This WFAN Caller Took the Carton Show Completely Off the Rails
This WFAN Caller Took the Carton Show Completely Off the Rails  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Thu Feb 05 2026
Description: Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get derailed by another unforgettable WFAN caller, sending the Carton Show into classic chaos. What starts as a normal sports conversation quickly turns into laughs, arguments, and the kind of off-the-cuff radio moments only WFAN can deliver. From wild takes to unexpected turns, this segment perfectly captures why live New York sports radio is unmatched.