Hour 3: McMonigle and Kostos Relive Heartbreaking New York Sports Losses
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMoniglePublished On: Thu Sep 03 2026
Description: McMonigle and Nick Kostos take a nostalgic trip through painful memories of Giants, Yankees, and Knicks defeats, debating whether the 2001 World Series was worse than the 2004 ALCS. They also discuss the history of WFAN, sharing personal stories from their days as interns and an encounter with the legendary Don Imus. (00:01:20) Ninja Turtles Debate (00:05:05) Animation Style Critiques (00:06:58) Painful Sports Memories (00:11:33) The Crying Game (00:16:32) Aaron Boone Tenure (00:18:29) Astros Cheating Scandal (00:22:30) Nerdy Music Habits (00:26:23) Yacht Rock Metallica (00:28:10) Patrick Ewing Era (00:32:30) 2001 vs 2004
The note was deleted
The note was saved
Your message was sent