Tell Me Lies Season 3 Episode 5 Recap | I'd Like to Hold Her Head Underwater
Tell Me Lies Season 3 Episode 5 Recap | I'd Like to Hold Her Head Underwater  
Podcast: Previously On with Jillian Bonanne
Published On: Wed Jan 28 2026
Description: In this episode of the Previously On podcast, Jillian is joined by Kenny Marshall to give their reactions to Tell Me Lies Season 3 Episode 5 "I'd Like to Hold Her Head Underwater." They dive into Stephen’s latest mind games, Bree’s mom and complicated past, and Lucy insisting she’s “fine” when she very clearly is not.Since everyone continues to tell lies on this show, Jillian & Kenny countdown the Top 5 Lies of the episode and once again declare their love for Bree & Wrigley (Team Brigley?) before discussing that disturbing ending and their fear of what's next for Diana. Plus, they get into the wild fan theories circulating online including secret setups, the mystery caller reveal, and the theme of accidental deaths.Follow Kenny: https://www.instagram.com/voyageofatvwatcher/https://www.instagram.com/baird_andlies22/00:00 Intro to Podcast00:38 Episode 502:55 Top 5 Lies in Ep 503:04 Stephen lying about Wrigley celebration06:08 Stephen still lives there09:01 Bree lying about seeing mom15:37 Pippa lying about being there for Lucy18:26 Tegan22:04 Bree lies about Oliver 31:55 Lucy lies no one's bothered her about it40:03 Lucy lies to Alex and degradation42:28 Diana standing up to Stephen45:45 Bree back with Evan47:22 Theories and conspiracies47:55 Wrigley's phone49:46 Bree and Stephen50:36 Who's calling Bree?51:55 Secret kinship53:40 Accidental deathsThank you to Matt Buechele (@mattbooshell) for creating our new theme song. You can listen to "Sunscreen" on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/artist/1gFHHF3QyQxjbbKXV3qLu9Buy our merch: ⁠https://www.etsy.com/shop/PreviouslyOnTeenTV⁠Follow Previously On Teen TV on Instagram: ⁠⁠https://www.instagram.com/previouslyon_teentv/Follow Previously On Teen TV on TikTok: ⁠⁠https://www.tiktok.com/@previouslyon_teentv⁠⁠Subscribe to our YouTube: ⁠⁠https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCe2lgvvZGKMrQ8v24FmDdWQ?sub_confirmation=1⁠