J.J. McCarthy Could Put Jaxson Dart Under Pressure
Podcast:Evan & Tiki Published On: Tue Sep 29 2026 Description: The Giants’ trade for J.J. McCarthy immediately raises a bigger question about Jaxson Dart’s future. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether McCarthy could create an uncomfortable quarterback battle once Dart returns, why an early-career injury can accelerate the pressure on a young quarterback, and why Minnesota giving up on McCarthy does not automatically mean the Giants made a mistake. John Harbaugh’s focus is simply winning the next game, but the Giants now have another potential answer if Jameis Winston struggles or Dart’s recovery hits complications. Plus, Case Keenum’s performance becomes a reminder of how valuable an experienced backup quarterback can be.