Craig Carton vs Big Mac’s “Five & Fly” Baseball Debate Gets HEATED
Craig Carton vs Big Mac’s “Five & Fly” Baseball Debate Gets HEATED  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Tue May 19 2026
Description: Did Chris McMonigle invent the baseball phrase “five and fly” or is Craig Carton right that Michael Kay STOLE it from the Carton Show? Craig & Big Mac spiral into an all-time WFAN debate after Michael Kay uses the phrase “five and fly” during a Yankees broadcast, leading to accusations, conspiracy theories, listener calls, Knicks ticket drama, Evan Roberts getting roasted, and complete sports radio chaos.