Peacocks, Pete Alonso, and Cheating to Win? Craig Carton Goes FULL Chaos
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMoniglePublished On: Wed Jan 21 2026
Description: Craig Carton and Big Mac deliver a wildly unhinged WFAN segment that only The Carton Show can produce. It starts with a caller celebrating the Yankees’ Cody Bellinger signing before veering into youth baseball nostalgia, the revival of New York’s Borough Cup, and a deep dive into Mets fans’ mixed emotions after losing Pete Alonso and trading for Luis Robert Jr. The madness escalates with peacocks roaming New Jersey backyards, haunted Lake Ronkonkoma lore, American history arguments, Ikea horse meatball debates, and an all-time discussion on whether cheating actually matters in baseball.
The note was deleted
The note was saved
Your message was sent