Hour 2: Big Mac and Craig Debate Fried vs. Schlittler for Yankees Game 1
Hour 2: Big Mac and Craig Debate Fried vs. Schlittler for Yankees Game 1  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Fri Sep 25 2026
Description: Craig and Big Mac engage in a fiery debate over the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation, specifically whether Max Fried or Cam Schlittler should start Game 1. They also honor CC Sabathia's legacy at Yankee Stadium and discuss iconic music moments involving Prince, Tom Petty, and the history of sketch comedy. (00:01:29) CC Sabathia Ceremony (00:04:40) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:08:00) Playoff Bye Analysis (00:13:10) Iconic Guitar Solos (00:18:00) Sketch Comedy History (00:22:10) Yankee Rotation Logic (00:25:45) Defending Rotation Arguments