Evan & Tiki
Evan & Tiki

Evan & Tiki brings balance, brains and edge to New York sports talk. Evan Roberts’ fan-first intensity pairs with Tiki Barber’s perspective from inside the game to create debate that’s informed, passionate and rarely predictable. Whether it’s Giants and Jets analysis, Yankees and Mets arguments, or Knicks, Nets and league-wide storylines, the conversation goes deeper than hot takes. Throw in Shaun Morash, who stirs the pot with unfiltered opinions and the raw pulse of the fanbase, and you have Evan & Tiki, a show where New York sports get talked through — not talked over.

From their GM it sounds like they're not, but history has proven otherwise through out the years!
WFAN presents a roundup of New York Jets discussions from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The hosts react to Joe Brady's halftime comments about wearing the Jets down, question Aaron Glenn's decision to stick with Geno Smith at 2-8, and break down why the defense gave up huge plays in the second half. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
The Jets were totally outclassed by the Bills, but Jets fans got a taste of young Cade Klubnick and now some want to see more of him. Bills Think they are a New York team, the Cowboys stink, and much more.
Aaron Glenn is sticking with Geno Smith, and Evan Roberts can’t stand his reasoning. After the Jets fell to 2–8 with a 31–12 loss to Buffalo, Glenn said benching a healthy Geno would be disrespectful. Evan still sees value in letting a veteran develop young targets like Kenyon Sadiq and Omar Cooper Jr., but admits Cade Klubnik’s brief cameo was the most exciting part of the game. Tiki Barber makes the case for giving the rookie a real look, and Evan explains why this decision could be the strongest argument yet for firing Glenn midseason. Nine quarters without a touchdown give Evan plenty more to rip: three straight passes after the run game got the Jets to Buffalo’s 15, unused timeouts before halftime, and field goals that were never going to keep pace with Josh Allen. Plus, Dallas puts up 40 and still loses to San Francisco, raising the question of how much breathing room the Giants really have in the NFC East.
The Jets have reached another embarrassing low after Bills fans took over MetLife Stadium, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are unloading on the dysfunction. From devastating penalties to Frank Reich abandoning a successful running game in the red zone, the mistakes keep piling up. But Evan sees an even bigger problem: Woody Johnson has little financial incentive to fix a franchise that continues to embarrass its own fans. Plus, Aaron Glenn's endless disappointment is getting old, and the treatment of Jets season ticket holders only adds to the frustration. Meanwhile, Evan's dream of Mike Tomlin coaching the Jets takes a crushing blow. After Jay Glazer's latest comments, Tiki explains why no amount of money or promises about building a legacy will convince Tomlin to take over this organization. Evan pushes back on the idea that the Jets can't attract an elite coach, but the franchise's reputation may be its biggest obstacle. Brian Flores, other potential candidates, and the challenges facing Woody Johnson's next coaching search are all on the table.
Joe Benigno has had enough of Aaron Glenn and wants the Jets to make a change before another season goes completely to waste. After watching Bills fans take over MetLife Stadium, Joe unloads on the embarrassing state of the franchise, Garrett Wilson's reaction to the crowd, and Glenn's refusal to give Cade Klubnik a real opportunity. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Glenn's loyalty to Geno Smith is preventing the Jets from evaluating their future, while Joe demands that Klubnik start against the Chargers regardless of Geno's health. The conversation turns to potential replacements for Glenn, including Bruce Arians, and a fascinating NFL Draft debate featuring Arch Manning, Jeremiah Smith, and the danger of trading away valuable picks. Plus, Mike Vrabel sparks controversy with his comments about the Patriots, Mike Tomlin questions his leadership, and a devastating sequence involving Drake Maye and Aidan Hutchinson sends shockwaves through the NFL.
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate Jets fans' efforts to protest Woody Johnson and Aaron Glenn's tenure in charge of the team, NBA superstars' load management as LeBron ducks Egor Dёmin's Nets, and how many quarterbacks Garrett Wilson has dealt with.
Frank Reich's Jets offense is a complete mystery, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are struggling to understand how things have gotten this bad. Despite moving the football effectively between the 20s, the Jets continue to collapse in the red zone, even with Breece Hall and Braelon Allen available. How does Reich go from coordinating the NFL's top red-zone offense in Philadelphia to running the league's worst unit? The offensive failures are raising serious questions about the Jets' coaching staff.
Jets fans are so fed up with Woody Johnson that they're raising money to fly a protest banner over MetLife Stadium, but will it accomplish anything? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber clash over the planned airplane protest, with Tiki ripping it as a complete waste of money while Evan defends frustrated fans desperate to make their voices heard. The debate gets heated as they question whether Woody Johnson is capable of fixing the Jets and whether fan outrage can influence a billionaire owner.
Aidan Hutchinson's celebration turns into a potential season-ending disaster, and Drake Maye could be facing the same fate! Cinco de Luncho counts down the five biggest moments from Week 10, headlined by a shocking sequence that leaves the Lions star injured while celebrating a sack that also knocks the Patriots quarterback out of the game. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether dangerous celebrations are worth the risk.
Mike Vrabel is under fire after a brutal Patriots loss, and his postgame comments have Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber questioning what's really happening inside New England. Vrabel blasts players who complain instead of finding ways to win, only to backtrack when reporters question whether he's calling out his own team. Mike Tomlin adds fuel to the controversy by questioning Vrabel's leadership and suggesting there could be serious problems behind the scenes.
Joe Benigno is absolutely disgusted with the Jets, and Aaron Glenn is taking the heat! After watching Bills fans invade MetLife Stadium, Joe rips the embarrassing state of the franchise, blasts Garrett Wilson's reaction to the opposing crowd, and demands that Glenn be fired. But his biggest issue is the quarterback situation. Joe insists Cade Klubnik must start against the Chargers, even if Geno Smith is healthy, as the Jets desperately need to find out what they have in their young quarterback.
Mike Tomlin isn't coming to save the Jets, and Tiki Barber is making sure Evan Roberts finally understands why. After Jay Glazer declared that Tomlin wouldn't take the Jets job for any amount of money, Evan admits his dream coaching candidate may be completely out of reach. But Tiki takes it even further, ripping the idea that a legendary coach would willingly take on Woody Johnson's dysfunctional organization just to build his legacy.
The Jets can't stop embarrassing themselves, and now Bills fans are taking over MetLife Stadium! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the devastating penalties that destroyed the Jets' chances against Buffalo and the humiliating atmosphere inside their own building. Evan questions how Aaron Glenn, Demario Davis, and Garrett Wilson responded to the visiting fans, while Tiki explains why a well-coached team shouldn't let the crowd become an excuse.
The Jets have become an embarrassment, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are running out of patience. After another ugly loss to the Buffalo Bills, Aaron Glenn is once again preaching disappointment, but is that enough? Evan questions whether Woody Johnson truly feels the humiliation of watching Bills fans invade MetLife Stadium while loyal Jets season ticket holders keep paying for a terrible product.
The Cowboys just gave Giants fans another reason to believe they can win the division! Despite putting up 40 points against the 49ers, Dallas surrendered a staggering 584 yards of offense in a wild loss that exposed just how vulnerable its defense really is. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Cowboys are destined to blow games they should win and how many victories the Giants actually need to capture the division.
Aaron Glenn's coaching decisions have Evan Roberts absolutely furious after another miserable Jets loss to the Bills. With three timeouts available, why did the Jets abandon the running game near the goal line? Why did they repeatedly settle for field goals against Josh Allen and Buffalo? Evan blasts Glenn's game management and Frank Reich's struggling offense, which has now gone nine straight quarters without scoring a touchdown. Tiki Barber agrees the mistakes are becoming painfully repetitive.
Aaron Glenn's loyalty to Geno Smith has Evan Roberts furious after another embarrassing Jets loss to the Bills. With the Jets sitting at 2-8 and their season effectively over, Glenn refuses to consider benching Geno for rookie Cade Klubnik, arguing that doing so would be disrespectful to his veteran quarterback. Evan unloads on that explanation, insisting the Jets should be prioritizing their future instead of protecting Geno's feelings.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle grill Willie Colon over his take that the Jets should give Aaron Glenn a third year, and they also cross Rex Ryan off the Jets head coaching candidates list after his shocking arrest. Plus, Boomer and Gio wonder if there is a path to Jim Harbaugh replacing Aaron Glenn, and the Evan and Tiki crew sound off on how bad things have gotten for Glenn in what his likely his final season as head coach.
The Giants blew a late lead to the Commanders, but Gregg Giannotti says John Harbaugh and company deserve some grace, while Boomer Esiason says the silver lining was J.J. McCarthy, who New York just might have something in. Plus, Tiki Barber sounds off on the main reasons why the Giants lost a game they should have never conceded, while Shaun Morash went off on John Harbaugh for his handling of the kicker position. Craig Carton warns Giant fans that losing the division would be one of the worst collapses in league history.
Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti break down the NFL trade deadline winners and losers, the Jaguars' case as the best team in football, the Patriots' struggles and a loaded NFC North playoff race. Plus, their Week 10 picks, a big credibility test for the Bengals against Pittsburgh, a Steelers vs. Rams debate and their NFL midseason awards, including MVP, Coach of the Year and Super Bowl predictions.
From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans go over some of the biggest trades at the NFL Trade Deadline, including Kirk Cousins returning back to the Vikings. Then, they debate which NFC North team will be left out of the playoff picture. They also discuss whether the Colts made a huge mistake not dealing Jonathon Taylor. They end the podcast with #QuestionMark.
It has been along time since a Giants loss mattered this much this late int he season, we break down everything and anything that went wrong from a gut wrenching night at Metlife Stadium. Plus all the usual Football Friday segments.
The Giants were a first down away from putting Washington away. Instead of giving Cam Skattebo another carry on third-and-3, they called a quarterback run that lost two yards. Jordan Stout shanked the ensuing punt for 12 yards, and Stefon Diggs scored the go-ahead touchdown. Tiki Barber traces how that sequence, a missed 33-yard field goal and Washington’s pressure on the final drive turned a winnable game into a three-point loss. The Giants still lead the division, but the Commanders now own the tiebreaker. Shaun Morash calls out John Harbaugh for sticking with his rookie kicker, arguing that a big leg doesn’t help if the Giants won’t trust it after a chip-shot miss. Shaun also wants Abdul Carter to turn pressures into game-changing sacks. Tiki counters that keeping Jayden Daniels from breaking loose mattered more than chasing sacks against Washington.
John Harbaugh didn’t seriously consider going for it on fourth-and-inches from his own 12, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber see a chance the Giants let slip away. Evan explains why the clock made the gamble worth taking, while Tiki spots the opening Jameis Winston could have exploited on a sneak. The 24–21 loss leaves the Giants atop the division, but Washington now owns the tiebreaker. The blame doesn’t stop with Harbaugh. Tiki takes issue with the late play-calling but puts more of the loss on player execution. Evan zeroes in on Malik Nabers’ fumble at the Washington 17, while Shaun Morash takes stronger exception to Nabers skipping his postgame media availability. Then Cam Skattebo offers his own theory for why he didn’t get more late carries: Did his fumble in the first Washington game cost him some trust?
The Giants lost to Washington by three, and Shaun Morash puts their kicking problem at the top of his list. Did an early missed field goal make the Giants feel like they had to take deep shots on the final drive? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun weigh that theory against Washington’s blitz, revisit the third-and-3 call that took fourth down off the table, and debate the pass interference flag on Deonte Banks. J.J. McCarthy threw for a career-high 293 yards, but the Giants didn’t let him attempt another pass after his touchdown to Isaiah Likely until they were trailing. Tiki backs Boomer Esiason’s A-plus grade, while the late interception keeps the rest of the crew from going that high. Big Blue still leads the division, but Jacksonville looms as a test of whether these Giants can hang with the league’s best.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber analyze the New York Jets' offensive woes and what to expect in their upcoming divisional clash with the Buffalo Bills. They also discuss Jaden Daniels' impressive rookie season and poke fun at Jameis Winston's bizarre pre-snap antics. The duo wraps up with a review of common language blunders in the Idiots with Idioms segment and shares their Week 10 NFL picks.(00:01:50) Jets Offensive Expectations(00:08:00) NFL Week 10 Rooting Guide(00:13:15) NFL Draft Capital Discussion(00:16:40) Jameis Winston's Viral Chant(00:28:02) Idiots With Idioms Segment(00:38:20) NFL Week 10 Picks
Dominic Zvada’s missed chip shot tops Shaun Morash’s five reasons the Giants lost to Washington. Shaun argues the miss didn’t just leave three points on the board; it changed how Big Blue played the rest of the game. Malik Nabers’ fumble and a costly third-and-three call also make the list, and Deonte Banks’ pass interference penalty sparks a debate over why underthrown balls can draw such a punishing flag. Tiki Barber has a theory about the failed Jameis Winston sneak that left two Giants standing still: Winston may have run the wrong play. The hour also gets Evan Roberts and Shaun going over former Mets prospect Pete Crow-Armstrong’s unanimous MVP and whether the Mets could make Tarik Skubal an offer he can’t turn down.
The Giants still lead the NFC East, but Tiki Barber isn’t backing off his verdict after the Washington loss: Big Blue is “marginally good.” Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash weigh how much patience John Harbaugh has earned and why a blowout against Jacksonville could change the tone fast. After years of being out of the race by November, this loss stings precisely because fans expect more.
J.J. McCarthy threw for a career-high 293 yards against Washington, but after his touchdown pass to Isaiah Likely, the Giants didn’t let him throw again until they were trailing. Tiki Barber backs Boomer Esiason’s A-plus grade for the throws McCarthy made under pressure. Shaun Morash gives him a solid A, while Evan Roberts can’t overlook the late interception.
Cam Skattebo wondered if his fumble in the first Washington game was why he didn’t get more carries with a chance to ice the rematch. Tiki Barber doesn’t buy that John Harbaugh lost faith in him. His gripe is simpler: When the Giants needed three yards, they put the ball in J.J. McCarthy’s hands instead of trusting their best runner.
Malik Nabers put the ball on the ground at Washington’s 17-yard line, and Evan Roberts calls it a mistake the Giants couldn’t afford. Tiki Barber gives Washington’s defender credit for the late interception and says skipping the postgame podium was a bad look, not a locker-room problem. Shaun Morash is less forgiving about the timing: Fans had just rallied behind Nabers after the Fox broadcast criticized him.
John Harbaugh didn’t seriously consider going for it on fourth-and-inches from his own 12, and Evan Roberts thinks the Giants missed a chance to take control of the clock. Tiki Barber questions whether replay had enough evidence to overturn Jameis Winston’s first down, then spots the lane that opened for another sneak while Winston was singing “Who Let the Dogs Out.”
A missed 33-yard field goal has Shaun Morash calling for the Giants to replace their rookie kicker. His beef with John Harbaugh: Why keep a kicker for his big leg if you don’t trust him enough to try a long field goal with the game on the line? Harbaugh says he still believes in the rookie, and Evan Roberts explains why he doesn’t see a change coming. Shaun also wants more from Abdul Carter than a strong pressure rate. Tiki Barber pushes back on the criticism of Carter’s night against Washington, explaining why keeping Jayden Daniels in the pocket mattered more than chasing sacks. Shaun gets the logic, but he wants Carter finishing those plays down the stretch.
The Giants were a first down away from putting Washington away, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wanted the ball in Cam Skattebo’s hands. Instead, a designed J.J. McCarthy run on third-and-three lost two yards and left the Giants punting on fourth-and-five. Evan explains why even a short Skattebo gain could have kept the offense on the field, while Tiki wonders why the Giants didn’t lean on fullback Patrick Ricard in short yardage.
The Giants needed one more first down to put Washington away. Instead of giving Cam Skattebo another carry, they called a run for J.J. McCarthy on third-and-three and lost yards. A 12-yard punt and a pass interference flag helped set up Stefon Diggs’ go-ahead touchdown, and Washington’s blitz forced a game-sealing interception.
David Stearns actually names some pitchers he thinks will be a lock in the starting rotation. Plus, he gives an update on Jefferson Rojas!
The Giants prepare for their biggest home primetime mid-late season game in what feels like forever. The Jets have an old hat putting his name out there, and much more.
Cam Skattebo is primed for a massive redemption game against the Washington Commanders! Evan Roberts predicts 107 rushing yards from the Giants running back, while Tiki Barber shares his confidence but warns that mistakes in the rainy conditions could be costly. After his disastrous first meeting with Washington, a benching, and the Giants' unsuccessful attempts to acquire Jonathan Taylor or Tony Pollard, Skattebo has the perfect opportunity to prove he belongs as New York's lead back. With the Giants looking to deliver a crushing blow to Washington's division hopes, Evan expects an electric MetLife Stadium crowd despite the miserable weather. The guys debate whether the Giants made the right decision at the trade deadline, how dangerous Jayden Daniels remains, and whether the conditions favor New York. Plus, concerns about Mikal Bridges and Mike Brown's Knicks rotations, and encouraging injury developments for the Jets.
Mike Tomlin has Evan Roberts dreaming about the Jets again! Tomlin’s latest comments about a potential coaching return have Evan convinced the door is open, but Tiki Barber remains skeptical. Meanwhile, Aaron Glenn is running out of excuses. Evan and Tiki rip the lack of progress under the Jets head coach and debate whether anything over the final eight games could justify bringing him back. The Giants have a golden opportunity to bury the Commanders in the NFC East, but can they stop Jayden Daniels from running wild again? Tiki breaks down the challenge of containing Washington’s quarterback and the danger of aggressive blitzing. Plus, Evan and Tiki clash over whether Steve Cohen and the Mets could offer Tarik Skubal a massive $400 million contract, and Tiki celebrates the launch of his new podcast with his wife, Tracy.
The Jets are 2-7, and Evan Roberts is furious about the party atmosphere in their locker room! With players screaming and playing ping pong during Geno Smith's media availability, Evan blasts the team's terrible optics ahead of a showdown with Buffalo. Tiki Barber understands the frustration but questions whether it's really a big deal. Plus, Bruce Arians says he's healthy and itching to coach again. Could the 74-year-old become the Jets' next Bill Parcells and finally turn this franchise around? Meanwhile, the Giants face a massive divisional showdown with Washington, and another loss could fuel the talk that they're frauds. Evan and Tiki debate whether the Giants should hold on to J.J. McCarthy as insurance for Jaxson Dart, why the Jonathan Taylor trade fell apart, and whether Bijan Robinson could become a realistic target. Shaun Morash delivers five reasons the Giants should win, and a heated debate erupts over the Giants' whiteout and the Jets' upcoming blackout!
Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash share their stat predictions for J.J. McCarthy as the Giants prepare to face the Commanders. They provide essential tips for fans attending the game at MetLife Stadium and discuss the latest updates on Garrett Wilson trade rumors and team roster building.(00:02:00) J.J. McCarthy Stat Predictions(00:05:25) Minnesota To New York Transition(00:10:20) Giants Fan Experience Advice(00:13:45) Draft Picks Versus Veterans(00:19:40) Garrett Wilson Trade Rumors(00:23:15) MetLife Stadium Logistics(00:27:40) McCarthy's Durability Concerns(00:33:25) Knicks Struggles And Harden(00:38:20) Giants Versus Commanders Picks
The Giants missed out on Jonathan Taylor, but could an even bigger blockbuster be coming? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why the Colts refused to pull the trigger on a deal and whether the Giants could make another run at Bijan Robinson. With Atlanta struggling, Evan wonders if the Falcons might actually consider moving their star running back for a massive haul of draft picks. Plus, Shaun Morash delivers five reasons the Giants should beat the Commanders, including a revenge opportunity and a major advantage for John Harbaugh. But the real fireworks come when Evan exposes Tiki and Shaun's double standard over the Giants' whiteout! After ripping the Jets for doing the same thing, the two suddenly have a different opinion. The debate gets even better when the Jets' upcoming blackout enters the conversation!
The Jets are 2-7, and Evan Roberts has had enough of the laughing and screaming coming from their locker room! After hearing players celebrating a ping pong game during Geno Smith's media availability, Evan unloads on the team's embarrassing lack of urgency. Tiki Barber pushes back on whether it's really a problem but agrees the optics are terrible. With Buffalo coming to MetLife Stadium, is Aaron Glenn losing control of the culture?
Bruce Arians is itching to coach again, and the Jets may have a fascinating new name to consider! After the 74-year-old revealed he's healthy and interested in returning to the sidelines, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Arians could become the Jets' next Bill Parcells. His history of developing quarterbacks and transforming franchises makes him an intriguing possibility, but is his age too big a gamble? And would he even want the Jets job?
Jayden Daniels torched the Giants with his legs in their last meeting, and Tiki Barber has a warning for New York: make him pay every time he takes off! After Daniels rushed for 103 yards and two touchdowns against the Giants, Evan and Tiki debate how to contain Washington's dangerous quarterback without exposing the defense to big plays. Could aggressive blitzing actually make things worse?
How far should Steve Cohen and the Mets go to land Tarik Skubal? Evan Roberts believes a bidding war with the Padres and Blue Jays could push Skubal's contract to a staggering eight years and $400 million. But Tiki Barber strongly disagrees, warning that MLB's financial uncertainty and Skubal's injury history make that kind of commitment irresponsible. The debate heats up over whether any team will actually offer $50 million a year.
Mike Tomlin has Evan Roberts dreaming again! After Tomlin leaves the door open to a potential coaching return in 2027, Evan sees a glimmer of hope for the Jets. But Tiki Barber isn't buying it. Could Tomlin actually return to the sidelines, and would New York have any chance of landing him? Meanwhile, Evan and Tiki tear into the idea of giving Aaron Glenn another season with the Jets. With eight games remaining, Evan argues there's absolutely no evidence Glenn deserves a third year, although a dramatic turnaround could reopen the conversation. Plus, Giants fans prepare for a rainy Thursday night showdown with Washington, and one ambitious caller considers pulling off an unbelievable Devils-Giants doubleheader.
Attention then turns to the Giants' massive Thursday night showdown with Washington. Tiki Barber breaks down the offensive line's inconsistent run blocking and explains why execution, not opposing defenses, has been the biggest issue. The guys debate whether the rainy weather favors the Giants, revisit the failed pursuit of Jonathan Taylor, and question how much draft capital New York should have been willing to sacrifice. Plus, the Jets could finally get their young offensive weapons on the field together as Garrett Wilson works toward a return.
Giants fans are fired up for Thursday Night Football, with callers predicting touchdowns, a dominant victory, and an electric MetLife Stadium despite the miserable weather. But Evan and Tiki aren't ready to guarantee a blowout. They explain why Jayden Daniels remains a dangerous threat, why Washington won't go down without a fight, and why the Giants could be headed for another nerve-racking finish with major division implications.
Cam Skattebo has a chance to turn his Washington nightmare into a redemption story! Evan Roberts is predicting a monster performance from the Giants running back after his costly mistakes in the first meeting with the Commanders led to a benching. With New York failing to land Jonathan Taylor or Tony Pollard at the trade deadline, Skattebo believes the Giants have faith in him. But Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether that confidence is justified or simply a product of the asking prices being too high. With the Giants looking to bury Washington in the division race, the guys break down how the rain and wind could impact the game and why Evan expects one of the most electric MetLife Stadium crowds in years.
David Stearns may not be handing Marcus second base, but he's certainly in the mix.
The Giants didn't make a single trade at the deadline, does that leave us disappointed? Plus Brian Cashman had some things to say and we analyze.
Evan and Tiki explore Brian Cashman's recent comments regarding Hideki Matsui's managerial potential and what it means for the Yankees' future. They also break down a caller's hypothetical playoff roadmap for the New York Giants and debate the credentials of NFL coaching candidates like Jason Garrett and Aaron Glenn. Finally, they reflect on the Cy Young Award race and the New York Mets' interest in elite starting pitching. (00:01:50) Matsui Manager Discussion (00:05:45) Giants Playoff Roadmap (00:08:50) Jason Garrett Evaluation (00:15:55) Aaron Glenn Coaching Tiers (00:22:15) Underrated Giants Talk (00:26:45) Cy Young Award History (00:36:55) Tarik Skubal Free Agency
The Giants went big-game hunting and came away empty at the NFL trade deadline! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether missing out on Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard was actually a failure, especially after neither running back was traded. Plus, the shocking report that the Giants even called about Bijan Robinson! Shaun Morash questions why New York couldn't strengthen its defensive tackle depth, while the crew debates whether John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen made the right call by protecting their future. Meanwhile, Evan delivers a strong warning about the Jets potentially making trade deadline decisions to help Aaron Glenn save his job. Kirk Cousins' move to Minnesota sparks a heated debate over the Vikings' playoff ceiling, with Tiki predicting an NFC Championship Game appearance. Plus, Malik Nabers fires back at criticism of his body language, and the guys defend the Giants receiver against what they believe was an unfair narrative.
Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets is in serious jeopardy, and SNY's Connor Hughes reveals why a coaching change could be coming if things don't turn around. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine the Jets' quiet trade deadline, why Geno Smith and Will McDonald weren't moved, and whether Glenn can still save his job. Meanwhile, Miami's quarterback situation could deal a crushing blow to the Jets' hopes of landing the No. 1 draft pick. Across town, the Giants failed to land Jonathan Taylor, but Hughes explains why they refused to mortgage their future. He also reveals the powerful one-on-one conversation with Matt Nagy that helped unlock a new level of confidence in JJ McCarthy. Plus, the impact of the Giants' impressive rookie linebacker, the possibility of losing defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson, and growing injury concerns surrounding McCarthy and Jaxson Dart.
Brian Cashman's comments from the GM Meetings have Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash sounding the alarm! Why are the Yankees making budget cuts while insisting Giancarlo Stanton remains a major part of their plans? Evan is stunned by Cashman's explanation for parting ways with Brian Sabean and Omar Minaya, while Tiki Barber pushes back on the outrage. Things get even more heated when Cashman counts Jorge Posada's championships while addressing the Yankees legend's frustration with the organization. Plus, Shaun unleashes his five biggest problems with Cashman's comments, including Ryan McMahon, Stanton and the Yankees' fundamental flaws. The Mets' pursuit of Tarik Skubal raises another fascinating debate: Would landing baseball's top available pitcher even generate massive excitement among Mets fans? The crew also tackles Aaron Glenn's uncertain Jets future, Jaxson Dart's troubling injury history, the bizarre Rex Ryan legal situation and a wild Yankees-Mets trade proposal involving Stanton and Kodai Senga.
Shaun Morash unleashes his five biggest problems with Brian Cashman's comments from the GM Meetings, and the Yankees' offseason outlook is raising serious concerns! From Cashman's continued belief in Ryan McMahon to his defense of the team's fundamentals, Shaun questions whether the Yankees are willing to acknowledge their biggest weaknesses. The frustration reaches another level over Cashman's refusal to reveal his contract length and his explanation that budget constraints forced the departure of two respected executives. But the biggest argument centers on Giancarlo Stanton. Shaun believes the Yankees desperately need to stop relying on the injury-prone slugger, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on his value to the team. Plus, Evan proposes a wild Yankees-Mets trade involving Stanton and Kodai Senga that actually gets everyone thinking!
Rex Ryan's bizarre legal situation in Nashville takes center stage as the former Jets coach faces six misdemeanor charges stemming from an incident involving two pedestrians. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to the stunning details and debate whether Ryan could have been unaware he struck the pedestrians before driving away. Meanwhile, the Mets could be preparing to make a massive run at Tarik Skubal, but Evan believes even landing the star pitcher might produce a surprisingly muted reaction from fans. The crew debates why the looming MLB lockout and Juan Soto's blockbuster signing could dampen the excitement. Plus, serious concerns about Jaxson Dart's ability to stay healthy, potential coaching alternatives for the Jets and why Aaron Glenn's struggles have become impossible to ignore.
Brian Cashman's comments from the GM Meetings are raising serious red flags about the Yankees! Evan Roberts is stunned that Cashman blamed budget constraints for parting ways with respected executives Brian Sabean and Omar Minaya, while Tiki Barber argues it's simply a business decision. Shaun Morash is even more frustrated by Cashman's continued faith in Giancarlo Stanton, warning that the Yankees cannot afford to count on an aging, injury-prone slugger.
The Patriots have found a wild solution to their stadium traffic nightmare: paying fans $50 to stay after games! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the unusual parking incentive at Gillette Stadium, the catch that keeps fans from leaving early, and whether the Giants and Jets should consider something similar at MetLife Stadium. Tiki also shares how he dealt with stadium traffic during his playing days.
Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets is anything but secure! SNY's Connor Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to reveal where Glenn stands with the organization, why the Jets refused to move Geno Smith and Will McDonald at the trade deadline, and what it would take for Glenn to save his job. Hughes also explains why Geno could return as a bridge quarterback and whether rookie Cade Klubnik might get an opportunity before the season ends. On the Giants side, Hughes breaks down why the team couldn't land Jonathan Taylor and reveals the powerful private conversation with Matt Nagy that helped transform JJ McCarthy's confidence after his struggles in Minnesota. Plus, why rookie linebacker Reese has become a defensive game-changer, the brilliance of Dennard Wilson's coaching, and the possibility that the Giants could lose key members of John Harbaugh's staff.
The Jets' race for the No. 1 overall pick just got a lot more complicated! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why Miami's quarterback situation could be a disaster for the Jets' draft position, how the Colts factor into the battle for the top pick, and why the Eagles could become another major threat in the quarterback sweepstakes. Evan admits he's officially all-in on the tank, with every remaining win and loss potentially shaping the Jets' future.
Kirk Cousins is back in Minnesota, and the Vikings suddenly have Super Bowl aspirations! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Cousins can turn Minnesota into a legitimate contender behind Brian Flores' dominant defense. Tiki makes a bold prediction that the Vikings will reach the NFC Championship Game, while Evan sees an early playoff exit. Could Cousins accomplish something no midseason quarterback acquisition has ever done? Meanwhile, Malik Nabers fires back at criticism of his body language during the Giants' win over Philadelphia. Evan and Tiki defend the young receiver, blasting the FOX broadcast for pushing what they believe was an unfair narrative about his attitude and leadership. Tiki explains why being an alpha isn't everything and why Nabers' fiery personality shouldn't be mistaken for being a bad teammate.
The Giants stood pat at the trade deadline, but could their lack of aggression come back to haunt them? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to frustrated Giants fans who believe New York missed a golden opportunity to strengthen a playoff contender. With Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard staying put, Evan questions what more the Giants realistically could have done. But should they have pursued Jesse Bates or DeForest Buckner? And can the Giants afford to assume they'll be in this position again?
The Giants swung for the fences at the NFL trade deadline and came away empty! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether missing out on Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard is actually a disappointment, especially with the Giants exceeding expectations under John Harbaugh. Even more surprising, New York reportedly made a call about Bijan Robinson! Shaun Morash likes the aggressive approach but fears the Giants' failure to add defensive tackle depth could come back to haunt them.
We look ahead and await the NFL Trade Deadline which stayed rather quiet throughout the course of our Tuesday show.
Carson Wentz's disastrous performance has Evan Roberts wondering if the Jets could take advantage of a desperate Vikings team at the NFL trade deadline. But should New York actually trade Geno Smith? Evan refuses to give him away for a late-round pick, arguing that competent quarterback play is crucial to developing the Jets' young weapons. Tiki Barber pushes back, insisting the franchise needs a clear plan for its future quarterback and must find out whether Geno even wants to return next season. The debate heats up over Aaron Glenn's uncertain future, a reported second-round offer for Will McDonald, and whether the Jets should consider packaging Geno and Breece Hall in a blockbuster deal. Plus, Kirk Cousins and Daniel Jones emerge as potential Vikings options, while Evan vents about Carson Benge losing the National League Rookie of the Year award and the draft pick the Mets missed out on.
The Giants are reportedly leading the race for Jonathan Taylor, but will the Colts finally lower their asking price before the NFL trade deadline? Evan Roberts believes Indianapolis is bluffing and predicts a last-minute deal, while Tiki Barber insists the Giants shouldn't get desperate and increase their offer. With a second- and fifth-round pick reportedly on the table, the guys debate whether Joe Schoen and John Harbaugh should make one final push. Meanwhile, Kevin O'Connell emerges as an intriguing potential replacement for Aaron Glenn if the Vikings move on from their head coach. Minnesota's quarterback disaster sparks questions about J.J. McCarthy, Kirk Cousins, and a desperate deadline search for help. Plus, Evan entertains the fantasy of bringing Sean McVay to the Jets, and the upcoming Giants whiteout against Washington ignites a hilarious argument over Shaun Morash's sudden enthusiasm for a promotion he previously criticized when the Jets did it.
The Giants are no longer playing with house money! Evan Roberts declares that winning the NFC East is now the expectation, and he's tired of fans acting like anything beyond this point is a bonus. With the Eagles struggling and the Cowboys and Commanders falling behind, Evan insists the Giants must capitalize on their opportunity because there's no guarantee they'll be back next year. Tiki Barber weighs in on whether Jonathan Taylor is the missing piece, why John Harbaugh wants a true bell-cow running back, and how much New York should sacrifice at the trade deadline. Meanwhile, the Jets reportedly turned down a significant offer for Will McDonald despite his desire to be traded, raising more questions about the franchise's direction. Evan also unloads on Aaron Glenn's coaching failures, the guys debate whether the Vikings will find a quarterback before the deadline, and a caller sparks the ultimate Jets coaching fantasy involving Kyle Shanahan.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber discuss the unfolding drama of the NFL trade deadline, including the San Francisco 49ers' acquisition of Keenan Allen. They analyze the impact of the Sauce Gardner trade for the Jets and look ahead to the Giants' matchup against the Ravens. (00:01:50) MLB Salary Cap Debate (00:06:00) Secondary Coaching and Panic (00:09:15) Challenging Official Penalties (00:12:45) Giants Fans Rivalry Behavior (00:18:10) Connor Hellebuyck Playing Decisions (00:21:20) Kirk Cousins Rumors Update (00:25:30) Evaluating Rookie Quarterback Starts (00:34:40) Keenan Allen Traded Away (00:39:10) Sauce Gardner Trade Impact (00:43:20) John Harbaugh Coaching Stats
Shaun Morash takes NFL trade deadline madness to another level with a hilarious Cinco de Luncho countdown of the five most ridiculous things people have ever traded! From McDonald's Monopoly pieces and state quarters to Pokémon cards, Shaun questions why anyone thought these trades were worth making. He also takes a shot at the Colts for surrendering multiple first-round picks for Sauce Gardner, a deal that's already looking questionable.
Aaron Glenn is running out of excuses as the Jets continue to unravel! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber rip the struggling head coach, with Evan admitting how painful it is to watch a beloved former player fail so badly on the sidelines. The disrespect reaches another level when the winless Chargers are revealed as massive betting favorites over the Jets. Meanwhile, the Giants are barely favored against the Commanders despite their surprising success, leaving the guys stunned by how little respect New York is getting.
The Giants are no longer playing with house money, and Evan Roberts says anything short of winning the NFC East would be a failure! With the Eagles struggling and the Cowboys and Commanders falling behind, Evan insists New York must capitalize on its opportunity. He fires back at fans who are already satisfied with the season, warning that championship windows can disappear faster than anyone expects.
The Giants are planning a whiteout against the Commanders, and Shaun Morash is suddenly all for it! But Evan Roberts isn't letting him forget how strongly he criticized the Jets for doing the exact same thing. The argument explodes when Evan attempts to expose one of Shaun's deleted tweets, only for his big reveal to backfire. Tiki Barber defends the Giants' promotion, insisting a winning team has earned the right to create a special atmosphere, while Evan argues that whiteouts are ridiculous regardless of the team.
The Giants have reportedly made the best offer for Jonathan Taylor, but the Colts are refusing to budge on their massive asking price! With the NFL trade deadline approaching, Evan Roberts believes Indianapolis is bluffing and predicts they'll eventually cave rather than lose their chance to make a deal. Tiki Barber disagrees with the idea of chasing Taylor, warning that the Giants would look desperate if they increased their offer without a counter from the Colts.
Kevin O'Connell could become one of the Jets' most intriguing head coaching candidates if the Vikings' season falls apart! With Aaron Glenn's departure viewed as inevitable, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate where O'Connell belongs on their coaching wish list. Despite his impressive regular-season record, Minnesota's revolving door at quarterback and lack of playoff success raise serious questions. Could the Vikings move on from O'Connell without losing defensive mastermind Brian Flores?
Carson Wentz delivers a quarterback performance so disastrous that Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are comparing it to some of the worst games in NFL history! From Sam Darnold's infamous "seeing ghosts" nightmare to Jake Delhomme's playoff collapse, the guys struggle to believe just how badly Wentz played. With Brian Flores leading an incredible Vikings defense and Justin Jefferson stuck in a dysfunctional offense, is Minnesota wasting a legitimate championship opportunity? Evan also defends his controversial belief that a Bills-Vikings Super Bowl would be a dream matchup, despite Minnesota's offensive disaster. Plus, the conversation shifts to the Mets as Evan unloads on Carson Benge losing the National League Rookie of the Year award. He questions the voting process, the emphasis on traditional statistics, and whether voters were influenced by the extra draft pick the Mets stood to gain.
The Jets have a chance to capitalize on Minnesota's quarterback disaster, but Evan Roberts refuses to sell Geno Smith cheap! Evan demands a second- or third-round pick for Geno, while Tiki Barber argues that holding out for such a steep price could cost the Jets valuable draft assets. With Carson Wentz struggling badly, could Kirk Cousins or Daniel Jones be better options for Kevin O'Connell? The trade deadline debate gets even hotter when a caller proposes sending Geno Smith and Breece Hall to Minnesota for a first- and second-round pick, a deal Evan would gladly accept. Meanwhile, Evan rips the possibility of the Jets rejecting a reported second-round offer for Will McDonald. The two also question Aaron Glenn's influence over personnel decisions and whether the Jets have a real plan for their future.
Should the Jets trade Geno Smith before the deadline, or would moving him do more harm than good? Carson Wentz's disastrous performance has Evan Roberts eyeing the desperate Minnesota Vikings as a potential trade partner, but Evan refuses to give Geno away for a late-round draft pick. He argues that losing their veteran quarterback could stunt the development of young Jets weapons like Omar Cooper Jr., Kenyon Sadiq, and Mason Taylor.
WFAN presents a collection of reactions following the Jets’ brutal loss to Kansas City from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. Evan Roberts issues a formal apology for predicting a New York win, Tiki and Evan break down Aaron Glenn's repeated postgame catchphrases, and Joe Benigno sounds off on the red zone woes and Will McDonald's trade request. Plus, Craig Carton questions if players made "business decisions" and quit on the field. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
WFAN presents a collection of discussions breaking down the Giants’ gritty victory in Philadelphia from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The guys react to the Giants snapping their 13-year losing streak in Philly, examine why an ugly win is still a win, and debate whether Jameis Winston or J.J. McCarthy gave the offense the better spark. Plus, Craig Carton crowns Big Blue the kings of the NFC East while demanding an apology over Joe Milton. That and more on Best Of Giants on WFAN!
Not every diehard Mets fan is open to the idea of Jacob deGrom returning for the 2027 season.
A Victory Monday for Giants fans but Tiki still sees plenty of negatives. The Jets have no answers in Kansas City, and the Jets start the trade deadline off locally.
The Giants finally end their Philadelphia nightmare, but Tiki Barber isn't celebrating without some serious concerns! Despite a 19-11 victory that snaps a 13-game losing streak in Philly, Tiki blasts the Giants' sloppy offense, questionable play-calling, and inability to dominate a struggling Eagles team. Evan Roberts argues that winning is all that matters, especially with the Giants sitting at 5-2-1 and closing in on a division title. Plus, Evan makes a surprising confession about wanting Jameis Winston to stay in the game over J.J. McCarthy! Meanwhile, the Jets completely unravel in a humiliating 35-12 loss to the Chiefs. Evan apologizes for predicting a Jets victory and accuses the team of quitting in the second half. Aaron Glenn comes under fire for his repetitive excuses and baffling assessment of the offense, while Tiki questions the predictable play-calling and Geno Smith's costly sacks. With the Giants eyeing a home playoff game and the Jets spiraling, New York's football teams couldn't be heading in more different directions.
Did FOX launch an unfair attack on Malik Nabers? Evan and Tiki unload on Joe Davis, Greg Olsen, and Pam Oliver for turning Nabers' body language into a narrative about selfishness and being a bad teammate. The guys dissect the broadcast, challenge Olsen's criticism, and play Nabers' postgame explanation that tells a very different story. Meanwhile, the Giants' impressive defensive performance has Evan convinced they need to go all-in on Jonathan Taylor before the trade deadline. Tiki pushes back on the potential asking price, sparking a heated debate over how much the Giants should sacrifice to capitalize on a winnable division. Plus, the Jets earn rare praise for an innovative kickoff strategy despite another embarrassing performance, Will McDonald requests a trade, and a bizarre challenge controversy raises questions about NFL officiating.
The Jets' ugly loss to Kansas City has Evan Roberts wondering whether Aaron Glenn can survive a team that appears to have quit. The offense keeps marching downfield only to settle for field goals, costly penalties erase big plays, and Tiki Barber sees a coaching problem with no simple fix. Joe Benigno joins the outrage, demands Glenn's dismissal, warns about Will McDonald's desire to leave, and makes the case for giving Klubnik a shot at quarterback. The conversation also turns to the Giants' big win in Philadelphia, Malik Nabers, and the attitude of Eagles fans. Shaun Morash runs through a wild NFL Sunday, including the Bears, Cowboys, Bengals, and Rams. Plus, Evan absolutely unloads on Tom Brady for taking an unnecessary shot at the Jets during the Patriots' embarrassing loss to Green Bay, arguing that Brady should be making fun of the Bills instead!
Evan and Tiki analyze the NFL's decision to move the Giants vs. Jaguars matchup into the marquee late afternoon window. They discuss the Jets' trade of Andre Cisco to the Lions and debate the merits of firing Aaron Glenn mid-season. The conversation also highlights rookie performances and provides predictions for the Bills-Vikings Monday Night Football game. (00:01:44) Giants Game Flexed (00:07:03) Firing Aaron Glenn Discussion (00:11:17) Arvel Reese Impact (00:17:58) Giants Weather And Skattebo (00:21:32) Andre Cisco Trade News (00:25:45) NFL Trade Strategy Debate (00:31:19) J.J. McCarthy Performance Review (00:35:54) Monday Night Football Picks
The Jets' Aaron Glenn crisis is getting uglier. After another miserable performance, Evan believes the players have given up on their head coach, and the pressure is building on Woody Johnson to make a change. But would firing Glenn now accomplish anything beyond satisfying frustrated fans? With Glenn's future looking increasingly bleak, the debate turns to whether the Jets have any reason to wait until the offseason.
Tom Brady takes an unnecessary shot at the Jets during the Patriots' embarrassing loss to the Packers, and Evan Roberts absolutely loses it! Evan blasts Brady for taking the easy way out, arguing that his record against Buffalo makes the Bills a much more deserving target. Plus, Green Bay's decision to go for two with a massive fourth-quarter lead sparks a debate over whether the Packers were simply playing the numbers or rubbing it in.
Joe Benigno has officially had enough of Aaron Glenn and the Jets! After another humiliating loss to the Chiefs, Joe B demands Glenn be fired immediately, blasting the team's disastrous red-zone offense, backbreaking penalties, and a defense that appears to have completely quit. Evan Roberts wonders whether losing the locker room has made Glenn's firing unavoidable, while Tiki Barber explains why the problems go far beyond one coach. Joe B also sounds the alarm over Will McDonald's desire to leave, lays out his plan for Geno Smith and Cade Klubnik, and reveals why he wants absolutely no part of Justin Herbert but would welcome Jim Harbaugh. Plus, Joe makes a bold prediction about quarterback prospect LaNorris Sellers, questions the Jets' future, and celebrates the Patriots getting embarrassed by Green Bay.
The Jets are falling apart, and now Will McDonald wants out! Evan believes McDonald's trade request is further proof that he isn't part of the team's future and predicts he'll be gone by the deadline, despite Aaron Glenn's insistence on keeping good players. But amid another embarrassing Jets performance, Evan and Tiki actually praise one brilliant decision: using fullback Andrew Beck on kickoffs, a move that could catch on across the NFL.
The Giants have a golden opportunity to make a playoff push, and Evan believes they cannot let Jonathan Taylor slip away at the trade deadline! After an encouraging defensive performance, Evan argues that adding an elite running back could transform the Giants' offense and put them in position to win the division. Tiki pushes back, warning that the Colts' asking price could be too steep and questioning whether running back is really the biggest problem.
Did FOX manufacture a controversy around Malik Nabers? Evan and Tiki rip Joe Davis, Greg Olsen, and Pam Oliver for portraying the Giants star receiver as selfish based on his body language during Sunday's game. Evan plays the broadcast clips to make his case that FOX pushed an unfair narrative, while Tiki blasts Olsen for implying Nabers was a bad teammate without any real evidence.
Philadelphia is furious after the Giants finally snap their 13-game losing streak in Philly, and Evan Roberts is loving every second of it! After hearing the Eagles' postgame crew trash the Giants despite losing 19-11, Evan fires back at the Philadelphia critics. With the Giants sitting atop the NFC East and their division rivals struggling, Evan and Tiki Barber explain why a home playoff game is becoming a very real expectation.
The Jets completely quit in the second half against the Chiefs, and Evan Roberts has seen enough! After confidently predicting a Jets victory, Evan delivers a brutal apology and rips Aaron Glenn for allowing his team to surrender in a humiliating 35-12 loss. Tiki Barber blasts the predictable offense, Geno Smith's costly sacks, and the inexplicable decision to abandon a productive running game.
The Giants finally win in Philadelphia, but Tiki Barber is furious with how they got there! Despite ending a decade-plus losing streak against the Eagles, Tiki rips the Giants' sloppy offense, questionable execution, and inability to dominate an inferior opponent. With the Giants sitting at 5-2-1 and eyeing a division title, Tiki warns that playing down to the competition could eventually cost them.
Aaron Glenn still has his job, but our hosts are wondering who will be the next head coach when Glenn is inevitably fired, either during or after this season. The Carton Show ponders an outside-the-box possibility in Brian Billick, while Boomer and Gio return to Rex Ryan, and whether he could have a successful second tenure in New York. Plus, Evan says Woody Johnson needs a reality check that perhaps Mike Tomlin could provide, and he and Tiki go off on the outside possibility that Russell Wilson interviews for the job whenever it becomes available.
The Giants are reportedly aggressively pursuing reinforcements before the trade deadline, and Evan Roberts says it feels inevitable that Big Blue will add a legit running back to be their new No. 1. Tiki Barber says Giants fans are getting too "trade drunk" and need to remember the realistic expectations for the season. Plus, Boomer and Gio wonder if Derrick Henry is a realistic trade option, and Pat Leonard joins The Carton Show with all the latest trade rumors surrounding Big Blue.
Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti: Bears dominance, Lamar done in Baltimore? Picks and preview for all the games. Game of the Week has the best defense against the best offense. And, are these storylines headline worthy?
From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans start the podcast be examining an interesting matchup this weekend between the Packers and the Patriots. Then, they discuss how well J.J. McCarthy has been playing and if he keeps it up and they name the NFL coaches who are currently on the hot seat. They end the podcast with #QuestionMark.
The giants head to Philly with major expectations, and that sometimes isn't a good thing. Evan is feeling a Jets upset, is he delusional? Plus Idiots with Idioms and a full football Friday.
Derrick Henry to the Giants sounds like a blockbuster move, but is there any realistic chance Baltimore lets him go? Evan digs into Henry's relationship with John Harbaugh and uncovers some revealing comments that could eliminate one major concern about a potential reunion. Tiki and Shaun question why the Ravens would trade their star running back after acquiring Jacoby Brissett, while Evan argues that Henry's age and declining production could still make a deal possible. Just how much should the Giants be willing to give up? Plus, the Giants have a golden opportunity against an Eagles team starting Joe Milton, but a loss could tighten the NFC East race. The guys debate the Giants' playoff expectations, revisit parallels to the 1997 team, and consider whether Jim Harbaugh would ever coach in the same division as his brother. Meanwhile, Garrett Wilson is ruled out for the Jets against Kansas City, but Breece Hall is ready to return.
Geno Smith is putting up some of the best numbers in Jets history, but his success could create a major problem for the franchise. Evan Roberts questions whether Geno’s pursuit of 4,000 passing yards and Aaron Glenn’s desperation to win could prevent the Jets from evaluating their younger quarterback. Tiki Barber believes winning still has to come first, setting up a fascinating debate over the team’s future. Six years into Steve Cohen’s Mets ownership, Evan delivers a disappointing report card despite massive spending, the arrival of Juan Soto, and improvements to the farm system. The guys also examine the departures of Pete Alonso and Jacob deGrom before turning to a massive Giants-Eagles showdown. Shaun Morash unleashes his five biggest reasons for hating Philadelphia, Nick Sirianni’s quarterback gamesmanship gets mocked, and Evan absolutely loses it over fans screaming during the national anthem. It's a fiery Football Friday filled with New York sports frustrations!
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber analyze the New York Jets' dismal season and the potential for major coaching changes, specifically discussing the prospect of Jim Harbaugh moving to New York. They evaluate Sean Morash's rooting guide for the Jets while debating the value of draft picks over a miracle playoff run. Tiki also shares his perspective on the grueling nature of NFL coaching and explains why he would decline a hypothetical $6 million head coaching offer. (00:02:36) Loser Jets Rooting Guide (00:09:09) Harbaugh and Herbert Rumors (00:14:38) Steve Pikiell Cancer Fundraiser (00:21:31) Tiki Rejects Coaching Roles (00:27:54) Idiots With Idioms (00:31:05) Week 9 NFL Picks (00:38:47) J.J. McCarthy Stat Predictions (00:46:04) Rant Against Jets Coaching
Evan Roberts has had enough of fans disrespecting the national anthem! From screaming team chants during the anthem to refusing to stand, Evan unleashes a fiery rant about behavior that drives him absolutely crazy. Tiki Barber offers a more relaxed perspective, but Evan refuses to back down. Meanwhile, Shaun Morash delivers his five biggest reasons for hating the Philadelphia Eagles ahead of the Giants' massive rivalry showdown. From DeSean Jackson to Nick Sirianni, Shaun has plenty of old grudges to settle, and the guys wonder whether Giants fans could invade Philadelphia on Sunday. Plus, Evan reveals an unbelievable coincidence involving Craig Carton, Kerry Kittles, and his vote in the governor's race that leaves everyone stunned.
Geno Smith is putting up some of the best numbers in Jets history, but could his success actually hurt the franchise's future? Evan Roberts questions whether Geno's pursuit of a 4,000-yard season will prevent the Jets from evaluating their younger quarterbacks, while Tiki Barber argues that winning games still needs to be the priority.
Six years into Steve Cohen’s ownership, the Mets have spent a fortune, landed Juan Soto, and rebuilt their farm system, but where are the wins? Evan Roberts gives Cohen a C-plus while Shaun Morash goes with a B-minus, sparking a debate over disappointing results, the departures of Pete Alonso and Jacob deGrom, and whether Cohen has actually delivered on his promises.
Could Jim Harbaugh actually take a job with one of the Giants' biggest rivals and go head-to-head with his brother John twice a year? Evan, Tiki, and Shaun debate whether the Harbaugh brothers would ever be willing to coach in the same division, especially with potential coaching changes looming across the NFC East.
The Giants have a golden opportunity to take control of the NFC East, but could overlooking Joe Milton and the struggling Eagles come back to haunt them? Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down why this is a game the Giants should win, how a loss could bring the Cowboys closer in the division race, and why taking care of business against Philadelphia and Washington is so important.
First, David Stearns would have to feel comfortable trading for Jacob deGrom, then deGrom would have to say yes to the trade. On top of that, there's the finances! Is Jacob deGrom a realistic move for the 2027 Mets roster?
The Eagles are changing quarterback's and some Giants fans are more nervous. Plus the Knicks look like the Knicks of last year once again.
Joe Milton has Giants fans sweating! The Eagles' surprise decision to start Milton has Shaun Morash officially on worry watch, fearing the quarterback's mobility and cannon arm could bring Philadelphia's struggling offense back to life. Tiki Barber shares those concerns, especially considering his longtime fascination with Milton, but Evan Roberts isn't buying the panic. Is this a legitimate threat to the Giants or just another overhyped backup quarterback? Evan brings the numbers to calm everyone down, including John Harbaugh's perfect 6-0 record against quarterbacks making their first NFL start and the league-wide struggles of inexperienced starters. Can the Giants take advantage coming out of their bye week, or is Milton capable of pulling off a stunning upset? Plus, the Knicks crush the Bulls behind Jalen Brunson, the Nets give Evan a rare reason to celebrate, and a potential Braylon Allen trade sparks a heated Jets-Giants debate.
Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets looks increasingly bleak, but Evan Roberts isn't ready to declare his fate completely sealed. With the Jets sitting at 2-6, Evan lays out exactly what Glenn must accomplish to save his job, including an 8-9 finish and some shocking wins against legitimate contenders. Tiki Barber offers his own unlikely path to redemption, while Shaun Morash remains deeply skeptical. Can Glenn pull off a miracle, or will his coaching mistakes continue to cost the Jets winnable games? Plus, the debate over potential Jets coaching candidates heats up with Doug Pederson and Brian Flores entering the conversation. Evan dismisses Giants fans' fears about facing the Eagles in Philadelphia, Tiki weighs in on possible Giants trade targets, and the crew debates whether the Dolphins' perfect season will ever be matched.
Aaron Glenn is running out of excuses as the Jets continue to waste winnable games! Evan Roberts puts the blame squarely on the head coach, while Tiki Barber explains why Glenn's defensive play-calling responsibilities may be hurting his ability to make critical in-game decisions. With just one interception in 25 games under Glenn, Evan starts looking toward potential replacements, including Mike Tomlin, and debates whether even a late-season winning streak could save Glenn's job. Meanwhile, the Giants could have a massive decision to make before the trade deadline. Would Evan and Tiki surrender a second- and third-round pick for Jonathan Taylor? Both are willing to pay the price, but the Colts might demand even more. Plus, Shaun Morash revisits 13 years of Giants misery in Philadelphia, reliving heartbreaking collapses, the infamous Evan Engram drop, and the devastating Victor Cruz injury that started the losing streak.
Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down Jonathan Taylor’s cryptic comments regarding trade rumors and revisit a heated August debate about the New York Jets' season outlook. They discuss the New York Giants' quarterback situation and the emergence of Joe Milton before diving into a clash with New Jersey Devils fans. The crew also shares their picks for the Jaguars-Ravens matchup while Evan rants about the theatrical release of the new Godzilla film.(00:01:53) Jonathan Taylor Trade Rumors(00:06:00) Giants Quarterback Room Analysis(00:09:14) Evan's Jets Prediction Flashback(00:15:16) Sports Update(00:21:02) Jets Coaching Failure Debate(00:28:53) J.J. McCarthy's Future Development(00:35:00) Godzilla Minus One Controversy(00:41:17) Thursday Night Football Picks
The Giants haven't won in Philadelphia in 13 years, and Shaun Morash is reopening some painful wounds! From Evan Engram's devastating drop and the humiliating playoff blowout to Victor Cruz's heartbreaking injury that started the streak, Shaun counts down the five most memorable Giants losses in Philly. Can the Giants finally end their nightmare against the Eagles this Sunday? Meanwhile, Evan Roberts is already building his dream list of Jets coaching candidates, and Mike Tomlin sits near the top. Evan explains why proven winners must be the priority and why he's completely ruling out first-time defensive head coaches. Tiki Barber weighs in as the conversation turns to potential second-chance candidates like Kliff Kingsbury, Matt Nagy, and Doug Pederson, along with the rising offensive minds who could eventually enter the conversation.
The Giants want Jonathan Taylor, but are they willing to pay the massive price Indianapolis is demanding? With the Colts reportedly seeking a Christian McCaffrey-type trade package, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree they'd surrender a second- and third-round pick to bring the star running back to New York. But with the Vikings also in the mix and Indianapolis willing to keep Taylor, could the Giants miss their opportunity to land a game-changing weapon?
Aaron Glenn is under fire as the Jets continue to find ways to lose close games! Evan Roberts isn't buying the excuses, arguing that Glenn deserves blame for the team's failures, while Tiki Barber explains how Glenn's focus on calling the defense may be preventing him from making critical in-game adjustments. With just one interception in 25 games under Glenn, the Jets' defensive struggles have reached an almost unbelievable level. Could a five-game winning streak to close the season actually save his job?
Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets is hanging by a thread, but Evan Roberts believes there's still one unlikely path to saving his job. With the Jets sitting at 2-6, Evan lays out the exact formula Glenn needs to survive: beat the bad teams, split with the contenders, and finish 8-9. Tiki Barber offers an even more dramatic scenario involving four straight wins, while Shaun Morash questions whether Glenn deserves any benefit of the doubt. Is there anything this coach can do to change the narrative? Evan also predicts the Jets could give the Chiefs or Bills a serious scare, only for Glenn's coaching decisions to cost them another winnable game. The debate gets heated as Evan and Shaun revisit their disagreement over the Jets' preseason expectations, and the crew considers whether meaningful progress is even possible under Glenn.
The Giants are favored against the Eagles in Philadelphia, but their fans still can't shake years of painful losses. Evan Roberts fires back at the fear surrounding the matchup, arguing that the Giants' miserable history against their rivals means nothing under John Harbaugh. With Joe Milton in the spotlight, is it finally time for Giants fans to stop living in the past?
The 1972 Miami Dolphins might hold the one NFL record nobody will ever touch, and Evan Roberts can't stand how they celebrate it. Evan blasts the Dolphins for throwing a party whenever the last undefeated team loses, while Tiki Barber weighs in on why a perfect season has become nearly impossible. With more games, greater parity, and coaches prioritizing playoff health, is another undefeated NFL season officially out of reach?
Braelon Allen to the Giants sparks a heated trade debate! Evan Roberts refuses to entertain a lowball offer for the Jets' breakout running back, but Shaun Morash catches him off guard with a surprisingly reasonable proposal. Would the Giants really give up a future third-round pick for Allen? Evan explains why the Jets need to keep their offensive weapons intact for their eventual franchise quarterback, even with the trade deadline approaching.
Joe Milton might have Giants fans nervous, but John Harbaugh's incredible track record should have Big Blue feeling confident! Evan Roberts uncovers a remarkable statistic: Harbaugh went a perfect 6-0 against quarterbacks making their first NFL start during his time in Baltimore. With Milton preparing for his first start against the Giants, Evan believes the numbers offer plenty of reasons to calm down. Tiki Barber explains why Harbaugh and defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson should be able to confuse and pressure the inexperienced quarterback, while Shaun Morash remains uneasy about Milton's dangerous arm and mobility. Plus, Evan reveals the Giants' surprising history against first-time starters, and Harbaugh's extraordinary success coming off a bye week adds another reason to believe the Giants should take care of business in Philadelphia.
Joe Milton has turned Giants fans' excitement into full-blown anxiety! The Eagles' surprise decision to start Milton against Big Blue has Shaun Morash officially on worry watch, fearing his mobility and rocket arm could be exactly what Philadelphia needs to revive its struggling offense. Tiki Barber admits he's nervous too, but Evan Roberts thinks everyone is overreacting to an unproven quarterback.
The Giants cleared cap space and now big name trades seem in sight, but Tiki is weary. Plus Pat Murphy calls Brian Cashman to apologize
The Giants could be on the verge of a blockbuster trade, and Jonathan Taylor might be the missing piece that takes John Harbaugh's team to another level! Evan Roberts believes the Giants are almost certain to make a significant move before Tuesday's trade deadline, but Tiki Barber isn't convinced they should sacrifice valuable draft picks to go all-in. With the Giants sitting atop the NFC East, is now the time to make a championship push, or are fans getting too carried away? Evan digs into Harbaugh's aggressive trade history in Baltimore and makes the case for dealing draft picks to acquire proven stars. The debate heats up over Taylor's potential price tag, the Giants' uncertain quarterback situation, and whether they're really that far behind the Chicago Bears. Plus, a fascinating Jets-Giants trade proposal involving Breece Hall and Colton Hood sparks another debate about how both New York teams should approach the deadline.
Aaron Glenn hasn't been fired, but Evan is already building his list of potential Jets head coaches! From Mike Tomlin and Sean McDermott to Bill Belichick, Kliff Kingsbury and some truly wild suggestions, Evan and Tiki debate who could rescue the franchise. Should the Jets finally abandon their familiar strategy of hiring first-time defensive coaches and bring in a proven winner? Meanwhile, the Giants have taken control of a winnable NFC East, and Evan believes missing the playoffs now would be a massive disappointment. Could a blockbuster trade for Jonathan Taylor put them over the top, or would the asking price be too steep? Plus, Evan unloads on Sean Marks and the Nets' never-ending rebuild, blasts the ridiculous panic surrounding the Knicks, and admits Craig Carton's outdoor fire-building challenge might be his worst nightmare!
Could Jacob deGrom actually return to the Mets? With reports that the Rangers are willing to trade their expensive veterans, Evan dreams of bringing deGrom back to Queens for one final run. Tiki and Shaun aren't buying it, questioning whether the aging pitcher is really the answer. Evan insists it's about winning, not nostalgia, but Tiki calls him out for wanting an emotional reunion. Plus, could Corey Seager be a fit for the Yankees? Meanwhile, the Giants are favored in Philadelphia for the first time since 2009, and Shaun Morash is fired up! But with a commanding NFC East lead, Evan digs into the Giants' painful division collapses of 2006 and 2012. Could history repeat itself? The debate also turns to potential Giants trades, Garrett Wilson entering concussion protocol, and the Jets' expanding coaching search, including the wild possibility of Russell Wilson getting an interview.
Evan and Shaun discuss Pat Murphy’s apology to Brian Cashman following the Brewers' World Series victory. They also evaluate the New York Jets' potential draft strategies and speculate on the New York Giants' pursuit of Jonathan Taylor. Additionally, they explore a unique simulation experience at George W. Bush’s presidential library.(00:01:50) Pat Murphy's Apology(00:05:15) Presidential Decision Pods(00:08:55) Jets Draft Strategy(00:14:55) NBA Trade Rumors(00:20:05) Station Fire Challenge(00:25:20) Giants Odds Surge(00:28:55) Jets Roster Analysis(00:35:10) Jonathan Taylor Speculation(00:40:30) NFL Injury Update
The Giants are favored in Philadelphia for the first time since 2009, and Shaun Morash is absolutely fired up! In a special Cinco de Luncho, Shaun takes a hilarious trip back to the last time Big Blue entered Philly as the favorite, a game that ended in a humiliating 40-17 loss. But with the Giants now holding a commanding NFC East lead, Evan Roberts uncovers some troubling history. Could the Giants be headed for another division collapse like 2006 or 2012?
Could Russell Wilson actually become the next Jets head coach? With reports linking the former Giants quarterback to the NC State coaching job, Evan Roberts floats the wild possibility of Wilson interviewing for the Jets. Tiki Barber weighs in on whether Wilson could make the transition to coaching, while the crew imagines the chaos of his introductory press conference. Plus, the Jets' coaching search continues to grow with some surprising veteran names.
Could Jacob deGrom really return to the Mets? With the Texas Rangers reportedly ready to unload expensive veterans, Evan Roberts sees an opportunity to bring one of his favorite Mets back to Queens. But Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash aren't convinced, questioning whether a 39-year-old deGrom is worth the gamble. Evan argues that a one-year deal makes perfect sense for a Mets rotation desperate for help, while Tiki pushes back and suggests Clay Holmes would be the smarter investment.
Evan Roberts absolutely unloads on ESPN for declaring the Knicks' season chaotic after just seven games! Despite being a proud Knicks hater, Evan calls out the ridiculous headline and argues that the defending champions are nowhere near a crisis. Meanwhile, a Jets coaching search could be looming, and Evan and Tiki explore David Shaw as an unexpected candidate while debating who should lead the hiring process.
Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets looks bleak in Evan's eyes, and he's already building a massive list of potential replacements! From Mike Tomlin and Sean McDermott to Bill Belichick, Kliff Kingsbury and even Nick Saban, Evan and Tiki debate which veteran coaches deserve consideration. Has the time finally come for the Jets to abandon their failed coaching formula and hire someone with a proven track record?
Craig Carton has challenged the WFAN shows to an outdoor fire-building competition, and Evan makes a stunning admission: he's absolutely terrified of fire! While Evan plans to stay safely in the car, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash are confident they can crush Carton's team. Plus, Evan announces an ambitious plan to transform his body with 100 pushups a day, and Tiki isn't exactly convinced. Meanwhile, the Giants have a golden opportunity to win the NFC East, and Evan believes missing the playoffs now would be a massive disappointment. Tiki breaks down the challenge of stopping a healthier-looking Saquon Barkley against the Eagles, while the guys debate whether the Giants have already made the in-season move that saved their season.
Are Giants fans getting too carried away with their trade deadline dreams? Tiki Barber delivers a reality check, warning that the Giants aren't ready to mortgage their future for a championship push. Evan Roberts pushes back, arguing that John Harbaugh's team has a golden opportunity to win the NFC East and that the Giants might be closer to the Chicago Bears than Tiki wants to admit.
John Harbaugh has a history of making moves, and the Giants could be next in line for a blockbuster! Evan Roberts digs into Harbaugh's 18 seasons in Baltimore, revealing 14 in-season trades that could offer a major clue about his plans for the Giants. But Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash question how many of those deals actually made a significant impact.
The Giants are gearing up for a potentially massive trade deadline, and Evan Roberts is convinced Jonathan Taylor could be headed to New York! With John Harbaugh aggressively pursuing roster upgrades and the Giants sitting two games up in the NFC East, Evan believes a blockbuster move is coming. But Tiki Barber pumps the brakes, questioning whether the Giants are truly one superstar away from becoming a championship contender.
Evan breaks down his ideal scenario for the Mets bullpen!
John Harbaugh doesn't deny big name hunting at the trade deadline. We play MLB Free Agency Bingo, Evan defends the NBA on Election Day, and much more
The Giants have a golden opportunity to win the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes they can't afford to stand pat at the trade deadline! John Harbaugh has made it clear he's looking to upgrade the roster, but his preference for long-term pieces creates a fascinating dilemma. Evan argues that improving the Giants' playoff chances is worth the investment, while Tiki Barber questions whether a major addition could disrupt the chemistry this team has built. Could Tony Pollard be the answer at running back? What about a blockbuster deal for Breece Hall that could leave the Jets with serious regrets? Evan and Tiki debate the realistic cost of acquiring a running back, explore the possibility of reuniting Derrick Henry with Harbaugh, and explain why timing is everything with crucial games against the Eagles and Commanders approaching. With the division within reach, the pressure is on the Giants to make the right move.
The Jets' season is already a lost cause, and 51% of fans in Evan Roberts' poll are rooting for the team to tank! Evan refuses to root against his own team, while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Jets fans can actually stomach more losses on Sundays. With the Colts and Cowboys also holding the keys to the Jets' draft position, the stakes are getting even bigger. Plus, could Mike Tomlin expose the real reason top coaches might want nothing to do with Woody Johnson and the Jets? Evan also passionately defends Mike McCarthy as one of the NFL's most disrespected coaches, sparking a heated disagreement with Tiki over how McCarthy stacks up against Tomlin, Sean Payton and John Harbaugh. The guys tackle the Cowboys' struggles, Ben Johnson's success with the Bears, and the Knicks extending their dominance over the Nets. Plus, Evan and Shaun clash over the NBA shutting down for Election Day while the NHL keeps playing.
Evan Roberts is calling his shot: Tarik Skubal is coming to the Mets! Shaun Morash agrees, but Tiki Barber believes the Dodgers will keep baseball's best pitcher. With an MLB lockout looming, the crew plays Free Agent Bingo, predicting where the biggest names will land, including Jazz Chisholm, David Bednar, Gleyber Torres, Michael King and more. Plus, Evan questions whether Japanese slugger Sato actually fits the Yankees and explains why Luis Arraez makes more sense in the Bronx. Meanwhile, Giants playoff expectations are soaring! The crew predicts potential postseason matchups, including a Giants-Bears showdown, while Shaun dreams up the NFL's next great rivalries. Plus, the Jets' coaching search raises serious questions about Woody Johnson's hiring history, and Election Day sparks a heated debate over whether sports leagues should take the night off.
Evan and Tiki consider Doug Pederson for the Jets head coaching vacancy while reacting to Jerry Jones' comments on coaching structure. They also dive into trade rumors involving Geno Smith and Garrett Wilson, the impact of election day on sports viewership, and the Giants' future under JJ McCarthy. (00:01:50) Doug Pederson To Jets? (00:05:41) Jerry Jones Coaching Opinions (00:13:38) Justin Herbert Performance Issues (00:16:58) Election Day Viewing Habits (00:21:06) Ravens Blockbuster Trade Proposals (00:27:27) Westchester Voting Machine Problems (00:31:19) Japanese Baseball Free Agency (00:38:49) Giants Quarterback Depth Debate
The Giants are suddenly thinking division titles and playoff wins! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are buying into Big Blue's postseason chances, with predictions of potential matchups against the Bears, Packers and even Cowboys. Shaun Morash takes things further with his Cinco de Luncho, predicting the NFL's next great playoff rivalries, including a wild Jets-Raiders showdown. Has the Giants' turnaround completely changed expectations for the season? Plus, Election Day sparks a heated argument as Evan blasts the NHL for scheduling games while the NBA takes the night off. Evan also vents about problems with his ballot in Westchester County. Meanwhile, Woody Johnson's history of hiring inexperienced head coaches comes under scrutiny, raising questions about the Jets' next coaching search. And a new report casts doubt on Evan's prediction that the Mets will land Japanese slugger Sato, as the looming MLB lockout threatens to complicate free agency.
Are Yankees fans already forgetting what went wrong? Evan Roberts questions why fans are suddenly desperate for Japanese slugger Sato when they've spent years complaining about home runs, strikeouts and poor defense. Shaun Morash wants more offense at any cost, but Evan argues Luis Arraez would be a much better fit. The debate gets even hotter over Brian Cashman's plans for Giancarlo Stanton and whether the Yankees can afford to count on him next season.
Tarik Skubal to the Mets! Evan Roberts makes his boldest free agency prediction, declaring that Steve Cohen will outbid the competition to bring baseball's best pitcher to Queens. Shaun Morash agrees, but Tiki Barber isn't buying it, predicting Skubal stays with the Dodgers. With an MLB lockout looming, the pressure is on for teams to make their biggest moves before everything shuts down.
Could Mike Tomlin deliver the harsh truth Woody Johnson desperately needs to hear about the Jets? Evan Roberts wants the Jets owner to sit down with Tomlin after the season, even if the respected coach has no interest in taking the job. With Tiki Barber doubting Tomlin would ever come to New York, Evan argues that Woody needs someone willing to tell him exactly what's wrong with his franchise, even if the biggest problem is Woody himself!
Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash get into a heated battle over sports shutting down for Election Day! Evan praises the NBA for taking the night off and blasts the NHL for continuing to play games, while Shaun argues that fans shouldn't have to give up their sports. The disagreement gets increasingly heated as Evan questions why hockey can't take one night off for something more important. Plus, the Knicks have now beaten the Nets 15 consecutive times, and Evan is fed up after watching Brooklyn blow another opportunity at Madison Square Garden. He also fires back at fears that the Nets could eventually leave Brooklyn, explaining why the franchise isn't going anywhere. And a special Election Day edition of Posted and Toasted uncovers an old Jets tweet that perfectly predicted the Aaron Glenn disaster.
The Jets are 2-6, their playoff hopes are fading, and more than half of the fans in Evan Roberts' poll want the team to keep losing! Evan refuses to embrace tanking, while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Jets fans can actually root against their own team once Sunday arrives. With the Colts and Cowboys both tied to the Jets' draft future, Evan reveals exactly who he's rooting for when those two teams face off.
Could Derrick Henry reunite with John Harbaugh on the Giants? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the possibility of landing the Ravens' star running back, whether Baltimore would even consider trading him, and how much elite football he has left at 32 years old. With questions surrounding Lamar Jackson's future this season, could the Ravens actually become sellers? Plus, the Giants face a tough reality in the running back trade market. Evan examines past deadline deals involving Christian McCaffrey and Jay Ajayi to reveal what it actually costs to acquire a difference-maker. With Jonathan Taylor, Tony Pollard, and other big names potentially available, is there a deal worth making, or are the Giants chasing an opportunity that simply isn't realistic?
Could Breece Hall end up with the Giants and leave the Jets looking foolish? Evan Roberts reluctantly admits that trading Hall across town makes plenty of sense for the Giants, and Tiki Barber would love to see his favorite running back in blue. But there's a major problem: the Jets have little incentive to make the deal unless they're blown away by an offer. Evan explains why the asking price could make a blockbuster trade nearly impossible.
The Giants have a golden opportunity to win the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes they need to get aggressive before the trade deadline! John Harbaugh has made it clear the Giants are open for business, but his reluctance to sacrifice draft picks for a short-term rental raises a major question. Should the Giants prioritize the future or do everything possible to capitalize on their chance to host a playoff game? Evan makes the case for trading for Tony Pollard, even with his expiring contract, while Tiki Barber worries about disrupting the chemistry of a running back room that's finally finding its rhythm. With critical matchups against the Eagles and Commanders approaching, the clock is ticking. Can the Giants make a meaningful upgrade before their biggest games of the season, or will the trade deadline pass without a deal?
WFAN delivers the top fallout and debate after New York dropped to 2-6 with coverage from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. Evan and Tiki debate if firing Aaron Glenn right now actually accomplishes anything, explore Garrett Wilson trade speculation ahead of the deadline, and montage Glenn’s repetitive "disappointed" postgame press conferences. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
New York Mets are in need of at least one starting pitcher. Is free agency the place for David Stearns to find the Ace of the staff? Visit TheRicoB.com for everything Rico Brogna Podcast P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
The Jets lose to the Raiders in yet another example of the Jets being the Jets, even Minka Fitzpatrick thinks so. The Giants get a BYE week only dreams are made of.
The Jets have hit another embarrassing low, and Evan Roberts has seen enough! A humiliating 38-33 loss to the Raiders leaves New York at 2-6, with Aaron Glenn facing mounting criticism and a season spiraling out of control. Evan unloads on the coaching staff, the defensive collapse, the disastrous special teams and a franchise that continues finding new ways to lose. Tiki Barber questions the red-zone failures and lack of execution, while both agree the Jets are wasting a roster capable of much more. Is Aaron Glenn already a dead man walking, and would firing him now accomplish anything? Evan exposes Glenn's painfully repetitive postgame press conferences, Tiki weighs in on the Raiders' improving culture, and the guys debate the Cowboys' latest collapse and what it means for the Giants. Plus, Tiki celebrates finishing the New York City Marathon while Evan suffers through another miserable Sunday at MetLife Stadium.
Minkah Fitzpatrick says "Jets being Jets," and Evan Roberts isn't buying the team's attempt to explain it away! Evan and Tiki Barber rip the Jets' embarrassing PR response and question why this team keeps making the same costly mistakes. From Aaron Glenn's questionable late-game decisions to disastrous red-zone execution, the frustration keeps mounting. Is coaching the biggest difference between the struggling Jets and the first-place Giants? And could all this losing permanently damage the Jets' culture? Meanwhile, the Giants have a golden opportunity to take control of the NFC East, but John Harbaugh is making headlines for another reason. His reported attempt to go directly to the Titans' owner about Jeffrey Simmons has upset some NFL executives. Could a major Giants trade be coming?
The Jets have found another brutal way to lose, and patience with Aaron Glenn is running out! Joe Benigno demands Glenn be fired immediately after another crushing defeat, but Evan Roberts questions whether making a coaching change now would actually accomplish anything. Evan and Tiki Barber break down the disastrous defense, costly penalties, red-zone failures, and baffling decision to abandon Braylon Allen in the second half. Is Glenn already among the worst coaches in Jets history, and who could possibly save this franchise? Plus, a wild trade idea has the Giants dreaming of Derrick Henry reuniting with John Harbaugh! Could Lamar Jackson's potentially season-ending injury make the Ravens willing to deal their star running back? The guys also react to the Cowboys' stunning collapse against Arizona, the Chiefs losing again, Minnesota's first defeat, and Tampa Bay winning without completing a single pass.
Evan and Tiki review the news of Bill Belichick's breakup with Jordon Hudson and discuss his future as a potential candidate for the Jets. They examine the Knicks' historical success after playing the Nets and debate the fatigue comments made by Josh Hart. The discussion concludes with picks for the Monday Night Football matchup between the Seahawks and Bears.(00:01:20) Belichick Relationship Breakup News(00:05:22) Belichick Jets Coaching Potential(00:10:15) Dedication Of Sports Fans(00:15:20) Knicks Nets Statistical Trends(00:20:20) Woody Johnson Management Critique(00:27:00) Searching For New Leadership(00:32:02) Monday Night Football Picks(00:36:00) Trading Picks For Coaches
Could Derrick Henry be the Giants' next blockbuster addition? A caller floats the stunning possibility of Henry reuniting with John Harbaugh, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber love the idea! With Lamar Jackson potentially done for the season and the Ravens struggling, could Baltimore actually consider moving its star running back? The guys examine what a trade might cost, Henry's contract, and whether Cam Skattebo's recent improvement changes the Giants' plans.
The Dallas Cowboys pull off an unbelievable collapse, blowing a 14-point fourth-quarter lead as Gardner Minshew and the Arizona Cardinals storm back for a stunning overtime victory! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Dallas' historic meltdown, Mike Tomlin's brutal assessment of the Cowboys, and a wild NFL Sunday filled with surprises.
Joe Benigno has officially had enough of Aaron Glenn! After another infuriating Jets loss, Joe unloads on the head coach, blasts the defense, and demands Woody Johnson make a change immediately. With the Jets continuing to waste winnable games through costly penalties, red-zone failures, and disastrous coaching decisions, Joe believes Glenn is already among the worst coaches in franchise history. His solution? Find the next Bill Parcells, and do whatever it takes to convince Mike Tomlin to save the Jets.
John Harbaugh is making enemies around the NFL, but the Giants might not care! After reportedly going directly to Titans owner Amy Adams in an attempt to acquire Jeffrey Simmons, Harbaugh is facing backlash from executives who believe he violated an unwritten rule. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the controversy actually matters and what it reveals about the Giants' aggressive approach. With the trade deadline approaching, Evan predicts the Giants could make a significant move to strengthen their roster.
The Giants are taking control of the NFC East, and Shaun Morash is tired of everyone treating their first-place standing like a joke! With the Cowboys blowing a two-score lead and the Eagles falling to Washington, the Giants suddenly have a golden opportunity to run away with the division. But with Philadelphia and Washington up next, could two wins effectively put the division race to bed?
Minkah Fitzpatrick says "Jets being Jets," and Evan Roberts is furious that the organization tried to spin his words! Evan and Tiki Barber blast the Jets' embarrassing PR response and question whether Fitzpatrick's brutal assessment exposes a much bigger problem. If even the team's veteran leaders recognize the dysfunction, why can't they do anything to fix it?
The Jets have become so dysfunctional that fans are begging the NFL to intervene, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Woody Johnson's struggling franchise isn't getting rescued. With Aaron Glenn's future looking increasingly hopeless, Evan declares that the Jets will have a different head coach next season. But who can actually fix this mess? The guys debate potential replacements, the importance of hiring an experienced coach and whether Johnson can finally make the right decision.
Aaron Glenn keeps saying the same thing after every Jets loss, and Evan Roberts is sick of hearing it! After another embarrassing defeat, Evan plays a collection of Glenn's painfully repetitive postgame press conferences and questions whether the head coach has any answers left. With the Jets sitting at 2-6, frustrated fans are demanding Glenn be fired immediately, but Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether replacing him with Frank Reich would actually accomplish anything.
The Jets have found another humiliating way to lose, and Evan Roberts is absolutely furious! Despite scoring on their first six possessions and out gaining the Raiders by more than 100 yards, the Jets fall 38-33 in another embarrassing display of dysfunction. Evan blasts Aaron Glenn and a coaching staff that continues to waste a talented roster, pointing to defensive failures, costly penalties and a disastrous special teams breakdown.
Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans update you on some blockbuster trades that went down this week in the NFL - including Jeffrey Simmons solidifying the Bears as a legitimate Super Bowl threats. They also talk about what other teams are in their "Super Bowl Window." Next, Stink brings up Jared Goff's name in the MVP conversation and previews a possible "battle of the frauds" game happening this weekend. They end the podcast with #QuestionMark.
Is it time for the Jets to consider trading Garrett Wilson?? Evan Roberts says absolutely not, while Craig Carton says it has to at least be considered. Plus, Boomer and Gio bemoan Gang Green seemingly falling into the same old story as many previous years, as the conversation has become centered on the future of the head coach and how long it will take to turn things around. The Evan and Tiki crew also react to Wink Martindale blasting Woody Johnson and the Jets.
Craig Carton says the Giants are in the driver's seat to win the NFC East, and it's time to solidify that position by taking a big swing at the trade deadline to try and "steal a title." Boomer and Gio debate the looming trade deadline, and if Jonathan Taylor would be worth investing in. Evan and Tiki get into the trade deadline debate as well, while Evan declares that Big Blue needs just five wins in the next 10 games to lock up the division.
Boomer and Mike breakdown the crazy NFL trades and project which may happen. They pick all the games in the NFL, and ask which of the current playoff teams can actually win the Super Bowl on a loaded Week 8 episode of Kickoff
Bo Bichette has elected to opt in to his contract with the Mets. Let's take a look to see if it's worth it for the Mets to be spending 42 million dollars on an average third baseman. Visit TheRicoB.com for everything Rico Brogna Podcast P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
The Jets get set for yet another must win, but should they be more open to options at the trade deadline. A Football Friday with all the fix ins is here
Evan Roberts is drawing a hard line: trading Garrett Wilson would be a massive mistake for the Jets, even if the return includes multiple first-round picks. Shaun Morash pushes back, warning that Wilson's frustration with losing could eventually force the Jets into a trade when they have far less leverage. Tiki Barber argues that New York needs more weapons, not fewer, especially with a rookie quarterback potentially on the way. Why gamble on draft picks when the Jets already have a proven star? The heated debate exposes a bigger problem with the Jets: coaching, not talent. Evan and Tiki insist the organization must finally get its coaching situation right instead of continuing to strip away valuable players. Plus, the Jets prepare to face the Raiders, Evan fears Fernando Mendoza could make an unexpected appearance, and an apparent sound effect during Amazon's NFL broadcast has Evan furious.
Jalen Brunson is Philadelphia’s Athlete of the Year, and the reaction is priceless! Evan and Tiki rip the Philadelphia sportswriters for honoring the Knicks superstar who helped embarrass the Sixers, questioning whether Philly has completely lost its pride. Does Brunson’s Villanova connection really justify this stunning decision? Plus, Boomer Esiason floats a surprising Giants trade target: Raiders running back Ashton Jeanty. Evan loves the potential upside of adding a former sixth overall pick, but Tiki strongly disagrees, arguing Jeanty isn't a significant upgrade over Cam Skattebo. Would the Giants be wasting valuable draft capital or buying low on a future star? The debate heats up as Evan defends his proposal against accusations that he's trolling Giants fans. The guys also revisit why the Jets must keep Garrett Wilson, the dangers of stripping weapons away from a young quarterback, and the latest injury concerns surrounding Breece Hall.
Ashton Jeanty's comments about Jets defenders not wanting to tackle have Evan fired up, especially after the defensive coordinator's uninspiring response! Evan rips the lack of intensity and demands that the Jets use the criticism as motivation against the Raiders. Tiki explains the power of bulletin-board material, while concerns grow over David Bailey's injury and Aaron Glenn's future. Could an unlikely late-season surge actually save Glenn's job? Meanwhile, Evan predicts the Giants will add a running back before the trade deadline despite Cam Skattebo's emergence. Tiki weighs in on the cost of acquiring Ashton Jeanty and whether the Giants need more competition. Plus, Bo Bichette's $42 million decision to remain with the Mets sparks a debate about his value, Bad Tiki makes a wild Halloween return, and Shaun Morash delivers his five worst things about Halloween!
Evan Roberts revisits a $100 bet he placed in February for the New York Giants to win the NFC, expressing frustration that the odds remain at 40-1 despite the team sitting in first place. Sean Morash provides a comprehensive rooting guide for fans during the bye week, while Tiki Barber prepares for his eighth New York City Marathon. The crew also makes their weekly NFL picks, including a unanimous selection for the Jets over the Raiders. (00:01:50) NFL Cleat Issues (00:04:20) Giants Rooting Guide (00:11:45) Tiki's Marathon Prep (00:16:20) NBA Cup Importance (00:23:50) Evan's Longshot Bet (00:34:25) Idiots With Idioms (00:37:45) NFL Betting Picks
Could Aaron Glenn actually save his job with the Jets? A frustrated caller fears Woody Johnson will bring Glenn back regardless of how the season ends, but Evan argues that a surprising late-season turnaround could completely change the conversation. Tiki weighs in on whether Glenn can still prove himself as a head coach, while serious questions emerge about Frank Reich's ability to develop the Jets' next young quarterback. Plus, Shaun Morash delivers his five worst things about Halloween, taking aim at candy corn, silly string, smashed pumpkins, and kids who refuse to say trick or treat! Evan and Tiki weigh in on Shaun's complaints before a hilarious disagreement erupts over his Friday Cinco tradition.
Bad Tiki is back after nearly a year, and nobody at WFAN is safe! The outrageous AI character makes a Halloween return with relentless shots at Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, Shaun Morash, and the brand-new studio. From mocking the Mets and David Stearns to delivering an absolutely ridiculous Halloween costume reveal, Bad Tiki picks up right where he left off.
Ashton Jeanty says some Jets defenders don't want to tackle, and Evan is stunned by the team's response! After hearing the defensive coordinator's lackluster comments, Evan questions whether the Jets have the leadership needed to fire up their defense. Tiki explains how powerful bulletin-board material can be and why Sunday's matchup with the Raiders is a chance for the Jets to prove their toughness. If they fail to respond, Evan believes it will only strengthen the argument that coaching is the team's biggest problem.
Cam Skattebo has won over Giants fans, but Evan isn't convinced he's done enough to stop the team from upgrading at running back! Evan argues that Ashton Jeanty still offers greater upside and predicts the Giants will trade for another back before the deadline. Tiki pushes back on surrendering valuable draft picks and explains why bringing in competition could actually motivate Skattebo. Plus, Bo Bichette is staying with the Mets after exercising his $42 million option, but is that really good news? Evan and Tiki explain why the expensive short-term commitment makes sense despite Bichette's disappointing season. The guys also react to the Jets' latest injury report, including concerns about David Bailey's availability against the Raiders.
The Giants trading for Ashton Jeanty might sound crazy, but Evan Roberts is all in! After Boomer Esiason floats the surprising idea of acquiring the Raiders’ former sixth overall pick, Evan argues the Giants could buy low on a potential star. Tiki Barber isn't buying it, insisting Jeanty hasn't proven he's a significant upgrade over Cam Skattebo and questioning why the Giants should sacrifice valuable draft capital for another unproven running back. The debate intensifies as Evan pushes back against accusations that he's trolling Giants fans, while Tiki warns that adding Jeanty could disrupt the running back room without actually improving it. Would a third-round pick be worth the gamble? Plus, the guys revisit the Jets' coaching concerns surrounding Aaron Glenn and discuss injury updates involving Breece Hall and David Bailey.
Jalen Brunson is Philadelphia’s Athlete of the Year, and Evan Roberts is absolutely disgusted! The Philadelphia Sports Writers Association has decided to honor the Knicks superstar despite his role in ending the Sixers’ season and humiliating their fans. Evan calls the decision embarrassing and questions whether Philadelphia has any sports pride left, while Tiki Barber explores whether Brunson’s Villanova roots make the selection defensible. Has Brunson officially become the king of Philadelphia, too?
Evan Roberts is furious with Amazon Prime after hearing what he believes was a fake sound effect during a missed extra point in the Packers-Panthers game. Evan insists the broadcast added an unnecessary crashing sound to the kick, calling it embarrassing and questioning why an NFL game needs cartoonish sound effects. Tiki Barber isn't nearly as bothered, sparking a hilarious debate over whether Evan is making too much of it.
Evan Roberts is fed up with Jets fans dreaming about first-round picks instead of appreciating Garrett Wilson. Evan and Tiki Barber argue that trading a proven star would be a massive gamble, especially when the Jets are preparing to develop their next franchise quarterback. Tiki points to how the Bengals surrounded Joe Burrow with weapons, while Evan insists the Jets already have enough draft capital and need to stop creating more holes on their roster. The debate intensifies as Shaun Morash continues warning that Wilson could eventually want out, but Evan calls out the contradiction between worrying about losing players and rooting for the Jets to tank. Plus, Tiki insists coaching is the Jets' biggest problem, Evan fears Fernando Mendoza could haunt the Jets against the Raiders, and Tiki gets some unexpected support for his upcoming New York City Marathon.
Evan Roberts refuses to budge on Garrett Wilson, but Shaun Morash believes the Jets are making a massive mistake by keeping their star receiver. Shaun warns that Wilson's growing frustration with losing could eventually force his way out, leaving the Jets with far less trade leverage. With multiple first-round picks potentially on the table, is now the time to cash in before it's too late?
Pat Murphy is a World Series Champ but a mic catches him take a shot at Yankee culture, Joe Beningo stops by In Studio, Connor Hughes talks Trade Deadline, and much more
Pat Murphy takes a shot at the Yankees after leading the Brewers to a World Series championship, and New York fans are furious! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dissect Murphy's viral exchange with former Yankee Jake Bauers and debate whether his comments expose a much bigger problem in the Bronx. Has the Yankees' reputation for big spending, selfish play, and a lack of accountability become impossible to ignore? Tiki questions Aaron Boone's ability to hold his stars accountable, while Evan argues that Milwaukee's winning formula isn't so easy to replicate with a roster full of highly paid players. Plus, Evan rips the Brewers' surprisingly subdued championship celebration, and the blockbuster Jeffery Simmons trade to the Bears raises questions about whether the Giants should have gotten involved. The crew also makes its early 2027 World Series predictions, while Milwaukee's stunning championship has Evan reconsidering what's possible for the Giants.
Joe Benigno storms into the WFAN studio and unloads on David Stearns, declaring he'll never forgive the Mets executive for letting Pete Alonso walk. Even with Milwaukee celebrating a championship, Joe has zero confidence in the Mets' direction, questions Juan Soto's impact, and makes his feelings clear about what the team needs this offseason. The conversation turns explosive when the Jets come up. Joe is running out of patience with the coaching staff, Evan refuses to entertain trading Garrett Wilson, and the possibility of a quarterback change looms if the losing continues. Plus, Garrett Wilson addresses speculation about wanting out of New York and reveals just how much the constant losing hurts. The guys also celebrate the Knicks' championship, praise Mike Brown's accountability, examine the Yankees' handling of Anthony Volpe, and debate whether the Giants should make a move at the trade deadline.
Ashton Jeanty just gave the Jets the ultimate bulletin-board material! The Raiders running back claims some Jets defenders don't want to tackle, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Aaron Glenn must use those comments to fire up his team. With Glenn's future increasingly uncertain, Connor Hughes joins the show to reveal just how much trouble the Jets head coach could be in, why Garrett Wilson isn't likely to be traded, and why bringing back Rex Ryan would be a massive mistake. Across town, the first-place Giants are exploring potential trade deadline upgrades. Hughes reveals their interest in Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard, but questions whether they're legitimate Super Bowl contenders. Plus, Evan weighs in on David Stearns' role in the Brewers' success, the Knicks pull off another massive comeback, and Shaun Morash delivers his five most memorable Halloween moments in New York sports history.
Evan and Tiki analyze whether the New York Mets should gamble on an eight-year, $320 million contract for Tarik Skubal despite his injury history. They also discuss the New York Jets' quarterback future involving Cade Klubnik and engage in a heated debate about the merits of living in New York versus Florida.(00:01:50) NFC East Division Race(00:03:15) Tarik Skubal Mets Rumors(00:08:40) Yankees Roster Construction(00:13:28) Cade Klubnik Draft Discussion(00:22:30) New York Vs Florida(00:31:54) NFL Trade Deadline Moves(00:40:40) Historic Sports Droughts(00:43:35) Packers Vs Panthers Preview
The Mets need a legitimate ace, and Evan Roberts is ready to take a massive risk! Evan makes the case for giving Tarik Skubal an eight-year, $320 million contract despite his injury history. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh in on whether the Mets should go all-in on one of baseball's best pitchers. Plus, the Yankees face their own offseason decisions, including protecting young talent and potentially pursuing Japanese slugger Sato. Meanwhile, Tiki boldly picks the Giants to win the NFC East, as the crew debates whether New York can hold off the Cowboys. Evan also considers trading multiple Jets first-round picks for Justin Herbert, but is the price too steep? Plus, the WNBA's scheduling problems and a hilarious Halloween parenting debate!
Derek Jeter's unforgettable Mr. November home run, the Mets' heartbreaking World Series collapse, and the night Mike White stunned the Bengals! Shaun Morash delivers his five most memorable Halloween moments in New York sports history, sparking plenty of nostalgia and painful memories for Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber. From the Jets beating the Giants in a rare Halloween showdown between Boomer Esiason and Phil Simms to Alex Rodriguez's historic reviewed home run in the 2009 World Series, the countdown is packed with unforgettable moments. Evan relives the agony of the Mets' 2015 World Series loss, while Shaun reveals why Halloween 2001 stands above them all, featuring Jeter's iconic Yankees moment, Jason Kidd's Nets debut, and Michael Jordan's return to Madison Square Garden.
Ashton Jeanty just called out the Jets defense, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Aaron Glenn better make his players pay attention! The Raiders running back claims some Jets defenders don't want to tackle, sparking a heated conversation about effort, toughness, and accountability. Tiki examines the potential culprits, while Evan argues that failing to respond with their best defensive performance of the season would be another damning indictment of Glenn's leadership.
Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets is looking increasingly bleak, and Connor Hughes delivers a troubling outlook for the head coach. Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to explain why Glenn could be coaching for his job, how the Jets' repeated game-management failures are costing them victories, and why bringing back Rex Ryan would be a terrible idea. Plus, could Garrett Wilson eventually demand a trade if the losing continues? Across town, the Giants are eyeing a potential trade deadline splash. Hughes reveals their interest in Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard, but warns against sacrificing too much draft capital for a team that may not be a legitimate Super Bowl contender. The conversation also explores how the rest of the NFL views the Giants, the importance of their quarterback play, and why Will McDonald could be the Jets' biggest name to watch at the trade deadline.
Garrett Wilson is shutting down the trade speculation, but his frustration with the Jets' constant losing is impossible to ignore! Evan Roberts blasts the New York media for fueling rumors that Wilson wants out, arguing that Jets fans overwhelmingly want their star receiver to stay. After Wilson declares his love for New York while admitting the losses hurt more every week, Evan and Tiki debate how much longer his patience can last.
Joe Benigno has had enough of the Jets' dysfunction! With another disappointing season unfolding, Joe blasts the coaching staff, questions Geno Smith's reluctance to take chances, and warns that a loss to the Raiders could push his frustration over the edge. Could a coaching change be coming, and when should the Jets turn to Cade Klubnik? The debate heats up over Garrett Wilson as Joe admits he's considered trading the star receiver for a massive draft haul, while Evan argues the Jets can't afford to strip weapons away from their next quarterback. Plus, Joe celebrates the Knicks' championship, praises Mike Brown's willingness to hold players accountable, and weighs in on the Mets' missed opportunity with Pat Murphy.
Joe Benigno is back in the WFAN studio, and he's absolutely furious with David Stearns! Joe declares he'll never forgive the Mets executive for letting Pete Alonso walk, predicts Alonso could reach the Hall of Fame as an Oriole, and questions whether Stearns deserves any credit for Milwaukee's championship success. But Joe isn't stopping there. He calls out Juan Soto for failing to carry the Mets when they need him most, blasts the team's disastrous replacement for Alonso at first base, and explains why he has zero confidence in the organization's direction. Plus, Evan and Tiki explore the possibility of adding Tarik Skubal to the rotation, the upcoming free-agent frenzy, and the looming MLB lockout.
The Yankees are getting mocked by World Series champions, and the criticism of their culture is getting harder to ignore! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber revisit Pat Murphy's viral comments and debate whether Aaron Boone's unwillingness to hold his highly paid stars accountable is holding the franchise back. Evan also questions why Hal Steinbrenner's desire to win should mean anything when Brian Cashman continues running a team that repeatedly falls short. Meanwhile, Milwaukee's championship has Evan wondering whether the Giants could pull off their own miracle Super Bowl run, even if Tiki insists he's been preaching that possibility for months! Plus, the crew makes its way-too-early 2027 World Series predictions, debates a potentially shortened baseball season, and examines what the Brewers' success says about building a championship team.
The Brewers are World Series champions for the first time, but Evan Roberts is furious with how they celebrated! Where was the massive dogpile, the emotion, and the pure chaos that should come with winning a championship? Evan and Tiki Barber react to Milwaukee's surprisingly subdued celebration before debating whether Pat Murphy's demanding managerial style could ever work with the Yankees and their highly paid stars. Is Aaron Boone's lack of accountability part of the problem? Plus, a blockbuster NFL trade sends Jeffrey Simmons from the Titans to the Bears for a massive haul of draft picks! Should the Giants have gotten involved, or is the price simply too steep for a team still building toward contention?
Pat Murphy takes a shot at the Yankees moments after the Brewers win the World Series, and his viral comments have New York fans fired up! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what Murphy actually meant when he suggested Yankees players only care about themselves. Is Milwaukee's championship-winning manager exposing a harsh truth about the Yankees' culture, or simply taking an easy shot at a big-spending franchise that hasn't delivered?
That's right. Is there someone who can fill in for Brett Baty and his super utility role?
The Giants may be active at the trade deadline after listening to Joe Schoen, The Jets own the Colts pick, The Knicks win, and much more
The Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, and the NFL trade deadline presents a massive opportunity. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how aggressive Joe Schoen should be with limited draft capital and a legitimate chance to win the division. Could Tony Pollard provide the boost the Giants need after Tyrone Tracy's injury, or would Jonathan Taylor be worth a blockbuster move? Plus, J.J. McCarthy's impressive Giants debut raises a fascinating question: Have the Giants already made the best move of the deadline? Meanwhile, Evan fires back at the idea of trading Garrett Wilson, arguing the Jets would be creating another unnecessary hole instead of building toward the future. The Colts' fire sale boosts New York's draft hopes, while the possibility of a J.J. McCarthy trade to the Jets sparks another quarterback debate. Plus, the never-ending Rex Ryan reunion conversation, concerns about the Jets' coaching, and the Knicks finally getting their first win of the season.
Jorge Posada says he doesn't feel welcome around the Yankees, and Shaun Morash is putting Brian Cashman on blast! With CC Sabathia questioning the absence of former players and Derek Jeter's complicated history with Cashman, Shaun believes the Yankees have lost the championship culture that once made them special. Evan Roberts pushes back, arguing Posada's bitterness over how his career ended could explain the tension, while Tiki Barber explains why keeping franchise legends involved matters. Meanwhile, the Jets face massive decisions ahead of the NFL trade deadline. Would dealing Garrett Wilson or Breece Hall be a disastrous mistake for their next young quarterback? The debate turns to Matt LaFleur as a potential head coaching candidate and why the Jets might struggle to attract him. Plus, Jaxson Dart's bye-week concert outing sparks a hilarious return to Shaun's infamous Zach Wilson apple-picking controversy, and Evan defends his obsessive World Series scorekeeping.
Wink Martindale unloads on the Jets, questioning Aaron Glenn's ability to handle defensive play-calling and head coaching duties while taking a direct shot at Woody Johnson for not paying for a defensive coordinator. Shaun Morash sees Martindale's comments as validation of his earlier reporting, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Glenn is simply overwhelmed or the Jets have a much bigger coaching problem. Tiki also breaks down the disastrous goal-line sequence against Miami and explains how one small formation mistake can cost an NFL team a game. Plus, could J.J. McCarthy actually threaten Jaxson Dart's future as the Giants' starting quarterback? Tiki defends Kayvon Thibodeaux's impact, and the crew debates whether the Giants should pursue Jonathan Taylor. There's also a wild Justin Herbert-to-the-Jets trade scenario, a heated Jorge Posada and Brian Cashman debate that exposes Shaun's old Yankees tweets, and questions about David Stearns' legacy in Milwaukee.
Evan and Tiki discuss the intense accountability culture Jim Harbaugh brings to the Giants and wonder if the Jets should target Sean McDermott to fix their organization. They examine the historical rarity of 3-0 comebacks in the World Series and debate the merits of trading Garrett Wilson. The conversation also covers the recent string of major NBA injuries and the aesthetic changes to the WFAN studio.(00:01:50) Harbaugh's Leadership Tactic(00:06:00) New York Hockey Rivalries(00:09:10) Sean McDermott Jets Fit(00:15:15) Trading William Contreras(00:20:30) Station Internal Debates(00:27:45) Trading Garrett Wilson(00:34:45) Mike Tomlin's Next Move(00:38:15) WFAN Studio Feedback(00:42:15) College Quarterback Prospects(00:46:15) NBA Injury Wave
Could Justin Herbert actually become the Jets' next franchise quarterback? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explore a potential blockbuster trade, the massive draft capital New York could offer, and whether Jim Harbaugh might ever consider moving on from his star quarterback. Evan admits he'd be interested despite Herbert's flaws, but questions whether the Chargers would ever make him available. Plus, Shaun Morash gets confronted with his own brutal old tweets about Jorge Posada while defending the former Yankees catcher amid his criticism of Brian Cashman. A caller floats a wild conspiracy theory involving Darren Mougey deliberately pushing Garrett Wilson toward a trade request, prompting Evan to explain why Wilson's loyalty to the Brooklyn Nets makes him unlikely to quit on the Jets. The crew also debates whether Milwaukee's success has any bearing on David Stearns' Mets tenure.
Wink Martindale takes aim at the Jets, blasting Aaron Glenn for trying to handle defensive play-calling and head coaching duties while suggesting Woody Johnson refused to pay for a legitimate defensive coordinator. Shaun Morash sees Martindale's comments as vindication of his earlier reporting, but Evan Roberts questions whether the former Giants defensive coordinator is telling the whole story. Tiki Barber argues that Glenn's defense has largely performed well, but his struggles managing critical game situations are becoming impossible to ignore. Plus, Tiki breaks down the Jets' disastrous goal-line sequence against Miami, revealing how a subtle formation mistake involving Mason Taylor helped destroy a golden touchdown opportunity. The crew also examines whether Glenn is getting enough game management support and reacts to a concerning groin injury for Jets defender David Bailey.
Could J.J. McCarthy actually steal Jaxson Dart's job as the Giants' starting quarterback? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what it would take for McCarthy to force a legitimate quarterback competition in 2027, with a Super Bowl victory emerging as the ultimate measuring stick. Even a deep playoff run might not be enough if McCarthy isn't the driving force behind it. Plus, Tiki pushes back against Giants fans frustrated with Kayvon Thibodeaux, explaining why his impact goes far beyond sacks and missed opportunities. The conversation also turns to the Giants' running backs, Cam Skattebo's response to John Harbaugh's challenge, and whether New York should consider giving up a second-round pick for Jonathan Taylor.
Jorge Posada says he doesn't feel welcome around the Yankees, and Shaun Morash is putting Brian Cashman squarely in the crosshairs! With CC Sabathia questioning why former players aren't around and Derek Jeter's complicated relationship with Cashman, Shaun believes the Yankees have lost the championship culture that once made them special. Could shutting out their legends be contributing to their repeated October failures? Evan Roberts pushes back, arguing that Posada's frustration may stem from how his playing career ended and Cashman's notoriously blunt handling of aging stars. Tiki Barber explains why having franchise legends around can be invaluable, even when their philosophies differ from modern coaching. Is it time for Cashman to repair these relationships? Plus, Evan discovers he and Alex Rodriguez share one hilarious obsession: they have no life outside of baseball!
Trading Garrett Wilson or Breece Hall could be a disastrous decision for the Jets, and Evan Roberts wants no part of it! With the NFL trade deadline approaching, Evan argues that stripping away offensive weapons would only set up the team's next young quarterback for failure. Instead of tearing apart the roster, the Jets need better coaching and a real plan to develop their future franchise quarterback. Meanwhile, Evan celebrates a thrilling 12-inning World Series game and shows off his obsessive scorekeeping skills. A classic Bill Burr comedy routine sparks a hilarious on-air blunder when Evan repeatedly calls the comedian Aaron Burr, sending callers into a frenzy. Plus, Shaun Morash explains why he chose sleep over extra-inning baseball, and Evan reveals why he's afraid to coach his son's Little League team.
Jaxson Dart spends the Giants' bye week at a concert while J.J. McCarthy stays focused on football, reigniting Shaun Morash's infamous criticism of Zach Wilson's apple-picking getaway! Shaun demands vindication for ripping Wilson years ago, but Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that quarterbacks can't take time away. Evan Roberts explains why he has far more confidence in McCarthy's situation than he ever did in Wilson's. Meanwhile, the NFL trade deadline has transformed into a frenzy, with contenders aggressively making moves to win now. Could Matt LaFleur be the perfect next head coach for the Jets? Evan loves the idea but fears the franchise's reputation, along with LaFleur's family connections, could make the job an impossible sell. Plus, a caller blasts Evan over his Giants and Knicks comments, and Evan proudly unveils his latest World Series scorekeeping masterpiece.
Could J.J. McCarthy actually end up quarterbacking the Jets? A caller proposes a blockbuster trade with the Giants, sparking a fascinating debate between Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber. Even if McCarthy leads the Giants to the playoffs, Evan argues they shouldn't rush to trade him with Jaxson Dart's injury history still a concern. Tiki weighs in on what it would take for McCarthy to succeed with the Jets, including the possibility of a coaching change. Plus, could Kayvon Thibodeaux be a more realistic trade candidate? Meanwhile, the debate over Garrett Wilson's future continues, with Evan pushing back against trading away proven young talent. The Knicks finally get their first win behind a strong defensive performance, while the Nets suffer a heartbreaking overtime loss. And Jaxson Dart's belief that he could return for the playoffs raises another intriguing quarterback question for the Giants.
The Jets have already stockpiled draft picks, so why would they even consider trading Garrett Wilson? Evan Roberts argues that moving their star receiver would be a massive mistake, especially when the team should be building around its young talent instead of creating more holes. Tiki Barber weighs in on the Jets' rebuilding strategy, the possibility of landing Jeremiah Smith in the draft, and why better coaching could unlock Wilson's potential. Plus, Evan unloads on Frank Reich's disastrous performance as offensive coordinator. Meanwhile, the Giants' trade deadline debate continues as Evan makes a passionate case for acquiring Tony Pollard, even if it impacts Cam Skattebo's development. And could Rex Ryan actually return to coach the Jets? Evan explains why Woody Johnson deserves blame for keeping that conversation alive.
The Giants are in first place in the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes it's time to get aggressive at the NFL trade deadline! But with limited draft capital, Tiki Barber questions how much Joe Schoen should sacrifice to improve the roster. Could Tony Pollard be the perfect addition following Tyrone Tracy's injury, or should the Giants pursue a bigger name like Jonathan Taylor? The debate heats up over balancing a potential playoff run with the franchise's long-term future.
From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans talk about the road to redemption that J.J. McCarthy is on as he leads the Giants to an overtime win in his first start. Then, they breakdown Seattles win against KC on Sunday night and how JSN is emerging as the NFL's top receiver. Finally, Stink has a response for...Mike Tomlin?
The Giants are in the driver's seat in the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes the division is theirs to lose! After watching the Cowboys beat the Eagles, Evan is more convinced than ever that John Harbaugh gives the Giants a significant coaching advantage over Brian Schottenheimer. With just five wins needed over their final ten games, Evan and Tiki Barber map out the path to a division title and explain why Dallas' explosive offense might not be enough to catch Big Blue. But can the Giants survive their mounting injuries? Evan and Tiki debate whether the team should make a major move at the trade deadline, with DeForest Buckner and Jeffery Simmons emerging as intriguing defensive targets. Plus, could J.J. McCarthy's success eventually create a quarterback controversy with Jaxson Dart? Tiki pushes back on looking too far ahead while the Giants are winning, and the guys examine the Eagles' stunning collapse and what it means for the NFC East race.
They evaluate the New York Giants' path to winning the NFC East after key divisional shifts and look ahead to potential moves at the trade deadline. The conversation also dives deep into the New York Jets' coaching crisis and the impact of the Quenton Nelson trade. Additionally, they discuss the early struggles of the Knicks and Nets along with predictions for the World Series.(00:01:50) Giants Division Race(00:15:00) Sports Update(00:23:55) College Playoff Outlook(00:30:45) NFL Trade Rumors(00:43:45) Sports Equinox Recap(00:49:15) Evan's Tiny Office(01:01:40) World Series Analysis(01:07:15) Jets Coach Search(01:16:00) Posted And Toasted(01:23:15) Halloween Costume Ideas(01:28:54) Joe Benigno Interview(01:44:15) Mike Tomlin Interest(01:57:15) Cinco De Luncho(02:02:10) Quenton Nelson Trade(02:09:50) Joe Schoen Discussion(02:21:30) Super Bowl Halftime(02:38:15) Knicks Pistons Preview(02:46:15) MLB Trade Candidates(02:58:15) Tomlin Coaching Future
The Jets are already facing another potential coaching search, and Evan Roberts has a list of candidates to replace Aaron Glenn! From Mike Tomlin and Jon Gruden to Kliff Kingsbury and Rex Ryan, Evan and Tiki debate who could finally turn this franchise around. Could Woody Johnson actually bring Rex back? Evan explains why it wouldn't shock him, while Tiki breaks down the biggest problem with Glenn's leadership. Plus, the Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, and fans are dreaming about invading Philadelphia for a showdown with the Eagles. The Rangers' goaltending struggles spark frustration, the Brewers' World Series dominance exposes Tampa Bay's embarrassing fan support, and Evan predicts a wild November of MLB free agency before a potential lockout. Shaun Morash joins the fun as the crew revisits some outrageous old social media posts in another edition of Posted and Toasted.
Joe Benigno has had enough of Aaron Glenn! After another brutal Jets loss to the Dolphins, Joe unloads on the coaching staff and demands Glenn be fired if the Jets lose to the Raiders. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Jets are wasting a talented roster, why Frank Reich deserves blame, and whether Mike Tomlin, Rex Ryan, or Brian Flores could rescue the franchise. Plus, could Fernando Mendoza make his NFL debut against the Jets? A blockbuster NFL trade sends Quenton Nelson from the Colts to the Seahawks, potentially delivering the Jets an enormous draft pick as Indianapolis begins selling off talent. Meanwhile, the Giants are suddenly facing championship-level expectations in the NFC East, and Evan wonders how much credit Joe Schoen deserves for their turnaround. Plus, Joe explains why Knicks fans shouldn't panic over an 0-3 start, and Shaun Morash reveals five classic Halloween candies that desperately need a comeback.
Evan and Tiki react to the news of Jay-Z performing at the Super Bowl halftime show and look back at their previous artist predictions. They discuss potential roster moves for the Giants involving DeForest Buckner and address the Jets' coaching search featuring Mike Tomlin. The conversation shifts to the winless starts for the Knicks and Nets and the Jets' inability to record interceptions. (00:02:10) Super Bowl Halftime Reaction (00:05:50) NFL Roster Shake Ups (00:14:20) Jets Head Coaching Search (00:21:20) NBA New York Struggles (00:26:45) NFL Officiating Frustrations (00:30:00) MLB Postseason Trade Targets (00:38:55) Jets Interception Drought Analysis
The Giants are in first place, but Evan Roberts questions whether Joe Schoen is still calling the shots! With John Harbaugh seemingly controlling the franchise, Evan wonders how much power the general manager actually has heading into the NFL trade deadline. Tiki Barber pushes back, arguing Schoen deserves major credit for building a winning roster. Meanwhile, expectations have skyrocketed, and Evan believes anything short of an NFC East title would now be a major disappointment. On the Jets side, the search for Aaron Glenn's potential replacement heats up as callers push for an established head coach. Brian Flores, Mike Tomlin, and Jon Gruden enter the conversation, along with a wild possibility of trading for Justin Herbert. Evan admits Herbert is overrated but insists he'd still be interested in bringing the talented quarterback to New York.
The Jets could be the biggest winners of a blockbuster NFL trade! The Colts send All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson to the defending champion Seahawks, and Evan Roberts immediately sees massive implications for New York. With the Jets owning Indianapolis' first-round pick from the Sauce Gardner trade, could the Colts' potential fire sale deliver a top-three selection? Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether Jonathan Taylor could be next and what Seattle's aggressive move means for its Super Bowl hopes. Meanwhile, Kirk Cousins is set to start against the Jets, but Evan predicts Fernando Mendoza could make his NFL debut if the Raiders struggle. The guys debate whether the Jets' defense is actually good enough to stop him, before Shaun Morash sparks a heated Halloween candy debate with his five classic treats that deserve a comeback.
Joe Benigno is officially fed up with Aaron Glenn! After the Jets' disastrous loss to the Dolphins, Joe rips the coaching staff, blasts Frank Reich's offensive failures, and demands Glenn be fired if the Jets lose to the Raiders. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question how a team with so much talent continues to lose, whether Glenn is losing the locker room, and why Garrett Wilson remains an afterthought in the offense. Joe lays out his dream replacements, including Mike Tomlin, Rex Ryan, Brian Flores, and Sean McDermott, while debating whether the Jets should eventually give Cade Klubnik a chance over Geno Smith. Plus, Joe refuses to panic over the Knicks' 0-3 start, explaining why last season's championship has earned the team a free pass, much to the amusement of the Nets-loving Evan.
The Rays are getting embarrassed on and off the field! With the Brewers dominating the World Series and Milwaukee fans taking over Tampa Bay, Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash rip the Rays' fan base for failing to show up when it matters most. Is there any excuse for opposing fans taking over your ballpark during the World Series? Plus, Evan warns that baseball could be headed for a chaotic offseason, predicting a frenzy of free-agent signings involving the Yankees, Mets and the rest of MLB before a potential December lockout brings everything to a halt. The crew also has some fun with another edition of Posted and Toasted, revisiting outrageous old tweets, Evan's hatred of the Adam Gase hiring, and some hilarious Halloween memories.
The Jets are already looking toward another coaching change, and Evan Roberts has a wish list of candidates to replace Aaron Glenn! Mike Tomlin, Jon Gruden and Kliff Kingsbury are among the names being considered, but could Rex Ryan actually return to New York? Evan explains why Woody Johnson might seriously consider bringing Rex back, while Tiki Barber breaks down Glenn's struggles managing the responsibilities of an NFL head coach.
The Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes winning the division is a realistic goal! With John Harbaugh leading the charge, Evan and Tiki Barber break down the standings, the path to a division title, and why Giants fans should seriously consider making the trip to Philadelphia. But could a struggling Eagles team actually make its fans even more hostile toward visiting Giants supporters? Plus, the Rangers' goaltending problems have fans demanding a trade, but Shaun Morash isn't ready to panic. The crew also looks back at the Sports Equinox, including Shaun's costly betting adventure, before debating whether sports fans would actually be happier without the constant heartbreak of rooting for their teams.
The Giants are legitimate NFC East contenders, but will John Harbaugh make a major move before the NFL trade deadline? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Big Blue should go big-game hunting for defensive help, with Jeffery Simmons and DeForest Buckner emerging as intriguing possibilities. Evan predicts the Giants could land Buckner from the Colts, while Tiki questions whether adding a big name is worth disrupting a team that's finally finding its rhythm. Plus, could J.J. McCarthy's success create an unexpected quarterback controversy with Jaxson Dart? Evan believes the conversation could become very real if McCarthy keeps winning, but Tiki blasts the idea of worrying about next season while the Giants are sitting in first place. The guys also discuss the Jets' bleak future, mounting Giants injuries, and Evan's annual controversy over celebrating the Mets' 1986 World Series championship.
The Eagles are collapsing, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Philadelphia's fans have already checked out! After another ugly loss to the Cowboys, the Eagles have dropped five straight games, their quarterback situation is uncertain, and Saquon Barkley's injuries are becoming a major concern. With the Giants coming to Philadelphia after their bye week, Evan and Tiki explain why this is no longer the Eagles team that once terrified the NFC East.
The Giants are going to win the NFC East! Evan Roberts is more confident than ever after watching the Cowboys beat the Eagles, and he believes John Harbaugh gives Big Blue a massive coaching advantage over Brian Schottenheimer. Despite Dallas having more offensive firepower with Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and George Pickens, Evan argues that the Giants are simply the better-coached team.
WFAN presents the best reactions to the Giants' 27-21 overtime win against the Texans from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. Boomer and Gio look at J.J. McCarthy's near-flawless debut under center, Evan and Tiki discuss whether Big Blue should bring in kicking competition for Dominic Zvada over the bye, and Craig Carton takes his verbal lashing after guaranteeing a Giants blowout loss. That and more on Best Of Giants on WFAN!
WFAN presents a collection of reactions to the Jets' disastrous 28-25 loss to the winless Miami Dolphins from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. Evan Roberts vents his sheer depression and jealousy over watching competent coaching across town, while Boomer and Gio question Aaron Glenn's clock management and Bill Parcells' endorsement of him. Plus, Craig Carton demands accountability for Frank Reich freezing out Garrett Wilson. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The New York Mets and David Stearns have a lot to do during the offseason. Free agency may be the key to success. Is Tarik Skubal target number 1 on free agency? Visit TheRicoB.com for everything Rico Brogna Podcast P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
The Jets are finished, Aaron Glenn has failed, and Evan Roberts has officially had enough! After another humiliating loss to the winless Dolphins, Evan unloads on the same coaching mistakes that continue to destroy the Jets' season. Meanwhile, the Giants pull off a stunning overtime upset of the Texans, leaving Evan jealous of what John Harbaugh has built. Evan and Tiki Barber compare the two coaches, rip Glenn's disastrous clock management, and debate whether Woody Johnson can attract a proven replacement like Mike Tomlin, Sean McDermott, or Jon Gruden. The Giants' victory also sparks major excitement over J.J. McCarthy, who delivers a nearly flawless performance in his first start and potentially creates a future quarterback controversy with Jaxson Dart. Tiki breaks down Cam Skattebo's resurgence, the Giants' dominant rushing attack, and a controversial penalty. Plus, the Jets' valuable draft picks, possible changes in Las Vegas, the NFL's last unbeaten team, and the Knicks' early-season struggles round out a wild Monday in New York sports.
The Jets are cooked, Aaron Glenn looks completely overwhelmed, and Evan Roberts has officially had enough! After another embarrassing loss to the Dolphins, Evan unloads on Glenn's disastrous coaching decisions and declares the season over before Halloween. Meanwhile, Tiki Barber is celebrating a stunning Giants upset over the Texans, exposing the massive coaching gap between Glenn and John Harbaugh. Are the Jets wasting a talented roster, and could Woody Johnson's reputation prevent them from landing a proven winner like Mike Tomlin? Plus, Tiki breaks down J.J. McCarthy's impressive Giants debut, why Harbaugh made the right quarterback decision over Jameis Winston, and how Cam Skattebo and the Giants defense responded to being challenged. Evan admits he's jealous of Giants fans as their season takes off while the Jets spiral toward another lost year.
The Jets are unraveling, and Evan Roberts has had enough of Aaron Glenn. After another brutal loss to the Dolphins, Evan and Tiki Barber rip the Jets' defensive failures, Glenn's baffling timeout management, and Frank Reich's disastrous red-zone play calling. Plus, was Garrett Wilson really screaming at Geno Smith, or was his frustration directed at the coaching staff? Evan explains why he's ready to consider Sean McDermott or Jon Gruden as the Jets' next head coach. Meanwhile, the Giants have a quarterback controversy brewing! J.J. McCarthy's impressive performance has Evan and Tiki wondering whether Jaxson Dart could actually lose his starting job. They praise John Harbaugh's coaching impact, the Giants' suddenly dominant rushing attack, and the emergence of Deonte Banks. But rookie kicker Dominic Zvada's struggles raise serious concerns. Plus, the Knicks' championship hangover continues, and Evan revisits his bold Fernando Mendoza prediction.
Aaron Glenn's disastrous coaching continues to sink the Jets, and Evan Roberts has seen enough. After another embarrassing loss to the Dolphins, Evan believes Glenn has proven he's not the long-term answer. But firing him midseason would accomplish absolutely nothing unless the Jets could immediately land a legitimate replacement. Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether Sean McDermott, Jon Gruden, or Mike Tomlin could rescue the franchise, why Frank Reich isn't the solution, and whether Woody Johnson can possibly justify bringing Glenn back for another season. Meanwhile, the Giants are celebrating a stunning upset of the Texans that has vaulted them into the NFC East favorite conversation. Tiki praises J.J. McCarthy's composure, the Giants' coaching, and their resilience while blasting the controversial penalty on Cam Skattebo. Plus, the Raiders consider a quarterback change, the Chiefs and 49ers suffer their first losses, the Vikings remain unbeaten, and the Jets' growing collection of valuable draft picks offers one reason for optimism.
Evan and Tiki explore the depths of Jets' desperation, with Evan acknowledging he'd now welcome Bill Belichick or John Gruden to lead the team. They also debate Nikola Jokic’s stance on booing fans and review the Giants' victory over the Texans.(00:01:50) Jokic vs Booing Fans(00:05:15) Giants Draft History Debate(00:11:12) Jets Eye Bill Belichick(00:15:40) MetLife Stadium Locker Rooms(00:18:45) NFL Playoff Tiebreakers(00:22:15) DeMario Davis Defends Jets(00:25:50) Mike Tomlin Winning Pedigree(00:32:10) Virtual Measurement Tech Debate
Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs are no longer undefeated after a stunning loss to the Seahawks! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber go around the NFL to break down Kansas City's offensive struggles, the 49ers suffering their first loss to the Falcons, and the Vikings becoming the league's last unbeaten team behind Kyler Murray. Plus, the Raiders are considering a quarterback change, potentially setting up Fernando Mendoza's NFL debut against the struggling Jets. Meanwhile, Evan finds another reason to root against the Cowboys as the Jets' collection of first-round draft picks becomes increasingly valuable. With Indianapolis, Dallas, and New York all potentially delivering premium selections, the Jets could have a massive opportunity to reshape their future. Plus, Tiki praises Brian Flores' defensive brilliance, the Giants continue celebrating their upset of Houston, and a hilarious debate breaks out over Evan's exhausting sports doubleheader with his son.
The Giants just pulled off a stunning upset of the Houston Texans, and suddenly they're the favorites to win the NFC East! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down how the Giants overcame being double-digit underdogs, why John Harbaugh deserves enormous credit, and how J.J. McCarthy delivered a remarkably composed performance against a dangerous Texans defense. With the Giants showing toughness and resilience, is this the victory that makes the rest of the NFL take them seriously?
Aaron Glenn has lost Evan Roberts' confidence, but firing him in the middle of the season won't solve the Jets' problems. After another embarrassing loss to the Dolphins, Evan unloads on Glenn's repeated coaching mistakes, disastrous game management, and inability to get the most out of his roster. Despite believing Glenn isn't the long-term answer, Evan argues that replacing him with Frank Reich would be a pointless move.
The Giants have a kicking problem, and Dominic Zvada's struggles are becoming impossible to ignore! After another rough performance, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the rookie kicker's confidence is shattered and if John Harbaugh needs to bring in competition. Tiki explains why Zvada may be overthinking his kicks, while Evan suggests bringing back Ben Sauls as insurance before the Giants' next game. Plus, Evan revisits his bold August prediction that Fernando Mendoza would make his first NFL start against the Jets in Week 8, and suddenly it looks like he might be right! The guys also debate whether J.J. McCarthy can truly challenge Jaxson Dart, praise linebacker Arvell Reese's relentless hustle, and explain why the Giants keep winning on the margins while the Jets continue to lose.
The Jets' coaching nightmare keeps getting worse, and Evan Roberts is ready for a major change! After another brutal loss to Miami, Evan and Tiki Barber break down Garrett Wilson's heated sideline outburst and why his frustration may have been directed at the coaching staff rather than Geno Smith. Frank Reich's disastrous goal-line play calling comes under fire, while Geno's comments about taking a costly sack leave Evan stunned.
Aaron Glenn is running out of excuses! Evan Roberts blasts the Jets' embarrassing defensive performance against Miami, including an eight-minute drive where Glenn refused to use his timeouts and a late-game collapse that denied the offense one final chance. Tiki Barber agrees the coaching has to improve, while Evan questions whether Glenn is actually getting worse after 24 games as a head coach. Meanwhile, the Giants have a fascinating quarterback dilemma brewing. After J.J. McCarthy's impressive performance, could Jaxson Dart actually lose his starting job? Evan and Tiki debate why a potential quarterback controversy could be a great problem for the Giants. Plus, Tiki breaks down the suddenly explosive rushing attack, praises Greg Roman's simplified offense, and explains how John Harbaugh's coaching staff has transformed the Giants' depth and helped Deonte Banks revive his career.
J.J. McCarthy delivers a nearly flawless performance in his first Giants start, and Tiki Barber admits he was wrong to question John Harbaugh's quarterback decision! After the Giants' stunning overtime victory over the Texans, Tiki breaks down McCarthy's impressive accuracy, poise under pressure, and ability to avoid costly mistakes. With Jameis Winston thriving in a specialized short-yardage role, Evan Roberts and Tiki agree the Giants' quarterback controversy is officially over.
Aaron Glenn's coaching failures have Jets fans reaching their breaking point! After an embarrassing loss to the previously winless Dolphins, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber rip Glenn's inexplicable decision to leave all three timeouts unused before halftime. Tiki argues the Jets have plenty of talent, but their inability to execute the little things continues to cost them games. Even Geno Smith's mistakes aren't enough to distract from the real problem: coaching.
Aaron Glenn is finished, the Jets' season is already over, and Evan Roberts has completely lost faith in his football team! After another miserable performance against the Dolphins, Evan unleashes his frustration over Glenn's horrific coaching decisions and declares the Jets cooked before Halloween. The breaking point? Glenn's baffling failure to use his timeouts before halftime, especially when compared to John Harbaugh's brilliant game management in the Giants' stunning upset over the Texans. Meanwhile, Tiki Barber celebrates a Giants team that continues to respond to adversity, with Cam Skattebo and the defense stepping up after being publicly challenged. Evan admits he's jealous of Giants fans and argues the Jets have just as much talent but nowhere near the coaching. With Woody Johnson's reputation looming over the franchise, Evan wonders whether a proven winner like Mike Tomlin would even consider taking the Jets job.
The Yankees held their postmortem press conference this week, and our hosts had some STRONG thoughts on what was said. Chris McMonigle sounds off on Hal Steinbrenner putting the blame solely on the players and not having a word of criticism for Brian Cashman and/or Aaron Boone. Plus, Evan and Tiki agree that the owner did not do a good job conveying a mindset of accountability and looking at making any meaningful change this offseason. Gregg Giannotti took aim at the Yankee fans who were furious with the press conference and the season as a whole, wondering how they get any enjoyment out of fandom.
J.J. McCarthy has been named the starting quarterback against the Texans, and Craig Carton RIPS the "panicky, ridiculously stupid" move by John Harbaugh to make a QB change while in first place. Plus, Tiki Barber questions if McCarthy is being put in a position to succeed given Houston's defense and his newness to the offense, while Boomer Esiason is not surprised that the switch was made at this time.
Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti: A TNF Thriller, is this the end of the Rams? Picks and preview for all of the Week 7 games, including a potential Super Bowl preview? Where will these big name QB's be next year, and Boomer suggests a Justin Herbert trade that could shake up the NFL!
From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans return to the Audacy Airwaves to first discuss all the implications to the Jalen Hurts situation in Philly. Stink gives his perspective of dealing with both team and independent doctors. Then, they debate whether Green Bay has found their footing after two very impressive wins. They end the podcast with #QuestionMark.
Bradfo catches up with two former Mets turned Rays, Freddy Peralta and Steven Matz to discuss their journeys to the World Series, what has changed since their Mets days, Matz's memories of the Mets World Series run, and more!
Evan Roberts is officially nervous about the Jets, and a matchup with the winless Miami Dolphins suddenly feels like a potential disaster. Despite Miami's ugly record, Evan warns that the Dolphins are better than people think, while the Jets continue to sabotage themselves with costly penalties, red-zone failures, and an offense that can't get Garrett Wilson the football. Tiki Barber weighs in on Frank Reich's struggles and why another sloppy performance could effectively end the Jets' season. Meanwhile, the Giants face a massive test against the Houston Texans as J.J. McCarthy prepares for his first start in blue. Are Giants fans already accepting defeat, or can McCarthy deliver something special? Evan and Tiki debate expectations against C.J. Stroud and a dangerous Houston defense, while Giants defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson turns up the heat by calling out players for unacceptable effort. Plus, Evan blasts the Cavaliers after another stunning collapse and fires back at accusations that he's secretly a Knicks fan.
The Knicks' championship ring celebration has turned into a controversy for all the wrong reasons! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree that assistant coaches receiving their rings late is hardly a scandal. But Madison Square Garden sending employees a fake offer to choose championship rings as a phishing test, when some may not receive rings at all, is a different story. Evan and Tiki blast the stunt as mean-spirited and question how anyone thought it was a good idea. Meanwhile, Tiki studies Giants game film to identify the defenders behind Dennard Wilson's fiery criticism, with Tremaine Edmunds standing out for all the wrong reasons. The debate also turns to the Giants starting J.J. McCarthy over Jameis Winston, whether his mobility can revive the running game, and what the decision means for their chances Sunday. Plus, frustration with the Brooklyn Nets, the Jets' underused screen game, and a surprising World Series pitching decision.
Evan and Tiki preview the Giants and Jets as they get ready for week 7 in the NFL. Can JJ McCarthy be the guy? Will the Jets take care of business against the winless Dolphins? Connor Hellebuyck gets traded to the Devils. Shaun's rooting guide. Idiots with Idioms. Week 7 picks.
Evan and Tiki on the theory that the NFL might be looking to add games on Tuesdays and Wednesdays in the future. Cinco de Luncho-O: safe to say Niko, who's filling in for Shaun, is a big fan of JJ McCarthy.
Evan and Tiki take calls on JJ McCarthy as he gets set to make his first start for the Giants. Shaun's Week 7 rooting guide. Idiots with Idioms. NFL Picks for Week 7.
The Knicks' championship ring controversy takes an ugly turn! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to a stunning report that Madison Square Garden sent employees a fake email promising championship rings, only for it to be a phishing test. With some longtime employees reportedly not receiving rings at all, Evan and Tiki blast the stunt as mean-spirited and downright cruel. But when it comes to assistant coaches waiting for their rings, both agree the outrage is completely overblown.
Who was Giants defensive coordinator Denard Wilson calling out with his explosive "traitorous" comments? Tiki Barber went straight to the game film and has answers! After reviewing the Giants' defensive breakdowns, Tiki identifies Tremaine Edmunds as the biggest offender, pointing to multiple plays where the veteran linebacker failed to hustle to the football. Jihad Ward also makes the list, raising questions about whether his effort contributed to his release.
The Giants are turning to J.J. McCarthy, but Evan Roberts isn't convinced John Harbaugh is making the right move! With Jameis Winston heading to the bench and a difficult matchup looming, Evan questions why the Giants wouldn't wait until after the bye week. Tiki Barber explains how McCarthy's mobility could unlock the struggling running game and why Tyrone Tracy needs to become the featured back.
Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts analyze the New York Giants' offensive line struggles and the potential of trading for star running back Jonathan Taylor. They also break down a Week 7 rooting guide for fans and share their official NFL picks for the upcoming games.(00:01:50) Giants Fan Rooting Guide(00:05:02) Patrick Ricard Potential(00:08:55) Jonathan Taylor Trade Debate(00:14:38) Devils Trade For Hellebuyck(00:17:43) Feeding Garrett Wilson(00:21:31) Kayvon Thibodeaux Accountability(00:30:31) Idiots With Idioms(00:34:33) Week 7 NFL Picks
Giants defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson is furious with his players, calling out defenders who fail to hustle to the football as "traitors" to the defense! After an embarrassing defensive performance against the Saints, Wilson promises a completely different level of effort against the Houston Texans. Tiki Barber loves the accountability and explains exactly what went wrong on Alvin Kamara's touchdown, while Evan Roberts wants to know which Giants players Wilson is targeting.
Evan Roberts has seen enough of the Cleveland Cavaliers! After watching Cleveland blow a 29-point lead to the Philadelphia 76ers, Evan unloads on the team he picked to reach the NBA Finals and considers abandoning his prediction altogether. Meanwhile, a caller accuses Evan of secretly being a Knicks fan, sparking a heated defense of his Brooklyn Nets loyalty. Back on the football field, J.J. McCarthy faces a massive challenge against the Houston Texans, and Tiki Barber explains what the Giants' new starting quarterback must show to inspire confidence. With C.J. Stroud looking dangerous and Will Anderson wreaking havoc, the Giants could be in serious trouble. Plus, Evan's concerns about the Jets continue to grow as their disastrous red-zone offense comes under fire, raising serious questions about Frank Reich's ability to maximize the team's weapons.
Evan Roberts is suddenly terrified of the winless Miami Dolphins, and he believes the Jets could be walking straight into a season-ending disaster. Despite Miami's 0-5 record, Evan points to the brutal competition the Dolphins have faced and warns that the Jets' constant mistakes, costly penalties, and inability to get Garrett Wilson involved could come back to haunt them. Tiki Barber weighs in on whether Aaron Glenn's team can finally stop giving games away, because losing this one could effectively end the Jets' season.
From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Trading for Freddy Peralta and Marcus Semien? Didn't work! Letting Pete Alonso go and signing Jorge Polanco? Failure! So what moves did YOU WANT to happen? And would things have worked out better? Visit TheRicoB.com for everything Rico Brogna Podcast P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
The Giants have made a decision at QB< but won't declare it for the season. Brian Cashman catches heat from Tiki and Morash, and much more.
The Giants are handing the offense to J.J. McCarthy, and John Harbaugh is making a massive gamble with his team sitting in first place! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber originally preferred Jameis Winston, but both see the upside in giving McCarthy a chance. Can his mobility rescue a disastrous Giants running game, or will this quarterback switch threaten their division lead? Shaun Morash explains why he wanted McCarthy all along, while Harbaugh boldly declares the Giants can win more than just the division. Plus, the guys debate whether McCarthy's impressive fourth quarter against the Saints was legitimate or inflated by prevent defense and a disastrous New Orleans offense. They revisit their original predictions for McCarthy's first Giants start, question why Minnesota gave up on him so quickly, and explore whether a change of scenery could unlock the former first-round pick. Evan even sparks a heated Nolan Ryan debate with Tiki over whether certain players need to leave their original teams to become stars.
Breece Hall in a Giants uniform? Evan Roberts hates the thought of the Jets trading away one of their most dynamic weapons, especially as they try to build around a future young quarterback. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash would love to see Hall in blue, with Tiki ranking him ahead of Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard. But would the Giants pay the price? The debate heats up as the crew evaluates potential running back targets ahead of the NFL trade deadline and explains why a Saquon Barkley reunion is almost impossible. Meanwhile, Yankees fans are still furious with Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman, J.J. McCarthy faces serious questions about his readiness to start, and the infamous Roger Clemens-Mike Piazza bat incident reignites some heated Mets-Yankees trash talk. Plus, Evan explains why he's determined to enjoy every moment of the World Series with the possibility of a lengthy baseball shutdown looming.
Brian Cashman is under fire for taking another shot at former Yankees who dare to criticize the organization. His latest comments about players who have won just one championship spark outrage from Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash, who blast the hypocrisy of dismissing CC Sabathia and Anthony Rizzo. Evan Roberts finds Cashman's vindictive streak hilarious, even while acknowledging how insulting the remarks are. Meanwhile, Hal Steinbrenner's criticism of the Yankees offense raises a major question: Will ownership finally authorize a significant offseason upgrade? The guys also debate whether an impending MLB lockout will kill excitement for next season, how the Giants can overcome their defensive struggles against Houston, and whether their quarterback change will join the most memorable in New York football history. Plus, Shaun's controversial quarterback rankings and a heated debate over whether catching a hockey puck is more impressive than snagging a baseball.
Evan and Tiki analyze the New York Jets' recent struggles, focusing on the high impact of their penalties and the lack of team discipline. They also debate which professional sport offers the most difficult path to a championship and discuss the New York Yankees' strategy regarding Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.(00:01:50) Championship Banner Philosophies(00:05:20) Hardest Professional Championships(00:09:14) Breece Hall Injury Update(00:13:20) Quenton Nelson Trade Rumors(00:18:15) Analyzing Jets' Impactful Penalties(00:21:40) Coaching And Discipline Debate(00:27:50) Newsroom Championship Debate(00:30:56) Yankees Roster Strategy(00:36:23) NFL Week 7 Picks
Shaun Morash unveils his five most memorable in-season quarterback changes in New York football history, and his rankings immediately come under fire! From Kurt Warner giving way to Eli Manning to the Jets turning to Chad Pennington and Vinny Testaverde, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the decisions that shaped their franchises. But when Shaun admits he's ignoring quarterback changes from before his lifetime, Evan calls out his hypocrisy over leaving Joe Namath off the list.
The Giants' defense is getting called out in brutal fashion! After another ugly performance, defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson blasts the team's tackling and labels players who refuse to pursue the football as "traitors." Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine the Giants' embarrassing defensive struggles and why switching from Jameis Winston to J.J. McCarthy won't magically solve their problems. With the Texans offense heating up and Marvin Harrison Jr. potentially getting another shot at the Giants, the pressure is mounting.
Brian Cashman is getting ripped for taking another shot at former Yankees who criticize the organization! His latest comments about players who have won only one championship ignite a heated debate over his treatment of CC Sabathia, Anthony Rizzo, and Alex Rodriguez. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash blast Cashman for disrespecting the very players who helped build his championship résumé, while Evan Roberts finds his vindictive streak hilarious despite acknowledging the insult.
The Roger Clemens-Mike Piazza feud erupts all over again! Shaun Morash celebrates the 26th anniversary of Clemens throwing a broken bat toward Piazza, calling the Mets legend a coward for refusing to charge the mound. Evan Roberts fires back, ripping Clemens and explaining why Piazza's reaction still bothers him decades later. The heated Mets-Yankees trash talk escalates when the crew revisits the infamous footage and Tim McCarver's memorable call. Plus, Evan takes issue with Roger Goodell showing up at the Knicks' season opener, sparking a debate about celebrity fans and Mike Tomlin's appearance. The crew also discusses a potential rift between Joe Buck and Troy Aikman before a caller floats the unthinkable: Saquon Barkley returning to the Giants in a trade. Evan explains why an Eagles-Giants deal is virtually impossible.
Breece Hall to the Giants? Evan Roberts is furious at the possibility of the Jets trading away their star running back, especially when they should be building around their next franchise quarterback. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash would love to see Hall in Giants blue, but Evan argues the Jets would be making a massive mistake unless they receive an overwhelming return. With the NFL trade deadline approaching, the debate heats up over which running backs the Giants should pursue. Tiki ranks Hall ahead of Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard, while Shaun makes the case for a cheaper option. Plus, a furious Yankees fan unloads on Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman, sparking another debate about the franchise's championship drought and spending habits.
J.J. McCarthy is getting his shot with the Giants, but could his success become a nightmare for the Minnesota Vikings? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash revisit their original predictions for when McCarthy would make his first start, with Shaun coming closest to getting it right. But the bigger question is whether Minnesota gave up on its former first-round pick too quickly and whether getting traded was exactly the wake-up call McCarthy needed.
The Giants' quarterback controversy is heating up as fans debate whether John Harbaugh made the right call benching Jameis Winston for J.J. McCarthy! Evan Roberts questions how Harbaugh handled the announcement inside the locker room, while Tiki Barber explains why the decision might not be as dramatic as it seems. With the Giants sitting in first place, is Harbaugh making a brilliant proactive move or risking a winning formula?
John Harbaugh is rolling the dice on J.J. McCarthy, and the first-place Giants are putting their division lead on the line! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber originally preferred Jameis Winston, but both admit McCarthy brings an exciting unknown to an offense desperately searching for answers. Can his mobility revive one of the NFL's worst rushing attacks, or is Harbaugh taking an unnecessary risk with a team trying to win now?
We aired Hal Steinbrenner, Brian Cashman, and Aaron Boone's end of year press conferences. React to Knicks banner night, and the Giants reportedly name a new starting quarterback.
The Knicks raised their championship banner, received their rings, and then immediately lost their season opener to the 76ers. But Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber aren't sounding the alarm. Evan, a proud Knicks hater, admits the loss didn't even bring him joy because the celebration was so much bigger than the game. With OG Anunoby, Mikal Bridges, and Karl-Anthony Towns struggling, the question becomes how long Knicks fans can ride the championship high before another loss actually starts to hurt. The emotional ceremony also leads Evan to a heartbreaking realization about Joe Namath and the Jets' fading connection to their last Super Bowl championship. Plus, Tiki explains why the Knicks may have been emotionally drained, the guys debate when a championship hangover becomes a legitimate concern, and Josh Hart's brutally sarcastic comments about the Knicks' 0-1 start raise questions about the urgency needed to defend their title.
Hal Steinbrenner is pointing the finger at the Yankees' offense after another disappointing October, but Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone aren't taking the fall. Steinbrenner makes it clear that the players deserve most of the blame for the team's postseason collapse, while confirming Cashman's extension and defending his decision to stick with Boone. With another championship opportunity wasted, is Yankees ownership holding the right people accountable? Evan and Tiki break down the biggest takeaways from Steinbrenner and Cashman's press conference, including Aaron Judge's health, Giancarlo Stanton's uncertain role, and the organization's plans for 2027. Plus, Boone faces tough questions about the Yankees' inability to beat elite postseason opponents, pushes back against Anthony Rizzo's criticism, and admits he still hasn't proven himself at the highest level.
Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman face the media, and their answers leave plenty for Yankees fans to be furious about. Steinbrenner puts the blame on the players while defending Cashman and Aaron Boone, but Evan Roberts isn't buying the excuses. From Hal's response to Aaron Judge's demand to go all in to Cashman's bizarre claim that Giancarlo Stanton finished the season healthy, Evan and Tiki Barber dissect a frustrating day for the Yankees. Evan also unloads on Boone's disastrous postseason lineup decision and questions why nobody in the organization is being held accountable. Meanwhile, the Giants are reportedly turning to J.J. McCarthy as their starting quarterback against Houston. Tiki warns that the move could backfire against the Texans' pass rush, especially with the Giants still fighting for a playoff spot. Plus, callers weigh in on the Yankees' leadership, and Jalen Brunson delivers a memorable reminder about never leaving games early.
Evan and Tiki analyze the recent press conference where Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman addressed the Yankees' disappointing season. They also discuss the reported quarterback change for the Giants, moving from Jameis Winston to J.J. McCarthy. Additionally, the conversation touches on Garrett Wilson's unexpected fandom for the Brooklyn Nets and the Knicks' opening night loss. (00:01:55) Yankee Presser Reaction (00:05:15) Giants Quarterback Change (00:09:25) Yankee Fan Callers (00:14:55) Yankees Strikeout Problems (00:18:30) Salary Cap Discussion (00:22:50) Analytics vs Instincts (00:26:55) Garrett Wilson Nets Fan (00:32:45) Knicks Season Opener (00:36:25) Small Market Comparisons
Hal Steinbrenner is facing tough questions about the Yankees' future, and his response isn't sitting well with everyone. With Brian Cashman reportedly receiving a new contract despite another season without a championship, frustrated Yankees fans are questioning whether ownership is too comfortable with the status quo. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber take aim at Steinbrenner's reluctance to address a potential MLB lockout and the proposed salary cap, including one reporter's pointed question about how a cap would actually benefit Yankees fans. Plus, a passionate caller rips the Yankees' reliance on analytics, sparking a debate about whether the numbers are really to blame for their postseason failures. The conversation also shifts to the Giants' offensive struggles without Jaxson Dart and why their inability to stay ahead of the chains continues to haunt them. And Garrett Wilson earns some unexpected love from Evan after revealing his Brooklyn Nets fandom!
Hal Steinbrenner's defense of Brian Cashman has Yankees fans fired up, and Evan Roberts isn't buying the lack of accountability. How can Steinbrenner blame the players while insisting the man who assembled the roster continues to do a great job? Evan and Tiki Barber break down the contradictions from the Yankees' press conference, the franchise's repeated failures, and why the same approach keeps producing disappointing results. Plus, the Yankees' strikeout-heavy lineup comes under fire as Evan argues that Cashman needs to prioritize hitters who put the ball in play. The conversation also shifts to the Giants, where a reported quarterback change from Jameis Winston to J.J. McCarthy raises questions about Winston's struggles, the team's predictable running game, and what John Harbaugh hopes to accomplish with a new starter.
The Giants are reportedly making the switch to J.J. McCarthy, and Tiki Barber thinks John Harbaugh might be making a major mistake. With the Giants sitting at 3-2-1 and firmly in the playoff race, is throwing McCarthy into the fire against the Texans' dangerous pass rush really the smartest move? Tiki explains why Houston's defense could expose the young quarterback's inexperience and why Jameis Winston might still give the Giants their best chance to win. Evan Roberts and Tiki debate the timing of the quarterback change, McCarthy's thrilling comeback against the Saints, and whether the Giants should have waited until after the bye week. With a division title suddenly within reach, the Giants are taking a gamble that could have major consequences for their season.
Aaron Boone faces a brutal line of questioning about the Yankees' continued postseason failures, and even he admits he hasn't proven himself at the highest level. After another October disappointment, Boone is challenged on why his teams consistently struggle against elite competition and whether he's capable of finally delivering a championship. His response? The Yankees still have to prove they can get over the hump. Boone also pushes back against Anthony Rizzo's criticism of the organization's repeated failures, defends his leadership style and refusal to publicly embarrass players, and addresses the Yankees' offensive struggles. Plus, why he believes the Brewers and Rays have an athleticism advantage, whether the hitting staff needs changes, and how the Yankees plan to avoid another disappointing October in 2027.
Hal Steinbrenner is putting the blame squarely on the Yankees' players after another October disappointment, while Brian Cashman gets an extension and Aaron Boone appears safe. Despite spending more than $300 million on payroll, the Yankees still haven't delivered another championship, and Steinbrenner faces tough questions about why the same leadership continues to get opportunities. Is ownership holding the wrong people accountable?
Hal Steinbrenner is doubling down on Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone, and Yankees fans may not like what they're hearing! During a revealing postseason press conference, Steinbrenner defends his leadership group, blames the players for another disappointing October, and insists the Yankees had a championship-caliber roster. Meanwhile, Cashman confirms he's agreed to a new contract despite the team's continued failure to deliver another World Series title. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber listen as Steinbrenner and Cashman face tough questions about accountability, clubhouse culture, and criticism from Yankees legends CC Sabathia, Anthony Rizzo, and Joe Girardi. Steinbrenner also responds to Aaron Judge's call for ownership to go all in, refuses to embrace his father's public approach to holding players accountable, and explains why Boone isn't responsible for the team's postseason collapse. With the offense under fire and the same leadership remaining in place, the biggest question is whether the Yankees are truly willing to change or simply expecting different results.
The Knicks are officially defending champions, but how long will their championship glow protect them from criticism? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate when fans should start worrying about a potential championship hangover following their opening-night loss to the 76ers. With Josh Hart sarcastically calling the Knicks the worst team in the NBA, the guys examine when the celebration ends and the pressure to repeat begins.
The Knicks raised their championship banner, celebrated their title, and then lost their season opener to the 76ers. But Evan Roberts has a stunning admission: even as a Knicks hater, he couldn't enjoy their defeat! Evan and Tiki Barber explain why the emotional ring ceremony mattered far more than the final score and why Knicks fans shouldn't lose a second of sleep over ugly performances from Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby, and Karl-Anthony Towns. But the celebration also sparks an unexpectedly emotional moment for Evan. Watching legends from the Knicks' 1973 championship team participate in the ceremony makes him think about Joe Namath and the Jets. With time running out to reunite the franchise's Super Bowl III heroes with a future championship team, Evan shares why the Knicks' special night left him feeling jealous, emotional, and genuinely sad about the Jets' championship drought.
From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Freddy Peralta pitches the Tampa Bay Rays to their 3rd career World Series appearance. David Stearns must be smiling. Plus, more of your emails and VOICE mails! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
The Giants still won't name a quarterback, they release Najee Harris. The Knicks get set to hang a banner and Aaron Boone is coming back
The Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, but John Harbaugh's quarterback dilemma could threaten their surprising season! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber make the case for sticking with Jameis Winston over J.J. McCarthy, while questioning whether the uncertainty is creating anxiety inside the locker room. With a massive opportunity to steal a vulnerable division, Evan argues the Giants have everything to lose, sparking a heated debate over whether this season is already being played with house money. Plus, who deserves to take control of the Giants' crowded backfield? The guys weigh in on Tyrone Tracy, the team's defensive coaching, and the looming matchup with Houston. They also rip Dan Quinn and the Commanders over another embarrassing game-management controversy, Evan celebrates the Knicks' championship defense by wearing a 2003 Nets division championship shirt, and the crew debates whether anyone actually cares about a Brewers-Rays World Series.
Aaron Boone is returning for a 10th season with the Yankees, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the organization is wasting its chance to make a much-needed change. Is the looming MLB lockout the only reason Boone still has a job? With the Yankees stuck in a cycle of postseason disappointment, Evan questions why the team would bring back a lame-duck manager instead of pursuing Alex Cora or Carlos Beltran. Meanwhile, the Giants have released Najee Harris just days after he complained about his limited carries. Was the timing a coincidence, or did Harris talk his way out of New York? Tiki weighs in on the running back situation, Tyrone Tracy's opportunity, and whether the Giants could pursue Jonathan Taylor. Plus, Evan shares a hilariously fitting Jets airplane disaster, the guys debate the Jets' future under Aaron Glenn, and Knicks fans prepare to pay outrageous prices for opening night's championship banner ceremony.
The Knicks are raising their championship banner at Madison Square Garden, but their opening night celebration is already stirring debate! Evan Roberts questions the bizarre championship T-shirts, while Shaun Morash wonders if the Knicks are boldly predicting another title. Plus, should the NBA Cup banner go up alongside the championship banner, and will Knicks fans finally stop panicking over regular-season losses? The Giants face a major quarterback decision between Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy. Tiki Barber explains why he's still hesitant to hand McCarthy the starting job despite Winston's struggles. Meanwhile, Garrett Wilson's frustration with the Jets offense is boiling over, and the debate over Wilson versus Malik Nabers takes another surprising turn.
Evan, Tiki, and Shaun discuss the excitement surrounding the New York Knicks raising their championship banner at Madison Square Garden. They provide their season predictions, including win totals and potential NBA Finals matchups, while debating the strength of the Eastern Conference. The crew also revisits David Stearns’ impact on the Mets and critiques the decision to include the Rangers logo on the new Champions Plaza street sign.(00:01:50) Rams Injury Report(00:02:56) Mets Pitching Lab Concerns(00:06:03) Giants Draft Review(00:12:55) Champions Plaza Controversy(00:16:10) Tyrone Tracy's Role(00:20:55) New Team Trivia Game(00:26:20) Evaluating David Stearns(00:30:44) Knicks Championship Ceremony(00:34:38) NBA Season Predictions
The Knicks are finally entering a season as defending NBA champions, and Evan Roberts believes their championship could completely transform how New York fans react to winning and losing. Will Knicks fans finally stop panicking after every regular-season loss, or will the pressure to repeat create even more anxiety? Evan and Tiki debate how much patience the defending champions have earned and why opening night is about much more than the final score. Plus, Jaylen Brown raises eyebrows by referring to the Knicks as "former champions" ahead of their banner ceremony. Was it an innocent mistake or a calculated troll? The crew also reacts to the Yankees announcing that Hal Steinbrenner, Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone will face the media, with major questions looming about the team's future.
The Giants have a major quarterback decision looming, and Jameis Winston's struggles are making the case for J.J. McCarthy impossible to ignore! Tiki Barber breaks down McCarthy's encouraging moments against the Saints, why his late-game success might be misleading, and why he's still not ready to bench Winston. With Giants fans overwhelmingly favoring McCarthy in Shaun Morash's poll, could John Harbaugh be preparing a quarterback change? Meanwhile, the Knicks are getting ready for their historic championship banner ceremony at Madison Square Garden, but another debate is brewing. Should the Knicks also raise an NBA Cup banner now that they've won the NBA title? Evan Roberts makes the case for celebrating both accomplishments, while the crew looks back at memorable championship banner ceremonies across New York sports history.
Jalen Hurts' future in Philadelphia is suddenly in serious doubt! Former WFAN boss Spike Eskin joins Evan and Tiki to discuss the Eagles' handling of Hurts' medical situation, the growing criticism of the organization, and why he believes there's a strong chance Hurts has played his final game in Philadelphia. Meanwhile, the Knicks are preparing to raise their championship banner at Madison Square Garden, but their opening night giveaway has Evan Roberts scratching his head. Is the team's bizarre championship T-shirt simply a design mistake, or are the Knicks already calling their shot on another title? Shaun Morash has a wild theory, and Evan gets ripped for selling his tickets to the historic celebration.
The Jets are getting called out for another frustrating defensive performance, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber aren't letting them off the hook! Despite some fans finding positives in the loss to the Patriots, the guys rip the Jets for allowing a depleted offensive line and backup running back to control the game. With missed opportunities, costly mistakes, and an inability to win the little battles, the Jets continue to find ways to beat themselves. Plus, a hilarious edition of Posted and Toasted uncovers some outrageous old tweets from WFAN personalities, including Evan's brutal Pedro Martinez comparison and Shaun Morash's criticism of LeBron James. The guys also revisit J.J. McCarthy's uneven performance, as Tiki explains why a few impressive throws aren't enough to convince him the young quarterback should start against the Texans.
Aaron Boone is back for a 10th season with the Yankees, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the organization missed its opportunity to make a desperately needed change. After years of postseason disappointment and a franchise stuck in neutral, why are the Yankees sticking with a manager who has yet to deliver a championship? Evan argues that the looming MLB lockout is the only legitimate explanation, but questions what message that sends to a frustrated fan base. With Boone entering the final year of his contract, the guys debate whether he's already a lame duck and if anything short of a World Series title can save his job. Could Alex Cora or Carlos Beltran be the Yankees' next manager? Plus, the discussion turns to the Jets, as Evan explains why even an embarrassing loss to the Dolphins shouldn't lead to Aaron Glenn getting fired midseason.
Najee Harris is out of New York, and the timing of his release has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber raising eyebrows! Just one day after John Harbaugh addressed Harris' complaints about his limited carries, the Giants cut ties with the running back. Was this simply roster management, or did Harris talk his way off the team? Tiki explains why Tyrone Tracy could now take control of the backfield, while the guys explore the possibility of the Giants making a blockbuster move for Jonathan Taylor. Plus, Harbaugh's comments about Saquon Barkley spark another debate, and Evan shares an unbelievable story about his sister's Jets-themed airplane backing into a pole and forcing an evacuation. The guys also react to the staggering $1,800 ticket prices for the Knicks' championship banner ceremony and question whether fans are paying a fortune for seats that can't even see the banner being raised!
Frank Reich has been a major disappointment running the Jets offense, and Evan Roberts is running out of patience! Evan agrees with Craig Carton's harsh criticism of Reich but wonders why Craig seems to have such a personal dislike for the Jets offensive coordinator. Tiki Barber offers a hilarious theory involving Boomer Esiason, while Evan admits he tried to give Reich a fair chance before turning against his offense. Plus, the guys question whether anyone actually cares about a Brewers-Rays World Series and debate what it would take to make the matchup compelling. Evan reveals a surprising World Series historical fact, while Tiki admits he may need an elimination game to get invested. The Rangers continue their perfect start at home, and the Commanders face more criticism over Dan Quinn and Jayden Daniels' latest fourth-down confusion.
The Giants have everything to lose, and Evan Roberts is furious that fans are treating their first-place team like it has nothing at stake! With the NFC East suddenly there for the taking, Evan argues that John Harbaugh cannot afford to waste a golden opportunity by making the wrong quarterback decision. But is J.J. McCarthy actually the better option than Jameis Winston? Tiki Barber weighs in on the importance of winning, building a culture, and whether McCarthy's impressive fourth quarter is enough to earn him the starting job.
The Giants are in first place, but John Harbaugh's quarterback dilemma is threatening to become a major distraction! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber both believe Jameis Winston should remain the starter over J.J. McCarthy, especially with a difficult road matchup against the Houston Texans looming. Tiki warns that the uncertainty could create anxiety inside the locker room, while Evan questions why a division-leading team is even considering a quarterback change. With reports of an uneasy atmosphere surrounding the Giants, the guys debate which quarterback the players actually trust, whether McCarthy's impressive fourth quarter changes the equation, and if Harbaugh could switch back to Winston if the experiment fails. Plus, the Giants still haven't settled their running back situation, and Tyrone Tracy may have earned his chance to take control. Despite all the injuries and uncertainty, Evan and Tiki believe the Giants can still win the NFC East.
WFAN presents a collection of heated fallout from the Jets’ frustrating loss to the Patriots, featuring Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. Gio vents about Frank Reich repeatedly calling shotgun runs on third and fourth-and-short, Boomer shares an elevator encounter with a fan offering coaching advice, and the crew investigates Aaron Glenn’s bizarre "we get the ball" halftime remark. Plus, Craig Carton goes scorched earth over an unheralded running back shredding the defense to close out the game. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
WFAN presents a deep dive into the Giants' rough afternoon against the Saints from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. Boomer and Gio debate whether it’s time to bench Jameis Winston for rookie JJ McCarthy, while Tiki Barber pulls from his own playing career to explain why Cam Skattebo was held out after recurring fumbles. Plus, John Harbaugh's fiery presser, and Craig Carton questioning Skattebo's standing on the team. That and more on Best Of Giants on WFAN!
It was the first season of Bo Bichette in a New York Mets uniform. Evan Roberts evaluates the third baseman shortstop and if Bo is better off opting out or returning to the Mets. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
No moral victories for our football locals after brutal losses, but plenty of controversy and conversation between both exist in the aftermath.
The Giants have a quarterback controversy after J.J. McCarthy nearly engineered a miraculous comeback against the Saints! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether McCarthy deserves to start over Jameis Winston, with Tiki breaking down the good, the bad, and the ugly from McCarthy's wild fourth quarter. Is he really just a younger, more athletic version of Winston? And is Jameis one bad performance away from losing his job? Meanwhile, Evan absolutely unloads on Cam Skattebo, calling him one of the most overrated athletes he's seen in years! After Skattebo played just six snaps, Tiki explains why his struggles go well beyond fumbling and why John Harbaugh is desperately searching for a running back to seize the starting job. Plus, stunning news about Jalen Hurts' season-ending blood clots, the Giants somehow maintaining control of the NFC East, and why the Jets deserve no sympathy after their loss to the Patriots.
The Jets blew another winnable game against the Patriots, and Evan Roberts has had enough of the coaching staff. Frank Reich's disastrous short-yardage play-calling, Geno Smith's costly mistakes, and a defense that couldn't stop New England's backup offensive line have Evan questioning whether Aaron Glenn and his staff are capable of turning things around. Tiki Barber breaks down the execution failures, while the Jets' league-worst red zone offense only adds to the frustration. Then, Aaron Glenn finds himself at the center of another embarrassing Jets controversy. Did he actually forget who was getting the ball to start the second half? Evan and Tiki initially defend Glenn, but a suspicious audio cut during his Monday press conference raises even more questions. Plus, the Giants' running back rotation comes under fire, J.J. McCarthy's future sparks debate, and the shocking Jalen Hurts health news sends concern throughout the NFC East.
Joe Benigno is absolutely LIVID after another Jets loss to the Patriots! Joe unloads on the officiating, Frank Reich's questionable play-calling, Geno Smith's inability to escape sacks, and the continued failure to get Garrett Wilson the football. With must-win games against the Dolphins and Raiders looming, Joe demands answers and even calls for Cade Klubnik to get a shot if the season falls apart. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber weigh in on whether the Jets can still salvage their season. Meanwhile, the Giants' special teams are becoming a disaster after Charlie Jones' costly fumble helped derail a furious comeback attempt. Evan and Tiki debate John Harbaugh's late-game decisions, while Shaun Morash gets roasted for seemingly jinxing the Giants with his bold predictions. Plus, a heated argument over whether Giants fans have wildly overrated Cam Skattebo, the Cowboys' struggles boosting the Jets' draft position, and a wild Sunday around the NFL.
Evan and Tiki break down the quarterback controversy between J.J. McCarthy and Jameis Winston following the Giants' recent blowout loss. They also discuss the fallout of Jalen Hurts' season-ending injury and analyze Tiki's exclusion from a prominent NFL running back graphic. (00:01:50) Jalen Hurts Injury Update (00:05:10) Giants Quarterback Debate (00:08:20) NFL Hall Of Fame Discussion (00:12:45) Giants Running Back Room (00:19:30) Coworker QB Starting Picks (00:24:50) Giants Game Strategy Talk (00:28:15) International Game Security Issues (00:32:30) Nabors Vs Wilson Comparison (00:40:12) Monday Night Football Picks
Jalen Hurts is out for the season, but the circumstances surrounding his final game have Evan and Tiki questioning the Eagles. Why was Hurts allowed to play after reportedly spending the night in a London hospital with a blood clot and getting no sleep? Howie Roseman and Philadelphia could face some serious questions about that decision. Meanwhile, the Giants have a quarterback controversy brewing after J.J. McCarthy nearly engineered a stunning comeback against the Saints. John Harbaugh refuses to commit to Jameis Winston, and Evan believes that tells us everything about what's coming next. Plus, the Jets' defense gets blasted for an embarrassing finish, Harbaugh's harsh assessment of the Giants' running backs sparks debate, and a remarkable Alvin Kamara milestone reignites the argument that Tiki Barber belongs in the Hall of Fame.
Are Giants fans making Cam Skattebo one of the most overrated athletes in New York? Evan Roberts unloads on the hype surrounding the young running back, arguing that his fumbling problems and underwhelming production justify John Harbaugh's decision to keep him off the field. Tiki Barber weighs in on the importance of discipline, while Shaun Morash argues that Skattebo brings an energy the Giants desperately lacked in their latest loss. Should the Giants be giving Tyrone Tracy more opportunities instead? Plus, Shaun delivers his Cinco de Luncho with a wild Sunday around the NFL, including Robert Saleh and Brian Daboll celebrating their first Titans victory, the Cowboys' struggles potentially handing the Jets a premium draft pick, and the Steelers surviving an overtime thriller. The crew also debates the NFL's overtime rules, the nearly impossible task of recovering an onside kick, and more special teams chaos.
The Giants' special teams are becoming a disaster, and their latest meltdown may have cost them an incredible comeback! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the costly mistakes that doomed the Giants, from Charlie Jones' devastating fumble to the failed kickoff that burned precious seconds off the clock. Evan questions John Harbaugh's late-game decisions, including two onside kicks and the timing of a crucial field goal, while Tiki explains why the strategy made sense despite the poor execution. Plus, Shaun Morash is taking serious heat from Giants fans after predicting a huge day for Charlie Jones, only to watch him commit a game-changing fumble. Is Shaun officially a Giants mush? The crew revisits his disastrous predictions and debates whether special teams have become the Giants' biggest liability.
Joe Benigno is absolutely LIVID after the Jets' latest loss to the Patriots! Joe joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber for a fiery rant about the controversial penalty that wiped out a touchdown, Frank Reich's disastrous play-calling, Geno Smith's lack of mobility, and a defense that continues to make costly mistakes. Joe is fed up with the Jets wasting opportunities and demands that they beat the Dolphins and Raiders to keep their season alive. Plus, Joe blasts the media for trying to get Garrett Wilson to turn on the Jets, while Evan wonders whether Wilson actually needs to become more vocal about demanding the football. Could Cade Klubnik get his chance if the Jets fall to 2-6? Joe wants to see what the young quarterback can do before another lost season slips away.
Aaron Glenn is at the center of another embarrassing Jets controversy, and a mysterious press conference audio cut is only making things worse. Did the Jets head coach actually forget his team wasn't receiving the second-half kickoff against New England? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber initially defend Glenn, believing his comments were taken out of context. But when the Jets' own video feed cuts out during his explanation, the situation suddenly looks suspicious. Evan questions whether the team has created an unnecessary controversy while Tiki insists Glenn's terrible win-loss record is the real issue. Plus, the Giants' confusing running back rotation comes under fire after Cam Skattebo barely sees the field. Tiki explains why constantly switching backs prevents anyone from establishing a rhythm, while Najee Harris voices his own frustration. The guys question whether John Harbaugh needs to stop experimenting and finally commit to a lead running back.
The Jets have the worst red zone touchdown percentage in the NFL, and Evan Roberts can't believe how badly they're wasting their offensive talent. Frank Reich's questionable play-calling continues to frustrate Evan, while Tiki Barber explains why the Jets' inability to pressure opposing quarterbacks is making matters even worse. With Garrett Wilson and other offensive weapons at their disposal, there's simply no excuse for ranking dead last in red zone efficiency.
Evan Roberts is furious after the Jets blow another winnable game, and he's putting the coaching staff on blast. Frank Reich's obsession with shotgun runs on third and fourth down, Geno Smith's failed quarterback sneak, and a defense that let the Patriots run out the clock behind a battered offensive line have Evan questioning whether Aaron Glenn's staff is good enough to win. Tiki Barber breaks down the execution failures, while Evan refuses to accept moral victories from a team that keeps making the same mistakes. Plus, Garrett Wilson isn't getting the football enough, the Jets continue to waste opportunities, and the guys debate whether there's any reason to believe things will improve. The conversation also turns to the Giants' playoff hopes in a struggling NFC East, J.J. McCarthy's development, and concerning news about Jalen Hurts' health.
Jameis Winston or J.J. McCarthy? The Giants have a massive quarterback decision looming, and Tiki Barber believes Winston deserves one more chance to prove himself against the Texans. But with McCarthy's mobility offering a completely different dimension to the offense, the debate gets heated over which quarterback gives the Giants their best chance to win. Evan Roberts puts Tiki on the spot as Giants fans weigh in on McCarthy's wild comeback against the Saints. Tiki explains why the quarterback debate might be missing the Giants' biggest problem: a rushing attack that has completely fallen apart without Jaxson Dart. Plus, despite all the offensive struggles and uncertainty under center, the Giants somehow remain comfortably atop the NFC East!
Skattebo went from the Giants' featured running back to barely seeing the field, and Evan Roberts isn't holding back! After Skattebo played just six snaps against the Saints, Evan calls him one of the most overrated athletes he's seen in years. But was John Harbaugh punishing Skattebo for his fumbling problems, or is there a much bigger issue with his game? Tiki Barber explains why Skattebo's struggles go far beyond turnovers, drawing on his own early-career mistakes and the tough lessons he learned from Tom Coughlin. Plus, Harbaugh delivers a fiery challenge to his entire running back room, demanding someone step up and earn the starting job. The conversation takes a serious turn with breaking news that Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts will miss the remainder of the season due to blood clots.
The Giants have a quarterback controversy after J.J. McCarthy nearly pulled off an unbelievable comeback against the Saints! With New York trailing 34-10 in the fourth quarter, McCarthy brought the Giants within one play of a stunning victory. But was his performance really as impressive as the numbers suggest? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether McCarthy has earned the starting job over Jameis Winston. Tiki goes throw by throw through McCarthy's roller-coaster performance, exposing several dangerous mistakes before a stretch of exceptional passing. Evan makes a surprising comparison, calling McCarthy a younger, more athletic version of Winston. Plus, Tiki breaks down the Giants' final offensive play and explains why Malik Nabers appearing wide open doesn't mean McCarthy missed an easy game-winning touchdown.
Boomer and Gio believe Sunday's game against the Patriots could define this Jets season in terms of its relevance, and Boomer gives them a 50/50 shot of winning. Plus, Craig Carton sounds off on the need for the football world to show Gang Green some more respect, while Evan calls on Aaron Glenn and company to beat the hated Pats to show that they are a team worthy of being invested in for the rest of the season.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle went off on the Saints being road favorites against the 3-1-1 Giants this weekend. Is John Harbaugh's group being overlooked? Plus, Tiki Barber breaks down Cam Skattebo's fumbling issues and reveals his conversation with Tyrone Tracy as he could potentially see more carries moving forward, while Gio worries that he might be buying into these Giants too much.
From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti: A TNF dud, Bills, Rams and Niners concerns, picks of the week, BOLD predictions and more
A Football Friday with heavy Jet optimism from Evan, a look ahead to Giants Saints, and the Shaun Morash rooting guide.
Evan Roberts is feeling dangerously confident about the Jets heading into their showdown with the Patriots! Evan believes Drake Maye and New England's offense have been exposed against elite defenses, and Aaron Glenn's surging Jets defense could be the perfect matchup to pull off a massive upset. Tiki Barber sees a path to victory, but can Geno Smith and Frank Reich deliver enough offense to make it happen? Evan makes one thing clear: moral victories aren't good enough anymore. Meanwhile, Giants fans are suddenly nervous about facing the Saints, with Abdul Carter's injury adding another major concern. Plus, Tiki pushes back against Ryan Fitzpatrick's harsh criticism of Bo Nix, arguing Sean Payton deserves more blame for Denver's conservative offense. And could Tanner McKee actually create a quarterback controversy in Philadelphia? Evan makes a bold prediction about the Eagles' backup quarterback that could put Jalen Hurts under the microscope.
The Brewers are headed to the World Series, the Dodgers are finished, and David Stearns is once again at the center of a heated Mets debate! Evan Roberts blasts the obsession with how much credit Stearns deserves for Milwaukee's success, arguing that the only thing that matters is what he delivers in New York. Meanwhile, a new report about the Dodgers' plans for Tarik Skubal could open a massive opportunity for the Mets. Could Steve Cohen make a blockbuster move before a potential MLB lockout? Plus, Evan and Tiki Barber question the Yankees' continued silence following their playoff elimination, especially amid reports of frustration with Aaron Judge's comments. The guys also debate Brewers manager Pat Murphy's unusual Bob Uecker tributes, react to the NBA's gambling restrictions, and examine what Jameis Winston and the Giants must do to beat the Saints.
Jameis Winston is gearing up for the ultimate revenge game against the Saints, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash are predicting the full Jameis experience! Touchdowns, interceptions, and potentially a pick-six are all on the table. Plus, with Jalen Hurts potentially facing an extended absence, the Eagles' addition of Joe Milton raises questions about Philadelphia's quarterback situation. The Jets' showdown with the Patriots sparks a passionate debate over what actually constitutes progress for a struggling franchise. Evan argues that eight or nine wins would represent a massive step forward, while a frustrated caller refuses to celebrate anything short of meaningful postseason contention. Shaun also counts down the five greatest Jets victories over New England. And the Giants have a serious running back dilemma. Tiki wants more Tyrone Tracy, Evan makes the case for Najee Harris, and Shaun wants Harris off the field entirely. With Cam Skattebo's fumbling concerns growing, the battle for carries is heating up.
Shaun Morash breaks down the ideal NFL outcomes for New York fans in his Week 6 rooting guide. They examine the history of the Cleveland Guardians as a tortured franchise and debate the fame of Jennifer Connelly. Finally, the group locks in their NFL picks for a crucial weekend of football.(00:01:50) Shaun Morash’s Rooting Guide(00:06:31) Analyzing Turnover Worthy Passes(00:09:42) Jennifer Connelly vs. Tiki(00:15:51) Cleveland’s History of Torture(00:22:00) Jets and Knicks History(00:26:58) Idiots With Idioms(00:36:27) Official NFL Week 6 Picks
Shaun Morash is rooting for a Jets humiliation, an Eagles loss, and anything that helps the Giants make a playoff push! His Week 6 NFL rooting guide is back, and he's got a rooting interest in nearly every game across the league. But is Shaun already settling for a wild-card race instead of dreaming bigger for Big Blue? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber challenge his strategy as the Giants prepare to face the Saints. Meanwhile, Jameis Winston's reputation for risky throws gets put under the microscope, and the turnover-worthy play numbers reveal some surprising results. Plus, Evan has an ambitious plan to avoid Giants spoilers while attending the Jets and Nets games, and a caller can't believe Evan doesn't know how famous Jennifer Connelly is!
The Giants have a major running back dilemma, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash can't agree on the solution! With Cam Skattebo struggling to protect the football, Tiki believes Tyrone Tracy deserves more opportunities, while Evan makes a passionate case for Najee Harris to eventually become the lead back. Shaun takes things even further, arguing that Harris looks too slow and should be replaced by Devin Singletary. Plus, Shaun counts down the five greatest Jets victories over the Patriots, bringing back unforgettable memories of Brett Favre, Chad Pennington, and the legendary 2010 playoff upset of Tom Brady. Evan relives the unforgettable revenge win in Foxborough and explains why it remains one of the happiest moments of his sports fandom. With another Jets-Patriots showdown approaching, can New York finally deliver another memorable victory?
Frustrated Jets fan challenges Evan over what should qualify as a successful season. Would nine wins without a playoff appearance really be worth celebrating? Evan passionately defends the importance of progress, arguing that eight or nine victories could finally establish confidence in Aaron Glenn and the Jets' future. Plus, Evan explains why he wears his Nets gear with more pride than ever despite the franchise's struggles and relentless criticism from Knicks fans.
Jameis Winston is facing his former team, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash are expecting the full Jameis Winston experience against the Saints! Evan predicts 350 passing yards, three touchdowns, and three interceptions, while Tiki and Shaun see plenty of turnovers coming as well. Could Winston's aggressive style lead to another wild afternoon for the Giants? Meanwhile, the Eagles have added Joe Milton from the Cowboys' practice squad, and the uncertainty surrounding Jalen Hurts is growing. With speculation that Hurts could land on injured reserve, the crew debates Philadelphia's quarterback depth, Tanner McKee's role, and whether Milton was brought in for more than just insurance. Plus, encouraging Giants injury updates on Abdul Carter and Andrew Thomas, concerns surrounding Theo Johnson, and the latest Jets injury news heading into their matchup with New England.
The Yankees have been eliminated for nine days, and Brian Cashman still hasn't addressed the fans! Evan Roberts is growing increasingly frustrated with the organization's silence, especially following reports that Yankees higher-ups weren't happy with Aaron Judge's comments about going all in. Evan explains why fans deserve answers and what the continued silence could mean for potential changes.
The Mets could have a golden opportunity to land Tarik Skubal! With reports suggesting the Dodgers won't pursue a massive deal before a potential MLB lockout, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine whether Steve Cohen and David Stearns could take advantage. Evan breaks down why Scott Boras may push to get a deal done before the lockout and why the Yankees are unlikely to enter the bidding. Plus, Evan unloads on the ridiculous debate over how much credit Stearns deserves for the Brewers reaching the World Series. The guys also rip the NBA's new gambling restrictions, arguing that the league isn't willing to go far enough to protect the integrity of the game. They question the NBA's bizarre opening-day schedule and debate whether expanding the College Football Playoff to 24 teams would destroy the importance of the regular season. Plus, Tiki revisits the Giants' crushing Super Bowl loss to the Ravens, and Evan shares an unfortunate bathroom story involving Gio and his cell phone.
The Brewers are headed to the World Series after sweeping the Dodgers, and manager Pat Murphy has Evan Roberts questioning one of the strangest motivational tactics in baseball! Murphy's fictional messages from the late Bob Uecker have Evan wondering whether the tributes cross a line, but Tiki Barber strongly defends the approach. Tiki even shares an emotional story about how Wellington Mara's death inspired the Giants during one of the best seasons of his career. Plus, the Brewers' success raises another uncomfortable question for Yankees fans about Aaron Boone's leadership. Evan also revisits a forgotten Dodgers World Series bet, while the guys react to Joe Milton joining the Eagles and the latest Jets injury news, including Breece Hall being ruled out and encouraging updates on Omar Cooper and Kenyon Sadiq.
Ryan Fitzpatrick absolutely blasts Bo Nix's performance against the Seahawks, but Tiki Barber believes the criticism is aimed at the wrong guy! Tiki argues that Sean Payton's conservative play-calling is holding Denver's offense back, relying too heavily on screens and refusing to let Nix attack downfield. Evan questions whether that approach can work against Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs, even with the Broncos' dominant defense. Meanwhile, could Philadelphia be heading toward a stunning quarterback controversy? With Jalen Hurts sidelined, Tanner McKee finally gets his opportunity, and Evan makes a bold prediction that the Eagles backup is about to shine against Carolina and potentially Dallas. Tiki praises McKee's talent and potential, while Evan believes two strong performances could ignite a legitimate debate about Jalen Hurts' future as Philadelphia's starter.
Evan Roberts refuses to let the Jets' miserable history against the Patriots crush his confidence! With David Bailey potentially facing a rookie left tackle, Evan sees a golden opportunity for the Jets defense to rattle Drake Maye and steal a massive road victory. But Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash aren't ready to trust the Jets offense, and Evan makes it clear that another close loss won't be good enough. Could beating New England completely change the conversation around Aaron Glenn and the Jets? Evan believes it would give the new regime its first signature victory, and the upcoming schedule could suddenly make things very interesting. The playoff talk even begins to creep in, with Evan revealing exactly what it would take for him to start dreaming about January football. Plus, Giants fans have their own reasons to panic ahead of the Saints game, including concerns about Abdul Carter's injury and the team's fumbling problems.
Evan Roberts is feeling dangerously confident about the Jets heading into their showdown with the Patriots, and he's got the numbers to back it up! Evan believes Drake Maye and New England's offense have bullied bad defenses but consistently struggled against top-ranked units. With Aaron Glenn's Jets defense ranked fifth in the NFL and rookie David Bailey wreaking havoc, could the Jets finally pull off a statement win in Foxborough? Tiki Barber believes the Jets can keep this game close, but questions whether Frank Reich and Geno Smith can generate enough offense to finish the job. Evan also sounds off on the Jets' disastrous penalties and insists that simply competing with New England isn't good enough. The Jets need wins, not moral victories, and beating the Patriots could be the turning point this franchise desperately needs.
From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans talk about how the Packers can breathe a sigh of relief after their big win against the Bears last week - but what's next? Then they have a conversation about about Dallas' defense and what needs to be fixed. Finally, they have a conversation about just how special of season Josh Allen is having. They end the podcast with #QuestionMark.
Let's see where your favorite Met Bullpen Arms rate after the 2026 season. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
Evan feels no embarrassment about David Sterns' former team knocking out the Dodgers, but should other Mets fans feel the same? The Giants expand the JJ McCarthy Package, and much more
David Stearns built the foundation of a Brewers team on the verge of the World Series, while his Mets are watching from home after a disastrous season. Should Mets fans be humiliated by Milwaukee's success, or should Stearns be the one feeling embarrassed? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Stearns deserves credit for the Brewers' remarkable run or criticism for failing to deliver similar results in New York. Shaun Morash weighs in on how the Mets dismantled a team that was competing with the Dodgers just two years ago. Plus, the Brewers' 3-0 NLCS lead brings back painful memories of the Yankees' historic 2004 collapse against the Red Sox. Derek Jeter's comments spark a debate about whether the Dodgers could pull off the impossible comeback, while former Yankee Jake Bauers' stunning resurgence raises even more questions about New York's roster decisions.
The Giants are reportedly planning to expand J.J. McCarthy's role, and Shaun Morash is furious! With Jameis Winston finding his rhythm, why would the Giants risk disrupting their offense with more quarterback gimmicks? Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, who believes John Harbaugh could be playing mind games with the Saints by leaking misleading information. Plus, Winston delivers a hilarious and heartfelt explanation of the "Jameis Winston Experience." Meanwhile, MLB's looming labor battle sparks a heated debate over salary caps, competitive balance, and whether anyone actually wants to watch a small-market World Series. Carlos Mendoza lands with the Phillies, Brian Cashman's silence continues, and a surprising political rumor involving Yankees president Randy Levine raises questions about a potential front-office shakeup in the Bronx.
The Giants are winning games, but are they actually as good as their record suggests? Tiki Barber isn't convinced, pointing to an inconsistent running game, a defense still missing Dexter Lawrence's interior pressure, and a team relying too heavily on individual heroics. Evan Roberts questions whether the Giants are actually better off after trading Lawrence, while the guys debate whether the struggling Eagles could still steal the NFC East despite their offensive line turmoil. Plus, Jaxson Dart's growing national celebrity sparks a debate about what makes a New York quarterback a star, and a caller floats a stunning Yankees managerial candidate to replace Aaron Boone. The brand-new Fan Answering Machine delivers hilarious messages, while Evan reveals his least-watched World Series and makes an embarrassing discovery about his Red Sox hatred!
Jalen Hurts will miss Sunday's matchup against the Panthers due to a superficial blood clot, a scary medical situation discovered after the team returned from London. They also investigate the feasibility of a Justin Herbert trade amidst the Chargers' struggles and debate whether Jose Ramirez is a lock for the Hall of Fame. Additionally, the conversation covers the Knicks' final roster moves and the impact of the NBA's second apron.(00:01:50) Dodgers Dynasty Debate(00:04:50) Jalen Hurts Injury News(00:09:31) Pop-A-Shot Records(00:15:55) Red Sox Audio Uncovered(00:19:39) Justin Herbert Trade Rumors(00:28:25) Knicks Roster & Cap(00:36:45) Broncos vs Seahawks Picks(00:43:53) Jose Ramirez Hall Debate
The Eagles have been dealt a frightening blow as Jalen Hurts is ruled out against the Panthers after doctors discovered movement in a blood clot in his calf. With Philadelphia already struggling at 2-3, the guys react to the scary medical situation, question the potential impact of the team's London trip, and wonder how Tanner McKee can keep the Eagles' season afloat. Meanwhile, a confident Jets fan insists New York has more talent than the Patriots, sparking a debate about coaching, roster advantages, and Sunday's matchup. Plus, Tiki Barber makes the case for getting Tyrone Tracy more touches in the Giants' offense, and Shaun Morash gets exposed by an old recording of his outrageous take on the 2018 Red Sox!
Shaun Morash has somehow erased an entire Red Sox World Series championship from his memory! While ranking the five World Series he's watched the least, Shaun makes the hilarious discovery that Boston won it all in 2018, a championship he completely forgot existed. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber can't believe the admission as the guys revisit baseball's most forgettable World Series.
The Eagles are unraveling, but Evan Roberts isn't ready to bury Philadelphia just yet! With Cam Jurgens traded, Lane Johnson retired, and Landon Dickerson publicly questioning his future, the Eagles are facing serious turmoil. Yet Evan believes their favorable upcoming schedule could put them right back in control of the NFC East. Tiki Barber isn't sold on the Giants as legitimate contenders either, pointing to their weak competition and inability to consistently dominate opponents.
The Giants may be winning, but the loss of Dexter Lawrence is still haunting their defense! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether trading their star defensive tackle was the right move, why the pass rush hasn't been the same, and whether the Giants are actually a better team without him. Tiki also exposes a major issue with the Giants' running game.
Could the Yankees be headed for a massive front office shakeup? A surprising political rumor has Yankees president Randy Levine being floated as a potential White House chief of staff, and Evan Roberts wonders what that could mean for the organization. Could Levine's departure open the door for Brian Cashman to move into the president's role and allow the Yankees to hire a new general manager? The speculation creates an intriguing possibility as Cashman's silence continues.
The Giants are reportedly planning to expand J.J. McCarthy's package, and Shaun Morash has had enough! With Jameis Winston building momentum, Shaun blasts the idea of disrupting drives just to get McCarthy a handful of snaps. Evan sees another possibility: John Harbaugh could be deliberately leaking misleading information to force the Saints to prepare for something that isn't coming. Is this smart gamesmanship or another unnecessary quarterback distraction?
MLB's looming labor war has Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debating whether a salary cap would actually save baseball or create even bigger problems. With the Brewers potentially facing the Rays in the World Series, Evan questions whether competitive balance really matters if casual fans refuse to watch. Tiki argues that baseball's real problem isn't player salaries but the league's failure to maximize shared television revenue, while Shaun believes giving smaller markets a legitimate championship shot could transform the sport.
David Stearns built the foundation of a Brewers powerhouse, but Evan Roberts has a message for Mets fans celebrating his former team's success: none of it matters until he wins in Queens. With Milwaukee on the verge of the World Series, Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether Stearns' success with a small-market team can translate to Steve Cohen's big-spending Mets. Meanwhile, former Yankee Jake Bauers has gone from a forgettable journeyman to a postseason hero, raising serious questions about talent evaluation and whether his breakout is sustainable. Plus, Francisco Lindor's vasectomy announcement leads to an unexpected and hilarious conversation about fatherhood, family planning, and why Shaun Morash refuses to follow Lindor's lead.
The Yankees' historic 2004 collapse against the Red Sox is back in the spotlight as the Brewers take a commanding 3-0 NLCS lead over the Dodgers. Derek Jeter admits the pain of blowing that series never completely disappears, while Shaun Morash reveals why he's suddenly rooting for Los Angeles to pull off the impossible comeback. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether another team overcoming a 3-0 deficit could ever erase the Yankees' humiliation. Meanwhile, Mets fans are divided over David Stearns' role in Milwaukee's success. Some see the Brewers' dominance as another indictment of the Mets' front office, while others believe it proves Stearns can eventually build a winner in Queens. Evan pushes back on both extremes, insisting Stearns' impressive Milwaukee résumé means nothing unless he delivers results in New York.
David Stearns built the Brewers into a powerhouse, and now they're on the verge of the World Series while the Mets are sitting at home after a disastrous season. Should Mets fans be humiliated watching Milwaukee thrive without him? Evan Roberts refuses to see it that way, arguing that Stearns' success with the Brewers means nothing unless he can deliver in New York. Tiki Barber questions whether Stearns should be the one feeling embarrassed. Shaun Morash points to an even bigger frustration: the Mets were battling the Dodgers in the NLCS just two years ago, only for Stearns to dismantle that core without adequately replacing it. Meanwhile, Milwaukee is dominating the very team New York couldn't beat. The conversation turns to the Yankees' own missed opportunities, the Brewers' surprising dominance, and why New York baseball fans should be angry with their front offices rather than embarrassed by Milwaukee's success.
The Giants are 3-1-1, the Jets are 2-3, those records may not have been surprising in August but how we got to them certainly is. Plus the future of Brian Cashman is once again on the table.
The Jets are exactly where everyone expected at 2-3, but their biggest strength has become their biggest disappointment. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question why Aaron Glenn’s offense is struggling while his defense dominates, and whether the Jets can turn things around against the Patriots. Meanwhile, Jameis Winston has stunned everyone by keeping the injury-ravaged Giants alive at 3-1-1. Plus, Steve Cohen’s surprise appearance at Freddy Peralta’s ALCS start fuels reunion speculation, Evan blasts Rays fans for empty playoff seats, and a heated debate erupts over MLB’s automated ball-strike challenge system.
The Jets' offense is failing to live up to expectations, and Tiki Barber identifies the biggest reason why. Despite Geno Smith protecting the football, the Jets are struggling to move the ball and score points. Tiki breaks down the rushing attack's alarming inconsistency and explains why Aaron Glenn's offense cannot succeed without establishing the run. Meanwhile, the Giants continue to show a toughness that was missing under previous coaching staffs, raising the question of just how much John Harbaugh has transformed the team. Evan Roberts also exposes a misleading Mets rumor involving Tarik Skubal and Steve Cohen, explaining how an opinion turned into a supposed blockbuster report. Plus, Tiki reveals his conversations with Tyrone Tracy about protecting the football, Cameron Skattebo's costly fumble sparks debate, and the crew examines why trading Aaron Judge is far less realistic than some Yankees fans might believe.
Jameis Winston's roller-coaster ride with the Giants nearly cost him his starting job before another incredible comeback changed the conversation. Connor Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to explain just how close the Giants were to turning to J.J. McCarthy, why Winston has earned a longer leash, and whether the first-place Giants are getting disrespected as underdogs against the Saints. The Jets have their own problems despite Geno Smith's encouraging play. Hughes questions Frank Reich's unimaginative offense, praises Aaron Glenn's defensive turnaround, and explains what it will take to challenge the Patriots. Plus, the latest injury updates on Breece Hall, AD Mitchell, and Omar Cooper. LeBron James stirs up an unexpected Knicks debate by suggesting OG Anunoby deserved Finals MVP over Jalen Brunson. Evan and Tiki revisit the unforgettable moments from the Knicks' championship run, including Mikal Bridges' clutch three against Cleveland. Plus, Shaun Morash ranks his favorite October decorations, and the crew debates the potential end of Central Park's horse-drawn carriages.
Evan and Tiki analyze Gayle Benson's direct criticism of the New Orleans Saints and what it means for their upcoming matchup against the New York Giants. They also break down Drake May's recent performances and the potential for a surprising front-office shift involving Brian Cashman moving to the Mets. Finally, the discussion turns to the rising costs of sports streaming services through the YES Network and DAZN.(00:02:06) Gayle Benson Challenges Saints(00:09:10) Drake May Versus Jets(00:17:28) Brian Cashman's Future Options(00:28:31) Yankees Fans Criticize Cashman(00:36:41) YES Network Streaming Costs(00:47:52) Audacy App Voice Messages
The Giants are facing a desperate Saints team after owner Gayle Benson publicly blasted the organization's performance, but will that pressure make New Orleans more dangerous or push them closer to collapse? Evan Roberts isn't buying the idea that an angry owner suddenly makes a bad team better, while Shaun Morash worries Kellen Moore could pull out all the stops against the Giants. Plus, Shaun admits his Giants playoff anxiety has him expecting disaster every week. Meanwhile, Evan sees a golden opportunity for the Jets to expose Drake Maye and the Patriots. Despite Maye's recent resurgence, his struggles against strong defenses have Evan believing the Jets could force a rare interception and potentially pull off the upset. And in a bizarre twist, could former Jets coach Adam Gase actually take over the Chargers offense? The possibility has Evan absolutely disgusted.
Shaun Morash brings the Halloween spirit to Cinco de Luncho with his official ranking of the five best October house decorations! From hilarious tombstones and classic jack-o'-lanterns to massive skeletons, Shaun lays out what every festive front lawn needs. But his number one choice might surprise you: Giants and Jets flags! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber jump into the debate as the crew argues over giant skeletons, lazy homeowners who leave decorations up all year, and the squirrels destroying everyone's pumpkins. Plus, Evan defends his father-in-law's Halloween decorating efforts, and Shaun reveals why showing off your New York football pride is the perfect way to celebrate October.
LeBron James just reopened a Knicks championship debate by suggesting OG Anunoby was the team's real Finals MVP, despite Jalen Brunson winning the award. Evan Roberts questions whether LeBron was genuinely praising OG or deliberately trying to stir up trouble inside the Knicks locker room. Tiki Barber isn't buying the controversy, but the debate raises a fascinating question about who truly deserved the honor. Evan and Tiki relive the most unforgettable moments from the Knicks' championship run, including OG's legendary tip-in, Brunson's 45-point masterpiece, and Mikal Bridges' clutch three against Cleveland that Evan believes deserves more recognition. Plus, the Jets receive important injury updates from Aaron Glenn, including AD Mitchell's hand procedure, Breece Hall's uncertain status, and encouraging news about Omar Cooper ahead of the Patriots matchup.
The Jets have a Geno Smith resurgence, an impressive defense, and a major problem on offense. Connor Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to question Frank Reich's unimaginative play-calling and explain why the Jets aren't doing enough to get Garrett Wilson the football. With Aaron Glenn's defense thriving, can the Jets pull off a massive upset against the Patriots? Plus, injury updates on Breece Hall, AD Mitchell, and Omar Cooper. The Giants are winning, but Jameis Winston nearly played himself out of a starting job before his incredible comeback against Washington. Hughes reveals how close the Giants were to considering J.J. McCarthy, addresses the team's alarming fumbling issues, and explains why oddsmakers still don't believe in the first-place Giants. Plus, David Bailey's Defensive Rookie of the Year case and the remarkable turnaround of Deonte Banks.
The Jets' offense is falling well short of expectations, and Tiki Barber has identified the biggest problem. Despite Geno Smith taking care of the football, the Jets are struggling to generate yards and score points. Tiki breaks down the alarming rushing numbers, explains how opposing defenses are shutting down Breece Hall and Braelon Allen, and makes it clear that Aaron Glenn's team won't find offensive consistency until it establishes the ground game. Plus, Cameron Skattebo's costly fumble could open the door for Tyrone Tracy to earn a bigger role with the Giants. Tiki reveals the advice he's given Tracy about ball security and explains why earning John Harbaugh's trust could be the key to more touches. The crew also debates the Yankees' postseason disappointments, defends Max Fried and Cody Bellinger's championship credentials, and examines Cleveland's remarkable history of playoff heartbreak.
The Mets are reportedly willing to match any offer for Tarik Skubal, but Evan Roberts isn't buying the viral headline! Evan tracks down the original comments from SNY's Chelsea Janes and exposes how her opinion about Steve Cohen and the Mets' spending power was twisted into a supposed report. With Skubal's future generating excitement, Evan warns fans about the dangers of believing everything they see on social media. Plus, could the Yankees actually trade Aaron Judge? The crew examines why Judge's age, massive contract, and no-trade clause make a blockbuster deal nearly impossible, even if the Yankees entertained the idea. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber weigh in as the conversation turns to what Judge could realistically bring back in a trade.
John Harbaugh has transformed the Giants into a team that refuses to quit, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash are taking notice. After another dramatic comeback against Washington, the crew debates whether the Giants would have lost these close games under Brian Daboll and the previous coaching staff. Is Harbaugh the biggest reason the Giants are finding ways to survive situations that once seemed hopeless? Plus, Cameron Skattebo's costly overtime fumble sparks a fascinating conversation about ball security, opposing players mocking him, and whether his trash talk makes him a target. Tiki reveals his conversations with Tyrone Tracy about fixing fumbling problems and explains why protecting the football is critical to earning more opportunities. The crew also weighs in on Shohei Ohtani's injury, frustrated Dodgers fans, and the Knicks' intriguing preseason roster decisions.
Evan Roberts has had enough of MLB’s automated ball-strike challenge system! After controversial non-challenges impact critical postseason moments, Evan demands that baseball stop playing games and simply get the calls right. Tiki Barber pushes back, defending the strategy and entertainment of the challenge system, while Shaun Morash sides against Evan in a heated debate over the future of umpiring. Plus, Evan continues blasting Rays fans for embarrassing playoff attendance and refuses to back down from angry Florida listeners. The conversation also turns to the Giants, with a debate over a controversial two-point conversion decision against Washington and whether John Harbaugh deserves credit for winning games the previous Giants coaching staff would have lost.
Steve Cohen shows up at the ALCS to watch former Met Freddy Peralta throw six scoreless innings, and Evan Roberts wants to know what’s really going on! Could Cohen be laying the groundwork for a reunion, or is he simply enjoying playoff baseball? Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether Peralta could return to Queens, why his turnaround makes the Mets look bad, and why New York desperately needs to add starting pitching this offseason. Meanwhile, Evan absolutely unloads on Rays fans for failing to sell out another ALCS game. With Tampa Bay just three wins away from the World Series, Evan calls the empty seats an embarrassment to baseball and refuses to back down from angry Florida fans.
The Jets are 2-3, but their biggest problem is the one nobody saw coming! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down how Aaron Glenn has transformed the defense into a top-five unit while an offense expected to carry the team ranks just 27th in scoring. Glenn is thriving as a defensive play-caller, but his game management continues to raise serious questions. Can the Jets finally get their offense going before facing the Patriots? Meanwhile, the Giants are exceeding expectations despite losing key players to injury. With Jaxson Dart sidelined and Brian Burns out, Jameis Winston has stepped up in a way few expected. Evan and Tiki debate the biggest surprises of the NFL season so far and how both New York teams have reached their current records in completely unexpected ways.
In this edition of the Rico Brogna Mailbag, Evan discusses some offseason moves the Mets should be interested in. The big move being that of Bryce Harper? P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
The Yankees fans were reminded by the Guardians of what could have been, so why hasn't Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone yet had their end of the year presser? Plus the Jameis Winston experience remains a heavy discussion.
The Yankees’ elimination wounds reopen after Cleveland lights up the same Rays team that shut down New York. Shaun Morash is furious that Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone still haven’t faced the media, while Evan Roberts argues the Yankees should take their time before making any major decision. The biggest fight centers on Cashman’s future, with Morash demanding a fresh organizational voice and Evan defending the GM for building a promising young core. Boone’s controversial Game 3 lineup decision remains impossible to ignore. Evan, Tiki Barber and Morash also debate the NFL’s evolving overtime strategy after Sean McVay’s conservative approach costs the Rams, rip Rays fans for failing to fill the building against Cleveland, and examine what Aaron Judge really means when he says the Yankees need to go “all in.”
The Yankees' World Series drought has fans demanding major changes, but should Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman both lose their jobs? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber want Boone gone while defending Cashman's track record, but Shaun Morash argues it's time for a complete overhaul. A fan poll reveals overwhelming frustration, and the debate gets heated over whether the Yankees are simply teasing fans with regular-season success. Meanwhile, CC Sabathia delivers a harsh assessment of the Yankees' lost championship standards, blaming the absence of former champions in the clubhouse. The crew debates whether veteran leadership, better roster construction, or a new manager is the answer. Plus, Ravens safety Kyle Hamilton makes comments that could be interpreted as a shot at John Harbaugh, sparking a debate over whether both Baltimore and the Giants benefited from their breakup. And Tiki proposes a wild new way to settle NFL ties that Evan absolutely cannot stand.
New York sports have been rocked by a brutal wave of injuries, and the damage could define multiple seasons. Aaron Judge missed the Yankees' postseason collapse, Jaxson Dart and Brian Burns are done for the year, and Igor Shesterkin's injury has dealt another crushing blow to Rangers fans. Shaun Morash ranks the five most impactful injuries in New York sports, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate which loss hurts the most and whether Jameis Winston's success changes how Giants fans should feel about losing Dart. Plus, John Harbaugh invokes Abraham Lincoln, Winston Churchill and Michael Jordan while praising Jameis Winston, sparking a hilarious discussion about the Giants coach. Evan digs into the history books to determine whether Demario Davis was right to call the Jets' win over Cleveland historic, and the guys debate Aaron Boone's responsibility for the Yankees' failures. Shaun also finds himself under fire for his allegedly biased WFAN Fan Focus updates.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question why the first-place Giants are considered home underdogs against the struggling 1-4 Saints. They also analyze Jameis Winston's performance as a starter versus his role as a backup and discuss the strange reporting around the Marvin Harrison Jr. trade.(00:01:50) Quarterback Injury Impact Debate(00:02:55) Secretariat Trivia Game(00:04:52) Giants vs Yankees Injuries(00:07:13) Shaun Morash Fan Focus(00:08:35) Mr. Ed Baseball Episode(00:11:20) Rangers Goaltending vs Quarterbacks(00:13:15) Aaron Boone Era Bracket(00:18:00) Deodorant Sensitivity Email Discussion(00:19:58) Jets Roster Moves(00:20:56) Giants Disrespected in Betting Lines(00:27:20) Jameis Winston Starter Evolution(00:34:00) Coaching Decisions and Ties(00:38:59) Marvin Harrison Jr. Trade Analysis
New York sports are suffering through an unbelievable injury nightmare, and Shaun Morash has had enough! Aaron Judge missed the Yankees' postseason collapse, Jaxson Dart and Brian Burns are done for the year, and Igor Shesterkin's injury has dealt another devastating blow to the Rangers. Shaun ranks the five most impactful injuries in New York sports, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber aren't convinced he has the order right. The biggest debate centers on Jaxson Dart and what the Giants might have accomplished with their young quarterback healthy. With Jameis Winston keeping the Giants in the NFC East race, Evan and Tiki question whether Dart's absence is really as devastating as Shaun believes. Could the Giants have been legitimate NFC Championship contenders with Dart? Plus, the guys debate whether Judge's absence was the most damaging injury of them all and just how unprecedented this brutal stretch has been for New York sports fans.
Was the Jets' victory over the Browns actually historic? Demario Davis made the bold claim, and Evan Roberts went digging through 26 years of Jets history to find out if he was right. The results are surprisingly revealing, but Shaun Morash isn't buying it. Even if the win was incredibly rare, does it really mean anything if the Jets can't build on it? With a massive matchup against Drake Maye and the Patriots looming, the guys debate whether Aaron Glenn's team can turn one victory into something bigger. Plus, the Giants' surprising start has everyone questioning their preseason predictions, while Tiki Barber breaks down the ball-security mistakes that continue to haunt NFL running backs. The conversation also turns to CC Sabathia's loyalty to Milwaukee, Juan Soto's impact on the Yankees and whether fans should appreciate stars who deliver before leaving town.
John Harbaugh is winning over Evan Roberts in the most unexpected way! The Giants head coach invokes Winston Churchill, Abraham Lincoln and Michael Jordan while praising Jameis Winston's relentless optimism, and Evan absolutely loves it. With Winston undefeated as the Giants' starter, Evan explains why Harbaugh's historical comparisons make perfect sense and why he's more jealous than ever that the Giants landed him. Plus, Yankees fans are demanding accountability after another disappointing October. Evan pushes back against the idea that Brian Cashman controls Aaron Boone's lineups, placing the blame squarely on the manager for questionable decisions. The conversation also turns to Robert Saleh's struggles as a head coach, Brian Daboll's difficult situation in Tennessee and a stunning report that the Giants were prepared to hire Josh McDaniels if they couldn't land Harbaugh.
Could Alex Rodriguez actually become the next Yankees manager? A caller floats the idea of replacing Aaron Boone with A-Rod or a member of the Core Four, sparking a debate about whether Rodriguez could succeed in the dugout. Evan Roberts believes A-Rod could be a good manager but explains why his fractured relationship with the Yankees makes a reunion nearly impossible. Plus, another hilarious edition of Posted and Toasted uncovers some outrageous old tweets from WFAN personalities, leaving Tiki Barber guessing who said what. Shaun Morash also finds himself in the hot seat when a listener calls out his biased Fan Focus updates. Evan questions whether Shaun is taking too many shots at rival teams, leading to a spirited argument about fandom, entertainment, and whether sports updates should be objective.
CC Sabathia delivers a brutal assessment of the Yankees, claiming the franchise has lost its championship standards because former legends are no longer around the clubhouse. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether bringing back championship veterans could restore the winning mentality, while questioning what the Yankees really need to get back on top. The conversation turns to Brian Cashman's decision not to pursue Freddie Freeman more aggressively and whether that mistake cost the Yankees a franchise-altering presence. Plus, Aaron Boone's constant lineup changes come under fire as the crew questions the Yankees' reliance on platoons, questionable roster construction, and lack of consistency. With fans demanding change and Alex Rodriguez calling for a philosophical shift, the pressure continues to mount on the Yankees' leadership.
Did Kyle Hamilton just take a shot at John Harbaugh? The Ravens safety suggests Baltimore would have lost its latest close game under the previous regime, sparking a heated debate over whether he's criticizing his former coach. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate Hamilton's comments and whether Harbaugh's departure was actually the best thing for both the Ravens and Giants. Then the conversation turns to the Yankees, where frustration over another championship-less season has fans demanding change. Evan and Tiki want Aaron Boone fired but believe Brian Cashman deserves to stay, while Shaun argues the entire operation needs a fresh start. The crew launches a fan poll, debates whether consistent regular-season success means anything without a World Series title, and makes some wild predictions about just how much longer Cashman could remain in charge.
Rays fans take the heat after attendance drops for an ALCS game against Cleveland, giving Evan Roberts all the ammunition he needs after Tampa Bay supporters insisted Yankees fans weren’t driving the crowds. Evan calls the turnout embarrassing and says the contrast proves exactly who was filling the building when New York was in town. The conversation then turns to Aaron Judge’s call for the Yankees to go “all in.” Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate what that actually means for a team without an obvious 2009-style free-agent shopping spree available. Could it mean spending huge on the best talent available, changing the manager, or something else entirely? They also push back on criticism questioning how much Judge cares about winning.
Sean McVay’s conservative overtime approach leaves Evan Roberts frustrated after the Rams give Buffalo the chance to get two possessions. Evan says he has officially changed his mind on the NFL’s new overtime strategy and now wants the football first, while Tiki Barber argues the bigger issue is whether coaches stay aggressive after making that choice. The conversation then swings back to the Yankees as callers admit Cleveland’s success against Tampa Bay reopened old wounds. Shaun Morash argues the Guardians showed an urgency the Yankees lacked in October, while Evan pushes back on using one Cleveland outburst as proof that New York’s entire offensive approach is broken.
Aaron Boone’s Game 3 lineup decision is still infuriating Evan Roberts, who calls leading off Trent Grisham a fireable offense and wonders whether Hal Steinbrenner could ultimately overrule Brian Cashman on Boone’s future. Shaun Morash is just as frustrated, arguing Yankees fans deserve answers instead of another delayed press conference filled with familiar explanations. The bigger battle centers on Cashman. Morash says nearly three decades under the same general manager is enough and wants a fresh set of eyes before another young Yankees core falls short. Evan pushes back hard, crediting Cashman for rebuilding the roster with promising young talent and arguing that firing him now would be the wrong move.
WFAN presents a roundup of reaction to the Jets' 13–10 victory over the Cleveland Browns from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The hosts highlight David Bailey's three-sack performance, the defense racking up eight total sacks, and Braelon Allen capitalizing on a botched punt snap. Plus, a look at pre-snap penalty concerns ahead of the New England matchup. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
WFAN presents a compilation of analysis surrounding the Giants' 23–23 overtime tie with the Washington Commanders from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The shows break down Jameis Winston stepping in for Michael Penix Jr. to lead a second-half rally, Malik Nabers' key catches, Abdul Carter's defensive presence, and whether escaping Washington with a tie feels like a win. That and more on Best Of Giants on WFAN!
The Giants lost, won, lost, but then tied and we dissect how to feel about it. Plus the Jets save their season with a win over the red hot Browns.
The Giants somehow escaped Washington with a tie that felt like a win after trailing for nearly the entire game and watching the Commanders botch their chance to win in overtime. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Jayden Daniels’ costly late-game mistake, the Giants’ relentless comeback and why gaining ground in the NFC East makes this tie worth celebrating. Jameis Winston’s huge second half strengthens his grip on the quarterback job, while the J.J. McCarthy package raises questions about unnecessary disruption. Plus, Cam Skattebo’s overtime fumble highlights a troubling ball-security problem, Dominic Zvada struggles through three missed field goals, and Tiki digs into why the Giants’ running game failed for most of the afternoon.
The Jets survived an ugly, rainy battle with Cleveland, and David Bailey delivered a superstar performance when they needed it most. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber praise a defense that carried the Jets to a 17-12 win while questioning Frank Reich’s decision to repeatedly move away from Braelon Allen and Garrett Wilson. The officiating also comes under fire after several controversial calls and non-calls. The Giants’ wild tie with Washington still feels like a win to Evan, especially after their late comeback improved their position in the NFC East. Evan and Tiki also debate Cam Skattebo’s fumbling, Jameis Winston’s uneven play, John Harbaugh’s late-game decisions and whether Jim Harbaugh and Dan Quinn are already facing serious pressure.
The Jets finally have something to build on after beating Cleveland, but Joe Benigno says the real test comes next against New England. Joe joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to praise David Bailey’s three-sack breakout, Braelon Allen’s bruising performance and a defense that repeatedly bailed out the offense. They also hammer the Jets’ constant penalties and debate whether Aaron Glenn can turn one ugly win into a legitimate season. The Giants suddenly have real NFC East hopes after their tie with Washington, with Joe boldly predicting a 9-7-1 finish and a division title. Evan and Tiki also debate the NFL’s overtime strategy, run through the biggest results around the league and examine Frank Reich’s handling of Braelon Allen and an offense repeatedly derailed by penalties.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber evaluate Jameis Winston's impact on the Giants and the team's playoff potential amidst a smoke and mirrors debate. On WFAN, they compare the elite production of Malik Nabers and Garrett Wilson while breaking down Demario Davis' claim of a historic Jets victory over the Browns.(00:01:50) J.J. McCarthy Packages(00:05:35) Giants Playoff Viability Debate(00:08:45) Ball Security Techniques(00:12:30) Skattebo Fumble Analysis(00:16:25) Malik Nabers vs Garrett Wilson(00:20:30) Jets Defensive Impact(00:26:15) 1997 Giants Tie Trivia(00:34:10) Demario Davis Historic Claim(00:38:30) Rams Bills MNF Predictions(00:43:30) Dan Quinn Coaching Criticism
The Giants keep forcing JJ McCarthy into the offense, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are struggling to understand why. With Jameis Winston playing well, the McCarthy packages felt predictable, disrupted the offense and even contributed to a delay of game. Tiki argues that if the Giants insist on using McCarthy, they need to make defenses respect him as an actual passing threat. Cam Skattebo’s overtime fumble also comes under the microscope, with Tiki explaining exactly how the rookie needs to protect the football in critical situations. Then the Garrett Wilson versus Malik Nabers debate returns after both receivers delivered big performances. Evan gives Wilson the season-long edge, while Tiki narrowly awards this week to Nabers after his huge game-tying contribution.
Shaun Morash takes center stage for Cinco de Luncho, running through the five biggest stories from a chaotic NFL Sunday. The Packers embarrass Chicago, Fernando Mendoza gets his first NFL action, Philadelphia blows a game in London, and San Francisco survives Seattle in a thriller. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber jump in throughout as Shaun delivers his rapid-fire tour around the league, with Nick Sirianni taking full responsibility for a costly late-game decision and the NFC picture continuing to shift around the Giants. The segment mixes serious NFL fallout with the usual Cinco de Luncho chaos as the crew reacts to the biggest winners, losers and head-scratching moments of the week.
Joe Benigno is encouraged by the Jets’ ugly win over Cleveland, but he says beating the Patriots would completely change the conversation around Aaron Glenn’s team. Joe joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to praise David Bailey’s breakout, the Jets defense and Braelon Allen while hammering the constant penalties that continue to put the offense behind schedule. Joe also explains why he has been so demanding of Bailey and why he expects greatness from the young pass rusher. The conversation shifts to the Giants’ tie with Washington, Dan Quinn’s disastrous late-game management and why Joe believes the Giants have a legitimate chance to win the NFC East.
Cam Skattebo’s ball security becomes the biggest Giants concern after another fumble in a critical moment. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the rookie officially has a problem yet, how the Giants could adjust their running back rotation, and why Tiki believes correcting the issue comes down to repetition and technique. Tyrone Tracy also earns praise for both protecting the football and immediately supporting Skattebo after the mistake. John Harbaugh’s late-game strategy also gets a closer look after he repeatedly chose extra points instead of following the NFL trend of going for two while chasing a 14-point deficit. Evan and Tiki debate whether the Giants’ personnel, red-zone struggles and rainy conditions made the conservative approach the smarter call.
Evan Roberts unloads on the officiating in the Jets’ win over Cleveland, pointing to several calls and non-calls that he believes went heavily against New York. From a missed hit on Geno Smith to questionable pass interference decisions, Evan calls the performance one-sided and incompetent, while Tiki Barber agrees the Jets had legitimate reasons to be furious. The Jets still found a way to survive, and David Bailey was a huge reason why. Evan and Tiki break down Bailey’s three-sack breakout, the schematic adjustment that created favorable one-on-one matchups, and why his performance offered real hope for the defense. They also react to Jim Harbaugh’s bleak postgame message and Evan’s interest if the Chargers coach ever became available.
David Bailey and the Jets defense rescued a game that felt dangerously close to slipping away. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the ugly 17-12 win over Cleveland, with Bailey dominating as a pass rusher and Braelon Allen pounding the Browns on the ground. Evan celebrates simply surviving while ripping Frank Reich for repeatedly moving away from Allen and struggling to keep Garrett Wilson involved. The conversation then shifts to the Giants, where Evan refuses to treat their tie with Washington like a disappointment. After rallying from 14 points down late, the Giants improved their position in the NFC East, giving Evan every reason to call it a “win tie.”
Skattebo had the Giants marching toward a potential overtime victory before his aggressive running style finally burned him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Skattebo’s costly fumble, his growing ball-security problem and why protecting the football had to matter more than fighting for another yard in that situation. The focus then shifts to the Giants’ struggling running game and the questionable use of J.J. McCarthy. Tiki explains what went wrong with the blocking and play selection, while Evan questions why the Giants repeatedly inserted McCarthy when Jameis Winston was finding his rhythm. Plus, the rainy conditions contributed to a frustrating day for the Giants’ receivers.
The Giants had countless chances to lose, yet somehow walked out of Washington gaining ground in the NFC East. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why this was a rare “win-tie” after the Giants erased a 14-point deficit, survived critical fourth downs and watched the Commanders completely mismanage the final seconds of overtime. Jayden Daniels’ decision to take a sack with no timeout remaining becomes the centerpiece of a stunning finish, with Evan and Tiki questioning whether Daniels and Dan Quinn even understood their timeout situation. They also credit the Giants for refusing to quit and making crucial second-half adjustments that gave them a chance to escape a game they appeared destined to lose.
The Giants escaped Washington with a tie that somehow felt like a win. After trailing for 93 percent of regulation, missing three field goals and nearly giving the game away in overtime, the Giants survived thanks to a stunning late-game collapse by Jayden Daniels and the Commanders. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate just how happy Giants fans should be after the wild finish, while Jameis Winston’s brilliant second half makes a strong case for keeping him firmly in control of the offense. Plus, Dominic Zvada’s rough afternoon, Cameron Skattebo’s costly overtime fumble and the Giants’ continued fight all factor into one conclusion: not all ties are created equal.
The Giants suddenly are in the driver's seat for a division title, and Evan Roberts says the NFC East is there for the taking, starting on Sunday against the Commanders. Plus, Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to talk about Jameis Winston and Geno Smith, and how they can both improve on Sunday. As for Geno, if he struggles against Cleveland, could the noise grow for Cade Klubnik to get a look? Evan and Tiki debate that possibility.
The Yankees season ends in another early playoff exit, and our hosts have A LOT to say about the team's performance in the ALDS and what should happen next. Evan Roberts loses it over Aaron Boone's decision to bat Trent Grisham leadoff, calling it a fireable offense. Callers flood the phone lines to Boomer and Gio demanding a leadership shakeup. Chris McMonigle says the Grisham decision was Boone's worst ever as Yankee manager. All of that and much more Yankee ranting after elimination day.
Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti: Cowboys and Eagles panic meter, Bryce Young resurgence, Week 5 Picks, Quarter season awards, plus more!
From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans return back to the Audacy airwaves to breakdown everything we've learned in the NFL through the first four weeks of the season. Stink pumps the brakes on Brock Purdy for MVP. Then, they preview the Eagles/Jags matchup in London and talk about the "battle of the struggling QB's." They end the podcast with #QuestionMark.
The Fellas are back for a final Yankees fan therapy session as the Bronx Bombers fail once again to get the job done. It’s been 10 years of the NYYST Podcast and 10 years of heartbreak.
The Giants suddenly are alive realistically for a division title after that Cowboys loss, plus the Jets simply cannot lose Sunday. That and much more on a Football Friday
The Giants’ NFC East dream suddenly looks real after the Cowboys’ stunning home loss. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash examine how Dallas’ flaws, Philadelphia’s offensive line problems and the Giants’ 3-1 start have transformed the division into what could be a race to nine wins. A victory in Washington could give the Giants even more control, while John Harbaugh’s coaching continues to fuel belief that this team can survive without Jaxson Dart. The quarterback situation remains fascinating. Tiki explains why rushing Dart back would make no sense, while the crew debates whether Harbaugh could unexpectedly turn to J.J. McCarthy if Jameis Winston struggles. Plus, the Yankees’ Trent Grisham decision remains impossible to defend, Richard Sherman raises eyebrows with his Joey Porter Jr. speculation, and Evan makes a surprising prediction for the Jets against Cleveland.
The Jets have reached a must-win moment against Cleveland, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Aaron Glenn’s team can rebound from its ugly loss to Chicago. Evan feels surprisingly confident, but Glenn’s 4-17 record looms over everything, especially after his old comments about head coaches owning the final four minutes resurfaced while the Jets continue to fail in those exact situations. The hour also turns to Jerry Jones’ desperate win-now approach with the Cowboys, Anthony Rizzo revealing how quickly New York pressure can overwhelm Yankees players, and why Rizzo believes Luis Arraez could provide exactly what the Yankees lineup is missing.
The Jets desperately need a win against Cleveland, and another ugly performance could turn MetLife Stadium against Aaron Glenn. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why this matchup feels like a must-win, why Jets fans still believe they can salvage the season, and how the Giants can seize control of the NFC East against Washington. The Knicks are putting Karl-Anthony Towns contract talks on hold, raising questions about how far they should go to keep their championship core together. Plus, the crew revisits their wildly inaccurate Yankees preseason predictions, debates the Giants’ biggest opportunity of the season, and remembers Bears legend Mike Ditka.
Evan and Tiki analyze Jim Harbaugh's NFL track record and debate whether the Chargers' offensive scheme is holding back Justin Herbert. They compare the growth of the Knicks to the stagnation of the Yankees while addressing Evan's lack of championships as a New York fan. The crew also reviews the mysterious injury to Adonai Mitchell and closes with their Week 5 NFL predictions. (00:01:50) Harbaugh's Winning Record (00:06:10) Knicks vs Yankees Trajectories (00:11:20) Todd Bowles Decision Critique (00:16:40) Adonai Mitchell's Finger Injury (00:20:45) Jayden Daniels Injury Status (00:26:55) Idiots With Idioms (00:32:10) Alexis Lafrenière Window Seat (00:38:20) Week 5 NFL Picks
The Jets are running out of room for mistakes, and their matchup with Cleveland has become a must-win if they want any hope of a competitive season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why falling to 1-4 would be an unmitigated disaster, especially after the Jets already blew a winnable game against Green Bay and looked completely noncompetitive against Chicago. The crew also looks at the Giants’ golden opportunity to grab control of the NFC East against Washington and debates the NFL’s biggest must-win games of the weekend. Plus, they remember Mike Ditka after his passing, from the unforgettable 1985 Bears to his success as a player and coach and the infamous Ricky Williams trade.
The Knicks are shutting down extension talks for now, putting Karl-Anthony Towns’ contract situation on hold as they focus on defending their championship. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how New York should handle KAT, including the danger of his $62 million player option and whether the Knicks should eventually be willing to trade him rather than pay that number. Evan wants the Knicks to play hardball without sacrificing their chance to win another title, arguing that a deadline trade would be crazy. The conversation also touches on Josh Hart and Deuce McBride’s contract situations, trust in Leon Rose and the lingering concern that ownership could influence how aggressively the Knicks spend.
Jets fans haven’t given up yet, and Sunday’s home game against Cleveland feels like their chance to finally get rewarded. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why the matchup remains a surprisingly strong ticket despite bad weather and a 1-3 start, while warning that another ugly performance could unleash loud boos and even calls for Aaron Glenn’s job. The Giants also enter a massive divisional matchup against Washington with reasons for confidence. Tiki points to their special teams advantage, improving secondary and the need for a stronger pass rush, while Evan believes the ugly weather could actually play directly into the Giants’ hands.
Anthony Rizzo offers a revealing look at what it feels like to walk into the Yankees’ pressure cooker. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Rizzo admitting the intensity hit him immediately after his trade to New York and debate whether that pressure helps explain why the Yankees so often come up small in the biggest moments. Rizzo also pushes back on the idea that every Yankees season should still be labeled World Series or bust. Rizzo then identifies Luis Arraez as the type of contact hitter the Yankees need, sparking frustration over why such an obvious fit has repeatedly been ignored. The conversation also touches on Joel Embiid calling himself an easy target after Mike Breen’s report involving LeBron James.
Aaron Glenn once said the final four minutes belong to the head coach, and now that standard is coming back on him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into the Jets’ brutal late-half execution, whether Frank Reich deserves more of the blame, and why Glenn still has to own the failures of his coaching staff. With a 4-17 record through 21 games, Evan says there simply isn’t evidence yet that Glenn is a good head coach. The conversation also contrasts Reich taking responsibility for the Jets’ offensive struggles with Lions defensive coordinator Kelvin Sheppard defending his calls, while Sean Payton taking play-calling duties back from Davis Webb sparks a full-circle coaching discussion. Jerry Jones’ aggressive approach and the massive price Dallas paid for Quinnen Williams also come under scrutiny.
Evan Roberts has a surprising feeling about the Jets: they’re going to beat Cleveland. Despite the embarrassment against Chicago, Evan believes the Browns are vulnerable, Geno Smith can bounce back, and Frank Reich must make Garrett Wilson a priority again. But the stakes are enormous for Aaron Glenn, who desperately needs a meaningful win to strengthen his case for another season. Evan and Tiki Barber also rip Todd Bowles’ late fourth-down decision against Dallas and debate how the Giants will keep finding different ways to win each week. The hour then turns somber with the news that NFL legend Mike Ditka has died at 86.
The Giants are 3-1 and suddenly alive in the NFC East, but respect still has to be earned. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash explain why the Giants remain underdogs against Washington, why skepticism could linger for weeks and how John Harbaugh has given this team a toughness that keeps them winning despite major injuries. The biggest question is Jameis Winston. Tiki believes the Giants have to trust his fearless style, while Evan says his real confidence comes from Harbaugh and the team around the quarterback. Plus, the crew revisits the Yankees’ indefensible Trent Grisham decision, and Evan closes with an unexpected burst of confidence that the Jets will beat Cleveland.
The Giants’ quarterback situation could get unpredictable fast. Tiki Barber explains why bringing Jaxson Dart back late in the season would be too risky, even if the Giants reach the playoffs, while Evan Roberts wonders whether John Harbaugh could suddenly turn to J.J. McCarthy if Jameis Winston starts unraveling. The conversation also turns to Dallas after Richard Sherman questions whether Joey Porter Jr. was really too sick to play. Evan and Tiki push back on the speculation before returning to the Giants’ growing NFC East hopes and the biggest reason Evan believes in them: Harbaugh’s coaching advantage over Cowboys head coach Brian Schottenheimer.
The Cowboys’ shocking home loss has completely changed the NFC East picture, and the Giants suddenly have a legitimate path to the division title. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down Dallas’ costly mistakes, Philadelphia’s mounting problems and why nine wins could now be enough to take the East. With the Giants sitting at 3-1, Sunday’s matchup in Washington has become enormous. A win could create real separation inside the division and turn what recently felt like wishful thinking into a serious playoff push. Shaun admits his outlook has changed, even as Jaxson Dart’s injury leaves him wondering how big this season could have been.
Evan and Hoff give their ratings for every position player to step on the field this season for the New York Mets.
The Yankees are eliminated once again and it feels the same as it does every October. A Fan interference call is being way over blown, and Trent Grisham frustrates us all.
Aaron Boone’s decision to lead off Trent Grisham in the Yankees’ season-ending loss sends Evan Roberts over the edge. Evan calls the move a “fireable offense,” while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash examine how Grisham ended up taking the final at-bat of the season and whether Boone or Brian Cashman deserves the blame. The bigger problem is impossible to ignore: without Aaron Judge, the Yankees simply weren’t good enough offensively. The crew also debates the fan interference call that wiped away Anthony Volpe’s apparent game-tying homer, defends the fan who reached over the wall, and looks at the troubling postseason pattern that continues to haunt the Yankees under Boone.
Aaron Judge wants the Yankees to go “all in,” and his pointed comments after another crushing postseason exit put Brian Cashman and the front office on notice. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Judge believes the Yankees have done enough to build a championship team and whether Aaron Boone has finally run out of chances after another October filled with bad defense and offensive failure. They also break down Max Fried’s uneven elimination-game start, Jazz Chisholm’s frustration with being booed and why his Yankees tenure appears finished. Plus, the Yankees’ promising young core offers some hope, but the biggest question remains whether this organization can actually make the changes necessary to produce a different ending in 2027.
The Yankees’ season is over after three straight losses to Tampa Bay, and the biggest offseason priority is clear: this lineup has to make more contact. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine the Yankees’ strikeout problem, why Luis Arraez could be the perfect addition, and whether Brian Cashman should reshape the offense around contact hitters while keeping the pitching foundation intact. Aaron Boone’s future also comes under fire after another disappointing postseason exit, with the looming lockout potentially complicating any managerial change. Plus, the crew revisits the controversial fan interference play, grades the station’s Yankees-Rays predictions, and ranks which New York teams are now closest to a championship.
Evan and Tiki vent their frustrations over the Yankees' disappointing postseason sweep by the Rays, focusing on questionable managerial decisions by Aaron Boone. They debate the team's reliance on home runs versus the Rays' superior fundamental play and discuss the uncertain futures of Brian Cashman and several free agents. (00:01:50) Boone's Management Blunders (00:04:48) Rays Exploit Defensive Miscues (00:07:18) Grisham Leadoff Analytics Critique (00:09:48) Boone and Cashman Future (00:12:20) Rebuilding for Postseason Success (00:14:58) MLB Strike Zone Challenges (00:19:50) Thursday Night Football Preview (00:20:58) George Steinbrenner Legacy (00:22:33) Braves Eliminated & Acuna (00:23:20) Yankees Free Agent Decisions (00:26:55) Postseason Performance Samples (00:32:20) MLB Labor Negotiations Update (00:43:00) Thursday Night Football Picks
The Yankees are done after three straight losses to the Rays, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the lasting memory won't be controversial fan interference or defensive mistakes. It'll be an offense that failed when it mattered most. A caller who witnessed the disputed home run firsthand describes the chaos at Yankee Stadium, while Evan and Tiki defend the fan who was removed and question why he should face any punishment. Then Shaun Morash unveils his updated rankings of New York's five men's teams closest to a championship, and things get heated. The Knicks take the top spot, but Shaun putting the Rangers second, Giants third and Yankees fourth sparks a fierce debate. Are the Rangers really closer to a title than the Yankees? How much does Jaxson Dart's injury hurt the Giants' chances? And could a looming baseball lockout completely alter the championship picture?
Evan Roberts takes a victory lap after being the only one in the group to pick Tampa Bay over the Yankees, while Tiki Barber, Shaun Morash and the rest of WFAN’s Yankees believers have to answer for their failed predictions. The crew also revisits the bizarre fan interference moment and whether the overturned home run actually changed the outcome. Then the focus returns to Aaron Boone’s future. With a potential lockout complicating a managerial change and Alex Cora potentially available down the road, the Yankees could have another reason to stick with Boone for now. The debate turns to who could realistically replace him, including Carlos Beltran and other fresh alternatives.
The Yankees need a new offensive identity after another crushing postseason exit. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into a decade of American League results showing just how important avoiding strikeouts has been to reaching the World Series, and why the Yankees must prioritize hitters who consistently put the ball in play. Luis Arraez emerges as an obvious target who could bring elite contact to the lineup, while the Yankees also need to solve their positional logjams and find stability around Aaron Judge, Ben Rice and their young talent. Plus, Aaron Boone’s future remains under scrutiny, but a looming lockout could make replacing him far more complicated than it seems.
Jazz Chisholm’s Yankees tenure appears headed for an ugly ending after a disastrous season and postseason. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to Chisholm questioning why Yankees fans booed him during the elimination loss and explain why his response shows he still doesn’t fully understand the expectations that come with playing in New York. Once one of the Yankees’ most exciting players, Chisholm struggled badly enough to lose his starting spot in the biggest game of the season. Evan says he wouldn’t even give Jazz a qualifying offer, while the conversation turns toward what must change for the Yankees in 2027 and whether Aaron Boone can deliver a different message to a promising young core.
Aaron Boone gets an endorsement from Aaron Judge, but Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash still see a manager who looks overmatched when the Yankees face baseball’s best teams in October. Judge credits Boone for navigating a season filled with injuries, while the debate continues over whether simply reaching the postseason is enough to justify keeping him. Max Fried also comes under the microscope after an elimination-game start that was better than his final line but still ended with four runs allowed and a loss. The conversation turns to the Yankees’ bullpen, the growing desperation of the fan base and a promising young core featuring Ben Rice, George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones that could finally give New York something different to build around.
Aaron Judge is putting pressure on the Yankees after another brutal postseason exit. The captain says he expects Brian Cashman and the front office to go “all in,” and his hesitation when asked whether they’ve done enough speaks volumes. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down Judge’s message and why his championship window and Yankees legacy are becoming impossible to ignore. The focus then turns to Aaron Boone, with Shaun declaring it’s simply time for a change despite the complications of a looming lockout. After another October ending with poor defense and a disappearing offense, the Yankees have become stunningly predictable, leaving fans wondering how much longer the organization can accept the same result.
The Yankees’ postseason failures are becoming painfully predictable. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash examine the damning pattern under Aaron Boone: when the Yankees have home-field advantage, they advance, but when they face a higher-seeded opponent, their season ends. The conversation also turns toward Brian Cashman and whether the Yankees’ playoff results are really as random as he has suggested. Then Anthony Volpe’s apparent game-tying home run creates chaos at Yankee Stadium. After replay ruled spectator interference and awarded Volpe an RBI double, the crew debates whether the ball would have cleared the wall and strongly pushes back against fans blaming the spectator for the Yankees’ loss.
The Yankees scored just five runs and collected 12 hits in their three-game playoff exit, forcing a painful question about whether this lineup simply wasn’t good enough without Aaron Judge. Evan Roberts points to the brutal numbers without Judge and admits the offensive collapse shouldn’t have been nearly as surprising as it felt. The conversation then shifts from Aaron Boone’s Trent Grisham decision to a much bigger organizational problem. Shaun Morash argues the Yankees repeatedly stick with struggling players in crucial moments, while Evan and Tiki Barber examine a roster that now needs Ben Rice, George Lombard Jr. and other young players to develop into stars as Judge gets older.
Aaron Boone’s decision to lead off Trent Grisham has Evan Roberts furious after the Yankees’ season-ending loss. With Grisham struggling at the plate, Evan calls the lineup decision a “fireable offense” and argues the Yankees essentially lost the game before the first pitch by giving one of their worst hitters an extra plate appearance. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash join the debate over Grisham’s role, including the decision to let him keep hitting late in the game before he ultimately made the final out of the Yankees’ season. The frustration goes beyond one at-bat as the crew questions why Boone and the Yankees continue trusting struggling players in the biggest postseason moments.
The Yankees wake up today needing to go 1-0 to survive until Thursday. Odell signs elsewhere, the Jets AD Mitchell mystery continues, and much more.
The Yankees are down 0-2 to the Rays, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash demand changes with the season on the line. Aaron Boone cannot simply run back the same lineup after two ugly losses, sparking a debate over sitting Jazz Chisholm and Trent Grisham while turning to Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Heliot Ramos for a desperately needed spark. Evan also floats an extreme way to get Aaron Judge back on the postseason roster, while Shaun finds renewed hope after nearly giving up on the season. Plus, Max Fried vows to make his Game 3 start regardless of what happens with the expected birth of his child, leading Evan, Tiki and Shaun into a revealing debate over choosing between a career-defining game and being there for childbirth.
The Yankees’ ugly Game 2 loss ignites a heated debate over where it ranks among the franchise’s most embarrassing postseason performances. Evan argues that the 2024 World Series collapse will ultimately sting far more, while the conversation turns to lineup changes, Aaron Judge’s mysterious injury status and whether the Yankees could use an injury replacement to get him onto the roster. The Jets also enter unfamiliar territory as favorites against the Browns, putting even more pressure on Aaron Glenn to finally deliver a meaningful win. The crew examines Glenn’s repeated game-management problems, when the Jets might turn to Cade Klubnik and why firing Glenn during the season still makes little sense. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. lands with Minnesota, the Giants protect another quarterback on their 53-man roster, and the sports-versus-childbirth debate gets wildly personal.
Curtis Granderson joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber with the Yankees facing elimination and explains why New York pressure is real, why Tampa has been such a difficult environment for the Yankees and how they can finally wake up their struggling offense. Granderson also weighs in on Aaron Judge’s absence and delivers a verdict Mets fans will love: in his postseason experience, Citi Field was louder than Yankee Stadium. The focus then shifts to the Yankees’ must-win Game 3, with Max Fried under pressure to set the tone and Aaron Boone needing to push the right buttons. Plus, Tiki reflects on Lane Johnson’s sudden retirement as the Eagles take another major hit, opening the door even wider in a chaotic NFC East.
Tiki and Evan react to Eli Manning’s confirmation that Arch Manning would be open to playing for the New York Jets if drafted. They also address the New York Yankees' struggles with hitting and fielding as the team faces a potential sweep in Game 3 against the Tampa Bay Rays. (00:01:50) NY Fan Energy and Eagles Trade (00:06:04) Yankee Culture and Management (00:10:42) Giants Identity and Winning Ugly (00:14:35) LeBron James vs. Mike Breen (00:19:41) Yankees Facing Elimination (00:26:12) Sports Rivalry Trolling (00:32:15) Eli Manning on Arch Manning (00:38:37) Game 3 Final Predictions
LeBron James is pushing back on a story Mike Breen shared about Joel Embiid being late to practice, turning what sounded like praise for LeBron’s leadership into a bizarre controversy. Evan Roberts believes Breen’s account and argues that LeBron may be denying the story for a noble reason: protecting Embiid from criticism. Tiki Barber sees another possibility, that Breen was simply given bad information by his source. The debate becomes whether LeBron’s denial actually proves his leadership in a different way, with Evan arguing that he’s willing to absorb the controversy rather than let it fall on Embiid. Plus, the Yankees face elimination after two brutal offensive performances, Alex Cora passes on the Phillies job, and Rangers-Islanders trash talk heats up.
Lane Johnson’s sudden retirement delivers another massive blow to an Eagles team already dealing with injuries and instability. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why walking away from football is such a personal decision, with Tiki recalling the moment during his own final season when he knew he was finished but never considered retiring immediately. Johnson’s departure also throws the NFC East even further into chaos. Philadelphia is weakened, Dallas has major defensive concerns and the Giants are sitting at 3-1 with a legitimate opportunity to contend for the division. Evan and Tiki debate whether the Giants can actually become the NFC East favorite and what they still need to prove before anyone fully buys in.
Curtis Granderson joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber with the Yankees facing elimination and explains why playing under New York pressure can weigh heavily on players. The former Yankee and Met says the Yankees need to loosen up, find a spark offensively and take their comeback one game at a time rather than thinking about winning three straight. Granderson also breaks down the challenges of playing on Tampa’s turf, Aaron Judge’s difficult road back from a calf injury and whether the Yankees should consider getting Judge onto the postseason roster. Plus, Granderson settles a New York baseball debate from his own experience, revealing that Citi Field was louder than Yankee Stadium during his postseason runs.
Aaron Glenn enters a critical spot with the Jets favored against Cleveland, their first game as favorites in nearly two years. Evan argues the Jets simply have to win if this season is going to mean anything, while the crew examines Glenn’s lack of a signature victory and why another loss could accelerate calls to see what Cade Klubnik can do at quarterback. The criticism of Glenn goes deeper than the record, with repeated game-management issues and his postgame uncertainty raising questions about whether he is improving as a head coach. The debate also turns to Frank Reich’s role and whether he could better support Glenn without a midseason firing. Plus, the Giants lose Braxton Berrios for the season and move Jake Haener onto the 53-man roster.
The Yankees’ disastrous Game 2 loss to Tampa Bay ignites a heated argument over whether it was really more embarrassing than their 2024 World Series collapse. Shaun Morash sides with the idea that this latest meltdown felt worse in the moment, while Evan Roberts argues that history will remember the World Series failure far more painfully. The infamous 2004 collapse against Boston also enters the debate. Then the focus turns to Aaron Judge and a growing mystery around his health. Evan questions whether Judge is more injured than the Yankees are admitting and examines whether the team could potentially use Giancarlo Stanton’s health issues to create a postseason roster opening if Judge becomes available.
The Yankees’ struggling lineup takes center stage as Evan, Tiki and Shaun Morash debate the changes needed to create an October spark. Anthony Volpe, Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Trent Grisham are all discussed as possible lineup casualties, while Ben Rice, Cody Bellinger and Austin Wells could take on bigger roles. Then the conversation goes completely off the rails over whether the birth of a child should ever lose out to a Super Bowl, with Tiki and Shaun defending the game while Evan strongly disagrees. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. joins the Vikings’ practice squad, the crew revisits the Giants’ late interception return and how gambling changes the way fans watch end-of-game decisions.
Max Fried is taking the ball with the Yankees’ season on the line, regardless of whether his girlfriend goes into labor. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to Fried’s firm commitment to his Game 3 start and debate one of sports’ toughest personal decisions: whether a player should ever miss the birth of a child for a postseason game. The conversation turns personal as Evan and Tiki share their own experiences around childbirth and work, while the Yankees remain at the center of everything. Despite an ugly 0-2 hole against the Rays, Evan argues the series is far from impossible to save, pointing to past Yankees teams that have successfully battled back from the same deficit.
The Yankees looked finished after falling behind 0-2 to the Rays, but the mood is starting to change before Game 3 at Yankee Stadium. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether there is still reason to believe, with Shaun going from wanting the season put out of its misery to embracing the possibility of a comeback. The focus remains on Aaron Boone making real changes. Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Heliot Ramos emerge as potential answers, while Trent Grisham’s health and Ryan McMahon’s struggles create difficult decisions. With the Yankees back home and their season at stake, the message is simple: change the lineup, find a spark and win one game to make this a series again.
The Yankees need a spark with their season on the line, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash agree Aaron Boone cannot simply run back the same lineup for Game 3 against the Rays. They debate sitting Jazz Chisholm, Ryan McMahon and Trent Grisham, while giving Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Heliot Ramos a chance to change the series. Then Evan takes the desperation to another level. With Aaron Judge off the roster, he argues the Yankees should find a way to create an opening and get their superstar back for a must-win game. Tiki wonders whether Judge’s injury is more serious than the Yankees have let on as their season reaches the brink.
In a end of the year Mailbag, Evan dives into your questions and comments. One of the biggest ones being "Was this the worst season ever"? P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠Breakingt.com/products/the-rico Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
It is a vent session for all Yankees fans after an inexplicable fundamental loss in Game 2.
The Yankees are staring at a 2-0 hole against the Rays after a stunning defensive meltdown that Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber struggle to explain. Four official errors, additional costly miscues and another lifeless offensive performance have the Yankees looking like a team that short-circuits when the postseason pressure rises. Evan and Tiki debate whether the turf played a role, how much responsibility belongs to Aaron Boone and whether the Yankees’ lack of accountability has become an organizational problem. With just five hits and two runs through two games, the offense is every bit as concerning as the defense. The series technically isn’t over, but after a loss this ugly, it certainly feels that way.
Mariano Rivera delivers a blunt message with the Yankees down 0-2 to Tampa Bay: the series isn’t over, but the mental mistakes have to stop. The Hall of Fame closer explains how the Yankees can fight back, why returning to Yankee Stadium matters and what separates physical errors from unacceptable mental miscues. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the Yankees’ lack of accountability after costly decisions from Austin Wells and Jazz Chisholm, and whether their recurring October problems point directly to Aaron Boone. They examine why the Yankees keep losing the same way in the postseason, whether pressure is exposing them and how much longer Boone can survive without getting this team over the top.
The Yankees’ defense melted down again in Tampa, leaving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering why the same fatal flaws keep resurfacing under Aaron Boone. Cam Schlittler delivered a fascinating postgame message, first saying the Yankees “didn’t show up” before taking the blame himself, while Tiki’s criticism of Boone’s lack of accountability from 2024 suddenly sounds just as relevant today. The hour also ranks the Yankees’ brutal defensive miscues, revisits their painful history of postseason near-miss home runs and debates whether this team can actually recover. Plus, John Harbaugh admits he regretted an aggressive two-point decision, Tiki celebrates his victory on The Weakest Link, and Shaun Morash delivers a bleak prediction for when the Yankees might win again.
Yankee fans are in a state of panic as the team falls into a 0-2 hole against Tampa, leading to radical suggestions for roster changes. Tiki and Sean weigh in on Aaron Boone's managerial decisions, the struggles of the offense, and whether Gerrit Cole or Carlos Rodón should lead the charge in a potential Game 4. They also explore the controversial idea of manipulating the injured list to get Aaron Judge back into the lineup for a do-or-die stretch. (00:01:50) Giants Wide Receiver Issues (00:05:30) Caller Slams Aaron Boone (00:08:35) Brian Cashman's Job Security (00:13:15) Alex Cora Managerial Rumors (00:20:50) Tri-State Sports Focus Update (00:26:30) Faking Injuries For Judge (00:34:15) Volpe Moving To Third (00:44:30) Schlittler Pitch Count Debate
Tiki Barber’s criticism of Aaron Boone from the Yankees’ 2024 World Series collapse sounds painfully familiar after another defensive disaster. Evan Roberts digs up Tiki’s old rant about accountability, and Tiki explains why it’s even more troubling that different Yankees keep making the same fundamental mistakes when the pressure is highest. Then Evan ranks all five defensive miscues from the latest playoff loss, from Jazz Chisholm’s disastrous throw and Austin Wells’ catcher’s interference to the George Lombard Jr. and Luis Arraez mistake that helped break the game open. Shaun Morash counters with his own bleak countdown of what could happen before the Yankees win another game, sparking plenty of Knicks and Rangers shots along the way.
John Harbaugh admits he immediately regretted the Giants’ early two-point attempt, validating Evan Roberts’ criticism of the decision and raising questions about how aggressive Harbaugh will be going forward. The conversation then takes a hilarious turn as Tiki Barber relives winning The Weakest Link and $97,500 for charity, along with the painful moment he blanked on Cast Away. The Yankees’ postseason heartbreak also comes back into focus after Cody Bellinger’s near grand slam. Evan runs through an incredible collection of playoff home runs that missed by mere feet, including Gleyber Torres’ fan-interference double in Game 1 of the 2024 World Series, showing just how differently several Yankees postseason runs could have unfolded.
Cam Schlittler delivered a revealing message after the Yankees’ ugly playoff loss, first declaring that the team “didn’t show up” before walking it back and ultimately putting the blame on himself. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Schlittler’s comments and why the Yankees’ disastrous defense made his difficult outing even harder. The bigger concern is painfully familiar. The Yankees’ bats disappeared, their defense collapsed, and another postseason ending suddenly feels predictable. With callers questioning Aaron Boone and the team’s preparation, Evan and Tiki debate whether the Yankees can finally change the script or if the same weaknesses are about to end another season.
Tropicana Field takes center stage as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber rip a ballpark where catwalks can actually affect postseason baseball. Evan refuses to blame the stadium for the Yankees’ mistakes, but argues there’s no excuse for Major League Baseball to be playing October games under those conditions. The conversation then turns from the Trop to Tampa Bay’s fans, with Evan challenging them to fill the building again if the Rays advance. Meanwhile, the Yankees’ looming elimination raises an even bigger question: could another familiar October failure finally cost Aaron Boone his job? Brian Cashman appears far safer, but running it back only to suffer the same postseason fate could force the Yankees to make a significant change.
Aaron Boone is facing a familiar and potentially damning problem: the Yankees keep losing the same way every October. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine whether Boone’s consistently good but never great tenure is finally approaching its expiration date as the Yankees sit on the brink against Tampa Bay. The pressure surrounding this Yankees team is nothing like the carefree 2017 run, and the results have become painfully predictable: quiet bats and costly defensive mistakes. Evan and Tiki debate whether coaching, preparation or the pressure of expectations explains the recurring failures, while a near-grand slam from Cody Bellinger becomes the moment that perfectly captures how quickly Game 2 slipped away.
Mariano Rivera knows exactly what it takes to escape an 0-2 postseason hole, and the Yankees legend believes this team can still fight its way back. But Rivera makes one thing clear: the mental mistakes have to stop. He explains why returning to Yankee Stadium could provide the spark the Yankees desperately need and questions whether they want it badly enough. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber then debate the costly decisions from Austin Wells and Jazz Chisholm and their refusal to admit they would handle those moments differently. Are the Yankees simply playing aggressively, or has desperation started producing the same damaging mistakes that keep haunting them?
The Yankees desperately need a vibe change, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber had the ultimate solution: Mariano Rivera. The plan was for the legendary Yankees closer to calm a panicked fan base and provide some hope with the team facing a 2-0 hole against Tampa Bay, but technical issues turned the attempted surprise into hilarious chaos. Once the Rivera plan falls apart, the conversation returns to the Yankees’ problems on the field. Callers question why Aaron Boone won’t make more drastic lineup changes, while Evan and Tiki debate whether moving players out of position would only make matters worse. With the Yankees struggling to hit and their defense suddenly collapsing, there are few easy solutions left.
The Yankees have managed just five hits and two runs through two games against the Rays, turning their 2-0 series deficit into much more than a defensive problem. After the offense exploded against Boston, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are stunned by how quickly the bats have disappeared with the season hanging in the balance. Yankees fans unload on Aaron Boone’s approach, questioning whether his public support of players has created a lack of accountability when costly mistakes keep happening. The bigger concern is an increasingly familiar postseason pattern: the Yankees beat teams they’re supposed to beat, but struggle when facing teams that proved better over the regular season. With elimination approaching, the pressure on Boone, Brian Cashman and the entire roster is only growing.
The Yankees completely unraveled defensively against the Rays, committing four official errors with several other ugly miscues in one of their worst postseason defensive performances. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber can’t explain how normally reliable defenders like Ryan McMahon and Luis Garcia suddenly failed to make routine plays, while Jazz Chisholm’s costly decision only added to the chaos. The meltdown brings back painful memories of the Yankees’ 2024 World Series defensive collapse and raises another uncomfortable question about Aaron Boone. With the Yankees now facing a 2-0 series deficit and needing three straight wins, Evan says the series isn’t technically over, but after a performance like this, it certainly feels that way.
WFAN presents a collection of discussions celebrating the Giants' 36-24 win over the Arizona Cardinals to take sole possession of first place in the NFC East, featuring Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The shows react to the full "Jameis Winston Experience," Deonte Banks’ game-clinching pick-six on 4th down, Theo Johnson’s touchdown, and Arvell Reese stepping up with Brian Burns sidelined. That and more on Best Of Giants on WFAN!
WFAN presents a collection of discussions reacting to the Jets' dismal 23-12 loss to the Chicago Bears from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. The guys react to mind-boggling stats—including Chicago running 89 plays and racking up 34 first downs while the Jets managed just 32 total plays—plus Frank Reich's questionable play-calling, Garrett Wilson only getting 4 targets, and whether Aaron Glenn can turn things around. That and more on Best Of Jets on WFAN!
It's that time of the year when there's no Mets baseball. So let's give out some awards. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
The Jets were unwatchable and the score didn't tell the story of a miserable day in Chicago. Plus the G Men go to first place for the first time since 2015.
The Jets have reached a new low. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber rip a lifeless, embarrassing performance in Chicago that left Evan convinced Aaron Glenn is not the answer. From 17 minutes of possession and a nonexistent offense to crushing penalties, missed tackles and Garrett Wilson disappearing from the game plan, the Jets looked completely hopeless. Glenn’s “I don’t know” response about Wilson only made matters worse. Evan explains why he still wouldn’t fire Glenn during the season, while Tiki breaks down how Chicago physically dominated the Jets and exposed their defense. Plus, the Bears call the game “easy” and “boring,” Woody Johnson’s endless coaching cycle comes under fire, and the Giants provide a painful reminder of what competent coaching can accomplish.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber evaluate the New York Yankees' must-win Game 2 against the Tampa Bay Rays and the high expectations for pitcher Cam Schlittler. They discuss the possibility of the New York Jets pursuing Mike Tomlin for their head coaching vacancy and react to an NFL official's unprofessional conduct toward Trey McBride. Additional topics include Odell Beckham Jr.'s release and betting picks for Monday Night Football.(00:01:50) Yankees Rays Game Preview(00:06:01) Yankees Lineup Strategy Debate(00:09:44) Luring Mike Tomlin To Jets(00:16:01) Cam Schlittler Ace Performance(00:20:33) Aaron Judge Roster Debate(00:23:50) Arvel Reese Defensive Impact(00:27:39) Official Yells At McBride(00:36:01) Odell Beckham Jr Reaction(00:39:40) MNF Saints Falcons Picks
The Giants are 3-1, alone in first place, and suddenly winning the kinds of games they used to give away. Jameis Winston delivered the full experience against Arizona, overcoming ugly interceptions with huge throws, while Deonte Banks sealed another dramatic win and John Harbaugh’s coaching continues to transform the Giants. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down Harbaugh’s game management, the defensive adjustments that changed the game, and the Giants’ suddenly electric home atmosphere. Plus, the running back rotation remains unsettled, Najee Harris gets benched after a fumble, and Evan makes a bold prediction that Tony Pollard could become a Giant before the trade deadline.
Aaron Glenn is under fire after another disastrous Jets performance, with Joe Benigno arguing the fan base has reached its breaking point and questioning how much longer Glenn can survive if the losing continues. The Jets’ penalties, nonexistent pass rush and offensive failures fuel a heated debate about whether Glenn has already proven he is not the answer and whether an experienced coach like Mike Tomlin, Rex Ryan or Jim Harbaugh could rescue the franchise. Plus, Karl-Anthony Towns says he and the Knicks are nowhere near an extension, the Giants sit atop the NFC East, and the biggest developments from Week 4 around the NFL take center stage.
The Yankees managed just one hit in their Game 1 loss to Tampa Bay, but Evan Roberts believes the anger toward Austin Wells is badly misplaced. Wells made an unacceptable baserunning mistake after breaking up the no-hit bid, yet the bigger problem was a lineup that produced virtually nothing. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate Wells, Aaron Boone’s decisions, Trent Grisham’s struggles and potential lineup changes for Game 2. Now the pressure shifts to Cam Schlittler against Freddy Peralta. A second straight loss could send Yankee fans into full-blown panic and crush the confidence surrounding the team. Plus, the crew weighs possible lineup changes and what it will take for the Yankees to even the series.
Aaron Glenn’s response to another Jets embarrassment only creates more frustration. After John Harbaugh pushed a “1-0” mentality with the Giants, Glenn delivers essentially the same message days later, leaving Evan unimpressed and reinforcing the growing belief that the Jets desperately need an established, successful head coach. The coaching conversation expands to Jim Harbaugh, Sean McDermott and Nick Sirianni as potential options if the Jets eventually move on from Glenn. Meanwhile, the Giants sit alone atop the NFC East, the Eagles suffer a costly collapse, and the NFL’s biggest Week 4 developments include the Patriots upsetting Buffalo, the 49ers rolling and surprising starts from the Raiders and Browns.
Aaron Glenn is running out of answers, and Joe Benigno believes the Jets coach could be fighting for his job. After another brutal performance filled with penalties, defensive breakdowns and an ineffective offense, Joe unloads on the state of the franchise and warns that a loss to Cleveland could push an already furious fan base over the edge. The conversation turns to what comes next if Glenn cannot stop the collapse. Joe makes the case for bringing Rex Ryan back, while Mike Tomlin, Jon Gruden and other experienced coaches emerge as potential answers. The biggest concern goes beyond the record: the Jets appear to be getting worse, and Garrett Wilson's frustration only adds to the fear that Glenn is losing control.
Jameis Winston’s mistakes are inevitable, but his ability to immediately bounce back may be exactly what the Giants need. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Winston actually played well against Arizona and why the good, bad and ugly of his game can still produce winning football. The Giants also have a major question developing at running back. Tiki explains why Tyrone Tracy still needs to regain the coaching staff’s trust, while the crowded rotation suggests their long-term bell cow may not currently be on the roster. Evan then delivers a bold prediction: Tony Pollard will become a Giant before the trade deadline.
John Harbaugh’s decision to chase two points before halftime sparks a debate over whether the Giants got unnecessarily aggressive against Arizona. The gamble ultimately didn’t cost them, but Evan Roberts questions why Harbaugh was chasing points so early while Tiki Barber sees the logic behind the decision. Then the Giants’ crowded backfield takes center stage. Najee Harris went from converting a crucial two-point attempt to fumbling on the next possession, and Harbaugh responded by giving Cam Skattebo the final seven carries. With Tyrone Tracy and Devin Singletary also fighting for roles, the Giants suddenly have some difficult decisions to make at running back.
Jameis Winston gave the Giants everything that comes with the Jameis Winston experience, throwing costly interceptions before delivering the huge plays they needed to beat Arizona 36-24. His response after the Cardinals retook the lead proved critical, while Deonte Banks sealed the win with a pick-six for his second straight game-changing defensive play. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash credit John Harbaugh and his staff for a Giants team that keeps finding ways to win despite not playing its best football. At 3-1 and alone in first place, the Giants have restored belief at MetLife, and their ability to adjust defensively has Evan convinced once again that coaching is the difference between winning and losing.
The Jets’ humiliation continued after the final whistle when Bears linebacker Devin Bush called the game one of the easiest he’s ever played and admitted he was actually bored. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber say the comments weren’t even trash talk, which only makes them more damning after the Jets barely kept Chicago’s defense on the field. The conversation turns to Woody Johnson and the Jets’ endless cycle of failed coaching hires. Evan argues Johnson needs to stop searching for the next unproven answer and spend whatever it takes to land an established, successful NFL head coach. The Giants provide the painful comparison, with Tiki pointing to their disciplined defense and Evan crediting John Harbaugh for transforming what competent coaching looks like in New York.
Jets fans are officially losing hope. Evan Roberts says he’s done believing Aaron Glenn can turn this around after another humiliating loss, but he strongly pushes back on firing Glenn during the season. With Frank Reich struggling to generate offense, Evan sees no benefit to another desperate midseason coaching change. The frustration extends to Garrett Wilson, who once again wasn’t maximized despite being the Jets’ biggest offensive weapon. Tiki Barber explains why the offense needs to manufacture touches for Wilson instead of waiting for opportunities to develop. As callers abandon their preseason optimism and the schedule threatens to make things even uglier, Evan believes the Jets are headed toward another brutal three or four-win season and, eventually, another search for a head coach.
The Jets look completely hopeless after an embarrassing performance in Chicago. Evan Roberts declares Aaron Glenn a “dead man walking” after watching the Jets get pushed around, miss tackles, commit costly penalties and barely possess the football. Tiki Barber’s film review only confirms how badly Chicago dominated Glenn’s defense. The offense was just as alarming. Garrett Wilson disappeared, Frank Reich’s game plan produced almost nothing, and the Jets ran only 29 offensive plays excluding sacks. Evan and Tiki also hammer Glenn for answering “I don’t know” when asked why Wilson wasn’t more involved, as another ugly loss raises serious questions about whether this season is already spiraling beyond repair.
The Giants released Odell Beckham Jr. after barely using him for three games. Our hosts react to the news and debate if there was ever any point of reuniting with OBJ in the first place. Plus, Evan and Tiki discuss the team's chances in the NFC East without Jaxson Dart, and if J.J. McCarthy has any chance of pushing Jameis Winston for the starting job. Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to talk all things Big Blue, including McCarthy and how he may be used the rest of this season.
The Yankees steamrolled the hated Red Sox in a two-game Wild Card Series sweep, and we have full reactions from all of our hosts, who were pleasantly surprised at how efficient the Yankee lineup was from top to bottom. Plus, debating whether or not Aaron Judge will play in the ALDS, how the Yankees will set up their rotation, and if the Bombers should be favored against the Rays. Meanwhile, Evan and Tiki feel like the Yanks were a little over the top in celebrating a Wild Card Series win, and Boomer and Gio debate which Yankee is likeliest to carry the team and be their new "Mr. October."
From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Boomer and Mike are back to talk all the headlines from week 3, another splashy Cowboys trade, Week 4 picks, Game of the Week, a QB Power Rankings and more!
Evan reads some emails reacting to episode 763 and David Stearns season ending press conference.
From 'NYYST' (subscribe here): The Fellas are back to discuss the recent sweep of the Red Sox in the WC series. A look ahead to preview the upcoming ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays.
This is time for Jameis Winston to prove his worth, Aaron Glenn needs his super powers, and the great Judge debate continues.
Jameis Winston is entering put-up-or-shut-up territory for the Giants. After weather and circumstances limited what could be learned from his first two appearances, Sunday against Arizona is viewed as the game that should finally reveal what Winston has left. If his arm and accuracy remain concerns, the conversation around J.J. McCarthy and when he could realistically take over will only get louder. The Jets also face what Evan calls the most important game of the Aaron Glenn era, with a loss to a Bears team starting a backup quarterback threatening to wipe away the optimism from last week. Plus, the Yankees face a major Aaron Judge decision, including whether he should return directly to right field rather than disrupt a lineup featuring Ben Rice and Luis Garcia.
Aaron Judge may not be 100 percent, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber see no justification for keeping him out of the Yankees lineup against Tampa Bay. They debate how Aaron Boone should handle Judge, why Ben Rice has emerged as a legitimate star, and how the Yankees’ ability to develop young players has separated them from the Mets. Gerrit Cole’s Game 1 start and the rest of the ALDS rotation also come into focus. The hour also hits the Giants’ challenge of winning with Jameis Winston and whether J.J. McCarthy could eventually fit Matt Nagy’s offense. Plus, Evan and Tiki react to Jack Hughes’ painfully awkward in-game interview, the Jets reach the point where encouraging signs need to become wins, and Shaun Morash deals with the possibility that his UPS driver saw far more than expected.
The Yankees’ ALDS matchup with the Rays has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber going in opposite directions. Tiki sees New York’s starting pitching and postseason experience carrying the Yankees in four, while Evan predicts Tampa Bay in four and warns that Gerrit Cole could put the Yankees in an immediate hole in Game 1. Shaun Morash lands on Yankees in five as the debate heats up over Cole versus Carlos Rodon. Aaron Judge’s role also looms over the series, with the guys weighing whether his presence alone makes the Yankees better and how carefully he should be used coming off injury. Plus, Tony Romo and CBS part ways, the Giants’ J.J. McCarthy gamble gets another look, and the Jets’ offensive line comes under fire.
Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts debate the validity of the current MLB playoff format and the logic behind a caller's demand to bench Aaron Judge for the division series. They analyze the Yankees' travel issues heading to Tampa and share their favorite moments from the movie Major League. Finally, they make their official Week 4 NFL picks for the Jets, Giants, and key national matchups. (00:01:52) MLB Playoff Bracket Debate (00:05:35) Yankees Playoff Series Benefits (00:09:23) Yankees Travel Plane Trouble (00:12:54) Selecting Your Playoff Opponent (00:19:21) Major League Movie Appreciation (00:22:54) NFL Week 4 Analysis (00:28:51) Benching Aaron Judge Debate (00:35:24) Idiots With Idioms Segment (00:39:52) Official NFL Week 4 Picks
MLB’s playoff format is under fire, with the Yankees’ path exposing why the bracket system and lack of reseeding can create frustrating matchups. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the flaws in the setup, why facing the Rays in a best-of-five could actually benefit the Yankees, and whether MLB could overhaul the postseason under a new CBA. The conversation turns to an even wilder possibility: letting the best teams choose their playoff opponents. Evan and Tiki imagine the drama, insults and incredible television that could follow from a live selection show. Plus, they discuss the Yankees’ pitching plans, Gerrit Cole’s importance and the team’s travel trouble getting to Tampa.
Aaron Judge’s ALDS role remains a major question as Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate how the Yankees should protect him coming off injury. One possibility is keeping Judge out of right field on Tampa Bay’s turf, using him as a dangerous bat off the bench before potentially returning him to the field at Yankee Stadium in Game 3. The Giants also face an interesting quarterback dynamic with Jameis Winston starting and J.J. McCarthy waiting behind him. Evan believes the crowd could turn quickly if Winston struggles. Plus, Shaun unveils his “Cinco de Ronco” list of the opponents New York fans could despise by the end of the weekend, including Ben Johnson, Trey McBride and Rays pitcher Drew Rasmussen.
Aaron Boone is trusting Gerrit Cole in Game 1, even though Evan Roberts argues the numbers clearly point to Carlos Rodon as the better matchup against Tampa Bay. Tiki Barber understands the gamble, saying Cole’s mentality, leadership and postseason résumé matter, but the decision could invite major criticism if the Yankees fall behind early. The conversation also shifts to the Giants’ bet on J.J. McCarthy and whether Matt Nagy and John Harbaugh can unlock a quarterback who never received a full opportunity in Minnesota. Plus, the guys revisit Henrik Lundqvist and Cam Talbot before debating the fallout from old social media posts surfacing after Braden Bell landed the Trail Blazers’ play-by-play job.
The Yankees’ ALDS showdown with the Rays sparks a sharp split as Evan Roberts picks Tampa Bay in four while Tiki Barber takes the Yankees in four and Shaun Morash goes Yankees in five. Evan’s biggest concern is Gerrit Cole in Game 1, arguing the matchup favors Carlos Rodon and warning that an early loss could set the tone for the entire series. Aaron Judge’s impact also becomes a major debate, with Evan and Tiki arguing that even a diminished Judge makes the Yankees more dangerous simply by being in the lineup. Plus, Tony Romo and CBS part ways, raising questions about whether Romo will continue broadcasting and where he could land next.
Jack Hughes’ awkward in-game interview becomes the biggest debate of the final stretch, as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber rip the plastic-cutlery joke and especially the follow-up shot about Hughes having “no sense of humor.” They explain why Hughes handled the uncomfortable moment about as well as he could before skating away. The conversation then turns to the Giants, including why J.J. McCarthy’s athleticism could fit Matt Nagy’s offense better than Jameis Winston. Plus, Shaun Morash reveals an embarrassing encounter involving his UPS driver, while the Jets face growing pressure to turn encouraging signs into actual wins before frustration starts building inside the locker room.
Aaron Judge wants back in the Yankees lineup, but his return creates a major ALDS dilemma. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether a compromised Judge is still an automatic start, where he should hit, and which productive Yankee could lose at-bats or force a defensive sacrifice. Ben Rice has become a star before their eyes, and Evan argues his emergence highlights the biggest difference between the Yankees and Mets: developing young talent that can rescue a season. Plus, Gerrit Cole gets Game 1 against Tampa Bay, Carlos Rodón could be lined up for Yankee Stadium, and the Giants prepare to lean on Jameis Winston after being forced into their backup quarterback plan.
Aaron Glenn is facing what Evan calls the most important game of his Jets tenure. After an encouraging performance against Detroit, the Jets now draw a Bears team expected to start a backup quarterback, leaving little room for excuses. A win could give the season real momentum, while a loss would send the Jets to 1-3 and raise serious questions about where Glenn’s team is headed. Tiki breaks down the chess match between Glenn and former Lions colleague Ben Johnson, including whether the Jets can finally turn their frequent blitzes into actual pressure. The offense also has to keep building around Garrett Wilson and the tight ends, while the offensive line must improve. Plus, the Yankees continue weighing how Aaron Judge fits back into the lineup without sacrificing Ben Rice or Luis Garcia.
Jameis Winston remains under the microscope as the Giants prepare for Arizona, with Evan and Tiki expecting an offense that may need far more than game management to win. Winston has looked uncomfortable so far, and Tiki argues that Matt Nagy must find the balance between letting him play his aggressive style and protecting the Giants from the mistakes that can come with it. The Yankees also face a difficult Aaron Judge decision. Evan and Tiki reject reshuffling the infield just to create a DH spot and argue that Ben Rice and Luis Garcia need to remain in the lineup. If Judge is healthy enough to return, right field or a major role off the bench makes far more sense than weakening the rest of the roster.
Jameis Winston has reached put-up-or-shut-up time with the Giants. After coming off the bench against the Rams and battling ugly weather against Tennessee, there are no more excuses heading into Sunday against Arizona. Evan and Tiki want to see whether Winston can finally push the ball downfield and prove his arm is still there. J.J. McCarthy is not an immediate threat to start, but his arrival creates real pressure if Winston struggles. With John Harbaugh focused on winning now, another shaky performance could quickly turn the conversation toward how soon McCarthy can realistically learn the offense and take over.
The Yankees sweep of the Red Sox is complete, Sonny Gray hates his manager, the Yankees kids keep thriving, and now a Yankee takeover in Tampa is possible
The Yankees demolished the Red Sox 18-2 across two games, but it was how they won that stood out most. Smart baserunning, timely contact, bunts, hustle and dominant starting pitching made this version of the Yankees feel completely different from the stale playoff teams of recent years. Max Fried delivered when his command was not perfect, while young players like Spencer Jones and Luis Garcia Jr. brought energy and aggression. Meanwhile, Boston unraveled. Chad Tracy’s stunning decision to pull Sonny Gray after just 70 pitches became the defining moment, especially after Gray openly said he wanted to stay in the game. The Yankees showed the killer instinct their fans have been demanding, while the Red Sox walked away with questions about their manager, clubhouse and future.
Tiki and Shaun debate the Yankees' potential starting rotation for the American League Division Series, weighing Gerrit Cole's track record against Carlos Rodón's recent dominance. They also preview the Browns-Steelers matchup and discuss the takeover of Yankee fans in Florida.(00:01:20) Cole vs. Rodón Decision(00:04:32) Postseason Pitching Strategy(00:06:48) Rodón's Success vs. Rays(00:09:16) NFL and MLB Preview(00:13:40) Yankees Florida Takeover(00:17:18) Sports Update(00:20:32) Steelers and Phillies Talk(00:23:56) Analyzing Pitching Data(00:28:19) Browns vs. Steelers Picks(00:33:20) Jets Success Outlook
The Yankees eliminated the Red Sox, but the biggest question immediately shifts to Aaron Judge and whether he will return for the Division Series against Tampa Bay. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate how much Judge can realistically play, whether the Yankees would risk him in the outfield, and why his return could leave Giancarlo Stanton without a roster spot. They also explain why this Yankees team feels different, from its dominant rotation to the impact of young players and a lineup no longer completely dependent on home runs. The conversation also turns to the Giants after Joey Porter Jr. lands with Dallas and reports emerge that Marvin Harrison Jr. could become available. Tiki raises concerns about Harrison’s effort, while the possibility of adding his talent to the Giants sparks a bigger debate about risk, coaching and the future of New York’s offense.
The Yankees steamrolled the Red Sox and now head into the ALDS with serious championship confidence. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why this team suddenly has 1998 vibes, from dominant starting pitching and a deeper lineup to Aaron Boone’s managing and the emergence of the Yankees’ young core. They also debate Aaron Judge’s role against Tampa Bay, why playing the outfield could be crucial, and whether Trent Grisham has done enough to stay in the lineup. The expected Yankees fan takeover at Tropicana Field may not be the lock everyone assumes, as Evan digs into past playoff crowds and surprising ticket prices. Plus, Mike Vrabel fires back at rumors that he no longer believes in Drake Maye, sparking a debate over whether his answer actually settled anything and a wild hypothetical involving May and Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart.
John Harbaugh shuts down the Odell Beckham Jr. drama and makes it clear why the Giants moved on, dismissing any conspiracy theories while bluntly saying Odell was not doing enough for the offense. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber also debate the Giants’ new “1-0” slogan and whether players actually need motivational messages like that. Then the focus shifts to the Yankees, where Aaron Judge’s return creates a major roster decision. Jose Caballero, Ahmed Rosario and Trent Grisham all enter the conversation, along with whether New York really needs another bullpen arm. Plus, Aaron Boone leaves the door open between Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodon for Game 1 against Tampa Bay.
The Yankees demolished Boston and Shaun Morash sees unmistakable 1998 vibes, from their killer instinct and dominant pitching to Aaron Boone’s managing and a young core that keeps delivering. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the Yankees look deeper and less dependent on Aaron Judge, but warn that their fundamentals must remain sharp against Tampa Bay. Then Evan challenges the assumption that Tropicana Field will become a Yankees home game. After digging into past Rays playoff crowds, ticket prices and fan turnout, he argues the expected takeover may never materialize. The hour closes with encouraging Jets injury news on Minkah Fitzpatrick and concern that Breece Hall may not be ready to play.
Aaron Judge’s potential return creates a complicated Yankees decision heading into the ALDS. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree Judge belongs in the lineup if he can play right field, but a DH-only role could force the Yankees to disrupt a lineup that just dominated Boston and potentially weaken their defense. They also rip Jason Benetti’s unnecessary Babe Ruth comparison during Sonny Gray’s playoff start and debate the crowded NBC broadcast booth. Then a caller sparks a Giants quarterback hypothetical: if Drake Maye’s struggles continue, would they trade Jaxson Dart for the former MVP runner-up? Tiki and Shaun Morash strongly reject the idea, arguing the Giants still need to discover just how high Dart’s ceiling can be.
Mike Vrabel pushed back hard on rumors that he doesn’t believe in Drake Maye, insisting Maye was a major reason he took the Patriots job. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber aren’t completely convinced, questioning whether Vrabel actually answered the bigger issue and whether his opinion of Maye could have changed after watching his recent regression. The conversation turns to just how quickly things could unravel for Maye if his struggles continue, with Evan predicting his Patriots future may not last much longer. Plus, the Yankees’ aggressive approach and dominant pitching have Evan and Tiki preaching small ball against Tampa Bay, while Aaron Judge’s desire to return sparks a debate about his role. Tiki also explains why the Giants shouldn’t pay a premium price for Joey Porter.
The Giants missed out on Joey Porter Jr. after Dallas paid Pittsburgh’s price, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash explain why that gamble made more sense for the Cowboys than for New York. The bigger intrigue comes at wide receiver, where reports that Marvin Harrison Jr. could become available spark a debate over whether the Giants should take a chance on the former top pick. Tiki raises concerns about Harrison’s effort and body language, while Evan argues a new environment with John Harbaugh, Matt Nagy and Jameis Winston could unlock his talent if the price is low enough. The crew also revisits the 2024 receiver class, with Malik Nabers looking like the strongest choice among the early selections.
Aaron Judge wants back in the Yankees lineup for the Division Series, but his uncertain role creates a major roster decision. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Judge can handle the outfield, especially on Tampa Bay’s turf, and whether his return could make Giancarlo Stanton expendable after Stanton never received an at-bat against Boston. The guys are stunned the Yankees never used Stanton even with the Wild Card clincher out of reach, raising questions about whether he was truly part of their plans or simply a threat off the bench. Evan argues that even a less-than-100-percent Judge changes how opponents attack the Yankees lineup, while the crew debates whether the Wild Card round even feels like the real postseason.
The Yankees knocked out the Red Sox in two games, and something about this team suddenly feels different. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down the dominant rotation, the impact of young players like George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones, and an offense that is still hitting home runs without depending on them for everything. The guys also react to the wild celebration outside Yankee Stadium and debate how much of the scene was genuine fan emotion versus social media content being encouraged by bars and digital outlets. Plus, they revisit their series predictions, including the hosts who nailed the Yankees sweep and the ones who expected Boston to force a third game.
The Yankees advanced, but did they really accomplish enough to justify another champagne-soaked clubhouse celebration? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether winning a best-of-three Wild Card series deserves a full party when the Division Series begins just days later. The conversation then turns to the White Sox and Guardians, whose playoff matchup sparks memories of Major League and the fictional postseason showdown from the iconic movie. Charlie Sheen, Pedro Cerrano, Willie Mays Hayes and Jake Taylor enter the conversation as the crew imagines Cleveland leaning all the way into the nostalgia.
Chad Tracy’s decision to pull Sonny Gray after just 70 pitches sends the Red Sox into chaos. Gray had allowed only one run, yet Boston went to a struggling bullpen and watched the Yankees immediately take advantage. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash rip the move and question whether Tracy has already lost his clubhouse. Gray makes his frustration impossible to ignore, saying he wanted to live or die with the moment before delivering an ominous “I don’t know” when asked about returning to Boston. Wilson Contreras also appears unhappy with the organization’s reliance on analytics. Plus, the crew dives into the suspicious substance spotted on Gray’s neck and wonders how neither the Yankees nor the umpires caught it during the game.
The Yankees crushed Boston by playing the exact brand of October baseball fans have been demanding for years. They mixed timely contact, aggressive baserunning, hustle and small ball with dominant pitching, while the Red Sox made costly mistakes and repeatedly overmanaged their starters. Max Fried battled through shaky command to deliver six strong innings, and young players like Spencer Jones and Luis Garcia Jr. injected speed, energy and confidence into the lineup. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash point to the Yankees’ newfound killer instinct and pitching depth as the biggest reasons this team feels different. Now Aaron Boone faces a fascinating decision with Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón both in the mix to start Game 1.
The Yankees left no doubt in Game 1, Cam Schlittler and Ben Rice are the new generation, now we look ahead to Game 2
Cam Schlittler overwhelmed the Red Sox again, and Aaron Boone finally managed like he had a horse worth riding. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down Schlittler’s dominant postseason performance, Boone’s decision to push him deep despite a rising pitch count, and why the Yankees’ starting rotation may have become the identity that can carry them through October. They also contrast Boone’s aggressive approach with Boston pulling Peyton Tolle after just 83 pitches. Aaron Judge also created an unexpected pregame mystery by not taking part in the Yankees’ on-field introductions despite being in the dugout supporting his teammates. The crew debates whether Judge was simply keeping the spotlight on the active roster or whether his absence reflected frustration with how the Yankees handled his injury and playoff status.
Cam Schlittler and Ben Rice have turned the Yankees’ postseason into a showcase for the organization’s young core. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Schlittler’s dominant performance against Boston, Rice’s huge night, and how a lineup filled with inexpensive, homegrown talent has changed the feel of this Yankees team. The conversation turns to Brian Cashman’s role in building a group that could define the next era in the Bronx. The crew also defends Yankees fans over the controversial mound-visit boos, praises NBC’s playoff broadcast approach, and debates how Aaron Boone should manage every run in a tight postseason game. Plus, Tiki explains why moving Arvell Reese to the edge too soon could hurt both the Giants and the young linebacker’s development.
The Giants suddenly have a path to stealing the NFC East. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash look at a wide-open division, why Philadelphia and Dallas suddenly feel vulnerable, and how Jameis Winston now becomes the biggest variable in keeping the Giants in the race. They also break down the team’s ugly red-zone offense, Najee Harris moving up the running back hierarchy, and Kayvon Thibodeaux fooling everyone with his reaction to Odell Beckham Jr.’s release. Then the focus shifts to October baseball, where Shaun declares the Red Sox the Yankees’ new Twins after another dominant playoff showing. The guys also react to the Astros getting called out by one of their own players over empty playoff seats, Susan Waldman delivering an accidental insult to Big Mac, and the unforgettable Yankee Stadium scene after Ben Rice’s grand slam.
Evan and Tiki analyze the Yankees' postseason matchup against former pitcher Sonny Gray and the Red Sox. They argue over Brian Cashman's roster management and whether the decision to stick with Austin Wells over other catching options will haunt the team. The conversation also explores potential lineup changes and Max Fried's inconsistent postseason history. (00:01:50) Sonny Gray's Yankee Return (00:06:30) Yankees Postseason History Trivia (00:10:20) Jameis Winston Leadership Debate (00:14:45) Evaluating Brian Cashman's Deadline (00:18:45) Austin Wells Catcher Debate (00:25:00) Boone's Aggressive Bullpen Use (00:32:20) WFAN Fan Focus (00:36:40) Comparing Boone and Cora (00:43:00) Max Fried Postseason History
Shaun Morash declares the Red Sox the Yankees’ new Twins, arguing Boston has become an October punching bag as the Yankees keep shutting down their offense. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on just how far that comparison can go, but Shaun sees a matchup the Yankees should dominate for years. Then Susan Waldman delivers what might be the ultimate insult to Big Mac by suggesting he hasn’t watched every Yankees game. The guys debate whether the shot was really aimed at Craig Carton, revisit Big Mac’s Yankee Stadium habits, and celebrate the incredible scene after Ben Rice’s grand slam sent drinks flying through the bleachers.
The Astros are unraveling, and now one of their own players is calling out the fans. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to thousands of empty seats in Houston, Bennett Sousa criticizing the atmosphere, and why the Astros suddenly feel nothing like the powerhouse Yankee fans once despised. The conversation then turns back to the Giants and their continued red-zone failures. Tiki explains why the coaching staff may be overthinking things with Jameis Winston, especially after abandoning a rushing attack that was working against Tennessee. Plus, the guys debate the difference between TV and radio play-by-play and why postseason broadcasts can frustrate fans used to their local announcers.
The Giants suddenly have a real opening in the NFC East. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down a division with no dominant team, why Philadelphia and Dallas look vulnerable, and how Jameis Winston could keep the Giants firmly in the race. They also react to Kayvon Thibodeaux pretending he had just learned about Odell Beckham Jr.’s release, a performance convincing enough to fool Tiki. Plus, Najee Harris appears to be moving ahead in the Giants’ backfield, Tyrone Tracy’s role is shrinking, and special teams could become a major factor in how this team wins close games.
NBC’s Yankees-Red Sox broadcast earns strong praise for using analysts who actually know both teams. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Joe Girardi and Lou Merloni added valuable detail, why national broadcasts often frustrate local fans, and why this formula may be the best alternative when Michael Kay and the YES crew are unavailable. The Yankees’ in-game decisions also come under the microscope, including whether Anthony Volpe should have bunted with a one-run lead and Cam Schlittler dominating. Evan and Tiki highlight two successful Yankees challenges that helped manage Schlittler’s pitch count and create a scoring opportunity. Tiki also explains why moving Arvell Reese to the edge too quickly could hurt his development with the Giants.
Yankees fans got crushed for booing when pitching coach Matt Blake visited Cam Schlittler, but Evan Roberts comes to their defense. He explains why the emotional playoff atmosphere, limited sightlines and fear of Schlittler being removed made the reaction understandable, while pushing back on the idea that the crowd simply didn’t know baseball. The conversation shifts to just how quickly the Yankees have moved from the Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole era toward a young core led by Schlittler and Ben Rice. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash credit Brian Cashman for building that group without a painful transition, revisit the Michael King trade, and explain why Boston already has plenty of reason to despise the Yankees’ newest young stars.
The Yankees are winning with a lineup that looks nothing like the expensive powerhouse fans are used to seeing. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash marvel at a starting group loaded with homegrown players making less than $1 million, with Ben Rice, Spencer Jones, George Lombard Jr. and Austin Wells helping fuel the October run. They also look ahead to Max Fried’s chance to finish off Boston, debate which National League opponent Yankees fans should want in a potential World Series, and rip the decision not to show postseason player introductions on television. The crew argues those introductions are part of what makes playoff baseball feel special and should be available for fans watching at home.
Aaron Judge was noticeably absent from the Yankees’ pregame player introductions despite being in the dugout supporting his teammates, creating an unexpected controversy after their dominant win. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate why Judge stayed off the field and whether he was simply trying to keep the attention on the active roster or sending a message about his playoff status. The crew also wonders if Judge’s decision actually created more attention than an introduction would have. Plus, callers react to Cam Schlittler’s intense demeanor, and the conversation returns to Aaron Boone’s willingness to push his ace beyond the pitch-count limits Yankees fans have become accustomed to.
Cam Schlittler dominated the Red Sox again, and Aaron Boone made the kind of old-school decision Yankees fans have been begging to see. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash break down Boone pushing Schlittler past 110 pitches, why Boston’s early hook of Peyton Tolle backfired, and how trusting the starter helped set the tone for a convincing Yankees win. The bigger takeaway may be the Yankees’ postseason identity. Instead of living and dying with Aaron Judge and home runs, this team can lean on a dominant rotation. After Schlittler’s latest performance against Boston, the crew argues Boone has to keep riding his starting pitching if the Yankees are going to make a deep October run.
The Yankees get ready of another October, though this is in September. Judge is off the roster, apparently Odell is too.
Aaron Judge is officially off the Yankees’ Wild Card roster, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why the organization finally overruled its superstar. Judge wanted to play, but the Yankees appear unwilling to risk their long-term investment with the season hanging on a best-of-three series against Boston. Evan argues there can be no Judge excuse if the Yankees lose. Meanwhile, Giancarlo Stanton is somehow back after not playing since April 24. Evan praises Stanton’s postseason toughness and believes he could still deliver a memorable October moment as a dangerous bat off the bench. The conversation turns to Stanton’s complicated Yankees legacy, his remarkable playoff availability despite years of regular-season injuries, Trent Grisham’s return, and how the Yankees should build their roster around a rotation expected to carry a heavy postseason workload.
The Giants’ trade for J.J. McCarthy sparks a major debate about what comes next for Jaxson Dart, Jameis Winston and New York’s quarterback room. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why Minnesota giving up on McCarthy does not guarantee he will fail, how John Harbaugh could unlock him, and why a fifth-round pick is a worthwhile gamble for a former first-round quarterback. They also examine the uncomfortable possibility of McCarthy pushing Dart or Winston if he takes advantage of his opportunity. The Yankees unveil an unconventional Wild Card roster loaded with position players, opening the door for Aaron Boone to aggressively deploy Jazz Chisholm, Anthony Volpe and Giancarlo Stanton. Plus, Case Keenum’s huge performance gets attention, and Posted and Toasted digs up old J.J. McCarthy takes from around WFAN.
The Yankees finally open their Wild Card showdown with the Red Sox, and Evan Roberts argues Boston’s season was built on one historic hot streak surrounded by long stretches of mediocre baseball. That puts even more pressure on the Yankees to take care of business at Yankee Stadium, with Cam Schlittler on the mound and Gerrit Cole potentially waiting for a winner-take-all Game 3. The bigger consequence could come for Aaron Boone. Evan believes a series loss to Boston could end Boone’s Yankees tenure, while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh how much Aaron Judge’s situation and the short-series format could factor into that decision. Plus, the Giants’ trade for J.J. McCarthy, John Harbaugh’s plans at quarterback, and an early Rangers season prediction.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber analyze the San Diego Padres' stunning choice to activate Joe Musgrove for the Wild Card series despite his long-term injury absence. They also break down the New York Yankees' postseason roster decisions and the New York Giants' release of Odell Beckham Jr. following his brief return. (00:01:25) Joey Porter Jr. Rumors (00:07:55) WBC Impact On Injuries (00:11:14) Joe Musgrove's Padres Return (00:14:16) Odell Beckham Jr. Released (00:17:48) Giants Defense And Boone (00:25:43) MLB Salary Cap Battle (00:30:23) Coughlin's J-Fund Push-Up Challenge (00:36:18) Yankees-Red Sox Series Predictions
Odell Beckham Jr.’s return to the Giants ends without a single catch as Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber react to his release and debate whether his brief comeback will even be remembered. They also examine the Giants’ aggressive approach, the J.J. McCarthy move and whether Joey Porter Jr. is worth the draft capital and massive contract that could come with a trade. The conversation shifts to Aaron Judge missing the Yankees’ postseason roster, whether playing in the World Baseball Classic deserves any blame, and the bizarre wave of stars returning just in time for October. Joe Musgrove’s comeback after nearly two years away sparks a heated debate over whether players who miss the entire regular season should be eligible for the playoffs.
Aaron Boone’s future could hinge on this Wild Card series against Boston. Evan Roberts believes a loss to the Red Sox may be enough for the Yankees to move on, arguing that Brian Cashman has historically reached a breaking point with managers after long runs without a championship. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Aaron Judge’s situation, the short-series format, or even an upcoming lockout could influence that decision. The conversation also turns to what Evan actually wants from the Yankees this postseason, including a potential ALCS matchup with Houston. Then Shaun closes the hour with his Cinco de Lunch, unloading five reasons Boston sucks ahead of Yankees-Red Sox and Rangers-Bruins.
J.J. McCarthy gets a fresh start with the Giants, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate whether John Harbaugh can help revive the former first-round pick’s career. With expectations dramatically different after New York acquired him for a fifth-round pick, McCarthy now has a chance to prove he can become a reliable NFL backup or potentially something more. The conversation turns to whether McCarthy could already be the Giants’ No. 2 quarterback this week behind Jameis Winston and what Harbaugh needs to see before trusting him. Plus, the surprising early success of backup quarterbacks across the NFL, the Mets watching Freddy Peralta thrive elsewhere, and a baseball lawsuit sparked by a dangerous stadium wall.
The Yankees open their Wild Card series against Boston with Evan Roberts calling the Red Sox frauds, pointing to one historic hot streak surrounded by long stretches of losing or mediocre baseball. Evan believes the Yankees were the far more consistent team, even while acknowledging how unpredictable a best-of-three series can be. Attention turns to Cam Schlittler’s workload in Game 1 and the possibility of Gerrit Cole starting a winner-take-all Game 3 despite his history of struggles against Boston. Evan, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash also debate how Carlos Rodon could be used in an emergency before briefly turning to Shaun’s Rangers season prediction.
Posted and Toasted takes aim at old J.J. McCarthy opinions as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig through some memorable WFAN receipts. The segment revisits skepticism surrounding McCarthy before the draft, including doubts about his physical profile, how much Michigan asked him to do and whether he was ever worthy of a first-round investment. The McCarthy debate continues with callers questioning why the Giants should believe in him now, while Evan keeps coming back to the low cost of the gamble. New York gave up only a fifth-round pick, giving John Harbaugh a chance to see whether McCarthy can become something more.
The Yankees are taking an aggressive approach into the Wild Card round, carrying only 10 pitchers and loading Aaron Boone’s bench with offensive options. Evan Roberts loves the strategy, arguing that Boone can treat his starting lineup as temporary and attack every matchup with weapons like Giancarlo Stanton, Jazz Chisholm, Anthony Volpe and Ryan McMahon. The biggest decisions may come early. Evan explains why he would start Volpe over Chisholm against the lefty, while the deep bench gives Boone freedom to make moves by the fourth or fifth inning. Stanton’s return also sparks debate over whether a hitter who has been out for months can still be trusted in the biggest spot.
The Giants’ trade for J.J. McCarthy immediately raises a bigger question about Jaxson Dart’s future. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether McCarthy could create an uncomfortable quarterback battle once Dart returns, why an early-career injury can accelerate the pressure on a young quarterback, and why Minnesota giving up on McCarthy does not automatically mean the Giants made a mistake. John Harbaugh’s focus is simply winning the next game, but the Giants now have another potential answer if Jameis Winston struggles or Dart’s recovery hits complications. Plus, Case Keenum’s performance becomes a reminder of how valuable an experienced backup quarterback can be.
Giancarlo Stanton’s Yankees legacy takes center stage as Evan Roberts pushes back on the criticism surrounding all the regular-season games he has missed. Evan points to Stanton’s postseason availability and production, arguing that if October is what ultimately matters for the Yankees, his playoff résumé has to carry enormous weight. The debate turns to how the Yankees should actually use Stanton after more than five months without a game. Rather than disrupt the lineup, the expectation is that Stanton becomes a dangerous late-game bat off the bench. Evan even lays out the dream scenario: Stanton spending the night preparing in the cage before Aaron Boone calls on him for one unforgettable Kirk Gibson-style moment.
Giancarlo Stanton’s return sparks a passionate defense of his Yankees legacy. Evan Roberts argues that despite all the missed regular-season time, Stanton has repeatedly found a way to be available when October arrives, and his postseason production deserves far more respect than it gets. That leads directly back to Aaron Judge. Evan believes Judge wanted to play in the Wild Card round, but the Yankees stepped in and protected their long-term investment, while Stanton was given the green light because his future carries far less risk. The conversation also turns to Boston activating Garrett Crochet after months away, Trent Grisham making the Yankees roster, and the remarkable number of major roster gambles surrounding this Yankees-Red Sox series.
Aaron Judge is officially off the Yankees’ Wild Card roster, forcing New York into its biggest postseason test without its superstar. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Yankees made the right call protecting Judge, who wanted to play despite the injury risk, and why his absence cannot become an excuse if they lose to Boston.
An ugly victory couldn't mask the panic in Big Blue's front office following a season-ending ACL injury to star pass-rusher Brian Burns and a desperation trade for J.J. McCarthy. With Jameis Winston struggling to run the offense and key starters dropping fast, the Giants find themselves treading thin ice as their season descends into high-stakes drama.
Despite an explosive performance from Geno Smith and the offense, a second-half defensive breakdown cost the Jets a signature win in Detroit. From Aaron Glenn’s late-game play-calling to the frustrating two-point analytics debate, we break down every angle of New York’s heart-wrenching loss.
Final Words from Evan on the Mets 2026 season.
The Giants live in taking any win they can, the Jets have moral victory Monday, Joe B joins the show, and the Giants trade for a quarterback during our show.
The Giants survived an ugly win over the Titans, but Brian Burns’ season-ending ACL injury immediately casts a shadow over their 2-1 start. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why injuries remain the biggest threat to this team, how New York gutted out a game it probably loses in previous years, and why players are already pointing to John Harbaugh as the difference. Jevon Holland continues to dominate the Giants defense, while Jameis Winston and the offense have major issues to fix after another touchdown-free week. Evan and Tiki debate Winston’s future as reports suggest the Giants are aggressively looking to add quarterbacks, plus they examine the red-zone failures, questionable play calling and the growing concern surrounding MetLife Stadium’s turf.
The Jets had a signature win within reach in Detroit, only for the defense to collapse when it mattered most. Geno Smith and the offense erased a 14-point deficit, Garrett Wilson delivered a huge touchdown catch, and the Jets tied the game late before allowing the Lions to march right back down the field. Aaron Glenn’s clock management, costly penalties, poor special teams and the inability to contain Jahmyr Gibbs all come under the microscope. There are real reasons for optimism about Geno and the offense, but close losses will only take Glenn so far. Plus, the Mets’ disastrous 74-win season makes everyone revisit their wildly inaccurate preseason predictions, while Cam Schlittler gets the Game 1 start for the Yankees and an embarrassing old photo surfaces just before the postseason.
The Giants make a stunning move for J.J. McCarthy, sending a fifth-round pick to Minnesota and immediately raising questions about Jameis Winston’s future. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they debate whether McCarthy is simply insurance or a legitimate threat to take over the starting job, and how quickly the former first-round pick could get his opportunity. Joe Benigno weighs in on the Jets after a frustrating loss to Detroit, balancing a brutal defensive performance with major optimism over Geno Smith and the offense. Plus, Shaun and Tiki go around the NFL, react to another wild Sunday, and debate Boston’s pitching strategy against the Yankees as the Red Sox prepare to start rookie Payton Tolle in Game 1.
Tiki and Evan examine the New York Giants' recent acquisition of J.J. McCarthy and the maturity questions surrounding the young quarterback. They explore LeBron James' claims about nearly joining the Knicks and provide their weekly predictions for Monday Night Football. Additionally, they discuss the Yankees' roster decisions ahead of the American League wildcard series. (00:02:16) Faith in Giants Coaching Staff (00:07:32) McCarthy Maturity and System Fit (00:13:19) Quarterback Lottery Ticket Strategy (00:18:07) WFAN Fan Focus Updates (00:24:30) LeBron James Knicks Comments (00:35:20) Monday Night Football Predictions (00:42:45) Yankees Postseason Roster Outlook
J.J. McCarthy is a New York Giant, and suddenly the quarterback picture has another fascinating layer. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate the trade, why McCarthy arrives as Jameis Winston’s backup, and whether a fresh start could eventually turn the former first-round pick into something much bigger for the Giants. The conversation also turns to Drake Maye’s alarming stretch with the Patriots, Garrett Wilson’s early edge over Malik Nabers, and LeBron James claiming he once envisioned finishing his career with the Knicks. Plus, Evan blasts the Yankees over their handling of ticket refunds after another weather-impacted weekend.
Shaun Morash’s Cinco takes center stage with the five most interesting moments from a chaotic NFL Sunday. Shaun is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they revisit the Rams blowing a 16-point halftime lead in Denver, the Commanders beating Seattle with a backup quarterback, Cleveland improving to 2-1, and Baltimore stunning Dallas with a late field goal. The Cowboys’ decision to kick into the end zone instead of attempting a squib kick sparks another clock-management debate, while Tiki explains why the NFL’s new kickoff rules have made that strategy much harder to execute. The segment closes with a quick turn toward Yankees-Red Sox and Boston’s decision to start Payton Tolle in Game 1.
J.J. McCarthy is headed to the Giants, and the debate immediately turns to whether the former first-round pick can eventually take Jameis Winston’s job. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they clash over the fifth-round pick, McCarthy’s limited NFL opportunity, his injuries, and whether a reunion with John Harbaugh can unlock the quarterback the Giants once considered drafting. Tiki views the deal as a worthwhile gamble on a 23-year-old quarterback with a strong arm and athleticism, while Shaun remains skeptical after McCarthy’s struggles in Minnesota. They also debate whether McCarthy actually needs to play this season and how quickly the Giants could face a legitimate quarterback decision.
The Giants stun everyone by trading for J.J. McCarthy, immediately raising questions about what the former first-round pick could become under John Harbaugh. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to the surprise move, McCarthy’s uneven start in Minnesota, and whether the Giants are taking a worthwhile gamble on his upside. Before the breaking news, Joe Benigno unloads on the Jets’ defense and special teams after a frustrating loss to Detroit, but comes away encouraged by Geno Smith and the offense. Joe praises Garrett Wilson and the Jets’ emerging weapons while warning that Aaron Glenn’s team has to stop settling for moral victories and start turning promising performances into wins.
Cam Schlittler is getting the ball for Game One, but the strangest Yankees storyline comes from an old photo that surfaced just before the postseason. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash laugh about the image while defending Schlittler’s right to do whatever he wants in his private life. The bigger concern for Red Sox fans is whether releasing the picture only gives Schlittler more motivation. The crew argues that he already pitches with a chip on his shoulder and could take the leak as another slight from Massachusetts. With Schlittler officially starting the Wild Card opener, confidence is sky-high that he will embrace the moment and bring even more intensity against Boston.
Aaron Glenn is back under fire as frustrated Jets fans unload on another crushing loss. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much blame belongs on Glenn after the defense faded badly in the second half, the pass rush disappeared, and missed tackles against Jahmyr Gibbs helped Detroit finish the job. The criticism goes beyond coaching, with costly penalties, special teams failures and execution all playing a role. Tiki also breaks down the protection failure that led to Geno Smith’s late turnover and explains why the quarterback may have expected the free blitzer to be picked up. Plus, the crew owns its wildly optimistic Mets preseason predictions after a 74-win season.
The Jets had a signature win within reach against Detroit and watched it disappear because the defense could not make one final stop. Geno Smith helped erase a 14-point deficit and tied the game late, but the Lions answered immediately, leaving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber frustrated by another winnable game slipping away. The bigger surprise is how encouraging the Jets offense looked despite the loss. Geno made big-time throws, Garrett Wilson delivered a huge touchdown catch, and the passing game carried an offense that got almost nothing from the run game. Aaron Glenn’s clock management, costly penalties and defensive approach all draw criticism, but the hosts argue the blame goes well beyond the head coach.
Jameis Winston may already be under pressure despite the Giants’ 2-1 start. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to reports that New York is aggressively looking to add one or even two quarterbacks, and debate whether Winston could eventually lose his job to someone who is not even on the roster yet. Tiki says the upcoming game against Arizona is where Winston needs to play better after difficult circumstances in his first two appearances. The conversation then turns to potential quarterback options, including Jimmy Garoppolo and Justin Fields, before taking an unexpected turn toward Geno Smith. After doubting Geno entering the season, Evan and Tiki acknowledge how impressive he has been through three weeks.
Giants players are openly saying what fans were thinking: this is a game they would have lost last year. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Jameis Winston and Cam Skattebo crediting the change inside the building, and why John Harbaugh is already creating a level of trust that simply was not there before. Jevon Holland gets major praise after another game-changing performance, including the interception that sealed the win over Tennessee. Evan and Tiki break down the intelligence behind Holland’s play and why he has been the Giants’ best player through three weeks. They also address the growing frustration surrounding MetLife Stadium’s turf after Brian Burns’ season-ending knee injury.
The Giants got the win they absolutely needed, but Brian Burns’ season-ending ACL injury hangs over an ugly victory against the Titans. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to another devastating injury, why health could become the biggest threat to the Giants’ season, and why surviving a sloppy game still matters when the alternative is another crushing loss. The offense left plenty to worry about. New York repeatedly failed to finish drives in the red zone, penalties killed opportunities, and Matt Nagy’s direct-snap call to Cam Skattebo drew immediate criticism. Still, the Giants found a way to advance to 2-1, with Evan and Tiki pointing to John Harbaugh and the new coaching staff as a major reason this team feels different.
Newly retired Mets broadcasting legend Howie Rose returns to his old WFAN stomping grounds for a special conversation with Evan Roberts. Howie reflects on the emotions surrounding his final Mets broadcast, the incredible reaction from fans and players, and why he knew it was finally time to retire. He takes listeners behind the scenes of some of the most memorable calls of his career, including the Rangers’ unforgettable 1994 Stanley Cup run, and shares stories from his decades covering the Mets, Islanders and New York sports. Plus, Howie remembers the early days of WFAN, his relationships with broadcasting legends like Marv Albert, the moment he nearly walked away from the Mets, his favorite memories from Shea and Citi Field, and why he remains optimistic about the Mets’ future. A celebration of one of the defining voices in New York sports history.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle side with Aaron Boone when it comes to the discourse surrounding Aaron Judge's return. The two also debate if Judge actually will play in the Wild Card Series against Boston, as the captain insists he plans on playing, while Boone initially said he likely won't. Plus, Evan and Tiki believe Judge is the one who gets to call the shots when it comes to his return. If Judge can't make it back from his calf injury, Tommy Lugauer believes the Yankees can still win a championship without him.
Jaxson Dart's season is done, and for Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, that means the Giants' season is done. Tiki Barber makes it clear that he does NOT feel the same, ripping any Giants fans for quitting after two games and one bad injury. Plus, Boomer and Gio discuss how expectations have changed for Big Blue, Connor Hughes joins Evan and Tiki right when the Dart news broke, and Pat Leonard of the Daily News joined The Carton Show and called out John Harbaugh and the Giants for how they handled the Dart injury updates.
From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Is there a world that next year Juan Soto mans first base?
Kickoff with Boomer Valenti: The Chiefs Dynasty is back, the Packers and Chargers might stink, and Jaxson Dart's season is over. The guys give their Week 3 picks and wrap up with a game of "QB or HC"
The Jets may be sitting on a draft gold mine. Green Bay’s ugly performance has Evan Roberts dreaming about the Packers’ first-round pick, and with Indianapolis also struggling, the Jets could find themselves armed with multiple premium selections. Evan and Tiki Barber debate just how realistic the draft jackpot could become while still keeping the focus on winning now. The Giants conversation turns to life with Jameis Winston after Jaxson Dart’s injury. Shaun Morash pushes back on the idea that Giants fans should simply move on, while Evan doubles down on his comparison to the 2015 Jets and Ryan Fitzpatrick. They debate what would actually make this season successful, whether winning with Winston would strengthen the Giants’ future around Dart, and why Sunday’s matchup should lean heavily on the running game.
CC Sabathia’s long-awaited Yankees ceremony gets thrown into chaos by the weather, forcing the team to move the celebration to Friday afternoon. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber understand why Saturday’s game had to be moved, but they question whether squeezing the ceremony into a difficult time slot is the best way to honor Sabathia and the fans who bought tickets specifically for the occasion. The conversation also turns to the Jets’ difficult matchup with Detroit, where Aidan Hutchinson and the Lions’ pass rush could put major pressure on the offensive line. Plus, what the Jets need to do offensively to bounce back, what Jameis Winston must show for the Giants against Tennessee, and why life without Jaxson Dart has hit Giants fans so hard.
The Yankees could make the unconventional call to start Max Fried in Game 1 against Boston and save Cam Schlittler for Game 2. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why the second game of a best-of-three may actually be the most important, how the Yankees’ pitching depth gives them flexibility, and whether Aaron Boone should simply embrace Schlittler as his ace. The Giants also face a major test against Tennessee as their pass rush struggles to make an impact and Andrew Thomas works toward a return. Plus, new information emerges about why CC Sabathia’s ceremony stayed on Friday, and Shaun Morash finds a surprising reason to believe the Giants’ season may still have life.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber evaluate the potential for the Giants to move on from Daniel Jones in favor of a trade for Joe Burrow. They also discuss Jordan Love's early-season struggles, the Yankees' mathematical consistency, and the viral trailer for the John Madden biopic starring Nicolas Cage. The conversation shifts to a full slate of Week 3 NFL picks and the weekly Idiots with Idioms blooper reel. (00:01:50) NFL Game Predictions (00:05:20) Daniel Jones Trade Discussion (00:08:45) Jordan Love Analysis (00:13:40) Pro Football Injury Report (00:17:00) Yankees Win Total Predictability (00:23:00) Nicolas Cage Madden Reaction (00:30:30) Idiots with Idioms Segment (00:35:55) Week 3 NFL Picks (00:48:05) Jalen Brunson SNL Appearance
Brutal weather is rolling in, the Giants get set to play with Jameis, the Jets get set for the Lions, and the Yankees and the CC Ceremony get moved
A major twist emerges in the controversy surrounding CC Sabathia’s Yankees ceremony. The Yankees told the show they offered Sabathia and his family the opportunity to move the celebration to next season, but CC requested that it remain Friday. That changes where the blame falls, although frustrated fans who bought Saturday tickets still want answers about refunds. Then Shaun Morash talks himself into a new sliver of hope for the Giants, comparing their current situation to the unlikely 2022 playoff team. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the comparison as the debate turns into whether Jameis Winston, a strong running game and improved coaching could somehow keep the season alive.
The Giants’ defensive front has been shockingly ineffective, and Tiki Barber can’t understand why a unit loaded with pass-rushing talent is near the bottom of the league at generating pressure. With Brian Burns potentially unavailable and Kayvon Thibodeaux among the players who need to produce more, Sunday against Tennessee could reveal what kind of Giants season this will become. The conversation also turns to John Harbaugh bringing longtime Baltimore assistant Jerry Rosburg onto the practice field after questionable game-management decisions. Plus, the Yankees’ limited Josh Hart bobblehead giveaway creates another headache for fans after the schedule change.
Cam Schlittler may be the Yankees’ ace, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe that could be exactly why he belongs in Game 2 against Boston. They debate why the second game of a best-of-three can carry the most weight, how Max Fried fits into the Game 1 plan, and why the Yankees’ three-ace rotation gives them options most teams simply do not have. Plus, Garrett Crochet could become a dangerous weapon out of the Red Sox bullpen, and the Yankees take heat over the handling of CC Sabathia’s ceremony and frustrated ticket holders.
CC Sabathia’s Yankees ceremony is moved to Friday afternoon because of the weekend weather, leaving many fans frustrated after buying Saturday tickets specifically to see him honored. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the game itself had to be rescheduled, but wonder whether the ceremony should have been moved to a future date instead. They also get into the confusion surrounding the Josh Hart bobblehead giveaway and ticket refunds, while emphasizing that Sabathia’s career deserves a proper celebration with fans able to be there.
CC Sabathia’s Yankees ceremony is suddenly moved to Friday afternoon because of the weekend weather, creating frustration for fans who bought Saturday tickets specifically to see him honored. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the game needed to be rescheduled, but question whether the ceremony should have been pushed to a future date instead of squeezed into a difficult time slot. They also break down the complications surrounding the Josh Hart bobblehead giveaway, ticket refunds and the challenge of properly honoring Sabathia on short notice. Evan and Tiki understand the Yankees were forced into a tough situation, but believe CC and the fans deserved a smoother solution.
The Giants are trying to keep their season and their fan base alive without Jaxson Dart. Cameron Scott urges fans to show up and bring the same energy they had in Week 1, sparking a debate over whether Giants fans can truly rally around Jameis Winston after losing the quarterback who fueled so much optimism. Shaun Morash admits the fan base is hurting but says the team’s other players still deserve their support. The conversation then turns toward the Giants’ future at quarterback. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun debate whether New York could use a premium 2027 draft pick on another quarterback, why Dart’s surgery and the team’s eventual draft position matter, and how Winston’s performance could shape that decision.
The Giants may have lost Jaxson Dart, but Evan Roberts refuses to accept that their season is finished. He doubles down on his comparison to the 2015 Jets, arguing that Jameis Winston could become the veteran quarterback who unexpectedly keeps the Giants competitive. Shaun Morash admits a nine or 10-win season would be hard for Giants fans to reject, even if Winston ultimately isn’t the long-term answer. That leads to a bigger debate over what Giants fans should actually want now. Would they rather win big with Winston or lose while young players like Abdul Carter emerge as stars? Evan and Tiki Barber push back hard on the idea that development should matter more than serious winning, while Shaun argues there is more nuance when the difference is only a few wins.
The Jets could be sitting on a massive draft opportunity thanks to other teams falling apart. Evan Roberts looks at Green Bay and Indianapolis and sees a realistic path to multiple top-10 picks, giving Jets fans another reason to obsess over every Packers and Colts loss. The conversation then shifts to the Giants after Michael Penix Jr.’s performance sparks a comparison to Jaxson Dart. Evan, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate the injury concerns surrounding both young quarterbacks, what Penix’s situation could foreshadow for Dart, and why the Giants may need a reliable veteran option behind him next season.
Jaxson Dart is out for the season and coping continues, Aaron Judge vs Aaron Boone, a Noreaster is coming, and much more
Jaxson Dart is done for the regular season, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber aren’t ready to bury the Giants. With Jameis Winston taking over, they debate whether New York can still manufacture a winning season and why the 2015 Jets offer a surprising blueprint for turning a devastating quarterback injury into an unexpected run. John Harbaugh’s carefully chosen words about Dart’s recovery spark an even bigger conversation about playoff expectations, while the Giants’ offense may need a dramatic shift toward a physical running game built around Winston. Plus, the concern surrounding Dart’s long-term recovery, potential quarterback additions, and what the Giants must accomplish this season to build real expectations for 2027.
Aaron Judge plans to fight his way back for the Yankees’ postseason run, but his injured calf creates a massive risk-reward decision. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Judge should play through the injury, the danger of a potentially worse setback, and why Judge made it clear he intends to return as the Yankees’ right fielder. They also examine Judge’s growing power within the organization and whether his postseason legacy factors into his urgency to play. Plus, the Giants search for quarterback depth behind Jameis Winston, with names including Jalen Milroe and Zach Wilson entering the conversation. The hour also hits the Yankees’ potential returns of Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham and how both could fit into the postseason roster.
Jameis Winston has the opportunity he’s been waiting for, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe this could be his final chance to prove he can lead an NFL team. With Jaxson Dart out, Winston inherits a Giants roster that still has weapons, but he must reignite a fan base already devastated by losing its young quarterback. The debate heats up over whether crashing ticket prices are about Dart’s injury or simply brutal weather headed for MetLife Stadium. Plus, Evan blasts the idea that stalled Karl-Anthony Towns extension talks have created a “cloud” over the defending champion Knicks. The contract situation could eventually force a difficult decision, but Evan sees no reason it should threaten the Knicks’ title defense this season.
Evan expresses his outrage over Pete Alonso’s comments about being "meant to be" with the Baltimore Orioles. They also analyze Frank Reich’s use of analytics to justify a failed fourth-and-one play call for the Jets. The conversation shifts to the Giants' quarterback situation following an injury to Jaxson Dart and ends with a celebratory note for Sal Licata’s Emmy win. (00:02:00) Rival City Championships (00:05:45) Alonso Dead To Evan (00:11:25) Giants Attendance Debate (00:16:05) Yankees Pitching Predictions (00:21:25) New York Quarterback Options (00:27:45) Reich Analytics Defense (00:35:40) Scheduling Conflicts Suck (00:43:30) Sal Licata Emmy
Pete Alonso has finally pushed Evan Roberts past his breaking point. After hearing Alonso say he believes in the “baseball gods” and was meant to be in Baltimore, Evan declares the former Met dead to him. The standing ovations, curtain call and continued love from Mets fans only make Alonso’s comments sting more, as Evan unloads on the first baseman while still blaming Steve Cohen and David Stearns for letting him leave.
Giants ticket prices are crashing ahead of Jameis Winston’s first start, and Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash clash over the reason. Evan blames the miserable weather forecast for driving tickets down to around $20, while Shaun argues Jaxson Dart’s injury popped the balloon for a fan base that finally had real hope. The argument gets heated as they compare prices for upcoming Giants home games and debate just how much enthusiasm disappeared when Dart went down. Evan also makes a broader case that fans are becoming less interested in attending NFL games because the at-home experience is simply too good, while Giants season-ticket holders weigh in on whether Dart’s injury has already changed the market.
Jaxson Dart’s season-ending injury has crushed the optimism surrounding the Giants, and some fans are already waving the white flag. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that the season is over, arguing that Jameis Winston still has enough around him to keep the Giants competitive if he can deliver. The bigger loss may be the excitement Dart created. Giants fans finally thought they were getting answers about their young quarterback, and now that development is frozen for the rest of the season. With Winston taking over, the Giants face a very different season and a fan base desperate for any reason to believe again.
Karl-Anthony Towns and the Knicks have hit an impasse in extension talks, but Evan Roberts isn’t buying the idea that it creates a cloud over their championship defense. The real question comes after this season: will Towns take a major discount to help the Knicks stay under the second apron, or could this ultimately be his final year in New York? Then the focus shifts to Jameis Winston and the massive opportunity created by Jaxson Dart’s injury. Tiki Barber lays out what the Giants must change offensively to help Winston succeed, while Evan argues this may be Jameis’ last legitimate chance to fulfill his dream of becoming a Super Bowl starting quarterback.
Aaron Judge belongs in the Yankees’ postseason lineup if he’s healthy enough to play, regardless of how well the team performed without him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that the Yankees should simply stick with the players who carried them during Judge’s absence, pointing to the impact their captain still brings and the central question of whether his return makes them better. Meanwhile, Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham are nearing potential postseason returns, but neither should automatically reclaim a starting job. Evan and Tiki see Stanton as a dangerous right-handed power bat off the bench, while Spencer Jones has done enough to keep his place in the lineup.
Aaron Judge isn’t backing away from the risk of returning for the Yankees’ postseason run. Judge says the future isn’t guaranteed and he’ll do whatever he can to get back, sparking a debate over why this October opportunity is too important to pass up. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber also consider whether the possibility of a lengthy MLB lockout could factor into Judge’s willingness to push through his calf injury. The conversation then shifts to the Giants’ quarterback situation behind Jameis Winston. Callers float potential lottery tickets, including Jalen Milroe and Zach Wilson, while Evan argues that losing a starting quarterback doesn’t automatically mean the season is over.
Aaron Judge is determined to return for the Yankees’ Wild Card series, but playing through a calf strain could come with a frightening risk. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Judge should push to play, how concerned the Yankees should be about a potential Achilles injury, and whether another week of recovery could make a difference.
The Giants need another quarterback after losing Jaxson Dart, but how aggressive should they get? A caller proposes trading for J.J. McCarthy, launching a debate over whether New York should sacrifice draft capital for a young quarterback with upside or simply add an available veteran behind Jameis Winston. Jimmy Garoppolo emerges as a logical possibility, while names like Anthony Richardson, Joe Milton and Pittsburgh’s young quarterbacks enter the conversation as potential lottery tickets. Aaron Rodgers even gets floated if Pittsburgh’s season falls apart, but that idea is quickly rejected as the Giants weigh the difference between finding immediate insurance and taking a chance on someone who could have a future in New York.
John Harbaugh isn’t ready to surrender the Giants’ season. His decision to say Jaxson Dart is out for the “regular season” sparks a debate over whether Harbaugh was deliberately sending a message that he still expects his team to be playing in January. With Jameis Winston taking over, Tiki Barber explains why the Giants must reshape their offense and lean into a physical downhill running game instead of trying to replicate what worked with Dart. The conversation also turns toward Dart’s long-term recovery, the concern surrounding his meniscus injury and why the Giants need to spend this season proving their young core can become the foundation of a contender.
Jaxson Dart is done for the regular season, but the Giants’ season doesn’t have to die with him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what New York should expect with Jameis Winston taking over, including whether a veteran quarterback can still lead this team to eight, nine or even more wins. Evan points to the 2015 Jets and Ryan Fitzpatrick as proof that losing a young quarterback doesn’t automatically destroy a season. The conversation gets heated over whether wins and losses should remain the Giants’ ultimate measuring stick or whether the focus should shift toward the development of young building blocks like Abdul Carter and Malik Nabers.
The Andy Green hiring has been a mix reaction. Evan weighs in on player reactions along with emailer reactions.
On an emotional episode Evan and Tiki discuss why the Giants' season isn't over despite the worst case news surrounding Jaxson Dart, while Morash can't buy in. Oh and the Mets have a manager.
Jaxson Dart’s potentially season-ending injury has Giants fans reeling, but Tiki Barber refuses to accept that the season is already over. He blasts the “loser mentality” of giving up and argues the Giants must immediately rally around Jameis Winston, regardless of how ugly his first appearance looked. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash explain why the uncertainty surrounding Dart has been such a gut punch for fans, especially after hope briefly emerged that the injury might be minor. The debate gets heated over whether Giants fans need time to grieve or should move forward immediately, while the focus shifts to Winston, John Harbaugh and whether the Giants can keep winning without their young quarterback.
Jaxson Dart’s knee injury has turned the Giants’ rising expectations into immediate uncertainty. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much the injury changes the season, why Jameis Winston now faces an enormous challenge, and whether the Giants gave fans false hope about Dart’s condition before getting a definitive diagnosis. Tiki explains why major knee injuries can be difficult to evaluate without imaging and why the rest of the roster must now elevate its play. The conversation also turns to the Mets making Andy Green their full-time manager. Evan believes Green earned the opportunity through his work with young players, but questions why the Mets did not conduct a broader formal search and admits his trust in the organization remains shaky. Shaun Morash also wonders whether the Mets strategically dropped the news while New York was consumed by Dart’s injury.
Jaxson Dart’s season is officially over after suffering MCL, PCL and meniscus damage, sending the Giants into a brutal new reality. Connor Hughes explains why the initial optimism disappeared after the MRI, what surgery means for Dart’s recovery and why a high draft pick could force the Giants to reconsider their quarterback future. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber also debate whether Giants fans are giving up too quickly, while Jameis Winston takes over an offense that may need to protect him from himself. Can the Giants lean on the running game and keep their season alive, or has Dart’s injury already changed everything they hoped to learn this year?
Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts analyze the devastating loss of New York Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart and what it means for the team's playoff hopes. They debate whether Jameis Winston can effectively lead the offense and discuss potential backup additions like Josh Johnson or Joe Milton. They also address the Yankees' postseason seeding and the upcoming NBA Media Day.(00:01:52) Yankees Postseason Outlook(00:05:35) Wild Card Scenarios(00:09:13) Impact Of Jackson Dart Injury(00:12:36) Winston's Must-Win Game(00:18:18) NBA Media Day Excitement(00:22:56) Jameis Winston's Expectations(00:27:41) Giants Fan Sentiment(00:32:27) Searching For Backup Quarterbacks(00:40:52) Analyzing Quarterback Connections
Jameis Winston is suddenly carrying enormous pressure after Jaxson Dart’s season-ending injury. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Winston can keep the Giants’ season alive, why his experience in the offense gives him a real chance, and how quickly things could unravel if the interceptions pile up. They also explain why Winston’s personality and growing media ambitions will face a different level of scrutiny now that he is the starter. Plus, the Giants go from despair to playoff hope, Tiki lays out what a convincing win over Tennessee could change, and the Knicks’ championship continues to torment everyone outside their fan base.
Jaxson Dart’s season-ending injury already ranks among the most painful moments Shaun Morash has experienced as a Giants fan. From the 2002 Wild Card collapse to the DeSean Jackson nightmare and Plaxico Burress shooting himself, Shaun reveals where the Dart news lands on his personal list of Giants heartbreak. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber then look at what comes next and why Dart’s recovery could completely reshape how this moment is remembered. A caller pushes back on the idea that Dart hasn’t accomplished much, while Evan argues John Harbaugh deserves more credit for reviving the Giants fan base. The debate also returns to whether declaring the season over is realistic or simply giving up too soon.
C-Mac joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber for a heated Giants debate after Jaxson Dart’s season-ending injury. Evan pushes back hard on C-Mac and Shaun Morash declaring the season “over,” arguing that giving up this early is a loser mentality even after such a crushing setback. C-Mac explains that losing Dart doesn’t mean the Giants can’t win games, but it completely changes the purpose and excitement of the season because fans will no longer get the quarterback evaluation they expected. The argument then turns to tanking, the Giants’ future with Dart and whether staying hopeful is admirable or simply delusional.
Jaxson Dart’s season is over after suffering MCL, PCL and meniscus damage that will require surgery. Connor Hughes explains why the Giants initially believed Dart had avoided a major injury, how the MRI completely changed the outlook and why the setback could eventually force a difficult quarterback conversation if New York lands near the top of the draft. With Dart sidelined, Jameis Winston becomes the Giants’ starter. Hughes explains why the locker room embraces Winston but believes the offense must protect him from himself by limiting his throws, leaning on the running game and avoiding situations where his aggressive style can become costly.
Jaxson Dart’s knee injury continues to crush the optimism surrounding the Giants, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into why fans initially believed they had escaped a devastating outcome. Tiki explains why avoiding an ACL tear did not guarantee good news and why proper imaging was always needed before anyone could understand the severity. Giants callers vent about another major injury hitting one of the franchise’s most important players, while Tiki argues the team now gets a chance to reveal who will step up when adversity hits. The conversation also returns to Andy Green, as a Mets fan makes the case that keeping him provides valuable continuity entering a potentially complicated offseason.
Andy Green is officially the Mets manager, but Evan Roberts still has a major issue with how the organization reached its decision. Evan believes Green earned the job through his handling of young players, yet questions why David Stearns did not conduct a full formal search and admits he simply does not trust the Mets enough to assume every option was explored. Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that Green represents a settlement, while Shaun Morash wonders whether the Mets intentionally announced the move while New York sports attention was consumed elsewhere. The debate turns to Green changing his mind about managing, the reaction from Mets fans, and whether the franchise really needed a bigger-name hire.
Jaxson Dart’s injury has brought the Giants’ biggest preseason fear to life. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine how quickly the team’s growing expectations can collapse without its starting quarterback and why Jameis Winston now needs to provide an exceptional response while the defense finally lives up to expectations. The conversation also turns to the confusing information surrounding Dart’s injury. Tiki questions how optimistic timelines could emerge before proper imaging was completed and explains why non-medical impressions can be misleading. Plus, callers challenge the hosts over Aaron Glenn’s costly mistakes, while Evan pushes back on the idea that the Jets’ loss can be blamed entirely on their head coach.
Tiki Barber doubles down against Giants fans who believe Jaxson Dart’s injury has effectively ended their season. One caller argues that fans deserve time to be devastated after losing the young quarterback who represented so much hope, but Tiki insists injuries are part of football and the Giants still have games to win. Shaun Morash explains why another stretch of backup quarterback football feels like Groundhog Day for a fan base that has endured years of instability. But Tiki keeps coming back to John Harbaugh, arguing that if Giants fans truly believe they finally have an elite head coach, losing Dart cannot automatically become a death sentence for the season.
The Giants still don’t know how long Jaxson Dart will be sidelined, and the uncertainty is driving fans crazy. What initially sounded like a relatively minor injury has turned into multiple possible timelines, including the possibility of Dart missing the rest of the season. Evan Roberts wrestles with the confusing reports and the emotional whiplash surrounding Dart’s status, while Tiki Barber wants no part of the speculation. Tiki argues that until the Giants have a definitive answer, obsessing over every report accomplishes nothing. His focus is simple: Dart is unavailable right now, Jameis Winston is playing, and the Giants need to prepare for the quarterback they actually have.
Tiki Barber is furious with Giants fans already declaring the season over after Jaxson Dart’s potentially serious injury. He calls out the “loser mentality” surrounding the team and argues that going from an unproven second-year quarterback to veteran Jameis Winston is no reason to surrender the season. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash push back on just how quickly fans should move on, explaining why losing Dart crushes much of the excitement surrounding this Giants season. Tiki insists the focus has to shift immediately to Winston, John Harbaugh and the winnable games ahead, while the debate turns to whether Giants fans can truly rally around their new starting quarterback.
Following a crushing loss to the Rams, the Giants are spiraling after news breaks that quarterback Jaxson Dart may need season-ending knee surgery. As Jameis Winston takes the reins, the hosts clash over whether John Harbaugh and the front office lied to fans about the severity of the injury.
Jaxson Dart was injured, Jameis Winston sucked, Joe B joined the show, and much more on a wild Tuesday,
Jaxson Dart’s knee injury turned a brutal Giants loss into a much bigger concern. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Dart going down, the uncertainty surrounding his availability, and the growing question of whether the young quarterback can stay healthy. Meanwhile, Jameis Winston delivered a disastrous performance off the bench, leaving the Giants with little chance to compete after Dart exited. Shaun Morash joins Evan and Tiki as the criticism turns toward John Harbaugh. They debate his late-game personnel decisions, rip the Giants’ clock management before halftime, and examine whether keeping key starters on the field contributed to more injuries. Tiki also explains why the Rams exposed New York’s defense and why the Giants still have a long way to go before matching the NFL’s elite.
Jaxson Dart’s knee injury completely changed the Giants’ night as the Rams dominated New York and exposed just how much this offense depends on its young quarterback. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much of the ugly loss can fairly be evaluated without Dart, while digging into Jameis Winston’s struggles, the red-zone play calling and John Harbaugh’s decisions in his first real wave of criticism as Giants head coach. The defensive concerns may be just as serious. The Giants’ highly touted pass rush sits near the bottom of the NFL in pressure rate despite major expectations for Brian Burns, Abdul Carter and Kayvon Thibodeaux. Shaun Morash also relives his emotional game-night tweets and his ongoing feud with Jets fans before breaking news hits: Aaron Judge is expected to miss the Yankees’ Wild Card Series with a calf strain.
Joe Benigno unloads on Aaron Glenn and Frank Reich after the Jets let a winnable game slip away, ripping the late-game decisions, play calling, penalties and missed opportunities that turned another Sunday into a “same old Jets” loss. Still, Joe believes this roster is significantly better than last year and explains why he remains optimistic about the team’s future. Jaxson Dart’s injury also sucked the life out of the Giants almost immediately. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Jameis Winston’s rough relief appearance, a brutal offensive line performance and John Harbaugh’s history trying to survive with backup quarterbacks. Plus, Aaron Judge is expected to miss the AL Wild Card series and Jazz Chisholm is set to return.
Evan and Tiki evaluate the timeline for Jaxson Dart's return to the Giants and discuss the Jets' addition of Will Levis. They also delve into Yankees playoff scenarios, Aaron Judge's injury status, and the rumors regarding Aaron Boone potentially managing the Mets. (00:01:51) Giants and Jets Quarterbacks (00:08:03) Parenting and Team Fandom (00:11:35) Rams Dirty Play Allegations (00:17:32) Yankees Playoff Scenarios (00:23:11) TreVeyon Henderson Media Exchange (00:26:55) Aaron Judge's Injury Impact (00:33:40) Aaron Boone Manager Rumors (00:39:10) Giants Draft Pick Critique
Aaron Judge’s potential return becomes a major Yankees debate as Evan and Tiki weigh whether even a diminished Judge still makes the lineup better and what a World Series run without him could mean for the conversation around his legacy. The Yankees also have one narrow path left to steal the AL East, requiring a perfect finish and help from Tampa Bay. Tiki also goes carry by carry through TreVeyon Henderson’s rushing performance after an awkward exchange with a reporter, arguing Henderson had every reason to be frustrated by questions about his consistency.
Jaxson Dart’s injury may not keep him out as long as Giants fans feared. Shaun Morash says he’s hearing an encouraging outlook, while Tiki Barber and Shaun both predict Dart returns October 11 against Washington. Evan Roberts is slightly more cautious, picking October 18 against the Saints as the quarterback’s comeback date. The crew also examines what Jameis Winston’s performance could mean for Dart’s timeline, reacts to the Jets signing Will Levis to the practice squad, and pushes back on complaints that the Rams played dirty. After a brutal Giants loss, the bigger truth is impossible to ignore: Los Angeles was simply the far better team.
Jaxson Dart’s injury instantly changes the Giants’ outlook, putting Jameis Winston in charge of keeping the season afloat. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine Winston’s brutal first appearance, why a full week of preparation should help and whether the Giants can survive until Dart returns. John Harbaugh’s 6-11 record when starting backup quarterbacks during the Lamar Jackson era adds another concerning layer. Shaun Morash also counts down the five worst parts of the Giants’ loss, from the offensive line collapse to injuries and questionable coaching. Plus, Aaron Judge is expected to miss the AL Wild Card series, Jazz Chisholm is set to return and a Mets fan takes Yankees trolling to another level.
Joe Benigno unloads on Aaron Glenn after another “same old Jets” loss, hammering his fourth-down decisions, overtime strategy, and late-game management. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into the coaching mistakes, Frank Reich’s brutal play calling, costly penalties, special teams breakdowns, and a Jets offense that disappeared when the game was there to be won. Despite the frustration, Joe isn’t ready to bury the season. He believes the defense has taken a major step forward, Geno Smith gives the Jets competent quarterback play, and the roster is dramatically better than last year. The conversation also turns to Jaxson Dart’s injury, the Giants’ opportunity in the NFC East, and why Joe desperately wants Glenn to prove he can become the Jets’ long-term answer.
Shaun Morash becomes the target of “Posted and Toasted” after an emotional night of Giants tweets, including panic over Jaxson Dart, frustration with Abdul Carter and a brutal comparison to the Brian Daboll era. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber pile on as Morash defends his reactions and gets dragged back into his long-running feud with Jets fans over the infamous Aaron Rodgers chicken-wing video. Then the show gets hit with major Yankees news: Aaron Judge is expected to miss the Wild Card Series against Boston because of a calf strain. Evan and Tiki react to the severity of the update and what it means for the Yankees’ postseason hopes.
John Harbaugh’s red-zone decisions come under scrutiny after the Giants failed to capitalize on Javon Holland’s huge forced turnover. Evan Roberts questions why New York leaned on Najee Harris and settled for a field goal, while Tiki Barber explains how losing Jaxson Dart forced the Giants to run plays designed for a completely different quarterback. That raises a bigger question about Jameis Winston’s fit behind Dart. The offense is built around Dart’s mobility and zone-read ability, something Winston simply cannot replicate when thrown into the game without a tailored plan. Evan and Tiki also push back on the idea that Harbaugh should be immune from criticism, arguing that even great coaches deserve heat when their in-game decisions fall short.
Jaxson Dart’s knee injury hangs over everything after the Giants were thoroughly outclassed by the Rams. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how differently the game might have looked with Dart, whether concerns about his durability are fair, and why losing the quarterback makes this Giants team nearly impossible to evaluate. The bigger on-field alarm is a pass rush that was supposed to be the strength of the defense. Brian Burns, Kayvon Thibodeaux and company have produced one of the NFL’s worst pressure rates through two games, leaving an already vulnerable secondary exposed. The Giants may be 1-1, but the circumstances surrounding that record have changed the conversation completely.
John Harbaugh takes his first real wave of Giants criticism after a night filled with questionable decisions. Evan Roberts blasts the Giants for snapping a field goal attempt with five seconds still on the play clock, then kicking into the end zone instead of burning more time before halftime. He calls the sequence coaching malpractice after the Rams nearly turned those extra seconds into points. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber also debate whether Harbaugh should have pulled key starters once the game was slipping away, especially after Brian Burns and Andrew Thomas were hurt late. Tiki then zooms out on the bigger picture, arguing the Giants may have climbed out of the NFL’s bottom tier, but they still are not ready to compete with teams like the Rams, Bills, and Chiefs.
Jaxson Dart’s latest injury sparks an uncomfortable Giants debate: can they rely on their franchise quarterback to stay on the field? Evan Roberts makes clear he is not questioning Dart’s toughness or blaming him for getting hurt, but missing time in consecutive seasons is becoming impossible to ignore. The focus then shifts to Jameis Winston after his brutal relief appearance. Tiki Barber explains why an offense designed around Dart’s mobility and quick decision-making does not fit Winston’s game, meaning the Giants may need major changes if Dart misses time. Evan also compares Winston’s performance to other backup quarterbacks forced into action and finds his effort far worse, setting the stage for the first criticism of John Harbaugh.
Jaxson Dart’s knee injury immediately overshadows everything for the Giants. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the frightening hit, the uncertainty surrounding Dart’s status, and the growing concern about whether their young quarterback can consistently stay on the field. Tiki explains why this injury looked more like terrible luck than something Dart could have prevented. Jameis Winston’s performance only made the night worse. Evan and Tiki rip the veteran backup for missed throws, poor decisions, and failing to give the Giants a chance after Dart went down. Shaun Morash joins the conversation with a more optimistic view of Dart’s injury, while the Giants are left facing major questions at quarterback.
Tune in for a selection of Monday's conversations about Gang Green's gutting defeat at the hands of the Green Bay Packers in Week 2. Boomer and Gio lament how the Jets let a probable win slip away in the fourth quarter, while Evan and Tiki express their disappointment that the defense's dominant effort was squandered. Last, but not least, Craig blasts head coach Aaron Glenn's late-game decision-making: 'He cost us a W!' All that and more ...
The Jets lost in a classic Jets way, plus we look ahead to Giants-Rams and discuss Aaron Judge's latest injury
The Jets found another brutal way to lose, blowing a 10-point fourth-quarter lead before falling to Green Bay in overtime. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber unload on Aaron Glenn’s late-game clock management, including his decision not to use a timeout and give the Jets another possession. Evan calls the sequence infuriating, while Tiki points to Glenn’s inexperience balancing defensive play-calling with his responsibilities as head coach. The frustration goes well beyond Glenn. Geno Smith and the offense completely stalled down the stretch, the offensive line was overwhelmed, and the Jets’ running game disappeared after looking like the team’s identity a week earlier. Evan and Tiki also debate the critical fourth-and-one decision, ripping the shotgun formation and blocking failures that left Braylon Allen with no chance. A game the Jets appeared positioned to win instead became another painful lesson in failing to finish.
Aaron Glenn’s overtime decision becomes the flashpoint after the Jets let a winnable game against Green Bay slip away. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why Glenn chose to take the football despite an offense that had stalled, and why his explanation only made the decision more frustrating. From the failed fourth-down play to poor clock management and costly special teams mistakes, they examine how the Jets wasted a dominant defensive performance. The conversation also hits Breece Hall’s struggles, Garrett Wilson’s limited opportunities and the evolving NFL overtime strategy. Plus, Aaron Rodgers looks old and appears to take a shot at Mike McCarthy, Caleb Williams and Jayden Daniels suffer injuries, Carlos Beltran emerges as a possible Mets managerial candidate, and Howie Rose gets a heartfelt sendoff.
Aaron Glenn is taking heat after the Jets let a winnable game against Green Bay slip away. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into the clock management, questionable fourth-down decision, costly penalties and another failure to create turnovers. Glenn is only 19 games into his Jets tenure, but the mounting mistakes have Evan wondering whether the evidence is already pointing in the wrong direction. The Yankees are also facing a harsh new reality after Aaron Judge’s injury. Tiki and Shaun Morash challenge Evan’s season-long confidence in the Yankees, arguing that Tampa Bay has proven to be the better team and that New York can no longer be expected to reach the World Series. Plus, the Giants prepare for Monday Night Football against the Rams, Mike Tomlin embraces his new role as an NFL troublemaker, and the wildest moments from around the league get the Cinco de Luncho Morash treatment.
Evan and Tiki preview the Giants' Monday night matchup against the Rams, weighing Sean Morash's pessimism against the team's week one success. They also honor the memory of legendary executive Ernie Accorsi, with Tiki sharing personal stories of their time together in New York. Additionally, the conversation covers the Jets' disappointing loss to the Packers and questionable coaching decisions in overtime. (00:02:11) Giants Face Monday Night Challenge (00:05:10) Rams Injury Report Impact (00:10:17) Evaluating Jaxson Dart Performance (00:16:51) Remembering Legend Ernie Accorsi (00:21:30) Accorsi's Most Famous Trades (00:24:21) Rams Third Down Efficiency (00:31:06) Giants-Rams Official Game Picks (00:35:57) Analyzing NFL 2-0 Teams (00:44:18) Jets Overtime Strategy Critique
The Giants head into Monday Night Football with real confidence after an encouraging opener, but the Rams present a much tougher test. Tiki Barber believes John Harbaugh has already changed the team’s personality, while Evan Roberts expects the Giants to prove they belong even if they fall short in Los Angeles. The matchup could swing on the trenches and the Rams’ injuries. Tiki zeroes in on the Giants offensive line and the need for the pass rush to get after Matthew Stafford, especially if Puka Nacua and Jordan Whittington are limited or unavailable. Shaun Morash remains nervous that Stafford and Sean McVay could break the Giants late, while Jaxson Dart and Malik Nabers enter with a chance to build on an impressive Week 1.
Shaun runs through the wildest NFL developments in Cinco de Morash, including the Chargers’ brutal start, Caleb Williams’ dramatic injury scare and Jayden Daniels hurting his elbow again. Patrick Mahomes also acknowledges the constant claims that Kansas City gets favorable calls after a controversial overtime decision goes against the Chiefs. Plus, attention turns to Giants-Rams on Monday night, with Puka Nacua’s status and Los Angeles’ injuries potentially opening the door for the Giants.
Aaron Glenn’s decision-making is becoming impossible to ignore. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the Jets’ failed fumble challenge, disastrous clock management before halftime and the growing list of troubling moments through Glenn’s first 19 games as a head coach. Evan wants Glenn to succeed, but admits the evidence is mounting that he may not be the answer. Jets callers are already losing patience, but Evan says Glenn deserves the full season before a final judgment. The blame also extends beyond the coach, with costly penalties, missed fumble recoveries and player execution helping Green Bay steal a game the Jets appeared positioned to win. Tiki points to the defense as Glenn’s strongest argument while the pressure continues to build.
Aaron Judge’s injury has completely changed the Yankees conversation. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash challenge Evan Roberts over his season-long belief that the Yankees were the American League’s best team, arguing that Tampa Bay has proven otherwise and that New York’s flaws can no longer be ignored. Evan owns being wrong about Judge’s injury but refuses to bury the Yankees’ postseason chances, insisting a short series can still swing their way. The debate turns to the overworked bullpen, Anthony Volpe, Spencer Jones and whether this roster was ever as dominant as expected. Plus, Jets fans vent after the loss to Green Bay, with the offense’s late-game collapse, missed fumble recoveries and frustrating mistakes coming under fire.
Jets fans take heat for the atmosphere at MetLife, and Evan Roberts wants none of it. After hours in miserable rain and another crushing loss, Evan defends the crowd, argues the stadium was louder than critics claim and explains why the frustration felt so familiar for a fan base accustomed to painful endings. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh in on the whiteout, the weather and just how miserable the entire experience became. The conversation then circles back to NFL overtime strategy after Evan realizes he had one detail wrong about the Colts-Chiefs finish. That correction leads to a deeper debate over why teams choosing to defend first may need to stay aggressive on fourth down, and why Aaron Glenn’s bigger problem was failing to adjust his overtime plan to what the Jets were actually doing on the field.
Aaron Rodgers struggles against New England, looks noticeably slower and then gives a postgame answer that sounds a lot like criticism of Mike McCarthy. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Rodgers’ performance and the not-so-subtle message he sent about Pittsburgh’s play calling. The NFL injury news gets ugly as Jayden Daniels suffers another concerning setback and Caleb Williams goes down with a hamstring injury that could impact the Jets in two weeks. Plus, Tom Brady analyzes Daniels’ injury, the Bears offense crashes back to earth, and an innocent Fox sideline report about preparing wet footballs produces one of the funniest lines of the day.
Aaron Glenn’s overtime decision leaves Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber questioning whether the Jets coach understood what was happening in front of him. With the offense sputtering and the defense dominating Green Bay, Glenn chose to take the football first, then defended the move by pointing to what the Jets had done in a completely different game. Evan and Tiki explain why that reasoning made the decision even more frustrating. The criticism goes far beyond overtime. They break down questionable fourth-down choices, a disastrous short-yardage play, poor clock management and special teams mistakes that helped waste a tremendous defensive performance. After another collection of costly in-game decisions, the biggest concern is becoming impossible to ignore: coaching played a major role in the Jets letting this one get away.
The Jets’ failed fourth-and-one becomes the next flashpoint in their crushing loss to Green Bay. Evan Roberts liked Aaron Glenn’s decision to be aggressive, but Tiki Barber argues the Jets’ struggles blocking all day made going for it far more questionable. The biggest problem was the play itself, with Braelon Allen taking a shotgun handoff and getting hit before he had any chance to generate momentum. Tiki breaks down the blocking failures from the tight ends and offensive line, while Evan points out that the Jets attacked the exact area Aaron Glenn said they wanted to avoid. After looking like the team’s identity a week earlier, the run game and offensive line failed when the Jets needed one yard most.
Aaron Glenn’s explanation for the Jets’ disastrous end-of-regulation clock management only fuels more frustration. Evan Roberts blasts Glenn for admitting he never considered using a timeout, while Tiki Barber argues that Glenn’s defensive responsibilities may have kept him from thinking like a head coach in the moment. The bigger concern is whether anyone on the staff was helping him manage the situation. The Jets’ problems extended to the offense, where Geno Smith missed chances to extend plays with his legs and the entire unit collapsed after a late miscommunication with Braelon Allen. Five straight drives went nowhere as the offensive line struggled, Geno took sacks, and the Jets failed to finish another game they had under control.
Aaron Glenn’s late-game clock management becomes the biggest target after the Jets blow a 10-point fourth-quarter lead in a crushing overtime loss to Green Bay. Evan Roberts is furious that Glenn let nearly a minute disappear instead of calling timeout and giving the offense another chance to win, while Tiki Barber points to the difficulty of balancing defensive play-calling with head-coaching responsibilities. The frustration runs much deeper. Geno Smith and the offense regressed, the offensive line struggled, penalties piled up, and the Jets repeatedly failed in critical moments. Even Packers coach Matt LaFleur admitted he was confused by New York’s handling of the final minute, adding another layer to a loss that felt painfully familiar.
Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to give his take on Jaxson Dart making the leap in year two after a promising Week 1 performance. Plus, Evan Roberts says fans should embrace the optimism from Week 1 and believe that both New York teams could be on the rise. The Evan and Tiki crew wonder if Tyrone Tracy's job is at risk if he struggles again in Week 2, while Gio believes both the Giants and Jets are catching their Week 2 opponents at just the right time.
Pete Alonso returned to Queens this week, and it brought about PLENTY of debates. Gio says Alonso hitting his 300th career home run to tie the game in the ninth for the Orioles, and getting a curtain call as a visiting player afterward, cemented 2026 as the most embarrassing season in Mets history. Plus, KFC Barstool called in to Boomer and Gio to rip Sean Manaea for criticizing Mets fans for calling for that curtain call. Tiki Barber called out Manaea as well, while Evan sounded off on Alonso for taking the curtain call. On The Carton Show, Craig and C-Mac debate how David Stearns must feel about Alonso's return, and how it might impact Steve Cohen's thought process about the future.
It is two days before Packers-Jets. a White Out is in effect, NFL Picks, and all the Football Friday trimmings.
Josh Allen and the Bills open their new stadium by overwhelming Detroit, giving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber a sobering reminder of what the Jets are chasing in the AFC East. They marvel at Allen’s rare combination of passing, rushing, durability and regular-season dominance, while debating whether his legacy ultimately depends on finally winning a Super Bowl. The Jets may never find a quarterback better than Allen, but Evan argues they can still build a roster capable of beating Buffalo. The conversation shifts to why the Jets have a real opportunity against Green Bay, especially if they can control the game on the ground. Plus, the Giants’ fast start sparks optimism that John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart can create lasting stability, while a frightening Jared Young collision leads to criticism of the Mets’ national broadcast for discussing his future while he was being treated.
Jets fans have officially inherited New York’s desperation crown, at least according to Evan Roberts. Evan argues that years of losing have made Jets fans more passionate than Knicks fans after New York’s championship, sparking a heated debate with Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash over whether winning actually changes a fan base’s hunger. The hour also digs into encouraging signs around Aaron Glenn, including Demario Davis calling the Jets’ in-season practices some of the hardest he has experienced. Plus, the guys debate how the Mets should handle Howie Rose’s final broadcast if bad weather threatens Sunday’s ceremony, compare Josh Allen’s championship pressure to Aaron Judge’s, and revisit the controversy over whether O.J. Simpson should still be acknowledged in Buffalo Bills history.
The Jets want MetLife Stadium covered in white, but Evan Roberts isn’t buying in. Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether fans should feel obligated to follow the team’s whiteout request, why the Jets should provide shirts or white ponchos, and whether the entire promotion makes the franchise look cheap. Tiki explains why rainy weather could actually favor the Jets against Green Bay, while the crew also weighs Aaron Donald’s possible return against the Giants, Dan Campbell’s costly decisions, Aaron Judge’s chances of playing this weekend, and the safest NFL knockout-pool picks.
Tiki Barber details the technical changes he made to secure the football, explaining why ball security is a matter of physics rather than psychology. They provide rooting guides for Giants and Jets fans before making their official Week 2 NFL picks and debating historical MLB sabotage. (00:02:01) New York Football Rooting Guide (00:07:44) Winning vs. Tanking Debate (00:11:25) Physics of Ball Security (00:17:31) Jets Whiteout Gear Debate (00:21:02) Giants Super Bowl Hype (00:25:36) Idiots with Idioms (00:34:06) 2001 World Series Betrayal (00:37:01) Week 2 NFL Picks (00:45:31) Deonte Banks Injury Status
The Jets want MetLife Stadium covered in white, but Evan Roberts isn’t buying the plan. With fans being asked to wear white without getting free shirts, Evan rips the organization for looking cheap and predicts the whiteout could fall flat. Tiki Barber and callers debate whether fans should simply embrace the request, while the Jets’ plan to distribute ponchos only adds another wrinkle. The conversation also hits Aaron Donald’s possible return against the Giants, Dan Campbell’s questionable late-game decisions, Aaron Glenn’s changed approach with the Jets, and the Pro Football Hall of Fame’s revamped voting process.
Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti: Week 1 reaction, Josh Allen's MVP performances, and Week 2 picks
Aaron Judge and Josh Allen may play different sports, but Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash see the same pressure building around both superstars. Each has reached the top tier of his sport, but the conversation has shifted from individual greatness to one demand: win a championship. That comparison leads back into the fight over sports fandom and desperation. Evan argues that fan bases like the Mets and Jets create a different atmosphere because they have waited so long to win, while Shaun pushes back on the idea that previous championships make fans less desperate. The guys also debate whether belief, rather than desperation, is what creates those unforgettable playoff crowds, and Evan notices one surprising trend among young Knicks fans: Karl-Anthony Towns jerseys everywhere.
Evan Roberts says Jets fans have become New York’s most desperate and passionate fan base now that Knicks fans have finally celebrated a championship, and that claim sets off a heated argument. Tiki Barber sides with Evan, while Shaun Morash pushes back and argues that winning does not make fans any less desperate for another title. The debate turns into a larger fight over whether championship-starved fans experience sports differently from those who have already tasted success. Plus, Evan revisits his controversial stance that O.J. Simpson’s football accomplishments should still be acknowledged in Bills history without necessarily honoring Simpson himself, and the guys return to how the Mets should handle Howie Rose’s farewell if weather disrupts his final home broadcast.
Howie Rose’s final Mets broadcast could be threatened by miserable weather, and Evan Roberts wants the franchise prepared to give the legendary voice a proper sendoff. From moving Sunday’s game into a Saturday doubleheader to bringing Rose back for one final call on Opening Day next season, Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate how the Mets can avoid an anticlimactic farewell. The Jets are also showing early signs that Aaron Glenn’s demanding approach may be working. Demario Davis says the team’s in-season practices are among the hardest he has experienced, fueling optimism about Glenn’s defense and leadership. Plus, the guys marvel at Josh Allen playing through illness and question whether Tyrone Tracy’s flu should keep him off the field Monday.
A frightening collision leaves Jared Young motionless on the field, but the Fox broadcast quickly becomes part of the story. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question the decision to discuss Young’s future with the Mets while he was still being treated, arguing that the timing of Ken Rosenthal’s report felt completely wrong even after Young gave a thumbs-up. The conversation then takes a sharp turn when a caller rips Evan for praising “O Canada.” Evan doubles down, insisting that liking another country’s anthem does not make him unpatriotic and declaring once again that “America the Beautiful” is simply a better song than “The Star-Spangled Banner.”
John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart have completely changed the outlook for the Giants. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that fans should temper expectations, arguing that this team should not be afraid of getting good faster than expected. Unlike the 2022 Giants with Brian Daboll and Daniel Jones, they see Harbaugh and Dart as a foundation capable of delivering sustained success and keeping the franchise from falling back into dysfunction. The Jets also enter their matchup with Green Bay believing they have a legitimate path to victory. With the Packers struggling to stop the run, Evan and Tiki want the Jets to lean into their identity, control the clock and produce another punishing, double-digit-minute drive.
Josh Allen’s dominance puts the Jets’ long-term challenge in sharp focus. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber marvel at Allen’s rushing ability, durability and command of Buffalo’s offense after another explosive Bills performance, while acknowledging how difficult it will be for the Jets to eventually knock Buffalo off in the AFC East. But Allen’s career still comes with one massive question: can he finally win a Super Bowl? Evan and Tiki debate how much January success should define an otherwise brilliant quarterback, why Patrick Mahomes still gets the edge in the postseason, and whether Allen will eventually break through. They also explain why the Jets do not necessarily need a quarterback as good as Allen to beat Buffalo, pointing to the Rex Ryan era as proof that the right roster can still take down a superior quarterback.
Pete Alonso didn't take long to hit his 301st home run of his career as he sends one to the seats in he series finale. Follow that up with three more home runs later in the game and the Orioles beat up on the Mets. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
Aaron Judge is injured again, is there worry? Plus Evan has an issue with the Jets home opener
Aaron Judge’s latest injury scare has the Yankees staring at a major October concern. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how worried fans should be after Judge exited with lower-body tightness, whether he can possibly be fully healthy for the postseason, and why protecting him as the designated hitter may now be necessary. That decision could force major lineup changes involving Ben Rice, Luis Garcia, George Lombard Jr. and Anthony Volpe. With the AL East slipping away, the Yankees’ priority shifts toward getting ready for October. Plus, Evan unloads on Pete Alonso’s surprising Yankee Stadium comment after his emotional return to Citi Field, while the crew examines why the Mets’ failure to properly replace Alonso made his homecoming even more painful for fans.
Steve Cohen standing and applauding Pete Alonso’s game-tying 300th career home run sets off Evan Roberts. Evan’s frustration is not simply that the Mets owner celebrated a moment that hurt his own team. It is that Cohen could have kept Alonso in New York, never made him an offer this offseason, then publicly celebrated his return to Citi Field. Tiki Barber is far less bothered, while Shaun Morash questions what Cohen’s reaction says to the players still wearing Mets uniforms. The hour also turns to Garrett Wilson’s understanding of long-suffering Jets fans and Alijah Vera-Tucker admitting how losing can become normal. Evan predicts Elliott Ramos will make a postseason impact for the Yankees, the Knicks’ championship ticket prices spark disbelief, and the Giants-Rams matchup creates a hilarious debate over whether Shaun should use the Rams as emotional insurance in his knockout pool.
The Knicks abruptly paused individual ticket sales after opening-night prices soared past $1,000 for the cheapest seats, blaming a pricing mistake and promising refunds. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether it was truly an error or whether fan backlash forced Madison Square Garden to reverse course. Plus, Tiki explains Tyrone Tracy’s fumbling problem and why ball security could decide the Giants’ matchup with the Rams, the crew revisits how Yankee fans welcomed Reggie Jackson back to the Bronx, and Evan refuses to let the Jets bully him into wearing white for their home-opener whiteout against Green Bay.
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate the Buffalo Bills' decision to exclude O.J. Simpson from the Wall of Fame at their new stadium. They also discuss the New York Jets' controversial whiteout home opener and provide picks for the Thursday Night Football matchup between the Bills and the Detroit Lions. (00:01:50) Juan Soto Position Change (00:04:50) Jets Whiteout Game Controversy (00:10:45) Mets Management and David Stearns (00:17:14) O.J. Simpson Wall of Fame (00:29:30) Bills vs Lions TNF Picks (00:34:15) New York Jets Identity (00:38:05) Weather and Jets Game Prep
The Bills’ decision to leave O.J. Simpson off the Wall of Fame display at their new stadium turns into a much more uncomfortable debate for New York sports. Evan argues that Simpson’s football history should still be acknowledged, while Tiki believes Buffalo is justified in moving on from a player whose legacy became defined by far more than football. Then the argument comes home to the Giants. Lawrence Taylor becomes the key example as Evan challenges where teams should draw the line when honoring controversial franchise legends. If O.J. is removed from public celebration, what standard should New York teams apply to their own complicated icons?
Yankee fans criticizing Mets supporters for cheering Pete Alonso have a problem: history shows the Bronx did the same thing for Reggie Jackson. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash revisit Jackson’s 1982 return to Yankee Stadium, when fans gave him a huge ovation after he homered off Ron Guidry, and Shaun unloads on anyone trying to lecture Mets fans now. The crew also debates the Jets’ first-ever whiteout against Green Bay, with Evan refusing to ditch his green jersey just because the team asked fans to wear white. Plus, the Yankees’ fading AL East hopes hinge on Tampa Bay finally losing, and Sterling Shepard’s return to New York inspires a look at some of the strangest crosstown reunions in local sports.
The Knicks suddenly paused individual ticket sales after opening-night seats appeared with a get-in price above $1,000. Madison Square Garden blamed a pricing mistake, promised to roll prices back to last year’s levels plus a 12% increase and said buyers would receive refunds. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Knicks genuinely screwed up or simply retreated after getting hammered by fans. The conversation then shifts to Jameis Winston’s growing importance with the Giants. Tiki explains why Winston has become such a valuable leader behind Jaxson Dart, while the crew points to one sideline moment that showed exactly how quickly Winston looks out for the Giants quarterback.
Tyrone Tracy’s ball security is becoming a serious concern for the Giants, and Tiki Barber explains exactly what the running back is doing wrong. Tiki breaks down the technique he used to eliminate fumbling from his own game and why one mistake against an elite opponent can completely change a game. Evan Roberts and Tiki also wonder what John Harbaugh’s actions will reveal about Tracy’s role, especially with Najee Harris pushing for opportunities. The conversation also turns to the Yankees’ catching situation after Ali Sánchez appeared unaware the game had ended, plus a fascinating Jets hypothetical: would Josh Allen have failed in New York, and would Sam Darnold have developed much faster in Buffalo?
The Giants’ matchup with the Rams turns into a hilarious fight over “emotional insurance” as Evan Roberts argues Shaun Morash should take Los Angeles in his knockout pool. The logic is simple: if the Giants pull the upset and start 2-0, Shaun will be too euphoric to care that his pool entry is dead. Shaun strongly disagrees, insisting there are smarter survivor options and no reason to risk thousands of dollars against his own team. The guys also look at the Knicks bringing recognizable veterans Bruce Brown and James Wiseman to training camp, plus Jacoby Brissett’s surprising run of passing production and why his career has made him an ideal veteran backup quarterback.
Steve Cohen standing and applauding Pete Alonso’s game-tying 300th career home run creates a heated debate over what the Mets owner was really celebrating. Evan Roberts is bothered less by the applause itself and more by the fact that Cohen could have kept Alonso, never made him an offer this offseason, then welcomed him back and cheered one of his biggest moments. Shaun Morash sees another problem: Cohen was applauding a home run that hurt his own team, which sends a strange message after years of owners insisting every game matters. Tiki Barber is less bothered, but the conversation turns to how Mets players might view the moment and whether Cohen’s handling of Alonso now feels contradictory.
Garrett Wilson understands exactly what Jets fans have endured, and Evan Roberts loves that the star receiver knows how quickly New York will rally around a team that finally gives them something to believe in. Wilson’s comments about rewarding the fan base spark a bigger conversation about why Jets fans remain so passionate despite years of losing. That leads to a revealing contrast with former Jet Alijah Vera-Tucker, who admits the losing eventually became something players could grow numb to. Tiki Barber explains why changing that culture takes more than individual players, then breaks down why advanced football grades can be misleading without knowing each player’s exact assignment. Evan also makes a bold prediction that Elliott Ramos will deliver for the Yankees in the postseason.
Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field ends with a comment that rubs Evan Roberts the wrong way. After Alonso says New York feels like a homecoming whether he’s at Citi Field or Yankee Stadium, Evan argues that lumping the two ballparks together diminishes the love Mets fans just showed him. Tiki Barber sees it as a harmless, if awkward, remark as the debate over Alonso’s relationship with New York continues. The Yankees also have decisions to make with October approaching. With the AL East essentially gone, Evan and Tiki debate whether this is the time to experiment with Luis Garcia at second base and even give Anthony Volpe a look at third.
Aaron Judge’s lower-body injury could force the Yankees into a major postseason lineup shuffle. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Judge now needs to become the designated hitter, what that would mean for Ben Rice and Luis Garcia, and whether the Yankees can trust Garcia defensively at second base with October approaching. The concern goes beyond whether Judge will return. The Yankees need his bat, but protecting him in the field could create difficult decisions everywhere else. Plus, the conversation shifts to Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field and why the Mets’ failure to adequately replace him has made fans miss him even more.
Aaron Judge’s latest injury scare has the Yankees facing an uncomfortable question just before the postseason. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how concerned fans should be after Judge left with a lower-body issue, with Evan believing the early signs suggest this is not a season-ending injury while Tiki warns that Judge has only recently returned and may not be fully ready for the grind. The bigger concern is October. With the AL East effectively gone, the Yankees need Judge healthy more than ever, and there’s no guarantee they’ll get an uncompromised version of their superstar. If the injury happened in the field, moving Judge to designated hitter could quickly become part of the postseason plan.
Pete Alonso came through with a big game tying home run in the 9th inning at Citi-Field. Unfortunately, this time he was wearing a Baltimore Orioles jersey. It also just so happen to be his 300th home run of his career. The Mets still had opportunities to win, but instead a three run in the park home run by Coby Mayo sealed the Mets fate. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
A curtain call was given to Pete Alonso and Evan is unhappy with Pete. Plus Wink Martendale throws shade at Brian Daboll, and much more in an abbreviated show
Pete Alonso’s curtain call has Evan Roberts HEATED, and the debate over Mets fans cheering his game-tying homer turns into a showdown with Tiki and Shaun Morash. Did Alonso rub it in, or did Steve Cohen and David Stearns bring this embarrassment on themselves? Plus, Sean Manaea’s comments spark another argument over how players view frustrated fans. The Yankees face a major October decision: should Gerrit Cole start against the Red Sox despite his struggles against Boston? Meanwhile, the Jets’ historic drive fuels excitement about their offense, and the Giants prepare for a prime-time test against the Rams. Plus, Wink Martindale takes a shot at Brian Daboll while praising Jaxson Dart. 00:00 Alonso Curtain Call Fight 12:52 Manaea Fires Back 38:31 Yankees Division Hopes 49:50 Wink Takes a Shot 1:01:47 Jets Make History 1:10:19 Knicks Banner Night 1:19:42 Gerrit Cole Playoff Debate 1:33:32 Cohen’s Broken Promise 1:49:37 Giants Respect Debate 1:56:52 Jets Playoff Dreams #WFAN #EvanAndTiki #Mets #Yankees #Jets #Giants
Pete Alonso’s 300th career home run came at Citi Field against the Mets, and Evan Roberts could not get past what happened next. After Alonso tied the game and received a curtain call from the crowd, Evan argued that his former favorite Met did not need to come back out of the dugout and “rub it in.” Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash pushed back hard, insisting Alonso was simply giving Mets fans the acknowledgment they demanded. The debate explodes into a larger argument over Mets fans cheering Alonso, Sean Manaea calling the reaction to an opposing player “crazy,” Kodai Senga showing far more understanding, and the anger still directed at David Stearns for letting Alonso leave. Plus, the Yankees continue owning the Twins, while Shaun refuses to completely surrender hope that New York can still chase down Tampa Bay.
Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field keeps stirring up raw emotions after Mets fans celebrated his game-tying home run and pushed him out for another curtain call. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the fans crossed a line, whether Alonso needed to come back out of the dugout, and why his departure still feels so different from other former Mets. The Yankees continue owning the Twins, but Tampa Bay has now moved ahead of New York as the American League favorite while Shaun Morash still sees a possible Yankees sweep of the Rays. Plus, the Jets establish their offensive identity with the longest timed drive in franchise history, Jaxson Dart earns praise after his strong start, and Wink Martindale takes an unmistakable shot at Brian Daboll.
Gerrit Cole’s ugly history against Boston creates a massive Yankees playoff question. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Cole should even start against the Red Sox in a best-of-three Wild Card series, especially with Max Fried’s dominance in the matchup and another strong rotation option available. The conversation turns to whether Cole belongs in Game 1, should be protected from an elimination game, or could even be pushed aside as the Yankees map out October. The Mets’ handling of Pete Alonso also remains a major sore spot, with Evan arguing Steve Cohen has continued the franchise’s frustrating history of letting beloved stars leave. Plus, the Giants’ travel plan for their Monday night matchup in Los Angeles, the excuses that could follow another Giants win, Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees lineup, and Evan already dreaming about what a 2-0 Jets start could mean.
The Giants keep winning, but Evan Roberts says the excuses will keep coming no matter who they beat. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash run through how victories over the Rams, Titans, Cardinals, Commanders and even Eagles could all be explained away, while Tiki argues the way the Giants win still matters when judging their performance. Then the Jets enter the spotlight. Evan is already imagining what a 2-0 start would feel like after years of losing, especially with a home win over Green Bay potentially sending his optimism through the roof. The crew also looks back at rare seasons when both the Jets and Giants started hot and wonders how crazy New York could get if both teams keep winning.
Pete Alonso’s departure remains a major wound for Mets fans, and Evan Roberts argues Steve Cohen has only added to the franchise’s painful history of letting beloved stars leave. Evan points to Alonso and Jacob deGrom as two all-time Mets who were allowed to walk, while comparing the situation to David Wright, whose long-term deal never became a source of resentment because the organization kept its homegrown star. The conversation also turns to fans who once wanted Alonso gone and are now staying quiet, plus Aaron Judge returning to the Yankees lineup, Anthony Volpe’s work at second base, and the Yankees’ postseason rotation possibilities involving Gerrit Cole, Max Fried and Cam Littler.
Gerrit Cole’s history against the Red Sox has the Yankees facing a fascinating October decision. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Cole should start in a potential best-of-three Wild Card series against Boston, especially with Max Fried and Cam Littler producing far better results in the matchup. The question quickly becomes bigger than simply choosing three starters. If Cole is part of the rotation, should the Yankees protect him from a possible elimination game by starting him in Game 1? Or should they trust the matchup data and consider leaving him out entirely? With the postseason rotation potentially affecting the Division Series too, every choice comes with a risk.
Two years after Juan Soto chose the Mets over the Yankees, Evan Roberts admits the early results have been painful for Mets fans. The Yankees have kept reaching October, while the Mets have missed the postseason, sparking a debate over whether adding Max Fried and Cody Bellinger ultimately left the Yankees in a better short-term position than simply keeping Soto. The conversation also turns to a fascinating Mets what-if: if Soto had stayed with the Yankees, would Pete Alonso still be in Queens? Plus, Evan weighs the emotional value of a potential Knicks championship banner night against a Yankees playoff game, and the Yankees make roster moves by bringing back Clarke Schmidt while designating Oswaldo Cabrera for assignment.
The Jets may have found exactly what their offense needs to be. Their 19-play, 11-minute-and-48-second march against Tennessee was the longest timed drive in franchise history, built almost entirely on pounding the football and keeping the Titans’ defense trapped on the field. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why that bruising approach could become the Jets’ identity and give them a path to success. The record sends Evan down a rabbit hole of the longest drives in NFL history, including one from Tiki’s Giants during their 41-0 NFC Championship Game demolition that consumed nearly the entire fourth quarter.
Wink Martindale clearly hasn’t forgotten his Giants breakup. While praising Jaxson Dart, the former defensive coordinator slips in a pointed comparison involving Cam Ward that Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber immediately view as another shot at Brian Daboll. The Giants’ strong start also has the crew looking back at the old regime with a lot more amusement. The Pete Alonso debate rolls on as callers challenge Mets fans for celebrating their former star. Evan argues Alonso is a unique case, while Tiki explains why that kind of lasting love can actually show young Mets what succeeding in New York can mean. Plus, an old prediction about Alonso’s return to Citi Field comes remarkably close to reality.
Pete Alonso’s dramatic return to Citi Field sparks a fierce debate after Mets fans celebrated his game-tying home run and pushed him into another curtain call. Evan Roberts defends Mets fans for still loving Alonso but argues Pete didn’t need to come back out of the dugout after hurting his former team, while the conversation turns to why Alonso’s departure still hits differently than Jacob deGrom’s. Plus, the Yankees continue their complete domination of the Twins, but Tampa Bay has now moved ahead of New York as the American League favorite. Shaun Morash still has a gut feeling the Yankees could sweep their crucial four-game series against the Rays and turn the division race upside down.
The Yankees have crushed the Twins again, but a much bigger problem is staring them down in the American League race. Tampa Bay has finally jumped New York in the betting odds, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the Yankees are running out of time. Shaun Morash still cannot let go, convinced a four-game sweep of the Rays could completely change the division race. The conversation then swings back to Pete Alonso and the Mets fans who celebrated his return. Evan defends fans for showing Alonso love in a lost season while insisting he personally wanted Kodai Senga to strike him out. The debate expands to Jacob deGrom, whether Mets fans would ever root for a former star against their own team, and why Alonso’s departure still feels different.
Sean Manaea calls the Citi Field reaction to Pete Alonso “crazy,” and Evan Roberts immediately unloads on the Mets pitcher for missing the entire point. Alonso was not just another opposing player, and Evan argues Manaea completely ignored what Pete still means to a fan base furious that the Mets let him leave. Kodai Senga offers the exact opposite perspective after surrendering Alonso’s 300th home run, saying the reaction showed how beloved Pete remains and how much he meant to the organization. Evan and Tiki also revisit Alonso’s departure, his decision to opt out, and why David Stearns still has plenty of ground to make up before anyone can declare the Mets were right to move on.
Pete Alonso’s game-tying home run and curtain call at Citi Field sends Evan Roberts over the edge. Evan still loves Alonso, but argues that coming back out of the dugout was unnecessary and felt like one more chance to rub the Mets’ mistake in their faces. Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash strongly disagree, saying Mets fans were demanding the moment and Alonso was simply giving them the goodbye they wanted after hitting his 300th career home run. The argument gets personal as Shaun calls Evan’s anger misdirected, while Evan insists cheering Alonso is one thing and watching a former Met take a curtain call on the road is something else entirely.
Pete Alonso steps back into Citi-Field for the first time since signing with the Baltimore Orioles. How will the fans welcome Pete back? Plus, Francisco Lindor AND Pete Alonso are both looking for career home run number 300. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
Pete Alonso returned and Francisco Lindor didn't love Mets fans' responses. Plus the Chiefs are back, and much more.
Pete Alonso’s emotional return to Citi Field sends Evan Roberts over the edge. Evan unloads on anyone criticizing Mets fans for showering Alonso with love, insisting the fan base did nothing wrong after enduring a miserable season. His biggest target is Steve Cohen, who told Alonso that Citi Field would always be his home despite, according to Evan, never making him an offer to stay. Shaun Morash pushes back on how far Mets fans went, especially when Jonah Tong was pitching well and fans booed after he walked Alonso. Francisco Lindor’s postgame comments defending Tong add another layer to the debate, while callers clash over whether cheering Alonso crossed the line. The hour becomes a heated argument over loyalty, ownership, David Stearns, and what Mets fans are entitled to feel after a lost season.
Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field reignites the fury over David Stearns letting the homegrown slugger walk. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why the Mets are undeniably worse without Alonso, why fans had every right to cheer him, and how Sandy Alderson’s defense of Pete dismantles the arguments behind the decision. With “Fire Stearns” chants ringing out, Evan says the Mets failed because they never came close to replacing their star. Plus, the Chiefs remind everyone how dangerous they can be with Patrick Mahomes and Kenneth Walker, the Giants face more questions about Tyrone Tracy after another fumble, and the Jets get encouraging injury news on Omar Cooper Jr. and Minkah Fitzpatrick.
Pete Alonso’s return sends Mets frustration boiling over as Joe Benigno unloads on David Stearns and Steve Cohen for letting the franchise star walk. Joe calls the decision one of the worst in Mets history, argues Alonso has outperformed Juan Soto, and says Andy Green deserves to remain manager after his work with the club’s young players. The mood is much brighter around the Jets after a dominant 23-10 win over Tennessee. Joe raves about Geno Smith, Breece Hall, the offensive line and the revamped defense while predicting the Jets can beat Green Bay and become much better than expected. Plus, Aaron Judge’s response to whether a pitcher should win MVP ignites a heated debate over Cam’s candidacy and whether pitchers should ever take home the award.
Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts critique Nate Burleson’s recent analysis of Robert Saleh and Joe Burrow before considering Tom Brady’s potential as a cinematic villain. They engage in a heated debate over whether Tarik Skubal is delivering the greatest pitching season in history compared to Ron Guidry and Christy Mathewson. The conversation also touches on Mitchell Voit’s appearance and Gerrit Cole’s awkward post-game celebration. (00:02:03) Burleson CBS Critique (00:06:18) Brady Villain Potential (00:11:14) Tarik Skubal Discussion (00:18:01) Predicting Craig Carton (00:21:01) Fantasy League Dispute (00:24:00) Skubal Pitching Debate (00:32:25) Pete Alonso Return
Russell Wilson stunned Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber by calling Robert Saleh the “king of culture,” prompting a brutal reaction to the former Jets coach’s new reputation. They question whether Wilson did any research before making the claim and wonder if he was simply trying to generate attention with an outrageous take. Wilson wasn’t finished. His declaration that Joe Burrow will be gone from Cincinnati if things go badly this season sparks another round of disbelief. Plus, the conversation shifts to Mets prospect Mitch Voit, a prediction that the Mets will pursue Tarik Skubal, Garrett Cole’s awkward Yankees celebration, and why Cam Schlittler has separated himself in the playoff rotation.
Aaron Judge’s stance on pitchers winning MVP sets off a heated argument over whether a starting pitcher can truly be the most valuable player in baseball. Evan argues that pitchers should remain eligible and points to Pedro Martinez’s 1999 season as proof, while Tiki and Shaun push back hard on how much value a pitcher can provide when appearing only once every five days. The debate turns into a full-on baseball philosophy fight over workload, team success and whether modern starters can ever do enough to win MVP. Plus, a Mets caller raises a bizarre question after spotting an injured player leaving Citi Field before Pete Alonso’s return, leading to a discussion about the club’s future at first base.
Joe Benigno is delirious over the Jets after a dominant 23-10 win over Tennessee, and he believes this team is ready to blow past expectations. He raves about Geno Smith, Breece Hall, the offensive line and the revamped defense, calls the Sauce Gardner trade an all-time fleece, and boldly predicts the Jets can beat Green Bay and become a legitimate factor this season. Then the mood turns furious. Joe unloads on David Stearns and Steve Cohen for letting Pete Alonso walk, calling it one of the worst mistakes in Mets history and saying Stearns should be fired. He argues Alonso has been better than Juan Soto, blasts Soto’s lack of big moments, and says Andy Green has earned the right to manage the Mets moving forward.
Posted and Toasted digs up some wild old WFAN takes, including a prediction that Pete Alonso would hit 500 home runs, Shaun Morash mocking Robert Saleh lookalikes, and Craig Carton taking a shot at Sean Payton and the Broncos that looks very different in hindsight. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber try to identify who posted each one while revisiting some of the station’s funniest receipts.
John Harbaugh’s comments about the Giants’ fumbling issues have Evan Roberts wondering whether Tyrone Tracy is already losing the coach’s trust. Harbaugh publicly backed Isaiah Likely and Cameron Scott after their mistakes, but Evan notices Tracy never received the same vote of confidence. With the Giants continuing to add competition at running back, Evan questions how many more chances Tracy will get to prove he belongs. Evan and Tiki Barber also react to encouraging Jets injury news involving Omar Cooper Jr. and Minkah Fitzpatrick, while Mets callers defend cheering Pete Alonso and blasting David Stearns for letting him walk.
Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field puts the Mets’ decision to let him walk back under the microscope. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber argue the Mets are unquestionably worse without Alonso, while Sandy Alderson’s breakdown of the move leaves David Stearns’ reasoning looking even harder to defend. Evan says the biggest problem is simple: the Mets never replaced their homegrown star. Plus, Patrick Mahomes and Kenneth Walker remind everyone how dangerous the Chiefs can still be, and the electric atmosphere around the Jets sparks a debate over which New York fan base has become the most desperate for winning.
Francisco Lindor’s defense of Jonah Tong draws a warning from Evan Roberts, who insists Mets players should be careful about lecturing fans after a brutal season. Evan says he has no problem with Lindor supporting his teammate, but pushes back on the idea that Mets fans crossed a line by cheering Pete Alonso. The argument escalates as a caller calls the Citi Field reaction “pathetic,” while Evan and Shaun Morash debate whether fans were actually rooting against the Mets. A flashback to Tino Martinez’s 2003 return to Yankee Stadium adds another wrinkle, as the crew compares how Yankees fans treated a beloved former player once the game was out of reach.
Evan Roberts refuses to apologize for Mets fans cheering Pete Alonso, arguing that their support for a franchise favorite was never an attack on Jonah Tong or the current team. The debate intensifies over whether fans crossed the line by rooting for Alonso while Tong was trying to deliver one of his best starts. Tiki Barber pushes Evan on how young Mets players might view the bizarre atmosphere, while callers weigh in on the fan reaction. The conversation also revisits how Yankees fans treated Tino Martinez and how Mets fans welcomed Mike Piazza back, raising the bigger question of when loyalty to a former star should end once the game begins
Evan Roberts erupts after Pete Alonso’s return to Citi Field, ripping anyone who says Mets fans were wrong for cheering their former star. Evan argues that a fan base watching an awful, underachieving team had every right to shower Alonso with love, and he unloads on Steve Cohen for telling Pete that Citi Field will always be his home despite never making him an offer to stay. Tiki Barber says Alonso’s return finally ignited years of frustration Evan had been holding in over the direction of the Mets. Shaun Morash agrees fans had every right to celebrate Pete, but pushes back when that support begins affecting Jonah Tong and the current Mets on the field.
Tune in as the hosts of Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle react to Gang Green's resounding win over the Tennessee Titans and old friend Robert Saleh. While the Titans were unimpressive, the Jets more than handled their business. What are the takeaways for this Jets team as they look to restore their credibility and build confidence within the fanbase?
The New York Giants kicked off their season with a statement victory behind Jaxson Dart's poise and a relentless ground attack. We break down Malik Nabers' return, line-of-scrimmage dominance, and what this win means for the rest of the season.
For the first time since 2009 the Giants and Jets each won their season openers in the same year. We break down the terrific day it was for the locals, plus the Yankees seize the Subway Series.
The Giants delivered everything the John Harbaugh era promised, overpowering the Cowboys in a dominant opening-night win at MetLife Stadium. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the physicality, coaching and control that made this feel different from recent Giants teams, while Jaxson Dart impressed with quick decisions, three touchdown passes and a clear evolution from last season. The running game imposed its will, Isaiah Likely created matchup problems, and the Giants overcame mistakes and questionable officiating without losing command. The Jets gave New York another reason to celebrate by pounding Robert Saleh and the Titans. Evan loves the identity Frank Reich’s offense showed behind a dominant line and heavy doses of Breece Hall and Braelon Allen, while Geno Smith delivered an encouraging debut. The Jets finally looked competent, physical and functional, leaving both New York football fan bases with something they have rarely shared lately: a happy Monday.
The Giants stunned Dallas 28-20 behind Jaxson Dart, a physical offense and a dramatic return from Malik Nabers, whose status remained uncertain until the weekend. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down John Harbaugh’s bizarre attempt to prove Nabers was healthy, the Giants’ dominant ball control, Dak Prescott’s costly interception and Tyrone Tracy’s fumble that quickly buried him in the backfield rotation. The Jets also opened with a convincing 23-10 win, but Evan spots late-first-half mistakes from Aaron Glenn and Geno Smith that better teams could punish. Plus, the Sauce Gardner trade suddenly looks even sweeter if Indianapolis struggles, the Yankees’ Subway Series win still leaves their AL East hopes hanging by a thread, and Cameron Scattabo’s backflip sparks another celebration debate.
Robert Saleh’s Tennessee debut could not have gone much worse. Titans fans were already booing and calling for his firing after an ugly loss to the Jets, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Saleh’s quick return to head coaching was questionable from the start. They also revisit Matt LaFleur’s costly fourth-down gamble, Kellen Moore’s aggressive two-point decision and another classic Chargers collapse. The Giants and Jets are both 1-0, and optimism is building around New York football. Tiki explains how the Giants can beat the Rams by controlling possession and pounding the run, while Evan argues Los Angeles is vastly overrated. Plus, Shaun Morash gets credit for warning everyone away from the Chargers in knockout pools, the Colts give Jets fans another team to root against, and the crew reacts to a wild, record-setting opening week across the NFL.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Mets fans should cheer for a Pete Alonso home run during his emotional return to Citi Field. They also break down the Giants' victory over the Cowboys, highlighting the physical presence of Patrick Ricard and the team's ability to stop the run. (00:02:02) Patrick Ricard Impact (00:06:09) Giants Post-Game Analysis (00:14:20) Pete Alonso Returns (00:20:10) Predicting Carton's Reaction (00:23:16) Backup Quarterback Value (00:31:33) Jets Victory Analysis (00:36:04) MNF Betting Picks
Tyrone Tracy’s costly fumble could put his Giants role in jeopardy just one week into the season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down a crowded backfield featuring Cam Skattebo, Devin Singletary and Najee Harris, while Tiki explains why Deonte Banks may face an even bigger challenge trying to contain Puka Nacua against the Rams.
The Chargers’ stunning loss to Arizona tops Shaun Morash’s biggest stories from a chaotic NFL Sunday, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to huge performances across the league. Lamar Jackson and the Ravens roll, Carson Wentz unlocks Justin Jefferson, and the Bears erupt for 59 points ahead of their upcoming matchup with the Jets. After the highest-scoring Week 1 ever, Tiki argues the offensive explosion is tied to starters barely playing in the preseason and defenses struggling with regular-season speed. Plus, the crew talks about influencers taking over NFL crowds, Taylor Swift fatigue and the upcoming John Tuggle movie that has Evan ready to head back to the theater.
Robert Saleh’s tenure in Tennessee is already off to a brutal start. Titans fans booed the offense, chants calling for Saleh’s firing broke out in the opener, and Evan Roberts points out that Saleh is already giving the same answers about losing that he gave during his Jets tenure. The crew questions why Saleh received another head coaching opportunity so quickly and argues Brian Daboll had accomplished more with the Giants. Attention then turns to the Giants’ upcoming matchup with the Rams. Tiki Barber explains how New York can win again by controlling possession, staying balanced and running effectively, while Evan doubles down on his belief that Los Angeles is vastly overrated and Monday night is absolutely winnable.
The Jets and Giants finally gave New York football fans something almost unheard of, with both teams winning on the same Sunday for just the 10th time since 2017. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber put the rarity of that moment into perspective before debating two massive coaching decisions that helped shape Sunday’s NFL action. Kellen Moore gambled on a two-point conversion rather than trusting the Saints defense, while Matt LaFleur gave up an eight-point lead opportunity in a decision the crew calls horrific. Plus, Shaun Morash takes a victory lap after warning everyone not to trust the Chargers in knockout pools, and a Giants fan explains why the MetLife Stadium crowd finally felt overwhelmingly blue against Dallas.
Scattabo celebrated his touchdown with another backflip, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Giants should embrace it or save it for the biggest moments. Scattabo says John Harbaugh wants him to be himself, and that freedom has become part of the identity of this new Giants offense. The conversation then turns to Tyrone Tracy after another costly fumble. Tiki explains exactly what Tracy must fix with his ball security, why he still brings a home-run element the other Giants backs do not, and why his opportunities could disappear quickly in such a crowded backfield. The guys also weigh in on Tony Romo and Mark Sanchez and why their situations are very different.
The Yankees took two of three from the Mets, but their AL East outlook somehow got worse. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Tampa Bay’s relentless winning has put the Yankees in a position where they may need to sweep a four-game series against the Rays to keep realistic division hopes alive. Attention then turns back to a huge New York football weekend. The Giants controlled Dallas with long, physical drives that kept Dak Prescott on the sideline after his costly interception, while callers celebrate what looked like a completely transformed offense. The Jets’ dominant opener has fans dreaming too, but Evan warns that one win over Tennessee is nowhere near enough for any “I told you so” declarations about Aaron Glenn.
Malik Nabers’ return came with one of the wildest stories of the Giants’ opener, as John Harbaugh actually tackled him to prove his knee was ready for contact. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Nabers’ decision to play, his strong return and why Jaxson Dart’s response to several big hits was another encouraging sign for the Giants. The Jets also cruised past Tennessee, but Evan was frustrated by Aaron Glenn and Geno Smith’s messy end-of-half execution. The mistakes did not cost them against the Titans, but both hosts agree that kind of sloppy situational football has to disappear before the competition gets tougher.
The Jets finally looked like a competent, physical football team, and Evan Roberts believes they may have found their identity. Frank Reich leaned on a dominant offensive line, fed Breece Hall and Braelon Allen, and watched Geno Smith deliver the kind of steady quarterback performance the Jets desperately needed. Tiki Barber was impressed by Geno’s accuracy and leadership, while the defense overcame Minkah Fitzpatrick’s early injury and kept Tennessee under control. Rookie Kenyan Siddiq flashed immediately, Omar Cooper showed his potential before suffering a high ankle sprain, and the Jets even controlled the game enough for fans to relax in the second half. After beating Robert Saleh and opening 1-0, Evan isn’t predicting a Super Bowl run, but for the first time in a long time, the Jets unquestionably have a season.
Jaxson Dart’s growth may be the clearest sign that these Giants are changing. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Dart’s three-touchdown performance, his quicker decision-making and the discipline he showed by taking easy completions instead of constantly chasing the spectacular play. The bigger takeaway is the identity John Harbaugh has already established. Callers celebrate a Giants team that looks bigger, stronger and far more physical, while Tiki points to the culture and humility developing around Dart. After years of ugly wins and frustrating losses, the Giants didn’t escape Dallas. They controlled the Cowboys and looked like the better team.
The Giants couldn’t have scripted John Harbaugh’s debut much better. New York controlled the Cowboys from the opening drive, imposed its physical style and delivered the kind of dominant performance Giants fans have been waiting years to see. The biggest difference was obvious: coaching mattered. Jaxson Dart looked more decisive, getting the ball out quickly and taking advantage of a Dallas defense that couldn’t pressure him. The Giants pounded the football, Isaiah Likely created matchup nightmares, and a crucial sequence after Tyrone Tracy’s fumble showed how this team can overcome mistakes instead of unraveling. Even against a flawed Cowboys defense, the Giants finally looked like the bigger, tougher and better-coached team.
The Patriots losing to the Seahawks has Evan wondering if there is hope for the Jets to shock the NFL world and make a playoff push this year. Plus, should Garrett Wilson feel snubbed for not being named a team captain? Meanwhile, Boomer and Gio discuss how Sam Darnold's injury in Seattle further highlights the Jets' need for a more reliable backup quarterback, and the Evan and Tiki crew discuss what the realistic expectations should be for Geno Smith and the team in 2026.
The season is finally here, and Phil Simms sat down with Boomer and Gio to give his take on how the team looks with John Harbaugh in the fold. Plus, how will Jaxson Dart perform in year two? Evan and Tiki discuss the daunting task that awaits the Giants in their season opener against the Cowboys, Craig Carton rips the team for its handling of Darius Slayton, and debating if the Giants have better weapons on offense than the Jets. Finally, Evan wonders if Harbaugh is picking a fight with the New York media.
Carlos Beltran is the newest baseball player to go into the Hall of Fame wearing a New York Mets hat. The Mets have decided that it's time to retire the number 15 in celebration of Carlos making the hall of fame. Evan, decided to go through the hall of famer's Mets career to find his top Mets moments. You'll be surprised and shocked at what he found! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com
We look back at the tragic events 25 year's ago. wWe look ahead to a Subway Series and finally a Football preview with game previews and picks.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber reflect on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, remembering the heroes who ran toward danger and the role New York sports played in helping the city regain a sense of normalcy. Tiki recalls returning from the Giants’ opener in Denver, while Evan shares his memories of experiencing the attacks from Washington, D.C. Then the focus turns to Week 1. The Jets may have the better chance than the Giants to start 1-0, but Geno Smith remains the biggest unknown. Can he reinvent himself again, and can the Jets avoid beating themselves? Meanwhile, Malik Nabers’ uncertain status complicates the Giants’ matchup with Dallas, while the crew also debates which Giants newcomers and rookies could make the biggest impact this season.
Malik Nabers is making the final call on whether he plays against the Cowboys, and his comments about protecting his career leave Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering if the Giants will open the season without their biggest weapon. Tiki and Evan lean toward Nabers sitting, while Shaun Morash predicts he plays and delivers five catches for 56 yards. The debate turns to how teammates would handle his decision and why the mental hurdle may matter as much as the physical one. Anthony Volpe’s huge return sparks a victory lap over how the Yankees finally handled his development, while Aaron Glenn’s decision to stick with Jason Sanders at kicker raises immediate Jets concerns. Plus, John Harbaugh gets a warning about dealing with the New York media, and the show reflects on September 11, the Giants’ connection to first responders and the lasting meaning of Mike Piazza’s iconic home run.
John Harbaugh’s Giants debut against the Cowboys carries huge stakes, and history says Week 1 could be a powerful sign of where this season is headed. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash look back at Giants coaching debuts, debate how aggressively New York should attack Dallas, and explain why the Giants should want the football immediately instead of deferring. They also break down the importance of stopping the run and unleashing the pass rush against Dak Prescott. The Jets face their own Week 1 questions, including how heavily Breece Hall should be used and the franchise’s bizarre history of opening seasons with revenge games. Plus, Malik Nabers weighs in on playing under a snap count, the show remembers September 11 through powerful listener stories, and Shaun unveils another Giants-focused football segment.
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate the upcoming NFL season, specifically highlighting a grim three-win prediction for the Jets. They discuss the impact of coaching on the Giants' potential and compare the benefits of NFL Sunday Ticket versus Red Zone for fans. The conversation also previews the Yankees versus Mets series and concludes with official Week 1 betting picks.(00:01:50) Shaun Morash’s NFL Rooting Guide(00:05:11) Football’s Use of Baseball Idioms(00:08:34) Jets and Giants Season Predictions(00:14:04) Rams Predicted as NFL Busts(00:17:46) 49ers vs Rams Game Recap(00:19:58) Sunday Ticket vs Red Zone(00:27:16) Yankees vs Mets Series Outlook(00:32:14) Yankees Playoff Clinching Scenarios(00:37:01) Official NFL Week 1 Picks
The Giants cannot afford to ease into John Harbaugh’s debut against Dallas. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash explain why New York should attack immediately, lean on its running game and force Dak Prescott into obvious passing situations so the Giants’ pass rush can take over. The crew also looks back at recent Giants coaching debuts and the striking connection between winning Week 1 and reaching the playoffs. Tiki explains why stopping the run has to come first defensively, while Evan argues the Giants should take the football if they win the coin toss instead of deferring. Plus, a caller gets some jersey advice for Sunday night, and Evan doubles down on his prediction that Odell Beckham Jr. will score a touchdown against the Cowboys.
The Jets are opening another season in a revenge game, and Evan Roberts has had enough. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash run through the bizarre history of former Jets players and coaches immediately getting a shot at their old team, including Robert Saleh, Aaron Rodgers, Sam Darnold and Chad Pennington. Evan also revisits last year’s Week 1 loss and makes one thing clear: playing well means nothing if the Jets still lose. The Giants face an intriguing Week 1 trend of their own. Recent Giants head coaches who won their debut went on to make the playoffs, adding even more weight to John Harbaugh’s opener against Dallas. Plus, the crew calls out Tommy Lugauer for claiming they never reach out to him despite their active group chat.
Breece Hall is healthy enough to play, but will the Jets finally unleash him? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash react to Frank Reich’s comments about Hall’s workload and reveal the stunningly small number of games in which Hall has reached 20 carries. They debate whether Reich will truly feed his star running back and how Hall can hurt defenses as both a runner and receiver. Malik Nabers also makes it clear that if he plays, he does not want the Giants deciding his snap count for him, sparking a debate over who should control that decision. Plus, a caller shares a remarkable September 11 story involving the Giants, and the show looks back at the New York sports headlines from the morning of the attacks, including Michael Jordan’s looming return.
Anthony Volpe returns with a grand slam and five RBIs, but Evan Roberts sees his breakout as proof the Yankees mishandled him for years. Sending Volpe down, forcing him to earn his way back and adding defensive versatility may have finally unlocked the player the Yankees kept waiting for. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether one huge game is enough to believe Volpe has truly changed and whether his hot bat could keep Jazz Chisholm out of the lineup. Plus, Nolan McLean gets his chance to prove himself against the Yankees as the Subway Series puts the Mets rookie directly in the New York spotlight.
Aaron Glenn is sticking with Jason Sanders as the Jets’ Week 1 kicker, and Evan Roberts immediately sounds the alarm after what he saw from Sanders’ leg. With the Jets operating on such a small margin for error, Evan and Tiki Barber explain why one missed extra point or field goal could become a major problem. John Harbaugh also gets a warning about trying to intimidate the New York media, while the crew debates whether Jaxson Dart’s promising rookie season is being overshadowed by questions about his durability. The hour also includes powerful September 11 memories from a first responder and a conversation about why New York sports rivalries still mattered even after the city came together.
Malik Nabers is making the final call on whether he plays against the Cowboys, and his concern about risking his long-term career has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber leaning toward him sitting out. Shaun Morash believes Nabers will play, while Tiki explains why the decision is as much mental as physical and how the Giants locker room would handle losing its biggest receiving weapon. The conversation then turns emotional as callers share memories of September 11 and the role New York sports played in the city’s healing. Evan and Tiki reflect on the Giants’ connection to first responders and why Mike Piazza’s unforgettable home run after 9/11 remains bigger than baseball.
The Giants’ offseason overhaul takes center stage as Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts identify Tremaine Edmunds as the newcomer most likely to make the biggest impact. Tiki also explains why the team’s added size and physicality stand out as the clearest signs of John Harbaugh’s vision taking shape. The conversation also turns to the rookie class, with Malachi Fields emerging as a potential breakout contributor. Plus, callers continue reflecting on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, sharing memories of that day and the difficulty of reaching family and friends as New York and Washington dealt with the attacks.
The Jets may have the better chance than the Giants to start 1-0, but everything could come down to Geno Smith. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate which version of Geno will show up against Tennessee and whether the Jets can trust a quarterback coming off a rough season to reinvent himself once again. The Titans don’t scare Evan nearly as much as the possibility of the Jets beating themselves. Plus, the crew makes a bold prediction that the Jets will finally end their interception drought, while Malik Nabers’ uncertain status adds another major question heading into the Giants’ opener against Dallas.
Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts reflect on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, honoring the firefighters, police officers and other heroes who risked and lost their lives trying to save others. Tiki recalls returning to New York after the Giants played in Denver the night before the attacks, while Evan shares what it felt like experiencing that terrifying day from Washington, D.C. They also remember how sports helped New York begin to feel normal again, from Mike Piazza’s unforgettable home run to the Giants returning to the field. Twenty-five years later, the memories remain vivid, even as a younger generation now knows September 11 only as history.
From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets are trying to put their stamp on the Miami Marlins season by sweeping them. Hopefully this will be revenge for knocking the Mets out of the playoffs at the end of the season last year.
The Patriots and Drake Maye imploded, Tiki looks back at Week 1's in his career, and a failed Yankee prospect won't go away.
Drake Maye’s brutal fourth quarter has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber wondering if the Patriots are far more vulnerable than expected, and whether that suddenly gives the Jets a clearer path to surprise people in the AFC East. Evan also admits Sam Darnold’s injury immediately made him think about Seattle potentially trading for Geno Smith, sparking a debate over Geno, Russell Wilson and how aggressive the Seahawks should be at quarterback. The Giants’ opening stretch also comes under the microscope, with Evan more confident about beating the Rams in Week 2 than Dallas in Week 1. Tiki pushes back on that logic as they debate Dak Prescott, Matthew Stafford, the Rams’ travel and the Giants’ offense. Plus, the Yankees take care of business, the Mets keep winning, and the John Sterling home run call machine makes an unexpected return.
John Harbaugh showed a much sharper side with the Giants media, pushing back on questions about Darius Slayton and refusing to reveal Malik Nabers’ status. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Harbaugh was simply having fun or trying to intimidate reporters, and why that strategy will not stop the New York media from pressing him for answers. The Yankees also lose Jazz Chisholm to the injured list, opening the door for Anthony Volpe’s return after a dominant Triple-A stretch. Evan and Tiki debate Volpe’s proper role, whether Aaron Boone can manage the situation correctly, and how his return could affect George Lombard Jr. Plus, skepticism about Matthew Stafford and the Rams, the Giants cornerback competition, and Mike Tomlin’s debut at the desk.
Mike Tomlin has Evan Roberts’ attention before the Jets even play a game. Evan admits his “wandering eye” is still fixed on Tomlin and believes the former Steelers coach already sounds like he misses coaching enough to return next year. Tiki Barber pushes back on how soon that comeback could happen, while both agree Tomlin’s blunt style and credibility make him a natural on television. Evan also delivers a confident prediction that the Mets will smoke the Yankees, while the crew debates Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and the dangerous Rays. Plus, Sam Darnold’s hip injury raises questions about Seattle’s season, Shaun Morash unveils his Giants rooting guide, NFL fan traditions get ripped apart, and Robert Saleh gets a harsh assessment as he tries to prove himself again as a head coach.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber discuss Anthony Volpe’s return to the Yankees on WFAN and revisit past predictions about his career longevity. Tiki reflects on the specific coaching adjustments that solved his NFL fumbling issues and joins the crew in analyzing the upcoming Rams-49ers game in Australia. They also examine the massive hype and record-breaking ticket prices surrounding the Giants' opener against the Cowboys.(00:01:50) Subway Series Doubleheader(00:04:13) Anthony Volpe Archive Callouts(00:07:48) MLB Playoff Format Criticisms(00:12:45) Mets Player Assessment Discussion(00:17:15) Rams Versus 49ers Strategy(00:22:30) Tiki Career Trivia Segment(00:27:00) Fixing Tiki's Fumbling Issues(00:32:04) NFL Week 1 Injury Report(00:39:00) Patriots Versus Seahawks Analysis(00:44:40) Rams Versus 49ers Picks
Shaun Morash unloads on the NFL traditions he cannot stand, blasting the Seahawks’ “12,” Bills Mafia, the Vikings’ Skol chant, Eagles fans and Detroit’s third-down signs. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber jump into the chaos as the Jets’ simple stadium chant gets rare praise.
Sam Darnold’s hip injury immediately has the crew wondering how long Seattle can survive without its starting quarterback and whether Drew Lock is enough to keep the Seahawks afloat. The uncertainty also catches Shaun Morash’s attention as a Giants fan watching potential NFC wild-card competition. That sets up the debut of Shaun’s new weekly Giants rooting guide, where every NFL matchup gets broken down based on what outcome helps Big Blue most. Evan Roberts goes from mocking the idea to embracing it, while Tiki Barber joins the debate over how the guide could eventually shift from playoff positioning to draft positioning if the Giants’ season goes south.
Mike Tomlin’s television debut has Evan Roberts convinced the former Steelers coach already misses the NFL. Evan admits his “wandering eye” remains fixed on Tomlin as a potential Jets option and believes a coaching comeback could come quickly, while Tiki Barber argues Tomlin may need more time away before returning. The Yankees debate heats up as Jose Caballero gets praised over Anthony Volpe, while the Rays’ ability to put the ball in play makes them a legitimate threat. Evan then delivers his strongest prediction of the hour, declaring the Mets are going to smoke the Yankees this weekend. Plus, Evan fires back at a caller who insists he secretly hates the Giants.
John Harbaugh’s combative approach with the media becomes the center of another Giants debate. Evan Roberts makes clear he enjoys Harbaugh pushing back, but warns that trying to intimidate New York reporters will only make them press harder. Tiki Barber agrees that Harbaugh can handle the media however he wants, but the questions are not going away. The conversation also touches on Anthony Volpe’s return and Evan’s concern about how Aaron Boone will use him before turning to the physical future of football. Tiki explains why he does not expect the sport to fundamentally change despite growing concern about head injuries, emphasizing the inherent violence players accept when they choose to keep playing.
Anthony Volpe is back with the Yankees after tearing up Triple-A, but his return comes with Jazz Chisholm headed to the injured list and major questions about how Aaron Boone will use him. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Volpe should play second base, compete with Jose Caballero for at-bats, and finally settle into the utility role they believe fits him best. There is also concern about how Volpe’s return could affect George Lombard Jr., who replaced him at shortstop and gave an awkward answer when told Volpe was coming back. Plus, Evan explains why he remains skeptical of Matthew Stafford and the Rams despite Stafford’s massive previous season.
John Harbaugh’s relationship with the New York media suddenly turned combative. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down Harbaugh’s sharp responses to questions about Darius Slayton and Malik Nabers, including whether he was simply pushing back or trying to intimidate reporters into backing off. Evan warns that tactic will not work in New York, where Giants reporters will keep pressing no matter how uncomfortable Harbaugh makes it. They also examine why Slayton was cut, how Deonte Banks has earned a fresh opportunity under the new coaching staff, and whether Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history should create real concern despite his huge previous season.
Evan Roberts refuses to buy the Rams hype, arguing that Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history make Los Angeles far less intimidating than everyone assumes. He even feels better about the Giants beating the Rams in Week 2 than Dallas in the opener, sparking a heated debate with Tiki Barber over Stafford, the Rams’ talent and whether their unusual travel schedule could leave them vulnerable. The conversation shifts to the Yankees after George Lombard Jr.’s grand slam, including a listener’s push to revive the John Sterling home run call simulator. Plus, a Jets fan unloads on Bill Belichick amid problems at North Carolina, while Evan and Tiki explain why Belichick’s college tenure does nothing to change how they view his NFL legacy.
The Giants’ season opens with a daunting matchup against Dak Prescott and the Cowboys, and Evan Roberts is already more confident about their chances in Week 2 against the Rams. The Giants’ ugly history against Dallas, their limited preseason work with Jaxson Dart and questions surrounding Malik Nabers all fuel the concern, while Tiki Barber pushes back on Evan’s surprising confidence in a road upset over Los Angeles. The debate centers on whether the Cowboys or Rams present the bigger early-season challenge, with Matthew Stafford’s age and injury history becoming a major point of contention. Plus, the Seahawks’ quarterback situation after Sam Darnold’s injury keeps Geno Smith and Russell Wilson in the conversation, and the Mets somehow provide one of the night’s most compelling games.
Drake Maye’s disastrous fourth quarter has Evan Roberts wondering if the Patriots are already showing signs of a major regression, and whether that could give the Jets a real opening in the AFC East. After watching Maye throw three fourth-quarter interceptions, Evan sees a possible roadmap for the Jets to surprise people this season. Sam Darnold’s injury creates a completely different Jets thought: could Seattle become desperate enough to trade for Geno Smith? Evan floats the possibility while Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash immediately point to Russell Wilson as the more logical Seahawks option. The debate turns into a heated argument over whether Geno or Wilson is closer to playing winning football right now.
The NFL Season will kickoff tonight, and the Giants can look to the Patriots playing tonight as inspiration. We give our Super Bowl picks, and much more.
The Giants have a blueprint for a massive turnaround, and it looks a lot like last year’s Patriots. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber compare Jaxson Dart’s rookie numbers to Drake Maye’s, John Harbaugh’s arrival to Mike Vrabel’s impact, and explain why Big Blue could be positioned for one of the NFL’s biggest jumps. The biggest obstacle is clear: a run defense that finished near the bottom of the league must dramatically improve. Plus, Aaron Judge returns to the Yankees lineup without the storybook moment Evan wanted, while the crew looks ahead to intriguing Subway Series pitching matchups and debates whether the Mets can ever truly become New York’s baseball big brother.
John Harbaugh’s critics get called out as the Giants’ new coach becomes the center of a heated debate. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber push back on the idea that Harbaugh’s playoff disappointments diminish his coaching résumé, comparing his career to Sean Payton, Mike Tomlin and other respected NFL coaches. They also debate what success should actually look like for Harbaugh in New York and whether matching Tom Coughlin’s two Super Bowls is an unrealistic standard. The Yankees’ division hopes are fading as Tampa Bay keeps winning, Aaron Judge’s postseason struggles return to the spotlight, and the Yankees’ incredible streak of 34 straight winning seasons gets some perspective. Plus, Garrett Wilson is left off the Jets’ captain list, MLB expansion could reshape the leagues, and Montreal, Nashville, Portland and Salt Lake City emerge as possible destinations.
Jaxson Dart holds the key to how far the Giants can climb in 2026, but Connor Hughes has serious reservations about whether Matt Nagy’s offense will bring out his best. Hughes explains why Dart may need to become a top-10 or top-12 quarterback for the Giants to make a massive leap, and why the new system could put far more pressure on him than last year’s offense. The conversation also turns to Odell Beckham Jr.’s surprising resurgence, why Darius Slayton was cut and the Giants’ defensive concerns entering the opener against Dallas. On the Jets, Hughes predicts an opening-week loss, explains why Aaron Glenn appears secure entering the season and weighs Breece Hall’s expected workload. Plus, the crew sets the stakes for another season of NFL picks.
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash announce their Super Bowl predictions, selecting teams like the Bears, Broncos, and 49ers to reach the big game. They also discuss the breaking news regarding Rutgers coach Steve Pikiell and reflect on Tiki's past NFL openers. (00:01:50) Super Bowl Predictions (00:06:28) Reviewing Past Picks (00:11:15) Title Game Logistics (00:17:07) Steve Pikiell Diagnosis (00:19:39) Tiki Career Trivia (00:31:10) Giants Roster Outlook (00:33:45) Jalen Brunson Hosting SNL (00:39:30) NFL Week 1 Picks
The Super Bowl predictions are officially on the record, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash go in three very different directions. The crew also revisits their wildly different February predictions, debates strength of schedule.
The NFL is back, but the opening-night Super Bowl rematch brings up one problem: Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash can barely remember anything that happened in last year’s championship game. They revisit just how dull the Patriots-Seahawks Super Bowl was and why that lack of memorable moments has taken some shine off the rematch. Shaun also runs through five things fans need to remember as the new season begins, from the Bills’ new stadium and coaching change to Aaron Rodgers reuniting with Mike McCarthy, Mike Evans changing teams and Jaxson Dart’s record against Dallas. Plus, a diehard Jets caller explains his anxiety over Geno Smith and the team’s quarterback situation.
The NFL picks competition is back, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash agree on a punishment designed to make the losers miserable. The two who fail to finish first will have to attend a sporting event wearing a shirt promoting an opinion they absolutely hate, sparking ideas involving Jalen Brunson, Malik Nabers, Joel Embiid and Evan’s baseball takes. The crew also revisits the Giants’ decision to move on from Darius Slayton, rejecting the idea that the veteran receiver was somehow disrespected. With a new coaching staff setting its own priorities, they argue the Giants simply made the roster decision they believed was best.
Jaxson Dart can change the Giants’ entire outlook, but Connor Hughes has major concerns about whether Matt Nagy’s offense is built to maximize the young quarterback. Hughes explains why Dart must become a top-10 or top-12 quarterback for the Giants to make a Patriots-like leap and why Nagy’s system could make that development much harder. Hughes also breaks down why Odell Beckham Jr. earned his way onto the roster and helped make Darius Slayton expendable. The conversation then shifts to the Jets, where Breece Hall’s workload remains a question entering Week 1, Hughes predicts an opening loss and explains why Aaron Glenn enters the season with significant job security.
The Yankees’ streak of 34 consecutive winning seasons gets put into stunning perspective against every other major New York sports franchise. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much credit the organization deserves, why Yankee fans may take sustained success for granted, and whether the Dodgers have any realistic chance of eventually challenging the streak.
Garrett Wilson being left off the Jets’ season-long captain list sparks questions about what the decision really means. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber listen to Wilson’s reaction, debate whether he sounds disappointed, and explain why the snub should not become a lingering issue inside the Jets locker room.
John Harbaugh’s critics come under fire as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber reject the idea that the Giants should pump the brakes on their new coach. Harbaugh’s playoff disappointments are compared to the résumés of Andy Reid, Mike Tomlin, Sean Payton and other top coaches, with the argument that players have too often failed to execute in his biggest losses. The Yankees are also running out of room in the AL East race as Tampa Bay keeps winning and a four-game series with the Rays starts to look like a must-sweep. Aaron Judge’s return sparks another debate over his postseason struggles, whether a fresher Judge can finally change the October narrative, and why this Yankees roster may not need him to carry the entire offense.
Aaron Judge returned to the Yankees lineup, but the storybook moment never came. Evan Roberts admits he was disappointed by Judge’s hitless night after comparing it to the unforgettable comeback homers from Alex Rodriguez and David Wright, while Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that Judge’s first game back mattered much at all. The Yankees also face a tricky reality as Judge works his way back and may not finish every game, creating late-inning lineup decisions like the one that put Heliot Ramos in a huge spot. Plus, the Subway Series pitching matchups take shape, and a caller sparks a bigger debate over whether the Mets could ever truly become New York’s baseball big brother.
The Giants’ turnaround case keeps getting stronger as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber point to recent NFL examples of teams making massive year-to-year jumps. With Jaxson Dart entering Year 2 and John Harbaugh taking over, the Giants have the kind of quarterback-coach combination that can change a season quickly. The conversation shifts to the Jets, where Evan dismisses the idea of curses and says years of losing come down to organizational incompetence. That leads to a dream scenario involving Howie Roseman somehow taking control of the franchise. Plus, Giants rookie Jack Kelly earns praise as the definition of a Harbaugh-style football player, and the crew gets sidetracked debating C-notes, Roman numerals, and some long-shot Giants bets.
The Giants enter the season with a stunningly similar setup to the Patriots team that made a massive leap behind Drake Maye and Mike Vrabel. Jaxson Dart’s rookie numbers closely mirror Maye’s, while John Harbaugh gives New York the accomplished veteran coach that could accelerate the turnaround. The argument is simple: if New England could make that jump, why can’t the Giants? The biggest warning is the defense. New York’s run defense was among the league’s worst, and unless that changes, the quarterback development and upgraded roster may not matter. The pass rush offers real upside, but stopping the run could determine whether this Giants season becomes a surprise or another disappointment.
Radio new year is here, Aaron Judge rides into The Bronx and the Giants and Jets officially hit game week
Aaron Judge is finally back, and the Yankees now have 19 games to turn survival into a legitimate October push. After going 45-39 without their MVP, the Yankees stayed afloat, but Tampa Bay remains four games ahead and Boston is still lurking. The debate turns to whether Judge can shake off three months without real game action quickly enough to change the AL East race. The bigger priority may be getting Judge fully ready for the postseason, especially with Aaron Boone planning to pull him early from games. Should Judge lead off to maximize his plate appearances, or should the Yankees rethink how they use him late? Plus, the lineup looks deeper with Cody Bellinger, Spencer Jones, Luis Garcia and others surrounding Judge for the stretch run.
The Giants are moving on from Darius Slayton, and Shaun Morash is taking heat for calling the veteran receiver “gutless” in big moments. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine why Slayton became expendable, from the costly drops to a disappointing camp, while questioning whether the Giants have left Jaxson Dart with one of the NFL’s weakest wide receiver rooms. Malik Nabers’ health, rookie Malachi Fields and Odell Beckham Jr. now carry even more pressure.
Aaron Judge is coming back, but how healthy is he really? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate the biggest possible outcomes for Judge and the Yankees, including the fear that pushing through his injury could threaten his postseason. They also shut down the wild internet conspiracy theory surrounding Judge’s extended absence. The Jets face what feels like an immediate season-defining game against Tennessee, while former Jets coach Robert Saleh heaps surprising praise on their offense and urges Titans fans to keep New Yorkers out of the stadium. Plus, the crew examines Jaxson Dart’s lack of chemistry with the Giants’ new-look receiving corps, the Eagles’ strange relationship with Jalen Hurts, whether Shohei Ohtani can truly keep pitching and hitting full-time, and the NFL’s growing push toward football nearly every day of the week.
Tiki, Evan, and Shaun analyze the lineup strategy for Aaron Judge's return to the Yankees and revisit their summer predictions regarding his recovery timeline. They also discuss Zach Rosenblatt’s reporting on the Jets, focusing on Woody Johnson’s relationship with Robert Saleh and the organizational outlook on Geno Smith. (00:01:50) Nicknames and Kon-Tiki (00:05:56) Jameis Winston Backup Debate (00:15:47) Judge Return Predictions (00:22:38) Zach Rosenblatt Jets Report (00:38:26) Judge Conspiracy Theory (00:43:04) Jets Super Bowl Hopes