Hour 4: Yankees' Playoff Pitching Strategy and Craig's Beef With Houston
Hour 4: Yankees' Playoff Pitching Strategy and Craig's Beef With Houston  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Tue Sep 15 2026
Description: Craig and Big Mac evaluate the Yankees' pitching rotation for the upcoming Wild Card series and the decision to rest Aaron Judge. They analyze major NFL storylines following Week 1, including the Chiefs' dominance and the Giants' victory over the Cowboys. The conversation also detours into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Craig’s refusal to return to the city of Houston. (00:01:20) Yankees Rotation Strategy (00:05:15) Wild Card Race Prep (00:10:30) Craig Sounds Like Mel Brooks (00:14:15) Rock Hall Of Fame (00:17:45) NFL Week 1 Recap (00:23:40) Division Storyline Rankings (00:26:50) Host NFL Betting Records