Craig Carton DISOWNS Big Mac Over a LEFT-HAND Fist Bump
Craig Carton DISOWNS Big Mac Over a LEFT-HAND Fist Bump  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Tue Feb 03 2026
Description: Things get wild on the Carton Show as Craig Carton delivers a viral life lesson on why you NEVER fist bump with your left hand and threatens to disown his own co-host, Chris McMonigle, over it. What starts as a simple compliment turns into a full debate on street rules, handshake etiquette, earrings, George Michael, Pete Best, Jets media drama, and whether anyone in the room can be trusted as a “home team guy.” Add in gambling talk, Jets sources getting called out, and classic Carton roasting, and you’ve got pure WFAN chaos from start to finish.