Episode 20: Yankees CHOKE away Subway Series
Episode 20: Yankees CHOKE away Subway Series  
Podcast: The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Published On: Tue May 19 2026
Description: Chris McMonigle is NOT happy as he breaks down a nightmare Subway Series finale in which David Bednar blows a ninth-inning save before the Mets take it in extra innings. C-Mac gives the verdict on whether the Yanks are officially in one of their trademark "swoons" (2:50) while sounding off on what he calls the worst loss of the Yankees season so far (8:45). Plus, why the Max Fried update was good news (10:10), a plea to Aaron Boone to stop batting Trent Grisham leadoff (22:00), why Austin Wells has become a MAJOR problem (26:00), and how big of a concern the bullpen has become (35:50).