Hour 4: Craig and Big Mac Investigate Mitchell Robinson’s Broken Hand
Hour 4: Craig and Big Mac Investigate Mitchell Robinson’s Broken Hand  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Mon Jun 01 2026
Description: Craig and Big Mac weigh the impact of Mitchell Robinson’s hand injury on the Knicks' championship hopes while evaluating Odell Beckham Jr.’s return to the Giants. They share nostalgic stories about scamming CD clubs and risky childhood games before debating the mysterious circumstances behind Robinson's fracture. 02:03 - Ewing Guest Announcement 05:48 - Vanilla Ice Lyrics 10:44 - Underage Drinking Scams 17:08 - Pinky Bone Anatomy 25:42 - Robinson Speculation 31:30 - Building Chicken Annexes 38:26 - Knicks Parade Logistics 48:37 - OBJ Return Analysis 54:52 - Bathroom Wall Punch