Gerrit Cole's Physical Condition and Craig's Jonah Hill Feud
Gerrit Cole's Physical Condition and Craig's Jonah Hill Feud  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Thu Apr 30 2026
Description: Craig and Big Mac discuss Gerrit Cole's physical appearance during a recent rehab start, comparing his current physique to former pitchers like CC Sabathia. They also explore the terminology of Phish fans and recount a cringeworthy past interaction where actor Jonah Hill called Craig a disgusting human being. The segment wraps up with an interview from a teacher leading a massive field trip at a Mets game. 02:06 - Gerrit Cole's Physical Condition 05:13 - Defining Phish Fan Slang 09:01 - Craig's Jonah Hill Confrontation 15:26 - Mets Field Trip Interview 17:01 - Trevor Bauer Mets Debate