Hour 3: Gerrit Cole Return & The Great Five and Fly Debate
Hour 3: Gerrit Cole Return & The Great Five and Fly Debate  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Tue May 19 2026
Description: Craig and Big Mac celebrate the news of Gerrit Cole's return to the Yankees rotation as he prepares to face Tampa Bay this Friday. They engage in a heated debate regarding the origin of the baseball term "five and fly" following a clip from a Michael Kay broadcast. The discussion also features an announcement for an upcoming live show at the Salt Shack in August. 01:20 - Wemby Generational Performance 04:40 - Forgotten Sports History 10:35 - Cars For Kids Jingle 15:37 - Rotisserie Chicken Debate 19:39 - SNY Camera Angles 23:46 - Evan Roberts Ticket Pricing 36:36 - Salt Shack Show Announcement 40:14 - Five and Fly Controversy