Posted and Toasted Roasts Old J.J. McCarthy Takes
Posted and Toasted Roasts Old J.J. McCarthy Takes  
Podcast: Evan & Tiki
Published On: Tue Sep 29 2026
Description: Posted and Toasted takes aim at old J.J. McCarthy opinions as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig through some memorable WFAN receipts. The segment revisits skepticism surrounding McCarthy before the draft, including doubts about his physical profile, how much Michigan asked him to do and whether he was ever worthy of a first-round investment. The McCarthy debate continues with callers questioning why the Giants should believe in him now, while Evan keeps coming back to the low cost of the gamble. New York gave up only a fifth-round pick, giving John Harbaugh a chance to see whether McCarthy can become something more.