it.

The Jets may own three first-round picks, but Shaun Morash warns that still might not be enough to control their quarterback future. With Tiki Barber projecting several potential last-place teams that could also be searching for quarterbacks, the Jets could find themselves stuck behind multiple desperate franchises in the 2027 NFL Draft. Tiki pushes back, believing the upcoming class has enough talented quarterbacks to keep the Jets from falling into no man’s land. Shaun and Tiki also run through Tiki’s projected last-place finisher in every NFL division and debate which teams could immediately enter the quarterback market. Plus, the Giants’ expanded throwback uniform schedule has Shaun wondering whether the franchise is preparing to make its classic look permanent.

The Giants’ pass rush could be the key to beating Dallas. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber zero in on the Cowboys’ uncertainty at right tackle and argue that Brian Burns, Abdul Carter and the Giants’ defensive front must turn that weakness into sacks and constant pressure on Dak Prescott. With questions in the secondary, getting home quickly could determine whether the Giants can control the opener. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also examine Odell Beckham Jr.’s return to the Giants, why his leadership could matter as much as his production, and how a physical, run-first identity could give John Harbaugh’s team the foundation it needs to become a winner.

Spencer Jones has made the Yankees’ upcoming lineup decision impossible to ignore. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber argue that Jones has become the complete player the Yankees hoped for, bringing power, speed, defense and production against lefties. With Aaron Judge nearing a return, they believe Jones has earned the right to stay in the everyday lineup over Trent Grisham, even when October arrives. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as the conversation shifts to Malik Nabers and the mental challenge of returning from a major injury. Tiki explains why Nabers may have to adjust to playing before he feels completely like his old self, and why getting comfortable with that reality could be the biggest hurdle in his comeback.

The Giants want to reestablish their toughness against Dallas, and Tiki Barber believes John Harbaugh has built a team capable of doing exactly that. Tiki and Shaun Morash explain why the Giants’ physical training camp, commitment to the run game and desire to impose their will could give them an advantage against the Cowboys in Week 1. Tiki also compares Harbaugh’s demanding approach to playing for Tom Coughlin and explains why hard coaching can make players better. The conversation returns to Malik Nabers, with Tiki detailing the mental challenge of trusting a surgically repaired knee and why Nabers may need more successful practice reps before he truly feels ready to play without hesitation.

Odell Beckham Jr. didn’t make the Giants on reputation alone. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash explain why Beckham earned his roster spot with a strong camp, while his experience and leadership could become even more valuable if Malik Nabers isn’t ready for Week 1. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they turn toward the Giants’ offensive identity. Tiki believes John Harbaugh is building a physical, run-heavy team capable of controlling games while Jaxson Dart and the passing attack develop. Even with Nabers potentially limited or unavailable against Dallas, Tiki says the Giants can lean on their ground game and toughness rather than forcing the offense to become a finished product immediately.

Malik Nabers’ Week 1 status is becoming a serious concern for the Giants. Tiki Barber believes the star receiver is unlikely to face the Cowboys, pointing to Nabers’ continued work with trainers and the mental hurdle of fully trusting his repaired knee. The debate centers on whether Nabers should accept a limited role or wait until he feels capable of playing an entire game without hesitation.

Mets help the Yankees, but Yankees can't help themselves. The Jets QB Situation takes center stage.

The Jets’ quarterback plan is already under fire. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question why Cade Klubnik is the only real insurance behind Geno Smith, with Tiki warning the Jets may simply have no plan if Geno goes down. They debate Jimmy Garoppolo, Will Levis and Joe Milton as alternatives, while wondering whether the franchise is repeating the same mistake it made behind Aaron Rodgers. The Mets finally give Yankees fans something to celebrate by beating Tampa Bay, only for the Yankees to waste the opportunity with an ugly loss to the Angels. Plus, Aaron Boone’s bullpen decisions get defended, Trent Grisham’s role comes under fire, and Spencer Jones makes a strong case to stay in the Yankees lineup every day.

Chris “Mad Dog” Russo joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber and puts major pressure on the Yankees, saying they have to win the American League and reach the World Series. Russo also unloads on the Mets’ decision to let Pete Alonso go, placing the blame on Steve Cohen and raising concerns about the chemistry between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto. Mad Dog also predicts baseball could lose part of next season before a labor deal gets done, pumps the brakes on the Jaxson Dart hype, and explains why he expects both the Giants and Jets to be more competitive. Plus, Russo opens up about missing New York sports radio and his return to the WFAN orbit through SiriusXM.

The Jets’ quarterback search could take a massive turn if a proven star becomes available. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash run through the NFL’s biggest names and debate which quarterbacks could realistically land in New York. Joe Burrow has a slim but believable path, Jalen Hurts looks like an intriguing fit, and C.J. Stroud could become fascinating if Houston takes a major step backward. They also explain why Dak Prescott, Matthew Stafford and other veteran options may not be worth sacrificing the Jets’ three first-round picks. The conversation expands into whether Mike Tomlin could someday make the Jets more attractive, plus the pressure surrounding the Giants as John Harbaugh prepares to coach games that count. The Yankees also enter the spotlight as Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone face the only test that will truly define their season: October.

They analyze the social media feud between Cam Schlittler and a podcast host alongside his dominance on the mound against Boston. The discussion covers the ethics of retired jersey numbers for the New York Giants and Tiki Barber's own experience with University of Virginia honors. They also review a personal statement from Tony Romo regarding his health and future at CBS. (00:01:55) Schlittler's Social Media Feud (00:07:15) Schlittler's Success Against Boston (00:10:45) Giants Retired Number Debate (00:15:50) Jets Practice Squad Update (00:19:45) Tiki's Retired Jersey Experience (00:23:30) Aaron Judge Toughness Debate (00:30:50) Tony Romo Public Statement (00:36:30) Piazza and Clemens Beanball (00:43:15) Giants Running Game Outlook (00:48:30) Yankees Roster Construction

Cam Schlittler is taking heat for firing back at a Red Sox podcaster who called him ugly, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber see the social media shots as fair game after she went personal first. More importantly, they argue Schlittler has backed up his trolling by dominating Boston and embracing the hatred that comes with the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry. The conversation also turns to the Giants giving Jalin Hyatt No. 81, whether certain franchise numbers should be protected without being officially retired, and Tiki’s preferred solution from Virginia: retire the jersey while keeping the number in circulation.

The Yankees’ season comes down to one brutal standard: reach the World Series or face another disaster. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone deserve more credit for navigating injuries and roster issues, but Evan makes clear that none of it will matter if October ends early. The postseason will ultimately decide how every move, lineup decision and deadline addition is remembered. The final stretch also features Shaun Morash’s best parts of September, including John Harbaugh finally coaching meaningful Giants games and Aaron Judge nearing a return. Plus, Evan refuses to entertain Nets fans comparing Brooklyn’s failed superteam to the champion Knicks, while his Mets scoreless-game streak faces a major test once football Sundays arrive.

Joe Burrow to the Jets may sound outrageous, but Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash can actually see a path if Cincinnati disappoints and Burrow becomes frustrated. The debate expands to Jalen Hurts, who Tiki believes could fit perfectly with the Jets’ offensive identity, while C.J. Stroud, Lamar Jackson, Dak Prescott and Matthew Stafford are also examined as possible future targets. The bigger question is whether the Jets should use their three first-round picks to draft and develop their own quarterback or cash in those assets for an established star. A caller adds another potential game-changer: Mike Tomlin, whose arrival could instantly make the Jets a far more appealing destination for a veteran quarterback.

Justin Herbert to the Jets sounds tempting, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber struggle to see a realistic path to making it happen. They examine the scenario where Jim Harbaugh falls for a top quarterback prospect, the Jets own a premium draft pick, and Los Angeles considers resetting at the position. Even then, Evan wonders whether Jets fans would rather draft their own young quarterback than spend major assets and money on Herbert. The conversation also hits Herbert’s reputation in big games, possible veteran quarterback options for the Jets, Jalin Hyatt returning to the Giants’ practice squad, and a revealing round of Posted and Toasted featuring old Yankees, Giants, and Sirius tweets.

Chris “Mad Dog” Russo joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber and declares the Yankees have no excuse not to reach the World Series, arguing their payroll and the state of the American League put major pressure on Aaron Boone and the organization. Russo also unloads on the Mets for letting Pete Alonso leave, putting more blame on Steve Cohen than David Stearns and raising concerns about the clubhouse dynamic involving Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto. Plus, Mad Dog pumps the brakes on the Jaxson Dart hype while predicting the Giants will be better under John Harbaugh, and reflects on WFAN joining SiriusXM and what he still misses about local New York sports radio.

The Jets’ endless search for a franchise quarterback takes center stage as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber trace decades of disappointment from Joe Namath to Mark Sanchez, Sam Darnold and Zach Wilson. With another quarterback-heavy draft looming, Tiki argues the Jets need more than talent. They need the right coaching infrastructure to finally develop someone successfully.

The Jets still have a glaring problem behind Geno Smith. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Joe Milton, Jimmy Garoppolo or Will Levis could provide real insurance, but keep coming back to the same concern: Cade Klubnik may be forced into a role before he is ready. Tiki argues the Jets need a veteran who can actually win games if Geno misses time, not another developmental project.

The Jets’ quarterback plan is already under fire. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question why Cade Klubnik is the only real insurance behind Geno Smith, with Tiki warning the Jets may simply have no plan if Geno goes down. They debate Jimmy Garoppolo, Will Levis and Joe Milton as alternatives, while wondering whether the franchise is repeating the same mistake it made behind Aaron Rodgers. The Mets finally give Yankees fans something to celebrate by beating Tampa Bay, only for the Yankees to waste the opportunity with an ugly loss to the Angels. Plus, Aaron Boone’s bullpen decisions get defended, Trent Grisham’s role comes under fire, and Spencer Jones makes a strong case to stay in the Yankees lineup every day.

With all this talk about the advantage teams might have in getting home-field advantage in the best-of-three wild-card rounds, Bradfo went to two young pitchers who have just recently learned all about needing to perform on the biggest stages in front of the most hostile crowds - Payton Tolle and Cam Schlittler. The Red Sox rookie and Yankees ace offer entertainment, insight and education when it comes to what it's like to live that life of having rabid fans root against you when it counts the most.

After losing back to back series to Brewers and Astros, the Mets have put themselves to a pace of losing 90 games in 2026. Not what David Stearns drew up in the offseason, is it now! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Despite Red Sox announcers and fans melting down the Yankees rightfully stomped Boston in the weekend series. The Giants cut Evan Neal and keep Odell Beckham Jr

Boston is furious over the controversial Rafael play, but Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash aren’t buying the excuses after the Yankees demolished the Red Sox 16-1. They break down why the replay call stood, why Boston still had every chance to survive the inning, and why the outrage over Jazz Chisholm stealing bases only made the Red Sox look worse. The Yankees took three of four, claimed the season-series tiebreaker and strengthened their grip on the top wild-card spot. The hour also turns to the Jets’ shaky backup quarterback situation, the return of Juan Soto, David Cone seemingly predicting an Elliott Ramos home run, and whether the red-hot Rays have enough momentum to threaten the Yankees in the AL East.

Evan Neal is officially done with the Giants, reopening the debate over where the former No. 7 pick ranks among the biggest draft busts in franchise history. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash revisit their old predictions, explain why Neal never developed and compare his failure to infamous Giants first-round misses. The Jets also face a major backup quarterback question behind Geno Smith, with Jimmy Garoppolo emerging as the preferred insurance policy. Plus, the crew debates Geno’s future, a possible future pursuit of Joe Burrow, puzzling Jets roster cuts, Odell Beckham Jr. making the Giants and Red Sox radio ripping Jazz Chisholm for stealing during a Yankees blowout.

The Jets’ endless quarterback search takes center stage as Joe Burrow emerges as the dream solution if Cincinnati ever makes him available. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why trading premium draft capital for a proven franchise quarterback could beat taking another swing in the draft, while weighing Jalen Hurts, Baker Mayfield and the Jets’ missed opportunities with Jaxson Dart and Tyler Shough. The conversation also turns to the Yankees taking three of four from Boston, Red Sox broadcaster Will Fleming’s apology after ripping Jazz Chisholm, and whether Aaron Boone showed enough urgency. Plus, the Giants’ Odell Beckham Jr. expectations, a wild Super Bowl prediction, and the Jets’ long history of first-round disappointments.

Evan and Tiki analyze the hypocrisy of Mets fans booing Jose Altuve while simultaneously embracing Carlos Beltran. They also discuss the bizarre story of pitcher Tarek Skubal allegedly taking a team espresso machine with him after being traded and react to the Orioles claiming Luis Robert Jr. off waivers. (00:01:50) Mets Fans Boo Altuve (00:05:31) Evan's Astros Prank Confession (00:11:45) Pulling Off The Tripleheader (00:15:11) Mets Rookie Award Debates (00:18:40) Josh Hart Slams Announcer (00:25:08) Mets Pitcher Robert Stock (00:28:02) Skubal's Stolen Coffee Maker (00:36:01) Luis Robert Jr. Claimed (00:41:41) Fantasy Baseball Misery

Mets fans loudly booing Jose Altuve sparks a heated debate over the Astros cheating scandal and whether the outrage still makes sense. Evan Roberts questions the hypocrisy of crushing Altuve while remaining open to Carlos Beltran managing the Mets, arguing that Houston was far from the only team pushing the limits during that era. The conversation also celebrates a fan who pulled off the rare Yankees-Mets-Yankees tripleheader across New York, debates Mets Rookie of the Year candidates Carson Benge and Nolan McLean, and turns to Josh Hart calling for Red Sox broadcaster Will Fleming to be fired after his Jazz Chisholm rant.

The Giants get their share of chaos too, with Shaun Morash laying out a wild run to the NFC Championship and beyond while sizing up Odell Beckham Jr.’s most likely impact. Plus, the hosts rip Red Sox broadcaster Will Fleming’s apology after his Jazz Chisholm rant, arguing he still failed to properly address the player he attacked.

The Jets passed on every young quarterback available, and that decision could eventually define Darren Mougey’s tenure. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether New York should have taken a chance on Jaxson Dart, Tyler Shough or Shedeur Sanders instead of entering another season without a true franchise quarterback. They also question whether Cleveland has given Sanders a fair opportunity and revisit the Jets’ long history of disastrous first-round picks. The conversation then shifts to Garrett Wilson versus Malik Nabers after reports that the Jets once tried to trade up with the Giants to pair Nabers with Wilson. Plus, the Yankees’ George Lombard Jr. sparks a debate over whether a struggling young player should sit or be allowed to play through mistakes.

Joe Burrow becomes the ultimate Jets quarterback fantasy as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether New York should abandon the draft gamble and go all-in on a proven franchise star if Cincinnati ever makes him available. The Aaron Rodgers pursuit is defended as the right idea despite the disastrous result, while the Jets’ endless search for a long-term quarterback remains the franchise’s biggest problem. The conversation also turns to Darren Mougey passing on Jaxson Dart and Tyler Shough, whether the Jets should have traded up in the second round, and why drafting a young quarterback immediately starts the clock on a new regime. Plus, the Mets’ painful Pete Crow-Armstrong trade resurfaces as another brutal New York what-if.

The Jets cannot afford to gamble behind Geno Smith. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate the need for a proven backup quarterback, with Jimmy Garoppolo emerging as Tiki’s clear choice over the inexperienced Cade Klubnik. They explain why even a healthy starter can go down at any moment and why the Jets need someone capable of immediately running the offense. The conversation also turns to the massive expectations surrounding the Rams and whether their Super Bowl hype has gone too far. Then the Jets’ long-term quarterback future takes center stage, including whether a huge Geno season could change their plans and the possibility of pursuing Joe Burrow if he ever becomes available.

Odell Beckham Jr. is back on the Giants roster, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash agree he earned his spot after a strong enough finish to camp. But the excitement comes with questions about what Odell has left, Malik Nabers’ health and how the Giants’ receiving hierarchy could shake out. The Jets’ final cuts leave Evan wondering what the point of preseason even was after several players who appeared to perform well failed to make the team. Then the conversation turns heated over Red Sox radio blasting Jazz Chisholm for stealing bases during a Yankees rout. Evan rejects the unwritten-rule outrage, arguing Boston waved the white flag and the Yankees had every right to keep playing.

The Yankees may have slammed the door on Boston’s playoff hopes, but the Rays are suddenly creating a new problem. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether the Yankees have effectively locked up the top wild-card spot, why Tampa Bay’s bizarre late-game wins feel dangerous, and whether the AL East race is truly over. They also revisit Aaron Boone’s controversial lineup choices against Boston, David Cone seemingly predicting Elliott Ramos’ three-run homer moments before it happened, and the bigger problem with MLB replay. The hour closes with a debate over position players pitching in blowouts and whether baseball is eventually headed toward a mercy rule.

Boston’s frustration reaches another level as the Red Sox radio crew explodes over the controversial Rafael play, calling it one of the worst decisions of the season before acknowledging just how close the replay actually was. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash push back on the outrage and argue the Yankees still earned their blowout win. The conversation then takes a hilarious turn with a Yankees fan wondering whether his five-year-old should be allowed to buy Red Sox gear at Fenway Park. From there, the Jets take center stage after a fan hires a witch to cleanse the franchise’s bad luck. The hosts dismiss the curse talk and focus on the real concern: whether the Jets need a veteran backup quarterback behind Geno Smith after Cade Klubnik’s shaky preseason.

Boston is melting down over the controversial Rafael play, but Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash say the Red Sox have nobody to blame but themselves. They break down why the replay call stood, why overturning it could have created an even bigger mess with the baserunners, and why one disputed play doesn’t excuse a 16-1 Yankees blowout. Then the outrage shifts to Jazz Chisholm, as the Red Sox radio broadcast rips him for stealing bases with Boston already waving the white flag. Evan, Tiki and Shaun fire back at the idea that the Yankees should stop competing just because the Red Sox decided the game was over.

Evan Roberts, and Shaun Morash discuss George Lombard Jr.’s defensive struggles and what it could mean for the postseason. Plus: -Why won’t Aaron Boone give Lombard a day off? -Chris McMonigle gives his thoughts on Lombard -Craig Carton says Yankees should have pushed Gerrit Cole back for Red Sox

Geno Smith was sharp in his preseason debut, leading Boomer and Gio to have some level of optimism that the Jets offense will be much improved this year. Shaun Morash went on an epic rant against the optimism level from Jets fans, scoffing at the idea that it's remotely possible for the team to win eight games with Geno under center. Plus, Evan and Morash ponder a Mike Tomlin/Lamar Jackson team-up with the Jets, while Craig Carton debates whether Joe Burrow is a possibility or a pipe dream.

Loads of Giants figures joined WFAN this week to talk about the upcoming season, including John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen, who talked with Boomer and Gio about the makeup of the team and how key players have looked in camp. Plus, Brian Burns discussed the defense's new identity with Evan and Morash, while Jaxson Dart talked about his medical tent narrative, the feeling around camp this year, and much more with Craig and C-Mac.

After a walk off win Tuesday, the next two games become blowouts against the Milwaukee Brewers. Even in a game where the Brewers lose their starting pitcher after one pitch, the Mets offense is backed to being non existent. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Evan and Shaun are Live at the Salt Shack in Babylon oh yeah!! George Lombard is setting Yankee error records but Shaun continues to defend him, the highly anticipated Snoopy Bowl is later tonight, Jerry Recco joins, Shaun gives a Cinco, Idiots with Idioms, Shaun's Giants prediction and more. Have Fun With Ya Salt Shack!

George Lombard Jr. has committed an error in six straight games, turning the Yankees rookie’s defensive struggles into a major debate before a crucial Red Sox series. Evan Roberts believes sitting Lombard now could make the mental pressure even worse and wants him to play through it, while Shaun Morash argues a night off could help stop the spiral before it becomes a bigger problem. They also dig into the Yankees’ shaky offense, their difficult matchups against Boston’s left-handed pitching and why Aaron Judge’s return could be the boost the lineup desperately needs. Plus, Evan recounts a wild night at Citi Field featuring Mets squishy dumplings and an unexpectedly revealing singles night.

George Lombard Jr.’s defensive struggles have become impossible to ignore as the Yankees head into a huge series with the Red Sox. Evan Roberts argues that sitting the young shortstop now could make the situation even bigger, while Shaun Morash believes a breather could help stop the spiral before it becomes a national story. They debate whether the pressure and praise surrounding Lombard have gotten into his head and what happens if the errors continue against Boston. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they also clash over whether Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith should play in the preseason, compare Malik Nabers with Garrett Wilson, and reveal how they would approach ranking all 32 NFL head coaches.

The Giants hype hits another level as Shaun Morash predicts a 12-win season, the NFC’s No. 1 seed, a trip to the Super Bowl and an MVP campaign from Jaxson Dart. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts, with Jerry Recco joining the conversation as the crew debates the NFL’s best coaches and where John Harbaugh belongs. The Jets also get a painful Aaron Rodgers revisit, with Evan admitting they probably should have tried to make it work and questioning how Aaron Glenn handled their split. Plus, Kevin Durant’s Nets regret, Brian Cashman’s future with the Yankees, George Lombard Jr.’s defensive struggles and plenty of chaos from the live Long Island broadcast.

Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash analyze the current state of the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry, noting the absence of true villains in the modern era. They transition into a debate regarding the Jets' quarterback hierarchy and the future of Geno Smith compared to young prospects. The segment includes a beach power ranking discussion and a review of the week's funniest on-air gaffes. (00:03:04) Yankees Red Sox Rivalry (00:07:50) Volpe Lombard Performance (00:13:27) Jets Quarterback Situation (00:17:50) Big Mac Christie Jokes (00:24:05) Idiots With Idioms (00:29:00) Baseball Triple Header (00:32:36) Yankees Roster Moves (00:39:52) Aaron Rodgers Hypotheticals

Yankees-Red Sox still matters, but the rivalry feels different when there is barely a Boston player Yankees fans truly hate. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash look ahead to a crucial four-game series with major tiebreaker implications and explain why taking three of four could put the Yankees in control of a potential Wild Card matchup. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as the conversation shifts to the Jets’ quarterback situation and how long Geno Smith should keep the job if things go badly. Plus, George Lombard Jr.’s defensive struggles, Yankees versus Giants fandom and which championship New York fans need most.

The Jets’ quarterback future takes center stage as Evan Roberts weighs the dream scenario of making a massive move for Joe Burrow against drafting their next franchise quarterback. The conversation circles back to Aaron Rodgers, with the decision to move on from him now sitting squarely on the résumé of Aaron Glenn and the Jets’ new regime. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan, and the final stretch gets increasingly chaotic with a ranking of Long Island’s best beaches, a very memorable nude-beach story and the Rachel-versus-Monica debate from Friends

Andy Reid remains the gold standard as Evan Roberts, Shaun Morash and Jerry Recco debate which current NFL head coach they would choose to build a franchise around. Reid’s success in Philadelphia and Kansas City puts him at the top for Evan, while Sean McVay, Jim Harbaugh, Mike Vrabel, Mike Macdonald and Ben Johnson all enter the argument.

The Jets’ Aaron Rodgers decision gets a major second look, with Evan admitting they probably should have tried to make it work instead of immediately moving on. Jerry Recco joins the conversation as they question Aaron Glenn’s handling of Rodgers and wonder whether keeping him as a transition quarterback could have changed the Jets’ direction. Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor also spark intrigue after Soto was the first to congratulate Lindor on a home run, raising questions about whether their relationship has genuinely improved. Plus, Kevin Durant admits his biggest sports regret was failing to win a championship with the Nets, and the crew debates whether Brian Cashman’s long Yankees tenure may finally be nearing its natural endpoint.

Jaxson Dart should be playing in the preseason, and Evan Roberts wants the Giants to buck the NFL trend of protecting quarterbacks from game action. Shaun Morash pushes back, arguing joint practices now provide the meaningful reps teams once relied on preseason games to deliver. Their debate gets especially heated over Dart’s running style, injury risk, and whether a few drives can actually change anything. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they also argue over Geno Smith sitting out and clash over Malik Nabers versus Garrett Wilson. Evan defends Wilson’s production and consistency, while Shaun insists Nabers has the higher ceiling and is the more explosive receiver.

George Lombard Jr.’s defensive spiral has become the Yankees’ biggest concern entering a massive series against the Red Sox. Evan Roberts believes sitting the young shortstop now could only magnify the pressure, while Shaun Morash argues a breather may be exactly what Lombard needs after six straight games with an error. The debate turns to whether hype, criticism, and social media have gotten into the 21-year-old’s head. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they also debate Lombard’s long-term ceiling, whether he can become a true star, and how quickly Yankee Stadium could turn on him if the mistakes continue against Boston.

Citi Field’s Singles Night takes a bizarre turn as Evan Roberts reveals what attendees told him about the crowd and dating scene. Plus, Evan defends his mission to collect as many Mets squishy dumplings as possible for his kids and admits he’s enjoying George Lombard Jr.’s error streak more than Yankees fans would like.

George Lombard Jr.’s six-game error streak has Yankees fans debating whether he needs a breather or should keep playing through it. Evan Roberts warns that if the defensive issues continue, Lombard’s playoff job could eventually be in jeopardy, while Shaun Morash pushes back on waiting too long to act.

George Lombard Jr. has made an error in six straight games, but Evan Roberts agrees with Aaron Boone that sitting him now could make the mental problem worse. Shaun Morash wants Lombard to get a breather as the Yankees open a huge series against the Red Sox.

The Yankees’ trade deadline is already producing wildly different results. Luis Garcia Jr. looks like a massive addition and Austin Wells has quieted the catcher concerns, but Fernando Cruz’s injury exposes the bullpen hole Brian Cashman failed to fill. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash also debate whether Eugenio Suárez could still help the Yankees in October. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as Connor Hughes reveals the Jets tried to trade up for Malik Nabers and weighs whether the Jets have a legitimate path to eight wins. Plus, the Jets and Giants roster debate heats up, and Evan predicts Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field with Baltimore could turn the ballpark into an Orioles home game.

Brian Cashman’s trade deadline is looking better offensively, but the Yankees’ bullpen could become the decision that defines their postseason. Luis Garcia Jr. has been a massive addition, Austin Wells is finally producing like a functioning major league catcher, and the lineup is clicking. But Fernando Cruz’s devastating injury exposes the risk of Cashman failing to add a reliever, leaving major questions about how the Yankees will get the final nine outs in October. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they debate whether Eugenio Suarez should be added off waivers, George Lombard Jr.’s alarming error streak, and whether Anthony Volpe could actually become part of the conversation again. Plus, Mike Breen tells an incredible story about celebrating the Mets’ famous 1986 World Series comeback from inside the Red Sox radio booth.

The Jets wanted Malik Nabers badly enough to explore trading up with the Giants, and Connor Hughes reveals New York had Nabers ranked as the best receiver in his draft class. Hughes explains why the Giants quickly shut the door, why the Jets believed Nabers had best-in-the-NFL upside, and whether missing out ultimately worked in their favor. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as Hughes also lays out a path to a surprising Jets season, raises major concerns about their defense, and explains why Jaxson Dart still looks uncomfortable and needs more preseason work. Plus, the Giants’ growing tension with Cam Skattebo, Odell Beckham Jr.’s roster outlook, and a heated debate over why an MLB mercy rule may eventually become inevitable.

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field could turn into an unforgettable scene, with Evan Roberts predicting Mets fans may treat the former franchise star like the home-team hero. Evan compares Alonso’s looming reception to Eddie Giacomin’s legendary Rangers return and debates whether the Mets should even raise the home run apple if Alonso reaches a milestone. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as the Geno Smith versus Jaxson Dart argument heats up again, including whether the Jets have any realistic path to eight wins. Plus, the NFL officially kills the Pro Bowl games, the guys dream up a wild Yankees-Mets tripleheader, and a ridiculous Babe Ruth conspiracy takes over Cinco de Five.

Evan Roberts sees a massive gap between the Giants and Jets, even after admitting the Jets may have more talent at several offensive positions. His biggest reasons are coaching and a Giants pass rush he believes could become the team’s identity. Meanwhile, Shaun Morash pushes back on the Giants hype as the Jets prepare for another season surrounded by low expectations. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. They also debate whether Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith should play in the preseason finale, rip the NFL for forcing season-ticket holders to buy preseason games, revisit painful New York sports memories, and look ahead to Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field.

Evan Roberts explains why he believes the Giants can dramatically outperform the Jets despite giving the Jets the edge at several offensive positions. John Harbaugh is the biggest difference, while Evan believes the Giants’ pass rush could become the identity of a surprisingly successful season. Shaun Morash pushes back on some of the Giants optimism and questions the offensive line comparison. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. They also debate whether Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith should play against the Jets, revisit the Nets’ dramatic 2002 playoff win over Indiana, compare Pete Alonso’s return to Tom Seaver’s 1977 homecoming, and reveal Evan’s perfect prediction of the Jaxson Dart interview question count.

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field could become an uncomfortable night for the Mets, with Evan Roberts predicting fans may treat Alonso like the home-team star. Plus, Evan and Shaun Morash battle over Jaxson Dart versus Geno Smith, debate a new extra-innings idea, and get pulled into the absurd Babe Ruth conspiracy.

The NFL officially ends the Pro Bowl games, and Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash agree the format had become meaningless while debating whether the honor can finally regain value. Then the Jets argument explodes again. Evan insists an eight-win season is at least possible if Geno Smith rebounds, while Shaun says the season is basically doomed before it starts.

A mercy rule is coming to Major League Baseball, and Evan Roberts believes the way managers now surrender blowouts makes it inevitable. After the Mets essentially waved the white flag against Milwaukee, Evan and Shaun Morash debate how a run rule could work, why teams would embrace it, and whether fans would accept games ending early.

Connor Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash with revealing details on how close the Jets came to pursuing Malik Nabers in the draft. Hughes explains why the Jets had Nabers ranked ahead of Marvin Harrison Jr., why the Giants shut down trade talks, and why Nabers was viewed as a potential best-in-the-NFL receiver.

Mike Breen reveals an incredible story from Game 6 of the 1986 World Series, admitting he celebrated the Mets’ legendary comeback while standing inside the Red Sox radio booth. Evan and Shaun react to Breen’s confession and debate how New York fans handle championships, droughts, and decades of bragging rights. Plus, Evan explains exactly how unbearable he would become if the Jets ever won a Super Bowl.

Eugenio Suarez is available, and the Yankees have a chance to add the power bat Shaun Morash has wanted for years. Evan and Shaun debate why Suarez makes more sense than Amed Rosario and how he could become a dangerous October weapon off the bench. Plus, Aaron Judge’s looming return creates major lineup decisions, while George Lombard Jr.’s five-error skid sparks an uncomfortable shortstop debate.

The Yankees’ offense is clicking, and Brian Cashman’s deadline moves are looking better by the day. Luis Garcia Jr. has been a huge addition, while Austin Wells is making the decision not to add a catcher look justified. But Fernando Cruz’s injury has exposed the bigger concern: Cashman failed to reinforce the bullpen, and the Yankees may enter October scrambling to figure out who gets the final nine outs.

Zac Thornton pitches another solid game by going 6 innings against the Brewers. Nate Lavender continues to dominate out of the bullpen. Add that with solo home runs by Francisco Lindor and Luis Robert Jr, and you have yourself a one run game going into the 9th inning. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

The Yankees’ bullpen is showing dangerous signs at the worst possible time. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash, filling in for Tiki Barber, question whether heavy workloads for the bullpen could eventually undo a team built around a dominant starting rotation. If October arrives with the bullpen running on fumes, the Yankees may have no choice but to ride their starters deeper than usual. They also debate Jazz Chisholm not stealing in a critical eighth-inning spot and Aaron Boone’s bizarre explanation that Jazz “attempted to.” Plus, SNY’s feed cuts out at the exact moment Francisco Lindor makes a spectacular game-saving catch, George Lombard Jr.’s early defensive mistakes spark concern, and the Yankees’ approach to pitching Yordan Alvarez comes under fire.

Brian Burns is buying into the new-look Giants, calling the combination of talent and John Harbaugh a “dream come true” and insisting the team feels ready to finally start fast. Burns opens up about Harbaugh’s demanding camp, Deonte Banks’ turnaround, the new defense and why Giants fans should feel confident. Isaiah Likely also joins the show to explain why he chose New York, what stands out about Jaxson Dart and how Harbaugh’s culture is already taking hold. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they debate what Odell Beckham Jr. can realistically provide in his Giants reunion and whether nostalgia is inflating expectations. Plus, Aaron Judge’s possible September 8 return gains steam, and the Yankees’ decision to keep Gerrit Cole out of the upcoming Red Sox series draws scrutiny.

A massive Jets rumor has Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash imagining the ultimate franchise reset: Mike Tomlin as head coach and Lamar Jackson at quarterback. Evan believes Woody Johnson would aggressively pursue Tomlin if the job opens, while Shaun questions the reporting but admits money and desperation could make Tomlin a legitimate possibility. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they debate whether the Jets have any real chance to surprise this season, revisit Malik Nabers versus Garrett Wilson, and discuss Andy Green as a potential Mets general manager. Plus, Ric Flair’s bizarre Dolly Parton tribute sparks disbelief.

Evan and Shaun break down the Yankees loss to the Astros and how they need to ride their starting rotation, the Jets are hoping to bring Mike Tomlin in as Head Coach, Giants vs. Jets conversation, Brian Burns and Isaiah Likely join the show, and a lot more!

Evan and Sean discuss Pete Alonso's upcoming return to Citi Field as he nears the 300-career home run milestone. They debate how Mets fans will react to the former star and contrast the atmosphere with other notable player returns. Additionally, they touch on win probabilities for the Jets and Giants while debating the naming of the Little League World Series. (00:01:55) Pete Alonso's Milestone (00:06:00) Monday Night Schedule (00:09:35) Moon Landing Conspiracy (00:13:45) Interview Question Predictions (00:17:00) Jets Win Probability (00:21:50) Squishy Dumpling Promotion (00:26:15) Little League Debate (00:32:20) Saquon Barkley Bust (00:39:00) Wilson vs Nabers (00:43:15) Sean Morash Recap

Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field could turn into an unforgettable scene, especially with the former Met closing in on 300 career home runs. The debate gets heated over just how far Mets fans should go in welcoming Alonso back, including whether it is acceptable to actually root for him to succeed against the Mets.

Mike Tomlin and Lamar Jackson to the Jets becomes the ultimate fantasy scenario as Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash react to a report linking Woody Johnson to the former Steelers coach and raising the possibility of Jackson eventually becoming available. Evan believes Tomlin would absolutely be a Jets target, while Shaun is skeptical of the reporting but admits money could bring Tomlin back to coaching.

The Jets debate explodes again as Evan Roberts pushes back on Shaun Morash for declaring there is essentially no chance they surprise people this season. Evan argues that unpredictable seasons happen all the time, while Shaun insists the Jets remain one of the NFL’s worst teams and says optimism should be kept in check. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as the Malik Nabers versus Garrett Wilson argument also heats back up, with Shaun defending his belief that Nabers has the higher ceiling. Plus, Evan and Shaun react to Ric Flair’s questionable Dolly Parton tribute and remember Parton’s legendary career and memorable Thanksgiving halftime performance.

Isaiah Likely is ready to show the Giants everything he can do. The newest Giants tight end explains why New York became the right destination in free agency, how John Harbaugh’s arrival helped shape the move and why he sees Jaxson Dart developing the command every offense needs from its quarterback.

Brian Burns is all-in on the Giants’ new direction under John Harbaugh, calling the combination of this roster and an established winning coach a “dream come true.” Burns explains why Harbaugh’s demanding approach has energized the team, why the defense feels ready for Week 1 and how Denard Wilson’s new system is more complex and detailed.

Aaron Judge’s return is starting to feel real, with September 8 emerging as the date gaining serious momentum. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash weigh whether Judge could skip a rehab assignment, return immediately as the Yankees’ DH and give the lineup a massive September boost.

George Lombard Jr.’s defensive mistakes are piling up, but Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash warn against overreacting to a 21-year-old still learning on the fly. They also question the Yankees’ approach to pitching Yordan Alvarez, revisit SNY’s disastrous Mets broadcast cutout and have some fun with Shaun’s social media meltdown.

The Yankees’ bullpen is raising serious October concerns as Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash question whether heavy workloads could force Aaron Boone to ride his starters deeper in the postseason. Plus, they debate Jazz Chisholm’s costly non-steal and Boone’s bizarre explanation before ripping SNY for cutting out during Francisco Lindor’s spectacular catch.

Geno Smith is at the center of a heated Jets reality check as Evan Roberts argues there is still a path to a competitive season while Shaun Morash insists the quarterback will ultimately hold them back. Evan puts the Jets’ chances of reaching eight wins at 20 percent, sparking a furious debate over whether that is realistic optimism or completely absurd. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they break down the Jets’ offensive talent, Geno’s ceiling, the defense’s uncertainty and where eight possible wins could actually come from on the schedule. The argument even spills into a Jets versus Giants talent comparison before turning toward Malik Nabers and his possible Week 1 return.

Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts, and the Jets debate turns combustible. Shaun insists they are headed for another miserable season, while Evan pushes back on dismissing them before the games begin. They set an early-season benchmark that could force Shaun to reconsider, then clash with callers over whether the Jets’ skill-position talent really compares with the Giants. The argument explodes around Malik Nabers and Garrett Wilson, with questions about quarterback play, injuries, tight ends and which receiver has the higher ceiling. The Giants also come under the microscope, including whether John Harbaugh can push them toward the playoffs, concerns about their defense, and why the Jets’ outlook may ultimately come down to coaching and quarterback play.

Toronto is taking shots at the Yankees again, with Blue Jays radio hosts calling them a “dumb” baseball team and essentially guaranteeing they would beat New York in the playoffs. Evan pushes back hard, arguing this Yankees team is far different from last year’s version, while the conversation turns to which AL East opponents actually present the biggest postseason danger. The hour also dives into Jets and Giants optimism, whether Jets fans are jealous of the excitement surrounding the Giants, and what Aaron Glenn needs to show to keep his job. Plus, Shaun Morash takes on the debut of the Aaron Boone nickname game, fantasy football’s most annoying league members get ranked, and the crew debates why drafts should be held as close to Week 1 as possible.

Evan and Shaun debate if the Jets can win 8-games this season, Malik Nabers vs. Garrett Wilson, Shaun guesses the Aaron Boone nickname, no-one cares about the Yankees-Astros rivalry anymore, and much more.

The Yankees-Astros rivalry just does not feel the same anymore. Houston once represented the team standing between the Yankees and the World Series, but that hatred has faded as the Astros’ core has changed. Jose Altuve remains the exception, with Yankee Stadium still ready to unload on him even as the larger rivalry loses its edge.

Evan and Shaun analyze the shifting dynamic of the Yankees-Astros rivalry and Jose Altuve's role as a persistent villain. Shaun faces scrutiny over his past bug-torture habits and a deleted tweet regarding Gio Urshela's Hall of Fame prospects. They also plan an investigation into Citi Field's concession availability during promotional nights. (00:01:50) Yankees-Astros Rivalry Analysis (00:06:50) Shaun's Bug Torture Confessions (00:10:04) Fantasy Football Draft Strategies (00:13:15) Debating Fantasy Punishment Enforcements (00:17:45) Morash's Deleted Hall-of-Fame Tweets (00:24:40) Citi Field Concession Investigation (00:34:45) Giancarlo Stanton Playoff Concerns (00:38:40) Lombard Jr. Expectations Debated (00:45:10) Zach Wheeler Cheating Allegations

Aaron Boone’s endless Yankees nicknames finally become a game, and Shaun Morash gets put to the test on everything from “Bus” and “Izzy” to “Squid.” The results are rough, the nicknames get increasingly ridiculous, and even Boone’s own family nickname enters the mix. The conversation then shifts to fantasy football, including the worst people to have in a league and why drafts should happen as close to Week 1 as possible. The hour closes with the Jets and Aaron Glenn, as the crew debates what Glenn must show to keep his job and why New York could suddenly become an appealing destination for a new head coach if things go badly again.

Toronto is talking trash about the Yankees again, with Blue Jays radio hosts calling New York a “dumb” baseball team and guaranteeing they would beat the Yankees in the playoffs. Evan pushes back on the shot, arguing Toronto is judging this Yankees team through last year’s failures while ignoring how much has changed. The debate turns to which AL East teams should actually scare the Yankees most in October and why Toronto still feels like a house of horrors. The conversation then shifts to the Jets and Giants, as Shaun Morash argues some Jets fans are jealous of the excitement surrounding the Giants. Evan explains why there is still a path to Jets optimism, even after Aaron Glenn’s disastrous first season.

Posted and Toasted delivers another round of old social-media receipts, including a self-deprecating Shaun Morash post and a freezing-cold take about Jaxson Dart and the Giants. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as the show digs through some painfully funny history.

The Jets have five games to prove Shaun Morash wrong. Shaun says a 3-2 start would force him to reconsider his bleak outlook, while Evan Roberts calls Week 1 against Tennessee a “do we have a season” game and argues the Jets still have a path to surprise people. The debate then erupts again over Malik Nabers and Garrett Wilson, with Shaun insisting Nabers has the higher ceiling while Evan points to Wilson’s production despite constant quarterback turnover. The Giants-Jets divide ultimately comes down to two words: coach and quarterback. Evan believes John Harbaugh can elevate the Giants into the playoffs, while he has far less faith in Aaron Glenn doing the same for the Jets.

Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts, and he isn’t buying the Giants as a playoff team. Shaun still sees roughly an eight-win roster, pointing to major concerns on the defensive line and at cornerback even as optimism grows around other parts of the team. Then the Jets-Giants comparisons get heated. Callers push back on Shaun’s pessimism about the Jets, sparking arguments over Malik Nabers versus Garrett Wilson, the two teams’ skill-position talent, and whether the Jets’ young tight ends deserve the hype. Shaun keeps coming back to the same conclusion: the Jets still stink, no matter how much potential their offense may have.

The Jets’ talent becomes the center of a heated argument as Evan Roberts pushes back on Shaun Morash’s insistence that Geno Smith makes all of it irrelevant. Evan lays out potential wins on the schedule and argues that dismissing an eight-win season as impossible goes too far, while Shaun keeps coming back to the same conclusion: without the quarterback, none of the surrounding talent matters. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as callers jump into the debate, including comparisons between the Jets and Giants skill-position groups. That sparks another argument over Garrett Wilson, Malik Nabers, A.D. Mitchell and whether Jaxson Dart is already better than Geno Smith, before the conversation turns toward Nabers potentially being ready for Week 1.

Geno Smith turns the Jets’ season into a heated argument over whether they have any realistic chance to surprise people. Evan Roberts expects a bad year but refuses to dismiss them completely, pointing to the offensive line, Garrett Wilson, the running game and Smith’s past success as reasons a competitive season is at least possible. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts and takes the much harsher position, arguing Smith will ultimately sink the offense and that the Jets have virtually no path to being good. Evan fires back with a 20 percent chance of eight wins, setting off a fierce debate over hope, quarterback play and just how bad the Jets really are.

In what looked like a well played series, the Mets lost two of three on the final at bats of the game. The bullpen let down the team for the first time since the trade deadline. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Giancarlo Stanton’s latest calf injury could end both his season and his Yankees career. The debate turns to whether New York should finally move on from Stanton, how his remarkable October availability shapes his legacy, and why injuries to Ryan Weathers and Max Fried reinforce the idea that the Yankees can never have enough pitching. George Lombard Jr. then becomes one of the day’s hottest arguments after a shaky defensive weekend. Shaun Morash doubles down on his belief that Lombard should eventually be among baseball’s elite shortstops and reach the Hall of Fame conversation, setting off callers and plenty of pushback. The Giants also take center stage as Jaxson Dart’s repeated trips to the blue medical tent become both a running joke and a legitimate concern heading toward the regular season. The show also hits Tarik Skubal’s Dodgers future, the Jets’ preseason flashes, Deshaun Watson and Cleveland’s dysfunction, and the tightening AL East race.

Giancarlo Stanton may have played his final game for the Yankees. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash react to Stanton’s latest calf injury, why his remarkable October history makes this setback different, and whether New York should finally move on this offseason. Ryan Weathers’ elbow injury also reignites the debate over the Yankees’ pitching depth and proves why Evan believes a contender can never have enough starting pitching. Then George Lombard Jr.’s rough defensive weekend turns into a heated argument over expectations for the Yankees’ young shortstop. Shaun puts Lombard on a path toward becoming one of baseball’s elite at the position, callers push back hard on the early Hall of Fame talk, and the debate quickly goes off the rails.

The Dodgers’ handling of Tarik Skubal has Evan Roberts convinced they have no intention of keeping the ace long term. After back-to-back starts featuring two of the highest pitch counts of Skubal’s career, Evan argues Los Angeles is riding him hard because they expect him to leave, opening the door for the Mets to become the obvious landing spot. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts and pushes back on just how certain that conclusion really is. The hour also turns into a heated Deshaun Watson debate after the Browns quarterback fires back at Cleveland fans for booing him. Evan calls the Browns more dysfunctional than the Jets, while Shaun argues the reaction is partly fueled by the fan obsession with Sanders. Plus, George Lombard Jr.’s Yankees future, Anthony Volpe’s role, Francisco Alvarez frustration, and a birthday-text feud with Tommy Lugauer.

Jaxson Dart’s trips to the blue tent have become a full-blown Giants storyline, and Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash debate whether the quarterback is now under unfair scrutiny every time he takes a hard hit. They break down why Dart may need to pop right back up after contact, whether the Giants should be helping protect him from unnecessary evaluations, and why returning to the game helped kill the latest injury controversy. The Yankees have also dragged themselves back into the AL East race, forcing Evan to admit the division is no longer over with New York just three games back. Plus, the Giants’ improving secondary, Odell Beckham Jr.’s roster chances, Geno Smith’s Jets outlook, and the best quarterbacks to resurrect their careers with a new team.

John Harbaugh’s message to Tyrone Tracy has Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash reading between the lines after two costly preseason mistakes. Harbaugh managed to defend Tracy while stressing the importance of his missed block and fumble, raising real questions about where Tracy stands in the Giants’ running back pecking order. Evan and Shaun debate whether Najee Harris could emerge as the lead back, while Tiki Barber’s earlier pick of Tracy creates a three-way split with Cam Skattebo also getting support. They also revisit Evan and Shaun’s legendary 2018 Jacob deGrom versus Luis Severino argument, react to Deshaun Watson’s apology to Browns fans, revisit the Jaxson Dart “Big Blue Tent” debate, and look at the Yankees’ tightening AL East race. Evan also explains why the WNBA’s latest culture-war controversy has turned him off from the league.

John Harbaugh’s comments on Tyrone Tracy reveal just how unsettled the Giants’ running back pecking order has become. After two costly preseason mistakes, Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash debate whether Tracy could be buried on the depth chart and what Najee Harris’ arrival means for his role. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. The debate turns into three very different predictions for the Giants’ leading rusher, with Evan backing Najee Harris, Shaun choosing Cam Skattebo, and Tiki’s earlier pick of Tracy still hanging over the conversation. Plus, Evan revisits the hilarious 2018 Jacob deGrom versus Luis Severino argument that helped launch his relationship with Shaun.

The Yankees have dragged themselves right back into the AL East race, forcing Evan to admit his earlier declaration that the division was over no longer holds up. With New York just three games behind Tampa Bay, Evan still picks the Rays to win the East, but acknowledges the Yankees have made it a legitimate fight. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. The conversation also turns to Geno Smith and quarterbacks who revived their careers with new teams, including Vinny Testaverde, Rich Gannon and Sam Darnold. Plus, the Jaxson Dart debate continues over whether the Giants quarterback is getting treated differently around the NFL.

Jaxson Dart’s growing blue-tent reputation is creating a bizarre problem for the Giants. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash debate whether Dart is now being watched more closely because of last season, why taking a few extra seconds to get up could keep sending him for evaluations, and whether John Harbaugh deliberately put him back into a preseason game to shut down another injury controversy. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. The Giants’ preseason also delivers reasons for optimism, including Deonte Banks looking improved and unexpected offensive-line depth. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr.’s dropped touchdown sparks a debate over whether he can still make the roster, while David Bailey’s early flashes give Jets fans something to get excited about.

Deshaun Watson’s response to being booed sends Evan Roberts off on the Browns, with Evan arguing Cleveland should have cut him and declaring the franchise even more dysfunctional than the Jets. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts and pushes back, arguing some of the boos are fueled by fans wanting Sanders at quarterback. The debate quickly turns into a heated argument over Watson’s performance, contract, and whether Cleveland should still be giving him another chance. The conversation also hits George Lombard Jr.’s huge expectations with the Yankees, Francisco Alvarez’s struggles with the Mets, Shaun’s absurd birthday-text feud with Tommy Lugauer, and Evan’s new “Big Blue Tent” nickname for Jaxson Dart after another trip to the medical tent.

The Dodgers’ handling of Tarik Skubal has Evan Roberts convinced they have no intention of signing him long term. After Los Angeles pushed Skubal to two of the highest pitch counts of his career in consecutive August starts, Evan argues the Dodgers are treating him like a rental and riding him as hard as possible before he leaves. Shaun Morash pushes back on declaring it a done deal, but agrees the workload is strange. Evan takes the argument one step further, predicting that if the Dodgers are truly out, the Mets could become the clear favorite to land Skubal. Plus, the Yankees’ future comes into focus with George Lombard Jr., Anthony Volpe’s potential role at second base, and questions about how the infield could look in 2027.

Shaun Morash’s George Lombard Jr. projection ignites an all-out fight with a Yankees caller who absolutely unloads on him. After Shaun says Lombard should eventually be in the Hall of Fame conversation, the caller rips the take, attacks Shaun personally, and sparks a fiery response that sends the show completely off the rails. Evan Roberts breaks down who won the confrontation as Shaun defends what he actually meant: Lombard has the potential to become one of baseball’s elite shortstops, not that he is already destined for Cooperstown. More callers pile on, Anthony Volpe comparisons resurface, and the debate becomes a wild argument over how soon fans should crown a young Yankees prospect.

George Lombard Jr.’s rough defensive weekend raises the first real questions about the Yankees’ prized young shortstop. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash debate whether the miscues are anything to worry about, why his elite range still jumps off the screen, and whether Yankee fans are rushing to crown Lombard after being burned by Anthony Volpe. The conversation escalates when Shaun projects Lombard as one of baseball’s future elite shortstops, while Evan pushes back on putting enormous expectations on a player this early. Plus, the Yankees’ pitching injuries strengthen Evan’s argument that a contender can never have enough starting pitching, and Giancarlo Stanton’s remarkable postseason availability becomes part of the discussion surrounding his uncertain future.

Giancarlo Stanton may have played his final game for the Yankees after another calf injury likely ends his 2026 season. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash react to the bizarre setback, what it means for Stanton’s Yankees legacy, and why his history of showing up in October made this injury especially stunning. Ryan Weathers’ elbow injury adds another major concern to a suddenly thinner rotation. Evan argues the Yankees’ latest setbacks prove you can never have enough starting pitching, while Shaun pushes back on how much the injuries really change the outlook.

Craig Carton calls out John Harbaugh for putting Jaxson Dart back into a meaningless preseason game. Plus: -Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts on the importance of keeping Dart healthy -Boomer Esiason disagrees with Craig on Jaxson Dart take -Bart Scott predicts a 6-11 season for the Giants -Evan and Tiki on Odell Beckham Jr.’s chances to make the team

Steve Cohen spoke to the media this week, and doubled down on his belief that David Stearns is the right man for the job. Boomer and Jerry react to Cohen's comments, as do Evan and Tiki. Plus, Craig Carton has a wild hypothetical where the Dodgers' owner suddenly selling his shares of the team leads to Shohei Ohtani in Queens, and Jerry Recco wonders if Francisco Lindor's improved play is another sign that he and Juan Soto cannot coexist.

The Yankees were hit with another injury blow, this time to Max Fried. Evan and Tiki discuss if the prognosis is truly as optimistic as Aaron Boone made it out to be, and wonder how the Yanks continue to survive this injury wave. Plus, Boomer and Jerry wonder how long the Yanks can stay afloat with so many key players out, Craig Carton and Emmanuel Berbari discuss the starting rotation without Fried, and is George Lombard Jr. the spark that can take the Yanks on a deep playoff run?

Steve Cohen, the owner of the New York Mets speaks to the media about the 2026 Mets, David Stearns, Andy Green and the state of the team. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Evan and Tiki discuss the wild weather from Thursday night across the area, the Yankees sweeping the Orioles in Baltimore, Abdul Carter still talking about becoming Lawrence Taylor, Cade Klubnik's back-up QB chances, Rosie gives his cinco on facial hair stylings and Evan wonders what the future holds for Joe Burrow!

The Yankees are suddenly back in the AL East race, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are split on whether this surge is real enough to catch Tampa Bay. Tiki reverses course after four straight wins and an improving lineup, while Evan refuses to abandon the larger sample without Aaron Judge. Gerrit Cole’s dominant outing also sparks a major Yankees debate over whether he has actually been better in pinstripes than CC Sabathia. They also get into Michael Kay’s eyebrow-raising “offensive orgy” call, Anthony Volpe’s move to second base in the minors, Pete Alonso’s potential Hall of Fame path, and the roster decision looming for Spencer Jones when Cody Bellinger returns. Plus, the wild New York-area storms and tornado videos lead to a debate over what anyone is actually supposed to do when a tornado hits.

Abdul Carter wants to become the greatest of all time, and his pursuit of Lawrence Taylor’s legendary standard has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debating whether that confidence is inspiring or simply creating impossible expectations. Carter flashed plenty of potential as a rookie, but if he wants to be mentioned with LT, the production has to become undeniable. The Giants also have one of the NFL’s strongest insurance policies behind Jaxson Dart in Jameis Winston, while Dart’s aggressive running style remains a concern after some reckless moments as a rookie. Plus, Evan and Tiki look ahead to the Jets’ preseason matchup, what Aaron Glenn’s defense needs to show, Braylon Allen’s opportunity, and Geno Smith’s continued push to look like a steady starting quarterback.

The Jets may be staring at another long season. Brian Costello joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber from Pittsburgh and puts their ceiling at seven wins, while explaining why Aaron Glenn deserves the full season to prove he can make this team competitive. They also break down Cade Klubnik’s push for the backup quarterback job, concerns surrounding Kenyan Sadiq, and what Glenn’s defense could look like. Tiki turns to the Giants and the biggest thing he wants to see against Miami, while Evan insists Jaxson Dart simply needs to stay out of the blue medical tent. Plus, the Yankees’ bullpen keeps rolling, Evan gives proper credit for “Head to Bed,” and National Men’s Grooming Day sparks a ranking of the best facial-hair styles.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber analyze Joe Burrow's recent plea for organizational urgency, interpreting his comments as a sign that the quarterback may eventually force a trade from the Cincinnati Bengals. They also debate the use of home run props in the Yankees dugout and review the latest collection of linguistic blunders in the weekly Idiots with Idioms segment. (00:01:53) Joe Burrow's Future in Cincinnati (00:06:04) Predicting Burrow's Next Team (00:09:01) College Football Tight End Spotlight (00:12:38) Yankees and Mets Future Comparison (00:18:11) Debating Yankees Home Run Props (00:20:39) Radio Station Bathroom Construction Woes (00:27:57) Idiots with Idioms Highlight Reel (00:34:08) Aaron Boone's Unique Player Nicknames (00:37:41) Navigating Public Bathrooms in NYC (00:45:11) Potential MLB Labor Strike Risks

Joe Burrow’s comments about urgency in Cincinnati sound like a quarterback running out of patience. The Bengals star says he is tired of waiting until next year, fueling a debate over whether he could eventually force his way out and why the Jets would be an unlikely destination. The Rams, Eagles, Broncos and even Giants enter the hypothetical conversation as possible future fits. The conversation also turns to Mason Taylor’s opportunity with Kenyan Sadiq sidelined, whether the Mets can ever become more consistently successful than the Yankees, and a spirited argument over whether the Yankees should embrace a home run celebration prop.

Jaxson Dart has one major assignment against Miami: play well and stay out of the blue medical tent. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why another injury scare would ignite questions about Dart’s durability, playing style, and whether the Giants can count on him for a full season. Evan even unveils a new nickname tied to Dart’s repeated trips to the tent. Tiki also lays out what he needs to see from the Giants defense, especially against the run and in the secondary. Plus, the conversation turns back to Aaron Glenn’s Jets future and what kind of season could put his job in real danger.

The Yankees bullpen is becoming a real strength, and Evan Roberts finally admits he wasn’t the first to come up with the “Head to Bed” nickname. Even without their top late-inning arms available, the Yankees still finished off Baltimore behind strong work from Gerrit Cole and Ryan Yarbrough. Then things take a sharp turn on National Men’s Grooming Day. Jaxson Dart’s training camp mustache leads Evan and Tiki Barber into a full ranking of the coolest facial hair styles, from goatees and mutton chops to the Fitzpatrick beard and handlebar mustache.

Brian Costello joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber from Pittsburgh and delivers a sobering outlook for the Jets, putting their ceiling at seven wins while explaining why Aaron Glenn still deserves the full season to prove he can make the team competitive. Costello also breaks down Cade Klubnik’s strong push for the backup quarterback job, growing concern around Kenyan Sadiq’s limited practice work, and the changes Glenn is making to the Jets defense. The biggest goal is simple: avoid another embarrassing season and show meaningful progress from September through December.

WFAN-on-WFAN crime takes over as Evan Roberts discovers his “Head to Bed” nickname for the Yankees bullpen may have been stolen by his own coworkers. After hearing Emmanuel Berbari use the phrase with Craig Carton without giving Evan credit, Evan launches a full investigation into who actually created it and demands recognition for one of his proudest inventions. The accusations only grow after a caller claims Jake from Jomboy has been using “Head to Bed” for months, creating another twist in the ownership battle. Evan also revisits another alleged case of WFAN idea theft involving Michael Kay’s “offensive orgy” line as the station’s plagiarism accusations pile up.

Abdul Carter says he wants to become the greatest of all time, but invoking Lawrence Taylor immediately puts enormous pressure on the young Giants defender. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber love the confidence, yet make clear that becoming LT requires dominance on both the tape and the stat sheet. Carter showed flashes as a rookie, but now the expectations are impossible to ignore. The conversation also turns to Jaxson Dart’s physical playing style and why Jameis Winston gives the Giants one of the NFL’s best backup quarterback situations. Plus, Evan and Tiki weigh the Giants-Dolphins practice fights and whether that training-camp aggression is actually a good sign.

Pete Alonso’s Hall of Fame future sparks a fascinating Mets debate, as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wonder whether enough success in Baltimore could eventually make Alonso more closely associated with the Orioles than the Mets. Evan argues that reaching 500 home runs would likely be necessary to put Alonso on a Cooperstown path, with postseason success potentially influencing which team defines his legacy. The Yankees also face a looming roster crunch with Cody Bellinger nearing a return, and Evan insists Spencer Jones cannot be the player sent down after his recent surge. They also discuss Anthony Volpe’s move to second base, the possibility of catching Aaron Judge on a minor-league rehab assignment, and Evan’s mission to land the Howie Rose retirement-day Mets giveaway.

The Yankees have won four straight and cut Tampa Bay’s AL East lead to four games, forcing Tiki Barber to reverse his earlier declaration that the division race was over. Evan Roberts isn’t convinced, arguing that the Yankees’ lengthy stretch without Aaron Judge still shows a team only slightly above .500 despite the recent surge. They debate whether Cody Bellinger’s return, improved offense from Elliott Ramos and Luis Garcia, and dominant pitching can change the race. Gerrit Cole’s latest gem also sparks a bigger argument, with Evan making the case that Cole has actually been a better Yankee than CC Sabathia, even if CC remains the more beloved figure.

The Mets have now won 4 of their last 5 series. Most recently beating the San Diego Padres at home. Is something magical happening in Queens? P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

The Yankees escaped Baltimore with a 5-3 win, but Pete Alonso’s controversial foul ball became the defining moment. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the Yankees caught a massive break, while also giving them credit for capitalizing with clutch offense and strong bullpen work after the call. The bigger issue is MLB’s replay system and why baseball still lacks the technology to definitively rule on towering fair-or-foul home runs. George Lombard Jr continues to make an immediate impact with his bat, speed and defense, fueling a debate over just how high his ceiling could be. Evan and Tiki also push back on the sudden criticism surrounding Giants running back Tyrone Tracy.

Aaron Glenn is owning the mistakes that helped derail his first season with the Jets, including choosing the wrong coaching staff and wasting energy battling the New York media. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Glenn’s self-reflection is a promising sign or whether the bigger problem remains his quarterback decisions, with Geno Smith now carrying enormous weight in Year 2. The Giants spark plenty of heat too, as Evan defends his “Big Blue Tent” nickname for Jaxson Dart while Giants fans push back. The conversation turns to whether this could be the Giants’ best roster since 2011, the crowded running back and receiver battles, and Odell Beckham Jr.’s chances of sticking. Plus, George Lombard Jr.’s ceiling fuels a Yankees prospect debate that leads straight into Derek Jeter, Jose Reyes, and the danger of putting superstar expectations on young players.

The Jets were right to keep Aaron Glenn, but another bad season could completely change their coaching outlook. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why firing Glenn midseason would make little sense, why Frank Reich should not be viewed as an automatic replacement, and how three first-round picks could make the Jets a far more attractive destination if they conduct a coaching search after the season. Aaron Judge’s 2018 injury return offers a fascinating comparison for his current comeback, including what it could mean for his postseason readiness and defensive role. Plus, Keith Hernandez goes out of his way to encourage A.J. Ewing, Tiki recalls giving Tyrone Tracy advice, the worst New York sports jerseys get ranked, and the Nets’ sale of Julius Erving is revisited as one of the franchise’s defining mistakes.

Evan and Tiki break down Pete Alonso crucial foul ball hit in the 7th inning of last night's Yankees-Orioles game. Geno Smith will start for the Jets in preseason week two against the Steelers.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the controversial call on Pete Alonso's fly ball down the left field line against the Yankees. What is the Giants running back room going to look like following the signing of Najee Harris. The 5 worst jerseys in NY sports since 2000. What is Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets?

Evan Roberts calls out Shaun Morash for a glaring double standard after Shaun criticized Evan for doing Mets content during WFAN programming, only to go live with Talkin' Giants while Evan & Tiki were on the air. Tiki backs Evan’s argument that specialized YouTube shows are not really competing with WFAN’s broader radio coverage. The conversation also digs into MLB replay after Pete Alonso’s disputed foul ball, why Hawkeye cannot settle every call, and a wild idea to extend foul poles with lasers. Plus, Aaron Glenn will ultimately be judged on wins, while George Lombard Jr. draws comparisons to Jeremy Peña and a young Miguel Cabrera.

The Jets drafted David Bailey second overall, and the expectation is enormous: he needs to become the kind of defensive superstar the franchise has rarely had. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Bailey can develop into a true game-wrecker, why even strong Jets defenses have lacked that dominant presence, and how the shadow of Darrelle Revis still hangs over highly drafted defensive stars. The final stretch also features a Giants playoff disagreement, with Evan believing they can get in while Tiki sees an eight or nine-win team falling short. Plus, Pete Alonso’s absence gets measured against the Mets’ disastrous first-base production, MLB’s replay controversy comes under fire, and New York’s ugliest jerseys spark a debate over whether winning changes how fans remember uniforms.

Odell Beckham Jr. says the NFL never identified a specific banned substance, only that his testosterone levels were too high, shedding new light on the suspension that helped keep him unsigned last season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down how Beckham’s appeal delayed the punishment and why his timing made finding a team even tougher. Keith Hernandez then surprises Evan by revealing he went out of his way to speak with struggling Mets youngster A.J. Ewing. That sparks Tiki to share the ball-security advice he gave Tyrone Tracy during his rookie year and what he learned from Giants legend Frank Gifford. Plus, a Nets fan relives the franchise-altering sale of Julius Erving, and the possibility of Frank Reich replacing Aaron Glenn midseason gets an early reality check.

The Giants’ roster battles take center stage from there, with questions about Najee Harris, Tyrone Tracy Jr., Jalin Hyatt and a crowded receiver room. Odell Beckham Jr.’s chances of making the team are suddenly looking real, while George Lombard Jr. sparks another Yankees prospect debate and a reminder of just how impossible Derek Jeter comparisons can become.

Jaxson Dart’s trips to the blue medical tent have inspired a nickname Giants fans absolutely hate. Evan Roberts defends calling Dart “Big Blue Tent,” arguing the frequency is impossible to ignore, while Tiki Barber pushes back on taking the nickname too far. The debate turns into a bigger question about how quickly fans attach expectations and narratives to young players. George Lombard Jr. becomes the next test case as Evan and Tiki debate comparisons to Derek Jeter, Jose Reyes, Alex Rodriguez and other shortstops. They argue that prospect expectations can become ridiculous before a player has even established himself, while also revisiting how perceptions changed around Anthony Volpe, Michael Conforto and other highly touted young players.

George Lombard Jr is giving the Yankees exactly the kind of spark a top prospect can provide in a pennant race. His clutch contact, aggressive baserunning and brilliant defense have Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering just how high his ceiling can go, leading to comparisons ranging from Andrelton Simmons and Jose Reyes to Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez. The conversation turns to the Giants and what Evan sees as an unfair rush to bury Tyrone Tracy. One missed preseason block and the excitement surrounding Cam Skattebo have changed the narrative quickly, but Evan argues Tracy has already proven he can be a dynamic NFL back and still views him as the Giants’ RB1.

The Pete Alonso controversy gets even louder as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber compare the stunned reactions from Yankees and Orioles broadcasters after Alonso’s apparent home run remained a foul ball. Even Yankees voices admit they caught a break, while Baltimore’s broadcasts are left furious over a decision that looked impossible to explain from the angles shown on television. Then the frustration turns into conspiracy talk, with Orioles radio questioning whether the New York-based replay center somehow favored the Yankees. Evan and Tiki dismiss that theory while explaining why the original call on the field was so difficult to overturn. Aaron Boone also weighs in with the one opinion almost nobody else seemed to share: he thought the ball was foul.

The Yankees survived a massive Pete Alonso scare in Baltimore when his towering shot was ruled foul, a call Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe completely changed the game. They credit the Yankees for taking advantage and finishing off a 5-3 win, but the controversy raises a bigger question about why MLB still cannot definitively judge fair-or-foul home runs with modern technology. Evan and Tiki call for taller foul poles, better camera angles and even new tracking technology to eliminate the guesswork. They also debate whether Alonso still cares about making headlines in New York, while the Orioles broadcast pours gasoline on the rivalry by mocking Mets fans after his earlier home run.

The Yankees keep winning, but almost nothing about it feels comfortable. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down encouraging injury news on Max Fried, the slow road back for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, Jazz Chisholm’s growing struggles, and whether this battered Yankees roster can finally get healthy enough to become dangerous in October. The Mets bring a different kind of frustration after Fernando Tatis Jr. robbed Francisco Lindor, sparking a wild debate over whether fans in the front row have an obligation to help their team. Steve Cohen’s comments on the Mets’ disappointing season ignite another examination of David Stearns, the decision to move on from Pete Alonso and Cohen’s admission that the organization may have taken too much risk. Evan and Tiki also debate the dangers of massive free-agent contracts, Geno Smith’s need for preseason reps and Evan’s grim Jets prediction, plus George Lombard Jr., the Nets’ painful history, NYCFC fandom, Citi Field’s mysterious concession lines and a prediction of a brutal baseball work stoppage.

The Yankees keep winning, but nothing about it feels comfortable. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into another stressful victory, Aaron Judge’s slow progress toward a return, Giancarlo Stanton’s recovery and why Max Fried’s latest IL stint sounds more precautionary than disastrous. They also debate whether the Yankees deserve credit for surviving an injury-riddled season or criticism for barely playing .500 baseball despite dominant pitching. Jazz Chisholm’s slump and defensive mistakes are becoming harder to defend, while Trent Grisham suddenly delivers the offense New York desperately needs. Plus, Fernando Tatis Jr.’s robbed grand slam sparks a wild debate over whether Mets fans sitting in home run territory failed their team, Evan declares the Mets finished, and the conversation shifts to the Nets, Giants, Cowboys and whether Tiki could survive one more NFL game.

Geno Smith needs real preseason work, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the Jets cannot afford to ease him into the season. With Smith learning another new offense, they argue he needs reps with the starters, a chance to establish himself as the offensive leader, and enough game action to be ready for Week 1. They also debate whether strong play from Cade Klubnik could eventually create pressure at quarterback. The Yankees could have another bullpen weapon coming in Luis Gil, while George Lombard Jr.’s remarkable defense continues to turn heads. Evan also unloads on the Mets over Jorge Polanco, Ronny Mauricio and the decision to move on from Pete Alonso, while the conversation hits Paul Goldschmidt’s decline, fan interference, and even the New York Red Bulls.

The Dodgers are under the microscope as Mark Walter faces a federal criminal investigation, raising fresh questions about the franchise’s financial power and the advantages that have allowed Los Angeles to keep spending aggressively. The conversation turns to whether anything could actually threaten the Dodgers, why their biggest free-agent misses barely slow them down, and the fantasy scenario rival fans would love to see if ownership were ever forced to sell. Steve Cohen also addresses the Mets’ trade deadline and makes it clear he remains committed to David Stearns despite questionable offseason decisions. Plus, the Yankees’ biggest American League threats are ranked, with Boston, Tampa Bay and one very familiar enemy looming over October. The Jets get a grim Geno Smith prediction, and Tiki Barber gets an unexpected reminder of just how heavily he was used during his playing career.

Evan Roberts admits the Nets helping build a Celtics championship still bothers him more than contributing Mikal Bridges to a Knicks title. Tiki Barber pushes back, arguing the Knicks rivalry should hurt more, while Evan explains why the disastrous Boston trade remains impossible to escape. Evan also owns his Kyle Tucker miss, wonders whether David Stearns should publicly wear an “L” over Pete Alonso, and questions Citi Field’s bizarre concession situation on $5 Tuesday. Plus, the crew debates empty NFL preseason stadiums and Evan makes a brutal prediction for baseball’s next work stoppage: a season that might not begin until Mets-Yankees in mid-July.

Pete Alonso’s return puts the Mets’ biggest offseason decision back under the microscope. Evan Roberts says David Stearns should show some humility and literally wear an “L” when Alonso comes back to Citi Field, while Evan and Tiki Barber wonder why Steve Cohen wasn’t directly asked whether letting Alonso go was a mistake. Evan also owns his bad Cody Bellinger and Kyle Tucker take after dismissing Bellinger, while Tiki explains why Bellinger’s defense and ability to handle New York matter so much. Plus, Tiki revisits the Giants’ infamous 2005 loss in Seattle, and a historic 22-0 blowout sparks a debate over whether fans should ever leave a game early.

Steve Cohen is standing firmly behind David Stearns. The Mets owner reiterates his commitment to the president of baseball operations, praises his intelligence and adaptability, and says he was pleased with the club’s trade deadline and the young talent added to the organization. But the support comes with pressure. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Cohen’s comments and question whether Stearns can improve after risky offseason decisions failed to deliver. Cohen also weighs in on the turmoil surrounding the Dodgers, while the conversation turns to Shohei Ohtani’s unusual opt-out clause and why he still seems unlikely to leave Los Angeles.

Pete Alonso becomes the centerpiece of a bigger debate over whether teams are too afraid of the ugly final years of long-term contracts. Evan and Tiki argue that if a star delivers several elite seasons, the deal can still be worth it even if the back end turns bad, with Gerrit Cole serving as a prime Yankees example. The conversation also examines David Stearns’ risk-averse approach with the Mets and whether avoiding long commitments can cost a team championship-caliber talent. Then the focus shifts to the Jets, where Geno Smith’s return inspires a grim prediction about another losing season, an eventual quarterback change and New York once again searching for its long-term answer.

Geno Smith needs to play in the preseason, and the Jets cannot afford to treat him like an established quarterback who can simply show up Week 1 ready to roll. The case is made for giving Smith significant reps with the starters as he learns another new offense, builds chemistry and tries to establish himself as the leader of the team. Aaron Glenn remains vague about his plans, while the strong preseason showing from Cade Klubnik creates another layer of intrigue. The conversation also turns to why the Jets should keep Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall even if the season goes sideways, plus a surprisingly deep New York Red Bulls and NYCFC debate.

Pete Alonso’s absence is becoming impossible for the Mets to ignore. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber unload on the disastrous production replacing Alonso, with Jorge Polanco heading back to the injured list and Ronny Mauricio still stuck in the minors. Evan argues that any long-term benefit from avoiding Alonso’s contract eventually has to make up for how badly the decision has hurt this season. The conversation also turns to the Yankees, where Luis Gil could emerge as a high-leverage bullpen weapon, George Lombard Jr.’s defense is already making a massive impact, and Paul Goldschmidt’s fading production has pushed him toward a bench role.

Tiki Barber gets hit with the ultimate hypothetical: for $100 million, could he suit up for one more NFL game? Tiki says he could probably make it work, but admits the recovery would be brutal and the thought of taking NFL contact again is far from appealing. The football talk also turns to the Giants adding Najee Harris, with Tiki viewing the move as protection against injuries in the backfield rather than a sign of panic. Evan Roberts and Tiki also weigh in on Dallas signing 37-year-old Von Miller and why a limited pass-rush role could still make him valuable. Plus, the conversation dives into the NFL’s oldest active players and a Yankees fan shares the painful story of giving up the exact seat where a home run later landed.

Francisco Lindor was robbed of a grand slam by Fernando Tatis Jr., but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber can’t stop thinking about the Mets fans sitting right behind the play. Should they have attacked the ball and made Tatis’ catch more difficult, or is it unfair to expect fans to react like players when a baseball is flying toward them? Evan argues that fans sitting in the front row of home run territory need a game plan because they can legitimately impact the outcome. The debate turns into a hilarious breakdown of fight, flight and freezing in the moment, along with memories of infamous fan interference. Plus, Evan admits his own sports teams have given him very little reason to experience meaningful-game stress.

The Yankees keep surviving, but every game feels like a struggle. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether New York deserves credit for staying afloat through a brutal run of injuries or criticism for barely playing .500 baseball despite outstanding pitching. Aaron Judge is making slow progress, Giancarlo Stanton is moving closer to a return, and Aaron Boone’s comments make Max Fried’s injured-list stint sound more precautionary than catastrophic. Jazz Chisholm is becoming another source of frustration. His bat has disappeared, the strikeouts are piling up, and a defensive mistake has Evan questioning whether Chisholm should still be guaranteed everyday at-bats. The Yankees may be headed for October, but getting Judge, Stanton and Fried healthy at the right time could determine how far they actually go.

The Padres saw first hand how good Carson Benge has been as he prevented not one but TWO runners from scoring in the first inning. This is now becoming a daily occurrence from the rookie right fielder. 11 base runners on and one scores, The Mets defense is alive and well. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Evan and Tiki discuss the Max Fried injury and the implications it has for the future of the Bronx Bombers. They also continue the discussion on Jaxson Dart's health, Breece Hall's injury update, the Jets QB situation, Indispensable Yankees rule the Cinco and the boys react to the news of Jose Iglesias throwing out the first pitch tonight at CitiField.

Max Fried is back on the injured list with the same elbow issue that already cost him nearly two months, and Evan Roberts has zero confidence the Yankees will see him pitch again this season. Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether Fried can realistically return for October, why Carlos Rodon suddenly carries even more pressure, and how the injury reinforces baseball’s harshest lesson: you can never have enough pitching. The Yankees also face a difficult roster decision when Cody Bellinger returns, with Spencer Jones looking like the likely casualty. On the Mets side, Evan refuses to call their four-game winning streak a playoff push but is enjoying the young talent and looking toward 2027. Plus, David Stearns leaves the door cracked for Andy Green’s managerial future, and the guys debate whether winning down the stretch could change the Mets’ plans.

Craig Carton called out Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber for supposedly ignoring the biggest question about Jaxson Dart returning to a preseason game after a blue-tent evaluation. There was just one problem: they had already debated it. Evan brings the receipts, while Tiki explains why a young quarterback like Dart still needs valuable preseason reps. The conversation also turns to Breece Hall’s groin injury and why Tiki worries missed practice time could affect his Week 1 readiness. Plus, the Yankees face a difficult decision with Spencer Jones when Cody Bellinger returns, Evan makes the statistical case for batting your best hitter leadoff, and the Jets debate whether winning now matters more than chasing future draft position.

Jaxson Dart’s constant trips to the blue tent are not an NFL conspiracy. After reviewing every incident, Evan Roberts admits he was wrong and joins Tiki Barber in pointing to the real issue: Dart repeatedly stays down after hits, giving concussion spotters every reason to pull him from the game. They explain why Dart and his teammates need to change that pattern. Evan and Tiki also react to the Giants signing Najee Harris, debate whether he could eventually surpass Tyrone Tracy in the backfield, and examine what the Jets must become offensively to have any chance of winning. Plus, Jets fans argue over tanking for a quarterback and Evan explains why three first-round picks make losing on purpose unnecessary.

Evan and Tiki evaluate which Yankees are most indispensable following a string of injuries, highlighting players like Ben Rice and George Lombard Jr. They discuss the Jets' offensive goals and dive into a debate regarding Jackson Dart’s frequent blue tent visits and the effectiveness of current concussion protocols. They also cover the return of Pete Alonso and Jose Iglesias' special appearance at Citi Field. (00:01:50) Yankees-Orioles Series Preview (00:05:21) Most Indispensable Yankees List (00:08:58) Jets Offensive Potential (00:12:14) Jackson Dart Blue Tent (00:17:12) Concussion Protocols And Safety (00:22:19) Jose Iglesias Mets News (00:25:48) Evaluating Jackson Dart Development (00:29:30) Pete Alonso Playoff Roadmap (00:37:46) Pete Alonso Return To Citi Field (00:40:40) NFL Standings Projections

Max Fried is headed back to the injured list with a recurrence of the left elbow bone bruise that already cost him more than two months, putting even more pressure on a Yankees roster that can’t afford another major loss. Evan and Tiki debate which Yankees are now the most indispensable, with Ben Rice, David Bednar, Gerrit Cole and George Lombard Jr. all entering the conversation. Lombard’s immediate defensive impact and the energy he has brought to the Yankees make a strong case for the top spot, while Bednar’s dominance at the back end of the bullpen could make him even more important in close games. The hour also touches on the Jets’ need to finally produce a top-half offense and Jose Iglesias returning to Citi Field to throw out the first pitch.

Jaxson Dart’s constant trips to the blue tent may have a simple explanation. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber review the quarterback’s previous injury evaluations and identify the recurring pattern: Dart stays on the ground after hits, immediately drawing the attention of medical spotters. Evan even reverses his previous belief that the NFL was unfairly targeting Dart, arguing the tape tells a different story. Tiki explains why teammates need to help Dart up when he is okay and how a quarterback’s reaction to contact can influence whether he gets pulled for evaluation. Plus, the debate turns to the Giants backfield, where Tyrone Tracy is viewed as the current RB1 while Najee Harris emerges as a bold pick to eventually lead the running backs in rushing.

The Giants are signing Najee Harris, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber don’t see the move as a punishment for Tyrone Tracy’s costly pass-protection mistake. They explain why Tracy still belongs atop the depth chart, how Harris can strengthen the backfield once healthy, and why Joe Schoen keeps attacking positions where the Giants need more depth. The conversation also turns to Jets fans calling for a tank, with Evan arguing that three first-round picks give New York a path to a franchise quarterback without intentionally losing. Plus, concern grows around Max Fried’s injury and what it could mean for the Yankees’ postseason rotation.

The Jets should be trying to win, not dreaming about draft position before the season even starts. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea of rooting for losses, arguing that New York has enough offensive talent and future draft capital to prioritize progress now instead of another reset. Evan also brings the numbers behind his case for batting Aaron Judge leadoff, showing how many additional plate appearances the Yankees could create for their best hitter. Plus, the debate turns to whether Andy Green’s strong run managing the Mets could eventually change his mind about wanting the job, and “Posted and Toasted” digs up some revealing old WFAN tweets.

Craig Carton called out Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber for supposedly failing to question why Jaxson Dart returned to a preseason game after a blue-tent evaluation. Evan fires back with the receipts, proving they not only asked the question but debated it extensively, while Tiki explains why Dart still needs those valuable preseason reps. The first 20 minutes also bring encouraging news on Breece Hall’s groin injury, though Tiki raises concerns about what missed practice time could mean for his Week 1 sharpness. Plus, Evan argues the Yankees must keep giving Spencer Jones opportunities when Cody Bellinger returns, and a Mets caller pushes for Kodai Senga to embrace “Ghostbusters” as his bullpen entrance music.

Cody Bellinger’s return could force the Yankees into a roster decision fans will hate. Evan Roberts lays out the limited options, with Spencer Jones looking like the most likely player to be sent down despite showing promise. Tiki Barber ultimately agrees that Jones may be the move, while Evan argues the Yankees should consider carrying one fewer pitcher instead of sacrificing a young bat. The conversation then takes a lighter turn into baseball walk-up music and whether sponsorships could eventually invade one of the sport’s best traditions. Evan and Tiki celebrate the connection between players, fans and iconic songs, including memories of Mets music that became permanently tied to baseball.

The Mets are finally playing winning baseball, but Evan Roberts refuses to entertain the idea that they are suddenly back in the playoff race. Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether fans can enjoy the young talent, improved bullpen and recent surge without becoming delusional about October, with Evan insisting it would take a massive winning streak before that conversation even begins. The focus then shifts to Andy Green and whether the interim manager can make the decision harder for David Stearns. Stearns says the expectation remains that Green returns to the front office, but Evan hears enough wiggle room to believe a dominant finish could change the plan. Plus, the Yankees’ Max Fried concerns continue, and their struggling offense faces more pressure to finally produce.

Max Fried is back on the injured list with the same elbow issue that already sidelined him for nearly two months, and Evan Roberts fears the Yankees may not see him pitch again this season. Evan and Tiki Barber break down why the recurrence is so alarming, whether even an optimistic Aaron Boone update can be trusted, and how Fried’s absence suddenly puts more pressure on Carlos Rodon, Garrett Cole, Ryan Weathers and the rest of the rotation. The injury also revives the trade deadline debate over Tarik Skubal and the warning that teams can never have enough pitching. Plus, the guys explain how the American League playoff schedule could help the Yankees survive with only three starters in the Division Series.

The hosts of WFAN react to the biggest storyline of the Giants' preseason game against the Vikings: second-year QB Jaxson Dart making yet another visit to the medical blue tent for a concussion evaluation. Evan and Tiki say perception is not necessarily reality when it comes to Dart's concussion history, while Craig GOES OFF on John Harbaugh.

The Mets destroy the Nationals in a three game series. Another sweep in the Month of August! Everything is clicking for the New York Mets. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Paul Rosenberg debate Jaxson Dart's tendency to wind up in the NFL's infamous "blue tents," the Yankees' survival, why Evan isn't buying the Mets hype, and whether or not Cade Klubnik looked like a real NFL quarterback in the preseason.

Jaxson Dart has already been sent to the blue medical tent six times, putting him just one trip behind Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen for their entire careers. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Dart’s playing style is the real problem or whether NFL spotters are treating the Giants quarterback with extra caution. They break down the hit against Minnesota, Tyrone Tracy’s missed block, Dart’s belief that he is being targeted, and why these interruptions could become a serious problem once the regular season begins. The conversation also turns to the Jets after Cade Klubnik’s brief preseason opportunity. Evan comes away intrigued and frustrated that Aaron Glenn gave the rookie only two drives, while Tiki explains why the Jets may not want to create an unnecessary quarterback controversy with Geno Smith.

Jaxson Dart’s repeated trips to the blue tent are becoming impossible to ignore, with Evan Roberts arguing the Giants need clarity on their young quarterback by Thanksgiving. Tiki Barber explains why Dart still needs live reps and how the new coaching staff can help determine whether he becomes New York’s long-term answer.

Jaxson Dart’s second season could define the Giants’ future at quarterback. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much progress Dart must show, why year-two improvement is so important for franchise quarterbacks, and whether comparisons to Josh Allen and Eli Manning strengthen the case that New York should know exactly what it has by season’s end. The Giants also bring in Najee Harris for a visit, raising questions about Tyrone Tracy and the running back room. Plus, Kodai Senga’s surprising bullpen success creates a new Mets debate, Joe Burrow’s future in Cincinnati comes under scrutiny, Cade Klubnik flashes for the Jets in the preseason, and Tommy John’s remarkable legacy sparks a Hall of Fame conversation.

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Paul Rosenberg close out Monday's show by debating Jaxson Dart's future, talking about scoring baseball and why Evan threw up at a Mets game,

The Mets are red hot, but Evan Roberts still refuses to call them a playoff contender. Tiki Barber sees reasons for optimism heading into a huge series against the Padres, while Evan insists the Mets remain a bad team on a hot streak until they get within seven games of a playoff spot. The debate also turns to whether Andy Green could earn the Mets’ permanent managerial job with a strong finish. Plus, Evan defends his stance on Jaxson Dart, arguing that by the end of Year 2 the Giants should know whether they truly have their franchise quarterback.

Jaxson Dart’s second season remains the defining question for the Giants. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Dart can prove he is a true franchise quarterback, how much a new coaching staff should matter, and why clear improvement is essential after watching quarterbacks like Josh Allen and Drake Maye make major Year 2 jumps. Joe Burrow’s long-term future in Cincinnati also comes under scrutiny, while the Jets’ young quarterbacks create preseason intrigue. Tiki reveals he’ll run the New York City Marathon, Evan makes a bold prediction about Fernando Mendoza’s first NFL start, and the conversation closes with Tommy John’s extraordinary impact on baseball and whether his unique legacy belongs in the Hall of Fame.

Najee Harris is visiting the Giants, and the timing immediately raises questions about Tyrone Tracy and New York’s confidence in its running back room. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Giants are sending Tracy a message or simply protecting themselves with another proven option. The conversation then shifts back to Jaxson Dart and the pressure surrounding his second season. Evan argues that franchise quarterbacks usually reveal themselves by Year 2, while Tiki points to the development and playmaking ability Dart still needs to show. Plus, Josh Allen and Eli Manning comparisons fuel the debate, and Kodai Senga’s surprising success in the Mets bullpen starts to create a legitimate closer conversation.

Jaxson Dart’s second season could define his future with the Giants. Evan Roberts argues that history gives young quarterbacks very little time to prove they are true franchise players and says New York should know the answer on Dart by November. Tiki Barber stresses how much coaching and scheme will matter, especially as the Giants build an offense around what Dart does best. The conversation also turns to Odell Beckham Jr.’s push to make the Giants roster. Tiki liked what he saw in Beckham’s preseason return, but with a crowded receiver room and special teams value working against him, OBJ still has plenty to prove before securing a spot.

Jaxson Dart’s repeated trips to the blue tent are becoming a real concern for the Giants. Evan Roberts points to six evaluations in 13 games and argues that the pattern cannot continue once the regular season begins, while Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that Dart should have been pulled from the preseason game after taking a hard hit. Tiki also agrees with Shaun O’Hara’s criticism of Tyrone Tracy for blowing a protection assignment and failing to pick up his quarterback afterward. Plus, the debate turns to Dart’s long-term future, with Evan arguing the Giants should know by November whether their young quarterback is truly the franchise answer.

Jaxson Dart’s repeated trips to the blue medical tent have Giants fans wondering whether every big hit is about to become a problem. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the NFL is being overly cautious with Dart, whether he needs to get up faster after contact, and why comparisons to Tua Tagovailoa still go too far when Dart has only been diagnosed with one concussion. The calls turn into a broader argument about how physical football is supposed to be. Tiki explains why tough training camps matter, breaks down Tyrone Tracy’s missed protection that led to Dart getting drilled, and pushes back on the idea that every violent-looking hit should automatically trigger panic. Evan also admits football is the one sport he has absolutely no desire to pretend he could play.

Cade Klubnik got only two preseason drives, but it was enough to leave Evan Roberts intrigued and wondering why Aaron Glenn pulled him so quickly. With Geno Smith sitting out because of an ankle issue, Klubnik showed enough against Tampa Bay to separate himself from Bailey Zappe and Brady Cook, even if Evan is not ready to call for a change at starter. Tiki Barber explains why giving Klubnik too much preseason runway could create an unwanted quarterback controversy if the rookie starts building momentum. Evan still believes Geno is the better option to open the season, but if the Jets spiral later in the year, Klubnik could quickly become the quarterback everyone wants to see.

Jaxson Dart has already been sent to the blue medical tent six times, just one fewer than Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen over their entire careers. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the frequency is impossible to ignore, but they push back on comparisons to Tua Tagovailoa because Dart has only been diagnosed with one concussion.

Boomer Esiason and Gregg Giannotti discuss the earl portion of the Giants schedule and if they can have a strong start to the season. Plus: -Shaun Morash dishes on how badly he needs the Giants to beat the Cowboys Week 1 -Tiki Barber and Shaun on what Jaxson Dart must show in Year 2. -Craig Carton shares his concerns about the Giants depth to Chris McMonigle -Craig and C-Mac on why Giants fans are expressing concern over Matt Nagy -Boomer & Gio on if John Harbaugh can continue his preseason success with the Giants

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle were live from Jets training camp this week, speaking at length with Aaron Glenn, Darren Mougey, Breece Hall, and others about the upcoming season and what changes have been made to turn the franchise around. Plus, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate if the Jets should pick up the phone and see if J.J. McCarthy is available.

Boomer and Gio believe Yankee fans take their team's success for granted, especially given where the team stands right now amid several injuries to key players. Plus, Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate if Jazz Chisholm Jr. should be benched so Luis Garcia Jr. can play second base when the team is at full strength, while Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss how Giancarlo Stanton will be handled when he returns, as he takes a next step toward being cleared to play.

The trade deadline is over, the season is pretty much over, so what do we do as Mets fans? Hit the mailbag! In the lates episode Evan answers YOUR emails. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Jaxson Dart should play against Minnesota, but only if the Giants protect him with their starting tackles. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they break down what Dart must show in Matt Nagy’s offense and why this preseason opportunity matters. The Jets need David Bailey to flash immediately, especially with Giants rookie Orville Reese creating an unavoidable comparison across town. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. enters a fascinating fight to keep his NFL career alive, the Giants’ wide receiver and cornerback rooms face major questions, and Cade Klubnik gets a chance to prove the Jets have something behind Geno Smith.

The Titans already have New York’s attention after an ugly preseason showing from Cam Ward and former Giants corner Cor'Dale Flott. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they explain why Tennessee’s struggles only crank up the pressure on the Jets to win Week 1. With Flott getting beaten repeatedly and Garrett Wilson waiting in the opener, the Jets could have a matchup they need to exploit. Shaun and Tiki also debate Geno Smith’s leash, what Cade Klubnik must prove in the preseason, and why Aaron Glenn’s defense could determine whether the Jets finally show real progress. Plus, Shaun argues Yankee Stadium is getting shafted by MLB’s All-Star Game rotation, and the guys question why Giants legend and Hall of Famer Harry Carson still hasn’t had his number retired.

Darius Slayton’s drops have Shaun Morash worried that the Giants will once again learn the hard way they cannot trust him in the biggest moments. Tiki Barber sees another possibility, explaining how Tom Coughlin forced him to fix his fumbling issues and why John Harbaugh could have a similar impact on Slayton’s technique and focus. Shaun also unloads on Jerry Jones and declares the Cowboys are going nowhere near the Super Bowl, while the Yankees’ lineup creates another major debate over Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Luis Garcia Jr. Plus, Tiki and Shaun revisit unforgettable New York preseason moments involving Victor Cruz, Lawrence Taylor, Jason Sehorn, Mark Sanchez and Aaron Rodgers.

Aaron Glenn could be trapped by the Jets’ biggest weakness. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they debate whether an elite defense can save Glenn if Geno Smith and the offense fail to score enough points. With the Jets potentially forced to win on the margins, every game could become part of the evaluation of Glenn’s future. The Yankees also face a looming October lineup problem. Jazz Chisholm’s struggles against lefties spark a debate over Luis Garcia Jr., Giancarlo Stanton, Trent Grisham and how Aaron Boone can keep his best bats in the lineup. Plus, the Giants’ running back situation, Cade Klubnik’s opportunity, J.J. McCarthy speculation, Tiki’s rookie encounter with Christian Peter, and the return of football tailgates at MetLife.

The first fooooootbaaallllll friiiiidaayyy of the year! Shaun and Tiki break down the first preseason games for the Jets and Giants, David Bailey's debut against the Buccs, the Giants biggest concerns and a whole lot more.

The Jets may be better off resisting the urge to chase another quarterback and simply letting this season play out. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate whether J.J. McCarthy would really solve anything, why Aaron Glenn’s future complicates the quarterback picture, and how the Jets’ three first-round picks could make next year’s draft the cleanest path to finding their future at the position. Cade Klubnik also gets a chance to create some optimism with a big preseason performance. Plus, the return of football at MetLife brings a heated tailgate food debate, Geno Smith and Odell Beckham Jr. jerseys make a comeback, and the crew celebrates another edition of Idiots with Idioms.

Jazz Chisholm’s struggles are creating a major Yankees lineup problem, especially against left-handed pitching. The debate turns to whether Luis Garcia Jr. needs to take over at second base and whether Aaron Boone must start experimenting now instead of waiting for October. That could mean Giancarlo Stanton returning to the outfield, Trent Grisham sitting, or Jazz losing playing time to keep the Yankees’ best bats in the lineup. Plus, Spencer Jones’ future gets debated, the Giants’ running back situation comes into focus, and Aaron Glenn’s ability to survive another losing Jets season may depend on just how dominant his defense becomes.

Luis Garcia Jr. is forcing the Yankees into a difficult lineup decision, and Shaun Morash believes Aaron Boone cannot let Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s feelings stand in the way. If the Yankees get healthy, Garcia’s bat has to remain in the lineup, which could mean preparing him for second base before the postseason instead of waiting until it is too late. Tiki Barber and Shaun also revisit some of the wildest preseason moments in Giants and Jets history, from Victor Cruz’s breakout and Lawrence Taylor’s legendary mic’d-up performance to devastating injuries involving Jason Sehorn and Mark Sanchez. Plus, the Giants’ cornerback depth becomes an urgent concern after missing out on Terry and Arnold.

Darius Slayton’s costly drops remain impossible for Shaun Morash to ignore, even with a new Giants coaching staff in place. Tiki Barber explains why John Harbaugh could be exactly what Slayton needs, drawing on how Tom Coughlin forced Tiki to completely change his ball-security habits and become a better player. Shaun makes it clear that Slayton’s reputation and contract cannot protect him if the mistakes continue, while Tiki argues that focused coaching and relentless technique work can still change a veteran’s game. Plus, Shaun takes aim at Jerry Jones and dismisses the Cowboys’ latest Super Bowl expectations before the show dives into memorable New York preseason moments.

Yankee Stadium keeps getting passed over for the MLB All-Star Game, and Shaun Morash has had enough. With future host cities lining up and the current stadium getting older, Shaun argues it is ridiculous that baseball still has not brought the Midsummer Classic to the Bronx. Tiki Barber agrees the continued wait is becoming harder to explain. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as the conversation also turns to another New York sports oversight. A caller asks why Giants legend and Hall of Famer Harry Carson has never had his number retired, leading Tiki and Shaun to question how one of the franchise’s greatest players has remained overlooked.

The Titans looked so bad in preseason that Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are already raising the stakes for the Jets’ Week 1 opener. Cam Ward struggled badly, Cor'Dale Flott was getting beaten in coverage, and Tennessee suddenly looks like a team the Jets simply cannot afford to lose to. Garrett Wilson could have a major opportunity if Flott’s issues carry into the regular season. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also debate Geno Smith’s leash and what Cade Klubnik needs to show in the preseason. If the Jets stumble early, could Klubnik become a real option, or would turning away from Geno only create more chaos?

Cade Klubnik has a real opportunity to make the Jets rethink their quarterback plans, but Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber agree he has to earn it. Geno Smith remains the safer choice for Aaron Glenn, especially with so many young offensive pieces whose development could suffer if the rookie quarterback isn’t ready. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also dive into the Giants’ biggest preseason questions. Orville Reese has fans dreaming about a return to the franchise’s physical linebacker identity, while Colton Hood gets an important early test in a cornerback room filled with uncertainty. Plus, the Jets’ tight ends could give their offense a major matchup advantage.

Jaxson Dart should play in the Giants’ preseason opener, but Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber agree it needs to be a real dress rehearsal with his starting tackles protecting him. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki as they lay out what they need to see from Dart and why simple quarterback competency matters more than flashy highlights. For the Jets, David Bailey enters the spotlight with enormous expectations and an inevitable comparison to Giants rookie Orville Reese. Cade Klubnik also gets a major opportunity behind Geno Smith. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. fights for a roster spot in what could be his final NFL chance, while questions surround the Giants’ wide receiver depth and Malik Nabers’ health.

Mets can't win their third series in a row, but do find a way to take the season series against the Braves. High Five! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Shaun Morash hosts solo and is suddenly buying back into the Yankees. After another stirring comeback, he argues this team feels different, with George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones injecting life into the lineup while Trent Grisham and Ryan McMahon heat up around them. The frustration with Brian Cashman’s deadline remains, and Morash warns that Spencer Jones could still become the odd man out when Cody Bellinger returns. The Giants create an entirely different debate as John Harbaugh addresses the possibility of adding Terrion Arnold. Morash says that if the Giants’ background work and the NFL’s plans leave a realistic path for Arnold to play, the secondary is too vulnerable for New York to simply walk away. Malik Nabers’ Week 1 outlook also gets a boost, while Jayden Daniels gets blasted for the terrible optics of fighting LSU over another quarterback wearing No. 5.

The Yankees suddenly look alive, and Shaun Morash is buying back in. After another dramatic comeback and a surge fueled by George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones, Shaun argues this team feels different from the stale Yankees of recent Octobers. The pitching remains dominant, struggling bats are waking up, and the Bronx has rediscovered its energy. Shaun hosts while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are away and explains why a healthy return for Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger could make the Yankees a legitimate World Series threat. He also tackles the looming Spencer Jones roster crunch, whether New York can still chase down Tampa Bay, concerns about the bullpen, and Major League Baseball’s maddening TV maze. The next big test is whether this momentum survives once the Yankees’ stars return.

The Giants should sign Terrion Arnold if their background work clears a path for him to play. Shaun Morash argues New York cannot afford to take the moral high ground while winning organizations routinely gamble on talented players with serious off-field concerns, especially with the secondary looking like the Giants’ biggest weakness. Talkin' Giants co-host Justin Penick joins Shaun and agrees the NFL is not a morality league, though he stops short of viewing Arnold as an automatic starter. Shaun also looks ahead to the preseason opener, from Malik Nabers trending toward Week 1 to Odell Beckham Jr.’s anticipated return to the field, Deonte Banks’ critical test and Arvell Reese’s growing hype. Plus, Jayden Daniels gets ripped over his LSU No. 5 dispute, and the Yankees’ young surge gets another look.

Craig Carton gets confronted over the studio mystery nobody wanted solved: who was clipping their nails at work. After the evidence points directly at Craig, he jumps in to defend himself while Shaun Morash unloads on what he calls one of the grossest possible workplace habits. The confrontation quickly spirals into a hilarious debate over whether clipping nails in the studio is actually worse than Shaun’s preferred method of doing it on the toilet. From movie theater food to secret drive-thru eating habits, Craig and Shaun turn an ugly discovery into a wildly entertaining argument about personal boundaries, food, and disgusting routines.

Craig Carton gets called out after Shaun Morash discovers nail clippers and nail remnants in the studio, leading to a hilarious confrontation over Craig’s workplace grooming habits. Craig admits there may have been some trimming during a commercial break, but he refuses to accept Shaun’s outrage without firing back.

Spencer Jones and George Lombard Jr. have injected life into the Yankees, and Shaun Morash believes the young stars may be helping revive a season that had become increasingly frustrating. Lombard’s rise up the order and Jones’ production have created a playoff-like energy at Yankee Stadium, even as Shaun remains furious with Brian Cashman and skeptical about how the roster will be handled.

Talkin Giants co-host Justin Penik joins Shaun Morash to break down the biggest questions facing the Giants before their preseason opener. The conversation starts with Terrion Arnold, as Justin explains why NFL teams remain fascinated by former first-round talent and why Arnold would still have to earn a starting role if the Giants sign him. Justin also lays out what he needs to see from Odell Beckham Jr. to justify a roster spot, whether Deonte Banks can finally turn camp buzz into real production and why Arvell Reese has him so excited. Plus, Shaun and Justin dig into the kicker competition and the under-the-radar offensive and defensive linemen worth watching.

The Giants should sign Terrion Arnold if their background work gives them a legitimate path to put him on the field. Shaun Morash argues New York cannot afford to take the moral high ground when other NFL contenders routinely gamble on talented players with serious off-field concerns. With the secondary looking vulnerable, Shaun says there should be virtually no excuse for the Giants to pass if Arnold can help them win. Shaun also reacts to John Harbaugh’s revealing comments about the Giants doing extensive homework on Arnold and explains why another team will sign him if New York does not. Plus, Malik Nabers continues trending toward Week 1, and the Yankees’ youth movement with George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones sparks a bigger reflection on Aaron Judge’s championship-less decade.

The Yankees’ biggest problem may soon be figuring out who actually plays. Shaun Morash explains why the returns of Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger could create a brutal lineup crunch, especially with Spencer Jones and George Lombard Jr. forcing their way into the conversation. Shaun believes Jones has shown enough to deserve a major role and argues the Yankees may even need to consider unconventional October lineups to keep their best bats on the field. Shaun also refuses to give up on the AL East despite Tampa Bay’s surge, pointing to the Yankees’ remaining head-to-head opportunities. With the Bronx energized by its young players and the pitching staff built for a short series, he sees a legitimate path to a deep postseason run.

George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones have energized the Yankees, but Shaun Morash sees a frustrating roster decision coming. Lombard’s immediate impact only makes Shaun more annoyed that the Yankees waited until after the trade deadline to call him up, while Jones has earned the runway to keep playing every day.

The Yankees have Shaun Morash believing again. After another comeback win over Seattle, Shaun argues this team has finally shaken off the frustration of the trade deadline and rediscovered the fight that disappeared during much of the summer. George Lombard Jr.’s arrival, Spencer Jones’ impact and dominant pitching have injected new life into a team that suddenly feels different from recent Yankees disappointments. Shaun explains why the Yankees are never truly dead, why their recent surge has changed his outlook on October, and how even struggling veterans are beginning to wake up. He also unloads on Major League Baseball’s confusing TV setup after spending nearly half an hour just trying to find the Yankees game.

Tiki and Shaun talk about the Yankees Jazz Chisholm problem and how that might affect the rest of the team. They also get into Aaron Glenn maturing as a Head Coach, the Jets never-ending search for a franchise quarterback, an interesting visit to Giants Training Camp and Rosie's Cinco on Top Space Events!

The Yankees may have a major October lineup problem brewing. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they argue Luis Garcia Jr.’s bat has become too valuable to sit once Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger return. That could leave Jazz Chisholm Jr. as the odd man out, with Garcia potentially moving to second base to keep the Yankees’ strongest offense on the field. Ryan Weathers also keeps forcing his way into the playoff rotation conversation, potentially ahead of Carlos Rodon. The Jets bring a rare dose of optimism after Aaron Glenn openly admits that not calling the defense last season was a mistake. Tiki praises Glenn’s self-awareness and willingness to change, while Shaun says the answer gave him renewed hope that Glenn can grow into the head coach the Jets need despite lingering concerns about the quarterback situation.

J.J. McCarthy’s stunning fall in Minnesota has Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber wondering whether the Jets should make a move. With the Vikings already naming Kyler Murray the starter, they argue New York cannot afford to ignore a former first-round quarterback while its own room remains unsettled around Geno Smith. Even if McCarthy never becomes the answer, the Jets need to keep taking swings at the most important position. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also react to Aaron Glenn sounding far more comfortable as a head coach, the Jets’ commitment to Geno, and why young quarterbacks now have such a short window to prove themselves. Plus, the conversation turns to Jaxson Dart’s development and the NFL’s renewed value of running backs.

Aaron Glenn is putting his fingerprints all over the Jets defense, and the stakes could not be higher. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate whether Glenn taking over the defensive play-calling can help save his job, why the Jets loaded up that side of the ball, and how much a breakout from David Bailey could change the outlook. Tiki explains why Glenn has to lean into his greatest strength rather than go down holding back. The Yankees’ Old Timers Day also comes under fire as Shaun and Tiki examine why younger fans are skipping the ceremony, whether the tradition has lost its appeal, and why the party outside Yankee Stadium may now be the bigger draw. Plus, Gary Cohen repeatedly butchers Chris McMonigle’s name, Tommy DeVito gets a new Patriots nickname, and a cosmic triple header sends the show deep into aliens, eclipses and outer space.

Tiki and Shaun evaluate the New York Giants' pursuit of cornerback Terrion Arnold while considering the team's secondary needs. They debate Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s lack of focus for the Yankees and warn fans about inflated ticket prices for the Knicks' home opener. The discussion also touches on the improbability of alien life and offers predictions for the upcoming NFL season. (00:01:55) Disney And Park Hoppers (00:03:23) Giants Visit With Terrion Arnold (00:06:55) Giants Secondary Concerns (00:13:18) Jazz Chisholm Focus Issues (00:16:57) Linebacker Leadership Roles (00:22:36) Knicks Ticket Prices Surge (00:26:03) Sports Update (00:28:35) Jalen Hurts Passing Video (00:33:54) Science Of Space Distances (00:39:42) NFL Playoff Predictions

Terrion Arnold’s visit with the Giants puts an uncomfortable spotlight on their biggest concern: the secondary. The former first-round pick comes with serious legal questions and an uneven NFL track record, but the Giants’ willingness to bring him in shows just how unsettled their cornerback room remains. There’s real concern that one vulnerable position group could undermine all the optimism surrounding the team.

Cade Klubnik’s first Jets training camp is already testing Tiki Barber’s optimism. Tiki sees the fourth-round quarterback as a true developmental project who must earn everything, and his early camp performance has not changed that reality. He explains why rookie quarterbacks face an enormous learning curve and uses former Giants teammate Jeremy Shockey as the rare example of a rookie who arrived instantly prepared for the NFL.

A cosmic triple header takes over Cinco de Luncho as Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash dive into a solar eclipse, planetary parade and meteor shower all happening at once. That launches a countdown of the best space events, from shooting stars and blood moons to UFOs, eclipses and asteroid strikes. The conversation quickly veers into classic Cinco territory as Tiki explains why the universe keeps expanding, Shaun questions what aliens might actually look like, and the pronunciation of Uranus becomes its own debate. Plus, they imagine what the dinosaurs may have seen before an asteroid hit Earth and wonder whether extraterrestrial life could be nothing more than bacteria.

Yankees Old Timers Day is losing its grip on fans. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate why so many seats are empty for the annual tradition, whether repeated dynasty reunions have created fatigue, and why younger fans would rather enjoy the bars around Yankee Stadium than watch former players take the field. They also question why the 1996 championship team barely received recognition. Plus, Aaron Glenn is betting heavily on his defense to turn the Jets around. Shaun and Tiki examine whether taking over the defensive play-calling can help save Glenn’s job, how the Jets strengthened that side of the ball, and why Baker Mayfield might have been the quarterback solution they missed years ago.

The Jets’ endless quarterback search takes another frustrating turn as Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber wonder whether Carson Beck could become the latest passer New York regrets missing. They examine why some quarterbacks develop later than expected, how quickly teams now have to make decisions on young passers, and why Jaxson Dart’s second season with the Giants is such an important test.

J.J. McCarthy’s rapid fall in Minnesota has the Jets facing an intriguing opportunity. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber argue that New York should at least explore adding the former first-round pick, especially with Geno Smith and Cade Klubnik leaving major uncertainty at quarterback. The price matters, but the Jets cannot afford to stop taking swings at finding their long-term answer.

Aaron Glenn’s surprising admission about his disastrous first season gives Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber new hope for the Jets. Glenn acknowledges that not calling the defense was a mistake and explains why he needs to get more involved, prompting Tiki to call it the best interview he has heard from Glenn since he became Jets head coach. Shaun believes that self-awareness could matter if the Jets struggle again and pressure quickly builds around Glenn’s future.

The Yankees finally have a good problem, but it could force a brutal decision. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they argue Luis Garcia Jr.’s bat has become too important to remove once Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger return. Their solution could mean Garcia at second base and Jazz Chisholm Jr. losing his everyday role.

WFAN hosts break down the Knicks' upcoming opening night ring ceremony against LeBron James and the 76ers, debating whether $2,000 ticket prices and schedule delays stem from LeBron hype or true New York basketball fever.

Tiki and Shaun talk about the excitement in Giants camp over John Harbaugh, the Jets struggling in their scrimmage against the Bucs, Shaun's hypothetical legacy debate between Jaxson Dart and George Lombard, Rosie's Cinco on the Top Interim Coaches in Sports and more!

John Harbaugh’s hard-nosed training camp has changed the expectations for the Giants. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Shaun is officially raising the bar: after watching Harbaugh toughen up the roster and establish a new level of professionalism, he believes the Giants should be ready to beat the Cowboys in Week 1. Tiki explains why that physical grind can create the mental edge a football team needs, while both wonder whether this new culture can finally erase years of losing. The Jets’ shaky quarterback room also comes under scrutiny, including whether Shedeur Sanders would even be worth considering if he became available.

Geno Smith’s nightmare joint practice against Tampa Bay immediately raises every concern about the Jets quarterback situation. After three early interceptions, Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber question Smith’s decision-making, revisit Aaron Glenn’s infamous “promised land” declaration and explain why the Jets could be setting themselves up for immense failure. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. The Giants inspire far more optimism as Jaxson Dart enters Year 2 under John Harbaugh, leading to a wild New York sports debate: who will ultimately leave the greater legacy, Dart or Yankees phenom George Lombard Jr.? Plus, the Knicks’ newly revealed schedule puts LeBron James in Madison Square Garden for their banner celebration, sparks debate over the NBA’s Christmas Day strategy, and creates the possibility of a massive Knicks-Yankees conflict on October 20.

Aaron Glenn is making it clear the Jets will not ease into the season. With the starters set to play in the preseason, Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber explain why Glenn’s approach could leave New York better prepared for Week 1 and why the new systems on both sides of the ball make those live reps even more important. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also debate Dan Campbell’s future in Detroit, whether Andy Green is forcing the Mets to reconsider their managerial plans, and the growing excitement around Yankees prospect George Lombard. The Mets’ young pitching, Kodai Senga’s possible bullpen future, and Bruce Arians’ underrated coaching legacy also enter the conversation.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate whether George Lombard Jr. or Jaxson Dart will have the better New York sports career -- and work through Shaun's hatred of "Rudy" while taking calls about other sports movies.

George Lombard Jr. and Jaxson Dart are giving New York fans two young stars to dream on, but who will ultimately leave the bigger legacy? Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate Lombard’s smooth, natural presence with the Yankees and why Dart still needs to become more consistent at quarterback for the Giants. The Giants’ secondary also remains a concern, with Colton Hood yet to separate himself enough to demand an immediate starting role. Plus, Shaun goes scorched earth on Rudy, calling the beloved football movie wildly overrated and ripping its acting and dialogue while callers rush to defend the classic.

Aaron Glenn is playing the Jets starters in the preseason, and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber love the approach. With new systems to learn and a critical season ahead, they explain why real game reps could leave the Jets better prepared for Week 1, even with the injury risk that comes with preseason football. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber.

A bizarre Blue Jays-Red Sox play exposes one of baseball’s strangest rules after Toronto’s scoreboard showed the wrong number of outs. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber break down how a runner who left early was still allowed to score, why the Blue Jays lost their chance to appeal, and why MLB should simply fix a rule that created 16 minutes of unnecessary chaos.

The Knicks will raise their championship banner against LeBron James and the 76ers, and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate whether the NBA is hijacking New York’s moment or simply making the smartest national television matchup. They also explain why Knicks fans should embrace the spotlight instead of resenting LeBron’s presence. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber. Christmas Day brings another scheduling fight, with the Knicks-Spurs matchup facing heavy NFL competition as football continues to take over the holiday. Plus, October 20 could become a massive New York sports night if Knicks opening night lands opposite a potential Yankees Game 7 in the ALCS, while callers help workshop nicknames for George Lombard Jr.

“Posted and Toasted” digs through the WFAN archives as Shaun Morash challenges Tiki Barber to identify the authors behind a collection of old social media posts. The trip down memory lane brings up Evan Roberts’ love of NBA basketball on Christmas, Boomer Esiason’s extremely American Labor Day message and an old WFAN guest lineup featuring Tiki himself.

Geno Smith throws three interceptions in the Jets’ first joint practice against Tampa Bay, immediately igniting fears that his turnover problems could wreck New York’s season. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber question Smith’s decision-making and warn that Aaron Glenn’s “promised land” declaration could become one of the most mocked quotes in Jets history if the quarterback struggles. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber.

Patrick Mahomes is somehow becoming underrated despite everything he has accomplished. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they push back on the idea that Josh Allen or Lamar Jackson should automatically rank ahead of Mahomes, with Shaun arguing that Mahomes still has a chance to become the best quarterback he has ever seen. The conversation expands into how NFL teams actually win championships, why elite quarterbacks or historic defenses usually define Super Bowl teams, and why the Jets eventually need to draft their long-term answer instead of settling for temporary fixes. Plus, Eli Manning’s legacy gets reconsidered, the Bears emerge as a surprise Super Bowl pick, and Kodai Senga’s move to high-leverage relief gives the surging Mets a potentially intriguing weapon.

John Harbaugh’s demanding training camp has Shaun Morash raising his expectations for the Giants, including a new belief that they should be ready to beat the Cowboys in Week 1. Shaun is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, who explains how a physical camp can toughen players, build confidence, and give a team the mental edge it has been missing. The Giants still have questions, but Harbaugh’s professionalism and intensity have changed the feeling around the team.

After sweeping the Guardians the Mets head to Pittsburgh and take two of three from the Pirates. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

George Lombard Jr. has given the Yankees something their lifeless offense desperately needed: energy, confidence and a potential new table setter. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Shaun argues the rookie should immediately move to the top of the lineup while Tiki warns that the Yankees remain a .500 team without Aaron Judge. They debate whether dominant outings from Gerrit Cole, Max Fried and Cam Schlittler can carry a lineup that still cannot consistently score, plus the possibility of a brutal Wild Card matchup with the Red Sox and whether Jazz Chisholm has played himself out of guaranteed everyday at-bats. The Giants also get a major NFC East opening after Laremy Tunsil’s injury weakens Washington’s offensive line. Tiki believes the Giants now have an edge over the Commanders, while Shaun says those division games have become must-wins for a team trying to stay relevant deep into the season.

The Yankees finally have the dominant starting pitching they’ve been missing, but their lifeless offense threatens to waste it. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Shaun sees reasons for optimism after the Yankees took two of three from Atlanta, especially with George Lombard Jr. injecting energy, defense and confidence into the lineup. Tiki remains far more concerned about a team that has played .500 baseball without Aaron Judge and still struggles to score. The debate turns to whether Lombard should already be hitting leadoff, how much patience Aaron Boone should have with Jazz Chisholm and Trent Grisham, and whether the Yankees can survive a potential Wild Card showdown with the surging Red Sox. Even with Judge and Cody Bellinger potentially returning, the Yankees may need their pitching to carry them in October.

Laremy Tunsil’s devastating injury could completely shift the Giants’ outlook against Washington. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they believe New York now has a legitimate edge over the Commanders, whose shaky offensive line could leave Jayden Daniels vulnerable. Tiki even agrees Dan Quinn could be closer to losing his job than returning Washington to the playoffs. The Giants optimism comes with one major concern: how Matt Nagy handles Jaxson Dart. Tiki expects a physical, run-heavy offense designed to protect the young quarterback, while Shaun worries Nagy could force his system instead of leaning into Dart’s strengths. They also debate the Giants’ playoff ceiling, Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s failed 50-50 expectations, the Yankees’ stagnant offense and an overworked bullpen.

Buffalo’s new $2.8 billion stadium is already taking heat for obstructed views, small scoreboards and a fan experience that Shaun Morash believes should embarrass the Bills. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they compare Buffalo’s new building to MetLife Stadium and debate whether the much-maligned home of the Giants and Jets has been unfairly bashed. The conversation turns to MetLife’s turf, whether NFL players should push for natural grass and Tiki’s theory that modern football shoes may be contributing to Achilles injuries. Plus, callers pitch an Aqueduct stadium for the Jets, Connor Green ranks the best stadiums in sports, and one optimistic Jets fan predicts a nine-win season.

Aaron Glenn is already facing enormous pressure, with betting odds making him the favorite to be the NFL’s first coach fired. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they examine the Jets’ difficult early schedule and why Week 1 against the Titans could become a season-defining game. Shaun sees a real path where an awful start leaves Glenn fighting to keep his job before November, while Tiki believes he could get more time. The conversation also turns to Sam Darnold and whether his Super Bowl success should finally erase doubts left over from his Jets years, the NFL’s ongoing turf debate, and the excitement surrounding Yankees prospect George Lombard Jr. His defense, confidence and preparation already have the crew wondering whether the Yankees have found something special.

Aaron Glenn is already facing enormous pressure before the Jets even take the field. With betting odds making him the favorite to be the NFL’s first coach fired, Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber examine how a difficult early schedule could put Glenn’s job in jeopardy. The Week 1 matchup with Tennessee looms especially large, with the possibility of an ugly start turning the heat up fast.

The newest stadiums may cost billions, but the classics still win. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as Connor Green ranks the Rose Bowl, Wrigley Field, Fenway Park, Lambeau Field and even the Roman Colosseum among sports’ best venues, sparking a debate over why old-school stadiums still have more character than their modern replacements. The conversation turns to MetLife Stadium, American Dream and the complications of maintaining a grass field at a venue packed with concerts and other events. Then a Jets caller predicts nine wins, but Shaun pushes back on the idea that the offense is set with Geno Smith at quarterback.

Buffalo’s new $2.8 billion stadium is already drawing criticism for obstructed views and undersized scoreboards, leaving Shaun Morash wondering how the Bills could spend that much and still miss on basic fan experience. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they compare Buffalo’s new home to MetLife Stadium and argue that MetLife may be unfairly trashed. The debate shifts to natural grass versus turf, whether NFL owners should spend whatever it takes to improve playing surfaces, and Tiki’s theory that modern football shoes, not just turf, could be contributing to the rise in Achilles injuries.

Matt Nagy’s handling of Jaxson Dart becomes the biggest concern as Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber dig into what the Giants offense could look like. Tiki expects a physical, run-heavy attack built to protect Dart, while Shaun worries Nagy could become too committed to his own system if the offense struggles. Greg Roman’s influence and the potential for competing offensive philosophies also enter the debate. The optimism around the Giants is still growing. Tiki believes the roster has enough talent to compete for a playoff spot if Dart stays healthy and continues developing, though major questions remain in the secondary and elsewhere. They also debate Dart’s franchise-quarterback timeline, Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame case and just how high expectations should climb this season.

The Yankees’ offensive struggles are putting enormous pressure on a bullpen that simply cannot get enough rest. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber explain why Fernando Cruz, David Bednar and the rest of the relief corps keep getting forced into meaningful innings, while the lineup’s lack of aggression on the bases only adds to the frustration. The conversation then shifts to Jaxson Dart and the Giants’ new offense. A caller questions whether Brian Daboll might have been better suited for Dart’s development, but Shaun clarifies that his real concern is whether Matt Nagy will adapt the system to fit Dart if the offense struggles early.

Laremy Tunsil’s torn triceps could dramatically reshape the NFC East race. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they believe the Giants now have a real advantage over Washington, especially with New York’s pass rush attacking a weakened Commanders offensive line. Tiki agrees the loss is massive and says Dan Quinn could be in serious danger if Washington slides again. The conversation also turns to Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s preseason 50-50 declaration. Tiki believes Jazz put unnecessary pressure on himself, while Shaun admits he never took the prediction seriously.

The Yankees’ offense has become impossible to trust, and a potential Wild Card matchup with the Red Sox suddenly looks dangerous. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber admit Boston would be the pick right now, while warning that a playoff loss after last year’s World Series run could force major organizational consequences. The frustration extends to Jazz Chisholm, whose struggles have opened the door for Jose Caballero to steal playing time. They debate Aaron Boone’s willingness to bench struggling veterans, the Yankees’ obsession with platoon matchups, Spencer Jones earning a longer runway, and whether elite starting pitching can overcome a lineup that simply cannot score enough runs.

George Lombard Jr. has given the Yankees something they desperately needed: energy, confidence and a reason to believe their offense can finally look different. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Shaun argues Lombard’s impact goes far beyond the box score. His defense, speed, poise and ability to create runs have made him look ready for an even bigger role. Tiki remains cautious because the Yankees still struggle badly to score, but their dominant starting pitching has created a legitimate path to winning in October. The biggest question is whether Aaron Boone should stop treating Lombard like a typical rookie and move him straight to the top of the lineup.

Willie Colon and Jerry Recco on what concerns they may have with Jaxson Dart this season. Plus: -Shaun Morash on what worries him about the Giants’ offense -Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle hear from a caller on whether John Harbaugh is right for Dart. -Tiki Barber revisits the takes around the Odell Beckham Jr. trade -Craig and C-Mac on whether or not the Giants should have pursued Stefon Diggs.

Freddy Peralta orchestrated a sitdown with Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor to squash their beef, according to ESPN. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the stunning report, while Evan Roberts wonders if brokering peace between the team's two stars changes anything about Peralta's damaged legacy in Queens. Plus, the great Jefry Yan debate, as Jerry Recco and Willie Colon debate if the pitcher's animated celebrations are appropriate, while Shaun Morash predicts the celebrating will backfire in the most Mets way possible.

George Lombard Jr. has made his Yankee introduction, and our hosts love what they see. Evan and Tiki rave about his defense at shortstop, and Ryan Ruocco of the YES Network calls in to the Morning Show to talk about Lombard's sparkling debut. Plus, Brian Cashman talks all things trade deadline with The Carton Show, and Evan Roberts is ready to declare the AL East race over.

That's right. The trade deadline has come and gone. The Mets win their 50th game in style by sweeping the series from a potential playoff team in the Cleveland Guardians. Exciting! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.comExplore the podcast

Shaun Morash fills in for Tiki Barber as he and Evan Roberts react to Boston’s historic surge and debate whether the Red Sox have officially overtaken the Yankees. They examine the Yankees’ struggles without Aaron Judge, George Lombard Jr.’s potential impact and why Trent Grisham must be removed from the leadoff spot. Plus, Jaxson Dart enters a defining second season, Shaquille O’Neal calls the Knicks’ championship lucky, Mike Tomlin emerges as a possible future Jets coach and Andy Green makes his case to remain Mets manager. Timestamps: 00:00 Red Sox Erase Yankees’ Lead 06:22 Yankees Without Aaron Judge 16:12 Football Finally Returns 45:46 Jaxson Dart’s Defining Season 1:11:54 Grisham Must Lose Leadoff Spot 1:26:26 Mrs. Met Makes History 1:28:36 Shaq Rips Knicks’ Championship 1:42:06 Yankees-Red Sox Showdown 1:48:16 Jacob deGrom Rejects Atlanta 1:52:06 Mike Tomlin to the Jets 2:12:48 Andy Green’s Mets Future 2:24:01 George Lombard’s Yankees Hype

The Red Sox have erased a 15.5-game Yankees advantage with a staggering 31-5 run, and Evan Roberts is starting to believe Boston may be for real. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan, and Shaun refuses to buy the hype, predicting the Yankees are about to turn their season around and still finish ahead of Boston. The timing of Boston’s surge also puts Michael Kay in the spotlight after his dismissive reaction to Red Sox fans chanting “Yankees suck” came just as the run began. Evan and Shaun debate whether the Yankees can survive without Aaron Judge, what their next 18 games could look like, and whether Cam Schlittler’s workload should become a concern. Plus, they rip MLB’s playoff format and debate just how great Schlittler must become to meet expectations.

Jaxson Dart’s second season could decide whether the Giants truly have their franchise quarterback. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash dig through recent NFL history and find a brutal trend: highly drafted quarterbacks who fail to break through in Year Two almost never become the long-term answer. They set the benchmarks Dart must hit and debate how quickly Giants fans should know what they really have. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. They also weigh the Jets’ chances of making a surprise playoff run, debate which last-place team has the best shot at a postseason leap, and rip into the Yankees’ lineup construction with Trent Grisham’s leadoff role under fire. Plus, Max Fried’s uneven postseason history, the Mets’ future at first base, and Shaun somehow convincing everyone he hosted a Giants town hall.

Shaquille O’Neal calls the Knicks’ championship a little lucky, and Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash aren’t buying it. Even as Knicks haters, they argue Shaq’s logic cheapens the execution and big moments that actually won New York the title. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts, and both admit the Knicks have made life miserable for anyone desperate to mock them. Mike Tomlin’s comments about potentially getting the coaching itch spark a bigger question about whether he could eventually become the Jets’ dream hire. Plus, Shaun is already convinced George Lombard Jr. has something special after just two games, Evan pushes back on the Yankees prospect hype, Brian Cashman’s job security comes under fire, Jacob deGrom’s refusal to go to Atlanta gets celebrated, and Mrs. Met makes mascot history.

Andy Green is giving Mets fans something to believe in despite a miserable season. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash debate whether Green’s aggressive “play to win” mentality, combined with a strong finish, could turn an interim job into a legitimate managerial opportunity. If the Mets can climb toward 80 wins after selling off bullpen pieces, would Green have done enough to force the organization to seriously consider keeping him? Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as the conversation shifts to Brian Cashman and the Yankees. Is Cashman’s remarkable record of consistent winning enough anymore, or has the lack of championships made a fresh voice necessary? Plus, the Yankees add veteran catcher Mitch Garver, Devin Williams trade receipts resurface, and another chaotic edition of Idiots with Idioms closes out the week.

Andy Green is starting to make a case for keeping the Mets job. His message after another win struck a chord: show up, compete and play to win because New York deserves it. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash debate whether Green can turn those words into enough victories to earn a real shot at managing the Mets beyond this season. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they set the benchmark for Green’s final 46 games, wonder whether an 80-win finish could change the conversation, and debate what the Mets still have to play for after a miserable season and major deadline selloff.

Mike Tomlin admits the coaching itch could return once the NFL regular season begins, and Evan Roberts immediately wonders whether the Jets could become his next destination. With Aaron Glenn’s future uncertain, Evan believes Tomlin could be the proven coach Woody Johnson eventually hands the franchise to, while Shaun Morash argues Tomlin may grow comfortable with television instead. The debate turns to whether Jets fans could eventually find themselves rooting for losses to improve their draft position and make the job more attractive. Plus, Brian Cashman’s seemingly untouchable status with the Yankees comes under fire, Shaun doubles down on George Lombard Jr. after just two games, and the crew looks back at Yankees prospects whose massive hype never matched reality.

Shaquille O’Neal calls the Knicks’ championship a little lucky, and Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash unload on the argument. They say Shaq is confusing luck with execution and admit that even Knicks haters have no choice but to respect what New York accomplished. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. The conversation also turns to whether the red-hot Red Sox can cool off enough for the Yankees to recover, Shaun’s immediate belief in George Lombard Jr., and Jacob deGrom refusing a trade to the Braves. Evan celebrates deGrom’s decision while defending the former Met against criticism that he no longer cares about winning.

Trent Grisham can’t keep leading off for the Yankees. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash argue Aaron Boone needs to make an immediate lineup change, with Ben Rice and Luis García Jr. emerging as better options to spark an offense that has gone cold. They also examine Max Fried’s wildly uneven postseason history and whether Yankees fans can fully trust him in October.

Jaxson Dart’s second season could settle the Giants’ quarterback future once and for all. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash dig through a decade of young quarterbacks and find a harsh pattern: prospects who remain mediocre in Year Two rarely develop into true franchise quarterbacks. Dart needs a real breakthrough, and Evan believes the Giants should know what they have by Thanksgiving.

Cam Schlittler’s incredible start has created enormous expectations, with Shaun Morash declaring the young Yankees pitcher needs to become one of baseball’s best arms and surpass even Ron Guidry’s career. Evan Roberts pushes back while also raising a more immediate concern: Schlittler has thrown a heavy workload, mixed dominant outings with recent struggles, and may need extra rest before October. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. Evan also admits the hype surrounding Nolan McLean went too far and resets expectations for the Mets rookie after an uneven season. Plus, the Michael Kay jinx debate continues, MLB’s playoff format gets ripped again, and Shaun’s sudden Yankees optimism reaches another level with a bold prediction for the Atlanta series.

The Yankees could actually benefit from falling in the standings. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash rip MLB’s playoff format, arguing New York may have an easier path to the ALCS as the third wild card instead of battling the Red Sox and Rays through the opening rounds. The absurd setup even sparks a conversation about whether the Yankees would be better off losing games to improve their October draw.

The Red Sox have erased a 15.5-game Yankees advantage with a staggering 31-5 run, forcing Evan Roberts to reconsider just how real Boston has become. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan, and Shaun remains defiant, insisting the Yankees will still finish ahead of the Red Sox despite Boston’s stunning surge. The timing is impossible to ignore. Boston’s run began the same night Michael Kay mocked Red Sox fans for chanting “Yankees suck,” giving Evan a perfect new jinx candidate. Meanwhile, Aaron Judge remains out, the Yankees have played .500 baseball without him, and Evan questions whether that changes anytime soon. Shaun sees the opposite, predicting the Yankees are about to heat up before a huge late-August showdown with Boston.

The Yankees remain at the center of the show as Evan declares their American League East chase over, questions whether Brian Cashman did enough at the trade deadline and tears into Aaron Boone’s late game management. The conversation examines a struggling offense, Aaron Judge’s recovery, lineup changes, the impact of the team’s newest additions, the strength of the bullpen and whether a healthier roster can still make noise as a wild card team. The discussion also expands across the New York sports landscape, including a bold prediction that the Giants will be the city’s next division winner and a growing divide among Mets fans over the direction of the team. The show mixes serious debates about roster construction, coaching and postseason expectations with broader baseball topics, fan reactions and the kind of sharp disagreements that shape another busy day in New York sports.

Evan Roberts has finally surrendered on the Yankees winning the American League East. After two months of lifeless offense, mounting injuries and a growing deficit behind the Rays, Evan declares the division race over and predicts the Yankees are headed for the wild card. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts, and he refuses to concede, arguing that Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger and a softer September schedule could fuel one final charge. The frustration explodes over Aaron Boone’s decision to remove Luis Garcia Jr. from a close loss, leaving Ali Sánchez to bat with the game on the line. Evan and Shaun debate whether Boone misunderstood Brian Cashman’s plan for Ben Rice, whether Cashman failed to add enough offense at the deadline and why Trent Grisham cannot remain the leadoff hitter. Plus, Evan makes a stunning prediction about the next New York team to win its division.

Evan Roberts reaches a breaking point with the Yankees, admitting for the first time this season that he no longer expects them to win the AL East. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan as they debate whether the surging Red Sox can sustain their run, why the Yankees cannot win without home runs and who should replace Trent Grisham in the leadoff spot. Brian Cashman’s handling of Ben Rice comes under fire, while Anthony Volpe’s future is reduced to a possible platoon role at second base. Evan also unveils “Head to Bed” for the Yankees’ late-inning bullpen, Yordan Alvarez’s Triple Crown chase gains steam, and concerns emerge about the Bills, Jets and Rams before another chaotic edition of “New Team, Who Dis?”

Jefry Yan’s explosive strikeout celebration has instantly divided Mets fans and irritated opponents. Evan Roberts loves the rookie reliever’s energy but worries his constant jumping could eventually trigger retaliation, put teammates in danger, or even lead to an injury. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber and argues that Yan’s emotion is exactly what a lifeless Mets team needs, especially after Christian Scott praised the spark he brings to the clubhouse. Evan and Shaun also debate whether the Mets should ever consider trading Francisco Lindor, why Luis Garcia Jr. could replace Jazz Chisholm at second base, and whether Spencer Jones deserves a chance over Trent Grisham. Plus, Evan reveals his five NFL win-total unders, Shaun makes an early Chiefs-Bears Super Bowl prediction, and the Jets, Browns, Buccaneers, Colts, Falcons, and Giants all come under scrutiny.

Jaxson Dart’s second season could define the Giants’ future, and concerns are already growing about his sloppy training camp and a crowded offensive coaching staff. Evan Roberts pushes back on fears that Matt Nagy, Greg Roman and Brian Callahan could force Dart into an offense that ignores his strengths, while questioning Shaun Morash’s sudden change in tone about the young quarterback.

The Jets are Evan Roberts’ fourth-biggest lock to finish under their projected win total, with major concerns surrounding Geno Smith, Aaron Glenn and an aggressive defense vulnerable to big plays. Evan also predicts rough seasons for the Colts, Buccaneers, Browns and Falcons, while Shaun Morash delivers a stunning Chiefs-Bears Super Bowl pick.

Jefry Yan’s leaping strikeout celebration has instantly made him the most polarizing player on the Mets. Evan Roberts enjoys Yan’s enthusiasm but fears his antics could provoke opponents, spark unnecessary fights, and put teammates in danger. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan and argues that Yan’s energy is exactly what this lifeless team needs.

The Red Sox are on a historic tear, but Evan Roberts refuses to believe their dominance will last. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan as they debate whether Boston can sustain its scorching run, overtake the Yankees and win the AL East.

“New Team, Who Dis?” returns as Evan Roberts puts Shaun Morash’s NFL roster knowledge to the test. Shaun tries to identify the new homes of familiar names.

Brian Cashman’s handling of Ben Rice comes under fire as Evan Roberts argues the Yankees should have developed him as a catcher from the beginning. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan as they debate who should replace Trent Grisham at leadoff and why the Yankees’ offense falls apart when the home runs disappear.

Aaron Boone’s decision to remove Luis Garcia created a chain of late-game problems, leaving Ali Sánchez to bat with the game on the line. Evan argues Boone ignored Brian Cashman’s stated plan to use Ben Rice as an emergency catcher, exposing a damaging Yankees disconnect.

The Yankees’ offensive collapse has fans wondering whether losing the American League East is only the beginning. Evan Roberts stands by his declaration that Tampa Bay has ended the race, while callers warn that the surging Red Sox could push the Yankees into third place. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts. The frustration turns toward Jazz Chisholm, his damaging approach at the plate and Brian Cashman’s decision not to add Luis Arraez at the trade deadline. Evan defends Chisholm’s power and speed but acknowledges that his postseason role may no longer be secure. The conversation also examines whether the Yankees’ coaches deserve blame when proven hitters suddenly stop producing.

Evan Roberts has reached his breaking point with the Yankees and officially declares their American League East chase over. Their lifeless offense, mounting injuries and growing deficit behind the Rays have convinced him there is not enough time to recover, even with Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger potentially returning in September.

George Lombard Jr. had the debut we all will remember forever. Plus a Giants legend is back and working with the 1's.

George Lombard Jr. delivered the Yankees debut fans had been waiting for, launching a home run and immediately showing the athleticism and defense that could transform the middle of the diamond. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Lombard already looks like a massive upgrade at shortstop, while Shaun Morash argues the Yankees should ride the excitement and move him to the leadoff spot. The debut created real hope, but the lineup still produced only two runs and needed nearly perfect pitching to win. Evan also calls out Austin Wells for swinging at the first pitch instead of letting Lombard enjoy a curtain call. Plus, a new report claims Freddy Peralta helped repair the strained relationship between Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor, sparking debate over what caused the disconnect and whether it actually hurt the Mets. The Yankees’ decision not to add a reliever at the trade deadline also comes under fire as concerns grow about the bullpen and Clarke Schmidt’s setback.

Odell Beckham Jr. is fighting for a Giants roster spot seven years after his stunning trade, and the old reactions are almost as dramatic as the comeback attempt. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber revisit the furious takes from Boomer Esiason, Mike Francesa, Shaun Morash and others, debate whether the deal ultimately worked, and explain why Odell’s leadership and early flashes in camp could help him survive the final cut. The Giants also turn Jaxson Dart’s emotional practice outburst into a John Harbaugh teaching moment. Plus, Evan unloads on Brian Cashman’s explanation for passing on Liam Hicks, the Mets test Kodai Senga in a short-relief role, callers speculate about the Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto rift, and an emotional baseball story connects the Lombard family with Davis Schneider’s unforgettable major league debut.

George Lombard Jr.’s electric Yankees debut immediately puts Anthony Volpe’s future at shortstop under the microscope. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Lombard can seize the job, how his ceiling compares with Mets prospect A.J. Ewing and whether his arrival gives the Yankees legitimate playoff hope once Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger return. The crew also questions whether Cam Schlittler is healthy or beginning to wear down, imagines John Sterling’s call for Lombard’s first home run and battles over a controversial Derek Jeter comparison. Plus, Keith Hernandez calls the Mets’ traded players “garbage” before issuing an apology, Davante Adams reveals how he took No. 17 from Malachi Corley, and a debate erupts over how much a fan should demand for a prized home run ball.

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash close out Tuesday's show by discussing what the expectations should be for George Lombard Jr. through the rest of the Yankees' season, and whether or not Justin Herbert's viral video with Madison Beer at Chargers practice is a sign of things to come in Los Angeles.

George Lombard Jr. electrified Yankee Stadium with a home run and standout defense in his major league debut, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much the Yankees should expect from their prized prospect over the final stretch. Can Lombard provide a consistent bat without being burdened as the team’s savior? The conversation turns to Aaron Boone’s struggling lineup construction, Trent Grisham’s continued spot at leadoff and whether Lombard or Ben Rice deserves the most at-bats. Plus, the Yankees keep surviving low-scoring games, callers react to Lombard’s unforgettable arrival, and the Mets’ ongoing Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor tension resurfaces.

Shaun Morash and CMac go to war over whether George Lombard Jr.’s first Yankees start truly mirrored Derek Jeter’s Opening Day debut as the team’s everyday shortstop. CMac argues the comparison stands, but Shaun blasts him for ignoring Jeter’s 1995 stint and says Lombard has not officially secured the job yet. Tiki Barber steps in as judge and delivers the final verdict, siding with Shaun and declaring CMac’s argument wrong. The fight then spills into Lombard’s unusual No. 96, whether he could change it within days, and Shaun’s claim that the Yankees rookie is already the greatest No. 96 in New York sports history.

George Lombard Jr.’s explosive Yankees debut immediately raises questions about Anthony Volpe’s future at shortstop. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Lombard can take the job for good, how he compares with Mets prospect A.J. Ewing and whether his arrival can help spark a postseason run. The Yankees still need Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger back, while Evan admits Cam Schlittler’s latest start left him worried about the pitcher’s health and workload. Plus, Keith Hernandez calls the Mets’ traded players “garbage,” quickly apologizes and nearly launches into another uncomfortable debate during a memorable broadcast. Shaun also unveils his best John Sterling-style calls for Lombard’s first major league home run.

The Tiki Time Machine returns to the Giants’ stunning trade of Odell Beckham Jr., revealing who celebrated the move, who defended the superstar receiver and who completely lost their mind. Tiki Barber tries to predict the old reactions from Boomer Esiason, Gio, Evan Roberts, Joe Benigno, Mike Francesa, Shaun Morash and Big Mac. Morash’s furious rant steals the show, while Evan’s refusal to trade elite talent proves consistent with his stance today. The old takes lead into a fresh debate over whether the deal ultimately worked, how Dexter Lawrence changed its legacy and whether Beckham’s leadership and early training camp flashes can earn him another opportunity with the Giants.

Brian Cashman’s explanation for passing on Liam Hicks sends Evan Roberts over the edge. Evan calls it one of the worst answers he has ever heard from the Yankees general manager, arguing that Hicks would have provided badly needed offense while Austin Wells struggles and Ali Sánchez offers almost nothing at the plate. Tiki Barber pushes back on the fit, pointing to Hicks’ defense and the Yankees’ desire for a right-handed catcher, but Evan insists the entire roster-building logic is backwards. Evan and Tiki also debate Kodai Senga’s potential future as a Mets reliever and react to speculation surrounding the reported rift between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto.

Brian Cashman’s failure to add a reliever at the trade deadline leaves the Yankees taking a dangerous gamble with a bullpen full of uncertainty. Evan Roberts calls the decision unacceptable for a championship contender, while Tiki Barber argues that Cashman had to trust his process rather than overpay or make a reckless gut call. The concerns only grow after Clarke Schmidt experiences forearm cramping during a short rehab outing, potentially disrupting the Yankees’ plan to move surplus starters into relief roles. Evan, Tiki and Shaun Morash debate whether Cashman protected too many prospects, how much faith the team can place in its current arms and whether holding onto Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler proves patience was the right approach.

Freddy Peralta may have left behind an unexpected Mets legacy by helping Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor work through their lingering tension. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the report that Peralta arranged a private conversation between the two stars, even as Soto denied that any formal meeting happened and Lindor downplayed its significance.

George Lombard Jr. delivered the Yankees debut fans had been waiting for, crushing a home run and immediately flashing the smooth defense and athleticism that made him such a highly anticipated prospect. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Lombard can become a real difference-maker in the division race.

A day after the smoke cleared, the hosts of WFAN continue to react to the Yankees' handling of the MLB trade deadline. Despite the addition of Luis Garcia Jr., who homered in his first game in The Bronx, the consensus is that Yankees didn't do enough, especially at the catcher position.

The trade deadline has officially struck Midnight! Freddy Peralta, Huascar Brazoban, AJ Minter and others have officially left the building. Evan breaks it all down as the Mets 2026 season has now hit the final stages of another disastrous season. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

We react to the MLB Trade Deadline after what was a terrible day for the Yankees and callers sound off

Brian Cashman’s trade deadline leaves the Yankees facing serious questions about their World Series chances. Shaun Morash unloads on the organization for failing to acquire a major-league catcher or another reliever while division rivals improved, and Evan Roberts agrees that leaving the deadline without addressing those needs was unacceptable. Tiki Barber pushes back on some of the harshest criticism, but even he acknowledges the Yankees are stagnating. The frustration intensifies with George Lombard Jr.’s perfectly timed promotion, which Shaun sees as an attempt to distract fans from an underwhelming deadline. Evan and Tiki also debate Cashman’s growing reluctance to trade prospects, Anthony Volpe’s uncertain future, the decision not to use Ben Rice at catcher, and whether Aaron Judge can realistically return in time to save the season.

Brian Cashman’s vague Aaron Judge update leaves Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash convinced the Yankees have no real idea when, or whether, their captain will return this season. Shaun argues Cashman opened the door to Judge missing the year, while Evan dismisses the conspiracy theories and believes the organization is simply stuck without answers. Tiki identifies the larger problem: Cashman and Aaron Boone continue to speak without the urgency Yankee fans feel as the playoff clock keeps ticking.

The Mets’ trade-deadline bloodbath puts the finishing touch on one of the most disappointing seasons in franchise history. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the massive sell-off, why moving the expiring contracts made sense and why the Luke Weaver trade remains the most troubling decision. With the bullpen gutted, Evan proposes an unexpected new role for Kodai Senga while questioning whether David Stearns can turn a collection of lottery-ticket prospects into a quick turnaround.

Evan, Tiki, and Shaun examine the Yankees' decision to option Anthony Volpe while elevating George Lombard Jr. to the major league roster. They speculate on Volpe's potential as a utility player or trade candidate and analyze the Red Sox's sudden dominance in the AL East. Additionally, the discussion pivots to the Jets' future under center and Brian Cashman's quiet trade deadline approach. (00:01:50) George Lombard Jr. Debuts (00:05:15) Volpe's Future Yankees Role (00:08:50) Change Of Scenery Trade (00:12:20) Mets Local Prospect Stories (00:17:15) Analyzing Prospect Scouting Stats (00:20:35) Jacob DeGrom Vetoes Trade (00:24:05) Red Sox Summer Streak (00:27:55) Jets Quarterback Trade Rumors (00:38:30) Brian Cashman Deadline Review (00:43:05) Tarik Skubal Trade Interest

Anthony Volpe has been sent to the minors, George Lombard Jr. is taking over at shortstop, and the Yankees may have finally admitted their former top prospect is not the player they expected. Evan predicts Volpe could return in 2027 as a second baseman and utility infielder, while others believe a trade and a fresh start would be best for everyone.

Shaun Morash rank the franchise’s most disappointing prospects of the last 20 years, from Gary Sánchez and Clint Frazier to Greg Bird, while debating how much blame belongs to the players and how much falls on the organization. Brian Cashman’s deadline strategy also comes under scrutiny after the Yankees failed to add a reliever for the first time in years. The crew identifies a clear shift away from short-term rentals, questions whether that philosophy hurt a legitimate contender and gives Cashman credit for developing Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler. Plus, Shaun’s growing loyalty to John Harbaugh sparks another Giants debate.

The Mets’ massive sell-off delivers the final blow to one of the most disappointing seasons in franchise history. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash revisit their wildly inaccurate trade predictions, assess the prospect haul and explain why moving the expiring contracts made sense. The one deal Evan still cannot fully accept is Luke Weaver, a dependable reliever who could have helped a bullpen that must be rebuilt next season.

Brian Cashman’s refusal to pay a trade-deadline premium has Shaun Morash furious that the Yankees wasted another chance to strengthen Aaron Judge’s championship window. Evan Roberts pushes back on blaming Hal Steinbrenner, arguing the failure to add a catcher was Cashman’s baseball decision, while Tiki Barber weighs whether the so-called Yankees tax justified standing pat.

Shaun Morash gets toasted by his own history when an old post reveals he once praised Brian Cashman for standing pat at the trade deadline, a brutal contrast to his current Yankees frustration. Tiki Barber tries to identify the author during “Posted and Toasted,” only to learn that Shaun’s past opinion was hiding in plain sight.

Brian Cashman’s evasive Aaron Judge update sends Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash into a furious debate over whether the Yankees have any idea when their captain will return. Shaun believes Cashman opened the door to Judge missing the season, while Evan argues the organization is not hiding anything and simply has no answers. Tiki says the bigger issue is the front office’s complete lack of urgency as the playoff clock keeps shrinking.

Brian Cashman’s underwhelming deadline sparks a bigger debate about how far the Yankees’ standard has fallen. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash examine whether simply reaching the postseason has become acceptable for a franchise that once lived by World Series or bust. The conversation turns to Cashman’s growing reluctance to trade prospects, the failures of Anthony Volpe and Jason Dominguez, and the success stories of Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler that complicate the argument. They also question how much Aaron Judge’s absence should excuse the Yankees’ struggles before reacting to a setback for Jets rookie Kenyon Sadiq that could cost him valuable training camp time.

Shaun Morash gets his flowers after perfectly predicting that the Yankees would call up George Lombard Jr. immediately after an underwhelming trade deadline to calm an angry fan base. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber revisit the prediction and debate whether there was ever a legitimate baseball reason to keep Lombard in the minors. The conversation then turns to Anthony Volpe, who is being sent down and will begin playing second base as his future with the Yankees becomes increasingly uncertain. Evan, Tiki and Shaun examine how the organization handled Volpe and Jason Dominguez, whether the Yankees failed to develop their prized prospects, and why Brian Cashman’s refusal to use Ben Rice regularly at catcher only makes the roster situation more confusing.

Shaun Morash blasts Brian Cashman for an “insulting” Yankees trade deadline, arguing that failing to add a major-league catcher or reliever showed zero urgency while the Red Sox and Rays improved. Evan Roberts agrees that leaving the deadline without a catcher was unacceptable, though he still believes the Yankees can contend. Tiki Barber pushes back on the harshest conclusions while questioning where the team’s momentum is headed. The frustration peaks with George Lombard Jr.’s promotion. Shaun believes the Yankees deliberately waited until after the deadline to call up their top prospect as a way to distract fans from Cashman’s failures, turning an exciting debut into another example of organizational dysfunction.

Before Sundays game between the Mets and the Marlins, the Mets finally found a taker for Freddy Peralta. How about that return???? Regardless, Mets still lose to the Marlins on Sunday and the entire series! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

The Yankees made their first major move by adding Luis Garcia Jr., but the pressure on Brian Cashman is only growing. With Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton still uncertain and the offense struggling, the debate turns to whether New York must still land a catcher, another bat and bullpen help before the deadline. Across town, the Mets begin a painful but necessary selloff while the Dodgers spark frustration and envy with another aggressive blockbuster. The conversation weighs prospect returns, roster fit, potential October lineups and the hard truth that deadline reactions can look very different one year later.

Brian Cashman added badly needed power with Luis Garcia Jr., but Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash agree the Yankees’ trade deadline will be an unmitigated disaster if a starting catcher does not arrive before the clock expires. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they debate Garcia versus Luis Arraez, why positional fit no longer matters for baseball’s worst offense since mid-June, and whether another bullpen arm is also essential. The uncertainty surrounding Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton makes the Yankees’ urgency even greater, while a fully healthy lineup could create major questions about playing time and defensive alignment. Meanwhile, the Mets continue selling, leaving Evan to call their deadline necessary but deeply depressing as the franchise collects lottery-ticket prospects for the future.

The Los Angeles Dodgers’ latest blockbuster has Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash admitting an uncomfortable truth: Yankees and Mets fans are jealous. Evan argues that New York’s teams have the money and resources to operate like Andrew Friedman’s machine, while Shaun says the Dodgers’ growing dominance proves Major League Baseball’s system is fundamentally broken. They clash over whether a salary cap would have prevented Los Angeles from landing Tarik Skubal, whether Rob Manfred benefits from the outrage, and whether anyone can stop the Dodgers from returning to the World Series. Plus, the Mets’ disastrous Freddy Peralta trade gets a painful retrospective, Evan apologizes to Mike Hampton, and the Yankees’ reported willingness to trade Will Warren for Adrian Morejon reveals how aggressively Brian Cashman pursued bullpen help.

Adley Rutschman reportedly closing in on a trade to the Red Sox sends Shaun Morash into a full-blown Yankees panic. Evan Roberts tries to restore some perspective with hours remaining before the deadline, but Shaun unloads on Brian Cashman for potentially allowing Boston, a division rival closing fast on New York, to land the best catcher available while the Yankees’ biggest weakness remains untouched. The deadline chaos continues with debate over Luke Weaver’s trade value, the Mets’ prospect returns, Luis Garcia Jr., Tyler Stephenson and other possible Yankees targets. Evan and Shaun also react to Cam Skattebo being warned about his backflips, revisit the most exciting Yankees deadline deals of Evan’s lifetime, celebrate a classic Howie Rose call and uncover the bizarre fishing injury suffered by Mets prospect Gabe Davis.

The Yankees’ trade deadline is closing fast, and Shaun Morash is already bracing for another Brian Cashman disappointment. Shaun demands a legitimate replacement for Austin Wells and warns that anything less would be an insult to Yankees fans, while Evan Roberts refuses to judge the deadline before the final deals are complete. They debate the confusing Adley Rutschman rumors, possible medical concerns, Luis Garcia’s fit, Jazz Chisholm’s future and whether the organization is wasting Aaron Judge’s prime. Evan and Shaun also clash over the Yankees’ pitching-fueled road trip, react to Jacob deGrom potentially landing with the Braves and revisit the Mets’ 1986 reunion. Evan explains why younger Mets fans are exhausted by repeatedly celebrating a championship they never experienced, especially with nothing new to honor four decades later.

The Yankees continue to look for a catcher they can add before the 6pm but division rivals are stealing them away while the Mets look to keep selling off pieces.

Brian Cashman has one nonnegotiable job at the trade deadline: find a major-league catcher. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash warn that returning with Austin Wells and the Yankees’ current options would be an insult to a frustrated fan base, even as Evan predicts a deal will get done.

The Yankees are running out of time to fix an offense that has made every victory feel nearly impossible. Shaun Morash is already furious with Brian Cashman, warning that the best trade targets are disappearing while the Yankees wait until the deadline’s final hours. Evan Roberts pushes back, arguing that the front office cannot be judged until the deadline actually passes. The debate covers New York’s desperate need for a catcher, the uncertainty surrounding Adley Rutschman’s medicals, Austin Wells’ ideal role and why Jazz Chisholm may not have a long-term future in the Bronx. Evan and Shaun also explain how dominant pitching masked a miserable lineup during a 6-4 road trip before questioning whether Mets fans have finally grown tired of celebrating the 1986 championship team.

Brian Cashman’s trade deadline approach has Shaun Morash convinced the Yankees are headed for another crushing disappointment. With catcher still an obvious weakness and the Red Sox pushing for Adley Rutschman, Shaun argues that New York is merely trying to improve instead of building a World Series champion. Evan Roberts agrees a catcher is mandatory but refuses to declare the deadline a disaster before it ends. Shaun also ranks the most exciting Yankees deadline deals of his lifetime, from David Cone to Cecil Fielder. Plus, Howie Rose delivers a brutal line about Jorge Polanco, callers debate the Dodgers’ deferred contracts, and the bizarre fishing injury suffered by Mets prospect Gabe Davis leaves everyone searching for answers.

Adley Rutschman reportedly nearing a trade to the Red Sox sends Shaun Morash into a full Yankees meltdown. With Boston closing in on New York and catcher remaining the Yankees’ biggest need, Shaun calls it a disgrace that Brian Cashman could let his division rival land the deadline’s most appealing option. Evan Roberts urges patience, reminding him that the deal is not complete and wondering whether Baltimore leaked the talks to pressure the Yankees into improving their offer. The deadline panic also sparks debate over Luis Garcia Jr., Luke Weaver’s trade value and whether Cashman still has the urgency to build a championship roster. Plus, Cam Skattebo reveals that Giants coach John Harbaugh was not happy about his backflip.

The Freddy Peralta trade officially looks like a Mets disaster, and Evan Roberts revisits the warning he issued when New York surrendered two top prospects for a one-year rental. After hearing the station’s original reactions, Evan and Shaun Morash rank who came closest to getting it right and unload on Peralta’s five ERA, short starts and complete failure to deliver. Peralta’s move to Tampa Bay creates another nightmare scenario if the Rays immediately fix him, while Evan explains why the debacle has given him a new appreciation for Mike Hampton. The conversation also turns to the Yankees’ aggressive bullpen pursuit, a reported Will Warren offer for Adrian Morejon, possible Jacob deGrom trade destinations and Harrison Bader’s latest alleged scooter incident.

The Dodgers landing Tarik Skubal forces Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash to admit an uncomfortable truth: Yankees and Mets fans are jealous of the machine Los Angeles has built. Evan says New York’s teams have the money and resources to operate the same way, while Shaun argues the Dodgers’ dominance proves Major League Baseball is fundamentally broken.

The Yankees still have no clear timetable for Aaron Judge, and Evan Roberts fears the captain may not return until the postseason. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan as they examine how Giancarlo Stanton’s recovery and the arrival of Luis Garcia Jr. could create a complicated lineup puzzle, including the possibility of Stanton returning to the outfield. They also push back against concerns about adding a new catcher to a dominant pitching staff, arguing that the Yankees’ unacceptable production at the position outweighs any adjustment period. Plus, Garcia’s awkward defensive fit matters far less to an offense desperate for power, and his extra year of control could make him the eventual replacement for Jazz Chisholm Jr.

The Yankees’ decision to dump Camilo Doval becomes a brutal reminder that trade deadline excitement can age terribly. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash replay their euphoric reaction to last year’s deal, admit they had no idea how badly it would fail, and credit Brian Cashman for moving on instead of doubling down on a mistake. As the Yankees wait for more help after adding Luis Garcia Jr., the Mets begin their painful sell-off. Evan calls it a necessary but dark day, refusing to pretend that a collection of unfamiliar prospects is immediately exciting. The returns may become valuable lottery tickets, but for now they only underline how far the Mets have fallen.

Brian Cashman added desperately needed power with Luis Garcia Jr., but Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash warn the Yankees cannot stop there. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they debate Garcia versus Luis Arraez, why the Yankees were right to prioritize offense over positional fit, and whether Garcia could eventually replace Jazz Chisholm Jr.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate over the potential impact John Harbaugh will have on the Giants. Plus, reaction to Malik Nabers starting camp completely off the PUP list (23:55); Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash on if it’s playoffs or bust for the Giants (32:30); Evan argues the Giants should sign Vita Vea (50:03)

Tiki Barber is already putting Geno Smith on notice, declaring that Cade Klubnik should get the QB1 if he outplays the veteran in training camp and the preseason. Plus, Evan and Tiki can already see the Jets' use of AI going hilariously wrong. Boomer and Gio wonder if Aaron Glenn's job is tied to how Geno performs this season, and The Carton Show reacts to Plaxico Burress comparing playing for the Jets to being in prison.

Gregg Giannotti has had enough of the Aaron Boone criticism when it is never followed by any kind of praise. He says Boone's critics who also rip the Yankees' use of analytics need to be consistent in their arguments. Plus, Evan Roberts says vintage Gerrit Cole has returned, and the rest of the American League should be scared. Chris McMonigle calls for Brian Cashman to stack the deck with pitching if there isn't a significant bat available at the trade deadline, and Boomer and Gio wonder why Boone doesn't have better odds to win Manager of the Year.

Baker Mayfield feels disrespected by Tampa Bay, and Tiki Barber believes the Jets must immediately explore whether the contract standoff has created a rare opportunity. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they argue that Mayfield’s toughness, leadership and proven competence could finally pull the Jets out of their decade-long quarterback abyss. Tiki says New York cannot keep prioritizing future draft picks while the franchise remains irrelevant, even suggesting the Jets should consider using one of their three first-round selections. They debate whether Tampa Bay is already crumbling, why waiting for the next quarterback class could backfire, and whether Mayfield could transform the Jets into a playoff contender or become a midseason trade target.

Malik Nabers is progressing faster than expected, but the Giants’ optimism comes with a serious warning. NFL reporter Connor Hughes explains why Nabers could contribute against the Cowboys in Week 1 barring a setback, while revealing that the rest of the wide receiver room has left plenty to be desired. Odell Beckham Jr. has endured a quiet start and is far from guaranteed a roster spot, while Abdul Carter is already wrecking practices. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they examine how John Harbaugh has immediately brought professionalism and raised the Giants’ floor. They also react to Tony Romo being placed on leave by CBS and debate whether Baker Mayfield could become the stabilizing quarterback the Jets desperately need.

The Yankees are depleted, inconsistent and desperate for help before the trade deadline. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they explain why injuries to Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, Cody Bellinger and potentially Jazz Chisholm have left the offense unable to survive. With fundamental mistakes piling up and every game feeling like the same frustrating coin flip, the Yankees need players who can keep the season afloat until their stars return.

Aaron Boone has reached his breaking point with a Yankees lineup that cannot score, but Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber question whether the manager is doing enough to fix it. Shaun demands an end to Trent Grisham batting leadoff, argues Jasson Domínguez deserves the extra opportunities and warns that another early deficit could leave the Yankees dead in the water against the Cubs. Boone’s frustration earns some respect, but his latest reference to runs as “points” sends Shaun into a full baseball rant. The conversation also turns to Will Warren’s recent struggles, the pressure surrounding potential roster upgrades and whether Boone’s bullpen management helped cost the Yankees another game.

Harrison Bader’s stunning scooter accident leaves Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber in disbelief after reports that he crashed into a fire truck and suffered a season-ending foot injury. Tiki calls the decision irresponsible, while Shaun launches into a fiery rant about electric scooters taking over trains and sidewalks. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also examine the leadership void facing the injury-ravaged Yankees and explain why the trade deadline must provide enough offense to survive until Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton return. Plus, the show ranks the greatest NFL revenge games, leading Tiki to relive his 234-yard, three-touchdown performance against Washington in his final regular-season game.

The Yankees are running out of healthy impact bats, and Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber to explain why the pressure is rising before the trade deadline. With Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger already unavailable, Jazz Chisholm’s latest injury scare could force the Yankees to reconsider every possible move.

Baker Mayfield could be the stabilizing force the Jets desperately need. The argument is simple: New York cannot afford another losing season, another coaching change and another complete organizational reset. Mayfield’s leadership, toughness and ability to revive struggling teams make him an opportunity the Jets have to explore.

Shaun and Tiki also react to Tony Romo being placed on leave by CBS and J.J. Watt stepping into the booth with Jim Nantz. Plus, they examine the Rams’ mysterious Ty Simpson selection, revisit the Lamar Jackson versus Josh Allen MVP debate, and explain why improved coaching has created legitimate optimism for both New York football teams.

Malik Nabers is recovering faster than expected, and Connor Hughes believes the Giants’ optimism about a Week 1 return is justified barring a setback. But his progress also exposes the team’s biggest concern: a wide receiver room that has failed to produce a clear No. 2 option. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as Hughes explains why Odell Beckham Jr. still has to earn his roster spot, how John Harbaugh has immediately made Giants camp feel more professional, and why Abdul Carter is already taking over practices against Andrew Thomas. The Giants may have raised their floor, but their passing game still depends heavily on Nabers getting healthy.

Jets fans are tired of waiting, and several callers are ready to sacrifice premium draft picks to bring Baker Mayfield to New York. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate whether Mayfield could be more than a bridge quarterback and finally make the Jets relevant again. Tiki argues that uncertain draft prospects should not stop the Jets from pursuing a proven leader, while skepticism about Geno Smith only strengthens the case for an upgrade. A Tampa caller explains why the Buccaneers may hesitate to pay Mayfield, the discussion expands to other quarterback-needy teams, and one unforgettable caller takes the Jets’ search to an absurd new level by proposing a trade for Patrick Mahomes.

Baker Mayfield says he feels disrespected by Tampa Bay, and Tiki Barber sees a major opportunity for the Jets. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they argue that New York should aggressively explore a trade before another quarterback-needy team beats them to it. Tiki believes Mayfield’s toughness, leadership and proven ability would instantly upgrade a shaky Jets quarterback room and help stop the franchise from falling deeper into its losing cycle. Shaun pushes the idea even further, wondering whether Tampa Bay’s contract standoff could eventually lead to a trade and whether the Jets should be willing to use one of their three first-round picks to make it happen.

Evan takes you through not only a deep dive of David Stearns deadline trades, but also the New York Mets history as well!

In a shorter show than usual ahead of the final game for the Yankees vs the White Sox we look back on what may have been the worst loss of the season and another NFL Training Camp game of "New Team Who Dis"

The Yankees had a four-run lead, a dominant Cam Schlittler start and countless chances to put away the White Sox, yet somehow suffered their most infuriating loss of the season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber unload on Ali Sanchez’s disastrous decision to attempt a back pick at third base with two outs, while the offense disappeared and the bullpen failed to protect another winnable game. Aaron Boone did not lose the game with his managerial decisions, but his refusal to call Sanchez’s mistake unacceptable created an even bigger controversy. Evan and Tiki debate whether Boone’s constant protection of his players represents the same lack of accountability that could punish the Yankees again in October. Plus, the Mets’ collapsing attendance, Spencer Jones being removed despite a strong night and Tiki’s surprising memories of “The Baseball Bunch.”

Cam Schlittler may already be the Yankees’ ace, but should he take the ball over Gerrit Cole in Game 1 of a playoff series? Evan Roberts argues Schlittler has earned the biggest assignment right now, while Shaun Morash leans on Cole’s experience and proposes saving the young star for potential elimination games. Tiki Barber explains why Cole can mentor Schlittler while still desperately wanting to remain the man. The debate expands into Aaron Boone’s looming decision, Max Fried’s place in the rotation and the backlash the Yankees could face if they choose wrong. Evan, Tiki and Shaun also test their NFL offseason knowledge in “New Team, Who Dis,” examine Breece Hall’s contract compared with the exploding running back market.

Don Mattingly publicly fires back at Bryce Harper, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the Phillies’ growing dysfunction could end with a franchise-altering breakup. They debate whether Mattingly was holding his star accountable or simply protecting the front office and his son, then explore a blockbuster Bryce Harper-for-Francisco Lindor trade that could completely reshape the Mets and Phillies. Evan and Tiki weigh Harper’s fit alongside Juan Soto, Lindor’s uncertain future in Queens and why the proposed swap could end badly for everyone. They also revisit the Yankees’ extra-inning failures, debate their trade-deadline options, react to Shaun Morash’s controversial pizza rankings and question whether a LeBron James documentary can recreate the impact of The Last Dance.

Robert Saleh responds to a report that he promised the Titans would beat his former team in Week 1. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Saleh’s return makes the opener deeply personal and why a Jets loss could bury their season before it begins. Plus, the Yankees’ handling of young players, Francisco Lindor’s Mets future and Malik Nabers’ progress at Giants camp.

Shaun Morash crowns buffalo chicken the best pizza slice of 2026 and completely leaves pepperoni out of his top five, igniting outrage from Evan Roberts and the callers. The ranking gets even more controversial when Shaun is accused of recycling an old Cinco list, forcing him to challenge the show to find the original audio. The debate expands to stuffed crust, specialty slices and why pizza crust somehow gets better with age.