Hour 4: Carton Blasts Aaron Judge for Refusing to Support Teammate for MVP
Hour 4: Carton Blasts Aaron Judge for Refusing to Support Teammate for MVP  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Mon Sep 14 2026
Description: Carton critiques Aaron Judge for stating he would not vote for a teammate as MVP despite a dominant season on the mound. They pivot to discussing Garrett Cole's controversial pre-pitch routine and a debate over the New York Giants' playoff potential. The conversation also explores personal anecdotes ranging from passive income with Tesla taxis to wardrobe disputes during television appearances. (00:01:20) Tesla Taxi Business Plan (00:05:57) Aaron Judge MVP Controversy (00:12:04) Garrett Cole Clock Antics (00:17:59) Personal Bathroom Tales (00:22:12) Wardrobe Conflicts at Fox (00:26:45) Fennel and Italian Slang (00:30:45) Jets vs Giants Wins (00:37:42) Rick Jeanneret Mentor Story