Big Mac Debates Yankees' Wild Card Pitching: Schlittler vs. Fried
Big Mac Debates Yankees' Wild Card Pitching: Schlittler vs. Fried  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Fri Sep 25 2026
Description: Big Mac and a caller clash over the Yankees' postseason rotation strategy and whether Cam Schlittler belongs in Game 1. They examine the historical success of Wild Card teams and discuss CC Sabathia's impact ahead of his stadium ceremony. The conversation also previews the Giants' upcoming matchup against the Titans. (00:01:27) Sabathia's Yankee Ceremony (00:03:40) Yankees Wild Card Rotation (00:08:02) Wild Card Success Stats (00:11:41) Rotation Strategy And Pressure (00:16:47) Giants vs Titans Preview