Trump's Midterm Strategy Is Wrong and Karl Rove Knows Why | Karl Rove
Podcast:State of Gold Published On: Tue Oct 13 2026 Description: GuestKarl Rove, Republican Political Strategist and Former Senior Advisor to President George W. BushGuest BioKarl Rove is one of the most influential Republican political strategists in modern American history. Known as "The Architect" of George W. Bush's two presidential campaigns, Rove served as Senior Advisor and Deputy Chief of Staff in the Bush White House from 2000 to 2007. Before his government career, he ran Karl Rove + Company, an Austin-based public affairs firm that worked on more than 75 Republican campaigns across 24 states. He writes a weekly column for the Wall Street Journal, appears regularly on Fox News, and is the author of the New York Times bestseller Courage and Consequence.Show Summary"Authenticity matters," says Karl Rove, and he means it as a warning. In this episode of State of Gold, host Jon Slavet sits down with the Republican strategist who helped put George W. Bush in the White House, to talk about what the GOP is getting wrong heading into the 2026 midterms, and what it would take to get it right.Rove argues that the current Trump-centric strategy is a mistake. If the president isn't popular, don't make him the issue. Let candidates like Mike Rogers in Michigan and Steve Hilton in California run as individuals. He points to Trump's biggest policy win, securing the southern border, and asks why the president never went to the border to celebrate it with the local (mostly Democratic, mostly Latino) officials who would have praised him on camera.The conversation moves to the Texas Senate race between Ken Paxton and James Talarico, the 2028 presidential field (Rove is blunt about JD Vance: "How do you go from saying Donald Trump is Adolf Hitler to saying I'm honored to be his running mate?"), and a California voter ID ballot initiative that Rove says could start rebuilding Republican credibility in the state. He closes with the story of his great-grandfather Olaf Julius Rove, a Norwegian peasant who came to America with nothing and whose great-grandson ended up working in the White House.Chapters00:01 – Welcome: Karl Rove, "The Architect," on State of Gold00:16 – The Ideal Republican Candidate: Why Authenticity Beats Consultants01:17 – The George W. Bush Playbook: Four Big Issues and One Nobody Expected03:04 – Dan Schnur's Rule: Authenticity, Authenticity, Authenticity03:35 – Trump's Midterm Strategy: Why Making the President the Issue Is Wrong04:05 – Let Candidates Shine: Mike Rogers, Susan Collins, Jon Husted, Steve Hilton05:06 – Message Discipline and Selling the Border Win05:21 – The Border Success Trump Never Celebrated06:52 – Too Little, Too Late: The Midterm Convention and the $5,000 Dividend07:37 – Three Explanations for One Promise: Tariffs, Profits, or Reconciliation08:08 – Trump's Billion Dollar War Chest: Why Holding Back Is Indefensible09:24 – Super PAC Math: When $1 of Campaign Money Equals $10 of PAC Money10:42 – Paxton vs. Talarico: YouTube Dominance and the Texas Senate Race11:12 – Paxton's History of Running Behind the Ticket11:43 – Austin, Travis County, and Why Talarico Went Left13:14 – The 2028 Field: JD Vance, Rubio, Youngkin, Kemp, Cotton, Cruz14:59 – Is Vance Authentic? Rove Says No15:31 – Hillbilly Elegy vs. the Milwaukee Speech: Populism vs. Conservatism16:32 – The Populism Trap: Why Grievance Politics Aren't Optimistic17:03 – Lincoln's Lesson: "As Our Case Is New, So Must We Think Anew"17:33 – How Republicans Win California: Quality Candidates and Wedge Issues19:04 – Voter ID on the California Ballot: A Common Sense Reform Play20:06 – Carl DeMaio, Reform California, and the Signatures to Get It Done20:53 – Voter ID Doesn't Suppress Turnout: The Alabama Example22:25 – The DSA Playbook: Force Democrats to Own Their Party's Fringe23:10 – "Workers Deserve More": The Stump Speech for Every Republican24:26 – America at 250: Rove on Resilience, History, and the Worst Times25:30 – The Country That Keeps Stepping Forward26:16 – Olaf Julius Rove: From Norwegian Peasant to the American Dream27:32 – The Desk, the White House, and the Gift of Being American28:33 – Reagan's Lesson: "We Can Be the Shining City on the Hill"29:05 – Jon's Family Story: From Ukraine Through Ellis Island to CaliforniaConnect with Karl RoveX: https://twitter.com/KarlRoveFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/karlrove/Instagram: https://instagram.com/karlrove/LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/karlrove/Official Website: https://www.karlrove.com/Enjoyed the episode? Subscribe to our podcast, leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify and join the conversation on Instagram and LinkedIn with the hashtag #stateofgoldpodcastConnect with State of GoldX: https://x.com/realjonslavetInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/stateofgoldpodcast/?hl=enWebsite: www.stateofgold.com