Hour 3: "Justin Herbert Is a Loser!" & NFL Quarterback Power Rankings
Hour 3: "Justin Herbert Is a Loser!" & NFL Quarterback Power Rankings  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Wed Aug 26 2026
Description: They dive into a spirited ranking of NFL quarterbacks, leading to a fiery debate over whether Justin Herbert is a top-tier player or a "loser." The conversation shifts to Big Mac’s vacation highlights, including a terrifying ordeal on a Disney gondola and the absurd punishments for their internal fantasy football draft. (00:02:03) NFL Quarterback Rankings (00:06:34) Justin Herbert Debate (00:13:02) QB Comparison Game (00:20:16) System QB Discussion (00:24:36) Big Mac Return (00:33:44) Giants Interview Review (00:39:18) Disney Vacation Stories (00:47:21) Fantasy Football Draft (00:55:47) Yankees Trade Deadline