Evan Calls Out Gary Cohen Over a Brutal Daniel Murphy Take
Podcast: Evan & TikiPublished On: Wed Apr 29 2026
Description: A strong night for New York sports quickly turned into a fiery debate when Evan Roberts revisited an old Gary Cohen opinion about Daniel Murphy that still bothers Mets fans years later. After hearing Cohen describe Murphy’s Nationals success as “painful” to watch, Evan dug up an old clip calling Murphy a “net negative” and questioned whether broadcasters and fans alike do enough to own their bad takes when history proves them wrong. Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun also break down whether two things can be true at once in sports fandom, debate how painful it really is watching former stars succeed with rivals, and hand out current “net negative” labels across New York sports. Plus, they react to another dominant Knicks performance, discuss Yankees pitching prospects and trade deadline possibilities, and even critique a listener designed WFAN “L” sign that sparked its own hilarious argument.
The note was deleted
The note was saved
Your message was sent