Hour 1: Craig and Big Mac React to Giants Trading for J.J. McCarthy
Hour 1: Craig and Big Mac React to Giants Trading for J.J. McCarthy  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Mon Sep 28 2026
Description: Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Giants' decision to trade for J.J. McCarthy on The Carton Show following a lackluster performance by Jameis Winston. They discuss the season-ending injury to Brian Burns and compare the contrasting vibes between Jets and Giants fans. (00:01:41) Giants Trade For McCarthy (00:04:50) Giants Beat Titans Ugly (00:08:15) Jets Show Life In Detroit (00:12:30) Winston's Poor Performance Analyzed (00:18:17) Evaluating Giants Offensive Style (00:21:30) Giants Defensive Concerns Rise (00:25:15) Debate Over McCarthy Potential