Giants' J.J. McCarthy Trade is an Indictment of Jameis Winston
Giants' J.J. McCarthy Trade is an Indictment of Jameis Winston  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Mon Sep 28 2026
Description: Big Mac and Carton react on The Carton Show to the New York Giants' trade for J.J. McCarthy after a poor showing from Jameis Winston. They discuss the New York Jets' improvement despite a loss to the Lions and analyze the contrasting reactions of both fan bases. (00:01:26) Jets Competent Football Recap (00:01:43) J.J. McCarthy Trade Impact (00:04:40) Giants Ugly Win Analysis (00:08:04) Jets Optimism vs Giants Frustration