Mets Opening Day Debate: Peralta Gets the Nod, McLean Gets the Love
Mets Opening Day Debate: Peralta Gets the Nod, McLean Gets the Love  
Podcast: Evan & Tiki
Published On: Fri Feb 27 2026
Description: Mets fans wanted the movie scene: Nolan McLean at Citi Field on Opening Day, homegrown phenom vs. Paul Skenes, two young flamethrowers kicking off the season with electricity. Instead, Carlos Mendoza goes with Freddie Peralta as the Opening Day starter, and it sets off a classic New York debate about what matters more: the ace, the moment, or the message. The show dives into why McLean has fans dreaming big. The kid looks like the future of Mets pitching, and Mets history is built on arms. But body of work still counts, and Peralta is the established top-of-the-rotation guy, even if he is only guaranteed for one season.