Hour 2: Craigie Challenges C-Mac's Kids to Yankee Trivia for Hats
Hour 2: Craigie Challenges C-Mac's Kids to Yankee Trivia for Hats  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Tue May 19 2026
Description: Craig and Chris debate whether the Mets perform better without Francisco Lindor and analyze the current state of the Yankees' lineup. They also dive into the decline of Sports Illustrated following a plagiarism scandal and the history of the legendary Sid Finch hoax. Finally, Chris's sons call in to earn exclusive Looney Tunes team hats by answering team trivia. 01:50 - Mets Performance Without Lindor 04:50 - Viral Mariners Foul Ball Incident 14:38 - Knicks and Cavaliers Series Debate 30:14 - Yankees Catcher and Infield Struggles 36:52 - Sports Illustrated Plagiarism Scandal 46:40 - Portuguese Dining in the Ironbound 01:02:54 - Yankee Trivia With C-Mac's Kids 01:09:19 - Evan Roberts' Performative Scorekeeping