Full Show: Giants Trade for J.J. McCarthy Amid Jameis Winston Struggles
Full Show: Giants Trade for J.J. McCarthy Amid Jameis Winston Struggles  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Mon Sep 28 2026
Description: Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Giants' decision to trade for J.J. McCarthy following underwhelming performances from Jameis Winston. They discuss the New York Jets' competitive spirit in their loss to the Lions and the devastating impact of Brian Burns' season-ending ACL injury. The conversation also previews the Yankees' wild card series against the Red Sox and proposes a radical change to NFL officiating. (00:01:50) Giants Trade for J.J. McCarthy (00:08:35) Jets' Performance vs Lions (00:17:30) Winston vs McCarthy Debate (00:45:00) Brian Dawkins Border Controversy (01:02:30) Two-Point Conversion Analytics (01:16:45) NFL Officiating Debate (01:32:30) Brian Burns ACL Confirmation (01:49:20) Drake May Patriots Struggles (02:03:15) Yankees Wild Card Preparation (02:17:45) Monday Night Football Picks