Craig Carton & C-Mac Go Off on NYC Loyalty, A-Rod & Championships
Craig Carton & C-Mac Go Off on NYC Loyalty, A-Rod & Championships  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Thu May 28 2026
Description: On this heated segment of the Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle dive into a fiery New York sports dilemma, would you rather see the Knicks win an NBA title or the Yankees add another World Series ring? Caller Vinnie from Staten Island sparks a full-blown debate, dragging in A-Rod lunch jokes, fan loyalty, and the ultimate NYC sports hierarchy. Craig pushes the emotional weight of a Knicks championship, while C-Mac admits the temptation of Yankees glory—leading to a back-and-forth about fandom, legacy, and bragging rights across New York sports.