Hour 4: Bench Aaron Judge? Evan and Tiki Blast a "Ridiculous" Fan Take
Hour 4: Bench Aaron Judge? Evan and Tiki Blast a "Ridiculous" Fan Take  
Podcast: Evan & Tiki
Published On: Fri Oct 02 2026
Description: Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts debate the validity of the current MLB playoff format and the logic behind a caller's demand to bench Aaron Judge for the division series. They analyze the Yankees' travel issues heading to Tampa and share their favorite moments from the movie Major League. Finally, they make their official Week 4 NFL picks for the Jets, Giants, and key national matchups. (00:01:52) MLB Playoff Bracket Debate (00:05:35) Yankees Playoff Series Benefits (00:09:23) Yankees Travel Plane Trouble (00:12:54) Selecting Your Playoff Opponent (00:19:21) Major League Movie Appreciation (00:22:54) NFL Week 4 Analysis (00:28:51) Benching Aaron Judge Debate (00:35:24) Idiots With Idioms Segment (00:39:52) Official NFL Week 4 Picks