Hour 1: Carton: Why You Can’t Trust Aaron Judge in the Postseason
Hour 1: Carton: Why You Can’t Trust Aaron Judge in the Postseason  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Thu Sep 17 2026
Description: Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Knicks' apology for a major ticket pricing error and the team's championship banner plans. They also debate the Yankees' postseason reliability, questioning if Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole can perform at a championship level given Judge's health and the team's inconsistent rotation. (00:01:04) Knicks Ticket Price Apology (00:08:08) Aaron Judge Injury Status (00:13:30) Yankees Playoff Rotation Strategy (00:17:46) Yankee Postseason Trust Ratings (00:19:46) Debate Over Judge Rehab