Hour 2: Jameis Winston Era Begins as Giants Season Spirals
Hour 2: Jameis Winston Era Begins as Giants Season Spirals  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Wed Sep 23 2026
Description: Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss Jameis Winston taking the reins for the New York Giants following a devastating injury to Jaxson Dart. They critique GM Joe Schoen's performance through a parody song, debate the merits of tanking for a top draft pick, and address rumors regarding a potential Colin Kaepernick signing. The conversation also highlights the lack of playoff football at MetLife Stadium and the current dynamic between Jets and Giants fans. (00:01:20) Peter Joins The Team (00:04:25) Winston Named Starting Quarterback (00:08:45) Giants Postseason Outlook (00:12:35) Comparing Giants And Jets (00:19:54) Joe Schoen Parody Song (00:23:03) Colin Kaepernick Rumors Dismissed (00:26:40) Debate Over Team Tanking (00:16:45) Andrew Thomas Injury Update (00:24:30) Jets Fans Classy Behavior