Aaron Judge’s October Could Define Yankees Career
Aaron Judge’s October Could Define Yankees Career  
Podcast: Evan & Tiki
Published On: Tue Sep 08 2026
Description: Aaron Judge is returning, but nobody truly knows how healthy the Yankees captain actually is. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate the most likely ways Judge’s season ends, from a World Series run to another injury derailing his comeback, and question whether he may simply be pushing through pain because October is approaching. The conversation also veers into a wild internet conspiracy theory claiming Judge’s absence was actually a secret PED suspension, an idea Evan firmly denounces despite the suspicious timing fueling online speculation. Plus, the crew compares Zach Wilson and J.J. McCarthy as quarterback disappointments and debates which former first-round pick deserves the harsher bust label.