Carton and C-Mac Debate if Aaron Judge is Actually Injury Prone
Carton and C-Mac Debate if Aaron Judge is Actually Injury Prone  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Thu Sep 24 2026
Description: Carton and C-Mac discuss the viral story of Sunny Hostin allegedly fabricating her role as a juror in a high-profile murder trial. The debate moves to the New York Yankees, specifically evaluating Aaron Judge's injury history and whether his physical frame makes him inherently prone to health issues. They also touch on the team's postseason legacy and a lighthearted prank involving show ratings. (00:01:00) Sunny Hostin's Jury Lie (00:06:21) Aaron Judge Injury Debate (00:12:21) Judge's World Series Legacy (00:14:38) Ratings and Radio Pranks (00:16:15) Giants Quarterback Update